I love in deep geek but the best video he ever put out is the one the mentioned LML. That dude probably doesn’t Praise Garth, it would ruin his silky voice.
@@DavidLightbringer have you seen vampire the masquerade Caine and Lilith I think the BS emperor was the Caine of the asoiaf world and the tiger woman/ night queen /his sister was the Lilth/ Abel of the tale
I really do think that it’s channels like this, and the online community we have built, that are keeping the book hype alive. It’s now been 13 years since the last book came out, and the ending of the show kinda sucked, and yet we are all still so hyped for the next one! The publishers and Grr Martin better sponsor all of these channels when the next book comes out, and they better pay well!!!
You should watch all the Elden Ring lore videos because it is riddled with all the stuff LmL talks about and it was created by GRRM and one of the best fantasy lores ever made
While I absolutely love the long interactive live streams I know everyone is not able to take the time to enjoy them fully. These shorter videos with analysis and theories on one specific topic are going to get a lot of attention. You are, as always, fascinating and entertaining. More and more people are noticing!
Even if all of LML theories turn out to be wrong it’d just show the brilliance of GRRM writing skills , world building and knowledge of so many different historical and mythological events and LML ability to take all of GRRM writings and weave a very plausible theory with about a 100 hours worth of content that back those theories !!! Keep up the hard work for us Myth -Heads!!!
Honestly loving this condensed overview of the weirwood net invasion theory! Would absolutely love it if as time goes on and theories are developed you dropped some summary videos like this one 👌
Regarding oak trees. In Europe, most forests had originally mostly contained oak trees. But the Celts had cut them down to make use of them. Later mainly beech trees would grow since they grow much faster. So the oak forests had been corrupted by beech trees after the oak had been cut down by men.
I don't know whether to kiss you or curse you for getting me thinking about these books like this again. This is all phenomenal stuff. Normally wouldn't comment much but you've been saying it helps the channel so here you go.
Awesome video. Your comments on Stannis' shadow baby being a "shadow clone" of Stannis himself made me think that perhaps the original Azor Ahai/Night's King has a similar relationship with the Others. Like they are collectively the fractured remains of Azor Ahai.
I must say, you do really have a staggeringly comprehensive take on the whole picture set up by, and, more importantly, underneath, this epic narrative old Mr. Martin has presented us with. I swear, the man should give up on his ever more obviously taxing efforts to complete his great work and just reach out to you to take up the task of finalizing the concluding chapters of his creation. You’ve got as clear a grasp of what’s going on, or what should go on, with it all, as the man himself…if not a clearer one, by this point!🤔😆
i appreciate that sentiment very much, but of course explaining something and writing something are two different (though related) undertakings. he’s already written as many words as are in ADWD for TWOW, but he’s got a few more chapters go. who knows what he may have rewritten… but it sounds like he’s coming down the home stretch and feeling more positive
I like the touch that Renly's crown is decorated with jet amidst all the horns/leaves motifs in his get-up, since jet is a smooth black stone that comes from fossilized wood. To get the stone, wood changes under extreme pressure. (Insert parallels to the motifs in David's theories about the green men, transformation, shadow babies, etc). Blackness added upon green and gold...it's a nice costuming detail that could be a random stone choice that fits the vibe but also works as an unintentional or intentional reference as a bridge between the stag/woodland/forest motifs (the before state of the land and more primal culture ties to jet's original state of wood) and the stone structures later built by the regional kings and leaders. It is a different reference to a black stone than obsidian (dragon glass, associated with the Others and volcanos, ice and fire) and the oily stone structures. It also teaches us that the Westerosi use the term jet for that stone, so we can't chalk up the material of those oily black stone structures across the world to simply being a vocabulary mix-up and that they are likely a separate material than normal jet from normal fossilized wood. Could be cool if they were some kinda freaky eldritch jet. I would laugh so hard if the oily black stone idea came from GRRM's inkjet printer malfunctioning and he got this idea for a weird, inky, jet and remembered the odd stones from Lovecraft.
So... looks like Theon Greyjoy was the "Nissa Nissa" of season 8. The Night King sacrificed him beneath the Winterfell weir wood. Also did you notice that when the Night King "died" (in the show) he shattered into ice bits that he melted into the ground beneath the weir wood! My first thought was that he was entering the weir wood network.
While watching I remembered that the Limes, the great wall the Romans built along their border in Germania, they started with a wooden construction, some wooden towers and later a wooden palisade. Only later they constructed a great wall out of stone ... so it's not unlike the Wall in Westeros, where first wood and Greenseers like guards in wooden towers watched over the border who were replaced by a great wall... Just my thoughts on that topic xD
This video format is perfect for my add/adhd brain, lol. Thanks for this super clear explanation with incredible art! Love it, David! ❤ Idk if it's just me but ASOIAF is the most complex stories I've ever read, and then tried to really understand so I'm grateful for the delivery!Always impressed by your big brain 😊
Loved The Wall parallel to Renly’s Tent and the Weirwood at the NightFort. Can’t wait for more analyzation through these chapter reads. Very stoked for the Dunc POVs and your interpretation of those events and what they may foreshadow. Cheers
So good! Concise, beautiful. I always found it difficult to wrap my head around the entire theory, as it's multi faceted and complex. This video finally got me all the way there. Bravo 👏 👏
Your comments re: the weirwood possibly originally being an oak tree + the death of the greenseer creating an “opening” for corruption to enter the net reminds me of the Arianne chapter from AFFC where kings guard knight Ser Arys Oakheart (Oak heart tree?) is killed by Areo Hotah. See Arys is “corrupted” when he breaks his vows and has an affair with Arianne, who turns him, bends his will to serve her own plan to place Myrcella on the iron throne.
"(The Emperor) Elagabalus was a priest in an obscure cult in Syria that venerated a black stone meteorite - a culture that would have been deeply strange to the Romans."
Glad to see that your channel is doing well, I remember when you were still trying to get 15k subs. Thanks for the theories and awesome commentary David!
hi! I've been following your channel for some time, and I there's still no video I didn't enjoy (: I admire how deeply you study the text and the mythology behind it, all theories are so interesting and you make it easy to follow the trail of thought in them. not to mention the visuals! there's clearly so much love and care you put into this channel, thank you, it's always a delight to see new videos pop up. also I rewatched this video today and it got me thinking. if we have direct allusions that the green men were slain for this sacrifice, for Nissa Nissa we have things like: "her spirit went into the sword of light" and "her scream broke the moon and brought down the meteors". but another interesting thing relating to Nissa Nissa you brought up here is "death by childbirth". 1) Nissa Nissa and the Night Queen seem to be thematically connected/dual figures, like Azor Ahai and the Night King. 2) in your Night Queen video you propose that she was some kind of an ice witch (like Melisandre is a fire witch). and she "conceived" the first white walkers from the Night King, but they are just shadow-clones made from his life force. and it's just like Melisandre made the shadow-clones of Stanis. here I see the a sort of eco of this theory: Nissa Nissa's death somehow allowed Azor Ahai's shadow to enter the weirwood net. so we have him "piercing her with a sword", and this act allowing him, or his "shadow" to enter the weirwood. and here we come back to the begining -- Catelyn remembering that her mother Minisa died in childbirth. so, did the same or similiar ritual happened with Nissa Nissa? "scream of agony and ecstasy" still works in the parallel with Melisandre this way. even if it has terrible connotations now, since it is highly debatable the "ritual" was consensual. Maybe Nissa Nissa died because it wasn't? 3) again, the ritual Melisandre did took Stanis's life force to make his "shadows", and he became weaker for it. and in Azor Ahai legend it's the opposite -- he took Nissa Nissa's life force away to make himself stronger. life force here is also the metaphor for the soul. and Nissa Nissa's soul is, as we suspect, connected to the spirits of the green men in the weirwood net. that is why her death helped banish them from it, right? so, maybe here the ritual is fully reversed, perverted. he is forcing himself on Nissa Nissa, and having her bear his literal or shadow-clone child -- mixing in blood of the green men with human and/or forging the link to the race that can control the weirwood. and through that connection he can possess the weirwoods and expel the spirits of green men to be "white shadows" of themselves. 4) in couple of your videos, you discussed how according to the tapestry in the s2 of HoTD and the s1 song, we may assume that the 3 heads of the dragon are: the dragon, the rider, and the spirit of some ancestor of the rider living in and being passed down his dragon's bloodline. and this makes dragons and people next of kin, and helps to establish the bond. 4.1) Azor Ahai was, most likely, a dragon lord of the past. So, with all the parallels, we can assume he may have tried to establish the same sort of link with the weirwoods. Put his own spirit in them, or the spirit of his family member. Or, since we're talking about 2 different races here, just having a human or demi-human spirit in the weirwood net could open it up to all other people? I'm just spitballing here, idk. 4.2) but the tapestry of forging the dragon bond does invoke the strong Azor Ahai parallels, with the woman being sacrificed (by the sword), and her spirit being put into a "fiery vessel". on the tapestry it is a dragon. in Azor Ahai legend it is a "sword of light". remember how the other metaphor for a comet/meteor that we know is "a red sword"? a sword of fire, you can say. and, once again we come back to the start: Nissa Nissa's scream broke the moon. or, even better: the moon kissed the sun, and the moon broke, died, "birthing" the flaming swords/dragons that fell on the earth and started the Long Night. the Azor Ahai put his sword in Nissa Nissa and it came out carrying her spirit, alive with it, like a child. the "birth" and "bloodline connections" seen to be very important here. 4.3) if Nissa Nissa carried the actual, not shadow-clone child of Azor Ahai while she died, did he use his connection to the child's spirit to enter the net with it? or the child survived? it there a chance that it was not the Azor Ahai that became the Night King, but this child instead? the shadow of Azor Ahai (literal or not). the sword aflame with Nissa Nissa's spirit, that took part in the corruption of the weirwood net. the greenseer leader of the night watch. the sacrifice to the others, one might even say. it fixes the timeline heresy a bit, at the very least. or it's the other way around, and the child actually is the Last Hero -- the flaming sword that Azor Ahai forged through terrible sacrifice, to enter weirwood net. and he ended up slaying his dad who became the Night King. still the prince that was promised to the others. and not delivered. ah, this was a long one. idk if it all makes sense. maybe it was all said before even! :"D but I just couldn't stop thinking about the parallels.
