Bonney's interactions with the crew so far and the nature of her power make me think she *is* going to join the crew. I can see her joining as am "apprentice", like Shanks and Buggy in their younger days. While I'm at it, another prediction I'm gonna throw out there: what if its not just Luffy's abilities that she can mimic through her Distorted Future technique? Could she have a variant where she becomes a cyborg like Franky, or a fishman like Jimbei? Or one where she mimics Chopper's forms? The door is open to any of these now really. That would really give here the perfect "apprentice ability". Sure, it sounds unlikely, but if you told me 100 chapters ago that we'd be seeing a Gear 5 Jewelry Bonney I'd think I was being trolled.
@@teddysama5745 there's something off with Boa's love for Luffy. I mean we've seen love being depicted in many ways in One piece but Boa is the only character the we seen have such a reaction and for it to be in her DNA makes me think it might have something to do with the Nika Fruit or previous users and Mero Mero no mi or its previous users. Question Theory: What would happen if Catarina Devon takes the appearance of Boa and comes face to face with Luffy?
@@adminotaku4799 I suspect you may be giving this more thought than Oda does. I think Oda is just cracking himself up and playing for the gag. As far as Catarina question, if i was a betting person, I would bet Katarina will fall for Luffy. Why? Gag. Just think about how funny it will be Katarina getting heart eyes like Sanji then flipping to her original form and now looks at Luffy with hate. She transforms again and again heart eyes LMAO
I had to sit with it for a second, but I love it. It felt like this was where we were going up eventually with all the hints Oda dropped. I don't see how it takes anything away from Luffy, if anything him giving her the motivation that leads to the transformation makes it better. Either way I think we need to wait and see what Oda does with it.
People forgetting when vegapunk was studying Kumas body he asked if a person is essentially their memories. So when Bonney went into Kumas memory bubble she experienced the feeling of being Kuma all his actions, emotions etc. the same way zoro experienced nothing happened. so while she’s 12 physically now Bonney has all the memories of her father so she’s lived more than 12 years mentally.
Nah not really. Bonney can still use gear 5 powers but she doesn't have enough stamina, he endurance is the only thing holding her back. But it makes sense since she's 12. She gonna be able to hold gear 5 for longer when she gets older
''She didn't earn it'' Luffy gave it to her and it is freedom, she doesn't have to earn it. Earning it would be to have the strength to use it for a long time.
Her devil fruit, to me, seems like a fancy way of saying its a copy fruit or a mimic fruit. She mimics what she sees to a certain extent. Reading the chapter, I only got the sense that she's free and enjoying the moment for once in her life. I never got the sense that she was suddenly a powerhouse in the series
I think people don’t understand that df atp still haven’t proven to be stronger than haki. Luffy is ofc way stronger. This is like Kafla from dbs getting SSJ. It’s not game changing she is just using a small power buff that still can’t damage gorosei somehow.
On one hand, I want Kuma to finally be at peace and rest. He's been through enough and has done enough in my books. Kind of like Tony stark situation. Bonney will be just fine with whom shes around now and watching her. On the other hand, I really really want to see Kuma (with his memories back) and bonney together again. If anything to say one last goodbye.
People need to understand that Nika isn't gear 5. Nika is a god who resembles freedom. Luffy's fruit awakened gives him the form of Nika. Bonny can't use gear 5 because luffy's gears incorporate his haki to insane degrees. Sure bonny is free but she isn't using gear 5.
@@grandu9761 nika is the god that existed once, its not a fruit power get your basics right the fruit is called hito hito no mi model nika. luffy is not nika when he is using gear 5, he only has his powers, hes still luffy nika is literally the god (a perseon) that existed
I just finished reading the new chapter of One Piece. I think the Bonnie haters might shut up for 5 seconds until something else happens that they don't like.
How she does what everyone was worried about and does some nika $h!t just cause she got tired doesn't mean anything we all knew she wasn't gonna have the stamina for it but that's not what people were mad about they mad because she got the form that took luffy 1000 ch to get and she got it in like 30 40 ch😂
@@randobando8354 Then the same people who are peeved about Luffy bestowing his freest form onto Bonney, who's father was ENSLAVED, are the very same people who would say Ace was stupid for turning back
@@randobando8354people being mad at her using a form for 10 seconds are really missing the entire point of what Nika is. It’s not about luffy unlocking a new form and the “ power” that comes with it. It’s the freedom and what it means to the world as a whole. Who cares how long it took luffy to get it. Him showing Bonney she has the freedom and capability to do it is the whole point. That’s what nika is. Freedom
For everyone who cried about Bonney turning into Nika last week: go ahead and apologize 😁 lasted 2 chapters and she can only turn herself rubbery Literally just have patience next time
Syv, when you mentioned the sulong's looking up at the moon and getting stronger in response to a need of like battle spirit, it reminded me of what we found out about Bardock in DragonBall super Manga in the granola ark in the flashback of when he originally faught Gas!!
Bonney asks Luffy - what was that form, he says thats what i look like when im at my freest. She’s seen him attack so she’s just mimicking that look and rough physiology, same as she did with her Buccaner form. I bet the more she learns about an ability or the more context she has she will mimick things to a more complex level
You all forgot the gorosei have a Vegapunk. If they don’t destroy his brain, who’s to say York can’t access other information from the brain outside her specialty to reprogram the pacifista
Her power works based on her understanding and belief of the future she imagines. Her devil fruit depends on her imagination. Luffy powers are based on his imagination. The nikka fruit is the embodiment of freedom. Freedom is for everyone. It is not an exclusive concept. To truly show freedom everyone can experience it. Ideally no one should have to pay a price for freedom. Having Bonney develop her power only based on how she understands and imagines nikka to be. Her vision of freedom. There are obvious differences how Bonney and luffy view freedom. I love how this gives both luffy and Bonney a huge chance to improved on their abilities before the final arc.
