Americans intentionally did not destroy their weapons and vehicals. They wanted Taliban to get their hands on them and keep this region in trouble. They basically want to teach a lesson to Pakistan and make sure pakistan don't try any advantures in afganistan
They did that because taliban is actually the American ally in the region right now, it’s now that America wants to teach Pakistan a lesson, they did that by doing the regime change in Pakistan, economically dismantled Pakistan through that. That’s how wars are fought now, only proxy
Our hate toward Pakistan is only because of the cooperation between Pentagon & ISI during the Cold War, which literally destroyed our beloved country Afghanistan. As an Afghan growing up in PK and now living in Germany only love for PK people. I love my Pakistani and Hindi friends here in Germany 🇦🇫🇵🇰🇮🇳❤️ let’s don’t hate each other. Btw. I love Indian geopolitical podcasts
bro they helped you to fight against ussr, ofc there will be some destruction, if pentagon and isi were not there than the country would have been destroyed by russia.
Afghanis have a great relationship with India. Afghan Royalties still live in areas of Dehradun-Mussoorie area. There is still a small Afghani Refugee camp ⛺near Rishikesh which recently got featured in some Indian TV 📺 shows. The Last President of Afghanistan 🇦🇫 was raised by his grandparents in Doon valley. Dehradun Cricket Stadium 🏟 serves as their 2nd Home Ground while many of their Army Officials were trained in Indian Military Academy (IMA) till 2021, when the Talibani's took over.
Afghanis u r referring to are like pdm supporters here in pakistan who are a minority. If majority of afghans opposed taliban, then they wont have taken over, plain and simple. The majority of afghans support taliban just like how majority of us pakistanis support imran khan
@@cuttingstitching-dressmaki3016 Can't explain you things, that you don't want to hear. We are not here to solve problems for your country. Sorry. You gotta do it yourself.
Warn the hypocrites that torturous punishment awaits them. The hypocrites take unbelievers as friends rather than believers. Do they look for honor at their hands? Truly all honor belongs to Allah. Quran 4:138-139
@@cuttingstitching-dressmaki3016 Believers! Do not take unbelievers as friends over fellow believers. Would you give Allah a clear reason to punish you? Quran 4:144
Over 25 lacs afghani refugees living in Pakistan. Personally I know lots of afghanis who have become super rich in Pakistan and others who have a good life in Pakistan. Hating Pakistan only shows ungreatfulness and that never leads to anything good.
Dear, I am so sorry! As an Afghan I grow up in Pakistan and I am soooo grateful for that. I love my best friends over there in Islamabad. Pakistan is my second homeland. We afghans should hate only the ISI, which literally cooperated with the U.S. to ruin Afghanistan. I can’t understand the hate toward pak people at all🫶
In the early 2000s and 2010s. We used to live in a colony. We had a house with 3 portions. We lived on the 1st one and the ground and the second were for rent. My father always gave the 2nd portion to Afghanis. He never discriminated them in any way. There were a lot of Afghanis living in that colony. The local people welcomed them with open hearts. And if Afghanis still hate the PEOPLE of Pakistan, then they are nothing but hypocrites.
Afghanistan currently has problems with all of its neighbors but this is nothing new. They have always had problems with everyone around them. There are present border clashes with Iran over water and oil. None of this stops Afghans from wanting to live in Iran or Pakistan for that matter. There are so many Afghans living in Iran and Pakistan - if they really hated Pakistan or Afghanistan , then why is the dream of every Afghan to leave Afghanistan and move to its neighbors?
We have ver good relationships with central Asian neighbors. Also, with China, we also have a good relationship with Iran. The only country we don't is Pakistan. we love pakistani people but hate the government
@@naweedanwari9787 We have good relations with everyone except India and its ally Afghanistan. We also love Afghan citizens which is why we have housed millions of Afghan refugees for decades but we hate the Afghan governments who have always been creating unrest and doing terrorism in Pakistan.
Wonderful podcast on geopolitical view, i strongly believe that tact and diplomacy is of highest importance, being atmanirbar and self reliance comes from people, new infrastructure and developments in different sectors...focusing on own development and growth, its is important to tap into to start ups that have high potential for financial and political gains...even start ups have lot of tie ups with organizations that work closely with governments and local corporations....focusing on things that lead to our own betterment is of utmost importance and ensuring the best for those around.....
I have newly found some interesting topics and am trying to know more to it.All of it started from your interesting podcasts.Thankyou Ranveer, for helping me expanding my knowledge towards the world🙂
Most of us Pakistanis have no hatred toward our Afghan brothers and sister, our government does not represent all of us as a whole, before we’re Afghan or Pakistani, we’re Muslims first ❤️
I grew up with the ppl from Afghanistan. They consider our country just like their own. While you still have some afghans that do hate Pakistan but just know that there more afghans in Pakistan than India. And we are still living together like brothers in Pakistan 🇵🇰❤️🇦🇫.
Afghans only hate your establishment (Army, ISI), who are responsible for the atrocities that have been going on for over 40 years. I grew up in Pakistan and moved out of Pakistan over 30 years a go, but I still visit Pakistan.
AIM is trying to say....we had a great relationship with them all the time except 2 yrs...that's why they hijacked our plane ...later followed by attacks by acquitters
Pakistani ISI and Pakistani Army with Pakistani militants hijacked the flight not Taliban. But Mullah Omar sheltered those people and helped Pakistan release the terrorists from Indian jail.
I haven't watched the video but i know this will be BS. Only diaspora Afghans started hating Pakistan after 2001. Pakistan and Afghanistan are brothers, ask most locals. The border between us is just an arbitrary line drawn by the British. Some people say Pakistan and India should be united but they dont realise that Pakistan and Afghanistan are MUCH closer.
Nope. Half truth. Eastern Pakistan Sindh and Punjab even Baluchistan are fairly similar to India. The Western part bordering Afghanistan is highly similar to ag. Historically much of Punjab Sindh was ruled by Sikhs after Afghans. In northern India Lodi Dynasty as well as Afghan nobles in even hindu empires were well known. Perspectives
@rajeevgangal542 only Punjab is similar to a small part of India. The people of Punjab and Sindh, however, are ethnically similar to North Indians. You can't say Balochistan is similar to India. The main people there are the Baloch and Pashtuns, who are both Iranic. There are also other groups but no Indic people except a small number of Sindhis. The complete Western and Northern parts of Pakistan are much more similar to Iran, Afghanistan, Central Asia, and South Western China.
We are not brothers we hate Pakistan, we are pashtunes afghans and the only brothers we have are our own pashtune tribes on the other side of the durandline. The very existence of Pakistan is a threat to Afghanistan and it's identity.
as a Pakistani Taliban and Afghani people are very respected in our hearts a high status and love and respect they are our brothers we are ashamed as people our government did't support them but india just want both of us to fight but we both will fight you hopefully Inshallah 🫂🫂🫂Pak Afghan for me both are Muslims better can govern and we respect and love afghans our respected brothers we can sacrifice ourselves for you and same you are never going to hurt Pakistani Muslim people for me both are Muslim lands Islamic lands respected and should be protected we are one Islam is our country and we are it's county men afghans are better than us they are our brothers take your lies of nonsense with yourself you will always see both of us against you and america
SubhanAllah! I testify that we Afghans, as you all truly know within your hearts love you Pakistanis our Muslim brothers, by Allah we are created for nothing else but to worship Allah and that logic surpasses any race or ethnicity. Right now our dear Muslim brothers in Gaza are being slaughtered and famished to death our Muslim sisters, our Mothers and Fathers in Gaza are bleeding, what will we answer Allah? That is what worries us the most at the moment.
I met Afghans in the US and surprisingly they were very warm towards India and held somewhat negative attitude towards Pakistan. I was also very surprised by their opinion
You indiansss r living in Fooools paradise I m pakhtoooon from pakistan have sooo many friends from Afghanistan, living in punjab province in pakistan very happily Yes there are Some political issues but to be very honest things have changed now ! We pakistanis nd afghans r Muslims first Islam comes first for us Pakistan zindabad Afghanistan zindabad
These fouls believe Pakistani pashtoon nd Afghan pashtoon will fight against Pakistan. Remember Hindus we are Muslims we have differences nd we express those differences openly unlike hypocrite Hindus but when it's come to war you will find pashtoon, baloch, Sindi, kashmiri in front row against you ... punjabi will be last to stand
Pakistan must take responsibility. 1. Honor Durant agreement 2. Return 40 billion ( for reconstruction) collected by Pakistan to destroy Afghanistan. If these TWO issue is solved - Afghanistan will be gooood neighbor.
I am Pakhtoon from KPK and Afghanis are our brothers and sisters, we live,go to same Masjid,funeral,wedding etc If Afghani hate Pakistan, they have rights to hate because our Army took dollars for the blood of Afghanis, The irony we Pakistani hate our own Army because they are involve in politics.
WE AFGHANS dont hate pakistani peoples they r so kind peoples but thier Government policies we r always against .they always wanted to destory our country without any mercy on us
I'm kashmiri The Quran and the Prophet Muhammad both emphasized the importance of unity and integration among Muslims. Afghans are our brothers and we all should stick together as brothers no matter what happens. As the prophet muhammed pabu would of wanted!! We all need to wake up and stop this nonsense.
