Tchaikovsky Symphony Nº 4 OP 36 Herbert Von Karajan WPO

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 198

  • @DavidPerez-wd6tx
    @DavidPerez-wd6tx Месяц назад +5

    Herbert von karajan, r.i.p y gracias por haber existido y habernos alegrado el alma con tus magníficas actuaciónes con la hermosa 🎵 de los grandes maestros ❤🎉

  • @pedritoseptiembre
    @pedritoseptiembre Месяц назад +2

    I've listened 100 times this Symphony...100 times repeating the same sensation of heaven

  • @FarisAl-Hilli
    @FarisAl-Hilli Месяц назад +3

    One of the most romantic and touching symphonies by Tchaikovsky especially, the 2nd movement.

  • @Kegeljan
    @Kegeljan 5 месяцев назад +9

    Malgré d'évidentes souffrances masquées et dignes, Karajan dirige ses troupes dans une interprétation flamboyante et riche de l'esprit Russe ! RESPECT MAESTRO.

  • @joseeduardocruz1272
    @joseeduardocruz1272 Месяц назад +4

    Sin duda un director grandioso!
    Ésta fue la primera pieza de Tchaikovsky que escuché con mi padre, cuando yo tenía siete años de edad y desde entonces me encanta, aún conservo el disco de vinil, que gran recuerdo de mi padre, que nos enseñó a apreciar la musica

  • @jerzfry
    @jerzfry 26 дней назад +1

    Wykonanie z moich lat młodości, wspaniałego ❤

  • @valeriysakov1410
    @valeriysakov1410 11 месяцев назад +7

    Браво симфония 4 композитор Чайковский ! Браво оркестр и диирижор Караян! Спасибо. Браво!

  • @igortsyb1
    @igortsyb1 2 года назад +4

    Herbert von Karajans Darbietung beeindruckt durch sein phänomenales musikalisches Gedächtnis, Emotionalität und Ausdruck, Schönheit und Geschmeidigkeit der Handbewegungen des Dirigenten. Was Tschaikowsky betrifft, so sind seine 4. und 6. Symphonie mein Favorit. Ich glaube, sie waren auch Karajans Lieblinge. Das Finale der 4. Symphonie ist die Schönheit der russischen Natur. Dort erklingen die bekannten Motive russischer Volkslieder über die Heimat.

  • @robertrosamond3749
    @robertrosamond3749 2 года назад +53

    Everyone should hear this symphony at least once during their lifetime.

    • @vincenzoconforti1323
      @vincenzoconforti1323 2 года назад +1

      I agree

    • @Dylonely_9274
      @Dylonely_9274 2 года назад

      Indeed

    • @brendan7094
      @brendan7094 2 года назад +2

      Just saw this symphony last night at the Kimmel theater. Music never brought tears to my eyes until then. Beautiful and emotional simply does not say enough to how I felt during the show. It was incredible.

    • @jamespaine7152
      @jamespaine7152 Год назад

      I wholely agree!

    • @gatosimple2354
      @gatosimple2354 Год назад +1

      Yo ya lo escuché muchas veces , es mejor director que los directores actuales . Pareciera que su alma va muy ligada a la Música( talento innato)

  • @dmitryluzin6884
    @dmitryluzin6884 6 месяцев назад +8

    Очень русское, певучее звучание, и бережно к авторским нюансам и темпам. Не каждому дирижеру, даже великим, удается это передать в музыке Чайковского. Поэтому Караян и велик!

  • @zcde345
    @zcde345 4 года назад +89

    Tremendous performance! Von Karajan was such an intense, controlled conductor that results in this very emotional Tchaikovsky symphony are explosive! Beautiful, powerful playing from the Vienna Philharmonic.

  • @mxyzptlk...
    @mxyzptlk... 4 года назад +88

    Tchaikovsky is a composition god.

    • @양기성-r2z
      @양기성-r2z 3 года назад

      ㅓㅎ ㄱ
      ㅎㅆ개귿
      ㅇㅋ

    • @scottmiller6495
      @scottmiller6495 2 года назад +9

      He was and so was the great Gustav Mahler oh my !!!!!

