Ser Arthur Dayne Explained ASOIAF LORE

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 фев 2023
  • • Where do Dragons come ...
    learn more about dragons here
    Ser Arthur Dayne Explained in Game of Thrones Explained A Song of Ice and Fire/Game of Thrones/ House of the dragon
    #gameofthrones #houseofthedragon #shortsfeed #fantasy #lore #daemontargaryen #fire #fireandblood #rhaenyratargaryen #asoiaf #got #hotd #winteriscoming #winterfell #north #westeros #thenorthremembers #movie #hbomax #hbo #moviescene #moviescenes #tvseries #tvshow #tv #grimdark #warhammer #warhammer40000 #warhammer40k #stark #starwars #marvel #kitharington #mattsmith #peterdinklage #show #showtv #short #shortfeed #shortsyoutube #shortsfeed #shortsvideo #targaryen
    Backing Track
    BONNIE GRACE
    Last Breath of Freedom
    Artwork in this video is used for commentary and educational purposes. Artwork belongs to HBO/A Song of Ice and Fire book series and other respective owners.
    If you see artwork you have created in this video and would like to be credited, message me via my email lore-ramble@outlook.com with a screenshot and credit link
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 357

  • @billthebanuk6212
    @billthebanuk6212 Год назад +2329

    "I want your sword"
    "Oh believe me, you finna catch it, with your face"

    • @unovasfinest2623
      @unovasfinest2623 Год назад +59

      Ngl i need a hood translation of ASOIAF in full

    • @Langley_Ackerman19
      @Langley_Ackerman19 Год назад +23

      Finna....
      How the hell did the word going to or gonna became finna 🤯

    • @thecockerel86
      @thecockerel86 Год назад +18

      ​@@Langley_Ackerman19 fixing to - finna

    • @thalmoragent9344
      @thalmoragent9344 Год назад +4

      ​@@unovasfinest2623
      Lmao YES 💀

    • @SH19922x
      @SH19922x Год назад

      Black dialect ruins everything.

  • @athiyant2437
    @athiyant2437 Год назад +1389

    Hope they'll make a show of Robert's rebellion

    • @bender2596
      @bender2596 Год назад +33

      They will in hotd they have to show how they’re dynasty ended

    • @rayram4179
      @rayram4179 Год назад +99

      ​@@bender2596 nope HotD is just about the Dance nothing else.

    • @bender2596
      @bender2596 Год назад +13

      @@rayram4179 trippin hotd finna have more seasons then GoT , it’s way more interesting

    • @rayram4179
      @rayram4179 Год назад +25

      @@bender2596 sorry bro i dont understand this. What means trippin ? I am German my englisch sucks

    • @bender2596
      @bender2596 Год назад +23

      @@rayram4179 it means that I don’t agree like “ oh your trippin “ like what you said was crazy . It’s kinda hard to explain

  • @chrisc.2513
    @chrisc.2513 Год назад +369

    I wish that more written material about Ser Arthur Dane was available. Dude seems like that classic hero with awesome skills and great humbleness.

    • @dustinhaas8538
      @dustinhaas8538 8 месяцев назад +18

      That’s the thing, the Prince and knight of most fairy tales were killed 15 years earlier, that’s what makes asoiaf so compelling, or one of the reasons

    • @hugp9134
      @hugp9134 6 месяцев назад

      Bro got shit on

    • @Knightstruth
      @Knightstruth 6 месяцев назад +3

      Definitely my favorite character.

    • @sweetiepeach69
      @sweetiepeach69 16 дней назад

      He's to GoT what Hashirama is to Naruto 😮❤

  • @minatodroger7890
    @minatodroger7890 Год назад +568

    The smiling knight f-ed around and found out

    • @smk3390
      @smk3390 17 дней назад +4

      He wanted to see dawn, the morning came upon him and the smiling knight didn't smile anymore.

