@@bruhwhat5485 no, your grandfather just like mine fought so his people, his family and their entire legacy would survive. Instead what he got was the fall of his nation because of foreign affairs and internal bickering. Then their former allies did what they do best, bolted away to those they had no quarrel with. Said allies have made their choice and now their people are paying for their leaders' decisions both new and old. But i suppose you wouldn't think about it because it's easier to live in ignorance and choose to speak for the dead. P.S. Go spread your sh*t somewhere where it matters and not a youtube video that has nothing to do with it. You disgust me.
@@bruhwhat5485 "And then they use your fight against nazism and for a normal life and reframe it as "denazification", while paying Nazis." - wtf. There are about 200 nationalities in Russia but only the Ukrainian nation is bad and it is being destroyed. Ukraine received nothing from the separatist regions, when, after a week of war, it was offered to recognize them (without reparations and with security guarantees from EU countries)) and abandon NATO (which has grounds, Cuba moment), it abruptly refuses and decides to wage a full-scale war.
@@Wladyslaw_Raginis We are so sorry that we enterrupted your occupation from Germany. But I guess being anihilated slightly worse than join USSR side for 40 years to become free after.
@@blackki540 1. Yes we can all see how Russia treats these 200 nationalities. Did you know that for every confirmed dead ethnic Russian soldier, there are 8 confirmed dead Buryat soldiers? 2. Yes, you cant really denazify while having entities like Rusich group on the government payroll 3. "Abandon NATO" you do realise that NATO is the only thing that, for example, protects the Baltics from a Russian "peacekeeping" mission, like they did in Molvoda in 1992, which resulted in creating the People's Republic of Transnistria, a now dictatorship breakaway republic with Russian soldiers in it? 4. About Cuba - NATO membership doesnt mean nuclear deployment. As seen with Finland, Putin is completely fine with a neighbouring country joining NATO, as long as no nuclear deployment - which Ukraine definetly would agree to and even has publicly agreed to.
I can’t imagine what it must have felt like to go from fighting the worst war in history to trying to return to normal life again. The trauma of that generation will be felt for centuries to come.
Yes, yes it is feels even now. As an example, US has their “Greatest generation”, so do we, Russians and all people of USSR - I think that those people, who were born in 1900-1927-ss was toughest of all our generations. They had their beliefs and ideals, that made them overwhelm death, as we call it. Literally, it is said, that “they conquered death”.
Soviet men does not feel trauma because the battles they fought were honorable. They paid with blood to rid the world of a great evil. American veterans come back with trauma because they are send to murder innocent women and children their warriors are send to generate profits for the corporations.
It feels like many people just don't understand that this song is a soldier's appeal to his murdered comrade. The song is full of sorrow and light sadness mixed with relief from the end of the war. The soldier calls on his dead comrade to stand up, knowing that this can never happen. He asks him: "How can I tell your family that you have been killed? How am I going to stand in front of your heartbroken wife alive? Get up! Take your greatcoat and let's go home! "
Okay now I'm crying more, my ignorant a$$ never thought of looking up the lyrics but I always felt sad listening to this song now its more sad that I know the story behind it and now I'm crying my eyes out 😭
@@MagogTheMagnificent I am a liberal, and I am categorically against war and Putin's policies. I think he's a fucker, a thief and a war criminal. It just hasn't come to a point where people could do something with it.
Brothers in arms? We were once one country. The second they had their little revoloution and decided to massacre those who wanted friendliness with Russia, they lost our respect. @@MagogTheMagnificent
Recently, I've been listening to a lot of Soviet World War songs. They have a peculiar property, one that raises them almost to the level of high art. They instill within the listener the pain of a soldier who lost his comrades, they create memories that were never there, they not only like other art make us feel things but make us feel as if we LIVED them. That is beautiful!
i also recomen watching some soviet war films, you just have to ask which are considered one of the best (my example is "Only old men are going to battle", if you will be able to watch it with subtitles of course.) There is plenty of older generation films that not only show the dreadfulness of war, but also teach a lot of different things, how to stay human in such conditions, how to brace your homeland and people who live with you, become as one and fight all as one for the brighter future of next generation. Those were great ideas that are unfortunately not present in modern pop-culture, neither the films nor the propaganda.
You can watch Soviet Storm and Unknown war documentries if you want to learn more about Eastern Front. They are both avaible on RUclips. You can also watch Come And See movie if you want to see how it was like to live in German occupied parts of the USSR (atleast the Belarus). Movie is also on RUclips. But you need an strong stomach...
I remember when my grandmother told me a story…. In the WW her mother during winter (my great grandmother) kept a Russian soldier in her little house in Serbia 🇷🇸 they ate and drank rakija/šlivovic And then the Russian soldier stood up and thanked for the food and the drinks (my great grandmother putted some water in his drinking bottle) and she asked him where he is going because he only had one shoe on his foot and dirty, broken clothes and he said: Berlin Im inlove with this story of my great grandmother because there we can see that they (the Russian soldiers and all the others) gave everything for their country and their families,they truly were real men and I’m amazed by them…. Greetings to all Russians from Serbia 🇷🇸❤️ (Omg I never thought this story would get so many likes what 😭)
maybe you sould learn about what russian soldiers did to german civilians, i have only respect to the soldiers (not of any particular nation) that kept some of their humanity and compassion during the war, war is stupid and so are those that praise the pawns in it
Моя прабабушка прошла всю войну медсестрой, её рост был 1 метр 50 сантиметров, и она таскала с поля боя здоровых мужиков. Она воевала под Сталинградом, и о ней писали в газетах. Была ранена в бедро и контужена, но из госпиталя сбежала на фронт. Я никогда не забуду ее патриотизма и мужества. My great-grandmother went through the whole war as a nurse, she's height was 4.92, and she pulled very big guys from the battlefield. She fought at Stalingrad, and they wrote about her in the newspapers. She was wounded in the thigh and contused, but fled from the hospital to the front. I will never forget her patriotism and courage.
I don't know man, that whitewashing bleeds away the substance of what is being sung about. There are reasons people go to war. Those reasons are political. There were reasons soviet men and women had to suffer. There were reasons that soviet men and women fought as hard as they did.
It is a peace-loving song, which is fundamentally contradictory to the ideologies linked to imperialism, that is genocidal fascism, monarchism/theocracy/caciquismo/gamonalismo (feudal rule) and the hypocritical liberalism. Only socialism seeks a peaceful world, because it eliminates the cause of wars: class struggle and struggle among the different sections of ruling classes. What WW1 would there have been, had the great powers not sought to subjugate one another's colonial working classes and peasants? What WW2 would there have been, had Nazi fascism not sought to turn whole peoples from proletarians and peasants into slaves for its ruling class? What Vietnam war would there have been, had Yankee imperialism not sought to subjugate the Vietnamese people and exploit their producing classes? And friend, what ideology put a stop to these wars if not the socialist ideology? It can be contrasted with Afghanistan, where Yankee imperialism's war of aggression has been defeated by reactionaries, who are already initiating conflicts with every single one of their neighbors except their ally in social-imperialist China. Soviet Russia did not begin its existence with invading other countries-instead it itself was invaded immediately, even if it meant putting a temporary stop to WW1. Socialist China both defeated Japanese imperialism together with the USSR and United States, and also relegated the Guomindang reactionaries to Taiwan, but it did not invade its neighbors in wars of aggression-instead the revisionists in the USSR initiated border conflicts in the 1960's and the United States threatened to invade through Korea. This song is a socialist song!
