Talk about Milo Yiannopoulos being on the legion of skanks podcast and the threat of people tagging Antifa online and threatening to throw milkshakes and shit.
@@dnw009 Yeah you're probably right there. It's a shame that people would react that way though as regardless of Phil's opinion this is an excellent video covering both sides fairly imo so the idea that people will instantly ignore that once he gives an opinion they don't like irritates me.
Is it acceptable to not like either of them? I don't care for Crowder's humor, but Klein also annoys me for his comfort with Antifa and deplatforming people he disagrees with.
@OFswag666 you're right, we should just let maza become the police of youtube and anyone he says is bad, just kick em off. Pewdiepie, nazi, kick im off. Ben Shapiro, alt right white supremacist, kick im off. Anyone who disagrees with maza, alt right bigot, kick em off
@OFswag666 Insult comedy is a thing. They air roasts on Comedy Central. The best comedians in the world mock people non stop. Chappelle, Richard Pryor, etc etc. But who chooses the protected class that is above mockery? "666" you mock Christianity. Go about your day. Let's say you name your self Muhammad killer. To quote the Joker "Everyone loses their mind." He recommends his audience to throw milkshakes at people they don't agree with politically. It's ok. Keep making your money. He calls himself a gay Mexican. Ok. Someone else calls him a gay Mexican... "That's fucking illegal"
Y.S. I agree, I think it has to do with peoples lack of self control and extreme need for approval and attention. About 5 years ago when i was a teenager I realized I was spreading negativity on FB. I’ve stopped posting sense. I only post about a few times a year or less. I’m happy because now if I post something it has to have weight and meaning to it otherwise it’s not worth breaking a streak of keeping to my fucking self about my shit opinions.
As a free speech / human rights / anti-censorship advocate. I'm firmly against this idea of "deplatforming" or banning those that have opinions that someone disagrees with. If I didn't defend the free speech for people that I disagree with I'd be a pretty large hypocrite. This quote is pretty accurate: “Goebbels was in favor of free speech for views he liked. So was Stalin. If you’re really in favor of free speech, then you’re in favor of freedom of speech for precisely the views you despise. Otherwise, you’re not in favor of free speech.” ― Noam Chomsky
@@melaneaa4071What exactly did he say that you find so inflammatory (As a watcher of his content, although I don’t always agree with him, I am still genuinely curious)
I don't believe he had his feelings hurt. Victimization is a form of currency for the left and Maza is raking in some bank. It's all just a naked power play. Absolutely despicable behavior.
Could anyone perhaps explain what happened at the very beginning? What is the reason of Crowder going after Maza for the first time? Did Maza do something controversial before Crowder and Maza started fighting eachother? While this video clears some things up in a non-bias way (which I really appreciate), I still feel like there is some context missing. Or am I wrong?
@@SneakyJ1991 this is the first 'fight' everything else is just clips from crowders response videos to vox videos taken from several years worth of content, and picked out of several hundred other videos entirely unrelated to vox.
You covered the Crowder/vox story really fairly, the only thing I'd add is in one part of the Twitter thread Carlos called for his followers to mass flag Crowder in retaliation. That was the specific censorship to which he was referring.
That "Censorship" is nothing else than calling on RUclips to enforce their own guidelines. If anyone is unhappy with that, why not use another platform? oh wait, there is none :^)
This is important, at no point does crowder directly initiate a call-to-action for his followers to do anything malicious. As where Carlos does directly call for violence on multiple occasions. I’m starting to see a pattern.
It really makes Maza look like a cry baby throwing a tantrum that RUclips won't get rid of the guy that systematically dismantles they one of his arguments
Too bad once again Phil didn't do that. He left out the part where Mazda is calling for massive false flagging of all of Crowders content. Or the fact that Crowder has reached out to Maza in the past. Or the fact that Crowder doesn't care that he's gay. All that stuff magically didn't get mentioned. Yet all of it is public record and available on Twitter and Crowders Channel.
everyday on the news, Twitter hate this, Facebook violates that, Ugh! who even needs to belong to those platforms, the bullshit bleeds through into most media now.
Can we stop with this? It's not a good look when you are trying to set up a reputable news source. Personally I don't care for it, physical violence is not a meme.
Nigerian Vibrator It’s not that simple or black and white. You know exactly what you’re doing and are just playing dumb because you’re a troll with nothing better to do than to get a rise out of people in the RUclips comment section. I’m not gonna explain to you why your argument is very loose (and appears to intentionally lack effort); but what I will say is that it’s not racist to face social consequences for saying something that is obviously meant to degrade or marginalize the other party. Nobody said you’re “not allowed” to say certain things, you can say anything you want. Just don’t bitch and moan when people get rightfully offended when you say something bigoted and unfunny just for the sake of “dark humor.” You’re not a comedian, you’re just a dick with no social cues. This comment is not necessarily for the low-grade troll I’m replying to but for all of the anti-SJWs that use the “you’re too sensitive” card as an excuse to repeatedly use unfunny, offensive “jokes” with the added benefit of not completely looking like an asshole. Maybe get out of your basements and experience real life instead of trying to be an edgy contrarian!
Brannie But that's not what's happening is it? You can't say whatever you want can you? Hundreds of channels have been demonised because crowder (who is a closeted homosexual himself) made a shirt calling the queer a fig. Social consequences are fine because freedom of speech implies that. But losing your income when you have a family to look after and bills to pay because you made a joke. No. It's never right no matter what idiotic group of brainwashed cunts say. You are wrong because if we had it your way people would be on the streets because of their opinions.
Milkshakes aren't violence, they just point out how pathetic farage (who bragged that if Brexit didnt pass he would take arms) and his peers are, afraid of getting a little dirty. Watch ThoughtSlime's vid on this dumb hysteria.
@@craigtrautmanjr9393 Getting physical is infinitely worse than words. If you can't see that then there is nothing anybody can do to help you. Remember the old adage, peace ends when conversation stops.
@@craigtrautmanjr9393 Question, if I spit on you would you consider that assault? Throwing anything at anyone is violence, are you a tard or what? A girl in Florida just got arrested for battery after throwing a milkshake on someone. Just because something might not cause immediate harm doesn't mean it's not assault. Who knows what they might be putting in those drinks, someone could have an allergic reaction, it could lead to escalation etc. The reasons for it being wrong and illegal are legit and you're just being disingenuous.
@@craigtrautmanjr9393 "Milkshakes aren't violence" The law disagrees, and I wish you'd be milkshaked every second you stepped out of your house until you realize what you're advocating.
@@duffman9908 some people wont change their mind with debate, they BENEFIT from scapegoating and dehumanizing others. They prey on fears so they can get people to give them power. When ride on their image of decisive authority, which gets tarnished by "eggings and milkshakings". It doesnt do much, it's really a futile act, like ramming a boat into Cthulu, yet those who hate leftism or love the status quo act like pogroms are being done.
Carlos said in a recent video "journalists should be gatekeepers of information." You realize how scary that idea is, right? He's downright evil if he believes that.
Yeah but being stupid doesn't mean you should be Doxxed. That could have affected his family's life and they probably don't share his same views. Doxxing doesn't just affect one person you know?
usucdik The press are not there to gatekeep. They are there to relay information speedily and effectively, giving people access to events occurring and important occurrences either locally or not. They are not there to keep information from people. Anyone can become the “press” which is immensely helpful these days as we can see information for ourselves instead of constantly relying on the “press”. They are not superior people capable of handling information that they can choose who gets access to it. That is dangerous and the opposite of what they should do.
usucdik This coming from someone who pursued journalism as a career. I left that path but I clearly remember the motivation for it. I didn’t want to control narratives or information. A gatekeeper is not what a journalist should be. Individual journalism is possibly the greatest way to keep the highly corporate and biased media in check.
Cove not good unless you consider the pro Biden News Networks as better alternatives. People constantly say the election is rigged in the DNC. I tell them my presidential candidate is a billionaire businessman that had never before held office and spent less than his crony establishment opponent, on behalf of the party of limited government. We desire a system where everyone rich or poor pays equal amounts.
Gotta say Phil, really respect how you covered the Crowder/Vox story. Very nice blend of giving both sides point of view using quotes and clips letting them tell their own story. This is an example of how to be a truly non-bias news medium.
@Michael Flemson you forgot to include that steven was outright lying when he called his coverage and bullying of a single individual repeatedly "friendly ribbing"
@@sudevsen It's not about crowder's income or Maza's income, this will harm youtube as a platform. Make it much harder for other creators to produce content. Nobody wins from this.
I agree, I don't totally like Steven Crowder, but I do believe he is a guy who makes himself untouchable by doing the right things. And if you are going to call yourself these words in a public forum you must also be able to be criticized by those words in a public forum. Oh and don't throw stones when you live in a glass house. And I used to watch and support a lot of what Vox was doing. And I think if Crowder ever got to sit on a campus near me I would love to have a chat with him on some of the things and definitely disagree on some of them.
Carlos Maza: I'm not trying to get Crowder banned, I'm just screaming at the RUclips team on social media about him, and trying to start a twitter mob against RUclips until they ban him. Totally not specifically targeting Crowder though, even though he's the only one I repeatedly use as an example!
@basdenoudsten1 You mean getting doxxed and harassed is just getting their feelings hurt? And I love hearing this stupid excuse for protecting bigoted remarks and riling animosity against minority classes but should 2 people who happen to be apart of those classes say 'White people should die' or 'castrate all men' White men lose their shit. Hell, they lose their shit with a Gilette ad that says men still need to get the toxic part of masculinity out of their systems. Same shit happens with the mere existence of Pride Month. While it's bad to make anyone feel bad for being White or not, straight or not, male or not, the tremendous distinction to be had between these groups is that one collection of groups have a lot more social influence than the other. Being minorities necessarily leaves people vulnerable, especially historically oppressed ones.
@@squeakydeedsdonesoapclean3719 he wasn't doxxed and It's hard to imagine debunking his shitty political propaganda can be considered harrasment. And I like how you had to throw in a generalisation about an entire race of people and missrepresent/damage controll for the blatantly sexist gillette ad while you where there incase you didn't look like enough of an idiot already. And no there are no "minorities" that are oppressed in modern Western society, privilege theory is a conspiracy theory.
@Almighty God George Soros #420 #GetRekd image thinking that trump souporters and the alt right are connected, or even better that they try to use the power of a mainstream corporation to get someone banned.😂 Listen, the alt right are a tiny group of nobody's with no power to gt someone deplatformed and no real numbers to start any kind of real violance, I doubt you could find me even one example of the so called "alt right" doing what this guy did.
basdenoudsten1 I am a centrist and I 100% agree with all the points you make. I mean all Crowder did was use mean words there was no harmful (provoking/encouraging violence or demeaning language) in any of his videos. Also that whole doxing thing, I see that happen countless times on here because everyone has idiot fans. It’s just people doing something THEY (they is capitalized because it’s very important word in this sentence) believe what their doing is right because THEY believe it’s what their idol wants or would help them. This happens constantly no matter what side your on, because *drum roll* people are stupid!
@@DextNRN the phone numbers were more than likely bots because of them all saying the same thing. that said they probably should have censored the numbers just to be safe
well yeah,Vox generally makes family friendly content like the music series or the travel series but Crowder ONLY makes political videos. Trending hates politics and edgy boys.
I think Sudev has a point here: Crowder's genre is what keeps him off the trending page. Most of the Vox videos I've seen on trending are more of the "today I learned" style videos, and the trending page LOVES those.
Sudev Sen Actually, I was challenging one of Maza's arguments. He said, "RUclips is designed to give those assholes a megaphone." 10:06 Which makes no sense considering the demonetizations and restrictions on crowder's videos.
Phil has turned into a little bitch. He won't give his take on things that are even slightly controversial. That's why he can easily call out the ant-vaccination crowd, but won't speak a word on Crowder/Maza.
