say what you will, but in my opinion, this is the perfect adaptation. it doesn't deviate too much from the personalities of the characters but it creates in original story out of well-established characters. It even animates itself to look like the classic cartoons.
I absolutely love this movie, and I'm absolutely fine if they don't make another. For what it was, the movie was pitch perfect Peanuts. Anything else risks updating and changing things, which cannot happen.
@@MaztRPwn some people see an opinion and think the speaker is saying some true fact everyone should agree. by stating its my opinion, i let people know that im not compelling them to agree with me
I was terrified about this movie ruining the Peanuts cast for me, and I have a firm place in my heart for Sunday comic strips. (Calvin & Hobbes, Peanuts, Garfield, etc) But this was genuinely such a charming and sweet adaptation that it's one of the few movies I actually bought a physical DVD for.
@@iliketurtles7782 Nah. _Peanuts_ was already animated back in the 60's, so that's alright for that IP. Bill Watterson is absolutely right. We don't need _Calvin and Hobbes_ to be ruined by being animated. Is nothing sacred anymore? Yes, I wouldn't mind seeing a Spaceman Spiff animated short or something, but that's about it. Movie/TV studios should leave _Calvin and Hobbes_ alone.
It’s confusing to me why all the other kids love to hate Charlie Brown. Charlie isn’t inherently annoying, and every time he does his own thing he gets ridiculed for it.
I remember seeing the previews where they all threw charlie under the bus for breaking an entire fence just for leaning on it while I was thinking, “What a piece of crap that fence was.”
And here I thought I was the only one. I was in the theater on opening weekend for this film. I grew up watching Peanuts. The Great Pumpkin, Christmas and all the Peanuts specials. We watched them every year. This movie was PERFECT.
The Peanuts movie was shockingly good. No cringy attempts to "modernize" it like 99.9% of other adaptations based on a famous property, it's almost like it could have come out 50 years ago! Hell, even the animation looks like the original movies, despite being 3D CGI! This right here is something special made by people who respect the source material, not by suits trying to turn brand recognition into a paycheck.
I feel like this deserved at least some sins off for the message at the end, especially if you're familiar with the giant ball of depression that was Charles Schultz and that his son wrote this movie. All throughout Schultz's career, the world conspires against Charlie Brown. He never wins anything, by design. He's the very embodiment of the idea that the world is cold and cruel and does not care about you, and no matter what you do you will never succeed. The ending of this movie has Heather (aka The Little Red Haired Girl) read off the laundry list of good deeds she saw Charlie Brown do the entire movie, and she acknowledges his worth. The movie is a son disagreeing with his father, saying "yes, the world is hard and cruel, but if you're a good person and work hard, the people that matter in your life will notice. There is good in this world. Even Charlie Brown can find happiness. YOU mattered." I think that's worth some sins off, don't you think? Or does that not bring the cheap laughs?
One of the things I love most about this film is that the storyline continues to flow so well and yet is at it's heart such a simple and effective story. Not every film has to have world ending stakes or be about some huge disaster. This film is like a throwback to films like Ferris Bueller where the story and goals are simple and relatable.
As someone who read a ton of Peanuts strips, it was like literally seeing Schulz's best strips being tied up by a single cohesive plotline, and it was done so simple yet so well
Bro, Snoopy is the reincarnation of an elder god prophesied to help rid the universe of Gorefield. He is the force that makes all of this happen, and Woodstock and the Beagle Scouts are his infinite arms that work the cosmos.
Ik this is cinemasins, but even many fans seem to miss that intention with Schroeder. "A boy named Charlie brown" had a rather trippy, imaginative moment that pretty much told a young me who wasn't even thinking about it that this was true.
@@The_Biscuit_From_Heaven lol, Snoopy is like someone performing a mass social experiment with clones in a facility somewhere. However I go with the "world in his playground" basics anyway xd.
All sinning aside, I adore this movie. In an era where movie adaptations of beloved children’s characters completely butcher them to a point of being nearly unrecognizable, for a perfect representation of the Peanuts gang to come from Blue Sky of all places is a miracle
The reason that Frieda's concern for her curls is the only fact the movie reveals about her is because that was literally her only character trait. Ever.
Well, she also did try to get Snoopy to chase rabbits--even to the point where she reported him to the Head Beagle for failing in his rabbit-chasing duties.
Yo, CinemaSins. The ending? The very last shot of the kids lifting up Charlie Brown? It freeze framing and turning into an OG comic drawing, giving tribute to the Peanuts creator, Charles Schulz? Yeah, that deserves multiple sins off.
This movie *ISN'T* wrong, this movie is fantastic. It stands out of all Blue Sky's films and I love it with all my might as it's what the movie we needed.
Yeah, and, before anyone goes Chucky on me for saying this, but I just wish it had more of a plot. People don't have to like the same thing, but only if you want to. But it's a really good film to me too. Now if you excuse me, I'll have to watch the Snoopy show.
@@mforrest9737 the whole channel is a joke. It’s not meant to literally say the movie is bad, it’s meant to make you laugh at all the little details that one might think up while watching the movie.