“And hold fast by the covenant of Allah all together and be not disunited, and remember the favor of Allah on you when you were enemies, then He united your hearts so by His favor you became brethren; and you were on the brink of a pit of fire…” [Quran, 3:103] I'm a Pakistani and i agree that there might be some differneces that escalted to conflicts and even hatred from both sides, but for the sake of Allah, i love my Afghan brothers and sisters and will never wish anything bad upon them. We are Muslims first and no God fearing individual will hate an innocent Muslim, especially the ones that are oppressed.
They r not muslim first though. They r pathans. U have given up ur identity so nothing left except islam. Except indian subcontinent muslims no one is "first" a muslim.
@@himanshugurjar9002 bro we are pathans and muslims. who are you to decide if i am hindu or muslim. i am muslim but we still hate pakistan and love india. and thats because they always supported terror against us and doesnt re unite us with our blood brothers.
Brother dont buy their propaganda. Afghanis u r referring to are like pdm supporters here in pakistan who are a minority. If majority of afghans opposed taliban, then they wont have taken over, plain and simple. The majority of afghans support taliban just like how majority of us pakistanis support imran khan
It was fixed. Their President Ashraf Ghani knew exactly what was coming and he played it to his advantage when he siphoned millions of dollars and fled to Dubai. For him, it was a blessing in disguise. As a matter of fact, the Taliban had many supporters within the then-Govt. The Afghan Army perhaps handed over the country on a platter. Unfortunately, now the West has to bare the brunt. Well, the West shouldn't have gone there in the first place. The US lost 2.3 trillion USD in the process. Afghan Govt kept half of that. The poor women and kids are now suffering.
All your concern is about $3 trillions. What about the people killed by west in Afghan? In the name of democracy and fight against terrorism, US is the biggest human rights abuser
it makes me sad seeing muslims uniting with hindus to destroy another muslim even though that muslim country helped more then the hindus every did just sad soviet war refuging so many afghanis doesnt make sense why afghanis would stab pakistan in the back after pakistan helping them for so long pakistan invested so much money in them sure pakistan did make money from afghanistan and they deported them but im preatty sure pakistan invested that money into afghanistan and the refugees were a punishment tot the taliban
Hi, i am from Afghanistan panjshir province and a tajik/persian by ethnicity. I want to say we Afghanistanis and pakistanis are brothers by faith, yes we have some political issues but faith is thicker than blood. You will see us in frontlines of jehad in support of our pakistani muslims when needed. Inshallah.
Then make sure that you not kill them first because otherwise there is nothing left for your Jihad 😃 You know evil is always destructed by itself be it on the long or short term. It is a law by nature but you do not believe i nature 🤣🤣🤣
Pakistan 🇵🇰 hosted Afghan brothers for 40 years,and Pakistan still hosts legal immigrants in the county, and we love and respect our Afghan brothers 😀. Pak-Afgha dosty zindabad.AA London UK 🇬🇧
Pakistan collected billions of dollars by the name of Afghan Refugees for 40-plus years, and not only gave nothing to Afghan refugees, but Pakistani police always robbed Afghans of their belongings, which they brought with them from Afghanistan , you have no shame
😞😞Pakistan collected billions of dollars by the name of Afghan Refugees for 40-plus years, and not only gave nothing to Afghan refugees, but Pakistani police always robbed Afghans of their belongings, which they brought with them from Afghanistan , you have no shame
Every country who host refugees get money from organization noting new the people were given no money the government got money not the people@@naftalikahn4559
We love the people of Pakistan, however, we’ve been betrayed by the government, army and ISI of Pakistan on numerous occasions. The whole world knows that Pakistan‘s army and military generals are for sale to the highest bidder. Too bad you missed opportunity to dive deep on the corruption of Pakistani generals, these generals betray not only afghans, but the Pakistani people themselves.
bro you are truly having a good heart for pakistanis . but trust me my afghan brother when the time comes and everything closes . the same people you thought you cared about will become your demise. an afghan from germany . zindbad afghanistan pak army murdabad punjab pakistan murdabad
@@Bigbootylicker88I'm a punjabi and I too hate our government and Isi like many punjabis. I consider myself muslim first therefore I love and respect all other Muslims despite their background but I have a genuine question, why do some Afghans hate on punjabis? (I see some punjabis hating on Afghans as well but I consider them nationalists which is literally as bad as kufr in Islam)
False generalised information. Pakistan helped the Afghans agaisnt the American Invaders and the Soviets. Although the sellout Musharraf helped the Americans, the Pakistani people burnt NATO supply trucks, protested and welcomed Afghan Muslim brothers
@@zulfizakarya5703 tell this love to Imran Khan and Asim Muneer, or much better, to Saudis and Iranis, who love each other soo so much. Wake up to reality madrassachhap
one thing you got wrong here, actually not every afghan military personal were kin for taliban. they literally hanged one famous afghan military general after they took over kabul.
This is riddled with misinformation.. Hamid Karzai and Amrullah Saleh fled Afghanistan moments before Taliban came to Kabul.. One can only guess what the Taliban would have done to them if they had stayed back.. where do you get such level of misinformation from so called “ geo political expert “ ..
North pakustanies are our blood brothers , we have same language culture food , yes we have some problems with pakistan government but not with pakustani people bcz we are one ummah and if they have problems with other nations we have to be on there side , we respect indians and pakistanies also , the problem is between governments not netween people , bcz we all are in same faith , sorry to say but look like you are trying to make us fight , no we will never be there enemies
@Kraken Thunder so much disasters in one comment cant point out all. First search how many rohingyas pakistan have. Then learn about difference between the words afghan and pashtun. To save your time its same actually. Pashtun is a title we got when we become muslims. Afghan is our national identity. Which means all pashtuns are afghans . If we talk about identity. But if we talk about citezenship so yes not all pashtuns are afghan citizens. And not all afghan citizens are afghans by nation. Its confusing right? Indians will not understand. Afghans on both sides of the border have communist socialists nationalist islamist. Etc. So it dosent matter which one comes in power in afghanistan. We have their reflection in pakistan too. Punjabis are our brothers not just pujabis but indian muslims too. Black white yellow brown we have all colors in our blood line we dont see color in people we see ideology. We have blue eyes gray hair white skin people brown and even blacks etc. Who shares same language and culture with us. Life is too short to hate some one. ❤
Pakistan is occupying Afghan soil for 65 years, the entire pashtune tribal territory is Afghan soil , the British annexed it due to politics during the 18th century and afghans did not have the military might to wage offensive war against British India , only defensive war was conducted. When the British left they take with them all agreements and contracts become null.
Pakhtunkhwa is pakistan British occupied it which means that it belongs to british and when they left they gave it to pakistan This is the china idealogy to take kp
Let’s remind the Indians who annexed parts of Afghanistan. It was a Punjabi Sikh Sardar by the name of Jarnail Hari Singh Nalwa from Gujranwala, who conquered Afghanistan. A Punjabi Jatt, the British took over the territory of Punjab which was sold to them by no other than the Hindu Maharaja Gulab Singh an opportunist Dogra who sold then India’s last line of defense for petty power.
Afghanistan is always had great friendship ❤️ God bless both countries now new afghan generation know better t🎉he enemy ISI with different agenda by name of tribes and language started civil wars in Afghanistan now we az afghans we are one nation pashtoon Tajik hazara huzbak one afghan . And always every Hard time india helped us its not about musilm or hindo its about humanity long live Afghanistan india.
But I think nobody told u about 1979 when Soviet union was fuc*ing Afghanistan, Pakistan was only country which helped u and due to the efforts of Pakistan Soviet army was compelled to leave Afghanistan
Afghanis these guys r referring to are like pdm supporters here in pakistan who are a minority. If majority of afghans opposed taliban, then they wont have taken over, plain and simple. The majority of afghans support taliban just like how majority of us pakistanis support imran khan or for that matter for better or worse how majority of hindus support modi. I hate modi myself but I cant deny the fact he has hindu support in india. Its better you people face facts too, that majority of afghans support taliban
Pakistan army is the cause of this hatred. Wrong policies. Pak and Afghan People love each other but both hate pak army especially after 9 May 2023, Army support is over and some big changes are on the way..............
I can confirm this, took a cab at SF airport and taxi driver was afghan, he asked where I was from and I replied India 🇮🇳 He was a translator who helped US army/ NAto and told me how Paxtaan was responsible for killing half of his family.
