If you feel useless, remember, it took 20 years, trillions of dollars, thousands of innocent Afghan civilians, and 4 US presidents to replace the Taliban with Taliban.
Please know that these were the exact conditions for millions of Afghans before the takeover as well. Afghans were selling children, marrying daughters to much older men for money, hospitals had a shortage of medical equipment and much more. It is disappointing that the media is shedding light on these issues now and was almost silent before the takeover.
These people think k that it was Jannah for us...that they food, water, money and everything just flowed and Afghanistan was a Dubai. 90% of Afgjans were already below the poverty line under the foreign occupation. All sectors were in a mess, most girls and many boys were not going to school under the US and NATO foreign invader terrorists and their Afghan puppets, corruption, sexual abuse, pedophilia, human trafficking, prostitution, starvation, drug abuse etc were rife in Afghanistan under the foreign occupation.
And it will now become even worse for these poor people, with women no longer allowed to work, resulting in another income loss. With women no longer allowed to receive an education, there will be no better future to look forward to. Without investments from foreign companies, there will be few, if any, better job opportunities. There seems to be little to no future left for this country, only more suffering. The only ones who will benefit from all of this are the Taliban leaders, living in large houses with air conditioning and enjoying nice meals. Is this what you want for yourself and your family? Of course not. Yet, you seem to be okay with allowing this fate to befall others. It's quite hypocritical. Perhaps a more fitting description for people like you would be fanatics. It's truly bewildering.
I'm a muslim and Despite whatever people say. USA helped Afghanistan a lot by sending aid all these years. People who praise taliban should go and live under them.
@@kasimashraf4001 I speak for pretty much the entirety of the country. afghans were polled by PEW Research and 99% want strict sharia law. Yes, 99%! So let them have it, without a cent more of western money.
This situation is not only in Afghanistan rather it's going in every single development country. Here, in Pakistan, the situation is worse than that. Many people are living below the poverty line. Their children are unable to get an education. There is a very high child labor ratio. Like this, you may hear millions of stories of Pakistani. Although, it is a free state, unlike Afghanistan. But I never saw BBC News with such a broadcast about other development countries or before the Taliban rule in Afghanistan.
Unlike Afghanistan? Afghanistan is a free state since last 2 years, it had been under war for 20 years before that, you are so brain washed to believe that Afghanistan was free when it was being invaded by outsiders and is not free when it's own people are rulers of it.
Pakistan...a "free state". This propaganda is getting pathetic. Everyone knows that the current regime is US installed, had foreign strings attached..foreign backers with "deep pockets" ad former foreign minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi would put it.
Wow, yet don't Pakistan want to run kashmir too? I wonder how they will be able to run another place when its in a big hole itself. You should puts some vids up of how bad life really is in pak
I watched some videos recently by Afghan just walking around different places in Afghanistan. In Kabul the shops were piled high with displays of all sorts of nuts and fruits. I also watched an interesting video on Taliban treating drug addicts. Personally, I would not fancy a religious theocracy as government but I don't trust western media to tell any thing like the whole truth on the country. It is easy enough to make a video on the homeless camped in the streets of L.A. or San Francisco and sell the message that America is a dreadful place.
i mean i am in california it is not that bad, and big deal the taliban do a couple nice things but most is bad they take away freedom they hate on other ethnic groups they change the flag they ban music they kill afghans who fought for their country they're invaders they should go back to pakistan
@@sikandar9381bro 92% of the country’s is in poverty, hazaras and Shias are still getting mistreated, woman don’t have any form of higher education, I’m from Afghanistan and I can safely say this is a shit situation
@@uptmr9768 At least you have proper law and order, no one can Kill, rape, do unjustice due to the Shariah imposed while in Pakistan anyone can kill, rape, corruption etc and no one is to ask! And Mullah Omar's son has already made a comment that when the country stabilizes we are projecting a shariah loving environment for women education! You guys have made Mada 9 Thnx to government, your currency is better than our's. still you regret being afghani lol. In Pakistan we give your examples to muslims due to the shariah you are following.
America isn't a bad country but stuff u saw are like best of best in kabul there isn't more than that .every day going to my English course now I'm used to seeing 5 and 9 yr kids working or begging for food.u see them everywhere u go it's so sad
@@bonnie7898 Taliban's biggest success is eliminating feudalism of warlord culture by tribal elders which never allowed formation of a homogenous nation in last 5000 years. The biggest mistake of USA is taking those warlord tribal elders as allies against Taliban, like Rashid Dostum, Abdullah Mohid, Massoud, etc who are infamous for genocides on other tribals according to UN. USA got no better option against Taliban except those criminals claiming to be followers of democracy who are ten times more hated by common people than any Taliban leader.
My sympathy for the people of Afghanistan is small... They had their chance to fight the Taliban over the many years American & NATO forces occupied their country. Even when the Americans finally left, they just sat back & allowed the Taliban to walk all over them. Death before slavery.
Majority of us Afghans support Taliban and our Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan government and security forces now. It was your US and NATO foreign invader terrorists who were the terrorists on our soil. Now the US sanctions us and stole all our Afghan assets and threatened countries with sanction of they recognize us
I guess its some kind of democracy for this region. The majority didn't want to fight at all, so they chose to be under Taliban. Had they fought, they would receive help and victory.
I counted five children and one looks like it has been born since we withdrew and he knew he would not have his foreign job. So he sends his eldest beautiful sad boy off to work for the family that he keeps growing!? ... and we are supposed to stay there to support them and continue to drain ourselves to give aid? There comes a point when reality has to set in and we let nature take its course.
there IQ is not high, they are not educated, many of them might not even know what earth looks like or structure of solar system and universe, education is need of revolution in countries like afghanistan, pakistan to get people on right track...
This is what happens when you send thousands of soldiers, provide weapons and training, and then when you leave because it is under control, the men of the country you helped just do not fight for their own land. Afghanistan lost because the men just did not care about fighting, mostly the women are suffering from the new regime, and they are merely seen as objects by the men. Shame on the men who failed their own country.
@@Ada-et7fv Sadly yes. I am sad for the women but honestly these guys deserved to get taken over. Rich countries lost plenty of money, weapons, and lives to work their asses up but they straight up surrendered their own country. Gg.
Oh have the Taliban stopped shooting at maternity hospitals killing women actually giving birth? Well now that's an improvement. How about the Taliban not beating women to death for wearing the wrong fashion? But hey that's peace eh?
@@cestwhat1317Yes, because of Us sactions. Americans will try to conquer a country, overthrowing its legitimate goverment, impose lgtv values, lose a war after 20 years and now they will kill 1 million children
@@kingkobrazxLol you are in California. Your family was most likely a collabolator with the occupiers and you a homosexual or otherwise a degenarate merchant class. If only we had a christian taliban in the west so we could rid of liberals, like the taliban did
I feel such sorrow for the young girl and the family at the end of the clip. Surely keeping your family smaller will make their chances of all servicing and doing well so much better though?
Yeah but if the US decides to invade again than they need as many men as possible to fight, also I think the US bomarding the country should be in Q not these peoples reasons for breeding
Having multiple kids is usually beneficial in poorer countries. If you only have one or two kids, they could easily die from sickness or an accident, leaving you with no children. If you have 10 children, there's a good chance some of them will survive.
What a "stupid" thing to say! This is how the Taliban operated 'before' the West came. You are practicing "cultural condescension..." in thinking that when these people had democracy that they were not capable or worthy of choosing their own lives? Stop playing pathetic games with 'other...' people's lives please?
And "who..." do you believe is not 'thinking?' This is how the Taliban operated 'before' the West came. The West brought democracy, allowing the people of Afghanistan to decide their own future... now the Taliban have taken this, and therefore "they" are the occupying force! You are practicing "cultural condescension..." in thinking that when these people if had democracy that they were not capable or worthy of choosing their own lives? That's not respecting the Afghan people. And if you did genuinely care for the Afghan people... you'd know that most of them did not wish for us to leave, and the Government, and particularly women of course wish for the West to stay. You're just it seems repeating anti-West propaganda, and not thinking for yourself unfortunately! @@phoenixrising8640
It's a sad news story, but a shocking fact should not go unnoticed. Despite the poor economic conditions and poverty, they still continue to breed. Life goes on with choices.
