Not exactly, the communists were doing horrible before they were forced to retreat so some forces in Yunnan. They just let the nationalists fight the Japanese with all their might and then the soviets also gave them help Manchuria which turned the tide. The Second United front in my opinion wasn’t as good for the nationalists as it was for the communists. There is a pretty decent chance we would have seen a western like republic of China. The warlords also were one of the factors that made the Chinese nationalists agree to the United front. So yeah it was more like the smart kid did all the work and then the popular kid took credit.
@@TheMoonManBGk fun fact the KMT started to try cleaning all the communist by starting it in Shanghai and murdering many CPC member but them make a blunder by also murdering people that's not join CPC, the warlord also executing many main leaders of CPC in other region. These insident then occur the people turn their side to support CPC and fight the warlord and KMT elites.
@@70_Bheta man, I can’t understand if you’re saying the nationalists are bad or not, because your sentence makes more sense than communist economic policies. Please translate
@@maozedong7536 I should've specified. The Central Philharmonic was banned from playing all western pieces, including the Yellow River Cantata, which Defend the Yellow River was a part of. So, Yin Chengzong, along with Jiang Qing (Mme. Mao), and others composed the Yellow River Concerto, which has the piano version of this song which was not banned.
@@parrotconservative well yes but that's popular opinion and not really into many other details,the Communists did many Inflitration against the Japanese and caused the Japanese kinda scared to get out of the cities since many of China was still underdeveloped.
@@Theotok0s true dude and actually chiang was not really want to against japan...he still thought clear cpc 1st then fight with japan is able he was not clear what happend until zhang detained him
From the Yellow River Cantata by Xing Xinghai. The work was temporarily banned during the Cultural Revolution due to its Western influences and traditional material recalling old customs and culture. During this period, the work was rewritten by multiple composers into the Yellow River Piano Concerto, with 'Defend the Yellow River' being the fourth movement. The end of the Cultural Revolution resulted in the new piano concerto to lose its fame, although in recent times, both the concerto and the original cantata have seen popularity.
I could feel the adrenaline of this song. It makes me wanna grab on any weapon that I can find and run all the way to the Yellow River and defend the line against the invading IJA.
The fact that a colonial empire that has defeated China several times managed to lose against the more underdeveloped and disunified Chinese warlords is crazy. I know they had support from the US and allies, don't sue me.
TBH, Chinese and Democracy wasn't a Good combination. Since China Was Ruled over Centuary with monarchy or Ironfist. After The Establisment of 1st Republic Of China Under That General (i Forgor his name💀) but he Declare A new State Called Imperial China after 1st Republic of china Was form and Spliting china into many Warlord From the tip of Xinjiang to The South of Yunnan was ruled by Warlord. And then Civilwar happend and overtrown the Imperial China and then There is Second Republic of China under Nationalist Banner, but their Goverment Was too Corrupt and then Another Civil war Happend after WW2 and Now China is Communist State And Ruled By Ironfist.
![[Eng CC] March of Steel Torrent / 钢铁洪流进行曲 [Chinese Military Song]](/img/1.gif)
When the two smartest kids team up to beat a smart transfer student.
Not exactly, the communists were doing horrible before they were forced to retreat so some forces in Yunnan. They just let the nationalists fight the Japanese with all their might and then the soviets also gave them help Manchuria which turned the tide. The Second United front in my opinion wasn’t as good for the nationalists as it was for the communists. There is a pretty decent chance we would have seen a western like republic of China. The warlords also were one of the factors that made the Chinese nationalists agree to the United front.
So yeah it was more like the smart kid did all the work and then the popular kid took credit.
@@TheMoonManBGk lmao.
They were brothers and their father is the Soviet Union
@@TheMoonManBGk fun fact the KMT started to try cleaning all the communist by starting it in Shanghai and murdering many CPC member but them make a blunder by also murdering people that's not join CPC, the warlord also executing many main leaders of CPC in other region. These insident then occur the people turn their side to support CPC and fight the warlord and KMT elites.
@@70_Bheta man, I can’t understand if you’re saying the nationalists are bad or not, because your sentence makes more sense than communist economic policies. Please translate
During the cold war, this song was banned in Taiwan for being too communist and then banned in the mainland for being too western.
