The Hateful Eight - Film Analysis & Meaning [HD]
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 окт 2024
- An in -depth analysis on the themes of Quentin Tarantino's The Hateful Eight (2015).
If you like my content, please follow me on Twitter at: / theauteurist_
Alex Cox on The Great Silence -
www.theguardia...
vimeo.com/5010...
• Video
Tarantino Hateful Eight Interview with Peter Travers (Property of ABC News)
• Video
**For educational purposes only**
This video essay is fair use under U.S. copyright law because it is (1) non-commercial, (2) transformative in nature, (3) uses no more of the original work than necessary for the video's purpose, and (4) does not compete with the original work and could have no negative affect on it's market.
The most wholesome moment was when Chris decided not to take the deal with Domergue
Yeah. I was really glad when I first saw that moment that in the face of certain death, not even the character most others make out to be a weasel turns to cowardice or betrays his ideals just to live.
@@blarghinatelazer9394 One thing I love of Tarantino is that he's fucking unpridicteable.
It was a great character point. It was like, even an asshole racist POS can still do the right thing.
Prince Luci that’s the whole commentary dumbass. No one is truly wicked, no one is truly racist. Domergue says the n word, the hangman says the n word and Chris says the n word and is particularly racist. In fact his whole family identity centers around the confederacy and hate for slaves. However even in a weak moment, Chris is not just one thing, because no person is just a racist or one thing.
In the extended version Manix says “Humor me” so they were both in on it
imagine someone finding that cabin being like what the f*ck happened here?
Lol on some red redemption shit
They'd probably be like, "YAY, i'm rich bitch!!"
“Cabin fever. Who knows.”
-The Thing (1982)
@@incidentalist Until they have a drink of water from the well...
Bloody vomit everywhere
A dead confederate general
Dead guy in the cellar
A man with his arm cut off
That arm handcuffed to a woman who is being hung
The rope is tied to a bed where a man has no testicles is dead
Next to the bed is a man with a bloody letter from Abraham Lincoln
A bunch of dead people in a well
And other dead bodies around the haberdashery
I like how Mannix shows more and more layers as the movie goes on. He is, like the rest, obviously not what you expect, at the beginning. He is the only character who bothers to ask O.B. if he is okay after O.B. comes in and wraps himself up by the fire in the blanket like a burrito. He is the only one who tries to coax the Colonel into joining the others at the table and eating something. I loved that the first time he sits at the table, he chooses to sit next to Warren. They both look at each other for a moment, and say nothing. That moment sticks in my mind for some reason, I am not sure why. Mannix is also one of the only characters who tries to stop what is about to happen between Warren and the Colonel. He is the only character who visibly flinches at the violence going on around him, and he's pretty much the only one who hesitates before using violence. When you consider what John Ruth says Mannix's family is famous for, it makes you think. I have to wonder if Mannix himself was a part of it at all. If he thought what his father was doing was justified, why did he leave home and go so far away ? What a fascinating character, I wanted more of him !
He also is 100% the Sheriff of Red Rock, considering during the penultimate shootout:
Grouch just admitted to poisoning the coffee, but Chris refuses to shoot him after he shows he is unarmed, there is NO ONE alive in that room besides Marquis who is not a murderer at that point, it would have been logical for Chris to shoot all 3 (plus Jody in the basement)
I agree with your comment, but one detail you forgot: he wasn't the only one who asked if OB was OK. Senor Bob of all people asks if OB is OK as well, and offers him some soup :D
@@downfromthereeefters
Oh I didn't forget about Bob asking if OB wanted soup. I just didn't see it as genuine, rather part of Bob's cover. I don't think Bob did it out of actual concern, unlike Chris.
I never said you poisoned the coffee. I said You 👈 didn't make the stew.🥘
Mannix was arguably the most sympathetic of the main protagonists. He wasn't a cold-blooded murderer like Daisy and her crew, a liar like Warren, and he also lacked the temper and aggression of John Ruth who beats the crap out of Daisy for relatively minor insults. His only vice was his racism but that was more a product of that time period and he was also the son of an extremely racist Confederate general so it obviously rubbed off on him. Even then, he still sees Warren as his equal (more or less) by the end and even turned down Daisy's offer to save him.