Start having a different conversation ranveer..... Same shit every video..asking same questions... "Geopolitical scenario".. Have a conversation man.. Do something interesting
Thankfully Imran Khan is more popular than AIM. And thats the reason AIM's U turns go unnoticed.😂 AIM has had non of his predictions correct. Non whatsoever. And neither has he claimed anything he said in this clip ever before. If he has, send me a link in the comments. What he has said is that India's foreign policy sucks. And here U turn 😂
Andre Reui, OW,RUSSIA bucatest,ROMANIA, South of France, The Coast of France, France, Savilla, Spain, Castillo, Spain, Madrid, Spain, Monaco, Geneva, Scotland, Venezuela, Honduras, Colombia, Mixhocaun, Puerta Vallarta, Perlita, Mexico to Mexico city Mexico, Kabul, Afghanistan, Suicide forest, Japan, Oculus Temple, Oregon, Ne
As a Tajik from Afghanistan listening to these so called experts makes me Laugh so hard 😂 First - Indian channels, RUclipsrs and Indian people are fed that Afghanistan means Pashtuns. Which is not true. 70 % of the Afghanistan population are not Pashtun (That is why? Every Indian Ambassador, embassy Staffs learn some Farsi before being posted to Afghanistan). We are Tajiks, Hazaras, Uzbeks etc… just like Hindi Language, Farsi is the national and link language of Afghanistan. Secondly, India will never be able to influence Afghanistan and the people of Afghanistan as much as Pakistan and Iran because we share borders and Afghanistan survival depends on each of them rather than India. Yes. India had helped Afghanistan in the past (We are thankful) but Afghanistan will never fight Pakistan on behalf of India. The tensions between Taliban and Pakistan is ethnically based rather strategically and also (I am not considering Taliban as the lawful Establishment of Afghanistan), they will go tomorrow or some day other than tomorrow). Pakistan doesn’t feel threatened yet by the Taliban. If they do, the chapter will turn because they will take their support of Taliban. How they will do it? By supporting Tajiks (they are still fighting in Panjshir). The moment Pakistan starts supporting non-Pashtuns in Afghanistan, all these border tensions will wrap up and so will the Taliban. Some idiots (Pashtun ethnically centred minds) from Afghanistan making noise, claiming some part of Pakistan based on Durand Border Agreements (Which is not reversible). I have always loved India because I have studied there. The people of India are beautiful, Kind and giving but I am starting to believe that India’s foreign policy is no more friendly. Evil inside and Afghanistan must be careful with India. Afghanistan’s peace stability does not depend on India but more on Pakistan and Iran.
I love how us pashtuns say that 60 percent of afghanistan is pashtun and then tajiks come and say they are 30 percent. Afghan was historically refered to pashtuns though yes recently its no longer that but now it means a citizen of afghanistan. We hate pakistan for supporting taliban, not just because pashtuns are there, those pashtuns dont even care about afghanistan anymore since they have not been part of it since the last 200 years. Those defenders in panjshir are shit, they dont have the support of pakistan or china to fight, hence theyll never win.
That's what even imran khan thought But now TTP is celebrating new year everyday Taliban is the ultimate ruler of Afghanistan, and they're more inclined towards India than Pakistan US, Soviet failed to eradicate Taliban, then the common people of Afghanistan or Pakistan shouldn't even dream about that
Afghans doesn’t hate Pakistanis. But afghans do hate Pakistan now due to Pakistan policies towards them. There was a time Afghanistan used to be considered Pakistan 5th province. Culturally afghans and Pakistanis especially northern Pakistanis are same people with same culture and customs. Common Pakistani doesn’t hate India either. It’s just politics
The issue is simple . Afghan were never in favor of Pakistan being created. Furthermore the British took Peshawar and left it to Pakistan. Do not fool yourself into believing the world is your friend .
😁 5th whatttt??? Pakistan is the 35th province of Afghans see afghans coming and going like it's their own territory! But what about pakistani? They can't even move in afghanistan See ur youtubers ... arrested 1000 times Afghans hate pakistan from their core of the heart ❤️ Terrorist factory 🏭🏭
@@maatira it was Afghans who sold Peshawar to the British in the first place and Afghans themselves refused Muslims entry into Afghanistan who were trying to escape colonialism.
Comman pakistani thrives on hating India and dreaming of ghazwa e hind😂 Pakistanis are fed hate for hindus in their school books. So it's definitely beyond politics. India China issue is more political with no hate among people.
I feel sorry for the Afghani people that despise and escaped the Talibans. Bet Talibans will have a field day with the Afghanis been thrown out of Pakistan. Bet if UN offered Pakistan funds for the Afghani refugees to be kept- Pakistan will keep them.They escaped the Talibans and now being thrown back to the Talibans.
Najeebullah was a KGB agent installed as President by Soviet Union, during the Soviet-Afghan war he killed thousands of Mujahdeens and their families. So he was brutally killed as an act of vengeance by the Taliban along with his brother. And he wasn't hung from a lamp post, he was hung from a basketball post. Taliban still has good relations with Pakistan and he was wrong that 'Haqqani Network screwed Pakistan' it's the HN that's is mainly screwing TTP in Afghanistan along with Pakistani special forces in secret ops along the Pak-Afghan borders. The distrust is in a section of IEA headed by Mullah Yaqub, who is the son of Mulla Omar but it also has a lot to do due to internal strife within the Afghan Taliban factions headed by Hibatullah Akhundzada, Mullah Baradar, HN, Mullah Yaqub etc. He's also wrong about Iran-IEA relations, they're not on good terms, have never been historically, just recently Iranian President Ibrahim Raisi threatened Afganistan over a water treaty on River Helmand and since IEA takeover there have been several incidents of violent clashed taking place between Iranian border forces and Afghan Taliban. Well clashed have also taken places with Pakistani and Tajik forces as well. Abhijit was wrong on a lot of counts in this 6-minute viideo clip.
Kabulis dislike pakistan for various reasons also they're not ethnis pakhtoons rather ethnic irani parsi type people the pakhtuns on afghan and pakistan side love pakistanis
If they can hate their host community pashtuns. In afghanistan we dont actually expect anything good from them. If they can hate tajik and uzbeks we dont expect anything good from them. If they can hate their own home country iran. We are too far for acceptance. Some people have these diseases of hatred. They Invited british soviets then U.S and nato. Just to keep them in power. I am refferring to few warlords of kabul not the common people. Their people lives in millions in Pakistan as a refugee. That is the reason pakistan is unique. We have accepted hazaras indian muslims bengalis rohingyas uzbeks tajiks pashtuns if you count host community of pakistan it is less than 100 million out of 220 million people. Still income equality is better than 99 percent of the countries. We accept and we love. Life is too short to hate someone.
We should avoid such discussions and certainly avoid uploading them on RUclips… This is not right… no need to discuss love and hate topics! Good professional relationship is what will help in the long run…With all nations ! Looks like it’s relatively easy to establish that with Afghanistan… whereas with Pakistan we need to help them get rid of their terrorists first!! So that needs some work!
When Russia invaded and killed Afghanistan India was with Russia, And when Americans invaded Afghanistan india was with America, This is just an international propaganda pakistan and Afghanistan are good friends and will remain good , India position in pak afghan matters is ,,begani shaddi mein abdullah dewana,,, Pakistan ❤Afghanistan
O paaji I've never heard so much rubbish in my life. There are more Pashtuns in Pakistan than in Afghanistan. Ask the Pakistani pashtuns if they like being part of Pakistan or not. Some of the most loyal Pakistanis are pashtuns my friend. Stop spreading misinformation to Indians. Yes Pakistani and Afghanistan governments have had there differences, but the majority of people of both sides support each other. Indians need to understand this.
India is playing its cards mich better, pakistan is faltering at maintaining balance among afghan refugees during drying of UN funds, domestic pashtun unrest, ttp intransigence, baloochi insurgency, kashmir failures, economic woes, american manouevres to maintain bases, chinese heartbreaks in investments, indian apathy to dialogues. Resultant afghan hostility to pak due to proposed phasewise expulsion of 44 lakh refugees will keep the pot boiling.
I remember growing up in Pakistan as a kid and millions (much more than official figures convey) Afghanis moved to Pakistan because of Soviet Union's invasion. Pakistanis were extremely worried that USSR would target Pakistan next. We all know what happened next. US won the war and defeated USSR, accelerating USSR's demise without a single American soldier firing an official shot. This was due to Pakistanis and on the front line due to Afghanis. I remember engineer Ahmed Shah Masood coming to visit universities in Karachi and trying to recruit Pakistani student volunteers for his group and many Pakistani student of religious persuasion went and fought with them. Millions of Afghani families basically settled in various areas of Pakistan and are for all practical purposes Pakistanis now. Officially I think the figure stands at 2.5 million refugees now but it ignores those who were able to get themselves Pakistani identity cards one way or another. Pakistani people showed them great compassion for over 35 years. There may be Afghani public and new generation (mainly expat Afghanis and their families) that does not remember that but the ones that do, I think will have a hard time justifying openly fighting Pakistan. Pakistanis consider them brothers and more Pashtuns are in Pakistan than in Afghanistan so if anything perhaps parts of Afghanistan should be in Pakistan and not the other way around by logic. If Indians think that partition should not have happened because culturally North India and Pakistan are similar, they should realize that besides Punjab province Pakistanis have much more commonality with Afghanistan and Persian culture as well. It just happens that Punjab province is the largest province population wise in Pakistan. Would be interesting to see how it plays out. This does not mean Afghanistan needs to be anti-India just to show that they are Pakistani friends. It is not a zero sum game. Obviously the karzai and Ghani government could not get a cohesive army together in a decade after American training and billions of dollars that believed in their version of Afghanistan enough to want to stand up and fight for it. You cannot blame anyone else for that.
@@areejshams3253 I wish I had visited India but I have not so pardon my ignorance. It seems that Indian Punjabi culture is still closer to Pakistani Punjab culture than say culture of GB to anything in India. Of course India is larger and has much more diversity from each corner.
