In 1954 at the age of 9, I discovered this piece in what I remember as sounding exactly like this performance, in a neglected stash of records. I remember being near tears at its beauty. It is no less beautiful now that I am older and supposedly understand the music better. Rubinstein understands and respects Chopin like no one else!
Everything was phenomenal about Rubinstein!. His personality, his supreme musicality... his concentration, his utmost respect for the music he was interpreting, his complete lack of pyrotechnics, his abandonment in performance...
Rubinstein was one of the all time greats his sound was unique, beautifull and singining, virile, positve full of life and spirit and nobility,... many pianists should learn learn from the master,...
А я была на этом концерте! Большой Зал Консерватории, начало октября 1964 г. Только что в институт поступила. Я просто обалдела от исполнения Артура Игнатьевича. Это идеальный Шопен. Романтики фортепиано - и автор, и исполнитель.
simply wonderful. thank you so much for posting! Rubinstein's Chopin has always transfixed me, and it is so nice to see such rare footage of him playing one of my all-time favorites!
Rubinstein always played Chopin with grace, style and elan. He had a fantastic intellect as well as great pianistic talent. One could surmise that the magnificent Barcarolle was the culmination of Chopin's stupendous talent. In my audio collection I have over 40 pianists performing this gem. My top favorites are Bella Davidovich, Vladimir Ashkenazy and Takako Takahashi and Juana Zayas. By no means am I disparaging Rubinstein, but if you love the Barcarolle, take a listen to these other fine artists.
Rubinstein always refers to this piece in his autobiographies as "my beloved Barcarolle". You can tell how special this piece was to him by the way he plays it. He puts in ritards and accelerandos where they're not indicated. Sometimes, depending on the recording, he will play bass notes an octave lower than written and ignore ties. The effect is wonderful. I wonder if Chopin played this exactly the same way each time. I doubt it.
It's worth hearing R's earlier recorded performance of this music 1928 (he made a number of later recording too) he was a pianist who could make the piano sing -he tried always to preserve the long line of the music -he saw it as a whole. Many people have remarked about how when he played it "seemed" to them, "right" even though they would play it differently. Barenboim mentioned this (Richter had admiration 4 R) see G Gould's comment on R & Guarneri quartet playing Brahms's piano quintet
Rubinstein is a consumate artist....let those commentors who are so critical give us their performance. Rubinstein's performace is not only flawless, it is unheard of by the pianists in the commecials scene of today!
Rubenstein told a story about this piece. Horowitz had arrived on the scene, preempting Rubenstein. At a brilliant Horowitz recital, one of Rubenstein's supporters said consolingly to him, "The Barcarolle will always be yours." "You can imagine how this cut me," he wrote. The piece is still his.
I don't think you have even heard the majority of Rubinstein's numerous recordings. There is absolutely no modern equivalent to his playing, nor was there a pianist who mastered Chopin like he did in his day.
I haven't heard Richter's performance for many years but I recall being impressed by it. As a piece it certainly ranks up there with the Barcarolle in terms of the subtlety of the notation.
completamente de acuerdo...Rubinstein fue un grande entre los realmente grandes...y muchos se atreven a compararlo con Pollini...dios mio! Pollini es simplemente un pianista mas que gano un concurso importante y salto a la fama...Rubinstein es Rubinstein
One of the best I've heard. Very few pianists play the Chopin Barcarolle well. Among the versions I've heard, I feel this and the one by Kristian Zimerman are the best. Zimerman seems a little mannered in his gestures, but if one can ignore that, it is very good.
Please erpooh- every note has substance and backed by a musicality that is awesome. Rubinstein was one of the greatest of the 20th century- other may have had more technic, but none came close to his understanding of any composition he performed.
This is my favorite of all Chopin's works (my favorite performance is by Lipatti). Is the introduction improvised by Rubinstein, or is there some edition that actually reads like that? Several other places in this performance sound like memory slips as well, but perhaps Rubinstein had an alternate score... Anyway, the interpretation is (otherwise) very beautiful. Thank you for posting this beautiful and rare recording of this seldom performed piece.
tengo una carta a manuescrita por el...fechada en 1919 agradeciendo a mi tatarabuelo (quien era fabricante y afinador de pianos) por afinarle un piano para un concierto en Monterrey... lo cito "...ya que nunca he tocado un piano mejor afinado..." curioso no?
