IDF Ignored Female Soldiers’ Warnings Pre-Oct. 7. Then They Were Massacred | Amanpour and Company

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 окт 2024
  • One year since the October 7th terror attack, 101 Israeli hostages are yet to be brought home from Gaza. The number includes five female soldiers who were stationed at the Nahal Oz base near the Gaza border fence that day. Hamas killed 15 in their unit. Months before the attack, the all-female unit had reported suspicious activity by Hamas, but their warnings were ignored. In a recent report for the Wall Street Journal, correspondent Anat Peled investigates that failure, the tragedy that ensued, and the wider implications. Peled joins the show to discuss.
    Originally aired on October 9, 2024
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Major support for Amanpour and Company is provided by Jim Attwood and Leslie Williams, Candace King Weir, the Sylvia A. and Simon B. Poyta Programming Endowment to Fight Antisemitism, the Leila and Mickey Straus Family Charitable Trust, Mark J. Blechner, the Filomen M. D’Agostino Foundation, Seton J. Melvin, the Peter G. Peterson and Joan Ganz Cooney Fund, Charles Rosenblum, Koo and Patricia Yuen, Barbara Hope Zuckerberg, and Jeffrey Katz and Beth Rogers.
    Subscribe to the Amanpour and Company. channel here: bit.ly/2EMIkTJ
    Subscribe to our daily newsletter to find out who's on each night: www.pbs.org/wne...
    For more from Amanpour and Company, including full episodes, click here: to.pbs.org/2NB...
    Like Amanpour and Company on Facebook: bit.ly/2HNx3EF
    Follow Amanpour and Company on Twitter: bit.ly/2HLpjTI
    Follow Amanpour and Company on Instagram: bit.ly/3SaTUhk
    Watch Amanpour and Company weekdays on PBS (check local listings).
    Amanpour and Company features wide-ranging, in-depth conversations with global thought leaders and cultural influencers on the issues and trends impacting the world each day, from politics, business and technology to arts, science and sports. Christiane Amanpour leads the conversation on global and domestic news from London with contributions by prominent journalists Walter Isaacson, Michel Martin, Alicia Menendez and Hari Sreenivasan from the Tisch WNET Studios at Lincoln Center in New York City.
    #amanpourpbs

Комментарии • 173

  • @Are_WeThereYet
    @Are_WeThereYet 14 часов назад +78

    Doesn’t sound like it was ignored out of incompetence or ignorance, but rather very deliberately.
    Nearly an invite to attack, which would the be used as a justification for retaliation

    • @afs6853
      @afs6853 14 часов назад +9

      It’s difficult to link anything conclusively, but the Nova festival was to take place elsewhere and was only definitively moved where it was om that day only a day or two before, after all.

    • @jessieheartart
      @jessieheartart 14 часов назад +2

      100000

    • @sandal_thong8631
      @sandal_thong8631 14 часов назад +6

      It could have been a deliberate policy to step back and let this happen. But I think it more likely a far-right authoritarian regime like Netanyahu's was more arrogant that this couldn't happen and so was incompetently dismissive in intelligence gathering and analysis. But after it did happen, it's now justification for all that they want to do.
      Likewise, it's possible they didn't want moderates in Gaza, or Lebanon; they could have wanted extremists who won't negotiate so they can impose a final military solution. Meaning it was years in the making.
      I guess we should be lucky that white South Africa didn't impose a final solution on the Blacks and non-whites there.

    • @dani_California_
      @dani_California_ 13 часов назад +7

      @@Are_WeThereYet it's so plain to see yet so little spoken about 🤔

    • @GrannyRalls
      @GrannyRalls 12 часов назад

      Max Blumenthal of Gray Zone breaks it all down on their RUclips channel complete with many admissions by IDF soldiers and others as to the who knew what when and what they did or did not do. Max has been reporting on this for many, many years. Truly despicable so-called humans (term used loosely).

  • @zannemoonstone
    @zannemoonstone 11 часов назад +26

    Nobody on that base was ever sufficiently protected.
    It confounds me how there are still people who cannot see that the entire operation was executed by that country itself.
    It is clear that that regime does not give one penny about its "own" people.
    The exercise was simply a gaslight to the world to justify the, well, obliteration of an entire "enemy nation". Innocent people who've suffered for over 70 years who truly have always deserved to live in peace.
    The events are tragic, yes, but the ignorance of the rest of the world is almost equally heartbreaking.