@@huggebugg3694 I agree that socialist democracy was replaced with fascism in the USSR, but this was only done after Stalin's death, when socialism was replaced with social-imperialism by Nikita Khrushchov. Mao Tse-tung condemned Khrushchov's government as a dictatorship of the Hitler type, and I believe this is a correct characterization. Khrushchov made revolution a crime once more, and he and his contemporaries and successors became the New Tsars. During WW2 the Communist Party made concessions to the bureaucratic stratum which before then was being combatted, so that this stratum could be won over in the war with the Nazi-fascist hordes. This led to the empowerment of the stratum. Stalin struggled against it after WW2 and was planning to initiate a democratization campaign and the incorporation of the people into the state, but he died before this could be finished, and 3 years after his death Khrushchov came to power through what can only be called a bloodless military coup. He started incarcerating and killing revolutionaries who opposed his revisionism and also committed the 1962 Novocherkassk massacre of striking workers. Khrushchov also put forward the revisionist and fascist theses of the three "peacefuls" and the two "wholes", perverting the Communist Party into a class-collaborationist, reformist party that hailed "peace" with imperialism (that means a peace under bayonets!) and "economic incentives" which meant the erosion of the socialist culture and its replacement by the bourgeois. Khrushchov, Brezhnev and Gorbachov were fascist leaders, and in 1991 their dictatorship was replaced by the liberal-democratic one of Yeltsin, Medvedev and Putin, no less imperialist. Many people confuse the ultra-bureaucratic, fascist and corporativist structure of the Soviet state after 1956 with the socialist and democratic structure before 1956. Stalin is lumped together with the New Tsars, his leadership confused with the Hitler-type dictatorship of fascists, his achievements for the laboring classes confused with the achievements of the ruling class in oppressing the former. The imperialist sphere of influence of the COMECON and Warsaw Pact was established after Stalin's death. Same with the KGB, and the wars of aggression in Hungary, Czechoslovakia and Afghanistan and imperialist proxy wars in Angola, Nicaragua, Ethiopia, Sudan, Tibet(!), DRC, Yemen, etc. etc. etc.
@@despa7726 ahh yes Mao Zedong very peace loving democratic leader just like Xi Jinping and ah Stalin en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_war_crimes very peace loving democratic guy if someone from the ussr heard this utter nonses
Respect to both of these fallen heros, their names will remain in the hearts of those who treasured them and in the songs of victory they died to achieve.
And then, the brothers in arms, the same people who fought together, who shared the bread together, who went to Berlin together, are now fighting between them... May the world find a union some day...
@@grebap it will happen when we find different species in universe imo. Human division will fade quickly in the face of a threat. And if not that than one day I pray we understand we are one people...
@@jakubzov just looking at how many times different cultures and enemies came together to fight a threat during history and ending up becoming very deep allies, France and Britain, Brazil and Argentina, etc
I remember when i was young my Russian mom was playing this song and always cry. At that time I didn't understand anything because I didn't talk Russian, but right now I'm playing this song and remember my mom...
Мой прадед умер во время великой отечественной, оставив после себя дочь и сына - его брат, пацан девятнадцати лет, тоже воевавший, всю жизнь посвятил его детям. Не женился сам, не завел своих детей, а всю молодость воспитывал своих племянников. Они и были его семьёй - и у нас все до сих пор его поминают только добром.
Listening to Okudzhava's songs, especially this one, makes me feel to forget everything. It's all over now, why even bother? Let's just take trench coats and let's go home. We deserve some rest, after all.
My grandfather was a Soviet soldier and actually a year too young to join, but he lied about his age to defend his country. Even though, I was born in another country, I still feel a warm feeling hearing old russian songs and deeply respect those brave soldiers.
While I'm certain your grandfather was a good man and obviously had good reasons to join, don't believe the Soviet Army was good. They did devilish things to the German civillans during the "Liberation of the West" and after the war ended. If you have the stomach, you should read up on it. The Rape of Berlin is one of them, they did unspeakable things to women, children and eldery.
When my great grandpa remember war, he always cries. He was a child when it's started. He was sent to concentration camp when he was just 6 years old. He died in 1999. All I know about him is all that my great grandma told me about him. Rest in peace, great grandpa Tolia.
Just when I was thinking why this has a sad tone even thoguh the war has ended and they are going back home, the line "What will I tell your family?" hits
Previously the line "sleep under a plywood star" is the definition of a buried soldier. There was no time to bury most of them so their comrades just dug a grave themselves, filled it with bodies, covered with soil and put this plywood star over them. Thats why many of the graves are lost and why people still find the remains.
It feels like many people just don't understand that this song is a soldier's appeal to his murdered comrade. The song is full of sorrow and light sadness mixed with relief from the end of the war. The soldier calls on his dead comrade to stand up, knowing that this can never happen. He asks him: "How can I tell your family that you have been killed? How am I going to stand in front of your heartbroken wife alive? Get up! Take your greatcoat and let's go home! "
We've actually learned that song on our singing school class. I was 14, I'm a native Russian speaker, but I still didn't get it the first rime. When I did get it, that hit me like a train. "Wake up, fellow soldier..." It is almost unbearable to sing this one.
I see some people think Soviets was only about Russia, however the Soviet Union was not only Russia but also 15 union republics together.Thanks to this friendship and cooperation of these different nations we won this war. My great-grandfather died in Poland on the way to Germany and he was Azerbaijani. RIP for these heroes who saved us from fascism.
@@user-fk5uc5ec4z они не помогали, они и были теми кто победил. Не Россия воевала, а Советский Союз, это государство не вписывается в формат одной только России как бы. Это исторический факт
@@robespierre4843 угу, но откуда появился советский союз? Революция в Российской Империи, а она в свою очередь силой захватила их и принудила к войне+русских было просто больше всех
The Russian army was facing not just the survival of their country, but the complete survival of their people... I couldn't imagine fighting against an enemy whose main goal was the complete ethnic removal of your culture, blood, and people. Only to return to everyday life.
My great grandfather was a tanker in ww2. My great grandmother told me that he was a very kind and cheerful person but also an alcoholic. He never talked about war to his family but it clearly crushed his soul. When he was drunk his children were not safe around him. Sometimes they had to hide from their own father because he chased them with an axe. He had 8 children. When he was around his late 40's he passed away sitting on a train going home. To be honest I hardly ever think about him since I never met him but THIS song and the thought that his soul is still going home is unbearable. I'm wiping my tears..
I cannot fathom the pain and hardships that the peoples, nations, and cultures from the USSR had to endure in WW2 and throughout their history. As someone from the west, I admire these people who defended and defied the spread of Nazism.
Слава и вечная память каждому погибшему, раненому, труженнику и фронтовику. Нет слов которые могут описать всю важность их жизней и заслуг. Никто не забыт - ничто не забыто.
Во Второй мировой мир спасли в первую очередь Советские люди - русские, украинцы, грузины, молдоване, латыши, татары, армяне, азербайджанцы, поляки и люди множества других национальностей. Половина, а может и больше, солдат были русские, это факт, но победили они не потому что русские, а потому Красную Армию поддерживала передовая социалистическая экономика - против СССР воевала не только Германия, а почти вся Европа, численно и ресурсно гораздо более сильные чем СССР. Если завтра в США произойдёт социалистическая революция, и её не задавят буржуи, то США из мирового оккупанта превратятся в мирового спасителя.
@@mrleshiy1718 Лол, США существенна помог СССР. Даже если это 5%, это целый участок фронта, которую немцы не пробили. И да, коммунизм, социализм, называй как хочешь - ху#₽%а.
@@Qazaqpyn_даже если это 5%, то на пять процентов позже победа была позже. но и Германия штатам бы не досталась. Сталин с начала войны просил открыть второй фронт.
Эта была общая победа наших прадедов из разных республик СССР, но больше всего пострадали конечно белорусы, русские и украинцы от масштабов разрушения жертв среди мирных жителей и солдат...всем вечная память.
My great grandfather was took by force in germany to work, he never wanted to talk about this part of his life, his slavery was ended by those people, thanks.
А мы с тобой, брат, из пехоты, А летом лучше, чем зимой. С войной покончили мы счеты, С войной покончили мы счеты, С войной покончили мы счеты, - Бери шинель, пошли домой! Война нас гнула и косила, Пришел конец и ей самой. Четыре года мать без сына, Четыре года мать без сына, Четыре года мать без сына, - Бери шинель, пошли домой! К золе и к пеплу наших улиц Опять, опять, товарищ мой, Скворцы пропавшие вернулись, Скворцы пропавшие вернулись, Скворцы пропавшие вернулись, - Бери шинель, пошли домой! А ты с закрытыми очами Спишь под фанерною звездой. Вставай, вставай, однополчанин, Вставай, вставай, однополчанин, Вставай, вставай, однополчанин, - Бери шинель пошли домой! Что я скажу твоим домашним, Как встану я перед вдовой? Неужто клясться днем вчерашним, Неужто клясться днем вчерашним, Неужто клясться днем вчерашним, - Бери шинель пошли домой! Мы все - войны шальные дети, И генерал, и рядовой. Опять весна на белом свете, Опять весна на белом свете, Опять весна на белом свете, - Бери шинель, пошли домой!
