The divide and rule you mentioned is actually implemented or trying to implement by the Christian churches in the south in order to make Hindus of the south feel insecure about their identity so they can feel distanced from Hinduism thus making things easy for the churches to convert them. Now the jihadis are also competing with them to cut and separate the south away from India. China, Islamist countries and many western countries are funding them.
@@sumuqh that's obvious na? That's their profession to be narrow minded! She did mention somewhere I think. She wants to believe the childhood stories but they have be narrow minded!
Ambedkar Nagar district in UP agriculture dates backs to 7500BCE. Prof. Shinde's Paper on Rakhigarh Skeleton proofs that Agriculture Develops in India Independently.
it's sad there is not much excavation and archaeology work happening in Pakistan, which consists of the largest ever area of the Indus Valley Civilization from Balochistan to Harappa to Swat to Thar. There should be Pak-India archaeological collaboration on this.
@@amrut13 Hindu comes from HImalaya and siNDU ocean (Indian Ocean) - word Hindu represents people living between these two boundaries. It is used in our sacred texts, much before Persian used the term.
@@mannysmandatories5595 Think long and hard what's the use of an Army doing a parade..in the end all they do is walk. Traditions are a way to live a disciplined life. As for why?? I really don't know its significance but even without it..aah why am i telling you this it feels like you aren't a seeker. Nothing i say will get to you unless someone walks on water in front of you.
@@mannysmandatories5595 okay first following a tradition isn't an offense. Ofcoarse there is a reason just google it. But at the same time I don't intend you to change your mind because even with the reason you are not wearing it anyway. oh and btw i have already written my reason of doing so in the original comment. For me that much is enough but for you..i guess you want to know who came first a chicken or an egg??
The part that Ranveer mentioned about people in Tamil Nadu still harbour the divisive narrative of Aryan-Invasion theory, was playing out yesterday, when in office I had interesting discussion (where I didn't allow it to heat up into argument), with a Tamilian spewing out all kinds of Periyarist, Colonial, Leftist-Sickular non-sense, going to an extent that before Britishers India as a nation didn't exist & he considers Tamil as a Nation, not India as a nation even now (except for constitution part).
@@linneshwharparameswaran6147 You don't have to apologise on anyone's behalf. I'm "a realist & an optimist" and I know there are still more sane Tamilians than insane ones in Tamil Nadu & elsewhere. But I wouldn't say the same thing for Keralites (I am one too) and for Bengalis. I mean in Kerala & Bengal, the proportionality of sane : insane is already less than 1.0.
@@linneshwharparameswaran6147 you don't need to apologize bro..... It's a plan of politician,,,,,,,for win election...... We are one,,,, we North Indian love every regional language,,, gujrati, Punjabi, tamil, telgu..... But I don't know why Tamil hate sanskrit
@@jklmnop3511 I certainly don't. Tbh doesn't really matter which is older. Both are older than ALL other languages. India could use both to levy soft power on an international stage
@@Manojshinde7it might be because a large portion of Indus civilisation is in Pakistan and Afghanistan. And they couldn’t care less about history and they don’t have money in reality as well to conduct a deep search.
The Mesopotamian civilization is the oldest civilization. Other civilizations, including the Indus Valley civilization, emerged later than the Mesopotamian civilization, but all the ancient civilizations emerged almost simultaneously, one after another. Therefore, the Indus Valley civilization is one of the oldest civilizations in the world and has equal importance in the history of ancient civilizations around the world, along with the others.
Homo Sapient migration into India was around 80,000 years ago, BEFORE the Toba Volcano eruption around 75,000 years ago. The question of Hinduism / Vedas vs IVC - which came first has NOT been answered.
@@DiatomAlgae and whatever we are following is brahmic religion that is not hindu nor sanatan because in our so called holy books it is nowhere mentioned that it is himdu or sanatan it was created by brahmans to rule on other people thats ehy they have kept themselves on top of other people and aslo they decided that what they will do
Love your podcasts, very interesting and educational discussions. I had visited the site at Dholaveera three times at different times and also at Lothal, but to my disappointment didn't see much excavations carried out from the first to the last visit. The museum at Lothal was having a good collection, the museum at Dholaveera was added much later. Another sad point was I came to know when I asked a guide why isn't much displayed there? The answer was most is taken to the Delhi museum. I also visited the Delhi museum and found a very small section on display, disappointed again. ❤😢👍
You need to get Dr Raj Vedam and Vedveer Arya to give you a phenomenal understanding of Indian civilizational history. As of today we can scientifically prove back to 15-17000 BCE.
What "civilisation" when there is not even agriculture? Of course there was some cultures emerging 17000BCE also, but not "civilisation". That is a complete different thing.
Please refer to Kizhadi (Kiladi) excavation near madurai going on in tamilnadu. Any civilization will extinct and a new civilization will flourish. So no civilization or no religion is superior to others. Still north Indians address south indians as madrassi, also north east people as Chinese instead of calling it by state they belong, hence still aryan and Dravidan theory prevails. First accept South Indians as Indians and all languages equal then others will also accept the same towards North.
@@rajeshbobba3851We can't erase the directions of our states where they are in our country (East, West North, South), and can't rename them like we rename many towns and places.
@@rajeshbobba3851 I am not doing on my own, as our union government has segregated the country on 6 zones or regions namely North Zone, South Zone, East Zone, West Zone, Central Zone and North East Zone. All these zones include our 28 states and 8 union territories.
We do not want to say and romancize that our country was the biggest and oldest .... But it's a fact .. reading it as a fact ,like a fact (nothing to be proud of ) and use it as a tool to make us the BEST civilization right now . 🙏 Har har mahadev
This is what romanticizing means. This is the first video of this guy I felt was level-headed because it isn't stroking the Hinduism ego that our people have. Of course such evidence based video will have people commenting about how we are the greatest no matter what.