I love how he sins Schroeder's piano for being a toy but sounding like a grand piano when that is the entire running gag joke within the series. Not only have they been very self aware about that but even refrenced how he seems to get way more range than he should with such few keys and the black ones only being painted on. His joke response to this is that he practices a lot and the answer to the mystery remains unsloved beyond him just being THAT talented. To anyone who ACTUALLY reads the comic and appreciates these characters, this would be just a fun opening scene but I think the cinemasins sins show does a good job of explaining this.
Not to mention the "Jingle Bells" bit in the Christmas special, where he gets three distinct sounds from it (piano, organ, toy) at will. Schroeder is secretly an engineering genius who created and miniaturized the synthesizer decades before anyone else!
he also sinned things like Frida's curls being her only personality, and Sally having a crush on Linus while he feels exactly the opposite about her, both of which have been long-time running gags within the comics and specials
That was a well made point about Linus. The Little Red Haired Girl was like my junior high crush that immediately went away in high school, while Linus is like my best friend that I’ve had through middle and high school.
And I also respect and love the use of the flowerly prose. The movies inclusion here is not a slam against this movie. And I think we are all David Mamet fans…abso-fuckin-lutely. This whole thing is a joke. They do this to good movies all the time. Relax its fun.😎
Fun fact: in the 1950s Leo's Toy Store was actually the first toy store wherein children could buy any toy that wasn't a rock (or an attempted murder thrown typewriter).
I'm pretty sure Freida's only character development in the comic strip was she had naturally curly hair! Patty (the girl with the bow, not Peppermint Patty) get's even less. I'm pretty sure her entire character is "girl with a bow".
Fredia was an annoying character that showed up on occasion. Her main trait was trying to get Snoopy to chase rabbits. Patty is Violet's best friend. They are the mean girls. Sometimes they are nice to Charlie Brown and sometimes they are mean to him.
Which is why Patty and Violet disappear sometime in the 60s - Schulz felt that Lucy had the crabby girl market cornered and Patty and Violet, despite being two of the original five characters, weren't needed. Shermy was similarly dropped from the strip with almost no fanfare; Schulz thought he was boring and that Linus covered the "best friend" aspect well enough that Shermy was expendable.
This movie made me tear up when I first saw it. I relate to Charlie feeling like he struggles to do anything right so the scene at the end where the red haired girl flips his “failures” on their heads and praises him for the good he did instead was incredibly touching.
He's not really criticizing this movie. He's just pointing out all the tiny nitpicks and flaws like a "tiny useless fence" at 1:46. He even called it "pretty charming" in the description.
Snoopy does not in fact have a bag of holding. (9:04). His doghouse is clearly a fully functional TARDIS. Bigger on the inside (it's established in the comics that the inside has multiple rooms), transports him to places outside the backyard, time travels to the past (to battle the Red Baron), and flies (to battle the Red Baron). Bag of Holding: no. TARDIS: yes.
Charlie Brown is a childhood classic for me. Pretty sure I was 13 when the Peanuts movie came out. But I love every second of it, nothing but nostalgia and made with love.
Alright so after watching it, I will say two things: 1. A little disappointed that there were no sins removed for the iconic piano riff 🎹🤩 but I can live with it! Sins were removed, and that's all that mattered (albeit at some unlikely times, but that's okay 😂) 2. Sin 105, where Jeremy talked about how Charlie Brown and Peanuts filmmakers should appreciate his friendship with Linus... I screamed, "THANK YOU!" at the screen. I WAS LITERALLY SO HAPPY WITH THAT ONE. Their relationship is my favorite Peanuts relationship (behind Snoopy & Woodstock) and, while I really do like the little red-haired girl a lot, I whole-heartedly agree that more focus should go into Linus & Charlie Brown. There have been some films that focus on them a little more, like "A Charlie Brown Christmas" and "Happiness is a Warm Blanket", but I do wish for much more of them. Linus really is the only one that loves CB unconditionally and always treats him kindly and fairly - besides in "A Boy Named Charlie Brown", where Linus gave CB his blanket as a parting gift when CB was in a spelling bee and then wanted to kill him when it seemed he lost it 😬😂 - but asides from that, Linus is just a great person, a great kid, and there's a reason (well, a bunch, really) why he's my 2nd favorite character (Woodstock is #1 lmao 😅) Going through a crisis right now, so thanks for giving me a laugh! 🤘🏾
3:16 - to be fair, that was also pretty much Frieda's only reason for existing in the comic strips, which is why she pretty much disappears after a few years.
6:28 I think this was based not on stereotype but on the narration in the Charlie Brown comics, they sometimes start with “It was a dark and stormy night”
No one ever noticed how much dialogue this movie outright steals, robs, thieves, burgles, pilfers, pirates, plagiarizes, mugs, yanks, sneaks, snatches, slips, snaffles, loots, abstracts, absconds, appropriates, shoplifts, embezzles, outright PURLOINS from existing Peanuts movies like A Charlie Brown Christmas.
I fell asleep during this movie in theaters. It's not like it was boring it was just that I got less than 2 hours of sleep and my dad wanted to someone to go with my sister when she saw it.
Before Spider-Verse and Puss In Boots The Last Wish we had Peanuts Movie. I don't think this movie is given enough credit for making stylized cgi the norm of today's animated films.
