The legit only reason I think maybe it’s not is the sheer amount of fucking tailing missions. That’s easily the worst thing in the game and makes me go I’m not sure whereas without em I’d be like by far black flag
@@alarrim29574I came here to comment the same thing. Any time I want to roll up a new playthrough of Black Flag, I end up stopping after a while due to the sheer number of tailing missions. Give me a cutscene any day of the week over slowly folowing NPCs for minutes on end while they spout exposition.
3 for me. For a game as old as it is by today’s standards, the gameplay has held up nicer than the previous four and I find its themed and story more resonating the older I’ve gotten.
I’m currently playing black flag and 3 again might have to m play rogue and unity as well to play the whole kenway/cormac/arno story as they all tie into each other
Assassin's Creed II is the most replayable for me. I've finished it before and then immediately started a new game. Also, it's pretty easy to get the Codex Pages as long as you get them as the story progresses. Make sure to synchronize all of the viewpoints to clear up the map and you will not miss them. The real pain is getting all of the feathers. Lol
@@cherryblack420 Same here. ACII will forever have a special place in my heart. I know the controls feel a bit clunky to people, but I love it so much. I would spend so much time just testing out Ezio's jumping capabilities. I've jumped from very high places that would have dislocated Ezio's arms in real life. Most of my deaths in the stats are from me just jumping to my death. It's difficult to die in combat in ACII. Lol
For me it's AC Unity, especially with the new ACU fixes mod there are so many new ways to play the game and the game still looks and feels great in 2024
@@Bad_Dog_Gamingunfortunately you need to go into your game files and manually delete your save. You could also play each mission in order again individually with the Progress Tracker
@@Bad_Dog_Gaming As 602Tman said, you can delete save file. But you can also just remove it and save that file somewhere else, so when you want to open a certain save file of yours, you can just paste it again in the saves folder.
For me, it's AC Odyssey. I can't fully explain why, but it's become my "comfort game". I can replay the game over and over and still find stuff to do. There is just so much about it that keeps me coming back to it. I do think part of it is the amount of choice (even if it ultimately doesn't matter). I can do subtle things to make each play different, or different enough, to not make it boring. Also, I still cannot fathom why AC Valhalla didn't get a NG+. I don't understand why it couldn't have. Even Mirage got one. I might replay Valhalla if there was the option, but I'm not about to go back and start from the beginning again.
Well mirage was much shorter and was a linear story without character choice. But odyssey was a fairly large game and had character choice. I feel like Valhalla should’ve gotten new game plus. But a second playthrough on that game is brutal. Too much game for me
Ac odyssey is my favourite Singleplayergame. Love the music and 1 year ago a was in greece and some islands, i climbed on a little mountain, looked at the ocean, sun was shining und heard ac Odysssey music. Had 10 minutes goosebumps and tears in my eyes. This feelt so Unreal 💥
@@Ghostrunner7069 the same happend with me for AC 3. I played it 2times and the save files got deleted midway and now i am a pro for completeing the prologue of that game.
The mercenary system also adds replay value to Odyssey because being randomly generated for the most part you’re not facing the same line up of enemies who are out to kill you, and they can appear all over the map. Add in the option to kill sponsors of these mercenaries and you have an ongoing randomised experience that happens across the whole game.
I had the same with Odyssey. I've played it 4x (main story only) and always tried to get different endings like being an absolute idiot, killing everybody that I could, banging everybody that I could and so on. It was pretty fun to get to see the different results.
@@texmex0077 i didn't even finish my first play through because it left me so burnt out i took a year and a half off and had to restart to relearn the game
Ac odyssey is my favourite Singleplayergame. Love the music and 1 year ago a was in greece and some islands, i climbed on a little mountain, looked at the ocean, sun was shining und heard ac Odysssey music. Had 10 minutes goosebumps and tears in my eyes. This feelt so Unreal 💥
Idk why but there is always something about starting up a new game of Black Flag and feeling the freshness of arriving in Havana for the first time and wearing the unaltered Duncan Walpole fit which is UNMATCHED 😩
for me its ac unity, not only for the assasination missions but for the parkour and side quests especially, i would just run around rooftops for hrs without doing any missions and still never get bored god what i would do for an ac game like unity
Ac odyssey is my favourite Singleplayergame. Love the music and 1 year ago a was in greece and some islands, i climbed on a little mountain, looked at the ocean, sun was shining und heard ac Odysssey music. Had 10 minutes goosebumps and tears in my eyes. This feelt so Unreal 💥
@@mihaimercenarul7467if the game was so mediocre it wouldn’t have been nominated for goty alongside rdr2, gow4, spider-man ps4, and monster hunter world
From 2010-2017 i played AC trilogy and Black Flag a zillion times. In recent times i grew a liking towards Unity and Origins so been playing those a lot.
"Assassins creed 2 is a game you replay years and years later" one of my favorite games in elementary school, now I'm replaying it for the first time in my own apartment lol
@@Aaron-sx7zfyou are correct that the Templars in Rogue are believable and compelling, but you’re only focusing on half of the comment. The Brotherhood in Rogue is not compelling. There are major issues with the Brotherhood in other games such as AC1 and Mirage, but your character can and does fix those Brotherhoods by going after the one bad apple at or near the top. Rogue makes the brotherhood cartoonish, and instead of rooting out a bad actor, you burn the whole thing down.