That's a landmine I don't think Phil wants to step on. although I will admit a lot of his fans are kind of frustrated with several situations that he hasn't really given his opinion on. Of course the only 2 issue I take with Phil is the fact that he never responded to the whole betterhelp thing. He never actually got back to us about the whole thing. The second thing is the fact that he used the term alt right conservatives. Which is kind of a contradiction considering all right as a standard is far right and I was not okay with him comparing normal standard conservatives to neo-nazis basically. But the men never corrected himself not that I can expect him to be perfect but that was pretty, uh.... Not ok
@@haegenspring1999 But that's the thing, he does give his opinions. But it's usually things like anti-vaxing and poisoning homeless people, because who really is going to disagree with him? That's why I like Joe Rogan, regardless of topic, he gives his opinion
I have thought about joining the mugclub for over a year now but refrained.. until this.. finally paid the fee as well.. if only youtube had a real competitor..
Awesome job with the Maza/Crowder. I feel you gave both sides a critical but fair view. Thank you for walking the median between sides. I feel like I can judge it without being blinded by bias.
Overall I think it was good, but I wish Phill had mentioned that Maza was encouraging his followers to mass flag Crowder's videos. That's the only issue I see.
Eeeh, i'm really torn on this,free speech is important and I don't think this is youtube's fault. Assholes will use any platform they can to be assholes, it's like blaming a fedora company because Nice Guys use it regularly. I don't know, if that's is indeed harassment than it should be looked further into, but we shouldn't blame youtube for not censoring channels. As long as it's not illegal shit it should stay up. You can criticise the videos and the people involved, but people shouldn't be criticised for having a opinion or making jokes.
Job Wesley Cox Jr I’ve watched his videos and although I disagree with him on plenty, I think he articulates his points pretty well. I like his new “Change my Mind” segments because he has college kids have respectful discussions with each other, even while disagreeing. I think that’s valuable.
And they won't stop untill youtube is 90s style cable tv. They just erased a comedian and founding youtbe partner for the same jokes they have been doing for 13 years.
but thats the thing, he surely wont tell his subs to go and harrass people, but they will do it anyway, because hate is at the very core of his thinking, its like the shooter of new zealand, he was a trump fan, that doesnt mean that trump encourages people to kill muslims, but he is sending messages to people who would do it because of the hate they carry, and its really dangerous
@@losfalsosdelapaz9933 Can you read minds? How can you possibly know that he or any of his viewers hate gays? Many are very annoyed that some activists that are gay, Maza in particular, attack others while using being gay as a shield to protect themselves from legitimate criticism. People hate that 'crybully' behavior much more than the person's sexual orientation.
@@losfalsosdelapaz9933 Please explain to me how hate is at the very core of his thinking? With your logic, who mind manipulated you to comment that the actions of cyberbullies/active shooters are because of people simply existing. Neither of those men support or have openly directed people into harming others. Also you just said that trump doesn't encourage people to hurt others so what "messages" is he sending exactly? Everyones actions are ultimatley their own, they make that decision to hit send or pull the trigger.
@@ravecaster Yes, it's really scary how the authoritarian politicians immediately went after citizen's rights to self defense (i.e. firearms), just like the New Zealand shooter told them to do.
"Non-violent crimes" Tricking someone into eating something they don't want to counts as violent to me. He was physically injured if he was throwing up.
Oh lord, NOT EVERYTHING is violence. Slapping is considered violence and all it does is hurt feelings. Way more than physically anyway. Its people like you making words violence that are making everything less fun
I'm disappointed Phil didn't address Maza's last comment that Crowder is RUclips's "ideal creator". Virtually every Crowder video is demonetized and Crowder just publicly addressed the fights over the wrongful strikes on his channel.
I think that depends. Does demonetized mean RUclips is making no revenue, or the revenue is being sent somewhere else instead of Crowder like the copystrike system. Even if he genuinely brings no money in for RUclips or himself, he does still generate views and engagement time with his videos, and I'd predict a lot of it. So he can still be an ideal creator, just not the ideal we initial assume him to be in terms of revenue generation.
@@somebodyintheworld5036 He is not ideal in anyway. Videos get demonitized because he is not ideal. He has no filter and is right wing two things youtube would rather stay away from and also its advertisers. If anything he is youtubes worst creator because even though they have demonitized him and shadow banned him he still gets views. Which doesnt look great to advertisers. RUclips would much rather him banned than not but they currently dont have a reason to ban him
@@MrAyuub22 So why wouldn't they just ban him? They don't need someone filing a complaint to ban him. They only ever ban conservatives because of overt calls to violence or public shaming. It would be easy to take several cases of his no-filtered speech and say they violate their TOS and bam. Done. RUclips has (a fuckton of) lawyers and they absolutely could make an ironclad defense for banning Crowder and all of the conservatives channels if they wanted to. Except that they don't want him/them banned. They want them here because they draw eyeballs and clicks. They demonetize videos when it goes too far- in other words when the video would look bad to the general public. But they don't want him going elsewhere.
Isaac Sherman they ban all sorts and they still want dollars in the stupid hate train so they’ll just keep taking all the money from crowders videos instead.
Crowder's channel is entirely demonetized. Meaning no ads appear on it. This was done by youtube because RUclips's algorithm or whatever thinks his channel is NOT IDEAL. He makes no ad revenue from youtube that's why he has the Mug Club to pay for his bills and earn money other than the in video ads that he does himself
Keep in mind that Carlos recently said in a Vox video that "journalists should be the gatekeepers of information." He is making the argument that what information you get should first be chosen by people like him. And he wants someone who gives you information he doesn't like to be silenced. That is some high level arrogance. No matter if you're liberal or conservative, you should always fear the person who thinks they are qualified to screen information for you in the name of "fighting fake news."
Watch the video where he clearly says that you should not treat the news like Fox News. You shouldn't become the news when you're a journalist. But that seemed to have flown over your head.
You don't get it. He's talking of personal harassment on his personal Twitter account. He's not on Vox talking about it. He didn't start out his threads with that intent. He's been harassed for years.
Perfectly unbiased provision of information on this story, it amazes me how the mainstream media can’t pull this off, but content creators like yourself can. Nicely done.
Hey Phil, this might go unnoticed but would you be able to make a memorial shoutout for 8964, the 30 year anniversary of the Tiananman Square Massacre. It's been wiped out from this current generations' memories with the government's encouragement, and I would just love to have a massive platform to shed some light on this memorable day where thousands lost their lives.
@@MohawkJonIs1311 its more than that. ruclips.net/video/w4RjuA65sgQ/видео.html watch this. Of course, it is rather dated, but its worth a watch. Notice how everyone knows the answer, but is afraid to go into any detail.
@@hcs4life21 neither did Crowder. But Maza feels worse than a scorned woman that he's not just calling for Crowder's demonetization, he wants him deplatformed.
Jacob Adkins Maza did nothing wrong, huh? Let’s see about that, he... 1. Has published multiple stories where he has presented false or misleading data (seriously, watch his video about conservatives controlling the media. I thought RUclips was trying to crack down on fake news and that’s the biggest piece of fake news yet. 2. Has endorsed the act of battery against people who have ideological differences. 3. Has pushed for people to mass flag Crowder’s video on Twitter. 4. Has claimed that Crowder told his fans to dox him when Crowder has NEVER told his viewers to dox ANYONE, even people he hates. And shit, that was BEFORE he even started the whole second Adpocalyse. You should see the way he acted when RUclips informed him that Crowder didn’t violate TOS for harassment. He was smearing RUclips on Twitter for falsely stating they support gay content creators as well as pushing for advertisers to pull from RUclips for being attached to “homophobic and racist” creators. I thought Maza was pretty damn deplorable before, but considering the way he acted when RUclips didn’t give him the answer he wanted, he’s officially the worst sort of person. The sad thing is, this guy is going to continue throwing his weight around to achieve his ideological agenda because RUclips won’t grow a backbone and put him in his place.
Crowder's Canadian healthcare system video is pretty amazing. Hard to doctor Canadian's pissing all over their own healthcare system but the left tried to get that video pulled while insinuating he did just that. They couldn't provide any proof.
@@RJT80 He fakes a booboo and the Canadians make him sit in a waiting room. Sounds like good triage. Maybe he should get hit in the head with a brick a few times and see if they'll see him. That'll own the libs.
When an ad pops up in the video and you're confused about it because it's philly d's channel and he's usually demonetized by the time you watch the video 😂
Wait Phil gets demonetized? Since when (asking seriously, not trolling)? Usually only clear right wing channels on RUclips get demonetized but Phil's channel is unbiased or at times left-leaning.
@@sandwichthief6811 yes, I typically watch his videos the morning after they're posted while I get ready for work in the morning and I almost never see mid-roll ads. It's usually because of the content he covers is graphic or pick whatever reason they might demonetize it.
Kevin I’m sorry you’re offended by _private companies_ not wanting to spread homophobia. It’s not about the words used, it’s about _the way_ they’re used.
@@romanlees9114 Not a liberal and I adore offensive humor. The only funny thing Crowder did was when he got BTFO'd by a teenage college kid and pretended to get all offended when the kid described certain facets of libertarianism as autistic, and the fairly brilliant takedown Chapo Trap House did of him. Other than that, he's unfunny trash.
Crowder is the real victim here. But Vox is giant corporation and therefore they wield an enormous power. And why the f*ck gets Corrrrrrrtez involved in this while she obviously didn't understand nothing?
@Jay Just so we're clear, the first amendment protects citizens from being censored by the government. Private institutions such as RUclips have the right to censor whomever they want, whenever they want, for whichever reason they want. I'm not going to argue for either side, but I want to establish that your (and their) first amendment rights and freedom of speech do not apply on this platform.
Carlos is still living in high school in his mind. He's never grown up and is not capable of living in the real world where his feelings might get hurt. He's got no spine
the whole point is that he’s an unbiased reporter. even if he gave us the story and THEN gave us his opinion, a lot of people will just retain the latter as fact. sad but true🤷♀️
@@michaelz8235 your ignorance is showing kiddo. you get triggered way too easily. learn to breath and take naps throughout the day to help counter your afternoon tantrums. Best of luck to your mental health. oh and there's a difference between libertarian and liberal. not that you could ever spot the difference.
I've seen this comment like 20 times over in the top comments since Phil first started the throat punch throwaway joke. How is this still funny to anyone?
Too true - How many ads are on Vox's videos vs anyone right of center? More victim carding... 75 mins of video debunking their videos, and 2 minutes total is making jokes about him directly, vs the other 70 mins of fact checking and counter points.
What do you expect from LGBT people who try to exploit themselves for money? It's no different than sex workers supporting feminism: They're exploiting themselves and feminism helps them get benefits and money.
RUclips should and he has every right to say something if someone is attacking him and his character, ethnicity and sexuality. If you don't like that... Cry us a river, melt like a snowflake or whine like a byotch 😂
Isn't it like black people call themselves and other black people the 'n' word, but white people can't. especially in the offensive way Crowder is using these gay terms. Imagine if Crowder was saying black man over and over instead of gay man, and if the black man uses the 'n' word in his title name, does that give Crowder the right to use the 'n' word in targetting this man? I find ga yinsults towards gay people aren't seen as more serious as racism or sexism.
@@Hmonglauj89 It's the same as a black person calling himself the 'n' word. Does it give the right for a white person to call him a 'n' word offensively because he himself refers to hi mself as an 'n'word? No, it doesn't.
@@kiragoe A lot of people would argue that if you're going to call yourself something, you can't reasonably expect other people not to address you by it as well. So your point, while valid, really doesn't matter here.
Hmmm well he doesn't get demonitized nearly as much as he should considering his bigotish nature and doesn't seem to think it's bad to put an obvious reference to the word fag on his merch. This man also has over 3 million subs. This man is being handed subs because the platform promotes people who are loud and the only people who are are the bigots and racists.
Kole Tokar I know right, especially when you actually watch crowder and all of his videos are suppressed from his subs, demonetization on all his vids, Carlos is out of his mind.
