Greatest JEWISH Speech!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
- This is hands down the MOST POWERFUL speech that talks about the struggles, identity and aspirations of the Jewish People. Herbert Pagani's poem written in 1976 couldn't be more relevant today.
This is a MUST watch for all.
The fact that this video is from 1976 just makes me feel sad. 45 years and nothing has changed...
You're comment is painful because it's fact! 💔
Right on!
@Thirdeye Coming I'm confused. Are you replying to me or to one of the other comments?
@Godsplan359 Yeah...because there aren't white Jews🙄
@Godsplan359 I made my point clear. You assumed a white person isn't Jewish.
@Godsplan359 The point is YOU ASSUMED, AND THAT'S MESSED UP!
I’m breathless. That was perhaps the single most beautiful and intellectually articulate speech I’ve ever heard.
This is indeed the best Jewish speech ever given
I'm so glad you know Herbert Pagani he is the cousin of my father. My family often speaks about him. I think he is great example for new generations.
What an incredible man your granduncle was!
Lets take a glimpse at how misguided the content of this speech is: The laws that guarantee humane treatment of laborers including paid benefits and holidays are clearly out-lined in Jewish law where as on Shabbos, we are not even allowed make our animals work, let alone our non-Jewish slaves (whom we are not allowed to free so what was he saying about Judaism being against slavery?) and on the 7th year we are not allowed to make our land work (yes, you heard that right, our rocks and trees have to keep Shabbos). Judaism is not against slavery, Please explain to me what does 'ama ha'ivria' means? Its a little Jewish girl that is legally sold to slavery by her father for no crime of her own, only because her father is poor. It would be more accurate to say that Judaism has such a deep respect for human life that if the world would follow Judaism then slavery would NOT have to be abolished because the laws of slavery, in Judaism, guarantee certain basic rights to all slaves, that most American citizens do not enjoy. Where would America be today if slave masters had treated their slaves differently? Why can't slaves have schools? Why can't slaves have comfortable lives? Most legal, paid jobs satisfy the Jewish definition of slavery. That is why I wrote and delivered a lecture on the legality of 'working' a salaried position as an observant Jew in one of the oldest and most respected Yeshivos in the world (its fine btw, we are allowed to work - maybe). I could likewise prove to you that Judaism is ideologically sexist and racist followed by proving you that Judaism requires utmost respect for the same people that it discriminates against. I could just as easily prove to you that Nazi Fascism is the only way to describe what the Jews did to conquer the land of Israel - we literally exterminated 7 nations, and by the same token, that in that same ideology lies the greatest care and concern for peace and mutual prosperity. I consider my self to be a non Zionist Jew bordering on anti-Zionist (though some would opine that I am extremely Zionist) and my respect for Judaism is absolute, but to conflate things that some misguided secular Jews have done with totally misunderstood artifacts of Judaism, i.e. Freund vs. resting on the 7th day, is absolute ignorance beyond proportion in my mind.
Wow we need more people like him and ruby
The rules of eved canani is only referred to the people of canan which we had a particular relationship with.
Our rules on jew slaves should be the ones regarding all other people.
Herbert when he spoke about Freud and all other personalities was referring to the fact that because they where jews and so non linked to any land they where living in, they were not in the society like others were for this reason they have dove their revolutionary works. There is no link to shabbat in any way.
@@Hhgguhhjhvg "The rules of eved canani is only referred to the people of canan which we had a particular relationship with. " - source? "Our rules on jew slaves should be the ones regarding all other people." so its ok for parents to sell their underage girls to slavery for their own monetary benefit? have you ever heard a an 'ama ha'ivria'? how about forcing a 12 year old girl into marriage? does the word 'naarah hameorasah' mean anything to you? "when he spoke about Freud and all other personalities was referring to the fact that because they where Jews and so non linked to any land they where living in, they were not in the society like others were" Perhaps, but a German Jew not linked to Germany? You have to brush up on German Jewish history. Jews were so comfortable in Germany that an entire movement was formed (in part) to remove the return to the Land of Israel from the Jewish religion. It called reform. Jews in Germany were so completely German that any part of Judaism that set them aside from Germans was perceived as an obstacle and needed to be changed. Anyway, I used the word conflate which means to combine. He combined his false concept of Shabbos, which he credits with being an intellectual precursor to modern day labor laws and ethics (totally untrue) to Freud, who's thoughts, writings, and practices were a precursor to modern day psychology.
That was really powerful. I’ve always been an advocate of Palestinian rights but listening/watching Rudy Rochman’s content has really enlightened me and made me see the other side and appreciate Israel and the people inside it. That was 4 years ago, fast forward to 6 months ago and I find out I have a Jewish grandparent. Life is interesting, what a privilege, we must ensure this privilege becomes a universal human right, not something someone need fight for.
Thanks. I wonder how you feel now, after the October 7th massacre?
One of the best speeches ever.
Amazing speech and such a true poem. Hits me right in the heart. Because of it I now have significantly more desire to learn French so I could understand him as he speaks those words with such incredible passion - עם ישראל חי!!!
@@johnny40coats4 and yet, the Jewish people cannot forget that not more than a century ago the entire white continent tried to kill all of it's members, and had huge success in it. And then, in the war for Israel independence, the Palestinians, Jordanians, Egyptians, syrians, Lebanese, Iraqis, Sudanis and the Saudis all tried to kill the Jews. They were far from successful.
We, as Jews, see the hatred day in and day out. It's not fascist, being on guard. you just wanted to make the comparison between Jewish nationality and fascism. You know what I think about people like you? 🤢🤮🤮
עם ישראל חי
@@johnny40coats4 Enough with lies, will ya? You're just a troll spreading bullshit to start a flame war. I mean, nobody is THAT stupid...... or are you?
@@vl3005 מחקו את התגובה של האנטישמי? מעולה!
@@johnny40coats4 no it is factual. There are hundreds of photos of Palestinian children forced to take up rifles and other weapons by the frauds that pretend to represent the people of Gaza and the West Bank.