For me, I love replaying every single Assassin's Creed mainly because I just love the games as a whole. I don't care that Valhalla is too long, i dont care that Black Flag has a lot of tailing missions, I don't care that Unity is basically a love story (😂jk). But each and every one of the games has something different and unique that makes me fall in love every time I play. I guess I'm just a simple casual gamer that loves stabbing NPCs 🤷🏾♂️
I don't think I have the standards of a casual gamer, but I also enjoy all of them lol. Gonna be doing a replay of the entire franchise (again) soon, just purchased Origins DLC's finally, and I still have yet to finish Valhalla (+DLCs) and play Mirage, feels like the right time with Mirage going on sale very often and with Shadows just around the corner 👀
For me it’s origins and odyssey but that’s because those are the first ac games I played and my favorites. I have 1500 hours on Origins, and more than 2,000 hours on Odyssey across 2 different accounts. After RDR2 and Far cry 6, Odyssey is my most played game. So for me definitely Odyssey.
Theres something about AC 2 that keeps me coming back even though its weak gameplay wise and very outdated. The story and music is so well done I can't get enough
I rarely replay open world games because they are just too big but I am replaying Origins and Odyssey in discovery mode and first person view, which offers a whole new perspective on the games. It's incredible the amount of close up detail you can see this way, particularly as you don't have to worry about being attacked!
For me it is Unity, it was the first AC I played and i was so impressed of the Parkour and since then i kinda fell in love with every AC. I just finished the Platin trophy for Unity and Syndicate and it was such an great experience playing these great games again. Love your Videos
In terms of getting right into the action, I’d argue Rogue. You learn how to assassinate, fight, sail, sneak and shoot in the course of a half hour and you’re more or less let out into the world. And you unlock more stuff as you go along at a quick pace, being a shorter game lets you get into the world and the side content much quicker. Good if you want a quick game to get into and play.
Yeah and the open world is pretty fun with the naval combat and the fact that it's black flag but up north. Plus you don't have to almost drown or get eaten by sharks to explore the ship wrecks
I love how much u Appreciate Odyssey first time i played on launch I didn't like it stopped early. years later literally 2023 I replayed it and damn the world is one of the best in games ever just that he have a classical Greek world in a game is meaningful to me.
I’d say rogue, it wastes no time bringing you to the open seas, relatively short story so no unnecessary tailing missions, and a decent story at that, enough collectibles to keep you busy, plus those interception missions, forts to take over, gang hideouts etc. easily the most accessible if you want to get right into it without a hefty tutorial. (Looking at you AC3)
Just finished AC Odyssey as Kassandra last week and gotta do a replay with Alexios today! Im not satisfied with my story result as I've had wrong choices in the Dialogue which resulted to Alexios and their mother dying! And I've enjoyed playing it for my 1st 115hrs. gotta do it shorter but better this time
I have severe game ADD (I can quickly hop from 1 game to another :) ) and never finished any AC game....but this video is so beautifully made that I'm thinking about installing Odyssey again and finally finishing it :) I had the most fun there of the AC games I own. P.S. I'm glad Hidden One mentioned The Witcher 3 too in this video, as that's my all time favorite RPG :)
Ive completed 2 runs and realized I still need more experience for mastery skills, on what play through did you finally Max out all skills? 3rd play through?
@@legaltowter9811 I played 3 Runs completely new and 2 were new game plus, so yeah 3 runs for enough xp to get all critical strike and chance mastery skills
Rouge is the most replayable imo. I think its the American trilogy perfected. It's short. It doesn't have as many god awful tailing missions as Black Flag and it doesn't have the incredibly long intro and hand holding that holds 3 back. You've got the awesome combat and a decent amount to explore. Its quick,it's got a decent story and it's got some of the coolest outfits. Still think Shay should have left the Templars at the end of it though. Maybe founded a third party trying to end the war and prioritise innocent lives. However I think that feeds into your point about the narrative being abit undercooked.
In my opinion, it's Mirage. I love the pacing of the game to get to the point of being an assassin, while properly developing the story at once and then you can go anywhere you want already, parkour around the city of Baghdad with what I believe to be the best parkour mechanics when you fix the default controls to your liking, and overall fun stealth and combat. Yes, the combat is simple in concept but I like how it actually challenges you rather than the enemies always being slower than you are and it rarely ever glitches with it. New Game+, the Full Synchronization Challenge, and the Parkour updates made this game so much more replayable.
For me its Rogue simply because it's 4-8 hours depending on how much dilly-dallying you do Further elaboration: you can finish the story 10 times in the same amount of time it takes to finish the story in Origins
@@moritakaishida7963 The main story in Origins is roughly the same length as AC2 though. Odyssey is nearly twice as long as Origins while Valhalla is about 6x longer. The lengths of the RPG trilogy aren't very comparable.
The problem of Ac Valhalla is its lack of a New Game+ mode. It would resurrect the game for sure. With rewards for completing the game in new Game+. For example, a proper viking assassin set. I just hope that day comes… whenever. Its a fine game when you experience it on a mid-low pace.
@@SteekStyIt is long, sure, but you spend most of the time looting gear and exploring. Just take your time with the game without recollecting all that pieces. I think it will multiply its replayability.
Me, who keeps replaying over and over every title of Assassin's Creed that comes to my hand (i gotta love the intriguing divergence between gameplay, parkour mechanism, historical location, character designs and outfits)
Ive played ever assassin’s creed game since the first. Ive replayed almost all of them at least once. The 2 i have to say i consistently had the most fun with were black flag and syndicate
Im actually replaying odyssey myself atm and I agree with you. It’s the best replaceable game for me due to the wide variety in missions choices, weapons and armor, skills, playstyles, character etc. Really enjoying my replay. Maybe I even gonna do a replay as Cassandra someday
My favorite game genre is JRPGS. Valhalla's game length is right up my alley and is actually one of my favorites in the series. I love long 100+ hr games. I never found it boring either.