Man whoever stumbles up to Minnie's at the end of all this mess is gonna be a rich rich man. A room full of bounties, and not to mention those that were brought along from the beginning.
I'd love for a epilogue scene of someone coming by and being like "Holy hell...what the hell happened?!"
Until they drink some water from the well...
Not Marco. Without a face Marco ain’t worth a peso. Oh and Jody DOmingray. No face no case
I would add one comment about Major Marquis who is clearly the most focused character of the movie in my opinion:
Major enters the haberdashery last and faces the a full room of white people who openly assault him with racism and 3 of them have conspired against his one and only ally in the room. He is mocked, exposed of falsification of his greatest achievement (being a pen pal of Lincoln), yet he manages to strive step-by-step. He becomes one of the 2 men with the gun, he kills his war enemy, he takes control of the situation when the conspired trio starts to act and he even distributes his power over everyone to a legit sheriff of the town! That who he is, the man who always starts at the bottom because of his skin colour, but nows how to reach the top.
It is critical to understand what brings him to his demise - a bullet from the bottom, a bullet from a hidden man. He is so accustumed of facing open challenges that he knows how to solve every problem, but he is not used to hidden danger, because every one he faces is very forward in his/her arrogance towards him because of his color. So he dies from a bullet from the man he did not see, because being black means he does not know how to identify the invisible problems, because everyone make sure that black man face as much problems as possible directly.
A great character, one of my favorites of all time!
nika gogibedashvili yes and yes!
The was one badass analysis...thanx!
Was not sure anyone would read this. Thank you for your support
Great analysis. The end part about the invisible problems made me think about mental illness and the black community, since it's a problem you can't see. Really eye-opening thing you said there.
nika gogibedashvili Gotdamn
Yeah I think the hateful eight is actually just as enjoyable as Tarantino’s other films, the storytelling, the strong characters, the dialogue, the time period, the nonlinear parts of it really work like his other films, the fact that everyone dies and it’s held in one room the whole film really is almost like Reservoir Dogs
Very much like Reservoir Dogs where everyone's lying especially Tim Roth's undercover cop and here as the Brit bounty hunter / thief. Mr. Blonde is more of threat in Res Dogs but that same actor is here also.
@@reimourrpower9357 also there's mr.blonde
Not everyone was lying in
RD.
of course its just as enjoyable, wait did not allot of people like it than his other movies?
Man can he direct a movie
@TECHNICS TECHNISHION Yes his dialogue is next level. You know when you watch a Tarantino flick your eyes are gonna be glued to the screen the entire time
Overrated. Way overrated.
@@thomasmcbride4966 Nah, just not your thing. That's okay
Thomas McBride, let me guess, Hitchcock is overrated too, huh?
Aesthetical Twat yes...
This is one of those movies that becomes a cult classic. The more you watch it, the more you appreciate it. For me, this is the best QT movie made. Everything about it is spot on. The actors, the plot, the mystery, the mood, the scenery, everything.
Yeah I remember not exactly liking it the first time or two now I really understand the craft in this film and Tarantino really did such a great job with this film. A true cult classic
It's terrible
There's literally no mystery. Tarantino himself ruins the mystery
It grows on you. Every dialogue and scene is a masterpiece
@@saif24feb you have a loose definition of the word masterpiece
My favorite part? The fact that Daisy looks like a demon by the end of the movie!
So beautiful.
its fair to say, when you watch this film for the first time, its absolutely amazing.
its fair to say, when you watch it the second time, you appreciate it more and enjoy the film just as much.
Its fair to say, after watching this movie 5 times within a week... you realize it is a MASTERPEICE. So many hidden gems. Im going to watch this movie again now, and probably find something else that i missed.
