TheCluelessComposer what is the purpose of midi. Ninety nine percent of people who watch those can’t read sheet music and are therefore not advanced enough to play it.
when i was 8 years old my dad told me if i could play this piece will buy me a classical grand piano .... 10 years later i found this piece again and i learned it in one day ... we just ordered the piano
In '74 when I was 17 I saw "The Sting" with Paul Newman and Robert Redford in London. A great movie and I loved the music. When I got back to Copenhagen I went to the record shop to try find Scott Joplin's rags. They were a bit curious about my sudden interest in rag time music.
Inspiring! My ten year old is playing this piece in simplified version, thank you so much to show him one day he needs to accomplish this full version!
My piano students love to play the simplified version of this song. When I want to motivate the younger kids I teach the version on Alfred Adult All in one book. We use this link when we want to listen. Thank you so much
Oh, man. I LOVE your dynamics throughout the piece. They're perfectly timed and have the perfect shifts in intensity. Whenever I'm good enough to tackle this piece, I'll use your interpretation as my go-to standard.
Here in Brazil (I'm in Rio de Janeiro) we have a composer and pianist like Scott Joplin: Ernesto Nazareth. If you hear any ragtime made by Nazareth in fact you'll love and will appreciate this compositions!
Nice playing Paul, I grew up in a family of piano players and I defected to the guitar as my instrument of choice. But to this day I love hearing good piano music and yours certainly is very very good. A joy to listen to and to play along with. Never learned this song on guitar but thanks to you I have an opportunity to now. Thanks for the inspiration! :)
49 years ago I was playing this and the "Maple Leaf"....I've never let the "Maple Leaf" go, but this one I have, so must revisit and commit to memory again! Have never tackled "Solace" and "Easy Winners" so they'll be next!! Thanks for posting and God Bless!
@@adrianthomas6244 Thanks and same to you, as a musical side note;-) one of my favorite Christmas songs of all time is "Merry Christmas Everyone" by your kin folk Shakin' Stevens!!!
Mis ojos están clavados en tu asombrosa forma de tocar el piano. Es increíble y sé que continuarás con este estilo todos los días de tu vida. Gracias Michael. Dios te bendiga.
excellent thanks... I'm just picking up the music again after about 30 years - and was unfamiliar with the last 2 repeated sections... your exact and dynamic playing really shows off this piece well!
Natalia, I'm a piano teacher and I play this song. if you want to learn to play this and other songs, contact me on my email: pedro.professordepiano@gmail.com
What I love about this recording is how respectable the tempo is. A lot of people think you should play ragtime as fast as possible because it’s “impressive”. It makes it sound tacky and sloppy. Good work!
Historical note: This type music was relegated to the saloon because its composers were black and not allowed to play in the big concert halls of the time. Rag Time music had a more respected following in Europe by the European composers than it had in America with its silly Jim Crow laws. History kind of repeated itself 50 years later when many blues artists went to Europe and found a huge following...that later became the British Invasion.
BEST VERSION EVER OF THIS TIMELESS CLASSIC!!! HE IS A MASTER...ONLY THE MASTERS MAKE APPEAR VERY HARD TO PLAY SONGS, AS IF THEY WERE VERY EASY TO PERFORM!!!
Musique très bien jouée du film " l'arnaque " 1973 avec Paul Newman et Robert Redford , musique de Scott Joplin créé au debut du XX siècle. Très grand film à voir absolument. Je tiens à vous remercier monsieur pour votre interprétation de ce Ragtime inoubliable. Un cinéphile depuis 60 ans.🤗😀👍✋
This is my favorite piano piece of Scott Joplin he's actually my favorite pianist ever he's realy great i've been dreamed to be a pianist like him his piano pieces are great and the entertainer is the best bettween them .
@@doyouhaveanyregrets that was more for the ragtime pianists who would play like coked up parkinsons patients. "Ragtime should not be played fast", _not_ "Ragtime _should_ be played _slow_ "
Well done! Perfect tempo, nice clarity, without sacrificing the playfulness of this one. It reminds me of “The Easy Winners” - both are rare Joplin compositions of pure carefree joyousness without a hint of sadness or regret. I imagine Joplin wrote them during a happy uncomplicated time in his life, having found love, recognition, and a measure of wealth. But Joplin's nature was not given to endless sunshine. Your performance of this one is as good as I've heard. Much better than Rifkin's, which is idiosyncratically slow (however, I generally view Rifkin as the gold standard of Joplin players). Both you and Rifkin feel the need to accent the A♭ (bar 18) in the descending bassline at the end of the first strain. I don't like this at all. That note is so delicious in part because it is so far out of the key; it stands out on its own. If anything, it should be 𝘶𝘯𝘥𝘦𝘳emphasized.
