well this was quite a very interesting halloween story that was from henry's forest, an engine similar to molly was sent to an old branch line that was stored with gunpowder, some supernatural moments, and getting to see D261 blew up his second chance on being purchased before he left. wow, what a story. you and the others that took part of this film definitely did an awesome job on this story you written.
This was the first time in a long while where I was genuinely on edge when watching a Thomas story. This is how you do it. Answering questions but not too many. Leaving in suspense. Not to mention dreading when something horrifying will show up. This was smashing good work.
I feel as though they could have answered a couple of more questions. How a diesel could could vanish from Sodor without the other train line wondering where he went, or if the red light disappeared after some sort of sacrifice by taking the diesel?
if I’m correct the reason we never saw D261 again was because Henry sacrificed him to the spirit or the god which was causing all the trouble which made it come out and observed and determined Henry was not worthy of being a sacrifice due to him give giving a sacrifice
10:01 the WHISTLE, love it! Honestly this amazing production and it's sequel are making such a great new story for Sodor's catalog of horror and the supernatural.
All I can say is… WOW. This is definitely one of the best fanmade Halloween content I’ve seen. I like how it takes place during Bowled Out as well. There’s a lot I’d like to talk about, but we’d probably be here all day if I did.
This was a nice take on a ghost story, this is by far the best thing i saw this spoopy month, love how there was always a red hue until the Diesel disappeared
The usual fan production woes (some poor VA and patchy audio work) aside, this is easily one of the most captivating fan productions I've ever seen. Well-paced, well-"filmed", a brilliant mixture of a classic Thomas tale with a completely original horror story that manages to suspend without ever becoming too silly or try too hard to be disturbing. Bravo.
I’m not usually scared of horror Thomas content, (with a few exceptions) but this made me feel like there was going to be a jump scare or something throughout the entire video. It’s night while I’m watching this and I moved from my desk to my couch because I thought I’d be less scared there if something did happen.
I will be theorizing this series starting here I think the reason why lady didnt take henry, was because he was rebuilt. Therefore didnt have any value to her
This is a good example of how to do a horror/spooky Thomas story. I was legit on edge when Henry's encounter near the end. What i also love was how nothing was truly answered. It was all still left a mystery of what really happened. Great job
I wonder if the diesel angered the spirits or if they like Henry? Cause it seems almost like they were protecting Henry. Great job it was a true horror story
If you look back at this first video, most of Edward's stories here have foreshadowed actual lore; the standing stones are connected with the treasure Stafford tells Percy about and the stuff the military uncovered under them, the monster that stalks Killdane is the monster Rosie encountered during the war, Godred being the engine Thomas talked to about Percy, and while the murderous engine made of scrap seemingly hasn't shown up yet, we do at least have the murderous engine part: Lady in this series has been confirmed to be going around and killing engines (as well rolling stock and people) while harvesting their souls to lure in new victims (she has also been seen to transform one of these souls from a human to a truck and herself from an engine to a person and back in order to accomplish these goals).
@@denzelmungin8296 I have a sneaking suspicion that the magic in Shining Time is all gone. Remember the movie Thomas and the magic railway? If the magic is all gone then bad things will happen.
@MUISonicFrontiers2959 Indeed, it's like Mr. Conductor dream having a bad dream that shining time goes abandoned and it's losing its magic. We already lost 4 engines that died. Gordon, toad, toby and possibly donald. Oliver, percy and duck are still active. I'm pretty sure them 3 green engines were begging lady to not kill them and she given them 3 orders to follow her and kidnap more of their friends if they want to live.
@@thenamesmichael7335 Hmmm, there's something that's bugging me. I think that Lady is either being controlled by something or someone, or the magic is gone. I'm thinking one of those things.
@@MUISonicFrontiers2959well just as in the crying wolf episode that came out 3 weeks. Jezebel before she became a tank engine lady. She met John the little blue engine. She had a bound with him after her father purchased it. One day she rode in John into a mine tunnel and all of a sudden the mine collapsed onto the two and killing them both to the ground. Many workmen as well. After that. Jezebel came to life and transform into a purple tank engine named lady and deceived john after his spirit came along too with her. The line is haunted where they both died. I just don't quite get why jezebel became evil after her death. Did she blame her father or something after her death. Where or what or how she gotten powers from. Possibly the sodor sliver rock? She did killed gordon dump his corpse along with john into the melting pits as a sacrifice. After that lady created a new deceived engine running out of the smelter yard
26:45 seems henry got an idea of my "nope situation" where is there a considerable amount of danger i'll go "nope" and do anything in my power to get away or terminate the danger
Impressive stuff! The quality is very nice, and the choice of putting the story where you did in the timeline is really well done! The writing here is also very well done! My only real concern is the voice acting is quite lackluster, with fairly flat delivery. D261 and Edward's voice actor did a good job, but the others don't hit that note. Also, Henry and the diesel moving on their own, it just took me out of the emersion. All and all, very nice story! I'm very happy to see you tackle original stories of your own!