Muy interesante. No sabía que también dio recital en Monterrey en esa época . Rubinstein dio grandes temporadas en México por 40 años. Las de 1919 1921 dejaron honda huella por su propuesta innovadora en programa, por ejemplo. Según el maestro en sus memorias, el mexicano uno de los más cálidos y mejores públicos del mundo por su sensibilidad...
This is a beautifully poised performance, poetic and passionate in equal measure. The tempo never drags or rushes but is always flexible to the needs of the music. Given the poor quality picture, the sound is remarkably good. What is the year of the performance? Thanks for a great post.
I have no idea what piano he used.-I thought it worth mentioning his earlier performance because it is widely regarded as a great performance. Sachs: "the 1928 recording..(London April 18th 1928) for instance is amazing in it's mixture of quiet intimacy, melodic splendor, mounting eroticism, and dazzling explosion of joy....one of the most important etc., p 428. My CD sounds reasonable with very little hiss. And it certainly is an evocative performance -easy 2 buy cheap too. frogmanpiano
1) The appoggiature should be played on the beat. 2) The tempo accelerates gradually through the three blocks of material until slowing at the return of the opening.
Chopin had never been to Venice, but while in Nohant, he heard a description of the gondolieri and their songs from Delacroiz, recently returned. My understanding is that this was Chopin's inspiration: the swaying of the gondola, a guitar, a secret kiss beneath a bridge, warm night, shimmering brilliant reflections in the canal. Is there a piece more parlante than this?
Thanks, that was what I signed on to say. The Lipatti version of this Barcarole is one of the most perfect recordings ever created. I love Rubinstein as well, but there is something other-worldy about Lipatti. Does anyone out there in the ether have a Lipatti video? Does such a thing exist?
Rubinstein's "masculine", unsentimental rendition of Chopin's Barcarolle convincingly reveals its undercurrent of epic, "heroic" dignity (unlike some shallower "salon" interpretations of other pianists who merely indulge in the sentimentality of the Barcarolle's "lyrical" salon façade).
My attention was brought to the ongoing discussion between Bruce88keys and MASTERCLASSES. Since these 2 users are not able to have a civilized discussion I decided to remove all their "literary contributions" and to block them. I posted these videos (and other ones) because I believe their not available commonly and because I want to share them with people who can enjoy them or who try to see them as "educational". SO PLEASE! ... IF I MAY ASK KEEP IT CIVILIZED!!!
Well, who would've thought that a fine artist like Rubinstein (I attended one of his last concerts), leads to such reactions. Apparently this discussion thread is leading away from what RUclips is all about. Donaldcallen is right and I will look elsewhere for more value in thought.
Again- these anti-Rubinstein folks have me wondering if they have cotton in their ears! Whatever Rubinstein performed was honest, sincere, and supported with an enormous technic tempered by blazing musicianship and style. He never played an insecure note of music in his life!!
Видеоклипы
He embodies the nobility of spirit and passion that is the essence of Chopin. An incredible master playing a signature work.
In 1954 at the age of 9, I discovered this piece in what I remember as sounding exactly like this performance, in a neglected stash of records. I remember being near tears at its beauty. It is no less beautiful now that I am older and supposedly understand the music better. Rubinstein understands and respects Chopin like no one else!
Phyllis, I couldn't agree w/ you more...even at my ripe ol age of 58 ~
Everything was phenomenal about Rubinstein!. His personality, his supreme musicality... his concentration, his utmost respect for the music he was interpreting, his complete lack of pyrotechnics, his abandonment in performance...
Rubinstien is the best performer of Chopin with no doubt.
Wonderful... doesn't matter how many times I watch it, I am moved to tears. Impeccable musical timing and expression...
