E38 - Aaron Judge Ejected After Ryan Blakney's Strike 3 Call, Telling Ump He's Been Bad All Game
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 сен 2024
- HP Umpire Ryan Blakney ejected Yankees CF Aaron Judge for arguing a strike three call in the 7th inning, after Judge walked away while telling Blakney how he feels about the umpire's full-game performance. Let's look at the rules to find out why this is ejectable. Report: www.closecalls...
Buy Me a Coffee: www.buymeacoff...
Discord: / discord
Facebook: / closecallsports
Twitter: / closecallsports
This is a hell of a recent streak of ejections over correct calls.
Have any of them involved Angel Hernandez?
Babies gonna baby
@@donaldthomas7070There are only two types of people who bring up Angel Hernandez whenever they can in a situation that doesn't involve him: idiots, and those who couldn't umpire a tee-ball game.
Which one are you?😊
@@donaldthomas7070 When did he ever make a correct call?
@@donaldthomas7070Angel miles the Guardians game I believe in Houston and actually called a good game. No ejections or anybody questioning him all game. I was shocked but good game Angel.
I think he deserved it but... who am I to Judge?
We'll allow this, based on your username 😉
😂😂😂
Nice to hear Michael Kay acknowledging Jomboy 😅
LOVE the Craig Ferguson shout outs with the swearing flags 🤣
Who?
Judge getting ejected? Damn he is frustrated... hell, I've seen worse strike 3 calls against him (in the graphic but low on him due to his height)... he's normally Mr. Mild.. but he's struggling so I'm assuming this is frustration on his part... The ump... at least on the AB's shown here.. good calls.
That's exactly right. He's playing like sh*t so he's frustrated. He crossed the line.🤷🏽♂️
@@jamesrivera6068 he crossed the line on his T sure, because everyone does that
Yeah, I was surprised when I saw it was Judge...
I doesn’t matter if it was a bad call or not. You don’t throw someone out for saying “that’s bullshit” while walking away.
@@devxplayerdevelopment that's not what he said. He made it personal. He said "you"
It was all 3 Ps, really. Personal in that it went from saying the call was bad to saying the ump was bs; Profane, obviously; and Prolonged in that he was referencing a prior time in the game. No issue with this one.
Great explanation, so why do you say you don’t like the ejection?
Players have been ejected just for questioning a call without saying anything insulting. Here Judge said BS so he _should_ be ejected, otherwise it’d be unfair leniency.
Eh, I think it's fine, but I do think that this comment plus that body language usually gets a warning before an ejection at the big league level. I don't hate the ejection, but also am not crazy about it
Its the "YOU" thatll get ya everytime
When you are embarrassed in public, one reaction is to get aggressive. Judge was out of line.
Way too much whining by these MLB players - it filters down to lower levels too. What's wild is those were all good calls by Blakney. Kick them out!
He should also be suspended for putting his hand on the umpire. Even if it's one game.
Great breakdown.
As a Yankees fan... judge has absolutely no argument here when he has been playing like shit and missed a hanging change up in that exact at bat.
A Yankee whining that a call didn't go their way? NO WAY!
Tell me I was bullshit on the last pitch: Fine, that gonna be a warning to stop. Tell me I have been bullshit all game: now you're arguing past pitches and plays: easy ejection.
1:10-1:13 the cursing bleeps with country flags reminds me of the late late night show with Craig Ferguson
"I got you fam..."
Thx Lin and nice lip reading!
love the craig ferguson call back to the flag bleeps.. great stuff
Probably saving the "uh oh" for a special occasion, lmao.
Good to see that All-Stars get held to a standard with directed/personal sentence enhancement as well.
His warning was “that’s bs man,” but if a guy tells me, “you,” - BOOM, gone.
Completely agree with the stance. It was a justifiable ejection that probably shouldn't have happened
If it was justifiable, then why shouldn't it have happened? No one gets special favors.
Perfect call Lindsay. I am a Yankees fan and I believe the ump was justified in tossing him. In his defense, Judge rarely goes too far and this COULD potentially have been a warning but not necessarily.
The umpires need to be replaced…the mlb is barely watching already
I don’t have a problem with it. He used the magic word. That’s automatic.
Buh bye
Cmon Aaron! You use a 35” chandler bat! If you can’t reach an on the line outside strike with a stick like that, it’s on you. Swing at those!