@TheHiddenOne690 You could potentially play 10 seconds of the most memorable/recognizable parts of the songs at the end of the review of each theme song, or let it play in the background as you give the review. That way, you could potentially avoid the copyright issue with the ranking too, since you're talking over the music and you don't extend the use of the song.
@@TheHiddenOne690 Maybe I can look it up on other channels, but I'd rather know it from your opinion. Hope you have plenty of time to do so. We support you ✌🏼⚔️
Yeah what you mention in Odyssey about clearing an area and than r3visiting it again for a mission is so true, i sae that in valhalla and now I literally ignore everything and just actually clear an area if its within a mission
My favourite part about black flag is just walking into a tavern/just standing near a group of singers on an island....I swear they have the most beautiful music
For my the most replayable was Odyssey mainly because the new game plus worked so well in that scenario, you get to keep all your stuff, you are no longer level locked out of regions opening up a different direction, you can make different choices and when you completed a legendary armor set again it automatically levels up to your current level which is great for playing around with armor sets you skipped the first time and you can pick a different play style. I've played all of them more than once but Black Flag and Origins also stand out as worth a replay ,,,, or 2 (I play Black Flag every couple of years since 2013) I have replayed Valhalla after I got the season pass for 10 bucks but cripes by the time I finished the main stories I was so burned out on it I still haven't touched the two DLCs, never done a raid mission and have zero interest in their roguelike add-on (especially with the way the game is crash prone which is the worst for a roguelike)
Its probably not the right answer.... but weirdly enough i find myself going back to unity the most. I avoided it when it came out and played it for the first time like 2 years ago and was blown away.
I have no idea how many times I’ve played black flag now to 100% and I have no idea how many more times will I play it. Even tho the game didn’t get as much love as it should have during development, it still is my favorite game.
Black flag has a massive advantage here because of the ship combat and exploration that can’t be found anywhere else instantly making it an insanely replayable game regardless of it being an assassins creed pirate games are that scarce. Otherwise black flag is huge and you can miss a lot by rushing through the main story and there is a lot of replay there
syndicate is the most replayable for me i cant even finish odyssey without getting bored origins is alr and i will get bored with black flag unity is great
I would replay Rogue right after Black Flag. So I can experience hot Caribbean, then icy North Atlantic, which is cool and makes it fun and exciting to play both. Both games have same gameplay, Rogue slightly has better mechanics in naval and watch out for enemy hiding on rooftop or in bush, something black flag didn’t have. Of course I prefer black flag overall in story & open world, I like rogue overall in gameplay and snowy atmosphere.
@@Barco-b8k rogue was honestly great and deserved more. People complained about it being a clone and not having much content which is fair but it still delivered with what it had, and the dual sword alone was way cooler than anything edward had.
AC1 through Revelations feels like a distant memory at this point. I feel like that series is the real assasssins creed, and it died a loooong time ago
Assassin's Creed Odyssey has the best story, in my opinion. Looking for his mother Myrine, battle vs the cult, battle vs Minotaur, Cyclop and Medusa. Enough to say ATLANTIS, just wow 😯 I'm in love with that game
This list is probably so close to mine, I’m so surprised. I swear I thought I was the only one who liked playing through AC3, and have replayed it multiple times. AC Odyssey is a no brainer too with its multiple endings and choices and builds. AC Brotherhood is a classic AC experience where combat and stealth are fun, along with the old parkour system. It’s also not that long. And then AC Mirage has replay ability in mind, with the permadeath mode and new game plus, it’s so great. And then Unity being just behind those games, the stealth and parkour are always fun, but some Unity jank can easily just ruin the vibe, but when you’re in a flow it’s great.
My first assassins creed game was revelations and it gave me a unique perspective of ezio, since the first tike i played him he was older playing 2 and brotherhood felt like an old man reflecting on the life hes lead it was pretty unique i liked it
"Valhalla is my second cuz the pacing of the story is way too long, now I know what you'll say, The Witcher 3 for example is also very long, yes, but the difference is The Witcher 3 is actually a good game" ~The Hidden Savage 04.05.2024
Ive been getting caught up on AC since most of them are free on PSN and i was willing to pay for Valhalla, and im working on getting Mirage. So far, i like the story of Origins best, but... Odyssey is just really fun to play.
I'm also not willing to play Valhalla again ever. I already suffered to end the game once just to see the story and there's no need to repeat this pain again.
I think it’s fair where you put Syndicate.. I enjoyed that game very much. Played it twice so far and might again but not for a while. I heard one of the funniest crowd reactions that I’ve ever heard in a video game in Syndicate. Doing a mission where a funeral was being held, the people were crowding d I couldn’t get through so I shot my gun in the air and after scattering like roaches with the light on some guy yells out “Never saw a more clearer sign to fuck off!” 😂😂😂 Had to edit this to say I missed playing Unity 10 years ago because mostly of the bad stuff I was hearing about the game but I just started playing it a few days ago and got it dirt cheap and also bought any add-ons and DLC’s possible and those were not pricey at all. I am so glad I did because not for nothing but I am having a BALL playing this game! It’s really making me miss the old, real Assassins Creed games. Especially playing Unity after replaying Valhalla for a week (was only doing that because I thought they were having the Yuletide festival but sadly, they are not. Why? Because Ubisoft.) It took a little bit to get used to the controls and all but I love Unity.
