Dunki Movie Analysis: Hit or Flop? | What Really Didn't Work? | Shah Rukh, Taapsee | Honest Review

Поделиться
HTML-код

Комментарии • 939

  • @mensxp
    @mensxp  11 месяцев назад +3

    If you liked this HONEST REVIEW, SUBSCRIBE to MensXP Channel for more such reviews: ruclips.net/channel/UC7eZNThpjgXe5H0QwBN-XsQ

    • @Shivamgupta-pc5gf
      @Shivamgupta-pc5gf 11 месяцев назад

      That exactly is the point of the movie.That the we didn't need visas 140 years ago and that national security is linked to immigration.Thats just stupid.
      Educate yourself.I will tell you how..Watch Inside job(2010),the big short,jawan and then Dunki.Suddenly,your outlook will change.The real culprits are the rich and the rigged system.The 2008 financial crisis was blamed on the immigrants in USA.Infact, the crooks were the bankers and politicians and bureaucracy.
      And thats the reason why the movie is earning less.Its not for everybody especially with the kind of political environment we live in.The makers knew that.That is why they didn't dub it in other languages.Yes it is not perfect.
      If immigrating outside India is bad,then is migrating within India good?think for yourself.The movie can be extrapolated to migrating within India too.

    • @VivekForPresident2028
      @VivekForPresident2028 10 месяцев назад

      Kaam toh kar Rahi hai bhai
      Hirani ki saari filmom ka aisa hi rehta hai
      Unko bumper opening nahin lagti hai
      Dheere-dheere chalti hai lambi chalti hai

  • @nitappy
    @nitappy 11 месяцев назад +46

    Another observation is that even if they were 30 when they went to London, how did they end up looking like they’re 65 in 25 years? They are shown way older than they should be.

    • @cometstar4050
      @cometstar4050 11 месяцев назад +5

      stress can make you look older than your actual age. Depends upon perception as well. To me they looked to be someone in their early 50s.

    • @nitappy
      @nitappy 11 месяцев назад +1

      None of the people I know in 50s look like this. They looked like their own grandparents. 😄

    • @trulyyoursish
      @trulyyoursish 11 месяцев назад

      Then they were about 25 😊

  • @apoorvsingh4459
    @apoorvsingh4459 11 месяцев назад +113

    I think the main message of the movie is that how some people are mad about going abroad and have misconceptions that everything will be great there, but after going and staying there they realise the importance of home and why there can be no place like home and the happiness you get there is unmatched. It is perfectly depicted in Nikle the ham ghar se, that was the heart of the movie for me and worked well for me. The message about illegal immigration was kind of hit and miss though

    • @indianfan1029
      @indianfan1029 11 месяцев назад +5

      They didn't work on the screenplay. Jo message tha, wo kaise deliver karna hai, usme 0 out of 100 marks. May be Shahrukh interfered, ya Kanika dhillon, gud gobar kar diya story ka.

    • @swapnildalvi5794
      @swapnildalvi5794 11 месяцев назад

      Bro the message you have mentioned is very well executed in the movie and illegal immigration is the very crux of this issue as mainly poor and incompetent people choose such a dangerous path/route in hope of a better future. If they had to elaborate each and every issue in detail then they would have made it as a OTT series.
      And the fact is that its a very dark movie as compared to other Raju Hirani movies. May be these negative reviews are coming out due to that. The movie couldnt have been made better with such a dark topic. In fact its a boldest Raju Hirani movie till date and an absolute masterpiece which some people may take time to resonate with.
      And almost every Raju Hirani movie had a love story as a sub plot which didnt dwelled deeper on their relation but just provided as a vehicle to carry the story forward, for eg. 3 idiots, Lage Raho Munnabhai. So imagining or assuming that someone is interfering in a movie making process just to prove his or her point sounds childish and shows the lack of maturity. These are all professionals and know better than us.

    • @amittracy
      @amittracy 11 месяцев назад

      Donkey movie is slow and boring. Srk is donkey of Bollywood 🤣🤣🤣

    • @apoorvsingh4459
      @apoorvsingh4459 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@swapnildalvi5794 the movie is good but there are some problems definitely. I think the point about illegal immigration which they wanted to prove wasn't convincing enough, compared to his other movies like 3 idiots, Pk which were very convincing in putting their viewpoints across.
      I personally resonated more with the concept of home and it will always bring you true happiness, and it was conveyed very effectively too

    • @adityasingh-tr3tu
      @adityasingh-tr3tu 11 месяцев назад

      Wah bhisdike 0 out of 100, salaar ka fan h kya😅

  • @ReadUp1
    @ReadUp1 11 месяцев назад +49

    Being a huge fan of Rajkumar Hirani and SRK it is very hard to accept this for me, but still I agree with you.

  • @amolghimire5776
    @amolghimire5776 11 месяцев назад +36

    The topic of Dunki itself is not known to mass audience. Previous films of Hirani had relatable subject matter, Doctors and medical system in Munna bhai, Gandhi in Lage raho, Education system in 3 idiots, Religion in PK even Sanjay dutt life is well known. Also, Raju Hirani himself said that he wrote this film with SRK in mind which he had never done before. As you guys said, Hirani's last two films doesn't have rewatchable factor.

  • @esmaeelakther213
    @esmaeelakther213 11 месяцев назад +124

    Actually this is no less than other Hirani movies. The difference here is 2 things:
    1) The theme is darker than other movies which makes the second half more serious and doesnt give us a fully happy climax. But this was needed for a film with such a theme.
    2) The subject is not relatable for many people within india who haven't considered leaving India. This is super relatable for those who have moved out of india/home for better opportunities. This is especially hard hitting for many who travelled out of india for earning and supporting their families but even after many years just able to do enough to send money back home to families. While still being just living a bare minimums abroad.