Rubinstein was one of the all time greats his sound was unique, beautifull and singining, virile, positve full of life and spirit and nobility,... many pianists should learn learn from the master,...
Listening to this performance is surely one of the most transcendental musical experiences I have ever had.
Came across thia again-Rubinstein's Chopin is virile, passionate, musical, exact, yet has a supreme calmness-AWESOME and inspirational
А я была на этом концерте! Большой Зал Консерватории, начало октября 1964 г. Только что в институт поступила. Я просто обалдела от исполнения Артура Игнатьевича. Это идеальный Шопен. Романтики фортепиано - и автор, и исполнитель.
Поздравляю!! Здоровья Вам!
Piękno muzyki Fryderyka Chopina to fenomen graniczący z cudem ❤️
One of our greatest pianists ever. Magnificent!
My favorite Chopin piece by my favorite pianist.
A trick : watch movies at Kaldrostream. Me and my gf have been using it for watching lots of of movies during the lockdown.
@Bryce Colton definitely, I have been watching on Kaldrostream for years myself :)
@@milojames510 cringe bot advertising which is absolutely off the topic of the video
He is a magician, just incredible.
What a treat!! This is one of my favorite pieces. This must be my lucky day!
No one can compare, such a beautiful interpretation…
This is by far the greatest interpretation of Chopin's op. 60 I have ever heard.
It’s that heartbreaking simplicity around 9’00 that I really adore...
This indeed a rare privilege. I thank you from the bottom of my heart for sharing this.
simply wonderful. thank you so much for posting! Rubinstein's Chopin has always transfixed me, and it is so nice to see such rare footage of him playing one of my all-time favorites!
This stuff gives me the shivers.
"YES, HE IS DEFINITELY THAT GOOD!"...RIP
Twotea22- these videos are MORE than educational-they are food for the soul!
The actor James Cagney said it best: "Some performers can just come out and fill-up the entire stage!" This was certainly true of Rubinstein...
Arcydzieło, rewelacja ! Chopinie, geniuszu ❤️
I love the physical and emotional abandon with which he plays leading up to the climax at 6:40 and afterwards. What passion.
Wonderful use of his body, very economical.
How wonderfully still he sits!
It's the little things that reveal the truly great ones...
Magnífico, que dominio del tempo. Rubinstein, un de los grandes caballeros del piano...como pocos. Thanks for this rare material.
This is from a performance in September of 1964; the first time Rubinstein had performed in Russa since 1932.
Rubinstein always played Chopin with grace, style and elan. He had a fantastic intellect as well as great pianistic talent. One could surmise that the magnificent Barcarolle was the culmination of Chopin's stupendous talent. In my audio collection I have over 40 pianists performing this gem. My top favorites are Bella Davidovich, Vladimir Ashkenazy and Takako Takahashi and Juana Zayas. By no means am I disparaging Rubinstein, but if you love the Barcarolle, take a listen to these other fine artists.
FANTASTIC!!!!!
I love the sound of his right hand, especially ♥
clear, deep, bright & comfortable....♥♥♥
this is so beautiful
thanks for posting
Just fabulous! Better than the studio recordings!
My favorite pianist!
Rubinstein always refers to this piece in his autobiographies as "my beloved Barcarolle". You can tell how special this piece was to him by the way he plays it. He puts in ritards and accelerandos where they're not indicated. Sometimes, depending on the recording, he will play bass notes an octave lower than written and ignore ties. The effect is wonderful.
I wonder if Chopin played this exactly the same way each time. I doubt it.
It's worth hearing R's earlier recorded performance of this music 1928 (he made a number of later recording too) he was a pianist who could make the piano sing -he tried always to preserve the long line of the music -he saw it as a whole. Many people have remarked about how when he played it "seemed" to them, "right" even though they would play it differently. Barenboim mentioned this (Richter had admiration 4 R) see G Gould's comment on R & Guarneri quartet playing Brahms's piano quintet
Brilliance...nothing else can explain it
Rubinstein is a consumate artist....let those commentors who are so critical give us their performance. Rubinstein's performace is not only flawless, it is unheard of by the pianists in the commecials scene of today!