I’m proud to be Jewish and my country is Israel ever word he said is my belief 🙏🏽🇮🇱❤️
😂 your religion is so lame. Your are not from Israel but from Eastern Europe
@@TheAbsoluteTruthTV It's good to hear more and more people stand up and speak the truth, just be human. But you can already see from everywhere in the world standing against Hamas and for Israel! Kudos to those who have a heart ♥️
@@TheAbsoluteTruthTV Yeah this is a conspiracy theory and blatant lies.
1) The rave had to be approved by the military because of the proximity to the border and was approved hence it was known.
2) That was confirmed by multiple times by both military and non-military officials.
3) I could go on about the ease of recognition of armed personnel vs teenagers partying with musical equipment and tents around them. Or I could say that your numbers are way off, or that the aircraft didn't actually bomb the area because of proximity to an Israeli town, or that the terrorists went house to house and burned them down and raped women, beheaded children and the charred bodies were in the burnt houses.
The fact of the matter is: terrorist supporters, conspiracy theorists and antisemites are a lost cause and truthfully, this comment is here is not to change your mind, but for whoever reads this in the future.
God bless you. Will see in 5-10 years.
Indians and Jews are best buddies ❤
Amazing speech that was relevant 1,000 years ago as it is today.
Thank you Rudy.
מחזק מאוד.
הייתי צריכה לשמוע את האיש היקר הזה בדיוק עכשו.
גם כאן בהולנד המצב מפחיד!
תודה רודי
אחי תחזור הביתה.
אין מרום ליהודים בחוץ לארץ
@@chaimoberman752 אמת!
על ישראל חי. כולנו אתכם. רק לא להיתייאש
מה קורה איתכם בהולנד??
אתם חייבים לעלות לישראל!!
@@chaimoberman752 לא כי בארץ ממש בטוח להיות יהודי
I defend myself, therefore i am.
Шурик?
Let's make sure to not use that argument for the abortion topic lol
@@rithvikmuthyalapati9754 Bro im all pro abortion too.
@@rithvikmuthyalapati9754 eh?
@@citizenkhan4696 Why would someone who is Jewish be pro abortion? The whole reason behind abortion is to take a life of a unborn child that they consider"not human". The same sang the Nazis repeated to kill our brothers and sisters. When you consider someone "non human" because you think they are less than you, you are no better than Hitler yourself. A unborn is still a child. When you are pregnant you say you are having a baby, not a fetus. We must stand up for those who can't stand up for themselves or history will repeat itself. Aborting a child is murder and murder will not go unseen by God.
I still feel the lash on my back from the Egyptians.
I still wear the yellow badge by the German order.
I still running from the from all the pogroms around the world and around the clock.
I still see Jerusalem burn in front of my eyes.
But I hear and say every year from the day that I was born till the day of my death, Leshana Haba'a Biyerushalim, Next Year In Jerusalem.
I am a Jew.
❤
We are descendants of a Chinese diaspora fleeing from war famine and hunger to every corner of the world and still face persecution killings and insults today in some SEAsian country. Growing up, people called us Jews of the east. I do not regret as I’m Christian. God bless Israel, God bless His people called by His name.
❤💥❤Excellent!!!!!
It's not what he said. He is talking about the chinese diaspora in asia.
That was seriously powerful - with the music too just incredible - as a Chinese I cannot pretend to understand the struggle of the Jewish people (I can relate to it because we have faced exclusion around the world but we've always had the privilege of having a large nation) but I think the ideas this man expressed can inspire all cultures. Nationalism is not always racist; for some is about establishing an identity and standing up for yourself and your group. Now it makes so much more sense
Now, obviously not everyone in a group is the same, all good or all bad. But you cannot hate the people genuinely fighting for their dignity. We must judge clearly who is good, who is malicious, who is ignorant and who is knowledgeable...
I can imagine his frustration when he joined the left to fight against the blatant antisemitism of the right only to be alienated by leftists too, rejecting Jews as a marginalized group simply because they have achieved success. When allies are few and far. He had to forge his own path. An important message, common yet still revolutionary, encouraging people to have the right to be who they are. Thank you for sharing
FYI after the first few little bits of music, the main bit was from Ma Vlast by Bedrich Smetana. The melody in it was an inspiration fire the computer of Hatikvah.
China only against Israel because they want to annoy US. The real chinese people are with the Jewish people.
people were conditioned to confuse nationalism, which is a healthy survivalist thing, with nazism, which id racist and supremacist.
nazism is bad. nationalism is good.
I am Speechless,
profound and powerful
One of the most passionate speeches I have heard. From the heart. Hope one day there is peace.
Lets take a glimpse at how misguided the content of this speech is: The laws that guarantee humane treatment of laborers including paid benefits and holidays are clearly out-lined in Jewish law where as on Shabbos, we are not even allowed make our animals work, let alone our non-Jewish slaves (whom we are not allowed to free so what was he saying about Judaism being against slavery?) and on the 7th year we are not allowed to make our land work (yes, you heard that right, our rocks and trees have to keep Shabbos). Judaism is not against slavery, Please explain to me what does 'ama ha'ivria' means? Its a little Jewish girl that is legally sold to slavery by her father for no crime of her own, only because her father is poor. It would be more accurate to say that Judaism has such a deep respect for human life that if the world would follow Judaism then slavery would NOT have to be abolished because the laws of slavery, in Judaism, guarantee certain basic rights to all slaves, that most American citizens do not enjoy. Where would America be today if slave masters had treated their slaves differently? Why can't slaves have schools? Why can't slaves have comfortable lives? Most legal, paid jobs satisfy the Jewish definition of slavery. That is why I wrote and delivered a lecture on the legality of 'working' a salaried position as an observant Jew in one of the oldest and most respected Yeshivos in the world (its fine btw, we are allowed to work - maybe). I could likewise prove to you that Judaism is ideologically sexist and racist followed by proving you that Judaism requires utmost respect for the same people that it discriminates against. I could just as easily prove to you that Nazi Fascism is the only way to describe what the Jews did to conquer the land of Israel - we literally exterminated 7 nations, and by the same token, that in that same ideology lies the greatest care and concern for peace and mutual prosperity. I consider my self to be a non Zionist Jew bordering on anti-Zionist (though some would opine that I am extremely Zionist) and my respect for Judaism is absolute, but to conflate things that some misguided secular Jews have done with totally misunderstood artifacts of Judaism, i.e. Freund vs. resting on the 7th day, is absolute ignorance beyond proportion in my mind.