Grew up watching Peanuts animated specials and I absolutely loved this movie. Also, Escrow is an actual thing: an arrangement in which a third party temporarily holds money or property until a particular condition has been met. And just noticed, that during the test score scene, no. 11's name is well... an actual number!
8:02 this scene unlocked a core memory for me. I don't remember the trailer that well but I do remember it always playing on one of my rugrats vhs tapes that I rewatched constantly growing up in the car.
Schroeders piano is a ongoing joke in the comics, and when he did try a grand piano in his baby years he couldn't handle it. Also I love seeing the list of test scores and finding 5 on there, 5 is such an underrated character, along with his sisters 3 and 4. Snoopy may have knocked out that child, in the comics he does not hold back in boxing with the kids, judo chopping linus, and attacking charlie brown when forced to get a shot This is my comfort movie, and this video was very entertaining to watch!
10:05 It's funny how even their school doesn't know some of the kids' last names. By the way, the Patricia Reichardt listed at 14 is Peppermint Patty's full name.
So, I'm going to be the nerd here and simplify it some - but the reason kites usually come out in spring and summer is that the warmer air rises that adds to the lift of the kite even in lighter breezes, the same way you see birds just cruising and at times gaining altitude or holding it while not even flapping. Technically you could fly a kite in winter - however the usually thinner air and lack of thermals would increase the amount of speed needed via running or more wind in order to get it both airborne and to stay aloft. So Charlie Brown - who already struggles to fly a kite in ideal conditions, trying to fly one in arguably the most adverse conditions possible, so Lucy's jab at him isn't entirely unwarranted.
9:39 Actually, “escrow” is a word. It means a bond, deed, or other document kept in the custody of a third party and taking effect only when a specified condition has been fulfilled.
I mean, how do we know that Snoopy is a helium dog? He could be a hydrogen dog, which would still account for the fact that he floats but also makes things far more concerning that snoopy also breathes an explosive gas. No one let snoopy get near an open flame!
@@Park_Place The real not-right is the fact that Mexican spamthots are targeting everyone who's anyone, whether they have only 28 subscribers or 15,000,000.
4:15 somehow despite taking this joke too seriously you’re actually making a lot of sense. If a snowball can really do that much damage how did Sally survive being chucked into a snowbank
I think this was a great addition to the list of Peanuts film. The animation is 3D but still keeps up with the Sunday morning cartoon style of illustration; it's very unique. I also love the Red Baron scenes. Snoopy is probably one the greatest characters ever written and the fact they kept his dog house as the plane, while flying over the French countryside, instead of just having it from a fixed perspective from the side of his dog house, did his character so much justice.
You sir, missed the subtlety of Lucy saying nickels three times. Lucie was secretly referring to driving the double nickel (55) to get her half on the sack because she had 5 on it.
I love how often we get a "Tommy...how's the peeping?" in the outtakes. CinemaSins should do a tally of all their outtakes and give us a short video leaderboard!
This is the most heartwarming, lovingly crafted (because holy crap the effort they put into animating this...just read the making of book ...wow) film. The adaptation was absolutely perfect, to be frank. Again....a little too much Snoopy but that's an age old issue the Peanuts have always had. Funny enough though, I have a friend who absolutely adores Peanuts but refuses to ever watch this despite his own admiration for it's artistic style. He refuses for one reason only: the actual reveal of The Little Red-Haired Girl. It's a stark betrayal to the entire point of her character. She is meant to represent to all of us that girl that got away. That unrequited crush we've all had at some point. That girl/boy that we yearned for, cried over and desperately did everything to win over. By showing her face and making her accept Charlie Brown's affection (even just as a friend), it ruined the whole message Shultz gave with her. Yes....we wanna give Charlie Brown at least one win in a Peanuts story for once in his life....but maybe having him learn to accept himself and realize he doesn't need validation from anyone especially the Little Red-Haired Girl wouldve been a pretty swell ending. Personally, I really do agree with this negative to the film entirely but I still cherish this movie dearly and watch it almost yearly. The animation alone was a predecessor to Spiderverse, in my opinion, in how passionate animators could still be on film projects.
1:47 I don't know if it's intentional when they do this, but it's very funny to see that arrow point to one "tiny useless fence" when *right next to it* is another equally useless fence, albeit slightly bigger. 6:49 But what about *cartoon* helium dogs?
I had all the peanuts books when I was a kid. I clearly remember me asking my dad what it meant when Charlie was so upset by losing to an expansion team. The best peanuts thing ever is them playing to Rush 2112.
I love CinemaSins’ pedantry! I love it so much, I’m going to add my own pedantic Sins sin: Assuming the “man” in “snowman” refers to gender instead of realizing it’s a portmanteau of “snow” and “human”.
Missed Sin When Charlie Brown entered the library, he had his jacket and his winter hat on and then took off his shoes but in the very next scene, he has his normal clothes on and has his shoes on too.
This is one of the few movies my middle school students will sit quietly and watch with zero incidents of bothering me. Your sins of this movie mean nothing for that alone.