I don’t mean to rain on your parade, but the king of ragtime didn’t enjoy a whole lot of carefree uncomplicated times in his life. As an African American living in the reconstruction era life was not easy, despite being a prolific musician. Despite record breaking sales he had continuous financial challenges and died relatively young of syphilis.
Now the curtain is going up The Entertainer is taking a bow Does a dance step and sings a song Even gets all the audience to sing along Yes he knows just what he must do Knows how to bring down the house when he's through Snappy patter and jokes, he knows what pleases the folks The Entertainer, the star of the show It was in vaudeville that he was on the bill With all the singers, dancers, acrobats, and clowns There was a dancing bear, even a dog act there And a comedian who never let 'em down But when he came on to do his favorite song He really wowed them in the cities and the towns They came from near and far To see the vaudeville star The Entertainer Now the curtain is going down On the Entertainer, the artist, the pro He was put on this Earth To bring us laughter and mirth The Entertainer, the star of the show
@Paul Barton This version youre playing here sounds so well it helped bring me back to deeeep practice. Downloaded a tutorial for it. Once Again, Thank You for your educational videos, including all the ones which show your wrist motions ,hand shapes and your ease of finger gestures. In this rendition, Im particulary interested or drawn to your Left Hand movements. Your LH is kind of hypnotic as it swings in circular motion (if theres a term for that?) AGAIN: MUCH APPRECIATED. YOUR HARD WORK IS NOT UNNOTICED. 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌
Damn it I wish I could still play this. I knew the whole song but didn’t practice for months afterwards and I ended up forgetting the whole thing. Practice the piano kids!
The best presentation I ve ever heard.......perfect tempo... everybody plays it too fast...how dare you employ Dynamics.. what??? Legato phrasing... We need to talk...keep em coming...thanks for the post
I keep looking for classic ragtime pieces I can practice on my 61-key Casio. There is literally one note in this piece that stops me from being able to do it. Ah well, on to the next video. Also, great job! :)
for those that might benefit from your studies, thank you. Study hard. don't stop listening to and looking upon art that is well done. Your assignment for today is to close your eyes and listen to music that gives you comfort.
Bozz Skaggs thanks! Actually I started to play the violin again! I used to play the violin as well in fine arts school! I have a concert on 24 may! Im proud of myself to do what I love! For both psychology and art!
A nice rendition. Maybe some people say it's just a slightly slower than usual but in the case with many of Scott Joplin's pieces, they're often played way too fast. At this tempo played by Paul, I can at least dance some relaxing lindy hop to it, even though this dance technically wasn't around when THE ENTERTAINER came out.
NomadicAssassin1 - it makes sense, it just wasn’t what was on screen so it was making me mad lol. on the sheet music in the description it’s how he’s playing though
Tuna Time - in the bottom hand, last note on the second measure at the time stamp in my comment, he plays Eb in an octave but something else shows on the music. it sounds normal but isn’t what’s shown lol
I really can't stop listening to your version of this piece. It really has inspired me to look at my pressure control of each note. Thanks, I'm not to the next level yet, but you showed me where it is!
congrats Mr Barton I hope it’s okay to ask again to play Jimmy Johnson’s The Charleston transcribed from a piano roll, it’s freely available as a pdf. You play swing so well.
Thank you! You’re the only one that doesn’t play this super fast. Mr. Joplin always stated in his compositions “not fast.”
Only the true legends show the sheet music score instead of a midi piano roll
Well, both have their justification as they serve different purposes.
TheCluelessComposer what is the purpose of midi. Ninety nine percent of people who watch those can’t read sheet music and are therefore not advanced enough to play it.
@@midnightmusic1087 well for me MIDI is a tool that helps me to learn the piano ...
I cant learn with midi..only sheet helps me
@@tpasecretzz2703 I learn it off the sheet, but the midi app and my keyboard help me perfecting it.
