Oh MY! The Famous Bath Scene. She doesn't look too happy to see him. I agree with koppsr, who very aptly says, "she looks more like a frightened mouse than a on-her-way-to-be-seduced-woman." I love how Catherine's brother jerks a little bit when Isabella says "I remember I wore this yellow gown." It rather gives the impression that he remembers otherwise, no? "And as for dancing, don't even mention it. I'LL mention it at every turn to save YOU the trouble. Oh! Do you think HE'LL dance with me?"
I can't express my feelings for when I first saw that 'dream' scene. Lol, seriously, I stopped breathing, it was so 'un -Jane-Austen' like xD Creepy, but at the same time very gothic and romantic.
Well, she is naive and codependent enough to keep caving to his demands for her attention, so I guess he figures that is his key to overcoming her resistance.
i always laugh when i see the look in her eyes at 2:43, she looks more like a frightened mouse than a on-her-way-to-be-seduced-woman^^ but so cute^^ i love this movie so much :) thx for posting it :)
Emily Bronte was born in 1818 and published Wuthering Heights in 1847 . Jane Austen was born in 1775 and died in 1817 . Northanger Abbey was published in 1818 , after her death .. So yes the characters should not be talking about Wuthering Heights...and the person who said they studied English Lit and Bronte was before Austen maybe needs to resit their exam ;-) The manners , modes of dress and politics of the day had changed immeasurably by the time the Brontes came along as the Industrial Revo
Yeah, Catherine is so real and refreshing around all the hoity-toity people stuffed up with their rediculous "proper" habits! I like how Mr. Tilney makes fun of it all.
@snoofard well seeing as how i am an art history and fashion major i would know this. however, women in pop culture have every part of thier bodies hanging out- but does that make it- how you say- acceptable?
@karyn13house Me too! Carey Mulligan is adorable! Just not so much in this movie. I liked her character better in Pride and Prejudice, even though her part wasn't as big. And I loved her as Sally Sparrow!
@BastBlue So boring you felt the need to search for it on RUclips and comment on just how boring you found it....? Wow, an interesting, fun-filled life you have there.
Love Tilney in the Fantasy; I'm blushing just thinking about that happening in REAL life!! Darnit; why does Mrs. Allen have to ruin it!! Thats how u ask for her hand in marriage? How UNromantic!! GOD how fake Miss Thorpe is!! BTW; when I say I'm like Catherine; Im like her when I was younger; still got some of those characteristics; but not all!!
@kmarty290 no kidding! is she makes a small sharp turn... POP! out they come. lol. I can't believe these girls who proclaim they love someone and turn around and play like he doesn't even exsist. geez women, come to grips with urselves. lol
Oh gosh I love the way he says thank you to her.
Indeed, he's got a very pleasing voice, warm and soft.. I could listen to this quite some times too- same with the soup eating scene a bit later..
You would think that the number of times Thorpe swears would tell her that he's not the type of person she should be hanging around.
yeah I def. melted a bit when he said thank you to her. lol
Oh I agree. His voice is so great to listen to *swoon*
Exactly! Thorpe realises Catherine's innocent nature and uses it to his advantage. He's quite the little snake in the grass.
They talk about Wuthering Height eventhough its author Emily Bronte was born a year after Jane Austen died. :-S
I'm sitting here thinking "run Catherine RUN!" whenever Isabella and John are around
Oh MY! The Famous Bath Scene. She doesn't look too happy to see him. I agree with koppsr, who very aptly says, "she looks more like a frightened mouse than a on-her-way-to-be-seduced-woman."
I love how Catherine's brother jerks a little bit when Isabella says "I remember I wore this yellow gown." It rather gives the impression that he remembers otherwise, no?
"And as for dancing, don't even mention it. I'LL mention it at every turn to save YOU the trouble. Oh! Do you think HE'LL dance with me?"
"I...think it is a good thing too." :I'm so PLEEEEASED to hear you say that." ewww he's so creepy! his eyes are popping out of his head!!! O.O
Isabelle Thorpe= vicious version of Lydia Benett
Thank you! I was wondering at tht. I havnt read this book but I didnt think a JA novel wud contain such lurid material
"I could never triffle with a man's affections" my FOOT. Isabella is all kinds of horrid. Shallow and foolish girl!
I can't express my feelings for when I first saw that 'dream' scene. Lol, seriously, I stopped breathing, it was so 'un -Jane-Austen' like xD Creepy, but at the same time very gothic and romantic.
Well, she is naive and codependent enough to keep caving to his demands for her attention, so I guess he figures that is his key to overcoming her resistance.
Yeah, but he is moving so quickly, that is it understandable that she isn't jumping to that conclusion.
i always laugh when i see the look in her eyes at 2:43, she looks more like a frightened mouse than a on-her-way-to-be-seduced-woman^^ but so cute^^ i love this movie so much :) thx for posting it :)
"You know my nature: I could never trifle with a man's affections." Yeahhhh.... about that....