Мой прапрадед, Свежухин Андрей Прокопьевич был санинструктором в 49 А 352 СД 1160 СП. Прошел путь от Москвы и до Смоленской области. Вытащил с поле боя 113 бойцов и командиров с их оружием, за это был награждён Орденом Красного Знамени. 12 августа 1943 во время атаки из строя выбыл командир отделения, он принял командование на себя и повел красноармейцев за собой. Они выбили немцев из передней траншеи, и пошли в атаку на следующую, где завязалась новая драка. В той второй траншее и был смертельно ранен тов. Свежухин, как писали в наградном листе. Умирая, он сказал : "Друзья мои, идите вперёд на немца". За это был награждён Орденом Отечественной Войны первой степени, посмертно.
Вечное уважение со стороны Америки к тем людям, которые защищали свою страну зубами и когтями, храбрость, которой можно восхищаться. Кого некоторые хотят дискредитировать, называя рядового боевика «деспотичным социалистом»
(Before - sorry for me english,i don't using translate) Please - don't speak ALL America. I know - among you have very many good and understanding humans... But have and destroyers and propagandists. They don't want normal Americans to remember our sacrifice. Good luck,comrade.
Lyrics for those who want to sing along: A mi s toboy, brat, iz pyekhoti A lyetom loochshye, chyem zimoy S voynoy pokonchili mi schyeti S voynoy pokonchili mi schyeti S voynoy pokonchili mi schyeti Byeri shinyelʲ, poshli domoy! Voyna nas gunoola i kosila Prishyel konyetz i yey samoy Chyetirye guoda matʲ byez sina Chyetirye guoda matʲ byez sina Chyetirye guoda matʲ byez sina Byeri shinyelʲ, poshli domoy! K zolye i k pyeploo nashikh oolitz Opyatʲ, opyatʲ, tovarisht moy Skvortzi propavshiye vyernoolisʲ Skvortzi propavshiye vyernoolisʲ Skvortzi propavshiye vyernoolisʲ Byeri shinyelʲ, poshli domoy! A ti s zakritimi ochami Spishʲ pod fanyernoyo zvyezdoy Vstavay, vstavay, odnopolchanin Vstavay, vstavay, odnopolchanin Vstavay, vstavay, odnopolchanin Byeri shinyelʲ poshli domoy! Chto ya skaʐoo tvoim domashnim Kak vstanoo ya pyeryed vdovoy? Nyeooʐto klyastʲsya dnyom vchyerashnim? Nyeooʐto klyastʲsya dnyom vchyerashnim? Nyeooʐto klyastʲsya dnyom vchyerashnim? Byeri shinyelʲ, poshli domoy! Mi vsye - voyni shalʲniye dyeti I guyenyeral, i ryadovoy Opyatʲ vyesna na byelom svyetye Opyatʲ vyesna na byelom svyetye Opyatʲ vyesna na byelom svyetye Byeri shinyelʲ, poshli domoy!
It was these simple, but incredibly strong-willed men of the Red Army who reached Berlin and won. Not America or another country, it was the Russians who took the victory. 26.6 million people from USSR died during the Second World War
Да неужели? Флаг над рейхстагом водрузили советские солдаты, а не просто russians. Делая акцент на русских солдатах, вы оставляете без внимания подвиг людей из остальных 14 союзных республик.
@@user-lj2bn8id9u поверьте, как никто другой, я знаю, что Россия всегда была огромной многонациональной страной, но под термином "russians" я и имею ввиду всех россиян, если вы не заметили в тексте использованы и другие слова
@@user-lr1bt2kf9t Тобишь всех жителей бывших 15 союзных республик вы причисляете к россиянам? Да и что толку от других слов, речь-то о конкретном предложении, где прямым языком сказано кто одержал победу
Эту песню исполняет Булат Окуджава - не только известный советский бард, но ещё поэт и прозаик, участник Великой Отечественной войны. Он также написал небольшую, но невероятно пронзительную повесть "Будь здоров, школяр", в которой описывается жизнь молодого 18-летнего парня, вчерашнего школьника, оказавшегося на войне. Я думаю, эта повесть автобиографична. По тематике и трагичности произведение очень напоминает роман Э. Ремарка "На Западном фронте без перемен". Рекомендую к прочтению. Окуджава открылся с новой стороны для меня. Без слёз читать невозможно.
I have never before thought of this as it was it’s interesting how all the others think of this war as a map with sliding colors and not a constant long human battle it wasn’t their power level or size of army or development it was death of individual young men fighting to stop the cancerous spread of hatred
In my country It is generally accepted, that war is job. The hardest, but sometimes there are times when it needs to be done. Choice between bad and worse.
Tbh the countries on the allied side spread as much hate as the axis sides. Since the allied side won they paint themselves in high morals and we tend to believe it. But the truth is they were as much messed up if not more.
@@ankanbose2621 what a silly thing to say it’s so disconnected from reality nazis would kill you if you’re not aryan it’s that simple the allied forces especially the Soviet Union deserve the utmost respect and Stalin should’ve kept pushing for the execution of all remaining nazis
It's just two ways of looking at it and I can't say that any of them is wrong. Human tragedy is just as big as small compared with whole war. It is horrible that all of these people had to face it, but with out them facing it, it would've been much worse
My russian isn't the best, But since I've listen to this so many times while reading the english version on the bottom I've memorised it. I sang this to my cat the other night.
people nowadays don't appreciate what they did for their country and they had to sacrifice a lot of things. and i really appreciate what these Russians did for me and for westerns for liberating europe from facsist. thank you russian people for liberating europe and sacrificing a lot for us
Мой прадед был участником великой отечественной войны, был таникстом, участник битвы под Прохоровкой и других боёв на Курской дуге. Дошёл до Праги, умер в 2002 году. Другие два моих прапрадеда пропали безвести, один в ноябре 1941 года, другой попал в плен и умер в одном из концлагерей на юге оккупированной России в 1943 году. Другой мой прапрадед, носителем фамилии которого я являюсь, был офицером, начальником миномётного взвода. В одной из штыковых атак поднял свой взвод в рукопашную и лично зарубил шестерых немцев (так было указано в документе вручения ему ордена красной звезды). Другой мой двоюродный прапрадед был сапером, но где-то в 1941 подорвался на мине в Смоленской области. Собрал информацию о всех участниках великой отечественной войны моего семейного древа... ВЕЧНАЯ ИМ ПАМЯТЬ! НИКТО НЕ ЗАБЫТ! НИЧТО НЕ ЗАБЫТО!!!
I am writing a book about the Eastern front, or the great patriotic war. I would love it if you could give me a little more information, specifically about the bearer of the Red Star in your family.
наверное, мало кто это увидит, но, советский союз - он на то и союз, что там были Народы, которые жили и умирали вместе, были братьями, не было расизма или чего-либо такого, был Советский народ. Был, к сожалению. Мне 18 лет, и я мечтаю хотя бы мельком увидеть такую нацию, какой была советская.❤
Looking back, I wish I could just spend even one more day with my grandfather, just sit and talk or watch are favourite westerns. You'll always be in my heart Vic this drink is for you.
@@dispatcher22z20 I had never heard this song but its name, the first second of it was enough for me to love it. This is probably because the name itself reminds me of the lives lost in the war, who I have a ton of respect for
The russian cinematography have that statement - early soviet films about 2 World War were so sensual and naturalistic, because actors in these films didn't act, they remembered...
This is such a beatiful song. Another song I recommend listening to is Dark is the night (Tjomnaja noch/Темная ночь). It is also a soviet ww2 song. It's mostly about what they saw during the war and how they miss their homes and their wives.