@@UndyingNero Genuinely curious, "Bigotry" refers to refusal to alter your views even when faced with contradicting evidence... When has Crowder willfully neglected allowing evidence to reflect his views? (Not a fanboy just wondering why you say he is a bigot)
@@UndyingNero Bullshit. Have you actually seen one of his videos? I didn't even know the guy until today so I went to check out his content. You are outright wrong.
Yes, Crowder uses terms that are probably not desirable, but the other 99% of his videos are very legitimately criticizing mazza's ideas. He is hiding behind that 1% to not address Crowder's content
Agreed, Maza is hiding behind 0.1% of Crowders message. The things crowder calls Maza is just for fun, really not meant as harassment. Crowder is a comedian after all. Basicly like SNL for conservatives. If Crowder is banned, so should SNL, etc.
@@kurtjensen5798 so SNL is only for liberals? Last time I checked they have no problem mocking anybody who deserves to be mocked; doesn't matter if they're liberal, conservative, democrat, republican, black, white, etc. Not a very good comparison lol
If either he or Sargon of Akkad, the two people I actually give a shit about on RUclips go... I am going to finally make the move to Bitchute, a few of my other creators already left for there. That and Gab.AI which I already use.
Sugarwood I may not always agree with him, but rarely can I complain about the coverage. And while he does give his opinion, I like that he keeps it to the end after he's laid it all out.
@@Jack-lm5nx not only did he dropped an apology video... But he dropped the best apology video in the history of apology videos... He's by far my favorite when making apology videos
It's not that they can't explain, they've actually said that they don't violate their TOS and policies. The reason they have demonetized Crowder is because of a shirt he sells that says "Socialism is for figs" which people have misunderstood for another word, but RUclips themselves actually recognized it was "figs" and not the other word, but still demonetized him and told him to remove it.
even i was surprised , philip started out with painting a bleak image of crowder with the extracts of him throwing insults and giving a wide coverage to maza's victim twitter posts , but i was shocked when philip actually gave crowder's defence a chance to be heard . As content i am with philip on this one , from my experience i feel like he was forced to add Crowder's defense , not doing so would have hit him hard with his subs and reputation as " alternative news provider"
That could be said for crowder as well. He talks mad shit then gets called out for it and acts like he’s the one under attack. This is not a war. This a guy being called out for gay bashing. Maza said this isn’t about crowder,it’s about YT following its own guidelines regardless of how many followers a creator has. A gay man calling him self queer is a lot diff then a strait guy doing jazz hands and making a lispy voice ever time he refers to that gay guy. Just my opinion.
@@thestig572420 he gets called out all the time. He has no problem dishing it out. But this guy is trying to BAN him waving the gay wand around and RUclips is going to be screwed both ways from this situation wether they do or dont ban him.
Arkangel19024 He clearly said he’s not trying to ban anyone just get you tube to follow it own guidelines. Sry I just can not stick up for a grown man with the word FAG printed on his shirt. . Even worse is he didn’t have the balls to own it and says no no no that’s a fig leaf ,wink wink.
John Smith would that really be relevant though? I’m js, he was specifically talking about Maza, so he showed Crowders Maza comments. Relevance matters.
VIRTUAL REALMS I’m actually a huge Crowder fan, and I’m surprised that there was a fair reporting on his side of the story. That rarely happens for conservatives, so I will say thank you when it does.
Hector Perez lol I was about to type the exact same thing. I’m constantly blown away by the complete ignorance of the left. There is definitely ignorance on both sides, don’t get me wrong. But I always see folks from the left calling things like Crowder, Fox News, etc partisan bullshit. Yeah, it definitely is and I’d say most conservatives freely admit that. But for some reason the vast majority of the left seem to not realize the shows they gravitate to are equally partisan, just on the other side. My biggest problem with Maza is how he presents his content as if it’s above reproach. Then whenever he’s called out for making a shit video he falls back on being gay and claims everyone persecutes him for his sexuality.
Not gonna lie I was REALLY expecting you to cover voxs side a little stronger. But you didn’t. You gave the facts of both sides and left your own opinions out and unbiased. Thank you. Just subbed
Don't get used to it. Phil is good at presenting the many sides of a story but in many cases he is extremely biased and makes subtle implicit nods towards his bias. I really hate how he covers many stories but since he does give a lot of information I just learned to filter him out over the many years of watching. Just letting you know ahead of time that this instance is the anomaly, not the rule.
Eisenhorn i think he sides with the LGBT community but doesn't feel that this merits any sort of legitimacy because Vox boy is blowing it up much bigger than it is
I honestly have only ever seen one more of his videos back during the whole alinity and pewdiepie situation last year. I didn’t agree with how he kind of favored alinity more but I guess I’ll just have to watch more videos to find out. Thanks for looking out tho.
@@eisenhorn5614 Sometimes he's really good at it (like in this video), but I have seen others where his bias is interjected so potently it's painful. Enough to actually lose some of the pertinent facts. Overall, though, he usually does a pretty good job.
@@SiMeGamer He tries extremely hard to cover stories objectively, but sometimes it's impossible to act like all "sides" of a story deserve the same respect.
kreneks 01 That’s not half his audience, just the people who are most vocal. There’s plenty of people who are on Vox’s side that know if they were vocal about it they’d just be inviting harassment from Crowder’s fanbase.
@@GaiashKetoji dude. It's a youtube comment section. People aren't getting harrased here. All I've seen is arguing, with most of the support being for crowder.
kreneks 01 Because Crowder’s fanbase is loud. The most vocal group is not the largest. And as for harassment you’ve most likely not seen it because you don’t know what you’re looking for.
Note about Crowder's shirt: I'm sure the "fig" part is making a stab at a similar sounding word, but it's also actually a reference to a communist who'd been killed under a fig tree. hence "Communism is for figs."
Because I believe some people from the far left love to be triggered so if they see something closely representing something they can point out and screech about it
As a gay man myself, I side with Crowder sure what hes done isn't right but he shouldn't be targeted as this "monster" that Maza is touting. Carlos Maza is just another privileged man that thinks because hes gay if someone makes fun that hes being attacked. As for the doxxing that's not his fault. It'd be the same as Phil making fun of whoever and some irresponsible follower deciding to dox whoever he was making fun of. Its just another case of trying to play victim for his own monetary desire under the guise of LGBT. Hes trying to use his sexuallity as a weapon to silence things he doesn't agree with and it actually makes our community look bad. That's just my two cents.
As a conservative myself, I completely agree with your viewpoint. This is kinda where the "I don't care about your sexually" thing comes from. Judge a person's character; not their skin, sex, or anything of the sort.
And the guy is a comedian. He makes jokes about everyone and basically everything. He’s trying to entertain. Make people laugh. He’s said multiple times he doesn’t care if you are gay or straight. But context writes the narrative.
Uh, although I disagree with bullying Carlos in the sense of calling him names, The way Carlos wrote his tweets was very manipulative towards RUclips saying “nothing will happen because RUclips doesn’t care about their queer creators” is obviously very manipulative which, although I hate to say it, brings me more into Crowder’s side. I do not like his content as I do find it insulting what he as said towards the transgender community, however I do not believe his channel should be taken down.
You have my full respect. I happen to be a Crowder fan, but I love that regardless of how you feel about him and his comedy and views, you recognize that it's still not worth banning him for. You have a very good day now sir (or ma'am lol)
Don't get me wrong, the bullying sometimes is taken too far. But the vox guy definitely seems like he's just trying to use pride month to direct more outage at the issue because he's mad for getting his work scrutinized. Also, if you're going to comment to insult either person. Don't. It's not beneficial in any way.
Yeah when he emphasizes it every time he talks about the situation it's so painfully obvious.. He's just trying to use the community which is messed up imo
it seemed fair, but they left out a lot of stuff and made crowder look worse than he actually is, Maza is just as guilty of the same things crowder has done, but not much was done to show that in this video. Not mad, or butthurt, just wish they had been more even handed in the story.
Would have liked to see a link to Crowder's response alongside the original Vox accusations in the "Today's Stories" section of the show notes and links.
yeah thought it was really even on both political sides, not leaning left or right which is nice. Thats usually why I like Phil, give us the news with a touch of opinion so that way we can look at the facts for ourselves and make our own opinions!
The Crowder v. Box reporter just gives me an excuse to get the popcorn and watch. I wouldn't be surprised if RUclips really doesn't acknowledge the situation since other issues are coming up that are higher in priority.
I was honestly worried about the bias that may be present in the vox vs crowder segment but it was actually done great doing both sides justice in my opinion
Phil conveniently left out the false flagging campaign up Crowder's channel that Mazza put up on Twitter. That's a pretty damning piece of evidence that should have been introduced into that piece.
Phil seems to have missed the whole part where Vox false flagged crowders videos, crowder fought and won and Vox did the exact same thing again, with no punishment for falsely flagging the video.
Shayan Ali - Yes, Crowder jokingly insults people. Yes, it is offensive. No, it’s not close to harassment. No, a joke from some comedian will not ruin my day.
Johnus Smittinis how do you draw the line as to what is considered harassment? Secondly i keep seeing this argument,you seem to not understand that the amount of harassment he gets isn’t like one or two messages? It’s probably a lot but I can’t say but on principle making fun of someone’s sexuality and ethnicity where the punchline is the sexuality and ethnicity is harassment dude,and if not that extremely enablist-can we at least agree tot that Edit: should your personal capacity dictate how much other people should be willing to take? This sort of simplistic thinking does not solve problems just helps to defend shitheads like crowder
1. The shirt does not have a gay slur. It says 'fig.' As in, the fruit. 2. Maza has repeatedly stated that he wants Crowder banned. You lied when you claimed he said he doesn't.
That’s so obviously bullshit though. The phrase makes no sense as “figs” and Che is making a stereotypical gay gesture on the shirt. Anyone with a brain knows what Crowder means. I really hope you’re just being disingenuous and is not actually this dumb.
frisater96 Che was was captured in an area whose name when translated reads : the fig tree, I’m sure it’s meant to be a shirt that can be read both ways. You assigning your reading as THE reading is a problem.
@@jacobtsatskis5335 It's not meant to be read both ways. It's pretty clear in its message. The fact that there are people so utterly dishonest they would try to actually defend it really bothers me. Why not just be honest about your ideas like a big boy, instead of hiding behind fucking word riddles? And no. Steven Crowder is a cowardly, dishonest grifter, that's the problem here.
@Robert Rodgers I've personally spoken to many white supremacist (real ones, not the fake ones you have in mind) and they became like that due to the anti white sentiments from the liberal/sjw culture. I became a white nationalist (not a white supremacist) due to the anti white sentiments from democrats during 2016. It's liberals who are creating g these people by constantly demonizing straight white males and reporting on them like they are the worst race on the planet. I'm glad nationalism is taking over
Not of fan of steven crowder but carlos is one of the worst writers/journalists if you can call him that out there. He is completely biased and the majority of his videos are full of lies or complete bullshit.
@@craigtrautmanjr9393 Deplatforming for stating an opinion you don`t like is a precedent you want to see set huh? Hope you can stick to that if that ever happens to you.
@@quintonthevillain2745 crowder having a shitty opinion isnt why I want crowder to burn. My parents have those bad opinions. I USED TO HAVE THOSE OPINIONS. But if we call people slurs, we gotta face consequences for being fucks. And crowder's been preying on marginalized people for years. I heard about him when he was harassing illegal immigrants looking for work just for a laugh. Hes an awful person that loves to hurt people he hates.
@@craigtrautmanjr9393 i can bet you crowder isnt going anywhere. He will be around to debunk al of vox political ideology. I wan to see you democrunts crying rivers of tears to help with the fake climate hoax.
Oh hey...timecodes!
Oreo Prank Sentencing (00:06), TIA (3:41), Ebola and Measles Outbreaks (6:20), Vox Host Accuses Crowder of Bullying (7:19)
tia and outbreaks are switched i think
Philip DeFranco CRAP! You missed the Miley Cyrus story, groped and choked by a crazy fan in Spain!