  • @JackSpackProductions
    @JackSpackProductions 9 месяцев назад +98

    “It’s your sword I want.”
    “Say no more fam.”

  • @JakeDaDOG37
    @JakeDaDOG37 14 дней назад +11

    "He's better than my father"
    "Much better"

  • @felicitatumfortunae
    @felicitatumfortunae Год назад +1057

    Makes Ned Stark building his reputation on his being stabbed in the back seem a lot less honourable.

    • @trustn01rs
      @trustn01rs Год назад +348

      To be fair that's only shown in the show and it's not in the books

    • @gusadico
      @gusadico Год назад +349

      When you are a quest to save your sister f... chivalry tbh

    • @AndresRamirez77
      @AndresRamirez77 Год назад +234

      It wasnt a tournament, happened in real war, theres no rules of honor in war.

    • @ottovonbismarck7742
      @ottovonbismarck7742 Год назад +24

      You can cry.

    • @dbearded130
      @dbearded130 Год назад +183

      And he didn't build his whole reputation from this Ned has plenty of feats and honorable acts that are what people actually think about. Only weirdos who wanna fight him like Jaimie think of that first and foremost.

  • @Aidencros
    @Aidencros Год назад +254

    Actually, it was not said the smiling knight was the mountain of that generation, but that he was like the mountain in term of eagerness of men to defeat him in battle.

    • @poggerz6567
      @poggerz6567 Год назад +25

      Didn't jaime said it himself? He said that the smiling knight is the mountain of his time. It was in the flashback video on RUclips

    • @Aidencros
      @Aidencros Год назад +68

      @@poggerz6567 yes but not size wise.
      "The Mountain of my boyhood. Half as big but twice as mad."

    • @poggerz6567
      @poggerz6567 Год назад +32

      @@Aidencros that's because nobody in the series is as big as the mountain, so when people say he's the mountain of his time, people meant it as he's the knight that people are afraid of

    • @Aidencros
      @Aidencros Год назад +10

      @@poggerz6567 except the giants :p and Hodor, greatjon and smalljon Umber come pretty damn close.

    • @20jumps
      @20jumps Год назад +1

      ​@@Aidencroscan you be more annoying ❤

  • @aleksandartasic7007
    @aleksandartasic7007 10 месяцев назад +21

    Ser Arthur definitely deserves his own series

  • @ino7604
    @ino7604 Год назад +135

    What a character 👏 so cool . He's basically the ultimate badass

    • @ino7604
      @ino7604 10 месяцев назад +1

      @blizstar9015 some magic kinda . Dawn. The glowing lightsabre of westeros

  • @edguy9767
    @edguy9767 Год назад +21

    Wasn’t there a saying in the books or maybe the tv show saying “never have greater knights served worsed kings” to the fact that knights loved by many or seen as what true knight should always be serving horrible people

  • @Govanna348
    @Govanna348 Год назад +137

    Ned: We looked for you in the trident
    Dayne: Your friend who you served with would of been in the ground if we were there

    • @reposter6434
      @reposter6434 Год назад +9

      Daynes confidence was surreal

    • @Govanna348
      @Govanna348 Год назад +26

      @@reposter6434 because he is the greatest swordsman in history

    • @reposter6434
      @reposter6434 Год назад +8

      @@Govanna348 no he isn't... George has already said multiple times that Arthur Dayne was the greatest warrior. Second was Baristam selmy, you can just search it up bro. Not gonna argue with someone who hasn't read the books.

    • @Govanna348
      @Govanna348 Год назад +21

      @@reposter6434 my guy that is clearly what I said u need to read over the comment my guy

    • @reposter6434
      @reposter6434 Год назад +12

      @@Govanna348 oh... My bad dude. I was arguing with another guy on another video who was trying to say that Daemon Targaryn from HOTD was better than Arthur Dayne at comabt. I didn't read read through Ur comment since I was arguing with another dude for quite a while. My bad dude I do apologise.