The last time i watched it, i finally noticed how the front door was broken. it actually was the mexican guy.
update: guess what? i found something new.
when domigue is playing the final verse of the song... she is foreshadowing her desired outcome. She sings, "ill break my chains, into the bush i go. and you'll be dead behind me john, when i get to mexico.
I didnt understand why he got so mad at her for singing and broke the guitar. its because she was saying ima kill u and go to mexico lol
“Who the hell broke this goddamn door!?”
*Thick Mexican Accent* ~~ “Just fucking hold it!” 😂 I watched this movie two times this week after work. Fucking love this movie. By far my favorites Q Tarantino movie! By a landslide
Slapped myself on the forehead when you pointed out the chess board between Major Warren and General Smithers. I really liked this movie when it came out and this video basically puts it all into words for me.
Imho, the Major know shit wasn't right the minute he saw Daisy start to grin and make light of things immediately after John elbows her in the face. You can see it in his eyes and facial expression as his smile and laugh begin to fade and he starts piecing it together.
Facts
Good observation. I noticed that Daisy slowly appeared to be more callous and hard as the film progressed and she took the abuse from John Ruth with an almost masochistic pleasure. Major Warren sees this and watches her carefully.
I feel it would be best warched twice because of this
When you first watch it she just seems weird and crazy but if you watch it knowing she's planned the whole thing it changes
@@reimourrpower9357 she's thinking of all the diabolical things -, she and her brother will do to Ruth....
Yes fascinating analysis. You raise some interesting thoughts and theories.
I always thought the part where Marcus Warren tells the story about the generals son sucking him off in the snow was certainly manufactured to force the general into going for his gun as it had a sort of dream like quality to it. But its a great film and I dont think it got the credit it deserved when it came out.
Good video too.
Considering that Warren knew the General's son's full name, Chester Charles Smithers, I do believe that he indeed did come across and kill him. But I agree, the whole bit about forcing him to walk naked through the snow and putting his "big, black dingus" in his mouth were probably lies intended to trigger the General.
I'm just now seeing that Major "Marquis Warren" is probably somehow connected or related to mobster "Marcellus Wallace" of Pulp Fiction.
@@reimourrpower9357 nooo wayy that's true ahahahahah
@Sebastian Burns and? I know that turns you on but how do you feel when Marcellus & Bud / Bruce beat those inbreds to death? You enjoy that too?
the whole movie feels like a play in a theater, like Im there, with them, the actors...amazing.
Tarantino actually had plans to make this into a stage play
@@karlmarx828 Still does it seems, once he's finished his final movie and the limited tv series he's written a script for. I'm excited. I'd travel anywhere to watch that play.
I loved this film it’s my favorite of Terantino’s. I don’t understand why this film is regarded as one of his worst it is not... I love this film.(Terantino is my favorite director.)
Not his best but not bad period. Love this movie and find myself researching it from time to time. Nothing beats pulp fiction and Jackie Brown is... Ah hell, I just love them all as well! I hate that he plans to make 1 more final film and it might be star trek.
Easily his worst movie but a great movie nonetheless
@@GS-kj6ur Would you mind telling me what's so "worst" about the film ? I've seen The Hateful Eight 9 times.
You guys be must loving Jackie Brown where I had to watch that film in 5 days because how boring that was.
Tarantino is my favorite director as well. This is also my favorite film by him.
I absolutely love it.
@@SignalFlowers too much dialogue and the entire movie is shot in one cabin. Makes it pretty boring. You can argue Jackie brown is his worst movie but I enjoyed it
Unpopular opinion: This movie was more enjoyable to watch than Pulp Fiction.
This is my second favorite movie ever made, so hearing this made me very happy
I saw this in 70mm and Pulp was my favorite film until I saw this in theaters.
Quick question - why does the reviewer make a joke about Abraham Lincoln freeing the slaves? Did he not?
@@ultraviolet.catastrophe idk, i watched this video 2 months ago, and why are you asking me?
@@TechReviewishI just jumped on the top comment, yo. And besides, if it turns out true that Abe never freed the slaves, that's going to be revolutionary news. I will accomplish so much with that information
The absolute funniest part of the whole movie is when Mannix shoots Daisy right before she gets the gun and goes, “I ain’t dead yet you bl*** bastard.” I laughed along with Major Warren so hard I wheezed.
