It's because it is the recorded version playing over the concert. Proof is at 3:11. He stopped singing, but the audio had him sustained for an extra second.
Brent D: WHY YOU LIP SYNC?! I've listened to every song you guys got every damn day, and this one's my favorite. I know every note, every word, every pitch..tis exactly the same. T-T Still love you, ass munch
STORY TIME : I live in PANAMA CITY BEACH BARRY KERCH CAME TO VISIT HIS MOTHER WHO BRINGS HER DOGS TO THE VET I WORKED AT . SHE HAD HIM COME IN WITH HER TO THE VISIT AND ME AND MY COWORKER ABOUT PEED OUR PANTS AND HE TOOK A PIC W US AND GAVE US BOTH SIGNED DRUMSTICKS!!! He’s super laid back and humble and cool and HAWT!!!
Recently I was lucky enough to see Shinedown live and they were freaking amazing. I loved every second of it. All the memories that some of their music was attached to made me smile so much. Before the concert, I hadn't been to one in 7 years and I don't think I could've picked a better one to go to.
There's no way he hit every single note on this song exactly the way they are in the studio version. He was probably singing live but they're playing the studio version for the DVD or however this concert was distributed If you've ever seen him sing this song live before or after this its never perfect like this
This is the studio version over the live version which is why it sounds exactly the same. Go to 03:10 - it's pretty obvious there. Don't get me wrong, Brent is a very talented singer but unfortunately this video does not show the live vocals.
I love how people think Brent lip syncs because of this video. No, he doesn't, he sings live and he sings bloody amazing live (yes I've seen them live, I'm not just going by videos) it's just the way this video was put together.
Ive seen it before but the way Zach looks at Brent on the lines "If you only knew how i refuse to let you go even when your gone" gives me chills every time. Zach is basically screaming at him "im not going anywhere and we are not going to leave you. We will help you through anything".
Coming from a guy who watched the Beatles debut on the Ed Sullivan show, I've listened to a lot of bands. Most need at least two guitars to fill sound and even then, they don't always sound good. I'm really amazed by Shinedown's song crafting. It's some of the best I've ever heard from a three piece band. I hope they have a long career.
@@escapemac I concede that point. Still, I find them highly creative songwriters. The Beatles also used orchestration but we don't think of them beyond the Fab Four behind their instruments.
If you only knew I’m hangin’ by a thread of web I spin for you. If you only knew I’d sacrifice. With beating.all before I lose you. I still wrote on to the letters you return. I swear. It’s four o’ three. And I can’t 😴.
If you only knew. How many times I've heard you sing badly, to this song. If you only knew. You used to have a singing voice, now it's gone. I still hold on to records from years ago. 'Cause they sound much better.
You actually think it's playback? You can clearly see a difference but what I'm trying to say is that he sounds great live. I mean he's better than all of the other bands I have seen live but this doesn't mean it's fake. But who knows though...
Potatomato Mayo I dont think, I HEAR its playback when comparing to the cd, Im a musician and singer myself and my ears are very trained to this. You can even see a few parts where he doesnt sing out the note as long as the playback. Im not saying he is a bad live singer, but in this vid its playback. Its a shame he doesnt sing live like I know he can, its his choice though
You guys this actually IS the real audio from the concert, if you listen to them side by side, the real one and this, they're different. He's just really THAT good!
+maxgansman ummm no!It's not true! I just saw them live last month and Brent's voice is just incredible live, not to mention it was outdoors with a temp of almost 100 degrees and humid and muggy as hell! I had 5th row so was very close to the stage and he sang every word on key and tempo, actually was damn near perfect! ! thank you very much! ! undoubtedly the best live band I've seen and I've seen many! !
Okay here's a couple of things that I have noticed because my ear is tuned into this 1. I know for a fact that Brent can sing beautifully live because I've actually seen a Shinedown concert and I've seen them live and his voice, completely raw, is amazing! 2. Brent is really singing at this shoe, but this concert was filmed and edited with the album track over his voice and it completely shadows his raw talent, which is very disappointing. 3. I can tell the difference in his voice from The Sound of Madness days compared to his voice now on the ATTENTION ATTENTION record. I can't even tell the difference in his voice from The Sound of Madness days and the Amaryllis days. There is a complete difference.
one of the few Shinedown songs that I see has the wrong lyrics..mostly......its 4:03 and I can't sleep with you next to me.....the only thing I still believe in is me.....if I only knew....I believe in me!!!!
