Dune 1984 is a flaming hot mess. It looks good but some scenes are incoherent or downright revolting. That said, David Lynch got the Fremen mostly right and the sandworm scenes are spectacular.
@cringecentral_ because it followed the story and gave a bit of extra background information that the new one leaves out. If you don't know the story at all, you'll learn more from the 84 movie than you will the new one
@@mrmagoo3072the older one changes things though, biggest of which being the bene gesserit powers and the overall message of the story, and in my opinion does so in a negative way
❤❤❤YOU DO NOT HAVE TO FEAR DEATH IF YOU BELIEVE IN JESUS CHRIST, AND TRUST IN HIM WITH ALL YOUR HEART, BECAUSE HE ATONED FOR YOU FOR ALL YOUR INSULTS, THAT YOU WOULD OBTAIN PEACE WITH ALMIGHTY GOD, AND GO TO HEAVEN BY HIS GRACE!!!!!❤❤❤!!!❤❤❤!!!❤❤❤!!!❤❤❤
❤❤❤YOU DO NOT HAVE TO FEAR DEATH IF YOU BELIEVE IN JESUS CHRIST, AND TRUST IN HIM WITH ALL YOUR HEART, BECAUSE HE ATONED FOR YOU FOR ALL YOUR INSULTS, THAT YOU WOULD OBTAIN PEACE WITH ALMIGHTY GOD, AND GO TO HEAVEN BY HIS GRACE!!!!!❤❤❤!!!❤❤❤!!!❤❤❤!!!❤❤❤
I watched the 1984 movie after seeing Part II, and that worm-riding scene made me chuckle. He's literally standing there, throwing the rope off as if it was an unmoving truck 🤣
@no_nuts_he_crazy in no way would I call 84 dune trash. It was beyond overly ambitious. Trying to cram the crazy dune universe into 2 hours was impossible without the studio taking carge over David Lynch.
That's because Lynch's version - while being commercially unsuccessful - was visionary in terms of production and costume design and influenced about every science Fantasy movie. Including new dune.
The Lynch Dune was a little weird. Instead of Paul teaching the Fedaykin the Weirding Way, he taught them how to use machines called the "Weirding Module". It was essentially a microphone and a high powered megaphone. Kind of a dumb idea. He could have just shown Paul teaching them ninjutsu or something, and it would have been acceptable.
@@roumonada Nar, the Weirding Module was one of the coolest things I have ever seen and the way you could say lines like "My name was a killing word". It completely changed my life, and still for me is one of the coolest gadgets ever even after reading the book. Before I read the book I saw it as a natural extension of weaponising the voice. Lynch is weird, but he just made a personal choice as the director (who worked with Frank Herbert btw who loved Lynch film except the ending) not to use the martial arts because he didn't think it would be as interesting on film and just look like kung fu in the desert.
Lynch is a genius director and when anchored he can really make magnificent stuff, but it also had one of the greatest set and costume designers in the business at the time who worked and won Oscars for 2001. A lot of the actors also had read the book and fans including Kyle MacLachlan who played Paul, Frank Herbert doubted him at first but when he chatted with Kyle he learnt he was in a fact a Dune Superfan and really grasped the character.
@markanthony1004 Zendaya hasn't got a chance to show her feminine side or any sensuality in the first Dune. People will need to see more of her. I find her attractive, but several of my friends just see her as okay looking.
I think Dennis heard the complaints about the excessive use of high volume to make a scene Uber epic because there was very little of that in part 2. I like watching movies late when my better half is in bed asleep but I can't do that with Dune pt1. Everyone whispers to each other and then...............AHHHHHGEEEEEYAAAAA!!!!! 😱
It bores the shit out of me. Its predictable, vaguely middle-eastern nonsense that you hear in literally any movie/scene set in a desert. The original Dune has incredible, memorable music.
it's the difference between Toto and a guy who makes his living writing blockbuster epic film music. He said he "invented a couple new instruments for this score" like good job, buddy, but it's you. The problem is you. @@allrequiredfields
It is pretty cool for this time as well. The profoundness of the characters is much bigger in the Lynch's movie. Another thing that does not appear in the new one is the voices off, each character has. The psychological aspects are completely neglected in the new movie, to my opinion.
