Has Keerthi History read NOTHING about the Indus Valley Civilisation?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 сен 2024
  • Support this channel by becoming a member / @vimoh
    Or make a one-time donation by clicking the Super Thanks button under this video!
    In this response video, I address the misconceptions raised by Keerthi History regarding the teaching of the Indus Valley Civilization. Contrary to her claim that children are only taught about the civilization's drainage system, I delve into the depths of history textbooks to showcase the extensive knowledge imparted about this remarkable ancient civilization. From its urban planning, trade networks, sophisticated script, and artistic achievements to its agricultural practices and social structure, my video reveals a comprehensive understanding of the Indus Valley Civilization that goes far beyond the drainage system.
    I am Vimoh, an Indian atheist and my videos have to do with religion, atheism, Indian culture, and sometimes contemporary political happenings.
    Below are some videos from this channel that every Indian atheist must watch.
    ✔️ Videos for the Indian atheist - • Delving Deeper
    ✔️ How I became an atheist - • My journey between rel...
    ✔️ Why I am not a "Hindu atheist" - • Why I am not a Hindu A...
    ✔️ Why I am not a "Hindu atheist" (part 2) - • Belief in karma = beli...
    ✔️ The Indian atheist problem - • The Indian atheist pro...
    ✔️ Why atheism is important - • You can't fight irrati...

Комментарии • 1,5 тыс.

  • @alltcsr24
    @alltcsr24 5 месяцев назад +1707

    Keerthi wants to keep her audiance in constant victimhood mindset.😂

  • @khanaafaq6202
    @khanaafaq6202 5 месяцев назад +2276

    Now i understand why she win award from modi😂

    • @VijayaLakshmi-fy7he
      @VijayaLakshmi-fy7he 5 месяцев назад +16

      😂😂

    • @lucyjude7639
      @lucyjude7639 5 месяцев назад +94

      And also supporting kangana ranaut for her recent trending interview that Subash Chandra Bose as first PM of India 😂

    • @anime4life636
      @anime4life636 5 месяцев назад +13

      @@lucyjude7639 Azad Hind Fauj had a government and it was led by SC Bose . oh wait you didnt know that i bet

    • @lucyjude7639
      @lucyjude7639 5 месяцев назад +42

      @@anime4life636 s it's called Indian national army otherwise, yet Chandra Bose was not PM 😜

    • @amkai2928
      @amkai2928 5 месяцев назад +15

      @@anime4life636 abe woh fauj hai😂😂😂.

  • @boring.101
    @boring.101 Год назад +1457

    When you sleep in class 6th, saying history is boring then wake up at graduation thinking "ye to kabhi padha hi nhi "

  • @baazishaik4395
    @baazishaik4395 Год назад +1175

    Keerthi belongs to whatsApp history student team.

    • @ASFACT2805
      @ASFACT2805 4 месяца назад

      😂😂 ye adh pakke bal chapri tere hisab se history me PhD hai 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @ASFACT2805
      @ASFACT2805 4 месяца назад +7

      ye Jo bole tumhre propganda ko suit kre wo sahi baki bole wo galat whts app

    • @ASFACT2805
      @ASFACT2805 4 месяца назад +6

      dushro ke nam pr video use krke view pane wala chapri hai 😂😂 bs

    • @IK-dx6fr
      @IK-dx6fr 4 месяца назад +5

      And your daddy Dhruv is the Principal of that University

    • @kionpanda9135
      @kionpanda9135 4 месяца назад +3

      Hey madarsha boy

  • @DSds..
    @DSds.. 4 месяца назад +916

    She graduated from the WhatsApp University with the degree of MV History (Modi's Version of History)

    • @sreeya2019
      @sreeya2019 4 месяца назад +3

      Well said

    • @sshankar8639
      @sshankar8639 4 месяца назад +4

      Dude !! You nailed it 😮😮

    • @meghajose5707
      @meghajose5707 4 месяца назад +1

      So true...

    • @VDOless
      @VDOless 3 месяца назад +2

      KeerthiBigotry

    • @ariya_07
      @ariya_07 3 месяца назад +1

      She don't know nothing about history 🙄
      she always talk about Hindu kings and queen 🙄 gives them huge amounts of respect but when it's comes about mughal empire her behaviour change towards them😒 she makes them bad and called all of the history which we read in our text book are fake 😂 history never change dear someone tell that so called historian 🙄 she is openly taught us false history and we are still believing on her like how dumb we are 😒🤷🏻‍♀️

  • @user-pu8wb4sl7d
    @user-pu8wb4sl7d Год назад +571

    Out of all the achievements of Indus Valley Civilization, I feel most proud of the drainage system considering this was so advanced for their time.

    • @spuriusscapula4829
      @spuriusscapula4829 Год назад +17

      what are we to do with this "pride". It's so meaningless.

    • @spuriusscapula4829
      @spuriusscapula4829 Год назад +16

      @@lakshyavarshney9942 but pride is usually meant for something you have had some direct or indirect effect on, what I meant is there is no point being proud of something some ancient people did ages ago.

    • @rishuuuuuu
      @rishuuuuuu Год назад

      What an idiotic statement that is. Are you dumb ? Don’t you have knowledge about what significance the ancient history and cultural connect has on a nation ? @@spuriusscapula4829

    • @KINGSTUNAX
      @KINGSTUNAX 9 месяцев назад

      ​@@spuriusscapula4829right winger traditionally have this habit developed in them specially Indian right winger to take credit for the things they didn't do it in the first place. because they know for the fact that they are useless, unintelligent, uneducated and lazy that they cannot create the same thing or better one therefore take the credit for others work like Edison vs Tesla

    • @thomascromwell6840
      @thomascromwell6840 9 месяцев назад +15

      ​@@spuriusscapula4829Pride has many connotations. You can be proud of your son and you can proud of your country for landing a rover on Mars. It doesn't always mean an elevated sense of one's ego. It is also about the pleasure one derives from being associated with those who do incredible deeds.