What a stupid statement. Congrats, you've just described what humans have done since the dawn of our existence some 200,000 years ago. Of course "they" breed. Humans always breed, ESPECIALLY when poor. Breeding decreases when socio-economic status improves. It INCREASES when socio-economic status declines. How the hell do you not know this, are you mentally retarded?
It is one of the ironies of life that the poorest people tend to breed more with the consequences that those children will suffer and become calloused and rather harsher than normal.
Then you’re not a Muslim. It’s one thing to live in a secular country but to say secularism is better than the laws of Allah is clear cut kufr (disbelief). May Allah guide you brother, study your deen and don’t speak without knowledge.
These lunatics have taken Afghanistan back to the dark ages.It’s beyond saving and tragically will be one of the greatest crimes against the young generation of its people 😢.
Because his wife is his property, and her body is there for his pleasure. He's not going to do without because she might produce another child. That's marketable inventory.
As a muslim,i am very sad for the situation of that people,they liberated their country but i think they did not make the leadership in the hands of THE LEADERS WITH vision,any way i pray for my people.
They were much better when US was in there…Radical Islam breaks that country apart. US completed its mission of neutralizing Al Qaeda and Bin Laden the rest is on afeghanistan to realize on its own the truth is that afeganistan is a country full of savages there is too many of them you can’t change this who don’t desire a change. But the good people in afeganistan were living a better life thanks to USA’s presence. Everything is worst now. But that is not USA’s problem to solve. USA only had to focus on Al Qaeda and Bin Laden and that’s what they accomplished with minimal casualties.
As a muslim, I can say you have been victim of propaganda by the biggest propaganda channel . I don't support Taliban and state that they are doing fantastic. But these situations were there before too and people used to get killed by Nato also. Obviously there would be these conditions, 20 years of war and after that sanctions by the West. If BBc really cares, why not tell it's government to lift sanctions. Obviously they would require quite a time to manage their economy and educated economists
The problem is MUSLIM citizens feel ok to get treat like that in their country. They still support their MUSLIM leader to the heartbeat because even it bad but still same roots, same skintone, same religion!! US IS STUPID, they’re not ask them to involve. But you’re chose to go there & force Muslim citizens to living in CIVILIZATION & MODERN LIFE WHEN THEY WANT LIVE IN RELIGIOUS LAWS & TRIBES LIFESTYLE!! So many wasteful moneys & wasteful people dead for NOTHING!! Now, Taliban take this country as CITIZENS AFGHANS WANT, its their choice & it their country. Let their RUNNING THEIR COUNTRY AA THEY WANT, EVEN PPL IS POOR, HUNGRY, NO FOODS, NO MEDICINE, NO TECHNOLOGY WHATEVER, but it’s their choice & their wishes!! So they can keep women wear hijab, no education, sold girls,etc.. good or bad, RIGHT OR WRONG ITS STILL THEIR CHOICE BECAUSE IT THEIR COUNTRY!! All ppl need to do is DOING THE BEST FOR THEIR PEOPLES & THEIR COUNTRY. UNLESS THEYRE GOING TO YOU, BEGGING YOU HELP, SHOWING THEIR NEED YOUR HELP THE MOST & GRATEFUL THANKS YOU IN HEARTBEAT, THEYRE ASKING HELP YOU SHOWING MERCY & HUMANITY RIGHT, it’s the times you chose to do right thing as SHOULD INVOLVED & HELP!! You show hands to people who don’t want, who don’t like, who’s BLOODY HATE YOU IS TOTALLY STUPID OF ANY LEVELS!!
We still are. Tell your US terrorist government to stop the cruel sanctions and return all our Afghan assets they stole, and to stop interfering in our internal affairs
They only shows about women and poverty they will not show the progress and stability of Afghanistan wann see the reality on the ground better Watch Afghan vloggers or RUclipsrs .
"I will be forced to sell my children to survive" I wonder if afghans know how remarkble it is that this is commonly viewed as an option in their culture, demonstrating how children are seen as the father's property and expendable. I believe that in most cultures, parents would just start walking with their kids before they ever had that thought. other people may surrender children to other families or orphanages and such, but they wouldn't say "well if I"m going to give them up, I reckon they're worth some money".
@@NegativeOpposite yes, u owe us reparations for the least if not aid, all our Afghan assets back amd dropping of sanctions or not bullying countries into not recognizing us with the threat if sanctions if they do.
Its weird being in a time when the heights of technology and information sharing are within our grasp and yet still people are wage slaved into starvation or selling children.
Yeah but it's a similar story here just on a smaller scale. We've got a financial industry awash with money and huge bonuses, we have drones delivering packages, driverless transport, AI, all that stuff, then you've got people dying from the mould in their rented homes, parents who work full time and can't afford dinner, energy bills that our breaking the bank...
@@lewis123417 I'm not sure if that's what you tell yourself to sleep well at night or if you're just that oblivious. Either way, ignorance is bliss ig.
This happened before we went it. Regiments and training teams of the Afghan police and army regularly raised their concerns about the mens deviancy with underage boys and were told to ignore. Exporting our values to these people doesn't work.
It was the former warlords and the Afghan security forces who had the rep for bacha bazi ("boy play"). Foreign Policy (10/28/2002) had this on the subject: "The Taliban had a deep aversion towards bacha bazi, outlawing the practice when they instituted strict nationwide sharia law. According to some accounts, including the hallmark Times of London article “Kandahar Comes out of the Closet” in 2002, one of the original provocations for the Taliban’s rise to power in the early 1990s was their outrage over pedophilia."
@@worldview730 Nothing ever has , Russia failed, Americans failed and the British twice . I think in the end Afghanistan will break up into separate states or sadly there will be another civil war and one warlord running it , either way that’s how it looks . Whatever money gos into the place seems to be lost or ends up in bank accounts somewhere in the world , the population continues to suffer endlessly and the killing carry’s on regardless of who is in power , it’s a graveyard for any democracy and it’s a very harsh life …… The likes of Tony Blair and George W Bush made a shambles of it and they both made a fortune out from it . In the end it’s like another Vietnam and that turned out to be a graveyard for US soldiers because the politicians lost there bottle . This may sound bad but it’s best left alone and because of the recent past and the history of wrong doings the west is hated . They don’t want outsiders interfering with there country and if the shoe was on the other foot you would feel the same way ……
@theatheist friend, I'm a Malaysian, my country is an Islamic country, but my country is the most peaceful country in the world, so it's human's fault not God's,
Our soldiers, along with the Americans spent spent twenty years giving life and limb to protect the Afghans. They were taught how to fight, and left copious weapons when we pulled out so they could fight for their country. The Afghans cowards far outnumbered the Taliban, yet instead of fighting they let the Taliban have everything while they try to run into any country that will have them. The Afghan girls have far more courage than the men.
Its the culture.. they easily make agreements with each other during conflict and barter their way out of it rather than stay as one cohesive purposful mass. Its not a western army nor is it a western culture. They have a network of tribal loyalties and relationships. Of course, they wear a uniform and learn to solider for pay.. but when the chips are down will revert to what they know.. and they did. Might also be something to do with their nato training teaching them to lean on air cover and nato support too much too.. even though on paper they could survive without it.. in reality they could not..
100% so glad it’s just a small minority who spout the refugees welcome rubbish, though sadly, they’re the minority the majority constantly elects… Weird world isn’t it…
This was unfortunately always going to happen. They have more loyalty to their individual tribes than the country we basically went in and formed for them. When the shit hit the fan, it was less a matter of cowardice and more that many of the AFN just didn't care enough to fight for it.
@@gyver8448 You really think they fought believing in the Bulshit that the US was going to make the country, no it was only for US money and to provide for the family
These are deep pocket media won't tell you the truth, wont tell you about the Afghan's culture, Won't tell you how peacefull is Afghanistan after NATO left.
Well yeah, why would western governments prop up a terrorist government with aid? They want the taliban they can have them, and their economic mismanagement
The USSR destroyed Afghanistan and it hasn’t climbed back since. Not allowing women or girls to go to school and work is cruel and extremely stupid (economically).