This still slaps 120 years later.
fr
when i was 8 years old my dad told me if i could play this piece will buy me a classical grand piano .... 10 years later i found this piece again and i learned it in one day ... we just ordered the piano
I am pretty sure i need the whole summer for this piece😂
@@guygoldstein3739 me too!
This actually made me feel emotional. Well done matey!! You go!
Are you sure it isn't the easier version?
What an amazing dad. I am jealous
As someone who is learning the piano (and currently struggling) I respect people that have mastered it like this, it’s really an accomplishment.
This is nothing, you should watch him go play some Bach fugues.. that'll really blow your mind.
@@DangerRussDayZ6533 I wouldnt say nothing, this ist definitely not a beginner piece, especially Not in this arrangement
damn this song brings back memories i dont have
_Someone put it into words_
HI SISTER
Piece*
Dean Winchester love your username
Book Butterfly lmao thanks. i’m a fake supernatural fan lol
Crisp and clean. One of my favourites.
I've never heard of this song, i'll go watch a vd cover of it nw
@@salimaaqid5011 Now go watch The Sting.
This is a must learn for anyone who takes the piano seriously. Great songs always stand the test of time.
Such a good one, thus one is
Easy winner is another favorite of mine
This makes me want to start a silent bar fight
😆 funny
Even funnier.
Fantastically written
You're funny 😆😄
Where you get killed by silent guns and women cry you theatrically in mute
In '74 when I was 17 I saw "The Sting" with Paul Newman and Robert Redford in London.
A great movie and I loved the music.
When I got back to Copenhagen I went to the record shop to try find Scott Joplin's rags.
They were a bit curious about my sudden interest in rag time music.
Grazie grazie grazie. Bella interpretazione , giusta velocità e giusto tocco. Ed alla fine arriva la lacrima . Che emozione . Saluti dall' Italia
Awesome Paul. As always. Would like to see you performance of La Campanella.
You do realize that is supposedly one of the hardest pieces in the world. Ever made
@@vedhadas4238 probably why he said it
Def why i said it
Oh sorry then
Vedha Das it’s refreshing to see someone apologizing for what they say in RUclips comments 👍🏽
Inspiring! My ten year old is playing this piece in simplified version, thank you so much to show him one day he needs to accomplish this full version!
It's amazing how perfectly played this is.
Practice, Practice, practice..;-)
You have a very delicate touch in your playing. I love it!
I like Scott Joplin, the rags are so pretty
you real mozart?????????????????????????????????????????????????????!*
Same he's my favorite pianist
Salima Aqid did you really just say that to mozart
@@cam3nW No Mozart is an ancien pianist he's dead i can't say that to him
Salima Aqid oh yeah? Look at who made that comment..
My piano students love to play the simplified version of this song. When I want to motivate the younger kids I teach the version on Alfred Adult All in one book. We use this link when we want to listen. Thank you so much
That's so great!! Good luck with your students :)
I learned the simplified version as a kid but later I wondered why my teacher never showed me the original one, it would have been possible.
You make it look so easy! Love your: elephants, piano playing, music choices and the crisp sound of that piano.
Bravo!
Oh, man. I LOVE your dynamics throughout the piece. They're perfectly timed and have the perfect shifts in intensity. Whenever I'm good enough to tackle this piece, I'll use your interpretation as my go-to standard.
Here in Brazil (I'm in Rio de Janeiro) we have a composer and pianist like Scott Joplin: Ernesto Nazareth. If you hear any ragtime made by Nazareth in fact you'll love and will appreciate this compositions!
Mal conhecia! Obrigado por compartilhar, companheiro. Grande abraço.
Nice playing Paul, I grew up in a family of piano players and I defected to the guitar as my instrument of choice. But to this day I love hearing good piano music and yours certainly is very very good. A joy to listen to and to play along with. Never learned this song on guitar but thanks to you I have an opportunity to now. Thanks for the inspiration! :)
The second and fourth strains of this are the real masterpiece, the fourth in particular is one of the more sentimental things in ragtime.
So amazing watching your left hand movement. 😀
This is just so delightful to listen and watch.
49 years ago I was playing this and the "Maple Leaf"....I've never let the "Maple Leaf" go, but this one I have, so must revisit and commit to memory again! Have never tackled "Solace" and "Easy Winners" so they'll be next!! Thanks for posting and God Bless!
