When people are raised with the idea that they are superior because they are born in a certain religion then there's no scope for improvement or self reflection
_India Implemented CAA saying that minority were persecuted in Pak. Hence, persecuted people will be given Indian citizenship._ _Pak officially condemned it saying that CAA excludes Momins._ _Lol, India is accusing you of persecuting the minority. Instead of refuting it. You're trying to say that 'people not only from minority but even people from majority are persecuted in Pak.' 😂Hence, India should not exclude them_ 😂 O bhai, jra akal to haath maaro.😂
The lies about history were told in both countries. There was no India before the British and no Hindusthan before Ghouri. The Kingdoms from Northwest ( current Pakistan) like Maurya, Kushan, Porus, have never heard of Bharat, Hindusthna, , India or Hindu. They always attacked and massacred ganga jamuna ( current India). Mauryans alone killed 30 million Ganga jamnis and destroyed their Gods. Northwest ( current Pakistan) has always had trade and cultural ties with Central Asia and attacks towards Ganga jamuna (current India minus Chinese Burmese Tibet states of so called " northeast India" created by British). Islam was accepted in these regions due to trade ties and mix marriages. Dozens of nations in Northwest and the rest of today's India supported then and some fought against them. South Asia is not a country like Europe. Ask south Indians, they hate Indus valley and its Kings. South Indians didn't want to call them " hindus" ppl of Indus Sindh ( Pakistan) until Indra Gandhi bombed them twice. India, Indoo Hindus don't exist on the east of Indus valley. U are gangudeshi.
*_Nahi Hoga Bhai. Pak Ki Society Change Nhi Honi Itni Jaldi. Itne Double Standards, Itni Bigotry._* *_I Even Listen To Highly Educated People In Pak. They Seems To Driven By Some Ideology. Instead Of Talking Rational, They Willingly Resort To Their Biases._*
Pakistan me discuss hota hai humme zazba hai hum atomi takat hai nation first nahi religion first hai baki religion wale nichale darze ke hai hum pakistani to jannati hai 😅😅
Also greek mathematican Erathosthenes was the first person to discover earths circumference. Also quadratic equations were Euclid, Diophantus, and Archimedes. Most of islamic golden age was just Arabs translating greek, chinese and hindu philosophy, science and concepts. Like the whole arabic number system and algebra was taken from india and aryabatas works. Damascus steel was from tamil nadu etc.
Arabs didn't say it was their own teachings. To translate things you need knowledge depth and curiosity. They translated but also refine and refuted ideologies
Because In pakistan we cant say that we need a secular country straight forward . if we say . we have to answer we are muslim or not? If muslim then why want secular state. If not muslim then why left islam. If we answer why left islam. We will be persecute by the state..
Host of this show may wish to flaunt his historical ignorance but ought to be done at his own expense. He doesn’t have to go very far like the United States. All he has to do is to take a look at India. Pakistan as a nation-state is a failed state for two simple reasons. It failed to develop political institutions. It also failed to develop a dynamic economic sector. How much this failure owes to a static Islam or the sheer incompetency of Muslims remains an open question? Indian Union and American Union offer two great examples to the DIM, DULL and the DUFFERS.
Enjoying the discussion. Intend to listen all the way, although in chunks. For, Pakistani people Nehru is the reference. Indians believe Sardar Patel or Maulana Azad or others from a plethora of leaders would have done a better job.
Ibn Sina wrote the Canon of Medicine and roughly a hundred years later, Khilji burned down the University of Nalanda and with that a treasure trove of knowledge. Someone has to pay for the consequences of karma. That's why you guys are hooked up on just 'one' book, and everything else is oblivious to people of your ilk. Embrace STEM instead of fiction and keep your religion to the confines of the walls of your house and then only progress can be made.
پاکستان بننے کی وجوھات متحدہ خطہ میں مسلمانوں کی معاشی صورت حال اور تہزیب تھا ۔علمی نہں الحمدللہ تقسیم کے بعد ھم اس قابل ھوے دونوں طرف علم بارے سوچا جاتا ھے اب مسلمانوں نے بیدار ھوکر داٸیں باٸیں سوچنا شروع کردیا ھے شکریہ قاٸد
Karachi is port city so the people are hard working. SAME as Mumbai Chennai Surat Kochi Kolkata and so on. India developed when interiors started to develop. Like Bangalore Pune Noida Indore etc. Pakistan needs to develop its interiors.