    • @Tennisisreallyfun
      @Tennisisreallyfun Год назад +5

      I don’t think I’ve ever seen a composer who is able to combine in equal measure a pension for sophisticated compositional techniques with, at the same time, crowd-pleasing techniques. It’s almost as though the music was designed to send music lovers like us into states of rapture while, at the same time, render itself lovable and almost approachable to those maybe first stepping foot into the world of classical music! And I love that! I think that’s exactly what turns so many away from our world. It’s this preconceived notion that we are somehow aloof and pretentious and that the only way to enjoy it is to be “cultured”. That’s such a sad notion to behold. Classical music should be for the world to enjoy, and composers like Tchaikovsky are making that happen, and making it easier for people to then go deeper and step foot into the more complex music. He’s just amazing🤩

    • @manueljoseblancamolinos8582
      @manueljoseblancamolinos8582 Год назад +1

      @@Tennisisreallyfun Tchaikovsky was the type of composer who takes pity on the audience and doesn't abuse their attention span. This is manifested, for example, in the fact that in his symphonies ,concertos and chamber music the first movement is usually the most complex and important and that there are always relaxation movements after more complex movements. It also happens with the endings, which are often the clearest and simplest movements without looking for a complexity similar to that of the first movements, which would be what a principle of symmetry would require. Only in some works, such as the Manfred symphony, Tchaikovsky departs from this general principle of consideration for the listener's attention span.

    • @Tennisisreallyfun
      @Tennisisreallyfun Год назад +5

      @@manueljoseblancamolinos8582 Well that’s rather harsh, don’t you think? I mean, I agree that Tchaikovsky follows the fast-slow-scherzo-fast, etc type format for his symphonic works with lots of your standard sonata form writing throughout. So yes, all very “standard”. Look, like any great composer, even Tchaikovsky has his average, throw-away pieces, but then that is the case with most people. But then again, so does Beethoven. And so does Mozart and I can argue so does Dvorak and so do many other “great composers”. But it’s his melodies that attract me the most. For every throw-away piece, there are twenty godly ones. They are so beautiful!!!!!! And they are so breathtakingly original that one almost stands back in astonishment at the ease with which he creates these godly melodies. You may say he takes pity on an uncultured audience, that is your right, but as a violinist I choose to recognize his sophistication and look at him through a lens of a composer whose melodies are rarely so contemplative and deeply emotional that your “standard” audience fails to appreciate them (I’d use the “Pathetique” as an exception here). And I really do think that’s good because I think that our world of classical music is starting to decline in prominence. Without composers like Tchaikovsky, the amount of people who’d bother to listen and dwindling as quickly if not more quickly than the cultured people out there like you and I who still maintain the fire within that represents our love for our great art.

  • @expeditioni5902
    @expeditioni5902 4 года назад +53

    Who's jamming out to this oldie in 2020? I am!!!! They had so much talent back then

    • @scottmiller6495
      @scottmiller6495 2 года назад +3

      Nobody that I know of !!!!!

    • @expeditioni5902
      @expeditioni5902 2 года назад +1

      @@scottmiller6495 LOL I don't even remember typing that!

    • @doddsalfa
      @doddsalfa 2 года назад +1

      Is breathing a oldie?

  • @OnceUponLater
    @OnceUponLater 3 года назад +24

    Credit to the cinematography! Captured so many moments where a section deserved visibility. This often goes so unnoticed

    • @roberthill799
      @roberthill799 2 года назад +3

      The editing of images during the pizzicato section is great.

  • @noneofit85
    @noneofit85 2 года назад +8

    No other compositor creates the emotions and the energy Tchaikovsky brings out in me. A true Master..
    And this masterpiece executed by Karajan is beyond any doubt the best.

  • @andrewgrundy744
    @andrewgrundy744 5 лет назад +36

    The legend that is Herbert Von Karajan and probably the most charismatic conductors ever.One of the greatest Tchaikovsky interpreters

    • @tubaguyry3540
      @tubaguyry3540 4 года назад +6

      Karajan stands alone at the top for me. No other conductor is even in the same galaxy as he.

