The Quran: A Literary Miracle?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 окт 2024
- This video contrasts claims made by Muslim apologists with claims the Quran makes about itself and the first audience’s response to hearing it. The notion of a miraculous Quran that astounds Muhammad’s contemporaries and compels them to believe appears nowhere.
Videos cited: • Miraculous Qur'an • The Greatest Miracle o...
Most recent revision of the Free Resource is here: bit.ly/3QfN0no. My Patreon supporters make all this possible: www.patreon.com/islamcritiqued.
Let me take up your challenge...there are still jinn in Islam after hearing you. Alonzo Harris is one of them
God of heaven and earth Jesus Christ bless you brother 🙏✝️💐
@@solascriptura1536 Now that was seriously Funny 🤣🤣.. And yes I totally agree with you 😁
@@solascriptura1536 lol don't forget Safraz Hussain, although that could just be him using many different accounts.
@Thunderous One 😂😂👍👍👍
The last one is hilarious 👍👍
The Quran and Muhammad were so convincing that after he died so many Muslims left Islam that Abu Bakr had to go and fight the Ridda (Apostasy) Wars to "bring them back". He probably fought these wars by reciting the Quran to convince the apostates that it is from Allah, lol.
Apostate wars? So much to learn from mxhmeds madness
Muhammad won bcz of a traitor Zoroastrian Persian named Rūzbeh Khoshnudan this guy was a magi and also known Sasanid fighting tactics but later he was given an Arabic name which is Salman and he was known as Salman Farsi (Salman the Persian)
Millions have memorised the holy koran by heart, there is no compulsion in Religion sura Al kafiroon. Muhammad ( pbuh) bought the people out of darkness and in to light. Study his life please from being an orphan and his unmatchable character . He(pbuh) was known as the trust worthy so much that even the Jews would put their trust in him by letting him look after their valuables, money, etc. Please go and ask the scholars before you forward your opinions because as with many others you are deceiving many.
@@anwarsheikh7771 Memorizing a text has little to do with understanding it. How many of these people have read the Quran carefully, as well as the tafsirs, hadiths and Sharia? I know a friend who memorized about half, but when I started to discus scientific and ethical issues in the Quran, he was baffled.
You mention "no compulsion" but if you read the tafsirs they clearly state that this verse (which is an early revelation) has been abrogated by later verses. If it wasn't, then the Quran would contradict itself because other verses say to fight those who do not believe, so clearly there is compulsion, as do sahih hadiths:
Messenger of Allah said: I have been commanded to fight against people so long as they do not declare that there is no god but Allah, and he who professed it was guaranteed the protection of his property and life on my behalf except for the right affairs rest with Allah. - Sahih Muslim 21a
I have studied his life, I have read the Sira. He did some terrible things, have you not read it?
@@anwarsheikh7771 Or memorizing it could be a form of the "Mark of the Beast" on your forehead, lol! 😉
it amazing to see many times people in that time say there is nothing but old tales with out any fear and intimidation unlike now
Yes, the Quran is a miracle. It's a miracle that such a historically, morally and scientifically inaccurate book can be taken seriously enough to be read and shared.
Amen haha
Give an example to support your opinion. Or it is just that : your opinion whoch worth nothing.
@@munawaralias8980 Historic: Abraham never lived in Saudi Arabia, nor did he build the Kaaba. Solomon did not speak to birds. Mecca is not the oldest settlement on earth.
Morally: Two words, "sex slaves". Oppression of non-Muslims. Spread of religion through warfare. Also, much of its morality (like the famous "killing one man is like killing all mankind" passage) is borrowed from other sources.
Scientifically: Mountains are not stakes. The earth is not egg-shaped. The sun does not "travel" anywhere. Bees do not make honey in their stomachs. There is no barrier between seas. Sperm does not come from the spine. Humans don't start embryonic development as clots.
Example please?
@@Draezeth how does solomon speaking to animals count as "historical inaccuracy"?
for the scientifical "inaccuracies" : earth is an ellipsoid (which if you don't know is an irregular egg shape), the sun rotates around itself thats obvious , bees have a food stomach and a honey stomach , ever seen the fraser river and strait of georgia in canada? , the surah says "gushing fluid" and it says BETWEEN the back bone and the ribs exactly between the 12th rib and l3 vertebra , "علقة" means an embryo or "the clinging thing" which fits perfectly because we fit close to the body and depend on the mother to survive
The religion spread through wars yes , did they kill the innocent?No , did they kill every woman and child only left virgin women like in the bible?Absolutely not what about you say that to the western countries and how they destroyed countries to spread their religion or you forgot about them? The non muslims weren't opressed, how do you think muslims lived in el medina together with jews before the jews broke the treaties they had all their rights yet still broke them .Sex slaves was a common thing at that time, sex outside of marriage is forbidden and fun fact the prophet muhammed peace be upon him and his companions freed 39237 slave.