I swear you put more thought into a single video than D&D put into the last three seasons of GOT. Love your theories and all the worldbuilding. Keep being awesome.
In what way do you think Stannis "later" dreams the murder. I thought he literally committed the murder in the dream, essentially warging the Shadow Baby, and his denial was such that he believed it to be a dream.
While I tune in for live streams, sometimes my friends who loved the series are intimidated to join. These videos are perfect for sucking them into your weirdwood net 😂
I’m very new to this, but I heard/read (probably from LML) that the oily black stone may be the result of the petrification of the Ebony/Nightshade trees. They produced ancient monumental structures by using the wood of the black trees, then “enchanted” it with magic, petrifying it and giving it its oiliness and cementing its magic properties. Maybe the Wall (very similar to the 5 Forts) was built with a similar magic but using Weirwoods instead. Normally when something is described as oily, I think primarily of it being slick by touch, but oily can also describe something that shimmers with slickness. A shimmering slickness would be a good way to describe the Wall, “alive with light”. Maybe weirwoods and Nightshade trees were the same/similar until Azor Ahai changed the ones in Westeros by evicting the Green Seer spirits from them. Azor Ahai fought the evil in the East successfully and built the Forts, then went to the Western borders of mankind and tried to do something at the Arm of Dorne, but didn’t work, so he fought on further to the Neck, which also didn’t work, then tried for a final time at the Wall, which only partially worked as the Weirwoods were a little different to the Ebony he used successfully in the East. The Wall is a sticking plaster rather than a final solution like the Forts. The wood of the Weirwood was used to build the Wall and spirits of the Green Seers were sacrificed to enchant it, with the White Walkers being spirits that were able to escape being sacrificed and seek revenge on humanity.
Hi David, I don't know if you've already raised this point since I last read your essays, but have you ever looked into the "Wormwood" prophecy from the Book of Revelations? Here's the relevant verse: "The third angel blew his trumpet, and a great star fell from heaven, blazing like a torch, and it fell on a third of the rivers and on the springs of water. The name of the star is Wormwood. A third of the waters became wormwood, and many died from the water, because it was made bitter." (Rev 8:10-11) Of course there are the obvious parallels between the bloodstone meteorite and Azor Ahai as the source of the weirwoods, as well as the third trumpet call and the three attempts to forge lightbringer. But what isn't so obvious is that "wormwood", a plant used to treat intestinal worms, is from the Artemisia family of plants, and that Artemis is the Hellenic precursor to Diana, a Roman moon Goddess. Perhaps this is the founding myth of a fiery comet begeting a tree that has moon symbolism that GRRM reinterpreted and we'd to his own mythos. It's one of the few precursor myths we've been missing so far. Most of the other mythical events in asoiaf seem to have had a basis the myth of our world. Anyway mate, keep up the good work. Hope you are well.
i do see the parallel and yes I have in one very old essay looked at some of the “mythical astronomy” in Revelation - there’s quite a lot of it! But here specifically we’re talking about turning the waters bitter, and that compares well to poisoning the green see. Remember we talked about how brackish waters are part of this via Bracken and Bittersteel? How the Brackens poisoned the weirwood? The bitter, brackish water is a symbol of the corrupted wwnet. And then we have Bloodraven the wyrm in the wood - he’s playing that symbolic role of a dragon who’s invaded the wwnet, which was originally Azor Ahai’s thing
@@DavidLightbringer those are such interesting parallels. Good job on the whole "brackish"/"Braken" connection too. I really can't wait for these ideas to come together in Winds.
I wonder if Nissa-Nissa was actually a Green Woman or "of the Green Men" (Woman seems more fitting than Man imo). It would explain the "Tiger Woman" depiction from Yi Ti since, like you said in the theory about Ned Stark's "Old Ones", the Old Ones/Green Men lived on Leng, and I don't remember if you say so but I believe that the Green Men are close relatives of the Children of the Forest, perhaps even the first mixed offspring of CotF and humans. Maybe Nissa-Nissa was some kind of Lengi Green Man royalty and the excuse Azor Ahai gave for marrying her was to unite the bloodlines and empires of the Great Empire of the Dawn and the Kingdom of Leng's Green Men. Only, Azor Ahai really just wanted access to the incredibly magically powerful blood of the Green Men royalty. There is power in king's blood after all, which he used to call down the Moon Meteors™, accidentally or otherwise, and bring on the Long Night. Perhaps Azor Ahai was taught about the Weirwood Net by Nissa-Nissa or a relative of hers, planting the seeds in his head to bust into the WN in the first place
As much as I enjoy these videos (and, to be clear, I'm not even taking the piss here, I really do enjoy them), it sometimes feels like the stereotypical conspiracy theorist who has newspaper articles pinned to his walls, and 826 metres of red string linking words all over the place. You probably are right about a lot of things with the symbolism, but one wouldn't want to get carried away with it too much. It's like that old joke, wherein the book says that the sky was blue, and your English teacher expects you to write a fifteen page essay about how the blueness symbolises the melancholic depressivity of the chapter, whereas the author actually just meant to simply remark that the sky was literally blue.
I don't think the weirwood trees could have been anything other than a species of maple. They're the only trees I know of with leaves like five fingered hands. And some have crimson leaves, while others have sap that runs more freely. I wouldn't be surprised if there's even a white barked species I can't think of right now. They also can grow quite wide with age.
Have you read Elden Ring's story? Because George wrote the universe, I see alot of similarities with comets and meteors brining both ruin and arcane horrors. A great primal tree that's taken control of by a wielder of said arcane horror, and that same man that corrupted the world is remembered as a hero, a warrior that all should strive to be like. In a surprising turn of irony his son spends his undying breath keeping the influence of the stars at bay, heralding events similar to the one that granted his father such power. There's so many similarities I'd recommend a dive on your free time
I really love your theories, and all this about Azor Ahai, Nissa Nissa & the Weirwoodnet and green men!! IT makes so much sense!! And once more :Thank you LML, you are not crazy 😄💪🙌Please do more of these summaries about your therories, as other also mentions :I think even more people will have time to watch your incredible theories and content ✌️🫶🐉🔥and Praise Garth, ofc ✌️
Always here to support your incredible (and minblowing) channel!!!! can you PLEASEEE do a scripted video of the parallels of the dance of dragons with the long night and also a symbolic review of the world of ice and fire and where these parallels show?