Oh my she is exquisite!
That bathtub fantasy was hot! lol
such a creeper he was stalking her before they even met lol
Thorpe is so obssesive it seems.
don't apologize that you are leaving thorpe, you won't be missed
James Morland is so cute~
It's corset that gives that impression,lol.I as member of male population don't really care either way,she's a cutie.Carey Mulligan
I love Henry!!!!!!!!
AAHHHHHHH!!!!!!!! Catherine is having wet dreams of Henry!!!! lol
Emily Bronte was born in 1818 and published Wuthering Heights in 1847 . Jane Austen was born in 1775 and died in 1817 . Northanger Abbey was published in 1818 , after her death .. So yes the characters should not be talking about Wuthering Heights...and the person who said they studied English Lit and Bronte was before Austen maybe needs to resit their exam ;-) The manners , modes of dress and politics of the day had changed immeasurably by the time the Brontes came along as the Industrial Revo
That scene with her fantasy isn't in the DVD! o.o when it skipped right past that part I was a little put-out to be honest XD
Yeah, Catherine is so real and refreshing around all the hoity-toity people stuffed up with their rediculous "proper" habits! I like how Mr. Tilney makes fun of it all.
isabelle looks familiar to me. she looks like the Catherine in pride and prejudice 2005
Thorpe and his sister are both creepers.
personally when Isabella said that about my brother some one would have been slapped right across the face.
How rude
haha i love that she is secretly fruity
Thank You scampostrini !
they were already in love but he unexpectedly came into a fortune and became a viscount so general tilney consented to the marriage
Does Thorpe seriously think he has a chance with Catherine or any woman at that?!
mr. thorpe reminds me of a hobbit
Is it just me or there's some Jude Law aspect on that Mr. Tilney?
Carey mulligan!! just noticed that!
@mommastime2shine "My dear Catherine, I remember ALL of the most important dates according to the style of my hair at the time :)"
Loving the Thorpe-hate!
@imova you mean Mr. Morland?.
What a creeeeper!
mr thorpe is coming on a bit too strong!
@snoofard well seeing as how i am an art history and fashion major i would know this. however, women in pop culture have every part of thier bodies hanging out- but does that make it- how you say- acceptable?
poor innocent catherine
Ahhhh...he's so creepy!
John Thorpe- Worst proposer of marriage ever.
*mouth drops open*
okay that was NOT in the book
but . . . .
Thorpe looks like a leprechaun to me does anyone else think that?
I think I need to read Northanger Abbey again because this movie doesn't feel like Jane Austen to me. Some parts do, but some really don't.
mr. tilney sounds a bit like alan rickman at times.
it could just be me though.
@karyn13house Me too! Carey Mulligan is adorable! Just not so much in this movie. I liked her character better in Pride and Prejudice, even though her part wasn't as big. And I loved her as Sally Sparrow!
actually in the book catherine is 17 not 15
OMG I KNOW! I hated that so much! I didn't understand why they cut that out.
he looks like a cave man.. John does.. *ick*
O...kay?? That was weird, I´m sure Jane Austen didn´t write THAT!!!
LOL I don't blame her for her rather...ehem...carnal thoughts. I read "The Monk" and it truly is one of the most sexual, dirtiest books I've read.
@BastBlue So boring you felt the need to search for it on RUclips and comment on just how boring you found it....? Wow, an interesting, fun-filled life you have there.
@chefb2you definitly ! i really doubt that young ladys in the 18 hundrets would rly think that way . . . i dont know :S
I want to go on a walk with Mr. Tilney. Ok, fine. I want to marry him....there should be more Mr. Tilney's in the world!
wow. naiive
Lol John Thorpe is definatly a jerk but his brutality is hillarious in this movie!
Yes, I agree! Perhaps with a bit of a pike-ish influence...?
@stoneoffarel I know, that is quite too far, don't you think...
Love Tilney in the Fantasy; I'm blushing just thinking about that happening in REAL life!! Darnit; why does Mrs. Allen have to ruin it!! Thats how u ask for her hand in marriage? How UNromantic!! GOD how fake Miss Thorpe is!! BTW; when I say I'm like Catherine; Im like her when I was younger; still got some of those characteristics; but not all!!
@kmarty290 RIGHT ON!
Thorpe makes me want to puke
@Nymphadoramoony - in full agreement with u! hahaha!
Please don't insult hobbits that way.
I know ! What a creep!
@kmarty290 no kidding! is she makes a small sharp turn... POP! out they come. lol.
I can't believe these girls who proclaim they love someone and turn around and play like he doesn't even exsist. geez women, come to grips with urselves. lol
thorpe is insufferable
Watched this in class ... Damn sooo boring
More like an orc
Hate the parts not true to the original Austen.
John Thorpe is.....Not attractive and he's kinda creepy...
Lol xD I don't like him either
I do not like Mr. Thorpe at all
Ewwww...I don't like John Thorpe.