Это вот то самое ощущение , когда вы вместе с кем-то прошли через что-то большое и сложное. А теперь пора домой. И вот обое идёте каждый сам к себе , с раздумиями
Памятники стоят не просто для красоты, жаль никто этого не понимает, никто даже не задумывается о них, о страданиях что они пережили, смеются над нашими маршами. Парады не для показателя силы, они для памяти, памяти тем, кто сражался за свое существование, буквально идущими в туман по тонкому канату, висящему над пропастью
I may be reading into this, but seeing the soldiers cigarettes light in the darkness, and then seeing the lights behind them but no one there, makes me wonder if the lights are supposed to be their friends they’ve already lost
Destroying war memorial by Ukraine hurt my soul, it's not their fault, they were just souls and died for Nazi ignorance and aggression, you didn't disrespect any russian you disrespected everybody who fought in this war as well as from your country
Actually they're supposed to represent dead soldiers, one's who would normally smoke with them, but died in battle. There's other images in a very similar style that follow this idea.
This song reminds me of my cousin who died 3 years ago and all the happy memories and bonding we had when he was alive. Someday we will see each other and have a toast there.
USSR 1945 you are sitting at your destroyed hometown cafe after the war ended while this song is playing on old radio and your rememver your comarades who you fought with.
If you miss a couple of lines, it's fashionable not to understand the main meaning : "And with you, brother, from the infantry... and you are sleeping with your eyes closed under a plywood star..." (the symbol of the red army on the grave of a friend, a colleague who almost did not live to see the tragedy; the same growth meant that they could be the 1st red army, so that it was easier to find them later, take into account, and so on).".. What will I tell your family, how will I stand in front of the widow"
My great grandpa fought in WW2, he was a tankman on the front lines in the soviet union. I wish he was still alive to tell me all his stories about the war. He survived , but sustained quite some blows to his head which caused his temper to change for the worse. Though he would yell often, he still cared very deeply for his family. Sadly I was too young the last time I saw him, and do not remember him that well except for pictures. I was about a year old when he passed. And my stepmother’s grandpa also fought in WW2, he went to Berlin all by himself. And until the day he died, he received gifts and medals from the government on his birthday & on May 9th. May they both rest in peace🙏🏻
Я мало знаю о моём прадеде, но родственники мне рассказали, что он был пехотинцем и участвовал в бое на Курской дуге. Всё же это было больше танковое сражение, чем пехотное. На Курской дуге моего прадеда ранили, и его демобилизовали в 1943 по ранению. Он дожил до Дня Победы, но в 1959 году он умер из-за именно этого ранения во время войны.
My grand grandfather was a commander of partisan squad in Belorus during WW2. I didn’t have a chance to meet him as he passed away before I was born. But I made a research and found his military records in archives. He and his squad were making diversions, stopped train with German supplies and even captured a German general. My grandmother (his daughter) says he was tough, but gentle person. Whenever she asked him about war, he didn’t say anything, but she saw pain and tears in his eyes…
We are all wicked children of war. Dude knew war has turned him into a savage, but being one is the only way to survive such hell, because in a war like that, victory means survival.
Only people from the countries of the former republics of the USSR and Germany are able to realize all the pain. Because everyone has dead relatives in this nightmare
Игры
Imagine you fought just to have a normal life, you liberated whole eastern Europe to Berlin, and your memorial gets destroyed.
@@bruhwhat5485 no, your grandfather just like mine fought so his people, his family and their entire legacy would survive. Instead what he got was the fall of his nation because of foreign affairs and internal bickering. Then their former allies did what they do best, bolted away to those they had no quarrel with. Said allies have made their choice and now their people are paying for their leaders' decisions both new and old. But i suppose you wouldn't think about it because it's easier to live in ignorance and choose to speak for the dead.
P.S. Go spread your sh*t somewhere where it matters and not a youtube video that has nothing to do with it. You disgust me.
@@bruhwhat5485 "And then they use your fight against nazism and for a normal life and reframe it as "denazification", while paying Nazis." - wtf. There are about 200 nationalities in Russia but only the Ukrainian nation is bad and it is being destroyed. Ukraine received nothing from the separatist regions, when, after a week of war, it was offered to recognize them (without reparations and with security guarantees from EU countries)) and abandon NATO (which has grounds, Cuba moment), it abruptly refuses and decides to wage a full-scale war.
Sorry but you just liberated your country. You didn't liberate Poland, Baltics, Czechoslovakia, Hungary... You occupied them for 45 years.
@@Wladyslaw_Raginis We are so sorry that we enterrupted your occupation from Germany. But I guess being anihilated slightly worse than join USSR side for 40 years to become free after.
@@blackki540 1. Yes we can all see how Russia treats these 200 nationalities. Did you know that for every confirmed dead ethnic Russian soldier, there are 8 confirmed dead Buryat soldiers?
2. Yes, you cant really denazify while having entities like Rusich group on the government payroll
3. "Abandon NATO" you do realise that NATO is the only thing that, for example, protects the Baltics from a Russian "peacekeeping" mission, like they did in Molvoda in 1992, which resulted in creating the People's Republic of Transnistria, a now dictatorship breakaway republic with Russian soldiers in it?
4. About Cuba - NATO membership doesnt mean nuclear deployment. As seen with Finland, Putin is completely fine with a neighbouring country joining NATO, as long as no nuclear deployment - which Ukraine definetly would agree to and even has publicly agreed to.
I can’t imagine what it must have felt like to go from fighting the worst war in history to trying to return to normal life again.
The trauma of that generation will be felt for centuries to come.
Пф подожди еще не известно что ждет нас самих.
Yes, yes it is feels even now.
As an example, US has their “Greatest generation”, so do we, Russians and all people of USSR - I think that those people, who were born in 1900-1927-ss was toughest of all our generations. They had their beliefs and ideals, that made them overwhelm death, as we call it.
Literally, it is said, that “they conquered death”.
@@na-chto-ya-trachu-vremya it makes me sad how few of them are left. We will see the last of them pass very soon.
@@SabreWolferos indeed.
Soviet men does not feel trauma because the battles they fought were honorable. They paid with blood to rid the world of a great evil. American veterans come back with trauma because they are send to murder innocent women and children their warriors are send to generate profits for the corporations.
It feels like many people just don't understand that this song is a soldier's appeal to his murdered comrade. The song is full of sorrow and light sadness mixed with relief from the end of the war. The soldier calls on his dead comrade to stand up, knowing that this can never happen. He asks him: "How can I tell your family that you have been killed? How am I going to stand in front of your heartbroken wife alive? Get up! Take your greatcoat and let's go home! "
You right bro 👍 hi from Russia
Okay now I'm crying more, my ignorant a$$ never thought of looking up the lyrics but I always felt sad listening to this song now its more sad that I know the story behind it and now I'm crying my eyes out 😭
I am Russian, and we will never forget what hell our grandfathers had to go through for our future
Yet you forget the brothers in arms of your grandfathers as you wage war against their sons.
@@MagogTheMagnificent I am a liberal, and I am categorically against war and Putin's policies. I think he's a fucker, a thief and a war criminal. It just hasn't come to a point where people could do something with it.
Brothers in arms? We were once one country. The second they had their little revoloution and decided to massacre those who wanted friendliness with Russia, they lost our respect. @@MagogTheMagnificent
Meanwhile Poland in those years:
@@bed3rf625 Sorry, I am not responsible for the policies of the ghouls who have been in power in my country throughout history and now
Recently, I've been listening to a lot of Soviet World War songs. They have a peculiar property, one that raises them almost to the level of high art. They instill within the listener the pain of a soldier who lost his comrades, they create memories that were never there, they not only like other art make us feel things but make us feel as if we LIVED them. That is beautiful!
You articulated my thoughts well
i also recomen watching some soviet war films, you just have to ask which are considered one of the best (my example is "Only old men are going to battle", if you will be able to watch it with subtitles of course.) There is plenty of older generation films that not only show the dreadfulness of war, but also teach a lot of different things, how to stay human in such conditions, how to brace your homeland and people who live with you, become as one and fight all as one for the brighter future of next generation. Those were great ideas that are unfortunately not present in modern pop-culture, neither the films nor the propaganda.
You can watch Soviet Storm and Unknown war documentries if you want to learn more about Eastern Front. They are both avaible on RUclips. You can also watch Come And See movie if you want to see how it was like to live in German occupied parts of the USSR (atleast the Belarus). Movie is also on RUclips. But you need an strong stomach...
do you know of any more songs like this one and dark night? i've been looking to no avail
@@grqfes on the 22nd of June is good
I remember when my grandmother told me a story….