Good luck sir and have fun 🔥
Ah I love playing the entertainer and the maple leaf rag 🍁 on the piano, fab playing by Paul Barton, greetings from wales uk 😀
@@adrianthomas6244 Happy new years to you!! Keep a song in your heart!!!:-)
@brucetowell3432 all the best to you and your family from wales uk
@@adrianthomas6244 Thanks and same to you, as a musical side note;-) one of my favorite Christmas songs of all time is "Merry Christmas Everyone" by your kin folk Shakin' Stevens!!!
Mis ojos están clavados en tu asombrosa forma de tocar el piano. Es increíble y sé que continuarás con este estilo todos los días de tu vida. Gracias Michael. Dios te bendiga.
00:09 Intro
Part 1:
00:17 A
01:16 B
02:17 A
Part 2 (Trio):
02:47 C
Part 3:
03:47 B
03:54 A
Structure name: *Six-part Rondo form*
excellent thanks... I'm just picking up the music again after about 30 years - and was unfamiliar with the last 2 repeated sections... your exact and dynamic playing really shows off this piece well!
Paul is so amazing! I spend more time on this channel than any other on RUclips. Blessings to you and your family from deep in the heart of Texas.
Really very helpful seeing the sheet alongside you playing! Really beautiful!
Like we wouldn't notice that Db chromatic bass note replacing the stock C maj in the head :) Nicely done!
Thank you so much for all you show us . You give as happy in our life .
When you have small hands and there are so many octaves.... Hands don't fail me now!!
11:47 I’m so glad I found a simpler version. Tiny hands here too.
I'm young and my hands are super tiny and i find some difficulty while playing hard songs.
Awesome to see this played with such relaxed hands.
Красота неимоверная! Браво исполнителю!
This is my dream to play this beautiful music. I am from Russia , 60 year old. Self learning.
Same for me, 42 year old Chicago
Natalia, I'm a piano teacher and I play this song. if you want to learn to play this and other songs, contact me on my email: pedro.professordepiano@gmail.com
Same for me, 45 from Italy...self learning and hopeless
What I love about this recording is how respectable the tempo is. A lot of people think you should play ragtime as fast as possible because it’s “impressive”. It makes it sound tacky and sloppy. Good work!
It turns out we have recordings of the composer and he plays sooooo fast.
Feels like I'm walking into the Saloon. Whiskey on the rocks!
Historical note: This type music was relegated to the saloon because its composers were black and not allowed to play in the big concert halls of the time. Rag Time music had a more respected following in Europe by the European composers than it had in America with its silly Jim Crow laws. History kind of repeated itself 50 years later when many blues artists went to Europe and found a huge following...that later became the British Invasion.
Rocks ?????? Surly you jest !!!!!
@@howardwayne3974 I think he must be one of those woke flakes lol
No ice, only whiskey
BEST VERSION EVER OF THIS TIMELESS CLASSIC!!! HE IS A MASTER...ONLY THE MASTERS MAKE APPEAR VERY HARD TO PLAY SONGS, AS IF THEY WERE VERY EASY TO PERFORM!!!
One of my favourite piano pieces of all time
Musique très bien jouée du film " l'arnaque " 1973 avec Paul Newman et Robert Redford , musique de Scott Joplin créé au debut du XX siècle. Très grand film à voir absolument. Je tiens à vous remercier monsieur pour votre interprétation de ce Ragtime inoubliable. Un cinéphile depuis 60 ans.🤗😀👍✋
This is my favorite piano piece of Scott Joplin he's actually my favorite pianist ever he's realy great i've been dreamed to be a pianist like him his piano pieces are great and the entertainer is the best bettween them .
You'll get there with patience and practice!
Clair de Lune is my goal
1.25x
Perfect 👌🏻
I agree
Yes
“Ragtime should not be played fast, it is never right to play ragtime fast” - Scott Joplin (the composer of this piece)
@@doyouhaveanyregrets that was more for the ragtime pianists who would play like coked up parkinsons patients.
"Ragtime should not be played fast", _not_ "Ragtime _should_ be played _slow_ "
@@isaacdavis1363 I totally agree
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS VIDEO AND FOR THE FREE MUSIC SHEET. HOPE TO WATCH MORE VIDEOS FROM YOU.. ALL THE BEST!