@@dewansharma658 Mesopotamian civilization is generally thought to be the oldest civilization. Indus valley and ancient Egyptian is considered to be the next and each developed around the same time
@@Voiddrifter725 Ignorance of what? I speak from experience. Some cities and towns in Eastern India have several temples in every block, each with gods painted like cartoons, often angrily staring down at us. But as Acts 17 of the Bible says, "The God who made heaven and earth does not live in temples made by people."
@@christianfrommuslimyou are stuck with the blank and white image of a god or creator. This fantasy you have about god who were a white robe and not believing in death all just fantasies bro
Uzbekistan capital name is Samarkand means they are not tribal before converted to Islam…Hinduism forgot or destroyed by roman and Muslims in other countries
@@navminhas412 You told: "people who brought some sankrit words to IVC stayed in uzbekistan for hundred of years before entering modern india. thats why there are these names outside india." Then how comes names like Singapore (Simhapura in Samskrit), Sentosa Island (Santhosha in Samskrit), etc. which are far East to India?
While archeology is great in establishing historical facts do not dismiss ancient texts that provide markers to historic events. Indians left lots of astronomical markers in their texts. There is a general attitude of delegating this to the realm of romanticism
No chance, they don't worship hindu gods, nor they talked about mahabhart and ramayana,,,all of Hinduism gods were created during early Vedic period(1500bc) by priestly class to rule others.
Chitrod Gujarat is the first area of civilisation Harappa Empire better known as the Bhagwan MangalDev Chitroda Empire as it evolved with each of my Empires including Devs to Bhagwans. The world cannot question Indian Hindus ever as they would seem stupid. 🤴🏽🕉🔺➕
"The British turned the Dravidians and Aryans against each other" LOL stop blaming the British for everything. People don't need excuses to dislike each other. The Dravidian Aryan divide is as old as the Vedas.
Both have the same history mf, Ancient Tamil grammar text Aggatiyam was written by Rishi Agasthya, who is also a celebrated author of several Rig Vedic hymns, it's indeed the Brits who started this fight
No that's not true it was always the north never wanted to let the credits go to southern civilisations because of the color northern scholars were constantly undermined the Southern civilisations... Kept influencing the Britishers as if everything were started from up north and they are the dominant race the southern society was described as living with primitive technology... How biased... Now trying to claim everything as Indian... But for the fact the Harappan civilization was following a non Aryan and more likely to be Dravidian civilization... Because these were the terms that existed and were used back then... These words were said by John Marshall.., Funny fellas...😅😅
The subcontinent has produced 100s of languages, different forms of fine arts from every region of the country with deep level of intricacy, extremely complex and highly evolved classical raaga music (only culture in the world that has identified not 7, not 12 but 22 notes/shrutis), innumerable types of musical instruments, complex designing of fabrics (multiple different styles of fabric art in different regions of the country), and highly evolved numerous cuisines with complicated methods of cooking in different regions of the world. When the world is just awakening to the health and environmental benefits to veganism and still have very rudimentary vegeterian food, our subcontinent adopted and has developed a highly evolved vegeterian diet, growing and cooking vegetables, and using spices that most other countries in the world have not even seen before. This degree of evolution in all different domains of culture and life, may be enough anecdotal evidence to support the theory that ours is probably the oldest civilization and culture in the world.
According to a genetic study it would seem that the people who started the Vedic culture and beliefs they came when Indus Valley Civilization was almost vanished. Not a complete proof of anything but definitely something to be noted
Im 4th generation Indian South African... I may look Indian but that where it ends... As she says culture is evolving... My outlook to life is not Indian but African.
Culture is amalgam of various aspect. Food, Dress, Music, Art, Literature style etc etc. Now a days we have adopted all western Chines Food, Dress, Music except Caste System, which is original to India.
Saraswati is called Haraxvati in Afghanistan & Saraswati is now called Ghaghar Hakkra river system. Saraswati was considered a minor tributary of the Haraxvati in Afghanistan. Harappan civilization sites are found all over India from Udhampur in J&K , Sinauli, Daimabad, Inamgaon, several places in Karnatak , Keezhadi in TN etc. All these sites vanished with the onset of Rig Vedic civilizations. The documentary series from Indus to Vaigai clarifies many things as well as the books written by Dr R. Balakrishnan
That's what she said. Very less is talked about contemporary cultures apart from Indus Valley, it should be taught and given the due importance... Indian Govt is at wrong here trying to hide the Keezhadi site excavation and history.
The Joe Rogan episode that Ranveer vi is mentioning here is perhaps none other than the "Joe Rogan Bob Lazar podcast", it's from 2017, back before the Spotify deal. Good to see Ranveer vi is interested in all the UFO talk. I hope he is also subbed to Curt Jaimungal's RUclips channel, the best UFO interview platform ever, big names like George Knapp, Jeremy Corbell, Steven Greer (this guy is a bit too dramatic) and many other podcasts and Jai asks some amazing questions which lends some great insights into the topic. The best UFO podcasts he has ever done are with Luis Elizondo, freakin loved it.
Indus valley civilization and its culture is the native culture of Indians...it is the base for India.. Hinduism came into existence when mughals arrived and gave word hindu..
it comes from persia. the indus valley civilization. fire worship etc. Indus valley people ate meat. this is proven through the pottery DNA that meat was consumed. asura and deva etc all persian stuff.
timid, incompetent archeology dept. of india not explored: 1. temples of tajmahal, kutubminar, 2. ellora kailasa mandir 3. carbon dating of gyanwapi 4. dwaraka 5. mathura temple inside mosque 6. carvings , carbon dating of thousands of temples wrapped as superficial mosque 7 carvings of thousands of temples which praveen mohan explored and apologetic tries to slow poision that sanatan civilization is not the greatest.
