My favorite is LE Sorcery - I love the colors don’t care if it’s too sparkly for my 72 year old eyes - those greens blue and “Venetian “ greenish yellow - be still my heart! I know it’s not “new” but I still love it. ❤ and love you too Charlotte 😊
@@Desertmermaid52 you’ve made me so happy! I’m 61 and I love Sorcery too. It’s an amazing palette. Charlotte being just about 40 allows me to imagine I’m in the same age bracket! ( sorry lovely Charlotte! ) I wouldn’t mind, but the absolute highlight of my social calendar is my grandchild’s birthday party 🎉🍾🎂🤣🤣. 😊😘 xxx
I'm 49 tomorrow and I love shimmery glittery eyes, especially on older women as it brightens up your whole face and has more impact than it does on younger women. You're never too old for sparkle!
I ordered the I Need a Warm palette with a really nice discount on Black Friday and it came today. I only swatched it, but so far it looks and eels stunning ❤ Great selection!
Natasha Denona had some amazing palettes this year. I love the Golden and Warm palettes. I’ll be honest, I’ve been using her discontinued Star palette all week as well.
I’m so tempted to pick up that Bobbi Brown!! I haven’t bought a BB palette in years, just a few singles here and there. This palette looks stunningly beautiful.
@@karenwillis3617 I’ve just done it today. In the U.K., it’s out of stock on Bobbi Brown, so I panic bought it from John Lewis. It’s my only palette this year, as I’m on a no buy / low buy. I’ve done well to last this long 😂😂!
Would love to see @RobertWelsh do your makeup and use those scary purples in the Roxa palette to give you an eyeshadow look that you love 😊. That would also help other mortals get better use from every colour in our small eyeshadow collections
Charlotte have you tried her Milky Way eyeshadow quad and Star Crossed quad? These can be found on the Selfridges website for $67. Both quads have all baked shades and are cool-neutrals. They were out of stock for a while because they sold out. But now they are back in stock. These shadows are like PML baked shadows. I would absolutely love if you did a video on these as they are”right up your street” I’m sure they will sell out quickly again.
Absolutely love these kinds of videos, as eyeshadow is my makeup weakness! I love the viseart and LE palettes as well, though I'm still "breaking them in." Curious what your all time rankings would be, even if the palette is no longer available. Happy holidays!
I love the Lisa Eldridge palette in Vega. It's a more cool toned palette. Not 2024 but still my favourite! My 2nd favourite is ND's I need a nude which I got this yr. I so want ND to bring out I need a cool. I will keep mentioning this 🤣. Emma x
The Roxa palette is the only one I bought this year and absolutely love it. I love colour and shimmers, especially pinks and purples and am enjoying this. I do also like the look of that Viseart one and of course Lisa Eldridge who is always fantastic! But I think I prefer sorcery over fawn in terms of colour story as I am more into cool and dark tones
It’s funny how different we all are. I prefer ND Golden pallet to Icy Nude because those deep yellow gold metallic shimmers look better on me. The Icy nudes tend to just look too frosty and white cast. But that eye look is 🔥 on you Charlotte!
Eyeshadow palettes especially the look of glitz & glamour style of extravagance is my love of beauty , along with hair & a little style of fashion mixed in ! 👁✨ The joy of celebration of beauty ! 🪅🫦
I am reaching most for Mario ethereal eyes palette. I love the understated shimmer. I just got the new Viseart palette, and love the understated duo chromes. Much prettier in real life. I think I am going to love that. I love a cool colour story.
Thank you for the reviews! I also just received the ND Warm Palette today and cannot wait to try it out tomorrow. I'm surprised Makeup By Mario's Moonlight Ethereal Palette isn't on your list.