  • @chillinbored
    @chillinbored 8 дней назад +1

    Seeing him, Rhagar, Gerald and Barriston on screen together would be great. A very nice balance against Robert, Eddard, Stannis and Jon Arryn.

  • @ethanmitchell7479
    @ethanmitchell7479 Год назад +8

    “I want yours!”
    “Heheh don’t mind if you do!”

  • @marine47ncaa25
    @marine47ncaa25 Год назад +49

    Sad that such a chivalrous and honor bound dude died from a dirty stab in the back.

    • @Urgh_I_have_to_go
      @Urgh_I_have_to_go 6 месяцев назад +1

      No he died from a horse

    • @SantomPh
      @SantomPh 5 месяцев назад +8

      No ome actually knows in the books. Ned says he would have lost if not for Howland Reed, but he never actually says what he did.

    • @mechamedeamigo3984
      @mechamedeamigo3984 2 месяца назад +3

      There are no dirty moves in a real war.
      Chivalry wins no war.

    • @user-ch8rz
      @user-ch8rz День назад

      Just like Ned Stark he is also unfit to play the Game of Thrones.

  • @blakrabbito
    @blakrabbito 11 дней назад +1

    Ser Aurthur Dayne the Knight of many cuts g

  • @noyaltiby-kx1do
    @noyaltiby-kx1do Год назад +11

    Mahn i wish more series would come up on this , like a few could be :
    1. Aegons conquest
    2. The blackfyire rebellion
    3. The war of the nine penny kings
    4. The dornish wars
    5 . The valariyan freehold
    6 . The age of heroes
    7. The first men and the arrival of the andals
    8. More about essos
    9. More about the continent in the south
    10. What is west of westeros
    11. About previous empires and kingdoms ( both weteros and essos )
    12. Life of the common people etc.
    13. About the legendary warriors of westeros and essos
    It would be great

    • @bullymaguire7843
      @bullymaguire7843 2 месяца назад

      A series about Valyria named Fire & Blood would be amazing...Nymeria story line can be fitted into that

    • @trisadarmanovi9966
      @trisadarmanovi9966 23 дня назад

      wow great 🫡

    • @trisadarmanovi9966
      @trisadarmanovi9966 23 дня назад

      best bro

    • @urjitdabhi
      @urjitdabhi День назад

      Also, some stories of yi-ti would be better

  • @turdferguson9356
    @turdferguson9356 9 месяцев назад +5

    "I wish you luck in the wars to come."

    • @petrrozsival8554
      @petrrozsival8554 3 месяца назад +3

      "And now it begins"
      "Noh......neu it ehnds...."

  • @oscardaone
    @oscardaone Год назад +14

    All hail king Authur

  • @antothijoselvin7792
    @antothijoselvin7792 Год назад +56

    Ser ARTHUR Dayne ⚔️ history of westeros 🔥 sword of the morningstar 🌟

  • @andres-zc2xd
    @andres-zc2xd Год назад +42

    then you shall have it sir.

  • @gregthebman
    @gregthebman 9 месяцев назад +2

    We need an sir Arthur Dane mini series🧐

  • @mr.j5228
    @mr.j5228 Год назад +8

    Thanks for the narration Napoleon Dynamite.

  • @jebathehutt4287
    @jebathehutt4287 Год назад +58

    Pretty sure Sir Barristan the Bold should have the title as the best swordsman in Westeros due to the fact that he doesn't need a magic sword to cut down anyone or everyone who stood in his way and duty. Barristan even cut down Maelys the Monstrous and countless others in the War of Ninepenny Kings without a magic sword

    • @AJK17.5
      @AJK17.5 Год назад +36

      Tbh Dawn isn't magic it just is a better metal they are very even though with the same metal sword but Arthur probably edges it still selmy has accomplished way more.