Thanks for posting this!
Rubenstein told a story about this piece. Horowitz had arrived on the scene, preempting Rubenstein. At a brilliant Horowitz recital, one of Rubenstein's supporters said consolingly to him, "The Barcarolle will always be yours." "You can imagine how this cut me," he wrote. The piece is still his.
THE greatest, I would say.
bless you for posting!
Fantastic!
it is amazing how he can play like this at the rare age (very old). Thank you for sharing!
You ought to see the **WONDERFUL** documentary "Rubinstein at 90" (ignore the Spanish subtitles): ruclips.net/video/hleasPwRSrY/видео.html
Magnifique!
Such aristocratic and beautiful playing. Rubenstein's interpretation of Chopin is always true to the Polish idiom and spirit.
Thanks twotea22..once again if all you ever post are these AR videos then you done many a great service
Great, I'd watched a cleaned version of this, early in this afternoon on Mezzo. Didn't know it was available on RUclips since 2006
I wish people would play this piece more today. People are so stuck on Chopin's ballades and etudes. Those have been played to death.
Great, I'd watched this early in this afternoon a cleaned edition on Mezzo, and didn't know it was on RUclips since 2006!
.. ah, Grand Maestro .. those who hv ears .. Let them hear then .. incomparable ..
I don't think you have even heard the majority of Rubinstein's numerous recordings.
There is absolutely no modern equivalent to his playing, nor was there a pianist who mastered Chopin like he did in his day.
I have been playing it for 40 years. Perhaps I'll post it.
@paulprocopolis, am also amazed at the sound quality. Crystal clear.
I haven't heard Richter's performance for many years but I recall being impressed by it. As a piece it certainly ranks up there with the Barcarolle in terms of the subtlety of the notation.
completamente de acuerdo...Rubinstein fue un grande entre los realmente grandes...y muchos se atreven a compararlo con Pollini...dios mio! Pollini es simplemente un pianista mas que gano un concurso importante y salto a la fama...Rubinstein es Rubinstein
One of the best I've heard. Very few pianists play the Chopin Barcarolle well. Among the versions I've heard, I feel this and the one by Kristian Zimerman are the best. Zimerman seems a little mannered in his gestures, but if one can ignore that, it is very good.
Thank you! Somehow i already suspected this!
imo one of the most genius pieces of piano music.
Astounding old live performance of Rubinstein! Looks like the 1940s, when he was only in his 60s!
@maikabright ...Flawless!
Arthur lives forever for us.
@brahmsian1stever ... Thank - You - Very - Much!!!! I couldn't have said it better!
Please erpooh- every note has substance and backed by a musicality that is awesome. Rubinstein was one of the greatest of the 20th century- other may have had more technic, but none came close to his understanding of any composition he performed.
At 7:25 total music bliss..I've said this once before thanks twotea22 for these wonderful videos
lol...you dare to tell Rubinstein how to play? I want to see you play this!
This is my favorite of all Chopin's works (my favorite performance is by Lipatti).
Is the introduction improvised by Rubinstein, or is there some edition that actually reads like that? Several other places in this performance sound like memory slips as well, but perhaps Rubinstein had an alternate score... Anyway, the interpretation is (otherwise) very beautiful. Thank you for posting this beautiful and rare recording of this seldom performed piece.
GOAT
Those lucky Russians in that audience!!!!
Rubinstein...this is music
I love this! Saw him at a concert San Francisco mid-60s. Any RUclips links to his apparent encore?
tengo una carta a manuescrita por el...fechada en 1919 agradeciendo a mi tatarabuelo (quien era fabricante y afinador de pianos) por afinarle un piano para un concierto en Monterrey... lo cito "...ya que nunca he tocado un piano mejor afinado..." curioso no?
Muy interesante. No sabía que también dio recital en Monterrey en esa época . Rubinstein dio grandes temporadas en México por 40 años. Las de 1919 1921 dejaron honda huella por su propuesta innovadora en programa, por ejemplo. Según el maestro en sus memorias, el mexicano uno de los más cálidos y mejores públicos del mundo por su sensibilidad...