1: black flag, love being a pirate 2: ezio trilogy, this is were it all started for me 3: unity, the parkour evolution of the new gen that time was simply amazing
Amazing how many say Odissey... and I agree! Also love black flag and I have special love for AC III coz it was my gateway drug to AC, I was amazed by it, then played everysingle game more than once except for Unity. Syndicate deserves more love as well
Despite AC3 not being in my top 5 favorites in the series, it’s weirdly my most replayed. Guess it’s just the story and time period for me. Definitely agree with the #1 choice also. Great list tbh valid points and great reasoning.
I think Unity is easily worth a 2nd/3rd playthrough because the setting and action are perfect, but I do have to say Odyssey just has so much more you can do that can make playthroughs unique
When I was young about like 8 I only had like about 9 games call of duty and 2 ac games and those being 3 and Black Flag. I’ve replayed those two AC games more than I can count.
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
To me it's black flag, the game doesn't take too long to give you your boat, and afterwards the Caribbean is your oyster
The ac black flag remake has a huge potential if only Ubisoft can execute it properly
The legit only reason I think maybe it’s not is the sheer amount of fucking tailing missions. That’s easily the worst thing in the game and makes me go I’m not sure whereas without em I’d be like by far black flag
@@alarrim29574I came here to comment the same thing. Any time I want to roll up a new playthrough of Black Flag, I end up stopping after a while due to the sheer number of tailing missions. Give me a cutscene any day of the week over slowly folowing NPCs for minutes on end while they spout exposition.
i say origins for the same reason but a better open world imo and also no tailing mission except for one in a side mission if i remember correctly
bro i want to get into the game but i played for like 30 mins before ending it because of the simple parkour and missions
3 for me. For a game as old as it is by today’s standards, the gameplay has held up nicer than the previous four and I find its themed and story more resonating the older I’ve gotten.
True.. Homestead, captain Kidds mission are masterpiece..
I’m currently playing black flag and 3 again might have to m play rogue and unity as well to play the whole kenway/cormac/arno story as they all tie into each other
Same here. I’ve beat AC3 three times…& I’ve never replayed any of the other AC games after beating them.
I beat that game like 4 times im a veteran now😂
@@MarkWeston-h8eaccept Jesus Christ he loves u ❤️❤️🔥died n rose to forgive u
I played AC Brotherhood many times I don't why but every time I played I felt something fresh every time.
saaaame, the music and the sound affect feel satisfy
Same here. The music is fantastic and gives it a great feel plus…. Ezio. I mean, c’mon man… he’s the coolest Assassin of the series
Assassin's Creed II is the most replayable for me. I've finished it before and then immediately started a new game. Also, it's pretty easy to get the Codex Pages as long as you get them as the story progresses. Make sure to synchronize all of the viewpoints to clear up the map and you will not miss them. The real pain is getting all of the feathers. Lol
I agree, I must have played it a thousand times
@@cherryblack420 Same here. ACII will forever have a special place in my heart. I know the controls feel a bit clunky to people, but I love it so much. I would spend so much time just testing out Ezio's jumping capabilities. I've jumped from very high places that would have dislocated Ezio's arms in real life. Most of my deaths in the stats are from me just jumping to my death. It's difficult to die in combat in ACII. Lol
For me it's AC Unity, especially with the new ACU fixes mod there are so many new ways to play the game and the game still looks and feels great in 2024
How do you replay it btw? It only has 1 save file. I want to replay it but don't know how to. I'm on PC
@@Bad_Dog_Gaminggo to ur genetic file and u can replay missions :)
@@Bad_Dog_Gamingunfortunately you need to go into your game files and manually delete your save. You could also play each mission in order again individually with the Progress Tracker
@@602Tman I'll try that, thanks
@@Bad_Dog_Gaming As 602Tman said, you can delete save file. But you can also just remove it and save that file somewhere else, so when you want to open a certain save file of yours, you can just paste it again in the saves folder.
For me, it's AC Odyssey. I can't fully explain why, but it's become my "comfort game". I can replay the game over and over and still find stuff to do. There is just so much about it that keeps me coming back to it. I do think part of it is the amount of choice (even if it ultimately doesn't matter). I can do subtle things to make each play different, or different enough, to not make it boring.
Also, I still cannot fathom why AC Valhalla didn't get a NG+. I don't understand why it couldn't have. Even Mirage got one. I might replay Valhalla if there was the option, but I'm not about to go back and start from the beginning again.
Well mirage was much shorter and was a linear story without character choice. But odyssey was a fairly large game and had character choice. I feel like Valhalla should’ve gotten new game plus. But a second playthrough on that game is brutal. Too much game for me
I believe its the setting. played odyssey 7ish times
Ac odyssey is my favourite Singleplayergame. Love the music and 1 year ago a was in greece and some islands, i climbed on a little mountain, looked at the ocean, sun was shining und heard ac Odysssey music. Had 10 minutes goosebumps and tears in my eyes. This feelt so Unreal 💥
Don't forget to play Odyssey, and Origins, in discovery mode and try it in first person view! It puts a whole new perspective on everything!
sameee
Odyssey and Black Flag are the most replayable for me. I think I love the sea, lol
@@mr.kwamid-86_43No.
@@mr.kwamid-86_43 💀💀💀
I have experienced the save game delete in black flag 6 times
I can't say the same after what has happened
@@Ghostrunner7069 the same happend with me for AC 3.
I played it 2times and the save files got deleted midway and now i am a pro for completeing the prologue of that game.