+Billabongs122988 What do you expect? The only real alternatives for us is to listen to the same stuff we listened to for years. And that's ok, but boring after awhile. Or we could listen to country, Yeah sure. (gag)
I'm old enough to have seen Led Zep. And I can tell you that Shinedown is better live! I've now seen them 8 times. Some of those were 8 hour drives both way.
+Ricky Dobbs You're right, it's off sync. They dubbed over the DVD. So, basically, while they were performing live, no playback was used. Cerinex, Ricky is talking about Brent Smith, the lead vocalist, pulling away from the mic, not either of the backup singers. And that line ending with "you" was Brent's line.
Great song...too bad the audio doesn't match the video...You can see him take breaths at 2:13 and 2:35 when there is clearly audio recorded...Pay attention guys. I want to know what they really sound like live...
Umm you can stfu you know nothing I was there go to hell or stop thinking you know shit if you knew any fucking thing about music or shinedown(which I know every lyric to every song by them.) Then you would know that the others sing also you dipshit
I am not a musician but a person who respects and admires those who have those abilities to touch others with words or music. But at around 3:17 when Brent is singing if you only knew it seems as if he turns and words are still coming out but mic is not by his mouth...Any answers to my question? I love Shinedown and this does not make me think any less of them. Just a question no need for HARSH criticism...Thanks
Why is the drummer not playing the drums during the intro of the track? Can't blame people for shouting lip sync when your drummer isn't playing the simplest of beats.
Yes, this is not truly 'live'. He is not lip syncing, they simple took the footage and probably put a session over it due to sometimes audio just doesn't come out great recording live. I have seen them twice, he is THAT good live, see for yourself. They go hard, great show, great singer, awesome band.
Idk what u guys are talking about vocal sync or any crap like that, but maybe you know too, that there are backing vocals, maybe they sound like the track because its only that great (: the bassist and guitarist are doing the backing vocals and harmonization.
He's lip syncing. Check out the frames after 4:00 you notice his voice is still strong, yet he has pulled the mic away from his mouth. At best, you should hear his voice taper off, but it's still as strong as if it were still right at his mouth.
Guys this is a concert DVD, the singing is genuine but on those DVDs the touch up the sound to improve quality on film... Do a little research. Video is also out of synch
Don't know why they don't have the drummer do the opening part of the song instead of playing it through the speakers...man...it's not that hard and I always pictured him playing that whenever I listneed to the song in the car...not anymore though...sucks that he doesn't play that part...
I LOVE SHINEDOWN I LOVE SHINEDOWN I LOVE SHINEDOWN I LOVE SHINEDOWN I LOVE SHINEDOWN I LOVE SHINEDOWN I LOVE SHINEDOWN, lol.....I REALLY REALLY DO LOVE SHINEDOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
![SHINEDOWN - Second Chance / February 2012 [HD] Rockpalast](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PnlRh02Fy7o/mqdefault.jpg)
![SHINEDOWN - Second Chance / February 2012 [HD] Rockpalast](/img/tr.png)
![Shinedown - If You Only Knew (Official Video) [HD Remaster]](/img/1.gif)
My goodness he sounds just like he did on the track, they all ROCKED my gosh I want to cry right now, I love Shinedown
Because it is the recorded version over the concert. That's why it sounds the same lol.
I seen them in concert, he sings great, all their songs
I’ve Sean shinedown live they actually sang the song but in this one they wer lip sinking in the 45 video he had the mic to far away from his mouth
@@Morgan_T31 there is very good vocal projection to you know mate 🤘
It's because it is the recorded version playing over the concert. Proof is at 3:11. He stopped singing, but the audio had him sustained for an extra second.
This guy is so talented and Hot:}
Brent D: WHY YOU LIP SYNC?! I've listened to every song you guys got every damn day, and this one's my favorite. I know every note, every word, every pitch..tis exactly the same. T-T Still love you, ass munch
he doesn't lip sync, it's just the video :)
He is lip syncing
You can tell
ClotSkull its a video dub over .its for all live video performances. not his choice .linkin park and a7x do live dvds that are 100% non dub .
It's 403 and I can't sleep. I ...
I LOVE SHINEDOWN AND LOVEBUGGMAry69
Brent Smith's voice was amazing to start with but it seems to have gotten better with time. One of the best live vocals I've heard.
I've been to a concert and I was speechless when I heard him singing just like that. Such powerful voice!
There isn't a better band to watch live than Shinedown!
I'm old . But Rock an Roll is my life
.