  • @randm2901
    @randm2901 Год назад +897

    As a tamilian I can't relate with her being another tamilian 😂

    • @user-yg5vc7ci4r
      @user-yg5vc7ci4r 4 месяца назад +54

      Ava namakellam oru asingam bro

    • @SENTHILKUMAR-hw6vi
      @SENTHILKUMAR-hw6vi 4 месяца назад +10

      True

    • @varunsampathkumars
      @varunsampathkumars 4 месяца назад +43

      Sangi bro, namma oorula ava video vyapaaram aagauthu nu therinju than English la video podura, adhulayaum nammalae stereotype pannitu irruka

    • @kronos456titan
      @kronos456titan 4 месяца назад +6

      Man here also you bring your tamil identity. I know you are proud of that. But you don't need to emphasize every time on every topic

    • @user-yg5vc7ci4r
      @user-yg5vc7ci4r 4 месяца назад +45

      @@kronos456titan If you don't understand, pls read again. She is Tamil, and she gave an interview for beerbiceps ( I think) about Tamil culture. But, she doesn't really understand our culture and history. So, that's why he mentioned she's not one of us. Nothing other than that :)

  • @sunitaprasad3081
    @sunitaprasad3081 Год назад +2164

    Keerti history is propaganda that's all

  • @arundantuluri6063
    @arundantuluri6063 Год назад +1096

    Finally someone is calling out this women's bs.It's honestly astounding how ridiculous her talking points are.But for some reason people take her seriously.

    • @yevodee4024
      @yevodee4024 Год назад +74

      @ Arun Dantuluri
      "Finally someone is calling out this women's bs [...] But for some reason people take her seriously."
      ===========================================
      There is no doubt that India has been looted and subjugated in the past by 'outsiders'.
      *That being said,*
      this whole claim that "We were not taught these things in our schools in India (until 26 May 2014)" is done as a part of the *EXAGERRATED, fraudulent narrative* of "the whole world has CONSTANTLY been conspiring against us".
      *"Us" in this case means 'Hindus' (i.e. SO-CALLED Sanatanists).*
      The underlying motive is to portray Hindus (i.e., SO-CALLED Sanatanists) as noble-minded, ethically-superior people who have been perpetually victimised by 'foreign forces' (and by traitorous enemies within) as a result of the former's noble-mindedness and high ethical standards,
      and *MOST IMPORTANTLY,* to go further by creating the impression that the gentleman who came to power on 26 May 2014 is a messiah who has begun the process of "undoing the injustices heaped on Hindus".

    • @manutiwari9946
      @manutiwari9946 Год назад +11

      ​@@yevodee4024you are right

    • @Supermanindia98
      @Supermanindia98 Год назад

      Yes her videos are nowadays... Rubbish ..

    • @Supermanindia98
      @Supermanindia98 Год назад

      @@deekshadisha584 jealous will be on some one who is successful... Not like this bitchy Keerthi who spread hatred across country .. shame on their parents for brought up such fraud lady. ..

    • @mangopudding5979
      @mangopudding5979 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@yevodee4024​ anti Hindu and anti India para site. So called Sanatanis? Lol Hindus and Sanatanis are the same people and Indians in general including Hindus have always been indeed noble minded and ethically much better than foreign inv aders, people are different and cultures are different...Marxist and leftists wrote the Indian history which is being taught in NCERT books, why people with other ideologies not allowed to write Indian history too? Even neutral ones were not allowed to write Indian history. The Indian history taught in NCERT is not even 10% of the real Indian history, so this alone proves that leftists/mar xists and other enemies of India are in reality were trying really hard to hide Indian history, otherwise so many people would not be coming up with real Indian history. Secondly the entire world knows that the euro pean colo nists dis torted the entire world history, all these facts are known to everyone yet you have the audacity to say it's an exaggerated conspiracy, you are ty pical indo trinated anti Hindu and an anti national left ist sc um who really needs to be in jail asap. You leftists whine about being rational but in reality are the exact opposite. Hindus never called themselves noble and ethically better than others, It's history which is witness of this, every historian around this planet has said this about Indians in general. So Stop your anti Hindu and anti India propaganda de ar leftist para site.

  • @sowmidiv
    @sowmidiv 10 месяцев назад +457

    Thankfully finally someone debunked her. She was quite manipulative and confident where people falls for her trap. I can see lots of tamil youtubers also debunking her views

    • @kuttykutty4795
      @kuttykutty4795 5 месяцев назад +22

      Ur right. I'm from Tamilnadu, Even many Tamil youtubers are pointing out her shit talks. She just wants to talk about what she wants instead of actual history

    • @muhammadmafaz8530
      @muhammadmafaz8530 5 месяцев назад

      She's spreading hatred which is not good for healthy society

    • @tc.science.2024.
      @tc.science.2024. 4 месяца назад +2

      Yes.....💯

    • @pixelforg
      @pixelforg 4 месяца назад

      She doesn't even know how to be manipulative without appearing manipulative, I could easily see through her BS in just a few videos

    • @ASFACT2805
      @ASFACT2805 4 месяца назад

      😂😂😂😂 Lol debunked 😂😂😂😂 Lol you

  • @d_visor7308
    @d_visor7308 Год назад +206

    I saw a video of her on how clothes were actually imposed upon us by British and Mughals. So according to her before 1200 people of India used to roam naked😂

    • @ujjwalyadav3783
      @ujjwalyadav3783 Год назад +10

      It is about traditional clothing .