    • @andrewgrundy744
      @andrewgrundy744 4 года назад +6

      Ryan Rhodes totally agree his Tchaikovsky is the best and his Beethoven is legendary

    • @Marinavalerevna
      @Marinavalerevna Месяц назад

      ​​@@andrewgrundy744 Светланов, Мравинский. Почему же только Караян?

    • @perlastella10
      @perlastella10 Месяц назад

      Saraste for me the top definetely.

  • @jamespaine7152
    @jamespaine7152 Год назад +18

    My favorite Tchaikovsky symphony conducted by my favorite conductor. Karajan fans should check out his 1973 BPO film.

    • @paullewis2413
      @paullewis2413 Месяц назад +1

      They should also check out his 1950’s recording with the Philharmonia, a better and less frenetic interpretation. 😊

  • @the_show_must_go_off
    @the_show_must_go_off 3 года назад +63

    0:41 1st
    19:14 2st
    29:08 3st
    35:03 Finale

  • @mjrsnafu
    @mjrsnafu 6 лет назад +56

    Just beautiful. I always tear up hearing the second movement but what follows is that wonderfully uplifting pizzicato. Wonderful

    • @HH576
      @HH576 4 года назад +8

      Michael : I feel the second movement awakens a sorrow that we are all born with.

    • @mjrsnafu
      @mjrsnafu 2 года назад +4

      @@HH576 That was very well said if I may say so

  • @shinyblack1690
    @shinyblack1690 5 лет назад +43

    The most thrilling account of this great symphony I've ever heard.

    • @asdfasdf-gm5uk
      @asdfasdf-gm5uk 4 года назад +6

      Mravinsky is better in my opinion....

    • @akshaygowrishankar7440
      @akshaygowrishankar7440 3 года назад

      @@asdfasdf-gm5uk Mravinsky is amazing, and Bernstein aswell

    • @MrAam1964
      @MrAam1964 3 года назад

      Listen to the 1957 Leningrad Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Evgeny Mravinsky as the reference

    • @remomazzetti8757
      @remomazzetti8757 2 года назад

      Try Artur Rodzinski's live performance with the New York Philharmonic: I've never heard anything quite like it. It's on RUclips coupled with an outstanding 5th.

    • @annpettus1775
      @annpettus1775 Год назад

      @@asdfasdf-gm5uk Wow, thanks for the suggestion. It's AMAZING.

  • @jamesmillen9120
    @jamesmillen9120 2 года назад +7

    An electrifying performance of the fourth. Have not heard better. Great musicianship and Karajan was at his best.

  • @genebo6476
    @genebo6476 Месяц назад +1

    mais que c'est fabuleux !!

  • @cathyswartz8408
    @cathyswartz8408 2 года назад +8

    Herbert Von Karajan is so intense and talented. Excellent performance from this great orchestra and strong powerful symphony 😍

  • @ww-nx6hj
    @ww-nx6hj 4 года назад +22

    Some people put on The Notebook, some people flip through old photos, i play Karajan's interpretation of Symphony 4 when I want a good cry.

    • @rodolforealini5556
      @rodolforealini5556 3 года назад +2

      I happy for you but your sensibility is on the first place for the cry for the great Thaycovsky, ciao.

    • @kellymullins4101
      @kellymullins4101 6 месяцев назад +1

      So true, it makes me so emotional as a violinist who hasn't preformed in a long while now, this was a piece I played in my very brief time in college and I would give anything to have that moment again.

  • @pianos1
    @pianos1 2 года назад +8

    You can't beat the old recordings! Karajan was surely the best conductor ever.