@David Lightbringer love the PP art! We’ll done. For the uninitiated you would want to include more about Bloodstone & connections. “Alive with light” Catelyn 1 the crystals in the Winterfell Sept. thoughts?
Hey daddy. I’m going to start reading the books this week! In huge part because of your content. Since you’re creating more varied video lengths now I had a couple of examples you could play with on a shorter format. You could create guides on how to read the books (tips on symbolism, recaps, main plot points) and also character profiles
I just started watching GOT a year ago, I’m always late to some great shows. My daughter got me watching promising I would love it. Honestly and sadly it took Ned losing his head to get me interested and still can’t get enough. I found LML, Grayarea, Quinn’s Ideas and a few others to listen to and love it. The breakdown ,foreshadowing and theories are wonderful. I’m so glad y’all add so much to the show and books. Keep it coming 😊❤
The one part of this theory that I can’t get past is nights king invading the weirwood net and then leaving to join the others- who he’d just evicted from it so that he could have its power. That part doesn’t make sense. Why go through all that trouble to get into the weirwoods only to remove yourself from it to lead the beings that you just kicked out? It seems more likely that Azor/ nights king remained in the weirwood net and the others are attacking because they want it back. Don’t get me wrong, I love your theories and channel as a whole, this is meant constructively. The others don’t seem to have access to the weirwood net, so Azor caused the long night, invaded the weirwood net, left and took over those he’d kicked out of it, and then led them south to attack mankind because….??? What’s the motive for the war?
I don't get married to specific details/symbols much, but I do buy into the idea of the "weirwood invasion." In fact, as a clarifying idea, I think R'hllor *IS* Azor Ahai, whether that's an individual or a group/council of individuals from the Great Empire. Whether it involves the invasion of the weirwoods specifically or another avenue was found to manifest in the warp/veil/spiritual realm, doing so caused a cosmic apotheosis that created a god, or god-like entity. And it's very reasonable to believe that this act caused some turmoil with the existing occupants which caused The Long Night and birthed the cursed people now known as The Others. I think *that* is what informs the final "Song of Ice and Fire." It isn't Jon's parentage, as I think bloodline power is built up to be a red herring. Instead I think the real song is Jon's resurrection as a "fire wight." As such, he will be touched by R'hllor and, consequently, act as a proxy to Azor Ahai/Great Empire to put the two ancient enemies back together. And I think Alt Shift X has the right of the ending, which is a peaceful resolution that brings balance to the seasons, in this case using Jon as a proxy to bring reconciliation to the spirits which schismed those 10,000 years ago.
yeah i mean that’s a very general description of the ending, but it’s correct - this story is all about reconciliation. of the Others to the trees, first and foremost. Jon Dany and Bran will all facilitate this. as for the ice and fire yea it’s not limited to one thing, it’s an expression of the harmony of opposites ideal which again goes back to reconciliation
@@DavidLightbringer Yeah. I guess that was me as an old man yelling obvious things at clouds. 😅 Probably also goes to show that I actually *am* married to at least one specific idea (Azor Ahai=R'hllor) and would love it to tie into the generally accepted closure. Sorry for getting a bit obtuse there.
LML read Lord of Light by Zelazny! You actually said Mahasamatman the other day. The audio version is good if that's your style. It's got everything! Kali and Durga, The Alchemical Wedding, Jon being taken over by Nights king. There's so much. I hear you state a theory of yours and I'm just like well that's basically what happens in Lord of Light!
Can we get an updated overview of your theories, involving the green and first men, the cosmology, and the god emperor etc? All these subtopics are so nebulous and only spiralled over the years. Would be great to tie it all together oncemore.
if the bloodstone causing the others to wake up how can they fight until the north of westeros? when all the man still in the dawn continent? can anyone explain the timeline? if the hero fighting the second long night? who defeated the first long night?
So I had to like the video but it was at 777 likes but I had to hit it. 777 is just a lucky number. LML your my absolute favorite asoiaf contact creator. Quinn is also awesome but your deep knowledge of historical myth is right up my ally and you crush it. I was a history majorly study mediterranean in biblical archaeology so all of this is just so amazing. Thanks for being amazing. 🎉
oh okay well that explains it! Mediterranean history, awesome! Have you checked out my other channel, Mythic Concepts? Or the video called "Eve Did Nothing Wrong" on this channel?
If i remember correctly, there's nights watchmen built /burried into the wall--sentinels -- maybe its not sentinels as in soldiers but sentinels as in trees and its green men/chikd of the forest spirits in the trees that were sacrificed to build the wall--built with the "help" of children of the forest
Elden Ring has alien life forms coming to the lands between via meteorites and it is included in those beings the one that created the Erdtree Network 😂
Great video! I think the Nissa Nissa figure in the Renly's death scene is Brienne. She has the moon and sun in the banner and later on she is given Oathkeeper (long night symbol) by Jaime aka the lion of night. What do you think David?
i think she is the last hero, picking up the sword from the green men / children of the forest, but she does do moon maiden stuff sometimes. it’s like a before / after
"shadow baby kisses. Hey Jon Snow" lmao I wish I could remember which video you said that in, because I laughed my ass off! I think you're awesome. I like your calm, weird AF demeanor. And you're smart AF too
I'm wondering about the symbolic significance in Catlyns exchange right before our Shadow Man enters the scene. The exchange starts with time running short, prompting Catlyn to recall a promise made by the green man. He cedes, and has a sort of bossing up transformation moment as he's putting on his helm as if hes in some sort of true or magically pure form or like hes tapped in to the powers and their now active, followed by a sort of challenging statement saying "now we see who is stronger." Then BRIENNE gets on her KNEES to "BUCKLE ON HIS BELT" that's heavy with the weight of SWORD (what a strong seed). This is as Catlyn is watching, then she starts begging in the name of the mother, followed by the entry of the shadow baby. Catlyn interprets it as the kings shadow, since we know Shadow is baby I'm thinking of interpreting this like the spawn produced when Brienne got on her knees just then, though I'm not sure if that works alongside the Shadow baby canonically being Stannis's azor again figure's. Of course the Shadow baby carries out the slaughter of the green man. I guess I have a lot of thoughts on this section as its so clearly allegorical but the one driving this comment the most is Catlyns recalling of a promise to the green man followed by a good old sexy time and how this might relate to the prince who was promised. Who is catlyn symbolizing here, and did the green men promise that person a prince? Did something go wrong with the prince? Are azor ahai and the promised prince definitely the same? Im seeing azor as like the prince who was supposed to be promised but was botched and when hes "reborn" the internal struggle would be like between untapped access to power and responsibility over its use + over keeping men out and away from abusing it. Like discipline, taming of man's baser impulses type themes. Catlyn calls the green man out on the promise made to her and then the Shadow baby comes in almost like it could be on behalf of Catlyn though maybe not necessarily at her bequest, or maybe the Shadow baby interests are third party to the catlyn green man exchange and is interrupting, angered by the promise between them perhaps. I'm definitely getting both the nights queen and Nyssa Nyssa murder story out of this but I'm just curious about the promise made by the green man. is it dual symbology or was a magical baby or some other promise made by the magic side? Sorry if this is all over the place, thoughts anyone?
Sorry to just pop off with such a long comment but there's more. Like we know the seed is strong with the green man, but he says now let's see who is stronger before Brienne gets on her knees. And when Azor ahai invades the net it's like man's immoral assumption of power that isn't supposed to be theirs, which hunger for power is like a very human urge albeit on the ugly side of things. So it's reading to me like man wants power and the green men are down to give it to them if they can act right, but man has this internal struggle between good and evil to put it in easy terms and the children produced from the union keep using it irresponsibly and shit, unfit to uninvade the net if you will, and the prince who was promised will be one that is able to uphold both ends of a bargain where man can have a little access to their wierwood net through the three eyed raven maybe because it benefits reasons both green men and man if there was someone in the government of man who could reliably and actually provide institutions of political accountability amongst lords, which the three eyed raven can if he overcomes his very human draw to power and self interest or even accidental bias/ignorance prone to man. We know that Bran becomes king in some sense by the end and the genuinely solid political utility provided by three eyed ravenry in the development of institutions is understated. Like the fact that he is both three eyed raven and king of westeros whatever that ends up looking like in the books by the end are two hugely significant roles and themes of the book running together and the fact that kings were once princes seems to all work together for me. I have more thoughts on Brans youth in Northern political culture where institutions based on honor are already much stronger than they are in the South , cripples bastards and broken things, and blood raven as a precedent that should all be included in this comment but this is turning into an essay. This has been my impromptu theory on how bran may well be the prince who was promised.
i think Cat would be playing the NN role, like Mel, since they are parallel characters, and that fits with Cat seeming to call in the shadow. There is a possible pattern of green men selling NN to AA, or offering her up - check out Greenbeard taking Arya "the golden squirrel" to Beric Ahai
The real theory is that Martin wrote these incredibly dense books filled with foreshadowing, symbolism, and references to mythology with no intention of finishing. Thus forcing us to be the critical readers our HS English teachers wanted.