It makes us realize that "peace" exists because there is a state of non-peace. It may not be possible to realize true peace simply by advocating "peace" without realizing it.
Peace exists because of the fact that Jesus Christ is our peace giver. Peace doesn't ever come from materialistic stuff or having accumulated wealth for one self. Sure,wealth helps us to have peace of mind ,to not worry so much but it doesn't actually sustain our peace for long. Jesus does that for us though. Just thought I'd point that out.. God bless
Have you watched the other side of reporting? Ie: not western side? Obviously after the Néocolonialist NATO gang got their @ss kicked by them, they portray them as evil and did nothing good after the white men left.... 😂
The US had good intentions when it comes to Afghanistan. They wasn't trying to change their Religion or anything like that. If the Taliban wasn't attacking Afghans all these years imagine where the country would be now. Countries like Germany, Japan and South Korea has been transformed after terrible wars
What part of Russia is a "dictatorship" do too many people not understand? 'Dictatorships...' don't even allow their own people to speak out, or know the truth! So why on earth would think for a moment they would tell "you" the truth?
If a Russian person even calls this a 'war...' they can face upwards of "10 years" or more in jail, or worse be murdered by the regime. Putin has said this 'war...' has to be called a "special military operation." Russian soldiers are brutalised, lied to and tortured by their own government. The families how lose loved ones, few get the death payments promised them, and soldiers themselves are left often with no pay or weapons with substandard equipment, which left many to freeze to death in winter. There are no free fair elections in Russia under Putin - all free media and political opposition has been shut down, journalists, politicians and ordinary people - imprisoned or murdered! Many have been taken in by Russian disinformation: by the way it was Russia under Stalin and the KGB in 1923 which arrived at the concept and coined the word 'disinformation!' They even gave it a Western sounding name, so we would more easily adopt it... so that worked? Putin has murdered "100 000s" of people in Chechnya, Georgia, Syria, Moldova, Belarus and Ukraine and elsewhere in the world. Syria, was a people's uprising as a result of the Arab Spring, which began in Tunisia in 2010, as a result Assad slaughtered peaceful protesters with gunships. The people fought bravely for years, but when Damascus was about to fall, Assad called in Putin. Assad and Putin then murdered "100 000s" of people, dropping bombs on children in their schools, burning them alive! In Russia itself, if people even call the Ukraine Russia War, a "war..." they can face up to "10 years" in jail, or if someone is a high profile politician or public figure, then can be imprisoned or even murdered. A recent UN stated the in a terror campaign orchestrated by Putin... "children" as young as '4' years old are being tortured and raped. We must act to stop this, and support the people of Ukraine to ensure this ends... in defeating the Putin Regime this could be a turning corner for humanity, in our search to end war, and all injustice? @@paul7TM
Seriously, why do the poor always bare more children than they can afford? Why bring another child into this world when you're barely surviving, and also living in a tyrannical society. The father at the end of the clip has me dumbfounded. It seems like he has seven children. The baby was obviously born after the Taliban took over
@@tareksahak4478 fuck you man. Fuck off . What is islam? Killing others? Disrespects others and their believes ? What a arrogancy is that. Be civilized man. Keep your religion behind at home. And be a human being in public . Rather be a Animal
Most desperate solution to a desperate situation is stop having children!!! It's cruel but it's completely viable!! Why have kids and curse them to a world of hell?!
Do u remember that piece they ir CNN did where they put makeup on for thso child and said that she was going to be married off to an old and but everyone who investigated, including our Afghan police found our that it was a lie😂😂😂
@HappyNuristani are u talking about that news video last year, that either CNN or BBC said that a little girl got married to an old man? That was a lie.
Lyse Doucet is s brilliant journalist! It's a wonder the Taliban let her report. The Taliban have dragged Afganistan into an abyss of sorrow, discrimination and poverty! Why is the world not reacting to this humanitarian crisis. The Taliban are not politicians; they are misogynistic tyrants with no idea of how to rule a country without threats and weapons.
Why we should do anything if Afghan people are happy with Talibans ruling them? Only bunch of Afghan womens were protesting while all the men just drop their guns and escaped like cowards.
Why are you ignoring the tortures and abuses Afghan civillians suffered under the US? Heck, the US itself is in ruins now, there are more drug addicts in US than there is in Afghan (the drug producer of the world), and it reduced thanks to Taliban
@@AksarallahI don't understand this. Our Islamic Emirate government is doing everything possible to help our drug addicts but America, who has so much money is not. But then again, US marines and NATO were guarding poppy fields in Afghanistan
@@phoenixrising8640 yes I agree with you. US keeps talking about progressive nation, whereas their country 10% is addicted to drugs. While Taliban did good job and now only 8% addicts in the largest drug exporter nation Proving how US doesnt care about Afghans at all, but simply impose their values on others. And ofcourse having more frontline to attack on Russia, and other geopolitics which they don't talk about
UK has left Afghan translators and their families behind, shallow promises from an even shallower government, Afghanistan and Iraq wars were utter disasters and the war criminals who started the wars and doing very well thank you
their lives are better than when the US or UK interfered in their domestic affairs. Don't pretend to show off their children's difficult lives, they are still alive and free. Just take care of the tens of millions of American people wandering the streets, don't pretend to be concerned about other countries' affairs. Hypocritical
Let’s good back and spend another 1.5 Trillion! To do nothing apart from fund the big military companies, over 50% of that money (our money) goes straight to those companies who lobby for war. It’s crazy how long that racket has been going on and we buy it every time.
Afghanistan doesn't exist anymore, its the Islamic Emirates. They aren't entitled to the money that was made by the Republic of Afghanistan. They want barbaric rule, we aren't going to prop them up with money
It's so hard to look at that little girl and think about how her education is about to end with her dreams crushed, solely because the rulers of the country decided so.
We gave the Afghans all the tools and education needed to repel the Taliban, move out of severe poverty and give the country a chance to develop, unfortunately they thought life back under medieval Taliban rule would be better, I feel sorry for the kids and future generations as the cowardly Afghan army failed their country.
I dont think these people really have a choice. We should stop the hipocrasy - US and europe are investing and supporting these criminals that have the afgan people under slavery.
We in Afghanistan feel very lucky. Stop believing all the propaganda..majority of us Afghans support Taliban and our Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan now
This is heartbreaking to see . In an age when there is no worry and the childhood is full of memories and fun I m saddened beyond words can describe at what these children and these families are going through
"all the boys are playing outside, I wish I could play too." So you just interviewed poor kids like you could find in Los Angeles? That's not journalism.
My proposal to the leaders and elders of Talibans, including you is to widen your vision of what defines your religion, especially now that your are in goverment. You cant set us on fire, if you did that, you would burn with us too. When you cant burn us, the reasoble course of action is for us to build together.
If they are no longer harboring terrorists, which does not seem they are, then leave them alone. They are not bothering anyone. Let them live how they want, not our problem.
The problem is MUSLIM citizens feel ok to get treat like that in their country. They still support their MUSLIM leader to the heartbeat because even it bad but still same roots, same skintone, same religion!! US IS STUPID, they’re not ask them to involve. But you’re chose to go there & force Muslim citizens to living in CIVILIZATION & MODERN LIFE WHEN THEY WANT LIVE IN RELIGIOUS LAWS & TRIBES LIFESTYLE!! So many wasteful moneys & wasteful people dead for NOTHING!! Now, Taliban take this country as CITIZENS AFGHANS WANT, its their choice & it their country. Let their RUNNING THEIR COUNTRY AA THEY WANT, EVEN PPL IS POOR, HUNGRY, NO FOODS, NO MEDICINE, NO TECHNOLOGY WHATEVER, but it’s their choice & their wishes!! So they can keep women wear hijab, no education, sold girls,etc.. good or bad, RIGHT OR WRONG ITS STILL THEIR CHOICE BECAUSE IT THEIR COUNTRY!! All ppl need to do is DOING THE BEST FOR THEIR PEOPLES & THEIR COUNTRY. UNLESS THEYRE GOING TO YOU, BEGGING YOU HELP, SHOWING THEIR NEED YOUR HELP THE MOST & GRATEFUL THANKS YOU IN HEARTBEAT, THEYRE ASKING HELP YOU SHOWING MERCY & HUMANITY RIGHT, it’s the times you chose to do right thing as SHOULD INVOLVED & HELP!! You show hands to people who don’t want, who don’t like, who’s BLOODY HATE YOU IS TOTALLY STUPID OF ANY LEVELS!!