Honestly watching dune 2 then dune 1984 made so much more sense especially mounting and getting off worms it’s sad bc you can see what lynch was going for and I think if the studios let him have fully control it would’ve been so widely successful
The moment when Paul rides sandworm, and the rock guitars are on with the choire. it was sooo awesome. New edition lack that kind of impact in that scene.
@@Mr_TopekStill, I Love 84 adaptation. I thought that new one will conquer my sympathis but it didn't, for me Lynch and Villeneuve did great job, both movies are great.
I just saw Dune 2 in the cinemas on the big screen. It was amazing with the surround sound, but seeing these clips next to the 84 version are cool too. Makes me want to see the original. I think the great thing about the current Dune is that it pays homage to the original in some kind of way.
I really disslike the new saga. The acting was horrible. The action felt like Ninja crap. No poetic writing. No true V.O. PAUL'S MOTHER JASSIC LETTING A MAN WIPE HER TEAR IN THE SECOND PART WAS DUMB. HE WOULD HAVE ENDED ON THE GROUND IN PAIN. 😅 I REALLY DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY PPL ARE NOT UPSET. THE FACT THEY TREAT THE SAND PPL LIKE A RACE INSTEAD OF A CULTER BOTHERED ME! 😅
@@Rubrick23. Cry about it. Even the original film's producers said the new saga is better. Everyone else likes it too. And it looks much better than the first saga. Also it's an adaptation, learn what it means.
I honestly want to watch the old version now, the more I see it the better it looks, those are some insane visuals that’s probably extremely hard to achieve back then.
Welcome to Dune..Be open mind to both movie version The original I had watched and it is my favorite movies ..give the Messiah more fulfilling ..while the new Dune movie is more action based ..still has the Messiah message yet focused more on action and as well characters interaction ..Both movies goes hand in hand..The original movie The Director did change the part of the sound weapons as the part of the lore ..in the book original sounds weapons wasn't in it ..
The 1984 version has some woeful departures from the book's canon but actually paints the complexity and weirdness of the Dune universe a lot better than the new version. For me, the 1984 version is the superior adaptation.
Kyle MacLachlans little battle speech prior to the battle of Arrakeen in 84' will still be hard to top ...to me that was one of the most epic speeches ever...and I absolutely love the new movie but that one scene in 84 remains to be one of my most vivid an favorit parts of Dune
@@NeverDauntedRadioNetworkWhich he is. Regardless of what the overarching message of the series is, Paul *IS* a hero to these people. So his speech should sound like a hero's speech. The new movie went way to far into the narrative of "strange white man is evil" and just completely ruins the whole tone of the story with that.
@@NovusIgnis You completely missed the point of the books if you think the movie framing Paul as a hypocrite is ruining it. You're supposed to walk away from the story questioning if Paul is a villain despite being referred to as a hero and messiah.
@@joosoo No, I *got* the point of the book. Despite whatever you may think in this modern era, Paul *is* a hero. He is liberating a planet from the oppressive rule of the galactic empire, and the fact that a prophecy was manufactured about someone like him doesn't change that fact. He's leaning into it as a tool to stoke their fervor and make them even more effective fighters, but at no point does he disregard or treat them as lesser. _He gives his water for the dead._ Did you happen to forget that? A detail that they comotley ignore in this movie but is critical in showing that Paul sees the Fremen as human beings, actual people with inherent value. They are not tools or pawns like they make it seem in the movie. It takes away the Atreides leadership and loyalty that he leads with. In the books, the Fremen worship him and follow him as much for that loyalty as for the fact that they think he's their messiah, which he actually is since he's doing the things that will lead them to their green paradise. The fact that the tales of their messiah were planted by the Bene Gesserit is irrelevant. In the book, they follow Paul because he is worth following. They would have followed him prophecy or no prophecy. He's the best fighter, he can see the future, he knows the ways of the dessert without even being Fremen. He wouldn't be the first stranger that they took into their fold, as evidenced by Liet Kynes or Duncan Idaho. He would have quickly risen in their ranks and gained the trust, respect, and loyalty of all the Fremen, just like he did. The fact that he could see into the future would just cement that. The only reason we're even having this discussion now is because Hollywood added in this false conflict with Chani so Zendaya could pretend to be a girl boss and rage against all the white people. It's just more leftist propaganda like always.
