You missed the entire story of how Razakars massacred Hindus! My own family members fled and saw how Hindus especially women were treated and slaughtered by Razakars.
I'm from hyderabad, we have been celebrating it for few years. Even TRS and MIM ended up taking flag march. Anyway credit goes to BJP because they raised this issue and started celebrating it on 17th Sep, other parties ended up joining so they won't end up portraying themselves as anti national.
@@yj9032Bro it happened because of BJP Mr KCR is not ready to acknowledge the day ,He don't want to anger Mr owaisi It's bjp who started celebrating this day unofficially Public stated questioning mr kcr Then he came around Bjp is the first party to hoist flags on this day
The same army killed poor people who are fighting aganist landlords Then Congress government backed those landlords who sucked the blood of Telangana farmers Common people of Telangana fought hard aganist them but Sardar Patel sent army aganist those poor souls and gave back the lands to landlords
After reading both Guha’s and Vikram’s book I came to conclusion that Savarkar’s biography part 2 by Vikram Sampath sheds a better light on the events and the situation of people at the time.
We Hyderabadis know about razakars and the terrible crimes they committed and how hindus were terrorized by the nizam during 1940s, and how nizam wanted to join Pak. Nizam even funded pak
It’s not ‘Bit of both’. - if Hindu women were forced to do naked dances on the streets if they had to celebrate their festivals - it’s oppression and racism that Sardar Patel fought!!!
@@Pranav_K_Menon Just saw your reaction to my comment. How can you judge about my clue based on just one of my comments. Please listen to all his CTC on south especially and come here to see the ground realty to see how far it is from the truth
Many kings of Central India also tried to stop freedom for their people. Odisha kings willingly joined India, infact most were almost proactively part of independence story. That is what makes me proud of Odia kings.
Leave it to liberal media like SG, Aakar Patel, Barkha Dutt, Shoba De along with liberal politicians would have created this hole in India’s heart anyway. I heard horror stories from my Dad and Grandparents about Razakars, nobody denounces it nor we mourn what happened.
If Minority is king, he will rule. Same thing happened in Kashmir.
9 месяцев назад+5
You should do a piece on the integration of Travancore to Indian Union. It was in the southern tip of India. The interesting part was, the Dewan of Travancore had similar delusions like the Prime Minister of Nizam. He wanted an independent Travancore. More interesting, the Dewan of Travancore was a Tamil Brahmin called Sir. C.P. Ramaswamy Iyer.
Nizam was made governor of Hyderabad whereas Maharaja Hari Singh was called to Delhi and asked to be in exile for six months but he was never allowed to come back to J&K till his death on 26.4.1961. His son brought his ashes back.
At 25.40 mins you said Sardar Patel was a Shrude person who sent the Army..!!.. In fact he was one of the very few Nationalist during that time who had the guts to oppose Nehru in National Interest.. So Please rectify yourself and apologize..!!.. Otherwise the whole narration was good..!!..
The point is that while the Congress Party portrayed a picture that India got Independence with nonviolence and civil disobedience the BJP on the other hand brought out that it was not correct and for freedom many Indians sacrificed their lives and many women lost their honour( due to raping, killing and dismembering of bodies etc). That is why this sort remembrance day etc. Sardar called the action against Nizam as police action simply because he never recognised as a separate state from the Union and there was no provision that the princely states declare their Independence, as they have option to choose join either India or Pakistan. Sardar did not want another Pakistan in the middle of India and called union's action as police action so that the Indian Army is not looked upon as agressor agsinst an Independent state led by Nizam and the forces were sent to control the riots etc. But one thing is clear that Sardar had some sort of influence in the Army which he utilised bring control of Nizam and throw Pakistani intruders in Kashmir.
Islamic colonialism was much much worse to India than British colonialism, but some selfish individuals totally avoid talking about this bitter truth of Indian History.
Mr. Truth_hurts, you seem to be incapable of accepting 'what happened' and continue to live in 'it should have been like this' illusory world. You can't even distinguish between invaders and settlers. You are a typical hindutvavadi, completely devoid of intelligence. For you, hatred is life.