Please talk about the Ohio tornadoes
Phil, the measles is at 3:41 and TIA is 6:20
Talk about Milo Yiannopoulos being on the legion of skanks podcast and the threat of people tagging Antifa online and threatening to throw milkshakes and shit.
I think the comments section would prefer to pass this question back to you Phil and get your personal opinion on the Crowder/Maza story.
Probably best to put that in a separate video so as to avoid the obvious outrage of bias.
@@dnw009 Yeah you're probably right there. It's a shame that people would react that way though as regardless of Phil's opinion this is an excellent video covering both sides fairly imo so the idea that people will instantly ignore that once he gives an opinion they don't like irritates me.
That is one amazing Uno reverse card if I ever saw one.
I think Phil did his job, no reason to put himself at risk. Keep telling us the news Phil, that's what brings me back at least.
I don't want Phil's take. There is enough commentary content out their. It's nice to have a neutral source every now and then.
Hopefully jake paul (the figurehead of the anti bullying committee) will be able to resolve this maza/crowder situation
🤣🤣
😂
Celebrity boxing with Jake Paul as the ref?
This actually made me laugh out loud.
He doesnt have the brain capacity to understand real sociopolitical matters lmaoooo
Seeing Steven Crowder and Carlos Maza’s face in the thumbnail, you know this video would be juicy
Is it acceptable to not like either of them? I don't care for Crowder's humor, but Klein also annoys me for his comfort with Antifa and deplatforming people he disagrees with.
@@OdinHyrule Oh he annoys you with his opinion? Crowder annoys many with his retarded opinions. Yet.
OdinHyrule hey I feel it. Crowder does make points that frustrate me and Vox does the same.
@@Kabsh11ufo "Retarded opinions"- isnt it past your bedtime buddy?
@@albion7186 gotem. You had the big boy pants on today
If mazza thinks this platform is for monsters maybe he and vox should use a different platform
@OFswag666 you're right, we should just let maza become the police of youtube and anyone he says is bad, just kick em off. Pewdiepie, nazi, kick im off. Ben Shapiro, alt right white supremacist, kick im off. Anyone who disagrees with maza, alt right bigot, kick em off
thats too hard for them, none of those idiots can learn to code
Garrett Cramer seriously. What a dumb thing to say
@OFswag666 some people would say you're a monster with 666 as a name. I vote to kick you off the platform because I'm offended...
@OFswag666 Insult comedy is a thing. They air roasts on Comedy Central. The best comedians in the world mock people non stop. Chappelle, Richard Pryor, etc etc. But who chooses the protected class that is above mockery? "666" you mock Christianity. Go about your day. Let's say you name your self Muhammad killer. To quote the Joker "Everyone loses their mind." He recommends his audience to throw milkshakes at people they don't agree with politically. It's ok. Keep making your money. He calls himself a gay Mexican. Ok. Someone else calls him a gay Mexican... "That's fucking illegal"
I stopped using Facebook months ago and have noticed a significant improvement in my satisfaction with my day to day life. Take the plunge man.
Likewise. It's better than when I gave up TV. Such a time suck and emotional opioid.
Same!!
I don't get it, you can filter what you can see....I just see my friends posts and things want to see.... I don't get why people hate FB.....
I deleted my facebook 4 days after I got it in the beginning of facebook when I saw how fake everyone was!
Y.S. I agree, I think it has to do with peoples lack of self control and extreme need for approval and attention. About 5 years ago when i was a teenager I realized I was spreading negativity on FB. I’ve stopped posting sense. I only post about a few times a year or less. I’m happy because now if I post something it has to have weight and meaning to it otherwise it’s not worth breaking a streak of keeping to my fucking self about my shit opinions.
As a free speech / human rights / anti-censorship advocate. I'm firmly against this idea of "deplatforming" or banning those that have opinions that someone disagrees with. If I didn't defend the free speech for people that I disagree with I'd be a pretty large hypocrite. This quote is pretty accurate:
“Goebbels was in favor of free speech for views he liked. So was Stalin. If you’re really in favor of free speech, then you’re in favor of freedom of speech for precisely the views you despise. Otherwise, you’re not in favor of free speech.” ― Noam Chomsky
Freedom of speech, like any freedom, has its limits. Freedom without limits is anarchy.
@@melaneaa4071What exactly did he say that you find so inflammatory (As a watcher of his content, although I don’t always agree with him, I am still genuinely curious)
I legit have a feeling Phil will talk about the Maza/Crowder issue exactly three months from today again
Have you seen it... In the cards?
No, he’ll talk about it in 3 weeks on Thursday.
@@mkobd shhhh don't spoil
just give him a strike and call it a day
I don't understand what's going on. Could someone please explain?
Maza had his feelings hurt, poor baby. Your on social media dude, grow some thick skin or get off the platform.
You're*
Yup
Crowder is trash. Sounds like Crowder and his fans are shaking in their boots. lol
I don't believe he had his feelings hurt. Victimization is a form of currency for the left and Maza is raking in some bank. It's all just a naked power play. Absolutely despicable behavior.
@@binaryvoid0101 if Crowder is trash, vox is radioactive horseshit
That kid is a sociopath. Don't think 15 months in jail will fix him.
What kid... Carlos??? What??
Who here immediately skipped to Crowder/Maza story?
John McDowell Same.
That is actually why I looked for this video.
I wanted to but i ended up watching it all
Could anyone perhaps explain what happened at the very beginning? What is the reason of Crowder going after Maza for the first time? Did Maza do something controversial before Crowder and Maza started fighting eachother?
While this video clears some things up in a non-bias way (which I really appreciate), I still feel like there is some context missing. Or am I wrong?
@@SneakyJ1991 this is the first 'fight'
everything else is just clips from crowders response videos to vox videos taken from several years worth of content, and picked out of several hundred other videos entirely unrelated to vox.
You covered the Crowder/vox story really fairly, the only thing I'd add is in one part of the Twitter thread Carlos called for his followers to mass flag Crowder in retaliation. That was the specific censorship to which he was referring.
Maza is trying to get YT to ban Crowder. The censorship is, in fact, YT 'hiding' Crowder's videos, which they have already been caught doing.
@benjovi55 it didn't seem like he reached out to maza either, though. At least it's fair.
That "Censorship" is nothing else than calling on RUclips to enforce their own guidelines. If anyone is unhappy with that, why not use another platform? oh wait, there is none :^)
And you know.. Phil could have added a personal opinion.
This is important, at no point does crowder directly initiate a call-to-action for his followers to do anything malicious. As where Carlos does directly call for violence on multiple occasions.
I’m starting to see a pattern.
the clips of crowder cut up are actually funnier than they are in context.
Got kinda cringy after a while
Gotta love a guy like phil giving the fact and only the facts in the crowder vs maza controversy
It really makes Maza look like a cry baby throwing a tantrum that RUclips won't get rid of the guy that systematically dismantles they one of his arguments
Too bad once again Phil didn't do that. He left out the part where Mazda is calling for massive false flagging of all of Crowders content. Or the fact that Crowder has reached out to Maza in the past. Or the fact that Crowder doesn't care that he's gay. All that stuff magically didn't get mentioned. Yet all of it is public record and available on Twitter and Crowders Channel.
magurgle hmm lets see would you get butt hurt when you get doxxed?
Mike stiles He put in enough info to paint the full picture, no need for extra details to add runtime
@@magurgle Yeah. He's really throwing a tantrum at the guy who harasses him to the point of doxing.
Exactly how much of a dumb shit are you?
So I don't use Twitter or facebook. Been Six years and I'm doing great.
Bro I'm in the same boat and it's the most freeing thing I've ever experienced
Getting rid of Facebook was one of the best decisions I made. Been more than a year now, and it's awesome.
I’ve never used Twitter and I’m so glad. Seeing all of what goes down on Twitter makes me happy I never joined the cesspool
everyday on the news, Twitter hate this, Facebook violates that, Ugh! who even needs to belong to those platforms, the bullshit bleeds through into most media now.
And yet we're all sitting here, in this shit filled traphouse tub, also known as the youtube comment section
Phil how dare you not threaten me with physical violence
Nick Lucas it's like he doesn't care
Probobly because it got old.
Can we stop with this? It's not a good look when you are trying to set up a reputable news source. Personally I don't care for it, physical violence is not a meme.
@@MatthewSchellGaming Pfft "reputable", so you want him to be some bland corporate news?
Humor never does please everybody's taste
@@indiecloud100 we could show more exsplosions durring the show, some fire too, and still be professional about it!
So he calls the self-proclaimed queer with a lisp a “lispy queer” and that qualified as harassment and bullying?
@nate So the color of your skin determines what you're allowed to say? Sounds pretty fucking racist to me bud.
Let’s not let Crowder off easy. He just wouldn’t back off this guy
Nigerian Vibrator It’s not that simple or black and white. You know exactly what you’re doing and are just playing dumb because you’re a troll with nothing better to do than to get a rise out of people in the RUclips comment section. I’m not gonna explain to you why your argument is very loose (and appears to intentionally lack effort); but what I will say is that it’s not racist to face social consequences for saying something that is obviously meant to degrade or marginalize the other party. Nobody said you’re “not allowed” to say certain things, you can say anything you want. Just don’t bitch and moan when people get rightfully offended when you say something bigoted and unfunny just for the sake of “dark humor.” You’re not a comedian, you’re just a dick with no social cues.
This comment is not necessarily for the low-grade troll I’m replying to but for all of the anti-SJWs that use the “you’re too sensitive” card as an excuse to repeatedly use unfunny, offensive “jokes” with the added benefit of not completely looking like an asshole.
Maybe get out of your basements and experience real life instead of trying to be an edgy contrarian!
There’s a line
Brannie But that's not what's happening is it? You can't say whatever you want can you? Hundreds of channels have been demonised because crowder (who is a closeted homosexual himself) made a shirt calling the queer a fig. Social consequences are fine because freedom of speech implies that. But losing your income when you have a family to look after and bills to pay because you made a joke. No. It's never right no matter what idiotic group of brainwashed cunts say. You are wrong because if we had it your way people would be on the streets because of their opinions.
don't let the stories distract you from the fact phil did not threaten us today :/
He could’ve at least threatened us with a bitch slap. :-(
You damm right
Jared Torres ikr😞
Kabliahk we all are hopefully Phil will take this as a learning moment and will grow
:(
Thank you for showing Tim Pool calling out Carlos Maza for being a hypocrite. That needed to be brought to light.
Milkshakes aren't violence, they just point out how pathetic farage (who bragged that if Brexit didnt pass he would take arms) and his peers are, afraid of getting a little dirty. Watch ThoughtSlime's vid on this dumb hysteria.
@@craigtrautmanjr9393 Getting physical is infinitely worse than words. If you can't see that then there is nothing anybody can do to help you. Remember the old adage, peace ends when conversation stops.
@@craigtrautmanjr9393 Question, if I spit on you would you consider that assault? Throwing anything at anyone is violence, are you a tard or what? A girl in Florida just got arrested for battery after throwing a milkshake on someone. Just because something might not cause immediate harm doesn't mean it's not assault. Who knows what they might be putting in those drinks, someone could have an allergic reaction, it could lead to escalation etc. The reasons for it being wrong and illegal are legit and you're just being disingenuous.
@@craigtrautmanjr9393 "Milkshakes aren't violence" The law disagrees, and I wish you'd be milkshaked every second you stepped out of your house until you realize what you're advocating.
@@duffman9908 some people wont change their mind with debate, they BENEFIT from scapegoating and dehumanizing others. They prey on fears so they can get people to give them power. When ride on their image of decisive authority, which gets tarnished by "eggings and milkshakings". It doesnt do much, it's really a futile act, like ramming a boat into Cthulu, yet those who hate leftism or love the status quo act like pogroms are being done.
Carlos said in a recent video "journalists should be gatekeepers of information." You realize how scary that idea is, right? He's downright evil if he believes that.
Yeah, the real TRUTH comes from QAnon and Alex Jones!