    • @pavlovskaya_farms
      @pavlovskaya_farms Год назад +41

      George RR said that Arthur and Barristan were equal in a fight. But would give the edge to Dayne only because Dawn was of superior quality to a standard sword

    • @marudhanayagam9756
      @marudhanayagam9756 Год назад +18

      In house of dayne they offer this sword only to those who is worthy to hold it. so he is best swordsman before that worthy enough to hold the great sword.

    • @afriendlycadian9857
      @afriendlycadian9857 10 месяцев назад +1

      It's not magic fool it's just made of a superior material

    • @duskry6426
      @duskry6426 10 месяцев назад

      Well, Valyrian steel IS a rare, powerful metal with which to make swords, but most of those swords are ceremonial in nature (like Ice), and not very suitable in battle. Hence the reason why most noble houses has them as treasures, not weapons.
      There are exceptions, like Dawn, Claw and Oathkeeper, but having them on to potentially lose them in battle is hardly the rule.

  • @thefuulio1382
    @thefuulio1382 5 месяцев назад +1

    Imagine Jaimie dissapointent when facing Eddard

  • @someonelol9999
    @someonelol9999 Год назад +6

    So chivalrous that he helps his friend elope with his little girlfriend and leave their family and all people to suffer.

  • @goochmcduck4285
    @goochmcduck4285 7 дней назад

    I love how it said that every young boy in the whole seven kingdom pretend played and wanted to be Arthur Dane.
    They’re family line and that sword are so damn interesting. Wish they do a whole show about house Dane and Dawn

  • @methuselahh_
    @methuselahh_ Год назад +7

    house dayne is probably my favorite house, with gerold darkstar dayne got to show up in the show he was awesome

  • @silverwindyt7932
    @silverwindyt7932 Год назад +21

    Y’all think Arthur Dayne would beat Prime Ageon the Conquest

    • @sozinscomet1316
      @sozinscomet1316 Год назад +18

      Everyday, Aegon was a great warrior, but the best of the 3 main Targaryen was Visenya (at least in combat) it's because of her there is a Kingsguard

    • @moversrus4048
      @moversrus4048 Год назад

      Easily

    • @landongest8364
      @landongest8364 Год назад

      Nah he’s just burn him

    • @yuan713
      @yuan713 9 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@sozinscomet1316if Visenyas one whose the other two? Daemond?

    • @uh9104
      @uh9104 Месяц назад

      @@sozinscomet1316aegon was not known for his dueling skills we actually don’t know if he was a good warrior we just know he fought on dragon back

  • @marvin9409
    @marvin9409 Год назад +21

    I think I've never seen a character with sich diverse fanfiction lol I still have absolutely no Idea how he'd look like 😂

    • @iancoates2100
      @iancoates2100 Год назад

      He was in the show

    • @hi-ls6lt
      @hi-ls6lt 11 месяцев назад +3

      He has never been described in terms of physical description which is why his fanart is very varied I would say. Most of course draw Arthur with purple eyes and black hair because he may have resembled his sister Ashara who had as such. We don’t know for sure of course. In the show he has dark hair.
      Alicent Hightower is actually kind of the same. Of course the show and most fanart have her with dark hair, I think that is also depicted in F&B illustrations, there is no specific for her apart from being slender and attractive. There’s some who think she had silver hair, because Alerie Hightower (Margaery’s mom in books) did and Jorah’s estranged wife Lynette was said to resemble Daenerys.

  • @mikeglisson4912
    @mikeglisson4912 8 месяцев назад +1

    Arthur Dayne was an awesome character prince rheagers best friend and an honorable friend

  • @vishalmishra579
    @vishalmishra579 Год назад +4

    Sword of the morning

  • @fergalosanchez7675
    @fergalosanchez7675 9 месяцев назад +3

    Too chivalrous for my liking, he died stopping Ned get to his sister because of his dead Princes order. If he allowed Ned reach his sister whom he wouldn’t have harmed in any way then he’d be alive

    • @alexpopa5436
      @alexpopa5436 6 месяцев назад +1

      Because he didn't know what Ned and Robert would do with Rhaegar's son.