Only kind to listen to good for the soul.
STORY TIME : I live in PANAMA CITY BEACH BARRY KERCH CAME TO VISIT HIS MOTHER WHO BRINGS HER DOGS TO THE VET I WORKED AT . SHE HAD HIM COME IN WITH HER TO THE VISIT AND ME AND MY COWORKER ABOUT PEED OUR PANTS AND HE TOOK A PIC W US AND GAVE US BOTH SIGNED DRUMSTICKS!!! He’s super laid back and humble and cool and HAWT!!!
One of the few bands that actually sound like the cd version live.
Recently I was lucky enough to see Shinedown live and they were freaking amazing. I loved every second of it. All the memories that some of their music was attached to made me smile so much. Before the concert, I hadn't been to one in 7 years and I don't think I could've picked a better one to go to.
0:08 He has such a gorgeous smile 😊
You can see his Adam's apple moving he's not lip syncing
Def not lip sync. He's so talented
There's no way he hit every single note on this song exactly the way they are in the studio version. He was probably singing live but they're playing the studio version for the DVD or however this concert was distributed
If you've ever seen him sing this song live before or after this its never perfect like this
This is the studio version over the live version which is why it sounds exactly the same. Go to 03:10 - it's pretty obvious there.
Don't get me wrong, Brent is a very talented singer but unfortunately this video does not show the live vocals.
He was singing live but for certain official live releases it’s common to re-record vocals
He was singing live at the show but its over dubbed with the studio version for some reason.
I just saw Shinedown November 17th, and they're one of the best live bands I've ever seen. They sound like studio live. no lip syncing there.
I love how people think Brent lip syncs because of this video. No, he doesn't, he sings live and he sings bloody amazing live (yes I've seen them live, I'm not just going by videos) it's just the way this video was put together.
Thank you ❤️🙏❤️ Such a Unique Singer ! Wish one day they will play in Paris 🙏🎸🙏 Here he is so moving !!!
No better poetry than this.
And what a beautiful smile Brent has...LOVE this song !!
Ive seen it before but the way Zach looks at Brent on the lines "If you only knew how i refuse to let you go even when your gone" gives me chills every time. Zach is basically screaming at him "im not going anywhere and we are not going to leave you. We will help you through anything".
OR....they might have dubbed in a clear track in this video because of quality issues....who knows.
Coming from a guy who watched the Beatles debut on the Ed Sullivan show, I've listened to a lot of bands. Most need at least two guitars to fill sound and even then, they don't always sound good. I'm really amazed by Shinedown's song crafting. It's some of the best I've ever heard from a three piece band. I hope they have a long career.
I think there were backing tracks on this.
@@escapemac I concede that point. Still, I find them highly creative songwriters. The Beatles also used orchestration but we don't think of them beyond the Fab Four behind their instruments.
Finally listened to this without crying!
If you only knew I’m hangin’ by a thread of web I spin for you. If you only knew I’d sacrifice. With beating.all before I lose you. I still wrote on to the letters you return. I swear. It’s four o’ three. And I can’t 😴.
live is perfect!!
rare band..
If you only knew. How many times I've heard you sing badly, to this song.
If you only knew. You used to have a singing voice, now it's gone.
I still hold on to records from years ago. 'Cause they sound much better.
S
Apple Frenzy What, are you 6 years old?
Boi his voice is still amazing
Brent smith gives his sweat his effort, he puts his heart on every single concert he make. much respect for Shinedown and all of its band members
Too much memories with this song... Love it
it's such a shame this isn't the real audio track. anyone who knows them and heard them live knows how good they actually are... :/
i was at the concert n can tell u all: his voice is amazing live!!! SD_ROCKS!!!!
His voice is stunning - they sound amazing live.
shame you dont hear his voice and only the original cd track... he got a great voice, why doesnt he learn to use it live as well? :(
Wtf r u talking about?!? This guy is amazing live!! Can't tell a difference between the record and live
Potatomato Mayo hehe thats exactly what Im talking about and you just confirmed it as well. Its playback
You actually think it's playback? You can clearly see a difference but what I'm trying to say is that he sounds great live. I mean he's better than all of the other bands I have seen live but this doesn't mean it's fake. But who knows though...