Yeah but being stupid doesn't mean you should be Doxxed. That could have affected his family's life and they probably don't share his same views. Doxxing doesn't just affect one person you know?
Bingo! The left's belief is control what reaches you which is why they will not debate with WORDS, but instead will try to deplatform pages.
usucdik The press are not there to gatekeep. They are there to relay information speedily and effectively, giving people access to events occurring and important occurrences either locally or not. They are not there to keep information from people. Anyone can become the “press” which is immensely helpful these days as we can see information for ourselves instead of constantly relying on the “press”. They are not superior people capable of handling information that they can choose who gets access to it. That is dangerous and the opposite of what they should do.
usucdik This coming from someone who pursued journalism as a career. I left that path but I clearly remember the motivation for it. I didn’t want to control narratives or information. A gatekeeper is not what a journalist should be. Individual journalism is possibly the greatest way to keep the highly corporate and biased media in check.
Some people are forgetting to mention that his active mission as a journalist at vox is to deplatform fox news
Good
Cove not good unless you consider the pro Biden News Networks as better alternatives. People constantly say the election is rigged in the DNC. I tell them my presidential candidate is a billionaire businessman that had never before held office and spent less than his crony establishment opponent, on behalf of the party of limited government. We desire a system where everyone rich or poor pays equal amounts.
Racist
Gotta say Phil, really respect how you covered the Crowder/Vox story. Very nice blend of giving both sides point of view using quotes and clips letting them tell their own story.
This is an example of how to be a truly non-bias news medium.
@Michael Flemson i personaly am okay with that
@Michael Flemson you forgot to include that steven was outright lying when he called his coverage and bullying of a single individual repeatedly "friendly ribbing"
@@surelyurcrazy7671
Oh, cool! A psychic! What's it like to know people thousands-of-miles-away's intent?
James Higdon the montage that was shown was literal bullying
@@thomasross6824 Montages don't show context. Next.
Thank you so much for covering the crowder/vox story in an unbiased way!! This is why I watch your videos.
@Slippery When Wet! You spelled crowder wrong.
@@TheDeadlyBlueWolf Yes, Crowder is the victim but in that sentence he was referencing maza. Its ok words are hard :)
@@TheDeadlyBlueWolf lmao you stupid, go march on the street for the lgbtqnhgahhgyryhRTARD rights
@@brtd8782 We will thank you! You and Stevie are more than welcome to come. We LOVE closeted fresh meat like you! 💅🏾🌈
@@swandivemedia9249 You're. Not. Funny. Ok?
Nice cover of that crowder-Mazda "war" but you forgot to mention the interview maza gave where he implied that he wants another adpocalypse
Yeah, a checkmark will never say that.
I guess thats what needs to be done for RUclips to take action as they only care about the money
@@sudevsen Ah yes let's damage everyone's livelihood so I can be petty
@@filipt7866 Crowder has Koch brothers funding.He'll be fine.
Maybe he should try to be nicer if he's so scared of losing his big bucks.
@@sudevsen It's not about crowder's income or Maza's income, this will harm youtube as a platform.
Make it much harder for other creators to produce content. Nobody wins from this.
It's weird how you shared that Carlos vs Stephen thing without any bias. That's actually pretty interesting to see nowadays.
Well... without any OVERT bias.
NaptimeGaming cuz Phillip is a good guy
NaptimeGaming I heard him snicker twice at jokes made by Crowder guy. Bias?
@@Seriouslygorgeous honestly philip is not biased
*Steven.
Thank you for giving time for the Steven Crowder vs Vox thing.
Steven Crowder is an intellectual coward...
...there is alot of his Cult Members around.
this Drama is bringing them out of the bushes...
@@godwings101
Not from what I've seen.
I agree, I don't totally like Steven Crowder, but I do believe he is a guy who makes himself untouchable by doing the right things. And if you are going to call yourself these words in a public forum you must also be able to be criticized by those words in a public forum. Oh and don't throw stones when you live in a glass house. And I used to watch and support a lot of what Vox was doing. And I think if Crowder ever got to sit on a campus near me I would love to have a chat with him on some of the things and definitely disagree on some of them.
@@godwings101 how lol? Seems like Maza is the one that cries harassment whenever he is debated on something
Carlos Maza: I'm not trying to get Crowder banned, I'm just screaming at the RUclips team on social media about him, and trying to start a twitter mob against RUclips until they ban him. Totally not specifically targeting Crowder though, even though he's the only one I repeatedly use as an example!
@basdenoudsten1 You mean getting doxxed and harassed is just getting their feelings hurt? And I love hearing this stupid excuse for protecting bigoted remarks and riling animosity against minority classes but should 2 people who happen to be apart of those classes say 'White people should die' or 'castrate all men' White men lose their shit. Hell, they lose their shit with a Gilette ad that says men still need to get the toxic part of masculinity out of their systems. Same shit happens with the mere existence of Pride Month.
While it's bad to make anyone feel bad for being White or not, straight or not, male or not, the tremendous distinction to be had between these groups is that one collection of groups have a lot more social influence than the other. Being minorities necessarily leaves people vulnerable, especially historically oppressed ones.
@basdenoudsten1 Crowder could just stop using terms like queer and gay as inherently funny insults, ya know, and not get banned?!
@@squeakydeedsdonesoapclean3719 he wasn't doxxed and It's hard to imagine debunking his shitty political propaganda can be considered harrasment.
And I like how you had to throw in a generalisation about an entire race of people and missrepresent/damage controll for the blatantly sexist gillette ad while you where there incase you didn't look like enough of an idiot already.
And no there are no "minorities" that are oppressed in modern Western society, privilege theory is a conspiracy theory.
@Almighty God George Soros #420 #GetRekd image thinking that trump souporters and the alt right are connected, or even better that they try to use the power of a mainstream corporation to get someone banned.😂
Listen, the alt right are a tiny group of nobody's with no power to gt someone deplatformed and no real numbers to start any kind of real violance, I doubt you could find me even one example of the so called "alt right" doing what this guy did.
basdenoudsten1 I am a centrist and I 100% agree with all the points you make. I mean all Crowder did was use mean words there was no harmful (provoking/encouraging violence or demeaning language) in any of his videos. Also that whole doxing thing, I see that happen countless times on here because everyone has idiot fans. It’s just people doing something THEY (they is capitalized because it’s very important word in this sentence) believe what their doing is right because THEY believe it’s what their idol wants or would help them. This happens constantly no matter what side your on, because *drum roll* people are stupid!
don't worry, Crowder has half-asian lawyer Bill Richmond
lmao. you cannot defeat half-asian lawyer Bill Richmond
This wins the internet for the day!
Also Did he and now Philip just doxx the people with the phone numbers being shown?
@@DextNRN the phone numbers were more than likely bots because of them all saying the same thing. that said they probably should have censored the numbers just to be safe
Close
People in today’s day and age couldn’t of handled 5 minutes in a Xbox chat room.
Amen
If they play 5 minutes of Dota they will die immediately.
@Tucson Jim Did you get butt hurt by someone while gaming?
Or on any playground in the 80s.
@Tucson Jim lolz. That's quite the imagination you got there.
99% of comments: "Philly D didn't threaten to assault me, unsubscribing."
1% of comments: Stuff that he actually talked about.
James Richardson exactly, joke is overdone
Uh yeah not on this video. Now it's mainly people calling Maza a retard.
water5000 I agree, he's an idiot.
Weirdly this comment is about neither...
So your stats are off.
Me Cooper I'm aware. It's called an exaggeration.
Vox is literally always on the trending page.
Ya know who is never on the trending page? Crowder.
The "Ideal creator"
well yeah,Vox generally makes family friendly content like the music series or the travel series but Crowder ONLY makes political videos. Trending hates politics and edgy boys.
@@pichum4st3r Maza is already failing if Crowder is still on the air so.....
I think Sudev has a point here: Crowder's genre is what keeps him off the trending page. Most of the Vox videos I've seen on trending are more of the "today I learned" style videos, and the trending page LOVES those.
Sudev Sen
Actually, I was challenging one of Maza's arguments.
He said, "RUclips is designed to give those assholes a megaphone." 10:06
Which makes no sense considering the demonetizations and restrictions on crowder's videos.
He says that Steven Crowder is "RUclips's Ideal Creator"
That truly makes no sense.
RUclips has always been against him. You should see the lawsuits.
I really wanted to know Phil's take on the Crowder/Maza situation.
We all know that when the subject is controversial, he never gives his opinion. That would upset the advertisers
Phil has turned into a little bitch. He won't give his take on things that are even slightly controversial. That's why he can easily call out the ant-vaccination crowd, but won't speak a word on Crowder/Maza.
That's a landmine I don't think Phil wants to step on. although I will admit a lot of his fans are kind of frustrated with several situations that he hasn't really given his opinion on.
Of course the only 2 issue I take with Phil is the fact that he never responded to the whole betterhelp thing. He never actually got back to us about the whole thing.
The second thing is the fact that he used the term alt right conservatives. Which is kind of a contradiction considering all right as a standard is far right and I was not okay with him comparing normal standard conservatives to neo-nazis basically. But the men never corrected himself not that I can expect him to be perfect but that was pretty, uh.... Not ok
Anthony Flores I think it’s tasteful that he doesn’t give an opinion. It lets us draw our own conclusions rather than picking a side.
@@haegenspring1999 But that's the thing, he does give his opinions. But it's usually things like anti-vaxing and poisoning homeless people, because who really is going to disagree with him? That's why I like Joe Rogan, regardless of topic, he gives his opinion
#MugClub - Thanks Carlos I hate paying RUclipsrs but Crowder just got my $69.00!!
I have thought about joining the mugclub for over a year now but refrained.. until this.. finally paid the fee as well.. if only youtube had a real competitor..
@@troytodd7253 just waiting for thay new service to pop up that will make RUclips die.
Mine as well. Now I have to watch Blaze TV to get my money's worth lol.
@@troytodd7253 pornhub is actually a viable alternative many creators have gone there and we could fill that site with non pornographic content.
Same!
Awesome job with the Maza/Crowder. I feel you gave both sides a critical but fair view. Thank you for walking the median between sides. I feel like I can judge it without being blinded by bias.
Overall I think it was good, but I wish Phill had mentioned that Maza was encouraging his followers to mass flag Crowder's videos. That's the only issue I see.
@@Adam_Hazzzzzze that's because that didn't happen.
@@Alfredo412
Unless the tweet that Crowder showed in his video was fake, it did happen.
Just the facts.
Eeeh, i'm really torn on this,free speech is important and I don't think this is youtube's fault. Assholes will use any platform they can to be assholes, it's like blaming a fedora company because Nice Guys use it regularly.
I don't know, if that's is indeed harassment than it should be looked further into, but we shouldn't blame youtube for not censoring channels. As long as it's not illegal shit it should stay up. You can criticise the videos and the people involved, but people shouldn't be criticised for having a opinion or making jokes.
You can genuinely dispise Crowder and still recognize Maza is a joke.
how? I don't agree with some of Maza's opinions but Crowder clearly called him a lispy queer in a negative way.
I Ya and?
Crowder is actually a joke though. Just watch his vids
@@Ohyouknowit why should someone even say something like that? What's the point? To look like a joke or to look plain stupid?
Job Wesley Cox Jr I’ve watched his videos and although I disagree with him on plenty, I think he articulates his points pretty well. I like his new “Change my Mind” segments because he has college kids have respectful discussions with each other, even while disagreeing. I think that’s valuable.
vox trying real hard to appeal to the mainstream media here
well they managed to make the new adpocalypse... again
NBC invested 200 million into Vox. They are the media establishment.
And they won't stop untill youtube is 90s style cable tv. They just erased a comedian and founding youtbe partner for the same jokes they have been doing for 13 years.