I got no problem with this ejection. As soon as you start making this kind of thing a grey area then people will argue that your grey area isn't big enough and that's just not a good way to approach this kind of thing.
I dont get your issue wirh the ejection. Can you argue balls and strikes or not?
She's wasn't arguing that he couldn't throw him out. She just wanted him to give a warning first. Ejections have serious consequences on the game so Umps are asked/taught to take steps to avoid escalating a situation to an ejection. Players are often given leway to vent without being thrown out. Since Judge hadn't said anything up to this point he might have been surprised by how short a leash he was given. Giving a warning allows the player a chance to realize they're at the end of the leash and the opportunity to avoid being thrown out. It allows the umpire to say, "I tried to let it go. You kept chirping. I told you to stop. You kept going. I did all I could to keep you in the game but you forced my hand."
We are going to go up to 200 ejections plus. I am sorry Lindsey but it is going to get warmed up
Have you ever heard the saying, lawful but awful, it happens in a lot of police encounters. Anyways, meaning while it was a worthy ejection it sucks because judge doesn’t usually argue, and is considered a chill guy. I think it would be different if it was like Josh Donaldson, or someone like that.
I think I have a reasonably long leash, but that leash disappears when it gets personal. In my mind, “you’ve been bad all game” is personal. It isn’t about being soft - I’ve never ejected a coach because my feelings were hurt. It’s about the authority I need to do my job, which includes representing the larger game. Maintaining that authority with both the participants and the public requires that we demand respect and not allow abuse. Both the NBA and NFL cracked down on demonstrative complaining for just this reason.
2 quick things: 1) “You’ve done badly today” doesn’t mean “You’re bad at your job”. To communicate that you’d have a third-party judge tell you why you don’t get postseason assignments. 2) Prolonged doesn’t mean “referring to an extended period of time”. It means “occurring over an extended period of time”.
Therefore, this is neither personal, nor prolonged.
At least that’s how I see it. Bad hook.
I don't think Judge meant that Blakney had been "bad" specifically in his at-bats. He's referring to the overall game. Blakney had a below average 93.6% accuracy rate in this game, which falls below the 50th percentile (47). And I think Judge was focusing on one notoriously bad call on a teammate.
Thank you for the video
Can you review the potential interference no-call at 2nd base from this game?
Wow judge would be the last person I would see get ejected from a game
Sorry, but this video is wrong! That pitch was not sitting on the edge, it was outside the box. It's a "ball." I umpired for 8 seasons behind the plate too. I know a ball when I see one. Judge was right on this call.....
No surprise, none.
I'm surprised this is his first one, because it's been shown on this channel repeatedly how bad he's been screwed on the low strike.
Which makes it all the more remarkable he was ejected from a game in which he had zero low strike calls!
I thought Lindsay did a good job with the lip reading.. was surprised Judge got ejected..
No just walk away he doesn’t see the umpire threw him out judge is one of captain first time ejection has happened just unbelievable during history made
@@alexanderbaumann2498 yes indeed
That absolutely called for a warning, not an ejection. He'd never even come close to an ejection before and even though he hadn't made bad calls on judge earlier in the game if you watch the full game he made a lot of bad calls for others earlier in the game and being the captain he's going to get mad at bad calls... There's been so much worse things that have been said to umpires that didn't get ejections in the past they're just getting too power hungry nowadays... You have to recognize that guys are going to be frustrated and he was walking away, not arguing, that was completely a call based on ego and they've been doing this a lot lately to a lot of guys from basically every team just for getting butthurt over a guy voicing frustration. You don't just kick a kid out of class for the day for being frustrated, you give them a warning and they generally correct it and apologize (yes I work in a school, hence the analogy), a warning would have absolutely calmed him down and not led to an ejectio , in this and many cases.
That was not a strike. The outline of the strike zone is very wide and low. You can clearly see the ball was outside the plate area. They need to be able to challenge these bad calls. Nobody goes to a game to see the umpire. It is a game of inches, and a review should be allowed.
I hate to see Judge ejected even though I understand why. I'm not a Yankees fan but I recognize Judge is an excellent ambassador for MLB. Even in this case he was careful not to show up the umpire or make histrionic gestures. Umps also normally give more leeway to the top stars of the game. I think the ejection was technically justified but it also would have been ok to let Judge walk away and pretend you didn't hear him.
