Love the 'banquet' analogy of the sacraments. Our beautiful Catholic church is SO physical and tangible in our living out the Faith. Most poor protestants just read and study the 'menu' without fully partaking in the whole meal. God bless you Eddie and guests!
Thank you for this. This has been helpful for me(Catholic) and my fiance(SDA), who has been investigating her church more and more and has been looking more deeply at Church history.
SDA congregations must differ. Mine doesn’t push fear, only God’s love. I have heard of some Adventists being inappropriate though, regarding the Gospel.
I believe it depends on one’s perspective. If you look at the book of Revelation focusing on the beast, plagues, and all that, surely fear could overwhelm you. But if you look at the book of Revelation focusing on the coming King Jesus, that’s certainly good news. Whatever, get ready Jesus is coming for His people who keep His commandments and His faith (Rev. 14:12)
I have been a Seven day Adventist all my life. And I have never known anyone that tries to instill fear or scare SD A’s in regards to Catholicism.Maybe their story is a little exaggerated😎
I loved this story so much it brought tears to my eyes l thought, thank God there are still some beautiful people out there, Praise the Lord for Paul and his mother and his little sister,,,😊
@Derrick. Google for Arthur Beem. They have a RUclips channel. Maybe you can leave a comment there for them to reach out to you. They also can be found on other sources too. All the best !
Same actually!!! This would be incredibly helpful💖! My fiancé and I are going through alot right now with SDA family members and church members having concerns about us having concerns on the SDA church itself. Also have a Bible study meeting with an old pastor that my sda family wants us to have. Been really wanting to talk more indepth with someone from this perspective. To better formulate my thoughts and look further into how we are called to serve The LORD our God
@@wisdom-seeker4526 There are a number of ex SDA videos on RUclips which you may like to Google. Reasons why they left. Personally though I have never an been SDA as I find the belief unusual : 1. Jesus is still preparing for our salvation at the heavenly sanctuary means salvation is not at Calvary 2. The sins that Jesus carry is finally not carried by Him but instead pass onto Satan. So the devil is the one who carries our sins which means Satan is our Savior ? Jesus saves because He is the Lamb of God who bore our sins. So this transferring to Satan like the sacrificial lamb in the Temple is bizarre. 3. The writings of EGW is 'on par with scriptures" . Similar to 2 Tom 3:16 All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching,rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness. EGW writing is her writings are a continuing and authoritative source of truth and provide for the church comfort, guidance, instruction, and correction
@@tony1685 Tony, don't be stubborn. SDA is a fake Christian church. Founded in the 1800's. History doesn't lie. Your pastor does. Use your common sense, its your salvation at stake.
Mr Eddie,I’m thankful for this video it helps Catholics realize what we’re up against,now with that being said I would like for you to ask this couple that was on your video if they ever suspected that Ellen white ever smoked medical marijuana???🤔😳😯
Wow, so exciting & inspiring. To think I wanted to look into SDA! An amazing couple seeking God together. Yes, it's about Authority for me too. So sad that the church Fathers were hidden from us Protestants all these years. But God has opened my eyes & I now read with a different lens, hallelujah
Catholics: We must not fall into relativism. We have to live out our faith, understand it, evangelize Protestants. We're all Christians but we're not the same. It's your duty to pray for anyone you know to become catholic. Pray and God will do the rest. But pray and live the Catholic faith. Do not be shy to expose your Rosary, to pray before and after food, to make sign of the cross. If you do, be sure you know how to respond if someone questions you about it. Collect Catholic pamphlets and just display them on your desk. Have your bible with you and read it with the liturgy of hours, whether there are people or not. Let's not hide.
The Church is a banquet....love that metaphor. Why let them(Protestants) just subsist on crumbs? Too many Catholics cannot believe what you just said. They take the easy path and don't get involved, they stay out of the fight for the Holy Church. It is aggravating. We have to be able to put our faith out there more and let ourselves suffer through it. Because there is faith grown in suffering. We cannot win everyone over so we have to keep treading along despite it. Just like Jesus did with the Jews of His day....they hated Him..(not all, of course).