I honestly don't know who these angry mobs everyone references are. Go to any discussion and it's filled with 100 comments about how stupid "powerscalers" are for not liking this development and 2-3 people actually critiquing the decision to let her copy G5. Also the argument is: (1) it definitely feels unearned, (2) thematic poignance doesn't make it justified given how long we waited for the G5 reveal (3) suffering isn't unique to Bonney and doesn't entitle her to become the literal God she worships. That's not how faith works. I don't become G-d if I pray everyday. Seeing Nika being real is enough of a miracle for any believer. She doesn't need white hair or rubbery powers to be "free". Freedom means being able to standup to Saturn mentally, not just physically. Sentimentality (awww Kuma gets to witness it!) shouldn't override good storytelling. Would any of you want Rebecca get Gear 4 in Dressrosa? That's the same story. Dad slowly losing himself inside a doll trying to save his daughter without her knowledge. Bet you wouldn't. Chapter 1119 did nothing to disprove it. She demonstrates very similar abilities (even usage of Haki) to G5 Nika, the only issue being the duration. But she's a kid. Ofc, it would be a shorter window. It's not about her being powerful or even stronger than Luffy. It's about making him less unique. He could have given her any other OP power and still kept the thematic beauty. Idk, I don't feel this one. That doesn't make me a hater. Nobody reads something for that long (14 years) just to hate lol. It's not an argument to paint detractors as some hateful group (powerscalers bla bla). Does it mean that I will stop reading it and burn the volumes? Fuck no, lol. I don't think it's that big of a deal. What makes it more annoying is the constant farming for "controversy" that doesn't seem to exist. Don't believe me? Open any chapter disc on reddit.
I think bonnie has an imagination fruit, a fruit that works opposing original nikas force being will. The opposite of having will is to think of having will
The “force” of Luffy’s fruit is imagination … Not really will. I guess you could say it’s more specific to say “the will to exercise and your imagination”.
I think York is the reason the brain is still functioning, when she would eat and use the bathroom it would satiate the other vegapunks so I think it also applies to the brain as well
I wonder that one keeps hinting at by using kids that have to go through grown up stuff, was joy boy really just a boy? He also inphasies on young boys wanting to adventure in the sea,luffys nakamas have come to be kids as well momo,bonny, otama and a few more situations like the kids that shanks meets. Joy boy had to be a actual boy in my opinion while Nikka was the warrior of liberation,the straw hats go on to embody an aspect of Nikka, what makes them special is what made Nikka Nikka, the cooking the love for the sea the love and knowledge of weather and medicine the urge to be free the urge to feed everyone and be friends with everyone ,that all boils down to who Nikka was and who joy boy sought to become
After letting it sit with me, I agree with Brago, as much as I enjoy the story in general, definitely confused on why at this specific moment? To throw one indirect punch? Just feels a bit forced and unnecessary, or overwritten.
It would be a twist is Imu and the Gorosei were the original devils of the world and the ancient kingdom used their blood to create devil fruits which could be why they were targeted.
every time someone does something new powerscallers get mad their hypotheticals arent comfirmed and forget about foreshadowing and the story thats taking place outside of fights and "feats".
0:45 Bonney has one of the saddest stories and has probably endured the most emotional/mental trauma and even direct oppression from the government of anyone in the series. And not to mention basically being forced to be a pirate at the age of 10 years old. "She didn't work for it" is a hot take imo. She deserves the ability more than anyone else imo.
@@MrJara1018**SPOILER WARNING** I mean they both are pretty much linked story lines. I personally feel like Kuma and Bonney's story are one in the same(to an extent). Like Kuma's story would not have been nearly as sad if Bonney wasn't a part of it, and the same goes for Bonney's story if you remove Kuma. But i'm mainly referring to stuff that happened to both of them, just bonney and instances that didn't directly involve her but had major consequences or effects to her story. I mean her mother passed before she was five. She got experimented on by the WG which resulted in giving her DF powers(which took her freedom to swim) and that resulted in an "incurable disease"(which took her freedom to go out in sunlight) and her father literally sacrificed himself(in secret) to have a chance to save her. Which left her an orphan being raised by the towns people/ fisherman and being forced to become a pirate. She was manipulated by the WG into thinking Vegapunk ruthlessly ended her father, and when she actually finds out the truth to everything that happened, she finds out that she just ruined any chance of her father re-gaining his memories through his DF fruit power. My main point though is this all happened to a child.
It is most definitely one of the hardest things to say in One Piece. For people that poke their head in and out. There's no way that it doesn't make sense. Also we have no information besides people being upset. If you made it this far and you get it, the. You know for several reasons why this has more information at some point in the very near future that makes all the whining be obsolete.
Maybe Bonney doesn’t need a dream. At the end of the day, she’s 12. Imagine a 12 year old accomplishes their live dream at 12? If we’re assuming she takes the apprentice role, like buggy/shanks, do we think either of them had goals? Shanks is going after the One Piece right now. I don’t think that was his goal at when he was on Roger’s ship
Personally I like the idea of Bonney getting her own Nika form. I think the issue is that the execution could have been done better. After the latest chapter, she didn’t even get to really use it on a gorosei so I feel like the transformation was pretty pointless
'Bonney is too powerful' Two yonko crews have three former warlords amongst them, and another yonko crew has a former admiral, and we are worried about Bonney being too powerful why?