@@kuttapan2268 it happened to me as well but only one time
Just after you start playing as Connor in the village
The mercenary system also adds replay value to Odyssey because being randomly generated for the most part you’re not facing the same line up of enemies who are out to kill you, and they can appear all over the map. Add in the option to kill sponsors of these mercenaries and you have an ongoing randomised experience that happens across the whole game.
Facts! Valhalla feels so empty compared to Odyssey, no threats when exploring the world (no sea battles as well)
Valhalla is definitely not a replayable game. You have to be insane to say otherwise
hot take valhallas my favorite of the newer games
More replayable than Odyssey. That game just took way too long
@@shaungotti1431Not a hot take, Valhalla has way more enjoyers than haters. It improved on what Origins and Odyssey had.
It’s barely playable let alone replayable
Well I'm sure the millions of copies sold will persuade Ubisoft not to make anymore games like Valhalla
I had the same with Odyssey. I've played it 4x (main story only) and always tried to get different endings like being an absolute idiot, killing everybody that I could, banging everybody that I could and so on. It was pretty fun to get to see the different results.
Ac valhalla has burned me more than twice now. Ac odyssey is just such a comfort game.
why would you wanna replay a game if it took you half a year to causally complete
@Taxevader-gk9ms Only did one full playthrough (not to 100%)
Second one I didn't even leave Norway
@@texmex0077 i didn't even finish my first play through because it left me so burnt out i took a year and a half off and had to restart to relearn the game
@Taxevader-gk9ms Trust that it's so not worth it.
Thank God odyssey exists
It took me 3 years to finish valhalla bro. Never again. I force myself to finally to end it
Completed AC oddsesy at least 3 times. Ready to go again in summer vacation
And then what do you mean with completed, like only main quests or main and everything in the world?
Most of the side quests too
if that's true then you must have like 800 hours on it
On my third playthrough now. I do side quests as needed for experience. There’s quite a bit to explore
Ac odyssey is my favourite Singleplayergame. Love the music and 1 year ago a was in greece and some islands, i climbed on a little mountain, looked at the ocean, sun was shining und heard ac Odysssey music. Had 10 minutes goosebumps and tears in my eyes. This feelt so Unreal 💥
Idk why but there is always something about starting up a new game of Black Flag and feeling the freshness of arriving in Havana for the first time and wearing the unaltered Duncan Walpole fit which is UNMATCHED 😩
for me its ac unity, not only for the assasination missions but for the parkour and side quests especially, i would just run around rooftops for hrs without doing any missions and still never get bored god what i would do for an ac game like unity
Your vids are gettin me back into the hype. Been burned out since origins. I’m ready 🔥
Ac odyssey is my favourite Singleplayergame. Love the music and 1 year ago a was in greece and some islands, i climbed on a little mountain, looked at the ocean, sun was shining und heard ac Odysssey music. Had 10 minutes goosebumps and tears in my eyes. This feelt so Unreal 💥
Bad taste, mediocre game
@@mihaimercenarul7467let people enjoy things ye lousy bullocks
@@mihaimercenarul7467if the game was so mediocre it wouldn’t have been nominated for goty alongside rdr2, gow4, spider-man ps4, and monster hunter world
From 2010-2017 i played AC trilogy and Black Flag a zillion times. In recent times i grew a liking towards Unity and Origins so been playing those a lot.
"Assassins creed 2 is a game you replay years and years later" one of my favorite games in elementary school, now I'm replaying it for the first time in my own apartment lol
It's my first time playing assassin's creed 1 and it's amazing and new experience for me
Yeeeeeessssssss another fan of 1!!!
@JosephCasimir-ci5bfexcept rogue is flawed where assassins just act like templars and templars act like assassin's
It was truly a revolutionary game for its time. It’s pretty wild to think it came out in ‘07
@@juhno7659its not flawed bc of that. You just bought into the the cartoon villain templar bs
@@Aaron-sx7zfyou are correct that the Templars in Rogue are believable and compelling, but you’re only focusing on half of the comment. The Brotherhood in Rogue is not compelling. There are major issues with the Brotherhood in other games such as AC1 and Mirage, but your character can and does fix those Brotherhoods by going after the one bad apple at or near the top. Rogue makes the brotherhood cartoonish, and instead of rooting out a bad actor, you burn the whole thing down.
AC 2, Brotherhood, Revelations, Black Flack, Rogue, Odyssey, and Valhalla all have mad replay value if you ask me
Best assassins creed channel
Hidden one is 1st and Altair stealth is second.
Valhalla's story alone took me double the amount of time it took me to complete Odyssey's main story and most side content
it dragged on for way to long and was so uninteresting tbh
Odyssey and Black flag are the ones I always tend to go back to.
Hoping AC: Shadows gets added to that list.
@@ComradeSteaky odyssey is the most overrated game of all time
@@SomeOne-hc3bd nope overrated. It’s beloved for superficial reasons
I only play older games and jrpgs these days, but it was AC Syndicate for me. I was kinda addicted to the game when I had my PS4.
Syndicate might be the most underrated AC game ever, and I haven’t even played the Jack the Ripper DLC because I only recently learned about it!