“In order for me to be scared of the Jodi domingrey gang I’d have to believe there was a gang. You know what I think? I think what’s left of the Jodi domingrey gang is laying right here. Dead on this mother fuckin floor.”
Marques did shoot his son. The evidence of this is that Marques is outside doing stable work while the General is offering his son's full name, and his reason for traveling to Wyoming. Tarantino makes sure that Marques is unavailable to hear the story so that there is no question that his story and full name reveal is the truth.
Possibly, but highly likely exaggerated. Chris Mannix seems to ironically be the one voice of truth throughout a movie full of deception. He called out the fake Lincoln almost instantly, so when he when told the old man that marquis was just trying to get a reaction I believe that is the case.
Wow good catch!
@@greenjebadiah Thank you so much. I really make an effort to pick these things apart.
I know I’m late here, but the story must be true. Exaggerated, yes, but recall the general saying that if his son had done what he set out to do in coming to Wyoming, he would have returned home
@@JB-lj5cc Yes, I agree. I just offered the evidence that couldn't be plausibly denied.
Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction and The Hateful Eight are my top three Tarantino films.
I agree but I loved Django unchained more than reservoir dogs and the hateful eight
sad to see Inglorious basterds isnt on that list
@@ryangarvey8207 you see
im also sad Jackie brown Death Proof and fucking Kill bill arent on that motherfucking list too@!
I liked Jackie Brown too. That's one of my favorites.
Top 3 for me in no particular order: Pulp Fiction, Hateful 8, and Kill Bill Vol 1&2 (It's one story so I'm counting it)
But I haven't seen reservoir dogs, or once upon a time,. I feel asleep during inglorious basterds opening dialogue lol
Great analysis! The red, white and blue comment at the end blew my mind!
Sean Laver Stay tuned I'm planning on creating more Tarantino-analysis videos & thanks for watching.
@@TheAuteurist you are so good in semiotic analysis. love it bro
Remember true romance (jeez I actually typed true lies for a second) and natural born killers are out there. Many have analyzed Quinton, I believe you can find new ideas
Yeah , but they weren't facing opposite directions.
@Gerald Sierveld, Photography Instructor Wow! That's really cool! Thanks 👍What's the course called?
that's an awesome review. a good touch on the politics too. loved mannix in the end as he even gained the northerner's respect after samuel l. jackson's character said that he may have been wrong about mannix after all. that duo was such an unlikely duo that made the ending of the film even better for some many unexpected twists.
Notice how in the ending shot the "flag" is shown from Daisy's perspective. This probably symbolises how justice should prevail and it is only possible if people unite, just like the Southerner and the Northerner did. It's almost like they're honoring a flag that is being raised.
...ha and great use of "Why You Always Lying" in conflict with Lincoln's so-called "proclamation" of "freeing" African captives from slavery, surprised no one else commented on that (that I've seen so far).
About a month ago I watched this movie for the second time. After that I found myself watching over and over and over. At first I thought it was the snow and the cabin having a soothing effect on me. But the more understanding and the more things I notice in this movie my mind is blown! I thought this was a mediocre Tarantino movie at first, but now I think its a masterpiece!
I actually think it's lesser of QT's films but after this Auteur breakdown, I'll give it another viewing. I don't think it wiil end up a 'masterpiece' but I may see more qualities.
His best script. Couldn't agree more
Inglorius basterds??
@@Joelmaquera I remember he said himself that The Hateful Eight was his best script
@@ReshiramR52 so? He also said Inglorius basters was his "masterpiece "
MrAndr144R he's not talking about Tarantinos masterpiece, he's talking about purely the script
Damn man I already really liked the movie, but this video made me love it more! Great video man, props to you!
Yeah, what was the deal with Tim Roth’s character? He’s never met these people, there is no way they’d know who he was. Why would he change his accent?