  • @alfonsoarizanino2538
    @alfonsoarizanino2538 3 года назад +5

    Para mi es la sifonia mas hermosa escrita por tschaikovsky y su vercion exelente Alfonso Arisa Niño (Bogota D.C.Colombia)

    • @alfonsoarizanino2538
      @alfonsoarizanino2538 3 года назад

      Karajan el mejor director de orquerta que haya dado el mundo dirigiendo la curta sinfonia de tscaykovsky la ma hemosa escrta por el compositor Alfonso Ariza Niño( Bogota D.C. Colombia)

  • @MrWilou35
    @MrWilou35 Год назад +3

    Ce 1er mouvement...ce fatum qui vous prend à la gorge et qui ne vous lâche plus de la première à la dernière note...et qui reviens dans le final...cette musique est définitivement un immense chef d œuvre

    • @Dylonely_9274
      @Dylonely_9274 Год назад +1

      L’entièreté de la symphonie est un chef d’œuvre authentique de la musique comme il en existe peu, un premier mouvement remarquable et spectaculaire jusqu’aux dramatiques derniers accords.

  • @robertoocana4639
    @robertoocana4639 3 года назад +17

    ,¡¡Sublime interpretación bajo la dirección del gran maestro Karajan!!..

  • @mariadelcarmenleyrasbergil3333
    @mariadelcarmenleyrasbergil3333 2 года назад +3

    La genialidad de Tchawiskosy, el talento de van Karajan y el buen hacer de los componentes de la Sinfónica de Viena, hacen de esta Sinfonia una obra Karajan.gracias a todos.Un Saludo desde Málaga, España

  • @bsamalslmh9722
    @bsamalslmh9722 Год назад +1

    الروح الوثابة لتشايكوفسكي تظهر هنا جلية من خلال هذا الاداء الرائع والقوة الثابتة في مهارة وتحكم القائد الفذ انه كرجان الرجل الصلب الفلاذي

  • @腿肉脂肪之丞
    @腿肉脂肪之丞 3 года назад +8

    Great. I love this heroic sound of Karajan.

  • @Astaroth17ad
    @Astaroth17ad 4 года назад +30

    8:24 Tchaikovsky playing his own symphony

  • @joseluisvilleda1217
    @joseluisvilleda1217 Год назад +3

    Interpretación cerca de la perfección absoluta...esta sí se consiguió cuando dirigió la Filarmónica de Berlín

  • @lucasgust7720
    @lucasgust7720 3 года назад +12

    I think this is the absolute best performance of this masterpiece.

  • @malenabetanzos344
    @malenabetanzos344 Год назад +5

    Compré la sinfonía en cassette a los 18 y desde entonces la siento y escucho fascinante

  • @789armstrong
    @789armstrong 5 лет назад +10

    Excellent! The WPO is in top form.

  • @Daniel-pw7md
    @Daniel-pw7md Год назад +5

    Goosebumps

  • @violettaverdi3773
    @violettaverdi3773 Год назад +4

    This music goes straight to the heart.

  • @samuelmedeiros7377
    @samuelmedeiros7377 2 года назад +3

    Esta número 4 de Tchaikovsky sem o Karajan não pode existir. Só ele para dar essa visão fantástica da obra.

    • @antoniocarlosrodriguescamp1497
      @antoniocarlosrodriguescamp1497 10 месяцев назад

      Bobagem .Há regentes geniais hoje em dia, igualáveis ou superiores à Karajan. Anos atrás poderíamos imaginar tantos músicos orientais , melhores intérpretes da nossa música do que os próprios ocidentais?

  • @Nick_Wees_Music
    @Nick_Wees_Music 5 лет назад +29

    40:44 The vapor on that middle trombone!

  • @Discovery_and_Change
    @Discovery_and_Change Год назад +13

    (Too many ad interruptions)
    0:47 begins | 8:58 celebration | 9:31 intro | 11:56 intro | 12:16 intro | 12:48 intro
    15:54 build up | 16:05 celebration | 16:35 intro | 17:36 playful build up
    18:27 | 18:34 dark | 18:49 | 18:57 ending | 19:22 2nd movement | 20:49 elegant
    26:03 elegant |

  • @alfonsoarizanino2538
    @alfonsoarizanino2538 3 года назад +3

    Karajan el mejor director que haya dado el mundo Dirigiendo la cuata sinfonia de Tschaykovsky que honor Alfonso Ariza Niño(Bogota D.C. Colombia)

  • @albertoabramjacob3189
    @albertoabramjacob3189 3 года назад +6

    🏳️🇨🇴 sencillamente bello la percusión me impacto

  • @yowzephyr
    @yowzephyr 4 года назад +9

    0:46 is a good place to start.

