Yes Ty this is how Yahushua treats us . He still is there for us no matter whatever we choose But does he get mad at us ; No He loves us unconditionally in spite of the fact we put our way ahead of His Sometimes we put Him on a back burner in our lives , But He always willing and welcomes us with open arms . Good on you Ba GBY . Thank your son for his service and thank you for sharing your testimony with us
"Strength Through Joy".... Spoken over and over again at the DNC Convention. Nazi talking point for election. Look it up. Why am I not surprised. Nazi's
I am a Christian in a RED state. I am a Democrat. You articulate what I have been feeling for a long time. I want to err on the side of kindness, love, forgiveness. Jesus did and still does. I attend church where everyone believes DT, because he is a Republican, is the only choice. I refuse to allow this man to divide me from my church - even if the people have the idea that because he is a Republican - he is the ONLY one they are ALLOWED to vote for. Thank you for your honesty. And I forgive you for being a part of the beginning of this "movement." You have opened your eyes, and your heart to the "world" on this website. You are a real man. I love that your grandchildren love you and know that you have their back.
When is tolerating intolerance ever acceptable? This is the paradox many are trapped in now. My response to Christian Nationalists and those who enable them is a quote from Bob Dylan's 'Masters of War.' 'Even Jesus Himself would never forgive what you do.'
I will err through God's Graces of love forgiveness mercy no matter what sex gender race title gays lesbians, as what the commandment says Love Thine Neighbors Help the poor hungry these kind of people does not see that Trump is the number 1 sinner as well he has no moral compass an adulterer womanizer lies vengeful look at the 10 commandments he follows which character does Trump represent in the Bible? By the way pro choice is now under the State not under the Executive . They want Pro life but trump wants to cut all the support system food stamps health care education planned parenthood contraceptions.
@@pttpforever I hear you. As a Christian, its important to forgive, to leave room for people to screw up...yes..and sin, in the HOPE that they will see, learn, grow and be better! You dont become a doormat. You stand Your ground on what you have experienced. And sometimes we have to separate or go no contact. But love overcomes a multitude of sins. ❤
That would be Donald J Trump and not a filthy communist Kamala who is against everything you’ve listed, despite the rhetoric. My goodness-the ignorance. The jaw-dropping ignorance of the propaganda-absorbing useful idiots. Communist regimes have always needed their useful idiots--and here you are for this one.
I'm very old and I'll. This may be my last chance to vote on this earth. Even if I have to crawl to the poles to vote, I'm thinking of my kids, grandkids and my 2 little great grands. Their future is in my precious Vote. This one's for you my wonderful family, to know Democracy, freedom and the right to make your own decisions in the future as an American Citizen. Vote with love and empathy in your heart. Grammy will be watching from Heaven.💙🇺🇲🛐👵
@@kathleenhack so you’re voting for Marxist Democrats who hate God, hate freedom, hate Democracy, hate decency, and hate the working class people of the country. What a horrible thing to leave your grandchildren.
@@kathleenhack You could vote early and/or by mail. Don't know what the rules are where you live. Just a suggestion. I hope you do vote, and live to see Kamala win and the end of this nightmare that is Trump. We are on the threshold. It will either be the darkness of Totalitarianism or Democracy and an inclusive future. That's how critical this moment in America's story is. It could go either way. Let's choose light over darkness.
I agree. I was skeptical to even watch. But I thank all Republican voters that plan to vote for Harris to help save our country from the evil maga cult!
Yeah, I was like hmm mmm. Glad I stopped to listen. And, to it all.... I'm always seeking those who capture what it is they see, from their unique vantage regarding the Republican Party throughout the last few decades and even the last 100 year's. The Party of Lincoln back during those years leading up to the Civil War and right on up to the last noble torch bearers of what that Party used to be (like Teddy Roosevelt or Ike Eisenhower ) essentially embodied the principles and goals of opportunity and equality FOR ALL IS the Democratic Party of today! So I'm always curious about folks with the experience of growing up differently like Frank to see how this could have ever happened so that I hopefully, grasp a bit more of how we as citizens and government can prevent the USA from going the way of these countries that have been decimated by non Democratic governments.
So this is another galaxy far far away and even Darth vaders just have to do one last act to become anakin again? Not sure that’s how it works, but I agree, it’s better than nothing. Just joshing
As a 78 year old woman and single mother with 2 cats, I still have a headache from all the glass ceilings I hit. It did my heart good to hear this podcast today. Thank you for your kindness..
Same!! I can't believe that in 2024, we will have to fight yet again for our daughters and granddaughters reproductive rights! Before we had Roe, doctors were not prosecuted for using the d&c procedure needed in miscarriages. Now? Doctors can't use that procedure at all and women, who have miscarriages are given the abortion pill to do what? Force them to bleed almost to death? Some of us who have had miscarriages needed the d&c procedure because our bodies couldn't clean out pieces of fetal tissues. But what do we expect from ignorant reich wing male politicians?
@JesperMilling OK, jesper. I have lived here for 45 years and rarely come across anyone screaming. RUclips personalities of all nationalities are obnoxious. It's not an American thing. Lots to complain about here in America, but you're stretching here.
While I agree that we should abide by the culture when touring in different countries, I would like to state plainly that speaking loudly is a part of our culture. We are loud in America, it has become a part of daily life. I don't bat an eye passing by a loud group of friends. Because it is a part of our culture. I believe our politeness and passion is a pleasure. I am not shouting all the time as an American. I know when to be quiet, as do most Americans. I believe all countries have beautiful cultures. As a young man, I hope to learn more as I live and grow. We mean no harm by being loud. It is simply part of our daily life.