Hiii! I'm a new subscriber, and I adore this video! I ordered the ND I Need a Warm on Black Friday, and it's my first midi pallet from her. I've only ever purchased her minis. Super excited about it. Lovely video ❤
Thank you for your honest review. I'm a huge fan of Lisa Eldridge, and I love all her eyeshadow palettes. I have also bought the pallet from Bobbi Brown, which surprised me positively as I was not familiar with the brand. I didn't try the pallet from Huda, I will soon though as it was delivered few days ago. Pallets from ND never disappoint me. ❤❤❤
Chanel's Divination quad pushed me beyond my disregard of deeper purples. Now the market is flooded with them. And I'm very much into it! Actually looking forward to a little side-by-side of Dior Celestial Purple and and a fancy little 6€ alternative 😊
Love it! Ty Charlotte! I would rank Lisa Eldridge Vega h at 2nd or 3rd as I prefer Cooler tones😅😅😅😅 Maybe Viseart right behind and ND I Need a Nude in the top spot today!!🎉🎉🎉
My most used has to be my ColourPop Cloud 9 palette. I'm a cool toned girly and I just love that palette. My Mario Ethereal Eyes Moonlight and Byredo Mineralscapes are in my top 5 - they are newer additions to my collection tho.
Happy Holidays!! you convinced me to buy the Viseart palette!! I have a Lisa Eldridge palette and I don't love it for some reason. I bought it because it was supposed to be better for mature eyes but I found them so so. Maybe it's just me!!
My favorite palette is the Roxa-palette, because I loooooove me a purple eyeshadow. That and my Hourglass-Dragon are coming with me, when my husband and I are going to my parents house, to celebrate christmas 🎅💜 A close second is the Sugar-palette from ABH. I think I can make a lot of different looks that isn´t to "showy". And my third is, The Golden-palette from Natasha Denona, I simply love the colors. I didn´t want to buy it at first. But it kept haunting me in my dreams 😆so I simply had to get it.
Same as you INAW palette Natasha Denona which is stunning to me anyway not boring at all😂 I have just managed to buy it with big discount, refuse to pay full price for these palettes. Also bought the Golden palette discounted which I also love. I feel the same way as you about the gold shades, not interested. Worth waiting for something you really want.🥰💜
Well, I don’t have any excitement in my life so the Ensley Reign Cold Moon palette is my number 1 and I love my coastal palette from Alter ego as my number 2 (which I hear is a dupe for Huda Rose Quartz) and my cool neutrals by make up by Mario is my number 3 for a base or under eye liner.
Ooh, you actually surprised me! I really thought the Huda Icy Nudes had your heart, but I’m wrong. That’s because I’ve been on an eyeshadow no buy this year and into next, so I forgot the I Need a Warm palette. Unforgivable, I apologise unreservedly 😅! Good job you’re here, keeping us plebs updated, Charlotte! 😂😂 xxx
I think I only bout three new palettes this whole year - are they all three ND , of course they are 😆😂😆- mini my dream ( came out the end of last year but I got it in Jan of this year ), golden palette, INAW palette: 1: mini my dream - both on its own and in combination with INAN and midi & mini glam 2: INAW 3: golden - your entire thoughts on this one was also my exact reaction to this one as well I took out the same to two shimmer shades that you also said you weren’t as interested in and now it’s perfect for me for what it is to fill that particular color story in my collection
I just started following you and watching your videos and I really like your content. I just ordered the I need a warm. I love it too. I decluttered the I need a nude and was hoping it was better and it is. Thanks for sharing ❤😊
I have found myself using Victoria Beckham’s eyeshadow sticks this year, so I really can’t say I have a favourite palette this year. I did purchase the Natasha Denona Roxa palette. I like it but I don’t love it either.
Got the beautiful Bobbi brown palette which I adore!! So tempted to get the Huda beauty icy nude palette for Christmas but are the different enough?! What do you think??❤
Oh gosh.... Bobbi Brown's holiday collection is drawing me in. *sigh* It's so classy. I don't need anything new though. Love your rankings. I need to pull out my I Need a Warm palette that I bought a few months ago and actually use it. It went onto the back burner for other things and never got pulled out. Next year....
2024 is not the year of the eyeshadow palettes however…. We have some really really beautiful ones to enjoy 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 Too bad we can’t talk about a Pat McGrath mothership this year🥺 there’s always 2025!