  • @elizabethtan8343
    @elizabethtan8343 5 лет назад +8

    There are many similar melodies in the No.1 Winter Daydreams, No. 2 Petite Russian and the No.4 ? Agree??

  • @lololili-q8m
    @lololili-q8m Год назад +1

    Meravigliosa

  • @hegzansiaani9213
    @hegzansiaani9213 3 года назад +4

    I spellbound by this when I was a kid........

  • @TadeuszburgryrrjahedMarian
    @TadeuszburgryrrjahedMarian 4 года назад +13

    His 112 th birthday in 2020!!! (There are older living)😁

  • @antoniocarlosrodriguescamp1497
    @antoniocarlosrodriguescamp1497 10 месяцев назад

    What an orchestra!!

  • @enriquepazescudero5870
    @enriquepazescudero5870 Год назад +1

    BELLISIMA INTERPRETACION.

  • @ddy1973
    @ddy1973 Год назад

    Super❤
    I am very happy with thissss...

  • @김재곤-s6b
    @김재곤-s6b 2 года назад

    이 영상을 거의 2년전까지 여러차례 봐왔는데, 어느날 갑자기 사라져서 저으기 당황하고 서운했었습니다.
    그러다가 오늘 문득 4번 교향곡이 듣고싶어 유트뷰를 뒤지다가 카라얀의 모습을 보고 반가운 마음에 듣고있습니다.
    그런데 한가지 유감인 것은 음량이 작게 설정되어 있다는 것입니다.
    아뭏든 반가운 영상입니다~^^

  • @MGHCJH
    @MGHCJH 2 года назад

    Excellent trombone showcasing.

  • @eduardoperetdias6257
    @eduardoperetdias6257 Год назад +1

    Sensacional

  • @ssophoss
    @ssophoss 6 лет назад +8

    Voy a coreografiar ésto...Ya que Tchaikowsky y yo nos entendemos

  • @ericwierzbinski4993
    @ericwierzbinski4993 5 месяцев назад

    Je ne peux pas m'empêcher de trouver une certaine esthétique 3eme Reich à certaines de ces images et mise en scène.

  • @BassistPaul
    @BassistPaul 10 месяцев назад

    Exquisite.

  • @nancysiebert2658
    @nancysiebert2658 9 месяцев назад

    ❤ me encanta.

  • @VonMeck
    @VonMeck 3 года назад +1

    BRAVI!

  • @shawnhampton8503
    @shawnhampton8503 3 года назад +4

    I get tired of the stylized look of these videos. But the performance is magnificent. I had the audio recordings of these 4, 5, and 6th symphonies but the DG recordings were just so harsh and un pleasant. It seems like the trumpets especially are super dominating here. Karajan's last years with Vienna were some of his best.

  • @keremy84
    @keremy84 2 года назад +9

    35:03 for Pink Floyd fans 😜

    • @musicminute2004
      @musicminute2004 Месяц назад

      Why?

    • @keremy84
      @keremy84 Месяц назад

      ​@@musicminute2004 it is in the "wish you were here" intro, before the guitar starts playing.

  • @_Chuvisco_
    @_Chuvisco_ 7 лет назад +6

    TEMPO!!

  • @StevenFontanella
    @StevenFontanella 7 лет назад +11

    0:46

  • @petermisch3586
    @petermisch3586 2 года назад

    Ein wahres Feuerwerk 🎆🎆🎆!!!

  • @ЕленаЕлена-щ1б
    @ЕленаЕлена-щ1б 2 года назад +1

    Sound and Interpretation like Beethoven. Nötig like TChaikowsky.

  • @berlinzerberus
    @berlinzerberus 7 лет назад +9

    PEERLESS!

    • @karllieck9064
      @karllieck9064 7 лет назад +2

      I agree, berlinzerberus.☺

    • @tubaguyry3540
      @tubaguyry3540 6 лет назад +3

      No one touches Karajan. Not even close.