Maybe if the ump knew he was having a bad day for calls you'd have a case, but Blakney was having a pretty good day. Probably why he wasn't taking any of Judge's _wassacominago._
no allow him to get away with many players can't screw off
NYY Judge ejected?! Oh no, why oh why did that mean 'ol umpire pick on our great slugger? And the rest of the MLB world just yawns.
false
So the Judge got hit with the game misconduct for criticising the home plate ref on the strike call.
It was a STRIKE. Judge was frustrated and he lashed out and blamed his failure on the ump. He needs to write a letter of apology to the ump.
No Yankee in the history of Baseball has ever had a called strike. Ever!
Don't see anything wrong with the ump on this one. Judge should have sat his butt down and kept it moving.
As an umpire now Brett Gardner should know better! he was famous for yelling at umps and throwing tantrums.
Aaron Judge or an umpire nobody has ever heard of, who did the fans pay to see? Fire the entire union of umpires.
Aaron Judge is arguably the most even tempered player in baseball. What he did might have warranted a warning from the ump at most. An ejection? Certainly not! Personalities matter. If you’ve got a player who is notorious for barking at umps that’s one thing. This was 100% bs
Umps have gotten increasingly soft & thin skinned.
As a Yankees fan this isn't the worst ejection as the call was correct, but Judge has been in the league since 2016 and has a pretty good reputation with basically everyone. Blakney was pretty soft and escalated things so quickly. Also, Blakney was really bad all game. There was a pitch to Gleyber that seemed pretty far outside based on tv broadcast for what it is worth, and missed some pretty egregious ones in favor of the yanks.
So..because he "has a good reputation" he gets especially favors? Spoken like a true lifelong incel Yankee fan.
@@FUGP72 You are truly a pleasant person. I am sure everyone in your life is elated when you walk into the room. 🤣. It is not that serious. We could have just had a civil conversation.
LMAO, "You wear both suspenders and a belt, what's that about?!"
AJ is just frustrated that his swing sucks this year, flying his shoulder to the sky and pulling off the ball with his bat rolling out of the zone. Maybe there is more to hitting than trying to get the ball up in the air and hoping it carries over the fence. Walking your happy ass back to the dugout twice as much as getting a hit isn't the umpire's fault.
Excellent breakdown
They need to raise the bar for ejecting players, after all, fans don't buy tickets to see umpires. Personally, I feel voicing displeasure over a call should only result in an ejection if the player is holding up the game i.e. standing there showing up the umpire. They should be able to say what they want while walking away or under their breath.
Please double check out now and no cip and no sprite boxes
Lindsey, your channel deserves more subs!
The HP Umpire is more objective on Top Chef.
I don't get why you wouldn't support this ejection. This is 100% defensible. Now personally I've probably let more go than this but who cares? We all have our different limits and this is defensible. Good ejection
It’s possible to not like something that’s defensible.
You must be as soft as the umpire then.
If a player is walking away there no need to eject him.
@@poluticon yes there is. Stop letting children dictate how the parents need to manage the game.
@@jordanissport if anyone is acting like a child it’s the umpire.
Clear ejection in pro ball imo. Surprised you disagree
I like this ejection. I like all the ejections. No umpire walks off the field or drives home from a game thinking, "You know...I should not have thrown that person out." NO! It's, "Wow...I really should have ejected that person."
Aaron...you're horrible. You're terrible. Get better, Aaron...(wow, that works for Boone or Judge!)
Piss poor analysis of this ejection. Judge was sticking up for his teammates' ABs, not just his own. To only look at Judge's AB's in this game is deceiving to the viewer of this video, and based on a litany of other videos I've seen on this channel, I suspect that was done intentionally, as this channel leans toward supporting umpires more often than not. Blakney was incorrect an awful lot throughout the game on the outside edge for right-handed batters, in essence calling pitches strikes that were 2-3 inches off the plate, and a simple look at his called strikes throughout this game and NOT just with Judge's ABs would've shown you that.
Once ai comes in who will these people argue at
no one because once ai takes over this great pastime will be dead as a doornail
If we had robo ump they wouldn't even have to complain. Just call for challenge,lose challenge and move on.
@@babybear24601 that would kill the game of baseball
In the Atlantic league... with the full-time ball/strike caller... they argued just as much if not more... the challenge system seems much better all around (and more accurate)...
They will kick the robot ump 🤖 ⚾️ and complain to the programmers.
Not only do I like the ejection, I think ejections should triple.
