Salam guys, Josh had to go synagogue, however we agreed to continue the prophethood and the reliability of the Torah next week, because if he accepts prophet Muhammed message as true then why does he reject him as true prophet?. We will find out next week 😊.
When you prove him, that the Quran is the word of God, then he must believe/accept, that the Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. is the final messenger. When he rejects, he automatically rejects Allah/God like Iblees: "And [mention] when We said to the angels, "Prostrate before Adam"; so they prostrated, except for Iblees. He refused and was arrogant and became of the disbelievers." (2:34)
Yeah... so he following the wrong path because you are following the right one right? There are few a words in English that describes a person like you "a religious fanatic", "ignorant" "intolerant", "disrespectful " etc.. And that makes one a Muslim? I think not.
Prophet Muhammad is mentioned in the Hebrew Bible Verse 16::: Mem chet (het) dalet mem ( Muhammad) PEACE ALL- may the GOOD forces be with you.- There is something on the internet about this but I am interested to get a hold of a Hebrew version
May Allah reward you akhi, watched it till the end and enjoyed how they also believe in the oneness of Allah and not associate partners with him. subhan Allah.
Our enemy is not the Jews but the Zionists who will be the followers of Dajjal while true Jews and Christians will work with the real Isa (as) when he comes down.
Islam and judasim can trace their routes back to abraham .where as the bible has been corrupted by people like james and paul . they have added stuff like trinity and misinterpreted most of it
Hence why we’re cousins in religion because our religions are closer then Christianity/Catholicism those religions were altered after the New Testament I don’t know how much the Torah was changed but some changes were made to it as time went by but that and the Bible were books we followed before the Quran was sent down as the final book
@S K Actually, according to your Bible, Jesus bowed down and prayed on with his face on the floor (like Muslims) until his forehead bled, just before he was arrested. Why did he do that? 😆 Go read your Bible, so you can get a clue.
This jewish brother is so humble and polite! May Allah guide him to the right path. I must say he has a very good behavior and knows to respect people!
The jewish boy was very humble, when Ali Dawah pulled out his iPhone 11 Pro Max, he didn’t feel shy to look at his older non-smart phone. He was honest and he was not arrogant.
Many orthodox jews don't have smart phones. In some communities it's believed that there's a lot of content on the internet that caters to our worst inclinations and sows divisiveness, so it's better to use the time to study or spend time with family :)
@KingOfKingz Bro in the Bible they take women by their own will so don't even come saying stuff you don't know."Kill every man,babe,cattle and every flock" but you can have their women????but yall dont talk about that tho. ("I often scraped it (semen) from the garment of the Messenger of Allah with my hand.") This is a strawman argument. No one of any note has claimed Muhammad had sexual intercourse with Aisha when she was 6 years-old. It was only their marriage that took place when she was aged 6. Sexual intercourse occurred when she was 9 lunar years-old (possibly 8 years-old if the Gregorian calender is used to calculate her age). Nothing in the Quran or authentic hadith narrations mentions “thighing” as far as I can find, but it is not forbidden. It is for a man to enjoy sexual intimacy with a woman without sexual intercourse by placing his sex organ between her thighs. Regarding your other question, during that time it was common for people to keep their clothes mostly on during sexual intercourse, which meant that sometimes semen could get on clothes. The hadiths I have seen in Sahih al-Bukhari do not say that it was “all over” his clothes, just that that there was one spot that had to be washed. The matter at issue with Aisha’s age is the validity of the hadith literature. An admission that Aisha’s age at marriage may have been different from 9 would shake the foundations of hadith science since it would imply that there are false statements in Sahih Bukhari and Muslim, therefore the majority of traditionalist scholars are unwilling to go that route. From what I have seen, using traditional methodology, the evidence in support of Aisha being 9 stronger than the evidence against it. Unfortunately I cannot find any source that researches this issue in an unbiased manner; they are either angrily defending the “honor” of al-Bukhari and Muslim (the traditionalist sources), or they mix weak and strong arguments, bad research and a disrespectful attitude toward the scholarly community in supporting a different age. A minority of prominent modern scholars, such as Ali Gomaa (Egypt’s Grand Mufti from 2003 to 2013) and Taha Jabir Alalwani (an Iraqi scholar who teaches in the United States) believe that Aisha was “in her late teens” at the time of the consummation of her marriage (mentioned in Misquoting Muhammad by Jonathan Brown). So the matter is not very cut-and-dry. The most prominent authority for Aisha’s age is Hisham bin Urwa (her nephew). But this same person is quoted in al-Dhahabi’s Siyar Aʿlām al-Nubalāʾ as saying that Aisha died at the age of 67 in the year 672, which would logically mean she was born around the year 605. Since her marriage was consummated in or around 622, that would make her 17 at the time of consummation. Before her marriage to the Prophet, there is mention in authentic sources of Abu Bakr having promised to marry off Aisha to a pagan man (Jubayr bin Mutam bin Adi). This promise must have been made before Islam, because it is highly unlikely that Abu Bakr would promise a pagan his daughter after he became Muslim himself. This means that, even if the promise was made when Aisha was an infant, it would have been made on or before 610 CE (the year of revelation), making her at least 12 in 622 CE when her marriage with the Prophet (peace and blessings of God be upon him) was consummated. 12 is not much “better” than 9, but the point is that this conflict with the official narrative is sufficient to throw doubt on the whole story. And if we assume she was bigger than an infant, perhaps 3, at the time of the promise, then that would make her 15 in 622 CE at the time of the consummation of her marriage with the Prophet (peace and blessings of God be upon him). Professor Salah al-Din al-Idlibi is the fairest-minded voice on this issue that I have found. He is a not a liberal Muslim who dismisses tradition, he is a hadith expert who works within the tradition and concludes in a 2018 paper that it is most likely Aisha was born about 4 years before the Revelation, making her close to 18 at the time of the consummation of her marriage near the end of the first year of the hijra. Another aspect of Aisha’s age is that, due to the Hypocrites in Medina, and later some of Shia, claiming that she was unchaste, there was a strong incentive for Muslims to give preference to any evidence that suggested she was extremely young at the time of her marriage while dismissing evidence against it. They did not necessarily fabricate evidence, but it is possible that there were authentic hadith narrations that supported a different age but that were not written down by the hadith scholars in their hadith collections because they preferred the age of 9. We know that hadith scholars refused to write down narrations they considered “absurd”, even if their chain was authentic. (See Jonathan A.C. Brown, “The Rules of Matn Criticism: There Are No Rules.”) Hope Uk Mary(peace upon her) was around 12-14.
Rahmat Izzat then that is just flat out anti Semitic, judaidism is an og religion bro they are the first monotheistic religion, we hate Zionist’s but not Jews and that’s the end of discussion
Why it should be this way ?? Coz they weren’t arguing ?? Josh was willing to explain Jewish tradition, he had 5 points that he believe contradict with Quran , any Muslim with a true knowledge of Islam would have cherished this, we know Islam is the truth .... yet this donkey didn’t even ask about one of This points !?
tinylilmatt I don't see any gun? Didn't they tell you not to do drugs at school, didn't you're mom say that drugs were bad? I think you're high if you see a gun my guy.
Alhamdulillah, I respect both gentlemen. They are communicating each other with humility. This is a great example how we as brothers should get along and talk to others. May Allah guide both of them.
I find this more interesting than a Christian and Muslim debating because I've heard so many times the similarities and differences between Christianity and Islam, so it was nice to see it now with Judaism.
