Time has nothing to do with the quality of a song, it could have come out yesterday and it would still be a great song, but it's because it's well done and because RYM knew about the band and The song
I really like Radiohead but I get tired of seeing them several times in the top 100 singles, there were already like 16 of their songs in the top, and I don't like that Paranoid Android is so low even though it is very good, But here they put at least like 4 of their songs.
I like this chart because it’s probably the most genuine one for now In a few months we are going to see a big drop in ratings for a few of these songs (which already is happening to hydr6c0don$ by Black Kray)
Fascinating. That was a really eclectic mix. I feel a few albums were probably a bit overrepresented, but the results covered many genres and countries. Really cool.
Swans in the top 3, that was unexpected but it's very understandable! One that was completely expected was Starless being so high, that's a perfect song.
should’ve let the feature fizzle out a bit, it basically just came out when this video was created edit: actually, thinking about it now, this serves as a great archive of the inevitability shifting track ratings across the site, considering singular songs have such a spotlight on them now
@@Billiamwoodsyeah but the visibility of certain songs gets more people to rate them and they often drop in rating. obviously doesnt happen w famous songs like heroes, but when it comes to relatively lesser known ones like katy song they start dropping
It makes me incredibly happy to see two songs from Ghosts of the Great Highway (Duk Koo Kim & Carry me Ohio), such a genuine heartfelt gem of an album!
@tristenc.2346 I went through that same experience, the following months after discovering carry me ohio led me to ghosts of the great highway, benji, admiral fell promises and I also want to die in new orleans. Im so happy to see someone share my love for this song!
might be a weird ask but i rlly wanted to get into sun kil moon but i found out mark kozilek did a lot of fucked up stuff before i did, is it reflected in the music? or is it just kind of an unfortunate footnote
obligatory "All music is subjective" disclaimer here seriously, if your favorite artist isn't on here then it's not a big deal stop complaining that other people think differently than you
the list has the highest rated songs but not in the actual order, also LONG SEASON live was at 30th place when i made this video but since i made It as soon as the list started existing It has already changed a bit
its weird how the weighting system is for lives, im not entirely sure how that works. But yeah Long Season LIVE being number 1 song is like part of what defines rym
This is biased by the demographics most likely to use rate your music. That said, it does provide an interesting list that will give you a lot of variety… sometimes
@@tristenc.2346 if that happened the #1 song of all time would be taylor swift or something lol, also companies would be incentivized to buy ratings and stuff since RYM would actually have cultural significance for once
I, like many others, hate music nerds, especially pretentious RYM ones. But I can't lie-they're usually correct. Also Black Kray at 32 is insanity, but totally valid and based.
@@OneHundredAndNineYears that's okay, but not many people know that fripp is the lead guitarist on bowie's heroes. So I thought you were referring to that
Excelentes canciones en su inmensa mayoria. Pero el único gran problema de siempre es el sesgo anglosajon. No hay una sola cancion en español, por ejemplo. Cuando temas de Café Tacvba, Spinetta, Los Jaivas, Charly Garcia, Caifanes, Silvio Rodriguez, Cerati, el mismo Juan Gabriel etc, etc, no le piden nada a decenas de canciones en esta lista. Igualmente hay una ausencia lamentable de generos Rock, Rap y sus sub-generos, son lo que domina. No es que esten mal, como dije, son prácticamente todas canciones maravillosas. Pero los sesgos son evidentes.
id say that out of the tens of thousands of songs that have enough ratings to have a shot to appear on the list, a song being number 99 (which is easily top 0.1%) isnt so bad.
@@3stebanano887 la mayoría de canciones no llegan ni a 10,000 ratings, uno cuando tiene su tiempo en rym solo acepta que es otra lista más y que no representa nada.
Suppers Ready by Genesis and Anesthetize by Porcupine Tree Easily eat up any of the songs on this list. Maybe Echoes or Shine On have a chance. Long Live Prog
I was like you 5 years ago bro. Only listened to prog and the long Pink Floyd tracks. Now I listen to death metal, noise and all that other good shit. Listen to In A Silent Way by Miles Davis, that album got me into jazz.