For me, I love replaying every single Assassin's Creed mainly because I just love the games as a whole. I don't care that Valhalla is too long, i dont care that Black Flag has a lot of tailing missions, I don't care that Unity is basically a love story (😂jk). But each and every one of the games has something different and unique that makes me fall in love every time I play. I guess I'm just a simple casual gamer that loves stabbing NPCs 🤷🏾♂️
I don't think I have the standards of a casual gamer, but I also enjoy all of them lol. Gonna be doing a replay of the entire franchise (again) soon, just purchased Origins DLC's finally, and I still have yet to finish Valhalla (+DLCs) and play Mirage, feels like the right time with Mirage going on sale very often and with Shadows just around the corner 👀
For me it’s origins and odyssey but that’s because those are the first ac games I played and my favorites. I have 1500 hours on Origins, and more than 2,000 hours on Odyssey across 2 different accounts. After RDR2 and Far cry 6, Odyssey is my most played game. So for me definitely Odyssey.
Theres something about AC 2 that keeps me coming back even though its weak gameplay wise and very outdated. The story and music is so well done I can't get enough
Bs theres only so many times yoy can play a linear game from 2000's with a rpg system quit fanboying. Youve orolly replayed it at most maybe 3 times
I rarely replay open world games because they are just too big but I am replaying Origins and Odyssey in discovery mode and first person view, which offers a whole new perspective on the games. It's incredible the amount of close up detail you can see this way, particularly as you don't have to worry about being attacked!
For me it is Unity, it was the first AC I played and i was so impressed of the Parkour and since then i kinda fell in love with every AC. I just finished the Platin trophy for Unity and Syndicate and it was such an great experience playing these great games again. Love your Videos
In terms of getting right into the action, I’d argue Rogue. You learn how to assassinate, fight, sail, sneak and shoot in the course of a half hour and you’re more or less let out into the world. And you unlock more stuff as you go along at a quick pace, being a shorter game lets you get into the world and the side content much quicker. Good if you want a quick game to get into and play.
Yeah and the open world is pretty fun with the naval combat and the fact that it's black flag but up north. Plus you don't have to almost drown or get eaten by sharks to explore the ship wrecks
Odyssey! You can literally use an entirely different play style every time you boot up the game.
Yawn
Played it 3 times. Went 3 times with poison assassin build. loved it 3 times
You can literally do that in any of the RPG AC games
For me, definitely Odyssey. I love the setting, the humour and the amount of stuff there is to do in it.
@@Charls03 you overrate a game based on superficial and meaningless qualities. It just shows you don’t appreciate what the older games so special
I love how much u Appreciate Odyssey first time i played on launch I didn't like it stopped early. years later literally 2023 I replayed it and damn the world is one of the best in games ever just that he have a classical Greek world in a game is meaningful to me.
For me, it's Assassin's Creed Brotherhood and Assassin's Creed Unity , I played both of them like 8-10 times including all side quests and dlcs
Same
Totally agree with Odyssey being number 1 due to changing protagonist, NG+, Abilities mastery and different endings
I’d say rogue, it wastes no time bringing you to the open seas, relatively short story so no unnecessary tailing missions, and a decent story at that, enough collectibles to keep you busy, plus those interception missions, forts to take over, gang hideouts etc. easily the most accessible if you want to get right into it without a hefty tutorial. (Looking at you AC3)
AC Valhalla: Definitely tired out after playing. It’s a slog completing it all.
just finished replaying odyssey on nightmare without a new game+ and i can confirm, may be the most replayable game of all time
@@monte6371 you need to play more games. Odyssey is mad overrated
Origins & AC2/Brotherhood IMO!
Just finished AC Odyssey as Kassandra last week and gotta do a replay with Alexios today! Im not satisfied with my story result as I've had wrong choices in the Dialogue which resulted to Alexios and their mother dying! And I've enjoyed playing it for my 1st 115hrs. gotta do it shorter but better this time
I have severe game ADD (I can quickly hop from 1 game to another :) ) and never finished any AC game....but this video is so beautifully made that I'm thinking about installing Odyssey again and finally finishing it :)
I had the most fun there of the AC games I own.
P.S. I'm glad Hidden One mentioned The Witcher 3 too in this video, as that's my all time favorite RPG :)
I played AC Odysseys story 5 times and its so good to replay
Ive completed 2 runs and realized I still need more experience for mastery skills, on what play through did you finally Max out all skills? 3rd play through?
@@legaltowter9811 I played 3 Runs completely new and 2 were new game plus, so yeah 3 runs for enough xp to get all critical strike and chance mastery skills
@@CYB3R2K Game is genuinely so good
Rouge is the most replayable imo. I think its the American trilogy perfected. It's short. It doesn't have as many god awful tailing missions as Black Flag and it doesn't have the incredibly long intro and hand holding that holds 3 back. You've got the awesome combat and a decent amount to explore. Its quick,it's got a decent story and it's got some of the coolest outfits.
Still think Shay should have left the Templars at the end of it though. Maybe founded a third party trying to end the war and prioritise innocent lives. However I think that feeds into your point about the narrative being abit undercooked.
AC3 has the most nostalgia to me and Odyssey’s massive map and decent story makes it quite replayable especially for different endings
I 100% agree with Odyssey. Played it for 26 times on 100% (every location, all chests, everything)
I think Odyssey is the only one that actually seems like it was designed with replayability in mind, for better or worse.
In my opinion, it's Mirage. I love the pacing of the game to get to the point of being an assassin, while properly developing the story at once and then you can go anywhere you want already, parkour around the city of Baghdad with what I believe to be the best parkour mechanics when you fix the default controls to your liking, and overall fun stealth and combat. Yes, the combat is simple in concept but I like how it actually challenges you rather than the enemies always being slower than you are and it rarely ever glitches with it. New Game+, the Full Synchronization Challenge, and the Parkour updates made this game so much more replayable.