I like to think that was another dream. When you're dreaming, you're just going in the motions without realizing it. The fact that Henry was back in the shed and D261 leaving the island, leaves us wondering. Did that really happen or was it another dream? We don't know as we never got to hear if D261 experiences what Henry has seen or not. I guess this story was sort of like "Duncan gets spooked", where some things aren't answered and it's for us to decide.
well this was quite a very interesting halloween story that was from henry’s forest, an engine similar to molly was sent to an old branch line that was stored with gunpowder, some supernatural moments, and getting to see D261 blew up his second chance on being purchased before he left. wow, what a story. you and the others that took part of this film definitely did an awesome job on this story you written.
Awesome production! The visuals and voicing are done quite well. However, if I may offer a suggestion, I'd consider turning down the volume of the music in some places. It's a little too loud/distracting during some parts of the narration and I struggled to hear what was being read. But overall, great story. The amount of effort put into this seriously shows!
At about 10:00, I could hear Lady's whistle in the distance. I don't I heard it on my first watch through, but I started paying more attention for it once your later videos established the pattern of her whistle foreshadowing some of the engines being taken later in the video.
3:30 - Are those stories actual ones that exist in the Thomas fan circle? Or are they just ideas that were thrown in as stories Edward would have told? Because they sound like really cool ideas for scary stories.
well done, i see now why you didnt use henry in the newer 411 video, though i expect him to remember in the following 411 video, if there is one hopefully, you`ve got my sub and bell fer sure, lol
Nice story but could you speak a bit louder? The background and your voice are nearly the same volume and you can see/hear it when henry makes his emergency brake.
Hang on why it was very interesting to see 2 things were you using molly for reference and 2 did d261 die or just send back to the mainland cuz the bit where it zooms in on the forest makes it seem like he really did die
nice story overall my only nit pick was the voice quality and editing find a nice medium where the voices and sounds/music work where one doesn't over power the other and your good and lastly when recording voices its a good rule of thumb to remove any background noise and clicking of the mouse as it breaks the immersion of the story but with that said I give this a 8/10! If you ever need any help I'd be glad to chip in I grew up with Thomas as a kid and I'd love to be a part of this!
Um, so the plane and those lorries. Do they actually come because of the false alarms? Or is what happened to that Diesel a sort of regular occurrence? If it was the latter, it would explain why lorries instead of fire engines showed up. Then again, if it was a regular occurrence, why would they only now cover up the line for good? And why was Henry spared while the Diesel was destroyed? Are the lights really the ghosts of those victims or is there more to the story?
Coming back to this after watching Old Stuck Up to bring myself up to speed, and have just noticed a hidden engine at 23:22 Which engine is that in the background?
well this was quite a very interesting halloween story that was from henry's forest, an engine similar to molly was sent to an old branch line that was stored with gunpowder, some supernatural moments, and getting to see D261 blew up his second chance on being purchased before he left. wow, what a story. you and the others that took part of this film definitely did an awesome job on this story you written.
Oh, D261. The Mocker of Old Engines, Like Edward.
R.I.P molly.
26:43 Easily one of the *the* best "NOPE"s ive ever heard 🤣 , execellent story my dude
This was the first time in a long while where I was genuinely on edge when watching a Thomas story. This is how you do it. Answering questions but not too many. Leaving in suspense. Not to mention dreading when something horrifying will show up. This was smashing good work.
I feel as though they could have answered a couple of more questions. How a diesel could could vanish from Sodor without the other train line wondering where he went, or if the red light disappeared after some sort of sacrifice by taking the diesel?