Honestly just do your homework please.
Ironically the Quran itself says that there will be no miracles due to the people not believing them in the past. So every time the Abduls say there are miracles in the Quran, they are going against what the Quran says.
Wow. Are used to listen to these types of videos all the time. I’ve been living caught up by false teachers within the Christian church.
@@blindvision4703 if you feel like you are being taught a false doctrine from your church, ask questions, question the teacher. We are not like Islam where we blindly follow what the Imams are saying and not question things.
Bingo
@@blindvision4703 please show me where this video is wrong 😑.. Take the time to take up my challenge or I’ll just assume that you already know that Islam ☪️ult is built on a platform of lies deceit and deception..
Abdools*
The Emperor's new clothes analogy is soooooo accurate. Thanks Yasir
According to Ibn Ishaq, the jibe 'All Ears' 9.61 was aimed at Muhammad by Habtal b al-Harith who said, "Muhammad is All Ears: if anyone tells him anything he believes it." In revenge, Muhammad said "If you want to know what Shaytan looks like, look at Nabtal!" Nabtal was a black man with inflamed eyes and ruddy cheeks.' (Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah translated by Guillaume, page 243). Lovely tolerant guy, that Muhammad. 😁
Thank you for another great video Colin. 😊 👍🏻
I would like to invite everyone to think of this for a monent:
There are no scholars arguing about the translation [in English for example] of Homer's Iliad. An ancient Greek poem dated approximately 1500 years before muhammad was born.
The text, the meaning, and the interpretation are all clear. When we read the text in English we know at all times what the protagonists feel, what their actions are, their motives, and what their words and statements mean. There is very little if any ambiguity on these matters. Finally, the narrative is coherent and flows naturally.
Then we have the miraculous koran which states [just to site two examples]:
1. "Dhul-Qarnayn reached the setting place of the Sun" [koran 18.86]. To this day no muslim can explain to us WHERE this place is and WHEN exactly does the Sun go there.
2. The koran [verse 4.34] also commands men to beat their wives to discipline them. Setting aside the fact that this is unacceptable, allah made it even worse since he did not care to explain how, or set limits to the beating method and severity to spare millions of women from abuse that can result in disfigurement or even death.
Didn't Allah say..with a toothbrush? Thought I glimpsed that when browsing thru...
no.. probably an explanation attempt from an apologist @@SusanLlewellyn-pp2xn
As usual...consistentlu good quality work.God bless.
Qur'an 17:59 We Refrained from sending miracles ( signs ). Islam loves to lie to gain a following.
According to the Qur'an, there are holes in Yasir Qadhi's narrative. 😓
But they needed dots to understand the Quran, uthman had to burn the first qurans😔 😪
The tame goat of Aisha ate two verses, allah couldn't protect it, hence according to Qur'an 15:9, allah has failed to protect the Qur'an.
So it's the "My dog ate my homework" kind of thing. And the teacher says, "That's an old tale!"😂
Greatest miracle in Islam is that it convinced 1.8 Billion Victims that Quran is a Miracle and perfectly preserved, a Book which has holes in it...a lot of Holes...
Prove it
@@muhammadshakir9 no need to prove what i said, its plain and clear,its obvious.
@@yakovmatityahu typical response of the uneducated
@@muhammadshakir9 “the standard narrative has holes in it”- Yasir Qadhi.
Textual variants (refuting the idea of perfect preservation), contradictions (refuting the Quran), reporting stories from apocryphal texts as alleged words of God (hence why Muhammad was accused of telling fables). There’s more
@@LazenTechtron Yasin alqadhi has his own issues but as usual anyone who agrees with your narrative you will take from lol.
You are so good at teaching brother…Jesus Christ is Lord.
Thank you 🙏.
I bear witness that it was reported by Islam Critiqued that this Video inspired the Jinns to leave Islam.
