I strongly recommend: Elden Ring Shadow of the Erdtree (Spoiler-Free Review)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 фев 2025
- Check out Gigabyte Aorus' industry leading range of Nvidia GeForce RTX 40-Series GPUs: www.aorus.com/.... Tune in to the GameOn Cancer fundraising livestream on Sunday, from 9am AEST right here on my YT channel for a chance too win a custom built PC courtesy of Nvidia and Gigabyte (ANZ residents only).
--
Shadow of the Erdtree is the perfect curtain call for one of the greatest games ever made - an expansion that manages the impossible task of making us feel that same feeling we had when we stepped out of that tomb and beheld Limgrave for the very first time.
Review code provided by Bandai Namco.
Video written and voiced by Ralph P.
Edited by Austin B.
#Review #EldenRing #shadowoftheerdtree
--
@NVIDIAGeForce #RTXOn
--
Thanks for taking the time to watch the video. If you'd like to support the channel even more, the best way is through my Patreon: / skillupyt
--
Twitter: Sk... (@skillupyt)
Instagram: www.instagram....
--
Grab 12% off any SteelSeries peripheral by using offer code SKILLUP at checkout: steelseries.pb...
--
Check out my curator page on steam:
store.steampow...
--
Recent vids:
Hades II early access review:
• Austin (already) stron...
Homeworld 3 review:
• Homeworld 3 - Review
Animal Well review:
• Austin strongly recomm...
No Rest for the Wicked Review:
• No Rest For The Wicked...
Stellar Blade Review:
• I recommend: Stellar B...
Dragon's Dogma 2 review:
• I recommend: Dragon's ...
Final Fantasy VII Rebirth review:
• I *very* strongly reco...
Judas overview:
• Here's how Judas is tr...
Pacific Drive review:
• I strongly recommend: ...
Helldivers 2 review:
• Austin strongly recomm...
Skull and Bones review:
• Skull and Bones - Review
Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League review:
• I absolutely do not re...
Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown review:
• Austin strongly recomm...
Game of the Year 2023:
• The best games (and ot...
I recommend: 2023 (This Year in Videogames)
• I recommend: 2023 | Th...
The Day Before - A Scam To Remember:
• The Day Before - A Sca...
Alan Wake II review:
• I strongly recommend: ...
Spider-Man 2 review:
• I strongly recommend: ...
Lords of the Fallen review:
• Austin is pretty mixed...
Assassin's Creed Mirage review:
• I do not recommend: As...
Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty review:
• I strongly recommend: ...
Final Fantasy XVI review:
• Final Fantasy XVI - Re...
Diablo IV review:
• I recommend: Diablo IV...
The Lord of the Rings: Gollum review:
• Gollum is way worse th...
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom review:
• I *very* strongly reco...
Redfall review:
• Redfall is an absolute...
Resident Evil 4 Remake Review:
• I *very* strongly reco...
Calisto Protocol review:
• I do not recommend: Th...
God of War Ragnarok review:
• I strongly recommend: ...
Gotham Knights review:
• I do not recommend: Go...
Saints Row review:
• Saints Row is terrible...
Elden Ring review:
• I *very* strongly reco...
Check out Gigabyte Aorus' industry leading range of Nvidia GeForce RTX 40-Series GPUs: www.aorus.com/en-au/graphics-cards/GV-N407SWF3OC-12GD/Key-Features. Tune in to the GameOn Cancer fundraising livestream on Sunday, from 9am AEST right here on my YT channel for a chance too win a custom built PC courtesy of Nvidia and Gigabyte (ANZ residents only).
We want to know if the bosses are actually hard compared to base game
I certainly hope you're gonna cover IGN fucking up a translation and trying to get Wukong devs in trouble for a load of BS allegations.
Hi, when is the final shape review coming?
awkward question, but are you going to covering your relation to sweet baby inc anytime soon? After that Kenzera Zau recommendation and with your good relationships with big companies, it feels like you are more and more leaning towards pleasing corpos and less about speaking openly to the community.
POE2 when?? - we know you were there, cant wait to see your take!
The duality of wanting to consume any fromsoft hype content vs. not wanting to spoiled in any way..
Indeed. Carefull with thumbnail, titles, shorts and the occasional stray tweet. Spoilers are everywhere
@@emperman i think i just made a mistake by commenting and clicking on this video 😂
Algorithm be like: oh you want more shadow of the erdtree?! 😂
What have we done…
i listen only... not a second of this video watched
I accidentally got spoiled about the final boss being Radahn and Miquella being like the Prince Lothric fight from Dark Souls 3.