    • @ujjwalyadav3783
      @ujjwalyadav3783 Год назад

      @@kira_bl8qy Abe lawde ek aaj se 20000 saal pehle log bilkul nanga ghumte the 🤣🤣🤣. Sale history ka kuch to pdh le. 🤧

    • @ujjwalyadav3783
      @ujjwalyadav3783 Год назад +10

      @@kira_bl8qy aur yaha pr parda system aurat ko edi se choti tak penguin bnane wale system ki baat ho rahi hai

    • @hefilial
      @hefilial 6 месяцев назад +7

      Actually this might be true

    • @Mohiuddin-q2t
      @Mohiuddin-q2t 5 месяцев назад +22

      ​@@ujjwalyadav3783It's better to be a penguin than being a pig 😂

  • @kimjongunvevo
    @kimjongunvevo 5 месяцев назад +537

    She wants to call Indus Valley Civilisation as a part of Sanatan Dharma, but without proper legitimate evidence.

    • @nelipoornachandra938
      @nelipoornachandra938 4 месяца назад +22

      Why not even in those history books they said they used to stone worship
      So they are part of sanatani because some intellectual like you decided as we are only the stone worshipers 😂😂

    • @kimjongunvevo
      @kimjongunvevo 4 месяца назад

      @@nelipoornachandra938 I'm not denying it's not. But is not a well established fact that they were actually Hindus. Those are just assumptions. More research is needed and the language needs to be deciphered to confirm it. Until then, anyone who promotes this unproven opinion has a propaganda.

    • @Namish-yv9mz
      @Namish-yv9mz 4 месяца назад +14

      The present day Hinduism wasn't followed by IVC people. But they practiced early stages of Hinduism. In other words, Hinduism which has changed drastically since the time of its origin actually originated in the Sindhu Civilization

    • @kimjongunvevo
      @kimjongunvevo 4 месяца назад +30

      @@Namish-yv9mz we don't have enough evidence for that. We haven't deciphered the language yet. Once we do have evidence, we will agree

    • @dialogues4144
      @dialogues4144 4 месяца назад +4

      Since you’re not smarter than the real archeologist who worked on the project, here’s the link to a research paper for your “proper legitimate evidence”

  • @TheGeorgeous
    @TheGeorgeous Год назад +313

    I take pride in the indus valley system having no particular places of worship, but the drainage is a close second. Many indian cities struggling with drainage issues in Amrit Kaal , 9 years after independence

    • @spuriusscapula4829
      @spuriusscapula4829 Год назад +11

      Vishwaguru

    • @gurnoorsingh2214
      @gurnoorsingh2214 Год назад +27

      Just vishwa guru things lol😂

    • @umar7182
      @umar7182 Год назад +7

      IVC is located in Pakistan. Why taking pride on something that doesnt belong to you in first place

    • @Soulreaper286
      @Soulreaper286 Год назад +22

      ​@@umar7182When was pak formed?

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  Год назад +51

      Nahi re. Pakistan ka hota toh IVC ko PVC bolte.

  • @MonuKumar44444
    @MonuKumar44444 4 месяца назад +61

    Keep them busy in history so they don't think about future

  • @karlmarx828
    @karlmarx828 4 месяца назад +168

    Whenever I feel down in the dumps, I remember the fact that the Indus Valley Civilization had an elaborate drainage system.

  • @GojoArc0
    @GojoArc0 Год назад +215

    I actually read and been taught about indus valley civilization and harappan civilization,in my class 6 and 7 ,and all of them are saying why this is not being taught,indeed they were all sleeping on last bench in 6 7 standard 😂😂

    • @joylearner7501
      @joylearner7501 Год назад +5

      💯😂🤣👍

    • @fenris4760
      @fenris4760 Год назад +2

      He said a lot of things which weren't there in our textbooks. Stop lying.

    • @GojoArc0
      @GojoArc0 Год назад +21

      @@fenris4760 every thing se said in her video,was in my Text book

    • @fenris4760
      @fenris4760 Год назад +1

      @@GojoArc0 And it was not mine. It is in the NCERT. But We had books from a private publisher till 9th class, and indus valley civilisation was a small topic.

    • @NoGiggityGiggity
      @NoGiggityGiggity Год назад +15

      @@fenris4760are you still in school?
      I completed mine last year
      And it had all of these
      Btw I’m an icse student

  • @jyotirmoymandal6102
    @jyotirmoymandal6102 Год назад +139

    I still have my ICSE 9th and 10th History book which has elaborately discussed everything these nincompoops claim we are/were not taught. One would be an absolute fool or first rate harami to say that people are just being taught about drainage system.

    • @rishuuuuuu
      @rishuuuuuu Год назад

      You might wanna re read the ncerts.
      What we have is a communist and marxist view of histwhich imposes hypotheses denying the very existence of the age old vedic civilisation.
      Being a upsc aspitwho have been through ncerts like 25 time or more…. I think i have the right to correct you with this.
      We are not been taught the real history…. Why we are not taught about the atrocities of islam invaders and rulers ? You tell me ?
      Also, ‘Harami’ is an islamic word which means child born out of a sex slaves which islam promotes in Quran chapter 4 verse 24.
      I think you are a communist or a marxist and probably a left leaning person who has been brainwashed in such a way that he has been trapped into believing that indian history starts from 1947 only.
      Please re read the ncerts.

    • @akhileshpatro8707
      @akhileshpatro8707 9 месяцев назад

      Check CBSE Ncert text book

    • @MohlaVarun
      @MohlaVarun 9 месяцев назад +15

      ​@@akhileshpatro8707Meri 6th standard ki books mein ye topics the.

    • @hwt_123
      @hwt_123 5 месяцев назад +6

      ​@@akhileshpatro8707 6th standard. Deals with prehistory, early urbanisation(ivc) and ancient history

    • @whykoks
      @whykoks 4 месяца назад +5

      Chalo andhbhakto ek minute ke liye maan liya ki history nahi padhaya gaya. Lekin jo padhaya gaya wo yaad hai?