I'm so glad this channel exists! All the time and effort, plus so many streams, videos and podcasts! I definitely spend my free time bingeing, but have much further to go...😅 Some things are still a little confusing about Azor Ahai. Was he one man or representative of a civilization or group of people? Like was he a stand-in for the Great Empire? Did they do something terrible to a group of people who could seek retribution magically? Did AA's creation of Lightbringer stem from the Comet impact? (Like was Lightbringer the actual impact)? Did AA /GE have knowledge of the impact & purposely omit that information in order to benefit in some way (magically, geo-politically, etc.)? Also, why infiltrate the Weirwoods? Is it like a horcrux thing, where something important was distributed & stored in the WW to guard it against those seeking to destroy it? And of course, the ultimate question: why are there Others? If they are like the sidhe/ fae, then they might have always existed in the liminal. They seem sentient and capable of planning. But then why come forth a second time thousands of years later? These videos always generate questions I didn't know I needed to ask. And seeing things I never knew were there. I wish more ASOIAF content creators delved deeper into the symbolic. So thank you so much for your in-depth analysis, which is as meaningful as it is revelatory!
seeing your bird only strengthens the urge to get a raven like mormonts or a hawk. i so wish i could i travel in time i just wanna come storming down into a valley mouned at the head of a mongolian horde with a huge hawk perched on one forearm sword in the other hand hair flowing in the wind screaming into battle. thats why the dothraki is my favorite fighting force for all their savagery and lack of tactic, i love their culture cause not much has changed with them. they still go from city to city and collect. unlike the ironborn tho they held that mentality over the ages. i still say if khal drogo had lived and the dothraki were capable of adjusting to different methods of battle, like how the mongols adapted siege engines and catapults and scorpions as they conquered theyd been unstoppable. another thing is in the books ALOT more houses had siege towers nd catapult and the like. in the show they acted like scorpions were new but in the book ser rodrick and house manderly had all the siege tech. IT SUCKS! they lost to the boltons the way they did. that was so... ehhh i hated that i wanted rodrick to take winterfell back but i guess thatd take away from jon taking it back.
I agree with what you say Lml, but I am wondering if this scenario also could parall another event in the ancient past. Two brothers are fighting. Two Stark brothers perhaps? One Lord of Winterfell and the Night's King? Or is it The Amethyst Empress and the Bloodstone Emperor?
Or when the Night's King took power, and took control of the original Green Watch, there were other green men still around, in other places, gathering an army to take him down? Is that what the Last Hero did perhaps? 🤔
yes, to your last! There are def green men around to fight back - think of Renly's troops who fled back to the Reach to reorganize and then take KL at the Battle of the Blackwater. They are the children who help the last hero in that part of the story. I think that NK AA is the dragon person, and NQ was the original Stark. But Brandon Breaker / LH could be the son of AA, making him both, it's hard to say. The Daynes deserve mention too, they are from the line of the Am Empress, it seems. A LH Dayne could be both Stark and "dragon," being a Dayne / GEOTD dragon
Perhaps a long shot but when you mentioned green men and Nissa Nissa being sacrificed together, perhaps Renly is still the green man but Nissa Nissa symbol would be Brienne and Melissandra. Though neither physically died, in Brienne was the anguish and Melissandra the ecstacy.
i think Brienne might actually be the last hero figure here, picking up the sword of the green men and swearing vengeance on NK AA. She has much of the same symbolism as Jon, post transformation stage. Brienne is a lot like Lyanna as the Knight of the Laughing Tree - Lyanna is the NQ and her costume of a tree knight represents a last hero / weirwood warrior type. She plays both roles but for symbolism, the KOTLT is like the child of NQ. That’s Brienne I think
In the interest of "Comments help the channel" here's a comment. Thanks for all the work you're putting into each and every stream. Thanks, also, for making me aware of the song "Ampersand" (which I tweeted to you about, idk the other day). Finally, I would urge you to listen, if you've not done so, to a favorite album of mine: it's called "Hawaii Part II" by Miracle Musical, released in 2012, it's approximately 42 minutes long. I wish you well in all things, and looking forward to the Dunk and Egg livestream today! Much love ♥
Wait a minute. Doesn’t it make more sense that azor ahai was trying to force nissa nissa’s soul into a dragon, and the dragon is named lightbringer, a flaming sword of the morning? Maybe that was the origin of dragon riding ? Using a child of the forest in a sacrifice ? By an anacoenf hero of house Dayne?
The weirwood trees are afraid of fire. Ghost of High Heart says so. “Nor do they love the flames,” / “And they remember when the First Men came with fire in their fists.” So the dragon men were among the first to come, and they burned the weirwoods from the start. They had a burning sword in their fists. The Others got a load of chyt to get off their chest.
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
"I have altered the Weirwoodnet. Pray I do not alter it further." - Azor Ahai
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
comment of the year!
😂😁
😂😂😂
Lol. Nice.
LML is the G.O.A.T of Asoiaf content. Promise you'll never stop posting awesome videos my man! Praise Garth
I love in deep geek but the best video he ever put out is the one the mentioned LML. That dude probably doesn’t Praise Garth, it would ruin his silky voice.
@@Matt-xc6sp I love in deep geek too and I totally agree that man's voice is as silky as they come
@@Matt-xc6sp I prefer our lil devil
Agreed. In Deep Geek and Preston Jacobs are pretty enjoyable too
My little brother is now reading the asoiaf books after I recently twisted his arm to watch GoT and lml with m. Praise Garth did all the work
When all the books for Asoiaf is done, I really would love to see David get to speak to GRRM to ask how much he got right.
hopefully the books will answer that question
@@DavidLightbringer have you seen vampire the masquerade Caine and Lilith I think the BS emperor was the Caine of the asoiaf world and the tiger woman/ night queen /his sister was the Lilth/ Abel of the tale
Hopefully we’ll all be alive to see those books get finished.
Also, he's already had questions personally answered by Grrm. That's a neat story.
@@Ash.Crow.Goddess he has?
The videos and lore have kept this series alive for me. And it’s my favorite modern fantasy series.
I really do think that it’s channels like this, and the online community we have built, that are keeping the book hype alive. It’s now been 13 years since the last book came out, and the ending of the show kinda sucked, and yet we are all still so hyped for the next one! The publishers and Grr Martin better sponsor all of these channels when the next book comes out, and they better pay well!!!
You should watch all the Elden Ring lore videos because it is riddled with all the stuff LmL talks about and it was created by GRRM and one of the best fantasy lores ever made
"Who is the leader of the others?" Cleo flies down on cue and poses to look fabulous. Well, I guess we have our answer. 😅
The Pink Dread strikes again! 😂
While I absolutely love the long interactive live streams I know everyone is not able to take the time to enjoy them fully. These shorter videos with analysis and theories on one specific topic are going to get a lot of attention. You are, as always, fascinating and entertaining. More and more people are noticing!
So true!!
Even if all of LML theories turn out to be wrong it’d just show the brilliance of GRRM writing skills , world building and knowledge of so many different historical and mythological events and LML ability to take all of GRRM writings and weave a very plausible theory with about a 100 hours worth of content that back those theories !!! Keep up the hard work for us Myth -Heads!!!
Honestly loving this condensed overview of the weirwood net invasion theory! Would absolutely love it if as time goes on and theories are developed you dropped some summary videos like this one 👌
I certainly now put more stock in the theory because of Elden Ring that GRRM did which had loads of stuff with a tree network
Regarding oak trees. In Europe, most forests had originally mostly contained oak trees. But the Celts had cut them down to make use of them. Later mainly beech trees would grow since they grow much faster. So the oak forests had been corrupted by beech trees after the oak had been cut down by men.