An iron fist and indoctrination has made this book a miracle.
Jesus rose from the dead and conquered death, making the Resurrection center point of human history- but sure a book that contradicts itself and the books it affirms out does it completely.
Allah is the best of all trolls
Send jesus
Let him ( appear ) to die on the cross
Wait 600 years for Christianity to spread
Choose the most controversial man as his final " prophet "
Alha forgot that in this 600 years countless people believed on Jesus through his crucifixion and resurrection.
@@yakovmatityahu this was one of the first reasons i left this peaceful religion.
@@aga7299 ohk are you turkish??? Hi am Indian.
@@yakovmatityahu hi my indian brother , no im from israel but my family is turkish .
We have alot of indians here , i really liked them
@@aga7299 oh ok...i recently came across a channel of a guy called Ciclin he dances in his icecream shop and dances with girls...he has 3 million subscribers...nice way to entertain and business...i guess he is also turkish...
Thanks for sharing, appreciate your work, keep up the good job.
God bless you.
Mother of all miracles. 🤔😱...
Copypasting, fabricating...
In short. 🤩
Isssslaaam = 🤯
If the eloquence of the language of Quran is so great, greater is in the failure on the part of Allah choosing Arabic where less than 4% of the world speak it.
@@TheQuranExplainsItself that's not true my friend, Arabic was exclusive to the Arab Peninsula, and even then every tribe had different dialects, hence why the Koran was in 7 recitations according to Momo. I just learned that those 7 recitations were for the people of Quraysh alone! Remember that Arabic is just an offshoot of Aramaic, which itself was already a declining language even during the time of Yeshua. Its still not a common language like English and Chinese. Reciting in Arabic is not the same as understanding and knowing Arabic.
@@TheQuranExplainsItself At that time Arabic was most popular! Are you kidding me? There is no historical evidence to support that
@@farookbazarwala5095 looks like @X disappeared.
Arabic is still accessible to anybody who wants to learn it. All muslim scholars know it. Even if you don’t want to learn it, you can verify the Qurans literary excellence through the expert consensus on the matter which is that the Quran is linguistically unmatched.
I remember Christian Prince describing to one of his callers that the challenge of the quran is destroyed by the extensive quotes from Jinn that the book contains. Obviously their words were good enough to make it into the quran, so they beat the challenge!
The one claim to be “amazing” cannot be self-attesting. Ahh the irony.
@Sajid Tanveer CP has his phone line opened for hours and hours daily and non of your Muslim scholars dare to call him🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@Sajid Tanveer what the heck are your dawah sisters going to do kid?
Hang on, isn't every word in the filthy, unholy koranus the word of allah? Does allah speak for djins?
We can't forget the ant,it's an amazing chapter
One of your all time greats. It takes down a powerful meme. Sheikh Colin, you have earned my respect anew. The Quran is pleasant to listen to when sung. I won't deny that. Some of the chapters have a rhyme scheme that translates well to music. I learned _tajweed_ and sang it well myself when I was still under the Islamic spell. But that aside, the meaning of its words is worse than mediocre. There's no _there_ there, so to speak.
I've been a bad subscriber. I haven't really tuned in for a couple years. I was there for the beginning of your ministry and commented on my other account _Time Is Fleeting,_ but there are too many channels to watch them all consistently. I must rectify this. Thaddeus of Reasoned Answers told me you are the best Christian polemicist he knows. I hope he'll forgive me just this once for breaking confidence. Maybe Thadd is right afterall.
Your depth of research - never less than impressive. I will enroll at your madrassa and take careful notes. One last thing, there's a guy running round impersonating you. He's brilliant, funny, and puts out original content on Islam, but he insists on wearing a head just like yours. His channel is Ask Truth Apologetics. The physical resemblance is uncanny.
You are a liar. You know nothing about the Quran.
Listen to Gospel Music instead. And Christmas Carol's. Don't waste your time on Islamic nonsense. ❤
@@SusanLlewellyn-pp2xnYes, I've discovered the joys of hymns lately. Very enjoyable. _Be Still My Soul_ is a current favourite. As for Xmas carols, undeniably great. _Come All Ye Faithful_ is breathtaking.
I'm the same user as _Sulayman Murtad,_ BTW.
Good video. You certainly taught those jinns a thing or two - I believe you.