First book I read cover to cover as a young girl. STILL ADDICTED TO THIS FUTURE MESSIAH STORYLINE! Everyone loves a savior story. The moment we rented this movie on VHS and the TV version (which has the voice narrative by actors in whole movie as thoughts and the BEST VERSION EVER)! Kyle will always be the best choice for Paul. Then the 90’s remake with different actors was good in its own way. Dune in 2000 is a great translation of the book as well. I can’t wait for them all to be finished, released so I can watch them back to back like a true DUNE NERD! You never want Dune to stop grasping the next generation of sci fi / Messiah addicts & creators who love a store of hope of Salvation from the vile Nero sick’o violent oppressor.
They're comparing one of the best sequences in the original. The sandworm was remarkable, especially for 1983. I guess it wouldn't be fair to compare...other sequences lol
@@netcurtainsJust seen it, part 2 is the best movie I've seen in the last 20 years. People applauded at the end of the movie 🔥🔥🔥The original movie was good for the time but it was trying to do too much for one film and the character development was weak at best.
@@jeanblier8571Meanwhile the new film had plenty of time to develop all of the things that it needed to, and then it didn't. It decided to change things that didn't need changing all because some stupid writers decided that this story would have been better if they wrote it instead, so that's what audiences will get.
@@netcurtainsThank you. Finally. Horrible acting. Wores action. No political war far. They treated the sand ppl like a race inzted of a culture. Lady jassica letting somebody wipe her tear away isn't in her nature. I was very upset. And mad ppl are loving the movie.
I hope the second installment is better than the first. I think David Lynch's version is still ahead of the first installment. It actually feels like the newer version skimped on the production. It feels less otherworldly.
The 1984 film was great, but Frank Herbert's work truly deserves the special effects and technology that the 2024 film can offer. *I CANNOT WAITTTTT!!!* ❤
The old and the new complete each other. That's not some fremen quote,btw.😂😂 I just mean that both films are more enjoyable having already seen the other.
Right? Like im here for the revitalization of Dune and i know the original is a little hacky. However there is just something about it that i love so much.
I will always love the original. I like the new ones too but they could do with a bit of color. Enough with the color grading and desaturating Hollywood.
Since i haven’t watched the originals, after being able to watch the new Dune movie when it’s released, im going to watch the Original versions and truly honestly had no idea they existed (i know it’s criminal) but wow they look so good for its time!
Same here.. I'm a bit sad that i can't experience the old movie as a first timer since know it all from the newer one. Nevertheless i HAVE to see this legendary movie
New version is trash. Dun isn't about race. It's about culter. It isn't about power. It's about understanding and fear of blood lines. Rulers is more of a planet source based thinking. New dune kicked up.
Кино
Dune 1984 looks like it's ahead of its time. I personally haven't seen it, but that trailer looks VERY well done
Brother thats not the original trailer. He re-edited scenes to match this modern one
Dune 1984 is a flaming hot mess. It looks good but some scenes are incoherent or downright revolting. That said, David Lynch got the Fremen mostly right and the sandworm scenes are spectacular.
@@fallinginthed33p Yes it is a hot mess. But I still love it. And the new Dune is brilliant.
The best part about the OG Dune is the baron, then the tv shows get a bit funky
@@fallinginthed33p LOL
2 incredible films exploring story in the way they could with different technology available. Respect both.