    • @mjrsnafu
      @mjrsnafu 6 лет назад

      My view entirely

  • @user-qt1eo7dq8v
    @user-qt1eo7dq8v Год назад +1

    Who’s filming this? Leni Riefenstahl?

  • @bilgehatun
    @bilgehatun 3 года назад

    Wonderfull

  • @FernandoBetelremanescente777
    @FernandoBetelremanescente777 2 года назад +2

  • @wm.traynor1143
    @wm.traynor1143 4 месяца назад +1

    The string passages in the second movement are divine.

  • @PinacoladaMatthew
    @PinacoladaMatthew 8 месяцев назад

    35:03 scared the shit out of me......nice one~

  • @blueapples
    @blueapples 2 года назад +1

    Karajan reigned supreme in more ways than one. For instance, in commanding how this video and his others from this same era were filmed. Compared to how orchestral performances are filmed now, the style used here seems too constricted -- close-ups with "artistic" camera angles and the like. For me I find it actually detracts from the performance, so I'd rather listen with my eyes closed ... or just haul out my CD version. ☺

    • @montymonto6430
      @montymonto6430 Год назад

      Could not say it any better. Contrived is the word for the filming. Musical performance is something else.

  • @yh3212
    @yh3212 3 года назад +6

    43:51

  • @megabugginout
    @megabugginout 3 года назад +1

    1:03 is Epic!

    • @Dylonely_9274
      @Dylonely_9274 2 года назад

      The whole piece is

    • @megabugginout
      @megabugginout Год назад

      Karajan is such a master that you can listen a minute of his interpretations and be fulfilled.

  • @Florestan88
    @Florestan88 Год назад

    21.53 this part reminds me of Mozart's e minor violin sonata 2nd movement

  • @derekligstezombie
    @derekligstezombie 7 лет назад +3

    Das ist nicht zu überbieten

  • @tatiachakhvadze8888
    @tatiachakhvadze8888 6 месяцев назад

    👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼❣️❣️❣️❣️

  • @gabofihi007
    @gabofihi007 3 месяца назад

    35:12 - 35:15 that bit from Wish You Were Here by Pink Floyd

  • @MrAam1964
    @MrAam1964 3 года назад +2

    Generous interpretation indeed with one of the most beautifull orchestra in terms of sound rendering! However, the 1957 Mravinsky/ Leningrad interpretation is unsurpassable

    • @fungling7982
      @fungling7982 2 года назад

      Mravinsky was too fast in my opinion

  • @Vohuslav
    @Vohuslav Год назад

    19:14 ❤❤❤❤

  • @한희선-z6v
    @한희선-z6v Год назад

    4 5. 6번을 아끼고사랑한다

  • @a.matusyan3936
    @a.matusyan3936 2 года назад +2

    This piece is based on Armenian Religious divine Liturgy, his genes must have spoken to him when he wrote this...

  • @jeanparke9373
    @jeanparke9373 Год назад +1

    36:35 Berezka kicks in here

  • @isaacsamuel9520
    @isaacsamuel9520 6 лет назад +1

    So sad that he didn't add the final crash

    • @caginn
      @caginn 5 лет назад +6

      Statistically speaking among the recordings I know there is no final 'crash', I think it is not in the score anyway. Yet you can hear it in Karajan's 76 recording for DG. Seems he was not consistent about it.

  • @timayla123
    @timayla123 2 года назад

    Well that belw me away!

  • @franciscoandresandres4414
    @franciscoandresandres4414 Год назад

    Aquí Karajan está algo mayor y con la espalda operada en el año 1975 no gasta las energías que gasta con la orquesta de Berlín porque el cuerpo (aunque lo intenta) no le permite los lujos de antaño. Tiene siempre los ojos bien abiertos y es mucho más conciso con las entradas

  • @bondjames417
    @bondjames417 2 года назад

    最高です

  • @anatolimarasov6523
    @anatolimarasov6523 4 года назад +2

    Да, это одно из лучших исполнений: Караян пронизан музыкой, но совместим ли Дух с Душой? и, главное, совместимы ли Они вообще? ...Что мы слышим?