@@areejshams3253 punjab is punjab. 😊there are some kashmiris in punjab but they have punjabi culture like nawaz sharif family. Khwajas in sialkot. Butts. Etc. 95 percent of punjab is punjabis which is similar to indian punjab most of them actually belonged to indian punjab in border districts. They migrated from india. And in return sikhs went to india. Indian hindu pujabis jatts or sikhs. Indian muslim punjabis and pakistani punjabi is same people. Pakistani punjab population is somewhere around 120 million. Still got the smaller portition of punjab. So if sikhs makes khalistan chandigarh will be the capital not lahore more muslim punjabis migrated than sikhs. Its maths.
it makes me sad seeing muslims uniting with hindus to destroy another muslim even though that muslim country helped more then the hindus every did just sad soviet war refuging so many afghanis doesnt make sense why afghanis would stab pakistan in the back after pakistan helping them for so long pakistan invested so much money in them sure pakistan did make money from afghanistan and they deported them but im preatty sure pakistan invested that money into afghanistan and the refugees were a punishment tot the taliban
So, the US never wants India to succeed, Afghans hate the US 50% and yet the US will ask the Taliban to keep honking Pakistan as Pak and China are getting closer , US doesn't want that The US uses Pakistan to keep us(India) busy with some or other things, The US needs India to contain China, Afghanistan and India will always remain good, India and Pakistan will never ever ever be in good terms unless the USA wants because the US controls the Pak Army + Pressure Armed groups.
im glad im alive here..... majority of the afghan have been to Pakistan .... once in their life. or so. and we always treat them like brothers. so the people are like brothers but there is a lot of hate towards the people who allowed usa to attack afghanistan... but it doesnt make sense. because the whole world gave permission to usa.... but we need to better our relations with afghanistan. because having alll 4 neigbours who hate us isnt good for us,. and lol India thinking ...... afghans and taliban love india lol yes sure ! ^ hahahahahaha
Keep Dreaming Indians and Afghans. I am a Pakistani PASHTUN. We Pasthuns are very loyal to Pakistan. InshAllah Karma spares no one. India will break into pieces just like it divided Pakistan in 1971 and to date dreams of dividing Pakistan.
see afganistan vs pak match and you can easily tell that how much afgan love pakistanis 😂 india loves afganistan because they love india 🇮🇳❤🇦🇫 and pakistan cant digest that
@@Win-5678 they also released all isis members now fighting them. Its called aam taatir. Hindus will not understand. Common forgiveness. Giving everyone a second chance. Even your national front members were forgiven warlords ex military officers you name it they forgive everyone.
while living in the USA ive found all afghan taxi drivers very very very friendly with indians. they are literaly overcome with pure friendship.
Americans intentionally did not destroy their weapons and vehicals. They wanted Taliban to get their hands on them and keep this region in trouble. They basically want to teach a lesson to Pakistan and make sure pakistan don't try any advantures in afganistan
but that same gov in US is showing full support to Pakistan
They don't want to teach Pak a lesson, They want war in Asia countries so tht they can sell their weapons..
They did that because taliban is actually the American ally in the region right now, it’s now that America wants to teach Pakistan a lesson, they did that by doing the regime change in Pakistan, economically dismantled Pakistan through that. That’s how wars are fought now, only proxy
@@surajraika7821 kabhi gala lagake peeche se choora marne wali kahawat suni hai?
Hahahahahahahaha You lindoooo know nothing
Ground realities
Our hate toward Pakistan is only because of the cooperation between Pentagon & ISI during the Cold War, which literally destroyed our beloved country Afghanistan. As an Afghan growing up in PK and now living in Germany only love for PK people. I love my Pakistani and Hindi friends here in Germany 🇦🇫🇵🇰🇮🇳❤️ let’s don’t hate each other. Btw. I love Indian geopolitical podcasts
Pentagon
If there is any war, we won't spare any Afghans residing in India.
love from india brother ❤❤🇮🇳
bro they helped you to fight against ussr, ofc there will be some destruction, if pentagon and isi were not there than the country would have been destroyed by russia.
@@NoneOfTheAbove123 You won’t do anything. You people are known for being pansies lmfao.
Afghanis have a great relationship with India. Afghan Royalties still live in areas of Dehradun-Mussoorie area. There is still a small Afghani Refugee camp ⛺near Rishikesh which recently got featured in some Indian TV 📺 shows. The Last President of Afghanistan 🇦🇫 was raised by his grandparents in Doon valley. Dehradun Cricket Stadium 🏟 serves as their 2nd Home Ground while many of their Army Officials were trained in Indian Military Academy (IMA) till 2021, when the Talibani's took over.
Afghanis u r referring to are like pdm supporters here in pakistan who are a minority. If majority of afghans opposed taliban, then they wont have taken over, plain and simple.
The majority of afghans support taliban just like how majority of us pakistanis support imran khan
@@cuttingstitching-dressmaki3016 Can't explain you things, that you don't want to hear. We are not here to solve problems for your country.
Sorry. You gotta do it yourself.
Warn the hypocrites that torturous punishment awaits them. The hypocrites take unbelievers as friends rather than believers. Do they look for honor at their hands? Truly all honor belongs to Allah. Quran 4:138-139
@@cuttingstitching-dressmaki3016 Believers! Do not take unbelievers as friends over fellow believers. Would you give Allah a clear reason to punish you? Quran 4:144
@@moholah3745 ok Done with your bullshit? Now getlost
Over 25 lacs afghani refugees living in Pakistan. Personally I know lots of afghanis who have become super rich in Pakistan and others who have a good life in Pakistan. Hating Pakistan only shows ungreatfulness and that never leads to anything good.
Dear, I am so sorry! As an Afghan I grow up in Pakistan and I am soooo grateful for that. I love my best friends over there in Islamabad. Pakistan is my second homeland. We afghans should hate only the ISI, which literally cooperated with the U.S. to ruin Afghanistan. I can’t understand the hate toward pak people at all🫶
@@parry5455 ❤️
Let's not confuse the people with the government.
In the early 2000s and 2010s. We used to live in a colony. We had a house with 3 portions. We lived on the 1st one and the ground and the second were for rent. My father always gave the 2nd portion to Afghanis. He never discriminated them in any way. There were a lot of Afghanis living in that colony. The local people welcomed them with open hearts. And if Afghanis still hate the PEOPLE of Pakistan, then they are nothing but hypocrites.
true dear
Afghanistan currently has problems with all of its neighbors but this is nothing new. They have always had problems with everyone around them. There are present border clashes with Iran over water and oil. None of this stops Afghans from wanting to live in Iran or Pakistan for that matter. There are so many Afghans living in Iran and Pakistan - if they really hated Pakistan or Afghanistan , then why is the dream of every Afghan to leave Afghanistan and move to its neighbors?
Ya because all these neighbors funded and supported terrorists in Afghanistan especially Pak,
I wish that Pakistan will never be peaceful.
We have ver good relationships with central Asian neighbors. Also, with China, we also have a good relationship with Iran. The only country we don't is Pakistan. we love pakistani people but hate the government
@@naweedanwari9787 We have good relations with everyone except India and its ally Afghanistan. We also love Afghan citizens which is why we have housed millions of Afghan refugees for decades but we hate the Afghan governments who have always been creating unrest and doing terrorism in Pakistan.
@@naweedanwari9787 soviet war giving refugee to 3 million people is crazy investing into afghanistan is crazy
The reason is called "WAR" or "DEATH" are you for reals?
As an afghan we don’t hate Pakistanis. Bcs they are our blood but we hate isi porki government
@Kraken Thunder I don’t mean Punjabi bcs the punjabis are ones who support isi
I mean Pashtuns Baloch wazir
Love from Pakistan Afghanis are our brothers our Muslims brothers ❤❤
They are not my blood, most afghans have zero connection to pakistan😂
The Pakistani Pashtuns and Baloch are our brothers, not sure about the rest.
@@pjr0167
I totally agree. Pakistanis and Indians are brothers because you share a culture and language.
8 days later Talibans are fighting Iran yet Abhijit says they are only wrong terms with Pakistan
Honestly it's a crime to let this man speak. Lying has limits too.
they are fighting because Iran tried to invade because of the water.
We afgnans dont hate pakistan india is capping hard
Lol 🤣
see the afganistan vs pakistan match
you will see the reality pakistani 😂
afganistan is true freiend of india and we indian love afganistan ❤❤🇮🇳🇦🇫
@@thanatos1243because Afghanistan is destroyed by Pakistan.
@@thanatos1243 that's a sporting rivalry, football had much more bloody fights even though between clubs of same country...
Your not Affghan
Wonderful podcast on geopolitical view, i strongly believe that tact and diplomacy is of highest importance, being atmanirbar and self reliance comes from people, new infrastructure and developments in different sectors...focusing on own development and growth, its is important to tap into to start ups that have high potential for financial and political gains...even start ups have lot of tie ups with organizations that work closely with governments and local corporations....focusing on things that lead to our own betterment is of utmost importance and ensuring the best for those around.....
I have newly found some interesting topics and am trying to know more to it.All of it started from your interesting podcasts.Thankyou Ranveer, for helping me expanding my knowledge towards the world🙂
Most of us Pakistanis have no hatred toward our Afghan brothers and sister, our government does not represent all of us as a whole, before we’re Afghan or Pakistani, we’re Muslims first ❤️
If ur govt. Does not represents u then stop calling yourself a JAMHURIAT whom u are making fool of? World or your own😂😂😂😂😂
@@shivapandey8503You absolute mug, Pakistan’s second biggest ethnic group is AFGHAN.