Allama Iqbal did his PhD from Germany. Did he take many of his ideas from Neitzhe? Some Iqbal's concept of Mard-e-Momin is highly influenced by Nietzsche's Superman
1946 pakistan banega 1947 pakistan zindabad 1970 operation searchlight 1971 bangladesh zindabad 2024 taliban ttp mission sharia 2025 khybar Pakhtunkhwa zindabad 2029 baloch liberation army 2030 balochistan zindabad 2034 sindh separatist movement 2035 sindhudesh zindabad 2040 (punjabis)ek tha pakistan 2050 (punjabis)kab tha pakistan 2100 kon tha pakistan lee jinnah did i create 5 countries or 1 whatever being jinnah i created jihaist factory in the world
Bro on the topic of what is a quam. You know germany before 1800s was never a single country. The Bavarians had a different culture and language from the Flanders or from north rhine-westphila. Each province of germany was a princely state with barons or zameendar who had their own culture, military, measuring units etc. Otto von Bismarck United germany stating people of the Rhine river or germans have more in common than they don't especially with their neighbors. They may not speak exactly the same language but its all from the same language tree. Theyre consider one country and quam today though east and west germay existed in 1989. Even people of shanghai, tibet, ugyurs, xianjins are different people than eastern Han Chinese. Or Iranians have azeris, tajiks, paktoon, balochs so aren't they irani? A quam can be created as all quam are created.
The state has taken reading habits and asking questions ability from its ppl coz Pakistan's creation has some very dirty secrets hidden in it. The state does not want Pakistani ppl to know that
It would have been useful if you had the Federal Minister of Education or the Education Secretary in your meeting. Failing it, this discussion is fruitless since everyone knows the problem.
The idea that we get impressed by repeating names is for salesmen. Even the guest says that he learnt this in MBA. This is something the MBA teaches his salespeople so they can sell his product. That is not the case for personal relationships. People (especially individuals with high intellect) look at the substance of the conversation rather than the way information is conveyed.
Bhai values mayne rakhi thi.... Padhe likhe log to baki duniya se bhi haiN, West se jyada padha likha kaun hi hoga but CEOs Indian bn rhe, koi to reason hoga 😊
Last time jab dhruv rathee ne moon bifurcation ko metaphor bola tha tab saare islamic scholar ne bahut bhala bura kaha tha dhurv ko. Let's see iska kya hota hai lets see 🙈
Even though Shahrukh tries to come across as a modern-thinking Pakistani, we can easily figure out the lingering Islamist in him. It's very evident in his allegory statement about the Quran. If you are given a set of rules to live by wouldn't it be better if it is direct and simple so that the majority of common people can understand it rather than allegorical and open to interpretation for a minority of scholars? The reason why there is so much animosity towards Islam is because each mullah interprets it according to his own convenience. After listening to the podcast I'm sure Shahruk is on the right path regarding his career. He will be a good politician because he'll be able to talk truth to power and religion to the masses.
1:09:00 how prejudice hinder our understanding and how as a muslim if u would read indian philosophies that does not belive in " the god " but still are revered in hindu thought i.e which is pluralistic as u uys look into us ??
Alama Iqbal was a confused fellow and so is his book reconstruction of religious thought in islam. Shahrukh admits that it took him four years to understand it, therefore, what sort of book this is. I think, in the end , the guest speaker has succumbed to public pressure. All the recommended books are worth reading, to my mind. except the last one.
Kitne bhi rational ho shahrukh bhai lekin islam par aakar rationality ka balloon phoot jaata h, qur*n k jaisi pathetic aur illogical and evil book maine aaj tak nhi dekhi. Aur haan apne ye so called "metaphors" wali theory lekar kabhi exmuslis k youtube channels ki live stream mein aao phir dekhte h
dammn how i ended up the otherside of our border ............47:30 i dont want to be disrespectful but indians had discovered quadratic equation in 4 th century and the number system was taken from indian numerals thats why when later it was discovered ....they europeans termed our modern numbers as hindu Arabic numerals and not only arabic numerals .
55:45 is allah giving humans deep hidden and profound meaning by stating 4 marriages ? Dont u think its not allah but in ur relegious conotation its ur messenger how he percieved the reality and described to the arab cult the way they could understand by addressing social reality.
When people are raised with the idea that they are superior because they are born in a certain religion then there's no scope for improvement or self reflection
You just described Muslims
Truth
@@rohitghildiyal8643yes and now many Hindus are beginning to be the same.