  • @kalyanimookherji8834
    @kalyanimookherji8834 Год назад +288

    An elaborate, functioning, maintained drainage system is an enormous reason to be proud of - considering situation in many of today's towns, cities etc

    • @yevodee4024
      @yevodee4024 Год назад +31

      @Kalyani Mookherji
      "An elaborate, functioning, maintained drainage system is an enormous reason to be proud of - considering situation in many of today's towns, cities etc"
      ========================================================
      There is no doubt that India has been looted and subjugated in the past by 'outsiders'.
      That being said, this whole claim that "We were not taught these things in our schools in India (until 26 May 2014)" is done as a part of the fraudulent narrative of "the whole world has CONSTANTLY been conspiring against us".
      "Us" in this case means 'Hindus' (i.e. SO-CALLED Sanatanists).
      The underlying motive is to portray Hindus (SO-CALLED Sanatanists) as noble-minded, ethically-superior people who have been perpetually victimised by 'foreign forces' (and by traitorous enemies within) as a result of the former's noble-mindedness and high ethical standards,
      and to go further by creating the impression that the gentleman who came to power on 26 May 2014 is a messiah who has begun the process of undoing the injustices heaped on Hindus.

    • @spuriusscapula4829
      @spuriusscapula4829 Год назад +8

      There's nothing to be "proud of" if we have nothing to do with it.

    • @anirbanghosh1670
      @anirbanghosh1670 Год назад +18

      When u are not interested to change the present. Then u glorify the past to make u feel proud.

    • @catsandrandom3844
      @catsandrandom3844 Год назад

      ​@@stxfdt1240we did not build them

    • @cyborg6282
      @cyborg6282 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@anirbanghosh1670Good quote buddy these people are the reason India is so backward.

  • @jayeshvaishnav1325
    @jayeshvaishnav1325 5 месяцев назад +57

    Damn, vimoh nailed it, i was waiting for someone to take her head on, you did it bro, she have more such things on her channel

  • @melaniecarmichael
    @melaniecarmichael 4 месяца назад +26

    At 38 years I still remember my history text speaking about the pottery, the great bath, proper housing structure n roads !! Not to forget the book also threw light about coins they used

    • @ptarchives
      @ptarchives 4 месяца назад

      Yeah...when he was narrating all the bulidings roads and stuff...it was like nostalgia . ❤

  • @Masterslavemorality
    @Masterslavemorality 11 месяцев назад +40

    NCERT has accounted most of history of Indian Mathematics
    Still this keerthi can't

  • @psk5849
    @psk5849 Год назад +74

    There's a mass level of psychosis going in this country through social media.

    • @tc.science.2024.
      @tc.science.2024. 4 месяца назад +5

      Exactly 💯

    • @tc.science.2024.
      @tc.science.2024. 4 месяца назад

      People should stand up against all this manipulation

    • @piya6929
      @piya6929 4 месяца назад +4

      exactly...and its making people even more ignorant that they already were, all in the name of 'pride'

    • @SasadharChakrabarti
      @SasadharChakrabarti 4 месяца назад +9

      BJP IT CELL doing with the help of lakhs of "influencers"..

    • @youneverknow01
      @youneverknow01 Месяц назад

      @@SasadharChakrabartiarre mai pareshan ho gya hu aise logo se kasam se.

  • @Indra-s1e
    @Indra-s1e 10 месяцев назад +30

    Hidden agenda in her videos. Many praise her, just blindly accept what she says.Dont search further to know what is true.

  • @nm-nm-nm
    @nm-nm-nm Год назад +69

    Take a shot everytime someone says 'drainage system'.

    • @cauliflowerhead2735
      @cauliflowerhead2735 Год назад +8

      Now I have alcohol poisoning 😂

    • @loop4569
      @loop4569 6 месяцев назад +3

      I am well hydrated because I took a shot of water

  • @bravoromeo69
    @bravoromeo69 Год назад +118

    I once told a Sanghi that since a lot of the Indus Valley Civilisation lies in modern day Pakistan, its something they would be proud of as well right? It was fun seeing the saffron fade from their face.

    • @hustler692
      @hustler692 5 месяцев назад +14

      pakistan is part of bharatvarsha .

    • @lg7631
      @lg7631 5 месяцев назад +38

      @@hustler692and India is a part of earth😂

    • @hustler692
      @hustler692 5 месяцев назад +11

      @@lg7631 so? did i deny

    • @mariagorettij2308
      @mariagorettij2308 4 месяца назад

      😂😂😂

    • @lg7631
      @lg7631 4 месяца назад +10

      @@hustler692 "Denying is a part of another dimension" -Jaggi Vasudev

  • @whimsicalvagabond6906
    @whimsicalvagabond6906 Год назад +40

    Exactly. I wonder what she was doing in school during history class.

    • @yevodee4024
      @yevodee4024 Год назад

      @Whimsical Vagabond
      "Exactly. I wonder what she was doing in school during history class."
      ===============================================
      Keerthi History KNOWS that she is uttering exaggerations, half-truths, and outright f@ L$€ claims.
      She and her ilk are neither ignorant, nor innocent.

  • @cauliflowerhead2735
    @cauliflowerhead2735 Год назад +99

    The reason she is ignoring all the other aspects of Indus Valley civilization taught in history books to create a false moral panic.