@@elishahabinsky5654 firstly I'm not Jewish, and secondly I don't speak French and the subtitles were very fast. I have a keen interest in seeing one day everlasting peace in the region that fills the aspirations of everyone, the point I was making and in my opinion it was, was the speach was delivered from the heart and extremely powerful. Passion can be read from any language.
@@danburridge5015 "the speech was delivered from the heart and extremely powerful. Passion can be read from any language." - respectfully, i would offer you to consider that Hitler, Stalin, Gedafy, and Hussein can be described the same way. Weren't these all deep and sophisticated people who just happened to be wrong about a few trivial points? And the Jews just happened to be perched on the other end of those little points. I actually live in a microcosm of a functioning two state solution. My town is the largest and fastest growing 'illegal settlement' in the West Bank. we have over 2000 Arabs working full time within our city. They live nearby. Their town is growing because our town is growing. We're living quite happily together. no 'speech was delivered from the heart'. No 'passion' to be read from any language. Just regular people who have the maturity to put down the newspaper and live their lives. We respect each other and never conflate headlines with our immediate surroundings. That's what's missing. not words of passion from the heart. I am deeply disappointed by the fact that these words of passion from the heart that have achieved nothing have received so much attention while the obvious solution to the conflict is in plane view for everyone to see.
Hope one day we can see a workable "United States of the Holy Land" where freedom of movement, unity and peace for all Muslims, Jews and Christians is in Gaza, Israel and West Bank. Tourism will flourish for all
Im proud to be Jewish ❤
Same here brother.
אכים!
proud to be jewish, even more proud of you brothers.
אחים*@@AGENTtoaster-eg4ju
I have never been more proud then I am now!
That's incredible awesome, as a Jewish man I couldn't be more happy to watch this than now, it's make me feel connected to my roots, my legacy thank you for that
This is the most beautiful summery of the Jewish straggler I have ever seen 😊.
ruclips.net/video/QXMG1tyJ-Uk/видео.html
This is 100percent truth and beauty. Im a Christian even as a child I hated hearing Jew jokes. Its like People don't want Jews to exist but when you look at history it makes no sense. Y'all have brilliant minds and the Jews contributions to mankind is amazing but when people aren't happy they blame you as a whole. On any earthly level it makes no sense. Im praying for you and Israel. Keep telling your peoples stories and truth. God is behind Israel and you will never be destroyed.
people will always dislike the different, thats just human nature. nontheless, thank you for your kind words, people like you infuse a bit of hope within us.
much love from Israel.
Lets take a glimpse at how misguided the content of this speech is: The laws that guarantee humane treatment of laborers including paid benefits and holidays are clearly out-lined in Jewish law where as on Shabbos, we are not even allowed make our animals work, let alone our non-Jewish slaves (whom we are not allowed to free so what was he saying about Judaism being against slavery?) and on the 7th year we are not allowed to make our land work (yes, you heard that right, our rocks and trees have to keep Shabbos). Judaism is not against slavery, Please explain to me what does 'ama ha'ivria' means? Its a little Jewish girl that is legally sold to slavery by her father for no crime of her own, only because her father is poor. It would be more accurate to say that Judaism has such a deep respect for human life that if the world would follow Judaism then slavery would NOT have to be abolished because the laws of slavery, in Judaism, guarantee certain basic rights to all slaves, that most American citizens do not enjoy. Where would America be today if slave masters had treated their slaves differently? Why can't slaves have schools? Why can't slaves have comfortable lives? Most legal, paid jobs satisfy the Jewish definition of slavery. That is why I wrote and delivered a lecture on the legality of 'working' a salaried position as an observant Jew in one of the oldest and most respected Yeshivos in the world (its fine btw, we are allowed to work - maybe). I could likewise prove to you that Judaism is ideologically sexist and racist followed by proving you that Judaism requires utmost respect for the same people that it discriminates against. I could just as easily prove to you that Nazi Fascism is the only way to describe what the Jews did to conquer the land of Israel - we literally exterminated 7 nations, and by the same token, that in that same ideology lies the greatest care and concern for peace and mutual prosperity. I consider my self to be a non Zionist Jew bordering on anti-Zionist (though some would opine that I am extremely Zionist) and my respect for Judaism is absolute, but to conflate things that some misguided secular Jews have done with totally misunderstood artifacts of Judaism, i.e. Freund vs. resting on the 7th day, is absolute ignorance beyond proportion in my mind.
@@elishahabinsky5654 explain me, what is wrong with us jews reviving our old civilisation Judea? Especially when the partition plan from the US was turned down by the Arabs
@@theplainguy5102 Well I supposed that depends on how you look at it. Is it reviving our old civilization or is it burying our old civilization. I think we can agree, that if someone like Hitler ym"sh would capture the land of Israel it would be better if he would call it Germany than if he would call it Israel, wouldn't you say? So its a question of narrative. Who is the state of Israel. An imposter using Jewish symbols, history, and culture to defraud the Jewish people of their heritage or something more like what I think you credit it with. I honestly came to Israel on a one way ticket with every intention to join the army only I checked into a Yeshiva to learn some Hebrew first(Aish Hatorah). That was my first exposure to Talmud Bavli. I was too intrigued to continue. I stayed there for 4 years and then moved on to a more advanced place, Yeshivas Mir, for another 11 years. I cannot see, from what I know now, how anyone who knows anything can liken the state of Israel to anything but fraud. I credit Rudy with his fact checking the anti Israel/Jewish bias. But to go so far as to say supporting Israel equates to reviving our old civilization. Respectfully, it upsets me just to heard such words. Just imagine Nazi's being credited with reviving the old Jewish civilization, how that could make someone feel. You may not look at it the same way but again, its a question of narrative.
@@elishahabinsky5654 i really don’t understand your argument, why don’t we have a right to come back to Judea if there was no actual country that established while we weren’t here?
Burying our old civilisation? How exactly? As my Jewish sister you already know how during history we are always being killed and discriminated due to the sole fact that we are jewish. Living in other state isn’t a solution, because Antisemitism will rise again, it is just a matter of when.