I just want to say, this is first pretty good list I've seen. BUT, no Kanye, no Stevie Wonder, no Lauryn hill, no Frank Ocean, none of the weekend, I'm SHOCKED yet satisfied there isn't a Taylor Swift song. But AMERICAN TTERRORISTT IS ON THE LIST.
@Pie_The_Man it truly depends, if were talking about the most popular music (or the ones most people would say are best) outside of the western anglosphere whatever stevie or frank ocean are not really know and ive never heard of them, taylor swift would definetely rank higher than any of who you mentioned cause she is known and popular worldwide, and 95% of the list on the video would be wrong cause its from to a specific, specifically american community. And trying to rank music by true quality or merit is impossible, cause if the best singer is actually Nepalese we will never know about it cause if they dont speak english they will never be considered popular enough to receive any awards or recognition by global music fans The premise of making any top whatever music is pointless cause it is so tremendously subjective and you cant possibly experience all kinds of music and popular bands that exist, unless you get extremely specific like "top Norwegian thrash metal 2010's songs" but otherwise you cant possibly make a top music in history cause you just cannot comprehend all of that human art in a single mind. People should just accept that the true top is "top 100 of my favorite songs of all time" Sorry this became a rant jajjajajaja you dont have to answer i got carried away in my thoughts
@Tacuara7 the reasoning for my judgement is that on RYM kanye has 3 albums in the top 100 Stevie has 2 as well as just generally a pretty solid Catalogue and frank ocean has blonde as well as again a pretty solid catalogue You really don't need to dig that deep, all 3 of these guys are well liked on that site and it would be easy for them to score top spots on this list but they just don't for whatever reason
@Tacuara7 dawg taylor swift doesnt even have a single album that even touches the top 10,000 albums of all time on RYM let alone top 1,000, no fuckin shit she didn't get any songs in the top 100, she's like the antithesis to "RYM-Core" I was moreso giving my condolences to lauryn hill because she (and a lot of female artists) really do get snubbed on that site, the miseducation of lauryn hill deserves a lot higher than like what is it at? 171th overall? Poultry.
@joepbijlholt3315 I could maybe narrow it down to 3 rn, spaceship, stronger, and crack music. There's also mercy and through the wire. I would say lift yourself is probably his best tho
@@dudemanofdude lift yourself the best period. Love that everyone has different favourites, I’d say real friends violent crimes and flashing lights are the best to me rn, but that changes every time someone ask’s
So how is this ordered? I see the ratings fluctuate from one song to the next through the order, so is there a different metric being used for the order?
@@brendancroft5290its an algorithm that factors in both the average rating and the number of ratings. So a song with 4.65 and 5,000 ratings will probably be higher than a song with 4.67 and 1,000 ratings.
Join my Discord Server
discord.com/invite/3FQbjNhND8
Lonely male college sophomore playlist
yeah thats basically just rate your music described
now it's getting filled by lonely autistic high schoolers
I am one of them
What would you put at number one
and white
@@山田-d2k didn’t want to say that because I didn’t want any weirdos arguing with me but yeah totally
For just coming out 2 years ago, the place where he inserted the blade at #98 is amazing
Time has nothing to do with the quality of a song, it could have come out yesterday and it would still be a great song, but it's because it's well done and because RYM knew about the band and The song
@@mardex47gd31 bro i'm happy for that, i'm not a hater xD I love the song
I think Fantano is also responsible for the reputation this album has. It’s amazing, but it wouldn’t be as known as it is, without his rating
@@robinschafer8472 black country, new road = 9, white country, new road = 10
@@Sangel_Art *Is sad
black kray having a single in the top 35 is so mindblowing
What's depressing is that it used to be in the top 3, but it fell a lot of places after the chart first came out.
such a good song tho totally deserves it
@@Lumen99
no way man I hate downvote spam that’s why I can’t take these sites seriously. like 90% of reviews are either the maximum or minimum score
@@i.theworstguys298 yeah. In my heart I like to pretend that is still has a 4.8 average because that's where it was before the charts were revealed
Seeing Minecraft song on this list make me happy. 😊
Long season being on there twice is really fitting
5:06 this will still be #3 in my mind forever
I just realized the timestamp is wrong but i was talking about hydrocodone
@JusticeSmith-gp9oicap
@JusticeSmith-gp9oihelllllll no
@JusticeSmith-gp9oiI know what you are.
your mind will be wrong forever
crazy how this list manages to still be better than the generic yt top 100 songs lists
If it's crazy, does that mean it would be normal for this list to be worse than generic lists?