    • @peterfazio9306
      @peterfazio9306 8 часов назад

      Israel is out of control right now for sure. However, I don't believe it was a false flag operation.

  • @krobbins8395
    @krobbins8395 13 часов назад +17

    I heard this story at the beginning of the war and it just dropped off of reporting. Its was confusing on why they didn't secure the hostages at the beginning and chose to handle the situation in the way it has been. The saddest thing to think is all these lives could have been spared because to a larger extent this war has been very harsh towards women and children!

    • @GrannyRalls
      @GrannyRalls 12 часов назад

      I truthfully think they didn't want all the hostages back in order to continue the war by saying they'd get them back through military force. They don't want them back because they told everyone they'd stop if they got them back and they don't want them back alive regardless because they will have a lot to say about their captivity that will not jive with the official Israeli narrative much like the elderly woman first released who said her captors took care of her every need and were kind to her.

  • @WheatAndChaff
    @WheatAndChaff 10 часов назад +11

    Everybody’s starting to connect the dots now, right? It sure seems that way.

    • @linvisible7782
      @linvisible7782 8 часов назад

      Many of us connected these dots a year ago 😢

  • @Marius_vanderLubbe
    @Marius_vanderLubbe 15 часов назад +62

    These people could care less about the suffering of Palestinians.

    • @jeffphan8256
      @jeffphan8256 12 часов назад +11

      Yeah this is all just "look at me, I'm the victim"

    • @ConstantGardener-q9q
      @ConstantGardener-q9q 10 часов назад

      You’re right. Hamas cares nothing about the suffering of Palestinians. That’s why they have used them as fodder in provoking a war.

  • @marjoriejohnson3147
    @marjoriejohnson3147 16 часов назад +30

    Thank you to Amanpour and Company for telling the truth~Finally~

    • @Kahlua2U
      @Kahlua2U 9 часов назад +1

      Yes…I have been searching for confirmation of this story I heard 9 months ago.

  • @letsRegulateSociopaths
    @letsRegulateSociopaths 9 часов назад +4

    and strange but one hour later netanyahu had a document in his hand granting him special war powers.... he let it happen. 3 separate governments told him what was coming (including the U.S., Egypt, and Jordan). The army was moved to the furthest place away and the billion dollar fence was magically turned off....

  • @Lorenzo939
    @Lorenzo939 9 часов назад +7

    There's footage floating around of an ex-IDF intelligence officer vlogging in real time from Israel saying something is wrong (ie it wasnt normal for the IDF to respond so slowly). Another interesting factor is that the people attending the the Nova festival were not observing the holiday (ie secular israelis), so it's possible they were considered worth sacrificing by the more extreme-right who control the knesset and Bibi. Has always seemed suspect & in the name of Greater Israel (ie maximalism/expansionism)

    • @saturnative
      @saturnative 8 часов назад

      Makes sense. They were targeted by IDF apache copter. IDF killed majority of hostages before they were taken to Gaza.

  • @Kahlua2U
    @Kahlua2U 9 часов назад +1

    Thank you. I’ve been searching for months to find documentation of this story…concerning the affirmative DISREGARD of the warnings.

  • @arman6119
    @arman6119 10 часов назад +6

    to quote Illan Pappa "the settlements attacked had been Palestine settlements that were bulldozed or set afire by idf..residents relocated to Gaza and settlements were given similar hebrew sounding name...Palestianian have held march to this area on the anniversay.....terrorits? imo

  • @dani_California_
    @dani_California_ 14 часов назад +29

    Women placed directly next to the border where your biggest enemy lives defenceless without arms and with their multiple warnings being ignored??😢 absolutely appalling and disgusting and pure insanity I saw another interview about this where it was said their "monitors" were their weapons. I'm beyond convinced this was all set up to happen and it was allowed to happen by the Israeli government so they could begin their genocide in Gaza, My heart goes out to everyone innocent who has been affected by this 😢 on all sides!

    • @TomMcinerney-g9b
      @TomMcinerney-g9b 14 часов назад

      > I'm beyond convinced this was all set up to happen and it was allowed to happen by the Israeli government so they could begin their genocide....
      I agree. A similar attitude was displayed by the Bush(43) government prior 9-11 (much to frustration of CIA, FBI, other people/agencies). The structure was not discontinued,
      there was just a casual approach which allowed the attacks to occur. Then the governments took actions they had aspired to before the attacks.