    • @yevodee4024
      @yevodee4024 Год назад

      @Cauliflower Head
      The reason she is ignoring all the other aspects of Indus Valley civilization taught in history books to create a false moral panic.
      ===========================================
      There is no doubt that India has been looted and subjugated in the past by 'outsiders'.
      *That being said,* this whole claim that "We were not taught these things in our schools in India (until 26 May 2014)" is done as a part of the *EXAGERRATED, fraudulent narrative* of "the whole world has CONSTANTLY been conspiring against us".
      *"Us" in this case means 'Hindus' (i.e. SO-CALLED Sanatanists).*
      The underlying motive is to portray Hindus (SO-CALLED Sanatanists) as noble-minded, ethically-superior people who have been perpetually victimised by 'foreign forces' (and by traitorous enemies within) as a result of the former's noble-mindedness and high ethical standards,
      and *MOST IMPORTANTLY,* to go further by creating the impression that the gentleman who came to power on 26 May 2014 is a messiah who has begun the process of "undoing the injustices heaped on Hindus".

    • @Ssssssffffffff788
      @Ssssssffffffff788 5 месяцев назад +6

      To create more communal harted. Her agenda is clear.

  • @tingneihatkuki8337
    @tingneihatkuki8337 Год назад +30

    Thank you Vimoh for doing this.
    In fact we had an elaborate chapter on Indus valley civilization in our NCERT textbook.

  • @sourabhmookherjee4218
    @sourabhmookherjee4218 Год назад +51

    A few months ago I went to the national musuem. There I saw a toy kitchen set, about 4,800 years old. 4,800 years ago someone took the effort to make them for a child. And she played with it, much like how young little girls play today. There, I felt a direct connection to people who lived so long ago.

    • @porothashawarma2339
      @porothashawarma2339 Год назад +5

      That’s deep bro

    • @alltcsr24
      @alltcsr24 5 месяцев назад +3

      So u think males can't play in a toy kitchen then and now 😢

    • @shriyas3432
      @shriyas3432 4 месяца назад +3

      Not only that, Ernest Mackay's notes say that he was confused as to what purpose a stone kitchen equiment would serve. Then, the site cook asked him if he could have that mortar and pestle for making that day's food. Even kitchen equipments can make you feel so connected to people living ago....

    • @sourabhmookherjee4218
      @sourabhmookherjee4218 4 месяца назад

      @@shriyas3432 absolutely. the silwatta is exactly the same as we use at home

    • @saumyashah4831
      @saumyashah4831 4 месяца назад

      ​@@alltcsr24😂😂

  • @RAMTA_SLAYER
    @RAMTA_SLAYER 5 месяцев назад +16

    Pure RAMTA history.😂
    Nothing to do with actual history.
    Even she got award for the propoganda from BJP.

    • @Namish-yv9mz
      @Namish-yv9mz 4 месяца назад +1

      What's RAMTA history now ?

    • @RAMTA_SLAYER
      @RAMTA_SLAYER 4 месяца назад

      @@Namish-yv9mz it's a fake history made up by RAMTE (Jai shree ram extremist).

  • @RR_theproahole
    @RR_theproahole Год назад +21

    Why not people can read NCERT class 6-8? Guys please read, it will take hardly 1-2 weeks and you'll be pretty much able to call the BS pf these people who just there to milk your emotions and ignorance.

  • @SKEPTICsss
    @SKEPTICsss Год назад +139

    i got 100 marks in class 6 history 😎

    • @cosmiclegend4181
      @cosmiclegend4181 Год назад +6

      I got total 95 in History Class 12 board exam while in theory i got 76/80

    • @kongspeaks4778
      @kongspeaks4778 Год назад +10

      ...and now I will debate against professional historians

    • @SunilSingh-eo4bl
      @SunilSingh-eo4bl Год назад +1

      @@cosmiclegend4181you took history in class 12. 😂😂😂.

    • @cosmiclegend4181
      @cosmiclegend4181 Год назад +3

      @@SunilSingh-eo4bl My choice🤷

    • @SunilSingh-eo4bl
      @SunilSingh-eo4bl Год назад

      @@cosmiclegend4181 👍

  • @juncando
    @juncando Год назад +19

    Right now with the floods. The drainage system does seem like the most important discovery.

  • @akmukherjee1971
    @akmukherjee1971 4 месяца назад +6

    That's the real point. Glad that at least someone pointed out. May this video reach to eider masses.

  • @ahnafazizict7684
    @ahnafazizict7684 Год назад +16

    Really liked it. These debunk videos are pretty nice

  • @raikishorimandal
    @raikishorimandal 4 месяца назад +6

    I clearly remember that my history textbook had information about Communal bath, Granaries, developed roadways and many more from The Indus Valley Civilisation chapter. The fact that I can recall these even after so many years is a prove in itself of how proud and fascinated I was when I read the chapter for the first time. What is the point of spreading such misinformation !?

  • @Ram_Mohammad_Singh_Adam
    @Ram_Mohammad_Singh_Adam 4 месяца назад +16

    I think she herself has not read history books in school days and now she thinks no one has read

  • @mrkarthickcs
    @mrkarthickcs 5 месяцев назад +19

    She graduated from Watsapp University

  • @raymasraymas
    @raymasraymas 11 месяцев назад +12

    So glad to see someone speak up that loud mouth, self declared historian

  • @Lucy-LosAngeles
    @Lucy-LosAngeles 4 месяца назад +4

    "No temples or places of religious worship were "found !!! 🤓"
    Lord Shiva's seal in a yoga posture ? Hmmm😏ok

  • @TheGeorgeous
    @TheGeorgeous Год назад +8

    Thank you for the work you do. Takes sizable effort to makes these rebuttals.

  • @NidzShah-ps6kr
    @NidzShah-ps6kr 4 месяца назад +4

    She is causing a fake moral dilemma. She knows very well that most people aren't going to verify anything, so she's claiming any nonsense.