As you spoke of your children, I just kept seeing Gus Walz crying and saying “that’s my dad”. Such affection between a father and son is touching and kind and what real men are made of.
I grew up in the same evangelical house. My father told me I was marrying one of his drinking buddies. I told him I would never marry him and left that house as soon as I was able. I am thankful for the federal assistance given to our family. I am honored to pay taxes, have voted for democracy my entire life and I'm thrilled I left religion.
I am an atheist and a progressive Democrat. I have alllowed my frustration with the hypocrisy of fundamentalist Christianity to drive me to the brink of being anti-religious. When I am told that I have no place in America, or that I cannot have morals without God or that Atheists worship the devil..yeah, I can feel a bit isolated, expecially in this red state I live in. I once sat across the breakfast table at a restaraunt from my brother in law and told him about my atheism. His face turned red and his eyes flashed in anger and betrayal and we haven't had much to say to each other since. It's very sad. You're renewed my faith in people. Thank you, Frank.
I'm an agnostic and a traumatized ex-evangelical Christian. Oh, i understand the feeling of isolation since leaving evangelicalism after thirty years of being driven nuts by "my frustration with the hypocrisy." However, being true to one's core values is rational but being in a " religious club" that feigns love or loves only when it's convenient is neither rational nor psychologically sustainable. Best wishes to you, and be a conduit of joy and reason in your red state.
I am also an agnostic. And I no longer care about the reactions 28:25 I get from religious types when they learn this about me. Their judgmental, mean and sometimes hateful reactions say more about their dark hearts than 1000 words can say.
I am sorry that your ignorant, holier than tho, “Christian” ex-community treats you the way they do all because you dared to question, to think critically Let us hope we are all god’s children and he loves us all
Thank you for these wise comments. From a 73 yo grandma, on night duty watching my 7 week old grandson. I'm voting for kindness, decency, good people, the good neighbors of this world, most of all to preserve our nation and our democracy.
I was a big Reagan fan. I too believed I deserved all the privilieges I had and the rewards they brought. Of course, today I can see these privileges clearly and that few other people had them. The biggest shock was when the economy tanked in 2008 and I watched my retirement investments drop. I screamed for government to do something! The Republicans hemmed and hawed. I thought I should give the young Black man from Chicago a chance. I have never looked back. I watched in horror as Republicans, first slowly but then always faster, morphed into this Tea Party/MAGA monster full of immoral conmen, liars, and then violent insurrectionists. The Republican Party has become a criminal conspiracy.
Several times a week now, I remind people I know that the republican party is a terrorist organization. I refuse to capitalize the letter R for them, they don't warrant even that scrap of respect.
good words, thank you. If I may add: as Americans, and too often wealthy Americans, it is a belief that it comes with 'privilege'. I guess I believe that it comes with responsibility...to society as a whole, that gives opportunity, via so many societal structures, such as transportation systems, good public schools, equal opportunity under the law, and the ability to VOTE. I pray that the MAGA party loses big time. be well...
I voted for Reagan when I was young and on the corporate make, until I realized the nastiness of his "Welfare Queen" message. That was the end of conservatism for me! Vote Harris/Walz!
Reaganomics was fascism. It was only a matter of time. MAGA is the logical consequence of Reaganomics. Every time the GOP got an inch it took a mile. What they couldn’t even mention much less get away with in Reagan’s time they do shamelessly in ours.
This was one of the most significant comments I've read in a long time. It's shows the growth, reality and meaningful thoughts a person has gone thru and came out on the side of what's right for your fellow citizens as well as yourself❤
SO much respect for Mr. Schaeffer!! A good American, a good, kind, caring human. The world needs more like him! And a LOT less like Donald Trump and JD Vance!
Thank you for sharing your enlightenment. I pray you are reaching large numbers of other disenchanted Evangelicals, Republicans, and Independents. God blesses you for your integrity. Saul became Paul.
Thank you for one of the best descriptions of the party I am so proud to be part of. We aren't perfect but we keep working on being better. Kindness and respect for others were the guiding principles my parents taught my sisters and me, principles they both lived by. Thank you again neighbor.
Frank, I'm a 73 year old Canadian female who was never caught up in religious fundamentalism, or whatever you want to call it. In my life, however, I've suffered plenty from the patriarchal mindset, associated with the right-wing-ism you speak of, that still permeates, subtly and not-so-subtly, our society. I resonate so much with your words. I'm grateful for the transformation you've undergone and your purposeful willingness to share your story and views. THANK YOU. 💗 P.S. I've never wanted to be an American, except for now, so I could vote Democrat and see Kamala and Tim in the Whitehouse!
My heartfelt gratitude to you, Ramona, and all your countrymen and countrywomen who have expressed similar support to us in the USA. Canadians are a civil people, stout-hearted and stalwart, the best friends to have in a tight spot.
@Ramona After this election, even Trump does not win, tell Canadians not to rely on the friendship with USA as much as possible, get closer with the European countries instead. It's because there will be another Trump 3.0 or 4.0.
@@san209nha9 We're "close" neighbours, yes. On the US side of the Peace Arch border crossing south of Vancouver is a sign reading: ""Children of a common mother." (Reference to US and Canada originally being British colonies.) On the Canadian side are words from the Bible: "Brethren dwelling together in unity." AND, I hear your message loud and clear. We may be a large country geographically, but population wise, we are small. A former prime minister, Pierre Trudeau, told the Washington Press Club: "Living next to you is in some ways like sleeping with an elephant. No matter how friendly and even-tempered is the beast, if I can call it that, one is affected by every twitch and grunt."