@@astra1097, yes, I know. I like learning the similarities and differences between Islam Judaism more over it with Christianity, because it's not talked about as much.
No way... Ya Allah... I'm lost for words. I remember seeing him during ramadan on a video when he was talking with brother Hamza, he was so open minded, respectful and overwhelmed me with kindness just watching. I sincerely made du'a for him to be guided, and just now see this in my reccommended may he be guided by Allah, ameen. SubhanAllah.
That's hilarious! I am a Hindu. Pls try and convert me. If you think I am ignorant, then try and convert me with real teachings of God Almighty. Pls... pls...
@@harisomakantan6168 If you really want to know about Islam ... Research it for sure you will find the truth ... Find some relegiuos person around you ..he can be imam of any masjied ...get in touch with any of your Muslims friends .. around you ...May Allah give you hidaya ... inshallah ...like my friend ...👍👍.. Hope to here from you soon ..
@@shahfahad1520 No I don't. I am very comfortable with my vedic teachings, Which is monolitic and has a Single entity as God, which you know nothing about. There is no need to convert anyone to anything. The fact that you and your likes are so closed up and hell bent on converting others is a sign of weakness. That if someone do not agree to Islam or its teachings, then basically they are "infidels" and most likely should be killed or something like that. The real true religion is patient and can accept different facets of truth as it should be. For you there is only one version because you never took time to explore others. Your fanactism limits you. SO if you don't have someone agreeing to Islam, then that person is lost! To me, that is infantile and a joke. The same Allah, you are worshipping, I am also worshipping, Allah, Krishna, Christ, Buddha are all the different facets of the Almighty Truth, which you can never understand nor will accept because of your fanatical conditioning of your religion. SO if you really want to know about Islam, then open up your mind and study other facets of truths ann not fear them. AND IN THE PROCESS, THERE NO NEED TO CONVERT YOURSELF FROM ISLAM. I really hope you can grasp, what I am trying to tell you here.
@@harisomakantan6168 if you have read my comment initially I told you to reaserch on Islam ..and suggested you how to convert bla bla ...stuff...well you have right to believe how you want and I respect that ... It will be waste if I tell you why Islam is best ..people convert it or rather revert it because they find truth according to them simple .. I have read Christianity and Judaism apart from Islam ...after all these 3 relegions come from same branch...well not fully known Hinduism still ...but one thing is very clear .. the people who are following Hinduism is not the right Hinduism ..infact it's sanatani dhram the real Hinduism which says not to worship idols.
@@harisomakantan6168 Infidel, what does it even mean? Basically non-muslim, just like you've got non-christians, non-jewish people etc, it's Muslims are basically a group of people who believe in Islam. And no, the Qur'an does not ask us to kill non-muslims unjustly, the Qur'an clearly states, to fight only in defense, in fact if even the Muslims start fighting amongst themselves, we are supposed to fight the aggressor. Basically, Islam is against aggression. Now, coming to what you said, the irony of your comment makes me laugh really.. You claim we're closed minded and so on, basically just bashed Muslims and also further stated we don't read about any religion and etc.. You have clearly not read about Islam, had you really atleast heard to it, you would know we're not allowed to fight in aggression or kill just anyone, atleast that's what it shows from how you wrote it. Furthermore, even when Muslims DO read about other religions, only unbiased would accept it.. When Muslims like Zakir Naik try to teach, we very well know how he has basically been been kicked out of his own country which falsely accuses him of terrorism, and of course, BJP with its million tricks and lies cannot be counted upon for a fair trial, because of the hatred they have for Muslims
Josh you are a young man with knowledge and patience and aint scared to answer questions some Jewish people won't even talk about. Top man may god keep guiding you.
Wow 😳 i live in NYC. I talk to many Jews all of the time and I have never ever seen a Jew who is this sincere when speaking about religion. Both parties are genuinely interested in one another’s views points without getting arrogant or angry. Just wow. Ali keep up the awesome work and may Allah guide this Jewish brother.
@@S_goldman_ No one is trying to convert. Debating about religion is good for everyone since it leads to everyone being more knowledgeable. And a side result could be that it leads to someone maybe questioning their religion and asking themselves if this is the right religion to follow if it has flaws or contradictions
@@S_goldman_ But yes Judaism isn't meant to spread worldwide as it's more of an exclusive religion that priorities Jews. But Islam tells Muslims to spread their religion worldwide to anyone that is willing to hear the message of God which is the same as what Christianity tells Christians. Which is why Islam is the second-fastest-growing religion, the religion with the highest number of converts, and will overtake Christianity by 2030
To you who bully Ali, and call him a clown, a showman and say that he is giving the wrong message. I hope you come up with a sensible answer in the day of judgment. Imagine Ali went back to Islam, his mother was not a believer and his father did not believe in god. A boy at such a young age who wanted to change his life when he probably thought this was unnecessary without believing in god to want to be rather grateful to the one who gave him a life. He had to sneak up on Fajr because his father did not want him to become a Muslim. He had to walk on his toes because he did not want his father to know that he was praying. But he did it just for the sake of Allah, in other words he did it to be grateful. Can you imagine that? is that why you should bully him and give him a bad name. Brethren, be afraid of Allah, if Ali does something wrong, talk to him in private not shout at people 99 percent interpret it wrong and all non-believers will be happy that we quarrel with each other. This is how war starts, it always starts with words and it also expands. So for the sake of Allah, if you absolutely must correct him because he does not give the right dawah. Go to him like a man and talk to him like a man. I am sure he wants to improve. May Allah bless you. Amen!
I agree completely, brother. I believe Ali is sincere - there is no reason anyone should insult Ali in the comment section, and if they wish to advise him, they should word it constructively. Better yet, reach out in private.
@Abdul Shahriad brother, with all do respect to Adam Saleh, fosueytube and etc. They are not that religous or in other words they dont know so much about islam, so it's maybe little bit easier for them to mock or bulllying. But actually this message was not for Adam and fousey. Since you said some names, let me say that this message was actually for Shamsi. Se Shamsi know mashallah aloot in islam, for him to start war with his mouth and spread it, it's a danger. As I said earlier people will belive him just because he know so much in islam. But clearly he dont know how to respect people who passed away for exampel Brother Eesa may Allah bless him.
This would be such a beautiful poem, if this wasn’t the same guy who almost fought an old man, claimed he would spit on a woman, and let that same woman fall by taking the chair away. Hatun is the True Warrior here! Like Muslims stop worshipping this dude. I know he acts just like your false prophet Muhammad, but whatever happened to common sense? May Jesus have mercy on you guys and I see a lot of Muslims becoming Followers of Christ soon!!🙏🏾👑✝️
@@jordanwafula6729 You must be crazy so to say that Hatun is a warrior. An warrior is not one with his or hers words. An warrior is one who is kind, respectful, praying 5 times, gives charity, help other people and so one. Now tell me what of those 5 things i mentiond is Hatun? Kind? Respectful? Or praying 5 times from sunrise to sunset? Do you really think she do that? The problem with you people are that, when muslim do good or have knowlege like an sciense, you guys BURN!! You burn so much that even you don't respect our prophet at least. And talk more shit you see muslims become christians.. is that why churchs gettin empty? See the Christian religon is not a problem as we say, the author of Christian is a problem. Allah Akbar ☝️
I’ve seen Josh for the second time at SC & he seems like a sincere soul who’s not only polite, well spoken & intelligent but very god fearing & god conscious & for this reason I believe Allah swt is bringing him more closer to Islam & InshaAllah Josh will embrace Islam in the very near future.
