As Ajit Doval 3.0 begins, a look at IB, RAW, intel titans & how India’s NSA office evolved
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 июн 2024
- In an unprecedented event, Ajit Doval has been appointed the NSA for a third term. In Episode 1469 of Cut The Clutter, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta takes you through the establishment of a dedicated cabinet rank of the NSA, the most notable people holding this post, and how the post changed under different prime ministers.
Ajit Doval, R.N. Kao, many unsung spymasters & India's intelligence evolution: • Ajit Doval, R.N. Kao, ... -
The importance of NSA Ajit Doval's elevation to cabinet & India's security architecture: • The importance of NSA ... -
National Interest from 2018: theprint.in/national-interest...
01:30 Unprecedented third term for Ajit Doval
03:40 Establishment of the post of NSA
07:20 Notable incumbents
12:50 Evolution of Higher National Security Management
18:15 Response to national security issues under the different PMs
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
I had no idea that Mr. Ajit Doval is 79 years old. He hardly looks any older than 60 years. 😐
Maybe that's a myth too.
We Pahadi look like that only 😄
@@harishrajora6453😂
Bahu pahadi khun hein aise hi hote hai hum 😂
@@naveenjoshi09 yes you look like 79.
Timestamp 4:00: it took 50 years to realize we need a NSA because of the lack of vision of the gandhi family politicians. Don’t try to lecture us that India had to learn about internal and external security and diplomacy for 50 years. What Sardar Patel achieved in terms of uniting the princely states to India was a masterclass in diplomacy and therefore we already knew what internal and external security needs were. Congress has given us Foolish defence ministers like AK Antony who thought the best defence against China is to leave the ladakh region undeveloped. Deep gratitude to Atal Bihari Vajpayee ji and his government who had the vision of instating a NSA 🙌🏻. I can however never trust Shekhar Gupta to give an unbiased report. He’ll always be a congress stooge. The thumbnail of the video showed Ajit Doval 3.0 policy and SG has spoken about him less than 20% of the run time and would much rather give me birth and death days of rn kao and other congress ministers. Stop using clickbait Shekhar. Shame on your team. Crooks
Shhh... Stay quiet, or else you'll be regarded as hawk 🦅 one day.
He is a history narrator, talks too much on old time stories and too less on the issue at hand.
Congress was the worst thing that happened to our country without a doubt.
this is literally the third episode on Ajit Doval aur kitna screen time chahiye uske liye bhai
Shekhar Coup-ta for a reason
UPA always preferred their politics over national security. Not a surprise anymore
Stop spreading fake propaganda
14:28 14:29 14:34 ⁰⁰⁰😊😊😊
Look who is concerned about Indian National security, a guy with the channel name "Australian life lessons with Mahesh"
@@yj9032 How is that fake propaganda. Trying to Blame 26/11 on RSS (thank God kasab was caught alive ), trying to neogiate with terrorists Yaseen Malik, making the army villain of this country, Nehru selling off land to Chineese along with the UNSC seat. Stop with the Dhruv tatti University.
@@nonameo7727 Could I not be concerned about India regardless of where I live? Or are you guys now against the free speech? India and its National Security is pretty important for Australia as well considering China’s foreign policy.
UPA was a disaster in Internal security, External Affairs & Anti-corruption.
BJP is a disaster. What anti corruption has bjp done or gained anything in the global scale? We have gone down in world indexes for multiple categories.
@@ThisWorldOfPranj you believe in global indexes? We are currently unhappier than Palestinians.
@@ThisWorldOfPranjon a global scale ..india regained its fastest economy growth, with stability in government . Made manufacturing a priority with defence manufacturing impetus helped to forge long standing relation with many anti China countries . What was congress policy on manufacturing
@@psyayimwone Manufacturing as a percentage of GDP has gone down. India's share of manufacturing exports in the world has gone down. Domestic Savings and Investments has gone down some 9 Lakh Cr vaporised with rising inflation since 2019.
Multi Alignment policy rebrand of Non-alignment achieved nothing and disappointed everyone of our partners who all had higher hopes due to stupidity by MFA & Modi.