I've always thought that the most blasphemous portion of Christianity was the teaching of young children that they were born into sin. And that they were so foul, and disgusting, and evil that God had to wash their filthy disgusting sins away by murdering his own son. And that that was an act of love, and if they didn't believe this ridiculous fiction that they would burn in hell, and deserve it. Blasphemous indeed. And secondly, something that I've never heard someone else talk about, is that the real root and font head of misogyny starts in Genesis when all of the fleshly sufferings of mankind are laid at woman's feet from the supposed "fall from grace" into our fleshly state due to her seduction by the serpent. How horrific is that.
Yes! When you’re woke your eyes are open, even the eyes to the soul. Rejoice if they call you woke. It means we’re working to progress our lives not trying to get back to America 1955!
It was supposed to be a people against the lies of the government onto its people. Now it's purely a far left ideology to destroy that movement and go entirely left field into pure insanity.
Not to contradict you but the term actually comes from the black community. I’ve been thinking about it a lot lately because the point was even though we’ve made so much progress racism is still alive and well. So not saying you’re wrong but the original lie was that racism was dead. The main people insisting on it of course are all mask off now. Now everyone is wide awake
As a 70 year old grampa with 3 daughters and 9 grandkids, Grampa Jim can totally understand where Frank is coming from. Thank you so much for your honesty, clarity, compassion, competence, and appropriate severity. Frank practically defines "response-ability" for what he has learned during his life. To err is human, let's "err on the side of kindness" and all blessings we need will follow. Thank you, Frank, for all you do. Very important stuff.
Ijust finished listening to the entire podcast. At first I wasn’t sure what to expect. I respect your opinion, and I to vote for kindness. I went from strong republican, to independent, to Never voting for another Republican until this MAGA mess is gone completely. Thank you for sharing your heart. As a 60 year old who remembers how hard it was for women in the 70’s and 80’s. I won’t go back.
@@deirdremorris9234 It’s the ONLY way effective change can happen. Our democracy involves not just the Executive branch, but it’s the Legislative branch that is truly responsible for creating & changing our laws. And hopefully creating better controls on our Judicial branch. 💙🇺🇸💙
Thank you Frank Schaeffer, please keep spreading your message. You have a perspective that not a lot of folks have, given your evangelical up bringing. The whole of America needs and deserves to hear this message!
God bless you, sir, for seeing the light and pulling yourself from the darkness. That’s the problem with those proclaiming their “faith” the loudest, it’s all about believing they’re better than other people, rather than becoming better people themselves
Well spoken Frank. I agree with you 100%. My wife and I used to follow the different candidates and voted on who we felt would represent America best and work for our country. Sadly, these last few elections we have voted against someone rather than for someone. I am voting blue because for once I see someone who has the country and its populace at heart and I think Kamala will do well for all of us.
I wish more people saw the Democrat party the way you and I see them. It's really touching how you talk about your grandchildren and your son. He sounds like a good man
I’m so very sorry for the intolerance you were taught and lived, but you’re a dedicated member of the enlightened life now and we are SO thankful that you are here!!
Beautiful way to express what the Democrat party means to those who appreciate it. It's fabulous and flawed, but it's inclusive at its core. It's the party of real freedom, but also the rule of law. I think more than anything, I want a fairer society that doesn't give privileged status to white, wealthy, cruel people. Most of the kindest people I know are spiritual but not religious. I'm still learning to be more kind. Your grandkids are lucky to have such a good and kind Ba. VOTE HARRIS-WALZ and BLUE to save our country. 💙🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊
Awesome…. I could not have said this any better. You brought tears to my eyes. This is the America I want for me, my children, my children’s children. God Bless you always.
I SO relate. My Father was VERY politically active & actually became a delegate for George Wallace's [last] convention appearance. I loved him, but was sad & confused about this. I assumed I would not live to be 18, having died during a beating. Mother was unloving & emotionally abusive. I was never hugged as a chld; not once. Our home was as suppressive & abusive (including emotional) as any Islamic home. I guess as repressive as yours & male-dominated. My self-realization & escape took literally decades, including two bad marriages. Phil Donahue (RIP) & "Dear Abby" parented me & am grateful they were available. Congradulations on your spiritual growth. Love is my companion now.
It does my heart good to hear the thoughts of another husband, father and grandfather that has softened in every way. I could run on but will not, Thank You.
Your grandchildren and children are very, very proud of you Frank. We all need to lead with kindness and follow up with empathy and caring about others.
As a Christian, I long ago decided if I was going to err, and we all err, I would do so on the side of kindness, generousity, good will, and humility. Have people taken advantage of me sometimes? Yes. Do I regret showing forgiveness and kindness in response? No. When I stand before Jesus at the end, will I be judged for empathy and compassion towards others whose choices I may not understand, but who are loved by Him as much as I have been? I may be wrong, but I don't think so. He is Love. He did not come into the world to judge it but to save it, one person at a time. Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Frank. They mirror my own.
Frank! I wish American churches had the opportunity to hear you speak on these topics. You have brought light and clarity and put into words what a lot of Christian’s haven’t been able to since Trump came on the scene. Thankyou
As a ex republican; we all follow the lead of people that raised us. I, like you, saw the errors of those who taught us their beliefs. Thank you for your story and honesty!
Thank you for your honesty, your humanity, and reality. I'm 80 and a caretaker of my grands , greatgrands, and others (special needs nephew). I thank God for democratic values.