I'm a muslim, and I'm crying. Please let us be together, build a better world. I wish Israel proves in action what it stands for in speech. It doesn't become the monster it had destroyed.
I am Jewish and I am standing by your side saying the exact same words. Let us finally be happy at this wonderful land together 🤍🤍🤍
I agree with you both (I'm Jewish) but I must state. People in the world want to seperate us and turn us against each other, for their own profits...
@@dcrafton3988 You wrong. All people want to see peace between both of you but the one you call it close friend who are actually don’t. Your fight is their glory. Your peace is their suffering.
@@putatdaun no they're suffrage is there suffrage has nothing to do with our .peace we offer them land they rejected the land. It's not our fault that they didn't want it.
See amir a lot of people would call you traitor and backstabber just because you talked to a jew so I don't think peace is an option right now. You know also cuz we offered them land and money and they didn't want to take it.
❤I feel myself a Jew. Most of the Indians alwsys stand with the the Jews all around the world. My country India will always be open for the Jews. I wish you you came to live in India in 1948. India is strong enough to accommodate peoples from all cultures and all religions.
That would have been amazing honestly.
Love India from Israel
@@EL-oj6uq they do NOT love you
Thank You, Love to visit India . My sister been there 3 times. A lot of family members going there again in few month. Some for multiple times. its a big country. 💌
However old this is, it feels more relevant than ever. Thanks for sharing Rudy. You are a true mensch
Yes. But why the last word in german? Just asking :)
@@lanadelreyismom because he is German duh
I’ve had a tough time accepting my heritage as of lately. I’m half Jewish because of my dads side, but that blood overpowers my moms side. I look very Jewish. I’ve been insecure of my skin, hair and eyes. I hate how people can tell that I’m Jewish. But this broke me down into tears. Thank you.
This is my first comment in like 10 years. You should be proud. Not insecure because you have ‘Jewish characteristics’.. Own up to your nose and olive skin and learn about your roots. Love yourself and move to a better future
That was such a beautiful speech with passion. Applicable today tomorrow and for ever until change comes.
G-d bless Israel, G-d bless the Israeli people and G-d bless the Jewish peoples in Israel and world wide. Amen.
brought me to tears
Lets take a glimpse at how misguided the content of this speech is: The laws that guarantee humane treatment of laborers including paid benefits and holidays are clearly out-lined in Jewish law where as on Shabbos, we are not even allowed make our animals work, let alone our non-Jewish slaves (whom we are not allowed to free so what was he saying about Judaism being against slavery?) and on the 7th year we are not allowed to make our land work (yes, you heard that right, our rocks and trees have to keep Shabbos). Judaism is not against slavery, Please explain to me what does 'ama ha'ivria' means? Its a little Jewish girl that is legally sold to slavery by her father for no crime of her own, only because her father is poor. It would be more accurate to say that Judaism has such a deep respect for human life that if the world would follow Judaism then slavery would NOT have to be abolished because the laws of slavery, in Judaism, guarantee certain basic rights to all slaves, that most American citizens do not enjoy. Where would America be today if slave masters had treated their slaves differently? Why can't slaves have schools? Why can't slaves have comfortable lives? Most legal, paid jobs satisfy the Jewish definition of slavery. That is why I wrote and delivered a lecture on the legality of 'working' a salaried position as an observant Jew in one of the oldest and most respected Yeshivos in the world (its fine btw, we are allowed to work - maybe). I could likewise prove to you that Judaism is ideologically sexist and racist followed by proving you that Judaism requires utmost respect for the same people that it discriminates against. I could just as easily prove to you that Nazi Fascism is the only way to describe what the Jews did to conquer the land of Israel - we literally exterminated 7 nations, and by the same token, that in that same ideology lies the greatest care and concern for peace and mutual prosperity. I consider my self to be a non Zionist Jew bordering on anti-Zionist (though some would opine that I am extremely Zionist) and my respect for Judaism is absolute, but to conflate things that some misguided secular Jews have done with totally misunderstood artifacts of Judaism, i.e. Freund vs. resting on the 7th day, is absolute ignorance beyond proportion in my mind.
@@elishahabinsky5654 You should probably see when this amazing speech was said. He made this speech in 1976, this is before Sheikh Jarrah and all the Intifadas. It doesn't matter that some parts are inaccurate, the message he gave about the struggles of the Jewish people is true.
Elisha Habinsky you lack the basic understanding of the Torah and the laws of Judaism. Clearly your are familiar with English translations which are erroneous and incomplete. Please take your hatred elsewhere, maybe one day you will be lucky enough to meet an actual jew who can help you understand. Wow, what a person you are filled with so much anger and resentment that you could here those words he spoke and reply with such hate. Must be a terrible weight on your soul.
What a tragedy that he died so young. His powerful poem ought to become very widely known and will speak to all generations.
ce discours m'a donné des frissons!! Merci d'avoir partager 🙏🏼🇫🇷🇮🇱
Are u even human, why do you support innocent killing
@@bibinthomas5282 We don't support Hamas here.
@@bibinthomas5282 Not a single Israeli supports killing innocent people.
@@Galasholet
so why don’t you speak up against the IDF?
@@user-db7dg9vc9z war always has civilian casualties, only this war is being published all over social media in the effort to destroy Israel. The same would have accrued in Iraq, Syria, Vietnam, Yemen, ect against the Americans... It doesn't make it right but the IDF are just doing their job in trying to destroy Hamas despite their cruel tactics of using human shields.
So much resentment & jealousy for so many contributions.
Wow. That is a decolonised Judean. May our nation long live.
Decolonized when hw call for colonization?
@@Whatever4867 dude you cant colonise land youre indigenous to... and to clarify. Palestinians are also indigenous to the land. We should live together. But regardless Israel/Palestine/Judea&Samaria however you wish to adress the land is also the land of the Jewish people.
@Pull out The lapel no most likely my parents were born in fucking Yemen. Because thats where theyre from.
@Pull out The lapel 75% of us are mizrahi or sephardi my guy 😂
@@dmitryaleskivic3378 🤣🤣🤣
Wow! Great speech pouring out his emotions Right from his heart. Very touching.