Jew here. I'm curious. To us Jews, a non-Jew is righteous person as long as they are faithful to the one true G-d, no partnership etc. You don't have to convert or be a Jew to be rightous in Judaism. Is that the same in Islam? Example, I'm a Jew, I believe, serve and submit to the one G-d, no other partnership etc. So am I considered rightous in Islam or even a Muslim?
@@nickname1734 Thanks for your reply. I wonder if that means faithful Jews can just continue as they are and wouldn't need to convert to Islam to be considered Muslims.
When he didn't hesitate to say "yes of course if you prove it to me", I knew this young man was a special one. Most of the people who speak with Ali don't want to change their mind even if they are proven wrong.
@@harisomakantan6168 hmm 😒 I'm one of the half million people that watched this video and I'm pretty sure almost all of them hear the truth except those who decided to cover their ears like you .duh
I liked that he gave straight forward answers for what proof he requires and that he would believe in Prophet Mohammad if he finds that he was a true prophet. People usually dance around these question and makes the discussion boring and unfruitful.
Mashallah! Let's pray that Jews find out the truth and accept it from our hand, with kindness and reason. They are our cousins after all and all humanity need guidance. Ameen.
Ali Dawah all the work you put in the Dawah is worth it you're truly an amazing person and I hope you the best my man if anybody hates on you just ignore them because positivity will always come first than negative. Mashallah I love what you do brother. Much love.❤❤
The signs of Allah's love for a person are as follows : 1. When Allah loves someone he puts them under trials ( the more righteous they are, the harder the trials) in order to purify them. 2. When Allah loves someone, he gives them the"understanding" of the religion of Islam. 3. Whomever Allah loves, he deviates them and their heart from disobedience and sins.. Jazak Allah'u khair 💚🕋صَلّی اللّٰہُ عَلٰی حَبِیبِہ مُحَمَّدٍ وَّآلِہ وَسَلَّمَ💚🕋
It’s so nice to see our young brother Ali doing a great job calling humanity to the path of ALLAH suphane te ala May Allah increase the knowledge and patient. JazakAllah
ma'sha'Allah, the Jewish guy has such a beautiful character and manners! May Allah swt guide him to the straight path, ameen. Get such positive good vibes from him
Ali, if someone says they have to leave then let them leave. Don't try to keep them longer. It serves no purpose and can annoy people and close them off.
I love this Jewish brother. He is so me.....❤❤❤ He just needs to complete reading quran ( which he has started already)... Praying for you my Jewish brother. I see the light coming towards you.
I genuinely have respect for this man, he is not like the other Jews and Qurayshi leaders who saw the signs and still denied. He is worth more than me to Allah
Are you ignorant or what? If you are Muslim you are worth more to Allah than this Jewish he is not on the right path while you are He is in denial of God's messanger so he is an infidel!
Hey I am Jewish but I am also interested in Islam. I spiritually lost and am searching for other faiths. Do you mind explaining what the tenets of Islam are. Thanks 🙏.
Jason M there are 5 pillars in islam 1 is shahada which is believing there is no another god but allah and muhammad is the messenger of god 2nd is salat which is preforming prayer and 3rd is zakat which is to give to charity and help the poor 4th is to fast during ramadan 5th is hajj which is to preform pilgrimage
Jason M If you don't want to pay I recommend a fully English version online. Search up yourself "clearquran.com" on Google. If you are okay with paying, another fully English version which I highly recommend is "The Clear Quran", by Dr. Mustafa Khattab. On Amazon I believe it is $5-7 USD. Whichever way you choose and whenever you read it, if at any point something is unclear, you can ask me for clarification.
@ishhh khan durrani Prophet Muhammad is mentioned in the Hebrew Bible Verse 16::: Mem chet (het) dalet mem ( Muhammad) - the question is what exactly is written about him??? Does anyone know? PEACE ALL- may the GOOD forces be with you.
@@Sketchbook9999 It is verse 5:16 in Songs of Solomon where the name is given as "Muhammadim" where "im" in Hebrew is for respect. This is found in the Hebrew Bible.
This was the most normal discussion I have noticed on this channel. Rather than trying to decipher what people are saying as they are talking over each other, this is informative. Really hope Ali Dawah puts out more content like this.
May Allah reward you brother Ali, in this world and in the hereafter. Love your approach of wanting to discuss as opposed to just debating (though each approach has its own place and merit). Keep up the good work 👍
I am a muslim but regardless of any religion is someone has a behavior like Josh i would always love to interact with them in any sort of daily matters. Josh is on a right path following the message of Muhammad already just through different methods i guess. May Allah always have him under his mercy and all the thoughtful human beings.
I like the personality of him (jew). he seems very calm and i also like when an other man confirms that we have a lot in common in oure religion.may allah guide us all❤ and inshallah we all have that many hasants to get in jannah inshallah!❤
I actually love the discussion very delighted to see Josh i think he is one of the enlightened jew i ever crossed on RUclips, very knowledgable and have the desire to seek the truth without having overcome by ego....wonderful discussion !
He was rocking backwards and forwards, he’s used to doing that as he would have been doing that ever since he was in yeshiva, whilst learning, it’s just something they’re used to doing
9:00 Saying that god rested means that he "ceased to do" is blasphemous because the universe in every second is guardianed by Allah. The universe would cease to exist if Allah ceased to hold it and sustain it with his power, knowledge, etc .. There is no rest for God that "fits his majesty", because resting is intrinsically un-God-ly.
Allah SWT Created the seven Heavens in 2 'Days', then 'ceased' creating any more Heavens . He Created the Earth in 2 'Days', then 'ceased' creating any more Earths. He finished Creating the contents of the Earth in 4 Days then Rose above the Throne - meaning to take charge /authority over all His Creation which He COMPLETED IN 6 DAYS. Therefore there is no Blasphemy in this.
@@lion_hawk - that same jew would agree exactly with your statement " He Almighty kept sustaining, mastering, managing, etc... the universe as a Rabb!" This Jew KNOWS that God NEVER RESTS NOR TIRES. He is trying to reinterpret the word 'rest' (which he admits cannot apply to God) to a more appropriate meaning such as 'ceased'. Meaning that after 6 Days, God finished/ceased / ended the 6 Day process of Creation. There's nothing blasphemous about that. That doesn't mean that God stopped being Rabb/Lord of all Creation (& all the other Attributes you mentioned) Put yourself in his shoes to understand his mind/thinking.
I valid points that you bring up Ali. I myself started to questioning the Christian Bible. I read the Student bible and then the King James Version. This is a great video. It shows alot to someone really truly wondering what to Believe. I am a Muslimina and there is only One God and Muhammad (SWT) is his final Messenger.
have you read Quran and hadith carefully ? since it's taught Muslims to make war with others ...it's surely Islam not a peacefull religion ...if you see Quran dan Hadith, there are many verses taught Muslims to make war with others , for example , QS [9:29]: Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued. QS [9:5] : Then, when the sacred months have passed, slay the idolaters wherever ye find them, and take them (captive), and besiege them, and prepare for them each ambush. But if they repent and establish worship and pay the poor-due, then leave their way free. Lo! Allah is Forgiving, Merciful. or in Hadith , quranx.com/hadith/Saliheen/In-Book/Book-19/Hadith-1839/ Abu Hurairah (May Allah be pleased with him) said in the interpretation of the Ayah reported: "You are the best of peoples ever raised up for (the benefit of) mankind..." (3:110): The best for mankind are those who bring them with chains round their necks till they embrace Islam (and thereby save them from the eternal punishment in the Hell-fire, and make them enter Jannah in the Hereafter)."[Al-Bukhari].