This is from a different video i saw long back. There are multiple path to find history. 1) archeology 2) language development. A language develops from simpler to complex over time. Then how come sanskrit it's so complicated and so well-designed, if its that old. It takes many years to get to that level of complexity. 3) tracking DNA to find ancestral flow. I think there are research on that line too
@@dravidian667 no one uses sanskrit because it is tough and also the northern india was destroyed many time but this language will rise again aur haan tamil is not older than sanskrit either it is after according to vedas or is a parallel language may be they are two language in ancient time one for common communication while other for providing knowledge
The the way, the book was published on 2002. I think it will help this debate. She said she was reading for PhD. I sincerely believe the book will throw light on what she is studying
Sanatan hi satya hain.. Dinosaurs bhi sanatani the. Australopithecus and megalodon ek saath hanuman chalisa padhe the under pacific ocean.. There are proves.. 😂😂 Yeast bhi ram nam gaake fermentation karata hain.. Pata nahi tha? Chi.. Sacche hindu nahi ho tum.. 😂
She is speaking NCERT history book which we all read. She needs to update herself. Please visit ancient temples to know how technically advanced we were. Please refer to Saraswati civilization.
Thank you for wasting my time. The video is not at all related to the actual Question or name you are giving to the video. The word Hinduism is not even used once in the entire video. Shame on you for using fake names for video for getting some views.
She is soooo cute. Her way of talking is sooo cute.. I’m seeing the video for her 🥰 Actually I stated watching for the content then I ended up seeing her only 😁
See what Disha did there, around 14:20 mark. She kept her scientific integrity by not confirming Abhijit's nationalistic out-of-India schtick. Credit to her!
Indus script has been successfully deciphered in the paper 'Deciphering Indus script as a Cryptogram by Yajnadevam' and he explains the whole decipherment in a video presentation given to Sangam talks on RUclips. His decipherment shows the Indus seals and other artifacts are used to write a form of Sanskrit and the symbols used there are pre-cursor of Brahmi script ( from which today's Hindi, Tamil and other North Indian scripts are derived. Kannada and Telugu have their own modern script but before that they might've used Brahmi too ) Most importantly, there are so many Vedic references like Ravi, Varuna, Agni etc... in Indus seals and writings.
Till now no one deciphered Indus valley script.🤣🤣🤣 So called claims of "deciphered Indus script" are mostly made pseudoscience peddlers or right wing hindutva scientists
Ask her why the language system/script of Indus valley civilization match more to south Indian or so called Dravidian languages ??And why certain traditions match to certain local tribes staying in Pakistan n Iran ??
Indus valley scripts nowhere match the Dravidian languages, they match with no language, that's the reason nobody has been able to understand it, rather should we ask why we find the Pashupatinath seal? Why we find the Teracotta of Mother Godess? Why we find Swastika in Indus valley civilization excavations?
@atharvamishra2813 no where it is said that dravid is a sanskrit word. It is derivation of dravidam(sorry for spelling error), which has been studied to be older than sanskrit.
You called this woman an archeologist!!. What she said is nothing new, all can be found in ncert history syllabus. She didn't even answer to the topic.
I had my DNA tested through NatGeo Genome project and as per the result like all humans my ancestors left Africa 60,000 years back, found their way to middle east and to Central Asia and then migrated down to an area what is current day Pakistan and from there they finally settled in Southern part of India, current day Karnataka. One thing happened when they arrived in current day Pakistan the migration forked into 2 directions. One going towards eastern India and other western India. Our ancestors might have been the part of the group which went on the west coast.
@@VSM101 absolutely right. We don’t know what that area was called say 5000 years back. That’s why most of us refer it as current day Pakistan. I will underline the words “current day “ to Indicate that it didn’t exist prior to 14th of August 1947
@@mlg1279 Science unlike faith is constantly changing based on new inventions and evidence. One thing about science is, it is peer reviewed and there should be acceptance by at least 99% of them. This is what gives the credibility to Scientific inventions or findings.
@@kirchunetwork1986 I don't 'believe' anything. I go by facts. And science isn't advanced enough for u to know where ur ancestors originated or travelled to.
Please read this book: The Civilizations of Africa: A History to 1800 by Christopher Ehret. Farming did not start from Turkey. By the way, "Ehret" is White America, not African.
Level of a civilization is a Function of its AREA . Because a large area needs Better Communication ( Language , Script ) , Uniform Standards ( Weights and Measures , Brick sizes , Classification and NOMENCLATURE systems etc ) , Better Transport and Organized Government , Armies , Policing etc . SINDHU-SARASWATI Civilization was the Largest in Area .
Indus valley did not used to have any Hindu diety or temples as no such things/structures have been found in archeology Even tho there are hundereds of structures which have been excavated They didn't even had Sanskrit or hindi as their main language Written Sanskrit(in which most Hindu text is written)was not even found before 5th or 6th century ad,which was much later than INDUS VALLEY(3000BC) And there's no evidence to suggest that Hinduism is older than IVC(other than what's written in sacred texts) if there was a full fledged religion running parallel or nearby to Indus valley they would've made some contact but that doesn't seem to be the case
Like the civilizations, religion, here Hinduism, itself evolves. We have added newer deities, while let go old-time deities from our daily practiced pantheon. We developed more time-relevant rituals. Animal sacrifice of the hunter tribes got replaced with panchagavyam + navadhanyam as the primary civilization became more lacto-vegetarian agriculturist. So Hinduism as we see it today didn’t exist even 1000 years ago in the same form. Hinduism is a constant flow, like a River, what started with Sindhu-Saraswati has come a long way to today’s new age sampradayas, e.g. Swaminarayan, Vedantic Order of Ramakrishna Paramhansa, Amma Amritananamayi, Sri Sri’s Art of Life, Sadhguru’s Isha Foundation, Prabhupada’s Iskcon and so on. That’s all Hinduism. So there is no scope of IVC (SSC) first or Hinduism first debate. Civilization and religion always go hand in hand.
It is difficult to follow her. I am sure she is an expert at her subject but she is not coherent enough and lacks clarity but thanks for this conversation.