My dad's name is actually Charlie Brown, and as a kid he would always get me the older Charlie Brown movies. Kids in my class would even ask if he had a dog named Snoopy. Not gunna lie it was a little annoying😅
I do think this a good film that honors the Peanuts in a way Charles Schulz would've wanted. And its a good thing there isn't going to be a crappy sequel.
I wouldn't count on it. X-Files is sadly from the looks of it also going to get a reboot. I'm beginning to think people aren't content with masterpieces, but need to see them stumble and fall
You missed a sin at 10:11 - "Pig pen" is apparently considered an acceptable full name for grading purposes, and some student named "5 95472" managed to score better than Pig Pen.
See Hollywood, this is how you adapt a property for a modern audience. No cringe toilet humor, no overpaid celebrities voicing the characters, no tacky pop culture references just a charming, and sweet film that stays with the source material.
When I worked in the DVD room at B&N, this movie had just come out, and we had it on constant repeat on the TV. I still love it, and tear up a bit at the end And the OOO gets me EVERY time 🤣
say what you will, but in my opinion, this is the perfect adaptation. it doesn't deviate too much from the personalities of the characters but it creates in original story out of well-established characters. It even animates itself to look like the classic cartoons.
I absolutely love this movie, and I'm absolutely fine if they don't make another. For what it was, the movie was pitch perfect Peanuts. Anything else risks updating and changing things, which cannot happen.
Not to mention that unlike the other blue sky movies this one isn’t mid
@@slockywush04 To be fair, the older Ice Age movies were pretty good
No shit it’s your opinion. Nobody was confused who typed this.
@@MaztRPwn some people see an opinion and think the speaker is saying some true fact everyone should agree. by stating its my opinion, i let people know that im not compelling them to agree with me
I was terrified about this movie ruining the Peanuts cast for me, and I have a firm place in my heart for Sunday comic strips. (Calvin & Hobbes, Peanuts, Garfield, etc) But this was genuinely such a charming and sweet adaptation that it's one of the few movies I actually bought a physical DVD for.
Watterson never wanted a movie because he was afraid it would ruin Calvin and Hobbes but I hope he can change his mind after seeing this
@@iliketurtles7782 Let's not push our luck here and just call this a miracle.
whoa
@@iliketurtles7782 Nah. _Peanuts_ was already animated back in the 60's, so that's alright for that IP. Bill Watterson is absolutely right. We don't need _Calvin and Hobbes_ to be ruined by being animated. Is nothing sacred anymore? Yes, I wouldn't mind seeing a Spaceman Spiff animated short or something, but that's about it. Movie/TV studios should leave _Calvin and Hobbes_ alone.
@@BaconBlitzz ain't that the truth considering the other movie remakes that came out just after they made this.
It’s confusing to me why all the other kids love to hate Charlie Brown. Charlie isn’t inherently annoying, and every time he does his own thing he gets ridiculed for it.
I know right!? It's so sad. Poor kid. He's nice quiet kid but the world hates him. Maybe it's because he's unlucky? Kinda like Eugene from Hey Arnold
because he's a non-conformist.
Actually... that sounds like the kids I went to school with... ridiculing anyone even slightly different from them.
I remember seeing the previews where they all threw charlie under the bus for breaking an entire fence just for leaning on it while I was thinking, “What a piece of crap that fence was.”
Cause he has less hair than Homer Simpson
I always have a soft spot for The Peanuts Movie, as it brought characters I constantly watched as a kid to the big screen.
And here I thought I was the only one. I was in the theater on opening weekend for this film.
I grew up watching Peanuts. The Great Pumpkin, Christmas and all the Peanuts specials. We watched them every year.
This movie was PERFECT.
@you know this Get your spam bullshit out of here!
Same
wow
Ok
The Peanuts movie was shockingly good. No cringy attempts to "modernize" it like 99.9% of other adaptations based on a famous property, it's almost like it could have come out 50 years ago! Hell, even the animation looks like the original movies, despite being 3D CGI! This right here is something special made by people who respect the source material, not by suits trying to turn brand recognition into a paycheck.
Schultz was the master
@@armaggon5920Schultz was dead
@pau6237 Yeah but he still created this.
@@armaggon5920 He's not the reason this movie is a faithful adaptation though.
@@MeemahSN He is the reason why it exists.
I feel like this deserved at least some sins off for the message at the end, especially if you're familiar with the giant ball of depression that was Charles Schultz and that his son wrote this movie.
All throughout Schultz's career, the world conspires against Charlie Brown. He never wins anything, by design. He's the very embodiment of the idea that the world is cold and cruel and does not care about you, and no matter what you do you will never succeed.
The ending of this movie has Heather (aka The Little Red Haired Girl) read off the laundry list of good deeds she saw Charlie Brown do the entire movie, and she acknowledges his worth.
The movie is a son disagreeing with his father, saying "yes, the world is hard and cruel, but if you're a good person and work hard, the people that matter in your life will notice. There is good in this world. Even Charlie Brown can find happiness. YOU mattered."
I think that's worth some sins off, don't you think? Or does that not bring the cheap laughs?
I love this message, thanks for picking up on it
Very well said
As Schulz once said, "Charlie Brown isn't a loser, because a loser would give up."
Beautifully put.