    • @beingarnav1993
      @beingarnav1993 11 месяцев назад

      haan Bhai but in chootiyo ko samjha k koi matlab nahi..inhone man bana diya hai😂

    • @anoushkas8726
      @anoushkas8726 11 месяцев назад +11

      Men's Xp hutiya logic: Animal murder bhi kare to theek par Dunki me logic ki kami hai😂😂😂😂

    • @abhisheksengupta1773
      @abhisheksengupta1773 11 месяцев назад +4

      I live in Australia and watched this movie but the writing was really bad. SRK and Vicky Kaushal were excellent.

    • @esmaeelakther213
      @esmaeelakther213 11 месяцев назад

      @@abhisheksengupta1773 it did resonate and connect well for me

    • @adibakhan8011
      @adibakhan8011 11 месяцев назад +1

      Well said

  • @raahinbelim
    @raahinbelim 11 месяцев назад +8

    11:20 spitting factsssssss✨

  • @ketan7537
    @ketan7537 11 месяцев назад +10

    This video is going to offend many 😂 but i totally agree with you guys 💯 Keep it up

  • @popculturecountdowns6618
    @popculturecountdowns6618 11 месяцев назад +29

    The main issue with this film was its final message was not clear I mean. First they showed dunki is a risky process but once they did the dunki successfully they were actually able to support their families they all achieved their goals like we saw in the end they even got the residentship and they were even getting the visas back to home just after 8 months but tapssi’s character was dying so they had to do something to get to India early even though that doesn’t make sense for other two characters they could just have come after 8 months legally secondly poor can’t get visas but at the same time one of their friend got the student visa even though he was not well off so when he cleared an exam he got the opportunity despite being poor so the makers themselves was not clear about the message.

    • @shiroyasha_007
      @shiroyasha_007 11 месяцев назад +4

      Agree, I have the same doubts about Animal too, its final message was not clear I mean

    • @apoorvsingh4459
      @apoorvsingh4459 11 месяцев назад

      I think the main message of the movie is that how some people are mad about going abroad and have misconceptions that everything will be great there, but after going and staying there they realise the importance of home and why there can be no place like home and the happiness you get there is unmatched. It is perfectly depicted in Nikle the ham ghar se, that was the heart of the movie for me and worked well for me. The message about illegal immigration was kind of hit and miss though

    • @trulyyoursish
      @trulyyoursish 11 месяцев назад +4

      To be straight up sarcastic the message was developed countries, open your borders so we can come take your jobs, your homes and your way of life.

  • @Mr_Mohit_Shukla
    @Mr_Mohit_Shukla 11 месяцев назад +24

    If I have to rank RKH films it will be:
    1)Munna bhai MBBS
    2) 3 Idiots
    3) Lage raho munna bhai
    4) PK
    5) Dunki
    6) Sanju

    • @amittracy
      @amittracy 11 месяцев назад +1

      Donkey is slow and boring movie. Srk is donkey of Bollywood

  • @MegaAbhinav03
    @MegaAbhinav03 11 месяцев назад +5

    1. This was not at all a mass entertainer and getting reviews and earning accordingly.
    2. When you say that SRK fans can’t accept the fact that this movie didn’t work as expected, same can be said for you for defending Animal since you are Ranbir’s fan.

  • @khabaroo7036
    @khabaroo7036 11 месяцев назад +5

    Most honest and real non filter reviewers currently on youtube

  • @chinkigarg3642
    @chinkigarg3642 11 месяцев назад +12

    Previously they used to give honest reviews but now they are no honest anymore
    A movie like Animal which is full of misogyny and loop holes are appreciated by these people but the movie like Dunki which is actually good and with good msz they are searching for the loop holes in the movie
    Also they like the star kid useless movie Archies by saying that they don't expect as they are new commers
    It seems like either they are doing paid reviews or forget that they have to review the honest reviews rather than paid reviews
    It totally shoews now men'sxp is doing anything to earn money and that's the only reason they are not able to crack even 1.5 millions subscribers even after more than 5-6 years

  • @kushalgulwani6737
    @kushalgulwani6737 11 месяцев назад +16

    In short Jawaan and Animal also had enough logical flaws. But they were convincing and here it could not convince. That is where art lies. EOD

    • @mohitparekh2551
      @mohitparekh2551 11 месяцев назад +5

      Screenplay is the reason. Editing, screenplay and direction was the reason they worked. Here the writing was clueless. SRK had no character arc whatsoever unlike previous hirani movies where each and every character had depth and were iconic.

    • @trulyyoursish
      @trulyyoursish 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@mohitparekh2551It felt like someone else wrote and directed this movie not Hirani.

  • @Attinder_dhiman
    @Attinder_dhiman 11 месяцев назад +5

    Aaj kal ke time mein no double meaning comedy , no glamorous scenes ke saath entertaining movie bna dena aur hamne ek baar bhi movie mein phone nahi uthaya. Raj kumar hirani rocks ❤️❤️❤️❤️

    • @trulyyoursish
      @trulyyoursish 11 месяцев назад

      Hum 30 mins ke baad hi phone ko dekhne lag gaye.

  • @abhishekpanigrahi3725
    @abhishekpanigrahi3725 11 месяцев назад +6

    Ek dum correct bro....but main toh iss chiz se hairan hoon ki logo ko saalar jaisi movie kaise pasand aa rahi😂....