I love how there are a lot of cool boss names, and then there's "Golden hippopotamus"
Thats definitely that hardest dlc boss cause ... its a hippo
Dark Souls 2 ptsd
So hard….
That mf took me longer than messmer fr 😭😭
Hibbobotamus hours
Embargo was up 45 minutes ago, but you waited for the nintendo direct to end, you clever boy
Ralph’s playing 3D chess
You cheeky sausage
@@joshuatealeaves i think you mean 4D
METROID PRIME 444444444444
@@tyguy3876i been waiting for that game since 2007. i havent owned a nintendo console in a decade but i may buy a switch just for that.
Oh Miyazaki, what swamp have ye prepared for me this time?
Has to be Deathblight lol
Frenzy 😂
@@Big_Daddy953oh dear god 🫠
How about a swamp with every status effect
@@JDG_YT2 It just kills you instantly
The sound it makes when you stagger an enemy is top 5 best gaming sounds
The #1 best sound in gaming is Sekiro's parrying.
No doubt. :D
Lies of P perfect parry sound or Bowser's yell in SM64 when you grab his tail are top 2 imo.
@@Wolfeyes1989PSNor bowser’s scream when you grab his weiner hehe 😊
Nioh 2 ki pulse sound is up there too lol
The sound you hear when a mini boss shows up in remnant 2 is top tier
In the immortal words of Yoshi P -- "Elden Ring DLC..."
"Elderinguh Dee ell ccssheeeeee"
Yoshi P is awesome lol
One week!
I wouldn't mention Yoshi P. around here... Skill Up hates the guy...
@@Azmodan514 wait why??
@@Azmodan514 Er don't think so. He didn't like FF16 much, if that's what you mean.
I've owned Elden Ring since it was released, I have only just now started playing it for the first time and I'm loving it. Can't wait to get the DLC too.
Never been a better time to start. Like Ralph said it's going to take awhile for you to get access to the dlc since Mohg has a recommended level of between 80-100. Just enjoy the ride though, I wish I could wipe my memory of my first playthrough so I could experience it for the first time again.
I bought it way after everyone else had already been playing it for quite some time. I out 150 hours in and never beat the game. That was over a year ago I last played and I recently started it again to catch up for the DLC. It has been a ton of fun.
Same, been waiting for them to drop a patch that finally supports ultrawide while still playing online.
It’s time to just accept it for what it is, I guess. I just wanted to see the stunningly glorious beauty of Lordran in 32:9, but Miyazaki cares more about PvP balance…I guess.
friendly reminder to not go on social media to avoid spoilers; people are already spoiling the ending/ final boss
Are you kidding me??? God that sucks so much, people just suck
is it confirmed to be real?
@@Sephirothkingdom782apparently yes, there's footage of player holding the boss weapon in the exact pose. I still would judge once I play the dlc myself though.
eh, does it really matter
Definitely sucks when people spoil that you fight Radahn and Miquella like the Prince Lothric and Lorian boss fight.
Man, after 50 hours and 100% completion of the dlc, I am so satisfied. Like the base game, the dlc exceeded my expectations. That’s only something From Soft can do at this point. Now that the work on the Elden Ring content is completely over, I am so excited to see what Miyazaki and the company are working on next
Sorry Chillup... I very very RARELY skip these reviews with minor spoilers, but the magic of finding a new area playing these game are always indescribable.
The exploration on FromSoft games is 50% de fun for me, so I will let a like already. Because you're a cool dude.
I'm taking a 10 days vacation just for this DLC.Just pure bliss over here.
Good gaming everyone! :)
Just flip your phone over and listen
I just love to hear them suck off fromsoft😂
I just came back to this review now after beating the DLC.
50 hours?!? Now that price tag makes a whole lot of sense
Yea from DLCS are notoriously usually really expensive but still super goof.
The old days this would of been called an Expansion, not DLC.
@@Swarm509 Some studios would call this sequel.
@@Swarm509 absolutely, Shivering Isles springs to mind.
I remember when Miyazaki said you could mainline the main game in 40 hours lol. That seems impossible. I put in at least 150 hours into it before I beat it.
Wanting increased complexity for the Shadow Realm Blessing strikes me as missing the greater context of what they are, namely they're not only supposed to improve your stats, but also encourage exploration for power in the same way the base game does even for fully-built endgame characters. The kicker however is that the Shadow Realm Blessing only works within the Land of Shadow, and thus it can't be too complicated due to the fact that you do have to step back into the Lands Between. Imagine if the Land of Shadow introduced this whole new amazing ability to increase your carry weight or cast more spells like you said... and then imagine playing without those new amazing abilities when you go back to fight Maliketh or Radagon or Malenia, because those abilities don't carry over into the Lands Between. You'll basically be locking players into wanting to play ONLY the expansion areas because all of the interesting new abilities are in there.