I recoment evrybody to watch a very short video. The Veil removed . is beautiful, also The Great Miracles is everythings that happen during Mass. Great video.
The only place where you can live a life of grace is in the Catholic Church. It is the only Church that has the tools (sacraments). An example, without confession, how will a baptized get back into grace. And once you loose your grace through mortal sin you can’t make any spiritual progress. The devil gets more sway over you and if you die in that state, you loose your salvation. What about repentance? Sure, but repentance (sorrow for your sin) has to be intense enough to at least amend partially for your sin. This is difficult for a mortal sin because a mortal sin is an infinite injustice to God (look what happened with Adam and Eve’s sin). This is where confession comes in, sorrow and the blood of Christ to wash away your sin. This is implemented in confession. Can Christ just grant you prefect contrition on your death bed as he did the good thief on the cross? Is it possible? Remember that this was before he instituted the Church and confession. The thief did not have access to those tools. Will a non Catholic get that gift on his death bed? Depends, Can he say he was seeking the truth and could not find it, or was he just justifying his life and finding himself teachers that agree with him so he/she can feel good about the sins he/she loves to commit. The Church’s mission is to save souls. It has all you need to be saved, that is the only sure way to salvation outside of which are no promises or guarantees or sacramental graces. Only uncertainty, division, spiritual anarchy, and confusion. No-one knows this better than a Catholic convert. Reference: The Catechism of the Council of Trent.
At minute 12, the point is made by Aurthur that sda believe “the entire test for the end times is of the day of worship. But I would offer that what SDA are teaching is that the issue comes down to one of authority. And I think that what I’m hearing from the three of you as well. The authority of RC vs authority of the word of God. Q: which day is the sabbath day? A:Saturday is the Sabbath Day Q:why do we observe the Sunday instead of Saturday? A: We observe Sunday instead of Saturday because the Catholic Church Transferred the solemnity from Saturday to Sunday. - Rev. Peter Geirmann C.SS.R the converts catacism of catholic doctrine p 50 Catholics may use a different catacism these days, but I could find several more official quotes that affirm the same story. why were they able to make this change except the claim of authority to be able to change God‘s law? It is on this claim of authority that the test of loyalty lies. Not about a day, but of who we worship. But the issue of the mark of the beast is future. And so it is worth noting the Adventists believe that God has his true followers in all the churches. I’m a lifelong Sda and I was never taught that Catholics were going to kill me. But I will affirm that seventh day adventists do teach that the Roman Catholic Church is the beast that comes out of the sea. And that people are warned against the worship of the beast and his image. And that the image to the beast is the mark of her authority. And the mark of Roman catholic authority is the changing of Gods law.
7th day Adventist is similar to Muslim in doing faith in fear. It's hidden in good health but actually behind is to threaten their members who fails It's not out of love but hate.
Thee technique of throwing out argument after argument, position after position so that people can't evaluate them is apparently called "Gish Gallop" You are wrong about what the Catholic teaching... i read up on it... Oh. Loved the testomony.
As an SDA, just need to correct the idea that Ellen White was the foundress of the church. The church was founded by many individuals from many denominations. Ellen White was in the mix, but not a lone founder. She never even held an official title.
Its not true. Its not through EGW that SDA intepret the BiBle. Adventist read the bible and allow the Holy Spirit to interpret the word of God to be shared with others to draw closer to God.This couple view of adventist is very narrow to their family experience. I wonder if they have allowed the Holy Spirit through prayer to help understand the Word of God. Some of the things both are saying are not true of Adventists. How did the forth commandment of God become a third commandment? Thats very interesting to know.
Protestants all claim the Bible is their authority and pray to the Holy Spirt to guide them. Yet their are over 33,000 protestant religions all claiming to have the truth. The Holy Spirt must be crazy telling protestant religions different so called truth.
Laughing out loud as someone who has read a lot of her writings. One of the criticisms of Ellen White from her modern day critics with her prediction that the United States would be superpower. Did she get that one wrong?