@@84bombsjetpack23chill bruh im geeked what does this mean
@@jsksjdjdjdjxnddnd I'm sober as fuck and reading that gave me an aneurysm
I really like Radiohead but I get tired of seeing them several times in the top 100 singles, there were already like 16 of their songs in the top, and I don't like that Paranoid Android is so low even though it is very good, But here they put at least like 4 of their songs.
@@mardex47gd31 yeah but its radiohead so its valid
It turns out that, indeed, there are some pretty good songs in this list.
check out the rest
Rym is so good for this because the average rym user has actually heard music they dislike and can express why, such a w list
I like this chart because it’s probably the most genuine one for now
In a few months we are going to see a big drop in ratings for a few of these songs (which already is happening to hydr6c0don$ by Black Kray)
some of the lowest songs already got replaced
@@mus1chartsthey usually shuffle around a lot since the ratings have a smaller difference
Pleasantly surprised to see Sun Kil Moon a couple times.
i cried listening to benji the first time
Fascinating. That was a really eclectic mix. I feel a few albums were probably a bit overrepresented, but the results covered many genres and countries. Really cool.
Swans in the top 3, that was unexpected but it's very understandable!
One that was completely expected was Starless being so high, that's a perfect song.
It really amazes me how shoegaze is just so good and it makes you feel levitated.
actually nvm what this comment originally said, derby county’s anthem is the greatest song of all time
I mean, it's not that wide of a variety. Rym users are part of certain groups of music listeners (Radiohead, Kendrick Lamar...)
@@relahtnelnarFtrue. Don’t trust anyone who hates on Bull of Heaven
I’m suprise there was no ELO
@@AntiShreddersYeah, there definitely should have been some ELO.
It’s a pretty biased list
Rym is a mix of sad boys and gangs, with some ocean man
should’ve let the feature fizzle out a bit, it basically just came out when this video was created
edit: actually, thinking about it now, this serves as a great archive of the inevitability shifting track ratings across the site, considering singular songs have such a spotlight on them now
This is still basically based on a decade+ of track ratings
@@Billiamwoodsyeah but the visibility of certain songs gets more people to rate them and they often drop in rating. obviously doesnt happen w famous songs like heroes, but when it comes to relatively lesser known ones like katy song they start dropping
Heroes is n1 now, as it should be, david bowie is the greatest musician of all time
As is Robert Fripp!
A day in the life is better imo opinion a much greater musical achievement
@@HenryAvery-qg1hd fair, very fair, both are the magnum opuses of music and beatles are the most important band of all time so it fits more
bach laughing in the distance..
It makes me incredibly happy to see two songs from Ghosts of the Great Highway (Duk Koo Kim & Carry me Ohio), such a genuine heartfelt gem of an album!
carry me ohio changed my life and was like the only song i listened for 6 months straight
@tristenc.2346 I went through that same experience, the following months after discovering carry me ohio led me to ghosts of the great highway, benji, admiral fell promises and I also want to die in new orleans. Im so happy to see someone share my love for this song!
might be a weird ask but i rlly wanted to get into sun kil moon but i found out mark kozilek did a lot of fucked up stuff before i did, is it reflected in the music? or is it just kind of an unfortunate footnote
@@milomessing5611 not really reflected in his music at all, but my opinion is i dont really let an artist take away from the art
@@tristenc.2346 i generally agree i just feel rhat context can ruin stuff for me sometimes. anyways good to hear thx!