  • @SLrandomshitposting
    @SLrandomshitposting 7 месяцев назад +1

    He was such a hunk

  • @Donstaa
    @Donstaa 22 дня назад

    Damn prince rhaegar is a true G instead of bringing his best men especially ser arthur to the most important battle of his life he leaves them behind guarding the one he truly loved damn if that ain't gangsta what is

  • @Allthingsasian
    @Allthingsasian Год назад +2

    Can you do a video on Elia Martell?

  • @GTA6VIGameguy
    @GTA6VIGameguy Год назад +26

    What happened to Dayne's sword after he was killed?

    • @potatobro_the_fifth2045
      @potatobro_the_fifth2045 Год назад +50

      Eddard returned it to the Daynes i believe

    • @theschnitzllover8274
      @theschnitzllover8274 Год назад +30

      Eddard returned it to house Dayne were the sword is kept until another member of house Dayne proves worthy, that person is then given, along with the sword, the title "the sword of the morning"
      Unlike other house we're the family sword is just given to the oldest son
      Edit: spelling

    • @SantomPh
      @SantomPh Год назад +10

      Eddard returned Dawn to Starfall, causing Ashara Dayne to commit suicide. He also made Jon Snow and the future lord Edric Dayne milk brothers

    • @Foggymist399
      @Foggymist399 Год назад +10

      In Hbo’s robberts rebellion storys. “The sword gathers dust above the mantel, waiting for the next Worthy dayne, and there it shall stay untill one is born.”

  • @val882
    @val882 Год назад +2

    Can you do one about house hightower during GoT ?

  • @MckenzieCalan
    @MckenzieCalan 15 дней назад

    Imagine a HBO done a series on him

  • @Baileaf11
    @Baileaf11 9 месяцев назад +1

    Ser Arthur may have had Dawn
    But Howland Reed had a Double Barrel Shotgun

  • @lilnjdevil116
    @lilnjdevil116 2 месяца назад

    Fine Ill rewatch Game of Thrones!

  • @ameliaflynnhayes
    @ameliaflynnhayes 2 месяца назад

    He was known by all the realm as the best swordsman

  • @cheepcheep8536
    @cheepcheep8536 Год назад +31

    Which Targaryen was ruling at his time?

    • @Omar-rx6lk
      @Omar-rx6lk Год назад +27

      Mad king

    • @maxi1ification
      @maxi1ification Год назад +28

      Aerys II, also known as the Mad King

    • @kalebhenson8028
      @kalebhenson8028 Год назад +19

      ​@@ottovonbismarck7742 "Arthur Dayne was a legendary knight who served in Aerys II Kingsguard" - Ice and Fire Wiki
      Imagine being so confidently wrong

    • @kalebhenson8028
      @kalebhenson8028 Год назад +17

      @@ottovonbismarck7742 he was 2 when Jahaerys reign ended, so there's no possible way he'd have been knighted by him.

    • @psychedelicsoul3260
      @psychedelicsoul3260 Год назад +3

      ​@ottovonbismarck7742 that was a different Dayne but held the same title

  • @randallholloway8686
    @randallholloway8686 23 дня назад

    Joffrey: "if he's fool enough to approach me... I'll give him a, red smile..."

  • @judochopmaster8233
    @judochopmaster8233 9 месяцев назад +10

    "I choose Dawn."
    "Wrong choice buckaroo- HYAH!"

  • @marvinsalmeron585
    @marvinsalmeron585 4 месяца назад

    Can only stay chivalrous when you know nobody is makinh a scratch on you

  • @TheRealRehman
    @TheRealRehman Месяц назад

    Ser Arthur Dayne is the Gol D Rogers of GOT....he was so powerful that they needed to take him out before the series started.
    Or else it would be "In the game of thrones, you either win or you die... unless Ser Arthur Dayne decides otherwise."