For me its Rogue simply because it's 4-8 hours depending on how much dilly-dallying you do
Further elaboration: you can finish the story 10 times in the same amount of time it takes to finish the story in Origins
ac odyssey is definitely the most replayable. i have 300+ hours in it and i just dont get bored of it!
AC 2 trilogy, Black Flag, Unity and Origins for me, these games have very special spaces in my heart
Odyssey is the Skyrim for Assassin's Creed. both is hated by old players but both is the most popular and replayable game in the series.
Origins, easily.
Ac 2
The RPG games are way too long and overly grindy to be even remotely fun to replay imo
@@inthecloudz1272 I agree
Fuck no, too long
@@moritakaishida7963 The main story in Origins is roughly the same length as AC2 though. Odyssey is nearly twice as long as Origins while Valhalla is about 6x longer. The lengths of the RPG trilogy aren't very comparable.
Origins and Black Flag are the only ones i really frequent, personally.
The problem of Ac Valhalla is its lack of a New Game+ mode. It would resurrect the game for sure.
With rewards for completing the game in new Game+. For example, a proper viking assassin set.
I just hope that day comes… whenever. Its a fine game when you experience it on a mid-low pace.
I havent played valhalla but isnt it like 1000+ hours long or something? wouldn't replaying a game that long feel like a chore?
@@SteekStyIt is long, sure, but you spend most of the time looting gear and exploring. Just take your time with the game without recollecting all that pieces.
I think it will multiply its replayability.
Me, who keeps replaying over and over every title of Assassin's Creed that comes to my hand (i gotta love the intriguing divergence between gameplay, parkour mechanism, historical location, character designs and outfits)
Ive played ever assassin’s creed game since the first. Ive replayed almost all of them at least once. The 2 i have to say i consistently had the most fun with were black flag and syndicate
Brotherhood and ac odyssey are prob the most replay-able in my opinion but W video anyway
Replayed Brotherhood 6 times, and will do it again eventually. I never get bored by it. Love that game.
On a gameplay level I and II both lack cutscene skip, meaning you need to watch the same cutscenes you’ve seen before.
Im actually replaying odyssey myself atm and I agree with you. It’s the best replaceable game for me due to the wide variety in missions choices, weapons and armor, skills, playstyles, character etc. Really enjoying my replay. Maybe I even gonna do a replay as Cassandra someday
Odyssey. the ways the story branches is super well done, and the dialogue and world-building are fucking great.
My favorite game genre is JRPGS. Valhalla's game length is right up my alley and is actually one of my favorites in the series. I love long 100+ hr games. I never found it boring either.
I'm not 100% sure if you've made a video about this, but would you be interested in ranking all the main theme songs of the games?
Actually, I'm also waiting for him to create that content
I've always wanted to but I don't know how to execute that video. I wouldn't want to just play 3/4 minutes of music 10 times.
@TheHiddenOne690 You could potentially play 10 seconds of the most memorable/recognizable parts of the songs at the end of the review of each theme song, or let it play in the background as you give the review. That way, you could potentially avoid the copyright issue with the ranking too, since you're talking over the music and you don't extend the use of the song.
@@TheHiddenOne690 Maybe I can look it up on other channels, but I'd rather know it from your opinion.
Hope you have plenty of time to do so. We support you ✌🏼⚔️
Smart smart
The beautiful thing here is so many of us have different picks which goes to show Assassins Creed as a gaming franchise has not hit a false note imo
Odyssey and Blackflag are the ones I find myself coming back to the most
Yeah what you mention in Odyssey about clearing an area and than r3visiting it again for a mission is so true, i sae that in valhalla and now I literally ignore everything and just actually clear an area if its within a mission
My favourite part about black flag is just walking into a tavern/just standing near a group of singers on an island....I swear they have the most beautiful music
For my the most replayable was Odyssey mainly because the new game plus worked so well in that scenario, you get to keep all your stuff, you are no longer level locked out of regions opening up a different direction, you can make different choices and when you completed a legendary armor set again it automatically levels up to your current level which is great for playing around with armor sets you skipped the first time and you can pick a different play style. I've played all of them more than once but Black Flag and Origins also stand out as worth a replay ,,,, or 2 (I play Black Flag every couple of years since 2013)
I have replayed Valhalla after I got the season pass for 10 bucks but cripes by the time I finished the main stories I was so burned out on it I still haven't touched the two DLCs, never done a raid mission and have zero interest in their roguelike add-on (especially with the way the game is crash prone which is the worst for a roguelike)
Valhalla would be one of the most replayable games if it didn't take 4 lifetimes to complete.
Its probably not the right answer.... but weirdly enough i find myself going back to unity the most. I avoided it when it came out and played it for the first time like 2 years ago and was blown away.
My favourite too
Agreed
For me it's 2 and brotherhood. I have played those games for SO MANY hours and i just never get enough of them.
Mirage and Odyssey are my first two AC games and I am blown away by the franchise.
I have no idea how many times I’ve played black flag now to 100% and I have no idea how many more times will I play it. Even tho the game didn’t get as much love as it should have during development, it still is my favorite game.
Black flag has a massive advantage here because of the ship combat and exploration that can’t be found anywhere else instantly making it an insanely replayable game regardless of it being an assassins creed pirate games are that scarce. Otherwise black flag is huge and you can miss a lot by rushing through the main story and there is a lot of replay there
Least replayable:
- Valhalla
- Syndicate
- Mirage
- AC 1
- Revelations
Most replayable:
- Black Flag
- Unity
- Odyssey
- Origins
- Brotherhood
This is facts
syndicate is the most replayable for me
i cant even finish odyssey without getting bored
origins is alr
and i will get bored with black flag
unity is great
Fair
I would replay Rogue right after Black Flag. So I can experience hot Caribbean, then icy North Atlantic, which is cool and makes it fun and exciting to play both.