@@user-il1ey2ur3x mujhe q bata rha h apni govt. Ko bata jo unhe nikal rhe h NAPAKISTAN se.😆😆😆😆
@@user-il1ey2ur3xit's not afghan it's pastun pathan
@@generalthoughts123 Pashtun means Afghan. 😂😂 We’re the same people.
Kabuliwala is part of Indian childhood poem. There's natural affection
Afghan don't identify by their regions/city but by their tribes.
Famous and our guru Rabindranath Tagore
? Wo kaya ha
Yes it’s about an afghan killing another merchant right ? Talk about foreshadowing afghan Pakistan relations
Its not a poem but a Story by Rabindranath Tagore.
I grew up with the ppl from Afghanistan. They consider our country just like their own. While you still have some afghans that do hate Pakistan but just know that there more afghans in Pakistan than India. And we are still living together like brothers in Pakistan 🇵🇰❤️🇦🇫.
Afghan leader gave kpk to Pakistan
@@phylicia595kpk Pakistan ❤️🇵🇰
pakistan murdabad
Afghans only hate your establishment (Army, ISI), who are responsible for the atrocities that have been going on for over 40 years. I grew up in Pakistan and moved out of Pakistan over 30 years a go, but I still visit Pakistan.
Not now brother... 17 lakhs are out.
AIM is trying to say....we had a great relationship with them all the time except 2 yrs...that's why they hijacked our plane ...later followed by attacks by acquitters
Pakistani militants hijacked the plane, the released were Pakistanis. Yes Taliban let them use their territory.
Pakistani ISI and Pakistani Army with Pakistani militants hijacked the flight not Taliban. But Mullah Omar sheltered those people and helped Pakistan release the terrorists from Indian jail.
No. I don't think he had thought this thru completely about this one.
Bhai kya bakwaas logic hai
Indians always try to portray that Afghans hate Pakistan. Tell me how many Afghan refugees are in India before talking Afghan hate Pakistan. Period
I haven't watched the video but i know this will be BS. Only diaspora Afghans started hating Pakistan after 2001. Pakistan and Afghanistan are brothers, ask most locals.
The border between us is just an arbitrary line drawn by the British. Some people say Pakistan and India should be united but they dont realise that Pakistan and Afghanistan are MUCH closer.
Nope. Half truth. Eastern Pakistan Sindh and Punjab even Baluchistan are fairly similar to India. The Western part bordering Afghanistan is highly similar to ag. Historically much of Punjab Sindh was ruled by Sikhs after Afghans. In northern India Lodi Dynasty as well as Afghan nobles in even hindu empires were well known. Perspectives
@rajeevgangal542 only Punjab is similar to a small part of India. The people of Punjab and Sindh, however, are ethnically similar to North Indians. You can't say Balochistan is similar to India. The main people there are the Baloch and Pashtuns, who are both Iranic. There are also other groups but no Indic people except a small number of Sindhis. The complete Western and Northern parts of Pakistan are much more similar to Iran, Afghanistan, Central Asia, and South Western China.
@@rajeevgangal542 how is Baluchistan similar to India?
We are not brothers we hate Pakistan, we are pashtunes afghans and the only brothers we have are our own pashtune tribes on the other side of the durandline. The very existence of Pakistan is a threat to Afghanistan and it's identity.
Afghnistan hate Pakistan
i saw quiet a few videos from You Tube travel vlogger's.... on which Afghan's were openly hating Pakistan.... (Nomadic Shubam, Naa Anvesh)
Watch other vlogs by Pakistanis visiting Afghanistan where Afghans are very hospitable towards Pakistanis.
@@cruisesoetz1087 see afganistan vs pak match you will see the reality dude
we india and afganistan are brothers 🇮🇳❤🇦🇫
@@thanatos1243 napak army murdabad
@@thanatos1243 bro is talking about a cricket match being relations between people
as a Pakistani Taliban and Afghani people are very respected in our hearts a high status and love and respect they are our brothers we are ashamed as people our government did't support them but india just want both of us to fight but we both will fight you hopefully Inshallah 🫂🫂🫂Pak Afghan for me both are Muslims better can govern and we respect and love afghans our respected brothers we can sacrifice ourselves for you and same you are never going to hurt Pakistani Muslim people for me both are Muslim lands Islamic lands respected and should be protected we are one Islam is our country and we are it's county men afghans are better than us they are our brothers take your lies of nonsense with yourself you will always see both of us against you and america
SubhanAllah! I testify that we Afghans, as you all truly know within your hearts love you Pakistanis our Muslim brothers, by Allah we are created for nothing else but to worship Allah and that logic surpasses any race or ethnicity. Right now our dear Muslim brothers in Gaza are being slaughtered and famished to death our Muslim sisters, our Mothers and Fathers in Gaza are bleeding, what will we answer Allah? That is what worries us the most at the moment.
@@Pixel3 exactly right this is in the hearts and minds of every Muslim now
mention pakistan again in the titles...india is obsessed...
we are always worried about our son
@@thanatos1243 you are step dad.
@@Adi-gh9du which is why we have keep fókin them up from time to time, incest relationships are forbidden in Hinduism unlike Islam
I met Afghans in the US and surprisingly they were very warm towards India and held somewhat negative attitude towards Pakistan. I was also very surprised by their opinion
Half of Pakistan is AFGHAN TERRITORY!
We should first get our TERRITORY!
As per nationalist hindus , full Afghanistan is Indian territory… to make it akahad bahrat , the bull shitt is endless …
@@doityourselfpakistan6535 🤣🤣🤣
@@doityourselfpakistan6535 your English proves your proper pakistani 🤣
@@inthebox2339 the things which i have said proves that ur ass just got burned :D
@@inthebox2339 we speak our own language proudly, you speak the language of your raping colonisers proudly.
You indiansss r living in Fooools paradise
I m pakhtoooon from pakistan have sooo many friends from Afghanistan, living in punjab province in pakistan very happily
Yes there are Some political issues but to be very honest things have changed now ! We pakistanis nd afghans r Muslims first
Islam comes first for us
Pakistan zindabad
Afghanistan zindabad
Terrorism zindabad😂😂
@@irose4066 Gao mutar zindabad. Jal gayi Hindu ki. Gali men tatti karne wale ki jalgyi.
These fouls believe Pakistani pashtoon nd Afghan pashtoon will fight against Pakistan. Remember Hindus we are Muslims we have differences nd we express those differences openly unlike hypocrite Hindus but when it's come to war you will find pashtoon, baloch, Sindi, kashmiri in front row against you ... punjabi will be last to stand
Pakistan must take responsibility. 1. Honor Durant agreement 2. Return 40 billion ( for reconstruction) collected by Pakistan to destroy Afghanistan.
If these TWO issue is solved - Afghanistan will be gooood neighbor.
im prtty sure pakistan invested like alot into afghanistan so the second one is already done
Visited Pakistan and saw many Afghans across Pakistan. Many afghans also own properties and busineses in Rawalpindi.
My Afghan friends have thriving business here
Those who think that majority afghan hate Pakistan are those who though, hamid karzai was pm of afg and will be able to defend the govt.
I am Pakhtoon from KPK and Afghanis are our brothers and sisters, we live,go to same Masjid,funeral,wedding etc
If Afghani hate Pakistan, they have rights to hate because our Army took dollars for the blood of Afghanis, The irony we Pakistani hate our own Army because they are involve in politics.
Also what was the army supposed to when the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan they were gonna invade us next
It was just a propagandist that america made and Pakistan army for dollar move in
In reality, from bottom of his heart, Ranbir puchna chah rha tha:::Kya Yeti and aliens Pakistan ko hate kerte hai?????
🤔🤔 . Yeti toh nahi karte
we love our afgan brothers ❤❤❤🇮🇳🇦🇫
So do u also love abdali and gaznawe?
@@urdad2955 bro those are porki names used just to tease India and Afghanistan . jai hind jai afghanistan
pakistan murdabad
@@urdad2955 lol endians always silent there
@@driftmaniac689lol spelling 🤡🤡
afghans and indians are literally not even the same ethnicity you panjeet
WE AFGHANS dont hate pakistani peoples they r so kind peoples but thier Government policies we r always against .they always wanted to destory our country without any mercy on us
I'm kashmiri
The Quran and the Prophet Muhammad both emphasized the importance of unity and integration among Muslims. Afghans are our brothers and we all should stick together as brothers no matter what happens. As the prophet muhammed pabu would of wanted!!
We all need to wake up and stop this nonsense.
I’m Kashmiri also but afghans some they’re affected by ethnic nationalism some of them that’s why they support India against Muslims shame
After a decade, Abhijit change his old T shirt
😂😂😂😂😂We afghans consider Pakistanis to be our brothers, maybe some afghans who want indian citizenship might say that
Pakistani detected
@@akashvalsan6609 😂😂😂😂the truth hurts
@@mohpat9989ou know how to speak 😂😂😂 miracle
@@Pranay_singh_ 😂😂😂😂😜only a hindutva terorrist will say that
Jealous porki spotted...Abe jaake bheekh ki line main lag.
we have kabuli pulao as part of our indian dish unfortunately we used kabuli channa instead of beef and pass it of as kabuli pulao/pulav
“Anything to avoid office work.” - Taliban 2023
“And hold fast by the covenant of Allah all together and be not disunited, and remember the favor of Allah on you when you were enemies, then He united your hearts so by His favor you became brethren; and you were on the brink of a pit of fire…” [Quran, 3:103]
I'm a Pakistani and i agree that there might be some differneces that escalted to conflicts and even hatred from both sides, but for the sake of Allah, i love my Afghan brothers and sisters and will never wish anything bad upon them.