This would explain why we never saw D261 in the show again.
if I’m correct the reason we never saw D261 again was because Henry sacrificed him to the spirit or the god which was causing all the trouble which made it come out and observed and determined Henry was not worthy of being a sacrifice due to him give giving a sacrifice
@@Clanngabang it can make sense/good theory
@@Clanngabang i think the lights were supposed to be aliens, not ghosts
@@joshwalter-t7ior the lady
10:01 the WHISTLE, love it! Honestly this amazing production and it's sequel are making such a great new story for Sodor's catalog of horror and the supernatural.
It’s lady
@@Drill-o4g I knew it was, as soon as I heard that peculiar whistle, I was immediately wondering why Lady was around.
All I can say is… WOW. This is definitely one of the best fanmade Halloween content I’ve seen. I like how it takes place during Bowled Out as well. There’s a lot I’d like to talk about, but we’d probably be here all day if I did.
Thank you for letting me be a part of this. Also I can tell this took a lot of work, and I really think it payed off.
Astonishing, though I wish to have seen Henry setting the spirits free, maybe they saved him from the diesel
26:44😂
This was a nice take on a ghost story, this is by far the best thing i saw this spoopy month, love how there was always a red hue until the Diesel disappeared
I don't think they're ghosts, but rather UFOs since Henry saw a flying saucer
The usual fan production woes (some poor VA and patchy audio work) aside, this is easily one of the most captivating fan productions I've ever seen. Well-paced, well-"filmed", a brilliant mixture of a classic Thomas tale with a completely original horror story that manages to suspend without ever becoming too silly or try too hard to be disturbing. Bravo.
love this story its actually one of the scariest Thomas and friend's story's I have seen these past 2 years amazing job dude!
This might be my favorite video from you not only the writing but the accuracy with the head codes
I’m not usually scared of horror Thomas content, (with a few exceptions) but this made me feel like there was going to be a jump scare or something throughout the entire video. It’s night while I’m watching this and I moved from my desk to my couch because I thought I’d be less scared there if something did happen.
I will be theorizing this series starting here
I think the reason why lady didnt take henry, was because he was rebuilt. Therefore didnt have any value to her
This is a good example of how to do a horror/spooky Thomas story. I was legit on edge when Henry's encounter near the end. What i also love was how nothing was truly answered. It was all still left a mystery of what really happened. Great job
I’m glad you liked it, I am actually working on a sequel.
@@daylight39 What sequel?
@@daylight39 Are there any characters from Shining Time Station(1989-1995) and Fireman Sam(1987)?
I wonder if the diesel angered the spirits or if they like Henry? Cause it seems almost like they were protecting Henry. Great job it was a true horror story
I think these were encounters with aliens.
I love how the devilish creature is literally just hooty
If you look back at this first video, most of Edward's stories here have foreshadowed actual lore; the standing stones are connected with the treasure Stafford tells Percy about and the stuff the military uncovered under them, the monster that stalks Killdane is the monster Rosie encountered during the war, Godred being the engine Thomas talked to about Percy, and while the murderous engine made of scrap seemingly hasn't shown up yet, we do at least have the murderous engine part: Lady in this series has been confirmed to be going around and killing engines (as well rolling stock and people) while harvesting their souls to lure in new victims (she has also been seen to transform one of these souls from a human to a truck and herself from an engine to a person and back in order to accomplish these goals).
Why is Lady doing all this?
@@denzelmungin8296 I have a sneaking suspicion that the magic in Shining Time is all gone. Remember the movie Thomas and the magic railway? If the magic is all gone then bad things will happen.
@MUISonicFrontiers2959 Indeed, it's like Mr. Conductor dream having a bad dream that shining time goes abandoned and it's losing its magic. We already lost 4 engines that died. Gordon, toad, toby and possibly donald. Oliver, percy and duck are still active. I'm pretty sure them 3 green engines were begging lady to not kill them and she given them 3 orders to follow her and kidnap more of their friends if they want to live.
@@thenamesmichael7335 Hmmm, there's something that's bugging me. I think that Lady is either being controlled by something or someone, or the magic is gone. I'm thinking one of those things.