Mr Faker Gupta,stop ranting randomly and selective information which your bosses are pleased to hear,why don’t you put facts about the atrocities of Razakars,
I am a Hyderabadi from the present Andhra Pradesh. I was in the College when the Police Action happened. I don't think it should be celebrated now at all because we forgot all about it and I think it is better that way.
@@simpleperson5364I think he alludes to the brutal events that happened in many parts of Hyderabad State. Lot of village goondas used the context for doing horrible things here and there. Government lack of capacity to manage these misbehaving goonda peoples will be openly acknowledged through these celebrations. Most politicians of that time recognised that Hyderabad integration to India can have been done more peacefully, like Nehru originally conceived. Outside the Pakistan backed Razakars who virtually took the power in the kingdom, Nizam themselves haven't been negative towards India, and in fact despised Pakistan and the Muslim League.
That wasn't massacre of Hindus by Razakars or Muslims but massacre of Telugu people by Non Telugu occupiers, hence it was a great day for Telugu people who were freed from non Telugu occupiers. Indeed it was a liberation day for Telugu people.
SG never disappoints to be a pseudo not telling the atrocities of razakars he was much focused on later repercussions of that atrocities what a waste......
All the negative marks bjp is getting the electoral bonds, playing with the appointment of the chief election commission officer, is getting compensated by positive marks like abolition of article 370, CAA, unknown gunmen on a supari hunting spree in erstwhile India etc. wondering in what a deep security mess the Congress party had left India with. Reebok nahi toh rebook sahi - China nahi toh pakistan hi sahi. Some sort of cleanup of the security mess is happening.
Sir, what single line jistification for 'integration' was there in this episode -"Some Congressmen furled Indian Flag in Hyderabad". What a Justification. Indian Govts, in collaboration with media, has since beginning tried to appease Islamists instead of Justice.
Razakars were milita of Nizam they were not against Hindus but against communists..ask who were the martyrs of Telangana uprising it was mostly yes the godless communist..it was against the landlords and Nizam so do no that no Hinduthva figure died during the uprising or subsequent police action and after that the army protected Hindu landlords and Nizam and Razakars subsequently many Hindu landlords became Congress leaders and HM Patel Made Nizam then Governor of Telangana and most Razakars went to Pakistan ..wow what a liberation by army..
I always respected SG even while aware of his leftist leaning. Today I realised SG is a big MC &BC. He conveniently ommited the horrible attrocities committed by Muslims on Hindus.
There are few uncertainities in this presentation. 1. Is it Goddard plan or Operation Polo. Are Plan and Operation different. 2. Nehru said "force will be used", is unbelievable, as Patel had to time it, without knowledge of Nehru, is well known 3. Originally it "was", MIM and not AIMIM. Please do not whitewash the disreputable roots of Owaisis. 4. Ram Guha, is another Left leaning historian. Please do not quote him. There are much better historians of Hyderabad. 5. You did not elaborate atrocities committed on hindus, but talked about Sunderlal commission, which was roundly rejected. Hindus lack the guts, vengence unlike muslims.
sir nice told... to kniw history is now important to let us know that the army mkilled muslims and us biased. but wgen itcimes tomoghuls....we should accept and move further...wah kya baat hai
Mr Gupta you havent saod a word about the mahyem and bloodshed Razakars under Kasim Rizvi & MIM did on Nizam's express appproval, did on the rural hindu populace which sowed the seeds of distrust till today !!! It was horrendous and you are giving some fake figures from a discredited repprt of post liberation. Did not expect this misinformation and cover up from you.
Typocal of modi's nonsense to win electoral dividends. This guy is too desperate and too self-centered to be good for the nation. Time he was thrown out.
*Those people who want to know about real life in Hyderabad state and the facts about rebellion against Nizam I advise them to watch the semi documentary movie "Maa Bhumi 1976" which is available on RUclips with English subtitles*
Sir you have beautiful way of whitewashing muslim excesses. When you could state hindu excesses why not state that the razaakars were killing hindus for years. But then hindu deaths don't matter in independent india😊
No one ‘liberated’ Hyderabad. People of the Hyderabad state won their independence through armed uprisings led by communists. Indian army came in the end and took all the credit just like how BJP is taking credit now.