So in a nutshell: Pick a struggle honey
this song never been banned in mainland.
lmfao what it was endorsed in the mainland
@@maozedong7536 I should've specified. The Central Philharmonic was banned from playing all western pieces, including the Yellow River Cantata, which Defend the Yellow River was a part of. So, Yin Chengzong, along with Jiang Qing (Mme. Mao), and others composed the Yellow River Concerto, which has the piano version of this song which was not banned.
Um,isn’t there is a 1955 CCP version up on the internet?
The happy song sang by two twin brothers when they're happy cooperating and trying to make their dad proud.
But secretly hate each other
The communist Chinese mostly let the Nationalist ones fight on the fronts so that they would take over china one day
@@parrotconservative well yes but that's popular opinion and not really into many other details,the Communists did many Inflitration against the Japanese and caused the Japanese kinda scared to get out of the cities since many of China was still underdeveloped.
@@Linkchidori Secretly?
Daddy Sun Yat Sen
The most controversial thumbnail ive seen in months
its not even the flag of the chinese united front too
@@stepanek7404 do they have an official flag? my understanding is they just all flew the ROC flag at the time under the united front
At that time，CPC and KMT are brothers
not really, they still hated each other but they also had a common enemy against the Japanese Imperalists
@@Theotok0s yes, any sibling can tell you that brothers hate eachother
@@Kolokommouna Chinese mentality
@giladpellaeon3664 true
@@Theotok0s true dude
and actually chiang was not really want to against japan...he still thought clear cpc 1st then fight with japan is able
he was not clear what happend until zhang detained him
From the Yellow River Cantata by Xing Xinghai. The work was temporarily banned during the Cultural Revolution due to its Western influences and traditional material recalling old customs and culture. During this period, the work was rewritten by multiple composers into the Yellow River Piano Concerto, with 'Defend the Yellow River' being the fourth movement.
The end of the Cultural Revolution resulted in the new piano concerto to lose its fame, although in recent times, both the concerto and the original cantata have seen popularity.
"As the song go on,they keeping lost more territories"
Just like me on hearts of iron 4
“My greatest enemy is also my greatest friend.”
When we have a common enemy.
based thumbnail
"the enemy of my enemy is my friend"
RUclips put this in a mix that is called "music of japan"
What a unified force! Surely, once they have beaten back the Japanese, both sides can come to a peaceful agreement!
I could feel the adrenaline of this song. It makes me wanna grab on any weapon that I can find and run all the way to the Yellow River and defend the line against the invading IJA.
i would *NOT* go there if i were you i heard the kuomitang wanted to fucking explode it (and they did)
SECOND UNITED FRONT!!!
When the koumingtan joins the third international in kaiserreich
when you like china 1937 but you don't know what political party to pick:
fuck it i choose the soviet controlled sinkiang i dont even care anymore
中國共產黨+中華民國國民革命軍
抗日时是国共合作，共产党的军队是国民革命军的一部分
The fact that a colonial empire that has defeated China several times managed to lose against the more underdeveloped and disunified Chinese warlords is crazy. I know they had support from the US and allies, don't sue me.
the thumbnail
TBH, Chinese and Democracy wasn't a Good combination. Since China Was Ruled over Centuary with monarchy or Ironfist. After The Establisment of 1st Republic Of China Under That General (i Forgor his name💀) but he Declare A new State Called Imperial China after 1st Republic of china Was form and Spliting china into many Warlord From the tip of Xinjiang to The South of Yunnan was ruled by Warlord. And then Civilwar happend and overtrown the Imperial China and then There is Second Republic of China under Nationalist Banner, but their Goverment Was too Corrupt and then Another Civil war Happend after WW2 and Now China is Communist State And Ruled By Ironfist.
You mean Emperor Yuan shikai
@@cyanfloy2473 yeah That Guy
缝合体（确信）
bruh
WHOLESOME BIG SABLIN CHUNGUS
if only japan won midway and coral sea.
Still would had lost but would had gave them one or two more years tho, it would most likely just dent US moral.
Чин чан чон чин чи чон чин
Racist
@@randomdude1332 no u
@@dimitrichkerenau What a kid
@@randomdude1332 коммуниста спросить забыли
@@dimitrichkerenau 一樣是個孩子