  • @munnamulani391
    @munnamulani391 Год назад +6

    Great work vimoh bhai I watched he'd few reels on instagram I loved your work and then I started following you

  • @asaikumar2002
    @asaikumar2002 Год назад +17

    Keerthi is an Apakeerthi in the eyes of history! 😂

  • @nikhil-nn6mz
    @nikhil-nn6mz 5 месяцев назад +10

    Really needed this bro. Her channel is crap, she's distorting history with WhatsApp University knowledge!

  • @alphas-ex6fe
    @alphas-ex6fe 5 месяцев назад +10

    Finally i can breathe

  • @rameshkanan3139
    @rameshkanan3139 Год назад +28

    Your are absolutely right...right wing propogandist like keerthi talk as if we are never taught about Indus Valley civilization,Chakrapathi Sivaji Maharaj etc....but she is making good money...

    • @non-patrioticBoy
      @non-patrioticBoy 6 месяцев назад

      She is actually a right wing propaganda artist. And she is kind of taking the side of Hinduism only. She does not talk about the contributions to this country by other religions like Islam and Buddhism.

  • @mdmudhussain
    @mdmudhussain Год назад +39

    Very Informative. Sometimes an argument is simple to counter, like you said "What's wrong in feeling pride that IVC had drainage system?"
    That is a very simple & good counter argument but it's sometimes hard for normal people like us to counter it when people like Keerthi makes the argument by presupposing that having drainage system is not pride full.
    Good one vimoh! Happy to be your subscriber.

  • @sobanahmed2012
    @sobanahmed2012 Год назад +9

    If the Indus civilization language is unknown to us.. how those ancient people read veds in Sanskrit?? 😮

  • @kiranraavi4240
    @kiranraavi4240 Год назад +12

    Sir thanks for tackling stuff like this. A lot of this "outrage" online is born out of ignorance and lack of proper study themselves.

  • @kalebj7001
    @kalebj7001 Год назад +40

    Maybe Ms. Keerthi did her schooling from a different board of education.. NCERT and ICSE history textbooks have Indus Valley details in separate chapter of ancient Indian history.. even most probably fnyhe State board HSC history textbooks mention in detail about it.. so which board did Ms. Keerthi do her schooling in? Even if that's not the case she's a history graduate, I'm sure she would have had classmates from different school boards.. she could have atleast asked them 🤔

    • @RR_theproahole
      @RR_theproahole Год назад +21

      She was sleeping on the last benches😂

    • @Anesh10
      @Anesh10 Год назад +10

      This is a basic history chapter. All History books, under any state board must have this. If any board doesn't, better runaway from that system

    • @rahulchakraborty8916
      @rahulchakraborty8916 Год назад +4

      I am also from CBSE my friend... I even have those books! There is really not much about that great civilization... keep in mind! Those books was made by marxists historians.

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  Год назад +15

      That's just a plain lie.

    • @uttamraj3786
      @uttamraj3786 Год назад +12

      @@rahulchakraborty8916 There is plenty of stuff about Indus valley civilization in history books. It is also important to note that these are school history books not graduation level texts.

  • @seemaislam6995
    @seemaislam6995 4 месяца назад +4

    As a history student i read the Indus valley civilization in detail. This was a great civilization. But these people , they only want to manipulate the facts. They should read history before pointing out. Thanks Vimoh for your work.

  • @sharonpenukonda578
    @sharonpenukonda578 4 месяца назад +6

    Thanks for exposing her

  • @armstrong2450
    @armstrong2450 Год назад +8

    why modern drainage systems are still so bad in many cities of India

  • @sachinmohite1557
    @sachinmohite1557 4 месяца назад +2

    I am a teacher.. whole chapter of Indus valley civilization is there in 6th class history.. she must go back to school

  • @lol-wp5cw
    @lol-wp5cw 4 месяца назад +3

    I am from commerce background and studying for CA. I had totally lost touch of history subject. I knew what Indus Valley civilisation was, but didn’t know any details. Her videos have proved to be informative to me. So i don’t see your point in getting mad if she is just spreading knowledge.

    • @comradeleppi2000
      @comradeleppi2000 4 месяца назад

      Informative😂 most of histories she spoke is wrong

  • @kedarsaurav
    @kedarsaurav 4 месяца назад +2

    I'm a Civil Engineer. Building an efficient drainage system to suit the needs of the city is in fact very challenging. The fact that they did it that many years ago without the knowledge of metallurgy is very commendable. So there's nothing to be ashamed of.

    • @fishyfish6510
      @fishyfish6510 3 месяца назад

      Skill issue. You guys need to step up lol😂 You have all the new tech with simulation, the finest digging tools and you can't compete with a bunch of ancient farmers with bronze tools

    • @kedarsaurav
      @kedarsaurav 3 месяца назад

      @@fishyfish6510 Lol.

  • @vipulpaliwal13
    @vipulpaliwal13 Год назад +5

    new gem found
    SUBSCRIBED!!

  • @murlikrishna4653
    @murlikrishna4653 5 месяцев назад +2

    Awesome video!

  • @AjitMaliakal
    @AjitMaliakal Год назад +12

    The problem is that people like keerti just want to gain popularity by pushing false and wrong narratives.

  • @naithanidaanish
    @naithanidaanish 4 месяца назад +1

    Finally, someone said this. Many thanks

  • @yash_kapadia
    @yash_kapadia Год назад +11

    Make elaborate drainage systems great again

  • @Atheism712
    @Atheism712 Год назад +4

    Finally someone said.....thank you sir

  • @spuriusscapula4829
    @spuriusscapula4829 Год назад +6

    My alimentary canal has an elaborate drainage system.

