Untold Stories of Pakistan's Economy, IMF, and Why Investors Are Afraid?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- Untold Stories of Pakistan's Economy, IMF, and Why Investors Are Afraid? @raftartv Podcast with Ali Khizar, Head of Research, Business Recorder
In this podcast, Business Recorder's Head of Research Ali Khizer discusses the pressing economic challenges facing Pakistan, advocating for structural reforms and emphasizing the need for a strong, decisive government. From the impact of privatization to the complexities of fiscal decentralization, Khizer provides insights into Pakistan's economic landscape and offers pragmatic solutions for sustainable growth.
#pakistan #pakistaneconomycrisis #imfdeal #default #elections2024 #establishment #pakistanarmy #pdmgovt #shehbazsharif #bilawalbhutto #nawazsharif #maryamnawaz #imrankhan #asifalizardari #pakistaneconomycrisis #pakistanelection #pakistandefault #cantonment #dollar #dollarprice #imf #imfloan #privatisation #privatization #pia #pakistanrailways #steelmill #pakistaneconomy #pakistaneconomiccrisis #pakistaneconomycollapse #alikhizar #businessrecorder #imfpakistan
For more amazing content, SUBSCRIBE NOW!
RUclips
/ @raftartv
RUclips
/ @raftarnewsofficial
RUclips
/ @raftarsports
Website:
raftar.com/
Pakistan need independence from its own army...
pakistan needs independence from illiteracy and nepotism
You can't turn madarsaified youth into industrialized, pro-scientific and analytical minds. Can't be done.m
Brother, do the people have the courage/willingness to confront the Omnipotent Army?
@@SulemanAbbas-jp3imthe Root cause of these so called nepo+illiteracy is one and only army .
Real power not قلم power.
Zrraaa socho blke zyda soch🤔
Just wait black vigo is oñ its way
1947 se lekar aj tak economy nazuk dor se he guzar rahi ha ab marne wali ha😂
What nobody wants to talk about foundation of pakistans downfall is its Army. It is the Army which is in power even today and no one wants to admit this. Unless to touch the army no progress can happen in Pakistan.
How wrong u can be? u think muahs would be better if be better were army to leave?
Each Corps Commander has more than 30 orderlies. They have three serving fauzis to take care of one pet dog. Even a Lt Col has more than 12 orderlies to wash clothes, polish shoes and take care of other household jobs.
Every fauzi gets free electricity, free accommodation, free plot according to his rank. The bills for all these is paid by tax payers money.
Pension bill for army is paid from civil budget.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
This men is really truly pakistani
Best program highly informative
Pakistan exists to service the needs of the generals. In return, the generals give them contempt, brutality, corruption and nepotism.
Looking at how Pakistan is being run, who in their right mind would want to invest in Pakistan where the army generals are convinced that Pakistan in their full ownership. Meaning, no has a right to breath without being sanctioned by an army officer. They have the power to shutdown your business without a minute's notice. Pakistan's court are joke, they wait for the generals to write their decisions. They are merely expected to read them in court. That's the reason judges take up to six months to deliver their detailed judgements.
Very China-like characteristics of the army leadership........must get LOTS of inspiration from them........as they say be careful with whom you hang out with.
You guys (Raftar) are very professional and amazing ❤️
Your video quality, editting, shooting are top class 💯 Great job
Your regular viewer from 🇮🇳
Faizan Bhaaaaai aap bhi bohat barhia subscriber ho
❤ @@raftartv
Kindly make detailed video on "RAYMOND DAVIS CASE" caused in Lahore in 2011
Very interesting interview. I wish all the very best for your Country as he Said in the end that in the next two years Some Positive Changes will be visible.
Very informative
بہترین پروگرام ،۔Raftar چینل چند بہترین ڈیجیٹل چینلز میں سے ایک ہے،۔بہترین پروگرام اور بہترین مہمان،۔ایسے شوز کرتے رہا کریں،۔ایسے شوز معاشرے میں بہتری لانے کی بہترین عملی تصویر ہیں،۔
Who ever wants to live a good life than one must remember 1 thing. Pakistan se Bhaag .