🤗
One of the things I love most about this film is that the storyline continues to flow so well and yet is at it's heart such a simple and effective story.
Not every film has to have world ending stakes or be about some huge disaster. This film is like a throwback to films like Ferris Bueller where the story and goals are simple and relatable.
I mean it's also a throwback to the classic, cozy Peanuts specials as well
As someone who read a ton of Peanuts strips, it was like literally seeing Schulz's best strips being tied up by a single cohesive plotline, and it was done so simple yet so well
Schroeder’s piano sounds like a grand piano to him (and the other children). Else you’d also have to sin that no real dog is as intelligent as Snoopy.
Bro, Snoopy is the reincarnation of an elder god prophesied to help rid the universe of Gorefield. He is the force that makes all of this happen, and Woodstock and the Beagle Scouts are his infinite arms that work the cosmos.
Ik this is cinemasins, but even many fans seem to miss that intention with Schroeder. "A boy named Charlie brown" had a rather trippy, imaginative moment that pretty much told a young me who wasn't even thinking about it that this was true.
@@The_Biscuit_From_Heaven lol, Snoopy is like someone performing a mass social experiment with clones in a facility somewhere. However I go with the "world in his playground" basics anyway xd.
How. Dare. You.
This movie is a certified banger
I know right this is a good movie
The peanuts movie is one of my favorite blue sky movies
@@lacrimosaknight
Well, Cinemasins told us while sinning Cinemasins that they were blockheads.
And by blockheads...I mean assholes.
@@orcaman1353 Me too.
All sinning aside, I adore this movie. In an era where movie adaptations of beloved children’s characters completely butcher them to a point of being nearly unrecognizable, for a perfect representation of the Peanuts gang to come from Blue Sky of all places is a miracle
The reason that Frieda's concern for her curls is the only fact the movie reveals about her is because that was literally her only character trait. Ever.
Well, she also did try to get Snoopy to chase rabbits--even to the point where she reported him to the Head Beagle for failing in his rabbit-chasing duties.
Yeah that’s her only character trait
I agree. I wish they did more with her than a one line character lol.
@@phoenixnychead beagle? It’s spike isn’t it?
Don't forget, she also at one point had a cat. Those are the only three I know though.
Yo, CinemaSins. The ending? The very last shot of the kids lifting up Charlie Brown? It freeze framing and turning into an OG comic drawing, giving tribute to the Peanuts creator, Charles Schulz? Yeah, that deserves multiple sins off.
This movie *ISN'T* wrong, this movie is fantastic.
It stands out of all Blue Sky's films and I love it with all my might as it's what the movie we needed.
Yeah, and, before anyone goes Chucky on me for saying this, but I just wish it had more of a plot. People don't have to like the same thing, but only if you want to. But it's a really good film to me too. Now if you excuse me, I'll have to watch the Snoopy show.
It’s a joke,
@@paulnewmo What's a joke?
@@mforrest9737 cinmasins fans lol
@@mforrest9737 the whole channel is a joke. It’s not meant to literally say the movie is bad, it’s meant to make you laugh at all the little details that one might think up while watching the movie.
I love how he sins Schroeder's piano for being a toy but sounding like a grand piano when that is the entire running gag joke within the series. Not only have they been very self aware about that but even refrenced how he seems to get way more range than he should with such few keys and the black ones only being painted on. His joke response to this is that he practices a lot and the answer to the mystery remains unsloved beyond him just being THAT talented. To anyone who ACTUALLY reads the comic and appreciates these characters, this would be just a fun opening scene but I think the cinemasins sins show does a good job of explaining this.
Not to mention the "Jingle Bells" bit in the Christmas special, where he gets three distinct sounds from it (piano, organ, toy) at will. Schroeder is secretly an engineering genius who created and miniaturized the synthesizer decades before anyone else!
he also sinned things like Frida's curls being her only personality, and Sally having a crush on Linus while he feels exactly the opposite about her, both of which have been long-time running gags within the comics and specials
The fact that it took them seven years to make this tells you how sin-free this film is.
They took 10 years to make a sins video of The Room. And that's widely considered to be one of the worst films ever.
That was a well made point about Linus. The Little Red Haired Girl was like my junior high crush that immediately went away in high school, while Linus is like my best friend that I’ve had through middle and high school.
Abso-fucking-lutely not. This is one of the most wholesome and heartwarming films ever made. There is nothing wrong with it.
@you know this shut up
Absolutely correct
aside from the Meghan Trainor element. she doesn't belong here
I have high respect for your use of *“Abso-fucking-lutely-not”* 🤘🏻😏
I use that word all the time! Glad to see I’m not the only one 👌🏻💯
And I also respect and love the use of the flowerly prose. The movies inclusion here is not a slam against this movie. And I think we are all David Mamet fans…abso-fuckin-lutely.
This whole thing is a joke. They do this to good movies all the time. Relax its fun.😎
Fun fact: in the 1950s Leo's Toy Store was actually the first toy store wherein children could buy any toy that wasn't a rock (or an attempted murder thrown typewriter).
XDDDD
I'm pretty sure Freida's only character development in the comic strip was she had naturally curly hair! Patty (the girl with the bow, not Peppermint Patty) get's even less. I'm pretty sure her entire character is "girl with a bow".