@@CarlosMartinez-jg6gg so Christians never went to war? Never killed people and called it religion. Killed children, women, elderly? Hmmm... Suspicious
Salam guys, Josh had to go synagogue, however we agreed to continue the prophethood and the reliability of the Torah next week, because if he accepts prophet Muhammed message as true then why does he reject him as true prophet?. We will find out next week 😊.
I wanna find out when will you make a video about the chalange about sheikh salih fawzaan.
When you prove him, that the Quran is the word of God, then he must believe/accept, that the Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. is the final messenger. When he rejects, he automatically rejects Allah/God like Iblees: "And [mention] when We said to the angels, "Prostrate before Adam"; so they prostrated, except for Iblees. He refused and was arrogant and became of the disbelievers." (2:34)
Alii jezakallah khiyer borther
In sha Allah next time again and a Little Bit Longer
⚡【Ｍｅｌｋｏｒ】⚡ how about you tell us and provide proof, instead of running your mouth
Josh is such a nice guy. He’s not rude nor arrogant. May Allah guide him to the right path
Yeah... so he following the wrong path because you are following the right one right?
There are few a words in English that describes a person like you "a religious fanatic", "ignorant" "intolerant", "disrespectful " etc..
And that makes one a Muslim?
I think not.
@@harisomakantan6168 huh? What does that have to do with my comment?
Oh nvm lol
I didnt say my path. I said right path. Leave the rest to God and go take a chill pill.
Prophet Muhammad is mentioned in the Hebrew Bible Verse 16::: Mem chet (het) dalet mem ( Muhammad)
PEACE ALL- may the GOOD forces be with you.-
There is something on the internet about this but I am interested to get a hold of a Hebrew version
May Allah reward you akhi, watched it till the end and enjoyed how they also believe in the oneness of Allah and not associate partners with him.
subhan Allah.
DawoodSAVAGE even i was surprised how kind that person was
Dawood SAVAGE I love you! Biggest fan. If you have the time can you please reply.
Our enemy is not the Jews but the Zionists who will be the followers of Dajjal while true Jews and Christians will work with the real Isa (as) when he comes down.
DawoodSAVAGE 💓💓💓💓
Fancy seeing u here
What a kindhearted young man, this Jewish guy. I really like him.
Assalamualaikum wa Rahmaatullahi wa barkathu
We should say MashAllah when we praise something or. Someone
@@Ashu-mg6ef I thought we are supposed to tabarkAllah for someone and mashallah when something good happens to us. Maybe I’m wrong
Islam and judasim can trace their routes back to abraham .where as the bible has been corrupted by people like james and paul . they have added stuff like trinity and misinterpreted most of it
Hence why we’re cousins in religion because our religions are closer then Christianity/Catholicism those religions were altered after the New Testament I don’t know how much the Torah was changed but some changes were made to it as time went by but that and the Bible were books we followed before the Quran was sent down as the final book
@S K Actually, according to your Bible, Jesus bowed down and prayed on with his face on the floor (like Muslims) until his forehead bled, just before he was arrested. Why did he do that? 😆 Go read your Bible, so you can get a clue.
This Jew seems reasonable but others who don't even know about thier own religion keeps barking the same stuff
This what mature debate should be
💯
This is a genuine question. Isn't that considered backbiting?
@@wisdomofthawheedh4274 oh hello again
@@wahabakhtar2467 backbiting who? No one is mentioned here how can it be backbiting?
Don't buy these unhealthy oils all oils are not healthy all of them are very bad: sources in nutritionfacts.org
I don’t know why, but when he showed his baby blue brick phone I instantly respected him more.
Guy's a genuine person. He wants to learn. He wants to listen. He wants to know the truth. He doesn't care about technology.
You can tell alot about a person with the kind of phone they have
💥
Me too lol
It’s because Orthodox Jews don’t use technology (internet). They don’t use smart phones.
This jewish brother is so humble and polite!
May Allah guide him to the right path.
I must say he has a very good behavior and knows to respect people!
The jewish boy was very humble, when Ali Dawah pulled out his iPhone 11 Pro Max, he didn’t feel shy to look at his older non-smart phone. He was honest and he was not arrogant.
I didn't notice tbh
Many orthodox jews don't have smart phones. In some communities it's believed that there's a lot of content on the internet that caters to our worst inclinations and sows divisiveness, so it's better to use the time to study or spend time with family :)
Who cares about a mobile phone lol
Who cares
@@chayaalexandriaakin429 that is Rly smart
I was soo surprise to see a Jew and a Muslim smiling at each other, that's love man
To us, the Muslims, Jews are not our enemy but in fact, they are our cousins. But the Zionists on the hand are the real problem.
mariam hashmi this is what most people don’t understand, when I say that I love Judaism and jews all these people attack me
@KingOfKingz Christ said his disciples are in him and since he is God you are God too
@KingOfKingz Bro in the Bible they take women by their own will so don't even come saying stuff you don't know."Kill every man,babe,cattle and every flock" but you can have their women????but yall dont talk about that tho.
("I often scraped it (semen) from the garment of the Messenger of Allah with my hand.")
This is a strawman argument. No one of any note has claimed Muhammad had sexual intercourse with Aisha when she was 6 years-old. It was only their marriage that took place when she was aged 6. Sexual intercourse occurred when she was 9 lunar years-old (possibly 8 years-old if the Gregorian calender is used to calculate her age).
Nothing in the Quran or authentic hadith narrations mentions “thighing” as far as I can find, but it is not forbidden. It is for a man to enjoy sexual intimacy with a woman without sexual intercourse by placing his sex organ between her thighs.
Regarding your other question, during that time it was common for people to keep their clothes mostly on during sexual intercourse, which meant that sometimes semen could get on clothes. The hadiths I have seen in Sahih al-Bukhari do not say that it was “all over” his clothes, just that that there was one spot that had to be washed.
The matter at issue with Aisha’s age is the validity of the hadith literature. An admission that Aisha’s age at marriage may have been different from 9 would shake the foundations of hadith science since it would imply that there are false statements in Sahih Bukhari and Muslim, therefore the majority of traditionalist scholars are unwilling to go that route. From what I have seen, using traditional methodology, the evidence in support of Aisha being 9 stronger than the evidence against it. Unfortunately I cannot find any source that researches this issue in an unbiased manner; they are either angrily defending the “honor” of al-Bukhari and Muslim (the traditionalist sources), or they mix weak and strong arguments, bad research and a disrespectful attitude toward the scholarly community in supporting a different age.
A minority of prominent modern scholars, such as Ali Gomaa (Egypt’s Grand Mufti from 2003 to 2013) and Taha Jabir Alalwani (an Iraqi scholar who teaches in the United States) believe that Aisha was “in her late teens” at the time of the consummation of her marriage (mentioned in Misquoting Muhammad by Jonathan Brown). So the matter is not very cut-and-dry. The most prominent authority for Aisha’s age is Hisham bin Urwa (her nephew). But this same person is quoted in al-Dhahabi’s Siyar Aʿlām al-Nubalāʾ as saying that Aisha died at the age of 67 in the year 672, which would logically mean she was born around the year 605. Since her marriage was consummated in or around 622, that would make her 17 at the time of consummation.