Mashallah bahtreen continue on economy
Napak bhoj is the real bojh on Pakistan's economy.
The most logical and methodological program. Mazaa ageya. ❤
thanks bro!
Sir you know better about economy then government
Raftar Read This: Quality of life of an average Indian is 1000times better than an average pakistani
Here's my stats to back it up my claim
-Inflation rate in pakistan 29.7% , In India it's 5.10%
-Unemployment rate in pakistan 8.5% in India it's 6.8%
-Per capita income in pakistan $1400 in India it's $2800
- Indians GDP (nominal) $4.11 trillion
- pakistan GDP (nominal) $340billion
-Let me give you an example;
If an average pakistani spends pakistani rupees equivalent to $1000 and an average Indian spends Indian rupees equivalent to $1000, an average Indian would able to buy 25% more items or groceries etc than an average pakistani ..if they both spend $2000 an average Indian would be able to buy 50% more than an average pakistani
- To fill that gap it takes pakistan at least 30years if we assume it grows it's GDP at the rate of 8.5%, which is impossible looking at it's internal and external debt, lack of industries, lack of infrastructure, lack of skilled labor, poor education system
Conclusion; Come out of your La-La land and smell the coffee 😂
Moreover we Indians are more practical and rational in our approach, an average Indian intellect is way more sophisticated than an average pakistani, our education system is way way better than pakistans academia
yes that is true. India is light years ahead from Pakistan now. But there are some important things we must remember.
1. Pakistan never got independence in 1947.
2. Muslims divided India in 1947. British created Pakistan for its purpose.
3. Pakistanis Establishment is fully controlled by USA.
4. Pakistan is a proxy state of USA.
5. Pakistan was created to destablize the area .
on the other hand INDIA got its independence from British in 1947 and all of its leaders were loyal to its Country,
NEHRU was great leader who made strong institutions in India.
almost every Indian leader comes from Indian peoples not imported.
Nehru was secular in his nature while every pakistani leader was Islamic jihadi type.
India is a diverse country and secular in its nature while Pakistan was created by Religious fundamentalists and now Pakistan is WORST country in the world.
Pakistan is only country in the world which is going backward and even SOMALIA , Iraq . Lybia etc are way much better than pakisan.
Balochistan will be Free independent country...
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Can you Bring Atif Mian, Kaiser Bengali and Some Other Economists on the Show
Also bring some Analysts and Economists who are Experts in South Asia Economy, who can tell us what India did right
Absolute waste of time by watching this podcast because all these progressive thoughts don't fit right with Army Generals period. Change in status quo is death of Pak Army Generals.
Shahbast khushi ho rahi hai
Pakistan me log economy ko sunny lage
Or shour aany laga
Mashallah
Abhi tak ky 7k sunny waly
Apny sth 10 ki soch tabdeel karny ki silahiyat rakhte hn
Umeed nazar aa rahi
Allah abad rakhy ameen
Suggest that we avoid showing clips prior to the discussion… it is just a waste of time
Pakistan ka finance minister and Governor SBP is selected by approved by US saamraaj. Baqi sari reasons bekar han because Beggars are not choosers
Ek he chooran KO le kr ro
ویڈیو بہت اچھی ہیں ۔۔اگر پاکستان کو ترقی کرنی ہے تو سب سے پہلے پانچ ہزار کا نوٹ ختم ہونا چاہے ۔۔
سب سے پہلے ایک شناختی کارڈ پر ایک پلاٹ ایک فلیٹ ایک بنگلہ ایک گاڑی کی پابندی لگائی جانی چاہیے ۔۔
50😊😊
Matlab Demonitization?
Yar itny options hai...har economist hain jo sulotion bata rahy hain....par upper walo ko koi asar nahe hota
Raftar has the own level of podcast ❤
The only problem with same page is that it is same page but different book !