@@nitishsaxena1372 because of chuslims themselves and people like you librandus
@@nitishsaxena1372because of chuslims reality and librandus like you
_India Implemented CAA saying that minority were persecuted in Pak. Hence, persecuted people will be given Indian citizenship._
_Pak officially condemned it saying that CAA excludes Momins._
_Lol, India is accusing you of persecuting the minority. Instead of refuting it. You're trying to say that 'people not only from minority but even people from majority are persecuted in Pak.' 😂Hence, India should not exclude them_ 😂
O bhai, jra akal to haath maaro.😂
Good point 😂😂😂
Muslims ko bhi India Mai hi aana hai toh Pakistan banane ka point kya fir, phir to akhand Bharat bana do wapas
The lies about history were told in both countries. There was no India before the British and no Hindusthan before Ghouri. The Kingdoms from Northwest ( current Pakistan) like Maurya, Kushan, Porus, have never heard of Bharat, Hindusthna, , India or Hindu. They always attacked and massacred ganga jamuna ( current India). Mauryans alone killed 30 million Ganga jamnis and destroyed their Gods. Northwest ( current Pakistan) has always had trade and cultural ties with Central Asia and attacks towards Ganga jamuna (current India minus Chinese Burmese Tibet states of so called " northeast India" created by British). Islam was accepted in these regions due to trade ties and mix marriages. Dozens of nations in Northwest and the rest of today's India supported then and some fought against them. South Asia is not a country like Europe. Ask south Indians, they hate Indus valley and its Kings. South Indians didn't want to call them " hindus" ppl of Indus Sindh ( Pakistan) until Indra Gandhi bombed them twice. India, Indoo Hindus don't exist on the east of Indus valley. U are gangudeshi.
Pakistanis ke dimag ko salaam 😂😂
@@mpqw 🤣
*_Nahi Hoga Bhai. Pak Ki Society Change Nhi Honi Itni Jaldi. Itne Double Standards, Itni Bigotry._*
*_I Even Listen To Highly Educated People In Pak. They Seems To Driven By Some Ideology. Instead Of Talking Rational, They Willingly Resort To Their Biases._*
Jb tk ye kuran or islam se picha nhi chudate tbtk kuch bhi nhi badlega .
That standard applies on most of Indian momins as well
Nalanda University ko kisne jalaya Ye bhi bata dijiye
Pakistan me discuss hota hai humme zazba hai hum atomi takat hai nation first nahi religion first hai baki religion wale nichale darze ke hai hum pakistani to jannati hai 😅😅
imran is looks like bollywood actor miyang cheng 😊😊😊
Duffers posing as "intellectuals" with big arm mics in a mad rat race of podcasts. Pedestrian knowledge. Lofty jargons.
Also greek mathematican Erathosthenes was the first person to discover earths circumference. Also quadratic equations were Euclid, Diophantus, and Archimedes.
Most of islamic golden age was just Arabs translating greek, chinese and hindu philosophy, science and concepts.
Like the whole arabic number system and algebra was taken from india and aryabatas works. Damascus steel was from tamil nadu etc.
Arabs didn't say it was their own teachings. To translate things you need knowledge depth and curiosity. They translated but also refine and refuted ideologies
@@adnaanhaidar1 yea you needed knowledge and dept to create these concept as well. Which is what these civilization was originally doing.
Pakistan mai tho darwin theory of evolution padane par Teacher ko sorry bolna padtha hai 😓
Aik case aya hai aur shoor much gia. Theory of evolution har school har province main prhai jari ha
Because In pakistan we cant say that we need a secular country straight forward . if we say . we have to answer we are muslim or not? If muslim then why want secular state. If not muslim then why left islam. If we answer why left islam. We will be persecute by the state..
Host of this show may wish to flaunt his historical ignorance but ought to be done at his own expense. He doesn’t have to go very far like the United States. All he has to do is to take a look at India. Pakistan as a nation-state is a failed state for two simple reasons. It failed to develop political institutions. It also failed to develop a dynamic economic sector. How much this failure owes to a static Islam or the sheer incompetency of Muslims remains an open question? Indian Union and American Union offer two great examples to the DIM, DULL and the DUFFERS.
Coz Pakistan was made by duffers and run by duffers also
We have a substandard education system coz our education is not the state's priority.
We dont read coz of our substandard education.
Islam or kuran ka sahara mt lijiye varna doob jaoge .
Enjoying the discussion. Intend to listen all the way, although in chunks.
For, Pakistani people Nehru is the reference. Indians believe Sardar Patel or Maulana Azad or others from a plethora of leaders would have done a better job.
I am half expecting someone to shout out "Oye butcher of Gujarat".😂😂😂 The resemblance is uncanny.