Fredia was an annoying character that showed up on occasion. Her main trait was trying to get Snoopy to chase rabbits. Patty is Violet's best friend. They are the mean girls. Sometimes they are nice to Charlie Brown and sometimes they are mean to him.
Which is why Patty and Violet disappear sometime in the 60s - Schulz felt that Lucy had the crabby girl market cornered and Patty and Violet, despite being two of the original five characters, weren't needed.
Shermy was similarly dropped from the strip with almost no fanfare; Schulz thought he was boring and that Linus covered the "best friend" aspect well enough that Shermy was expendable.
@@phoenixnyc Honestly I kinda miss Sherman, he was one of my favorite characters when I was younger
There's absolutely NOTHING wrong with this movie
Yes there is! It literally says everything.
Some people just don't understand why these videos are funny.
you're wrong, but it is amazing
You are correct, this movie is flawless
no movie is without sin
This movie made me tear up when I first saw it. I relate to Charlie feeling like he struggles to do anything right so the scene at the end where the red haired girl flips his “failures” on their heads and praises him for the good he did instead was incredibly touching.
Charles Schutz once said "Charlie Brown is who we are, Snoopy is who we want to be."
10:33 she gasped when you said sh*t
It made me sad to see this movie being sinned just because it's one of the most wholesome films I've gotten to see in my lifetime.
Don't be silly, Jeremy sins from a place of love. And, as the channel moniker says, "No movie is without sin."
He's not really criticizing this movie. He's just pointing out all the tiny nitpicks and flaws like a "tiny useless fence" at 1:46. He even called it "pretty charming" in the description.
Snoopy does not in fact have a bag of holding. (9:04). His doghouse is clearly a fully functional TARDIS. Bigger on the inside (it's established in the comics that the inside has multiple rooms), transports him to places outside the backyard, time travels to the past (to battle the Red Baron), and flies (to battle the Red Baron). Bag of Holding: no. TARDIS: yes.
I remember watching this with my aunt in theaters while my parents worked out us moving to another house. Good times….
so glad to see people still talk about this movie , it’s my favorite
14:06 also, can't help but notice the lack of a bus driver.
Charlie Brown is a childhood classic for me. Pretty sure I was 13 when the Peanuts movie came out. But I love every second of it, nothing but nostalgia and made with love.
Ok
Alright so after watching it, I will say two things:
1. A little disappointed that there were no sins removed for the iconic piano riff 🎹🤩 but I can live with it! Sins were removed, and that's all that mattered (albeit at some unlikely times, but that's okay 😂)
2. Sin 105, where Jeremy talked about how Charlie Brown and Peanuts filmmakers should appreciate his friendship with Linus... I screamed, "THANK YOU!" at the screen. I WAS LITERALLY SO HAPPY WITH THAT ONE.
Their relationship is my favorite Peanuts relationship (behind Snoopy & Woodstock) and, while I really do like the little red-haired girl a lot, I whole-heartedly agree that more focus should go into Linus & Charlie Brown. There have been some films that focus on them a little more, like "A Charlie Brown Christmas" and "Happiness is a Warm Blanket", but I do wish for much more of them. Linus really is the only one that loves CB unconditionally and always treats him kindly and fairly - besides in "A Boy Named Charlie Brown", where Linus gave CB his blanket as a parting gift when CB was in a spelling bee and then wanted to kill him when it seemed he lost it 😬😂 - but asides from that, Linus is just a great person, a great kid, and there's a reason (well, a bunch, really) why he's my 2nd favorite character (Woodstock is #1 lmao 😅)
Going through a crisis right now, so thanks for giving me a laugh! 🤘🏾
Only sin this movie is guilty of is being adorable ♥️
3:16 - to be fair, that was also pretty much Frieda's only reason for existing in the comic strips, which is why she pretty much disappears after a few years.
missed outtake opportunity
Lucy: Charlie Brown's flying a kyte!
Woody: That's not flying! That's falling with style!
6:28
I think this was based not on stereotype but on the narration in the Charlie Brown comics, they sometimes start with “It was a dark and stormy night”
No one ever noticed how much dialogue this movie outright steals, robs, thieves, burgles, pilfers, pirates, plagiarizes, mugs, yanks, sneaks, snatches, slips, snaffles, loots, abstracts, absconds, appropriates, shoplifts, embezzles, outright PURLOINS from existing Peanuts movies like A Charlie Brown Christmas.
I fell asleep during this movie in theaters.
It's not like it was boring it was just that I got less than 2 hours of sleep and my dad wanted to someone to go with my sister when she saw it.
@@user-AAAA978
I have not seen it since no.
I will eventually.
9:52 i have officially become unalived
Before Spider-Verse and Puss In Boots The Last Wish we had Peanuts Movie. I don't think this movie is given enough credit for making stylized cgi the norm of today's animated films.
That’s what I keep saying. I truly believe that this style of animation is just perfect. Also this was a really great movie.
Grew up watching Peanuts animated specials and I absolutely loved this movie.
Also, Escrow is an actual thing: an arrangement in which a third party temporarily holds money or property until a particular condition has been met. And just noticed, that during the test score scene, no. 11's name is well... an actual number!