Before her marriage to the Prophet, there is mention in authentic sources of Abu Bakr having promised to marry off Aisha to a pagan man (Jubayr bin Mutam bin Adi). This promise must have been made before Islam, because it is highly unlikely that Abu Bakr would promise a pagan his daughter after he became Muslim himself. This means that, even if the promise was made when Aisha was an infant, it would have been made on or before 610 CE (the year of revelation), making her at least 12 in 622 CE when her marriage with the Prophet (peace and blessings of God be upon him) was consummated. 12 is not much “better” than 9, but the point is that this conflict with the official narrative is sufficient to throw doubt on the whole story. And if we assume she was bigger than an infant, perhaps 3, at the time of the promise, then that would make her 15 in 622 CE at the time of the consummation of her marriage with the Prophet (peace and blessings of God be upon him).
Professor Salah al-Din al-Idlibi is the fairest-minded voice on this issue that I have found. He is a not a liberal Muslim who dismisses tradition, he is a hadith expert who works within the tradition and concludes in a 2018 paper that it is most likely Aisha was born about 4 years before the Revelation, making her close to 18 at the time of the consummation of her marriage near the end of the first year of the hijra.
Another aspect of Aisha’s age is that, due to the Hypocrites in Medina, and later some of Shia, claiming that she was unchaste, there was a strong incentive for Muslims to give preference to any evidence that suggested she was extremely young at the time of her marriage while dismissing evidence against it. They did not necessarily fabricate evidence, but it is possible that there were authentic hadith narrations that supported a different age but that were not written down by the hadith scholars in their hadith collections because they preferred the age of 9. We know that hadith scholars refused to write down narrations they considered “absurd”, even if their chain was authentic. (See Jonathan A.C. Brown, “The Rules of Matn Criticism: There Are No Rules.”)
Hope Uk Mary(peace upon her) was around 12-14.
Rahmat Izzat then that is just flat out anti Semitic, judaidism is an og religion bro they are the first monotheistic religion, we hate Zionist’s but not Jews and that’s the end of discussion
The Jewish brother seems so genuine and down to earth may Allah guide him to Islam in shaa allah
Not a Muslim nor a Jew but I respect the healthy discussion, great debate guys
Prayers to you that these debates lead you the truth. Ameen 🙏😊
@@wishjcena Assalamualaikum
best comment
Why it should be this way ?? Coz they weren’t arguing ?? Josh was willing to explain Jewish tradition, he had 5 points that he believe contradict with Quran , any Muslim with a true knowledge of Islam would have cherished this, we know Islam is the truth .... yet this donkey didn’t even ask about one of This points !?
Respect to u who watch the video with an openmind.
This brother seems to be genuine, May allah guide him.
He seem to have a good heart. Might Allah guide him
tinylilmatt I don't see any gun? Didn't they tell you not to do drugs at school, didn't you're mom say that drugs were bad? I think you're high if you see a gun my guy.
💯👌
@tinylilmatt drugs...not even once.
@tinylilmatt where you there holding that gun??
Or???
Alhamdulillah, I respect both gentlemen. They are communicating each other with humility. This is a great example how we as brothers should get along and talk to others. May Allah guide both of them.
I find this more interesting than a Christian and Muslim debating because I've heard so many times the similarities and differences between Christianity and Islam, so it was nice to see it now with Judaism.
True but Jews have similar mindset of god being not imaginable
Moses' (pbuh) story was very similar to Muhammad's, (pbuh)
@@astra1097, yes, I know. I like learning the similarities and differences between Islam Judaism more over it with Christianity, because it's not talked about as much.
Jesus is the truth the way and the life
@@Ephesians--zs6pv, Jesus (Esa, pbuh) was one of the many Prophets of Allah.
No way... Ya Allah... I'm lost for words. I remember seeing him during ramadan on a video when he was talking with brother Hamza, he was so open minded, respectful and overwhelmed me with kindness just watching. I sincerely made du'a for him to be guided, and just now see this in my reccommended may he be guided by Allah, ameen. SubhanAllah.
One friend of mine converted to Islam from Hinduism ..2 months ago..I'm so happy for him ... Allah will give hidaya whome he wants
That's hilarious!
I am a Hindu.
Pls try and convert me.
If you think I am ignorant, then try and convert me with real teachings of God Almighty.
Pls... pls...
@@harisomakantan6168 If you really want to know about Islam ... Research it for sure you will find the truth ... Find some relegiuos person around you ..he can be imam of any masjied ...get in touch with any of your Muslims friends .. around you ...May Allah give you hidaya ... inshallah ...like my friend ...👍👍..
Hope to here from you soon ..
@@shahfahad1520 No I don't. I am very comfortable with my vedic teachings, Which is monolitic and has a Single entity as God, which you know nothing about. There is no need to convert anyone to anything. The fact that you and your likes are so closed up and hell bent on converting others is a sign of weakness. That if someone do not agree to Islam or its teachings, then basically they are "infidels" and most likely should be killed or something like that. The real true religion is patient and can accept different facets of truth as it should be. For you there is only one version because you never took time to explore others. Your fanactism limits you. SO if you don't have someone agreeing to Islam, then that person is lost! To me, that is infantile and a joke.
The same Allah, you are worshipping, I am also worshipping, Allah, Krishna, Christ, Buddha are all the different facets of the Almighty Truth, which you can never understand nor will accept because of your fanatical conditioning of your religion. SO if you really want to know about Islam, then open up your mind and study other facets of truths ann not fear them. AND IN THE PROCESS, THERE NO NEED TO CONVERT YOURSELF FROM ISLAM. I really hope you can grasp, what I am trying to tell you here.
@@harisomakantan6168 if you have read my comment initially I told you to reaserch on Islam ..and suggested you how to convert bla bla ...stuff...well you have right to believe how you want and I respect that ... It will be waste if I tell you why Islam is best ..people convert it or rather revert it because they find truth according to them simple ..
I have read Christianity and Judaism apart from Islam ...after all these 3 relegions come from same branch...well not fully known Hinduism still ...but one thing is very clear .. the people who are following Hinduism is not the right Hinduism ..infact it's sanatani dhram the real Hinduism which says not to worship idols.
@@harisomakantan6168 Infidel, what does it even mean? Basically non-muslim, just like you've got non-christians, non-jewish people etc, it's Muslims are basically a group of people who believe in Islam.
And no, the Qur'an does not ask us to kill non-muslims unjustly, the Qur'an clearly states, to fight only in defense, in fact if even the Muslims start fighting amongst themselves, we are supposed to fight the aggressor. Basically, Islam is against aggression.
Now, coming to what you said, the irony of your comment makes me laugh really..
You claim we're closed minded and so on, basically just bashed Muslims and also further stated we don't read about any religion and etc..
You have clearly not read about Islam, had you really atleast heard to it, you would know we're not allowed to fight in aggression or kill just anyone, atleast that's what it shows from how you wrote it.
Furthermore, even when Muslims DO read about other religions, only unbiased would accept it..
When Muslims like Zakir Naik try to teach, we very well know how he has basically been been kicked out of his own country which falsely accuses him of terrorism, and of course, BJP with its million tricks and lies cannot be counted upon for a fair trial, because of the hatred they have for Muslims
This guy is really respectful.
May Allāh guide him.
💯👌
Nike islamic commercial Check it out
I liked the ad bro. It looks great
Don't buy these unhealthy oils all oils are not healthy all of them are very bad: sources in nutritionfacts.org
@@dawoodfaqier9762 The ad is anti-Islamic akh
Josh you are a young man with knowledge and patience and aint scared to answer questions some Jewish people won't even talk about. Top man may god keep guiding you.