It is recommendable as well as commendable for BBC for giving light about the needs of Afghanistan and its Taliban rulers. The Taliban rulers also cited their plans for their country, as to development for their Economy, their Culture and Art, the ways of life that has to be preserved. Its societal identification and recognition, protection of children from harm and abuse, as well as restoration of its people from a Taliban Government. Economic progress that the people can live and grow, the agriculture sector to export, import and preserve its GDP and its way of life as Afghans.
taliban did not take over, usa brought the terrorist gang back from qatar and handed over Afghanistan to the terrorist gang to continue American crimes and further US goals
If you feel useless, remember, it took 20 years, trillions of dollars, thousands of innocent Afghan civilians, and 4 US presidents to replace the Taliban with Taliban.
@@bonnie7898The US was obviously responsible for the attack. It's also common sense. They needed an excuse to invade all these countries.
@@bonnie7898 Osama found in Pakistan and Taliban taking over Afghanistan in less than 3 days,"both were achieved "😂😂
@@Yilkanzhi_Nooristani
As if Both aren't related
@@bonnie7898that result was achieved along with the destabilisation of a very logistical region.
@@bonnie7898 Don''t worry, these religious shitheads will remain die-hard hitting squad for CIA forever.
Please know that these were the exact conditions for millions of Afghans before the takeover as well. Afghans were selling children, marrying daughters to much older men for money, hospitals had a shortage of medical equipment and much more.
It is disappointing that the media is shedding light on these issues now and was almost silent before the takeover.
These people think k that it was Jannah for us...that they food, water, money and everything just flowed and Afghanistan was a Dubai. 90% of Afgjans were already below the poverty line under the foreign occupation. All sectors were in a mess, most girls and many boys were not going to school under the US and NATO foreign invader terrorists and their Afghan puppets, corruption, sexual abuse, pedophilia, human trafficking, prostitution, starvation, drug abuse etc were rife in Afghanistan under the foreign occupation.
True, in almost all countries of the third world it is the same, no matter who is in power, these are unfortunately very poor countries
And it will now become even worse for these poor people, with women no longer allowed to work, resulting in another income loss. With women no longer allowed to receive an education, there will be no better future to look forward to. Without investments from foreign companies, there will be few, if any, better job opportunities. There seems to be little to no future left for this country, only more suffering. The only ones who will benefit from all of this are the Taliban leaders, living in large houses with air conditioning and enjoying nice meals. Is this what you want for yourself and your family? Of course not. Yet, you seem to be okay with allowing this fate to befall others. It's quite hypocritical. Perhaps a more fitting description for people like you would be fanatics. It's truly bewildering.
There's no denying those problems have become worse since the taliban took over.
Yes but they've become 100 times worse since NATO left.
I'm a muslim and Despite whatever people say. USA helped Afghanistan a lot by sending aid all these years. People who praise taliban should go and live under them.
Only problem is, the taliban wouldn‘t have gottn this powerfull without the US funding to fight communism.
Lol 😂
You are probably the one who helped the Americans empty the Afghan treasury when the US troop left?
@@Wiers75q Afghanistan is on brink of malnutrition and famine without external help. Are they gonna eat weapons?
@@roller2200 I hope so after all the ones we gave them.
Why are people without food continuing to have children?
Because they don't have TV
To sell
Their religion forbids contraception
@@sevi7503
Religion is the root of all evil
Because their religion allowing the man to have more than one wive
The majority of the afghan people want strict islamic law. The taliban are delivering. This is what islamic societies look like; don't complain.
Exactly, if men wanted to defend their women, they would have, women are merely seen as objects there.
And you speak for the majority? Have you ever met an Afghan? Or stepped foot on the country?
@@kasimashraf4001 I speak for pretty much the entirety of the country. afghans were polled by PEW Research and 99% want strict sharia law. Yes, 99%! So let them have it, without a cent more of western money.
@@purplehaze8557 why should other countries care what Afghanistan gets up to
@kareemdurrant139 because it produces copious amounts of heroin which is used to undermine western nations and fund terrorism..
This situation is not only in Afghanistan rather it's going in every single development country. Here, in Pakistan, the situation is worse than that. Many people are living below the poverty line. Their children are unable to get an education. There is a very high child labor ratio. Like this, you may hear millions of stories of Pakistani. Although, it is a free state, unlike Afghanistan. But I never saw BBC News with such a broadcast about other development countries or before the Taliban rule in Afghanistan.
Im Pakistani and I predict its going to become the next Afghanistan.
Unlike Afghanistan? Afghanistan is a free state since last 2 years, it had been under war for 20 years before that, you are so brain washed to believe that Afghanistan was free when it was being invaded by outsiders and is not free when it's own people are rulers of it.
Pakistan...a "free state". This propaganda is getting pathetic.
Everyone knows that the current regime is US installed, had foreign strings attached..foreign backers with "deep pockets" ad former foreign minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi would put it.
Wow, yet don't Pakistan want to run kashmir too? I wonder how they will be able to run another place when its in a big hole itself. You should puts some vids up of how bad life really is in pak
All because of religion. Religion decline progression.
I watched some videos recently by Afghan just walking around different places in Afghanistan. In Kabul the shops were piled high with displays of all sorts of nuts and fruits. I also watched an interesting video on Taliban treating drug addicts. Personally, I would not fancy a religious theocracy as government but I don't trust western media to tell any thing like the whole truth on the country. It is easy enough to make a video on the homeless camped in the streets of L.A. or San Francisco and sell the message that America is a dreadful place.
PROPAGANDA HIDE THE TRUE FACE OF WAR SIR.WE HAVE EVERYTHING WE NEED .AND NOW WE HAVE PEACE TOO.
i mean i am in california it is not that bad, and big deal the taliban do a couple nice things but most is bad they take away freedom they hate on other ethnic groups they change the flag they ban music they kill afghans who fought for their country they're invaders they should go back to pakistan
@@sikandar9381bro 92% of the country’s is in poverty, hazaras and Shias are still getting mistreated, woman don’t have any form of higher education, I’m from Afghanistan and I can safely say this is a shit situation
@@uptmr9768 At least you have proper law and order, no one can Kill, rape, do unjustice due to the Shariah imposed while in Pakistan anyone can kill, rape, corruption etc and no one is to ask! And Mullah Omar's son has already made a comment that when the country stabilizes we are projecting a shariah loving environment for women education! You guys have made Mada 9 Thnx to government, your currency is better than our's. still you regret being afghani lol. In Pakistan we give your examples to muslims due to the shariah you are following.
America isn't a bad country but stuff u saw are like best of best in kabul there isn't more than that .every day going to my English course now I'm used to seeing 5 and 9 yr kids working or begging for food.u see them everywhere u go it's so sad
These people don’t want to live how we do, accept it
They wasted 50 years trusting invaders like u but no more
Very true, sadly like most of the Muslim world they are intent on keeping their populations on a permanent state of barbarity
You’re right, they want to live their way in our country……….. next stop us to to live their way in our country
@@bonnie7898 Taliban's biggest success is eliminating feudalism of warlord culture by tribal elders which never allowed formation of a homogenous nation in last 5000 years. The biggest mistake of USA is taking those warlord tribal elders as allies against Taliban, like Rashid Dostum, Abdullah Mohid, Massoud, etc who are infamous for genocides on other tribals according to UN.
USA got no better option against Taliban except those criminals claiming to be followers of democracy who are ten times more hated by common people than any Taliban leader.
Not accepting it 😂😂😂 women and kids are being oppressed and used
My sympathy for the people of Afghanistan is small...
They had their chance to fight the Taliban over the many years American & NATO forces occupied their country.