Here is what Dr. G. Puin, a Quranic expert who studies manuscripts has to say about the Quran:
"The Koran claims for itself that it is 'mubeen,' or 'clear,' but if you look at it, you will notice that every fifth sentence or so simply doesn't make sense. Many Muslims-and Orientalists-will tell you otherwise, of course, but the fact is that a fifth of the Koranic text is just incomprehensible. This is what has caused the traditional anxiety regarding translation. If the Koran is not comprehensible-if it can't even be understood in Arabic-then it's not translatable. People fear that. And since the Koran claims repeatedly to be clear but obviously is not-as even speakers of Arabic will tell you-there is a contradiction."
I'm familiar with that claim and I have asked about it in the past in these videos but nobody has ever responded. I would love to see examples of these 'every fifth verse'.
@@two_tier_gary_rumain I don't know if he is still at the Saarland University in Germany but if so, perhaps you can find his contact info and send him a message. I've done that with people I wanted to get in touch with.
@@two_tier_gary_rumain CIRA International jut recently did a couple of videos about this with Jay Smith. I'd been wondering about these claims too. Very happy to finally have examples.
The RUclips channel "Thomas Alexander" also has an amazing series that occasionally gets into this, called "the 3 minute Qur'an study"
@@theastronomer5800 Easier said than done. I don't speak German.
@@Draezeth Yes, I've watched them all. I don't recall seeing anything discussing the corrupt 5th verses.
Bring on the continued textual criticism so their feeble religion can crumble …
the only thing that is crumbling is your pagan cult. Christianity is dying.
When Allah denied the claim that the Quran is his word, we are left with some very pressing questions: Who, in the eternity past-before creation, spoke the eternally un-created Quran into existence? Who is the “Most Honorable Messenger” of whom Allah says, “The Quran is his words”? In Quran 81: 19-21, Allah says, “Verily, this (Quran) is the word of a most honorable messenger, endured with power, and with rank before the Lord of the throne.”
This is mind blowing issue you raise. I have not taken cognizance of this verse in the Quran. What a sham what a show of shame and what confusion is this?
If Muslims say it's Muhammed they will basically acknowledge that he is god. They won't say Jesus because then they will basically be acknowledging that Jesus is God.
@@spiritualdiscovery8320 literally look up the verse first thing that will pop up 81:19 “Indeed, this ˹Quran˺ is the Word of ˹Allah delivered by Gabriel,˺ a noble messenger-angel,” 81:20 “full of power, held in honour by the Lord of the Throne,” / 21 “obeyed there ˹in heaven˺, and trustworthy.” It’s very clear and simple.
@@mariofufi5664 Reads like the writer of the Quran can't devide who is it speaking to, of, and who is speaking at all.
Clear as diahrrea such a book indeed...
@@mariofufi5664 What proof do you have that it was Gabriel that visited Mohammed and not the devil.
Matthew 7:15-16 (ESV): Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves. 16 You will recognize them by their fruits.
I never really understood what was so special about the Quran. What makes their recitation more eloquent than any other oral tradition such as the epic of Gilgamesh or the works of Homer? The Islamic claim of a miraculous Quran is arguably the worst form of evidence from an outsider perspective.
Behind the eloquent words spoken by a Muslim, is a sword.
@Crisanto Ballen - that is so accurate!!! 🤣🤣🤣
@Crisanto Ballen islam in a nutshell.
@Crisanto Ballen it sounds ugly. I’d rather listen to a recitation of the epic of Gilgamesh.
It is the second most boring and repetitive book I have ever read.
Number 1 was a textbook.
Ive genuinely tried to read the Quran many times and have always failed. It is one of the most painful readings anyone could ever subject themselves too. Im amazed anyone can describe it as a miracle with a straight face
it is not the eyes that are blind, but it is the hearts in the chests that grow blind. Quran Surah Al-Hajj.
The guy here is not qualified to speak on the Quran, no degree or whatsoever. Search Linguistic miracle of the Quran by manyprophetsonemessage it explain what is the miracle that arabic speaking muslims is referring to.
I also tried to read it. A hard read.
It is very confused, often illogical and reperitive. Narrations begin and one doesn't know of whom it is all about. Moses' story over and over again. No general moral, no spirituality. It is about hating and fighting the Kuffar and praising Mohammed.
Where is the verses the goat ate 🤔 👀
It became the dung 💩 of the Ground when the Goat did 💩 .