@yj9032 bhenchod, BJP is giving credit to Sardar Patel for Hyderabad. Patel was a Congresswala (one of the few decent ones). How does that equal to "BJP taking credit"? BJP didn't even exist in that era. Also, the rebellion against the Razakars was useless. They wouldn't have gotten shit done unless the Indian Army intervened.
Surprising he didn't mention role of Communist party .he not a real left wing person, it was Communists that liberated Hindu people in Hyderabad state in1947. Really great September 17 Hyderabad Liberation Day. Actually All Hindus of Hyderabad Nizam was unified by not Congress or BJP rather by The original Communist Party of India which spearheaded armed peasant rebellion against Muslim militia called Razakars.
![KSI - Dirty [Official Visualiser]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VoDh1h1dPUE/mqdefault.jpg)
You missed the entire story of how Razakars massacred Hindus! My own family members fled and saw how Hindus especially women were treated and slaughtered by Razakars.
uske baad general chowdhury ne aukad dikha diya😂
Current President of Congress Mr. Kharge's parents and grandparents were arsoned by Razakars.
Razakars massacred Telugu people, Razakars were non Telugu people who had occupied the Telugu heartland.
Secularism ko shekhar bhigadne nahi dega, vo uska vo zinmedari hai jo vo khudpe daala hai 😅
Why should I trust you?
I'm from hyderabad, we have been celebrating it for few years. Even TRS and MIM ended up taking flag march. Anyway credit goes to BJP because they raised this issue and started celebrating it on 17th Sep, other parties ended up joining so they won't end up portraying themselves as anti national.
These BJP wallas want to take credit for everything 😂
Actually it’s only after the BJP announced that TRS and MIM started it (and call it integration day). Before that TRS talked about during T movement).
@@yj9032they just announced...they are not khangress who take pride in 1962 china war
@@yj9032Bro it happened because of BJP
Mr KCR is not ready to acknowledge the day ,He don't want to anger Mr owaisi
It's bjp who started celebrating this day unofficially
Public stated questioning mr kcr
Then he came around
Bjp is the first party to hoist flags on this day
MIM is the same razakar party
it is not integrated without blood but Indian army took over. IT IS VIJAY DIWAS.
The same army killed poor people who are fighting aganist landlords
Then Congress government backed those landlords who sucked the blood of Telangana farmers
Common people of Telangana fought hard aganist them but Sardar Patel sent army aganist those poor souls and gave back the lands to landlords
Getting part of country under hostile regime united to India would be counted as liberation what else u Call it
Imperialism😂😂😂😂
After reading both Guha’s and Vikram’s book I came to conclusion that Savarkar’s biography part 2 by Vikram Sampath sheds a better light on the events and the situation of people at the time.
What situation?
Big deal?
We Hyderabadis know about razakars and the terrible crimes they committed and how hindus were terrorized by the nizam during 1940s, and how nizam wanted to join Pak. Nizam even funded pak
why are you guys removing comments
Coz these people at Print are all Mullas in disguise.
They are khangress di*k Suckers... You didn't know 🤡
It’s not ‘Bit of both’. - if Hindu women were forced to do naked dances on the streets if they had to celebrate their festivals - it’s oppression and racism that Sardar Patel fought!!!
Yes on Dushehra 😢
Okay
*From their father arab to neo converts they always love to surrender* 😂
@dark-footagefukin khangress Dick rider... Sucking INDIs nipples 😂
@dark-footage actually its ur ami who r rap by mughals and forced to pay jizya and become mleech
@dark-footage ham logo ne to convert nahi kiya lekin tere ancestor ka pura dingdong hua aur tu paida hua😂😂
ab chuslim kon slave pata kar😂
@dark-footage jinke ancestor rap hua us main tu aata hain,ab kon *slave* tha smjha??
@dark-footage exactly i gave u example who is the sla..
impact to bohot bura hua hain spelling tak thik se likh nahi pa reho😄
You talk less about South and even if you do it's far away from the truth and you refuse to be realistic.