  • @joshuacherian6718
    @joshuacherian6718 4 месяца назад +1

    Excellent rebuttal.. 👍

  • @SahilKumar-zs2my
    @SahilKumar-zs2my 4 месяца назад +7

    Whenever i saw Keerti Thumbnail , I Simply report ✓ block ✓ the channel and later When i see vimoh in this , I clicked the Video 👍

    • @SasadharChakrabarti
      @SasadharChakrabarti 4 месяца назад +2

      Me too💯✅

    • @SasadharChakrabarti
      @SasadharChakrabarti 4 месяца назад +1

      She is BJP IT cell working in disguise like another 1000000s influencers paid by BJP IT CELL

    • @SahilKumar-zs2my
      @SahilKumar-zs2my 4 месяца назад +1

      @@SasadharChakrabarti 😀 👍

    • @SasadharChakrabarti
      @SasadharChakrabarti 4 месяца назад +1

      @@SahilKumar-zs2my you know these are BJP IT CELL direct linked channels in disguise... I can name 1000s in national level and 10000 in my state level in west bengal... They're getting paid by BJP IT .... Always spreading hate, propaganda to defame other politicians in west bengal they are thriving on this.....

  • @Vpy2023
    @Vpy2023 7 месяцев назад +4

    We have read all this in school, I have found several instances where she didn’t know what she was talking about. The moment a historian talks about greatness of a politician, I know they are talking nonsense. That channel is the best example.

  • @R.a.u.n.a.k
    @R.a.u.n.a.k 4 месяца назад +3

    As a student from Assam state board, i didnt really know about this. So there is some truth to what she said.

    • @fishyfish6510
      @fishyfish6510 3 месяца назад

      Really? I studied in Meghalaya state board they did taught us these things in class 6 but no one remembers because our teachers were boring😂but it's there in the books.
      It must be there in Assam state board I mean surely your state board is better than our substandard education in Meghalaya😂

    • @tamalikasikder5066
      @tamalikasikder5066 2 месяца назад

      I m from Assam and it's very clearly written in class 6 textbooks

  • @prasadkasu647
    @prasadkasu647 4 месяца назад +1

    Finally I found someone who saying yes we learn from school that history

  • @jayaramprakash6159
    @jayaramprakash6159 Год назад +22

    Shez a simply mouth motoring sanghi 😂😂😂

  • @imacarguy4065
    @imacarguy4065 4 месяца назад +1

    IN ALL FAIRNESS, the most mainstream thing known about the IVC was the drainage system but that could be due to the fact that its a sign of an advanced civilization so we always mention it.

  • @nikhilhembrom8952
    @nikhilhembrom8952 5 месяцев назад +7

    I mean we are taught about indus valley civilisation during 6th standard

  • @BOCCHITHEMETH
    @BOCCHITHEMETH 2 месяца назад +1

    Love of how you threw shade on her by talking diagonally to the camera at the start.

  • @Veekay_stpauli
    @Veekay_stpauli Год назад +9

    I feel that we, the people of Indian subcontinent, did not take much pride in having a good drainage system.
    And that, is probably the reason Cholera outbreaks are so common in India. And, repeatedly every government need to psend huge amounts of money to build a basic necessity as a toilet.

  • @nitiz5871
    @nitiz5871 4 месяца назад +1

    Drainage system in Indus valley is definitely something to be proud of as no other civilization at that time had a well planned city with roads and drainage..

  • @NoGiggityGiggity
    @NoGiggityGiggity Год назад +7

    I graduated from school last year and I was taught each of those things you mentioned
    Even figurines like dancing girl and bearded man
    Idk how she’s claiming all that bs

  • @snowwhite2038
    @snowwhite2038 Месяц назад

    I do remember watching this short of Keerthi like months ago (now her videos don't come into my feed anymore 😁) but as far as I can remember people in the comments section did point it out. People did take a notice of it and explained that the very mention of an extensive drainage system, public baths, two storeyed building and well connected roads was indeed an indication of the advancement of the civilization.

  • @trinaghosh1468
    @trinaghosh1468 Год назад +9

    It's not her fault , she must have followed suggestions to pass exam back in high school . 😜😜😜

    • @anirbanghosh1670
      @anirbanghosh1670 Год назад

      And she failed and now she is with a fake degree wants to change Sllybus itself

  • @bratwurstmitbiryani
    @bratwurstmitbiryani 5 месяцев назад +1

    I learned about IVC in 4th grade and even did projects about it. I was in IB board. I also remember studying Egyptian and Sumerian civilization. I made a snake and ladder sorta game as a project. Some 15 years later those memories were revieved when i saw that game board in Berlin's State Museums where they have a great collection of Egyptian items. It literally brought tears to my eyes. I never imagined i would even think about that game again.
    We should not just take pride in IVC but also other civilizations of humans. Your genetic descent shouldn't matter when taking pride in history. We are all humans and are related.

  • @MrRoshanfiroz
    @MrRoshanfiroz Год назад +5

    I was waiting for somebody to do a show fact checking wat these newly poped up godi historians. Great job. Jai hind

  • @HotPink-jz6rn
    @HotPink-jz6rn 3 месяца назад +1

    She asked why do we only talk about the great drainage system...because most likely in our history exam that was an "expected 5 mark question"...and it looks like that's the only thing she prepared for...😅

  • @tokris-d6q
    @tokris-d6q 5 месяцев назад +3

    We all studied in our schools about Indus valley civilization.
    ....

  • @The_Black_Caps
    @The_Black_Caps Месяц назад +1

    As a Tamilian we don't claim here and thanks for speaking up sir❤😭

  • @wdm276
    @wdm276 Год назад +5

    She might have read about that. But through ignorance or to push an agenda, she needs to have this narrative that people in this subcontinent were better and they had a specific religion and beliefs which all had scientific reasons behind them.

  • @kira_bl8qy
    @kira_bl8qy Год назад +6

    The intro hahahaha hahahaha 😂😂😅

  • @snehalpage9774
    @snehalpage9774 Год назад +3

    Yes good drainage system is some thing to be proud of in era of flooding smart cities.