In the WW her mother during winter (my great grandmother) kept a Russian soldier in her little house in Serbia 🇷🇸 they ate and drank rakija/šlivovic
And then the Russian soldier stood up and thanked for the food and the drinks (my great grandmother putted some water in his drinking bottle) and she asked him where he is going because he only had one shoe on his foot and dirty, broken clothes and he said:
Berlin
Im inlove with this story of my great grandmother because there we can see that they (the Russian soldiers and all the others) gave everything for their country and their families,they truly were real men and I’m amazed by them….
Greetings to all Russians from Serbia 🇷🇸❤️
(Omg I never thought this story would get so many likes what 😭)
✊
thank you. god bless
🇷🇸💙🇷🇺
Thank you, serbian sister
maybe you sould learn about what russian soldiers did to german civilians, i have only respect to the soldiers (not of any particular nation) that kept some of their humanity and compassion during the war, war is stupid and so are those that praise the pawns in it
I saw this image on an instagram post years ago. To this day one of the hardest pictures I've seen
Rinat Voligamsi - Twilight. Big Dipper
@@gonduras I want one of his paintings they’re insane
@@gonduras It is the big dipper, jeez
Not nearly so hard for the sniper.
Where can I get this image!
Моя прабабушка прошла всю войну медсестрой, её рост был 1 метр 50 сантиметров, и она таскала с поля боя здоровых мужиков.
Она воевала под Сталинградом, и о ней писали в газетах. Была ранена в бедро и контужена, но из госпиталя сбежала на фронт.
Я никогда не забуду ее патриотизма и мужества.
My great-grandmother went through the whole war as a nurse, she's height was 4.92, and she pulled very big guys from the battlefield.
She fought at Stalingrad, and they wrote about her in the newspapers. She was wounded in the thigh and contused, but fled from the hospital to the front.
I will never forget her patriotism and courage.
👍👍👍
Так она воевала или была медсестрой?
@@egormiloradovich4207 Санитаром. Я неправильно выразился
@@ForceCR ок
Сильно! Глубочайшее уважение
There are no ideologies, nations, and countries in this song, just pure human suffering and relief from horrors of war which committed by us humans
I don't know man, that whitewashing bleeds away the substance of what is being sung about.
There are reasons people go to war.
Those reasons are political.
There were reasons soviet men and women had to suffer.
There were reasons that soviet men and women fought as hard as they did.
It is a peace-loving song, which is fundamentally contradictory to the ideologies linked to imperialism, that is genocidal fascism, monarchism/theocracy/caciquismo/gamonalismo (feudal rule) and the hypocritical liberalism. Only socialism seeks a peaceful world, because it eliminates the cause of wars: class struggle and struggle among the different sections of ruling classes. What WW1 would there have been, had the great powers not sought to subjugate one another's colonial working classes and peasants? What WW2 would there have been, had Nazi fascism not sought to turn whole peoples from proletarians and peasants into slaves for its ruling class? What Vietnam war would there have been, had Yankee imperialism not sought to subjugate the Vietnamese people and exploit their producing classes? And friend, what ideology put a stop to these wars if not the socialist ideology? It can be contrasted with Afghanistan, where Yankee imperialism's war of aggression has been defeated by reactionaries, who are already initiating conflicts with every single one of their neighbors except their ally in social-imperialist China. Soviet Russia did not begin its existence with invading other countries-instead it itself was invaded immediately, even if it meant putting a temporary stop to WW1. Socialist China both defeated Japanese imperialism together with the USSR and United States, and also relegated the Guomindang reactionaries to Taiwan, but it did not invade its neighbors in wars of aggression-instead the revisionists in the USSR initiated border conflicts in the 1960's and the United States threatened to invade through Korea.
This song is a socialist song!
@@despa7726Sure the ussr was very peaceful, just so long as you don’t want more democracy ;)
@@huggebugg3694 I agree that socialist democracy was replaced with fascism in the USSR, but this was only done after Stalin's death, when socialism was replaced with social-imperialism by Nikita Khrushchov. Mao Tse-tung condemned Khrushchov's government as a dictatorship of the Hitler type, and I believe this is a correct characterization. Khrushchov made revolution a crime once more, and he and his contemporaries and successors became the New Tsars.
During WW2 the Communist Party made concessions to the bureaucratic stratum which before then was being combatted, so that this stratum could be won over in the war with the Nazi-fascist hordes. This led to the empowerment of the stratum. Stalin struggled against it after WW2 and was planning to initiate a democratization campaign and the incorporation of the people into the state, but he died before this could be finished, and 3 years after his death Khrushchov came to power through what can only be called a bloodless military coup. He started incarcerating and killing revolutionaries who opposed his revisionism and also committed the 1962 Novocherkassk massacre of striking workers. Khrushchov also put forward the revisionist and fascist theses of the three "peacefuls" and the two "wholes", perverting the Communist Party into a class-collaborationist, reformist party that hailed "peace" with imperialism (that means a peace under bayonets!) and "economic incentives" which meant the erosion of the socialist culture and its replacement by the bourgeois.
Khrushchov, Brezhnev and Gorbachov were fascist leaders, and in 1991 their dictatorship was replaced by the liberal-democratic one of Yeltsin, Medvedev and Putin, no less imperialist.
Many people confuse the ultra-bureaucratic, fascist and corporativist structure of the Soviet state after 1956 with the socialist and democratic structure before 1956. Stalin is lumped together with the New Tsars, his leadership confused with the Hitler-type dictatorship of fascists, his achievements for the laboring classes confused with the achievements of the ruling class in oppressing the former. The imperialist sphere of influence of the COMECON and Warsaw Pact was established after Stalin's death. Same with the KGB, and the wars of aggression in Hungary, Czechoslovakia and Afghanistan and imperialist proxy wars in Angola, Nicaragua, Ethiopia, Sudan, Tibet(!), DRC, Yemen, etc. etc. etc.
@@despa7726 ahh yes Mao Zedong very peace loving democratic leader just like Xi Jinping
and ah Stalin en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_war_crimes very peace loving democratic guy
if someone from the ussr heard this utter nonses
My great grandpa died protecting a bridge in Leningrad from the Germans in ww2, my great grandmother worked in armored trains, she died in 2020
Respect to both of these fallen heros, their names will remain in the hearts of those who treasured them and in the songs of victory they died to achieve.
@@YouHaveAnApeHeaddammi falastini 🇱🇧❤️🇵🇸
Stop spreading rumors
Heroes. Слава они!
@@snoopdogssb2wym rumors??? its not unlikely..
And then, the brothers in arms, the same people who fought together, who shared the bread together, who went to Berlin together, are now fighting between them... May the world find a union some day...
It's not going to happen in that generation. Not to us. Too much blood too much hatred.
@@romankuksin9918 its probably never going to happen, humans always create struggle out of nothing
@@grebap it will happen when we find different species in universe imo. Human division will fade quickly in the face of a threat. And if not that than one day I pray we understand we are one people...
@@jakubzov perhaps
@@jakubzov just looking at how many times different cultures and enemies came together to fight a threat during history and ending up becoming very deep allies, France and Britain, Brazil and Argentina, etc
I remember when i was young my Russian mom was playing this song and always cry. At that time I didn't understand anything because I didn't talk Russian, but right now I'm playing this song and remember my mom...
Stop spreading rumors
Мой прадед умер во время великой отечественной, оставив после себя дочь и сына - его брат, пацан девятнадцати лет, тоже воевавший, всю жизнь посвятил его детям. Не женился сам, не завел своих детей, а всю молодость воспитывал своих племянников. Они и были его семьёй - и у нас все до сих пор его поминают только добром.
allah rahmet eylesin...
Это так удивительно и так сильно, что ни я, ни кто-либо другой не сможет подобрать слов насколько это великий поступок
Это был его смысл жизни, он не мог иначе
Asalam o alikum
Лучше бы женился
Можно было бы завести семью и за племянником ухаживать
Listening to Okudzhava's songs, especially this one, makes me feel to forget everything. It's all over now, why even bother? Let's just take trench coats and let's go home. We deserve some rest, after all.
«Бери шинель, пошли домой»…..
Why even bother, yes, though he who should have taken coat is lying prone and will never answer to prompting.