    • @jameschen3553
      @jameschen3553 12 часов назад +2

      It isnt right they were not trained and given weapons stationed so close to the borders. I respect women serve in the Israel military, something all countries should do next to their men.

    • @Sad_Bumper_Sticker
      @Sad_Bumper_Sticker 9 часов назад +1

      @@jameschen3553But 1. do not place new untrained and unarmed rookies at the border regardless of gender. 2. Why was it only women? That is misogyny. 3. Also misogynist Army Culture (in all countries) to ignore the reports and warnings of very young women in the army.

    • @sensei121
      @sensei121 8 часов назад

      Zionism is a terrorist ideology and organisation and illegally occupying another people's lands for 76 years... They are the foreign immigrant terrorists occupying Palestine

  • @rsza5911
    @rsza5911 9 часов назад +6

    All killing is wrong but please keep in mind that the IDF invoking the Hannibal Directive killed most of their own on Oct 7

  • @aliwazzani-q6n
    @aliwazzani-q6n 15 часов назад +67

    give palestinians their rights and things will be fine

    • @mikeg2306
      @mikeg2306 13 часов назад +3

      That's not what Palestinians want.

    • @jeffphan8256
      @jeffphan8256 11 часов назад

      @mikeg2306 that's exactly what they want. Their right to their homes and dignity

    • @ConstantGardener-q9q
      @ConstantGardener-q9q 10 часов назад

      Spoken out of utter ignorance. Hamas did nothing for the Palestinians ..to the contrary, they stole the enormous amount of international aid meant to help the Palestinians. They provoked a war that put Palestinians in harms way. They are a corrupt cult of death and your ignorance perpetrates them.

    • @Sad_Bumper_Sticker
      @Sad_Bumper_Sticker 9 часов назад

      It’s complex because BOTH SIDES do not accept the other side’s ethnic historic Right to the Land. Both openly say the other side migrated, the identity of Palestinians is rejected as “Middle Eastern Migrants” and the Jewish Israeli ethnicity is rejected by the other side as “White. Europeam Migrants” which is wholly untrue because it ignores the Middle Eastern Jewish Israelis who were banished from Middle Eastern Countries after centuries of living there. The Pro-Palestinian “White European Convert Colonialism” argument ignores 1. that Ashenazi Jewish ppl were from Israel and are still genetically so, it ignores. Sephardic Jews and Mizrachi Jews and ignores Jewish people from Africa living in Israel. The pro-Palestinian side does not “Only Want” Ceasefire but they openly say that Israelis have not Right to the Land which is untrue. The ProPalestinan side calls for the removal of the entire Country of Israel which is Antisemitism. Calling for the “REMOVAL” of a 3 million population to take their Land is why ProPalestinian calls are decfacto calls for Gene-oh-Side.
      Sadly the Israeli side spreads the same narrative - that Palestinians are a mix of Middle Eastern Migrants, not an ethnicity.
      Both brutal uprising murders, decades of unaliving Israelis with SlimgShots and chest bombs set off on Israeli buses and cafes and brutal terrorist actions like October 7th is morally abhorrent. Palestinians argued that burning houses with families was acceptable because “All Kibutzim were army” and “All Israelis are Army”. This is how they justify their unaliving of Israeli civilians.
      And Israel does exactly the same claiming “All Palestinans support Hamas and work for Hamas”. Leveling Gazas towns and cities with bombs will not magically “Remove Hamas Terrorism”. The ONLY WAY PALESTINIANS WILL be praceful will be when 3 million Israelis “move back to Europe” which is the Antisemitic request made by the ProPalestinian side in e.g. Speeches and Marches.
      So tragically this is not a black and whiite, or a white and black, but a gray and gray conflict. Where BOTH SIDES WERE/ARE TAUGHT TO OPENLY CALL THE OTHER SIDE terms like “Animals” which is dehumanizing. Both sides dehumanize the other side. Both reject and demean the other sides Culture and Religion.
      Both Sides have tbeir own history books going back centuries earlier, their own versions of the history of the Land in 1920s, 1930s, 1940s, 1950s etc up to 2024.
      Both sides have tbeir own History Books and their own Archeology theories.
      It is truly🕊️ Utterly Hopeless. Today BOTH sides do not want a two State Solution.
      There is no hope. And what BOTH SIDES are doing will NOT. BRING PEACE 😢😢🕊️☮️

    • @Lorenzo939
      @Lorenzo939 9 часов назад +1

      @@mikeg2306 please enlighten us on what it is they want then?