  • @shahithabanu3067
    @shahithabanu3067 3 месяца назад

    Omg thank you so much for putting sense to her videos.

  • @AbarSuru-ww3bq
    @AbarSuru-ww3bq 4 месяца назад +6

    That's because she graduated from WA University.

  • @ashilyjustin4748
    @ashilyjustin4748 Год назад +19

    And one thing more IVC is not related to Hinduism, aajkl log Sanatan sanatan krke sbko jod de rhe , or ramayan Mahabharat itna hi purana tha toh uske saboot kyu nhi milte baat maan log Bhai log mythology or history me difference hai 🙄🙄

    • @spuriusscapula4829
      @spuriusscapula4829 Год назад

      BJP logo ko chutiya banaye ja rhi h

    • @arjyachatterjee6874
      @arjyachatterjee6874 Год назад +1

      O log Ram Setu or Dwarka Ruins ka evidence dete he.

    • @arjyachatterjee6874
      @arjyachatterjee6874 Год назад +2

      Ekto bol raha tha (Abhjit Chavda ke channel me) Dancing Girl asalme Ma Durga he. Mujhe ouski baat samaj me nehi aai.

    • @ashilyjustin4748
      @ashilyjustin4748 Год назад +6

      @@arjyachatterjee6874 abhijit chavda se bda fraud nhi koi bro he's political historian

    • @arjyachatterjee6874
      @arjyachatterjee6874 Год назад +1

      @@ashilyjustin4748 Abhi abhi Mohak ke liberal wala video check kar raha tha or dekhe kuch log puch rahe the ki Dhruv Rathee ko kyu hate Kiya jata he. Do or teen mahasya likha Dhruv Rathee ke thinking stupid he kyuki usne Lord Rama ko Spider Man se compare kiya tha.

  • @Waseem0071
    @Waseem0071 3 месяца назад

    I have visited the ruins of Moen Jo Daro. Believe me it is one of the finest example of town planning. You cannot even imagine how perfectly it was planned and executed. Finest indeed that city was.

  • @adityamaurya8034
    @adityamaurya8034 Год назад +13

    It's not just her, from some time people has evolved that history textbooks lack this lack that... These things history books didn't tell about Gandhi Nehru etc. Like abhijeet chavda , beer biceps and all...I don't think Ranveer has ever seen a history textbook of class 11 and 12... I am not saying there's no historical bias...but according to these people this bias is so much that entire book has to be replaced rather than Modified 😂😂

  • @AbhishekSharma-tg9ke
    @AbhishekSharma-tg9ke 5 месяцев назад +1

    That camera angle shift in the beginning lol 😂

  • @kuldeepsingh5114
    @kuldeepsingh5114 9 месяцев назад +8

    Keerthi history is from Chennai which does not have an elaborate drainage system. In contrast, it has a pathetic drainage system😅

  • @lishyajennifer
    @lishyajennifer 3 месяца назад

    Thank you for this information. Some people simply throw words stating that they know everything

  • @latvialava6644
    @latvialava6644 3 месяца назад +3

    Not even once, she mentioned word religion or beliefs!!!!
    Bruh :- We didn't find anything related to religion or temples!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭 Bhai, tum sarre liberals pgl ho chuke ho kyyy

    • @vedikasingh6491
      @vedikasingh6491 3 месяца назад +1

      That is what he is saying....there is nothing more to teach than what is already taught.

  • @RedRebel008
    @RedRebel008 5 месяцев назад +2

    Make more videos on Her, the amount of Misinformation she is able to spread and in such a wide group is terrifying, and she always blames it on the education system, and the children watching her videos also do the same, We really needed counter content, I am going to Subscribe right away.

  • @TheClanOfHari
    @TheClanOfHari Год назад +6

    I think it depends on the state and also in CBSE there is not much about it in the texts as far as I remember while my sister studied and in my state syllabus it was just a short chapter.

    • @OAParis
      @OAParis Год назад +5

      In my ICSE syllabus, I was taught about Indus valley in 7th standard and then again in more details in 9th standard

    • @hypernova1360
      @hypernova1360 8 месяцев назад +5

      Bro in class 6-7 ncert history books everything about seals , great bath etc. is mentioned and cbse use ncert books, so I don't know what you are talking about.

    • @combinatorics1224
      @combinatorics1224 6 месяцев назад +7

      In our WB state board Indus valley was covered in depth in class 6 history book. From that book we came to know that Indus had trade links with ancient Persia and Sumer.

    • @anime4life636
      @anime4life636 6 месяцев назад

      it is not indepth at all . lmfao indepth would be more than 500 page chapter @@combinatorics1224

    • @swift150_67
      @swift150_67 5 месяцев назад +2

      We learnt everything in detail of Great bath, well planned city, drainage system, their occupation, entertainment etc., way back in 1977, and still remember every bit of it. She can only fool the few new generation kids, that too who doesn't want to do any research, just want to believe anyone!!! She better understand that there are many intellectual class still exists in this country ...

  • @sabatanveer8486
    @sabatanveer8486 4 месяца назад

    Thankyou sir for enlightening us. She made me feel like that I am an illiterate and herself a historian.

  • @KartikD7
    @KartikD7 Год назад +10

    It's the person's viewpoint and thinking which makes him/her become egoistic and bigoted with their religion and culture... pride is good, but when u say it forcefully it shows ur staunch mindset. I personally think there is nothing to be proud of...it's a fact that they used such technologies at that time which is still surprising but it's also a fact that we don't know about it completely as we couldn't yet decipher the language, but attaching our feelings corrupts the fact.

  • @tanya.0_0
    @tanya.0_0 3 месяца назад +1

    Thankyou for doing this, I would appreciate if you could manage to debunk more of her videos as they’re so full of hate and misinformation Thankyou ! More power to you 😊