Imagine if you're playing Phantom Liberty, and you get all these snazzy Relic Abilities that allow you to shoot rockets at full auto or do amazing finishers, but then you can only use those abilities within Dogtown; it would SUCK massively to be locked out of such a unique set of abilities because you can only use them in one small area of the larger game, and I bet it'll fester resentment among the playerbase if they did that.
In summary, the Shadow Realm Blessings being "boring" is exactly what it should be within the greater context of Shadow of the Erdtree being an *expansion* to Elden Ring, because at the end of the day it is still an area connected to the Lands Between, and players should maintain parity in terms of new abilities between realms, hence why you're able to carry all the new weapons, spells, and items you find in the Shadow Realm to the Lands Between.
Well put I thought he was off the mark as well with how the new system is meant to only fix balancing issues not change the combat up. I enjoy Skill Up’s nuanced reviews but I dislike any ideas for innovation he proposes in this.
This without talking about how broken it would be for PvP and could make twinks much worse than what they are.
I wish leveling up in the base game worked like this, or like Sekiro
The difficulty system is there because FromSoft have learned from previous expansions that some players want to enter with their end-game builds and just an equal amount of players will do it with relatively fresh characters. This is just a way for them to make sure you won't stomp on everything immediately and loose out on the experience.
Exactly, I rolled a new character just for the DLC out of tradition but from what it sounds like now I'm probably just gonna use my NG+3 character.
Considering the approach to levelling in the DLC, I really wish it opened up much sooner, or was just a standalone experience. I am playing Elden Ring again on Steam Deck (having beaten it once on Xbox) and I'm about 40 hours in and I just don't think I can be bothered getting to Mohg again.
@@chrisp2588 Follow Varre's quest and he will give you an item that will teleport you there.
@@YetiCoolBrother the dlc is balanced around you having the blessings, on ng+3 you are missing out on three playthroughs worth of blessings.
@@chrisp2588 no thanks, it's balanced around end game characters. also a playthrough with all remembrances can just be 20 hours. You can even get to mohg as soon as or before you kill radahn.
I bought Elden Ring back in March as my first FromSoftware game. I accidently bought it at full price as I thought there was still a discount (pay attention to your purchases!) but I'm happy for that mistake. This has easily become one of my if not my favorite games that I have played. The sheer size and scale of the world pairing it with the deep the mythos has given me a feeling no other game may ever even encapsulate. I see this DLC as a friendly gesture of the middle finger to those that charge the same price for only a quarter of the content this has to offer, even if that quarter is great.
Edit: I am departing off the pickle of Elden Ring and now I must try finger but hole.
Listening to this one - always appreciate how Shill writes his review for the curious but not wanting to have things be visually spoiled people like myself.
20:50 "Wanna be one of those annoying, spinning perfume enemies that wear bedsheets over their heads? Now, you, too, can be that annoying."
I laughed real hard at this lmao
Even a "spoiler-free" review will have things I personally consider to be spoilers, but I look forward to watching this after I've played it. For now, I'm commenting and liking for the algo
I didn't even play Elden Ring base game yet, when I finally play it I sense this will consume my entire life for some time.
Oh, yeah if you like it you will be hooked. 150-200 hours of content.
If it's your thing than yeah, it will consume your life. ER is dangerous. Everytime I wasn't playing it, I was thinking about playing it.
What the hell are you waiting for man. It’s glorious 🤘🏽
@@DarkDonnie-82 My backlog is huge, I didn't even played Sekiro yet. But I will get there. And I will wait for a base game + DLC sale in the future.
Just finished my build got all flaks fully upgraded last night and beat game again can’t wait for this
can't wait for this! first time listening to your review and not watch anything on screen lol - congrats on 1M subs!
Same 😂
You don’t often see development companies with so much consistency. I don’t think I can even name one besides From Soft that never misses. Capcom has been doing well lately though.
Being a AC vet (all the way from Armored Core on PS) FromSoft NEVER misses!
there are plenty
elden ring might be pretty good, but they are going in a direction that makes their games kinda ass/sucks out the enjoyment. still better than your greedy AAA company but they are not in their peak anymore, sadly
@@Exel3ncebrother listen to yourself.
Since 2009 we have had:
Demon’s Soul’s, DS1 (AotA), Bloodborne (tOH), DS2 (3 DLCs), DS3 (AoA + tRC), Sekiro, AC6 and now ER (SotET).