  • @christineleitner960
    @christineleitner960 13 часов назад +14

    This is shameful and needs to be further exposed. The families of these female soldiers deserve justice.

    • @onlyme80
      @onlyme80 12 часов назад

      💯💯 have you spoken to biden about this, since israeli PR minister does not care even for there own people

    • @meh.7539
      @meh.7539 10 часов назад +1

      Nope. Those soldiers are legitimate targets in an occupied territory. That's 100% on them for not understanding it or not believing it.

    • @christineleitner960
      @christineleitner960 9 часов назад

      @@meh.7539 What you clearly fail to understand is that justice is for holding those in command accountable for refusing to listen to the clear warning signs they were presented with. If action had been immediately taken these soldiers may very well be with their families, along with the hostages and everyone else harmed or killed on October 7th. Their families deserve better from their government.

    • @meh.7539
      @meh.7539 8 часов назад

      ​@@christineleitner960 What you fail to understand is that they are an occupying force, they shouldn't be there. There presence *was* the injustice.
      "If action had been immediately taken these soldiers may very well be with their families". I think you're confused, you see none of the people living in Israel *have* to be there. They never *had* to be there. I remind you that they are the oppressors. They have *concentrated* the Palestinians in a geographically small area. They control all of the food, fuel, water, and electricity that goes into or out of that *concentrated area*. Those women you're defending could have chosen not to join the army, they didn't *have* to join that "elite unit". They chose to do that and by doing so chose to continue that concentration and genocide. What happened to them is their own fault.

  • @marlonjaimon8325
    @marlonjaimon8325 13 часов назад +20

    What would you do if you were under occupation? Aren't these women part of the IDF? There are not your average person on the street

    • @ConstantGardener-q9q
      @ConstantGardener-q9q 10 часов назад

      Congratulations on justifying Hamas terrorism. And if you knew anything about the Palestinian plate, you would know that Hamas is a corrupt organization that stole billions of aid meant to help the Palestinian people and did absolutely nothing for the Palestinian people. Your fake solidarity doesn’t help anyone except your sense of self righteousness, read history book

    • @Lorenzo939
      @Lorenzo939 8 часов назад +1

      Agreed, but I would also consider the average Israeli a victim of conditioning. It's not that hard to imagine how easy it is to control the culture (ie media and education) of a country slightly smaller than New Jersey. A quick 5min explainer that barely scratches the surface, but is still a good intro: ruclips.net/video/a7cgzz5W8uM/видео.htmlsi=IqAY5q3Hh11ImNm8

  • @nou3123
    @nou3123 11 часов назад +16

    maybe in the next life they won't casually work as a guard/lookout for a concentration camp

    • @ConstantGardener-q9q
      @ConstantGardener-q9q 10 часов назад

      Maybe in the next life they won’t casually enlist as terrorists in a Hamas death cult in order to start a war at the expense of Palestinian children, women and elderly. Disgusting comment demonstrating an utter lose of humanity. Congratulations

    • @nou3123
      @nou3123 9 часов назад

      @@ConstantGardener-q9q im sorry, who ethnically cleansed the indigenous population and put them into a dense area that they do high tech massacres against every 10 years? the Israelis. The only disgusting person here is you, as you defend a genocidal ethno state akin to the Nazi state. Hamas is a symptom of what's been done to the Palestinian people. History didn't begin on oct 7th. Maybe you should think with your brain instead of just reciting stupid westernized israeli propaganda

    • @WuhanMan2013
      @WuhanMan2013 8 часов назад

      Excellent remark.

  • @susanWilder2175
    @susanWilder2175 15 часов назад +12

    Typical dismissal of women. Infuriating!

    • @saturnative
      @saturnative 8 часов назад

      They were just IDF monsters. No women there.

  • @knightlife22
    @knightlife22 12 часов назад +35

    If you illegally occupy someone and oppress them for decades it’s not realistic to expect them to break out of the prison you’ve put them in just to have a conversation. Free Palestine.