Wow; so deep and true. Thank you Rudy .עם ישראל חי .!
Lets take a glimpse at how misguided the content of this speech is: The laws that guarantee humane treatment of laborers including paid benefits and holidays are clearly out-lined in Jewish law where as on Shabbos, we are not even allowed make our animals work, let alone our non-Jewish slaves (whom we are not allowed to free so what was he saying about Judaism being against slavery?) and on the 7th year we are not allowed to make our land work (yes, you heard that right, our rocks and trees have to keep Shabbos). Judaism is not against slavery, Please explain to me what does 'ama ha'ivria' means? Its a little Jewish girl that is legally sold to slavery by her father for no crime of her own, only because her father is poor. It would be more accurate to say that Judaism has such a deep respect for human life that if the world would follow Judaism then slavery would NOT have to be abolished because the laws of slavery, in Judaism, guarantee certain basic rights to all slaves, that most American citizens do not enjoy. Where would America be today if slave masters had treated their slaves differently? Why can't slaves have schools? Why can't slaves have comfortable lives? Most legal, paid jobs satisfy the Jewish definition of slavery. That is why I wrote and delivered a lecture on the legality of 'working' a salaried position as an observant Jew in one of the oldest and most respected Yeshivos in the world (its fine btw, we are allowed to work - maybe). I could likewise prove to you that Judaism is ideologically sexist and racist followed by proving you that Judaism requires utmost respect for the same people that it discriminates against. I could just as easily prove to you that Nazi Fascism is the only way to describe what the Jews did to conquer the land of Israel - we literally exterminated 7 nations, and by the same token, that in that same ideology lies the greatest care and concern for peace and mutual prosperity. I consider my self to be a non Zionist Jew bordering on anti-Zionist (though some would opine that I am extremely Zionist) and my respect for Judaism is absolute, but to conflate things that some misguided secular Jews have done with totally misunderstood artifacts of Judaism, i.e. Freund vs. resting on the 7th day, is absolute ignorance beyond proportion in my mind.
The best speech I have ever heard in my life.
MAGNIFICENT....
Dam Rudy, you brought the heat today! That gave me chills. Shalom
Free Phalistine
@@hashir780 rofl free what?
@@mikhaell3524 Innocent children
@@hashir780 check out Rudy Rochman. Your brainwashed kid. Seriously though.
@@hashir780 this is exactly what the IDF is doing...
Wow Rudy. Thanks for sharing. Sums it up exactly as it is.
Rudy, i am weeping/exulting with joy!!!! Chaver, thank you. Baruch HaShem!!!
Wow Rudy, truly shook me to my core. Thank you for sharing such a magnificent speech on the Jews and there long history of struggles that many people don’t know about. May peace be present to everyone who chooses to accept it ❤️🇮🇱
Lets take a glimpse at how misguided the content of this speech is: The laws that guarantee humane treatment of laborers including paid benefits and holidays are clearly out-lined in Jewish law where as on Shabbos, we are not even allowed make our animals work, let alone our non-Jewish slaves (whom we are not allowed to free so what was he saying about Judaism being against slavery?) and on the 7th year we are not allowed to make our land work (yes, you heard that right, our rocks and trees have to keep Shabbos). Judaism is not against slavery, Please explain to me what does 'ama ha'ivria' means? Its a little Jewish girl that is legally sold to slavery by her father for no crime of her own, only because her father is poor. It would be more accurate to say that Judaism has such a deep respect for human life that if the world would follow Judaism then slavery would NOT have to be abolished because the laws of slavery, in Judaism, guarantee certain basic rights to all slaves, that most American citizens do not enjoy. Where would America be today if slave masters had treated their slaves differently? Why can't slaves have schools? Why can't slaves have comfortable lives? Most legal, paid jobs satisfy the Jewish definition of slavery. That is why I wrote and delivered a lecture on the legality of 'working' a salaried position as an observant Jew in one of the oldest and most respected Yeshivos in the world (its fine btw, we are allowed to work - maybe). I could likewise prove to you that Judaism is ideologically sexist and racist followed by proving you that Judaism requires utmost respect for the same people that it discriminates against. I could just as easily prove to you that Nazi Fascism is the only way to describe what the Jews did to conquer the land of Israel - we literally exterminated 7 nations, and by the same token, that in that same ideology lies the greatest care and concern for peace and mutual prosperity. I consider my self to be a non Zionist Jew bordering on anti-Zionist (though some would opine that I am extremely Zionist) and my respect for Judaism is absolute, but to conflate things that some misguided secular Jews have done with totally misunderstood artifacts of Judaism, i.e. Freund vs. resting on the 7th day, is absolute ignorance beyond proportion in my mind.
@@elishahabinsky5654 well said 👍❤️
We are so sorry for what the Jews have been through but that’s not an excuse to oppress the Palestinians. Please don’t do to the Palestinians like what Hitler did to you.
Yeas. Verklempt here to have the breath of fresh air.
@@elishahabinsky5654 so basically Jews don't have slaves and didn't. Only a Jew taking their circumstances for granted wouldn't be a Zionist. G-d is a Zionist - the concept of a Jewish homeland which is the full simplicity of what Zionism is, is right in the Tanakh, and it's specific about location. To oppose that is to tell G-d that you're above and are superior. Mishigas.
I'm not crying, you are!
And ubl will cry
❤ beautiful. Bravo. Please spread this. ❤
אני בן 22, לא ממזמן למדתי כתלמיד תיכון בארץ ישראל. אני צריך הסברים ממערכת החינוך ומכל אחד ואחת מהמורים שלי למה לעזאזל אני רואה את זה בפעם הראשונה היום.
רוב הכסף הולך לבטחון, מערכת החינוך בישראל היא בדיחה.
@@Galasholet מערכת החינוך מקבלת יותר כסף ממערכת הביטחון...
@@yakov95000 טעות בידיך. רוב הכסף שהולך לחינוך מגיע בסוף לחינוך דתי. הכסף שהולך לחינוך ממלכתי/חילוני ולכלל מערכת החינוך בוודאי קטן משמעותית מתקציב הביטחון.
אשכרה... סרטון מחנך שמביא צמרמורת, חובת צפייה. צריך להיות המנון
I shudder at the relevance of this as we speak. Please repost this.