I don't know whether to kiss you or curse you for getting me thinking about these books like this again. This is all phenomenal stuff. Normally wouldn't comment much but you've been saying it helps the channel so here you go.
I'd completely forgotten I had done that Virgin Mary style Nissa Nissa art 😂. Great video ✌️
🤣🤣🤣
Awesome video. Your comments on Stannis' shadow baby being a "shadow clone" of Stannis himself made me think that perhaps the original Azor Ahai/Night's King has a similar relationship with the Others. Like they are collectively the fractured remains of Azor Ahai.
yes, i think so. they’re ice dragons
I must say, you do really have a staggeringly comprehensive take on the whole picture set up by, and, more importantly, underneath, this epic narrative old Mr. Martin has presented us with. I swear, the man should give up on his ever more obviously taxing efforts to complete his great work and just reach out to you to take up the task of finalizing the concluding chapters of his creation. You’ve got as clear a grasp of what’s going on, or what should go on, with it all, as the man himself…if not a clearer one, by this point!🤔😆
i appreciate that sentiment very much, but of course explaining something and writing something are two different (though related) undertakings. he’s already written as many words as are in ADWD for TWOW, but he’s got a few more chapters go. who knows what he may have rewritten… but it sounds like he’s coming down the home stretch and feeling more positive
I like the touch that Renly's crown is decorated with jet amidst all the horns/leaves motifs in his get-up, since jet is a smooth black stone that comes from fossilized wood. To get the stone, wood changes under extreme pressure. (Insert parallels to the motifs in David's theories about the green men, transformation, shadow babies, etc). Blackness added upon green and gold...it's a nice costuming detail that could be a random stone choice that fits the vibe but also works as an unintentional or intentional reference as a bridge between the stag/woodland/forest motifs (the before state of the land and more primal culture ties to jet's original state of wood) and the stone structures later built by the regional kings and leaders. It is a different reference to a black stone than obsidian (dragon glass, associated with the Others and volcanos, ice and fire) and the oily stone structures. It also teaches us that the Westerosi use the term jet for that stone, so we can't chalk up the material of those oily black stone structures across the world to simply being a vocabulary mix-up and that they are likely a separate material than normal jet from normal fossilized wood. Could be cool if they were some kinda freaky eldritch jet. I would laugh so hard if the oily black stone idea came from GRRM's inkjet printer malfunctioning and he got this idea for a weird, inky, jet and remembered the odd stones from Lovecraft.
loved this thank you
So... looks like Theon Greyjoy was the "Nissa Nissa" of season 8. The Night King sacrificed him beneath the Winterfell weir wood. Also did you notice that when the Night King "died" (in the show) he shattered into ice bits that he melted into the ground beneath the weir wood! My first thought was that he was entering the weir wood network.
Lmao what a let down was that finale
While watching I remembered that the Limes, the great wall the Romans built along their border in Germania, they started with a wooden construction, some wooden towers and later a wooden palisade. Only later they constructed a great wall out of stone ... so it's not unlike the Wall in Westeros, where first wood and Greenseers like guards in wooden towers watched over the border who were replaced by a great wall...
Just my thoughts on that topic xD
These edits/videos are getting so good. More of this plz. Unfortunately I don't always have time to listen to the original streams. Great work.
This video format is perfect for my add/adhd brain, lol. Thanks for this super clear explanation with incredible art! Love it, David! ❤ Idk if it's just me but ASOIAF is the most complex stories I've ever read, and then tried to really understand so I'm grateful for the delivery!Always impressed by your big brain 😊
I loved revisiting this stream, it was a very interesting one to begin with. Everyone should watch the entire stream! ✨
What up sis? Its your big bro Chadro!
I watch this dude too!
You know I'm down with ASOIAF!
Small weirwood net girl!
Loved The Wall parallel to Renly’s Tent and the Weirwood at the NightFort. Can’t wait for more analyzation through these chapter reads. Very stoked for the Dunc POVs and your interpretation of those events and what they may foreshadow. Cheers
So good! Concise, beautiful. I always found it difficult to wrap my head around the entire theory, as it's multi faceted and complex. This video finally got me all the way there. Bravo 👏 👏
Your Green Man series is one of my absolute favorites. Thank you, David for your continued work! Very appreciative!
Your comments re: the weirwood possibly originally being an oak tree + the death of the greenseer creating an “opening” for corruption to enter the net reminds me of the Arianne chapter from AFFC where kings guard knight Ser Arys Oakheart (Oak heart tree?) is killed by Areo Hotah. See Arys is “corrupted” when he breaks his vows and has an affair with Arianne, who turns him, bends his will to serve her own plan to place Myrcella on the iron throne.
"(The Emperor) Elagabalus was a priest in an obscure cult in Syria that venerated a black stone meteorite - a culture that would have been deeply strange to the Romans."
Intrigued by Mel's role here in 'creating' Azor Ahai, given that she will also play a role in Jon's resurrection.
Glad to see that your channel is doing well, I remember when you were still trying to get 15k subs. Thanks for the theories and awesome commentary David!
Appreciate the editing and added art of this condensed livestream. Great work 👏
hi! I've been following your channel for some time, and I there's still no video I didn't enjoy (: I admire how deeply you study the text and the mythology behind it, all theories are so interesting and you make it easy to follow the trail of thought in them. not to mention the visuals! there's clearly so much love and care you put into this channel, thank you, it's always a delight to see new videos pop up.
also I rewatched this video today and it got me thinking.
if we have direct allusions that the green men were slain for this sacrifice, for Nissa Nissa we have things like: "her spirit went into the sword of light" and "her scream broke the moon and brought down the meteors".
but another interesting thing relating to Nissa Nissa you brought up here is "death by childbirth".
1) Nissa Nissa and the Night Queen seem to be thematically connected/dual figures, like Azor Ahai and the Night King.
2) in your Night Queen video you propose that she was some kind of an ice witch (like Melisandre is a fire witch). and she "conceived" the first white walkers from the Night King, but they are just shadow-clones made from his life force. and it's just like Melisandre made the shadow-clones of Stanis.
here I see the a sort of eco of this theory: Nissa Nissa's death somehow allowed Azor Ahai's shadow to enter the weirwood net. so we have him "piercing her with a sword", and this act allowing him, or his "shadow" to enter the weirwood.
and here we come back to the begining -- Catelyn remembering that her mother Minisa died in childbirth. so, did the same or similiar ritual happened with Nissa Nissa? "scream of agony and ecstasy" still works in the parallel with Melisandre this way. even if it has terrible connotations now, since it is highly debatable the "ritual" was consensual. Maybe Nissa Nissa died because it wasn't?
3) again, the ritual Melisandre did took Stanis's life force to make his "shadows", and he became weaker for it. and in Azor Ahai legend it's the opposite -- he took Nissa Nissa's life force away to make himself stronger. life force here is also the metaphor for the soul. and Nissa Nissa's soul is, as we suspect, connected to the spirits of the green men in the weirwood net. that is why her death helped banish them from it, right?
so, maybe here the ritual is fully reversed, perverted. he is forcing himself on Nissa Nissa, and having her bear his literal or shadow-clone child -- mixing in blood of the green men with human and/or forging the link to the race that can control the weirwood. and through that connection he can possess the weirwoods and expel the spirits of green men to be "white shadows" of themselves.
4) in couple of your videos, you discussed how according to the tapestry in the s2 of HoTD and the s1 song, we may assume that the 3 heads of the dragon are: the dragon, the rider, and the spirit of some ancestor of the rider living in and being passed down his dragon's bloodline. and this makes dragons and people next of kin, and helps to establish the bond.
4.1) Azor Ahai was, most likely, a dragon lord of the past. So, with all the parallels, we can assume he may have tried to establish the same sort of link with the weirwoods. Put his own spirit in them, or the spirit of his family member. Or, since we're talking about 2 different races here, just having a human or demi-human spirit in the weirwood net could open it up to all other people? I'm just spitballing here, idk.