No Dev company comes close in quality and output. Not Insomniac, Santa Monica, CDPR or Rockstar. All these companies have bangers but take 5+ years to release a game.
They are on a historic run. They deserve all the praise the receive.
@@Exel3ncewhat was their peak then?
SANTA MONICA STUDIO, HOUSEMARQUE, ANY FIRST PARTY NINTENDO OR SONY DEV TEAM.
Only FromSoft would hide the release of Elden Ring 2 in an expansion. The size of this "expansion" is mind-blowing. At least 50 hours, but looking like it's verging on 100 for a full playthorugh. I love FromSoft. Can't wait to see what the future holds.
you can finish this easily in with every boss dead in less than 15 hours. Cause I did, and i am not that good.
@@countryc0untsure buddy lol
Holy Cheesus the new weapons are siiiiiick! The light greatsword, heavy katana, and martial art class makes my buildcrafting juices all fizzy.
well get ready, because there are literally only 3 of each, martial arts only 2. Cause why add more of the new weapon types you marketed everywhere if you can just give every boss an old weapon type. Also one of the new weapon types has literally only 1 weapon.
and to think Miyazaki thinks he can do better than Elden Ring and Armored Core 6 we are not even at peak yet
bosses with even longer attack spams. How does he come up with these innovative ideas?
The reason I love this game so, so much is how utterly unique and different everybody's playthrough can be...when you said you didn't find any backhand swords it literally made me double take because the very first weapon I found, like literally within 15 mins of starting the dlc, was in fact backhand swords...incredible
Listening to this podcast style otw to work as i cant help myself. Cannot wait!
20:18 blood and wine
but that is arguably the best dlc ever made, so if shadow of the erdtree is going to draw comparisons to that I'll be happy
I honestly think Phantom Liberty is a tiny Bit better than Blood&Wine😅
@@kewa_design it could be, both are incredible
21:48 Just wanted to shoutout Armored Core 6. It has an incredible story and in my opinion, has the best Fromsoftware narrative yet.
That intro was so well written 👏🏽
11:40 Bro says "don't worry I won't spoil any L2 attacks". Literally less than a minute later he spoils the new katana L2 attack lmao. I don't even care about this kind of stuff and I still noticed.
i think its funny that at the cocoon it says "head to the realm of shadow" makes it sounds like a chill walk to the gas station
From Software has come A LONG way. From an incredibly low selling and niche Demon's souls to everyone being immensely excited for a DLC.
Demon Souls sold well and was critically acclaimed
Just here to see the new swamps.
And possibly crabs
Swamps of struggle man
Trivia: The overhead stance the great katana uses is called Jigen-Ryu, and it focuses on the strength of the first strike.
reminds me of ichimonji
Triple ichimonji
@@btchiaintkidding7837 haha that's what I thought too, but I've been playing Rise of the Ronin recently.
I just hope your player avatar screams when he does it, since kiai is part of the technique.
@@btchiaintkidding7837triple sashimi actually
NIIIHIIIIIIIIIILLL!!!! TOGHETA WE conquer the lands of Shadows ye Tarnisheds!!!
Aftermomths after months of rumination, my belief is that with this DLC, their main goal was weapon innovation.
Even beyond the new classes, the weapons are more unique, like unique guard counters with special effects, a chargable skill that does more than increase damage and size of particle effect, the smithscript series, Homing Bow and Ballista, Unique Heavy Thrusting Sword Moveset, a staff that can cast both Sorceries and Incantations.
Not to mention the beauty of the Light Greatsword Movesets.
They also made Armour choice more than ooh, big poise. Most armour sets have some cool effect.
Elden Ring at launch was and is an incredible game. By the time I was done with it I felt ready to hang up my Soulslike hat, for what else could meaningfully be done after delivering possibly the all-around magnum opus of soulslike. Then, I played Lies of P, and realized that the genre could still offer so much even with only a little reimagining of mostly pre-existing ideas. Both of those experiences led me to have high expectations for SotE. Expectations which the DLC fell short of.
The DLC did not meaningfully expand on what base Elden Ring offered, and often it stepped backwards on aspects that were previously great. Shallow exploration, poor execution of verticality, confusing map design in general (seriously I was happy to at least find a catacombs, compare that to base game), poor difficulty scaling, and in general a lack of finesse regarding what makes a From Soft bosses both good and challenging. It failed to iterate on the soulslike genre, other than setting a new bar for "hardest soulslike game," and while that may fit the reputation of the genre, that is not the point. Bosses are no longer elegant dances inviting you to learn the steps; they are demanding DDR runs, with a changing rhythm and insane tempo. They do not allow for meaningful self-expression through diverse builds, and in general just aren't fun. For some, this is what they wanted. Something soul crushing, a way to chase the memories of previous From Software games.