  • @Avi12075
    @Avi12075 11 месяцев назад +60

    Srk is actually competing with himself, don't compare mass action with drama and emotion.
    Srk is emotion ❤

    • @HelloWorld12347
      @HelloWorld12347 11 месяцев назад +5

      oo...ok...till now I was under the misconception that he is an Actor. Thanks for opening my eyes

    • @shreyansh8212
      @shreyansh8212 11 месяцев назад +2

      Ghaantaaa😂😂😂😂

    • @Avi12075
      @Avi12075 11 месяцев назад

      @@shreyansh8212 bajale 😂

    • @vedjoshi260
      @vedjoshi260 11 месяцев назад

      @@yashsharmas702Aree bhai aisa mt bol, "Woh log aayengee, tujhe dikhaenge... Samose ki taakat"

  • @srinivaschavaly7290
    @srinivaschavaly7290 11 месяцев назад +49

    It is not a flop by any means it has crossed the movie budget

  • @popculturecountdowns6618
    @popculturecountdowns6618 11 месяцев назад +2

    RJH MOVIES ACCORDING TO ME
    1. 3 idiots (nothing can beat that)
    2. Munna bhai mbbs (it was a breath of fresh air)
    3. PK (incredible concept great message)
    4. Laghe raho munna bhai (wild concept got too preachy and little messy in the end but still was entertaining
    5. Sanju (a great one time watch but biopics have a shelf life but still one of the best biopic ever made in India was really manipulative but still the way it was portrayed and the media manipulation angle was really genius)
    6. Dunki (hirani lowest point in his career jokes was hit and miss, message was not clear, topic was not relatable, it was a good film not great)
    Final thoughts their is no bad hirani films just good, best and greatest 😊

  • @mohitkumarrai5536
    @mohitkumarrai5536 11 месяцев назад +33

    Swades is cult classic

    • @parthoroy5044
      @parthoroy5044 11 месяцев назад

      Yeah that will always be in our heart

  • @samratsarkar1257
    @samratsarkar1257 11 месяцев назад +6

    Totally agree with u...ur analysis was bang on.... couldn't agree more 👍🏻

  • @anjanishtripathi5164
    @anjanishtripathi5164 11 месяцев назад +17

    Subject is unique so normal people can’t related
    But filmmaking and performance is top notch

  • @ravichavan1520
    @ravichavan1520 11 месяцев назад +1

    Youngsters who has moved out of India just miss the family and friends, nothing else. US and UK has all better environment, freedom, job opportunities but that homely feeling it lacks. And people are just missing that. It's just nostalgic.

  • @Enigmasuhail
    @Enigmasuhail 11 месяцев назад +37

    Dunki will be in theatres for long time.🎉

    • @meteor541
      @meteor541 11 месяцев назад +9

      Kyu ki tickets nahi bikengi 🤣

    • @vijaymehta5538
      @vijaymehta5538 11 месяцев назад +4

      Haan poster rahega movie nahin🤣. Rab di zameen 🤣

    • @KunalKeshav-dq6ty
      @KunalKeshav-dq6ty 11 месяцев назад

      Bc local theatres mein se animal hat gaya ye kya cheez hai

    • @chinnmay55
      @chinnmay55 11 месяцев назад +3

      Kis ka stardom dekhna hai toh opening collection dekh.. Salaaar achhi nahi average hai tabhi itna 296 cr in 2 days... Dunki 100 cr teen din😂😂.. Ghanta global star.. Prabhas ne beat kar diya srk ke stardom ko

    • @SahilSharma-mb7bg
      @SahilSharma-mb7bg 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@chinnmay55 hindi m dkho kitna kmaayi salaar ....most of theatre south m hi h south k log south ki hi dkhte h only isliye chal gyi or wha movies ka craze bhut h....and sath abhi mass movie dkhna chhate h log hall m....aksar drama film pr ott or hi dkh letr h ....but prabas action k alawa kisi or m chlega ??? Bilkul ni....atleast srk always took risk....joner smjo...joner matters....action movie hall m dkhne m mja aata h but drama nhi...

  • @cometstar4050
    @cometstar4050 11 месяцев назад +80

    The title of this video should be: Why Dunki didn't work for us!
    Just because you didn't like the movie doesn't mean that its a flop. The movie has earned more than its budget and its not even a week old so why are you assuming its flop? Apart from Munnabhai MBBS, all Raju Hirani movies have faced criticism at the time of its release. Critics absolutely bashed Sanju at the time of its release and now they are praising it. Critics are hypocrites!!!

    • @okthanks1643
      @okthanks1643 11 месяцев назад +2

      haha it's a bad movie accept that even sanju kar har maiden fateh is better than this donkey

    • @Rahulrooooo3475
      @Rahulrooooo3475 11 месяцев назад +5

      😂 bhaai rehne de chaprio ke smjh me ni ati esi movie😂

    • @nonameno4159
      @nonameno4159 11 месяцев назад

      So true these two morons are just trying to get more views by inciting the people with their illogical views. Dunki is showing growth tht means it is being appreciated by people.

    • @okthanks1643
      @okthanks1643 11 месяцев назад

      @@Rahulrooooo3475 bhai meine movie ko bura bola tu tm personally attack kyun karne lage that's show your mentality har chidz ko protect kar ne ki zarurat nahi movie mediocre thi first half thik tha lekin 2nd half mein kuch bhi emotional nahi tha and film memorable bhi nahi hain ek scene yaad nahi rhega 1 mahine baad yeh sach aur jahan tak baat rhi Tu yeh ek flop hiin rahegi aur daag raj kumar hirani ke carrier mein jis bande ne 2009 mein 3 idiots sie 200 crore kama liye tu 2023 mein 200 crore uske liye ek bezzati hain and pls yeh fan mat bano i don't hate srk but yeh mobie khrb hain

    • @sahilhoque079
      @sahilhoque079 11 месяцев назад +5

      Jab 3 idiots ya pk release hua tab bhi utna hype nahi tha aj jake uska esaash hua kitna masterpiece hai 🙂

  • @natsmukherjee
    @natsmukherjee 11 месяцев назад +30

    I went to watch danki with a Syrian girl. She cried so much during the movie even she could relate to the to too much. That level of good this movie is.

    • @princesolanki5914
      @princesolanki5914 11 месяцев назад +13

      Ye log animal ko defend or dunki oppose kr rhe h isi se hi inki cinema ki smjh pta chlti h😂

    • @jv3198
      @jv3198 11 месяцев назад +1

      Dunki toh tatti Nikli 😂

  • @Mario-rs4oh
    @Mario-rs4oh 11 месяцев назад +2

    Abbey people are liking it and giving great reviews after coming out of theater. Yesterday everyone gave standing ovation in theater in Chicago!