@@MUISonicFrontiers2959well just as in the crying wolf episode that came out 3 weeks. Jezebel before she became a tank engine lady. She met John the little blue engine. She had a bound with him after her father purchased it. One day she rode in John into a mine tunnel and all of a sudden the mine collapsed onto the two and killing them both to the ground. Many workmen as well. After that. Jezebel came to life and transform into a purple tank engine named lady and deceived john after his spirit came along too with her. The line is haunted where they both died. I just don't quite get why jezebel became evil after her death. Did she blame her father or something after her death. Where or what or how she gotten powers from. Possibly the sodor sliver rock? She did killed gordon dump his corpse along with john into the melting pits as a sacrifice. After that lady created a new deceived engine running out of the smelter yard
26:45 seems henry got an idea of my "nope situation" where is there a considerable amount of danger i'll go "nope" and do anything in my power to get away or terminate the danger
I like these fanmade Thomas Halloween stories, the fandom really makes them spooky, yet fun.
That was really scard and terrifying to listen to! I enjoyed it a lot, very well written and great narratation!😆😁👏☝
Great story! I never thought Henrys Forest could become something scary but you definetly proved me wrong!
I totally felt Henry's "Nope!" XD
Henry the moment he saw the three horrid lorries “Nope!”
@@ryancampbell4119 The three horrid lorries? Can you explain what they are?
A really new meaning to the ending phrase of bowled out
So glad I was able to help out in this man thanks for having me
You did a great job with your lines.
@@a05polzar thanks I loved doing them all
I wonder if Edward personally knows any dark tragedy that befell and costed the lives of any of his siblings!
I always love how in basically every fan made story over the last few years, that the HIT era characters are always used as throwaway characters.
Impressive stuff! The quality is very nice, and the choice of putting the story where you did in the timeline is really well done! The writing here is also very well done! My only real concern is the voice acting is quite lackluster, with fairly flat delivery. D261 and Edward's voice actor did a good job, but the others don't hit that note. Also, Henry and the diesel moving on their own, it just took me out of the emersion. All and all, very nice story! I'm very happy to see you tackle original stories of your own!
I like to think that was another dream. When you're dreaming, you're just going in the motions without realizing it.
The fact that Henry was back in the shed and D261 leaving the island, leaves us wondering.
Did that really happen or was it another dream?
We don't know as we never got to hear if D261 experiences what Henry has seen or not.
I guess this story was sort of like "Duncan gets spooked", where some things aren't answered and it's for us to decide.
Well, Killdane is quite possibly the last place I would ever expect to see Hooty. Neat to see another Owl House fan too.
Happy 1-year anniversary of Forest Horrors! I don't know where this series may go next, but one thing's for sure, Sodor's horrors are far from over.
well this was quite a very interesting halloween story that was from henry’s forest, an engine similar to molly was sent to an old branch line that was stored with gunpowder, some supernatural moments, and getting to see D261 blew up his second chance on being purchased before he left. wow, what a story. you and the others that took part of this film definitely did an awesome job on this story you written.
That’s epically terrifying, well done!
I had a feeling it wasnt a normal ghost story, the monent i saw that plane fly over.
It was a E-2 Hawkeye, not a fire fighting plane.
Thanks.
Awesome production! The visuals and voicing are done quite well. However, if I may offer a suggestion, I'd consider turning down the volume of the music in some places. It's a little too loud/distracting during some parts of the narration and I struggled to hear what was being read. But overall, great story. The amount of effort put into this seriously shows!
Yeah that's what I was thinking.
25:20 sound effect too loud,
What did the narrator said here? I can’t hear him! Can we plz turn the sound effects down?
This is My Best Scary Story I Never Heard Before.
This video is so appealing to me! Great job!❤
Ouch Henry, didn't have to say there's no home for D261.
Love it best story l have seen in a while l like how you combine tv series with yours
3:35 The Killdane Experiment.
At about 10:00, I could hear Lady's whistle in the distance. I don't I heard it on my first watch through, but I started paying more attention for it once your later videos established the pattern of her whistle foreshadowing some of the engines being taken later in the video.
3:33 Hooty being the monster is hilarious
Awesome story and improved visuals Daylight 3
3:32 Devilish indeed! *Devilishly Handsome.*
3:30 - Are those stories actual ones that exist in the Thomas fan circle? Or are they just ideas that were thrown in as stories Edward would have told? Because they sound like really cool ideas for scary stories.
so when Edward said at 4:00 did he make a Culdee fell reference
Coming back to this you can hear Lady's eerie whistle in the background at 10:00
This was really good, enjoyed it.
The only thing that I've noticed on these is usually the music is way louder than the voices that just seems to be a general trend on these videos
I like to believe that the engine that had the same basis as Molly is one of her brothers.
But...that IS Molly!!!