Prince Luci He has a bounty on his head under the name of English Pete Hickox. His accent is probably known so he must be used to mask it, especially in front of bounty hunters because they likely have heard of him.
It’s most likely an authority thing. He’s playing the part of a hangman, and it is assumed he got that job through merit. Using his normal cockney accent, he wouldn’t seem as authoritative or wise as he would with his proper English accent
antoine gagnon it’s still an English accent.
Jack Weaver that makes more sense.
The real hangman Oswaldo Mobray was killed. He then took his identity . The accent and mannerism was all part of the act to impersonate the real Hangman. As someone pointed above already he is really Pete Hiscox an English outlaw
The red white and blue thing at the end really got me
you really are an auteur
? explain
If I draw a simple outlined picture of a human body, can you show me on the picture where it touched you.
@@cliffbooth7075 people really are absolute sacks of shit now a days.
Hateful Eight, Inglorious Bastards, and Pulp Fiction are my top 3 Tarantino films....this movie here is a master piece....
Quentin has the magic to place a character in a role that fits the person extremely well, blonde and the cop he had trouble with that scene but played the psycho very very good, and orange he cant seem to catch a break he got popped in the same spot, but popped the lady with the candies in the same spot
Wow that's kinda funny. I watched The Thing for the first time last night. Today, for no reason in particular, I chose to watch the Hateful Eight (I literally don't remember why I chose it) also for the first time. And I never thought to compare the two.
Great Analysis. Truly opened my eyes to how awesome this film actually is!
I laughed where Mannix was reading Lincoln's Letter where he said "ole Mary Todd is calling.' " Then Mannix said, "That was a nice touch". Col. Warren then replied, "Thank you." Which meant that it was true that the Letter from Lincoln was indeed false and was just a made up letter by the Colonel. Then, all previous doubts by Mannix about the Letter were all justied.
3:21 Uh, yeah, AND The Thing.
Ennio worked on all three, dude...
Cool review of the great movie!
When Daisy is hanged at the end, behind her are a pair of snow shoes on the wall and they look like demon wings coming out of her back, furthering the reference to her evil nature. I also like the sedate scene setting at the start which makes it clear that this film will take it's time and yet the music sounds like an overture to a Wagnerian opera and therefore there will be upheavals.
Don’t forget Lincoln was a Republican, not a Demonrat. Anyway, great movie.
I avoided this movie on netflix for a long time, not knowing it was a Tarantino film, and often confusing it with that horribly shitty Adam Sandler "movie" Im glad I gave it a chance. Hands down one of the best films i've ever seen.
Ditto! I avoided the movie (Netflix) because it was directed by Tarantino. Binge watched it this morning and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Despite the word "ni_ _ _r" all over the dialogue. A Quentin Tarantino obsession BTW.
im pretty sure major warren did actually kill general smiths son but he probably didn't kill him in such an exaggerated way and probably intentionally hunted his son down and killed him as revenge
Tarantino just remakes old films that most people didn't see. He's a script thief.
"It's the lies of hateful people who cause bloodshed and start wars between people who should be friends." Wow... that is deep my friend. Disregard my previous comment.
You, my friend, just earned a new subscriber
I never though I would say but the hateful eight is my all time favorite movie man Quentin is genius
Their are only 8 villians in this movie. The hangman is the hero in this film. He is not filled with hate
What's that awesome western theme at the beginning of the video?
Wow...you are very good at analysis videos. Thanks brother 💓
The hell you say
Look at the cartoon of Samurai Jack the Drop... it's a similar thing...
I ask people why they hated this movie, but they can never explain it. I see a lot of commenters hating this one.