    • @jv3198
      @jv3198 11 месяцев назад

      Kya zabardast sucking karte ho yaar aap

  • @musicalconnection7890
    @musicalconnection7890 11 месяцев назад +276

    Dunki 200 cr paar..domestic mein 100cr paar..budget only 120 cr..family audience loving the movie..film has already found acceptance.. 300cr paar.. On the verge of crossing 400 cr😎

    • @THUGPUTIN
      @THUGPUTIN 11 месяцев назад +27

      Budget 120cr Isliye Hai, srk and hirani renumeration nai liya Hai... 10% profit lenghe... Srk ka fees 100cr seh Kam nai Hai aur hirani ka 50cr Tha... Par es film mein profit mangliyeh toh 120cr hai...
      Par srk distributor party keh paise aur media PR marketing keh paise dunki mein laga Hai...
      Are bhai, ek normal Akshay Kumar ka film ka budget 120cr hota Hai... Tamil actors ajith aur vijay 100cr fees leteh Hai.. 😂
      Amir, srk aur salman ka Asli budget 300 ya 400cr seh Kam nai hota... Pathaan aur jawan mein srk Bina fees liye 300 to 400 cr budget Tha...

    • @cometstar4050
      @cometstar4050 11 месяцев назад +5

      ​@@THUGPUTINWhatever the reason is, the budget is 120Cr. So that means the movie has recovered its budget. Raju Kirani and SRK are profit sharing because they are the producers of the film.

    • @crick_nerd1550
      @crick_nerd1550 11 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@THUGPUTINSRK is the producer of the Movie, so you mean to say he'll pay himself😂. It's a Rajkumaar Hirani Movie not SRK Movie, woh actors ko movie ke budget ke hisab se pay karte hai. Amir Khan ko PK je liya sirf 15cr mile jaha woh 50cr ka fees lete hai, Ranbir Kapoor ne 5cr leke puri Sanju movie kardali

    • @AmitKumar-kv4vg
      @AmitKumar-kv4vg 11 месяцев назад +6

      ​@@crick_nerd1550jo b ho movie below average thi

    • @crick_nerd1550
      @crick_nerd1550 11 месяцев назад +4

      @@AmitKumar-kv4vg bellow average? Abhi sirf teen he toh din huwe hai wait karo

  • @swastikdwivedi8925
    @swastikdwivedi8925 11 месяцев назад +16

    Rajkumar Hirani:- Border should be open blah blah blah...
    Shubham:- (in Ajay Devgn's voice) "Aise kaise" 😤

  • @PTeja007
    @PTeja007 9 месяцев назад +2

    If movie is bad, credit should go to Hero of the film for selecting the shit story. Stop praising hero for his acting. He is SRK for a reason

  • @this_Is_n0_One
    @this_Is_n0_One 11 месяцев назад +15

    Dunki may not be perfect but it's a definitely a recommended watch, my two cents is that the struggle and journey of Dunki route was shown quickly and wasn't explored enough, the issues faced living in foreign country as an illegal immigrant could've been explored more, instead the focus shifted to love story in the end which was unnecessary and not needed which took up enough screen time.
    Also, both of them not marrying for each other's sake was too much filmy and not realistic. Calling it Dunki and then not showing the theme itself and then making it into a romantic story in the end was a big stupid mistake. I guess had it been Aamir Khan he would've never agreed for this ending.

    • @mishuccet1
      @mishuccet1 10 месяцев назад

      you are right.....deviating from the topic didn't work for the movie and the love story seemed like replica of veer-zeera....it ended up being a mix of rab ne bna di jodi and veer zaara.....love story could have been more subtle....I think rajkumar hirani should keep Aamir khan as first choice for all his movies, unless he doesn't fit the role.....they complement each other......srk didn't look right fit for this role

  • @saifalikhan5832
    @saifalikhan5832 11 месяцев назад +2

    The main essence of the film is the dunki process, but raju hirani has shot only a few scenes of the dunki process that the biggest problm

  • @akshaymudia5421
    @akshaymudia5421 11 месяцев назад +9

    Both Menxp and people commenting are wrong.
    For menxp- Film will earn good amount and will be most probably super hit.
    For SRK fans - They are right that topic of the film is not something which will relate to larger audience.
    Overall, good family watch. Drama genre se film ka itna bhi chalna post pandemic badi baat h.

  • @aartisingh2323
    @aartisingh2323 11 месяцев назад

    She with every line u guys said in this..I totally agree with the " not opening borders" ..n also about " aa jao wapas, itni desh ki yaad aati hai toh " ..ek number baat ! Love u guys

  • @jananampatil535
    @jananampatil535 11 месяцев назад +35

    Last 8 mins of this video is horrible, their point of view is so narrow minded. People leaving India doesn't mean they hate this country or their patriotism in over. " Yahaan kaam karo/ economy mein contribute karo", These guys are saying this knowing the fact that unemployment records are at all time high in India. Most people who leave INDIA go abroad for job opportunities more than hatred for their country. You can leave your country and still have love and respect for your motherland.

    • @njha4531
      @njha4531 11 месяцев назад +4

      I think their issue are with those who move to another country because they think life is better their and then complain that life is difficult here .

    • @vaibhavthapliyal3429
      @vaibhavthapliyal3429 11 месяцев назад +2

      You missed the whole point, they took political assylum and with that they kind of embraced that their country is threatening their life based on their religion, opinion or caste, which kind of amounts to “hating” their own country. However this doesn’t apply to the usual people who migrate using the legal channels.

    • @jananampatil535
      @jananampatil535 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@vaibhavthapliyal3429 these guys were talking about people who left the country for jobs and study purpose, which is obviously the legal route, and when these people come to India they complain about Indian problems as if they don't have the right to do it !