  • @voriandayne-en9gb
    @voriandayne-en9gb Год назад +5

    He was not the greatest swordsman who ever lived. He’s just the best swordsman in his era. Just like Ser Davos Dayne, just like Ulrick Dayne, King Samwell “Starfire” and Ser Joffrey Dayne. Dafuq?

  • @RedClem
    @RedClem 5 месяцев назад

    Aemon the Dragonknight is my favorite swordsman

  • @josephpotter7776
    @josephpotter7776 6 месяцев назад

    Artie just wanted more cage time

  • @alexpopa5436
    @alexpopa5436 6 месяцев назад +1

    Aemon the Dragonknight feels more legendary than Arthur Dayne

  • @jamiejenkinson7029
    @jamiejenkinson7029 6 месяцев назад

    What would the match up be like with dayne and selmy

  • @theidirianthinker108
    @theidirianthinker108 5 месяцев назад

    I like how both Ser Arthr Dayn and Obryn were both these bad ass fucking warriors. And then just get cheap shotted and killed by being cought of gaurd.

  • @Alikk784
    @Alikk784 Год назад +2

    his armor was trash in GOT, unlike Targaryen armors in HOTD

  • @Knightstruth
    @Knightstruth 6 месяцев назад

    He dreamt an old dream.....

  • @Phantomkidx
    @Phantomkidx 11 месяцев назад +1

    Sr Duncan the tall and aemon the dragon knight and sr barristan Selmy has entered the chat

    • @f.n8581
      @f.n8581 10 месяцев назад +1

      Ser Arthur dayne is better than both

    • @Phantomkidx
      @Phantomkidx 10 месяцев назад

      @@f.n8581 0 feats

    • @dontme6996
      @dontme6996 9 месяцев назад

      *They see Ser Arthur Dayne with Dawn* all 3 leave chat

    • @akhydesrois2716
      @akhydesrois2716 Месяц назад

      ​@@f.n8581nah

    • @akhydesrois2716
      @akhydesrois2716 Месяц назад

      ​​@@dontme6996aemon the dragonknight is stated by grrm as the best swordsman to ever lived

  • @DavyDave1313
    @DavyDave1313 11 месяцев назад

    Did winds of winter ever come out?

  • @williamtorres4140
    @williamtorres4140 Год назад

    Arthur Dane in that first Image looks more like a Stark... Tony Stark

  • @MarcusHalverstram
    @MarcusHalverstram 29 дней назад

    He was also a shapeshifter

  • @Giggles_iJest
    @Giggles_iJest 3 месяца назад +1

    and Ned beat him

  • @asahall9108
    @asahall9108 Год назад +2

    Didn't Ned Stark actually have an affair with sir authors sister? Met her returning Dawn to the Dane house after he fell

    • @fazediamond5671
      @fazediamond5671 Год назад

      Yea maybe Jon is her son

    • @Basileus1453
      @Basileus1453 Год назад

      Potentially but personally I don't believe it. We know a Stark had sex with Ashara but I would say that was more likely Brandon Stark, Ned's older brother.

  • @NWLR-tv
    @NWLR-tv Год назад

    Idk why I thought hw was gonna say
    "The greatest Swordsman to ever Sword" instead of what he did say

  • @Shade_razor-79
    @Shade_razor-79 26 дней назад

    We should’ve gotten this series instead of the hedge knight

  • @TheRarook
    @TheRarook 10 месяцев назад

    Chivalry is easy when you're better than everybody else

  • @sebastianblackfyre
    @sebastianblackfyre 10 месяцев назад

    Daemon Blackfyre and Barristan Selmy

  • @hawks7111
    @hawks7111 7 месяцев назад

    first illustration reminds me of MCU Tony Stark

  • @ruthless_dude_6999
    @ruthless_dude_6999 2 дня назад

    Nah the best swordsman was prolly daemon blackfyre dude was a beast dropping kingsguard and lords alike

  • @cadmusravenstag4403
    @cadmusravenstag4403 8 месяцев назад +5

    Martin himself puts Aemon the Dragonknight above Arthur.