This is a beautifully poised performance, poetic and passionate in equal measure. The tempo never drags or rushes but is always flexible to the needs of the music. Given the poor quality picture, the sound is remarkably good. What is the year of the performance? Thanks for a great post.
Lipatti Nobility of soul not just posture
Lipatti does this greatly too.
I have no idea what piano he used.-I thought it worth mentioning his earlier performance because it is widely regarded as a great performance. Sachs: "the 1928 recording..(London April 18th 1928) for instance is amazing in it's mixture of quiet intimacy, melodic splendor, mounting eroticism, and dazzling explosion of joy....one of the most important etc., p 428. My CD sounds reasonable with very little hiss. And it certainly is an evocative performance -easy 2 buy cheap too. frogmanpiano
1) The appoggiature should be played on the beat.
2) The tempo accelerates gradually through the three blocks of material until slowing at the return of the opening.
@maikabright, exactly...
Have you heard Howard Tuvelle's performance...also on RUclips? "His day" goes on.......with a few......!
why doesnt it sound like this when i play this piece?
Chopin had never been to Venice, but while in Nohant, he heard a description of the gondolieri and their songs from Delacroiz, recently returned. My understanding is that this was Chopin's inspiration: the swaying of the gondola, a guitar, a secret kiss beneath a bridge, warm night, shimmering brilliant reflections in the canal. Is there a piece more parlante than this?
Thanks, that was what I signed on to say. The Lipatti version of this Barcarole is one of the most perfect recordings ever created. I love Rubinstein as well, but there is something other-worldy about Lipatti. Does anyone out there in the ether have a Lipatti video? Does such a thing exist?
It doesn’t. And yes, it is in my view the best, but of course Rubenstein is also wonderful and the two versions have much in common.
@paulphilip1 thank you
@erikkihss Yea, I wonder too....!
but I bet anything Chopin would of been damn proud of Artur's interpretations of his music! ..don't you? :)
An enchanting, melancholy and beautiful piece. But which year?
I go to Rubenstein for Chopin. I go to Gould for everything else.
Rubinstein's tone is always perfect but I prefer Dinu's playing because I feel like it can stop my brain and my heart.
אני אקשיב בביתי לנגינה בפסנתר וקונצרט כמו במאה ה-19 בבתי אצולה גבוהה.
he is a happy man, look at him play. He has no worries. haha
I echo that!!!
Introduction? Sounds just the same as any other performance me.
Wow! Heroic declamation, macho agogic! He proves that Chopin, perhaps, was no lyricist at all.
Sorry what are you getting? What do you mean?
Rubinstein's "masculine", unsentimental rendition of Chopin's Barcarolle convincingly reveals its undercurrent of epic, "heroic" dignity (unlike some shallower "salon" interpretations of other pianists who merely indulge in the sentimentality of the Barcarolle's "lyrical" salon façade).
@erikkihss silenzio, nn ci sono commenti
taken by the first chord
i wish i cud but i dont have a piano. i have no money to buy one.
My attention was brought to the ongoing discussion between Bruce88keys and MASTERCLASSES. Since these 2 users are not able to have a civilized discussion I decided to remove all their "literary contributions" and to block them.
I posted these videos (and other ones) because I believe their not available commonly and because I want to share them with people who can enjoy them or who try to see them as "educational".
SO PLEASE! ... IF I MAY ASK KEEP IT CIVILIZED!!!
14 years later, thank you for sharing this
Well, who would've thought that a fine artist like Rubinstein (I attended one of his last concerts), leads to such reactions. Apparently this discussion thread is leading away from what RUclips is all about. Donaldcallen is right and I will look elsewhere for more value in thought.
LOL
i give it back then..
only Chopin?
Again- these anti-Rubinstein folks have me wondering if they have cotton in their ears! Whatever Rubinstein performed was honest, sincere, and supported with an enormous technic tempered by blazing musicianship and style. He never played an insecure note of music in his life!!
6:44