You have to understand the history of subcontinent. Indus Valley civilisation was formed by union of middle eastern farmers and Indian hunter gatherers. Then came Aryans, who united with Middle East+Indian hunter gatherer to form ANI(Ancestral North Indian) Some IVC settlers+ANI moved South, where they further mixed with local hunter gathers. This formed ASI(Ancestral South Indian)
Link to our blog - beerbiceps.com/indian-archaeologist-shares-vedic-truths-breaks-aryan-theory/
this woman is a marxist, you know it when she has to redefine every term for you.
I enjoy this channel
The divide and rule you mentioned is actually implemented or trying to implement by the Christian churches in the south in order to make Hindus of the south feel insecure about their identity so they can feel distanced from Hinduism thus making things easy for the churches to convert them. Now the jihadis are also competing with them to cut and separate the south away from India. China, Islamist countries and many western countries are funding them.
Hinduism is since stone age.
More traditions kept on adding time to time, but oldest ones are from stone age.
American here, I absolutely adore these types of conversations especially about ancient civilizations and the subject has so much depth!
To indian it is still existent
Hey gangu😂
These guys just push fake news, funded by RSS
❣️
Sir you Read Journey of civilization indus to vaigai please Read this book Lot evidence available
Just finished watching the original podcast, now watching this again. I can’t get enough of these podcasts! Love your content Ranveer ❤
Wish i had done archaeology!! This looks coolest job of this era!!
Definitely.
Lucky🥺
It's not though. People in archeological community are very stiff & narrow minded
@@sumuqh that's obvious na? That's their profession to be narrow minded! She did mention somewhere I think. She wants to believe the childhood stories but they have be narrow minded!
Paisa nahi milta
Ambedkar Nagar district in UP agriculture dates backs to 7500BCE.
Prof. Shinde's Paper on Rakhigarh Skeleton proofs that Agriculture Develops in India Independently.
it's sad there is not much excavation and archaeology work happening in Pakistan, which consists of the largest ever area of the Indus Valley Civilization from Balochistan to Harappa to Swat to Thar. There should be Pak-India archaeological collaboration on this.
Research collaboration would be great but until the radical mindset is overcome, it's highly impossible.
nature's decision,, should not be tampered by zealots
Couldn’t agree more
Better leave it all buried. Radical Islamists would destroy anything uncovered. Just like they did to Afghanistan.
Ind-Pak collaboration. Lol no thank you
2:24....i loved when he Sayed Akhand Bharat area.....
Future 10 countries separate india will come Kashmir,Bengal ,Punjab,marathi,
telugu states,Tamil
@@freegood2103 cry . Cope harder .
@@debaprasad9379 world know who are crying now🌚
@@Bharatverse308 peaceful 🙂
@@freegood2103 marathi from Maharashtra... Proud to be an Indian 🇮🇳❤️
Hinduism is eternal constantly evolving n growing from time immemorial
Hinduism is name given by Persians for Sindhus
For how many years?
Time immemorial lmao 🤣
@@amrut13 sanatan dharma
@@amrut13 Hindu comes from HImalaya and siNDU ocean (Indian Ocean) - word Hindu represents people living between these two boundaries. It is used in our sacred texts, much before Persian used the term.
I liked the difference you put between civilization and culture.
Loved the part where he actually talked about hinduism and indus vally civilization
😂😂
Request to all Hindus to wear a Raksha Dhaga to show unity and respect to our ancestors.
@@mannysmandatories5595 Think long and hard what's the use of an Army doing a parade..in the end all they do is walk. Traditions are a way to live a disciplined life. As for why?? I really don't know its significance but even without it..aah why am i telling you this it feels like you aren't a seeker. Nothing i say will get to you unless someone walks on water in front of you.
@@mannysmandatories5595 okay first following a tradition isn't an offense. Ofcoarse there is a reason just google it. But at the same time I don't intend you to change your mind because even with the reason you are not wearing it anyway. oh and btw i have already written my reason of doing so in the original comment. For me that much is enough but for you..i guess you want to know who came first a chicken or an egg??
You mean Africans?
The part that Ranveer mentioned about people in Tamil Nadu still harbour the divisive narrative of Aryan-Invasion theory, was playing out yesterday, when in office I had interesting discussion (where I didn't allow it to heat up into argument), with a Tamilian spewing out all kinds of Periyarist, Colonial, Leftist-Sickular non-sense, going to an extent that before Britishers India as a nation didn't exist & he considers Tamil as a Nation, not India as a nation even now (except for constitution part).
As a Tamil I apologize for those troglodytes
@@linneshwharparameswaran6147 You don't have to apologise on anyone's behalf. I'm "a realist & an optimist" and I know there are still more sane Tamilians than insane ones in Tamil Nadu & elsewhere.
But I wouldn't say the same thing for Keralites (I am one too) and for Bengalis. I mean in Kerala & Bengal, the proportionality of sane : insane is already less than 1.0.
@@linneshwharparameswaran6147 you don't need to apologize bro.....
It's a plan of politician,,,,,,,for win election......
We are one,,,, we North Indian love every regional language,,, gujrati, Punjabi, tamil, telgu.....
But I don't know why Tamil hate sanskrit
somethings he said are true
@@jklmnop3511 I certainly don't. Tbh doesn't really matter which is older. Both are older than ALL other languages. India could use both to levy soft power on an international stage
Key: We're ONE OF THE oldest NOT THE OLDEST civilizations. A lot of us seem to forget it
We are oldest....we still don't know yet...may be 100 years from now world will know....but for now you and me would still be arguing
@Manojshinde7 Nubia and Egypt were both older than Harappa. But it wasn’t that far off age wise.
We are indeed the oldest "living" civilisation. There might have been older civilisations to ours but they are all extinct long ago.
@@Manojshinde7it might be because a large portion of Indus civilisation is in Pakistan and Afghanistan. And they couldn’t care less about history and they don’t have money in reality as well to conduct a deep search.