    • @sounakmallik4725
      @sounakmallik4725 10 часов назад

      U dont know what occupation is..and accusing israle as oppressor sounds like rabbits opressesing snakes...when its jews land been occupied by these jihadists..hav Some brain

    • @ConstantGardener-q9q
      @ConstantGardener-q9q 10 часов назад +1

      One person’s freedom fighter is another person’s terrorists. One person‘s terrorist is another person‘s freedom fighter. Meanwhile, it’s women, children, and elderly who suffer because of this kind of justification of violence.

    • @gillianespinoza3652
      @gillianespinoza3652 10 часов назад

      Yup.

    • @Sad_Bumper_Sticker
      @Sad_Bumper_Sticker 9 часов назад

      It’s complex because BOTH SIDES do not accept the other side’s ethnic historic Right to the Land. Both openly say the other side migrated, the identity of Palestinians is rejected as “Middle Eastern Migrants” and the Jewish Israeli ethnicity is rejected by the other side as “White. Europeam Migrants” which is wholly untrue because it ignores the Middle Eastern Jewish Israelis who were banished from Middle Eastern Countries after centuries of living there. The Pro-Palestinian “White European Convert Colonialism” argument ignores 1. that Ashenazi Jewish ppl were from Israel and are still genetically so, it ignores. Sephardic Jews and Mizrachi Jews and ignores Jewish people from Africa living in Israel. The pro-Palestinian side does not “Only Want Ceasefire” but they openly say that Israelis have not Right to the Land in the Middle East which is ethnically untrue. The ProPalestinan side calls for the removal of the entire Country of Israel which is Antisemitism. Calling for the “REMOVAL” of a 3 million population to take over (“back”) their Land is why ProPalestinian calls are de facto constitues calling for Gene-oh-Side. Also, the Land of current Israel was mostly never geopolitically “Palestine” but was geographically Other CModdle Eastern Countrie.
      Sadly the Israeli side spreads the same narrative - that Palestinians are a mix of Middle Eastern Migrants, not an ethnicity.
      Both brutal uprising murders, decades of unaliving Israelis with SlimgShots and chest bombs set off on Israeli buses and cafes and brutal terrorist actions like October 7th is morally abhorrent. Palestinians argued that burning houses with families was acceptable because “All Kibutzim were army” and “All Israelis are Army”. This is how they justify their unaliving of Israeli civilians.
      And Israel does exactly the same claiming “All Palestinans support Hamas and work for Hamas”. Leveling Gazas towns and cities with bombs will not magically “Remove Hamas Terrorism”. The ONLY WAY PALESTINIANS WILL be praceful will be when 3 million Israelis “move back to Europe” which is the Antisemitic request made by the ProPalestinian side in e.g. Speeches and Marches.
      So tragically this is not a black and whiite, or a white and black, but a gray and gray conflict. Where BOTH SIDES WERE/ARE TAUGHT TO OPENLY CALL THE OTHER SIDE terms like “Animals” which is dehumanizing. Both sides dehumanize the other side. Both reject and demean the other sides Culture and Religion.
      Both Sides have tbeir own history books going back centuries earlier, their own versions of the history of the Land in 1920s, 1930s, 1940s, 1950s etc up to 2024.
      Both sides have tbeir own History Books and their own Archeology theories.
      It is truly🕊️ Utterly Hopeless. Today BOTH sides do not want a two State Solution.
      There is no hope. And what BOTH SIDES are doing will NOT. BRING PEACE 😢😢🕊️☮️
      For a century Both Sides have commited VERY DIFFERENT attrocities on civilians, today both sides are guilty of DIFFERENT attrocities on civilians of the other side. Both sides do not admit to their owm guilt. Both sides claim they are 100% inmocent victims.
      ALMOST nobody is able to openly say that this 100yr old war is EXTREMELY COMPLEX. How to solve a conflict when both sides negate the other side’s right to the Land? There is no Geographical Border which will make Either the Palestiniand OR the Israelis satisfied.
      For peace, both sides need to reconsile and change.

    • @madnessends2477
      @madnessends2477 9 часов назад

      @@ConstantGardener-q9qits kinda crazy that ppl insist that “women, children and the elderly” are the ones that suffer when statistics pretty clearly show that men are make up the vast majority of casualities, and nomIm not referring to combatants. I guess men are simply not seen as sympathetic

  • @raoulhubris
    @raoulhubris 11 часов назад +3

    Thank you for telling this truth. The response seems to defend the government more than the populace . Michel is the best.