1984 dune is ass idk why so many ppl defend it
@cringecentral_ because it followed the story and gave a bit of extra background information that the new one leaves out. If you don't know the story at all, you'll learn more from the 84 movie than you will the new one
@@mrmagoo3072the older one changes things though, biggest of which being the bene gesserit powers and the overall message of the story, and in my opinion does so in a negative way
❤❤❤YOU DO NOT HAVE TO FEAR DEATH IF YOU BELIEVE IN JESUS CHRIST, AND TRUST IN HIM WITH ALL YOUR HEART, BECAUSE HE ATONED FOR YOU FOR ALL YOUR INSULTS, THAT YOU WOULD OBTAIN PEACE WITH ALMIGHTY GOD, AND GO TO HEAVEN BY HIS GRACE!!!!!❤❤❤!!!❤❤❤!!!❤❤❤!!!❤❤❤
@@cringecentral_a diferencia de la guerra de las galaxias que son mejores las Antiguas, Dune Antigua es un excremento
We went from Ginger villains to Baldies.😂😂
Bald is a smart choice 😉
❤❤❤YOU DO NOT HAVE TO FEAR DEATH IF YOU BELIEVE IN JESUS CHRIST, AND TRUST IN HIM WITH ALL YOUR HEART, BECAUSE HE ATONED FOR YOU FOR ALL YOUR INSULTS, THAT YOU WOULD OBTAIN PEACE WITH ALMIGHTY GOD, AND GO TO HEAVEN BY HIS GRACE!!!!!❤❤❤!!!❤❤❤!!!❤❤❤!!!❤❤❤
Bald makes people look intimidating, basically a trope for bad guys and strong men.
From ginger to hairless white supremacists
@@solastro5595not really
the dark vibe in the new one is insanely good
its woke with zendeya
Why? @@ElonHusky
@@ElonHusky me when the book criticizing the white savior complex has a “woke” adaptation:
@@ElonHuskyOMG 😱 THIS MOVIE HAS A POPULAR WOMAN IN IT 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
@@ElonHuskyelaborate
I watched the 1984 movie after seeing Part II, and that worm-riding scene made me chuckle. He's literally standing there, throwing the rope off as if it was an unmoving truck 🤣
1984 holds up pretty damn well.
I like the bottan
I think the old one is incredible for the time it was made
It’s trash compared to the likes of the original Star Wars trilogy which was near the same period.
You know nothing little boy@@no_nuts_he_crazy
The 1984 version was so ambitious especially considering that cgi was virtually non existent at the time.
@no_nuts_he_crazy in no way would I call 84 dune trash. It was beyond overly ambitious. Trying to cram the crazy dune universe into 2 hours was impossible without the studio taking carge over David Lynch.
How @@maggs131
1984? Yet the quality looks futuristic, looks like it's made in 2000s or something. The actors/actress in the top video looks fine as hell 😮
That's because Lynch's version - while being commercially unsuccessful - was visionary in terms of production and costume design and influenced about every science Fantasy movie. Including new dune.
Now we need a short like this but with the Jodorowsky's Dune concept art
The Lynch Dune was a little weird. Instead of Paul teaching the Fedaykin the Weirding Way, he taught them how to use machines called the "Weirding Module". It was essentially a microphone and a high powered megaphone. Kind of a dumb idea. He could have just shown Paul teaching them ninjutsu or something, and it would have been acceptable.
@@roumonada Nar, the Weirding Module was one of the coolest things I have ever seen and the way you could say lines like "My name was a killing word".
It completely changed my life, and still for me is one of the coolest gadgets ever even after reading the book. Before I read the book I saw it as a natural extension of weaponising the voice.
Lynch is weird, but he just made a personal choice as the director (who worked with Frank Herbert btw who loved Lynch film except the ending) not to use the martial arts because he didn't think it would be as interesting on film and just look like kung fu in the desert.
Lynch is a genius director and when anchored he can really make magnificent stuff, but it also had one of the greatest set and costume designers in the business at the time who worked and won Oscars for 2001. A lot of the actors also had read the book and fans including Kyle MacLachlan who played Paul, Frank Herbert doubted him at first but when he chatted with Kyle he learnt he was in a fact a Dune Superfan and really grasped the character.
The new dune part 2 gave me chills, it's been a while since I've seen a movie this good. I give it 1000 percent, best movie of the year hands down
The actress for Chani in the original is so fine 🫠
She also played Rachel in Blade Runner.
@@slappy8941 Also Einhorn in Ace Ventura Pet Detective.
And Zendaya isn’t?