Yeah, I was thinking the same thing about the word "escrow"... Like, dude, do you know nothing about how people buy houses??
8:02 this scene unlocked a core memory for me. I don't remember the trailer that well but I do remember it always playing on one of my rugrats vhs tapes that I rewatched constantly growing up in the car.
I remember it! It had kids and adults talking about watching Peanuts on home video and it had clips from the videos.
@@gamewiz720 yup after I saw this I check for it and there's a channel that has all the old vhs trailers available.
“You wanna talk about Peanuts videos?”
... For some reason, I was expecting all the sins to just be spoken as "Mwuah, mwuah mwuah mwuah! Ding!"
Schroeders piano is a ongoing joke in the comics, and when he did try a grand piano in his baby years he couldn't handle it.
Also I love seeing the list of test scores and finding 5 on there, 5 is such an underrated character, along with his sisters 3 and 4.
Snoopy may have knocked out that child, in the comics he does not hold back in boxing with the kids, judo chopping linus, and attacking charlie brown when forced to get a shot
This is my comfort movie, and this video was very entertaining to watch!
11:19 a HAMMER.
10:05 It's funny how even their school doesn't know some of the kids' last names. By the way, the Patricia Reichardt listed at 14 is Peppermint Patty's full name.
Hey, at least they remembered “5”!
So, I'm going to be the nerd here and simplify it some - but the reason kites usually come out in spring and summer is that the warmer air rises that adds to the lift of the kite even in lighter breezes, the same way you see birds just cruising and at times gaining altitude or holding it while not even flapping. Technically you could fly a kite in winter - however the usually thinner air and lack of thermals would increase the amount of speed needed via running or more wind in order to get it both airborne and to stay aloft. So Charlie Brown - who already struggles to fly a kite in ideal conditions, trying to fly one in arguably the most adverse conditions possible, so Lucy's jab at him isn't entirely unwarranted.
This is one of my low key favorite animated movies of the last ten years.
The Peanuts Movie: a family friendly show that's been wholesome for the better part of half a century...
Cinemasins: You must be judged!!!
true!
8:39 Did anyone notice on the article saying "I'm going to Disneyland"
I noticed.
FORESHADOWING
Thats a sin
9:39 Actually, “escrow” is a word. It means a bond, deed, or other document kept in the custody of a third party and taking effect only when a specified condition has been fulfilled.
Jeremy should’ve taken a sin off for the plane destroying the book report because that scene made me cry in the theater
THIS. IS. A. GOOD. MOVIE.
Im sad that Disney removed the peanuts movie from Disney+
It’s back
IT WAS ON DISNEY PLUS?????
Just watched it on Disney+ now.
cinema sins when the creators add an intentional flaw for comedic value😡
I mean, how do we know that Snoopy is a helium dog? He could be a hydrogen dog, which would still account for the fact that he floats but also makes things far more concerning that snoopy also breathes an explosive gas.
No one let snoopy get near an open flame!
Are you a time traveler?
Something's not right here
@@Park_Place The real not-right is the fact that Mexican spamthots are targeting everyone who's anyone, whether they have only 28 subscribers or 15,000,000.
@@kyrios_rn no, I’m a patron. Patrons get early access to videos, which is why I had such an early comment.
@@JCDavis314 time traveler would've been cooler
This movie was flawless how dare you review this beautiful and wholesome movie
4:15 somehow despite taking this joke too seriously you’re actually making a lot of sense. If a snowball can really do that much damage how did Sally survive being chucked into a snowbank
“Uh, hi, I’m Brown Charlie.”
“That’s-“
I died 😂
I do not understand the joke.
I've been a Peanuts fan since I was little.
I love this movie. Great animation, cute Characters with different personalities, and perfect for kids.
13:28 You missed sinning the Lucy cake topper. The fact that it exists in Snoopy’s daydream is creepy
Snoopy is simps for lucy 💙🖤
I think this was a great addition to the list of Peanuts film. The animation is 3D but still keeps up with the Sunday morning cartoon style of illustration; it's very unique. I also love the Red Baron scenes. Snoopy is probably one the greatest characters ever written and the fact they kept his dog house as the plane, while flying over the French countryside, instead of just having it from a fixed perspective from the side of his dog house, did his character so much justice.
"The conspiracy isn't against you, you're part of the conspiracy" - CinemaSins
That was deep 👍
4:55 I like how before he says it’s “ol number one.” 🤣
The "OOOOO" made me cry laugh. That bit was perfect.
You sir, missed the subtlety of Lucy saying nickels three times.
Lucie was secretly referring to driving the double nickel (55) to get her half on the sack because she had 5 on it.
So... Charlie didn't speak wrongly. He can't cook cupcakes. He probably can't bake them either, but he literally can not cook cupcakes
I love how often we get a "Tommy...how's the peeping?" in the outtakes. CinemaSins should do a tally of all their outtakes and give us a short video leaderboard!
This is the most heartwarming, lovingly crafted (because holy crap the effort they put into animating this...just read the making of book ...wow) film. The adaptation was absolutely perfect, to be frank. Again....a little too much Snoopy but that's an age old issue the Peanuts have always had.