This is not a bad list my man!
it’s from a site
Stairway to heaven only at 99 is crazy
Not even their best song
Not really, they have *Way* better (eg. Black dog, D’yer M’aker, Communication Breakdown, etc)
@@sirswanky8686exactly! Its a good song, but not their best
Actually nvm their best is Hats Off To (Roy) Harper
@@sirswanky8686Even if that’s your opinion, you can accept the general consensus being that it’s their signature song and best
This list single-handedly put me on to King Park and La Dispute, thanks! Now I'm looking for more like it
Would recommend mewithoutyou
so glad to see have a nice life here
@@rota5439 same, Deathconsciousness is my favorite album oat
@@mus1chartsYES! 🗣️🔥
hot take but i think the unnatural world has (at times) higher highs than deathconsciousness
Should've been higher HOWEVER!
@@slothers8685 Fr bro
Not a single jazz or classical song is crazy lol
How is Sweden here but not gymnopedie??
@@abeahmed2581 yeah no jazz Is Crazy mazy
There were a few jazz songs here
actually maybe just one, I saw one Nina Simone song so that’s it, damn that is wild
@@Rachl1284 yep exactly lol
never thought i would have seen Ain't It Funny ranked 16th best song of all time
obligatory "All music is subjective" disclaimer here
seriously, if your favorite artist isn't on here then it's not a big deal
stop complaining that other people think differently than you
or stop being so afraid of negativity and let people debate
@@john_smith_john
d1 online instigator
Glad to see “Helpless Child” by Swans is super high ❤
LONG SEASON APARECE 2 VECES, OTOKOTACHI NO WAKARE WACHIN
The real #1 is Fishmans LONG SEASON live performance at 4.87/5 stars, but it's not even on here because it doesn’t include live tracks lol
the list has the highest rated songs but not in the actual order, also LONG SEASON live was at 30th place when i made this video but since i made It as soon as the list started existing It has already changed a bit
Do people even watch videos before they comment? It's on here. Just deweighted.
so echoes live at pompei by pink floyd would be also on top 3 easily
i think the definitive ratings are a combination of the amount of ppl that rated and the avg score
its weird how the weighting system is for lives, im not entirely sure how that works. But yeah Long Season LIVE being number 1 song is like part of what defines rym
TWIN PEAKS THEME YEEEEAAAAHHHH
@@themovieguysam2590 i love Twin Peaks
@@mus1charts you and me both!! I made a video essay on Fire Walk with Me this past week actually. Just love that franchsie so much
@@themovieguysam2590 i'll check It out
This is biased by the demographics most likely to use rate your music. That said, it does provide an interesting list that will give you a lot of variety… sometimes
solution: make sure everyone gets on rym
That bias applies to literally every rating system ever used tho
@@tristenc.2346 if that happened the #1 song of all time would be taylor swift or something lol, also companies would be incentivized to buy ratings and stuff since RYM would actually have cultural significance for once
Guts theme is a massive W
Honestly, A day in the life is everyones “secret” #1
The fact that a minecraft song is on here is crazy lmao
Don't agree with all, but happy to finally see a top of songs with actually good music
I, like many others, hate music nerds, especially pretentious RYM ones. But I can't lie-they're usually correct. Also Black Kray at 32 is insanity, but totally valid and based.
I don't think this list is super pretentious tbh, its mostly just alternative staples and rock/pop classics
This is not a pretentious list at all
@@redblue8983 what is a pretentious list?
@cinzio4615 prolly some shit with merzbow and trout mask replica idk
@@Pie_The_Man thay are cool albums
i was excited to see 1 ween song, but 2? YEAHHHHHHH
CHICO BUARQUE - CONSTRUÇÃO MENCIONADO! Uma das maiores composições da história é brasileira! 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
WEEN MENTIONED
This would be perfect if number three was bumped up two places
Helpless child agenda will never die
That's litterally my playlist beside Bowie
1:55 I ALMOST SPIT OUT MY WATER (great song btw)
cocteau twins twice ‼️😻
The fact that so many books still name the
3:14 one of my favorites
Damn Robert Fripp is on that list 4 times
4 times actually: in the court, 21 st century, starless and heroes
You can edit your comment
@@alphamartin8209 Sorry I didn't watch the whole video 😅
@@OneHundredAndNineYears that's okay, but not many people know that fripp is the lead guitarist on bowie's heroes. So I thought you were referring to that
@@alphamartin8209 I just didn't know 21st century schizoid man was on the list
king park was on here when the list was legit before reviewbombing
Excelentes canciones en su inmensa mayoria. Pero el único gran problema de siempre es el sesgo anglosajon.