Potatomato Mayo I dont think, I HEAR its playback when comparing to the cd, Im a musician and singer myself and my ears are very trained to this. You can even see a few parts where he doesnt sing out the note as long as the playback. Im not saying he is a bad live singer, but in this vid its playback. Its a shame he doesnt sing live like I know he can, its his choice though
Hes right
You can hear it
You guys this actually IS the real audio from the concert, if you listen to them side by side, the real one and this, they're different. He's just really THAT good!
I am in love with Shinedown. They are the best. ❤
the vocals are from the studio recording but the music is live. smith has more of a studio voice than a live one.
+connor graham That's not true in the slightest.
+MynameisKyle99 It is so true
+maxgansman ummm no!It's not true! I just saw them live last month and Brent's voice is just incredible live, not to mention it was outdoors with a temp of almost 100 degrees and humid and muggy as hell! I had 5th row so was very close to the stage and he sang every word on key and tempo, actually was damn near perfect! ! thank you very much! ! undoubtedly the best live band I've seen and I've seen many! !
Yup. That's why I KNOW this particular song was his own, and not pre recorded.
This song makes me cry thinking aboqut the girl I like BC she doesn't know how I feel and all my friends say sh
Nobody loves Shinedown and knows Shinedown like I do
I love all Shinedown. This is my very favorite Shinedown song. Shinedown rocks! !
They are one of the best live preforming bands of al time they sound amazing
Okay here's a couple of things that I have noticed because my ear is tuned into this
1. I know for a fact that Brent can sing beautifully live because I've actually seen a Shinedown concert and I've seen them live and his voice, completely raw, is amazing!
2. Brent is really singing at this shoe, but this concert was filmed and edited with the album track over his voice and it completely shadows his raw talent, which is very disappointing.
3. I can tell the difference in his voice from The Sound of Madness days compared to his voice now on the ATTENTION ATTENTION record. I can't even tell the difference in his voice from The Sound of Madness days and the Amaryllis days. There is a complete difference.
It does suck the editor played the track over it 😭
i like shinedown, singer has great voice, he doesn't need lip sync!!
Luis Rodriguez Its not lip sync. The original song was dubbed over this video
I truly love Shine down! Brent has one of the most powerful voices ive heard!
Yes he does, i get chills every time i hear him
one of the few Shinedown songs that I see has the wrong lyrics..mostly......its 4:03 and I can't sleep with you next to me.....the only thing I still believe in is me.....if I only knew....I believe in me!!!!
I love how there are old people in the crowd listening to this new stuff. Progressive.
+Billabongs122988 What do you expect? The only real alternatives for us is to listen to the same stuff we listened to for years. And that's ok, but boring after awhile. Or we could listen to country, Yeah sure. (gag)
I'm old enough to have seen Led Zep. And I can tell you that Shinedown is better live! I've now seen them 8 times. Some of those were 8 hour drives both way.
4:00 to 4:05 is the audio off sync? He pulls away before finishing the "you" XD
Different vocalist is singing he's just a back up
+Ricky Dobbs You're right, it's off sync. They dubbed over the DVD. So, basically, while they were performing live, no playback was used.
Cerinex, Ricky is talking about Brent Smith, the lead vocalist, pulling away from the mic, not either of the backup singers. And that line ending with "you" was Brent's line.
mrknockknock1 Ahhh, okay haha i see it now...soooo noticable XD
I love Brent Smith and this band! There are so many songs I love of theirs that I don't even know which one is my favorite.
Great song...too bad the audio doesn't match the video...You can see him take breaths at 2:13 and 2:35 when there is clearly audio recorded...Pay attention guys. I want to know what they really sound like live...
He did not breath at 2:13. Sometimes the audio and video don't match up. Stuff happens.
Singers also learn to take quick breaths.
Umm you can stfu you know nothing I was there go to hell or stop thinking you know shit if you knew any fucking thing about music or shinedown(which I know every lyric to every song by them.) Then you would know that the others sing also you dipshit
Am I missing something at the beginning of the song? Shouldn't the drummer start when the drums start playing?
Bob Adams ever heard of sth called "intro"?? maybe u should go to a real live concert instead of posting shit on youtube!
#Brazil
I ARANGED ALL BUT ME BECAUSE OF THE CRAP YUP AND THE TOUR REDSIDENT EVIL I WENT NIGHTIE FOR ALONG TIME MOVING HELL YES TY YW
Who knew that Shinedown would not only find waldo, but recruit him for this concert?
I just saw them at Louder Than Life and his voice just gives you chills.
+Jared Paulin doesnt it? i got to see them do a little 3 man acoustic set awhile ago before they were this big. simply fucking amazing.