I legit don't understand how people think this is bad writing and some "girl power" stuff. It was REALLY obvious that she's not gonna have the same amount of power or longevity as Luffy would. And its even more wild that they say she hasn't "earned" it. People need to stop reacting and actually start reading.
15:06 Wait wait if everyone did get nika’s powers at the end everyone’s idea of freedom looks different so even if everyone got that ability no one will be the sun god or joy boy because that’s not how they see themselves free maybe not even luffy will because honestly do we think joy boy from 1,000 years ago has the same idea of freedom as luffy today probably not and i could honestly see whatever joy boy does think freedom is being completely opposite and maybe even rejected by luffy come the end of the story which i mean finial form ? Or more like One more power up loading not necessarily a ff.
Guys, she isn't "mimicking" it, she IS Gear5 Nika in that specific timeline where she pulls her powers from. So it's like the Spiderverse for example, where multiple Spidermen are fighting together in one dimension. Bonneys DF allows her to be one of the Nika Users in a different timeline, that's her Power. I wouldn't be surprised if she can use the power for a longer period of time than expected, it's up to Oda. Her powers aren't like a Sharingan, she isn't copying the powers, she HAS that power for a short time!
gear 5 is nowhere near as busted without the Haki to complement it. she can probably do the same wacky and toon force shenanigans but she won’t have the same attack power as luffy
Yal can have this 1…the world government gonna rename the strawhats after a timeskip…. “The White Hair Crew or The Red Eyes Crew” Or The Red Eyes White Hair Crew….
Ppl are way too critical about stuff week to week. Kakashi didn’t earn his Sharingan in Naruto. Just read the manga and let Oda cook. He will explain everything in due time. We don’t need to stress out our Mangaka’s over small stuff when we want to keep them alive to finish the stories. Having an issue with Bonnie’s powers is nasty work when the drawbacks are clear
Different series different context also he had to lose his close friend and take his eye out to get that ability (it didn’t just fall in his had because a backstory or just cause )it’s not even the highest version of the eye , it took bro years before he unlocked some the strongest versions and it’s not a direct “god ability “ like the Nika gear 5 was supposed y’all give oda all the excuses in the world he Alr did the most bear minimum to foreshadow gear 5 anyways had one piece RUclips’s over here finding anyway possible to make him seen like he not human Oda makes mistakes to , from every one piece vid I see when someone don’t like something yall do everything in y’all power to downplay there problems and come back with straight bs but to each there own lol
As much as I agree the whole Bonney debate isn't that big a deal, what I find interesting is that you seem averse to people having a different opinion. I love One Piece and I didn't like G5. Bonney as much, but it's whatever. Should people just never criticize what they love? I don't think that's healthy.
I dont mind the breaks, but I do dislike when reports come out saying that "Oda wants to finish the series in the next ___ years".... Not with all of these cliffhangers and breaks.
If Bonny is 12 now doesn't that mean she was 10 when we first met her? She was already a supernova. We shouldn't be shocked at her being ahead of her peers.
Holup gang I hate/love fairytale but that 7 year situation made sense since they had a character that used time magic and them getting 7 years of maturity at once was life threatening but main character will power kicked in and they succeeded
"Power scalers ruin One Piece" is the biggest cop out that the fandom does. Power scaling can become way too toxic but as a principle it's a completely valid way to judge the story. Oda being consistently inconsistent with his scaling and use of his power system (haki especially) damages his own world building. The One Piece world is built on power balance (the WG, the Marines, the Warlords, and the yonko). As soon as Oda becomes inconsistent it creates plot holes and destroys the reasons given to us as to why characters aren't making moves.
Her devil fruits not even awakened but her power drastically changed from age regression and progression to. Incarnating alternate future realities 😂 the bonnnyverse
Great points! I didn’t like it because it took away from luffys shine nothing is as special if there’s multiple of it. 1 of 1 is better than 1 of two that power should be luffys alone. Like if she not as strong with it then why give it to her at all ? I just don’t see the point
You know who isnt a detractor of gear 5 bonnie? Luffy You know who is the happiest about 5 bonnie? Luffy Luffy wants to be free and he wants everyone else to be free. To me One piece is about hope for the future, a desire to be better, and standing up for what you believe in. There is nothing positive to come from disliking bonnie over this.
Gear 5 is special. No one can use gear 5 like luffy. Even Bonney going “nika form” she’s not in gear 5. Shes cosplaying( Even if she can use a gear 5 attack. It won’t be even nearly as powerful as luffy and I imagine that one attack would be it) . As brago said she’s a kid putting on a Superman cape. That doesn’t take a single thing away from Superman. luffy and gear 5 are symbols of freedom. Bonney only went into her nika form because of that exact freedom luffy was showing her she had. Her “ god” was telling her she could do it
You guys it's just haters they're not really one piece fans furthermore her attack is called Nika like future which allows her to transform into a version of herself as if she were nika
She can be as strong as Luffy the point is not that no one else can be Nika other people can eat the devil fruit Harper works by allowing her to use any power which means she could even use the flame flame fruit power if she could imagine it
Power ups don't have to be earned. One Piece is more realistic about it as we don't always earn getting better at something. Sometimes it just happens or we just hear about something or we're given something. Just for proof that Oda doesn't feel the need to make everything get "earned" in a special way, I'll drop examples. Luffy didn't earn Gear 3rd Luffy didn't earn Gear 2nd Nami didn't earn the Clima Tact Nami didn't earn Zeus Zoro didn't earn Enma Momo didn't earn Dragon Form Law didn't earn awakening Etc etc
@@MrJara1018 He still didn't earn it. He just swapped for it. The downside of it doesn't matter because the topic is earning the power up, not the weakness of it. People were reacting before seeing Bonney's weakness so that doesn't matter.