1:54 adding to this, no one was mesmerised
"God mentioned flies and spiders in his book and gave the polytheists an example. The Jews laughed and said: What does this resemble the word of God, so God revealed the verse " source: tafsir al qurtubi al baqara 26
Kufr logic "evidence of people not being mesmerised means no one was mesmerised"
Without lies islam will die 😂😂😂😂
just like your hero’s channel 🪵? Christianity is already dead lmao.
The Miracle of the Quran... which one? 🤣😂🤣 Yasir Qadhi... bbbut the holes.
oh the irony of a Christian saying this.
@@Sarmad_1989 not really to be honest, if Muslims can talk about the Bible and the Torah, why can't the opposite be true. Let the people speak their mind, for you most certainly will.
Alonzo Harris.. The Best of Deceivers 😂
You must have some history with him lol. I see him as a confused man, questioning his religion without saying he's questioning his religion. I pray that one day he will leave the garbage of Islam.
In the context of current textual discoveries this is so funny.
(I have been watching you and Mel and Jay !)
I, as an arab know hundreds of poets that are more beutiful and have more wisdom and have higher morality than Quran.
And more important, they are written in a very unique way, and you sometimes stand in owe by the capability of phrazing so much beuty into so little sentances
Even Joe Biden can come up with better book and poetry than the Author of Quran...you know the thing.
@@yakovmatityahu 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I suspect the great minds of the time, were asked about the quran whilst facing a sword.
Such a shame, hundreds of years of great minds ignored because of one book.
You are a liar save that crap for someone else you couldn't look in the mirror with straight face and say that.
Well said Bro.The preislamic period had illustrious poets and the Jahiliya era is a myth propagated by Islam.
The LIES just keep coming! Around and Around they go where their Lies Stop nobody knows! God bless you brother and your ministry!
A shame Allah wasn't bilingual...
Islamic apologist: The Quran is a "miracle."
Inigo Montoya: You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.
Actually the miracle are 👇👇
(The mistakes, the wrong spellings, meaningless things, the confusions etc 😂🤣🤣🤣) and i will say it is a miracle since some well educated muslims still believe it's normal ignoring all the mistakes in it...😔😔
everything you have said is a lie. but it would all be true if you had said it about the Bibles.
@Guess Work you’re talking about the Bibles. full of errors and contradictions. your lies won’t change that fact.
@@Sarmad_1989 I've tried to change the facts of yr quran but I couldn't find any facts. It is ALL b.s.
@@ibatan7243 lmao you mean the Bibles is. Full of errors and contradictions.
@@Sarmad_1989
Ignoramus, is this the only sentence that yr master taught you and you keep on repeating just like a parrot who can talk but does not understand what is it saying? it is abt. time for u to grow-up.
IF the Qur'an has been eternally with Allah, how can it include reactions to it's revelation? The needed logic fails me
God detemined what we do from the very beginning (seriously this was debated in early Islam, for example that God acutally wrote that all the sinners in the Quran would be sinners and condemned to hell)
@@VenusFeuerFalle
So, there is no free will. Every breath we take is directly controlled by allah.
This is pretty much what you said.
Better question is "Why there is Surah Al Lahab? " while Quran has already eternal.... consequently Abu Lahab Doesn't have Free will
That is Logic 😊
@@VenusFeuerFalle yep. Islam requires full fatalism. insha'Allah. I make plans, but what really happens is up to allah.
One of multiple reasons for the underdeveloped state of many Islamic countries (especially without oil).
this is a pretty shitty argument bro😂 ur acting like God didn’t eternally know what would happen??
The true miracle of the Quran is that, it is an average sized book that can fit an unfathomable amout of holes!
All Ham to Allah!
Keep up the good work!
How many Muslims today are disturbed that they are not "amazed" by the eloquence and theological depth of the Quran and find themselves thinking they are "old tales" everyone's heard before? If it was not for the scholars telling them they should be amazed, who would be?
Thank you for exposing the inaccuracies and errors in the Qur'an both in historic aspects as well as grammatic, spelling and other logistical errors. If the Muhammadins are honest with themselves they HAVE TO admit the Qur'an is not what they build it up to be.
Was this before, or after that battle, where many readings were heard, and a fight broke out over the many readings?
@IC Have you been not putting out many videos lately, or is YT cheating me of content? I was happy to see you come into my feed. God bless brother.
The only miraculous thing about the Koran is that people read it and think it's beautiful. It was a tedious, repetitive, unorganized slog when I read it.