  • @beverlydwyer5162
    @beverlydwyer5162 16 часов назад +12

    War is just so stupid…. 😔

    • @BigBoy-rv2vu
      @BigBoy-rv2vu 12 часов назад +3

      Religions and wars.

    • @onlyme80
      @onlyme80 12 часов назад

      @@BigBoy-rv2vu how did you come up with that conclusion? let me guess... atheists!

    • @jeffphan8256
      @jeffphan8256 11 часов назад

      @@BigBoy-rv2vu this has nothing to do with religion. It has everything to do with colonialism.

  • @hmmcinerney
    @hmmcinerney 16 часов назад +12

    I keep seeing Hershs face everywhere. Hersh had a very comfortable and privileged life in America. Why did he feel the need to go to a foreign country and disposes and brutalise the indigenous people? He planned to go to Goa after Gaza, a little R and R when he tired of apartheid

    • @nawal4686
      @nawal4686 12 часов назад +3

      Because he was brain washed into thinking he is the chosen one and also that stealing land is his birth right - it all served him right

    • @Sad_Bumper_Sticker
      @Sad_Bumper_Sticker 9 часов назад

      Both Israelis and Palestinians have the right to the Land. Jewish people came from Israel and Israeli people are Ashenazi, Sephardic and Mizrachi from the Middle East expelled from Middle Eastern Countries after centuries of living there, also Aftican Jewish people living in Israel. Both Palestiinans and Jewish people have the right to the Land, both reject the other side’s to the Land, both have their owm history books and archeological sites, both reject the other side’s historical ethnic right to the Land. Both reject peace propositions. Both openly claim the other side are “migrants” without right to the Land. Israel reject the ethnic identity of Palestinians calling them “Middle Eastern random migrants”. Both sides dehumanize the other side. Both are guilty of a century of very different attrocities on the other side’s civilians. Both have their own version of events and battles since the 1920s,
      Both sides view themselves as 100% victim and do not admit to their own attrocities on the other side’s civilians.
      Both accuse the other side of “fabricating victimhood”.
      One side calls for the “removal of The Entire 3 million country” which is de facto calling for Gene-Oh-Side (“By Any Means Nexessary”)
      The other side reduced Gaza to rubble ruthlessly bombing cities and towns even though “Removing Hamas” is completely unrealistic.
      Both sides mock the other side’s culture and religion.
      Both sides dehumanize the other side.
      Both sides claim “THEIR” violence was / is acceptable because “The Other Side” attacked first.
      Israel does not admit grazing Gaza will not realistically reduce terrorism against Israel or bring back 11.07 Hostages, nor does it stop illegal settlement in the north.
      And Palestinians do not admit to mass roope of women 7.11, or burning entire families with children, or slaughering unarmed civilians at the music festival. Palestinians do not want any Jewish people in the Middle East so the problem was never “encrouching land borders” or “conflict over borders” since the Palestinian side calls for Gene-Oh-Side which is calling to the ethnic “moving out” of 3 million Ashenazi, Sephardic, Mizrachi Middle Eastern and African Jewish people from. the current country of Israel to where?? Europe?? America?? Palestinians also do not admit that decades of suicide bombs on Israeli busses and cafes. Or decades of slimgshots aiming rockes at Israeli heads. They justify burning families in Kibbutzes and kidnapping children and the elderly to Gaza, justify the murder of elderly frail Holocaust Survivors 7.11.
      This conflict is NOT black and white or white and black. It is trafically gray and gray. It is about vengeance and ethic cleansing. Both sides have extremist relgious views that the Holy Sites should only be inhabited by people of THEIR OWN RELIGION.
      This is a tragedy of endless vengeance on both sides. Both sides reject calls for peace. Both reject all propositions of borders. Both reject a Two State Solution or a One State Solution.

  • @JoannaRives
    @JoannaRives 13 часов назад +11

    Conveniently ignored.

    • @mithrasrevisited4873
      @mithrasrevisited4873 8 часов назад

      Conspiracy BS. They did not let jews be killed, this is more blame the je*ws again.

  • @ronaldcolson7779
    @ronaldcolson7779 12 часов назад +9

    They let it happen, I think

    • @mithrasrevisited4873
      @mithrasrevisited4873 8 часов назад

      Conspiracy BS. They did not let jews be killed, this is more blame the je*ws again.

  • @JimBarcelona
    @JimBarcelona 16 часов назад +12

    History will record 10/07 as a defensive failure. It's recorded that way in wikipedia. Agents of Israel have tried to change it, but it won't happen. RIP to those ignored.