Even when the Americans finally left, they just sat back & allowed the Taliban to walk all over them.
Death before slavery.
Majority of us Afghans support Taliban and our Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan government and security forces now. It was your US and NATO foreign invader terrorists who were the terrorists on our soil. Now the US sanctions us and stole all our Afghan assets and threatened countries with sanction of they recognize us
Taliban are our own Afghans, of all ethnicities and from all over Afghanistan. Clearly, u are ignorant of this
@@phoenixrising8640 clearly you missed the point dumbass...
Think before you type.
I guess its some kind of democracy for this region. The majority didn't want to fight at all, so they chose to be under Taliban. Had they fought, they would receive help and victory.
@@Truspio Exactly. They want to suffer under the Taliban.
I counted five children and one looks like it has been born since we withdrew and he knew he would not have his foreign job. So he sends his eldest beautiful sad boy off to work for the family that he keeps growing!? ... and we are supposed to stay there to support them and continue to drain ourselves to give aid? There comes a point when reality has to set in and we let nature take its course.
there IQ is not high, they are not educated, many of them might not even know what earth looks like or structure of solar system and universe, education is need of revolution in countries like afghanistan, pakistan to get people on right track...
People should send them condoms.
This is what happens when you send thousands of soldiers, provide weapons and training, and then when you leave because it is under control, the men of the country you helped just do not fight for their own land.
Afghanistan lost because the men just did not care about fighting, mostly the women are suffering from the new regime, and they are merely seen as objects by the men.
Shame on the men who failed their own country.
@@Ada-et7fv Sadly yes. I am sad for the women but honestly these guys deserved to get taken over. Rich countries lost plenty of money, weapons, and lives to work their asses up but they straight up surrendered their own country. Gg.
Very true the afghan men are chicken chit. The suffering the women and children experience is due to the afghan men.
And gd religion!
God is a DJ, Fact , ruclips.net/video/w5OFC2ug2BI/видео.html
Might even be Scottish.
Western medias: interviewing 5%
Western medias: Taliban is Bad
Remaining 95%: what this nonsesnse
How has the country changed, its peaceful too now, they forgot to mention that massive difference....
Oh have the Taliban stopped shooting at maternity hospitals killing women actually giving birth?
Well now that's an improvement.
How about the Taliban not beating women to death for wearing the wrong fashion?
But hey that's peace eh?
The dreams of children can now die peacefully as they die of hunger. Fixed it for ya.
yeah afghanistan is worse then ever now with them invader talib in charge i miss democratic republic of afghanistan
@@cestwhat1317Yes, because of Us sactions. Americans will try to conquer a country, overthrowing its legitimate goverment, impose lgtv values, lose a war after 20 years and now they will kill 1 million children
@@kingkobrazxLol you are in California. Your family was most likely a collabolator with the occupiers and you a homosexual or otherwise a degenarate merchant class. If only we had a christian taliban in the west so we could rid of liberals, like the taliban did
I feel such sorrow for the young girl and the family at the end of the clip. Surely keeping your family smaller will make their chances of all servicing and doing well so much better though?
Yeah but if the US decides to invade again than they need as many men as possible to fight, also I think the US bomarding the country should be in Q not these peoples reasons for breeding
They are not allowed to use birth control
kids are money source in rural areas, they are free labour
Having multiple kids is usually beneficial in poorer countries. If you only have one or two kids, they could easily die from sickness or an accident, leaving you with no children. If you have 10 children, there's a good chance some of them will survive.
It is because of this mentality that so many get sick because they lack everything. Wrong mindset in my opinion.@@Aa-dc2xu
So kids can work in a workshop, but the father can't and is unemployed? I smell bullshit.
If you hire a kid you can pay him/her a tenths of the wage you would have to pay her/his father.
Why don't you just think for two seconds there are hundreds of ressons why that is.
Its easy to judge. U r not here to see how desperate the people are
A country looks like this, after decades of war and occupation.
What a "stupid" thing to say!
This is how the Taliban operated 'before' the West came.
You are practicing "cultural condescension..." in thinking that when these people had democracy that they were not capable or worthy of choosing their own lives?
Stop playing pathetic games with 'other...' people's lives please?
Thank u. Idiots don't think.
And "who..." do you believe is not 'thinking?'
This is how the Taliban operated 'before' the West came.
The West brought democracy, allowing the people of Afghanistan to decide their own future... now the Taliban have taken this, and therefore "they" are the occupying force!
You are practicing "cultural condescension..." in thinking that when these people if had democracy that they were not capable or worthy of choosing their own lives?
That's not respecting the Afghan people.
And if you did genuinely care for the Afghan people... you'd know that most of them did not wish for us to leave, and the Government, and particularly women of course wish for the West to stay.
You're just it seems repeating anti-West propaganda, and not thinking for yourself unfortunately!
@@phoenixrising8640
The Afghans chose their fate. Leave them to that fate.
It's a sad news story, but a shocking fact should not go unnoticed. Despite the poor economic conditions and poverty, they still continue to breed. Life goes on with choices.
What if birth control is banned in their country, knowing those backward Taliban it probably is.
In opposition of the west, wich is declined for some reason
@@bonnie7898 the joke here is that there is no war In the west and they have Good economy yet they are declining, in opposite to other places.
What a stupid statement. Congrats, you've just described what humans have done since the dawn of our existence some 200,000 years ago. Of course "they" breed. Humans always breed, ESPECIALLY when poor. Breeding decreases when socio-economic status improves. It INCREASES when socio-economic status declines. How the hell do you not know this, are you mentally retarded?
It is one of the ironies of life that the poorest people tend to breed more with the consequences that those children will suffer and become calloused and rather harsher than normal.
I’m a Muslim but I despise religious rule. There’s a reason why the government and religion should separated.
Then you’re not a Muslim. It’s one thing to live in a secular country but to say secularism is better than the laws of Allah is clear cut kufr (disbelief). May Allah guide you brother, study your deen and don’t speak without knowledge.
The horror. 😢
The beauty. Inshallah, Afghanistan zindabad.
@@gfys756 taliban = evil
fuck the taliban
@@gfys756😂💣💣💥💥🤦♂️
@@mendissri...6200america for LGBT and 🔫 school..what a coward,america men are too soft
These lunatics have taken Afghanistan back to the dark ages.It’s beyond saving and tragically will be one of the greatest crimes against the young generation of its people 😢.
They wanted the Taliban.
They got the Taliban.
Why did they bring another life to the family when he cant feed the children now.
They can sell
Because his wife is his property, and her body is there for his pleasure. He's not going to do without because she might produce another child. That's marketable inventory.
That happens to a country with constant war and no access to education. I feel sorry for my people
As a muslim,i am very sad for the situation of that people,they liberated their country but i think they did not make the leadership in the hands of THE LEADERS WITH vision,any way i pray for my people.
They don't see it as a liberation. They see it as an occupation from one to another. Talk to Afghans and see what they think.
They were much better when US was in there…Radical Islam breaks that country apart. US completed its mission of neutralizing Al Qaeda and Bin Laden the rest is on afeghanistan to realize on its own the truth is that afeganistan is a country full of savages there is too many of them you can’t change this who don’t desire a change. But the good people in afeganistan were living a better life thanks to USA’s presence. Everything is worst now. But that is not USA’s problem to solve. USA only had to focus on Al Qaeda and Bin Laden and that’s what they accomplished with minimal casualties.
As a muslim, I can say you have been victim of propaganda by the biggest propaganda channel .
I don't support Taliban and state that they are doing fantastic.
But these situations were there before too and people used to get killed by Nato also.
Obviously there would be these conditions, 20 years of war and after that sanctions by the West.
If BBc really cares, why not tell it's government to lift sanctions.
Obviously they would require quite a time to manage their economy and educated economists
The problem is MUSLIM citizens feel ok to get treat like that in their country. They still support their MUSLIM leader to the heartbeat because even it bad but still same roots, same skintone, same religion!!
US IS STUPID, they’re not ask them to involve. But you’re chose to go there & force Muslim citizens to living in CIVILIZATION & MODERN LIFE WHEN THEY WANT LIVE IN RELIGIOUS LAWS & TRIBES LIFESTYLE!!