Ibn Sina wrote the Canon of Medicine and roughly a hundred years later, Khilji burned down the University of Nalanda and with that a treasure trove of knowledge. Someone has to pay for the consequences of karma. That's why you guys are hooked up on just 'one' book, and everything else is oblivious to people of your ilk. Embrace STEM instead of fiction and keep your religion to the confines of the walls of your house and then only progress can be made.
I'm from India 🇮🇳, I have already studied 6 books out of 10. There are 2 books is still pending for reading... Great conversation 👍👍
Books, readings.... It's all nonsense ... Pakistanis must keep the objective of creation of Pakistan.... To do Ghazwa e hind... and go to jannat.
First learn how to pronounce "Nietzsche", not "Neecha" .... and you still wonder why Pakistan is not progressing like India ..... 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
18:40 India got the lead because are faithful to their land, and they followed their own culture instead of being slaves of arabs.
Kamal ka podcast tha dosto, keep it up 👍🏻I'm big fan of Northern podcast from India
پاکستان بننے کی وجوھات متحدہ خطہ میں مسلمانوں کی معاشی صورت حال اور تہزیب تھا ۔علمی نہں الحمدللہ تقسیم کے بعد ھم اس قابل ھوے دونوں طرف علم بارے سوچا جاتا ھے اب مسلمانوں نے بیدار ھوکر داٸیں باٸیں سوچنا شروع کردیا ھے شکریہ قاٸد
Even their so called educated class is so opposed with their islam thing seriously.. Pakistani society can't be helped...
Thank u for calling us BALOCH, most of the people call us 'Balochi' which is irritating
Karachi is port city so the people are hard working. SAME as Mumbai Chennai Surat Kochi Kolkata and so on.
India developed when interiors started to develop. Like Bangalore Pune Noida Indore etc.
Pakistan needs to develop its interiors.
good discussion
Pakistan people here to watching this golden podcast 🎉
Hosting is not just asking questions. Host ko bhe thori study kar leni chaheye.😂
Book buddy ❤
You should ban the word Inshallah
Whoever uses the word, should be fined Rs 1,000
Then you can grow
India has a history of thousands of years; whereas, Pakistan has no history. I don't agree with Shahrukh on the issue of identity. I agree with Imran.
Lagta he Ramzan me hie nacha kia howa he tu ne.
Indian history is Pakistani history. Almost 2 out of 3 oldest civilizations exist in Pakistan not India. Lets not forget that
😂@@omer19951
@@omer19951 nothing should be said to you by anyone 😂.
سیدھا سیدھا فرید نیچا کہہ دیں😅
Allama Iqbal did his PhD from Germany. Did he take many of his ideas from Neitzhe? Some Iqbal's concept of Mard-e-Momin is highly influenced by Nietzsche's Superman
Iqbal was more inspired by Goethe.
Host ko kuch nhi pata 😂
1946 pakistan banega
1947 pakistan zindabad
1970 operation searchlight
1971 bangladesh zindabad
2024 taliban ttp mission sharia
2025 khybar Pakhtunkhwa zindabad
2029 baloch liberation army
2030 balochistan zindabad
2034 sindh separatist movement
2035 sindhudesh zindabad
2040 (punjabis)ek tha pakistan
2050 (punjabis)kab tha pakistan
2100 kon tha pakistan
lee jinnah
did i create 5 countries or 1
whatever being jinnah i created jihaist factory in the world
Beta ye sab ultha pad jayega
nahi, tera Mulk kutte ki maut marega@@mohammadfaraz664
The host seems completely blank. He must read all the books recommended by Shahrukh, in the first place.
Bro on the topic of what is a quam.
You know germany before 1800s was never a single country. The Bavarians had a different culture and language from the Flanders or from north rhine-westphila. Each province of germany was a princely state with barons or zameendar who had their own culture, military, measuring units etc.
Otto von Bismarck United germany stating people of the Rhine river or germans have more in common than they don't especially with their neighbors. They may not speak exactly the same language but its all from the same language tree. Theyre consider one country and quam today though east and west germay existed in 1989.
Even people of shanghai, tibet, ugyurs, xianjins are different people than eastern Han Chinese. Or Iranians have azeris, tajiks, paktoon, balochs so aren't they irani? A quam can be created as all quam are created.
The state has taken reading habits and asking questions ability from its ppl coz Pakistan's creation has some very dirty secrets hidden in it. The state does not want Pakistani ppl to know that
It would have been useful if you had the Federal Minister of Education or the Education Secretary in your meeting. Failing it, this discussion is fruitless since everyone knows the problem.