4.2) but the tapestry of forging the dragon bond does invoke the strong Azor Ahai parallels, with the woman being sacrificed (by the sword), and her spirit being put into a "fiery vessel". on the tapestry it is a dragon. in Azor Ahai legend it is a "sword of light".
remember how the other metaphor for a comet/meteor that we know is "a red sword"? a sword of fire, you can say. and, once again we come back to the start: Nissa Nissa's scream broke the moon. or, even better: the moon kissed the sun, and the moon broke, died, "birthing" the flaming swords/dragons that fell on the earth and started the Long Night. the Azor Ahai put his sword in Nissa Nissa and it came out carrying her spirit, alive with it, like a child.
the "birth" and "bloodline connections" seen to be very important here.
4.3) if Nissa Nissa carried the actual, not shadow-clone child of Azor Ahai while she died, did he use his connection to the child's spirit to enter the net with it? or the child survived? it there a chance that it was not the Azor Ahai that became the Night King, but this child instead? the shadow of Azor Ahai (literal or not). the sword aflame with Nissa Nissa's spirit, that took part in the corruption of the weirwood net. the greenseer leader of the night watch. the sacrifice to the others, one might even say. it fixes the timeline heresy a bit, at the very least.
or it's the other way around, and the child actually is the Last Hero -- the flaming sword that Azor Ahai forged through terrible sacrifice, to enter weirwood net. and he ended up slaying his dad who became the Night King. still the prince that was promised to the others. and not delivered.
ah, this was a long one. idk if it all makes sense. maybe it was all said before even! :"D but I just couldn't stop thinking about the parallels.
Bird flying into your hand right then felt pretty climactic, I half expected it to unveil the big reveal lol
George watches these videos and takes notes
I swear you put more thought into a single video than D&D put into the last three seasons of GOT. Love your theories and all the worldbuilding. Keep being awesome.
In what way do you think Stannis "later" dreams the murder. I thought he literally committed the murder in the dream, essentially warging the Shadow Baby, and his denial was such that he believed it to be a dream.
Really glad to get this summary analysis on the weirwoodnet invasion
While I tune in for live streams, sometimes my friends who loved the series are intimidated to join. These videos are perfect for sucking them into your weirdwood net 😂
Exactly! 😎
I’m very new to this, but I heard/read (probably from LML) that the oily black stone may be the result of the petrification of the Ebony/Nightshade trees. They produced ancient monumental structures by using the wood of the black trees, then “enchanted” it with magic, petrifying it and giving it its oiliness and cementing its magic properties. Maybe the Wall (very similar to the 5 Forts) was built with a similar magic but using Weirwoods instead. Normally when something is described as oily, I think primarily of it being slick by touch, but oily can also describe something that shimmers with slickness. A shimmering slickness would be a good way to describe the Wall, “alive with light”.
Maybe weirwoods and Nightshade trees were the same/similar until Azor Ahai changed the ones in Westeros by evicting the Green Seer spirits from them. Azor Ahai fought the evil in the East successfully and built the Forts, then went to the Western borders of mankind and tried to do something at the Arm of Dorne, but didn’t work, so he fought on further to the Neck, which also didn’t work, then tried for a final time at the Wall, which only partially worked as the Weirwoods were a little different to the Ebony he used successfully in the East. The Wall is a sticking plaster rather than a final solution like the Forts. The wood of the Weirwood was used to build the Wall and spirits of the Green Seers were sacrificed to enchant it, with the White Walkers being spirits that were able to escape being sacrificed and seek revenge on humanity.
Superb art choices as per usual, good sir.
The rowan tree is seen as the tree of protection, particularly against witches and enchantment.
Superb work. This spells it all out so clearly, even when I've watched most of your other videos!
David always brings some good ASOIAF deep lore and some smooth bass!
That transition at 2:23 creeps me out so much 😭😭😭
Great recap once again. Thanks for all you do.
Hi David, I don't know if you've already raised this point since I last read your essays, but have you ever looked into the "Wormwood" prophecy from the Book of Revelations? Here's the relevant verse:
"The third angel blew his trumpet, and a great star fell from heaven, blazing like a torch, and it fell on a third of the rivers and on the springs of water. The name of the star is Wormwood. A third of the waters became wormwood, and many died from the water, because it was made bitter." (Rev 8:10-11)
Of course there are the obvious parallels between the bloodstone meteorite and Azor Ahai as the source of the weirwoods, as well as the third trumpet call and the three attempts to forge lightbringer. But what isn't so obvious is that "wormwood", a plant used to treat intestinal worms, is from the Artemisia family of plants, and that Artemis is the Hellenic precursor to Diana, a Roman moon Goddess.
Perhaps this is the founding myth of a fiery comet begeting a tree that has moon symbolism that GRRM reinterpreted and we'd to his own mythos. It's one of the few precursor myths we've been missing so far. Most of the other mythical events in asoiaf seem to have had a basis the myth of our world.
Anyway mate, keep up the good work. Hope you are well.
i do see the parallel and yes I have in one very old essay looked at some of the “mythical astronomy” in Revelation - there’s quite a lot of it! But here specifically we’re talking about turning the waters bitter, and that compares well to poisoning the green see. Remember we talked about how brackish waters are part of this via Bracken and Bittersteel? How the Brackens poisoned the weirwood? The bitter, brackish water is a symbol of the corrupted wwnet. And then we have Bloodraven the wyrm in the wood - he’s playing that symbolic role of a dragon who’s invaded the wwnet, which was originally Azor Ahai’s thing
@@DavidLightbringer those are such interesting parallels. Good job on the whole "brackish"/"Braken" connection too. I really can't wait for these ideas to come together in Winds.
I wonder if Nissa-Nissa was actually a Green Woman or "of the Green Men" (Woman seems more fitting than Man imo). It would explain the "Tiger Woman" depiction from Yi Ti since, like you said in the theory about Ned Stark's "Old Ones", the Old Ones/Green Men lived on Leng, and I don't remember if you say so but I believe that the Green Men are close relatives of the Children of the Forest, perhaps even the first mixed offspring of CotF and humans. Maybe Nissa-Nissa was some kind of Lengi Green Man royalty and the excuse Azor Ahai gave for marrying her was to unite the bloodlines and empires of the Great Empire of the Dawn and the Kingdom of Leng's Green Men. Only, Azor Ahai really just wanted access to the incredibly magically powerful blood of the Green Men royalty. There is power in king's blood after all, which he used to call down the Moon Meteors™, accidentally or otherwise, and bring on the Long Night. Perhaps Azor Ahai was taught about the Weirwood Net by Nissa-Nissa or a relative of hers, planting the seeds in his head to bust into the WN in the first place
I think she was a green women too and yes that has to be tiger woman. these stories are all mixed up but the characters are important
@@DavidLightbringer Awesome! Keep up the good work, without your theories I think I would have gone mad from waiting for TWoW 😅
As much as I enjoy these videos (and, to be clear, I'm not even taking the piss here, I really do enjoy them), it sometimes feels like the stereotypical conspiracy theorist who has newspaper articles pinned to his walls, and 826 metres of red string linking words all over the place. You probably are right about a lot of things with the symbolism, but one wouldn't want to get carried away with it too much.
It's like that old joke, wherein the book says that the sky was blue, and your English teacher expects you to write a fifteen page essay about how the blueness symbolises the melancholic depressivity of the chapter, whereas the author actually just meant to simply remark that the sky was literally blue.
Loving this new format.
Love the condensed livestreams 🎉
Love all the content keep killing it!
I don't think the weirwood trees could have been anything other than a species of maple. They're the only trees I know of with leaves like five fingered hands. And some have crimson leaves, while others have sap that runs more freely. I wouldn't be surprised if there's even a white barked species I can't think of right now. They also can grow quite wide with age.
Good stuff LmL.
Have you read Elden Ring's story? Because George wrote the universe, I see alot of similarities with comets and meteors brining both ruin and arcane horrors. A great primal tree that's taken control of by a wielder of said arcane horror, and that same man that corrupted the world is remembered as a hero, a warrior that all should strive to be like. In a surprising turn of irony his son spends his undying breath keeping the influence of the stars at bay, heralding events similar to the one that granted his father such power.