Their embellishments explaination on qurans were so sweet talking
QURANAWAY FROM IT!☪️🏃♀️🏃♂️
I always knew Shakespeare was a prophet since he was a quite good writer.
This is excellent. I always enjoy your video and learn so much.
It’s crystal clear that Muhammad has not come from God.
1. If he was supposed to come after Jesus, wouldn’t he give us a sense of continuity, why did God has to start all over again?
2. What’s about his lifestyle, why is it so different than any other prophets before him?,isn’t God that said you should not take others’ wife, how come he has a pass on that one and on many others morally-related values?
3. How did Muhammad know the dude he met in the cave was Gabriel, who told him that? Why the Quran makes no sense whatsoever?
Reading the Quran is so nerve-wracking that I stopped in the middle. No correlation between the verses. It's was a waste of time.
This is packed, very resourceful!
Jesus is the ultimate miracle. Islam will never understand that. All praise be to Christ.
>That all of the other miracles are trivial to it
In the Mass, bread and wine literally become the body and blood of God
Meanwhile in Islam they have no concept of liturgical continuity that we see with temple Judaism and Catholicism
what nonsense is that even? you actually believe you drink the blood of god and eat his flesh every sunday? may Allah guide you.
@@Sarmad_1989 Not every Sunday. Every Mass. We celebrate the Holy Mass everyday, as Our Lord Jesus Christ taught us. You do not understand because you are not enlightened by God.
@@noelyanes2455 not enlightened enough to understand that claiming to fest on god flesh and blood is a satanic ritual?
@@Sarmad_1989 So doing what Jesus says is satanic? Clearly you are not a true Muslim if you reject your own prophets.
The miracle is that anyone could believe that garbage
Thank you for your ministry 💖🥰💖🥰💖🙏🙏
The biggest miracal are that there still are people who believe that lie in the year 2022.
miracle - 600 years+ after Jesus it invented stuff. -1000+ years after Moses it invented crap. and the crap was very crappy.
If the Quran is a literacy miracle I am the president of Ghana.
You can keep the Miracle of Your Koran, I will take the miracle of Jesus that He died for my Sins and has defeated death for our sakes as the Greatest Miracle!!
Surah 72:1-2
"... Surely we have heard an amazing Quran" ..."
Means: there are more than ONE Quran.
Otherwise it should read: "... Surely we have heard THE amazing Quran" ..."
Keep spreading godlogic apologetics and christian prince and cira international and shamounian and Lloyd de jongh and reasoned answers and david wood archives on Facebook and Twitter and Instagram and in your country Germany 🇩🇪 and other European countries but it is going to take years so take your time and be a messenger orpheusxl 😀😀😀😀
Well "quran" means "recitation" so they're just saying they heard a recitation of religious teaching and said that particular recitation was amazing. It wasn't made into a book called "the holy recitation" until later. At first it was just *a* recitation.
That is, if any of that happened at all. Mohammed may have never existed, and the Quran might just be recycled Syriac Monophysite and/or Abrahamite texts. But according to the traditional story, the Quran was a bunch of recited teachings for quite a while before it became a book called "the recitation"
@@efrencruz4422 A true messenger has to be called by God.
@@dugw15 And the question is: Where are the other 7 "readings" (dialects) that Mohammed claimed to have received?
@@OrpheusXL I know but I just said just keep spreading all the channels on Facebook and Twitter and Instagram and in your country Germany 🇩🇪 my friend 😀😀😀
12:43 Qur'an 6.25 explains this (away) by claiming that Allah has actively prevented such skeptics from hearing or understanding what is being read to them. Supposedly, only Allah is able to prevent anyone from becoming a Muslim immediately upon hearing the Qur'an.
lmao. ma sha allah brother! you just strengthened my belief in islam
My friend put the link for Mr. Woods video on why the quran was revealed in Arabic.
You're can use it to explain this too.
Solid. Now is there anything we know back then that indeed does sound similar to the Quran as literature?
Who’s with me that Jesus rising from the dead and taking our sins to the grave forever is a way greater miracle than a poorly constructed Arabic book? Or how about god creating the universe in six days just by speaking?! The Christian God is way better and way cooler than the Muslim God. Let’s just face the facts.
The most hilarious part is that the passage that denies the Crucifixion and Resurrection can be reinterpreted to say that those events actually happened.