I was raised in Soviet union. My parents were strict and father was physically abusive. But my grandmother spoiled me very much. And her love love still helps me in my life. Now I am spoiling my Grand children. I agree with you 100%.🇺🇸💙💙💙🙏
I had the same upbringing! I left the Baptist church after attending a Baptist University because I could not continue to be part of a group who refused to let women be part of the ministry! Since then I have grown tired of listening to men tell women how they should live, what they should do. I raised my son in a feminist household and he will tell you that himself. He is a good man. He loves his wife and adores the achievements his daughter has had as do I.
Frank, this one of most humbling things I have ever heard. We are different people from very different backgrounds and belief structures, but I was just rendered speechless. We may live opposite sides of the country, but I will gladly call you neighbor. You gave me hope in that idea of neighbors, of fellow countrymen, of humans. Thank you good sir, the world needs more like you. Peace
Never watched your channel before, and I’m glad I listened to your message of kindness. Wonderful message, and I’d be glad to be your neighbor. Thank you.
This has been the most erudite explanation of the difference between the current Republican Party and the Democratic Party. It is also the best argument for decency. You sir are a good man.
Thank you for what you are doing now to raise awareness about these dangerous Fundamentalist Christian Nationalists and their role in American Politics and beyond Love, Hugs and Peace
Thank you Frank for all you do, and for the best description of the Democratic Party, which speaks to why they have failed in the past, but also what makes them great.
I used to read your Father's writing, Frank. I am so proud of you and happy for you that you have rejected those thoughts, as have I. God bless you. Hang in there. Keep speaking and keep doing Good.
Just came across your channel, and want to thank you for the content. I am a 64 yr old Grandfather of three and a Kamila supporter. EVERYONE should hear your story. THANK YOU!!!
My deepest admiration for you Mr Schaeffer, your spectrum of experience is vast. Your final decision about what it means to be a blessed human spirit is priceless. TY for your integrity and love 🥀🕊️🤍
I am voting for kindness, equality, joy and love!💙
yes amen thank you so am I. government for ALL
Yes Ty this is how Yahushua treats us . He still is there for us no matter whatever we choose But does he get mad at us ; No He loves us unconditionally in spite of the fact we put our way ahead of His Sometimes we put Him on a back burner in our lives , But He always willing and welcomes us with open arms . Good on you Ba GBY . Thank your son for his service and thank you for sharing your testimony with us
"Strength Through Joy"....
Spoken over and over again at the DNC Convention.
Nazi talking point for election.
Look it up. Why am I not surprised. Nazi's
Ignorance knows no bounds. You won’t get any of those things from communists.
So you think anti-Christ communists will deliver that?? What utter fools.
I am a Christian in a RED state. I am a Democrat. You articulate what I have been feeling for a long time. I want to err on the side of kindness, love, forgiveness. Jesus did and still does. I attend church where everyone believes DT, because he is a Republican, is the only choice. I refuse to allow this man to divide me from my church - even if the people have the idea that because he is a Republican - he is the ONLY one they are ALLOWED to vote for. Thank you for your honesty. And I forgive you for being a part of the beginning of this "movement." You have opened your eyes, and your heart to the "world" on this website. You are a real man. I love that your grandchildren love you and know that you have their back.
When is tolerating intolerance ever acceptable? This is the paradox many are trapped in now. My response to Christian Nationalists and those who enable them is a quote from Bob Dylan's 'Masters of War.'
'Even Jesus Himself would never forgive what you do.'
@@pttpforever Amen
I will err through God's Graces of love forgiveness mercy no matter what sex gender race title gays lesbians, as what the commandment says Love Thine Neighbors Help the poor hungry these kind of people does not see that Trump is the number 1 sinner as well he has no moral compass an adulterer womanizer lies vengeful look at the 10 commandments he follows which character does Trump represent in the Bible? By the way pro choice is now under the State not under the Executive . They want Pro life but trump wants to cut all the support system food stamps health care education planned parenthood contraceptions.
@@pttpforever I hear you. As a Christian, its important to forgive, to leave room for people to screw up...yes..and sin, in the HOPE that they will see, learn, grow and be better! You dont become a doormat. You stand Your ground on what you have experienced. And sometimes we have to separate or go no contact. But love overcomes a multitude of sins. ❤
Jesus, our Lord, was the original liberal
I'm voting for America, democracy, Constitution, diversity, education and women's rights
That would be Donald J Trump and not a filthy communist Kamala who is against everything you’ve listed, despite the rhetoric. My goodness-the ignorance. The jaw-dropping ignorance of the propaganda-absorbing useful idiots. Communist regimes have always needed their useful idiots--and here you are for this one.
I'm very old and I'll. This may be my last chance to vote on this earth. Even if I have to crawl to the poles to vote, I'm thinking of my kids, grandkids and my 2 little great grands. Their future is in my precious Vote. This one's for you my wonderful family, to know Democracy, freedom and the right to make your own decisions in the future as an American Citizen.
Vote with love and empathy in your heart.
Grammy will be watching from Heaven.💙🇺🇲🛐👵
@@kathleenhack so you’re voting for Marxist Democrats who hate God, hate freedom, hate Democracy, hate decency, and hate the working class people of the country. What a horrible thing to leave your grandchildren.
@@kathleenhack You could vote early and/or by mail. Don't know what the rules are where you live. Just a suggestion. I hope you do vote, and live to see Kamala win and the end of this nightmare that is Trump. We are on the threshold. It will either be the darkness of Totalitarianism or Democracy and an inclusive future. That's how critical this moment in America's story is. It could go either way. Let's choose light over darkness.
That doesn't do anything about the loss of purchasing power of my dollars.
I was hesitant to listen to a Republican tell me what a Democrat is, but you did good Frank, you did good!😊😊😊
I agree. I was skeptical to even watch. But I thank all Republican voters that plan to vote for Harris to help save our country from the evil maga cult!