The Mesopotamian civilization is the oldest civilization. Other civilizations, including the Indus Valley civilization, emerged later than the Mesopotamian civilization, but all the ancient civilizations emerged almost simultaneously, one after another. Therefore, the Indus Valley civilization is one of the oldest civilizations in the world and has equal importance in the history of ancient civilizations around the world, along with the others.
Homo Sapient migration into India was around 80,000 years ago,
BEFORE the Toba Volcano eruption around 75,000 years ago.
The question of Hinduism / Vedas vs IVC - which came first has NOT been answered.
I also noticed that they did not answer the question in the title. Click bait?
The main question actually which should be answerd. That is brahmic religion is older or indus valley
@@utkarshsrivastava5576
'IVC' is the Vedic Civilization.
There is nothing called Brahmic Religion.
@@DiatomAlgae and whatever we are following is brahmic religion that is not hindu nor sanatan because in our so called holy books it is nowhere mentioned that it is himdu or sanatan it was created by brahmans to rule on other people thats ehy they have kept themselves on top of other people and aslo they decided that what they will do
@@utkarshsrivastava5576
Even Vedas and Upanishads were composed by Brahmins
This is the best explanation of culture.
08:45 The Saraswathi river system which "we call it as" gaghar hakra... 😂😂... Super
OMG she is so cute. OOpsey she is married.
Love your podcasts, very interesting and educational discussions. I had visited the site at Dholaveera three times at different times and also at Lothal, but to my disappointment didn't see much excavations carried out from the first to the last visit. The museum at Lothal was having a good collection, the museum at Dholaveera was added much later. Another sad point was I came to know when I asked a guide why isn't much displayed there? The answer was most is taken to the Delhi museum. I also visited the Delhi museum and found a very small section on display, disappointed again. ❤😢👍
Lovely discussion.Enjoyed thoroughly.All the support from Kolkata
You need to get Dr Raj Vedam and Vedveer Arya to give you a phenomenal understanding of Indian civilizational history. As of today we can scientifically prove back to 15-17000 BCE.
Also Nilesh Oak
What "civilisation" when there is not even agriculture? Of course there was some cultures emerging 17000BCE also, but not "civilisation". That is a complete different thing.
Not possible...no civilisation existed more than 5000 years ago..
@@kaamdev810 That’s a Judeo-Christian lie & propaganda
@@thechroniclesofsher7118 no thats reality....scientifically proven...
Please refer to Kizhadi (Kiladi) excavation near madurai going on in tamilnadu. Any civilization will extinct and a new civilization will flourish. So no civilization or no religion is superior to others. Still north Indians address south indians as madrassi, also north east people as Chinese instead of calling it by state they belong, hence still aryan and Dravidan theory prevails. First accept South Indians as Indians and all languages equal then others will also accept the same towards North.
Why do you say North, every state in Bharat has its own culture and food habits don't call North, South and East.
@@rajeshbobba3851We can't erase the directions of our states where they are in our country (East, West North, South), and can't rename them like we rename many towns and places.
@@rajvkl DNT cluster state's as per location south and north, every state is different in Food, language and culture and traditions.
@@rajeshbobba3851 I am not doing on my own, as our union government has segregated the country on 6 zones or regions namely North Zone, South Zone, East Zone, West Zone, Central Zone and North East Zone. All these zones include our 28 states and 8 union territories.
@@rajvkl THESE ARE TIME ZONES WHICH DEPEND ON LATTITUDE AND LONGITUDE WHICH ARE ZONAL AND HENCE THIS SEGREGATION. BUT WHY DO YOU USE IT ?
We do not want to say and romancize that our country was the biggest and oldest .... But it's a fact .. reading it as a fact ,like a fact (nothing to be proud of ) and use it as a tool to make us the BEST civilization right now . 🙏 Har har mahadev
😁😁😁
It's not fact at all😂.
@@nowwhat6716 Then please enlighten us with facts?
This is what romanticizing means. This is the first video of this guy I felt was level-headed because it isn't stroking the Hinduism ego that our people have. Of course such evidence based video will have people commenting about how we are the greatest no matter what.
@@dewansharma658 Mesopotamian civilization is generally thought to be the oldest civilization.
Indus valley and ancient Egyptian is considered to be the next and each developed around the same time
What a misleading title. No mention of Hinduism in the video. Stop click baiting man!
Exactly what I thought!
@@christianfrommuslim christianfrommuslim with Love, welcome to Hinduism 🌹
@@akashds6666 In what way?
@@christianfrommuslim Choose the way by yourself. But welcome for a constructive purpose
I think you don't know about Jainism 🗿
i am in luv with this girl.. her voice.. how she sounds
Teri bhabhi hai wo
No mention of Rakhigadi site, it older than Harappa.
May be she is not updated
TRUE
What a smart and beautiful woman!!! I am moving to Indiaaaaa!!! ❤
What about Tamil Nadu where found same material which was found in harrapan civilizations
RANVEER: BUT WHEN DID THE YETI COME?
Please also make video about findings at rakhigarhi, bandavgarh,sandhai, bhirrana, vadakapattu, keezhadi, adichanallur, poompuhar.
Sanatan is cyclic and timeless..... Its way older..... Hinduism is a name given.....
The title question was not answered. How do viewers vote on this question?
Hinduism or Harappan Civilization first?
Why does it matter?
I think it is good that the Harappan Civilization does not display the angry or erotic cartoon gods that we see so frequently in Hindu temples.
@@christianfrommuslimit's not vedic civilization there are lot evidence to prove this
@christianfommuslim cartoon gods, alright lol. Shows your ignorance.
@@Voiddrifter725 Ignorance of what? I speak from experience. Some cities and towns in Eastern India have several temples in every block, each with gods painted like cartoons, often angrily staring down at us.
But as Acts 17 of the Bible says, "The God who made heaven and earth does not live in temples made by people."