@@heidihagaThis was hardly a prophecy. It was predictable. Literally everyone with an ounce of sense, diplomat, political figures, political philosophers, anyone who came to explore the US and saw the vast landmass, the open frontier, and the resources predicted that the US will be a superpower
In the sense that hindsight is 2020 I can see why you would say that. However, the people who made the criticisms of her 150 years ago viewed themselves as a fledgling nation, and not as a future superpower. But im not trying to convince you, im just addressing your hyperbolic use of the word “all”.
Philosophy can lead someone to God. From Sherlock Holmes, he learned how to pursue the truth. He found the truth that he was seeking in the Catholic Church, the true church that Jesus founded in Matthew 16:18-19.
The difficulty with the Roman Catholicism is that it usurps the word of God. The Sabbath is the seventh day of the week per Genesis 2:2-3, not the first day of week. The Roman Catholic Church sought to change it to the first day, being God’s representative on Earth. Not good. There are many things the Roman Catholic Church teaches as facts that are not in the Bible. For example, the Bible says Jesus Christ is our intermediary with God, so we confess our sins to Jesus Christ. The Roman Catholic Church teaches that a priest is our intermediary, so we are to confess our sins to the priest. Not Biblical. Revelation doesn’t tell us what the mark of the beast is. I’ve heard several ideas, one of which is Sunday worship. It’s one idea. Adventism does focus on end-times, as Jesus Christ said he’s coming again. No one knows when, so best to be ready. I’ve never heard of Roman Catholics coming after us with guns. That sounds excessively extreme. That’s new to me. The SDA church and it’s originator encourage us to read our Bible, and to not yield to people.
Sunday is the Lord's Resurrection day not a j_ew rest day! Because the apostles Broke Bread Resurrection Day, first day of the week in ACTS 20:7, this is why we observe Sunday. Sab_bath / circumcision are nonbinding in the new covenant as stated by Paul in COR 2 & declared by Peter and the church at the Council of Jerusalem in ACTS 15. 2ND Sola scriptura is a false doctrine, The holy bible is a declared canon of the Catholic Church in the 4th century, it is a Catholic book based from the Sacred Tradition of the Catholic Church, not scriptures.
Obviously these two don’t even know their Bible because you’re not even giving or stating book chapter verse. This is a shame it’s very sad that they do not see the deception of Lucifer
You do not need to quote the chapter and the verse of what you quote in the Bible, all by itself. You need to understand what the entire chapter is saying and the context around the verse. You need to see how one individual verse fits in with what other sections in the Bible say.
Love the 'banquet' analogy of the sacraments. Our beautiful Catholic church is SO physical and tangible in our living out the Faith. Most poor protestants just read and study the 'menu' without fully partaking in the whole meal. God bless you Eddie and guests!
Amazing! This video came out just as i am debating a SDA ! Thank you for this video ! Its timely !
Me listening in 2024 .getting goosebumps. Such a great Testimony.God Bless Both of you. 🙏
Thank you for this. This has been helpful for me(Catholic) and my fiance(SDA), who has been investigating her church more and more and has been looking more deeply at Church history.
“To be deep in history is to cease to be Protestant”. - John Henry Newman
Jeremiah 29:13 When you look for me, you will find me. Yes, when you seek me with all your heart,
I love listening interviews like this while working
Praise God they had their spiritual blindness lifted.
Amazing testimony. God bless!
Gloria to God 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽 Very beautiful testimony and the end messages gave me goosebumps. Bless you guys 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽♥️
Wow this was an amazing testimony. I can't believe the amount of fear 7th day Adventists instill into their congregation. I feel bad for them.
Yes this is too sad, just unbelievable, and in today’s world!
SDA congregations must differ. Mine doesn’t push fear, only God’s love.
I have heard of some Adventists being inappropriate though, regarding the Gospel.