    • @pleaseshush9800
      @pleaseshush9800 25 дней назад +1

      he doesn’t lmao. he quite literally states multiple times that ser arthur is the best knight and swordsman ever.

    • @AgeoftheGeek_
      @AgeoftheGeek_ 22 дня назад +1

      No he doesn’t. Where THE FUCK did you get that from?! Seriously, I own every single book George has ever written and never come across that. Not even in any interview he’s given so where exactly did you hear or read that?! Very curious

  • @polly6896
    @polly6896 8 месяцев назад

    How? With Barriston around could anyone be considered a better swordsman. Definitely need an on screen adaptation

  • @hughcurran6817
    @hughcurran6817 24 дня назад

    I really hope he wasnt killed by ned. Instead they made a deal he joined yhe nights watch becoming quhorin half hand.
    I hope him and benjim were always ready for john to join the nights watch.
    Just a personal fan fiction probably lol.

  • @wazah1878
    @wazah1878 6 месяцев назад

    In the books though 7 took out those legendary 3 I’m not trying To down play it at all but they must have been all good swordsmen in their own rights to even hold their own against that level of skill the kingsguard wielded the.

  • @madmrssally5297
    @madmrssally5297 2 месяца назад

    I’m curious why Ned was kept from his sister. Why fight them instead of letting her talk to her brother? Robert wasn’t there. This scene always confused me.

  • @Chad0023
    @Chad0023 5 месяцев назад

    I've heard of so many ,'Greatest swordsman' to ever exist in ASOIAF😂

  • @akhydesrois2716
    @akhydesrois2716 Месяц назад

    What about aemon targaryen the dragonknight

  • @TheRealRightPrice
    @TheRealRightPrice Год назад

    All these legendary swordsmen sword fighting with greatswords which aren't designed at all for sword fighting.

  • @greenman6141
    @greenman6141 Год назад +2

    But he died an idiot. What was the point of trying to kill Ned Stark? Ned wasn't going to harm his own sister or her child. Rhaegar was already dead. It was a totally pointless and stupid fight and death. Ned and his sister would have had a little bit more time together if A Dayne had just let Ned go see her immediately.
    And SHE absolutely did not want Ned to be killed...she desperately needed him alive, to protect her child.
    Why was Arthur Dayne so dumb about this?

    • @hi-ls6lt
      @hi-ls6lt 11 месяцев назад

      Maybe it was just an order by Rhaegar to defend the tower against any of their “enemies” and the Kingsguard took that very seriously and literally. Stupid of course against Lyanna’s own brother but then again some people think any other Kingsguard apart from Jamie would have let Aerys burn King’s Landing.

    • @greenman6141
      @greenman6141 11 месяцев назад

      @@hi-ls6lt That's a really good explanation! And it is excellent at pointing out the big problems in the whole notion of what this Kingsguard is. If a King says..."Go rape every child under 11" , in theory the "honour" of these big but dim blokes would require that they do so. Honour. heh heh.
      Though I'm sure grrMartin voiced that through some character or another..the various competing claims upon what a knight (or really any person) is called upon to do.
      If you put a promise or oath before your own capacity to make ethical decisions, you are going to end up with no ethics.

    • @adamantiiispencespence4012
      @adamantiiispencespence4012 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@greenman6141Martin when asked for comment has always pointed out that Ned's recollection of events at the Tower of Joy is s dream and a fever dream at that. Meaning it probably played very differently from that.

    • @greenman6141
      @greenman6141 11 месяцев назад

      @@adamantiiispencespence4012 So...played differently.
      Arthur Dayne isn't dead.
      Jon Snow isn't Lyanna's
      Lyanna isn't dead.
      There was no fighting. They all had some lovely tea. and then a tickle contest.
      There are some events which seem fairly core. I do accept that the room where Lyanna lay dying probably was not filled with the scent of blue roses. .