@@christianfrommuslimyou are stuck with the blank and white image of a god or creator. This fantasy you have about god who were a white robe and not believing in death all just fantasies bro
Uzbekistan capital name is Samarkand means they are not tribal before converted to Islam…Hinduism forgot or destroyed by roman and Muslims in other countries
@@navminhas412 Why only "some" words? For your convenience of explanation?
@@navminhas412 Is it true about other languages too?
@@navminhas412 You told: "people who brought some sankrit words to IVC stayed in uzbekistan for hundred of years before entering modern india. thats why there are these names outside india." Then how comes names like Singapore (Simhapura in Samskrit), Sentosa Island (Santhosha in Samskrit), etc. which are far East to India?
@@satheeshprabhu2577 He follows Aryan invasion theory.
Believe in European superiority and still a slave by mindset.
While archeology is great in establishing historical facts do not dismiss ancient texts that provide markers to historic events. Indians left lots of astronomical markers in their texts. There is a general attitude of delegating this to the realm of romanticism
Indus valley civilization follow non vedic Hinduism 🕉️ for there culture and faith 😊 they are hindus 🕉 and shiv bhakts 😊😊😊
No chance, they don't worship hindu gods, nor they talked about mahabhart and ramayana,,,all of Hinduism gods were created during early Vedic period(1500bc) by priestly class to rule others.
Chitrod Gujarat is the first area of civilisation Harappa Empire better known as the Bhagwan MangalDev Chitroda Empire as it evolved with each of my Empires including Devs to Bhagwans. The world cannot question Indian Hindus ever as they would seem stupid. 🤴🏽🕉🔺➕
What do you mean by Indian Hindus?
@@shivinunitholi2493 There are non-Indian Hindus also......like Malaysia, Singapore or Cambodia, etc...
@@satheeshprabhu2577 How come "Indian Hindus" are superior or wiser than Hindus living abroad?
@@shivinunitholi2493 I didn't say that. For being superior or wiser, there are other clsses who claim so. (For example, Whites over Blacks, etc.)
"The British turned the Dravidians and Aryans against each other" LOL stop blaming the British for everything. People don't need excuses to dislike each other. The Dravidian Aryan divide is as old as the Vedas.
Both have the same history mf, Ancient Tamil grammar text Aggatiyam was written by Rishi Agasthya, who is also a celebrated author of several Rig Vedic hymns, it's indeed the Brits who started this fight
No that's not true it was always the north never wanted to let the credits go to southern civilisations because of the color northern scholars were constantly undermined the Southern civilisations... Kept influencing the Britishers as if everything were started from up north and they are the dominant race the southern society was described as living with primitive technology... How biased... Now trying to claim everything as Indian... But for the fact the Harappan civilization was following a non Aryan and more likely to be Dravidian civilization... Because these were the terms that existed and were used back then... These words were said by John Marshall..,
Funny fellas...😅😅
The subcontinent has produced 100s of languages, different forms of fine arts from every region of the country with deep level of intricacy, extremely complex and highly evolved classical raaga music (only culture in the world that has identified not 7, not 12 but 22 notes/shrutis), innumerable types of musical instruments, complex designing of fabrics (multiple different styles of fabric art in different regions of the country), and highly evolved numerous cuisines with complicated methods of cooking in different regions of the world. When the world is just awakening to the health and environmental benefits to veganism and still have very rudimentary vegeterian food, our subcontinent adopted and has developed a highly evolved vegeterian diet, growing and cooking vegetables, and using spices that most other countries in the world have not even seen before. This degree of evolution in all different domains of culture and life, may be enough anecdotal evidence to support the theory that ours is probably the oldest civilization and culture in the world.
I love ranveer podcast
*_Sanatana dharma named as hinduism is eternal, perpetual_* ..
According to a genetic study it would seem that the people who started the Vedic culture and beliefs they came when Indus Valley Civilization was almost vanished. Not a complete proof of anything but definitely something to be noted
Im 4th generation Indian South African... I may look Indian but that where it ends... As she says culture is evolving... My outlook to life is not Indian but African.
If you go at last every human will link to each other scientific theory are incomplete they just say all are come from Africa
Culture is amalgam of various aspect. Food, Dress, Music, Art, Literature style etc etc. Now a days we have adopted all western Chines Food, Dress, Music except Caste System, which is original to India.
Sadly
Saraswati is called Haraxvati in Afghanistan & Saraswati is now called Ghaghar Hakkra river system. Saraswati was considered a minor tributary of the Haraxvati in Afghanistan. Harappan civilization sites are found all over India from Udhampur in J&K , Sinauli, Daimabad, Inamgaon, several places in Karnatak , Keezhadi in TN etc. All these sites vanished with the onset of Rig Vedic civilizations.
The documentary series from Indus to Vaigai clarifies many things as well as the books written by Dr R. Balakrishnan
Country is diverse and widespread that's why today china is so worried.
We all have to save our culture too with fast moving time.
Ranveer please stop interrupting guests
Also , what is anchestry ?
Did she mean ancestry? Or is it a word ?
Ancestry. She meant ancestry. Her accent makes it sound like “anchestry”.
@@JohnLee-vg3ui ok
3:01, prehistoric humans coming of Africa into India. Wow, that's African invasion theory right there
It's good, but When you talk about Archeology where is "Keezhadi" ?
That's what she said. Very less is talked about contemporary cultures apart from Indus Valley, it should be taught and given the due importance... Indian Govt is at wrong here trying to hide the Keezhadi site excavation and history.
Why ended so prematurely??? Not everyone is on Spotify... Please publish full episode also on RUclips, thank you.
Its on youtube
Arya is NOT A RACE !!!
People should be watching these type of contest its better than scrolling through insta reels
Its ONLY as old as 3000 bce?
Only?
Thats what happens when you are fed fake numbers from childhood. Lakho karodo se niche sab kuch only lagta hai
The Joe Rogan episode that Ranveer vi is mentioning here is perhaps none other than the "Joe Rogan Bob Lazar podcast", it's from 2017, back before the Spotify deal.