I only have six palettes and my ranking would be : 1 mini retro and midi glam ND 2 mini biba 3 mini starlette 4 viseart coy 5 huda jaguar I absolutely HATE the jaguar one, absolutely horrible quality (although I love the color story). But seeing and loving the new viseart one, I might really need to get that one.
Greetings from Germany ❤ I absolutely love love love your videos!!! Also, xou are not desperately trying to sell uns lots of things we do not need all the time: thank you!! May I ask what you think about the ND I need a Nude?
I really love Denonas shimmers. They are so finely milled that they are perfect for aging eyes. My lids are very textured and Denonas formula vs dupes n stuff cant be matched. As for Hudas, im torn over that palette. I want to really love it but i cant. I absolutely love the color story. Its perfect that way. I love all of the mattes. Its the other shades. There are 2 shades that are unwearable for me and that the sandy silver and gold glitters. I have no idea why those 2 are in this palette. Its like rubbing your eyes with sandpaper and for what?? They do nothing. Then there are 2 of the shimmers that are textured and no matter the primer i applied was all over my face and hard to get off of my face. The others are ok but they also travelled. If i has to pick one palette to try here it would be the Bobby Brown. Thanks so much!! Nice list!! Glad they worked for you!!
ysl is fast becoming a favorite - i originally had two of the quads but i had to get that new neutral brown one. it’s the most basic color story but it’s anything but boring.
I love the Lisa Eldridge palette in Vega. It's a more cool toned palette. Not 2024 but still my favourite! My 2nd favourite is ND's I need a nude which I got this yr. I so want ND to bring out I need a cool. I will keep mentioning this 🤣. Emma x
Same here, Vega is my most used and loved palette. I used up French Grey, repurchased the shade and use it daily as my base shade. I have added the sparkly shimmer from the new Fawn palette which is going so well with Vega. My collection is tiny, one palette from Victoria Beckham, the two mini cool toned palettes from Viseart and LE Sorcery & Vega. I am perfectly fine and adore the quality, colour stories and versatility. So I bought nothing except the LE single in 2024.
My favorite is LE Sorcery - I love the colors don’t care if it’s too sparkly for my 72 year old eyes - those greens blue and “Venetian “ greenish yellow - be still my heart! I know it’s not “new” but I still love it. ❤ and love you too Charlotte 😊
@@Desertmermaid52 you’ve made me so happy! I’m 61 and I love Sorcery too. It’s an amazing palette. Charlotte being just about 40 allows me to imagine I’m in the same age bracket! ( sorry lovely Charlotte! ) I wouldn’t mind, but the absolute highlight of my social calendar is my grandchild’s birthday party 🎉🍾🎂🤣🤣. 😊😘 xxx
Good for you! I’m 50 and was on the fence about Sorcery but you convinced me 😊
I bet it looks lovely on you!! 💚
I'm 49 tomorrow and I love shimmery glittery eyes, especially on older women as it brightens up your whole face and has more impact than it does on younger women. You're never too old for sparkle!
Me too!
ND INAW is my favorite as well. Always makes a pretty look❤❤
I ordered the I Need a Warm palette with a really nice discount on Black Friday and it came today. I only swatched it, but so far it looks and eels stunning ❤
Great selection!
Thank you for the considered ranking. Im waiting for the Viseart - still in transit. I love INAW- it's such a good default.
Love this! My 2024 favorite is Lisa's fawn palette. Thanks!
Natasha Denona had some amazing palettes this year. I love the Golden and Warm palettes. I’ll be honest, I’ve been using her discontinued Star palette all week as well.
I’m so tempted to pick up that Bobbi Brown!! I haven’t bought a BB palette in years, just a few singles here and there. This palette looks stunningly beautiful.
@@karenwillis3617 I’ve just done it today. In the U.K., it’s out of stock on Bobbi Brown, so I panic bought it from John Lewis. It’s my only palette this year, as I’m on a no buy / low buy. I’ve done well to last this long 😂😂!