Nutsilica: Renaissance moving comix
I work with a self confessed Tarantino fan. He’s told me several times how he loves Tarantino movies but oddly enough he doesn’t like the slower paced ones lacking more consistent “action” because I think he doesn’t understand them and doesn’t really identify with Tarantino’s style. I’ve told him you have to read between the lines the most when you think the least is happening on screen. Even with slower scenes that may seem irrelevant, Tarantino will have his actors use their sheer raw skill of acting to draw something from nothing to create a powerfully acted scene that kind of digs up the nostalgia of when cinema goers would go to a movie during let’s say the 50’s, 60’s & 70’s because an actor had exceptional talent and you want to go and watch their acting performance first & foremost. This is most evident in Once Upon A Time In Hollywood with many of the Di Caprio scenes. There’s enough scenes in that movie where you’re constantly thinking, “man this guy can seriously act.” Brad Pitt’s character does steal the show hands down, but by the end of that movie you get a whole new appreciation for Di Caprio’s ability to perform in front of the camera even though you already knew he was a great actor.
@@cliffbooth7075 I like your name! The Cliff character and the Jake characters reversed too. The fist half, Cliff seemed like an obedient servant and that's all, then he jumps on the roof, takes off his shirt and all of the sudden he turns into this bad-ass better than the bad-ass parts Jake has played. Jake is revealed as this kind of pathetic cry baby in the second half.
People that say there is no story are not noticing the story.
At the end I thought Cliff was kind of like a dog, (I mean that in a good way). He was loyal to Jake all the way and Jake is the master, even though he doesn't deserve it. Cliff didn't seem to have an ego about it ir resentment against Jake. He would just listen admiringly.
Cliff is silent almost in an animal way.
Further down that thought, Cliffs' dog was more bad-ass than Cliff.
Nutsilica: Renaissance moving comix
Yeah I hear what you’re saying. Like when he went to the ranch where the old man was in the back bedroom. Cliff was 100% loyal to him in the moment & time even if it was only for 5 mins. He was ready to get savage if he needed to. The old man reassured him he was alright. He was a tired old man who couldn’t see. He was getting tended to sexually by a controlling younger woman. Cliff thought he wasn’t being ill treated or being taken advantage of in a bad way.
@@cliffbooth7075 And Jake is kind of an egomaniacal, 'friend.' Cliff doesn't care. He's loyal. Only at the very end Jake realizes how much of a friend Cliff is.
Tarantino isn't a guy who makes great movies, he's a genius who makes genius movies. Tarantino is pretty much the "Kubrick" of my generation. They're both brilliant geniuses who have made some of the absolute best and most intelligent movies ever (without being too over-the-too and remaining extremely good movies to the unintelligent or not-so-thoughtful/analytical person-no small feat...)
There's a reason every single Tarantino film has a cult following. Like Kubrick, Tarantino does practically _nothing_ on accident. You can pick it apart for days and not get to the bottom of everything. Everything means something, practically every detail exists for a specific and meaningful reason. It's incredible. It's truly artistic. Things you don't even notice until your fifth or sixth time watching end up having incredibly deep meaning and purpose.
The biggest irony of all of this (in your excellent video,) is how the America this movie is such a brilliant commentary on, received and watched this movie without thinking anything much more than "Wow! What a dope-ass action movie! Cool!" and then forgot about it completely. It happened that way specifically because of the very blindness or apathy that a massive chunk of this movie was literally pointing to with its message and symbolism.
What a travesty of its own original intent the US has become.
Nice analysis. Thank you. Watched this right after watching the movie today. I had only seen the movie once years ago. It’s now one of my favorite westerns and Tarantino films.
Superb! You are one of the few people on YT who truly understands the meaning of this film!
Ruth was the exact opposite of “dispassionate,” which was the entire point of why a hired hangman was preferred for proper justice as opposed to “frontier justice.” Also, the snow-covered Jesus with the impending blizzard is how you instantly know when they flashback/forward. It has a point. Jodi/Jody/Jodie was Daisy’s brother, the leader of the gang, so she wasn’t referring to herself.
One of the glaring facts of this movie that no one has pointed out in the meaningless of human life in this place, people being coldbloodedly killed and everyone carries on drinking coffee
please upload more of these videos.
love it . the details are amazing.
best i have come across so far.
I watched it 75 times so far!!!!