For me, I wanted something that asked what more can be done that is novel and interesting? Not just "How do we one up Sister Freide, and Orphan of Kos, and Malenia, and Radahn, and maybe do it all in the same fight?"
TL:DR; I wanted novelty a new challenge, not just: Combos that make Dancer of Boreal Valley combos seem short. An attack tempo that sometimes seems like it's from Sekiro. Delayed hits that make Morgott seem predictable. Damage that make pre-nerf Radahn look as weak. And layered magic/AOE spam that makes Gael seem boring.
Spot on
I cannot wait and I'm glad FS has delivered, once again. We need more dreamers like Miyazaki.
Got 90 hours into Elden Ring but never finished it (just exploring and messing around having fun) and got a little over half the map explored. Finally got back into it and boy is it still a great game. Just now exploring Caelid and is... interesting.
Time to get going faster so I can open up the expansion!
Don't rush the main game all of a sudden. The main game is still an A+ game
@@Wellgee i think it's better to just save content for future playthroughs otherwise you could burn out.
Damn you went 90 hours before exploring caelid?
@@Rutherfordbcrazy12 yes, I went north pretty heavy and ignored the "red area" early on. Probably more like 75 or 80 hours, I can be bad for leaving a game open and walking away. Either way I just went whatever way looked interesting.
@Swarm509 that's cool. You probably will be able to shred through that area at this point.
I actually want to acknowledge that I only had $40 in my PS account from bday money and such, and I just don’t have the funds to be buying games rn, so FromSoft fairly priced a HUGE expansion and didn’t add micro transactions and I can actually afford to play it because I saved up. In contrast, I’ve been a Destiny player for 10 years, and the final expansion in that saga released too. It was $50, it’s stuffed with micro transactions, none of my friends play it anymore, and most of the content that is truly unique is locked behind struggling to find between one and 11 other players that you don’t know to complete the content. So I made the decision to forego a game I invested 10 years into for a game that was brand new to me 2 years ago, because Elden Ring really is that special, and importantly, it was and is more accessible to me personally. Which is ironic considering its infamous difficulty lol. All I’m saying is there aren’t a lot of games or developers like FromSoft out there right now and I appreciate them.
Oh man, oh dude, oh man... I'm so excited... JUST TWO MORE SLEEPS!
With the scadutree fragments, they only effect your stats in the DLC. I feel like that works because then people who don't have the DLC won't be missing out on an a new game changer for weapons and build if they changed your weapon attributes. Whrn it comes to pvp, those who have the dlc would probably be at an advantage
15:25, that grab has Sekiro chained ogre flashbacks lol
Aristotel said:
You shouldnt care about much things in life, but we all should indulge in a good spank beyond erdtree”s Shadow.
Be aware tough, it may make you question your sanity and reality
As a diehard RPG fan I wish I could enjoy Elden Ring, hope everyone thats likes the games gets what they wished for, we need some good info from games from time to time
Are you unable to play for some reason? Nvm if it's too personal was jc
Its just good game with priority to consume player time. Its like butter on too many breads
@@thoughtsandgamesandstuff I am able to play it and I did, I just don't enjoy it. I need story and I really don't play the souls approach of adding info on items. I prefer proper RPG storytelling.
Gonna wait until my vacation before I dive into this. Looks and sounds like it's gonna be great!
Dude!!!!
that great katana stance is the Ichimonji double from Sekiro!!
I've never played any fromsoft/souls like. but I worked on the Collectible for the collector edition of this DLC.....also, a collector edition..... for a DLC ?!?!?!? hahaha! They knew this would be crazy popular! Always love your reviews by the way! :D
Damn the Nintendo Direct JUST ended
Ok and..??this is a review not a news video
What does that have to do with a review of Elden ring dlc… this isn’t
His news show
Metroid prime 4 baby
Nobody cares about Nintendo lmao hardware from early 2000s at best
Let me guess... They showed a bunch of cartoony platformers.
Youre talking about replayability but i dont see it happening. I could be wrong, but to gate weapon TYPES behind mohg seems ridiculous to me. I reckon its gonna be too much of a tall order for the majority of players to start a new character, go through varres questline (i guess), beat mohg, go to dlc, find the martial artists fists for example and then go back to the base game to RP as a monk.
I genuinely dont understand why people think thats a good idea. I would argue that: replacing certain base game end weapons with ones from the dlc would be the best solution, for example switching the giant crusher with a light greatsword or switching +2 talismans with some new ones would work ok. You then still maintain a form of progression. Otherwise the dlc seems TOO disconnected, which concerns me greatly tbh
Love your creativity, it's inspiring!