We are Muslims first and no God fearing individual will hate an innocent Muslim, especially the ones that are oppressed.
blahblahblah pfffffffffffffffffff 😛😜🤪. Thanks to your PM soon their will be no Pakistan.
They r not muslim first though. They r pathans.
U have given up ur identity so nothing left except islam.
Except indian subcontinent muslims no one is "first" a muslim.
Allah is not real a mythical character made to influence people nothing more.....
@@himanshugurjar9002 bro we are pathans and muslims. who are you to decide if i am hindu or muslim. i am muslim but we still hate pakistan and love india.
and thats because they always supported terror against us and doesnt re unite us with our blood brothers.
Brother dont buy their propaganda. Afghanis u r referring to are like pdm supporters here in pakistan who are a minority. If majority of afghans opposed taliban, then they wont have taken over, plain and simple.
The majority of afghans support taliban just like how majority of us pakistanis support imran khan
It was fixed.
Their President Ashraf Ghani knew exactly what was coming and he played it to his advantage when he siphoned millions of dollars and fled to Dubai. For him, it was a blessing in disguise. As a matter of fact, the Taliban had many supporters within the then-Govt. The Afghan Army perhaps handed over the country on a platter.
Unfortunately, now the West has to bare the brunt. Well, the West shouldn't have gone there in the first place. The US lost 2.3 trillion USD in the process. Afghan Govt kept half of that. The poor women and kids are now suffering.
All your concern is about $3 trillions. What about the people killed by west in Afghan? In the name of democracy and fight against terrorism, US is the biggest human rights abuser
it makes me sad seeing muslims uniting with hindus to destroy another muslim even though that muslim country helped more then the hindus every did just sad soviet war refuging so many afghanis doesnt make sense why afghanis would stab pakistan in the back after pakistan helping them for so long pakistan invested so much money in them sure pakistan did make money from afghanistan and they deported them but im preatty sure pakistan invested that money into afghanistan and the refugees were a punishment tot the taliban
Ye laya na bro podcast😎
Hi, i am from Afghanistan panjshir province and a tajik/persian by ethnicity.
I want to say we Afghanistanis and pakistanis are brothers by faith, yes we have some political issues but faith is thicker than blood. You will see us in frontlines of jehad in support of our pakistani muslims when needed. Inshallah.
so why taliban is bombing the pakistanis mosques and schools
What can we expect from quam lover🎉
Then make sure that you not kill them first because otherwise there is nothing left for your Jihad 😃
You know evil is always destructed by itself be it on the long or short term. It is a law by nature but you do not believe i nature 🤣🤣🤣
In Sha Allah
Yes we saw how Haqqani is treating you people. Good taqqaiva try but don't try again
Pakistan 🇵🇰 hosted Afghan brothers for 40 years,and Pakistan still hosts legal immigrants in the county, and we love and respect our Afghan brothers 😀.
Pak-Afgha dosty zindabad.AA London UK 🇬🇧
Pakistan collected billions of dollars by the name of Afghan Refugees for 40-plus years, and not only gave nothing to Afghan refugees, but Pakistani police always robbed Afghans of their belongings,
which they brought with them from Afghanistan
, you have no shame
😞😞Pakistan collected billions of dollars by the name of Afghan Refugees for 40-plus years, and not only gave nothing to Afghan refugees, but Pakistani police always robbed Afghans of their belongings,
which they brought with them from Afghanistan
, you have no shame
Every country who host refugees get money from organization noting new the people were given no money the government got money not the people@@naftalikahn4559
Afghanistan, Iran and pakistan are brothers. Period. We are muslims we are one ummah.❤
We love the people of Pakistan, however, we’ve been betrayed by the government, army and ISI of Pakistan on numerous occasions. The whole world knows that Pakistan‘s army and military generals are for sale to the highest bidder. Too bad you missed opportunity to dive deep on the corruption of Pakistani generals, these generals betray not only afghans, but the Pakistani people themselves.
bro you are truly having a good heart for pakistanis . but trust me my afghan brother when the time comes and everything closes . the same people you thought you cared about will become your demise. an afghan from germany . zindbad afghanistan pak army murdabad punjab pakistan murdabad
@@Bigbootylicker88I'm a punjabi and I too hate our government and Isi like many punjabis. I consider myself muslim first therefore I love and respect all other Muslims despite their background but I have a genuine question, why do some Afghans hate on punjabis? (I see some punjabis hating on Afghans as well but I consider them nationalists which is literally as bad as kufr in Islam)
False generalised information. Pakistan helped the Afghans agaisnt the American Invaders and the Soviets. Although the sellout Musharraf helped the Americans, the Pakistani people burnt NATO supply trucks, protested and welcomed Afghan Muslim brothers
No they didn’t help Afghanistan but destroyed together with the Americans Afghanistan.
Best yet to come. ❤❤
Sooo many Pakistanis are triggered in the comments section. 😂😂😂 Love it.
It's such a catharsis to see them in turmoil. Ah the relief.
Pajeet start all out war you will se Afghan brothers fighting with you .
No hate can be greater than the love one Muslim has for another
@@zulfizakarya5703 🤣
Gay Shri ram 😂
@@mountainleopard5370 still better than a pedophile prophet. 😂
@@zulfizakarya5703 tell this love to Imran Khan and Asim Muneer, or much better, to Saudis and Iranis, who love each other soo so much. Wake up to reality madrassachhap
one thing you got wrong here, actually not every afghan military personal were kin for taliban. they literally hanged one famous afghan military general after they took over kabul.
This is riddled with misinformation..
Hamid Karzai and Amrullah Saleh fled Afghanistan moments before Taliban came to Kabul..
One can only guess what the Taliban would have done to them if they had stayed back..
where do you get such level of misinformation from so called “ geo political expert “ ..
North pakustanies are our blood brothers , we have same language culture food , yes we have some problems with pakistan government but not with pakustani people bcz we are one ummah and if they have problems with other nations we have to be on there side , we respect indians and pakistanies also , the problem is between governments not netween people , bcz we all are in same faith , sorry to say but look like you are trying to make us fight , no we will never be there enemies
@Kraken Thunder so much disasters in one comment cant point out all.
First search how many rohingyas pakistan have.
Then learn about difference between the words afghan and pashtun. To save your time its same actually.
Pashtun is a title we got when we become muslims. Afghan is our national identity.
Which means all pashtuns are afghans .
If we talk about identity.
But if we talk about citezenship so yes not all pashtuns are afghan citizens.
And not all afghan citizens are afghans by nation.
Its confusing right?
Indians will not understand.
Afghans on both sides of the border have communist socialists nationalist islamist. Etc.
So it dosent matter which one comes in power in afghanistan.
We have their reflection in pakistan too. Punjabis are our brothers not just pujabis but indian muslims too. Black white yellow brown we have all colors in our blood line we dont see color in people we see ideology.
We have blue eyes gray hair white skin people brown and even blacks etc. Who shares same language and culture with us. Life is too short to hate some one. ❤
If you read the history it was afghan warlords who beat every Indian king and captured India
We didn’t beat every Indian king, we like India, we don’t like Pakistan
Good work...
Muhammad (pbuh) said: "Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him" (Bukhari 9.84.57).
Kya taliban me sab ‘yeti’ hai?
All Muslim brother pak army zindbad afg Taliban zindbad
@@saadniazi3117what about thise muslim brothers of your in pak taliban?😂
@@saadniazi3117yar atta ka jugaad karo baad ne ummaaah banana bhai
Khud ke khane ke vandhe hai ...😂😂pehle imran ko bacha lo bd me aana
@@saadniazi3117 Taliban did great job in Peshawar aps 😂
Pakistan is occupying Afghan soil for 65 years, the entire pashtune tribal territory is Afghan soil , the British annexed it due to politics during the 18th century and afghans did not have the military might to wage offensive war against British India , only defensive war was conducted. When the British left they take with them all agreements and contracts become null.
Pakhtunkhwa is pakistan
British occupied it which means that it belongs to british and when they left they gave it to pakistan
This is the china idealogy to take kp
Half of afghanistan is Persian and belongs to Iran and Tajikistan
Let’s remind the Indians who annexed parts of Afghanistan. It was a Punjabi Sikh Sardar by the name of Jarnail Hari Singh Nalwa from Gujranwala, who conquered Afghanistan. A Punjabi Jatt, the British took over the territory of Punjab which was sold to them by no other than the Hindu Maharaja Gulab Singh an opportunist Dogra who sold then India’s last line of defense for petty power.
Jao jaake bheekh ki line main lago...yeh sab bakwaas karne se bheekh nahi milegi.
Beggers with opinion is weird 😂😂😂😂
😂😂 joker
@@Vishwas0804IKR
Yeah look who's talking the ílligītīmate descendants of that nashedī Moootlīm Jahangir that allowed British to form Presidencies and Recruit Soldiers.