Bonney gonna join as an apprentice like shanks and buggy for Roger. She’ll be a 12 year old around then cause she’s comfortable with the straw hats hence apprentice
The people who say Bonney didn't earn it are not reading the story. They can't be. She's been on the seas just as long as Luffy has. As a CHILD, leading a pirate group whose sole mission is to go against the entire World Government to get her dad back. She was good enough/caused enough havoc to be considered a Supernova in the Worst Generation. So clearly she is strong and had to be getting stronger. It's like people forget. You're NOT making it into the New Wolrd at all unless you are a very talented pirate. Having to fight Marines, other pirates, the ocean itself, and even civilians on whatever island you land on from time to time. And she left her crew to go kill the world's smartest man on a government island. To say Bonney didn't earn it is the craziest shit I've ever heard. If Luffy earned it, then Bonney did too. What was Luffy's hardest moment? When he lost Ace? When he lost his crew? Bonney started her journey because she lost her dad. And made the hard decision to leave her crew, that she essentially grew up with, to chase her goal. And her transformation isn't a transformation. It's just part of her devil fruit ability. We've been shown time and time again with her ability that she can alter the living physical world. It's not like she actually has gear 5. She's just mimicking it. I mean, she basically just delivered a haki covered giant punch. Which she could always do. She's just got a fresh coat of paint on when she did it. The hate is wild.
Bonney's interactions with the crew so far and the nature of her power make me think she *is* going to join the crew. I can see her joining as am "apprentice", like Shanks and Buggy in their younger days. While I'm at it, another prediction I'm gonna throw out there: what if its not just Luffy's abilities that she can mimic through her Distorted Future technique? Could she have a variant where she becomes a cyborg like Franky, or a fishman like Jimbei? Or one where she mimics Chopper's forms? The door is open to any of these now really. That would really give here the perfect "apprentice ability". Sure, it sounds unlikely, but if you told me 100 chapters ago that we'd be seeing a Gear 5 Jewelry Bonney I'd think I was being trolled.
I always figured S bear and Bonnie would have a little big sister big little brother dynamic.
Until S-bear said the little "Ursus shock" i never thought it could be said in such a cute way XD
@@adminotaku4799ikr😄 I always thought adult Kuma's voice sounded so cute, gentle and kind.
The moment I saw boa seraphim, I said she will betray world government. No way boa can go against luffy
@@teddysama5745 there's something off with Boa's love for Luffy. I mean we've seen love being depicted in many ways in One piece but Boa is the only character the we seen have such a reaction and for it to be in her DNA makes me think it might have something to do with the Nika Fruit or previous users and Mero Mero no mi or its previous users.
Question Theory: What would happen if Catarina Devon takes the appearance of Boa and comes face to face with Luffy?
@@adminotaku4799 I suspect you may be giving this more thought than Oda does. I think Oda is just cracking himself up and playing for the gag. As far as Catarina question, if i was a betting person, I would bet Katarina will fall for Luffy. Why? Gag. Just think about how funny it will be Katarina getting heart eyes like Sanji then flipping to her original form and now looks at Luffy with hate. She transforms again and again heart eyes LMAO
I had to sit with it for a second, but I love it. It felt like this was where we were going up eventually with all the hints Oda dropped. I don't see how it takes anything away from Luffy, if anything him giving her the motivation that leads to the transformation makes it better. Either way I think we need to wait and see what Oda does with it.
People forgetting when vegapunk was studying Kumas body he asked if a person is essentially their memories. So when Bonney went into Kumas memory bubble she experienced the feeling of being Kuma all his actions, emotions etc. the same way zoro experienced nothing happened. so while she’s 12 physically now Bonney has all the memories of her father so she’s lived more than 12 years mentally.
Next chapter bout to end the controversy
its out now
It does. Half the internet going off for 5 mins of action 😂
As expected. lol Bonney can not even hold the form for a minute.
@@Archangelsvoid Soap Opera actors🤝Powerscalers -Most dramatic people on earth.
Nah not really. Bonney can still use gear 5 powers but she doesn't have enough stamina, he endurance is the only thing holding her back. But it makes sense since she's 12. She gonna be able to hold gear 5 for longer when she gets older
Bonney's transformation is less about her not earning and more about Joyboy BRINGING FREEDOM TO HIS FRIENDS. Joyboy/Luffy made her free.
Literally, the 'earned' argument is braindead. Like would they be satisfied if it took like 200 chapters? Prolly not
Give Oda credit, he's kept us on the hook this long. He knows what he's doing. I suspect this isn't his final form.
@@Pinko-Diamondor maybe they are the boruto/ demon slayer fan rejects that picked up onepiece from tiktok who simply don’t understand
i disagree, honestly if he has another form itd just annoy tf outta me
@@Atlas9766 Gear 5 form can't beat Shanks imo. Don't forget what Kaido said. Luffy need next power up.
@@Pinko-Diamond you're correct, a lot of it is from roblox anime games making one piece known to newer children
For real. These "Fans" have read 1118 chapters of this manga, but somehow still don't have trust in the author
Let’s get this Chapter review going Brago! Chapter dropped
Joy Girl totally embraced it! She made a short about it and everything!
