Reservation Dogs Season 3 Episode 2 - INDIGENOUS Review! Analysis & Breakdown

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
  • Review of Reservation Dogs by ACTUAL Native Americans!
    / indigenoustalk
    / indigenoustalkofficial
    / indigenoustalk
    Hi all this is Patrick from ‪@patrickisanavajo‬ I have always wanted to try different content other than the "Natives React" series. Natives React is STILL coming out with new episodes! This new channel Indigenous Talk will host videos I've always wanted to do. Right now the focus is Reservation Dog's Season 3 Episode Reviews!
    / nativefilmtalk
    / nativemediatheory
    / kickin_bird203
    / patrickisanavajo
    If you're reading this please consider subscribing! More videos coming to this channel soon! Ahe'hee' Thank you!

Комментарии • 55

  • @IndigenousTalkOfficial
    @IndigenousTalkOfficial  Год назад +18

    Patrick: You see the curvature of the Eggplant has got to have a deeper meaning 🧐👨🏽‍🏫🎬💭
    Elias: ITS NOT THAT DEEP! 😅

    • @nativemediatheory
      @nativemediatheory Год назад

      It isn’t! 🤣

    • @SusanBame
      @SusanBame Год назад

      When they started working on filming Season 3, isn't that about the time that the eggplant emoji became a "thing" that stood for sex? If you were texting and you wanted to refer to that part of the body, you insert an eggplant emoji? That's what I assumed it was all about. I think the eggplant is only from Season 3. It first showed up on a medallion William Knifeman wore out in the desert and then continued on with Maximus.
      And then just the word itself...egg, plant...may be a play on words here...and then we see Big on the exam room table half naked...was he being "probed"? Or is that what that was referring to? Him and his conspiracy theories and seeing Deer Lady and Bigfoot and all...does he have hybrid children (star children that his DNA was used to create)? Does Maximus?

    • @dashx1103
      @dashx1103 Год назад +1

      That's what she said.

    • @AhNee
      @AhNee Год назад

      Invasion of the Body Snatchers?

  • @witchdoctor1394
    @witchdoctor1394 Год назад +39

    This show, man... Reservation Dogs just gets inside your head and then walks out holding your heart in its hands. I've never watched a show that just left me emotionally exhausted in as many ways as this one. This is healing. This is is speaking our truths. Imma miss it when it's gone.

    • @IndigenousTalkOfficial
      @IndigenousTalkOfficial  Год назад +3

      To have these important stories shared at this caliber, amazing!

    • @1Nida
      @1Nida Год назад +1

      Such an important show. I’m 58 and dealing with a lifetime of issues. Reservation Dogs is good medicine.

    • @dashx1103
      @dashx1103 Год назад +1

      Well said.

    • @allisonchainz82
      @allisonchainz82 11 месяцев назад

      I think I read they may be making a movie

  • @chrystiecastillo293
    @chrystiecastillo293 11 месяцев назад +2

    I love how the episodes connect and later how Maximus is reunited with the uncles.

  • @AhNee
    @AhNee Год назад +3

    It bothered me that when Maximus was showing him the home movies, Bear had no flash of recognition from the names mentioned. The culvert can also symbolize rebirth.

  • @SaltJamie
    @SaltJamie Год назад +13

    I am so happy to find you guys back on the air, Life is better when you are in it!

  • @michaelrutledge3750
    @michaelrutledge3750 Год назад +4

    I thought the point about the culvert and walking over was astute, but that you partially missed the point. The constellations within the medicine wheel and later the culvert were also astute.
    I’m using academic terms and theories for a reason here, because each nation has variations and I don’t want to talk about anything sacred that isn’t already out there (right or wrong). Bear’s nation is one of the Moundbuilder surviving nations.
    There are academic theories about Moundbuilder religious beliefs, for this scene, that when we die, we take the Hand of God (Orion), which is a portal to the Path of Souls (Milky Way). On that path, our souls are confronted with a choice of paths and whether we reach our destination where our ancestors dwell depends on our choice.
    So when Bear is shown the culvert, his choice of path, either going up the hill over the portal and avoiding the spiritual path entirely, or through the portal, along the path of stars, will determine his fate. When he goes through the portal and walks among the stars and emerges the other side, he is no longer the person he was when he entered it. He made the right choice for his spiritual awakening.