I find Steven Crowder to be very amusing. I've also heard him say numerous times NOT to go after people that he talks about.
but thats the thing, he surely wont tell his subs to go and harrass people, but they will do it anyway, because hate is at the very core of his thinking, its like the shooter of new zealand, he was a trump fan, that doesnt mean that trump encourages people to kill muslims, but he is sending messages to people who would do it because of the hate they carry, and its really dangerous
@@losfalsosdelapaz9933 Can you read minds? How can you possibly know that he or any of his viewers hate gays? Many are very annoyed that some activists that are gay, Maza in particular, attack others while using being gay as a shield to protect themselves from legitimate criticism. People hate that 'crybully' behavior much more than the person's sexual orientation.
@Los Falsos de le Paz What's REALLY dangerous is people that fall for the trolling perpetrated by the New Zealand shooter.
@@losfalsosdelapaz9933 Please explain to me how hate is at the very core of his thinking? With your logic, who mind manipulated you to comment that the actions of cyberbullies/active shooters are because of people simply existing. Neither of those men support or have openly directed people into harming others. Also you just said that trump doesn't encourage people to hurt others so what "messages" is he sending exactly? Everyones actions are ultimatley their own, they make that decision to hit send or pull the trigger.
@@ravecaster Yes, it's really scary how the authoritarian politicians immediately went after citizen's rights to self defense
(i.e. firearms), just like the New Zealand shooter told them to do.
"Non-violent crimes" Tricking someone into eating something they don't want to counts as violent to me. He was physically injured if he was throwing up.
I bet that kid was confused as hell when he found out he was being sued by a homeless man lol but i agree that kids an ass
the kid deserves to get punished for that but 2 years and 20 grand for toothpaste is a bit much...
To be fair, if someone is handing you 20$ to eat an oreo, you have to be pretty stupid to expect there to not be anything up with it
Oh lord, NOT EVERYTHING is violence. Slapping is considered violence and all it does is hurt feelings. Way more than physically anyway. Its people like you making words violence that are making everything less fun
@@gjbffg5177 All slapping does is hurt feelings? Are you dense? Nevermind, don't answer that. It's obviously 'yes'.
I'm disappointed Phil didn't address Maza's last comment that Crowder is RUclips's "ideal creator". Virtually every Crowder video is demonetized and Crowder just publicly addressed the fights over the wrongful strikes on his channel.
I think that depends. Does demonetized mean RUclips is making no revenue, or the revenue is being sent somewhere else instead of Crowder like the copystrike system. Even if he genuinely brings no money in for RUclips or himself, he does still generate views and engagement time with his videos, and I'd predict a lot of it. So he can still be an ideal creator, just not the ideal we initial assume him to be in terms of revenue generation.
@@somebodyintheworld5036 He is not ideal in anyway. Videos get demonitized because he is not ideal. He has no filter and is right wing two things youtube would rather stay away from and also its advertisers. If anything he is youtubes worst creator because even though they have demonitized him and shadow banned him he still gets views. Which doesnt look great to advertisers. RUclips would much rather him banned than not but they currently dont have a reason to ban him
@@MrAyuub22 So why wouldn't they just ban him? They don't need someone filing a complaint to ban him. They only ever ban conservatives because of overt calls to violence or public shaming. It would be easy to take several cases of his no-filtered speech and say they violate their TOS and bam. Done. RUclips has (a fuckton of) lawyers and they absolutely could make an ironclad defense for banning Crowder and all of the conservatives channels if they wanted to. Except that they don't want him/them banned. They want them here because they draw eyeballs and clicks. They demonetize videos when it goes too far- in other words when the video would look bad to the general public. But they don't want him going elsewhere.
Isaac Sherman they ban all sorts and they still want dollars in the stupid hate train so they’ll just keep taking all the money from crowders videos instead.
Crowder's channel is entirely demonetized. Meaning no ads appear on it. This was done by youtube because RUclips's algorithm or whatever thinks his channel is NOT IDEAL. He makes no ad revenue from youtube that's why he has the Mug Club to pay for his bills and earn money other than the in video ads that he does himself
Keep in mind that Carlos recently said in a Vox video that "journalists should be the gatekeepers of information." He is making the argument that what information you get should first be chosen by people like him. And he wants someone who gives you information he doesn't like to be silenced. That is some high level arrogance. No matter if you're liberal or conservative, you should always fear the person who thinks they are qualified to screen information for you in the name of "fighting fake news."
That is Stalinism. I pent my youth in a communist hell, that is what they advocated and enforced.
Watch the video where he clearly says that you should not treat the news like Fox News. You shouldn't become the news when you're a journalist. But that seemed to have flown over your head.
@@Vapouriste Yeah, like a lot of the comment section quite obviously. Goddamn this is some next level chudness.
@@Vapouriste So Carlos has made himself the news. But he never said he was a journalist, right?
You don't get it. He's talking of personal harassment on his personal Twitter account. He's not on Vox talking about it. He didn't start out his threads with that intent. He's been harassed for years.
Perfectly unbiased provision of information on this story, it amazes me how the mainstream media can’t pull this off, but content creators like yourself can. Nicely done.
Hey Phil, this might go unnoticed but would you be able to make a memorial shoutout for 8964, the 30 year anniversary of the Tiananman Square Massacre. It's been wiped out from this current generations' memories with the government's encouragement, and I would just love to have a massive platform to shed some light on this memorable day where thousands lost their lives.
I see the vid of the man in front of the tanks all the time, I dont know what your talking about
@@MohawkJonIs1311 he's referring to the Chinese govt erasing it from it's history and potential from the world.
@@MohawkJonIs1311 its more than that. ruclips.net/video/w4RjuA65sgQ/видео.html watch this. Of course, it is rather dated, but its worth a watch. Notice how everyone knows the answer, but is afraid to go into any detail.
Thank you so much Alice for mentioning this. There might be hateful comments later but thank you, Hope you're having a great day.
@@MohawkJonIs1311 It is much more than the picture of the man and the tank. I think we always need to remember the cause and not the vision.
It's really hard to like maza even when you dont like crowder.
This is true, he's that awful.
Maza did nothing wrong, though.
Jacob Adkins you mean aside from calling for advertisers to boycott RUclips because someone said something mean about him?
@@hcs4life21 neither did Crowder. But Maza feels worse than a scorned woman that he's not just calling for Crowder's demonetization, he wants him deplatformed.
Jacob Adkins Maza did nothing wrong, huh? Let’s see about that, he...
1. Has published multiple stories where he has presented false or misleading data (seriously, watch his video about conservatives controlling the media. I thought RUclips was trying to crack down on fake news and that’s the biggest piece of fake news yet.
2. Has endorsed the act of battery against people who have ideological differences.
3. Has pushed for people to mass flag Crowder’s video on Twitter.
4. Has claimed that Crowder told his fans to dox him when Crowder has NEVER told his viewers to dox ANYONE, even people he hates.
And shit, that was BEFORE he even started the whole second Adpocalyse. You should see the way he acted when RUclips informed him that Crowder didn’t violate TOS for harassment. He was smearing RUclips on Twitter for falsely stating they support gay content creators as well as pushing for advertisers to pull from RUclips for being attached to “homophobic and racist” creators.
I thought Maza was pretty damn deplorable before, but considering the way he acted when RUclips didn’t give him the answer he wanted, he’s officially the worst sort of person. The sad thing is, this guy is going to continue throwing his weight around to achieve his ideological agenda because RUclips won’t grow a backbone and put him in his place.
When 90% of their videos are demonitized and removed from suggested videos you can't rightfully call them RUclips's ideal creator
Crowder's Canadian healthcare system video is pretty amazing. Hard to doctor Canadian's pissing all over their own healthcare system but the left tried to get that video pulled while insinuating he did just that. They couldn't provide any proof.
I don't see a problem since those 10% are going straight into RUclips pocket
@@RJT80 He fakes a booboo and the Canadians make him sit in a waiting room. Sounds like good triage. Maybe he should get hit in the head with a brick a few times and see if they'll see him. That'll own the libs.
@@RJT80 that video was shit, just watch any response, crowder is what edgy stupid people think how an intelligent person is.
@@hghg2848 That has to be quite possibly one of the dumbest breakdowns I've seen so far. Congratulations.
I've never understood Pranking.
It's needless cruelty towards friends or worse: absolute strangers.
People just like hiding behind the claim of it being a prank. It was just plain cruelty.
When an ad pops up in the video and you're confused about it because it's philly d's channel and he's usually demonetized by the time you watch the video 😂
I'm too late... no ads
Wait Phil gets demonetized? Since when (asking seriously, not trolling)? Usually only clear right wing channels on RUclips get demonetized but Phil's channel is unbiased or at times left-leaning.
@@sandwichthief6811 he isn't substantially left so he's too far right for RUclips to be monetized.
@@sandwichthief6811 yes, I typically watch his videos the morning after they're posted while I get ready for work in the morning and I almost never see mid-roll ads. It's usually because of the content he covers is graphic or pick whatever reason they might demonetize it.
@@markatag2680 bullshit. 3 ads. one before, one middle, one after. you are a liar. have a nice day.
Ideal creator?? He is constantly censored, receives no ad revenue, and will never be trending regardless of views. Ok
Ideal creator for RUclips, not for himself. he's making the platform money, even if he doesn't receive any himself.
He’s trying to slander RUclips so that they’ll take more drastic actions to stop Maza’s assault.
Exactly what I was going to comment
Kevin I’m sorry you’re offended by _private companies_ not wanting to spread homophobia. It’s not about the words used, it’s about _the way_ they’re used.
@@Ranger1PresentsVirtualRealms Exactly.
Writer for Vox?
-100% Credibility
Nothe;GrapeFlavouredDog chowder is a “comedian” who got his fame from faking an attack against him.
You don’t know what “credibility” means 😂😂
"I hate being reduced to just a gay man !" *uses gaywonk as Twitter handle*
Mr Weryo try “being harassed with gay slurs” 🙄
Stop being PC to help out your own agenda
jason lewis Because crowder is lying hack with less credibility than Maza. Sorry if that hurts your feelings 😢
SerferTJ no hurt feeling. Maza just can’t take a joke because it isnt dick shaped.
Crowder is a conservative comedian. Vox can’t handle it
That's exactly what's happening.
Wait, aren't comedians supposed to be funny?
Warmly Calculated he is if liberals wouldn’t get offended so easily
@@warmlycalculated390 he is 😁
@@romanlees9114 Not a liberal and I adore offensive humor. The only funny thing Crowder did was when he got BTFO'd by a teenage college kid and pretended to get all offended when the kid described certain facets of libertarianism as autistic, and the fairly brilliant takedown Chapo Trap House did of him. Other than that, he's unfunny trash.
Crowder can’t be RUclipss ideal creater. Most of his videos get demonetized right after they go up lol
Crowder is the real victim here. But Vox is giant corporation and therefore they wield an enormous power. And why the f*ck gets Corrrrrrrtez involved in this while she obviously didn't understand nothing?
Censorship
Half Asian Lawyer is on the case!!!!
@Jay Just so we're clear, the first amendment protects citizens from being censored by the government. Private institutions such as RUclips have the right to censor whomever they want, whenever they want, for whichever reason they want. I'm not going to argue for either side, but I want to establish that your (and their) first amendment rights and freedom of speech do not apply on this platform.
@Jay freedom of speech isn't a thing on RUclips it's a private company they can do whatever they want when they want
The only pranks I like are Gus Johnson pranks.
yesss!!!
G money
And Drake pranking the NBA!
Ross
boys support boys !
Really good coverage of the crowder and maza situation. Good work
Carlos is still living in high school in his mind. He's never grown up and is not capable of living in the real world where his feelings might get hurt. He's got no spine
Remember when PhillyD use to give his opinion on controversial topics?... yeah it’s been awhile
lmfao, that means that he agrees with the right at that moment xD
@Darth Pepe I mean the price of petrol can be a pretty political topic...
the whole point is that he’s an unbiased reporter. even if he gave us the story and THEN gave us his opinion, a lot of people will just retain the latter as fact. sad but true🤷♀️
@@alotter That makes no sense.
@@alotter No... not really, no...