Trade india ne band nahi ki.pakistan ne ki thia..ajj Pakistan india se trade normal karde..Pakistan ko kisi se bhikh nahi mangni padegi..10 saal mai result nazar a jayege....china usa Pakistan ko economic crisis se nahi nikal sakte...ajj Pakistan india se trade kre..india ko central asia se trade karne de thru Pakistan tax le......ek Pakistan ka defense pe paisa bachega..import export sasti hogi..inflation kam hogi..ajj tak dushmni karke dekhli 10saal friendly relationship bna ke dekhlo..baki chote mote pblm ayege unko side pe rakh ne trade kre people to people relation normal kre result salo mai nazar ayege..peace ❤
Excellent analysis by Ali Khizar sb. Hats off to you sir.
There is a huge difference between India and Pakistan Khizerbhai.
Humare Bharat aane ki zarurat ni hai😅
Isne bharat aane ke baat ki hain kya
Isne bharat aane ki baat boli thi kya?
PPP has been presented in Karachi as per 50 to 25 % seats and Hyderabad 98 % seats in Hyderabad and other wise totally seats lying in enterore Sindh.
A very much needed and a comprehensive insight into Pakistan economics, worth spending an hour or so 👏👏👏
ہم بیرون ملک جاکر منتیں کررہے ہیں کہ ہمارے ملک میں کارخانے لگایں اگر ریٹاءرڈ فوجیں کی بھلاءی کے لیے بناءی گئی فاونڈیشن نے اگر کارخانے لگاے تو پیداوار ہوی روزگار ملا اس نے ٹیکس دیے تو بہت اچھا ہے
خداکےلیے منفی نفرتیں نہ پھیلایں ۔ پنجاب میں فنڈز ابادی کی بنیاد سے زیادہ لگاے جارہے ہیں لاہور کی ابادی بھکر سے زیادہ اس لیے لاہور پر زیادہ ہیسے لگتے پھر بھی بھکر کو اس کے حصے سے زیادہ دیا جاتا ہے
حکومتی نااہلی کا لیول یہ ہے کہ ایک سرکاری محکمہ، جو ستر ارب سالانہ خسارے میں ہے، کا ایک سینئیر افیسر جو دس ماہ بعد ریٹائر ہو جائے گا، وہ ابھی بھی دھڑا دھڑ غیر ملکی دورے کر رہا ہے جو سراسر قومی خزانے کا ضیاع ہے۔ لیکن کوئی سوچے تو نا۔
State owned Enterprises
Are over staffed 🎉
1:05:53
Pakistan needs to spend everything it can to educate.
آبادی ڈھائی پرسینٹ کے حساب سے بڑھ رہی ہے اس کم کرنا یا روکنا ہے تو روزگار بڑھانا ہوگا ۔۔ بے روزگاری بڑھنے کے ساتھ ہی بچوں کی پیداوار میں بھی اضافہ ہوتا ہے ۔۔
Every one know what to do but no one want to do it 😂
There were only two regimes when rate of growth was six percent. One is during Bhutto period and the other is during Imran Khan times despite COVID-19🦠😷. The reason is because these were popular leaders and foreign aid came because of popular mandate. One small cycle of growth was during Nawaz Sharif time because funding came with lot of corruption by Army generals and political class combined.
Only way to get out of this mess is to ask army business to compete with civil business. Army will eat away every source of income. The fauz will not allow country to prosper. The generals will make money and buy assets in the West or USA.
Keep dreaming that money borrowed will not be returned. Why you are paying half of your budget as interest on loans. Tell them you can not pay and see the consequences. You will be worse than Sri Lanka because Sri Lanka has a much better educational levels.
You can not reduce Army expenses as they will sell the country to China rather than reduce their luxurious life.
⚡ On brain drain the guest mentioned that from Bangladesh 1.3 million people went abroad in 2023 compared to Pakistan 0.8 million. i think from Bangladesh majority would be labour to middle east however from Pakistan main people moving abroad are educated professionals so their is a difference.
Please make a video on Qudratullah Shahab. Would highly appreciate it
سب سے بڑا نوٹ ہزار کا ہونا چاہے
Unless Pakistan's energy sector issues are resolved, Pakistan's economy will not get better. We are feeding the IPPs on common man, industry and even the government of Pakistan's resources.