Thankyou so much finally someone who plays it at the right speed! 😊
It is pleasant to see you play with so much ease.
This, does put a smile on my face.
Who wouldn't llike this??? This is a masterpiece!
Well done! Perfect tempo, nice clarity, without sacrificing the playfulness of this one. It reminds me of “The Easy Winners” - both are rare Joplin compositions of pure carefree joyousness without a hint of sadness or regret. I imagine Joplin wrote them during a happy uncomplicated time in his life, having found love, recognition, and a measure of wealth. But Joplin's nature was not given to endless sunshine.
Your performance of this one is as good as I've heard. Much better than Rifkin's, which is idiosyncratically slow (however, I generally view Rifkin as the gold standard of Joplin players).
Both you and Rifkin feel the need to accent the A♭ (bar 18) in the descending bassline at the end of the first strain. I don't like this at all. That note is so delicious in part because it is so far out of the key; it stands out on its own. If anything, it should be 𝘶𝘯𝘥𝘦𝘳emphasized.
I wouldn't be surprised if he was just sight reading this piece, or played it over once or twice before recording.
I don’t mean to rain on your parade, but the king of ragtime didn’t enjoy a whole lot of carefree uncomplicated times in his life. As an African American living in the reconstruction era life was not easy, despite being a prolific musician. Despite record breaking sales he had continuous financial challenges and died relatively young of syphilis.
@@sstroh32 he literally said that this and Easy Winners were the only songs he wrote while in joyful times
Now the curtain is going up
The Entertainer is taking a bow
Does a dance step and sings a song
Even gets all the audience to sing along
Yes he knows just what he must do
Knows how to bring down the house when he's through
Snappy patter and jokes, he knows what pleases the folks
The Entertainer, the star of the show
It was in vaudeville that he was on the bill
With all the singers, dancers, acrobats, and clowns
There was a dancing bear, even a dog act there
And a comedian who never let 'em down
But when he came on to do his favorite song
He really wowed them in the cities and the towns
They came from near and far
To see the vaudeville star
The Entertainer
Now the curtain is going down
On the Entertainer, the artist, the pro
He was put on this Earth
To bring us laughter and mirth
The Entertainer, the star of the show
what the😭😭
I like this slower pace. Going to download it - when I get a new ink cartridge for my printer. Thank you for uploading 🙂
This just makes me happy.
me too
I love this channel❤the pieces you play are always perfect👏👏👏keep it up☺
PAUL BARTON ...ERES UN GENIO.- HERMOSO RITMO . FELICITACIONES .-
His left hand: 👉🏻
👈🏻
👉🏻
👈🏻
👉🏻
👈🏻
👉🏻
👈🏻
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I remember my younger years when I used to play this.. love this piece,😊😊
r u an adult ?
@@salimaaqid5011 obviously
Flawless playing. Great job. Thanks for sharing.
my whole chilhood is back with this. Thank you!
Wow it a very busy full version of the entertainer but i really enjoyed it. Thanks for sharing 👏👏😀😀
Tempo spot on, well played.
I have an LP of Joplin's ragtimes recorded by James Levine. I used to like it a lot, but your interpretation is delightful!
Gracias Paul un buen Video me ayudó mucho,siempre quise tocar esa Pieza Original.
Wow, thats entertainment for you. I can listen to this all day. Very well played & now its my turn. Thank you for sharing it with me. 👏👏😀😀
Love to watching your play and wish I can do the same. Beautiful!
@Paul Barton
This version youre playing here sounds so well it helped bring me back to deeeep practice.
Downloaded a tutorial for it. Once Again, Thank You for your educational videos, including all the ones which show your wrist motions ,hand shapes and your ease of finger gestures.
In this rendition, Im particulary interested or drawn to your Left Hand movements.
Your LH is kind of hypnotic as it swings in circular motion (if theres a term for that?)
AGAIN: MUCH APPRECIATED. YOUR HARD WORK IS NOT UNNOTICED. 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌
Damn it I wish I could still play this. I knew the whole song but didn’t practice for months afterwards and I ended up forgetting the whole thing. Practice the piano kids!
Epic bruh moment
That’s actually same for me too
Oh no.. I better keep practicing it everyday so I don't forget it then..