@@aericabison23 complete nonsense what you have said.
the Bibles claim that god crated this universe in six days and on the 7th day he had to rest and take a breath, but the one true god created all the universes in six days in order to teach humans to be patient and he was not touched by any fatigue unlike what the Bibles claim.
@@Sarmad_1989 rest might just mean ceasing from labor, not being tired, when it comes to God. I think it might be a video on this channel about that; you and I may have to both watch it, you for the first time and me to refresh myself. also, depending on which verse in the Quran you read, I created the world is it six days or eight days. Which one is it? Your book says both.
@@blindvision4703 lmao it literally means that god had to take his breath. that is what it means. after spending six days to crate this universe god got tired, according to the bibles.
15:30: All the jinn just left the room!
People who claim that the Koran is in anyway special are people who are extremely limited in their knowledge of world literature and of art forms in general-they obviously are not familiar with such masterpieces as Homer's Iliad and Odyssey,the Mahabharata, the poems of Greek and latin masters like Virgil,Theocritus,Ovid and Lucretius,the poems of Dante,the plays of Shakespeare,Paradise Lost of Milton,the great poets of the Romantic era like Keats and Shelley not to mention sublime musical masterpieces like Bach's St Matthew Passion,the Messiah of Handel,Beethoven's Missa Solemnis and the great Requiem masses of composers like Mozart,Verdi,Berlioz and Faure not to mention the sublime passages in the Bible itself like the psalms,the book of Ecclesiastes and the sermon on the mount.
You make a lovely point. Now let's compare the authors of all those and the author of the Quran. Let's play a little spot the differences.
Once again the tenacity and diligence of your mission is awe inspiring. I am something of an amateur Islamic scholar compared to you, yet steadfast and enthusiastic nonetheless. What impresses me most is your ability to keep trudging through mediocre literature. I would have ditched the Hadith and Quran long ago for Rumi, Pseudo Dionysus, the Gnostic Gospels, or the Gospel of Ramakrishna for example. I guess I am just a mystic Bhakti guy who doesn't have the attention span for the often times incoherent monotony of orthodox Islamic thought. Well played, your zeal is your hairshirt.
The qur'an is poorly written and excessively repetitive.
It's really funny when sitting in CP or Sam's channel and a muslim posts a, listen to this challenge, but when the miracle doesn't happen, it doesn't seem to bother muslims...I wonder if they actually believe their own miracles.
Good video
Thank you. I learn so much from your videos.
Islam, Muhammad and the Quran didn't come with any miracles, no why it spread so much is because people were _forced_ into believes or they got killed.
It’s funny how all the greatest miracles of the Quran are actually it’s most self destructive. The Quran itself is full of remarks that the native speakers of the language were not impressed. It was actually one of the most interesting things to me when reading it the first time, because most of the retorts to the criticism were stupid or missing. The Quran is literally mumble rap.
Ok give an example
@@somedonny8466 you’re commenting on a video that details an example and you’re asking for an example…
@@pa21thebeast lan süslu evrenin genislemesi kuranda var denizlerin birbirine karismasi bin bang acikla hadi yalanmi
It is a miracle that the words of God can be understood in any language.
A book that can only be understood in one language is a deficient book.
A semi literate or even illiterate society prizes anything that involves reading and writing. Indeed, if you cannot read, a person who interprets the letters on the page is regarded as a miracle worker...my God, how did he do that? It must be a miracle!
It’s a miracle anyone still believes this incoherent dribble is the word of allah
It is the word of allah...
Definitely not the word of Yehovah.
According to Ibn Ishaq, Ibn Abbas said that there are eight verses in the Quran that mention 'old tales' and these all refer to al-Nadr b al-Harith who used to say he 'could tell a better story than Muhammad.' (Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah translated by Guillaume, page 136). No wonder Muhammad ordered al-Nadr to be beheaded after the Battle of Badr in 624CE on the way back to Medina with the loot! 😁
What good is a monolingual miracle? 🤦
Well, it is a miracle that 1.6b people believe in that book. Its also a miracle that people believe Mohammad was moral person. So yeah its a miracle, but not in the way muslims present it.
Kardeşim bu yalancı inanma turkiyede deyilsinki karşıma alıp anlatayım ALLAH bilir ne yalanlar ureti size
Thanks for info IC God bless
Yes it's miraculously fake
The miracle is miraculous, the most miraculous, therefore the Quran is a miracle. Sound logic.