50 ans se sont passées..et rien n'a changé.. toujours d'actualité
Excellent. Tres bien. I come from Wales but Israel will always be my home
This gave me the chills. Thank you Rudy
Just discovered HIM ! HOW POWERFUL ! A KIND OF MODERN PROPHET ! ❤
So powerful and so moving.
Very enlightening and best speech and true.
Christian's God to his people: You are valued and loved ❤ ✝
Jew's God to his people: You are blessed, you are the chosen ones ✨ ✡
Muslim's God to his people: You are more valued as dead 🤦♀🤦♂ ☪
B E A U T I F U L ❤️ I'M C R Y I N G.
My heart can't handle This.
Lost for words.
Wow!!!! That brought tears to my eyes.
תודה רבה רודי על כל התמיכה, הנתינה והעזרה שלך מבחוץ ,אתה מעורר השראה ואני מעריץ אותך על האומץ והעזרה והדאגה לעמך אני מודה לך בשם כל מדינת ישראל ,תבורך מפי אל עליון בבריאות ,אושר ועושר ועוד... שמור על עצמך מכל הרוצחים האנטישמיים בגולה.
Herbert Pagani (1976) - "Pleading for my Land"
The other day I was in the subway and heard two ladies say: "Did you read the news again? These Jews with their stories? What jerks!" It's true. We are jerks. For centuries we've been annoying the world. It's in our nature. What can you do? Abraham with his "One god", Moses with his 10 commandments, Jesus with his other cheek always ready for a second slap, then Freud, Marx, Einstein, all were intruders, revolutionaries, enemies of the order. Why? Because no order, whatever the century, would not satisfy them since they were orders Jews were always excluded from. To call everything in question, to see further, changing the world to change its destiny. Such was the destiny of my ancestors. This is why they were hated by all defenders of established orders. The Right's anti-Semitism blames the Jews for having executed the Bolshevik revolution. It's true, there were many of them in 1917. The left's anti-Semitism blames the Jews for being the giants of Capitalism. It's true, there are many Jewish capitalists. The reason is simple: Religion, culture, and revolutionary ideas on one side, and stocks & banks on the other are the only portable goods, the only property available for those who don't have a country. And now that they have a country, anti-Semitism re-emerges from its ashes. Sorry! From OUR ashes. It's called anti-Zionism. It used to be applied only to individuals, now it's applied to a Nation. Israel has become a ghetto - Jerusalem is Warsaw. Many of today's Nazis besiege us in Arabic and if their crescent is sometimes disguised in a sickle, it's only for better trapping the liberal leftists of the world. I, who am a Jew of the Left, I reject a Left that only cares about the liberation of some at the expense of others because I am precise of those others. I support class struggles, but I also support the right to be different. If the Left wants to count me with its members, it cannot exclude my problems. And my problem is simple. My problem exists since the Roman deportations of the 1st century after Jesus Christ. Everywhere we went we were expelled, dishonored, banished, tracked, denounced, crushed, burned and converted by force. Why? Because our religion, our culture, was dangerous. It was an example for democracy. Some examples? Judaism was the first to create the Sabbath, the day of the weekly mandatory rest. You imagine the joy of the Pharaohs, always late in building the next pyramid. Judaism prohibits slavery. You can imagine the sympathy of the Romans, antiquity's most significant wholesalers of free labor. It is said in the Bible: "Earth does not belong to man, but to God". From this a law was created, the automatic return of real-estate every 49 years. Every 49 years... You can imagine the effect of such a law on the Popes of the Middle Ages and the builders of empires during the Renaissance. It was imperative that the people not learn the truth. They started by banishing the Bible. Then there were libels. Walls of defamation that became the walls of defamation that became the walls of ghettos. Then the Inquisition, the flames, and later the yellow stars. Auschwitz is only an industrial example of genocide, but there were thousands of genocides. It would take me three days only to name all the pogroms of Spain, Russia, Poland & North Africa. Due to continuously having to flee and move, the Jew went everywhere. One extrapolates: Jews are from nowhere. I am effectively from nowhere. We are among the people like a child on welfare. I don't want to be adopted anymore. I no longer want my life to depend on the mood of my landlords. I no longer want to be a "citizen-rentner" I've had enough of knocking at History's doors and waiting until I'm told to "enter". I'm entering and I shout! I am at home on Earth and on Earth I have my Land. It has been promised to me, and this promise will be kept. What is Zionism? It can be reduced to a simple sentence: "Next year in Jerusalem." No, it's not the slogan from Club Med. It's written in the Bible. The best-selling and the most wrongly read book in the world. And this prayer became a roar, a roar that is over 2,000-years-old. And the fathers of Columbus, Kafka, Proust, Chagall, Marx, Einstein, and even Mr. Kissinger, repeated this roar, at least once a year, on Passover. Then, is Zionism equal to racism? Don't make me laugh! Is "Sweet France, dear country of my childhood" a racist anthem? Zionism is the name of a struggle for freedom! In the world, everybody had their Jews. The French have theirs: They are the Breton, Occitans, and the immigrant workers. The Italians have Sicilians; Americans have their Blacks; the Spanish their Basques. We? We are EVERYONE'S Jews. To those that tell me: "And the Palestinians?", I answer: "I am a 2.000-year-old Palestinian. I am the oldest oppressed man in the world." Oppressed and often suppressed. I will negotiate with them, but I will not yield my place. And the political options of a government never called into question the existence of a Nation. Then why Israel? When Israeli will be out of danger I will choose among Jews and my Arab neighbors, those who are my brothers of ideas. Today, I must be united with my People, even those whom I hate. In the name of this insurmountable enemy: Racism. Descartes was wrong: "I think, therefore I am" doesn't mean anything. We have been thinking for 5000 years, and we still don't exist. I defend myself, therefore I am!
Thank you for the translation.
Wow. C'est tellement fort... Merci pour cette vidéo et merci à Herbert Pagani pour ce discours magnifique.
All I can say is Wow!. Thank you Rudy for sharing this.
That touched my heart and my mind god bless and save and guide israel into peace, i hope people someday will understand that the jews will not abandone their ancestors land ever never ever.