Bonney is just cosplaying Nike guys; no big deal 🤝
''She didn't earn it'' Luffy gave it to her and it is freedom, she doesn't have to earn it.
Earning it would be to have the strength to use it for a long time.
I’m calling it now. Bonnie is a failed version of the Nika fruit
Emeth ‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️💯💯💯
Her devil fruit, to me, seems like a fancy way of saying its a copy fruit or a mimic fruit. She mimics what she sees to a certain extent. Reading the chapter, I only got the sense that she's free and enjoying the moment for once in her life. I never got the sense that she was suddenly a powerhouse in the series
Omg you uploaded this on my birthday. Best gift ever
Happy Birthday 🥳🥳
Lmfao i love how off they are about the fairy tail timeline but i fucks with it😂
I think people don’t understand that df atp still haven’t proven to be stronger than haki. Luffy is ofc way stronger. This is like Kafla from dbs getting SSJ. It’s not game changing she is just using a small power buff that still can’t damage gorosei somehow.
I mean S bear can extract Kumas memories from Bonney and take his old memories back
I thought the same the same thing but I wonder if the hierarchy for s bear is the same as the kuma seraphims if so it could be a possibility
On one hand, I want Kuma to finally be at peace and rest. He's been through enough and has done enough in my books. Kind of like Tony stark situation. Bonney will be just fine with whom shes around now and watching her.
On the other hand, I really really want to see Kuma (with his memories back) and bonney together again. If anything to say one last goodbye.
Bonny is the mokujin of one piece, that how her powers work.
The Giant is about to safe the strawhats from escaping egghead
People need to understand that Nika isn't gear 5. Nika is a god who resembles freedom. Luffy's fruit awakened gives him the form of Nika. Bonny can't use gear 5 because luffy's gears incorporate his haki to insane degrees. Sure bonny is free but she isn't using gear 5.
Gear 5 is Nika, what you're on about?
It just luffy calling it gear 5.
she uses Haki with G5 in 1119 💀
@@rainiwakura2430 blud she doesnt even have conquerers, her haki doesnt compare
@@grandu9761 nika is the god that existed once, its not a fruit power
get your basics right
the fruit is called hito hito no mi model nika.
luffy is not nika when he is using gear 5, he only has his powers, hes still luffy
nika is literally the god (a perseon) that existed
Kinda weird, luffy gear 5 form IS nika. Luffy just doesn’t know what else to call it than gear5
Bonnie transforming is like the super monkey special.
Hilarious this discussion is even needed 😂
I just finished reading the new chapter of One Piece. I think the Bonnie haters might shut up for 5 seconds until something else happens that they don't like.
How she does what everyone was worried about and does some nika $h!t just cause she got tired doesn't mean anything we all knew she wasn't gonna have the stamina for it but that's not what people were mad about they mad because she got the form that took luffy 1000 ch to get and she got it in like 30 40 ch😂
@@randobando8354 Then the same people who are peeved about Luffy bestowing his freest form onto Bonney, who's father was ENSLAVED, are the very same people who would say Ace was stupid for turning back
@@randobando8354people being mad at her using a form for 10 seconds are really missing the entire point of what Nika is. It’s not about luffy unlocking a new form and the “ power” that comes with it. It’s the freedom and what it means to the world as a whole. Who cares how long it took luffy to get it. Him showing Bonney she has the freedom and capability to do it is the whole point. That’s what nika is. Freedom
For everyone who cried about Bonney turning into Nika last week: go ahead and apologize 😁 lasted 2 chapters and she can only turn herself rubbery
Literally just have patience next time
What if the sun is really the moon??😮
And now, Power Scalers will be glazing Emeth. I can already see it. 😂
“Emeth top 1. Gear 5 Luffy now in the mud. This ruins the whole story! Reeeeee”- power scalers.
Syv, when you mentioned the sulong's looking up at the moon and getting stronger in response to a need of like battle spirit, it reminded me of what we found out about Bardock in DragonBall super Manga in the granola ark in the flashback of when he originally faught Gas!!
Bonney asks Luffy - what was that form, he says thats what i look like when im at my freest.
She’s seen him attack so she’s just mimicking that look and rough physiology, same as she did with her Buccaner form.
I bet the more she learns about an ability or the more context she has she will mimick things to a more complex level
That facial expression when brago said "They have vice admirals" was beautiful
Regarding moonlight: it’s the closest thing to a dream for the sun.
And everyone related to the moon has been waiting for the dawn.
Just remember oda gave us one the hardest panels when the elders pulled up
You all forgot the gorosei have a Vegapunk. If they don’t destroy his brain, who’s to say York can’t access other information from the brain outside her specialty to reprogram the pacifista
Behind All the fluff Luffy Clapped an Emperor now an Admiral in back to back Arcs
17:49 Deku and *Bakugo
Her power works based on her understanding and belief of the future she imagines. Her devil fruit depends on her imagination.
Luffy powers are based on his imagination. The nikka fruit is the embodiment of freedom.
Freedom is for everyone.
It is not an exclusive concept. To truly show freedom everyone can experience it. Ideally no one should have to pay a price for freedom. Having Bonney develop her power only based on how she understands and imagines nikka to be. Her vision of freedom.
There are obvious differences how Bonney and luffy view freedom.
I love how this gives both luffy and Bonney a huge chance to improved on their abilities before the final arc.
I honestly don't know who these angry mobs everyone references are. Go to any discussion and it's filled with 100 comments about how stupid "powerscalers" are for not liking this development and 2-3 people actually critiquing the decision to let her copy G5.