Funny enough though, I have a friend who absolutely adores Peanuts but refuses to ever watch this despite his own admiration for it's artistic style. He refuses for one reason only: the actual reveal of The Little Red-Haired Girl.
It's a stark betrayal to the entire point of her character. She is meant to represent to all of us that girl that got away. That unrequited crush we've all had at some point. That girl/boy that we yearned for, cried over and desperately did everything to win over.
By showing her face and making her accept Charlie Brown's affection (even just as a friend), it ruined the whole message Shultz gave with her. Yes....we wanna give Charlie Brown at least one win in a Peanuts story for once in his life....but maybe having him learn to accept himself and realize he doesn't need validation from anyone especially the Little Red-Haired Girl wouldve been a pretty swell ending.
Personally, I really do agree with this negative to the film entirely but I still cherish this movie dearly and watch it almost yearly. The animation alone was a predecessor to Spiderverse, in my opinion, in how passionate animators could still be on film projects.
1:47 I don't know if it's intentional when they do this, but it's very funny to see that arrow point to one "tiny useless fence" when *right next to it* is another equally useless fence, albeit slightly bigger.
6:49 But what about *cartoon* helium dogs?
CinemaSins: *sins this movie*
Me: We don't do that here.
There is nothing wrong with this movie!!!
sure
Yes there is
The video literally says “Everything wrong with The Peanuts Movie”
@@PussInBootsTheLastWishFan2003 I mean you're not wrong
Literally over 100 sins and nothing is wrong ok 👌
Good Grief!
"Home lawn, escrow, refinancin'....you name it, we got it" --Senor Cardgage
14:20 , A sin was missed! There is NO bus driver!
7:06 Today I learned what agoraphobia is
Also 9:35 learned that escrow is a word
I had all the peanuts books when I was a kid. I clearly remember me asking my dad what it meant when Charlie was so upset by losing to an expansion team. The best peanuts thing ever is them playing to Rush 2112.
“Everyone in 2020.” Hysterically funny. I cried with laughter.
I'm the biggest peanuts fan and this movie absolutely hit the mark, from the characters to the line drawing. Rip blue sky, you were one in a million
I'm sinning the 56 seconds of sponsors.
6:49 how do you know that, have you seen a helium dog?
I still have no idea why this was not nominated for best Animated Picture.
I love CinemaSins’ pedantry! I love it so much, I’m going to add my own pedantic Sins sin: Assuming the “man” in “snowman” refers to gender instead of realizing it’s a portmanteau of “snow” and “human”.
This movie made all of nostalgic, which is extremely impressive considering the studio that made it
No. There is nothing wrong with this movie.
explanation?
This man has a talent for making a good movie look terrible tho lmao
2:40 - True, but he also humiliated her in front of all those people by making her fall on her butt. And on ice, too.
To be fair that was on accident
5:26 Well, she does have red hair. You cannot blame Charlie Brown for recognizing the wonderful quality of that.
Missed Sin
When Charlie Brown entered the library, he had his jacket and his winter hat on and then took off his shoes but in the very next scene, he has his normal clothes on and has his shoes on too.
This was a really impressive movie - good fun story, and an amazing adaption of 2D to 3D. They even got the eyes right :)
Cinemasins can say all they want. Peanuts movie is a masterpiece
Finally!! One that made me laugh all the way through!!! Felt like it did when you first started doing this!! Excellent
I was waiting for this one!
This is one of the few movies my middle school students will sit quietly and watch with zero incidents of bothering me. Your sins of this movie mean nothing for that alone.
My dad's name is actually Charlie Brown, and as a kid he would always get me the older Charlie Brown movies. Kids in my class would even ask if he had a dog named Snoopy. Not gunna lie it was a little annoying😅
"Why is everybody always picking on me?" - Your dad probably.
The cool thing about Snoopy is that he’s not just Charlie brown’s dog. He is everyone’s dog
I do think this a good film that honors the Peanuts in a way Charles Schulz would've wanted. And its a good thing there isn't going to be a crappy sequel.
The sequel might not be so crappy if this movie was fantastic.
I wouldn't count on it. X-Files is sadly from the looks of it also going to get a reboot. I'm beginning to think people aren't content with masterpieces, but need to see them stumble and fall
This movie needs a sequel.
You missed a sin at 10:11 - "Pig pen" is apparently considered an acceptable full name for grading purposes, and some student named "5 95472" managed to score better than Pig Pen.
yes. there is a character in the peanuts called 555 95472
5:06 😂 get the fucking dog off the bed 😂
9:28 The person writing the subtitles know your name but he doesn’t say it. Give my boy C.B a break his parents don’t talk much
See Hollywood, this is how you adapt a property for a modern audience. No cringe toilet humor, no overpaid celebrities voicing the characters, no tacky pop culture references just a charming, and sweet film that stays with the source material.
When I worked in the DVD room at B&N, this movie had just come out, and we had it on constant repeat on the TV. I still love it, and tear up a bit at the end
And the OOO gets me EVERY time 🤣
The audio outtakes were the best I’ve heard in awhile, good work!!
This video starts at 1:10 instead of right away. Ding.