@markanthony1004 Zendaya hasn't got a chance to show her feminine side or any sensuality in the first Dune. People will need to see more of her. I find her attractive, but several of my friends just see her as okay looking.
@@markanthony1004 No she isn't, not compared to Sean Young, the Chani of the first version. Light-years distance.
Usul has called a big one. Again it is the legend.
This is the sentance i was looking for.Respect✌🏻
Mmmmmmmmmm shaihulud
The girl in 1984 was really beautiful
Sean Young also played Rachel in Blade Runner.
@@xjudoflip7381🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂
@@xjudoflip7381 Those are the biggest hemorrhoids I have ever seen!
Eh. Just a white woman with 70s hair 😅
@@tonijackson3421 if that’s all you see....
Stillsuits from Lynch's Dune kick ass.
Yes very close to how I imagined them to be from the book. The catch pockets etc.
that cut made the 84 movie really enticing tbh 😅
With this music, voices and sound effects you managed to make the 1984 movie look decent :o
o yeah...like the power of any horror movie lies greatly on its sound effect
That song is so epic.
The wide shots of the worms in the 1984 version look amazing. A well done miniature will always look better than cgi in my opinion
This I completely agree on and was one of the only things better in the original.
Correct.
What?!? Hahahaha
Copium
I like the child actress in 1984 that plays Paul sister, “For he is the qusat saterach” 😊
She was the best one in the film:
Her performance was so good. Creepy little child using the Voice, running around stabbing people.
The best. I missed her a lot in the new boring versions
Was sorta pissed when his sister wasn't other than a baby in her mothers womb in new film. Also she was supposed to kill the Baron!
A sack of rice could be falling over and the soundtrack would immediately go "WOOOOAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHEEEEEEAAAAH" ^^
Glad I’m not the only one noticing that - it’s so awful - they did that with Wonder Woman in justice league too didn’t they ? Was so so distracting
Yes lol. I needed earplugs watching Dune Part 1 at the Imax.
The IMAX theater sound was so overwhelming that I couldn't understand the dialog some of the time 😆
I think Dennis heard the complaints about the excessive use of high volume to make a scene Uber epic because there was very little of that in part 2. I like watching movies late when my better half is in bed asleep but I can't do that with Dune pt1. Everyone whispers to each other and then...............AHHHHHGEEEEEYAAAAA!!!!! 😱
It's the sound tracks that get me
It bores the shit out of me. Its predictable, vaguely middle-eastern nonsense that you hear in literally any movie/scene set in a desert. The original Dune has incredible, memorable music.
@@allrequiredfields at last someone said this, thank you
The best part of the new Dune's music score was the brief inclusion of some of Toto's original theme towards the end.
@@allrequiredfields Toto!
it's the difference between Toto and a guy who makes his living writing blockbuster epic film music. He said he "invented a couple new instruments for this score" like good job, buddy, but it's you. The problem is you. @@allrequiredfields
that moment the 80's proves it's self again. 80's is the worm, the worm is the 80's
Stilgar: "Nothing fancy."
1984's Paul: **Proceeds to delimitate a construction site with the rope on the worm's back.**
Lynch's Dune is underrated, honestly. If you guys search for the SpiceDiver fan-edit, the movie is pretty cool for its time.
It is pretty cool for this time as well. The profoundness of the characters is much bigger in the Lynch's movie. Another thing that does not appear in the new one is the voices off, each character has. The psychological aspects are completely neglected in the new movie, to my opinion.
The new one is terrible...
@@nidhoggvomwalde2280 visuals are excellent though, but this is the only good thing I would say, and actors are not bad
The old one and the new one and the books and the books by the guys kid are all, DUNE.
@@arzabael useless.
It was so nice to see the original actors. The book describes the looks
Honestly watching dune 2 then dune 1984 made so much more sense especially mounting and getting off worms it’s sad bc you can see what lynch was going for and I think if the studios let him have fully control it would’ve been so widely successful
Обожаю Вильнева и его Дюну.
Люблю Дюну 1974 года и это не мешает восхищаться новой Дюной.