No hay una sola cancion en español, por ejemplo. Cuando temas de Café Tacvba, Spinetta, Los Jaivas, Charly Garcia, Caifanes, Silvio Rodriguez, Cerati, el mismo Juan Gabriel etc, etc, no le piden nada a decenas de canciones en esta lista.
Igualmente hay una ausencia lamentable de generos
Rock, Rap y sus sub-generos, son lo que domina. No es que esten mal, como dije, son prácticamente todas canciones maravillosas.
Pero los sesgos son evidentes.
I like to see how different is from the single chart
swans top 3 love to see it, I would've picked that song as well. Also love the filth pfp
Gnarly radical on the block im magical
CHICO BUARQUE MENTIONED!!!!!
6:23 Madvillainy.
0:05 that is criminal
id say that out of the tens of thousands of songs that have enough ratings to have a shot to appear on the list, a song being number 99 (which is easily top 0.1%) isnt so bad.
This is definitely in the top 100 best “best 100 songs” playlists ever but only in 100-75th place im sorry against rym
Also 2:51 is funny asf
3:23 My favourite song
GEROGERIGEGEGE MENTIONED‼️‼️‼️
So surprised it was there its amazing!!
Wesley’s theory should be higher
Crazy how the video starts with the greatest song ever made and doesn’t end with it, but at least Duk Koo Kim is on here!
Muchas canciones que no me parecen la gran cosa, sin embargo, es un buen top
El hecho de que sea por votación de los usuarios hace que sea más objetiva pienso yo
@@3stebanano887 la mayoría de canciones no llegan ni a 10,000 ratings, uno cuando tiene su tiempo en rym solo acepta que es otra lista más y que no representa nada.
0:59 ❤️❤️❤️
you shouldve featured another several secs of each song. i have no idea if i like it otherwise
just look up the songs if you're curious
katy song is so mich better than every other song in the top 10
So glad Duk Koo Kim just about made it
Also no stevie wonder at all like come on
And no Michael Jackson
@@Stike8473bro didn't watch the video apparently
@@blob_cancel_aftercast thanks I didn’t see that, but only Billie Jean and still no Stevie:(
So happy that HANL is on there. Well deserved
I want a playlist of this top
It would probably take 15 minutes to make
@@parkerohlin3836 good idea
Death Grips - On GP is such a deserved top 50 placement
Frankly deserved the top 1 placement but hey that's just me
Suppers Ready by Genesis
and Anesthetize by Porcupine Tree
Easily eat up any of the songs on this list.
Maybe Echoes or Shine On have a chance.
Long Live Prog
Suppers Ready is top 331
I was like you 5 years ago bro. Only listened to prog and the long Pink Floyd tracks. Now I listen to death metal, noise and all that other good shit. Listen to In A Silent Way by Miles Davis, that album got me into jazz.
you should do AOTY if possible
true (its also the better site)
1:53 crazy how a Minecraft song is here
wheres nettspend?
😭😭😭🙏🙏🙏
I just want to say, this is first pretty good list I've seen. BUT, no Kanye, no Stevie Wonder, no Lauryn hill, no Frank Ocean, none of the weekend, I'm SHOCKED yet satisfied there isn't a Taylor Swift song. But AMERICAN TTERRORISTT IS ON THE LIST.
Cause the list is very biased towards an elitist white american millenial male opinions as thats most of the users in that website
@ignaciogonzalez7904 lauryn hill and swift yeah sure but Stevie kanye and frank ocean absolutely had a shot of making this lol
@Pie_The_Man it truly depends, if were talking about the most popular music (or the ones most people would say are best) outside of the western anglosphere whatever stevie or frank ocean are not really know and ive never heard of them, taylor swift would definetely rank higher than any of who you mentioned cause she is known and popular worldwide, and 95% of the list on the video would be wrong cause its from to a specific, specifically american community.