Would love to see @RobertWelsh do your makeup and use those scary purples in the Roxa palette to give you an eyeshadow look that you love 😊. That would also help other mortals get better use from every colour in our small eyeshadow collections
Charlotte have you tried her Milky Way eyeshadow quad and Star Crossed quad? These can be found on the Selfridges website for $67. Both quads have all baked shades and are cool-neutrals. They were out of stock for a while because they sold out. But now they are back in stock. These shadows are like PML baked shadows. I would absolutely love if you did a video on these as they are”right up your street” I’m sure they will sell out quickly again.
Absolutely love these kinds of videos, as eyeshadow is my makeup weakness! I love the viseart and LE palettes as well, though I'm still "breaking them in." Curious what your all time rankings would be, even if the palette is no longer available. Happy holidays!
That PML quad will always remind me of my early 90s kids' Dunlop Steffi Graf tennis racket. And i love that!
My number 1 also...inlove with i need a warm pallette ❤
I love the Lisa Eldridge palette in Vega. It's a more cool toned palette. Not 2024 but still my favourite! My 2nd favourite is ND's I need a nude which I got this yr. I so want ND to bring out I need a cool. I will keep mentioning this 🤣. Emma x
I agree, we indeed need a "I need a cool," from ND 😉
I need a cool too 😊
The Roxa palette is the only one I bought this year and absolutely love it. I love colour and shimmers, especially pinks and purples and am enjoying this. I do also like the look of that Viseart one and of course Lisa Eldridge who is always fantastic! But I think I prefer sorcery over fawn in terms of colour story as I am more into cool and dark tones
It’s funny how different we all are. I prefer ND Golden pallet to Icy Nude because those deep yellow gold metallic shimmers look better on me. The Icy nudes tend to just look too frosty and white cast. But that eye look is 🔥 on you Charlotte!
I love the way you say purple, perple! so endearing!
Eyeshadow palettes especially the look of glitz & glamour style of extravagance is my love of beauty , along with hair & a little style of fashion mixed in ! 👁✨
The joy of celebration of beauty ! 🪅🫦
What a great video, such fun! I love makeup, and your love of makeup comes through on every video!
Best Palette very hard to choose : Byredo Minerales , I need a Warm ND, YSL Stora Dolls and Over Brune, Chantecaille Cheetah LE Vega and Fawn🙋♀️🇬🇧
I love the cheetah palette. It was my splurge for the year. I fell for the packaging but love all three shades.
I am reaching most for Mario ethereal eyes palette. I love the understated shimmer. I just got the new Viseart palette, and love the understated duo chromes. Much prettier in real life. I think I am going to love that. I love a cool colour story.
Love your consistency ❤
Thank you for the reviews! I also just received the ND Warm Palette today and cannot wait to try it out tomorrow. I'm surprised Makeup By Mario's Moonlight Ethereal Palette isn't on your list.
I just ADORE the Mario Moonlight palette and I really did not expect to love this much! Also, I really loved the ND Golden palette this year😊
Well I own the Top 3!! Yeah 👍🏻 Love 💕 you. Happy New Year Charlotte !!
For me there are three palettes, ND I need a warm, Saigu Boheme, and LH Shimmer saga ❤❤❤
Hiii! I'm a new subscriber, and I adore this video! I ordered the ND I Need a Warm on Black Friday, and it's my first midi pallet from her. I've only ever purchased her minis. Super excited about it. Lovely video ❤
Thank you for your honest review. I'm a huge fan of Lisa Eldridge, and I love all her eyeshadow palettes. I have also bought the pallet from Bobbi Brown, which surprised me positively as I was not familiar with the brand. I didn't try the pallet from Huda, I will soon though as it was delivered few days ago. Pallets from ND never disappoint me. ❤❤❤
I love the Roxa and the Bobbi Brown palette. I've also got the Danessa Myricks lightwork VI palette coming. Half price black friday bargain!