Afghanistan is always had great friendship ❤️ God bless both countries now new afghan generation know better t🎉he enemy ISI with different agenda by name of tribes and language started civil wars in Afghanistan now we az afghans we are one nation pashtoon Tajik hazara huzbak one afghan . And always every Hard time india helped us its not about musilm or hindo its about humanity long live Afghanistan india.
True brother
india love afganistan ❤❤
But I think nobody told u about 1979 when Soviet union was fuc*ing Afghanistan, Pakistan was only country which helped u and due to the efforts of Pakistan Soviet army was compelled to leave Afghanistan
Afghanis these guys r referring to are like pdm supporters here in pakistan who are a minority. If majority of afghans opposed taliban, then they wont have taken over, plain and simple.
The majority of afghans support taliban just like how majority of us pakistanis support imran khan or for that matter for better or worse how majority of hindus support modi. I hate modi myself but I cant deny the fact he has hindu support in india. Its better you people face facts too, that majority of afghans support taliban
He never says that they don't.
Old Indian movies always potraied Afgani as shrew but very caring people.
Pakistan army is the cause of this hatred. Wrong policies. Pak and Afghan People love each other but both hate pak army especially after 9 May 2023, Army support is over and some big changes are on the way..............
Tiger force is going to take over the Pakistani defence?
the afghani taliban tiktokers gulp there gonna take down pakistan
I can confirm this, took a cab at SF airport and taxi driver was afghan, he asked where I was from and I replied India 🇮🇳
He was a translator who helped US army/ NAto and told me how Paxtaan was responsible for killing half of his family.
Start having a different conversation ranveer..... Same shit every video..asking same questions... "Geopolitical scenario".. Have a conversation man.. Do something interesting
if you dont like geopoltics then dont watch problem solved
should he have asked about wildlife and best coaching centre for SATs in Afghanistan ??
no one forced you to watch.... get a life dude
Apparently It's the hot topic in the country. People are loving it so expect some more.
Thankfully Imran Khan is more popular than AIM. And thats the reason AIM's U turns go unnoticed.😂
AIM has had non of his predictions correct. Non whatsoever. And neither has he claimed anything he said in this clip ever before. If he has, send me a link in the comments.
What he has said is that India's foreign policy sucks. And here U turn 😂
Your analysis that Afghanistan 2.0 is having good relations with Iran is not coming true. Fighting already happening.
We love our Indian brothers 🇦🇫 🇮🇳
Correction Iran and Afghanistan is fighting for water issue
Is he the famous meme guy of 2019 😂
Andre Reui, OW,RUSSIA bucatest,ROMANIA, South of France, The Coast of France, France, Savilla, Spain, Castillo, Spain, Madrid, Spain, Monaco, Geneva, Scotland, Venezuela, Honduras, Colombia, Mixhocaun, Puerta Vallarta, Perlita, Mexico to Mexico city Mexico, Kabul, Afghanistan, Suicide forest, Japan, Oculus Temple, Oregon, Ne
*real Muslims will never fight each other*
As a Tajik from Afghanistan listening to these so called experts makes me Laugh so hard 😂
First - Indian channels, RUclipsrs and Indian people are fed that Afghanistan means Pashtuns. Which is not true. 70 % of the Afghanistan population are not Pashtun (That is why? Every Indian Ambassador, embassy Staffs learn some Farsi before being posted to Afghanistan). We are Tajiks, Hazaras, Uzbeks etc… just like Hindi Language, Farsi is the national and link language of Afghanistan.
Secondly, India will never be able to influence Afghanistan and the people of Afghanistan as much as Pakistan and Iran because we share borders and Afghanistan survival depends on each of them rather than India.
Yes. India had helped Afghanistan in the past (We are thankful) but Afghanistan will never fight Pakistan on behalf of India. The tensions between Taliban and Pakistan is ethnically based rather strategically and also (I am not considering Taliban as the lawful Establishment of Afghanistan), they will go tomorrow or some day other than tomorrow).
Pakistan doesn’t feel threatened yet by the Taliban. If they do, the chapter will turn because they will take their support of Taliban. How they will do it? By supporting Tajiks (they are still fighting in Panjshir). The moment Pakistan starts supporting non-Pashtuns in Afghanistan, all these border tensions will wrap up and so will the Taliban. Some idiots (Pashtun ethnically centred minds) from Afghanistan making noise, claiming some part of Pakistan based on Durand Border Agreements (Which is not reversible).
I have always loved India because I have studied there. The people of India are beautiful, Kind and giving but I am starting to believe that India’s foreign policy is no more friendly. Evil inside and Afghanistan must be careful with India. Afghanistan’s peace stability does not depend on India but more on Pakistan and Iran.
I love how us pashtuns say that 60 percent of afghanistan is pashtun and then tajiks come and say they are 30 percent. Afghan was historically refered to pashtuns though yes recently its no longer that but now it means a citizen of afghanistan. We hate pakistan for supporting taliban, not just because pashtuns are there, those pashtuns dont even care about afghanistan anymore since they have not been part of it since the last 200 years. Those defenders in panjshir are shit, they dont have the support of pakistan or china to fight, hence theyll never win.
Gul Khan ka bacha.
All India wants a Stable, developing & prosperous Afghanistan...🎉
Pak wants to exploit Afghan & to be Pakistani slaves (total dependable on Pak)
That's what even imran khan thought
But now TTP is celebrating new year everyday
Taliban is the ultimate ruler of Afghanistan, and they're more inclined towards India than Pakistan
US, Soviet failed to eradicate Taliban, then the common people of Afghanistan or Pakistan shouldn't even dream about that
Good man these Indians have agenda , to divide thats what they r currently doing in there country.
Afghans doesn’t hate Pakistanis. But afghans do hate Pakistan now due to Pakistan policies towards them. There was a time Afghanistan used to be considered Pakistan 5th province. Culturally afghans and Pakistanis especially northern Pakistanis are same people with same culture and customs.
Common Pakistani doesn’t hate India either. It’s just politics
The issue is simple . Afghan were never in favor of Pakistan being created. Furthermore the British took Peshawar and left it to Pakistan. Do not fool yourself into believing the world is your friend .
😁 5th whatttt???
Pakistan is the 35th province of Afghans see afghans coming and going like it's their own territory!
But what about pakistani?
They can't even move in afghanistan
See ur youtubers ... arrested 1000 times
Afghans hate pakistan from their core of the heart ❤️
Terrorist factory 🏭🏭
@@maatira it was Afghans who sold Peshawar to the British in the first place and Afghans themselves refused Muslims entry into Afghanistan who were trying to escape colonialism.
Sold to british not u.
Comman pakistani thrives on hating India and dreaming of ghazwa e hind😂 Pakistanis are fed hate for hindus in their school books. So it's definitely beyond politics. India China issue is more political with no hate among people.
Taliban 3.0 ka update kab ayega?
I feel sorry for the Afghani people that despise and escaped the Talibans. Bet Talibans will have a field day with the Afghanis been thrown out of Pakistan. Bet if UN offered Pakistan funds for the Afghani refugees to be kept- Pakistan will keep them.They escaped the Talibans and now being thrown back to the Talibans.
Najeebullah was a KGB agent installed as President by Soviet Union, during the Soviet-Afghan war he killed thousands of Mujahdeens and their families. So he was brutally killed as an act of vengeance by the Taliban along with his brother. And he wasn't hung from a lamp post, he was hung from a basketball post. Taliban still has good relations with Pakistan and he was wrong that 'Haqqani Network screwed Pakistan' it's the HN that's is mainly screwing TTP in Afghanistan along with Pakistani special forces in secret ops along the Pak-Afghan borders. The distrust is in a section of IEA headed by Mullah Yaqub, who is the son of Mulla Omar but it also has a lot to do due to internal strife within the Afghan Taliban factions headed by Hibatullah Akhundzada, Mullah Baradar, HN, Mullah Yaqub etc.
He's also wrong about Iran-IEA relations, they're not on good terms, have never been historically, just recently Iranian President Ibrahim Raisi threatened Afganistan over a water treaty on River Helmand and since IEA takeover there have been several incidents of violent clashed taking place between Iranian border forces and Afghan Taliban. Well clashed have also taken places with Pakistani and Tajik forces as well. Abhijit was wrong on a lot of counts in this 6-minute viideo clip.
Iran and Taliban have just started fighting 😂😂 hardly 2 weeks after this podcast. what prediction
ओके चैनल ने कहा यह तो बहुत पहले से No No ❤❤😂😂😊😊 ciao
Kabulis dislike pakistan for various reasons also they're not ethnis pakhtoons rather ethnic irani parsi type people the pakhtuns on afghan and pakistan side love pakistanis
If they can hate their host community pashtuns. In afghanistan we dont actually expect anything good from them.
If they can hate tajik and uzbeks we dont expect anything good from them.
If they can hate their own home country iran. We are too far for acceptance.
Some people have these diseases of hatred.
They Invited british soviets then U.S and nato. Just to keep them in power. I am refferring to few warlords of kabul not the common people.
Their people lives in millions in Pakistan as a refugee.
That is the reason pakistan is unique.