There's so many similarities I'd recommend a dive on your free time
I really love your theories, and all this about Azor Ahai, Nissa Nissa & the Weirwoodnet and green men!! IT makes so much sense!! And once more :Thank you LML, you are not crazy 😄💪🙌Please do more of these summaries about your therories, as other also mentions :I think even more people will have time to watch your incredible theories and content ✌️🫶🐉🔥and Praise Garth, ofc ✌️
Always here to support your incredible (and minblowing) channel!!!! can you PLEASEEE do a scripted video of the parallels of the dance of dragons with the long night and also a symbolic review of the world of ice and fire and where these parallels show?
Damn! I forgot how gruesome and harrowing reading this chapter for the first time! Harrowing, Intense in the most incredible way
Always love your videos!
@David Lightbringer love the PP art! We’ll done. For the uninitiated you would want to include more about Bloodstone & connections. “Alive with light” Catelyn 1 the crystals in the Winterfell Sept. thoughts?
Such an amazing video!!! 🔥
Hey daddy. I’m going to start reading the books this week! In huge part because of your content. Since you’re creating more varied video lengths now I had a couple of examples you could play with on a shorter format. You could create guides on how to read the books (tips on symbolism, recaps, main plot points) and also character profiles
I honestly enjoy your videos more than the books❤😂
Excellent video ! great way to start the day ! Praise Garth and the Greenmen
Thankyou for this great summary!
I just started watching GOT a year ago, I’m always late to some great shows. My daughter got me watching promising I would love it. Honestly and sadly it took Ned losing his head to get me interested and still can’t get enough. I found LML, Grayarea, Quinn’s Ideas and a few others to listen to and love it. The breakdown ,foreshadowing and theories are wonderful. I’m so glad y’all add so much to the show and books. Keep it coming 😊❤
Love you David!
Azor Ahai / comes with the dawn and the weirwood net means Azor Ahai = Morning Wood
The one part of this theory that I can’t get past is nights king invading the weirwood net and then leaving to join the others- who he’d just evicted from it so that he could have its power. That part doesn’t make sense. Why go through all that trouble to get into the weirwoods only to remove yourself from it to lead the beings that you just kicked out? It seems more likely that Azor/ nights king remained in the weirwood net and the others are attacking because they want it back.
Don’t get me wrong, I love your theories and channel as a whole, this is meant constructively. The others don’t seem to have access to the weirwood net, so Azor caused the long night, invaded the weirwood net, left and took over those he’d kicked out of it, and then led them south to attack mankind because….??? What’s the motive for the war?
Thanks for the video, bro 👍
Literally just opened my youtube to this to have a wake and bake omg the seven are smiling upon me
I don't get married to specific details/symbols much, but I do buy into the idea of the "weirwood invasion."
In fact, as a clarifying idea, I think R'hllor *IS* Azor Ahai, whether that's an individual or a group/council of individuals from the Great Empire. Whether it involves the invasion of the weirwoods specifically or another avenue was found to manifest in the warp/veil/spiritual realm, doing so caused a cosmic apotheosis that created a god, or god-like entity. And it's very reasonable to believe that this act caused some turmoil with the existing occupants which caused The Long Night and birthed the cursed people now known as The Others.
I think *that* is what informs the final "Song of Ice and Fire." It isn't Jon's parentage, as I think bloodline power is built up to be a red herring. Instead I think the real song is Jon's resurrection as a "fire wight." As such, he will be touched by R'hllor and, consequently, act as a proxy to Azor Ahai/Great Empire to put the two ancient enemies back together. And I think Alt Shift X has the right of the ending, which is a peaceful resolution that brings balance to the seasons, in this case using Jon as a proxy to bring reconciliation to the spirits which schismed those 10,000 years ago.
yeah i mean that’s a very general description of the ending, but it’s correct - this story is all about reconciliation. of the Others to the trees, first and foremost. Jon Dany and Bran will all facilitate this. as for the ice and fire yea it’s not limited to one thing, it’s an expression of the harmony of opposites ideal which again goes back to reconciliation
@@DavidLightbringer Yeah. I guess that was me as an old man yelling obvious things at clouds. 😅 Probably also goes to show that I actually *am* married to at least one specific idea (Azor Ahai=R'hllor) and would love it to tie into the generally accepted closure. Sorry for getting a bit obtuse there.
Yassss! This stuff is fascinating and super awesome! Thanks LML
LML read Lord of Light by Zelazny! You actually said Mahasamatman the other day. The audio version is good if that's your style. It's got everything! Kali and Durga, The Alchemical Wedding, Jon being taken over by Nights king. There's so much. I hear you state a theory of yours and I'm just like well that's basically what happens in Lord of Light!
i’ve read half of it and yeah, clearly a HUGE influence
Zelazny is one of my favorite authors and deserves so much more notice than he receives.
Can we get an updated overview of your theories, involving the green and first men, the cosmology, and the god emperor etc?
All these subtopics are so nebulous and only spiralled over the years. Would be great to tie it all together oncemore.
yeah i did two theory icebergs a couple years ago, i’m due for another
@@DavidLightbringer you the realest 👑
@@DavidLightbringer the gods of vaylaria are the gemstone emperors however here’s the plot twist their were not 9 god kings but 14
if the bloodstone causing the others to wake up how can they fight until the north of westeros? when all the man still in the dawn continent? can anyone explain the timeline? if the hero fighting the second long night? who defeated the first long night?
This is exactly the video I needed
Fantastic work. Thanks
im curious who ended the first long night if azor ahai supposedly started it?
On the green tent wall bit. Made me think there could have been a huge hedge before the ice wall. hedge rows are kinda green walls.
Thanks David great insight as per usual, cheers form Aus
So I had to like the video but it was at 777 likes but I had to hit it. 777 is just a lucky number. LML your my absolute favorite asoiaf contact creator. Quinn is also awesome but your deep knowledge of historical myth is right up my ally and you crush it. I was a history majorly study mediterranean in biblical archaeology so all of this is just so amazing. Thanks for being amazing. 🎉
oh okay well that explains it! Mediterranean history, awesome! Have you checked out my other channel, Mythic Concepts? Or the video called "Eve Did Nothing Wrong" on this channel?
Rewatch binge 🎉
If i remember correctly, there's nights watchmen built /burried into the wall--sentinels -- maybe its not sentinels as in soldiers but sentinels as in trees and its green men/chikd of the forest spirits in the trees that were sacrificed to build the wall--built with the "help" of children of the forest
well that story is def a symbolic parallel to all this
Elden Ring has alien life forms coming to the lands between via meteorites and it is included in those beings the one that created the Erdtree Network 😂
Great video! I think the Nissa Nissa figure in the Renly's death scene is Brienne. She has the moon and sun in the banner and later on she is given Oathkeeper (long night symbol) by Jaime aka the lion of night. What do you think David?
i think she is the last hero, picking up the sword from the green men / children of the forest, but she does do moon maiden stuff sometimes. it’s like a before / after
@@DavidLightbringer It is a before/after thing!
When Brienne calls out "your Grace" it's cut off, and especially the way you read it sounds like Ygritte, who is another Nissa Nissa figure...
oh wow haha
"shadow baby kisses. Hey Jon Snow" lmao I wish I could remember which video you said that in, because I laughed my ass off! I think you're awesome. I like your calm, weird AF demeanor. And you're smart AF too
I'm wondering about the symbolic significance in Catlyns exchange right before our Shadow Man enters the scene. The exchange starts with time running short, prompting Catlyn to recall a promise made by the green man. He cedes, and has a sort of bossing up transformation moment as he's putting on his helm as if hes in some sort of true or magically pure form or like hes tapped in to the powers and their now active, followed by a sort of challenging statement saying "now we see who is stronger." Then BRIENNE gets on her KNEES to "BUCKLE ON HIS BELT" that's heavy with the weight of SWORD (what a strong seed). This is as Catlyn is watching, then she starts begging in the name of the mother, followed by the entry of the shadow baby. Catlyn interprets it as the kings shadow, since we know Shadow is baby I'm thinking of interpreting this like the spawn produced when Brienne got on her knees just then, though I'm not sure if that works alongside the Shadow baby canonically being Stannis's azor again figure's. Of course the Shadow baby carries out the slaughter of the green man. I guess I have a lot of thoughts on this section as its so clearly allegorical but the one driving this comment the most is Catlyns recalling of a promise to the green man followed by a good old sexy time and how this might relate to the prince who was promised. Who is catlyn symbolizing here, and did the green men promise that person a prince? Did something go wrong with the prince? Are azor ahai and the promised prince definitely the same? Im seeing azor as like the prince who was supposed to be promised but was botched and when hes "reborn" the internal struggle would be like between untapped access to power and responsibility over its use + over keeping men out and away from abusing it. Like discipline, taming of man's baser impulses type themes. Catlyn calls the green man out on the promise made to her and then the Shadow baby comes in almost like it could be on behalf of Catlyn though maybe not necessarily at her bequest, or maybe the Shadow baby interests are third party to the catlyn green man exchange and is interrupting, angered by the promise between them perhaps. I'm definitely getting both the nights queen and Nyssa Nyssa murder story out of this but I'm just curious about the promise made by the green man. is it dual symbology or was a magical baby or some other promise made by the magic side? Sorry if this is all over the place, thoughts anyone?