Chanel's Divination quad pushed me beyond my disregard of deeper purples. Now the market is flooded with them. And I'm very much into it!
Actually looking forward to a little side-by-side of Dior Celestial Purple and and a fancy little 6€ alternative 😊
Love it! Ty Charlotte! I would rank Lisa Eldridge Vega h at 2nd or 3rd as I prefer Cooler tones😅😅😅😅 Maybe Viseart right behind and ND I Need a Nude in the top spot today!!🎉🎉🎉
My most used has to be my ColourPop Cloud 9 palette. I'm a cool toned girly and I just love that palette. My Mario Ethereal Eyes Moonlight and Byredo Mineralscapes are in my top 5 - they are newer additions to my collection tho.
Happy Holidays!! you convinced me to buy the Viseart palette!! I have a Lisa Eldridge palette and I don't love it for some reason. I bought it because it was supposed to be better for mature eyes but I found them so so. Maybe it's just me!!
My fave is also ND INAW with HB Icy Nude as a close second!
My favorite palette is the Roxa-palette, because I loooooove me a purple eyeshadow. That and my Hourglass-Dragon are coming with me, when my husband and I are going to my parents house, to celebrate christmas 🎅💜 A close second is the Sugar-palette from ABH. I think I can make a lot of different looks that isn´t to "showy". And my third is, The Golden-palette from Natasha Denona, I simply love the colors. I didn´t want to buy it at first. But it kept haunting me in my dreams 😆so I simply had to get it.
Yay!!!! your favorite is my favorite. Its magical the way I get compliments when i where it
I love the YSL couture clutch palettes - the quality and color stories are really great. I have been surprised by how much I like them!
Same as you INAW palette Natasha Denona which is stunning to me anyway not boring at all😂 I have just managed to buy it with big discount, refuse to pay full price for these palettes. Also bought the Golden palette discounted which I also love. I feel the same way as you about the gold shades, not interested. Worth waiting for something you really want.🥰💜
My complete and total favorite is the I Need a Nude palette.
Well, I don’t have any excitement in my life so the Ensley Reign Cold Moon palette is my number 1 and I love my coastal palette from Alter ego as my number 2 (which I hear is a dupe for Huda Rose Quartz) and my cool neutrals by make up by Mario is my number 3 for a base or under eye liner.
Ooh, you actually surprised me! I really thought the Huda Icy Nudes had your heart, but I’m wrong. That’s because I’ve been on an eyeshadow no buy this year and into next, so I forgot the I Need a Warm palette. Unforgivable, I apologise unreservedly 😅! Good job you’re here, keeping us plebs updated, Charlotte! 😂😂 xxx
I think I only bout three new palettes this whole year - are they all three ND , of course they are 😆😂😆- mini my dream ( came out the end of last year but I got it in Jan of this year ), golden palette, INAW palette:
1: mini my dream - both on its own and in combination with INAN and midi & mini glam
2: INAW
3: golden - your entire thoughts on this one was also my exact reaction to this one as well I took out the same to two shimmer shades that you also said you weren’t as interested in and now it’s perfect for me for what it is to fill that particular color story in my collection
I just started following you and watching your videos and I really like your content. I just ordered the I need a warm. I love it too. I decluttered the I need a nude and was hoping it was better and it is. Thanks for sharing ❤😊
I just ordered the Natasha Denona palette and am excited for it ❤
Top 10 eyeshadow palette/single from your eyeshadow collection? maybe video? 😊
My top tree from this year: Fawn, I need a warm and Godlen palette for sure!
I have found myself using Victoria Beckham’s eyeshadow sticks this year, so I really can’t say I have a favourite palette this year. I did purchase the Natasha Denona Roxa palette. I like it but I don’t love it either.
Sa fait tellement longtemps que j’ai pas regardé RUclips 😢 i missed your videos ❤❤
Great video, maybe I'll be purchasing some of these with a gift from Santa!