@@haydennorris3672 I don’t care it’s my au for this story.
@@omerolopez9741Cringe.
3:35 I WAS NOT EXPECTING HOOTY
Me neither, lmao
well done, i see now why you didnt use henry in the newer 411 video, though i expect him to remember in the following 411 video, if there is one hopefully, you`ve got my sub and bell fer sure, lol
Lovely story very spooky!
So did d261 really die for real?
26:44 good answer
At exactly minute 10:00 you can hear Lady's whistle in the backround
3:33 Mouse cursor.
Nice story but could you speak a bit louder? The background and your voice are nearly the same volume and you can see/hear it when henry makes his emergency brake.
I love this so much (also the diesel survive?!)
@@daylight39 Nice job there, Daylight 3, it looks cooler.
@@daylight39 oh alright sorry about that got confused, peculiarly no one remember really
And this is why people you should never mess with henry forests
10:50 when the driver or fireman said Henry i thought i heard inmate and i cant stop laughing at myself
great video either way
This story gave me some spooks. I think this story is alright. Although it was A bit confusing in the end in my opinion.
21:02 Interesting Fact: The "New Forest Cicada (Cicadetta montana) is the only species of cicada native to the UK.
I couldn’t stop laughing when I saw the photo of Hooty 😂😂😂😂😂
Yeah I recognized it
I love those creepy pastas with those animations
Hang on why it was very interesting to see 2 things were you using molly for reference and 2 did d261 die or just send back to the mainland cuz the bit where it zooms in on the forest makes it seem like he really did die
@@daylight39 oo nice one btw I had a idea for you a ghost story about a engine that used to work edward line the w & s engine number 5 aj
@@daylight39 karma
@@daylight39 guess its suppsoed to be a mystery is it?
that was actually really good
That was a good story I thoroughly enjoy it
Why did I hear ladies whistle in the background this is not the magic railroad
perfect its spoopy! its horrorfuying! and its cleaver great work!
I feel like this is a cliffhanger
This is one of my favorite Halloween specials especially for 2024
The start of an EPIC Saga!!! Yeeee
10:47 is that firebox texture really just meat? lmao
I think they’re meant to be pieces of coal
@@johnott7293 don't think it would look anything like that but it's definitely still an image of meat
3:33 -> Hooty is the devilish creature…..
nice story overall my only nit pick was the voice quality and editing find a nice medium where the voices and sounds/music work where one doesn't over power the other and your good and lastly when recording voices its a good rule of thumb to remove any background noise and clicking of the mouse as it breaks the immersion of the story but with that said I give this a 8/10!
If you ever need any help I'd be glad to chip in I grew up with Thomas as a kid and I'd love to be a part of this!
Awesome story dude!
What do you use to make those videos?
How is henry moving without his driver and fireman
Anyone know the three mentioned stories, i think i know two, killdane expriement and broken wings
Was the red light really the spirit of the engine?
Excellent 👌
17:29 his voice rhymed with the song
So wait is this any other videos one complete storyline
Yes, there is a playlist called forest horrors
Bit of critism abou the audio: The music is way louder than the narration, which makes it hard to hear!
Wild and brilliant story
Who was the engine who crashed
This is just the prologue.
Henry the brave Engine how scared he was he always always look ahead .
Please do an Video to the Murdering Scrap Engine.
Why was an Hawkeye which is an AWACS doing that low
What is Hooty doing at Killdane
3:32 hoo hoo 🦉
Um, so the plane and those lorries. Do they actually come because of the false alarms? Or is what happened to that Diesel a sort of regular occurrence? If it was the latter, it would explain why lorries instead of fire engines showed up. Then again, if it was a regular occurrence, why would they only now cover up the line for good?
And why was Henry spared while the Diesel was destroyed? Are the lights really the ghosts of those victims or is there more to the story?
3:33 HOOT HOOT
I can barely hear your voice in some parts. Pleas increase it
Looks like this event took place during bowled out
Funny that it seemed like it
I love how it is Molly in the ghost story
I believe it's actually Molly's brother
I think Molly is a substitute for another engine. Right? Although this is a good story
Yep you got that right
Coming back to this after watching Old Stuck Up to bring myself up to speed, and have just noticed a hidden engine at 23:22
Which engine is that in the background?
I don't know what or who it is but I'm thinking it's one of the missing engines.
I like how you referenced Bowled out