Nor will the indigenous palestinians. So prepare for another 100 year war.
@@anjsmith8459 indigenous to Lebanon, Syria etc..
@@Oblivic And Palestine. What’s your point?
@@remembertotakeshowerspleas355they are arabs😂
אני גר בשדרות שמעתי את זה תוך כדי אזקעה זה ממש חיזק אותי תודה לך רודי
May we all feel shame for the treatment of our Jewish 'neighbours'. They have given the world so much and received abuse in return. They're a vibrant, intelligent people who should be shown compassion and respect. Let them be. Israel is theirs and they've more than earned it over centuries of sufferance.
This is what you call an amazing speech.
AM ISRAEL CHAI!
All I can say is wow...so beautiful and true
Maybe the BBC or Sky News could consider to play this in their next coverage on Israel? Ha.. as if.
Jews are so special in every way!!!! Everything you do or say is so unique. You are a chosen people of God to reach out to the world with all the special gifts and talents God has blessed you with. But your enemies want to supress you from reaching out and being a blessing to the whole world.
If i was born as a jew but I'm an atheist, am I still chosen?
@@roei89 Yes, Roee. You belong to the chosen race of God. Therefore you are very special in God's sight. You open your mouth to speak about your living God and you will find your uniqueness that the rest of the world don't have. How special and precious you Jews are to the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob!
@@shanthageorge8254 uhh... Ok.
Peace on both countries 🇮🇱❤️🇵🇸
INDEED 😄😄😄
I am not saying what *should* be, but palestine is not a country.
what does both mean?
there is only one!
@@chaimoberman752 There is only one world, and only one race of humans left upon it.
There used to be more, Neanderthal, Denison, etc. They are all gone now. It's just us. And even our species came very close to extinction several times. Some by our own hand.
You'd think that would mean something to us.
That is would make us all realize how small and precious this world and all of us are.
Yet we have fought over imaginary divisions from the beginning of our species.
You talk about which people have a nation and which do not.. but the nations are based on imaginary lines in the sand that sperate "us" from "them".
Until we learn to look beyond the constructs of our own imaginings, I worry that long term peace will forever be elusive to us all, and that the most vulnerable among us will always face the kinds of oppression so eloquently stated in this video.
We are all citizens of this world. And that includes both Jewish and Palestinian people.
Your mother's GPS coordinates at the time of your birth should not determine your value as a human being. We all know that right now it does. But isn't it past time that it didn't?
It doesn't matter if you are Christian or not, but treating your neighbor like your brother has *always* been good advice.. and we are *all* neighbors.
We are all brothers (and sisters).
We are just too wrapped up in the mindset we are taught from the moment we are born to see beyond it.
When you realize we are all family, then the core of the social rules we have been inventing and reinventing on how to treat people begin to make more sense.
Think of what a family is *supposed* to be like, whether you are from such a family or not.
Would such a family display greed towards one another? No.
Charity makes sense.
Treating one another with kindness makes sense.
Firm but fair and considerate rules make sense in any household.
None of us would deny a hungry son or daughter food, or clothing, or medicine, or a safe place to sleep..
I'm a parent. I can tell you that squabbles will happen whenever you are truly close to one another, but the bond that binds you together goes much deeper than petty arguments so you learn to speak things out and listen..
We hurt when our loved ones hurt, especially if we can't easily fix the problems they face. At least we want to help. At least we try to see people through their hardships, even if they have made dumb choices.
Love has never been blind. The blind mistake it's endurance and gentleness for blindness and frailty. For vulnerability. It isn't. It never has been.
Love *is* our greatest and strongest gift.
We are one family.
So hello there. I hope this day is treating you kindly from your side of the screen.. thank you for reading my rant..
I hope you have the kind of evening of peace and quiet I am intending to have with my husband and kids,.. whether either of our evenings will pan out that way or not xD
@@talalon4098 the people who live there, or were removed from there, should be able to live together in peace though.. in the end, any country's borders are imaginary constructs.. which means the countries themselves are imaginary constructs. I know how well we defend borders and why.. but sometimes I wonder if we as a people wouldn't be better off with a worldwide case of simultaneous amnesia....
This is from 1976 when I was only 3 yo yet it resonates as though no time has passed. Why do I say this? Because my sons do not feel comfortable wearing their kippot publicly after they both experienced incidents involving kids at their school trying to pull it off and/or making anti-semitic remarks. And no this is not happening in my birth country of Iran, a place my family escaped during the Iranian Revolution. This is happening in the heart of Los Angeles. Imagine in the 2020's, in the 'most democratic nation' in the world, and in one of the most diverse cities with a rich Jewish history, having to give a talk to elementary school classes on what a jew is (and isn't) and what a kippa is. (My kids were in Jewish Day School previously but we moved them to public school to give them greater exposure to what is out there, and they sure got it. As a result of what they experienced, we started giving talks at their public school every year during Hannukah (historical discussion--the kids learn the dreidel game and they all get a dreidel).
Brings us a lot of hope, thank you for posting
Please post this everywhere!! Amazing.
His speech is very moving. It must be shared as much as possible
This is amazing
Lets take a glimpse at how misguided the content of this speech is: The laws that guarantee humane treatment of laborers including paid benefits and holidays are clearly out-lined in Jewish law where as on Shabbos, we are not even allowed make our animals work, let alone our non-Jewish slaves (whom we are not allowed to free so what was he saying about Judaism being against slavery?) and on the 7th year we are not allowed to make our land work (yes, you heard that right, our rocks and trees have to keep Shabbos). Judaism is not against slavery, Please explain to me what does 'ama ha'ivria' means? Its a little Jewish girl that is legally sold to slavery by her father for no crime of her own, only because her father is poor. It would be more accurate to say that Judaism has such a deep respect for human life that if the world would follow Judaism then slavery would NOT have to be abolished because the laws of slavery, in Judaism, guarantee certain basic rights to all slaves, that most American citizens do not enjoy. Where would America be today if slave masters had treated their slaves differently? Why can't slaves have schools? Why can't slaves have comfortable lives? Most legal, paid jobs satisfy the Jewish definition of slavery. That is why I wrote and delivered a lecture on the legality of 'working' a salaried position as an observant Jew in one of the oldest and most respected Yeshivos in the world (its fine btw, we are allowed to work - maybe). I could likewise prove to you that Judaism is ideologically sexist and racist followed by proving you that Judaism requires utmost respect for the same people that it discriminates against. I could just as easily prove to you that Nazi Fascism is the only way to describe what the Jews did to conquer the land of Israel - we literally exterminated 7 nations, and by the same token, that in that same ideology lies the greatest care and concern for peace and mutual prosperity. I consider my self to be a non Zionist Jew bordering on anti-Zionist (though some would opine that I am extremely Zionist) and my respect for Judaism is absolute, but to conflate things that some misguided secular Jews have done with totally misunderstood artifacts of Judaism, i.e. Freund vs. resting on the 7th day, is absolute ignorance beyond proportion in my mind.