Glad I'm not the only one who was skeptical to watch lol. And I'm so glad I was wrong. ❤
Yeah, I was like hmm mmm. Glad I stopped to listen. And, to it all....
I'm always seeking those who capture what it is they see, from their unique vantage regarding the Republican Party throughout the last few decades and even the last 100 year's.
The Party of Lincoln back during those years leading up to the Civil War and right on up to the last noble torch bearers of what that Party used to be (like Teddy Roosevelt or Ike Eisenhower ) essentially embodied the principles and goals of opportunity and equality FOR ALL IS the Democratic Party of today!
So I'm always curious about folks with the experience of growing up differently like Frank to see how this could have ever happened so that I hopefully, grasp a bit more of how we as citizens and government can prevent the USA from going the way of these countries that have been decimated by non Democratic governments.
It seems like you believe in a world that may never exist, you probably believe in open borders, low testosterone.
It's not important what age you become a true man, just that you become one before you die...thank you Frank. A 68 yr old woman from Canada.
This 60 year old woman from Canada completely agrees. Than you so much Frank. I am sharing your message and vision wherever I can.
@@maxm5645 Greetings fellow Canuck ;)
So this is another galaxy far far away and even Darth vaders just have to do one last act to become anakin again?
Not sure that’s how it works, but I agree, it’s better than nothing.
Just joshing
Canada? Stop interfering in our elections.
TRUMP 2024
This 65 years old also from Canada, would say the same thing and would also add ' or a true women'.
As a 78 year old woman and single mother with 2 cats, I still have a headache from all the glass ceilings I hit. It did my heart good to hear this podcast today. Thank you for your kindness..
Same!! I can't believe that in 2024, we will have to fight yet again for our daughters and granddaughters reproductive rights! Before we had Roe, doctors were not prosecuted for using the d&c procedure needed in miscarriages. Now? Doctors can't use that procedure at all and women, who have miscarriages are given the abortion pill to do what? Force them to bleed almost to death? Some of us who have had miscarriages needed the d&c procedure because our bodies couldn't clean out pieces of fetal tissues. But what do we expect from ignorant reich wing male politicians?
An american who isnt shouting, but just speaking? what a rare pleasure.
What the hell does that even mean?
@@badgerboy97 Americans are usually very loud, even when they make videos for RUclips. They raise their voices and shout instead of just speaking.
@JesperMilling OK, jesper. I have lived here for 45 years and rarely come across anyone screaming. RUclips personalities of all nationalities are obnoxious. It's not an American thing. Lots to complain about here in America, but you're stretching here.
Believe me, it's a thing, ask anyone working with tourists in Europe.
While I agree that we should abide by the culture when touring in different countries, I would like to state plainly that speaking loudly is a part of our culture. We are loud in America, it has become a part of daily life. I don't bat an eye passing by a loud group of friends. Because it is a part of our culture.
I believe our politeness and passion is a pleasure. I am not shouting all the time as an American. I know when to be quiet, as do most Americans.
I believe all countries have beautiful cultures. As a young man, I hope to learn more as I live and grow.
We mean no harm by being loud. It is simply part of our daily life.
As you spoke of your children, I just kept seeing Gus Walz crying and saying “that’s my dad”. Such affection between a father and son is touching and kind and what real men are made of.
💙 True! From the Pro-Democracy 💙TEAM GUS! 💙
Very true! It was so refreshing to see
I wish every American would watch this. Beautiful.
SHARE IT WIDELY! an old pink male will be watched by other old pink males...until they find out what he's speaking about. still, share him`!
I grew up in the same evangelical house. My father told me I was marrying one of his drinking buddies. I told him I would never marry him and left that house as soon as I was able. I am thankful for the federal assistance given to our family. I am honored to pay taxes, have voted for democracy my entire life and I'm thrilled I left religion.
So sorry to hear you had a father that so badly misrepresented biblical principles.
Well done, Sally, and thank you from the 💛💙Pro-Democracy chorus . 💙Kindness counts! 💙
WELL DONE FRANK TELLING THE TRUTH ABOUT RELIGIOUS CULTS.
Yes. All religions are cults by definition.
Pseudo religious you mean, right? 🤔
I am an atheist and a progressive Democrat. I have alllowed my frustration with the hypocrisy of fundamentalist Christianity to drive me to the brink of being anti-religious. When I am told that I have no place in America, or that I cannot have morals without God or that Atheists worship the devil..yeah, I can feel a bit isolated, expecially in this red state I live in. I once sat across the breakfast table at a restaraunt from my brother in law and told him about my atheism. His face turned red and his eyes flashed in anger and betrayal and we haven't had much to say to each other since. It's very sad. You're renewed my faith in people. Thank you, Frank.
I'm an agnostic and a traumatized ex-evangelical Christian. Oh, i understand the feeling of isolation since leaving evangelicalism after thirty years of being driven nuts by "my frustration with the hypocrisy." However, being true to one's core values is rational but being in a " religious club" that feigns love or loves only when it's convenient is neither rational nor psychologically sustainable. Best wishes to you, and be a conduit of joy and reason in your red state.
I am also an agnostic. And I no longer care about the reactions 28:25 I get from religious types when they learn this about me. Their judgmental, mean and sometimes hateful reactions say more about their dark hearts than 1000 words can say.
I am an atheist and anti-religionist. Many of us are much more moral and Christ-like than most "christians".
I am sorry that your ignorant, holier than tho, “Christian” ex-community treats you the way they do all because you dared to question, to think critically
Let us hope we are all god’s children and he loves us all
I’m so sick of being saturated with the misogynistic Christian mythology and hypocrisy!!