لگتا ہے اورنگزیب نے اپنا کوئی دوست بھیج دیا ہے اپنی پبلسٹی کے لیے۔ 😂
Failing companies get high class consultants - Maybe we should find top consultants for good technical advice to close the gaps
The military can reinvent itself with strategic adjustments in line with 21 century kill chains. Ref Chris Brose conceptual framework etc
Defence spending has to be cut by half and savings siphoned to investment in human capital. Strategic adjustments with commercial pacifism and strategic empathy are an imperative 5G plus AI projects that add value
Very simple solution, give up Islam, and you can make progress immediately
Allah Pakistan ki madad farmaye..Ameen
They make sure duffers and corrupt won in these elections, this act can only be done by someone who is more Corrupt and suffer from them..
there is no Allah
Why dont you have a tax on
cash deposits beyound a threshold? demo + 40% tax on cash deposits!
good points. be with China but see that it is winwin for Pakistan and not winwin for PakArmyPolitician and Chinese businesses.
Your narration of pre election expectation appears to be your own and partisan. Every step taken by the establishment, judiciary and the military appears to take away the possibility of having a post election administration confident with a reasonable mandate impossible.
Millon dollars qustion
THAR coal in sindh can give 3 million barrel of Diesel everyday why rulers are not intrested to use THAR coal it means that still we are not an independent state
Abid Ali is that garment exporter ,he has 15 employees in his shop in Lahore!!!!
govt job waly kam na krny ki salary or kam krny ki rishvt lety hen۔ wo samjhty hen govt job sy un k hath mien badmashi ka licence AA gia hy so wo khub badmashi krty hen۔ hamary he Taxes sy salary leny waly hameen he zaleel krty hen۔ ye hy Pakistan system۔
السلام علیکم اپ کے اس پورے پورٹ کاسٹ میں اپ نے کے پی کے اور بلوچستان کے کسی شہر یا علاقے کا نام بالکل نہیں لیا کیا وہ پاکستان نہیں ہے
Consumption, corruption,cult will continue disastrously
نیت صاف ہونی چاہیے۰ جو کہ نہی ہے
⚡ atleast the guest mentioned we are north indian people or their type of people. Ab yeh mulk q bnaya phir agr loag aik jaisy hain.
mujh jese ek aam admi ko bhi pta h k 80 k era k baad se hmne koi development or export enhansing nae ki sirf america se dollar pakray han rental a**y bn k or yehi hmari tabahi ki waja h k wo dollar or qarz sirf hmari establishment ko hi gya h
What positive person and positive video. ALLAH kare kuch esa hojae
please invite dr shahid hasan sidiqui sb for best n complete analysis on pakistani economy
For Karachi people MUST WATCH clip from 27:32. To open their eyes.
Because he wants to divide Sindh , MQM mentality
@@mushtaqsoomro5417
پچھلے 16 سال سے سندھ میں پی پی کی چور حکومت ہے۔ کیا حال کر دیا ہے سندھ اور پورے کراچی کا۔ انتظامی بنیادوں پر سندھ کی تقسیم ہونی چاہیے۔ اسی طرح باپ کا مال سمجھ کر کھاتے رہیں گے چور کے بچے سندھ کو۔ اور سندھ کسی ایک جماعت یا قوم کے باپ کا نہیں ہے۔
@@mushtaqsoomro5417
پیپلا اور وڈیرہ ذہنیت۔۔۔ سندھ کو ایک یونٹ رکھو اور حکومت کر کے باپ کا مال سمجھ کر کھاؤ۔ اس لئے سندھ کی انتظامی بنیادوں پر تقسیم کے خلاف ہیں کہ ان کے حلوے اور حرام خوری بند ہو جائے گی۔😡😡
Ustad Nusrat Fateh Khan Sahab Ke Bare Men Detailed Video Banaen
Youthiya first, Pakistani second.