Love to Israel & all the jews around the world from india 🇮🇱❤🇮🇳
We too only have one country for us hindus. Our motherland that was torn apart for centuries. Too much blood has been spilled of our ancestors to protect the land from invasion & colonialism. But we'll be ready to spill even more to protect it now. Seeing this fierce, unbending, unyielding, undefying nationalism & love for your god makes me feel proud to be who i am. And glad to know, there are millions of people who would do the same for their people, their religion & their nation built on blood, sweat, tears & wits. A nation rebuilt from scratch.
Shalom to my jewish brothers & sisters. May peace be with jerusalem. 🙏❤
This is one of the most incredible things I’ve ever heard in my life
The moving voice sways the soul
Wow Rudy, thank you so much for sharing. He has such pathos, it's mesmerizing
Wow, I'm in awe.
Took my breath away.
Proud to be a zionist, Proud to be a Jew 🇮🇱🙏
Heart wrenching and so powerful... made me tearful... thank you for sharing...love from India and prayers for 🇮🇱and all God's precious people
Thanks for sharing Rudy....Long live Israel.
What a great speech!
Praise the peaceful around the world .. 🇮🇱🇬🇧🇺🇸🇩🇪🇮🇳 England and India ,Have worked together for years now in Industry & in Union of each other . I stand by Israel 🇬🇧🇮🇱🇮🇳❤
this guy is right in so many ways that it will take me 3 days to just say them all
It’s so powerful to watch it in those days !!!! Glad it just popped up on my feed 🙏
We Hindus support Jews!
Tears! why are these truths so painful and yet so meaningful. Will humanity never learn?
Magnificent! Powerful! Am Yisrael chai!
Awesome speech!!! We have to let world know 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Ani maskeem.
God bless Israel love from italy to all the jews in the world. Beautiful words.
Let's share it in all the platforms.
I've got goosebumps💥
So beautiful!
We won't stand down!
This is more important now than ever.
Jews were given the mission to be a light for the nations, all the corners of all the nations, and to stand apart.
Rather than hebrew subtitles. This video would have been more popular if it had Arabic subtitles.
This!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You might be right actually. I never thought of that.
I think English is somewhat of a universal language
ruclips.net/video/QXMG1tyJ-Uk/видео.html
Hey, if you can do it, add them! 😃
THANK YOU for this! Especially now!!!
Wow, that Bob Ross can flow!
45 years.. they are still defending
Very powerful
thank you for posting
100% agree!
WOW! so powerful! very important to remember this at these hostile times.
YES INDEED PROUD OF OUR INDIA that never discriminated or ostracised or oppressed the Jews who came in the 1st Century and stayed a free people always -!except for one instance the Arab sailors came visiting India and had a horrible fight wlth the Jews settled here and our local Hindu King rose to defend them . The 2000 yrs of no Anti Semitism is the one and only uniqe instance in history .
Incredibly accurate and overlooked sadly.
OMG...amazing in its breadth and ability to knit together the entire picture!
Different types of books and even religious books belonging to different religions can testify to Israel. Israel has always been there and will always be there. Think of it this way, that my parents' parents who did not go to school never thought that Israel was re-created in 1948, but they thought it had always been there. This is exactly the truth, facts, no fantasy or propaganda.
You stole the land from someone before even you lol better hope they don't come and claim it
@@oneillcfc7921 who from the cnanites?
they stole it from shem who is the great great grandfather of avraham.
what other state had a capital in israel?
Lets take a glimpse at how misguided the content of this speech is: The laws that guarantee humane treatment of laborers including paid benefits and holidays are clearly out-lined in Jewish law where as on Shabbos, we are not even allowed make our animals work, let alone our non-Jewish slaves (whom we are not allowed to free so what was he saying about Judaism being against slavery?) and on the 7th year we are not allowed to make our land work (yes, you heard that right, our rocks and trees have to keep Shabbos). Judaism is not against slavery, Please explain to me what does 'ama ha'ivria' means? Its a little Jewish girl that is legally sold to slavery by her father for no crime of her own, only because her father is poor. It would be more accurate to say that Judaism has such a deep respect for human life that if the world would follow Judaism then slavery would NOT have to be abolished because the laws of slavery, in Judaism, guarantee certain basic rights to all slaves, that most American citizens do not enjoy. Where would America be today if slave masters had treated their slaves differently? Why can't slaves have schools? Why can't slaves have comfortable lives? Most legal, paid jobs satisfy the Jewish definition of slavery. That is why I wrote and delivered a lecture on the legality of 'working' a salaried position as an observant Jew in one of the oldest and most respected Yeshivos in the world (its fine btw, we are allowed to work - maybe). I could likewise prove to you that Judaism is ideologically sexist and racist followed by proving you that Judaism requires utmost respect for the same people that it discriminates against. I could just as easily prove to you that Nazi Fascism is the only way to describe what the Jews did to conquer the land of Israel - we literally exterminated 7 nations, and by the same token, that in that same ideology lies the greatest care and concern for peace and mutual prosperity. I consider my self to be a non Zionist Jew bordering on anti-Zionist (though some would opine that I am extremely Zionist) and my respect for Judaism is absolute, but to conflate things that some misguided secular Jews have done with totally misunderstood artifacts of Judaism, i.e. Freund vs. resting on the 7th day, is absolute ignorance beyond proportion in my mind.
Love this. Thanks for what you do Rudy.