Thank you Frank .You have a Spine of Steel.We need 80 million like you.
Thank you for these wise comments. From a 73 yo grandma, on night duty watching my 7 week old grandson. I'm voting for kindness, decency, good people, the good neighbors of this world, most of all to preserve our nation and our democracy.
"Kindness is my religion" - the Dalai Lama
I love that quote. I admit for me, Kindness is my aspiration, I'm not as far along on this as his Holiness.
Thank you Frank from a 75 year old woman from Australia.
I have tears in my heart because you have talked about a compassion that I’ve not heard in a long time! Thank you, thank you! ❤
I was a big Reagan fan. I too believed I deserved all the privilieges I had and the rewards they brought. Of course, today I can see these privileges clearly and that few other people had them. The biggest shock was when the economy tanked in 2008 and I watched my retirement investments drop. I screamed for government to do something! The Republicans hemmed and hawed. I thought I should give the young Black man from Chicago a chance. I have never looked back. I watched in horror as Republicans, first slowly but then always faster, morphed into this Tea Party/MAGA monster full of immoral conmen, liars, and then violent insurrectionists. The Republican Party has become a criminal conspiracy.
Several times a week now, I remind people I know that the republican party is a terrorist organization. I refuse to capitalize the letter R for them, they don't warrant even that scrap of respect.
good words, thank you. If I may add: as Americans, and too often wealthy Americans, it is a belief that it comes with 'privilege'. I guess I believe that it comes with responsibility...to society as a whole, that gives opportunity, via so many societal structures, such as transportation systems, good public schools, equal opportunity under the law, and the ability to VOTE. I pray that the MAGA party loses big time. be well...
I voted for Reagan when I was young and on the corporate make, until I realized the nastiness of his "Welfare Queen" message. That was the end of conservatism for me! Vote Harris/Walz!
Reaganomics was fascism. It was only a matter of time. MAGA is the logical consequence of Reaganomics. Every time the GOP got an inch it took a mile. What they couldn’t even mention much less get away with in Reagan’s time they do shamelessly in ours.
This was one of the most significant comments I've read in a long time. It's shows the growth, reality and meaningful thoughts a person has gone thru and came out on the side of what's right for your fellow citizens as well as yourself❤
SO much respect for Mr. Schaeffer!! A good American, a good, kind, caring human. The world needs more like him! And a LOT less like Donald Trump and JD Vance!
Thank you for sharing your enlightenment. I pray you are reaching large numbers of other disenchanted Evangelicals, Republicans, and Independents. God blesses you for your integrity.
Saul became Paul.
Thank you for one of the best descriptions of the party I am so proud to be part of. We aren't perfect but we keep working on being better. Kindness and respect for others were the guiding principles my parents taught my sisters and me, principles they both lived by. Thank you again neighbor.
Thanks for reaching out Frank, we need couple hundred million more like you.
Frank, I'm a 73 year old Canadian female who was never caught up in religious fundamentalism, or whatever you want to call it. In my life, however, I've suffered plenty from the patriarchal mindset, associated with the right-wing-ism you speak of, that still permeates, subtly and not-so-subtly, our society. I resonate so much with your words. I'm grateful for the transformation you've undergone and your purposeful willingness to share your story and views. THANK YOU. 💗
P.S. I've never wanted to be an American, except for now, so I could vote Democrat and see Kamala and Tim in the Whitehouse!
Ditto!
Peace to you, sister... fellow Canadian.
My heartfelt gratitude to you, Ramona, and all your countrymen and countrywomen who have expressed similar support to us in the USA. Canadians are a civil people, stout-hearted and stalwart, the best friends to have in a tight spot.
@Ramona After this election, even Trump does not win, tell Canadians not to rely on the friendship with USA as much as possible, get closer with the European countries instead. It's because there will be another Trump 3.0 or 4.0.
@@san209nha9 We're "close" neighbours, yes. On the US side of the Peace Arch border crossing south of Vancouver is a sign reading: ""Children of a common mother." (Reference to US and Canada originally being British colonies.) On the Canadian side are words from the Bible: "Brethren dwelling together in unity." AND, I hear your message loud and clear.
We may be a large country geographically, but population wise, we are small.
A former prime minister, Pierre Trudeau, told the Washington Press Club: "Living next to you is in some ways like sleeping with an elephant. No matter how friendly and even-tempered is the beast, if I can call it that, one is affected by every twitch and grunt."
I've always thought that the most blasphemous portion of Christianity was the teaching of young children that they were born into sin. And that they were so foul, and disgusting, and evil that God had to wash their filthy disgusting sins away by murdering his own son. And that that was an act of love, and if they didn't believe this ridiculous fiction that they would burn in hell, and deserve it. Blasphemous indeed.
And secondly, something that I've never heard someone else talk about, is that the real root and font head of misogyny starts in Genesis when all of the fleshly sufferings of mankind are laid at woman's feet from the supposed "fall from grace" into our fleshly state due to her seduction by the serpent. How horrific is that.
well-said.
Hey, at least the story of Lilith didn't make it into Genesis! 😈
This is a religion that worships the image of a naked man being tortured to death.
Absolutely 💯
I hear you. For us who still stand on faith, trust Jesus message, it is quite a journey deconstructing Institutional Christianty. ❤
This is all that ‘woke’ ever meant.
Waking up from the lies we’ve been given
Yes! When you’re woke your eyes are open, even the eyes to the soul. Rejoice if they call you woke. It means we’re working to progress our lives not trying to get back to America 1955!
It was supposed to be a people against the lies of the government onto its people. Now it's purely a far left ideology to destroy that movement and go entirely left field into pure insanity.