I don't even want to come on here and entertain your politics. But your statement about the Sith Empire is completely atrocious .
My grandfather was a Soviet soldier and actually a year too young to join, but he lied about his age to defend his country. Even though, I was born in another country, I still feel a warm feeling hearing old russian songs and deeply respect those brave soldiers.
You are right to be proud of your grandfather. Cheers. 🍻
While I'm certain your grandfather was a good man and obviously had good reasons to join, don't believe the Soviet Army was good. They did devilish things to the German civillans during the "Liberation of the West" and after the war ended. If you have the stomach, you should read up on it. The Rape of Berlin is one of them, they did unspeakable things to women, children and eldery.
When my great grandpa remember war, he always cries. He was a child when it's started. He was sent to concentration camp when he was just 6 years old. He died in 1999. All I know about him is all that my great grandma told me about him. Rest in peace, great grandpa Tolia.
Just when I was thinking why this has a sad tone even thoguh the war has ended and they are going back home, the line "What will I tell your family?" hits
его друг убит
Previously the line "sleep under a plywood star" is the definition of a buried soldier. There was no time to bury most of them so their comrades just dug a grave themselves, filled it with bodies, covered with soil and put this plywood star over them. Thats why many of the graves are lost and why people still find the remains.
It feels like many people just don't understand that this song is a soldier's appeal to his murdered comrade. The song is full of sorrow and light sadness mixed with relief from the end of the war. The soldier calls on his dead comrade to stand up, knowing that this can never happen. He asks him: "How can I tell your family that you have been killed? How am I going to stand in front of your heartbroken wife alive? Get up! Take your greatcoat and let's go home! "
We've actually learned that song on our singing school class. I was 14, I'm a native Russian speaker, but I still didn't get it the first rime.
When I did get it, that hit me like a train.
"Wake up, fellow soldier..." It is almost unbearable to sing this one.
I see some people think Soviets was only about Russia, however the Soviet Union was not only Russia but also 15 union republics together.Thanks to this friendship and cooperation of these different nations we won this war. My great-grandfather died in Poland on the way to Germany and he was Azerbaijani. RIP for these heroes who saved us from fascism.
Правильное замечание, победа принадлежит советскому народу и стране, которой больше не существует
Fun fact: russians were only 60% of the red army
Я не отрицаю, что остальные республики помогали, но по-факту это была Россия
@@user-fk5uc5ec4z они не помогали, они и были теми кто победил. Не Россия воевала, а Советский Союз, это государство не вписывается в формат одной только России как бы. Это исторический факт
@@robespierre4843 угу, но откуда появился советский союз? Революция в Российской Империи, а она в свою очередь силой захватила их и принудила к войне+русских было просто больше всех
The Russian army was facing not just the survival of their country, but the complete survival of their people...
I couldn't imagine fighting against an enemy whose main goal was the complete ethnic removal of your culture, blood, and people.
Only to return to everyday life.
I expect it's tough living under a gangster regime fighting another gangster regime.
Not Russian. Soviet.
@@Tapok_J4F Not Soviet. Russian.
@@serjfagrin8155 Значит только русские воевали?
Смеялись всеми 15-ю республиками.
@@user-ul2ox7sv5q читай этнический состав РККА на 1944. Русских 58%, украинцев 22. Остальные народы по отдельности 3 и менее процентов.
My great grandfather was a tanker in ww2. My great grandmother told me that he was a very kind and cheerful person but also an alcoholic. He never talked about war to his family but it clearly crushed his soul. When he was drunk his children were not safe around him. Sometimes they had to hide from their own father because he chased them with an axe. He had 8 children. When he was around his late 40's he passed away sitting on a train going home.
To be honest I hardly ever think about him since I never met him but THIS song and the thought that his soul is still going home is unbearable.
I'm wiping my tears..
Stop spreading rumors
только сейчас дошло, что на картинке большая медведица..
@omkar mahadik , Big Dipper
а почему не маленькая медведица?)
А мне казалось что это Ковш Ореона
@@ZZmeyka ну потому что картина так называется
эти 3 звезды на небе, это солдаты которые не вернулись с боя
Отец очень любил эту песню Умер в 2012 92 лет 5 орденов, 6 медалей
Большой поклон вашему отцу..
@@Vitalii388 Спасибо Он прошел от Дона до Вены Два раза брал Будапешт В 1945 и 1956 Для меня он был лучшим отцом в мире
@@Vitalii388Мое уважение твоему отцу. Из Бразилии 🇧🇷
it's one of those songs that makes you "nostalgic" for a time you've never experienced...
I cannot fathom the pain and hardships that the peoples, nations, and cultures from the USSR had to endure in WW2 and throughout their history. As someone from the west, I admire these people who defended and defied the spread of Nazism.
Слава и вечная память каждому погибшему, раненому, труженнику и фронтовику. Нет слов которые могут описать всю важность их жизней и заслуг. Никто не забыт - ничто не забыто.
@@onemassage9260 а может просто человеку?
@@onemassage9260 но Они были люди.
Вот ето надо понять.
И ето здесь вообще причём если речь о советских солдат?
@@onemassage9260 так соществует только советский солдат или нацыст?
Абсолютно бесполезные смерти
Change my mind
@@claudiusaelianus7242 они воевали за коммунизм но за то они остановили Полное уничтожение славян и евреев в Европе.
The artist is Rinat Voligamsi if anyone's wondering. He does great surrealist art
Gets me crying all the time
This song is too sad to understand the lyrics😢( I'm the 99th like )
The stars/lights and the cigarettes against the dark foggy night making the big dipper is just amazing
Россияне - смелый и патриотичный народ. Вы спасли мир во Второй мировой войне. Любовь из Канады.
Во Второй мировой мир спасли в первую очередь Советские люди - русские, украинцы, грузины, молдоване, латыши, татары, армяне, азербайджанцы, поляки и люди множества других национальностей. Половина, а может и больше, солдат были русские, это факт, но победили они не потому что русские, а потому Красную Армию поддерживала передовая социалистическая экономика - против СССР воевала не только Германия, а почти вся Европа, численно и ресурсно гораздо более сильные чем СССР.
Если завтра в США произойдёт социалистическая революция, и её не задавят буржуи, то США из мирового оккупанта превратятся в мирового спасителя.
@@mrleshiy1718 Лол, США существенна помог СССР. Даже если это 5%, это целый участок фронта, которую немцы не пробили. И да, коммунизм, социализм, называй как хочешь - ху#₽%а.
@@Qazaqpyn_даже если это 5%, то на пять процентов позже победа была позже. но и Германия штатам бы не досталась. Сталин с начала войны просил открыть второй фронт.
Эта была общая победа наших прадедов из разных республик СССР, но больше всего пострадали конечно белорусы, русские и украинцы от масштабов разрушения жертв среди мирных жителей и солдат...всем вечная память.
Всех с Великой Победой! Не сортесь братья люди.
Песня сполна передала тот момент окончания войны. До мурашек.
"Why do Americans keep visiting my channel? They say my content is cheesy and a bit oily." 🚩🎥
My great grandfather was took by force in germany to work, he never wanted to talk about this part of his life, his slavery was ended by those people, thanks.
А мы с тобой, брат, из пехоты,
А летом лучше, чем зимой.
С войной покончили мы счеты,
С войной покончили мы счеты,
С войной покончили мы счеты, -
Бери шинель, пошли домой!
Война нас гнула и косила,
Пришел конец и ей самой.
Четыре года мать без сына,
Четыре года мать без сына,
Четыре года мать без сына, -
Бери шинель, пошли домой!
К золе и к пеплу наших улиц
Опять, опять, товарищ мой,
Скворцы пропавшие вернулись,
Скворцы пропавшие вернулись,
Скворцы пропавшие вернулись, -
Бери шинель, пошли домой!
А ты с закрытыми очами
Спишь под фанерною звездой.
Вставай, вставай, однополчанин,
Вставай, вставай, однополчанин,
Вставай, вставай, однополчанин, -
Бери шинель пошли домой!
Что я скажу твоим домашним,
Как встану я перед вдовой?
Неужто клясться днем вчерашним,
Неужто клясться днем вчерашним,
Неужто клясться днем вчерашним, -
Бери шинель пошли домой!