    • @user-mm1xr5xe9u
      @user-mm1xr5xe9u 3 месяца назад

      thats not true there is another thing, mostly illegals are the ones who do crimes there, mostly the uneducated and illegals one never integrate and then many request asylum saying its danger in their country specially sikhs and Muslims from India. Its chaos our people who are not educated actually dont deserve to live there, because they create mini punjab or India within cities and not for cultural reason because they dont wanna integrate. So that's why they have completely stopped. but yes some people are so crazy about abroad that they would do anything, but biggest problem is even after reaching there illegally they dont work hard and focus and become a good resident 99 percent of them do horrendous crimes.

  • @sarahgadavala
    @sarahgadavala 11 месяцев назад +21

    Just because you don't like the movie, doesn't mean movie is bad. Its a MASTERPIECE. just like raone and swades, people will realise worth and value of the movie slowly.And just for your information, if success of the movie is measured by box office collection so the movie has earned more than 200 crores in just 4 days.

    • @abhi9krsingh
      @abhi9krsingh 11 месяцев назад +3

      Its a superflop, l0dÜ 😂

    • @abhisheksengupta1773
      @abhisheksengupta1773 11 месяцев назад +3

      Acting was awesome but story had a lot of work to do. From a hardcore SRK fan

    • @TJSlatch
      @TJSlatch 11 месяцев назад +1

      Watch aja mexico chaliye and you know the difference between quality and hype

    • @koolaiddudeawesome9850
      @koolaiddudeawesome9850 11 месяцев назад +2

      @@abhi9krsinghsuperflop bhi nahi hai

    • @saketbhavsar1544
      @saketbhavsar1544 11 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@abhi9krsinghnot more than Salwar

  • @ViperExplained
    @ViperExplained 11 месяцев назад

    Totally agree 👍💯💯

  • @gauravrana724
    @gauravrana724 11 месяцев назад +6

    02:50
    Ye baat toh sahi hai.... Jawan aur Pathaan, dono films mein dekhne gaya kyunki craze tha. Par when it comes to Dunki, mann he nahi kar raha ja ke dekhne ka. SO.💔

  • @iamPrinceK
    @iamPrinceK 11 месяцев назад +14

    Raju Sir ki movies hype pr nhi balki Content & Word Of Mouth pr chlti h,
    Weekend pr nhi Week Days pr chlti h & Slow Burns hoti hain☺️😊🥰
    A perfect family film after a long time I have a feeling that it could be one of the biggest, if not the biggest grosser of the year🌟🤞✨

  • @HimanshuSethi7199
    @HimanshuSethi7199 11 месяцев назад +41

    The reason why I love the Punjabi version is because there is a lot of threats to main protagonist and the main protagonist couldn't complete the process giving an example that this isn't an easy thing to do

    • @abhishek_beniwal
      @abhishek_beniwal 11 месяцев назад

      Name of the punjabi movie?

    • @shreyatiwari6186
      @shreyatiwari6186 11 месяцев назад +7

      Even I have watched aaja Mexico chaliye and tbh it was better than dunki

    • @HimanshuSethi7199
      @HimanshuSethi7199 11 месяцев назад

      @@abhishek_beniwal Aaja Mexico Chaliye

    • @cricketintown8084
      @cricketintown8084 11 месяцев назад +4

      Bro did you notice one thing
      In dunki the main protagonist regularly beats someone along the way while in Punjabi version the main protagonist suffers all the way long and it's clearly visible it's very difficult

    • @cricketintown8084
      @cricketintown8084 11 месяцев назад +2

      Ammy Virk was a protagonist in Punjabi version
      While srk is the "hero"

  • @PremDev1122
    @PremDev1122 11 месяцев назад +2

    Looking at the trailer I was expecting it to be Swadesh part 2 as SRK was featured.

  • @Manish----
    @Manish---- 11 месяцев назад +10

    Dunki is doing good business. Super hit ❤

  • @dhruvboricha8163
    @dhruvboricha8163 11 месяцев назад +2

    The film has done well bhai 200cr in 4 days worldwide and 108 cr in India

  • @ninanina164
    @ninanina164 11 месяцев назад +3

    Like I said many times before..SRK as star and producer interfered 1000% to RKHs vision

  • @michaelansif82
    @michaelansif82 11 месяцев назад +1

    Movie is made on a budget of 85 crore so it won't be a flop might even become a superhit if it touches 200 crore in India. But it is true that he movie didn't give full satisfaction like previous Raju Hirani movies.

  • @nehajha3388
    @nehajha3388 11 месяцев назад +12

    It is a satire that they have defended the plot of Animal various times which was not practically illogical but are bashing the plot of Dunki and stating it to be analytically illogical.
    The message from the film was to aware people about their country and enjoy there instead of aspiring to live abroad and living in rags. It showed how it's not worth to go all through because at the end you will not get what you aspire and people would think a thousand times before taking the donkey route.

  • @kritikahooda7524
    @kritikahooda7524 11 месяцев назад +1

    I feel
    1. Dunki as a concept is not known much and hence not relatable also esp for those who never considered going abroad to support family or got their visa rejected.
    2. The jump to 25 yrs later also was too fastrack. Showing glimpses of struggles in those 25 yrs, inability to come back home would have strengthened the storyline.
    3. Other characters wanted to earn in UK hence giving IELTS. But sukhhi (Vicky) just wanted to get his girl back. He could have applied for a tourist visa. (NRI marrying girl from village and mistreating them was also another issue faced and once in news for a long time. )

  • @guptaavikaas
    @guptaavikaas 11 месяцев назад +3

    This is the first Hirani movie which I think does not have any repeat value.
    This would have been a good movie if made by any other director but by Hirani's standard, it's a miss.

    • @beingarnav1993
      @beingarnav1993 11 месяцев назад

      maybe not for ignorant PPL but familes are packing in the numbers with multiple viewings

    • @cometstar4050
      @cometstar4050 11 месяцев назад

      I have watched it twice and found so many nuances the 2nd time I watched it. So many hidden meanings and messages are there in the movie.