Not to contradict you but the term actually comes from the black community. I’ve been thinking about it a lot lately because the point was even though we’ve made so much progress racism is still alive and well. So not saying you’re wrong but the original lie was that racism was dead. The main people insisting on it of course are all mask off now. Now everyone is wide awake
As a 70 year old grampa with 3 daughters and 9 grandkids, Grampa Jim can totally understand where Frank is coming from. Thank you so much for your honesty, clarity, compassion, competence, and appropriate severity. Frank practically defines "response-ability" for what he has learned during his life.
To err is human, let's "err on the side of kindness" and all blessings we need will follow. Thank you, Frank, for all you do. Very important stuff.
Ijust finished listening to the entire podcast. At first I wasn’t sure what to expect. I respect your opinion, and I to vote for kindness. I went from strong republican, to independent, to Never voting for another Republican until this MAGA mess is gone completely. Thank you for sharing your heart. As a 60 year old who remembers how hard it was for women in the 70’s and 80’s. I won’t go back.
Right? Same here. I think I may vote Democrat all the way down the list. ❤
Please do. Project 2025 will end our democracy and we can't trust current GOP as they are party of MAGA now. These are NOT old-school Republicans.
@@deirdremorris9234 Please do!!! That way we can get all the good things accomplished!
@@jodyartur2617 That, and we absolutely cannot have Trump as president! The Heritage folks et all, are sprinkled throughout government.
@@deirdremorris9234 It’s the ONLY way effective change can happen. Our democracy involves not just the Executive branch, but it’s the Legislative branch that is truly responsible for creating & changing our laws. And hopefully creating better controls on our Judicial branch. 💙🇺🇸💙
All Republican voters need to watch this
"Groomed to be an a..hole by DIVINE RIGHT" ... Someone finally said it. Thy, Frank ...
Thank you Frank Schaeffer, please keep spreading your message. You have a perspective that not a lot of folks have, given your evangelical up bringing. The whole of America needs and deserves to hear this message!
"To err on the side of kindness" a beautiful description of the best of Christianity.
There are very few people in this world I have more respect for than Frank Schaeffer. I mean that, What an incredible, thoughtful human being.
I second that emotion.
Well said
God bless you, sir, for seeing the light and pulling yourself from the darkness.
That’s the problem with those proclaiming their “faith” the loudest, it’s all about believing they’re better than other people, rather than becoming better people themselves
I'm a Democrat...of course you are forgiven. Guilt is unproductive, so don't indulge.
Well spoken Frank. I agree with you 100%. My wife and I used to follow the different candidates and voted on who we felt would represent America best and work for our country. Sadly, these last few elections we have voted against someone rather than for someone. I am voting blue because for once I see someone who has the country and its populace at heart and I think Kamala will do well for all of us.
I wish more people saw the Democrat party the way you and I see them. It's really touching how you talk about your grandchildren and your son. He sounds like a good man
I am 70 years young. I will take kindness. God bless you Frank.
Let’s hope more Republican’s see the light as you have⭐️🥳⭐️
I’m so very sorry for the intolerance you were taught and lived, but you’re a dedicated member of the enlightened life now and we are SO thankful that you are here!!
Thank you Frank, this is wonderful.
Beautiful way to express what the Democrat party means to those who appreciate it. It's fabulous and flawed, but it's inclusive at its core. It's the party of real freedom, but also the rule of law. I think more than anything, I want a fairer society that doesn't give privileged status to white, wealthy, cruel people. Most of the kindest people I know are spiritual but not religious. I'm still learning to be more kind. Your grandkids are lucky to have such a good and kind Ba. VOTE HARRIS-WALZ and BLUE to save our country. 💙🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊
yes, that is why the Biden Harris Admin colluded with social media to censor political descent, usurping the 1st Amendment, very inclusive.
Awesome…. I could not have said this any better. You brought tears to my eyes. This is the America I want for me, my children, my children’s children. God Bless you always.
Your grandchildten are so blessed to have you!!!
Saying yes to grandchildren all the time is not love. don't be fooled by this tripe
Thank you, Frank for speaking the truth. I'm a proud Democrat.
I SO relate. My Father was VERY politically active & actually became a delegate for George Wallace's [last] convention appearance. I loved him, but was sad & confused about this. I assumed I would not live to be 18, having died during a beating. Mother was unloving & emotionally abusive. I was never hugged as a chld; not once. Our home was as suppressive & abusive (including emotional) as any Islamic home. I guess as repressive as yours & male-dominated. My self-realization & escape took literally decades, including two bad marriages. Phil Donahue (RIP) & "Dear Abby" parented me & am grateful they were available. Congradulations on your spiritual growth. Love is my companion now.
It does my heart good to hear the thoughts of another husband, father and grandfather that has softened in every way. I could run on but will not, Thank You.
Fantastic video Frank! I am so impressed with your discourse.
Your grandchildren and children are very, very proud of you Frank. We all need to lead with kindness and follow up with empathy and caring about others.
Bless you, Mr. Schaeffer. You are, indeed, a most wise man.
As a Christian, I long ago decided if I was going to err, and we all err, I would do so on the side of kindness, generousity, good will, and humility. Have people taken advantage of me sometimes? Yes. Do I regret showing forgiveness and kindness in response? No. When I stand before Jesus at the end, will I be judged for empathy and compassion towards others whose choices I may not understand, but who are loved by Him as much as I have been? I may be wrong, but I don't think so. He is Love. He did not come into the world to judge it but to save it, one person at a time. Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Frank. They mirror my own.