DISCLAIMER: OP is an OF bot account. Look at the profile bio link. They're appearing everywhere using Al to copy other comments that are popular. This is not a person, this is nothing more than an automated web script. Dislike and report!
I just wanna know: is the leaked video yesterday about the final boss real or not after all?
Thx a lot for answering 🙏🙏🙏🙏👍
Truth is, we don’t know. It’s definitely not going to play like that according to reviewers, so ithe real question is: is it Real but an extremely early version? Or is it not real at all? Either way, it will have an almost completely different move set and level of difficulty than that video. Some ppl are saying the final boss is either as hard or harder than melenia
Lands between is where you start, lands of shadows is where you go so there will be lands of light.
Lower, middle, higher. This is Zelda Tears of the Kingdom but better and we are getting the different sections of the world in content drops. Next time we go up!
I think they’re done. Will be focusing on a new game now surely
The lands between in and of itself is a land of light which is why the erdtree glows and the scadutree is shadowy, plus they already confirmed this is the last dlc
Lion! It's a dancing lion!
For real idk why he keeps referring it to a dragon. He did it in his preview as well.
Coming in to say I am going to avoid spoilers (even spoiler free) but really excited to watch this for your thoughts after I finish the DLC. Glad all the press around this game has been so positive
This video is the eighth straight content creator review in a row for me.
And by far the best.
You said what you wanted and or needed to say without major spoilers. Which I very much appreciate since a lot of these people are proudly slapping “No spoilers” on their videos, when what they really mean is “We assume you are up-to-date on every reveal from every source *before* this review, where we will not be adding any new images or facts except for everything already revealed up to this point and part of the zeitgeist.”
I decided to watch the main trailer and avoid everything else. It was hard but with my RUclips preferences and specific word exclusions, I made it months without anything besides the one thing I chose to watch (which was admittedly sparse and withholding as far as anything juicy besides the reveal of the Lion Dance boss) the main story trailer.
So I was beyond miffed clicking on all of the reviews before your’s (or, more specifically, the first one which ruined months of diehard dedication and self-denying as far as intentionally remaining as in the dark as I could) in which “No Spoilers” was the lead-in only to have tons of weapons displayed, one major boss I had heard nothing about (although she’s way bada$$ in a Pontiff sort of style, so now more excited to fight her than mad I know she exists) shown in-battle and a more-or-less complete rundown of every one of the biomes, the part I was the most excited to discover on my own, to a of weapons and boss remembrance equipment on-display.
Like trying to truly enter these From games as “blind” as possible becomes harder and harder with each new game (which, to be real, it feels like we’re all more-or-less treating this as). There are more and more rising lore analyzers and build-builders and really smart, clinical minds looking to connect every dot as they have come to appreciate this bond between themselves and the creators wherein small nuggets are mined for dozens of forms of speculative explanation and motivation breakdowns.
This previously very small community of From/Miyazaki enthusiasts were always the same recognizable faces and names I would engage in gank gang wars with in the city and steps and towers of the old Anor Londo in DS3 legit five years after the game came out and they/we were helping to keep pvp alive, our one respite set against the impossibly far off wait for Elden Ring.
And in most places I frequent I do still see these same people I have met online but don’t actually know, beyond our infectious love for keeping the game alive, however improbably long past its shelf-life.
But crucially I also see so so so many more people. That small (well, relative to what) group of us that kept these games alive and active have been joined up by so many new From fans (even if the “purity” of our sanctity to our bond cannot be replicated or given to these newcomers).
Stands to reason that out of this new crop of obsessive fans some of them would start and create content for their own channels and start producing lore and speculations.
So yeah. Such a bummer getting exposed less than two days out from a truly naked gameplay so much information and set pieces and known locations where events will go down.
So thanks again for being the only one so far to actually not have spoilers. Might want to pin my comment so people who have been screwed like I have out of the blind play they wanted or those who haven’t can know you are not guilty of these same egregious over-shares.
Great job and thanks. Cheers ya’ll. Happy hunting in the lands of shadow.
title said no spoilers - 30 secs in, "here are two main bosses" lmao
THE HYPE HAS NEVER BEEN SO INTENSE FOR THIS FRIDAY!!!!
It's actually thursday! They have posted release times!
Thursday night for console, thursday afternoon for pc 😎
Zero hype
@@vezolf4313 sucks to be you
So its Elden Ring 1.5? Not a true sequel but a full game in its own right if it takes 50+ hours. It's hard to argue you that, right now, FROM are the best developers on the planet not just for the quality of their games, but in the respect they give the gamer. I've been playing their stuff since Kings Field, jank and all and I'm a fan of their singular outlook on game design, even when it goes in odd directions like Chromehounds or the much under appreciated Ninja Blade. Their games never feel like they've been made by committee, suits looking at trends and going, yes a live service game next.