The original is one of my favorite movie. The soundtrack was created by the great toto
Likewise- in spite of its failings, you can see a genius movie shine through
The moment when Paul rides sandworm, and the rock guitars are on with the choire. it was sooo awesome. New edition lack that kind of impact in that scene.
@@bandzior21 I can only sense bias from this comment. Original saga looked like some children playing in kindergarten.
@@Mr_TopekStill, I Love 84 adaptation. I thought that new one will conquer my sympathis but it didn't, for me Lynch and Villeneuve did great job, both movies are great.
@@Mr_Topekimo, the 1984 looks goofy af, nostalgia hits pretty hard nowadays
I just saw Dune 2 in the cinemas on the big screen. It was amazing with the surround sound, but seeing these clips next to the 84 version are cool too. Makes me want to see the original. I think the great thing about the current Dune is that it pays homage to the original in some kind of way.
I still love the origional immensely!
I really disslike the new saga. The acting was horrible. The action felt like Ninja crap. No poetic writing. No true V.O.
PAUL'S MOTHER JASSIC LETTING A MAN WIPE HER TEAR IN THE SECOND PART WAS DUMB. HE WOULD HAVE ENDED ON THE GROUND IN PAIN. 😅
I REALLY DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY PPL ARE NOT UPSET. THE FACT THEY TREAT THE SAND PPL LIKE A RACE INSTEAD OF A CULTER BOTHERED ME!
😅
@@Rubrick23.You are sick in the head, respectfully.
@@Rubrick23. Cry about it. Even the original film's producers said the new saga is better. Everyone else likes it too. And it looks much better than the first saga. Also it's an adaptation, learn what it means.
@@Mr_Topekoriginal book , not movie
1984 Chani is stunningly beautiful.
Her smile is wowwwww ❤❤
And resembles the Chani of the books
Sean young
Okkkkkkkkkk
And 2024 obnoxius and unbearable...
Dune is one of the most beautiful movies I’ve ever seen
Hans Zimmerman’s score elevates the whole vibe on so many levels
I honestly want to watch the old version now, the more I see it the better it looks, those are some insane visuals that’s probably extremely hard to achieve back then.
Lynch's version was very dreamy and had some strange depth of soul that Villeneuve's didn't.
Look up Dune Redux here on RUclips, it's a fanesit of the 1984 and it's amazing.
Welcome to Dune..Be open mind to both movie version
The original I had watched and it is my favorite movies ..give the Messiah more fulfilling ..while the new Dune movie is more action based ..still has the Messiah message yet focused more on action and as well characters interaction ..Both movies goes hand in hand..The original movie The Director did change the part of the sound weapons as the part of the lore ..in the book original sounds weapons wasn't in it ..
The 1984 version has some woeful departures from the book's canon but actually paints the complexity and weirdness of the Dune universe a lot better than the new version. For me, the 1984 version is the superior adaptation.
Sean Young's beauty was unmatched 🐱
indeed, much better than Zendaya IMO
Anyone else get chills hearing this music?
Wow. I will actually watch the 1984 version. It holds up incredibly well.
The most recent one is technically spectacular as well.
The first Dune is mind blowing!!!! I just love them both the same!!!!
Kyle MacLachlans little battle speech prior to the battle of Arrakeen in 84' will still be hard to top ...to me that was one of the most epic speeches ever...and I absolutely love the new movie but that one scene in 84 remains to be one of my most vivid an favorit parts of Dune
And you know the problem with that great speech? It did too much to position Paul as a hero.
@@NeverDauntedRadioNetwork correct
@@NeverDauntedRadioNetworkWhich he is. Regardless of what the overarching message of the series is, Paul *IS* a hero to these people. So his speech should sound like a hero's speech.
The new movie went way to far into the narrative of "strange white man is evil" and just completely ruins the whole tone of the story with that.
@@NovusIgnis You completely missed the point of the books if you think the movie framing Paul as a hypocrite is ruining it. You're supposed to walk away from the story questioning if Paul is a villain despite being referred to as a hero and messiah.
@@joosoo No, I *got* the point of the book. Despite whatever you may think in this modern era, Paul *is* a hero. He is liberating a planet from the oppressive rule of the galactic empire, and the fact that a prophecy was manufactured about someone like him doesn't change that fact. He's leaning into it as a tool to stoke their fervor and make them even more effective fighters, but at no point does he disregard or treat them as lesser.