Frank! I wish American churches had the opportunity to hear you speak on these topics. You have brought light and clarity and put into words what a lot of Christian’s haven’t been able to since Trump came on the scene. Thankyou
Epic Testimonial.
Thank you for your honesty and integrity. Your words need to be heard by every person who loves their country.
Wicked is the word. Thank you for standing up for what's right, and standing in the face of this evil.
Thank you Frank. This was a great podcast. All of your podcasts resonate with me! I am most grateful to you!
I think you’re a lovely and enlightened person❣️
As a ex republican; we all follow the lead of people that raised us. I, like you, saw the errors of those who taught us their beliefs. Thank you for your story and honesty!
Thank you Frank. You're my hero.
Thank you for your honesty, your humanity, and reality. I'm 80 and a caretaker of my grands , greatgrands, and others (special needs nephew). I thank God for democratic values.
Frank Schaeffer, great content keep up the good content
I was raised in Soviet union. My parents were strict and father was physically abusive. But my grandmother spoiled me very much. And her love love still helps me in my life. Now I am spoiling my Grand children. I agree with you 100%.🇺🇸💙💙💙🙏
I enjoyed hearing what you had to say Frank. Thank you.
Great speech Frank, you make me want to believe again.
It was a pleasure to listen to you
Frank, I will take you for a neighbor any day! Thank you for your service to our country!❤❤
Thank you, Frank, for everything you are saying.
I love your honesty and courage to speak out.❤
Cudos to you Frank, many would not come clean about mistakes, we are all Gods children. Vote Blue. 🔵🔵
I had the same upbringing! I left the Baptist church after attending a Baptist University because I could not continue to be part of a group who refused to let women be part of the ministry! Since then I have grown tired of listening to men tell women how they should live, what they should do. I raised my son in a feminist household and he will tell you that himself. He is a good man. He loves his wife and adores the achievements his daughter has had as do I.
Gerald Ford was the first, last, and only Republican presidential candidate I ever voted for. I think, maybe, I was really voting for Betty.
The last great Republican president was Ike. One helluva man, a true patriot and wise leader.
Thanks, Frank, please keep up the good work! Spread the word! Defeat trump. Vote BLUE!
I'm with YOU, Frank. Thank you and BLESS you for speaking out this way. It's absolutely beautiful 💚💙💜
Frank, this one of most humbling things I have ever heard. We are different people from very different backgrounds and belief structures, but I was just rendered speechless. We may live opposite sides of the country, but I will gladly call you neighbor. You gave me hope in that idea of neighbors, of fellow countrymen, of humans. Thank you good sir, the world needs more like you. Peace
Healing and strengthening balm for broken souls. God bless you and your family forever.
Appreciate you Frank, thank you.
Thank you....tears form with your sincerity and compassion. Voting Blue
voting for a good neighbor!
Never watched your channel before, and I’m glad I listened to your message of kindness. Wonderful message, and I’d be glad to be your neighbor. Thank you.
I'm Voting 💙 so that I can Vote 💙 again, I'm Voting 💙 for my DAUGHTERS RIGHTS! 💙, I'm voting 💙 against Hate and for HEALING! BLUE 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
You must hate your daughter's baby if she gets pregnant. Just flush it down the toilet...right?
Vote to vote again.
This has been the most erudite explanation of the difference between the current Republican Party and the Democratic Party. It is also the best argument for decency. You sir are a good man.
Thank you for what you are doing now to raise awareness about these dangerous Fundamentalist Christian Nationalists and their role in American Politics and beyond
Love, Hugs and Peace
Thank you Frank for all you do, and for the best description of the Democratic Party, which speaks to why they have failed in the past, but also what makes them great.
Kamala Harris is qualified by her intelligence, her work history, and her compassion. Thank you ❤
@@susanr1903: The man was cleared, and awarded 13 million dollars...
Please visit online to Oakland in California her hometown! Please! Then come back to figure it out!☝️
I used to read your Father's writing, Frank. I am so proud of you and happy for you that you have rejected those thoughts, as have I. God bless you. Hang in there. Keep speaking and keep doing Good.
A very compassionate and bright person you are!
THANK YOU FRANK THAT WAS SO TRUE AND SO IMPORTANT. GOD BLESS YOU
Sins of kindness of trying to include everyone, acceptance is all that everyone wants. Thanks Frank for your insights and for being a good neighbor.
You are preaching about the practical love of Jesus! It has been so missing from our public discourse. This is like medicine to my soul. Thank You!
Thank You Frank for sharing your honest, sincere and helpful insights. It is highly appreciated. 😎
Frank, your truthful sharing from your life is very instructive, good info to follow in building a kind, well-lived life. Thank you.
I have always been a democrat. I love how you express your thoughts about the Democratic Party. Keep it up. Thanks
God bless you, Frank!
Just came across your channel, and want to thank you for the content. I am a 64 yr old Grandfather of three and a Kamila supporter. EVERYONE should hear your story. THANK YOU!!!
Loving kindness to you!
EXCELLENT! BULLSEYE! PERSPECTIVE IS EVERYTHING!
My deepest admiration for you Mr Schaeffer, your spectrum of experience is vast. Your final decision about what it means to be a blessed human spirit is priceless. TY for your integrity and love 🥀🕊️🤍
Dearest Frank!!!! GOD BLESS YOU!!! SOOOO MANY BLESSINGS TO YOU.....FOR GOD.....IS.....LOVE.....AND ....LOVE.....FOR ALL PEOPLE!!
Thank you sir for speaking such powerful truth with courage and honesty ! 💙 💙 💙
You are a light in this world, Frank.
Thank you Frank. I would love to be your neighbor.
You have a beautiful heart. Thank you.