So many wasteful moneys & wasteful people dead for NOTHING!!
Now, Taliban take this country as CITIZENS AFGHANS WANT, its their choice & it their country.
Let their RUNNING THEIR COUNTRY AA THEY WANT, EVEN PPL IS POOR, HUNGRY, NO FOODS, NO MEDICINE, NO TECHNOLOGY WHATEVER, but it’s their choice & their wishes!!
So they can keep women wear hijab, no education, sold girls,etc.. good or bad, RIGHT OR WRONG ITS STILL THEIR CHOICE BECAUSE IT THEIR COUNTRY!!
All ppl need to do is DOING THE BEST FOR THEIR PEOPLES & THEIR COUNTRY.
UNLESS THEYRE GOING TO YOU, BEGGING YOU HELP, SHOWING THEIR NEED YOUR HELP THE MOST & GRATEFUL THANKS YOU IN HEARTBEAT, THEYRE ASKING HELP YOU SHOWING MERCY & HUMANITY RIGHT, it’s the times you chose to do right thing as SHOULD INVOLVED & HELP!!
You show hands to people who don’t want, who don’t like, who’s BLOODY HATE YOU IS TOTALLY STUPID OF ANY LEVELS!!
@@jobwesleycoxjr5103
It is occupation
This is their choice. Remember how happy they were when the US left?
We still are. Tell your US terrorist government to stop the cruel sanctions and return all our Afghan assets they stole, and to stop interfering in our internal affairs
I remember thousands scrambling to escape on US airplanes and women throwing their babies at American soldiers
Uhh did you not see the airport videos? Delusional lmao
They only shows about women and poverty they will not show the progress and stability of Afghanistan wann see the reality on the ground better Watch Afghan vloggers or RUclipsrs .
Ultimately the rights of 50% of the population and the poverty is important
They aren't going to do a propaganda piece in favour of the taliban are they?
"I will be forced to sell my children to survive"
I wonder if afghans know how remarkble it is that this is commonly viewed as an option in their culture, demonstrating how children are seen as the father's property and expendable. I believe that in most cultures, parents would just start walking with their kids before they ever had that thought. other people may surrender children to other families or orphanages and such, but they wouldn't say "well if I"m going to give them up, I reckon they're worth some money".
90% of Afghans lived under the poverty line when your US and NATO foreign invader terrorists were on our soil...let that sink in😉
@@phoenixrising8640No, we don’t have to let anything “sink in”. Your peoples plight is your own, we owe you nothing. That’s why afghans are starving.
@@NegativeOpposite yes, u owe us reparations for the least if not aid, all our Afghan assets back amd dropping of sanctions or not bullying countries into not recognizing us with the threat if sanctions if they do.
ANOTHER country like the South African countries only this g they produce CHILDREN to die of be sold 💰💰💰💰
In Western countries they do more than that paedophile is more rich that airlines companies can we talk about it?
What the f$#@ has this got to do with us?
It’s all your fault
@@chinavirus841 what are you going on about?
maybe go learn and read upon the history and look at the way things have unfolded.@@trydowave
This is what the people wanted when they wanted america and the uk out, they had 20 year to sort them selves out and didn't
Now they actually have the audacity to ‘escape’ here… Parasites, NOTHING more. Barely human.
Its weird being in a time when the heights of technology and information sharing are within our grasp and yet still people are wage slaved into starvation or selling children.
When your society is in the grip of a backward religious ideology you aren't going to get the same progress as Liberal democracies
Yeah but it's a similar story here just on a smaller scale. We've got a financial industry awash with money and huge bonuses, we have drones delivering packages, driverless transport, AI, all that stuff, then you've got people dying from the mould in their rented homes, parents who work full time and can't afford dinner, energy bills that our breaking the bank...
It’s the same story everywhere. Even in your so perfect west
@@ringgame not really comparable lol. People selling their own children isn't really an issue in Europe, its unheard of
@@lewis123417 I'm not sure if that's what you tell yourself to sleep well at night or if you're just that oblivious. Either way, ignorance is bliss ig.
Maybe that man stop having so many kids and why don’t he go and work at the place we’re he sons are working instead of them
This happened before we went it. Regiments and training teams of the Afghan police and army regularly raised their concerns about the mens deviancy with underage boys and were told to ignore. Exporting our values to these people doesn't work.
It was the former warlords and the Afghan security forces who had the rep for bacha bazi ("boy play"). Foreign Policy (10/28/2002) had this on the subject: "The Taliban had a deep aversion towards bacha bazi, outlawing the practice when they instituted strict nationwide sharia law. According to some accounts, including the hallmark Times of London article “Kandahar Comes out of the Closet” in 2002, one of the original provocations for the Taliban’s rise to power in the early 1990s was their outrage over pedophilia."
And therefore we should keep out and let them get on with it .
Nothing will ever change in the country and it never will …..
Then what will work?
@@worldview730
Nothing ever has , Russia failed, Americans failed and the British twice .
I think in the end Afghanistan will break up into separate states or sadly there will be another civil war and one warlord running it , either way that’s how it looks .
Whatever money gos into the place
seems to be lost or ends up in bank accounts somewhere in the world , the
population continues to suffer endlessly and the killing carry’s on
regardless of who is in power , it’s a graveyard for any democracy and it’s a very harsh life ……
The likes of Tony Blair and George W Bush made a shambles of it and they both made a fortune out from it .
In the end it’s like another Vietnam
and that turned out to be a graveyard
for US soldiers because the politicians
lost there bottle .
This may sound bad but it’s best left
alone and because of the recent past
and the history of wrong doings the
west is hated .
They don’t want outsiders interfering
with there country and if the shoe was
on the other foot you would feel the same way ……
Boy love is as old as time
We should mind our own business
We did. As soon as we left, they surrendered their country.
@@ARandomPerson66 yep. I do not care
@@burntupretardporn should have been treated purely as an insurance issue
Exactly. The west tried and failed because its an impossible task in the middle east with things like democracy and womens rights. It just is
@@burntupretardpornit was a good day
May Allah make their situation better , Aameen. And the situation of every human .
@theatheistthey are suffering because of the zionist west
Lmfao
😂😂😂😂😂
@theatheist friend, I'm a Malaysian, my country is an Islamic country, but my country is the most peaceful country in the world, so it's human's fault not God's,
@theatheistyou’re suffering you have no humanity
Don't care. Not my problem. They can solve their own problems, just like we have in Europe
Many are coming to Europe for free housing and healthcare.
@@gfys756 Yeah that's why we need to close the border and send them the fk back to wherever they came from. 1nvaders not welcome.
@@LordOfSwedenYour politicians and the vast majority of your citizens feel differently.
Wow, What problems do Europe have?
Release their own money don't be cruel
Why would they give money to a terrorist regime that overthrew a democracy?
Stay out other countries rules and religion and worry about your own
Sure we'll do that, just means we don't have to send them aid anymore. Why would we prop up these regimes with aid?
I'm from Indonesia and I just be able to pray for all of you
Our soldiers, along with the Americans spent spent twenty years giving life and limb to protect the Afghans. They were taught how to fight, and left copious weapons when we pulled out so they could fight for their country. The Afghans cowards far outnumbered the Taliban, yet instead of fighting they let the Taliban have everything while they try to run into any country that will have them. The Afghan girls have far more courage than the men.
Its the culture.. they easily make agreements with each other during conflict and barter their way out of it rather than stay as one cohesive purposful mass. Its not a western army nor is it a western culture. They have a network of tribal loyalties and relationships. Of course, they wear a uniform and learn to solider for pay.. but when the chips are down will revert to what they know.. and they did. Might also be something to do with their nato training teaching them to lean on air cover and nato support too much too.. even though on paper they could survive without it.. in reality they could not..
100% so glad it’s just a small minority who spout the refugees welcome rubbish, though sadly, they’re the minority the majority constantly elects… Weird world isn’t it…
This was unfortunately always going to happen. They have more loyalty to their individual tribes than the country we basically went in and formed for them. When the shit hit the fan, it was less a matter of cowardice and more that many of the AFN just didn't care enough to fight for it.