Both games have same gameplay, Rogue slightly has better mechanics in naval and watch out for enemy hiding on rooftop or in bush, something black flag didn’t have. Of course I prefer black flag overall in story & open world, I like rogue overall in gameplay and snowy atmosphere.
@@Barco-b8k rogue was honestly great and deserved more. People complained about it being a clone and not having much content which is fair but it still delivered with what it had, and the dual sword alone was way cooler than anything edward had.
AC1 through Revelations feels like a distant memory at this point. I feel like that series is the real assasssins creed, and it died a loooong time ago
Assassin's Creed Odyssey has the best story, in my opinion. Looking for his mother Myrine, battle vs the cult, battle vs Minotaur, Cyclop and Medusa. Enough to say ATLANTIS, just wow 😯 I'm in love with that game
I havent even done the Atlantis DLCs yet and I already know its gonna be a banger
@@ezioauditore6371 yeah, bro, you will enjoy it
I mean it make sense for AC1 considering since we follow Altair memories in close timelapse there isn't much happening aside from what we already see.
This list is probably so close to mine, I’m so surprised. I swear I thought I was the only one who liked playing through AC3, and have replayed it multiple times. AC Odyssey is a no brainer too with its multiple endings and choices and builds. AC Brotherhood is a classic AC experience where combat and stealth are fun, along with the old parkour system. It’s also not that long. And then AC Mirage has replay ability in mind, with the permadeath mode and new game plus, it’s so great. And then Unity being just behind those games, the stealth and parkour are always fun, but some Unity jank can easily just ruin the vibe, but when you’re in a flow it’s great.
I'd say AC II for me. I'm the past 2 years, I've 100 percented it 3 times.
That story is just so damn good. And I always enjoy playing the tomb missions to get the armor of Altair
AC2, Odyssey and Black Flag are my most replayed. I really wish AC2 had replayable missions
2:15 sweet home Alabama
My first assassins creed game was revelations and it gave me a unique perspective of ezio, since the first tike i played him he was older playing 2 and brotherhood felt like an old man reflecting on the life hes lead it was pretty unique i liked it
"Valhalla is my second cuz the pacing of the story is way too long, now I know what you'll say, The Witcher 3 for example is also very long, yes, but the difference is The Witcher 3 is actually a good game" ~The Hidden Savage 04.05.2024
This is true asf. Valhalla is trash bro. DLCs and all
@@ezioauditore6371 I have 200 hours in valhalla
Oddyssey is really underrated, I don't care if it feels like it's ac or not it's still really fun. The best rpg ac of all of them.
Ive been getting caught up on AC since most of them are free on PSN and i was willing to pay for Valhalla, and im working on getting Mirage. So far, i like the story of Origins best, but... Odyssey is just really fun to play.
I once originally played and finished Origins on my pc, then a few years later, replayed it on my ps4 and loved it, it is my favourite AC game.
Valhalla is the only AC game ive spent over 300 hrs in. Thats a game i can keep loading up and always finding something to do
I'm also not willing to play Valhalla again ever. I already suffered to end the game once just to see the story and there's no need to repeat this pain again.
every time i've replayed origins i found something new
I think it’s fair where you put Syndicate.. I enjoyed that game very much. Played it twice so far and might again but not for a while. I heard one of the funniest crowd reactions that I’ve ever heard in a video game in Syndicate. Doing a mission where a funeral was being held, the people were crowding d I couldn’t get through so I shot my gun in the air and after scattering like roaches with the light on some guy yells out “Never saw a more clearer sign to fuck off!” 😂😂😂
Had to edit this to say I missed playing Unity 10 years ago because mostly of the bad stuff I was hearing about the game but I just started playing it a few days ago and got it dirt cheap and also bought any add-ons and DLC’s possible and those were not pricey at all. I am so glad I did because not for nothing but I am having a BALL playing this game! It’s really making me miss the old, real Assassins Creed games. Especially playing Unity after replaying Valhalla for a week (was only doing that because I thought they were having the Yuletide festival but sadly, they are not. Why? Because Ubisoft.)
It took a little bit to get used to the controls and all but I love Unity.
1: black flag, love being a pirate
2: ezio trilogy, this is were it all started for me
3: unity, the parkour evolution of the new gen that time was simply amazing
Bro Assassin's Creed 2 was that good that i had to delete a save file so i can make a new one just to play it again.
It was that good for me.
Black Flag was my most replayed AC game by a mile. Other than that, I would replay AC2 trilogy, AC Origins and AC Odyssey.
Amazing how many say Odissey... and I agree!
Also love black flag and I have special love for AC III coz it was my gateway drug to AC, I was amazed by it, then played everysingle game more than once except for Unity.
Syndicate deserves more love as well
Despite AC3 not being in my top 5 favorites in the series, it’s weirdly my most replayed. Guess it’s just the story and time period for me. Definitely agree with the #1 choice also. Great list tbh valid points and great reasoning.
I think Unity is easily worth a 2nd/3rd playthrough because the setting and action are perfect, but I do have to say Odyssey just has so much more you can do that can make playthroughs unique
When I was young about like 8 I only had like about 9 games call of duty and 2 ac games and those being 3 and Black Flag. I’ve replayed those two AC games more than I can count.
Me with 4 playthroughs of Odyssey under my belt:
Im replaying Origins and Oddessy on ng plus and it's been amazing 🤩❤️😌