Good to see Ranveer vi is interested in all the UFO talk. I hope he is also subbed to Curt Jaimungal's RUclips channel, the best UFO interview platform ever, big names like George Knapp, Jeremy Corbell, Steven Greer (this guy is a bit too dramatic) and many other podcasts and Jai asks some amazing questions which lends some great insights into the topic.
The best UFO podcasts he has ever done are with Luis Elizondo, freakin loved it.
Har Har Mahadev
Jay Sanatana Dharma....
Misleading Caption
Very good conversation.
*Sanatan Dharma was always there and always will be there no matter if humans exist to follow it or not It's a Dhram of multiverse!*
Sanatan Dharm was also practised by Homo Erectus? ☠️
😅
@@AbhishekVerma-ks4vw yoga postures me seals mili hai
😂😂😂
Indus valley civilization and its culture is the native culture of Indians...it is the base for India.. Hinduism came into existence when mughals arrived and gave word hindu..
Indus valley civilization was named hindu later. So there is no difference in indus valley and hinduism.
it comes from persia. the indus valley civilization. fire worship etc. Indus valley people ate meat. this is proven through the pottery DNA that meat was consumed. asura and deva etc all persian stuff.
timid, incompetent archeology dept. of india not explored:
1. temples of tajmahal, kutubminar,
2. ellora kailasa mandir
3. carbon dating of gyanwapi
4. dwaraka
5. mathura temple inside mosque
6. carvings , carbon dating of thousands of temples wrapped as superficial mosque
7 carvings of thousands of temples which praveen mohan explored
and apologetic tries to slow poision that sanatan civilization is not the greatest.
The place i was born in, Sindh Pakistan, the Ghakar hakra river was (as they mentioned) only a few kilometers away.
This is from a different video i saw long back.
There are multiple path to find history.
1) archeology
2) language development. A language develops from simpler to complex over time. Then how come sanskrit it's so complicated and so well-designed, if its that old. It takes many years to get to that level of complexity.
3) tracking DNA to find ancestral flow. I think there are research on that line too
Don’t be foolish there are many languages older than Sanskrit
@@dravidian667 nope there are not
Sanskrit the oldest than tamil and than other languages
@@pragyankhare1223 first get educated
@@dravidian667 i think the one who should acquire knowledge is you
@@dravidian667 no one uses sanskrit because it is tough and also the northern india was destroyed many time but this language will rise again aur haan tamil is not older than sanskrit either it is after according to vedas or is a parallel language may be they are two language in ancient time one for common communication while other for providing knowledge
She is really so cute and so beautiful.
The the way, the book was published on 2002. I think it will help this debate. She said she was reading for PhD. I sincerely believe the book will throw light on what she is studying
Indus civilization was a Buddhist civilization
Remind me again when Buddha was born and when the Indus valley civilization disappeared😂
@@fishyfish6510and when Hinduism started when shavism vashnavism shaktism started ?
@@fishyfish6510 jis budhdh ki baat kar rahe ho ..wo last wale the....
@@fishyfish6510 haddappa me stupa h
Sanatan hi satya hain..
Dinosaurs bhi sanatani the. Australopithecus and megalodon ek saath hanuman chalisa padhe the under pacific ocean.. There are proves.. 😂😂
Yeast bhi ram nam gaake fermentation karata hain.. Pata nahi tha? Chi.. Sacche hindu nahi ho tum.. 😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂 ye log nhi sudrenge Bhai
lovely discussion
She is speaking NCERT history book which we all read.
She needs to update herself.
Please visit ancient temples to know how technically advanced we were. Please refer to Saraswati civilization.
🤦♂️ RIP anthropology
We have read but nit understood because it is there in class 5 or 6 that time we used to ratta maring so
I personally used to do it
Thank you for wasting my time. The video is not at all related to the actual Question or name you are giving to the video. The word Hinduism is not even used once in the entire video. Shame on you for using fake names for video for getting some views.
She is soooo cute. Her way of talking is sooo cute.. I’m seeing the video for her 🥰
Actually I stated watching for the content then I ended up seeing her only 😁
We r men of culture 😛
Civilisation and religion are different.
watched just because she is damn beUTIFUL
See what Disha did there, around 14:20 mark. She kept her scientific integrity by not confirming Abhijit's nationalistic out-of-India schtick. Credit to her!
Ice age was in temperate zone not in tropical zone,that leads to more species in tropics
According to evolution in ncert and Campbell
Akhand bharat 🚩🚩🚩
Indus script has been successfully deciphered in the paper 'Deciphering Indus script as a Cryptogram by Yajnadevam' and he explains the whole decipherment in a video presentation given to Sangam talks on RUclips. His decipherment shows the Indus seals and other artifacts are used to write a form of Sanskrit and the symbols used there are pre-cursor of Brahmi script ( from which today's Hindi, Tamil and other North Indian scripts are derived. Kannada and Telugu have their own modern script but before that they might've used Brahmi too )
Most importantly, there are so many Vedic references like Ravi, Varuna, Agni etc... in Indus seals and writings.
Totally wrong information u got
Sanskrit has nothing to do here with indus script
@@somedeepbarat9852 go through the paper I mentioned!
Till now no one deciphered Indus valley script.🤣🤣🤣 So called claims of "deciphered Indus script" are mostly made pseudoscience peddlers or right wing hindutva scientists
@@chethan93 search that paper.... totally misleading information and horrible...
I don't know how did u believe that?
You can't escape easily from talking on Aryans history ..
Ask her why the language system/script of Indus valley civilization match more to south Indian or so called Dravidian languages ??And why certain traditions match to certain local tribes staying in Pakistan n Iran ??
Just saying word dravid itself is Sanskrit it means a place covered by oceans from 3 sides adi shankaracharya used it first💀
Indus valley scripts nowhere match the Dravidian languages, they match with no language, that's the reason nobody has been able to understand it, rather should we ask why we find the Pashupatinath seal? Why we find the Teracotta of Mother Godess? Why we find Swastika in Indus valley civilization excavations?