Bro one handing the two handers 😆😆😆
Just a bit of a feedback. For me, saying the number of Major bosses/ number of new areas in the game are things I consider as spoilers.
I love your videos btw, my go to RUclipsr for everything gaming and reviews.
I would have never seen this coming, neeeeever.
Honestly, with the amount of games releasing with severe performance issues you should probably think about if testing games on a 5000$ machine is really the smart way to go about it.
For me, the reviews lost alot of value since you got the 4090 and shortly after seemingly stopped extensive testing on your old 2080 Ti machine instead of playing a large portion on that machine as you said after getting the 4090.
Brother, any Final Shape review? Curious to know your final thoughts. Much love from Qatar
he mentioned in a recent video that he’d be getting to that review once his schedule clears up a bit in the coming weeks
@@zd5819 thank you 🙏🏻
I never really got the criticisms about the base game being too long. I mean, it was pretty much left down to the player to decide how long they wanted it to be & you could finish it fairly quickly if that was all you wanted. I on the other hand, did everything on my first playthrough, coz I wanted to experience everything From intended & you only get one first impression. I'm gonna do exactly the same with the expansion & I can't wait. Let's effing go!
8:08
It took me with 1 character, doing everything more than 200 hrs. Highly agree with that criticism.
Most dungeons or sidestuff rewards are re-use bosses, small rune rewards for defeating said bosses, and/or weapons/spells/etc. that you dont use for your builds.
This is what made me not do multiple runs with different builds like I do with their other games and just not buy this dlc.
Im sure the DLC is going to be great, I just feel that I had my fill.
Cannot wait! I will be on vacation when it launches, but as soon as I am back, I am booting this up.
Listening to this like a podcast I want to be fully surprised
One thing I need to give a big compliment to From Software is the performance of Elden Ring in general.
I play it on a Mini-PC without a dedicated GPU (AMD Ryzen 7, Radeon 780M) and it runs at 1440p and maximum settings at 40-60 fps...
My body is ready
Elden Ring's not for me, but I'm glad that the people who enjoy it are getting more. Have fun yall.
Play it now scrub!!!
@@christianbell8347 I did, just didn't enjoy it. Not for me.
mimic tear our savior
I can't wait for Elden Ring 2, never. Just like my beautiful Blood Born. 🤧
We in here, almost time!!
Thanks for your work and greeting from germany :) i am now in Australia (Adelaide) for the time. Nice experience so far.❤
I wish they would have added a way to jump straight to the DLC from the start menu with a new character boosted to the appropriate level instead of needing to grind the whole game until endgame before entering. Much like The Witcher 3 did
If you know what you're doing, you can beat Mohg and Radahn and be at a reasonable level in 3 or 4 hours, you don't need to grind the whole game. They even give you a teleport right to Mohg's doorstep.
And if you have an old file, you should have already done it.
If you're new to the game you're not ready for the DLC anyway.
Easy mode in any souls-like would be just the removal of the stamina bar really.
Help mode could be a visual sign to better determine parries and perfect parries (like quicktime events have).
There was only like 11 unique bosses in Elden ring quite literally, so 10 unique boss fights is pretty nice
U know what would've been nice? If they added a boss gauntlet like they did in Sekiro. The fact that they haven't is really disappointing.
It's a bit cringe how many times in this review you repeat "It's not a criticism" after what you just spelled out clearly IS a criticism. It's fine to have some criticism for a game that is otherwise clearly going to be highly praised. RUclipsrs just feel too scared of fanbases.
yea it was really annoying, and he greatly undersells how bad some of these "thought experiments" ugh...are...
like holy fuck that blessing system is trash, the bosses are all just recycled/retreads, and the map is massive...and empty now! as apposed to uh...massive and filled with shitty dungeons, what a improvement.
I feel like the reviewers are grossly overselling the dlc.
@@zomgpie2 For real, every time i see people criticizing any fromsoft's games, they always feel the need to say atleast 1 obligatory positive comment about the game despite it not being relevant to the discussion, i know they do that because they know how biased fromsoft fans can be.
In the recent weekly news video he mentioned he played the DLC on the plane to LA and I assume either wrote the review while on the plane or while juggling SGF commitments during the busy week. I don’t really think he was in a working environment conducive to creating a review for a massive open world DLC and it really shows in the video. I wonder why he didn’t just give the review to Austin? I get the feeling Skillup keeps the hype games to himself and leaves the rest to Austin. It was telling when he wished he reviewed Helldivers but gave it to Austin because it was surprise how much hype the game was post launch.