Мы все - войны шальные дети,
И генерал, и рядовой.
Опять весна на белом свете,
Опять весна на белом свете,
Опять весна на белом свете, -
Бери шинель, пошли домой!
Thank you
This song was so beautiful that it literally made me feel the coldness of Stalingrad and the heat of the war.
Мой прапрадед, Свежухин Андрей Прокопьевич был санинструктором в 49 А 352 СД 1160 СП. Прошел путь от Москвы и до Смоленской области. Вытащил с поле боя 113 бойцов и командиров с их оружием, за это был награждён Орденом Красного Знамени. 12 августа 1943 во время атаки из строя выбыл командир отделения, он принял командование на себя и повел красноармейцев за собой. Они выбили немцев из передней траншеи, и пошли в атаку на следующую, где завязалась новая драка. В той второй траншее и был смертельно ранен тов. Свежухин, как писали в наградном листе. Умирая, он сказал : "Друзья мои, идите вперёд на немца". За это был награждён Орденом Отечественной Войны первой степени, посмертно.
😔🙏
До слез, брат
The true liberators of Europe and heroes, I thank you great people, too bad most don't appreciate what you did for them.
The soldiers liberated it, the leaders subjugated it…
@@dannyzero692 This. This is how you describe it. Thank you.
@@dannyzero692 Indeed.
@@dannyzero692 Oh how sad, they took away the freedom to be nazis or business owners. What miserable conditions.
Yeah, too bad they don't get enough creedit for occupying our 15 republics.
As russian I can say this is very touching song
Als deutscher kann ich nur das Selbe sagen...
Agreed, as an American.
Exactly right, from Britain
Вечное уважение со стороны Америки к тем людям, которые защищали свою страну зубами и когтями, храбрость, которой можно восхищаться.
Кого некоторые хотят дискредитировать, называя рядового боевика «деспотичным социалистом»
(Before - sorry for me english,i don't using translate)
Please - don't speak ALL America.
I know - among you have very many good and understanding humans...
But have and destroyers and propagandists.
They don't want normal Americans to remember our sacrifice.
Good luck,comrade.
Булат Окуджава, обожаю его песни, Bulat Okudzhava, I love so his songs
Thanks for your serving, Soviet's soldiers.
Lyrics for those who want to sing along:
A mi s toboy, brat, iz pyekhoti
A lyetom loochshye, chyem zimoy
S voynoy pokonchili mi schyeti
S voynoy pokonchili mi schyeti
S voynoy pokonchili mi schyeti
Byeri shinyelʲ, poshli domoy!
Voyna nas gunoola i kosila
Prishyel konyetz i yey samoy
Chyetirye guoda matʲ byez sina
Chyetirye guoda matʲ byez sina
Chyetirye guoda matʲ byez sina
Byeri shinyelʲ, poshli domoy!
K zolye i k pyeploo nashikh oolitz
Opyatʲ, opyatʲ, tovarisht moy
Skvortzi propavshiye vyernoolisʲ
Skvortzi propavshiye vyernoolisʲ
Skvortzi propavshiye vyernoolisʲ
Byeri shinyelʲ, poshli domoy!
A ti s zakritimi ochami
Spishʲ pod fanyernoyo zvyezdoy
Vstavay, vstavay, odnopolchanin
Vstavay, vstavay, odnopolchanin
Vstavay, vstavay, odnopolchanin
Byeri shinyelʲ poshli domoy!
Chto ya skaʐoo tvoim domashnim
Kak vstanoo ya pyeryed vdovoy?
Nyeooʐto klyastʲsya dnyom vchyerashnim?
Nyeooʐto klyastʲsya dnyom vchyerashnim?
Nyeooʐto klyastʲsya dnyom vchyerashnim?
Byeri shinyelʲ, poshli domoy!
Mi vsye - voyni shalʲniye dyeti
I guyenyeral, i ryadovoy
Opyatʲ vyesna na byelom svyetye
Opyatʲ vyesna na byelom svyetye
Opyatʲ vyesna na byelom svyetye
Byeri shinyelʲ, poshli domoy!
so chill, perfection.
А песня грустная...
@@user-lt4rq2xi2g yes it is
Усталость от смертельной работы…
YASİN NEYAPIYON LOOO
It was these simple, but incredibly strong-willed men of the Red Army who reached Berlin and won. Not America or another country, it was the Russians who took the victory.
26.6 million people from USSR died during the Second World War
Yes, Russians were majority in the Red Army, but please do not forget the other nationalities that fought alongside
Да неужели? Флаг над рейхстагом водрузили советские солдаты, а не просто russians. Делая акцент на русских солдатах, вы оставляете без внимания подвиг людей из остальных 14 союзных республик.
@@user-lj2bn8id9u поверьте, как никто другой, я знаю, что Россия всегда была огромной многонациональной страной, но под термином "russians" я и имею ввиду всех россиян, если вы не заметили в тексте использованы и другие слова
@@user-lr1bt2kf9t Тобишь всех жителей бывших 15 союзных республик вы причисляете к россиянам? Да и что толку от других слов, речь-то о конкретном предложении, где прямым языком сказано кто одержал победу
@@user-lj2bn8id9u Русский и Россиянин разное, в России много национальностей. А в английском оба варианта kак russian
Эту песню исполняет Булат Окуджава - не только известный советский бард, но ещё поэт и прозаик, участник Великой Отечественной войны. Он также написал небольшую, но невероятно пронзительную повесть "Будь здоров, школяр", в которой описывается жизнь молодого 18-летнего парня, вчерашнего школьника, оказавшегося на войне. Я думаю, эта повесть автобиографична. По тематике и трагичности произведение очень напоминает роман Э. Ремарка "На Западном фронте без перемен".
Рекомендую к прочтению. Окуджава открылся с новой стороны для меня. Без слёз читать невозможно.
Спасибо, не знала. Обязательно прочитаю.
❤
Thank you for his name. I share a birthday with him. Agreed with you about All Quiet. That book made me feel hollow
Ехать под полную разуруху на старой машине. Ночь. Достав последнюю сигарету. Куда глаза глядят... Но добираешься до своего Рая на Земле.
Прямо безумный макс.
I like to see how foreigners listen my fellow's song. Especially at time like this
COMRADE.... What do u think of Ukraine
I still love this song. It was made in the soviet times not in the stupid Russian times
May you emerge victorious again friend. Hopefully with as less loss lof life as possible.
@@viralgistworld5499 Ukraine is nest of nazis
@@tusharnagpal266 oh they will win. Only 9% of the Russian army is in Ukraine so imagine what 50% would do, total chaos
Мой прадед погиб в 1941 в Белоруссии. Ему было 22 годика
I have never before thought of this as it was it’s interesting how all the others think of this war as a map with sliding colors and not a constant long human battle it wasn’t their power level or size of army or development it was death of individual young men fighting to stop the cancerous spread of hatred
In my country It is generally accepted, that war is job. The hardest, but sometimes there are times when it needs to be done. Choice between bad and worse.
Tbh the countries on the allied side spread as much hate as the axis sides. Since the allied side won they paint themselves in high morals and we tend to believe it. But the truth is they were as much messed up if not more.
You watching CNN sheep ?
@@ankanbose2621 what a silly thing to say it’s so disconnected from reality nazis would kill you if you’re not aryan it’s that simple the allied forces especially the Soviet Union deserve the utmost respect and Stalin should’ve kept pushing for the execution of all remaining nazis
It's just two ways of looking at it and I can't say that any of them is wrong. Human tragedy is just as big as small compared with whole war. It is horrible that all of these people had to face it, but with out them facing it, it would've been much worse
I just realized this is the picture on dark is the night without the other 3 soldiers
В этом смысл
Each one of those coats tells a story of a brave man lost to the war, they will not be forgotten
My russian isn't the best, But since I've listen to this so many times while reading the english version on the bottom I've memorised it. I sang this to my cat the other night.
bro's channel name is Turkish god Tengri, his profile picture is Prussia Flag and he posted an Soviet song. This is absolute madness.
more than enough to make a grown man cry
people nowadays don't appreciate what they did for their country and they had to sacrifice a lot of things. and i really appreciate what these Russians did for me and for westerns for liberating europe from facsist. thank you russian people for liberating europe and sacrificing a lot for us
Мой прадед был участником великой отечественной войны, был таникстом, участник битвы под Прохоровкой и других боёв на Курской дуге. Дошёл до Праги, умер в 2002 году. Другие два моих прапрадеда пропали безвести, один в ноябре 1941 года, другой попал в плен и умер в одном из концлагерей на юге оккупированной России в 1943 году. Другой мой прапрадед, носителем фамилии которого я являюсь, был офицером, начальником миномётного взвода. В одной из штыковых атак поднял свой взвод в рукопашную и лично зарубил шестерых немцев (так было указано в документе вручения ему ордена красной звезды). Другой мой двоюродный прапрадед был сапером, но где-то в 1941 подорвался на мине в Смоленской области. Собрал информацию о всех участниках великой отечественной войны моего семейного древа... ВЕЧНАЯ ИМ ПАМЯТЬ! НИКТО НЕ ЗАБЫТ! НИЧТО НЕ ЗАБЫТО!!!