  • @othergary
    @othergary Год назад +5

    That scene was shot north of Jet,Oklahoma. Great Salt Plains, a surrealistic area where salt incrusted land is bright as snow.

    • @hiitsrudd8567
      @hiitsrudd8567 Месяц назад

      Where Bonnie & Clyde visited with her family

  • @cheri7054
    @cheri7054 Год назад +10

    Love your review cuz you take lines and mention their importance. Awesome. Most reviewers tell us a recap in a different way. They instill their opinions but you all give us something to think about. You mention details Wow

    • @IndigenousTalkOfficial
      @IndigenousTalkOfficial  Год назад +3

      Thank you! We are still getting there and taking feedback, we know our review format will grow and change over time

  • @janetsuiter1889
    @janetsuiter1889 Год назад +2

    I thought once that Maximas was Bear meeting his future self, because his grandmother made spaghetti soup for him. And then I thought he was Bears grandfather maybe in his real life, Rita's Dad.

  • @dashx1103
    @dashx1103 Год назад +3

    Strong call back to Season 1 and the "orb." I hadn't even thought of that. Also, an amazing observation about the constellation/portal. Thanks!

  • @DavidRexGlenn
    @DavidRexGlenn Год назад +1

    The culvert that Bear walks through could always symbolize a rebirth of sorts, leaving childhood behind

  • @MindFeather
    @MindFeather 11 месяцев назад +1

    when you made the recent "Halloween Special #3" and said you had a new channel, i immediately subscribed to Hulu and binged Season 1 on saturday, Season 2 on sunday. while there are definitely several references to "Smoke Signals" in many aspects (the opening shot of Season 1 starting from a Rez radio station, the way they use music throughout, the character of Brownie feels a lot like Lester Falls Apart from the Smoke Signals book, etc etc, plus the bus ride that you mentioned here) this series also reminds me of Sherman Alexie's book, "Indian Killer." you've probably read it, but for those who haven't there are multiple characters in that book who are all "indian killers" in a wide variety of ways, from the entire gamut of people who mean well to people who don't, on both sides of the racial lines. here in this show there are ways in which the entire series feels a bit like "part 2" of that novel, especially in the wide variety of ways racism is on display. there's the obvious creepy wealthy white guy with his fetishes and tattoos, but even the tension between "city NDNs" and "Rez NDNs," between the youth culture and the traditionalists, and on and on. there's just tension and conflict everywhere. and it's all handled so brilliantly, so poignantly, so powerfully.
    i'm also both worried and curious if this season will touch on the way american media so often turns a blind eye to the way NDN women just "disappear" and are never heard from again. reading the BBC regularly there's a semi-annual report on how this happens all over Canada ... though i imagine it's a problem everywhere. also, i'm on board with Patrick's "conspiracy theory" -- i've only seen episode 1 of season 3 so far (today's a work day) but on the bus it definitely looks like Tini (sp?) has a few hickies after that conference.
    in the end i can't praise this show enough, and am so thrilled to see the return of Patrick & Jacob, and the expansion of the crew into the 4 strong, smart voices and points of view. every one of you brought something surprising and powerful to the table, themes and details i had not thought of, connections i had not made, and i'm grateful for the chance to hear your perspectives. more power to you all. i'm definitely hoping for a 4th season. makes perfect sense.

    • @MindFeather
      @MindFeather 11 месяцев назад

      dang, i meant to leave this comment on the S.3, E.1 video. my bad. sorry if there was confusion.

  • @SSPSoundz
    @SSPSoundz Год назад +4

    I can't wait for yall to cover episode 3! Keep it up and thanks for sharing your takes!
    Off to play Miles Davis - Star People now.

  • @MaryMary-pr4iu
    @MaryMary-pr4iu Год назад +3

    I love the Spirit Guide ❤❤❤ and the way his horse doesn’t listen, is cute

  • @AmanCreatesArt
    @AmanCreatesArt 9 месяцев назад

    Great analysis! Graham Greene is a treasure!

  • @BigDaddysBearCave
    @BigDaddysBearCave 11 месяцев назад

    Y’all rock!!!!