_He gives his water for the dead._ Did you happen to forget that? A detail that they comotley ignore in this movie but is critical in showing that Paul sees the Fremen as human beings, actual people with inherent value. They are not tools or pawns like they make it seem in the movie. It takes away the Atreides leadership and loyalty that he leads with.
In the books, the Fremen worship him and follow him as much for that loyalty as for the fact that they think he's their messiah, which he actually is since he's doing the things that will lead them to their green paradise. The fact that the tales of their messiah were planted by the Bene Gesserit is irrelevant. In the book, they follow Paul because he is worth following. They would have followed him prophecy or no prophecy. He's the best fighter, he can see the future, he knows the ways of the dessert without even being Fremen. He wouldn't be the first stranger that they took into their fold, as evidenced by Liet Kynes or Duncan Idaho. He would have quickly risen in their ranks and gained the trust, respect, and loyalty of all the Fremen, just like he did. The fact that he could see into the future would just cement that.
The only reason we're even having this discussion now is because Hollywood added in this false conflict with Chani so Zendaya could pretend to be a girl boss and rage against all the white people. It's just more leftist propaganda like always.
1984 is underrated, it's a good movie
1984 is sooo strange that you have to love it.
People talking about 1984 Chani was lit while Im just staring at the old sand WILF
Lol
Dune 1984 is a masterpiece.
The worms were really well done!
Love Dune. Frank Herbert is the best. Genius. Thx film makers. 4 bring this ❤
As 1984.
It looks great❤
The kiss scene of Paul and Chani in 1984 was breathtaking, so beautiful
I have to say, that music from Hans Zimmer make goosebumps every time ❤❤❤
WOW FOR 1984!!!
Say whatever you want, but people will always remember David Lynch's Dune!
I will remember it for sure but the new one I also will never forget 🙌🏻
It was panned though by critics and audience.
Only fans of classic sci-fi movies with nostalgia factor adore it.
The new Dune on the other hand ...
Never watched or had interest in watching it...The new one however had me hooked!
First book I read cover to cover as a young girl.
STILL ADDICTED TO THIS FUTURE MESSIAH STORYLINE!
Everyone loves a savior story.
The moment we rented this movie on VHS and the TV version (which has the voice narrative by actors in whole movie as thoughts and the BEST VERSION EVER)! Kyle will always be the best choice for Paul.
Then the 90’s remake with different actors was good in its own way.
Dune in 2000 is a great translation of the book as well. I can’t wait for them all to be finished, released so I can watch them back to back like a true DUNE NERD!
You never want Dune to stop grasping the next generation of sci fi / Messiah addicts & creators who love a store of hope of Salvation from the vile Nero sick’o violent oppressor.
He is a messiah, a savior tho? A bit unclear haha. I like that he's a dark messiah.
Wow that looks amazing I didn’t realise they got so much inspo from it
I love the sandworm from 1984, it's made so nicely for it's time!
Now do this with Toto's soundtrack
TOTO > HZ in Dune
David Lynch's Dune was beautiful.
Love the music of dune
Done part two is incredible and I also still love Lynch version. ❤
They're comparing one of the best sequences in the original. The sandworm was remarkable, especially for 1983. I guess it wouldn't be fair to compare...other sequences lol
Best scene ?in your opinion,here's my opinion,new dune sucks big time
@@netcurtainsJust seen it, part 2 is the best movie I've seen in the last 20 years. People applauded at the end of the movie 🔥🔥🔥The original movie was good for the time but it was trying to do too much for one film and the character development was weak at best.
@@jeanblier8571Meanwhile the new film had plenty of time to develop all of the things that it needed to, and then it didn't. It decided to change things that didn't need changing all because some stupid writers decided that this story would have been better if they wrote it instead, so that's what audiences will get.
@@netcurtainsThank you. Finally. Horrible acting. Wores action. No political war far. They treated the sand ppl like a race inzted of a culture. Lady jassica letting somebody wipe her tear away isn't in her nature. I was very upset. And mad ppl are loving the movie.
