🇮🇪 ESC 2022 Ireland: Reaction to Brooke Scullion - That's Rich

Had to drastically cut the music video again. Here's the ever-so-brief version of our reaction.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Curious what kind of music randomly pops into my head? Check out my playlist on Spotify.
open.spotify.c...
--------------------------------------------------------------
Intro Excerpt from Husavik by Atli Örvarsson

[@eurovisionHarry]

I feel like the performance was brought down by the fact it was on a talk show set, she said she has some big ideas she couldnt bring there but hopefully the final performance will be much better! She also revamped her song which gives a bit more depth as in some parts it fell a bit flat. So fingers crossed we might qualify for once hahaha

[@daymienjames8]

She is brimming with charisma and enthusiasm unlike the reviewers here

[@Leifdk1]

I like the song but I fear Eurovision might not be the best place for it to shine.
The performance felt a little amateur but if they can get it to come together when it counts (and add more attitude and edge) it might have a chance to qualify.
I kinda like it even if it doesn’t feel… “authentic”. Discount Carly Jepsen for now but I’m hoping it can be elevated.

[@gmolski9625]

Loving ur panel!! ❤️ Not huge fan of Irish entry this year tho, sadly 😢 song just doesn't stand out from what we've heard of other countries so far, it may not qualify thru to the final.. 🙄 Regards from Poland to whole 4 of You 🙋🏼‍♂️

[@magicwiccan1]

What exactly was repetitive??

[@alipanroosendaal9503]

It is not a classic but it will give energy to her semi. Borderline qualifier.

[@sus1221]

Brooke is incredibly fun and charismatic, and I'm glad that she's being introduced to a larger audience. But oh, man...I wish the song was stronger. I think she has a ton of potential, but just don't like the song. In my ranking I have it as 39th. (ahead of San Marino)

[@stickynorth]

Biggest ear-worm released this year so far... Besides the Odd's On Favorite, Chanel and SloMo that is...

[@sweetgirl070707]

For me it sounds generic and uninspired, but it's far from the worst entry released so far

[@TheFreeGreenChannel]

I love this song for some reason. The only song that stucked in my head this season (at least, so far). She's very charismatic.
Btw, where have you lost Tyler, it would be nice to hear his reaction to Israel and Ireland from the male side of American Eurovision audience.

[@MyrtleP]

Don't worry. Tyler will be back for most of the reactions. He was just away on a business trip when we recorded. I'm kind of glad he was going for the Italy video because he didn't like it AT ALL.

[@achnix3167]

I feel like any entry wouldve looked bad in this situation but yeah im not a fan

[@dazza4345]

Try playing the whole song .What's the point

[@kylestrain3231]

Reminds me of Blondie Good Boys.

[@AnAmericanInDenmark]

So, yeah, this just seems dated and a bit...lacking. It's neither well written nor well sung. It lacked the pop spunk needed to pull it off completely. I think this will struggle to qualify, as Ireland hasn't been super popular lately. But with the right injection of energy, she could win over the audience.

[@stickynorth]

A good song let down by meh performance... Same as last year with Maps, unfortunately... Should have done better but the staging made Leslie breathless when she needed power vocal abilities...

[@yvkon]

Let's just say this has potential.
I hope they get the performance right, for now it will not qualify imo.

[@markus_ch]

Good song, but ridiculous performance and outfits.

[@stickynorth]

The staging needs... ahem... work, work, work, work... The song is fun and catchy enough. Needs sleeker more adult staging though..

[@MyrtleP]

I see what you did there.

[@emreozberber4006]

Ugh really not liking this entry.. sorry