Finally Judge have enough. Umps being unfair with him is a disgrace, problem is this wasnt a bad call.
shut up bias
Sort of reminds of my first and so far only time in 10 years I threw a kid out. The 9th grader didn't like a strike in the earlier at bat and struck out. Walked of said that was a bad call, this blue is f***ing stupid. The back half of that is what got him eject. I have thick skin to coaches and vary seldom players putting in their skepticism as long as they don't harp about it. Using profanity that is a different story.
Judge is playing like Chris Davis these days, frustrating year so far.
Arron Bafoon has set the stage for all this crap when he got tossed five...5 pitches into a game for arguing a judgment call.
Yankee pride? It's more like Yankees cry.
Narcissists make good umps.
I enjoy your videos, but I have to respectfully disagree with you here. This is a text book ejection. Any time the rats start to argue with the word “you” followed by an expletive or personal attack, you go. It’s really that simple. Aaron and Boonie know this.
That’s how judge first ejection happens
Yes
Good afternoon
I can’t really say I don’t like an ejection when the ump is sticking up for his call that was correct. I understand he could have handled it differently but at the same time in the era of the dugout IPad, you have to give it to an ump who knows he’s right and tells you to head to the change room if you’re gonna argue.
Arson Judge will be ejected tomorrow
I failed to see what Judge did wrong along with thousands of other to get ejected! Likely just an umpire with a hair up is ass!!
1
You can’t say the word you in the mlb
I was hoping Judge would have been another Jeter having never been ejected.
Today is Friday August 9, 2024
He did call a bit of strikes on balls off the plate this game. Nothing as egregious as what CB or Angel would call, though. The Yankee bats are just frustrated with their own performance that its spilling over to blaming the umps. I hate seeing professional baseball players arguing B&S when they're only an inch off the plate.
I have no clouse 👁️👁️
meanwhile alanhess9306 says: wait judge was in the base path to the dugout, should have never been ejected!
DJ Texan will probably show up and tell us how Blakney should have apologized to Judge for calling a correct strike, and rubbed his feet on the way to the dugout, because that's what umpires in the 80s did.
The establishment club 7 8 9 10
What a shocker that a Yankees fan would be mad at this call
I mean, Judge isn't necessarily referring to the balls/strikes called in only his previous at bats. Were there poor calls on other batters before this?
There were poor calls all game for both sides
Ump had a very big strike zone. Players from both clubs were complaining all game
Hey did y’all know it’s impossible to talk to someone with your back turned to them? This is especially true if you’re walking away. Amazing stuff!
MLB is turned into the whining league
The real shimeka soina Clinton
Not a fan of parting shot ejections, and the postgame comments from the crew chief were even worse. He hadn't talked to the HP umpire at that point, so the speculation was no more credible than that of the fan in the worst seat in the house.
he doesn't need to he knows why he was ejected
@@critter2 I wasn't talking about a conversation with Boone or Judge, I was talking about the crew chief's comments to the media after the game. The crew chief is the only umpire allowed to address the media, but his comments were so uninformed that he might as well have said nothing at all.
Judge knows the rules.
Just because " he thinks he is a super star " doesn't mean he can get away with arguing balls and strikes.
Just walk away and shake your head. Sometimes people need to be taught a lesson.
The real shimeka soina Clinton aka Smart 🤓 pants 👖
I'm a Tigers fan, and Blakney was BS all game. He couldn't make up his mind on pitches outside to rightys.
bias
Hello
I can't stand jomboy
God these umps are babies. Half these ejections wouldn’t even happen if they weren’t so sensitive. In this case, the call was correct, but good grief - just move on and call the game.
It’s the rules. You make it personal, you’re done. Period. Has zero to do with sensitive.
rabbit ears. be better
That’s rare
first for judge, and fitst in 30 years for a Yankee captain. Donny Ballgame was the last captain to be tossed.
@@TKolb13Interesting fact - thanks for sharing it.
@@TKolb13 I’m a Blue Jays fan and Aaron Judge rarely gets tossed and usually Aaron Boone gets tossed about Judge’s strike zone
Aaron judge doesn’t like his first ejection he was walking way by umpire has been bullshit but judge is right word give some issues of warning thank you
GD Umpires are letting their egos run wild this season
The captain should get a little wiggle room.
You can't argue balls and strikes...why is it so hard for people to understand.
All the Yankee glazers in the chat are so mad.
that was soft as fuck....
This is a classic example of a over sensitive umpire hiding behind rules to get attention. What do the rules say about umpires using profanity?? Why don't umpires get suspended or fined???