Elden Ring really is modern day Morrowind. The exploration, the lore, the discovery, the massive expansion.
5:57 if only people were this open with division 2016 storytelling
Miyazakis next RPG is potentially just going to be the greatest game of all time. He’s refinging bloodbourne and Sekiro combat, he’s learned so much from Elden Ring, they’ve clearly realized the story needs to be a touch more prominent. I’m just hoping it’s not tooooo far away
They pulled a Zelda, and gave us the dark world... Nice
At this point Fromsoft is making fun of rest of the industry. Their dlc is better than 95% of games
Damn no “very” strongly recommend? From fell off 😢
For that you have to watch the God of War Ragnarök review and, i guess, experience it for yourself
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Lol they really made a boss called Rellana, someone needs to introduce new naming conventions to the Lands Between
Analler
Fixed 😎
Though I appreciate the positive vibes. I don't think many will need the recommendation. They hype is real.
Spent so much time playing this multiple times on both the PS5 and PC, but this review makes me feel like I forgot everything besides knowing I enjoyed it all. Hopefully it's not too hard to get back into.
Wow. Been waiting two years for this… so close!
Just pre-orded it, Dlc is fully downloaded and just waiting form my 100+ hours character to do some unprotected hand holding with a corpse, not only that but i will start my first playthrough of the dlc on new game plus 3, so wish me luck, i will need it....
Me, missing the *very* in the title: "omg no, does it suck?" 😅
A DLC/expansion where _rushing through the content_ (admittedly not speedrunning) would take about _15-20 hours!_ This isn't a mere DLC, this is almost Elden Ring 2, and it puts every other excuse for a DLC to shame!
You „strongly recommend“ so many games. Try to be a bit more critical.
You say that under a video for Elden Ring lol you couldn‘t find a more out of place video than this one
He praised Alan Wake 2, I don't know what you were expecting. 😂
@@lukew6725 Which isn't a good game?
1:38 " How do you make elden ring better". Let me say, I adore this game. I love so much about it and ive been looking forward to the dlc for months now. That said, when I was playing, especially because this is the first souls open world game from "from", I had a few things I would have liked to be improved;
- Story; Dont get me wrong, I really like the mysterie and the ambigiouity of souls games in general. Trying to piece the puzzle together. Yet, in Elden Ring, because it is so expansive and non linear, I felt many side quests got kinda lost on me because npcs were so far apart and direction non intuitive. I would love to see a little more hints or clues where to go next (for particular storylines) if you would like to follow up on that sidequest. I think it would add to immersion even more so than I already was. As much as I like Vaativydia, I think it would be an improvement if I didnt need to rely so much on a youtube channel to understand so much of this worlds rich lore.
- Button control; I think many people might not agree with me because they like a certain staleness I assume, but for example I would have really liked to see where you press " up " on the d-pad and then you can press a button to select specifically which skill you want to use instead of scrolling through skills until you find the right one. Ofcourse, you can equip less skills for particular builds, but I do think being able to select a skill more directly would widen build variety and smoothness overall.
- Lastly; Being able to properly coop with a friend. I honestly never understood why fromsoft actively obscure people to do so. Not being able to mount, limited potions, no progession sharing, no fast travel etc. Ive played from DS3, Demon Souls, Bloodbourne, Sekiro and I did understand it for those. Elden Ring seemed like the perfect chance to add 2 player coop.
What are your thoughts?
I think the spell scrolling is a balancing issue. It's not supposed to be easy to quickly switch between spells in intense combat encounters to stop you from getting too powerful. It's the same reason why you can't freely switch between weapons during combat without taking a weight penalty, it's supposed to be a bit of a pain.
It’s not spoiler free when you tell how many bosses there are in a first few seconds
If you think the number of bosses is a spoiler (it's not) then why are you watching a 30min review of the game? Maybe don't?
@@davidm2031 I can see why you’d say that, but I’ve watched dozens of similarly timed, spoiler free reviews that don’t tell you how many bosses are in the game.
I'm so hyped for this game that I haven't been able to focus on a single other game since the beginning of the month! I read a book instead of playing anything the other day because I couldn't find a game out of the 450+ games I have in my digital catalog.
I'd really love if Ralph criticized a game for what it was and not what he wants it to be. He always seems to do this. It's an annoying review model
I've watched a few different videos about this dlc. Had to turn yours off after a couple mins cuz you were saying too much. Your definition of spoiler free should be reevaluated.
Maybe you should grow up.