  • @AKARKIKARKI
    @AKARKIKARKI 11 месяцев назад

    What is your review of the Dunki movie?
    डंकी मेरे द्वारा अब तक देखी गई सबसे महान फिल्मों में से एक है। इसकी भावनाओं को महसूस करने और इसकी वास्तविकता को दिखाने से, यह एक उत्कृष्ट कृति है। यह वास्तविक दुनिया को दिखाता है कि आप्रवासियों के साथ कैसा व्यवहार किया जाता है, और इसे बहुत ही अच्छे तरीके से चित्रित करता है
    DUNKI is one of the greatest films I’ve ever seen. From its emotions felt and its reality shown, this is a masterpiece. It shows the actual world of how immigrants are treated, and portrays it very well. I love the acting in this, so though out and nicely done. Another one of srk’s films that make me entertained and relaxed. I loved this entire movie, the laughs I had from this is just too many to think about. It’s hilarious, fun, and a good family watch. It also has heartfelt moments that make your eyes tear up. Overall, this is amazing and I’ll forever support Rajkumar Hirani’s filmmaking. So incredible and remarkable. This film will keep you going and more interested for more. I highly recommend it for any family watch, any person that likes emotional/funny films and most importantly the reality kind of films that really show how it is and the way the world portrays us as. Such a fantastic film released for us. Srk has done it once again, made me surely proud with his work of art and his acting. I can tell you as a fellow watcher, this is so much better than his other past films in 2023. This one really hit it for me. Srk Always knows how to reach the audiences interest and get them into the film. Incredible work to the whole cast, and for the other actor shown Vicky Kaushal. All acted so good and it’s one of those films that you want to watch again and again, especially the trailer! It’s the type of movie you wish you forgot about it and rewatch the whole thing as it excites many like me. Again, brilliant and amazing film. Not only was the film phenomenal, but its songs was phenomenal as well. So joyful and lively. It really makes you want to dance out just as the other films srk does in. Deserves more than 5 stars if I could give it more. I absolutely loved it and will be waiting for more of srks upcoming films. Long live India 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
    My suggestion
    अपने अभी तक नहीं देखा है तो जरूर देखें एक बार बहुत अच्छी फिल्म है
    If you haven't seen it yet then definitely watch it once, it's a very good movie.

  • @raunaktodarwal
    @raunaktodarwal 11 месяцев назад +5

    FINALLY a truly honest, unbiased, unpaid review.

  • @nathanrenga78
    @nathanrenga78 11 месяцев назад +3

    Very clear analysis!

  • @razzakkazi3270
    @razzakkazi3270 11 месяцев назад +6

    Mana salaar ne jiyada collection kiya lekin dunki ne dil chuliya❤

  • @Itzsharmaz
    @Itzsharmaz 10 месяцев назад +1

    I second you guys that trailer didn't make me push to buy tkts rather it always made me to wait it for OTT

  • @kzmOP
    @kzmOP 11 месяцев назад +5

    Animal n dunki are both awsm in there in general....but animals once in rare film❤....people calling other chapri for liking are real narcissistic personality in personal life 😂 unko documentary laga instead of fiction 😂

  • @VikkiOnYT
    @VikkiOnYT 11 месяцев назад +1

    Appriciation for MensXP vdo Editing team

  • @subhajitbasu4187
    @subhajitbasu4187 11 месяцев назад +3

    1995 me body shaming to aise hi hota tha.

  • @saswatswain5
    @saswatswain5 11 месяцев назад

    DUNKI is a good movie. But there are few things, if they would have added then it would have been a superhit movie like 3 idiots, munna bhai series
    1.More logical reasons for Manu,Balli,Buggu to travel outside india. Sukhi's reason to travel was a great example.
    2.Adding few more scenes related to dunki travel might have helped the audience to connect more emotionally to the movie in 2nd half.
    3.Few more edge of seat moments(like underwater scene) also might have worked. Like they have shown scenes but in few seconds or minutes. People didn't get time to connect to those scenes.
    When this movie will be released in OTT then you will love it more as compare to current scenario in theatre.Same thing happened with swadesh.
    People didn't accept the movie in theatre but started acclaiming when they started watching in their home alone. Not saying it is great as swadesh but yes if you are thinking as average then once they release in OTT movie will turn out as a HIT or SUPERHIT movie for you.

  • @aryann_joon
    @aryann_joon 11 месяцев назад +5

    I just watched this movie a few hours ago , its mind blowingg . Definitely a hitt

  • @TJSlatch
    @TJSlatch 11 месяцев назад +1

    @Shubham @Rajesh pls watch “Aja Mexico chaliye” a punjabi movie which is far far better than dunki. From struggle to message. Everything is really good

  • @Km-qp6wb
    @Km-qp6wb 11 месяцев назад +15

    I watched dunki in theatres and on the jokes all the uncle's and old generation audiences were laughing but I didn't find it funny. The movie is for family audience and not to watch with friends

    • @Naman26449
      @Naman26449 11 месяцев назад +4

      Exactly bhai jokes were outdated
      I also didn't laughed at that but it still gives you a little smile and warm feelings
      Movie koi special nahi hai ki cult ban jayegi hirani ki baaki films ki tarah but acchi family entertainer hai😵‍💫

    • @samratsarkar1257
      @samratsarkar1257 11 месяцев назад +2

      Same thing happened with us bro , same same.but the die hard srk fan dint accept it.

    • @samratsarkar1257
      @samratsarkar1257 11 месяцев назад +1

      Very average movie

    • @atulranjan6084
      @atulranjan6084 11 месяцев назад

      true... 100

  • @sreetamadutt
    @sreetamadutt 11 месяцев назад

    And yes the interval and further transition was abrupt too. The struggle was also not highlighted as intensely as it should. Agreed.