This rocks. Scott Joplin was a genius and the US lucky to have such a talented BAME composer.
What a great work you made
The best presentation I ve ever heard.......perfect tempo... everybody plays it too fast...how dare you employ Dynamics.. what??? Legato phrasing... We need to talk...keep em coming...thanks for the post
You play this piece like no one!
Very well played. And with music sheet following - it's a great educational video.
Excelente PABLO!! gracias por compartir.👏👏👏
Wow it reminds me Charles Chaplin...! Absolutely wonderful piano song really neat and clever!!! Thanks again Paul you inspire me :) Cheers.
I keep looking for classic ragtime pieces I can practice on my 61-key Casio. There is literally one note in this piece that stops me from being able to do it. Ah well, on to the next video. Also, great job! :)
Just skip that note
Very good... Sounds good.. !!! Excelent performance... !!!
Is it just me or some of the notes look like they are smiling
The symbol is called a tie I think
linkmaze yes
Or slur. But in here I think it's all ties.
@@jogalysyndrone1316 yeah, none of them look like any slurs, I think they are all ties
Haha that's true. Yes the ties indicate no break between notes
Great execution, great rag time tune by Scott Joplin
Gracias Paul por tu talento
I used to play this when I was in the fine arts school! Now, Im studying psychology... I miss those days!
for those that might benefit from your studies, thank you. Study hard. don't stop listening to and looking upon art that is well done. Your assignment for today is to close your eyes and listen to music that gives you comfort.
Bozz Skaggs thanks! Actually I started to play the violin again! I used to play the violin as well in fine arts school! I have a concert on 24 may! Im proud of myself to do what I love! For both psychology and art!
@@blueberrymuffin9080 That's great! Best of life to you.
Paul it's a beautiful Performance on a lovely composition. Thank you ✨🌠
Very good, beautiful sound.
pretty nice! I can come back to this to check your fingerings so thank you!!
A nice rendition. Maybe some people say it's just a slightly slower than usual but in the case with many of Scott Joplin's pieces, they're often played way too fast. At this tempo played by Paul, I can at least dance some relaxing lindy hop to it, even though this dance technically wasn't around when THE ENTERTAINER came out.
bothering anyone else that he played Eb’s in an octave right around 0:27 instead of playing what’s on the music?😳😳
The Eb is used as a passing tone so get onto D. These chromatic passages are commonly used in jazz and blues.
NomadicAssassin1 - it makes sense, it just wasn’t what was on screen so it was making me mad lol. on the sheet music in the description it’s how he’s playing though
Turtle Maniac - it sounds good, I agree. it isn’t what is shown on screen, though. that’s what bothered me
Like when they are slurred/tied?
Tuna Time - in the bottom hand, last note on the second measure at the time stamp in my comment, he plays Eb in an octave but something else shows on the music. it sounds normal but isn’t what’s shown lol
Please, please do the gladiolus rag.
Your voicing is amazing! I'm struggling just to memorize the piece!
I'm 62, and I struggle to remember my own name :)
I really can't stop listening to your version of this piece. It really has inspired me to look at my pressure control of each note. Thanks, I'm not to the next level yet, but you showed me where it is!
Thank you for the free music sheet GBU
hi dude there s a mistake on the sheet at 0:29 on the bass line the D# is missing ty for your videos it helps a lot for me !!
Where should the D# go?
The music is beautiful
congrats Mr Barton I hope it’s okay to ask again to play Jimmy Johnson’s The Charleston transcribed from a piano roll, it’s freely available as a pdf. You play swing so well.
Boy do I wish I could play like this!!!!
Awesome! I have to learn this piece atm. The video helped a lot. Thx!
I love this song
Maybe try a Tom Brier rag sometime (Just Peachy, Meditation, Red Roadster Rag, and Razor Blades to name a few). Sounding good.
Scott Chopin was a legend in the true scene of the word he was one best Entertainer in the word
Damn! Just discovered the version I learned so hard is a simplified one ... !
pls everyone listen to the full thing, it's not just about the iconic first part.
When you need to find old-timey comedy music, this is what you are looking for
Really nice, Paul! Well done.
Bonita apresentação parabens
This paul burton is legend my friends it is very difficult praying faster and simple like that is not easy thing and playing all notes as they are