Got the beautiful Bobbi brown palette which I adore!! So tempted to get the Huda beauty icy nude palette for Christmas but are the different enough?! What do you think??❤
Oh gosh.... Bobbi Brown's holiday collection is drawing me in. *sigh* It's so classy. I don't need anything new though. Love your rankings. I need to pull out my I Need a Warm palette that I bought a few months ago and actually use it. It went onto the back burner for other things and never got pulled out. Next year....
… INAW has got to be my favorite warm neutral palette of. all. time. and they one and only “warm” tone palette I even own anymore
I was really surprised by the Bobbi Brown palette. I didn’t realize she was doing a palette like this either. Beautiful!
Hello beautiful Charlotte 😍
2024 is not the year of the eyeshadow palettes however….
We have some really really beautiful ones to enjoy 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Too bad we can’t talk about a Pat McGrath mothership this year🥺 there’s always 2025!
My very own Warm Denona is coming to me, probably next week. 😂
Ooh i love a ranking!
I adore the Natasha Denona I need a warm palette and prefer it over I need a nude.
I only have six palettes and my ranking would be :
1 mini retro and midi glam ND
2 mini biba
3 mini starlette
4 viseart coy
5 huda jaguar
I absolutely HATE the jaguar one, absolutely horrible quality (although I love the color story). But seeing and loving the new viseart one, I might really need to get that one.
Greetings from Germany ❤ I absolutely love love love your videos!!! Also, xou are not desperately trying to sell uns lots of things we do not need all the time: thank you!!
May I ask what you think about the ND I need a Nude?
Dear Charlotte I remember that you bought the byredo palette Where do you rank it in your palette collection in 2024😊
Have you seen that Viseart is bringing out a Chocolate and Lilac palette? Noice!!! I want!!!
Icy nude really gives ethereal eyes vibe with add-ons obv. Not sure why no one compares them…
Hi👋
Natasha Denona INAN, it is the perfect palette.
Loved hearing your favorites and ranking because I am boring too. 😊. Byredo Mineralscapes.
I really love Denonas shimmers. They are so finely milled that they are perfect for aging eyes. My lids are very textured and Denonas formula vs dupes n stuff cant be matched.
As for Hudas, im torn over that palette. I want to really love it but i cant. I absolutely love the color story. Its perfect that way. I love all of the mattes. Its the other shades. There are 2 shades that are unwearable for me and that the sandy silver and gold glitters. I have no idea why those 2 are in this palette. Its like rubbing your eyes with sandpaper and for what?? They do nothing. Then there are 2 of the shimmers that are textured and no matter the primer i applied was all over my face and hard to get off of my face. The others are ok but they also travelled. If i has to pick one palette to try here it would be the Bobby Brown. Thanks so much!! Nice list!! Glad they worked for you!!
Pantone's color of the year 2025 is Mocha Mousse. NDINAW exactly.
I have binned my ancient Biba palette now that I have INAW & INAN. I DON’T need a BIBA anymore.
No Byredo Mineral Scapes???😮
If you are watching this you don’t need that YSL palette you have that…. You do not need that
💜💜💖
💕💄
ysl is fast becoming a favorite - i originally had two of the quads but i had to get that new neutral brown one. it’s the most basic color story but it’s anything but boring.
21:30 yes very boring and basic 🤭
Dreaded made in America?
I love the Lisa Eldridge palette in Vega. It's a more cool toned palette. Not 2024 but still my favourite! My 2nd favourite is ND's I need a nude which I got this yr. I so want ND to bring out I need a cool. I will keep mentioning this 🤣. Emma x
Same here, Vega is my most used and loved palette. I used up French Grey, repurchased the shade and use it daily as my base shade. I have added the sparkly shimmer from the new Fawn palette which is going so well with Vega.
My collection is tiny, one palette from Victoria Beckham, the two mini cool toned palettes from Viseart and LE Sorcery & Vega. I am perfectly fine and adore the quality, colour stories and versatility. So I bought nothing except the LE single in 2024.
@romana.in.wonderland I got that single from Fawn too! I also mixed a couple of singles from Sorcery into my Myth palette.