Good thesis and break-down, love tha video............one thing thoe, in tha begenin of tha movie, Oswaldo says "justice without dispassion is not really justice" and u say Domergue was hung justly, but at tha end, Chris and Warren hang Domergue with desire to do so and passion whilst doin it becuz Jody shot Warren in tha balls and Chris was bout to drank poisoned coffee and got shot.......so they didnt hang her justly, they commited Frontier Justice....
She would not have died that easily and painlessly with frontier justice;))
I respectfully disagree, I also have to point out the danger of misquotation. Oswaldo never said "Justice without dispassion is not really justice," he says "For justice delivered without dispassion, is always in _danger_ of not being justice." There's a significant difference between what you said and what Oswaldo says. I believe Domergue's death was justified, regardless whether one thinks passion was involved in her hanging or not, she was a known and admitted murderer and infamous gang member. I believe the ending would also point more towards her being inevitably hung because that was her whole reasoning for even making it to the haberdashery. A reoccurring motif all throughout the movie is the only reason Domergue is alive is because of John Ruth, _The hangman_ . Again, the last few moments of the movie lead me to this extrapolation. "When the hangman catches you, you don't die by no bullet, when the hangman catches you, you hang."
I’d like to think the broken latch is a commentary on working together to solve a problem caused by another. Because it takes 2 boards of wood and 2 people to close it, yet every time it’s opened no one inside gets up to help they just yell at the ones who opened it.
Morricone also did the score for The Thing. Some of the unused, soundtrack album-only tracks from The Thing were even used in The Hateful Eight
This is his best movie and yes I’ve watched them all many a time but The Hateful Eight channels all his greatest movie techniques and creates this masterpiece. Awesome job analyzing this! You touched on ideas I hadn’t thought of and great cinema lesson on old westerns. Thank you!
Tip: Go back and rewatch the final act of the movie (just after Warren is shot), Tim Roth basically reprises Mr Orange when Warren shoots him out of his chair you can see and hear him rolling around for the rest of the movie, so he debatably survives to the end.
Damn good stuff. You earned a sub. I loved Hateful Eight. I think it's a better film than Basterds and Django... however unpopular that opinion might be.
I liked the scene where hes making the general angry and i thought it was funny but i also thought it was drawn out just a little too long
Great video. Really enjoyed watching an analysis of one of my favorite films. Makes me also want to check out the western films
I don't have such rich movie culture, so I'm definitely not a good judge overall...
But to me this clip is a fine analysis, and the author does know a lot of stuff.
So my question would be... why does this YT clip have such few up-votes ? Why less that 4% of the total views number ?
Tarantino is a genius making movies; I wish he would make more!
Wow, good job. I love QT's films, all of them! I did see Hateful on its Christmas 70mm roadshow tour and I'll be honest I hated it! It took me 7 years to revisit it. I decided to watch the extended 4 part version on Netflix and now I can't get enough of it! Great directors movies require multiple viewings - da
I wonder what the next stranger, who moseyed on up to Minnie's Habidashery for some steeeeeeew, thought when they came upon that scene...
Ummmmmmm, check please...
Also, I ain't marching 1000 feet out to the shitter to drop a stank pickle. I'm sorry folks, don't mind me hovering over the fireplace. I'm gonna stoke it then drop a few more logs on top to keep it going...
Great film but I'm sick of all this pointless symbolism throughout films.. if I spent my time looking for pointless symbolism I wouldn't be watching the actual film. Oooh it's so clever ......and useless..
Think this and then (IMO only) far superior Once Upon a Time in Hollywood are a slow return to Pulp Fiction form for Tarantino, but it is a direct cross, as you say, of Corbucci's masterpiece Great Silence and Carpenter's masterpiece The Thing (if you're gonna steal do so from the best)
10:20 although Lincoln declared the slaves free, it was technically Andrew Johnson who frees the slaves
Whoever takes off gloves in a Tarantino movie before he sits down at a table to talk, you know he is hiding something in his character/ choosing not to reveal something deeper/ putting on an act, Like the Jew Hunter, Marquis, and the Dr. Shultz. All wore gloves, all took them off to put on an act.
rofl
Killing Indians by blacks soldiers was not racism since it was an army decision. Speaking ill of the Hispanics was racism, and the Major excused the racism of the owner.