Your being as clueless as Shekhar is about hindus... Tell what you hate in what he told.. Don't just squabble like khangress
@@Pranav_K_Menon Just saw your reaction to my comment. How can you judge about my clue based on just one of my comments. Please listen to all his CTC on south especially and come here to see the ground realty to see how far it is from the truth
How did Nijam inherit land 😂😂😂, they occupied or bought it 😂😂😂
Bought it. 😂😂😂😂😂 Like all Hindu UC Zamindars all over India😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@sauron2000000 oh is it, thank you, your knowledge is valuable, btw which country did they come from
@@chanakyabharat756 Ummm India.
@@chanakyabharat756 They followed the same principle of might is right.
@@sauron2000000 oh is it , are you sure , I'm sure you think Babar is also from India
Hyderabad Day Reminds Us of the Dark Past and No one Got Punished
Many kings of Central India also tried to stop freedom for their people. Odisha kings willingly joined India, infact most were almost proactively part of independence story. That is what makes me proud of Odia kings.
Names?
Lol...😂😂... first read history and then comment
Leave it to liberal media like SG, Aakar Patel, Barkha Dutt, Shoba De along with liberal politicians would have created this hole in India’s heart anyway. I heard horror stories from my Dad and Grandparents about Razakars, nobody denounces it nor we mourn what happened.
I heard horror stories of Hindu atrocities on Muslims too
@@sauron2000000 Please cite some that were started by Hindus
@@nabhinayyam Nellie
@@nabhinayyam Silapathar. Hindu vs Hindu. Zero Muslim
@@nabhinayyam Hashimpura
Lesson in history how a small minority rules over a divided majority
If Minority is king, he will rule. Same thing happened in Kashmir.
You should do a piece on the integration of Travancore to Indian Union. It was in the southern tip of India. The interesting part was, the Dewan of Travancore had similar delusions like the Prime Minister of Nizam. He wanted an independent Travancore. More interesting, the Dewan of Travancore was a Tamil Brahmin called Sir. C.P. Ramaswamy Iyer.
Excellent narration 🎉
We need a Follow Traffic Rules Day, Civic Sense Day and Swacchata Divas
that shud be everyday of the year,.
Yeah, you do that
Nizam was made governor of Hyderabad whereas Maharaja Hari Singh was called to Delhi and asked to be in exile for six months but he was never allowed to come back to J&K till his death on 26.4.1961. His son brought his ashes back.
At 25.40 mins you said Sardar Patel was a Shrude person who sent the Army..!!.. In fact he was one of the very few Nationalist during that time who had the guts to oppose Nehru in National Interest.. So Please rectify yourself and apologize..!!.. Otherwise the whole narration was good..!!..
It was not communal situation, it was massacre of Hindus by Razzakars
@dark-footage AFSPA is to control muslims n separatists
True to leftist style he omits what was done by Razakkars to Hindu Families.
Highly biased video.
The point is that while the Congress Party portrayed a picture that India got Independence with nonviolence and civil disobedience the BJP on the other hand brought out that it was not correct and for freedom many Indians sacrificed their lives and many women lost their honour( due to raping, killing and dismembering of bodies etc). That is why this sort remembrance day etc. Sardar called the action against Nizam as police action simply because he never recognised as a separate state from the Union and there was no provision that the princely states declare their Independence, as they have option to choose join either India or Pakistan. Sardar did not want another Pakistan in the middle of India and called union's action as police action so that the Indian Army is not looked upon as agressor agsinst an Independent state led by Nizam and the forces were sent to control the riots etc. But one thing is clear that Sardar had some sort of influence in the Army which he utilised bring control of Nizam and throw Pakistani intruders in Kashmir.
Sound quality of video is improved😊
Islamic colonialism was much much worse to India than British colonialism, but some selfish individuals totally avoid talking about this bitter truth of Indian History.
Are you retarded
Mr. Truth_hurts, you seem to be incapable of accepting 'what happened' and continue to live in 'it should have been like this' illusory world. You can't even distinguish between invaders and settlers. You are a typical hindutvavadi, completely devoid of intelligence. For you, hatred is life.
Whats the point of re-uploading this video? I remember watching it last year. Are you trying to take advantage of the CAA notification?
Gentle correction:Suryapet is now in telangana.
I welcome this celebration as Nizam's golden period will be refresh in minds of Indian nation .