  • @sanketdongre369
    @sanketdongre369 11 месяцев назад +6

    If we keep the comparison out and just watch the film for what is it, I think it was an enjoyable watch. Me and my family loved the film. The emotional scenes were really heart touching. And I think the movies is growing on the audience with every passing day.

    • @trulyyoursish
      @trulyyoursish 11 месяцев назад

      My family and I were laughing at how bad it was.

  • @Janak183
    @Janak183 11 месяцев назад

    According to your thoughts about, why you went to abroad and saying that you miss your country you can come back and do in your own country. Yes as a living in abroad that doesn't mean we don't miss our country. We miss and sometime it feels very lonely but we know our responsibility for our family. We came here for better life and better opportunity than our country which we don't have there,and we can do, we can invest some money and we can start something to do in our own country but that didn't give us that, our business will work and we can earn money every month because some families can afford losses and some can't. That's why we choose abroad thinking about return of investment that, at least we invest some money and go to abroad, after it will sure that we will get monthly income and that thing we can't sure in our country.

  • @JavedShaikh-gy4dy
    @JavedShaikh-gy4dy 11 месяцев назад +11

    Its the second half that i liked most. There are lot of things you can relate with, i have seen people crying during this.. the boy in his 20s was crying when mannu passed.

  • @coolsand
    @coolsand 11 месяцев назад +1

    When Vanga said “That tyagi girl” in the interview I couldn’t hold it 😂😂

  • @Hajik-n7f
    @Hajik-n7f 11 месяцев назад +13

    Dunki Masterpiece ❤

  • @sparshhardik
    @sparshhardik 11 месяцев назад +1

    Very logically criticized. Kudos

  • @berlin5403
    @berlin5403 11 месяцев назад +5

    dunki is gaining super speed, family are loving it

  • @umeshnaik844
    @umeshnaik844 10 месяцев назад +1

    I really enjoy this movie .. much better compare to other movie .. agar bahut realistic banani hoti to ye movie adult category mein ban jati

  • @deepakverma2722
    @deepakverma2722 11 месяцев назад +3

    Bhai bahut dil se dekhne gaya tha. Itani bakwas movie bhai pehli baar laga pese chale gae.
    😮

  • @MegaAbhinav03
    @MegaAbhinav03 11 месяцев назад +1

    Totally agreed with ur reviews on the second half screenplay and message of the movie, but what happened while reviewing Animal, you weren’t logical and analytical that time.

  • @suyashjha1324
    @suyashjha1324 11 месяцев назад +3

    Shruti yaar please unblock kardo ab majhak nahi raha ye 😢

  • @prachuryyabaruah7
    @prachuryyabaruah7 11 месяцев назад +2

    at 5:38 this was 1995 guys🙆🏻‍♂️ aur fake certificates ab hi itne aasan hain toh socho tab kitni hogi. Yeh film bohot research ke baad banayi gayi hain aur mostly real incidentd ko hi potray kiya hain.

  • @_ScrollWithMe_
    @_ScrollWithMe_ 11 месяцев назад +7

    Maturity when you realise Adipurush earned more than Dunki ..but all of us know that how ADI the PURUSH is😂... so jab log ye samjhenge ki box office collection main toh tatti bhi kamai kar le par quality content main ye sab maine nahi rakhta... DUNKI❤is masterpiece..chapri audience jab tak ye samjhenge tabtak ye underrated ban chuka hoga... we all loved KGF❤ par isko uske sath compare karke inlogo na hug diya pura..KGF>>>SALWARRR.. aur Dunki 1 saal pehle 21st Dec release announce kar chuka tha par ye log apna ego dikhake same time pe release kar diya... kya faida hua.. SRK👑 ko in new actors ke sath clash karne ka ego bhari parne hi wala tha...Never go against your father..truely describes...if you 2 don't agree than congrats you also belongs to the chapri gang

    • @cometstar4050
      @cometstar4050 11 месяцев назад

      The budget of Adipurush and Salaar was very high. Dunki's budget is around 120 cr including promotions. So the movie should atleast be superhit.

    • @sids_TM
      @sids_TM 11 месяцев назад

      Is hisab se to jawan or pathan bhi tatti movie he . Jis hisab se tu audience ko blame kr raha he

  • @edgefanCWC
    @edgefanCWC 11 месяцев назад

    Jawan was awesome. And Pathaan, while slow in the middle, was also a big success.
    Salaar and Animal did well.
    But, Dunki is abt to cross 300cr too. 3 blockbusters in a year for the ageless and peerless King Khan 👏

  • @Anonymously237
    @Anonymously237 11 месяцев назад +5

    I loved the movie.. because of reviews i wasn’t planning to go to see this movie.. but thanks to my wife i went for the movie ..after a long time i watched a hindi movie which have a emotional content and great story line which is not explored much.. if you are skeptical go for it ,you will love it.. its a great great movie compare to jawan pathan .. just my take

  • @Zealous_barbarian
    @Zealous_barbarian 11 месяцев назад +1

    DUNKI has found its audience.

  • @niladribhowmick
    @niladribhowmick 11 месяцев назад +3

    Its a beautiful movie ❤. Though second half was little dull, first half was GREAT.

  • @ImranKhan-nb5lp
    @ImranKhan-nb5lp 11 месяцев назад

    Agree with you guys!, A Lackluster movie.