I am writing a book about the Eastern front, or the great patriotic war. I would love it if you could give me a little more information, specifically about the bearer of the Red Star in your family.
Though ive never been in a war, the song felt like sitting in the rubble of collapsed buildings in a gloomy day hearing the peace anouncement
Низкий поклон нашим воинам-защитникам великой отечественной войны. Вечная светлая память павшим в боях за светлое будущее🎉.
It's a music reminding of a heart-piercing nostalgia that is trying to be forgotten
наверное, мало кто это увидит, но, советский союз - он на то и союз, что там были Народы, которые жили и умирали вместе, были братьями, не было расизма или чего-либо такого, был Советский народ. Был, к сожалению. Мне 18 лет, и я мечтаю хотя бы мельком увидеть такую нацию, какой была советская.❤
Looking back, I wish I could just spend even one more day with my grandfather, just sit and talk or watch are favourite westerns. You'll always be in my heart Vic this drink is for you.
"They will never forgive us for liberating them from the Germans"
You dont need to even listen to this song to love it. It already is loved.
how can you love a song you have never heard!?!?
@@dispatcher22z20 I had never heard this song but its name, the first second of it was enough for me to love it.
This is probably because the name itself reminds me of the lives lost in the war, who I have a ton of respect for
The russian cinematography have that statement - early soviet films about 2 World War were so sensual and naturalistic, because actors in these films didn't act, they remembered...
Да, товарищ.
А на современные фильмы о Великой Отечественной больно и противно смотреть(на большинство).
This is such a beatiful song. Another song I recommend listening to is Dark is the night (Tjomnaja noch/Темная ночь). It is also a soviet ww2 song. It's mostly about what they saw during the war and how they miss their homes and their wives.
The Soviets are the heroes of the world
Couldn't help but learn this song, thank you for posting this beautiful but sad song, much respect
from Peru, much love to Russia
If the dead could speak there would be no war.
Это вот то самое ощущение , когда вы вместе с кем-то прошли через что-то большое и сложное. А теперь пора домой. И вот обое идёте каждый сам к себе , с раздумиями
Только тут он разговаривает с мёртвым товарищем, который "лежит под фанерной звездой" и "что же я скажу вдове"...
Грустная песня про друга солдата который погиб, он зовет его домой
Piekna bardzo Dziękuję 😊😊😊
Памятники стоят не просто для красоты, жаль никто этого не понимает, никто даже не задумывается о них, о страданиях что они пережили, смеются над нашими маршами. Парады не для показателя силы, они для памяти, памяти тем, кто сражался за свое существование, буквально идущими в туман по тонкому канату, висящему над пропастью
Randomly found this treasure...Wow!!Freakin jackpot
Боже, как же я люблю такие видео и иностранцев в комментариях. Мир не безнадёжен ❤
I may be reading into this, but seeing the soldiers cigarettes light in the darkness, and then seeing the lights behind them but no one there, makes me wonder if the lights are supposed to be their friends they’ve already lost
iirc that's exactly what it's meant to be. There's other paintings like it.
@@s.k5585who is the artist?
@@peterszekacs9492Rinat Voligamsi
Destroying war memorial by Ukraine hurt my soul, it's not their fault, they were just souls and died for Nazi ignorance and aggression, you didn't disrespect any russian you disrespected everybody who fought in this war as well as from your country
«Toda una vida no sera suficiente para agradecer lo que hizo el ejercito rojo por la libertad». (Ernest Hemingway)
I like the lights in the back indicating there are comrades behind him smoking as well clouded by smoke itself because of their numbers.
Actually they're supposed to represent dead soldiers, one's who would normally smoke with them, but died in battle. There's other images in a very similar style that follow this idea.
Круто, что такие песни не забывают
This song reminds me of my cousin who died 3 years ago and all the happy memories and bonding we had when he was alive. Someday we will see each other and have a toast there.
Play this at my funeral, else I'm coming back🥺❤️
USSR 1945
you are sitting at your destroyed hometown cafe after the war ended while this song is playing on old radio and your rememver your comarades who you fought with.
В то время не до кафе было
@@user-yc8fy7xj2g столовка, ладно)
Песня написано через 20 лет после 1945
You do a great deal, comrade!
please dont delete this
If you miss a couple of lines, it's fashionable not to understand the main meaning : "And with you, brother, from the infantry... and you are sleeping with your eyes closed under a plywood star..." (the symbol of the red army on the grave of a friend, a colleague who almost did not live to see the tragedy; the same growth meant that they could be the 1st red army, so that it was easier to find them later, take into account, and so on).".. What will I tell your family, how will I stand in front of the widow"
So sad that history was destroyed. People really think that they would have lived well under Hitler's occupation.
"Is it needed, to vow pointlessly?" made me think to the future imagining my own wedding, just to never see her again.
I am balling man
The painting is quite special, like those soldiers cigrettes are making an ursa Major combining with the stars in sky. Wow
Я вот в Минске живу и слушую это песню в 2 часа ночи аш крустоно стоновится от неё.Очень троготельная песня,держитесь ребята свами бог😢😢❤❤
My great grandpa fought in WW2, he was a tankman on the front lines in the soviet union. I wish he was still alive to tell me all his stories about the war. He survived , but sustained quite some blows to his head which caused his temper to change for the worse. Though he would yell often, he still cared very deeply for his family. Sadly I was too young the last time I saw him, and do not remember him that well except for pictures. I was about a year old when he passed. And my stepmother’s grandpa also fought in WW2, he went to Berlin all by himself. And until the day he died, he received gifts and medals from the government on his birthday & on May 9th. May they both rest in peace🙏🏻
Я мало знаю о моём прадеде, но родственники мне рассказали, что он был пехотинцем и участвовал в бое на Курской дуге. Всё же это было больше танковое сражение, чем пехотное. На Курской дуге моего прадеда ранили, и его демобилизовали в 1943 по ранению. Он дожил до Дня Победы, но в 1959 году он умер из-за именно этого ранения во время войны.
Мой прадед пропал на этой Курской дуге
Sorgligt beklagar sorgen 😢
My grand grandfather was a commander of partisan squad in Belorus during WW2. I didn’t have a chance to meet him as he passed away before I was born. But I made a research and found his military records in archives. He and his squad were making diversions, stopped train with German supplies and even captured a German general. My grandmother (his daughter) says he was tough, but gentle person. Whenever she asked him about war, he didn’t say anything, but she saw pain and tears in his eyes…
Трогательная песня
We are all wicked children of war.
Dude knew war has turned him into a savage, but being one is the only way to survive such hell, because in a war like that, victory means survival.
Вечная память солдатам Великой войны!
So sad that these songs of sadness are once again so relevant 70 years on.
the image is sad man. The guys smoking while their bratans smoking in heaven
ikr man. Wait you're me
Мы обязаны лишь помнить.
Большая медведиц из огней сигарет
Rinat Voligamsi - Twilight. Big Dipper
Every moment when I am not with you, I miss you so much...
Only people from the countries of the former republics of the USSR and Germany are able to realize all the pain. Because everyone has dead relatives in this nightmare
only people who were there to live the moment*
Только украинцы про это забыли и теперь у них герои ,это нацистские приспешники,которых они прославляют и именно поэтому мы сейчас там воюем