Northern podcast keep it up.... Book buddy is amazing ❤
Great job imran bhai , I realy appreciate u for making podcast with sharukh sir❤❤❤
Such a nice program.. This kind of debate must prevail in the entire country..
The idea that we get impressed by repeating names is for salesmen. Even the guest says that he learnt this in MBA. This is something the MBA teaches his salespeople so they can sell his product.
That is not the case for personal relationships. People (especially individuals with high intellect) look at the substance of the conversation rather than the way information is conveyed.
Bhai values mayne rakhi thi.... Padhe likhe log to baki duniya se bhi haiN, West se jyada padha likha kaun hi hoga but CEOs Indian bn rhe, koi to reason hoga 😊
For Indians constitution is as important as Quran for Muslim.
Last time jab dhruv rathee ne moon bifurcation ko metaphor bola tha tab saare islamic scholar ne bahut bhala bura kaha tha dhurv ko. Let's see iska kya hota hai lets see 🙈
Another set of "2 idiots"
Quran says stars are for decoration - what do you say to that?
Islamophobia
Many non Muslim people now realise that Islamophobia is the right and sensible reaction to Islamic ideology.
Mind it, We are not Arabs. We belong here.
Referring to golden age Islam as 'we'. Thereb goes your intellectual depth! But at least someone is thinking.
Even though Shahrukh tries to come across as a modern-thinking Pakistani, we can easily figure out the lingering Islamist in him. It's very evident in his allegory statement about the Quran. If you are given a set of rules to live by wouldn't it be better if it is direct and simple so that the majority of common people can understand it rather than allegorical and open to interpretation for a minority of scholars? The reason why there is so much animosity towards Islam is because each mullah interprets it according to his own convenience. After listening to the podcast I'm sure Shahruk is on the right path regarding his career. He will be a good politician because he'll be able to talk truth to power and religion to the masses.
Bhae host ko bhe thori study kar leni chaheye 😊
1:09:00 how prejudice hinder our understanding and how as a muslim if u would read indian philosophies that does not belive in " the god " but still are revered in hindu thought i.e which is pluralistic as u uys look into us ??
The guest is brilliant but the host has no idea what to say...he is just anti PTI nothing else...
Imran ap na to political science students ka laya books nahi pochi
Muslims were on the top 😂.
1:06:33 what was so funny to laugh about Sahih Bukhari ?
Have some mercy on yourself please.
First lie is in the name Allah's that's first and last
Alama Iqbal was a confused fellow and so is his book reconstruction of religious thought in islam. Shahrukh admits that it took him four years to understand it, therefore, what sort of book this is. I think, in the end , the guest speaker has succumbed to public pressure. All the recommended books are worth reading, to my mind. except the last one.
U r also in trouble why u satisfied other people please be practical and learn more about ur inner
Inshallah ka matalab hum per bharosa mat karo😅
Look up article 51A(h) in the Indian constitution. It will tell you the entire difference between the foundations of India and Pakistan.
Books ke naam plz comment me muje Leke👇🏻👇🏻👇🏻
Kaali pustak
Beautiful discussion. Very informative.. Great.
Lunda intellectual sharing surface level knowledge, please bring better people as guests not cartoons.
Kitne bhi rational ho shahrukh bhai lekin islam par aakar rationality ka balloon phoot jaata h, qur*n k jaisi pathetic aur illogical and evil book maine aaj tak nhi dekhi. Aur haan apne ye so called "metaphors" wali theory lekar kabhi exmuslis k youtube channels ki live stream mein aao phir dekhte h
Constitution and Pakistan 🤣
dammn how i ended up the otherside of our border ............47:30 i dont want to be disrespectful but indians had discovered quadratic equation in 4 th century and the number system was taken from indian numerals thats why when later it was discovered ....they europeans termed our modern numbers as hindu Arabic numerals and not only arabic numerals .
Why are you attached to the island with education, this is the big error in your country.
55:45 is allah giving humans deep hidden and profound meaning by stating 4 marriages ? Dont u think its not allah but in ur relegious conotation its ur messenger how he percieved the reality and described to the arab cult the way they could understand by addressing social reality.
They know more than us but they can't express their thoughts freely . Pakistan has blasphemy law. pakistani society is extremely radical.
For Muslim from Indian subcontinent Islam is first then country 🤣🤣 but for non Muslim country is first then any anything.
14:40 baghdad is not arab, but mesopotamia. arabs appropriated other's knowledge after attacking them.