Something amazing in the way in which Allah speaks to and about mohamed displays the very real existence of the spirit of Lust. 😁
How do the even say THE QURAN when there are more than 30 different Arabic Quran
It’s a miracle because we say it’s a miracle and you better not say it’s not a miracle.
like the Bibles calming someone got respawned? or that there were three millions Jews in Egypt? 😂
@@Sarmad_1989 doesn't the Quran confirm the jews captivity in Egypt? Your laughing at your own Quran.
@@Sheikh_Speare no lmao. The Bible claims there were three million Jews in Egypt and that at some point all the Egyptian kings were dead but yet there is no evidence for any of that. the Qur'an says they were only a very small group.
@@Sarmad_1989 I'm surprised that the numbers are super low in the Quran, especially since yall are obsessed with inflation and random numbers. However what really matters is that it confirms that there were jews in captivity. 3 million, 500, even 2, there were jews in captivity in Egypt. Historical evidence doesn't really matter at that point since the Torah, Bible and the Quran confirm the jews captivity.
@@Sheikh_Speare lmao it dose matter. the Christian and the Jewish books claim something which is entirely false. they even claim that after the king of Egypt was dead the Jews went back to Egypt to take over, yet there is no evidence for that at all, at no point during that period Egypt royal family had been missing.
It's interesting that they don't even claim it's directly from God. They claim it's from Gabriel as the intercessor. Which seems weird to me. Why wouldn't God just have revealed it himself..
The best part of these kinds of videos and their comments is that people simply push out their opinions & convictions, and vent hatred, anger & frustrations.
Nothing serious academically, historically, scientifically or logically.
Facts and figures are usually handicapped, opinionated or biased.
This then, only confuses more those already confused, misleads more who is already misled and satisfies more he that has already chosen his nest.
But, ARE WE READY TO FACE IT?
If yes:
Wouldn't it be nice, rational and spectacular a moment, that some of many efforts in producing many clips like this (that arguably, has little or no benefits for the minds and souls of men) be for once use to arrange a professional well mannered and regulated debate?
Many fellow famous RUclipsrs on the other side of the coin would be happy to do so.
BUT WOULD WE?
Problems with science-like expressions? Historical fallacies? Logical errors? Legal or moral objections? Fine!
Let episodes be dedicated to professionals in their fields addressing each topic, presenting all related research and papers, and then finally weighing them.
That indeed, would be great and truly beneficial for viewers and the society.
You clearly never watched the video bud. Lots of academic references and citations shown here that is used for arguments against your religion. How ironic that you appeal to muh experts in academia and history when even in the Quran contradicts and makes errors about actual historical figures. Hope you find your actual mind too since it seems lost somewhere.
@@ophanimangel3143What's wrong with your UNDERSTANDING?
Did you see this: "Facts and figures are usually handicapped, opinionated or biased". Or is there anything in the comment that suggests "NO scientific or historical data at all"?
"Lots of academic references and citations shown here...." Not sure if you read the comment too, LOL.
Putting things out context will not help. Why don't you explain what Nouman Ali explained.
It's funny how mohamad struggled to attract followers if the quran was so convincing until he was able to wield secular power to compel people to follow.
And this is all happening on this side of the majuj n hajuj imaginary wall,thank you brother for dissecting the beast that's iz lam,the miracle is that you come away unscathed after reading it's stupidity 🙄 🍻 👏
Is this the guy who said “ There are large holes in the narrative “
If the Quran was for all of humanity why is it only revealed in Arabic which couldn't be fully translated
Have you heard the seven commentators? I bet that the best poet of the current era can write poems like them
Salakalakem Mahi Mahi barracuda! Beautiful. Sounds lovely.
This is brilliant
Colin, could you do a video about the authors of Quran?
@Crisanto Ballen lol, he's their teacher boy. 😂
@@Sheikh_Speare you ultracrepidarian monster!!!
- mimi hijab
@@Sheikh_Speare like Jesus having a teacher (god head)? did god teach him about himself as he was growing up as the Bibles have claimed? god was learning about himself lol what nonsense.
@Crisanto Ballen I doubt that you believe in god.
@Crisanto Ballen like the Church’s love for toddlers? or Jesus love for babies? 😂 how many times did he order them to be slaughtered and ripping the womb of their mothers?
If only Muslims would ever realize it xD