I believe it depends on one’s perspective. If you look at the book of Revelation focusing on the beast, plagues, and all that, surely fear could overwhelm you. But if you look at the book of Revelation focusing on the coming King Jesus, that’s certainly good news. Whatever, get ready Jesus is coming for His people who keep His commandments and His faith (Rev. 14:12)
I have been a Seven day Adventist all my life. And I have never known anyone that tries to instill fear or scare SD A’s in regards to Catholicism.Maybe their story is a little exaggerated😎
@@Ramo718 I've heard it with other SDA conversion stories as well.
I loved this story so much it brought tears to my eyes l thought, thank God there are still some beautiful people out there, Praise the Lord for Paul and his mother and his little sister,,,😊
I’d love to interview this lovely couple. Great story!
If you need an introduction, just let me know.
@@CatholicReCon Yes please!
Any chance of a way to contact them? I’m an SDA looking into the Catholic Church and talking to someone that’s worked through this would be awesome.
@Derrick. Google for Arthur Beem. They have a RUclips channel. Maybe you can leave a comment there for them to reach out to you. They also can be found on other sources too. All the best !
Derrick, email me at info@eddietrask.com. Thanks! God bless!
Same actually!!! This would be incredibly helpful💖! My fiancé and I are going through alot right now with SDA family members and church members having concerns about us having concerns on the SDA church itself. Also have a Bible study meeting with an old pastor that my sda family wants us to have. Been really wanting to talk more indepth with someone from this perspective. To better formulate my thoughts and look further into how we are called to serve The LORD our God
@@wisdom-seeker4526 There are a number of ex SDA videos on RUclips which you may like to Google. Reasons why they left.
Personally though I have never an been SDA as I find the belief unusual :
1. Jesus is still preparing for our salvation at the heavenly sanctuary means salvation is not at Calvary
2. The sins that Jesus carry is finally not carried by Him but instead pass onto Satan. So the devil is the one who carries our sins which means Satan is our Savior ? Jesus saves because He is the Lamb of God who bore our sins. So this transferring to Satan like the sacrificial lamb in the Temple is bizarre.
3. The writings of EGW is 'on par with scriptures" . Similar to 2 Tom 3:16
All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching,rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness.
EGW writing is her writings are a continuing and authoritative source of truth and provide for the church comfort, guidance, instruction, and correction
@@tony1685 Tony, don't be stubborn. SDA is a fake Christian church. Founded in the 1800's. History doesn't lie. Your pastor does.
Use your common sense, its your salvation at stake.
I appreciated the honest in this couple. I applaud both for their conviction in seeking the Truth! Excellent interview! Thanks to all!❤❤❤
Thank you for sharing your beautiful convertion story
I am so happy for all your family!
You made me laugh when the RCIA priest said your first confession would be a doozy!
Great testimony, Thank you for sharing. one of my sister in law is now Adventism i wish i could send them this great testimony.😇🤩.
Mr Eddie,I’m thankful for this video it helps Catholics realize what we’re up against,now with that being said I would like for you to ask this couple that was on your video if they ever suspected that Ellen white ever smoked medical marijuana???🤔😳😯
Amazing grace ! Praise God for allowing us to listen to you all ... God bless you more !
Wow, so exciting & inspiring. To think I wanted to look into SDA! An amazing couple seeking God together. Yes, it's about Authority for me too. So sad that the church Fathers were hidden from us Protestants all these years. But God has opened my eyes & I now read with a different lens, hallelujah
God bless you, Belinda.
❤Thanks a lot to all.
You have great guest, but I will not listen anymore because of soooooo many commercials. God bless 🙏🏼
Catholics: We must not fall into relativism. We have to live out our faith, understand it, evangelize Protestants. We're all Christians but we're not the same. It's your duty to pray for anyone you know to become catholic. Pray and God will do the rest. But pray and live the Catholic faith. Do not be shy to expose your Rosary, to pray before and after food, to make sign of the cross. If you do, be sure you know how to respond if someone questions you about it. Collect Catholic pamphlets and just display them on your desk. Have your bible with you and read it with the liturgy of hours, whether there are people or not. Let's not hide.