@atharvamishra2813 no where it is said that dravid is a sanskrit word. It is derivation of dravidam(sorry for spelling error), which has been studied to be older than sanskrit.
Any proof?@@shreyaanghosh
Indus Valley civilisation not religion dominant.
You called this woman an archeologist!!. What she said is nothing new, all can be found in ncert history syllabus. She didn't even answer to the topic.
She is not updated
Theres no similarity between Indus and Hindu Culture. Worries me a bit.
Please invite KK Muhammad ji on Archeology and excavation
Madan Gowri treated as a expert about Tamil History and culture and his view is provided as evidence to a “science” conversation- Priceless 😂
I had my DNA tested through NatGeo Genome project and as per the result like all humans my ancestors left Africa 60,000 years back, found their way to middle east and to Central Asia and then migrated down to an area what is current day Pakistan and from there they finally settled in Southern part of India, current day Karnataka. One thing happened when they arrived in current day Pakistan the migration forked into 2 directions. One going towards eastern India and other western India. Our ancestors might have been the part of the group which went on the west coast.
@@VSM101 absolutely right. We don’t know what that area was called say 5000 years back. That’s why most of us refer it as current day Pakistan. I will underline the words “current day “ to Indicate that it didn’t exist prior to 14th of August 1947
That's what they are telling u... We will not know if that really was the case
@@mlg1279 Science unlike faith is constantly changing based on new inventions and evidence. One thing about science is, it is peer reviewed and there should be acceptance by at least 99% of them. This is what gives the credibility to Scientific inventions or findings.
@@mlg1279 it saved millions. You need to believe in science to accept this fact. Like you there are millions who deny and continue to question
@@kirchunetwork1986 I don't 'believe' anything. I go by facts. And science isn't advanced enough for u to know where ur ancestors originated or travelled to.
I saw the first one minute and she’s not able to explain clearly what is civilisation… Should I watch it further??
Please read this book: The Civilizations of Africa: A History to 1800 by Christopher Ehret. Farming did not start from Turkey. By the way, "Ehret" is White America, not African.
One of your best episodes yet.
India, Industan , Indu 🪷🕉️
Level of a civilization is a Function of its AREA . Because a large area needs Better Communication ( Language , Script ) , Uniform Standards ( Weights and Measures , Brick sizes , Classification and NOMENCLATURE systems etc ) , Better Transport and Organized Government , Armies , Policing etc . SINDHU-SARASWATI Civilization was the Largest in Area .
Im having a very hard time understanding , so who came first? Hinduism’s or the indus civilization?
Indus valley did not used to have any Hindu diety or temples as no such things/structures have been found in archeology
Even tho there are hundereds of structures which have been excavated
They didn't even had Sanskrit or hindi as their main language
Written Sanskrit(in which most Hindu text is written)was not even found before 5th or 6th century ad,which was much later than INDUS VALLEY(3000BC)
And there's no evidence to suggest that Hinduism is older than IVC(other than what's written in sacred texts) if there was a full fledged religion running parallel or nearby to Indus valley they would've made some contact but that doesn't seem to be the case
@@DrSiddharthVerma well said!
Rig Veda alone was written in 1500bce in Sanskrit. @@DrSiddharthVerma
no every Bharat civilization have archeology evidence because that civilization some time covered by Maya Devi to protect Vedas from Melechas persons
Blunt religeous hypocricy !
Where can I watch the whole podcast?
The fun fact is there is no word called " hinduism " in inscription
@सप्तसिन्धवः Darius is just Dara as we know it.
Sanatan Dharma is mentioned in inscriptions over 4000 years ago
Very Very interesting Podcast 👌🙌👏
Like the civilizations, religion, here Hinduism, itself evolves. We have added newer deities, while let go old-time deities from our daily practiced pantheon. We developed more time-relevant rituals. Animal sacrifice of the hunter tribes got replaced with panchagavyam + navadhanyam as the primary civilization became more lacto-vegetarian agriculturist. So Hinduism as we see it today didn’t exist even 1000 years ago in the same form. Hinduism is a constant flow, like a River, what started with Sindhu-Saraswati has come a long way to today’s new age sampradayas, e.g. Swaminarayan, Vedantic Order of Ramakrishna Paramhansa, Amma Amritananamayi, Sri Sri’s Art of Life, Sadhguru’s Isha Foundation, Prabhupada’s Iskcon and so on. That’s all Hinduism. So there is no scope of IVC (SSC) first or Hinduism first debate. Civilization and religion always go hand in hand.
Saraswati completly disappeared at 2000bce so plz keep correct facts..
It is difficult to follow her. I am sure she is an expert at her subject but she is not coherent enough and lacks clarity but thanks for this conversation.
So is it Indus Valley Civilization, Aryans, Saraswat Valley Civilization, Harrappan civilization who are the present day Indians descendants of???
You have to understand the history of subcontinent. Indus Valley civilisation was formed by union of middle eastern farmers and Indian hunter gatherers.
Then came Aryans, who united with Middle East+Indian hunter gatherer to form ANI(Ancestral North Indian)
Some IVC settlers+ANI moved South, where they further mixed with local hunter gathers. This formed ASI(Ancestral South Indian)
@@PaulAllen6304 ANI came around 35 0000 years ago...much later West Eurasians farmers settled in north West India..ASI were more ancient than ANI...
@@kaamdev810 ASI and ANI formed around the same time.
@@PaulAllen6304 thats not what the scientists found out in their study.. there was a gap of more than 10 thousand years..
@@kaamdev810 source?
Madan Gowri Himself is manipulator number one, who works for DMK whims..
brahmin traitors
Archeological podcasts are better than any other genres. This and kk Mohammed's made me your fan. Add indian Paleontogy aswell.
Indo-Aryans who migrated from the Anatolian Levanthian Caucases region or Indranians colonized that region soon after the glacial melt.