    • @sergeygryaznov9185
      @sergeygryaznov9185 3 года назад +2

      По моему грандиозное исполнение. Оркестр и дирижер великие мастера! Чтобы добавить русской теплоты в музыку Чайковского, нужно быть русским. Также говорят австрийцы, когда российские оркестры исполняют Штрауса, а немцы, когда исполняют Бетховена. Конечно, Караян противоречивая личность, но то, что он делал как дирижер - это убедительно, это ярко, это на века.

  • @PhilipPedro2112
    @PhilipPedro2112 8 месяцев назад

    0:48 through 1m38s could be something by Philip Glass.

  • @たぼもちやんこ
    @たぼもちやんこ 10 месяцев назад

    Is this sound same as CD of Deutsche Grammophon?

  • @ポトポトチャンネル
    @ポトポトチャンネル Год назад

    いいなー

  • @ВладимирКурохтин-ы2м
    @ВладимирКурохтин-ы2м 3 года назад +2

    33 бездаря поставили дизы

  • @aguador67
    @aguador67 3 года назад +1

    As much as I like Karajan, I understand that there is a criticism to be made of him, which I read in an authoritative biography (Roger Vaughan's). His orchestral conducting was like a car ride: it takes you smoothly along any road and you arrive at the end without much of a clue as to what has happened on the journey. There are no potholes, no switchbacks, no sharp curves. That's what happened to me with the interpretation of this work. Not to mention the mania for tuning to "bright A" (above 440 Hz), which also plays a role. In this sense, I was much more convinced by Barenboim's version with the Chicago Symphony. In my humble opinion, it has much more sense of the dramatic; and this symphony is very dramatic. I think Barenboim has captured it better.

    • @ww-nx6hj
      @ww-nx6hj 3 года назад +2

      Oh my God, are you on the wrong drugs? Barenboim's version was the equivalent of N'Sync covering Chuck Berry.

    • @aguador67
      @aguador67 3 года назад

      @@ww-nx6hj I take no drugs. However, maybe I could be wrong about Tchaikovsky's version (if you don't like Barenboim you can choose another of your taste). But I think that the criticism on Karajan is still valid.

    • @sarajotoku1461
      @sarajotoku1461 3 года назад

      Maybe Karajan's interpretations are more subtle or restrained but I find them so "deep" somehow and not at all lacking in drama. And I have no objection to a "beautiful" sound, to me it enhances the emotional power of the music.

    • @БорисЧемеровский-ж2б
      @БорисЧемеровский-ж2б 5 месяцев назад

      Замечательное исполнение великой симфонии ! ​@@sarajotoku1461

  • @륜우김-o1z
    @륜우김-o1z Год назад +1

    🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷👍🙂😊😇🙏🙏🙏

  • @Sibethoven
    @Sibethoven 4 года назад +3

    32:18

    • @davidevans3227
      @davidevans3227 4 года назад +1

      Clarinet? Flute? Strings? what is it you wanted to point out? i love this symphony 🙂

    • @sophiahannan443
      @sophiahannan443 3 года назад

      Please tell me you didn't purposely put that as the time stamp for the ad 😆

    • @Sibethoven
      @Sibethoven 2 года назад

      @@davidevans3227 his little nod and smile ;)

    • @davidevans3227
      @davidevans3227 2 года назад

      @@Sibethoven yes! 😊

  • @composerpatrick
    @composerpatrick Год назад +2

    There are so many moments in this that have been ripped off (or lovingly quoted, not sure) in other classical composer's works, movie themes, and with almost the same scoring.
    We blame popular styles of music for dumbing down the complexity of from the soul true classical music to three pr four chords at the same time they are taking ideas from established works to simplify their process of composing...see what im getting at? No wonder IT HAS ALL gone to 💩🤡🌍

  • @ye2z
    @ye2z 2 года назад +1

    8:40

  • @csabaiedit
    @csabaiedit 2 года назад

    Nagyon jó

  • @djmotise
    @djmotise 3 года назад +1

    You put the conductor's name before the Master's name at the end? And before the great orchestra? I wish people would stop with this excessive conductor worshipping.