Phil didn't threaten me with physical violence.
Unsubscribing.
If he milkshakes you, will it make you happy?
@@michaelz8235 toughest part is finding one worse than a republican
@@michaelz8235 your ignorance is showing kiddo. you get triggered way too easily. learn to breath and take naps throughout the day to help counter your afternoon tantrums. Best of luck to your mental health. oh and there's a difference between libertarian and liberal. not that you could ever spot the difference.
@@vlada Well, SOMEONE will be happy
I've seen this comment like 20 times over in the top comments since Phil first started the throat punch throwaway joke. How is this still funny to anyone?
Carlos: "RUclips is not doing anything according to its policies."
RUclipsrs: "First time?"
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Too true - How many ads are on Vox's videos vs anyone right of center? More victim carding... 75 mins of video debunking their videos, and 2 minutes total is making jokes about him directly, vs the other 70 mins of fact checking and counter points.
Buster Scruggs reference?
I read this and thought or the James Franco meme lol
You tube is to busy sensoring all the captain marvel and star trek discovery critics and bad reviews.
Wow that maza guy is manipulative....
kudos to you phil for the unbiased reporting. Love it!
What do you expect from LGBT people who try to exploit themselves for money? It's no different than sex workers supporting feminism: They're exploiting themselves and feminism helps them get benefits and money.
The dude is using his sexuality to say YT should do something though.
Its overused those days.
RUclips should and he has every right to say something if someone is attacking him and his character, ethnicity and sexuality. If you don't like that... Cry us a river, melt like a snowflake or whine like a byotch 😂
@Pieces109 what political violence? Who is the politician that is being threatened?
@@jobwesleycoxjr5103 just let you know because of both child RUclips just lash out shadowbanning random youtubers.
@@thedissidentleftist6997 so? Does that make you lose money?
reverse card- we pass the Crowder/maza question back to you, what is your opinion?
I think they were both terribly wrong in their actions, there was nothing to defend.
Isn't it like black people call themselves and other black people the 'n' word, but white people can't. especially in the offensive way Crowder is using these gay terms. Imagine if Crowder was saying black man over and over instead of gay man, and if the black man uses the 'n' word in his title name, does that give Crowder the right to use the 'n' word in targetting this man? I find ga yinsults towards gay people aren't seen as more serious as racism or sexism.
Carlos clearly calls himself a queer, literally saying hes a proud queer. Look at his Twitter name etc... also there is no such thing as hate speech.
@@Hmonglauj89 It's the same as a black person calling himself the 'n' word. Does it give the right for a white person to call him a 'n' word offensively because he himself refers to hi mself as an 'n'word? No, it doesn't.
@@kiragoe A lot of people would argue that if you're going to call yourself something, you can't reasonably expect other people not to address you by it as well. So your point, while valid, really doesn't matter here.
As a Mexican, I'm confused on being called a Mexican as an insult.
It's because white people don't know that not all Latino people are Mexicans. To white America, all Latino people come from Mexico.
It’s not. He’s just saying it racist to see any Hispanic and assume they are Mexican. Kinda like calling someone from Asia “that gay Chinese guy”.
@@KodiHful wow, that much self hate must hurt like a bitch
@Tim Portantno wonk IS a derogatory term.
@@KodiHful you are making an assumption that all white people think the same, I can confirm they do not.
Carlos calls for "bullying" then calls for deplatforming when he gets "bullied" 🤔 there's a word for this.
Yeah , it's called being a tattle tale little bitch. Maza dishes it out heavily, yet cries wolf when his ideas get put down in mocking way.
Does it start with a "b" and rhyme with sandwich?
False sense of victimhood
Liberal
That’s some juicy hypocrisy
"RUclips is a place for monsters..." [Slow turns to mirror and ironically nods.]
😅
"RUclipss ideal creator" I like the good fight but thats just not even close to the truth
That is how the left roles. They always say that a platform is in favor of the right, when in fact, it is the right that is constantly being censored.
Hmmm well he doesn't get demonitized nearly as much as he should considering his bigotish nature and doesn't seem to think it's bad to put an obvious reference to the word fag on his merch. This man also has over 3 million subs. This man is being handed subs because the platform promotes people who are loud and the only people who are are the bigots and racists.
Kole Tokar I know right, especially when you actually watch crowder and all of his videos are suppressed from his subs, demonetization on all his vids, Carlos is out of his mind.
@@UndyingNero Genuinely curious, "Bigotry" refers to refusal to alter your views even when faced with contradicting evidence... When has Crowder willfully neglected allowing evidence to reflect his views? (Not a fanboy just wondering why you say he is a bigot)
@@UndyingNero Bullshit. Have you actually seen one of his videos? I didn't even know the guy until today so I went to check out his content. You are outright wrong.
Yes, Crowder uses terms that are probably not desirable, but the other 99% of his videos are very legitimately criticizing mazza's ideas. He is hiding behind that 1% to not address Crowder's content
Agreed, Maza is hiding behind 0.1% of Crowders message. The things crowder calls Maza is just for fun, really not meant as harassment. Crowder is a comedian after all. Basicly like SNL for conservatives. If Crowder is banned, so should SNL, etc.
Bernie voice: "THE 1%!!!!!!!!!"
@@charlese.straut9998 typical socialist, always going after the 1%
But that 1% is bullshit and hurts the argument
@@kurtjensen5798 so SNL is only for liberals? Last time I checked they have no problem mocking anybody who deserves to be mocked; doesn't matter if they're liberal, conservative, democrat, republican, black, white, etc. Not a very good comparison lol
I am shocked at the unbias and facts presented in this video. No wonder they are coming at Philip for not choosing a side.
Carlos can dish it but can’t take it.
I think he takes it plenty
Clixy clix maza is top not bottom bruh
I mean I wouldn’t either of someone called me a historically gay slur, or whatever.
If Crowder gets banned i'm joining mug club.
Me too
If either he or Sargon of Akkad, the two people I actually give a shit about on RUclips go... I am going to finally make the move to Bitchute, a few of my other creators already left for there. That and Gab.AI which I already use.
@@adrianbundy3249 please leave now,dont wait
With that mug of yours, that'd be pretty ugly mug
@@complex_ Who the hell spends *_$99_* to get a shitty mug and more content from max chud?
Thank you, Phil, for your fair and engaging reporting. It's rare and definitely appreciated!
Sugarwood I may not always agree with him, but rarely can I complain about the coverage. And while he does give his opinion, I like that he keeps it to the end after he's laid it all out.
"fair" reporting
Imagine if someone milkshakes that maza dude.
“This was an attack on ALL gays!”
So...who’s seen Crowders apology video? 😂
Loved it!
Holy fuck that was amazing. I was baked last night and for the first 30sec was just in disbelief.
Instant classic
Perhaps the greatest apology video ever made.
I thought he bent the knee, but he didn’t and it was great.
Someone get Mary Ham!
It's time to rate an apology video!
the Courtney Love of Meme news?
@@WhiteNucklin This is the most accurate description of Mary Ham
Crowder made a 20 minute apology video
@@Jack-lm5nx not only did he dropped an apology video... But he dropped the best apology video in the history of apology videos... He's by far my favorite when making apology videos
@@Jack-lm5nx it is the great F you in the history of double handed apologies
Your time codes are messed up! HOW DARE YOU NOT BE PERFECT EVERYDAY?!?
Now it's our turn to throat punch Phil!
of course his channel shouldn't be removed. You tube can't even explain how his videos violated their TOS guidelines.
It's not that they can't explain, they've actually said that they don't violate their TOS and policies. The reason they have demonetized Crowder is because of a shirt he sells that says "Socialism is for figs" which people have misunderstood for another word, but RUclips themselves actually recognized it was "figs" and not the other word, but still demonetized him and told him to remove it.
Dope Sope and this was a completely made up reason for demonetizing him. They had to come up with something.
@@johnr8095 Exactly, it's ridiculous. They admitted he did nothing wrong, but demonetized him anyway.
bullying and harassment
plain and simple
click on any crowder video and you will see both these things
@@SilvanSage except he did do shit wrong, he has been dog whistling for nazis for years
he has been bullying and herrassing for even longer
I expected you to cover the Crowder/Maza situation with bias against Crowder, but was pleasantly surprised to see you cover both sides of the story.
even i was surprised , philip started out with painting a bleak image of crowder with the extracts of him throwing insults and giving a wide coverage to maza's victim twitter posts , but i was shocked when philip actually gave crowder's defence a chance to be heard . As content i am with philip on this one , from my experience i feel like he was forced to add Crowder's defense , not doing so would have hit him hard with his subs and reputation as " alternative news provider"
seems like the vox guy is someone who can dish it out but can't take it.
Right? That seems just par for the course now though.
@@paulgriffin8662 Exactly what I was thinking. The tactics he says are awful, are only awful when used on him.
That could be said for crowder as well. He talks mad shit then gets called out for it and acts like he’s the one under attack. This is not a war. This a guy being called out for gay bashing. Maza said this isn’t about crowder,it’s about YT following its own guidelines regardless of how many followers a creator has.
A gay man calling him self queer is a lot diff then a strait guy doing jazz hands and making a lispy voice ever time he refers to that gay guy. Just my opinion.
@@thestig572420 he gets called out all the time. He has no problem dishing it out. But this guy is trying to BAN him waving the gay wand around and RUclips is going to be screwed both ways from this situation wether they do or dont ban him.
Arkangel19024
He clearly said he’s not trying to ban anyone just get you tube to follow it own guidelines. Sry I just can not stick up for a grown man with the word FAG printed on his shirt. . Even worse is he didn’t have the balls to own it and says no no no that’s a fig leaf ,wink wink.
Thank You for your unbiased coverage of the Maza vs. Crowder story. Very fair and balanced.
Unlike Crowder who's the picture of partisan bullshit
John Smith would that really be relevant though? I’m js, he was specifically talking about Maza, so he showed Crowders Maza comments. Relevance matters.
VIRTUAL REALMS I’m actually a huge Crowder fan, and I’m surprised that there was a fair reporting on his side of the story. That rarely happens for conservatives, so I will say thank you when it does.
@@nicholascharles9625 and carlos maza isn't?
Hector Perez lol I was about to type the exact same thing. I’m constantly blown away by the complete ignorance of the left. There is definitely ignorance on both sides, don’t get me wrong. But I always see folks from the left calling things like Crowder, Fox News, etc partisan bullshit.
Yeah, it definitely is and I’d say most conservatives freely admit that. But for some reason the vast majority of the left seem to not realize the shows they gravitate to are equally partisan, just on the other side.
My biggest problem with Maza is how he presents his content as if it’s above reproach. Then whenever he’s called out for making a shit video he falls back on being gay and claims everyone persecutes him for his sexuality.
I really like how you share multiple views and content from multiple platforms. Great unbiased video 👍
Not gonna lie I was REALLY expecting you to cover voxs side a little stronger. But you didn’t. You gave the facts of both sides and left your own opinions out and unbiased. Thank you. Just subbed
Don't get used to it. Phil is good at presenting the many sides of a story but in many cases he is extremely biased and makes subtle implicit nods towards his bias. I really hate how he covers many stories but since he does give a lot of information I just learned to filter him out over the many years of watching. Just letting you know ahead of time that this instance is the anomaly, not the rule.
Eisenhorn i think he sides with the LGBT community but doesn't feel that this merits any sort of legitimacy because Vox boy is blowing it up much bigger than it is
I honestly have only ever seen one more of his videos back during the whole alinity and pewdiepie situation last year. I didn’t agree with how he kind of favored alinity more but I guess I’ll just have to watch more videos to find out. Thanks for looking out tho.
@@eisenhorn5614 Sometimes he's really good at it (like in this video), but I have seen others where his bias is interjected so potently it's painful. Enough to actually lose some of the pertinent facts. Overall, though, he usually does a pretty good job.
@@SiMeGamer He tries extremely hard to cover stories objectively, but sometimes it's impossible to act like all "sides" of a story deserve the same respect.