  • @ONeillsJimbaLounge
    @ONeillsJimbaLounge 15 часов назад +39

    Turns out most of those who were attacked on October 7 had actually served in the Israeli defense force because over 90% of the population has to serve. So Palestinians were not just attacking civilians. They were attacking current and previous Israeli defense forces who had stolen their lands and were then partying on stolen Palestinian land.

    • @marilynshepherd6480
      @marilynshepherd6480 15 часов назад +7

      That is what I have been saying all along

    • @mikeg2306
      @mikeg2306 13 часов назад +3

      That's disgusting! Unarmed people dancing are civilians no matter what their military status

    • @GrannyRalls
      @GrannyRalls 12 часов назад +3

      ​​@@mikeg2306I understand your statement's sentiment but just remember many former IDF picked up guns that day and fired back and many intruders were actually civilians from Gaza there to loot and wreak havoc just as the soldiers (whether active, former or reserved) had wreaked upon Gaza before 10-7-23 and currently as seen on TikTok where IDF soldiers brag about what they've done and continue to do.

    • @fattymoddy
      @fattymoddy 10 часов назад +4

      @@mikeg2306What’s disgusting is dropping 2000 lb bombs killing 40,000 Palestinian civilians a majority of whom are women and children. Till date as per UN, 900 Palestinian families totally wiped out.
      So, stop crying for 1200 most of who are Israeli army. Calling them civilians is a blatant lie!!

    • @elsonck2523
      @elsonck2523 8 часов назад

      @@mikeg2306 And so are the Palestinians at home sleeping in their beds amid 2am daily bombing raids!

  • @fikerehman9614
    @fikerehman9614 11 часов назад +9

    Occupation is expensive and this is the price you pay for it. So stop whining

  • @nahedha3253
    @nahedha3253 9 часов назад +3

    It is not a border! This is the segregation wall that Israel build on Palestinian lands.

    • @mithrasrevisited4873
      @mithrasrevisited4873 8 часов назад

      Not palestinian land. They are jordan and egyptian arabs there. The jews were there well before the arabs from saudi arabia arrived. Jordanians and Egyptians took the land in the 1940's and Israel won it back in the 1960's. The original israel state included Esst Bank and the Gaza, it is disputed land.

  • @Hiptoys
    @Hiptoys 8 часов назад +1

    So Israel knew what will happen!

  • @meh.7539
    @meh.7539 8 часов назад

    Never interrupt your opponent when they're making a mistake.

  • @ShilgenVens
    @ShilgenVens 12 часов назад +11

    WOMEN not GIRLS.

    • @meh.7539
      @meh.7539 9 часов назад +1

      Occupying force. Not women.

    • @WuhanMan2013
      @WuhanMan2013 8 часов назад +1

      And occupying soldiers.

  • @checkeredflagfilms
    @checkeredflagfilms 8 часов назад +1

    not until BN is overthrown will ANY meaningful inquiry take place and those responsible for failure will be held accountable. That why BN is prolonging the conflict. He knows he'll go straight to prison.

  • @ashleybrown325
    @ashleybrown325 9 часов назад +1

    Wow they were warned an no one looked at it !
    I would know they getting ready for an attack!

  • @kookoo4kokopuffs9330
    @kookoo4kokopuffs9330 11 часов назад +3

    What a huge failure, yes but what a tragedy for the additional loss of life.

    • @Lorenzo939
      @Lorenzo939 9 часов назад +1

      failure or sacrifice?

  • @MrJoeBobSmith
    @MrJoeBobSmith 8 часов назад +1

    Bro it was not incompetence... It was by design

  • @nahedha3253
    @nahedha3253 9 часов назад +1

    How come soldiers in an army base not armed! These are solidere on duty! She tried to paint them as innocent civilians!!! Seriously!

  • @marcogallazzi9049
    @marcogallazzi9049 11 часов назад +3

    Ignored my arse

  • @nahedha3253
    @nahedha3253 9 часов назад +1

    And how come this Israeli has perfect American accent!!!

  • @nj1638
    @nj1638 11 часов назад

    What a show the host put on.

  • @theother1406
    @theother1406 8 часов назад

    This is HUGE y'all

  • @nazliayub4786
    @nazliayub4786 10 часов назад

    Of course look who they're interviewing:

  • @virgomoon6400
    @virgomoon6400 10 часов назад

    Israel is having a difficult year. That says a lot.