  • @Naman26449
    @Naman26449 11 месяцев назад +5

    Bhay maybe dunki Genz's ko pasand na aye lekin family audience is loving it 😵‍💫

  • @rishijain9668
    @rishijain9668 11 месяцев назад +1

    Dunki is a good movie but this time i don't get emotional connect with characters which i think is a setback for me, i had very high hopes from RH and SRK, SRK has been under utilized in this movie, Boman Sir character was unnecessary, Dunki has a potential to become one of the greatest movie of Indian cinema but it fell short in many term, I think they made this movie in some hurry this movie can be easily made for 3 hrs, if they showcase the pain of tapsee, and other 2 guys and SRK journey after he deported from London, it has gain repititive value, I feel this time Raju Sir not at his best, Maybe in next week he back with a bang❤❤❤❤

  • @rameshgopal3394
    @rameshgopal3394 11 месяцев назад +10

    I dont think this will even cross PK collections...that itself proves its not connected as expected ...people can call it a hit as per the budget and collections but the expectations haven't been met for sure

    • @valley-girl
      @valley-girl 11 месяцев назад

      If it goes to Chinese market... It might become the biggest hit

  • @vivekpal7220
    @vivekpal7220 11 месяцев назад +2

    Dunki India-net Collection will wrap around 250-300 cr.

    • @Fhhddthbbchjkkog
      @Fhhddthbbchjkkog 11 месяцев назад

      And that eill make it super hit bcoz it's budget is only 120-150 crs .. it might even cross 300 and then it will be a blockbuster

  • @SibaDas-b9h
    @SibaDas-b9h 11 месяцев назад +3

    Bhai hat's off Raju hirani sir,Bhai woh collection ke liye movie nahin banate he ,Bhai abhi ye social drama nahin chalta he humne dekha he phir bhi Raju sir ne ye concept laya ,Bhai Dil se salute Raju hirani sir ,Bhai jago public jago iss tarah movie ko Nazar andaz mat karo taki aesi movie aur na aye , please all movie lovers support dunki movie ,Jay dunki Jay Raju hirani sir jay bharat

  • @shobhitparoha7518
    @shobhitparoha7518 11 месяцев назад +1

    till interval srk has look from zero
    after interval he suddenly transform into look from jab tak hai jaan

  • @rafiqarif6262
    @rafiqarif6262 11 месяцев назад +3

    Was a fantastic movie!!!!!!!
    More better than recent release
    Absolute wonderful

  • @harry1232244
    @harry1232244 11 месяцев назад +1

    Are Baba Salaar, Dunki, and Aquaman 2 saath main release hui hai... And there is a way of storytelling. Rajkumar Hirani has presented illegal immigration - the Dunki concept in its best form. So, from my side, it's an amazing concept but obviously, when some big pictures are released simultaneously earnings will be impacted.

  • @anutpalgogoi9741
    @anutpalgogoi9741 11 месяцев назад +2

    Illegal immigration from bangladesh has ruined Assam. So I cannot in my right mind support the sentiments of this film.

  • @Fhhddthbbchjkkog
    @Fhhddthbbchjkkog 11 месяцев назад +9

    Bhai dinki aaram se super hit ho jaegi bhai ... Uska budget 150 crs hai .. aur film 5 din me hi budhet ke kareeb ho gayi hai...
    Not every movie can earn 500 crs

  • @mohdzimam99
    @mohdzimam99 11 месяцев назад +1

    Aap log kis basis pr keh rhe ho ki dunki nahi chali?
    Dunki has done 200+ cr business in 4 days only.
    The neutral audience is loving the movie.
    And it has recovered its total budget of 120 cr, which means that the movie is a Hit.

    • @prakashbisht3774
      @prakashbisht3774 11 месяцев назад +3

      Bro box office ek time tak sahi define krta hai magar film 10 saal baad bhi dekhi jayegi ya nahi yeh important hai jese pathaan and jawaan ne itna kamay par I don't think so ye films Indian cinema ki history mein acchi movies ki list mein aayegi

  • @Socialman0007
    @Socialman0007 11 месяцев назад +6

    Srk fans sach nai sun sakte accept srk given hirani his first average movie.

    • @vijaymehta5538
      @vijaymehta5538 11 месяцев назад

      Not average pathetic is the right word😂

    • @samratsarkar1257
      @samratsarkar1257 11 месяцев назад

      একদম ঠিক বলেছ

  • @cinephilepro
    @cinephilepro 11 месяцев назад

    We want a Sandeep Reddy Vanga interview with you two. That would be awesome.🔥🤜

  • @poonammishra5360
    @poonammishra5360 11 месяцев назад +5

    At least keep it simple, it's a movie with some shortcomings but offers substantial knowledge about issues. Don't go into too much logic and intricacies, everybody is intelligent and don't need your guidance to understand the issue. Every common Indian settled in foreign face the consequences of being third person and sens of non belonging but couldn't come here and become senseless youtubers. The movie is good and offers entertainment although not one of the best work of director and having a weaker ending plot.

  • @invokeshit
    @invokeshit 11 месяцев назад +1

    True 'Dunki' is a serious and life threatening process many people die and even their dead bodies are not even identified. It includes going through various countries where some might get caught up and sometimes even trafficking also happens.
    Movie: "Chal Mexico🇲🇽 Chaliye"
    Staring Ammy virk Displays all these problems

  • @eternaltruth52
    @eternaltruth52 11 месяцев назад

    Message was pretty clear, 1. do not use Dunki route 2. You can live respectful life in your country instead of doing minion jobs in foreign country.

  • @prasantkumarofficial
    @prasantkumarofficial 11 месяцев назад +4

    RAJESH
    Animal 0 logic
    He needs DUNKI full 101 logic
    Hypocrisy Rajesh 🤣🤣🤣

  • @Sawriya_tanuj
    @Sawriya_tanuj 11 месяцев назад

    Totally Agreed

  • @gayathriswaminathan926
    @gayathriswaminathan926 11 месяцев назад

    Agree 100 percent..fiest half felt like stage drama n second half documentary..did not work at all to any level

  • @mizraltorasap8968
    @mizraltorasap8968 11 месяцев назад +3

    Dunki was fantastic bro, y these guys think its not worthy 😓

    • @TheeeAP
      @TheeeAP 11 месяцев назад

      Thik thak hai yaar aachi nahi utni

  • @imadarsh11_jha
    @imadarsh11_jha 11 месяцев назад +1

    Dunki didn’t worked for you. Don’t generalise your opinion.