Measles outbreak:
Ebola: Hold my beer.
In 2014, the year of the Ebola crisis, x10 the amount of people that died of Ebola were killed by Malaria in the affected countries.
I have to say that your analysis of the Vox/Crowder story was surprising impartial. I’m impressed.
Daniel García- Magán Correas he knows if he picks a side, half his audience will eat him alive
@@SuperCoon88 have you seen the comments? Most of his audience seems in favor of crowder, so not really half and half.
kreneks 01 That’s not half his audience, just the people who are most vocal. There’s plenty of people who are on Vox’s side that know if they were vocal about it they’d just be inviting harassment from Crowder’s fanbase.
@@GaiashKetoji dude. It's a youtube comment section. People aren't getting harrased here. All I've seen is arguing, with most of the support being for crowder.
kreneks 01 Because Crowder’s fanbase is loud. The most vocal group is not the largest. And as for harassment you’ve most likely not seen it because you don’t know what you’re looking for.
Note about Crowder's shirt: I'm sure the "fig" part is making a stab at a similar sounding word, but it's also actually a reference to a communist who'd been killed under a fig tree. hence "Communism is for figs."
Actually according to Steven it is from the bible. When Jesus cursed the fig tree because it was fruitless. Like socialism.
Either way, both are great responses.
If it really was fig, they wouldn’t censor it
@@missmorbid1439 well it replaces the "I" part of "Fig" with a fig. So yes it does say fig. Google image socialism is for figs and look at the shirt.
Because I believe some people from the far left love to be triggered so if they see something closely representing something they can point out and screech about it
I’ve been called worse things than Carlos Maza for spelling something incorrectly online.
That'll teach you to mess with the grammar mafia.
Yeah.. I don't think this is going to end well for Maza..
Vox is trash dude, cancel culture trash, who is as biggoted as someone who says the n word
Lmao 🤣
This is the BEST comment on here cuz it's so damn true.
As a gay man myself, I side with Crowder sure what hes done isn't right but he shouldn't be targeted as this "monster" that Maza is touting. Carlos Maza is just another privileged man that thinks because hes gay if someone makes fun that hes being attacked. As for the doxxing that's not his fault. It'd be the same as Phil making fun of whoever and some irresponsible follower deciding to dox whoever he was making fun of. Its just another case of trying to play victim for his own monetary desire under the guise of LGBT. Hes trying to use his sexuallity as a weapon to silence things he doesn't agree with and it actually makes our community look bad. That's just my two cents.
As a conservative myself, I completely agree with your viewpoint. This is kinda where the "I don't care about your sexually" thing comes from. Judge a person's character; not their skin, sex, or anything of the sort.
Really appreciate your pov thanks
And the guy is a comedian. He makes jokes about everyone and basically everything. He’s trying to entertain. Make people laugh. He’s said multiple times he doesn’t care if you are gay or straight. But context writes the narrative.
Uh, although I disagree with bullying Carlos in the sense of calling him names, The way Carlos wrote his tweets was very manipulative towards RUclips saying “nothing will happen because RUclips doesn’t care about their queer creators” is obviously very manipulative which, although I hate to say it, brings me more into Crowder’s side. I do not like his content as I do find it insulting what he as said towards the transgender community, however I do not believe his channel should be taken down.
You should check out some of his interviews with Blair White. They're very formal and interesting to listen to.
Same. I think Crowder is an asshole and really don't like him, but I don't think RUclips should ban him
@@sonictt1 Imagine unironically buying into the "every pepe is an alt right symbol" rhetoric.
@@TheSpartyboy or the 👌 sign
You have my full respect. I happen to be a Crowder fan, but I love that regardless of how you feel about him and his comedy and views, you recognize that it's still not worth banning him for. You have a very good day now sir (or ma'am lol)
tons of credit to the DeFranco team for the fair coverage on the Crowder/Maza story.
I've never wanted to punch someone more than the first dude
i mean daMn, how hard would it be to get one of his friends pretend to be homeless like every other prank youtuber, or like not do anything??
Phil?
I would pay a solid 2k to punch Crowder in the face and/or pour a milkshake on him.
Griffin F Steven crowder? Stupid democrat
Not only that but if he does live in Spain he's kicking his nation while it's down, spain has a 25% unemployment rate
Don't get me wrong, the bullying sometimes is taken too far. But the vox guy definitely seems like he's just trying to use pride month to direct more outage at the issue because he's mad for getting his work scrutinized.
Also, if you're going to comment to insult either person. Don't. It's not beneficial in any way.
That is exactly what it is, it's so transparent.
Crowder called him a "lispy queer". This is bullying and harassment.
1stDimensionFilms lmao no it’s not
@@Toyota_Echo He calls himself queer... It absolutely isn't.
Yeah when he emphasizes it every time he talks about the situation it's so painfully obvious.. He's just trying to use the community which is messed up imo
Good fair coverage of the Maza situation, well done.
Just coverage and nothing more. Interesting
it seemed fair, but they left out a lot of stuff and made crowder look worse than he actually is, Maza is just as guilty of the same things crowder has done, but not much was done to show that in this video. Not mad, or butthurt, just wish they had been more even handed in the story.
how was it fair? He didn't give an opinion. he just stated facts that happened.
Maza came off looking worse in my opinion in this video. May just be personal bias though
@@anxietyebriety6553 thats actually the definition of "fair"
did you forget that carlos calls for physically violence against people he does not agree with
I can't believe that anti-vax facebook moms actually brought the measles back. This really is the weirdest timeline, dude.
between them resurrecting dead diseases and drinking bleach, my faith in humanity has never been lower.
Waiting for the to send hate to Phil again for telling them to vaccinate.
Our government is weak they should have arrested after getting cured. This is becoming public health crises
wolff aringos consider that natural selection as far as the bleach drinking goes. The measles however makes them straight up murderers.
This is false. Religious people are much more to blame for the measles outbreak than Karen
Thank you Phil, I feel like you did a good job of being neutral in the Crowder story.
Would have liked to see a link to Crowder's response alongside the original Vox accusations in the "Today's Stories" section of the show notes and links.
Why is it a positive to be neutral when people are being targeted for their sexuality?
@@nathanrupley I agree. Neutrality on the subject? Wtf. What ever happened to blatant right and wrong?
Just the facts.
@@nathanrupley Especially when the attacker is literally a global warming denier.
Really impressed by the way Phil covered the vox story
yeah thought it was really even on both political sides, not leaning left or right which is nice. Thats usually why I like Phil, give us the news with a touch of opinion so that way we can look at the facts for ourselves and make our own opinions!
BaioWithMayo “i pass this onto you and ask what you think about this”
@John Smith oh I've watched them all dont worry haha, I'm a fan of his work and imo censorship isnt the right way to do things
The Crowder v. Box reporter just gives me an excuse to get the popcorn and watch. I wouldn't be surprised if RUclips really doesn't acknowledge the situation since other issues are coming up that are higher in priority.
Love how Maza thinks that RUclips sould care more for queer creators not treat all equal
I was honestly worried about the bias that may be present in the vox vs crowder segment but it was actually done great doing both sides justice in my opinion
Phil conveniently left out the false flagging campaign up Crowder's channel that Mazza put up on Twitter. That's a pretty damning piece of evidence that should have been introduced into that piece.
Mike stiles was just about to comment this. Idc what people say I can see phils bias seep through in a lot of things he covers and even doesn't cover.
Yea that's why I like this channel I feel like I can get a non-biased look at the actual facts and determine outlook based on what the facts are.
@@mikestiles373
Yea he did forget to add that piece.
Phil seems to have missed the whole part where Vox false flagged crowders videos, crowder fought and won and Vox did the exact same thing again, with no punishment for falsely flagging the video.
"What if superman was a serial killer"...so...brightburn?
exactly
earth 3 ultraman
i imagine thats why that video was made rn
I mean, brightburn's more of a school shooter than a serial killer.
@Christopher Columbus lol truly
The Carlos Maza situation is a classic case of school-yard "can dish it, but can't take it".
More like are we just gonna not talk about crowders shitty behaviour just because a vox journalist said it?
Like your momma!
Shayan Ali - Yes, Crowder jokingly insults people. Yes, it is offensive. No, it’s not close to harassment. No, a joke from some comedian will not ruin my day.
Johnus Smittinis how do you draw the line as to what is considered harassment? Secondly i keep seeing this argument,you seem to not understand that the amount of harassment he gets isn’t like one or two messages? It’s probably a lot but I can’t say but on principle making fun of someone’s sexuality and ethnicity where the punchline is the sexuality and ethnicity is harassment dude,and if not that extremely enablist-can we at least agree tot that
Edit: should your personal capacity dictate how much other people should be willing to take? This sort of simplistic thinking does not solve problems just helps to defend shitheads like crowder
Poor little homophobes... Everybody against them these days
1. The shirt does not have a gay slur. It says 'fig.' As in, the fruit.
2. Maza has repeatedly stated that he wants Crowder banned. You lied when you claimed he said he doesn't.
Yes, thank you for pointing that out! Mr. Defranco missed a few important key points in this story.
@@elizabethshuster218 Yes! Thought was awfully convenient for Phil not to mention this stuff against Maza. Led me to unsubscribe.
That’s so obviously bullshit though. The phrase makes no sense as “figs” and Che is making a stereotypical gay gesture on the shirt.
Anyone with a brain knows what Crowder means. I really hope you’re just being disingenuous and is not actually this dumb.
frisater96 Che was was captured in an area whose name when translated reads : the fig tree, I’m sure it’s meant to be a shirt that can be read both ways. You assigning your reading as THE reading is a problem.
@@jacobtsatskis5335 It's not meant to be read both ways. It's pretty clear in its message. The fact that there are people so utterly dishonest they would try to actually defend it really bothers me. Why not just be honest about your ideas like a big boy, instead of hiding behind fucking word riddles?
And no. Steven Crowder is a cowardly, dishonest grifter, that's the problem here.
Imagine being told to "delete your channel" but by the police.
Lmao right
Pull a keemstar and say you dont own the channel 😂
EDIt : this is a joke
@Robert Rodgers Black on black crime is a far greater treat to America than big bad white people thinking that they are superior
@Robert Rodgers lol
@Robert Rodgers I've personally spoken to many white supremacist (real ones, not the fake ones you have in mind) and they became like that due to the anti white sentiments from the liberal/sjw culture. I became a white nationalist (not a white supremacist) due to the anti white sentiments from democrats during 2016. It's liberals who are creating g these people by constantly demonizing straight white males and reporting on them like they are the worst race on the planet. I'm glad nationalism is taking over
Fair coverage of the Crower v Vox issue. Well done! That’s why I love Phil.
Just the facts.
He left out that the gay guy told all his followers to go and flag Crowder's videos... I wish he mentioned it...
Not of fan of steven crowder but carlos is one of the worst writers/journalists if you can call him that out there. He is completely biased and the majority of his videos are full of lies or complete bullshit.
@@karl3637 yep!
Except for the whole (while veiled a "question") telling his followers to go flag Crowder's videos, kind of a big deal.
Carlos Maza is a hypocrite.
He isnt, but even if he was, Crowder still deserves the deplatforming that RUclips IS FAILING TO PROVIDE.
@@craigtrautmanjr9393 Deplatforming for stating an opinion you don`t like is a precedent you want to see set huh?
Hope you can stick to that if that ever happens to you.
@@quintonthevillain2745 crowder having a shitty opinion isnt why I want crowder to burn. My parents have those bad opinions. I USED TO HAVE THOSE OPINIONS. But if we call people slurs, we gotta face consequences for being fucks. And crowder's been preying on marginalized people for years. I heard about him when he was harassing illegal immigrants looking for work just for a laugh. Hes an awful person that loves to hurt people he hates.
Well he's a liberal.
@@craigtrautmanjr9393 i can bet you crowder isnt going anywhere. He will be around to debunk al of vox political ideology. I wan to see you democrunts crying rivers of tears to help with the fake climate hoax.