  • @Tabaluca911
    @Tabaluca911 9 месяцев назад

    Who ever lived?
    *Serwyn of the mirror shield leaves lore

  • @vojtacech9156
    @vojtacech9156 Год назад

    How fool he was, sword is only a sword Arthur Dayne is the true steel

  • @tariqgough5394
    @tariqgough5394 Год назад

    Wait did he give him the sword dawn to fight with?

  • @matthewfarmer9500
    @matthewfarmer9500 9 месяцев назад +1

    He’s so cool. Until a man he wounded got up from the ground and stabbed him with a dagger. I guess Arthur Dayne isn’t that good.

  • @rickyt.5164
    @rickyt.5164 Год назад

    there are always another greatest swordsman who ever lived in westeros 🙂 what if we just put down the 'est' part and just use "great" instead, so word "greatest" doesnt lose its meaning 🙂

    • @greatestoldone7658
      @greatestoldone7658 Год назад +1

      this guy is the real deal though, I can't think of any better in the history of ASOIAF

  • @fernandotillman
    @fernandotillman 4 дня назад

    Jon Snows uncle !!!

  • @jevilz9858
    @jevilz9858 Месяц назад +2

    Wait his sword got forged from a star?
    That's how Mjolnir was forged too...

  • @jf_kein_k8590
    @jf_kein_k8590 10 месяцев назад

    Wasn't Jaime Lennister also his squire?

  • @Jonathan_D12
    @Jonathan_D12 10 месяцев назад

    If this is true, Allister Thorne would recognize him

  • @MrMadnessHero
    @MrMadnessHero Год назад

    Looks like Griffith and guts to me

  • @gaghhuh2943
    @gaghhuh2943 8 месяцев назад

    I actually believe that he decided to let ned kill him just so that the story was believable

  • @devilpupbear09
    @devilpupbear09 Год назад

    "Formed from heart of the dying star"?
    Are you shitting me with that Thor quote?

  • @mrsoready
    @mrsoready 2 месяца назад

    Could Dawnstar kill whitewalkers?

  • @Beyonder710
    @Beyonder710 9 месяцев назад

    The most Honorable Knight...stabbed in the back , shame on the world.

  • @danieldiaz2393
    @danieldiaz2393 Год назад

    And he was defeated by Ned Stark... And I am sticking to my version. Haha I just hope we get to see the end of this books.

  • @joekerr971
    @joekerr971 Год назад +3

    He's the greatest knight to have ever lived, that's why he's dead

  • @beaub152
    @beaub152 Месяц назад

    How did ned stark and howland reed beat him then?

  • @user-qx8gq4fk8z
    @user-qx8gq4fk8z 4 месяца назад

    Duncan McLeod would humiliate him

  • @anamariecameron7874
    @anamariecameron7874 Год назад +1

    there needs to be a tv series about house Dayne

  • @Julius_Dayne
    @Julius_Dayne Год назад

    A knight? Are we sure about that? Both Dawn and House Dayne itself predate the coming of the Andals, and consequentially the tradition of knighthood in Westerns, by several thousands of years.

  • @All_EDITZ124
    @All_EDITZ124 2 месяца назад

    I know arthur is the greatest and i really love him, but is this all the feats and statements he have???is there anything else, i always only know this one, Selmy feats are better than this, i want another feats of Sword of the morning

  • @AtticusTheDeathMetaller
    @AtticusTheDeathMetaller 9 месяцев назад

    The most based.

  • @user-ys8mk2dw1w
    @user-ys8mk2dw1w 26 дней назад

    My moneys on bronn.

  • @StormFalcon61
    @StormFalcon61 Месяц назад

    Karl Tanner from Gin Alley d dismantle him within 2 mins