Watch the movie closely. EVERYTHING that Mannix says is true, even when he didn't know it's true yet
Whatsoever shown in this movi is going around right from middle east till Pakistan. People are suffering huge loss of Lives , Properties, economy and environments. Apartheidal politics , groupism , fundamentalism, corruption, antisocial activities has gone beyond inhumanic level , hard to maintain socio-communal harmony.
Any significance to the inside part of Samuel L Jacksons coat being bright yellow? Always seemed to stand out to me compared to the drab colors the rest of the characters where.
Mannix says more than once (and at least once Warren is in ear shot and says nothing but looks embarrassed) that during the war, Warren had a "yellow stripe down his back". Yellow implies cowardice. His burning down the jail (and killing dozens of people without a care) also seems to imply this. So, the inside of the coat being yellow, could mean much of his bravado is for show, and underneath it, he has his cowardly moments. I honestly wish the movie would have just been about Mannix and Warren meeting up after years apart. Both are fascinating characters and I could have watched a movie about them alone. There is far too much going on with both of them, together and separate, and sadly most of it did not get explored to it's fullest potential.
that Jennifer didnt get an oscar for her performance puzzles me
Very good analysis! I'm curious though, I watched this movie Christmas 2015 and was very very eager to see it. Frankly, I was disappointed when I walked out of the theatre. A couple years later when it became available on Netflix, I watched it again and really liked it. Now it's one of my go to movies that I put on just to get some good entertainment. I love the "who dun it?" feel to it not to mention every single character is amazing it their own right. Anyhow, did anyone else not like it at first and then grow to love it like me?
This whole movie was beautiful, and I agree it definitely is a comment on American politics and how it affects our culture. The last part where mannix and warren hang Dahmer goo had me laughing and crying. I think mannix really was telling the truth about his job and he was doing his best to uphold his role as the law, I can respect someone who comes right out and says what they got a problem with instead of a back stabbing snake like the lady.
eq your audio. add a shelf boost to the top end. your s's and t'd are barely audible.
I've seen this movie probably a dozen or more times and today was the first time I got that Warren and Mannix were dressed the same at the end AND that the red, white, and blue motif was covered them and the bed. That's just brilliant.
What they're doing to President Trump is an example of frontier justice. It's thirst quenching and void of any dispassion.
All that symbolism soared way over my head like a metaphorical plane
7:59: What's with the Thing spoiler, my dude?!
Hateful 8 is on my top 3 Tarantino film list and this video break down has me loving Hateful 8 even more.
True romance was great. And THAT scene was the best.
Hard to call the best scene in that movie. I was going to name some here, soon as I tried i realized there really are just too many. Would be easier pointing out bad scenes
@@ZillMob True. When Walken turns around to look at his friends while Hopper is schooling him kills me. Great flick.
I thought it was simply a comedy. A pastiche.
I did not even pick up on the theme of the colors of the final shot being red, white, and blue cause there's so much blood lol.
Awesomeness at Universal Levels! Wow 🤩. Thank goodness for God, Amen 🙏🏼
And when Chris stopped when warren told him not to shooting her and he asked why instead of just doing it also warren had no way of stopping him if Chris decided not to listen to him, showed respect on Chris part
Definitely liked the video. Only recommendation would be knocking down the random sounds, as they take away from your dialog by being so sharp, or too loud.
Great stuff, keep it up :)
The only truthful person in this movie was AB 🤷🏿♂️...
Sad. What could have been, with this channel. Thanks for the analysis, I guess.
This movie is massively underrated.
The general actor also played Django and hildy previous owners before they sold them separately
Can someone explain why the blizzard is « a metaphor for hate itself »
Tarantino has made three masterpieces Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction and this.
Watching it through political racist eyes ruins it for me. I think you are off 😂
my only with this whole video is at 15:46 when you said the man from the south is facing north and the man from the north is facing south. they are both facing the same way lol