The Church is a banquet....love that metaphor. Why let them(Protestants) just subsist on crumbs? Too many Catholics cannot believe what you just said. They take the easy path and don't get involved, they stay out of the fight for the Holy Church. It is aggravating. We have to be able to put our faith out there more and let ourselves suffer through it. Because there is faith grown in suffering. We cannot win everyone over so we have to keep treading along despite it. Just like Jesus did with the Jews of His day....they hated Him..(not all, of course).
I would love to go on your show.
Invite me onto your show.
Blessings!
How the Catholic Church built western civilization is the book
Written by Thomas E Woods
Ivy League phd
Adventist doctors they do abortion .. no judgement but as Catholic we don’t want abortion why bcoz is a gift of life and God always provide
I recoment evrybody to watch a very short video. The Veil removed . is beautiful, also The Great Miracles is everythings that happen during Mass. Great video.
🙏❤
The only place where you can live a life of grace is in the Catholic Church. It is the only Church that has the tools (sacraments). An example, without confession, how will a baptized get back into grace. And once you loose your grace through mortal sin you can’t make any spiritual progress. The devil gets more sway over you and if you die in that state, you loose your salvation. What about repentance? Sure, but repentance (sorrow for your sin) has to be intense enough to at least amend partially for your sin. This is difficult for a mortal sin because a mortal sin is an infinite injustice to God (look what happened with Adam and Eve’s sin). This is where confession comes in, sorrow and the blood of Christ to wash away your sin. This is implemented in confession. Can Christ just grant you prefect contrition on your death bed as he did the good thief on the cross? Is it possible? Remember that this was before he instituted the Church and confession. The thief did not have access to those tools. Will a non Catholic get that gift on his death bed? Depends, Can he say he was seeking the truth and could not find it, or was he just justifying his life and finding himself teachers that agree with him so he/she can feel good about the sins he/she loves to commit. The Church’s mission is to save souls. It has all you need to be saved, that is the only sure way to salvation outside of which are no promises or guarantees or sacramental graces. Only uncertainty, division, spiritual anarchy, and confusion. No-one knows this better than a Catholic convert.
Reference: The Catechism of the Council of Trent.
At minute 12, the point is made by Aurthur that sda believe “the entire test for the end times is of the day of worship. But I would offer that what SDA are teaching is that the issue comes down to one of authority. And I think that what I’m hearing from the three of you as well. The authority of RC vs authority of the word of God.
Q: which day is the sabbath day?
A:Saturday is the Sabbath Day
Q:why do we observe the Sunday instead of Saturday?
A: We observe Sunday instead of Saturday because the Catholic Church Transferred the solemnity from Saturday to Sunday.
- Rev. Peter Geirmann C.SS.R the converts catacism of catholic doctrine p 50
Catholics may use a different catacism these days, but I could find several more official quotes that affirm the same story.
why were they able to make this change except the claim of authority to be able to change God‘s law?
It is on this claim of authority that the test of loyalty lies. Not about a day, but of who we worship. But the issue of the mark of the beast is future. And so it is worth noting the Adventists believe that God has his true followers in all the churches.
I’m a lifelong Sda and I was never taught that Catholics were going to kill me. But I will affirm that seventh day adventists do teach that the Roman Catholic Church is the beast that comes out of the sea. And that people are warned against the worship of the beast and his image. And that the image to the beast is the mark of her authority. And the mark of Roman catholic authority is the changing of Gods law.
7th day Adventist is similar to Muslim in doing faith in fear.
It's hidden in good health but actually behind is to threaten their members who fails
It's not out of love but hate.
Thee technique of throwing out argument after argument, position after position so that people can't evaluate them is apparently called "Gish Gallop"
You are wrong about what the Catholic teaching... i read up on it... Oh. Loved the testomony.
As an SDA, just need to correct the idea that Ellen White was the foundress of the church. The church was founded by many individuals from many denominations. Ellen White was in the mix, but not a lone founder. She never even held an official title.