@@azankhan88 you just hate modi that his party don't like Muslim nothing else , your whole data is fake.
Mr. Doval is a jewel... combined quality's of civil admin and military know how.... A rare personality.... Best of wishes.... Keep our region safer ... God bless the India with it's Indo pacific.... Interests ....
ajit kumar doval is so old. they should get younger blood.
If you know how he mishandled the pathankot operation, and the whole china affair in june2020 you wouldn't be saying this "he is a jewel or military know how".
you know a lot about doval, please write a book on him
@@surajbiradar9827 ok abdul . Roger that
@@surajbiradar9827How did he mishandle the Pathankot operation ? Do you know the turf wars that went on during that op
NSA is one post where experience and man management matters the most. Modi govt has maintained continuity and given the right person the right responsibility. Also underrated are the reforms under Vajpayee who appointed NSA officially for the first time and did the nuclear test against all the external pressure.
When will you apologise for the wrong articles on Gen Singh? Kutta kahi ka. Buddha.
Ajith Doval is the Minister of The Unknown
exactly, where chinese are gifted with possessions!!
@@reganjoans by your Grandfather Nehru.
@@drarunselvakumar5009 so that moodi is pimping everthing off?
@@reganjoans you are speaking about your Father profession. Just because you grew up in a bordello it is unfortunate that you see every man as either pimp or your mother’s customers
Shekhar chcha started from 2005 ish and then back all the way to 1962 and then came back.. but he never reached 2020 .
This guy Shekhar gupta is a part of tukde tukde gang and likes of arundhati Roy. He provides cover fire to pseudo liberals just like the place he works at Hindu. With digital media evolution no one gives a two hoot about Shekhar gupta. These guys along with Pranav Roy are dying breed.
i fail to understand why people diss Shekhar ji .. this is his channel and he will give HIS opinions .. if u dont like it u can always listen to dhruv rathee or some other deuche bag 😆..learn to show respect instead of sitting in your phateechar chaddi baniyaan and being a troll
@@pumplove81HIS opinions are not talking at a private dinner - he’s putting them in public - thus opening himself for public comments. I’m not sure what’s wrong with it !!
Spot on! If he comments in public, he has to listen to the public too!
@@pumplove81are you writing this sitting ON your tuta charpayi...😂😂😂... Get a life.... He can Express and WE can critique His Expression...
Congress party under successive PMs never prioritised national security. Shivshankar Menon was an unmitigated disaster..exemplified by the debacle in Sharm-El-Sheikh and 26/11.
Dear Mr.SG, hope to see you interview Mr Doval one day. Earlier the better.
If you do do a interview, I hope it is a critical interview with difficult questions! If media can’t ask difficult questions, the country can’t move forward in the right direction as politicians have a free hand.
This Dalal won't get it, purel because of 0 integrity. He's the genius who did the hit job on Gen.VK Singh saying as COAS he was planning coup against New Delhi
@@markpatelrelevant questions. One can’t ask urban naxal question they don’t have love for your country
He may be so scared to do that...even to thin of it...
@@markpatel Relevant questions. Not some BS difficult questions like "would you support Modi's actions during Godhra riots?" that are handcrafted to peddle some narrative.
Ajit Doval came up nice strategy with offensive defense. I hope it’s never reversed. People should know their vote has impact. IK Gujral stooped all intelligence operations under Pak and India paid heavy price. Same goes for MMS his downsizing of security apparatus resulted in 26/11. The lessons for India never let the guard down.
Till 1998 there was no NSA appointed because from 1947 to 1998 most of the Govt of Congress were headed by Gandhi & Nehru clan & their approach to national & international security was lackluster. They always thought of family first & country next so national security was then not so important to be given any credence.
Mr. Doval was humiliated by UPA given his amazing track record and achievements - to say that they did him a favour by appointing him is stretching it - the NSA, Mr. Narayanan under UPA ensured that Mr. Doval did not get a extension and his tenure was only for 6 months as DIB. Anyway he has had the last laugh.