@@jeanblier8571so you have no taste. 😅
I just saw the movie today and it was freaking amazing
Chani 1984 was SO beautiful!
Dune ist einfach fantastisch...einer meiner Lieblingsfilme und ich warte schon lange sehnsüchtig auf den 2 Teil ☺️
A younge Kyle MacLachlan was such a hottie!
Would be cool if they sneak him in as a older freemen or something in the next film
What's younge?
I hope the second installment is better than the first. I think David Lynch's version is still ahead of the first installment. It actually feels like the newer version skimped on the production. It feels less otherworldly.
Because i had seen the 1982 version since 2000, i want more of it.
Dune 2 was a masterpiece and by far the best movie of 2024.
2021 version is like a perfume commercial. Duuuuune by Calvin Klein. Deeeeesert Power by Channel.
The 1984 film was great, but Frank Herbert's work truly deserves the special effects and technology that the 2024 film can offer. *I CANNOT WAITTTTT!!!* ❤
New saga sucks ass😅
The old and the new complete each other. That's not some fremen quote,btw.😂😂 I just mean that both films are more enjoyable having already seen the other.
I knew about the 80s version but why am I only discovering now Lynch directed it 😭😭😭
New Dune was Masterpiece
Chaani in 84 is really beautiful
No matter how awesome the new movies are, they will never have that poncy git Sting getting a crysknife thru his head. Best moment in cinema history.
Right? Like im here for the revitalization of Dune and i know the original is a little hacky. However there is just something about it that i love so much.
Gotta love those winged underoos tho
New dune sucked ass big time. 😅 only ppl who don't get dune will justified it trash
Yeeess. I missed it a lot in new boring disneyish versions
That fight scene in the 1984 Dune with Sting is epic.
I love the otiginal Dune. The new one has it's good moments too.
La version de Lynch est inégalable !😊
84 was such a beautiful movie
Just Villeneuve out here recreating Sean young movies.
Damn, definetely constrained by the technologies of the time. Great ambitions from Lynch though🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
Lynch knows how to create unque atmosphere.
I will always love the original. I like the new ones too but they could do with a bit of color. Enough with the color grading and desaturating Hollywood.
Wooooo Weeeee! Soo excited!
woah the new dune’s new visuals and tech made the concept the story be more striking and provoking
No wonder I loved the trailer so much, I loved the original the first moment I saw it too!
Imagine we time travel back and show the new movie in theatres 😂
Well, that would be fun!
It would Still be a bore,
I prefer Lynch's blue within blue. But i am so excited for DUNE II coming this fall 🙌
Villeneuve is closer to the book.
I love the original Dune
I like the old version of Paul's first worm ride much more, the climbing on the worm, the worms being on the surface, the fremen following him up.
1984 Dune rocked
It really didn't at all
David Lynch, what a king 👑
Since i haven’t watched the originals, after being able to watch the new Dune movie when it’s released, im going to watch the Original versions and truly honestly had no idea they existed (i know it’s criminal) but wow they look so good for its time!
Same here.. I'm a bit sad that i can't experience the old movie as a first timer since know it all from the newer one. Nevertheless i HAVE to see this legendary movie
1984❤❤❤❤❤
Damn orson be doing the most in 1984
Honestly, the color grading in 1984 is so much better.
Lynch captured the feel but the screenplay was sabotaged, the characters were well done
Realy it's Cool🎉
I wish they kept the electricity crackling around the sandworm.
Nothing can beat 84’s Dune, but the new version is beautiful too
New version is trash. Dun isn't about race. It's about culter. It isn't about power. It's about understanding and fear of blood lines. Rulers is more of a planet source based thinking. New dune kicked up.
@@Rubrick23.How do you have a discussion of culture without a discussion of race
New one is also very boring...
@@Rubrick23.How was the new one about race?? You're confused my guy.
1984 is the best
One looks a lot more colorful than the other..
so much better ❤ dune 2024 is so good
1984 chani is sublime
Forty year old film looks just as good & was endlessly more intriguing than this recent one.
"The long sleeper live has the awakened fighters"