Wow 😳 i live in NYC. I talk to many Jews all of the time and I have never ever seen a Jew who is this sincere when speaking about religion. Both parties are genuinely interested in one another’s views points without getting arrogant or angry. Just wow. Ali keep up the awesome work and may Allah guide this Jewish brother.
Well we don't talk about religon much since we don't seek to convert others
Its the politics that divides us. However they are very fun to have discussions with. You will have more agreements with a Jew than a Christian.
@@S_goldman_ No one is trying to convert. Debating about religion is good for everyone since it leads to everyone being more knowledgeable. And a side result could be that it leads to someone maybe questioning their religion and asking themselves if this is the right religion to follow if it has flaws or contradictions
@@S_goldman_ But yes Judaism isn't meant to spread worldwide as it's more of an exclusive religion that priorities Jews. But Islam tells Muslims to spread their religion worldwide to anyone that is willing to hear the message of God which is the same as what Christianity tells Christians. Which is why Islam is the second-fastest-growing religion, the religion with the highest number of converts, and will overtake Christianity by 2030
NY jews are so rude
Josh looks very peaceful and you can see from his face he’s genuinely seeking god
Josh has a good heart may Allah (SWT) guide him and hes family AMEEN
Ameen
To you who bully Ali, and call him a clown, a showman and say that he is giving the wrong message. I hope you come up with a sensible answer in the day of judgment. Imagine Ali went back to Islam, his mother was not a believer and his father did not believe in god. A boy at such a young age who wanted to change his life when he probably thought this was unnecessary without believing in god to want to be rather grateful to the one who gave him a life. He had to sneak up on Fajr because his father did not want him to become a Muslim. He had to walk on his toes because he did not want his father to know that he was praying. But he did it just for the sake of Allah, in other words he did it to be grateful. Can you imagine that? is that why you should bully him and give him a bad name. Brethren, be afraid of Allah, if Ali does something wrong, talk to him in private not shout at people 99 percent interpret it wrong and all non-believers will be happy that we quarrel with each other. This is how war starts, it always starts with words and it also expands. So for the sake of Allah, if you absolutely must correct him because he does not give the right dawah. Go to him like a man and talk to him like a man. I am sure he wants to improve.
May Allah bless you.
Amen!
I agree completely, brother. I believe Ali is sincere - there is no reason anyone should insult Ali in the comment section, and if they wish to advise him, they should word it constructively. Better yet, reach out in private.
@Abdul Shahriad brother, with all do respect to Adam Saleh, fosueytube and etc. They are not that religous or in other words they dont know so much about islam, so it's maybe little bit easier for them to mock or bulllying. But actually this message was not for Adam and fousey. Since you said some names, let me say that this message was actually for Shamsi. Se Shamsi know mashallah aloot in islam, for him to start war with his mouth and spread it, it's a danger. As I said earlier people will belive him just because he know so much in islam. But clearly he dont know how to respect people who passed away for exampel Brother Eesa may Allah bless him.
Ameen
This would be such a beautiful poem, if this wasn’t the same guy who almost fought an old man, claimed he would spit on a woman, and let that same woman fall by taking the chair away. Hatun is the True Warrior here! Like Muslims stop worshipping this dude. I know he acts just like your false prophet Muhammad, but whatever happened to common sense? May Jesus have mercy on you guys and I see a lot of Muslims becoming Followers of Christ soon!!🙏🏾👑✝️
@@jordanwafula6729 You must be crazy so to say that Hatun is a warrior. An warrior is not one with his or hers words. An warrior is one who is kind, respectful, praying 5 times, gives charity, help other people and so one. Now tell me what of those 5 things i mentiond is Hatun? Kind? Respectful? Or praying 5 times from sunrise to sunset? Do you really think she do that?
The problem with you people are that, when muslim do good or have knowlege like an sciense, you guys BURN!! You burn so much that even you don't respect our prophet at least.
And talk more shit you see muslims become christians.. is that why churchs gettin empty?
See the Christian religon is not a problem as we say, the author of Christian is a problem.
Allah Akbar ☝️
I’ve seen Josh for the second time at SC & he seems like a sincere soul who’s not only polite, well spoken & intelligent but very god fearing & god conscious & for this reason I believe Allah swt is bringing him more closer to Islam & InshaAllah Josh will embrace Islam in the very near future.
Inshallah
Inshallah
Jew here. I'm curious. To us Jews, a non-Jew is righteous person as long as they are faithful to the one true G-d, no partnership etc. You don't have to convert or be a Jew to be rightous in Judaism. Is that the same in Islam? Example, I'm a Jew, I believe, serve and submit to the one G-d, no other partnership etc. So am I considered rightous in Islam or even a Muslim?
@@iosoi3145 According to Islam you are a Muslim if you submit and serve only to Allah same like Abraham, Mosha and Mohammed did.
@@nickname1734 Thanks for your reply. I wonder if that means faithful Jews can just continue as they are and wouldn't need to convert to Islam to be considered Muslims.
When the jew said "im so sorry for interrupting but" He instantly became my favourite person Ali has debated with
no one :
bystander: when is the marriage documentary coming out
💯😂🤣😂
Don't buy these unhealthy oils all oils are not healthy all of them are very bad: sources in nutritionfacts.org
@@abdulazizali9935 like hair oil ?
@@myyt7590 🤣
People are more focused on alis wedding than rather sorting there own lol he probz dont want no evil eye leave him alone its gone wierd
There is a Muslim brother who is facing a lot of difficulty in life from years. Please pray for him. May Allah Have mercy on All of us Wassalam.
May Allah taala grant him complete shifaa and aafiyah. Ameen.
@@antiextremism ameen
@@antiextremism ameen
Aameen ALLAHUMMA Aameen.
@@antiextremism Ameen
Jewish brother is amazing. I really really wish and pray Allah guides him to the best path and inshallah we all see him in Jannahtul Fridaus Ameen
You should speak to more Orthodox Jews. Most are down to earth and will be friendly to you.
Don't confuse them with secular liberal Zionists etc
He seems so genuine and eager to learn as well as teach. I really wish him the best, honestly.
Seen this kid before , very respectful and humble. May God guide him in the right direction 🤲🏼.
I haven't watched a respectful debate for a while. May Allah guide us all.
For anyone who's reading this smile more it's a sunnah😁
🙂
One good advice for Today🌹
You never know how Strong you are, until being Strong is the only choice you Have..🪂
Jazakulallahu khairan
@tracy Star 🥰🥰
@@goldenmotivationhayal2020 that is very true 👍
The head of Jews in Medinah a Rabbi called Abdullah bin Salam (RA) became Muslim I would recommend his story to Jews looking into Islam.
When he didn't hesitate to say "yes of course if you prove it to me", I knew this young man was a special one. Most of the people who speak with Ali don't want to change their mind even if they are proven wrong.
He didn't prove anything!
@@harisomakantan6168 he did 😂😂stop covering your ears and expect to hear the truth ain't gonna work like that
@@Asiyah2000 wow... only you can hear the truth lol... only you...
@@harisomakantan6168 hmm 😒 I'm one of the half million people that watched this video and I'm pretty sure almost all of them hear the truth except those who decided to cover their ears like you .duh
I liked that he gave straight forward answers for what proof he requires and that he would believe in Prophet Mohammad if he finds that he was a true prophet. People usually dance around these question and makes the discussion boring and unfruitful.