Also the argument is: (1) it definitely feels unearned, (2) thematic poignance doesn't make it justified given how long we waited for the G5 reveal (3) suffering isn't unique to Bonney and doesn't entitle her to become the literal God she worships. That's not how faith works. I don't become G-d if I pray everyday. Seeing Nika being real is enough of a miracle for any believer. She doesn't need white hair or rubbery powers to be "free". Freedom means being able to standup to Saturn mentally, not just physically. Sentimentality (awww Kuma gets to witness it!) shouldn't override good storytelling.
Would any of you want Rebecca get Gear 4 in Dressrosa? That's the same story. Dad slowly losing himself inside a doll trying to save his daughter without her knowledge. Bet you wouldn't.
Chapter 1119 did nothing to disprove it. She demonstrates very similar abilities (even usage of Haki) to G5 Nika, the only issue being the duration. But she's a kid. Ofc, it would be a shorter window. It's not about her being powerful or even stronger than Luffy. It's about making him less unique. He could have given her any other OP power and still kept the thematic beauty. Idk, I don't feel this one. That doesn't make me a hater. Nobody reads something for that long (14 years) just to hate lol. It's not an argument to paint detractors as some hateful group (powerscalers bla bla). Does it mean that I will stop reading it and burn the volumes? Fuck no, lol. I don't think it's that big of a deal. What makes it more annoying is the constant farming for "controversy" that doesn't seem to exist. Don't believe me? Open any chapter disc on reddit.
I think bonnie has an imagination fruit, a fruit that works opposing original nikas force being will. The opposite of having will is to think of having will
The “force” of Luffy’s fruit is imagination … Not really will. I guess you could say it’s more specific to say “the will to exercise and your imagination”.
First af man syv and brago what more could i ask for
Bonny is a nika worshipper from kuma, sooo i can understand
Exactly. That’s what I’ve been saying.
so if you're a Christian you should turn into Jesus after praying a lot and crying? LOL
@@rainiwakura2430sure, if you had bonneys fruit
Oh because she worships nika, she deserves fucking nika power??
is jesus walking around and telling you they believe you can be like them😂@@rainiwakura2430
I always skip sponsors but this transition was so smooth I watched it!
I think York is the reason the brain is still functioning, when she would eat and use the bathroom it would satiate the other vegapunks so I think it also applies to the brain as well
Keep up the awesome work and videos BDA law love the video
I wonder that one keeps hinting at by using kids that have to go through grown up stuff, was joy boy really just a boy? He also inphasies on young boys wanting to adventure in the sea,luffys nakamas have come to be kids as well momo,bonny, otama and a few more situations like the kids that shanks meets. Joy boy had to be a actual boy in my opinion while Nikka was the warrior of liberation,the straw hats go on to embody an aspect of Nikka, what makes them special is what made Nikka Nikka, the cooking the love for the sea the love and knowledge of weather and medicine the urge to be free the urge to feed everyone and be friends with everyone ,that all boils down to who Nikka was and who joy boy sought to become
After letting it sit with me, I agree with Brago, as much as I enjoy the story in general, definitely confused on why at this specific moment? To throw one indirect punch? Just feels a bit forced and unnecessary, or overwritten.
It would be a twist is Imu and the Gorosei were the original devils of the world and the ancient kingdom used their blood to create devil fruits which could be why they were targeted.
Bonnie couldn't handle the freedom luffy has... Interesting
Unpopular opinion : Gear 5 allows for out of this world things to occur, that can be an explanation.
That’s not an explanation at all.
I think that Bonnie's fruit is not an age age fruit but a probability fruit.
It is able to create any probable timeline.
Bro I feel you long hair natsu was fire
every time someone does something new powerscallers get mad their hypotheticals arent comfirmed and forget about foreshadowing and the story thats taking place outside of fights and "feats".
That got be from yall own fandom (one piece fans )because luffy is really weak compared to anime and manga too tier characters lol
@@nooooiamu Another 6 year old powerscaler. Wcyd
0:45
Bonney has one of the saddest stories and has probably endured the most emotional/mental trauma and even direct oppression from the government of anyone in the series. And not to mention basically being forced to be a pirate at the age of 10 years old. "She didn't work for it" is a hot take imo.
She deserves the ability more than anyone else imo.
Bonnie’s sad story is 75% Kuma sad story seeping into her life.
@@MrJara1018 Yes it's called generational trauma. Ever heard of it?
@@MrJara1018**SPOILER WARNING**
I mean they both are pretty much linked story lines. I personally feel like Kuma and Bonney's story are one in the same(to an extent). Like Kuma's story would not have been nearly as sad if Bonney wasn't a part of it, and the same goes for Bonney's story if you remove Kuma. But i'm mainly referring to stuff that happened to both of them, just bonney and instances that didn't directly involve her but had major consequences or effects to her story.
I mean her mother passed before she was five. She got experimented on by the WG which resulted in giving her DF powers(which took her freedom to swim) and that resulted in an "incurable disease"(which took her freedom to go out in sunlight) and her father literally sacrificed himself(in secret) to have a chance to save her. Which left her an orphan being raised by the towns people/ fisherman and being forced to become a pirate. She was manipulated by the WG into thinking Vegapunk ruthlessly ended her father, and when she actually finds out the truth to everything that happened, she finds out that she just ruined any chance of her father re-gaining his memories through his DF fruit power.
My main point though is this all happened to a child.
It is most definitely one of the hardest things to say in One Piece. For people that poke their head in and out.
There's no way that it doesn't make sense.
Also we have no information besides people being upset. If you made it this far and you get it, the. You know for several reasons why this has more information at some point in the very near future that makes all the whining be obsolete.