I don’t think Nizams dominion included parts of Tamil Nadu.
Correct
Superb narrative full of details I did not know till now Best wishes to Guptaji RKS
This is good to see the mention of Ram Guha's book which I have translated into Hindi as "Bharat Gandhi Ke Baad and भारत गांधी के बाद
The last 2 minutes were unnecessary. In the effort to appear unbiased, anti-Hindu views are included.
Integration happens without violence. Liberation means victory over resistance.
Mr Faker Gupta,stop ranting randomly and selective information which your bosses are pleased to hear,why don’t you put facts about the atrocities of Razakars,
Because you can read about that in books.
@@sauron2000000you cry in comments arguing for the flying flase underwear flying from Muslims and your father lol
Because you think delhi is india and india is delhi
I am a Hyderabadi from the present Andhra Pradesh. I was in the College when the Police Action happened.
I don't think it should be celebrated now at all because we forgot all about it and I think it is better that way.
Present AP? It's in Telangana you dumb
Why do you want to forget the brutal history???
@@simpleperson5364I think he alludes to the brutal events that happened in many parts of Hyderabad State.
Lot of village goondas used the context for doing horrible things here and there. Government lack of capacity to manage these misbehaving goonda peoples will be openly acknowledged through these celebrations. Most politicians of that time recognised that Hyderabad integration to India can have been done more peacefully, like Nehru originally conceived. Outside the Pakistan backed Razakars who virtually took the power in the kingdom, Nizam themselves haven't been negative towards India, and in fact despised Pakistan and the Muslim League.
@@simpleperson5364 chill he isn't even from Hyderabad, Telangana. He's from caste obsessed AP
Forgot bout it ? You don't belong to Bharat. You belong to Turkey or Arabian Peninsula coz you are too stupid to even think
That wasn't massacre of Hindus by Razakars or Muslims but massacre of Telugu people by Non Telugu occupiers, hence it was a great day for Telugu people who were freed from non Telugu occupiers. Indeed it was a liberation day for Telugu people.
telugu hindus. the razakars dnt go after telugu muslims
stop imposing yr sickular narrative.
Excellent history refresher
Hyderabad toh jhaki hai Lahore and Kasuri abhi baaki hai😂
Antarctica bhi baanki hai. Wahan bhi Jain Mandir banega aur killer whales ghaas fuus khayega😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Dont forget east pakistan
Bangalore water crisis needs a de clutter
Thank god it did not get article 370
Thanks
Amazing
SG never disappoints to be a pseudo not telling the atrocities of razakars he was much focused on later repercussions of that atrocities what a waste......
All the negative marks bjp is getting the electoral bonds, playing with the appointment of the chief election commission officer, is getting compensated by positive marks like abolition of article 370, CAA, unknown gunmen on a supari hunting spree in erstwhile India etc. wondering in what a deep security mess the Congress party had left India with. Reebok nahi toh rebook sahi - China nahi toh pakistan hi sahi. Some sort of cleanup of the security mess is happening.
Sardar is/ was Sardar. No doubt.
Pure and simple, it was massacre of hindus by razakars, SG lies
Sir, what single line jistification for 'integration' was there in this episode -"Some Congressmen furled Indian Flag in Hyderabad". What a Justification. Indian Govts, in collaboration with media, has since beginning tried to appease Islamists instead of Justice.
Complete nonsense. Your lack of brains shows.
Thanks BJP....I am from the same place, my grandmother has told the horror stories they have gone through under razakars..
Razakars were milita of Nizam they were not against Hindus but against communists..ask who were the martyrs of Telangana uprising it was mostly yes the godless communist..it was against the landlords and Nizam so do no that no Hinduthva figure died during the uprising or subsequent police action and after that the army protected Hindu landlords and Nizam and Razakars subsequently many Hindu landlords became Congress leaders and HM Patel Made Nizam then Governor of Telangana and most Razakars went to Pakistan ..wow what a liberation by army..
I always respected SG even while aware of his leftist leaning. Today I realised SG is a big MC &BC. He conveniently ommited the horrible attrocities committed by Muslims on Hindus.
Specifically, Yemeni.
22:06 He went to Pakistan and became a beggar!