Please make video on post poll violence in Bengal
People commenting anything without even reading the Title properly. It has nothing to do with Ajit's coronation as India's James Bond but is about the EVOLUTION of NSA's office.
Had to wait till the last part of the talk to learn about Mr Doval!
Wanted a more detailed discussion just on him.
CTC is create the clutter when it comes to nationalistic issues
Shekhar ji ...the post is more a chronology of the officers than insights into their functioning and issues of intelligence .... I was more reminded of my school history teacher teaching me succession of Kings than what they did, how they ruled and what were the socio economic impacts
It falls much below your usual standards of journalism
This man Shekar Gupta has no knowledge simply makes foolish videos with catch phrases. Faltu time waste karta rehta hai
Agree this is well below par !!
@@highhousefoodmart2011 Why don't you take his place and show the great wisdom you posses? Seniore, a few lines of criticism on Social media makes all of us look very intelligent. It does not make us intelligent though.
Outstanding video Shekher saab.Thank you Sir.🙏
It won't take much time for the IAS empire to take over this position also
SG has phenomenal storytelling skills.He should take a masterclass on how to remember so many names, dates connected to different anecdotes along with their political significance 👏👏
My Heartiest Humble Blindfolded Respect to Mr. Doval, R&AW Personnel. 🙏
IFS, IPS, IFS: only in India this matters.
aayein
"Please make video on post poll violence in Bengal"
You have captured contemporary history of intelligence services finely. You should also do a CTC on how the national security agency itself functions.
We support Ajit doval...
Great analysis, Shekhar Gupta Ji ❤ Loved every bit of it.
What would be good succession plan?
Thank you, Shekhar ji.
This video is very informative for those who have keen interest in security related affairs. You took us on a short ride in d past.
Thank you for enlightening us! Vande Matram!
I can’t find the link to the earlier 2 episodes of CTC on Mr.Doval you referred to.Kindly guide how to find them.
You can find them in description
I cannot find it in the description. I can see only the link to an old “In National Interest “.Can you please help in locating the links.Thanks
SG mentioned it as National Interest, not sure if he said CTC anywhere in this episode
Good Information , shekhar ji
Ajit Doval Ji... Zindabad.
you can read Shekhar Gupta’s face when he talks about out two subjects 1 . KPS Gill SG if ever he has had an affair it would have been KPS gill and 2 if SG - had a soutan it would be Ajit Doval
Thank you sir😊
A bit interesting evolution of NSA / RAW since independennce.
Ajit Dhoval is such a brilliant Spymaster and our country's National Security Advisor 🤘🏻💯🇮🇳.
A Very interesting CTC SG!
Lots of history lessons..
Wonderdul learning from a veteran.
Wow !
It took us half a century to identify our internal and external enemies and to link our internal and external security.
Yes, we Hindus are slow and have a huge inertia of 1000 years of slavery.
😭
They need to become a cohesive turbo charged security apparatus.
Interesting Foot note to end the show..!!!
04:40 1947 is not our birth. India was not born on 1947. India is Sanatan
India the country was born on 1947. Nation is debatable.
India is an idea in our mind. The idea differs between persons. There are no borders in the real world.
india is 80 billion years old according to vedas
Bhai universe 14 Billion saal pehle bna tha. 🥲 aur Earth 4 Billion saal pehle. 😂
@@dheerajchoudhary4721 universe have been destroyed many times before by an Indian called shiva
NSA Well explained!👍
He created and maintains India’s biggest internal threat.
super historic representation 🙏
Thanks for good info.
First time I liked your blog
I needed an advice,
I have received the joining letter from IB as Junior Intelligence Officer Tech..
should I join?
the salary is half of what I'm right now (90 thousand -> 44 thousand)...
don't join , if you care for money. else you will end up as another resource using the position for making personal gain
If u join then don’t tell Shekhar gupta.
you'll prolly end up doing undercover works, risking your life for the service of the nation. Just as Manh said, don't join if you care about money.