We have accepted hazaras indian muslims bengalis rohingyas uzbeks tajiks pashtuns if you count host community of pakistan it is less than 100 million out of 220 million people.
Still income equality is better than 99 percent of the countries.
We accept and we love. Life is too short to hate someone.
Afghnistan hate Pakistan afghanistan is against Pakistan
I'm pakistani patan Pakistan zindabad
We should avoid such discussions and certainly avoid uploading them on RUclips…
This is not right… no need to discuss love and hate topics!
Good professional relationship is what will help in the long run…With all nations !
Looks like it’s relatively easy to establish that with Afghanistan… whereas with Pakistan we need to help them get rid of their terrorists first!! So that needs some work!
When Russia invaded and killed Afghanistan India was with Russia,
And when Americans invaded Afghanistan india was with America,
This is just an international propaganda pakistan and Afghanistan are good friends and will remain good ,
India position in pak afghan matters is ,,begani shaddi mein abdullah dewana,,,
Pakistan ❤Afghanistan
😂😂 India is never with anyone 😂 “Non alignment literally means that😂
Why are the eyes so wide in the thumbnail 😂
But Najibullah got killed in 1996.
I am a proud Pakistani and I love Afghanistan and Afghans❤❤❤. And yes I hate my present govt
O paaji I've never heard so much rubbish in my life. There are more Pashtuns in Pakistan than in Afghanistan. Ask the Pakistani pashtuns if they like being part of Pakistan or not. Some of the most loyal Pakistanis are pashtuns my friend. Stop spreading misinformation to Indians. Yes Pakistani and Afghanistan governments have had there differences, but the majority of people of both sides support each other. Indians need to understand this.
Yeah you've successfully brainwashed some pashtuns, no wonder there is no pashto education and history in pakistan.
Lol every vlogger fone to afghanistan jabe abused.. 😂
But the thing is does the consent of pakistani pashtuns matter ?
Taliban will purge them to achieve the goals they've set
@@blaze7177 most Pakistani Pashtun are talbliban
Ttp and Pakistani Taliban are Pashtun. Afghan Taliban are also pashtuns
And yet they are willing to pay 4-5 million for Pakistani nationality.
Why
Your nextt vlog.should be onn, Why India hates Pakistan..
India is playing its cards mich better, pakistan is faltering at maintaining balance among afghan refugees during drying of UN funds, domestic pashtun unrest, ttp intransigence, baloochi insurgency, kashmir failures, economic woes, american manouevres to maintain bases, chinese heartbreaks in investments, indian apathy to dialogues. Resultant afghan hostility to pak due to proposed phasewise expulsion of 44 lakh refugees will keep the pot boiling.
indians want to see afghans and Pakistanis fight
We love afghans and iranians. period. Who cares about paki
I remember growing up in Pakistan as a kid and millions (much more than official figures convey) Afghanis moved to Pakistan because of Soviet Union's invasion. Pakistanis were extremely worried that USSR would target Pakistan next. We all know what happened next. US won the war and defeated USSR, accelerating USSR's demise without a single American soldier firing an official shot. This was due to Pakistanis and on the front line due to Afghanis. I remember engineer Ahmed Shah Masood coming to visit universities in Karachi and trying to recruit Pakistani student volunteers for his group and many Pakistani student of religious persuasion went and fought with them. Millions of Afghani families basically settled in various areas of Pakistan and are for all practical purposes Pakistanis now. Officially I think the figure stands at 2.5 million refugees now but it ignores those who were able to get themselves Pakistani identity cards one way or another. Pakistani people showed them great compassion for over 35 years. There may be Afghani public and new generation (mainly expat Afghanis and their families) that does not remember that but the ones that do, I think will have a hard time justifying openly fighting Pakistan. Pakistanis consider them brothers and more Pashtuns are in Pakistan than in Afghanistan so if anything perhaps parts of Afghanistan should be in Pakistan and not the other way around by logic. If Indians think that partition should not have happened because culturally North India and Pakistan are similar, they should realize that besides Punjab province Pakistanis have much more commonality with Afghanistan and Persian culture as well. It just happens that Punjab province is the largest province population wise in Pakistan. Would be interesting to see how it plays out. This does not mean Afghanistan needs to be anti-India just to show that they are Pakistani friends. It is not a zero sum game. Obviously the karzai and Ghani government could not get a cohesive army together in a decade after American training and billions of dollars that believed in their version of Afghanistan enough to want to stand up and fight for it. You cannot blame anyone else for that.
Only a small part of Pakistan's Punjab is similar to India's Punjab.
@@areejshams3253 I wish I had visited India but I have not so pardon my ignorance. It seems that Indian Punjabi culture is still closer to Pakistani Punjab culture than say culture of GB to anything in India. Of course India is larger and has much more diversity from each corner.
@@areejshams3253 punjab is punjab. 😊there are some kashmiris in punjab but they have punjabi culture like nawaz sharif family. Khwajas in sialkot. Butts. Etc. 95 percent of punjab is punjabis which is similar to indian punjab most of them actually belonged to indian punjab in border districts. They migrated from india. And in return sikhs went to india.
Indian hindu pujabis jatts or sikhs. Indian muslim punjabis and pakistani punjabi is same people. Pakistani punjab population is somewhere around 120 million. Still got the smaller portition of punjab.
So if sikhs makes khalistan chandigarh will be the capital not lahore more muslim punjabis migrated than sikhs. Its maths.
it makes me sad seeing muslims uniting with hindus to destroy another muslim even though that muslim country helped more then the hindus every did just sad soviet war refuging so many afghanis doesnt make sense why afghanis would stab pakistan in the back after pakistan helping them for so long pakistan invested so much money in them sure pakistan did make money from afghanistan and they deported them but im preatty sure pakistan invested that money into afghanistan and the refugees were a punishment tot the taliban
Afghans invaded India the most
Why they are after genital be it men or women?
Right now in sub continent region Afghanistan is playing as Pakistan, Pakistan is playing as India, and India is playing as America.
So, the US never wants India to succeed,
Afghans hate the US 50% and yet the US will ask the Taliban to keep honking Pakistan as Pak and China are getting closer , US doesn't want that
The US uses Pakistan to keep us(India) busy with some or other things,
The US needs India to contain China,
Afghanistan and India will always remain good,
India and Pakistan will never ever ever be in good terms unless the USA wants because the US controls the Pak Army + Pressure Armed groups.
No
Tf are you talking about
Shouldn't he be not talking these things!
This guy's analysis was not good.
Whenever I hear him
im glad im alive here.....
majority of the afghan have been to Pakistan .... once in their life. or so. and we always treat them like brothers. so the people are like brothers but there is a lot of hate towards the people who allowed usa to attack afghanistan... but it doesnt make sense. because the whole world gave permission to usa.... but we need to better our relations with afghanistan. because having alll 4 neigbours who hate us isnt good for us,.
and lol India thinking ...... afghans and taliban love india lol
yes sure ! ^
hahahahahaha
As an Afghan who lives in Norway. You’re very right. I’ve personally visited pakistan through the khyber pass with my familly
@@jamalsjamalse thank you brother
Hindi mai kra kro episode. Kl bla v pura English mai kiya. I am big fan ur episodes
Sab ko hindi nahi aati na isiliye
Keep Dreaming Indians and Afghans.
I am a Pakistani PASHTUN.
We Pasthuns are very loyal to Pakistan.
InshAllah Karma spares no one. India will break into pieces just like it divided Pakistan in 1971 and to date dreams of dividing Pakistan.
😂😂😂😂😂 kya joke mara!! Ek Modiji, shahji,Yogiji se Pakistan ki sare musalmano ko itna daar Aisa Yogi toh hazaro aayenge.
ISPR k chode, naam Hassan hai tera, khud ko Pashtun bataa rha hai?! 😂😂😂 Jhooth toh dimaag lagaa k bola karo bhikhmango.
Mulq mein aag lagi padi hai, iss bhikhari ko Ghazwa-e-Hind krna hai.😂
Your religion is paying karma . Muslims invaded torture killed and looted native of india. So looks like you are paying karma.
@@supriyapan2276 Jaise Dawood Ibrahim se sab Hinduo ko dar? 😂
Leaf beside his lips looks like he grown up moustache 😅
Baluchistan is yours!! cry more for Baluchistan.
We don't want it afghans want it stupid 😂😂😂
I am a proud Baloch from Pakistan. Those freedom fighters are Indian spys.
This is some wild form of Indian propaganda 😂 they really think the Taliban is against Pakistan lol
Study about 300 attacks by ttp from 2022😂😂famous one being destroying of mosque recently😂
Taliban hates Pakistan mate
@@Sanatan_in and same taliban released 100s of TTP from afghan jail when ever they took afghan 😂.
see afganistan vs pak match and you can easily tell that how much afgan love pakistanis 😂
india loves afganistan because they love india 🇮🇳❤🇦🇫
and pakistan cant digest that
@@Win-5678 they also released all isis members now fighting them.
Its called aam taatir. Hindus will not understand.
Common forgiveness. Giving everyone a second chance.
Even your national front members were forgiven warlords ex military officers you name it they forgive everyone.
Ye comment section ko to bawasir ho gaya😂😂😂
hamid karjai ran off before getting handed by taliban
Yeh Nayee Laya hai TAALIBAN 1.0 AND 2.0 😂