Maybe Bonney doesn’t need a dream. At the end of the day, she’s 12. Imagine a 12 year old accomplishes their live dream at 12? If we’re assuming she takes the apprentice role, like buggy/shanks, do we think either of them had goals?
Shanks is going after the One Piece right now. I don’t think that was his goal at when he was on Roger’s ship
Personally I like the idea of Bonney getting her own Nika form. I think the issue is that the execution could have been done better.
After the latest chapter, she didn’t even get to really use it on a gorosei so I feel like the transformation was pretty pointless
'Bonney is too powerful' Two yonko crews have three former warlords amongst them, and another yonko crew has a former admiral, and we are worried about Bonney being too powerful why?
I legit don't understand how people think this is bad writing and some "girl power" stuff.
It was REALLY obvious that she's not gonna have the same amount of power or longevity as Luffy would.
And its even more wild that they say she hasn't "earned" it.
People need to stop reacting and actually start reading.
15:06 Wait wait if everyone did get nika’s powers at the end everyone’s idea of freedom looks different so even if everyone got that ability no one will be the sun god or joy boy because that’s not how they see themselves free maybe not even luffy will because honestly do we think joy boy from 1,000 years ago has the same idea of freedom as luffy today probably not and i could honestly see whatever joy boy does think freedom is being completely opposite and maybe even rejected by luffy come the end of the story which i mean finial form ? Or more like One more power up loading not necessarily a ff.
Guys, she isn't "mimicking" it, she IS Gear5 Nika in that specific timeline where she pulls her powers from. So it's like the Spiderverse for example, where multiple Spidermen are fighting together in one dimension. Bonneys DF allows her to be one of the Nika Users in a different timeline, that's her Power. I wouldn't be surprised if she can use the power for a longer period of time than expected, it's up to Oda. Her powers aren't like a Sharingan, she isn't copying the powers, she HAS that power for a short time!
If she was nika she would be laughing uncontrollably correct? Or is that just luffy? I don’t personally think she is actually Nika
gear 5 is nowhere near as busted without the Haki to complement it. she can probably do the same wacky and toon force shenanigans but she won’t have the same attack power as luffy
Yal can have this 1…the world government gonna rename the strawhats after a timeskip….
“The White Hair Crew or The Red Eyes Crew”
Or The Red Eyes White Hair Crew….
Naruto taps into the power of the 9 tails at 12, Gon taps into his future potential at 12, etc etc
Ppl are way too critical about stuff week to week. Kakashi didn’t earn his Sharingan in Naruto. Just read the manga and let Oda cook. He will explain everything in due time. We don’t need to stress out our Mangaka’s over small stuff when we want to keep them alive to finish the stories. Having an issue with Bonnie’s powers is nasty work when the drawbacks are clear
Different series different context also he had to lose his close friend and take his eye out to get that ability (it didn’t just fall in his had because a backstory or just cause )it’s not even the highest version of the eye , it took bro years before he unlocked some the strongest versions and it’s not a direct “god ability “ like the Nika gear 5 was supposed y’all give oda all the excuses in the world he Alr did the most bear minimum to foreshadow gear 5 anyways had one piece RUclips’s over here finding anyway possible to make him seen like he not human Oda makes mistakes to , from every one piece vid I see when someone don’t like something yall do everything in y’all power to downplay there problems and come back with straight bs but to each there own lol
Kakashi was gifted the eye from a comrade fallen in battle , war
As much as I agree the whole Bonney debate isn't that big a deal, what I find interesting is that you seem averse to people having a different opinion. I love One Piece and I didn't like G5. Bonney as much, but it's whatever. Should people just never criticize what they love? I don't think that's healthy.
I would prefer a chapter consistently every 2 weeks rather than inconsistent breaks. That way Oda can rest more and the schedule isn't so irregular.
Bonnie is just Mr. 2 (Bonchan) with a few abilities resembling the user too. That's just it.
I dont mind the breaks, but I do dislike when reports come out saying that "Oda wants to finish the series in the next ___ years".... Not with all of these cliffhangers and breaks.
Wait.....could Bonnie just tell S-Bear to push out the memories of her dad and put it into himself? Then they could grow up together.
Syv had a dc Server and I'm still sad he deleted it we had a whole community 🤦🏾
Bonney carries Kuma’s will and Kuma wanted to be Joy Boy and liberate all the slaves, becoming nika is how she carries on his will.
If Bonny is 12 now doesn't that mean she was 10 when we first met her? She was already a supernova. We shouldn't be shocked at her being ahead of her peers.
Jamiuwu intro really foreshadowed this lmao
For the record, Joygirl is on cloud 9 and loves what’s happening. She’s leaning in hard. Bonney g5 critics, officially off her crew.
Holup gang I hate/love fairytale but that 7 year situation made sense since they had a character that used time magic and them getting 7 years of maturity at once was life threatening but main character will power kicked in and they succeeded
Vibes doce of MI favorite one piece RUclipsrs 🤩😌💯
Yeah whole crew going gear five
Seems like Bonny’s ability is becoming more and more like Chrollo’s ability from Hunter X Hunter
I honestly just think the only ones mad are the power scalers.
Thumbnail hella makes me want Kat to come back using Snakeman techniques….a boy can hope
"Power scalers ruin One Piece" is the biggest cop out that the fandom does.
Power scaling can become way too toxic but as a principle it's a completely valid way to judge the story.