Hmmmmm!
Thats normal, isnt it?
Liberated more like occupied 😂😂😂
Please do an episode on razakars and passing on MIM to Owaisis
Interesting facts
Why their is not a committe investigate the massacres of Hindus by razakars muslims.???
Is this is not appeasement policy of nehru chcha.
Haidrabad mukti sangram was going on for many more years .
Sekhar sir will come up with apex ultima paint that razkars are peaceful Loving and poem writing people in order to be in good books of pseudo
The dude needs to invest in a teleprompter
There are few uncertainities in this presentation.
1. Is it Goddard plan or Operation Polo. Are Plan and Operation different.
2. Nehru said "force will be used", is unbelievable, as Patel had to time it, without knowledge of Nehru, is well known
3. Originally it "was", MIM and not AIMIM. Please do not whitewash the disreputable roots of Owaisis.
4. Ram Guha, is another Left leaning historian. Please do not quote him. There are much better historians of Hyderabad.
5. You did not elaborate atrocities committed on hindus, but talked about Sunderlal commission, which was roundly rejected. Hindus lack the guts, vengence unlike muslims.
The call to attack Hyd nizam must have been Patels. You make it as if Nehru also initiated..I don't think he was in favour being so pessimist.
Is MIM the ancestors of AIMIM
Yes
Secularism ko shekhar bhigadne nahi dega, vo uska vo zinmedari hai jo vo khudpe daala hai 😅
Katappaaaa
Communalism se india maili ho gayi
Secularism se nehla do
(Feel to yahi waali aa rahi h dekh kr )
sir nice told...
to kniw history is now important to let us know that the army mkilled muslims and us biased.
but wgen itcimes tomoghuls....we should accept and move further...wah kya baat hai
Cruel Rajakars!
At this age of urs u still wisper lies
Mr Gupta you havent saod a word about the mahyem and bloodshed Razakars under Kasim Rizvi & MIM did on Nizam's express appproval, did on the rural hindu populace which sowed the seeds of distrust till today !!! It was horrendous and you are giving some fake figures from a discredited repprt of post liberation. Did not expect this misinformation and cover up from you.
Typocal of modi's nonsense to win electoral dividends. This guy is too desperate and too self-centered to be good for the nation. Time he was thrown out.
Average pseudo liberal mindset
*Those people who want to know about real life in Hyderabad state and the facts about rebellion against Nizam I advise them to watch the semi documentary movie "Maa Bhumi 1976" which is available on RUclips with English subtitles*
Ram Guha book !! Bundle of lies
Sir you have beautiful way of whitewashing muslim excesses. When you could state hindu excesses why not state that the razaakars were killing hindus for years.
But then hindu deaths don't matter in independent india😊
Europeans always want to do business..
The traitor muslims
bad programm.
not awaited from you.
Right winged is your new stamp since 2 years.
No one ‘liberated’ Hyderabad. People of the Hyderabad state won their independence through armed uprisings led by communists. Indian army came in the end and took all the credit just like how BJP is taking credit now.
And, the Razakars handed over their arms to communists to fight feudal rulers later on.
Bjp is not taking credit...they are announcing it as an day!! Avg khangress bhakt
@yj9032 bhenchod, BJP is giving credit to Sardar Patel for Hyderabad. Patel was a Congresswala (one of the few decent ones). How does that equal to "BJP taking credit"? BJP didn't even exist in that era. Also, the rebellion against the Razakars was useless. They wouldn't have gotten shit done unless the Indian Army intervened.
Surprising he didn't mention role of Communist party .he not a real left wing person, it was Communists that liberated Hindu people in Hyderabad state in1947. Really great September 17 Hyderabad Liberation Day. Actually All Hindus of Hyderabad Nizam was unified by not Congress or BJP rather by The original Communist Party of India which spearheaded armed peasant rebellion against Muslim militia called Razakars.
NIJAM WAS AN OUTSIDER. COPTAJI DO NOT MAKE COPTA
STOP GLORIFYING LEHRU CHACHA HE IS THE SOLE RASON MANY OF INDIA'S PROBLEM TODAY.
Hyderabadi l@n$00 no way lagi