  • @144Donn
    @144Donn 8 часов назад

    50 years ago with regard to the Yom Kippur war, there was GREAT failure to listen to the people on the ground. All sorts of reports were coming in from the front lines but vanity and cock-sureness bit them in the tuchus...as it tragically did here. Hopefully, it is a lesson which will not be forgotten. NEVER EVER take anything for granted. Hatred of Israel NEVER sleeps!
    There is another angle to consider, as Anat said they were focused on the Northern border as Hezbollah was considered a much stronger force. When one plays Chess, they can be so focused on a great move they up their sleeve that they do not see the obvious & immediate danger they are in. Israel may have been so focused on the beepers and walky talky moves that they lost focus of the Southern danger.

  • @acerrubrum5749
    @acerrubrum5749 13 часов назад +1

    Wowser, slaughtering unarmed soldiers.
    Geneva Convention
    Persons taking no active part in the hostilities, including members of armed forces who have laid down their arms and those placed hors de combat by sickness, wounds, detention, or any other cause, shall in all circumstances be treated humanely, without any adverse distinction founded on race, colour, religion or faith ...

    • @GrannyRalls
      @GrannyRalls 12 часов назад +2

      Not all of those who followed Hamas that day during their "prison break" were combatants and were seen making several trips back and forth with toilets, horses, tractors and anything that wasn't nailed down but those who carried weapons of any kind and used them were most likely carrying out revenge for all of the IDF incursions since 1945 during which they shot at anything that moved and only stopped when international pressure was applied from DC or domestically. This time, I believe Hamas and Palestinian civilians were purposefully allowed to be able to invade the base and kibbutzim but the ultimate goal was to kidnap people alive to be used for trades to get their own people held as political prisoners in Israeli administrative detention or who'd be found guilty of throwing rocks and given the mandatory sentence of 20 years. What a horror show the past year has been and it must stop. Period.

    •  8 часов назад

      Tell that to Hind and her entire family, oh you can't can you? They were all murdered when trying to get to one of the SAFE places recomended to them by the merciful zionists so she can't tell can she? Six years old life for her had only just begun! Sitting ducks one and all!

  • @gregoryallen0001
    @gregoryallen0001 8 часов назад +1

    they had the pagers and walkies for years.. the israelis LET IT HAPPEN sorry but obv

  • @Lorenzo939
    @Lorenzo939 8 часов назад

    I would also consider these women (and the average Israeli) a victim of conditioning. It's not that hard to imagine how easy it is to control the culture (ie media and education) of a country slightly smaller than New Jersey. A quick 5min explainer that barely scratches the surface, but is still a good intro: ruclips.net/video/a7cgzz5W8uM/видео.htmlsi=IqAY5q3Hh11ImNm8

  • @thosethatcan
    @thosethatcan 12 часов назад

    Es la verda.

  • @Marius_vanderLubbe
    @Marius_vanderLubbe 15 часов назад

    The hershy highway.

  • @foofkanon
    @foofkanon 12 часов назад +4

    Israel has always been a martial society. The fact that Israeli youth, many on molly were partying next to an open air prison is chilling. I am glad that this program is not spreading the SA lie anymore. How many children and women died because of those lies.

    • @ConstantGardener-q9q
      @ConstantGardener-q9q 10 часов назад

      And Palestine has always been a terrorist society. The fact that young Hamas terrorists, many of them drugs, were parachuting into a festival in an agricultural area is chilling. I am glad that the program is not spreading the lies that Hamas supports the Palestinians anymore. How many billions of dollars did they steal from the Palestinian people? How many women, children and elderly have died because of Hamas’ lies?

  • @Rhythmicons
    @Rhythmicons 14 часов назад +5

    Us ignored women who warned about 9/11 also.

    • @ConstantGardener-q9q
      @ConstantGardener-q9q 10 часов назад +1

      As I recall it was Condoleza Rice who ignored 9/11 warnings

  • @jessieheartart
    @jessieheartart 14 часов назад +6

    Highly Recommend this oct 7 doc by al Jazeera. ruclips.net/video/_0atzea-mPY/видео.htmlsi=GltDKsrgu_1SBLe5

  • @leoxvelllopez6476
    @leoxvelllopez6476 8 часов назад

    women most of the time talk nonesense, so when thay speak something serious nobody pay attention..