I just saw them a couple months ago and his voice is just beyond amazing. You're right about the chills.
Damn yes his voice does!!!
They sound great live!
Amazing song, the backing vocals are incredible!
They sound amazing live!
This is definitely dubbed over for the video. It sounds exactly like the studio version in a way that zero of his previous or later performances are
how about high tea thats around 3 pm ok canwe do 2 pm instead yup ty yw
I am not a musician but a person who respects and admires those who have those abilities to touch others with words or music. But at around 3:17 when Brent is singing if you only knew it seems as if he turns and words are still coming out but mic is not by his mouth...Any answers to my question? I love Shinedown and this does not make me think any less of them. Just a question no need for HARSH criticism...Thanks
I knew that into each live video there were some adjustement, obviously, the sound should be good.. But I don't know if it was in playback or not..
Why is the drummer not playing the drums during the intro of the track? Can't blame people for shouting lip sync when your drummer isn't playing the simplest of beats.
AM MARRIED TO ALL OF YOU WITJOUT THE COURTSHIP WE KNOW TY YW
Facking awesome 👏
Whenever I hear Brent's voice it makes my knees weak. Oh goodness LOVE Shinedown. My poor husband
that's like every time I see Zach play the guitar. I can't handle it. lol these damn men...
Why official video Hided From RUclips ?
what your blood tpye as a kid hun o postive and now zero ty yw
Thanks for this videos. Hopefully you will upload more of this amazing concert!
This song is so beautiful
This is absolutely beautiful ❤️
lipsync????
Thinking about you more than usual.
Eric is sooooo hot!!!!!!!
Zach is soooo cute!!!!!
Yes they are
adoro essa música, demais!!!!
Sounds good to me
Lip sink or not they are still amazing
Brent stop be so amazing omfg
I wish I could see them live...I love Shinedown. My idols!
YOU DID YOU MARRIED GREG KEMP HE A KING TY YW
They sound great live. Great band
Yes, this is not truly 'live'. He is not lip syncing, they simple took the footage and probably put a session over it due to sometimes audio just doesn't come out great recording live.
I have seen them twice, he is THAT good live, see for yourself. They go hard, great show, great singer, awesome band.
what kind of pick is that? it's like a violin
Idk what u guys are talking about vocal sync or any crap like that, but maybe you know too, that there are backing vocals, maybe they sound like the track because its only that great (: the bassist and guitarist are doing the backing vocals and harmonization.
He's lip syncing.
Check out the frames after 4:00 you notice his voice is still strong, yet he has pulled the mic away from his mouth.
At best, you should hear his voice taper off, but it's still as strong as if it were still right at his mouth.
Wow, Shame they put the recorded track over his voice. I know for a fact he wasn't lip syncing here.
Guys this is a concert DVD, the singing is genuine but on those DVDs the touch up the sound to improve quality on film... Do a little research. Video is also out of synch
imagine this in keke Wyatt's voice
If...I'm hanging by a thread and loving this... I love you for sharing bc you are you... laughing and loving this...
You make me smile way too big. My very favorite Shinedown and I'm going down loving this... it's 4 03 and... heart
{Other comment} she's no good for me
I really want to go to his concert
Don't know why they don't have the drummer do the opening part of the song instead of playing it through the speakers...man...it's not that hard and I always pictured him playing that whenever I listneed to the song in the car...not anymore though...sucks that he doesn't play that part...
i love shinedown but this is obvious lipsync. even the pauses sound exactly like the record :D
Made me really emotional...Almost cried! Damn they're perfect live!!! Thnx for sharing...
This is my VERY VERY Favorite SHINEDOWN SONG. ...........
He doesn't lip sync, that's why he changes up the way he sings most songs (mainly when he does acoustic).
he’s so incredible
I LOVE SHINEDOWN I LOVE SHINEDOWN I LOVE SHINEDOWN I LOVE SHINEDOWN I LOVE SHINEDOWN I LOVE SHINEDOWN I LOVE SHINEDOWN, lol.....I REALLY REALLY DO LOVE SHINEDOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
did you know this is the only guy that i have heard with controllable breathing while singing the other guys only sound good in there music video's
Perfect .. thank you ... and the other two songs? (Diamond Eyes and Cyanide Sweet Tooth Suicide)
Only the two. I do not bother you anymore :-D
And she could buy the 🎟
This song is a favorite. So many SHINEDOWN amazing songs. Love Brent!
I like Shinedown, but there's no way a performance that smooth was live.