44 par DA alag lagega Bhai 😂
@@amithabv1060 after DA is btaya, basic is 25000
As India becomes more prominent in the world, and our security needs and interests extend far beyond our border, look for more expansion of this position and other non-cabinet/appointment positions to increase. There is an ethos in the federal government, especially in the security and foreign services branches that the Cabinet level chiefs should handle all aspects of responsibilities that fall under their respective portfolio. We have to break that vertical power structure. There is a lot of value we are leaving on the table. The duties of the NSA, is an example of this. It is so important to spread out the duties and force agencies to focus with a narrow bandwidth so they get better at their purview.
That is his ability that's why he served various Govt
Very interesting... Thanks SG
The role of the NSA in the Indian context is an interface between India's intelligence agencies and the govt. of the day as well as the Indian National security face to the outside world.
There seems to be really a need for Indian cyber services (ICS), and some security officers taken from that now.
if such a thing did exist I would love try to be a part of it
There eventually would be need for this, but the thing is how much behind the we would be then.
Only such quality officers and patriots are dear to all well meaning politicians also.
You forget to inform that first NSA was created under Atal Bihari Vajpayee (BJP-lead NDA govt). Brajesh Mishra, then Principal Secretary to the Prime Minister, was appointed as the first National Security Advisor of India. The post was created on 19 November 1998 by then government headed by Atal Bihari Vajpayee.
Refreshing
Thanks!
Dear Arko,
Thank you for your kind contribution.
There must be some change in all important portfolios of govt.machinary.There are many excellent officers in our beurocracy,they must be given chance.
Primary job of IB was to keep an eye on political dissidents only, and still is.
More cluttered because of peripheral explanations and anecdots. Not to the point.
Almost like a college history lecture by Shekhar without any cogent explanation why an executive role which is given pseudonym of advisory role cannot be filled up with younger and more qualified people ..
Young people lack the experience as well as the ability to hold the post of the NSA. Not to mention a failure in most to see the larger picture.
Modiji's best decision in the 3.0 Show is continuing the Mr.Ajit Doval. Mr.Doval should allocate some time to resolve the long pending, challenging citizen cases that otherwise are not resolved by the local leaders or Cops. We have to leverage on your talents and Guts. No wrong in addressing them on request by the victims.
Next episode on the European Union election. Please
Hi Shekharji.. please make a video about Agniverr- is it a biggest foreign blunder, as china has a declining no. of youth joining forces this will be fulfilled by Nepali youth as they were snubbed b'coz of agniveer. this will give lifeline to China declining army problem and also their goodwill be bought among nepali society which till now was done through veteran gorkha of indian army. SHOULD INDIA GIVE EXCEPTION TO NEPAL TO COUNTER THIS ISSUE.
Nice posting...thank for the good news...
Excellent podcast by Shekhar truly in National Interest!! We are lucky that Doval has agreed to continue for one more term of 5 years.
A good peep into the evolution of Intelligence Masters of India. However I thought a review of the role of Ajit Dowal in successes and failures of national internal and external security should have been more appropriate, since we want to know why he is undependable to Modi ji. Don't forget Pulwama, Attack on Pathankot Sir Base, Chinese ingress in Ladakh Region, demeaning of civil society ( he called them as internal threat to be dealt with by IPS officers) etc all happened under his nose as NSA. The backlash on the relations with the US and Canada on the issue of clandestinely killing the US and Canadian Nationals who were Khalistan supporters, was his creations.
So we need more information on the activities of this guy, on whether he is doing his job well or not. Or he is just providing security and cover to the doings of Modi ji.
Super
Ajit Doval should use the third term as NSA chief to train some good people like hin
Sir aap hindi me kab suru kare ge
When I spent more than 20 mints, I expect something more important!
The Indian government official who escorted the hijackers to Kandahar during the Indian Airlines Flight 814 hijacking in 1999 was Ajit Doval, who is now the National Security Advisor of India!
Ok. You make it looks like he was the one who hijacked the plane and not the ISI.
He is credited with annexing a country wit India and also with putting Pakistan to it's place. Spare some time to let it sink it.