And trying to rank music by true quality or merit is impossible, cause if the best singer is actually Nepalese we will never know about it cause if they dont speak english they will never be considered popular enough to receive any awards or recognition by global music fans
The premise of making any top whatever music is pointless cause it is so tremendously subjective and you cant possibly experience all kinds of music and popular bands that exist, unless you get extremely specific like "top Norwegian thrash metal 2010's songs" but otherwise you cant possibly make a top music in history cause you just cannot comprehend all of that human art in a single mind.
People should just accept that the true top is "top 100 of my favorite songs of all time"
Sorry this became a rant jajjajajaja you dont have to answer i got carried away in my thoughts
@Tacuara7 the reasoning for my judgement is that on RYM kanye has 3 albums in the top 100 Stevie has 2 as well as just generally a pretty solid Catalogue and frank ocean has blonde as well as again a pretty solid catalogue
You really don't need to dig that deep, all 3 of these guys are well liked on that site and it would be easy for them to score top spots on this list but they just don't for whatever reason
@Tacuara7 dawg taylor swift doesnt even have a single album that even touches the top 10,000 albums of all time on RYM let alone top 1,000, no fuckin shit she didn't get any songs in the top 100, she's like the antithesis to "RYM-Core"
I was moreso giving my condolences to lauryn hill because she (and a lot of female artists) really do get snubbed on that site, the miseducation of lauryn hill deserves a lot higher than like what is it at? 171th overall? Poultry.
Blood promise (live) is so good man
3:23 That’s my favourite song
Beatles having 2 songs in the top 5 that's why they're the GOATSSSS
where is joanna newsom
anthony fantano ahh list
Hell yes Sun Kil Moon has made some of the greatest songs ever
No podría haber mejor no.1 que A Day In the Life
Super goated list
WE LOVE WEEN
Susumu Hirasawa at #33!!
DAMNN no nick drake, elliott smith. i love em
From the morning or place to be deserves a mention
Fr Waltz #2 is one of the best songs ever made
same, Can't Make a Sound or Things Behind the Sun should have been there
BLACK KRAY GOAT
1:05 come up in the spot lookin extra fly
how tf long season isnt n1????
no Runaway is crazy
Runaway is a good song but its not even kanye's best
@@dudemanofdudewhat’s his best in your opinion?
@joepbijlholt3315 I could maybe narrow it down to 3 rn, spaceship, stronger, and crack music. There's also mercy and through the wire. I would say lift yourself is probably his best tho
@@dudemanofdude lift yourself the best period. Love that everyone has different favourites, I’d say real friends violent crimes and flashing lights are the best to me rn, but that changes every time someone ask’s
Starless king crimson❤
So glad to see Marquee Moon so high
I don’t know where to start…
So how is this ordered? I see the ratings fluctuate from one song to the next through the order, so is there a different metric being used for the order?
Number of votes
@@angel.3939 wdym? I’m just curious cause I don’t quite understand
@@brendancroft5290its an algorithm that factors in both the average rating and the number of ratings. So a song with 4.65 and 5,000 ratings will probably be higher than a song with 4.67 and 1,000 ratings.
@@johnhenson6495 oh ok. That makes sense
six RH songs let's goooo
Where is Layla
Clapton is with Kanye in hell
@@abeepa64 what?
The only gorillaz song on here being Feel Good Inc is wild. I wouldve at least put Melancholy Hill on there
gorillaz getting a top 100 song at all is not at all a given
i didnt know people tended to view the glow pt. 2 title track as the best one off the album
strawberry fields forever number 4 is based though
on the block im magical
Bjork mentioned ‼x2
Why is the list not ordered by the actual rating? By the RYM rating the NO.1 would be Long Season by Fishmans...
it takes into account the amount of voters, so if theres a large amount of voters and it still has a high score, it gets bonus points basically
Live albums are rated lower automatically on rym. Long season live has the highest core but doesn't show up at number one on the charts