Sorry to just pop off with such a long comment but there's more. Like we know the seed is strong with the green man, but he says now let's see who is stronger before Brienne gets on her knees. And when Azor ahai invades the net it's like man's immoral assumption of power that isn't supposed to be theirs, which hunger for power is like a very human urge albeit on the ugly side of things. So it's reading to me like man wants power and the green men are down to give it to them if they can act right, but man has this internal struggle between good and evil to put it in easy terms and the children produced from the union keep using it irresponsibly and shit, unfit to uninvade the net if you will, and the prince who was promised will be one that is able to uphold both ends of a bargain where man can have a little access to their wierwood net through the three eyed raven maybe because it benefits reasons both green men and man if there was someone in the government of man who could reliably and actually provide institutions of political accountability amongst lords, which the three eyed raven can if he overcomes his very human draw to power and self interest or even accidental bias/ignorance prone to man. We know that Bran becomes king in some sense by the end and the genuinely solid political utility provided by three eyed ravenry in the development of institutions is understated. Like the fact that he is both three eyed raven and king of westeros whatever that ends up looking like in the books by the end are two hugely significant roles and themes of the book running together and the fact that kings were once princes seems to all work together for me. I have more thoughts on Brans youth in Northern political culture where institutions based on honor are already much stronger than they are in the South , cripples bastards and broken things, and blood raven as a precedent that should all be included in this comment but this is turning into an essay. This has been my impromptu theory on how bran may well be the prince who was promised.
i think Cat would be playing the NN role, like Mel, since they are parallel characters, and that fits with Cat seeming to call in the shadow. There is a possible pattern of green men selling NN to AA, or offering her up - check out Greenbeard taking Arya "the golden squirrel" to Beric Ahai
I was there for the original stream but still love the condensed recaps as my ADHD brain tends to wander 😂
The real theory is that Martin wrote these incredibly dense books filled with foreshadowing, symbolism, and references to mythology with no intention of finishing. Thus forcing us to be the critical readers our HS English teachers wanted.
Ashai looks like Pittsburgh in the 70s.
This gives me the same vibes as Kazuya chakra god being a thing at the end of Naruto lol
This channel is so random, it usually just plays in theback ground but all of a sudden i flip back and now theres a bird?
I'm so glad this channel exists! All the time and effort, plus so many streams, videos and podcasts! I definitely spend my free time bingeing, but have much further to go...😅
Some things are still a little confusing about Azor Ahai. Was he one man or representative of a civilization or group of people? Like was he a stand-in for the Great Empire? Did they do something terrible to a group of people who could seek retribution magically? Did AA's creation of Lightbringer stem from the Comet impact? (Like was Lightbringer the actual impact)? Did AA /GE have knowledge of the impact & purposely omit that information in order to benefit in some way (magically, geo-politically, etc.)?
Also, why infiltrate the Weirwoods? Is it like a horcrux thing, where something important was distributed & stored in the WW to guard it against those seeking to destroy it?
And of course, the ultimate question: why are there Others? If they are like the sidhe/ fae, then they might have always existed in the liminal. They seem sentient and capable of planning. But then why come forth a second time thousands of years later?
These videos always generate questions I didn't know I needed to ask. And seeing things I never knew were there.
I wish more ASOIAF content creators delved deeper into the symbolic. So thank you so much for your in-depth analysis, which is as meaningful as it is revelatory!
THE EDITING AT 21:00 GOT ME GOOD LMFAO
seeing your bird only strengthens the urge to get a raven like mormonts or a hawk. i so wish i could i travel in time i just wanna come storming down into a valley mouned at the head of a mongolian horde with a huge hawk perched on one forearm sword in the other hand hair flowing in the wind screaming into battle. thats why the dothraki is my favorite fighting force for all their savagery and lack of tactic, i love their culture cause not much has changed with them. they still go from city to city and collect. unlike the ironborn tho they held that mentality over the ages. i still say if khal drogo had lived and the dothraki were capable of adjusting to different methods of battle, like how the mongols adapted siege engines and catapults and scorpions as they conquered theyd been unstoppable. another thing is in the books ALOT more houses had siege towers nd catapult and the like. in the show they acted like scorpions were new but in the book ser rodrick and house manderly had all the siege tech. IT SUCKS! they lost to the boltons the way they did. that was so... ehhh i hated that i wanted rodrick to take winterfell back but i guess thatd take away from jon taking it back.
I agree with what you say Lml, but I am wondering if this scenario also could parall another event in the ancient past. Two brothers are fighting. Two Stark brothers perhaps? One Lord of Winterfell and the Night's King?
Or is it The Amethyst Empress and the Bloodstone Emperor?
Or when the Night's King took power, and took control of the original Green Watch, there were other green men still around, in other places, gathering an army to take him down? Is that what the Last Hero did perhaps? 🤔
yes, to your last! There are def green men around to fight back - think of Renly's troops who fled back to the Reach to reorganize and then take KL at the Battle of the Blackwater. They are the children who help the last hero in that part of the story.
I think that NK AA is the dragon person, and NQ was the original Stark. But Brandon Breaker / LH could be the son of AA, making him both, it's hard to say. The Daynes deserve mention too, they are from the line of the Am Empress, it seems. A LH Dayne could be both Stark and "dragon," being a Dayne / GEOTD dragon
Perhaps a long shot but when you mentioned green men and Nissa Nissa being sacrificed together, perhaps Renly is still the green man but Nissa Nissa symbol would be Brienne and Melissandra. Though neither physically died, in Brienne was the anguish and Melissandra the ecstacy.
i think Brienne might actually be the last hero figure here, picking up the sword of the green men and swearing vengeance on NK AA. She has much of the same symbolism as Jon, post transformation stage. Brienne is a lot like Lyanna as the Knight of the Laughing Tree - Lyanna is the NQ and her costume of a tree knight represents a last hero / weirwood warrior type. She plays both roles but for symbolism, the KOTLT is like the child of NQ. That’s Brienne I think
Have you ever noticed the parallels in the legendary story by Oscar Wild, Dorien Grey? It very much opens your eyes. That's for sure.
i’ve never read that one
What is it? Dorian Gray looks like that he sold his soul to devil for to be eternal young Dorian Gray is older than Count Dracula Vlad.
In the interest of "Comments help the channel" here's a comment. Thanks for all the work you're putting into each and every stream. Thanks, also, for making me aware of the song "Ampersand" (which I tweeted to you about, idk the other day). Finally, I would urge you to listen, if you've not done so, to a favorite album of mine: it's called "Hawaii Part II" by Miracle Musical, released in 2012, it's approximately 42 minutes long. I wish you well in all things, and looking forward to the Dunk and Egg livestream today! Much love ♥
Another excellent video 👌
Wait a minute. Doesn’t it make more sense that azor ahai was trying to force nissa nissa’s soul into a dragon, and the dragon is named lightbringer, a flaming sword of the morning? Maybe that was the origin of dragon riding ? Using a child of the forest in a sacrifice ? By an anacoenf hero of house Dayne?
Yes! I think that is one meaning of the story!
Interesting! You may be on to something.
I’d love to hear David’s take on the new “fan art” covers for Winds and Dream releases by Ertac Altinoz…
i did in one of the QnA last week, we broke it down.
The weirwood trees are afraid of fire. Ghost of High Heart says so.
“Nor do they love the flames,” / “And they remember when the First Men came with fire in their fists.” So the dragon men were among the first to come, and they burned the weirwoods from the start. They had a burning sword in their fists. The Others got a load of chyt to get off their chest.