Mashallah! Let's pray that Jews find out the truth and accept it from our hand, with kindness and reason. They are our cousins after all and all humanity need guidance. Ameen.
Don't buy these unhealthy oils all oils are not healthy all of them are very bad: sources in nutritionfacts.org
@@abdulazizali9935 ammm what about olive oil?
@@miiim all oils are processed they extract the fat and Throw everything else like all sugars they extract the sugar and throw everything else
@@miiim search oils on nutritionfacts.org youtube channel
@@miiim ruclips.net/video/A4WD8Bm7s_I/видео.html from Dr. michael greger
What a lovely Jewish brother..May Allah guide him and us all too..ameen ❤
Mashallah May Allah grant our brother Ali and other brothers and sisters highest level in jannah
Ali Dawah all the work you put in the Dawah is worth it you're truly an amazing person and I hope you the best my man if anybody hates on you just ignore them because positivity will always come first than negative. Mashallah I love what you do brother. Much love.❤❤
The signs of Allah's love for a person are as follows :
1. When Allah loves someone he puts them under trials ( the more righteous they are, the harder the trials) in order to purify them.
2. When Allah loves someone, he gives them the"understanding" of the religion of Islam.
3. Whomever Allah loves, he deviates them and their heart from disobedience and sins..
Jazak Allah'u khair
💚🕋صَلّی اللّٰہُ عَلٰی حَبِیبِہ مُحَمَّدٍ وَّآلِہ وَسَلَّمَ💚🕋
Where’s the second part please?
The young gentlemen was so polite Masha’Allaah 🥺 May Allaah guide him and give him jannah!
It’s so nice to see our young brother Ali doing a great job calling humanity to the path of ALLAH suphane te ala
May Allah increase the knowledge and patient.
JazakAllah
ma'sha'Allah, the Jewish guy has such a beautiful character and manners! May Allah swt guide him to the straight path, ameen. Get such positive good vibes from him
i remember this guy he was debating hamza long time ago.
He debated Brother Hashim Also.
Don't buy these unhealthy oils all oils are not healthy all of them are very bad: sources in nutritionfacts.org
@@abdulazizali9935 even olive oil? many people who use it don't have any health problems
@@AshG321M yes. That is not how doctors work. Search for "olive oil nutritionfacts.org " on youtube
@@AshG321M oils are processed foods like sugars
What a good listener he is! May Allah guide him.
How refreshing to see a respectful conversation between both of you.
Ali, if someone says they have to leave then let them leave. Don't try to keep them longer.
It serves no purpose and can annoy people and close them off.
That's a good nasiha and also part of dawah, you should not keep people long unill they get annoyed. 💯
Exactly
That's Islam for you... forcing everyone.
I love this Jewish brother.
He is so me.....❤❤❤
He just needs to complete reading quran ( which he has started already)... Praying for you my Jewish brother.
I see the light coming towards you.
Inshallah
You should talk to more regular Orthodox Jews. Nice people. Not talking about the secular zionists
Josh is a good person all in all out. Big respect to you may Allah Reward you for your honesty commonalities. From Africa
Such good character he has Tabarakkullah - May Allah guide him he’s genuine and wants to learn and he’s mature and calm
I genuinely have respect for this man, he is not like the other Jews and Qurayshi leaders who saw the signs and still denied. He is worth more than me to Allah
EaD
Are you ignorant or what?
If you are Muslim you are worth more to Allah than this Jewish he is not on the right path while you are
He is in denial of God's messanger so he is an infidel!
Fam what, you need go chill a bit. You shouldn't even be saying you're a lesser to someone else. Let alone to assume Allah's verdict/judgement.
It's good both are respectful. That's very good amazing. Alhamdulillah
Very kind Jew. Jews are like lost brothers to us Muslims. May God unite us again.
🥹❤️ after two years a jew Reading this comment and almost got tears in His eyes..
when a Jewish brother reverts its like a long lost family member has come back home
Hey I am Jewish but I am also interested in Islam. I spiritually lost and am searching for other faiths. Do you mind explaining what the tenets of Islam are. Thanks 🙏.
@@jasonm1539 hmm idk how to help you but I can advise u to read the Quran
Jason M there are 5 pillars in islam 1 is shahada which is believing there is no another god but allah and muhammad is the messenger of god 2nd is salat which is preforming prayer and 3rd is zakat which is to give to charity and help the poor 4th is to fast during ramadan 5th is hajj which is to preform pilgrimage
*** Thank you my friend I will make sure to check out the book.
Jason M If you don't want to pay I recommend a fully English version online. Search up yourself "clearquran.com" on Google. If you are okay with paying, another fully English version which I highly recommend is "The Clear Quran", by Dr. Mustafa Khattab. On Amazon I believe it is $5-7 USD. Whichever way you choose and whenever you read it, if at any point something is unclear, you can ask me for clarification.
I appreciate your video. Its so nice to see two young men from different faiths, sitting down, politely and respectfully discussing religion.
I seen this guy before ayyy much love homies
Don't buy these unhealthy oils all oils are not healthy all of them are very bad: sources in nutritionfacts.org
Do you watch a lot of boxing?
The respect you both have for each other, MashaAllah
Josh is the cutest, well-mannered young man, May Allah keep you safe.
Josh really seems to be sincere in his beliefs and his devotion to Allah. May Allah guide him.
Such a nice sincere Jewish gentleman. Perhaps no shahada, but the seed has been planted. May Allah grow it.
Alhamdulillah, he seems quite open minded. May Allah guide him to the right path through you. Inshaa Allah..aamiin
This is amazing. May Allah guide this man and his likes to the straight path, Ameen
Did the Jewish brother return for the debate? I'm curious. He seemed like a nice guy. You must contact him brother Ali.
May Allah guide him you can find him in many videos in speakers corner.
He was being polite and excused himself from this overzealous Muslim who has already decided his way was only way!
There are loads of these REAL Jewish people in London and all over the world.
@ishhh khan durrani Prophet Muhammad is mentioned in the Hebrew Bible Verse 16::: Mem chet (het) dalet mem ( Muhammad) - the question is what exactly is written about him??? Does anyone know?
PEACE ALL- may the GOOD forces be with you.
@@Sketchbook9999 It is verse 5:16 in Songs of Solomon where the name is given as "Muhammadim" where "im" in Hebrew is for respect. This is found in the Hebrew Bible.
As jew i was revert to Islam because Islam is very logic
😂😂😂😂😂
Judaism is the truth
much respect for both men, enjoyed listening to them
May Allah guide this Jewish brother
I've got mad respect from him❤
I seen him talk with br hamzah
He's very open minded
May Allah guide us all in 🌍
Get his number and interact with him more, I see him getting onto the right path!
How sure are you you are on the right path?
@@harisomakantan6168 100 sure I worship god only and I accept all the prophets there you go
The best talking better than tik tokks you have being doing and posted in the RUclips . I hope you keep doing this type talks...
This was the most normal discussion I have noticed on this channel. Rather than trying to decipher what people are saying as they are talking over each other, this is informative. Really hope Ali Dawah puts out more content like this.
May Allah reward you brother Ali, in this world and in the hereafter. Love your approach of wanting to discuss as opposed to just debating (though each approach has its own place and merit). Keep up the good work 👍
"His message was a true message but he was a false prophet." Unironically the most "Jewish" answer.