@@gyver8448 You really think they fought believing in the Bulshit that the US was going to make the country, no it was only for US money and to provide for the family
As soon as our lads left a newly liberated village in Helmand province, the Taliban would move back in without a fight the next day.
Those poor people, so very, very sad
NO NATO, NO DRUGS
You realise the taliban funded their war by selling drugs?
You forgot to mention that tiur government put in financial restrictions on the country.. worsening the poverty
These are deep pocket media won't tell you the truth, wont tell you about the Afghan's culture, Won't tell you how peacefull is Afghanistan after NATO left.
Well yeah, why would western governments prop up a terrorist government with aid? They want the taliban they can have them, and their economic mismanagement
Welcome to Fundamentalism!
At some point the people will have to get up and demand change and fight for their rights.
If the man would have fought the taliban then this would not be happening.
Easy 4u to say .here are people who show bravety and u hear there are killed by Taliban aome days later
savage rulers, savage way of life.
Ironic coming from a kumar 😂😂😂😂😂 look at your house before looking at others
Word of a pajeet😅😂🤣🤣🤣
I feel like some Indians like yourself live Under an illusion.
India Is worse than Afghanistan.
@@Palestine4Ever169😂💣💣💥🤦♂️
@@mendissri...6200 😂🤣🤣🐂🐂🐂👈💩💩👈you👨🏾🦳 ❤️❤️ 🔥😭😭🤮🤮
The USSR destroyed Afghanistan and it hasn’t climbed back since.
Not allowing women or girls to go to school and work is cruel and extremely stupid (economically).
I spoke to Afghan refugees in Germany they say taliban is great, I don't understand why they are fleeing
Free housing and healthcare.
free gibs from the weak west, saddly
There are also people who love Taliban more than their moms .maybe the ones u talked with are from this group
I saw pain in their eyes. Im praying for all of you.
This man needs to stop making children .Very simple .
They should all go to Europe and get the free stuff.
They are
Take these too. These liar are despicable...there those who are "being hunted by Taliban" , all the new LGBTQ etc etc etc liars
This happens in every country not just Afghanistan
Well not every country.
but there are countries like Afghanistan
But this does not happen in every countries. It does happen to some countries like North Korea and Myammar
Don't compare terrorists with other nations
There parents should of fought harder to keep the taliban from taking the country back.
It makes us realize that "peace" exists because there is a state of non-peace.
It may not be possible to realize true peace simply by advocating "peace" without realizing it.
Hunans beings can, apes can't. Too many apes in every single country
Good for Afghanistan. Embarrassing for NATO. Oh dear
The question is which will dominate?
Peace exists because of the fact that Jesus Christ is our peace giver.
Peace doesn't ever come from materialistic stuff or having accumulated wealth for one self.
Sure,wealth helps us to have peace of mind ,to not worry so much but it doesn't actually sustain our peace for long. Jesus does that for us though.
Just thought I'd point that out..
God bless
Great to see shariah working so well for the muslims.
Great to see barbaric Crusadors result in Afghanstan after 20 yrs.
Cry harder atheist, soon you will be gone.
@@fckyo9197 😂😂😂
@@thegoat11111 facts are funni to you?
@@rosy4111 learn English before you type
BBC never learns!!
Afghanistan is better off without European colonialism.
Never change.
Have you watched the other side of reporting? Ie: not western side?
Obviously after the Néocolonialist NATO gang got their @ss kicked by them, they portray them as evil and did nothing good after the white men left.... 😂
@sepulvedablvd7846 yeah, we didn't hand them an army supply of vehicles and weapons to retake it all right after we left 😶. FJB
Give attention to motorway to reduce the cost and build all road gor once and long time
The US had good intentions when it comes to Afghanistan. They wasn't trying to change their Religion or anything like that. If the Taliban wasn't attacking Afghans all these years imagine where the country would be now. Countries like Germany, Japan and South Korea has been transformed after terrible wars
Afghanistan was a bhuddist country I beleive
@@DJWESG1 That explains why they did not fight and surrendered
Afghanistan was dominated by the Taliban before, I don't know where you get that from?@@DJWESG1
You sound as if you've duped by Putin's propaganda...!@@paul7TM
What part of Russia is a "dictatorship" do too many people not understand? 'Dictatorships...' don't even allow their own people to speak out, or know the truth!
So why on earth would think for a moment they would tell "you" the truth?
If a Russian person even calls this a 'war...' they can face upwards of "10 years" or more in jail, or worse be murdered by the regime. Putin has said this 'war...' has to be called a "special military operation."
Russian soldiers are brutalised, lied to and tortured by their own government. The families how lose loved ones, few get the death payments promised them, and soldiers themselves are left often with no pay or weapons with substandard equipment, which left many to freeze to death in winter.
There are no free fair elections in Russia under Putin - all free media and political opposition has been shut down, journalists, politicians and ordinary people - imprisoned or murdered!
Many have been taken in by Russian disinformation: by the way it was Russia under Stalin and the KGB in 1923 which arrived at the concept and coined the word 'disinformation!' They even gave it a Western sounding name, so we would more easily adopt it... so that worked?
Putin has murdered "100 000s" of people in Chechnya, Georgia, Syria, Moldova, Belarus and Ukraine and elsewhere in the world.
Syria, was a people's uprising as a result of the Arab Spring, which began in Tunisia in 2010, as a result Assad slaughtered peaceful protesters with gunships. The people fought bravely for years, but when Damascus was about to fall, Assad called in Putin. Assad and Putin then murdered "100 000s" of people, dropping bombs on children in their schools, burning them alive!
In Russia itself, if people even call the Ukraine Russia War, a "war..." they can face up to "10 years" in jail, or if someone is a high profile politician or public figure, then can be imprisoned or even murdered.
A recent UN stated the in a terror campaign orchestrated by Putin... "children" as young as '4' years old are being tortured and raped.
We must act to stop this, and support the people of Ukraine to ensure this ends... in defeating the Putin Regime this could be a turning corner for humanity, in our search to end war, and all injustice?
@@paul7TM
Seriously, why do the poor always bare more children than they can afford? Why bring another child into this world when you're barely surviving, and also living in a tyrannical society.
The father at the end of the clip has me dumbfounded. It seems like he has seven children. The baby was obviously born after the Taliban took over
Allah giving every thing
Because they think child can be sold and then get money. Children is like own property in their mind.
As a foreigner, I could never understand how could they treat their women in unjust ways.
Allah's wish. ( Allah's Ass)
We treat our women as Islam said it.
@@tareksahak4478exactly. That’s why you’re doomed.
@@tareksahak4478 fuck you man. Fuck off . What is islam? Killing others? Disrespects others and their believes ? What a arrogancy is that. Be civilized man. Keep your religion behind at home. And be a human being in public . Rather be a Animal
Islam is a evil spirits
Most desperate solution to a desperate situation is stop having children!!! It's cruel but it's completely viable!! Why have kids and curse them to a world of hell?!
Dont be so Islamophobic BBC!
The biggest and best change is the Americans have gone...
I'm sure the women would disagree
I still remember bbc saying Taliban gonna boom drug business; 😅 two years after all gone
Do u remember that piece they ir CNN did where they put makeup on for thso child and said that she was going to be married off to an old and but everyone who investigated, including our Afghan police found our that it was a lie😂😂😂
You realise the taliban were funding the war by selling drugs
You remember the govt mandate asking parents to marry their daughters to soldiers?
@@phoenixrising8640how was it a lie bro?
@HappyNuristani are u talking about that news video last year, that either CNN or BBC said that a little girl got married to an old man? That was a lie.
Let them be, leave them alone.
Lyse Doucet is s brilliant journalist! It's a wonder the Taliban let her report. The Taliban have dragged Afganistan into an abyss of sorrow, discrimination and poverty! Why is the world not reacting to this humanitarian crisis. The Taliban are not politicians; they are misogynistic tyrants with no idea of how to rule a country without threats and weapons.
Why we should do anything if Afghan people are happy with Talibans ruling them?
Only bunch of Afghan womens were protesting while all the men just drop their guns and escaped like cowards.