Do we really need politicians to run a government? As finance minister you have Nirmala Sitaraman, as EAM there is S.Jaishankar then you have Shri Ashwini Vaishnav as minister of Railways and electronics. The only exception among politicians who knows about his job is Nitin Gadkari. As for the rest to put it mildly are a burden. One thing that Modi has done right is to place the right men at the right place. Mr.Ajit Doval and P.K.Mishra are indispensable in his scheme of things given the security challenges all around. However time has come to groom a crop of young people to take over from these gentlemen including Modi himself for after all men are mortal.
Headlines: ajit doval
The actual video: NSA during congress
Watched the entire video. What did we learn? 🤔
Who wrote which book.
Thank goodness no IAS Babu has ever run the NSA. All they do is bring their endless bureaucracy and analysis paralysis.
without listing, much anticipated..
Sir R N Kao was “50” years old when he took over intelligence, not 15.
its very hard for THE PRINT to post something good about india
Dear @shekhar Gupta, I enjoy your u hyphenated journalism and really appreciate your efforts to bring clarity in the current muddled environment.
However, I want to give some feedback/suggestion.
In many of your episodes, there is too much stress on history and very little on the analysis of current events. Eg. in this episode 1469 about Ajit Dhoval, you have spent almost the entire episode on history of the chief security advisor position. I would have liked to know your views on what can we expect from the third term of Mr Dhoval, and hat are the challenges in front of him, and hat would be same or different compared to his past 10 year stint.
Can you spend more time on analysis of current events and less on history? I understand that sometimes history is important to understand but my request is to not make that as the central theme for the episode. Thanks.
Could you please comment on what has happened in Odisha?
UPA excelled in one area of Governance.
Conflicts leading to policy paralysis and autonomous ministries of the Union leading to plunder and loot !
😭
There are some well written books by authors like Mr. B Raman and others who were actually involved in the operation of the Sikkim merger. There is no mention of Mr.Doval's name in any of these books.He appers to have been actively involved in resolving the MNF insurgency in Mizoram.NSAs over the years have been generally effective but there have been major failures like not foreseeing the Kargil invasion, the Mumbai attack and the Pulwama tragedy which still remains a mystery. Mr. Doval is 79 years old. How can your own career be in sync with his?
Saw report an indian national has been extradited to the US from the Czech republic in the Pannu case (khalistan politics) and not looking good for AD 3.0. Whatever be the past good record now could be spoilt with some amateurish moves by IB / RAW etc ?
And lo ! Opposition says we will get rid of nuclear assests !! Gajab hai bhai
15.00 India lost war mainly because of politics who were at the ruling Shekharji ?
Hi SG, you have explained the evolution of the office of NSA, in the next video please analyse the contribution of Ajit Doval as a long serving NSA.
This guy is a Rouge agent involved in the abduction of a Dubai Princess illegally in international waters, to help in return UAE handed over Michel involved in Rafael case.
Also known to have shell companies.
04:45 Just watch what you said old man 😂😂😂
India needs to be more aggressive than the previous 10 years.
Who remember the NAC Sonia Gandhi, the "advisor" to PM Manmohan Singh.
What about 1857
What about all before
This is a great insight into the inner workings of the government of India.Hope to see more @ThePrint videos exploring how staff manages the country's administration.
There are some gaps in your analysis… when Pakistan got the nuclear bomb in Lop Nor… we were surprised and Pakistan started the intifada in Kashmir and the push in Punjab… it was PV who just kept his head down and weaponised by 1994…. 91 to 94 was a brutal clearance by the security forces… of Kashmir and Punjab…
Illustrated India by nandi
How is this guy still relevant?
Shekhar Gupta has been in the business of promoting Ajit Doval for the last four decades.
Moron 😂
Where is the machine that turns potatoes to gold? Hand me that first
@@akirachingsubam139ask jumlendra. He is the inventor
Iam searching for a man who used sewage line gas for tea making ..
🙏
Typical Congress hypocrisy and double speak on having 2 NSAs. Extremely poor security policy, internal or external.