Yes they're not accepting because muhammed pbuh is Not from them. That's huge huge ego that will put them in hell im afraid
So he spoke the truth but he was false.. really insane
@@aakiftr9426 i mean jews betrayed mohammad twice
@@yankedhonor4281 they betrayed everyone. Every prophet. Because of ego
as a jew we have a lot of respect to islam since it is a monotheist religion.
Such a beautiful person Josh is! May Allah guide him to the Truth.
Mashalah Ali, may Allah protect you and guide Josh.
As a former Muslim and now Jews, I believe that these conversation should continue and it will make the world a better place.
❤
how to convert to judaism?
He is a really smart guy, respect to the both of you!
I am a muslim but regardless of any religion is someone has a behavior like Josh i would always love to interact with them in any sort of daily matters.
Josh is on a right path following the message of Muhammad already just through different methods i guess.
May Allah always have him under his mercy and all the thoughtful human beings.
🙄
16:36 a guy asks when is the MARRIAGE DOCUMENTARY” coming out lol.
montana Ali has been talking about it for the longest time. It’s the most anticipated documentary on RUclips lol
@montana It's like a meme now.
how humble and diligent them both. A chance for them both to become very best friend.
When he took out his phone my respect increased more, respect.
Why?
To me also...
This is a mature debate!👏🏼 👏🏼
I really enjoyed watching this video.
May Allah guide all people that have a good heart
Ameen🤲🏼❤️
They are both cool, calm and collected individuals, giving each other space to exchange knowledge may Allah guide and protect them both
I spoke to him that day, mashallah
Spoke to Ali Dawah, or the Kind Jewish man?
To whom, brother?
Mashaallah 😘😘. Muhammad saw is the best human in the world 😍😘
Islam is the most beautiful religion in the world 😍😍..proud to be muslim.
I get a lot of knowledge from this conversation. This is great, thx for sharing the video. May Allah bless us all.
I'd love to see part 2 of this.
hashim is my uncle name.. just for info only
16:35 guy asked about marriage documentary😂
Can you plz tell me why everyone keeps asking about his marriage documentry😅😅
Hahaha unexpected question suddenly
Lol
@@fatemachowdhury7973 Lol Lol lol hello
May Allah guide this Jewish guy. I like his honesty.
I like the personality of him (jew). he seems very calm and i also like when an other man confirms that we have a lot in common in oure religion.may allah guide us all❤ and inshallah we all have that many hasants to get in jannah inshallah!❤
First. Ali dawah is the best. And smile2jannah too. 😀.
Nd you
QWE TY ?????
@@CMZno you're the best but stop giving likes to yr comments 😂😂😅
QWE TY oh 😂. I don’t even think about it. I just like it without realising.
@@CMZno nevermind bro
He is a very nice man. May God guide him
That jewish guy is so humble and down to earth with his speech. May allah guide him ameen
I actually love the discussion very delighted to see Josh i think he is one of the enlightened jew i ever crossed on RUclips, very knowledgable and have the desire to seek the truth without having overcome by ego....wonderful discussion !
I feel like he's a muslim but the family culture keeps him as a jew (judaism religion). Because he was nodding during ayatul Kursi right?
We already have a lot in common with Jews than Christians. What's dividing us is politics
@@ahuman9628 Jews and muslims both believe ALLAH Is one...whilst Christians believe The Messiah is....astaghfirullah.
It is us who copying nodding
Everything mentions in the Quran they believe up until Esa and beyond
He was rocking backwards and forwards, he’s used to doing that as he would have been doing that ever since he was in yeshiva, whilst learning, it’s just something they’re used to doing
9:00
Saying that god rested means that he "ceased to do" is blasphemous because the universe in every second is guardianed by Allah. The universe would cease to exist if Allah ceased to hold it and sustain it with his power, knowledge, etc ..
There is no rest for God that "fits his majesty", because resting is intrinsically un-God-ly.
Allah SWT Created the seven Heavens in 2 'Days', then 'ceased' creating any more Heavens .
He Created the Earth in 2 'Days', then 'ceased' creating any more Earths.
He finished Creating the contents of the Earth in 4 Days then Rose above the Throne - meaning to take charge /authority over all His Creation which He COMPLETED IN 6 DAYS.
Therefore there is no Blasphemy in this.
@@mikhan5191 Allah SWT did not rest. He Almighty kept sustaining, mastering, managing, etc... the universe as a Rabb!
@@lion_hawk
- do you know the difference between 'cease' & 'rest'???
@@mikhan5191
It's the Jew who explained rest as a cease of action.
Done.
@@lion_hawk
- that same jew would agree exactly with your statement " He Almighty kept sustaining, mastering, managing, etc... the universe as a Rabb!"
This Jew KNOWS that God NEVER RESTS NOR TIRES.
He is trying to reinterpret the word 'rest' (which he admits cannot apply to God) to a more appropriate meaning such as 'ceased'.
Meaning that after 6 Days, God finished/ceased / ended the 6 Day process of Creation.
There's nothing blasphemous about that.
That doesn't mean that God stopped being Rabb/Lord of all Creation (& all the other Attributes you mentioned)
Put yourself in his shoes to understand his mind/thinking.
We need this type of jews brother, strong, self confidend, literate, honest and open minded...may god bless u and guide u my brother
I valid points that you bring up Ali. I myself started to questioning the Christian Bible. I read the Student bible and then the King James Version. This is a great video. It shows alot to someone really truly wondering what to Believe. I am a Muslimina and there is only One God and Muhammad (SWT) is his final Messenger.
You need Jesus sis🙏🏾✝️
@@jordanwafula6729 no you need islam my friend 🤲☪️
@@jordanwafula6729 as long as she is Muslim Jesus exist in her life as messenger of God and she definitely loves him as all Muslims do
have you read Quran and hadith carefully ? since it's taught Muslims to make war with others ...it's surely Islam not a peacefull religion ...if you see Quran dan Hadith, there are many verses taught Muslims to make war with others , for example , QS [9:29]:
Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of
Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued.
QS [9:5] :
Then, when the sacred months have passed, slay the idolaters wherever ye find them, and take them (captive), and besiege them, and prepare for them each ambush. But if
they repent and establish worship and pay the poor-due, then leave their way free. Lo! Allah is Forgiving, Merciful.
or in Hadith , quranx.com/hadith/Saliheen/In-Book/Book-19/Hadith-1839/
Abu Hurairah (May Allah be pleased with him) said in the interpretation of the Ayah reported:
"You are the best of peoples ever raised up for (the benefit of) mankind..." (3:110): The best for mankind are those who bring them with chains round their necks till
they embrace Islam (and thereby save them from the eternal punishment in the Hell-fire, and make them enter Jannah in the Hereafter)."[Al-Bukhari].
@@CarlosMartinez-jg6gg so Christians never went to war? Never killed people and called it religion. Killed children, women, elderly?
Hmmm...
Suspicious
May ALLAH the most merciful show him the true path.
I respect this young gentleman Josh, his respect his honesty and the way he listen intantively
Did the Jew ask for the marriage documentary as well?
Mian Hamid Lol😂
Yeah he will bcoz he's Muslim
@@barittos5585 He doesn't. You misunderstood the title.
@@2manyusernamestaken548 yeah i wrote that comment before watching the entire vid 🤦♂️ sorry
@@barittos5585 lol just couldn't resist 😂😂😂
Alhamdulillah, Subhan Allah, Masha Allah I dont know what to say! ❤️❤️
This is a great dialogue and a genuine respectfulness eminating from both sides. Both were awesome Allahybarak