Why are you ignoring the tortures and abuses Afghan civillians suffered under the US?
Heck, the US itself is in ruins now, there are more drug addicts in US than there is in Afghan (the drug producer of the world), and it reduced thanks to Taliban
@@farallimachathese women are paid puppets. That's the only reason they protest. It's the same women all the time.
@@AksarallahI don't understand this. Our Islamic Emirate government is doing everything possible to help our drug addicts but America, who has so much money is not. But then again, US marines and NATO were guarding poppy fields in Afghanistan
@@phoenixrising8640 yes I agree with you.
US keeps talking about progressive nation, whereas their country 10% is addicted to drugs. While Taliban did good job and now only 8% addicts in the largest drug exporter nation
Proving how US doesnt care about Afghans at all, but simply impose their values on others. And ofcourse having more frontline to attack on Russia, and other geopolitics which they don't talk about
Sell his children to survive ? God help them
This is what can happen when you have too many kids to feed. And life has always been about survival…..!
Leave them to it.
A country that’s best kept in the dark ages.
I'm sure the BBC gave them a couple of quid. Should've bought them a fan too to keep the flies off.
Odd thumbnail, didn't expect Taliban looking like glam metal boys.
UK has left Afghan translators and their families behind, shallow promises from an even shallower government, Afghanistan and Iraq wars were utter disasters and the war criminals who started the wars and doing very well thank you
5hey have ALWAYS been pissholes. And they always will be. Should never have gotten involved with the backwards filth..
It is funny how "interpreters" multiplied in numbers to get out to the West when the Taliban came to power. Muslims do not integrate.
their lives are better than when the US or UK interfered in their domestic affairs. Don't pretend to show off their children's difficult lives, they are still alive and free. Just take care of the tens of millions of American people wandering the streets, don't pretend to be concerned about other countries' affairs. Hypocritical
Let us strive to make a better world.
Then start with yourself and become a Muslim
A better world is not possible if i dont become a Muslim ? @@user-dh6pz5eo2r
They are just trying to say that Afghanistan was like Qatar when usa and nato was there
Let’s good back and spend another 1.5 Trillion!
To do nothing apart from fund the big military companies, over 50% of that money (our money) goes straight to those companies who lobby for war.
It’s crazy how long that racket has been going on and we buy it every time.
What about the starving kids of Britain 😍😍😍⛑️⛑️⛑️😍😍😍
Do you think this is worse than what's happening in Palestine? Why this double standard?
The only one's I feel sorry for is the women and girls. What an awful life for them.
We have a lot of doctors pilot ……as women .. but men work harder than all of Them to keep family safe
This is what America has done in the last 20 years. And then ceased Afghanis' own money too.
Afghanistan doesn't exist anymore, its the Islamic Emirates. They aren't entitled to the money that was made by the Republic of Afghanistan. They want barbaric rule, we aren't going to prop them up with money
inshallah oneday Afghanistan will be super power
It's so hard to look at that little girl and think about how her education is about to end with her dreams crushed, solely because the rulers of the country decided so.
you know you're a proper news junkie if two years later, you still recognise the bridge between afghanistan and uzbekistan. 😟
We gave the Afghans all the tools and education needed to repel the Taliban, move out of severe poverty and give the country a chance to develop, unfortunately they thought life back under medieval Taliban rule would be better, I feel sorry for the kids and future generations as the cowardly Afghan army failed their country.
I dont think these people really have a choice. We should stop the hipocrasy - US and europe are investing and supporting these criminals that have the afgan people under slavery.
You're delusional
All that "Money" the west sent got eaten up by corrupt politicians in Afghanistan
These movements don't start out of nothing
If you really think that happened you should probably watch "This is what winning looks like" by Ben Anderson. You need a reality check.
@@bishbashbosh3863 go and live there then, prove me wrong and send a postcard
@@cobralord4279 I think you're mentally challenged, go learn basic geopolitical history on these regions
Theyre suceeding in bringing their country back to the stone age good luck
I'm Chinese only some lucky ones can go to Taiwan in 1949 just like only lucky ones can escape in 2021 of afghan
We in Afghanistan feel very lucky. Stop believing all the propaganda..majority of us Afghans support Taliban and our Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan now
I spoke to Afghan refugees in Germany they say taliban is great, I don't understand what they are fleeing
@@supernova8709 for a better financial future. Please treat these Afghans well and help them.
@@supernova8709Well then they are.. Not REFUGEES..but invaders.
@@phoenixrising8640where do you live in Afghanistan? Why do you like the army asking parents marry their girls to soldiers?
This is heartbreaking to see . In an age when there is no worry and the childhood is full of memories and fun I m saddened beyond words can describe at what these children and these families are going through
We congratulate Afghanistan on its second anniversary of freedom from 20 years of brutal US/NATO occupation of their country. 👍
they choose the taliban.. they did not want help..
Cavemen should not rule a country. However, I fear that in the countrysie, things have remained pretty much the same.
Says the medival peasant
"all the boys are playing outside, I wish I could play too." So you just interviewed poor kids like you could find in Los Angeles? That's not journalism.
My proposal to the leaders and elders of Talibans, including you is to widen your vision of what defines your religion, especially now that your are in goverment. You cant set us on fire, if you did that, you would burn with us too. When you cant burn us, the reasoble course of action is for us to build together.
Like to spend alot of time in the mountains with lots of other men, don't they? Got something to tell us? Hey we won't judge. But facts is facts.
If they are no longer harboring terrorists, which does not seem they are, then leave them alone. They are not bothering anyone. Let them live how they want, not our problem.
Thank God we live in the secular West post enlightenment.
Not for long.
‘ thank god’ .. ‘ secular’.. 😂
Secular post enlightenment society that practices torture
Now there are no curroption. In Afganistan there are good governed now .
Heartbreaking these family story.🇮🇳🙏
You feeling sorry for them because they are Afghan
The problem is MUSLIM citizens feel ok to get treat like that in their country. They still support their MUSLIM leader to the heartbeat because even it bad but still same roots, same skintone, same religion!!
US IS STUPID, they’re not ask them to involve. But you’re chose to go there & force Muslim citizens to living in CIVILIZATION & MODERN LIFE WHEN THEY WANT LIVE IN RELIGIOUS LAWS & TRIBES LIFESTYLE!!
So many wasteful moneys & wasteful people dead for NOTHING!!
Now, Taliban take this country as CITIZENS AFGHANS WANT, its their choice & it their country.
Let their RUNNING THEIR COUNTRY AA THEY WANT, EVEN PPL IS POOR, HUNGRY, NO FOODS, NO MEDICINE, NO TECHNOLOGY WHATEVER, but it’s their choice & their wishes!!
So they can keep women wear hijab, no education, sold girls,etc.. good or bad, RIGHT OR WRONG ITS STILL THEIR CHOICE BECAUSE IT THEIR COUNTRY!!
All ppl need to do is DOING THE BEST FOR THEIR PEOPLES & THEIR COUNTRY.
UNLESS THEYRE GOING TO YOU, BEGGING YOU HELP, SHOWING THEIR NEED YOUR HELP THE MOST & GRATEFUL THANKS YOU IN HEARTBEAT, THEYRE ASKING HELP YOU SHOWING MERCY & HUMANITY RIGHT, it’s the times you chose to do right thing as SHOULD INVOLVED & HELP!!
You show hands to people who don’t want, who don’t like, who’s BLOODY HATE YOU IS TOTALLY STUPID OF ANY LEVELS!!
Just check the growing currency of Afghanistan and it will be enough for the Taliban leadership.
It is recommendable as well as commendable for BBC for giving light about the needs of Afghanistan and its Taliban rulers. The Taliban rulers also cited their plans for their country, as to development for their Economy, their Culture and Art, the ways of life that has to be preserved. Its societal identification and recognition, protection of children from harm and abuse, as well as restoration of its people from a Taliban Government. Economic progress that the people can live and grow, the agriculture sector to export, import and preserve its GDP and its way of life as Afghans.
Damn they failed at all of that
taliban did not take over, usa brought the terrorist gang back from qatar and handed over Afghanistan to the terrorist gang to continue American crimes and further US goals
Lie