Oda being consistently inconsistent with his scaling and use of his power system (haki especially) damages his own world building. The One Piece world is built on power balance (the WG, the Marines, the Warlords, and the yonko). As soon as Oda becomes inconsistent it creates plot holes and destroys the reasons given to us as to why characters aren't making moves.
Her devil fruits not even awakened but her power drastically changed from age regression and progression to. Incarnating alternate future realities 😂 the bonnnyverse
Great points! I didn’t like it because it took away from luffys shine nothing is as special if there’s multiple of it. 1 of 1 is better than 1 of two that power should be luffys alone. Like if she not as strong with it then why give it to her at all ? I just don’t see the point
I think its less about bonney getting gear 5 for free and more about luffy spreading freedom.
I think its a good twist...she dont have the strenght and haki like Luffy. But its very heartwarming for her story..
@@Pinko-Diamond Sure true but she still not at his level so doesnt bother me to much
I think its gonna b closer to demon slayer how the main guys power rubs off on ppl around him
You know who isnt a detractor of gear 5 bonnie? Luffy
You know who is the happiest about 5 bonnie? Luffy
Luffy wants to be free and he wants everyone else to be free.
To me One piece is about hope for the future, a desire to be better, and standing up for what you believe in.
There is nothing positive to come from disliking bonnie over this.
We wanted Gear 5 to be something special and this takes away from that
No it doesn’t … Not at all, whatsoever.
It doesn’t…
🙄🙄🙄
Stop having opinions if they’re gonna be dumb ones
Gear 5 is special. No one can use gear 5 like luffy. Even Bonney going “nika form” she’s not in gear 5. Shes cosplaying( Even if she can use a gear 5 attack. It won’t be even nearly as powerful as luffy and I imagine that one attack would be it) . As brago said she’s a kid putting on a Superman cape. That doesn’t take a single thing away from Superman. luffy and gear 5 are symbols of freedom. Bonney only went into her nika form because of that exact freedom luffy was showing her she had. Her “ god” was telling her she could do it
You guys it's just haters they're not really one piece fans furthermore her attack is called Nika like future which allows her to transform into a version of herself as if she were nika
She can be as strong as Luffy the point is not that no one else can be Nika other people can eat the devil fruit Harper works by allowing her to use any power which means she could even use the flame flame fruit power if she could imagine it
This chapter proves that the elder are not devil fruit users.
I feel like if anyone else is going to, Robin could probably replicate Gear 5th abilities too. She's already turned into a demon, why not a Nika?
This guy knows his stuff
Power ups don't have to be earned. One Piece is more realistic about it as we don't always earn getting better at something. Sometimes it just happens or we just hear about something or we're given something. Just for proof that Oda doesn't feel the need to make everything get "earned" in a special way, I'll drop examples.
Luffy didn't earn Gear 3rd
Luffy didn't earn Gear 2nd
Nami didn't earn the Clima Tact
Nami didn't earn Zeus
Zoro didn't earn Enma
Momo didn't earn Dragon Form
Law didn't earn awakening
Etc etc
But in order to Awaken his devil fruit, Luffy died fighting Kaido and learned to mold the rarest and strongest Haki prior.
Zoro did not “earn” Enma…. He traded for it with Shusui a blade he earned In combat. Enma is also very taxing to use , it nearly killed Zoro…..
@@MrJara1018 He still didn't earn it. He just swapped for it. The downside of it doesn't matter because the topic is earning the power up, not the weakness of it. People were reacting before seeing Bonney's weakness so that doesn't matter.
@@MrJara1018 That's Luffy. What did Kid and Law do to earn awakening? Also that new chapter probably got you feeling goofy huh? LoL
Goda has had decades to map out and detail what the DF are and how the rules work. We’re close to the truth I hope he delivers
Other dude sounds like blitzo from helluva boss
I genuinely had to see if he was the voice actor
Does brago know Syv reads spoilers. Brago doesn't read spoilers.
Diffrence between gear 5 luffy and boney HAKIIIIIIIII
Umm I understood it like luffy being nikka has the power to give freedom to other devil fruit users temporarily, I don't think she's nika now sooo idk
Bonney gonna join as an apprentice like shanks and buggy for Roger. She’ll be a 12 year old around then cause she’s comfortable with the straw hats hence apprentice
The people who say Bonney didn't earn it are not reading the story. They can't be. She's been on the seas just as long as Luffy has. As a CHILD, leading a pirate group whose sole mission is to go against the entire World Government to get her dad back. She was good enough/caused enough havoc to be considered a Supernova in the Worst Generation. So clearly she is strong and had to be getting stronger. It's like people forget. You're NOT making it into the New Wolrd at all unless you are a very talented pirate. Having to fight Marines, other pirates, the ocean itself, and even civilians on whatever island you land on from time to time. And she left her crew to go kill the world's smartest man on a government island.
To say Bonney didn't earn it is the craziest shit I've ever heard. If Luffy earned it, then Bonney did too. What was Luffy's hardest moment? When he lost Ace? When he lost his crew? Bonney started her journey because she lost her dad. And made the hard decision to leave her crew, that she essentially grew up with, to chase her goal.
And her transformation isn't a transformation. It's just part of her devil fruit ability. We've been shown time and time again with her ability that she can alter the living physical world. It's not like she actually has gear 5. She's just mimicking it. I mean, she basically just delivered a haki covered giant punch. Which she could always do. She's just got a fresh coat of paint on when she did it. The hate is wild.
Also can Bonnie affect the area like luffy or just have his form?
Bonney is like Ditto she can look and copy moves but she doesn't have the stats.
I love the fairy tale and bleach tangent 😂🫡