Unemployment Allowance for everyone,in Muslim Emirates of Pakistan
Then the unemployed people
Shall 🚫 not be over over staffed 🎉 1:09:06
BBis. Is a.partial unemployment Allowance
Pakistan.needs across the board
IPp🎉paid in dollars 💰
Is illogical. Impractical
Loses for 🎉 Economics of Pakistan
Printed out of Pakistan
Dollars 💶 printed in
USA.create our increasing
Debts 🎉
Resource are managed by cutting expenses , elementary
مطلب! پھر میں نہ ہی سمجھو۔۔۔۔😊
Sir BBC urdu news ne latest documentary video upload kari hai shoib khan underworld don karachi us par ak knowledgeable video app bhi bana den please
Unfortunately we are Pakistan
Is bafoq ko bolo rona band kar in jasa logo sa jan choro logo sa kam lo log kam kara jhta ha in jasa logo na hi mulk ka bera garak kiya ha
Ya guest muja Rishi Sunak jasa kyun lag raha ha 😅
Reduce army expenditure 10% every year
Excellent guest….
Vent ? This is already diet! 😮
Ali khizer sir is always awesome
جب تک اس ملک کے معیشت دان بنکنگ سیکٹر سے آتے رہیں گے معیشت روتی رھے گی۔
پاکستان کے بنک آج بھی اربوں روپے کما رھے ہیں۔
کوٸی بینکر اپنا منافع کیوں تباہ کرے گا
Please add sections to your videos
I feel sorry for future generation.
If Electric is Rs 60 / $280 = 21 cent which is not bad , main problem is lack of political stability & Price controls specially Dollar price.
Every house & villages should be forced to go Solar, govt only provide electricity after sunset & to commercial.
Pakistan's problem is lack of strategic depth in all aspects of government. This stems right from their founding father. "Aaj pakistan lena he, kal ka kal dekhenge" was flavour of discourse even then.
Abhi mayoosi aur barey ghi
Khizar bhai k me articles parhta hu BRecorder pe aur mera ek saval hai
a) Agar hamari currency ka value 200 par ajaye to kya hamari GDP short term 400B$+ hojayegi? Kyu k rupees me GDP Pakistan ki 1 lakh Billion rupees hain.
b) is saal ka budget tax collection 9.4 trillion rs hain jisme se large chunk debt servicing me jaata hai. Agar interest rates 15% pe ajaye to next year k budget me humein 4-5 trillion bach jayenge is se kya phir economy growth ki taraf jayegi?
Time stamp lagaya karain
If demand is low due to lowers spending pattern then economy will be shrinking.
Will create pressure on GDP and repayments of debt
Brother jitna m wait krta hn ap ki video ka koi nhi krta ho ga very informative content ❤but ghanti dabanny😅k bawajood bh ap ki videos ap k channel par aa kr dykhni parti han mjh😢😢
Why?
No idea bro .. mjhy har 2_3 din page open kr k kd chek krna parta h updates ka ....
One of the best podcast on state of economic affairs in present day , Mr Ali understands the problems and have precise solutions. He should be made FM or advisor to FM.
Very informative podcast ❤
We will be crushed if don’t generate 15 million world class young people with skills that add value to the nation within the next 10 years
English... please do something about hindi subtitles........
hahahah.......your comment makes me smile......with this jihadiUZ fazadi attitude there is simply no progress possible for Al Baqistan.......and I am NOT even a HIndu.......🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Thoda aur intezar . Waaah Raftaar
Bhai meri ap se hat jor🙏 k Guzarish ha KDA. land department. or on k staff ki Reshwat. pisay. leny k upar bi kuch bat kary bohat kharab ha KDA Ka nezam.
If leash is put on lumber wan then everything will be fixed under next 10 years. Otherwise we are doomed in a year or two.
اس بندے میں اک عدد خفیہ یوتھیا چھپا بیٹھا ہے ۔۔۔
جو صرف اہل نظر ہی دیکھ سکتے ہیں۔
Sir ab textile waley Uber he chalain gay😂 This is the perfect example of their exposure 🤣 😂 😂
Glad to see and hear him, very insightful and enjoyable discussion
Superb briefing