  • @CHELDRE
    @CHELDRE Год назад +1

    Chhee I’m so glad I found this this. I’m excited for you guys to talk about episode 3. Listener of Native film talk too; waiting on a new episode! Happy to see all of y’all doing this

    • @IndigenousTalkOfficial
      @IndigenousTalkOfficial  Год назад +2

      We talked for an hour and it’s a bit to edit, but Episode 3 is deep, the review is coming soon! Tomorrow or the next day.
      Ian’s (Native Film Talk) perspective has been so insightful! He brings up a lot of things the rest of us forgot about or didn’t see

  • @moonlily1
    @moonlily1 Год назад +2

    Can't wait to hear what you have to say about the Deer Lady episode.

    • @IndigenousTalkOfficial
      @IndigenousTalkOfficial  Год назад +2

      Coming tomorrow or the next day! Almost caught up to weekly

    • @moonlily1
      @moonlily1 Год назад

      @@IndigenousTalkOfficial I think you're going to love it.

  • @dashx1103
    @dashx1103 Год назад

    Would like to see a spin-off about the Conquistador and his people. "Conquista-dogs."

  • @perrodetokio
    @perrodetokio Год назад

    Amazing insights! ♥ Greetings from Córdoba, Argentina!

  • @FreshEnigma
    @FreshEnigma Год назад

    so cool to find this podcast clip on tiktok! I always wanted to hear more of your thoughts on the series after watching the natives react video you guys made a couple years ago ^_^

  • @mikeyfn-a6684
    @mikeyfn-a6684 10 месяцев назад

    Anyone else catch the fact that not only did Bear miss his bus, but also left his headphones 🎧 in the bathroom

  • @MrLS77
    @MrLS77 Год назад

    Loving Res Dogs, glad to come across your recaps, and I'll be looking for your other content.

  • @lindabailey7391
    @lindabailey7391 Год назад +1

    I feel bear will somehow bring Maximus to res, as Maximus relates to having ties there

  • @heidistandell9496
    @heidistandell9496 Год назад +3

    Maximus is such a sad character, and a warning to Bear. Be careful, "people will think you are nuts". Modern times is all about productivity, curing and getting people back to participating in capitalism, which is looked at as the means to a happy meaningful life. Earlier times in Europe and pre-contact times in the Americas, people who could talk to or see things that others couldn't were cared for and often revered, not punished for an inability to work and derided for not fitting in. Weird the church worships a man who said he could talk to God, and all the others who preceded him, yet burned wise women and seers as witches, then came to the Americas and killed or silenced people who said the same things here. Well, at least no one gets lit on fire anymore, but no wonder people who think differently often turn to drugs.

  • @cheri7054
    @cheri7054 Год назад

    Excellent review!!!!! Thanks

  • @SusanBame
    @SusanBame Год назад +1

    Love the Reservation Dogs series, and love hearing you guys talk about it. I always get something out of your conversations that I missed noticing while watching the episode -- like the star chart inside the tunnel, calling the tunnel the "portal." Good one.

  • @utej.k.bemsel4777
    @utej.k.bemsel4777 6 месяцев назад

    Strange, the algorythm gave me a video where coyote put the milkyway in its place...👍

  • @utaug595
    @utaug595 Год назад

    This is cool, please keep it up

  • @utaug595
    @utaug595 Год назад +1

    I want learn more about the cultural meanings of the show as a non-native.

  • @cheri7054
    @cheri7054 Год назад

    Love can just be. That's beautiful. So many push love and you can't do that.

  • @marlenemounce2918
    @marlenemounce2918 Год назад

    “All I can give you is cryptic aphorisms.”

  • @haymaker710
    @haymaker710 Год назад

    I think this show is sponsored by Sonic. This is the fourth time they mentioned Sonic.

  • @jonanderson4474
    @jonanderson4474 Год назад +1

    I still think John Trudell would have had a decent character on this show.

  • @lesweizman388
    @lesweizman388 Год назад

    maximus foreshadows epi 3 with him mentioning that he was raised in a residential school
    in regards to cuckoo's nest, please read the book
    the main character and narrator is the native american
    ken kesey hated the movie as they changed the pov and made it more a vehicle for jack
    it seems to me that season 3 is more about generational trauma than the first two seasons

  • @marshall_warpath8695
    @marshall_warpath8695 Год назад +1

    #SKODEN #STOODIS

  • @Ahzpayne
    @Ahzpayne 10 месяцев назад

    I would have expected more awareness and less use of the "A" word in reference to indigenous Australians. Especially considering the preferred term is also indigenous. Maybe you didn't know. Now you do.