Its not true. Its not through
EGW that SDA intepret the BiBle. Adventist read the bible and allow the Holy Spirit to interpret the word of God to be shared with others to draw closer to God.This couple view of adventist is very narrow to their family experience. I wonder if they have allowed the Holy Spirit through prayer to help understand the Word of God. Some of the things both are saying are not true of Adventists. How did the forth commandment of God become a third commandment? Thats very interesting to know.
Protestants all claim the Bible is their authority and pray to the Holy Spirt to guide them. Yet their are over 33,000 protestant religions all claiming to have the truth. The Holy Spirt must be crazy telling protestant religions different so called truth.
THE WIFE IS GIVING BETTER INSIGHT THEN DUDE...HE IS NOT GIVING DEEP INSIGHT.. WISH HE JUST BE QUIET AND LET HER EXPLAIN THIS STUFF...
7da against philosophy!!!
First 10 minutes and this man has already misleading and giving in accurate information information
All her prophesies failed
Laughing out loud as someone who has read a lot of her writings. One of the criticisms of Ellen White from her modern day critics with her prediction that the United States would be superpower. Did she get that one wrong?
@@heidihagaThis was hardly a prophecy. It was predictable. Literally everyone with an ounce of sense, diplomat, political figures, political philosophers, anyone who came to explore the US and saw the vast landmass, the open frontier, and the resources predicted that the US will be a superpower
In the sense that hindsight is 2020 I can see why you would say that. However, the people who made the criticisms of her 150 years ago viewed themselves as a fledgling nation, and not as a future superpower. But im not trying to convince you, im just addressing your hyperbolic use of the word “all”.
It’s a shame he would use philosophy and Sherlock Holmes to lead him a stray from God’s truth instead of using the Bible
Philosophy can lead someone to God. From Sherlock Holmes, he learned how to pursue the truth. He found the truth that he was seeking in the Catholic Church, the true church that Jesus founded in Matthew 16:18-19.
The difficulty with the Roman Catholicism is that it usurps the word of God. The Sabbath is the seventh day of the week per Genesis 2:2-3, not the first day of week. The Roman Catholic Church sought to change it to the first day, being God’s representative on Earth. Not good.
There are many things the Roman Catholic Church teaches as facts that are not in the Bible. For example, the Bible says Jesus Christ is our intermediary with God, so we confess our sins to Jesus Christ. The Roman Catholic Church teaches that a priest is our intermediary, so we are to confess our sins to the priest. Not Biblical.
Revelation doesn’t tell us what the mark of the beast is. I’ve heard several ideas, one of which is Sunday worship. It’s one idea.
Adventism does focus on end-times, as Jesus Christ said he’s coming again. No one knows when, so best to be ready.
I’ve never heard of Roman Catholics coming after us with guns. That sounds excessively extreme. That’s new to me.
The SDA church and it’s originator encourage us to read our Bible, and to not yield to people.
Sunday is the Lord's Resurrection day not a j_ew rest day! Because the apostles Broke Bread Resurrection Day, first day of the week in ACTS 20:7, this is why we observe Sunday. Sab_bath / circumcision are nonbinding in the new covenant as stated by Paul in COR 2 & declared by Peter and the church at the Council of Jerusalem in ACTS 15. 2ND Sola scriptura is a false doctrine, The holy bible is a declared canon of the Catholic Church in the 4th century, it is a Catholic book based from the Sacred Tradition of the Catholic Church, not scriptures.
Obviously these two don’t even know their Bible because you’re not even giving or stating book chapter verse. This is a shame it’s very sad that they do not see the deception of Lucifer
You do not need to quote the chapter and the verse of what you quote in the Bible, all by itself. You need to understand what the entire chapter is saying and the context around the verse. You need to see how one individual verse fits in with what other sections in the Bible say.
I am so glad that I became an sda Christian and can expose your errors and lies. I really need to explain your errors
These people are so fake they are making up so much as they speak 🗣️ it’s so obvious that they are just winging it.
Thanks for sharing this beautiful testimony.