God, this just makes me think of the Google Autofill series-those were the episodes that got me into SCB to begin with, I was really sad to see them go
So I have been thinking about this Pedro's death is kind of similar to Lily Potter's death. They both died willingly, sacrificing themselves to protect their family. They both could have ran away (Lily got a choice from Voldymoldy) and Pedro might've escaped with them but both chose not to and both had some kind of magic on their loved ones that protects them. I thought it was interesting at how much these storylines were similar.
So, I'm wondering how abuela found out she should give doorknobs to 5 year olds. Is she just the most lousy gift giver and gave the triplets doorknobs for their birthday and they started hitting walls with it out of disappointment? Did the candle somehow tell her. Did the kids steal doorknobs?
I can just imagine it… Bruno: “I wonder what we are going to do tomorrow…” Pepa: “Forget about tomorrow. Today is super dreary.” Julieta: “Can we just get along? Go find something to do?” Pepa: “Steal some doorknobs?” Bruno and Julieta: *confusion* Bruno: “Sounds great!” ~five minutes later~ Bruno: “I know what we’re going to do tomorrow!”
I would guess that when Alma touched her own door and saw what happened, she figured thats what the other doors were for, so she let them each touch one to see what would happen.
If you look at the pictures on the wall when they received their gifts, Everyone had an adult version of them except Antonio. I Do like to think it's because the previous ones were in the Era of Abuela- someone who Didn't look at them as who they Are; but what they could Be. I think Antonio's door shows him at his current age because he is in the Era of Mirabel and she accepts him for who he is Now. Also I Personally think only royalty and demigods change their environment when singing.
I noticed your thing about bruno's height. THIS IS NOT MY THEORY but I saw it and thought it made sense 5 year old camilo gets up in the middle of the night for a snack. Bruno has recently gone into hiding. he sees bruno in the kitchen standing on top of the counter to reach food, which is why he says he has a "7 foot frame". bruno says "camilo?" as he has now seen him. seeing bruno put him into shock and made him faint, which is why "when he calls your name it all fades to black". does it fit? does it work? i thought this was interesting.
I think Mirabel's "gift" is to be exactly what is needed by people, just like Bruno said. I don't think that was a throw away line--I think it's true! Mirabel very effectively breaks through the barriers of every single person she talks to and gets them to confide in her and trust her. She gets everyone to tell her about Bruno, gets Luisa to show her vulnerability, gets Isabela to finally unleash herself, and gets Alma to face her grief. She always just happens to be in the right place at the right time or notice the right thing. It might look like dumb luck or plot armour but I think it's actually her Gift
Theory: Camilo knows about the rats and says he “sees your dreams and feasts on your screams” because Bruno use to check on his nieces and nephews while everyone was asleep and one night Camilo caught Bruno and his rats and they probably all screamed. Camilo probably thought the whole thing was a dream
Just quickly, I have a correction. You said that the doors change with time, but thats not true. In that one scene they show all the kid versions of everybody getting their doors, and they all show up as the adult version of themselves. I saw a theory that Antonios door is as a child because in Mirabels new generation of being the lead of the house, she doesn't need every person with a gift to be fully adult with adult responsibilities from age 5, she will let them be kids. And her new doors will grow as they age.
@@Icelyn Yeah, I was about to say something like that too. I saw a theory that the doors show them how they look the next time some disaster is going to happen, for example, the magic disappears.
I saw some people commenting that they were a toxic relationship and I was like WHAT! He literally is the main person always helping with her anxiety and working with her to overcome it. Also, there are several moments that just being near him helps her calm down immediately. They are so in love it's ridiculous and I love it so much.
When I first saw the movie, I heard the first song incorrectly and mistakenly thought he had bad luck powers. And we all thought Dolores's gift was a nightmare.
I saw on TikTok from the actress for Dolores that she and the director just thought Dolores needed something to make her stand out and she played around with different squeaks and noises.
New theory idea: Abuela could "decide" what the gift for each child was gonna be (like what she though fitted the specific child best). And on Antonio's birthday Mirabel "decided" Antonio's gift to be surrounded with animals. signifying that Mirabel now "decided" the gifts This would fit in with that Abuela maybe wanted a person to pass the torch to! And I feel that also fits in with the cliché of "the perfect beautiful grandchild" (Isabella) being one of the powers Bruno-Abuela was afraid of what was to come in the future Delores-Could hear when a raid (much like the one that killed Pedro) is coming Julieta-Heals any wound with food etc I also feel that all the powers (up until Mirabel) show survival! And then Antonio is more of a "fun" gift that fits best for him. actually would discourage the village when talking survival, I'm thinking of the cattle, that situation has got to be pretty awkward...
That is freaking good question. Can he shape-shifting, stript, and shape-shifting back? What will happen to separated clothes? Disappear? Stay as is? (in this case Camilo is infinite source of clothes)
I think his powers should be limited to what he has with him. He becomes another person and needs their clothes to do so. His gift is to imitate people not change objects. It's just that people include clothes.
A much simpler answered to why Dolores squeaks is that's just a part of how we speak in Colombia (first time that I have heard the explination of the video). For me her side of the family mostly represent the coasts and making that sounds is just a part of what make our verbal comunication. I had witness complete (short) conversations were "ajá" (in all its different pronuntiations) was the closer to an actual word being said
8:55 I think all of Bruno's visions had multiples but were given toward the "negative" outcome, partly from his outlook, but mainly due to the effort required to stop it. Like "He told me I would grow a gut", well you're clearly not going to change your ways, so if I say you might get abs instead, you'd just be more disappointed later.
I think that's where the question; "Can Mirabel see the future?" came from. Like, did she have a vision of the future or does Hernando just work super fast?
The cracks show when the magic is weak. When there isn't cohesion in the family. Mirabel was feeling like she wasn't part of the family because she had no gift. She see the cracks. She goes to get everyone. Aubela comes, Aubela believes, Aubela includes Mirabel. The house heals because the family is strong and united again. Unfortunately removing the proof of Mirabel's words and immediately making the family and the magic weak again.🤷♀️
9:49 Partway through, I thought they were gonna reveal that Casita isn't magic at all, and it was just Bruno being as hyperaware as The Oracle from The Matrix but with an elaborate pulley system to shift things around at precise times.
About the image of the characters on their doors. During the opening song, you see Maribel by Abuelo's door. Next to her door are the framed photos of all the kids the day they got their door. If you look closely, it shows them as kids but the image on the door is of them as adults. They are children in front of the door but the image on the door is them the way they look currently in the movie. The exact moment that I'm talking about is even in this video at 4 minutes 47 seconds. I've had my own theory that the house knew that it was going to lose its powers during that time. Bruno even says he had his vision of Maribel the night that she didn't get her door. She was 5 but his image shows her as the current age in the movie. Meaning that the house knew that it was going to be destroyed when she was that age
And also in scene when Mirabel is decorating with the candle-things right before the pictures on the floor. The scene is 11min 36seconds and it's really close to the pictures.
The thing about Camilo saying Bruno has a seven foot frame is kind of a fun detail because as the song goes on, the claims about Bruno get more ridiculous and unrealistic. We go from an idea that is framed in reality (Bruno at the wedding) to blaming him about receding hairlines.
Camilo is bsing about Bruno. Being the same age as Mirabel, he remembers just as much as Mirabel which is next to nothing. I saw someone say he’s trying to get back at Mirabel for telling him (as Dolores) that Dolores is her favorite older cousin (of which Mirabel only has two). (Camilo was also intended to be an antagonist in earlier versions, which is why many of the toys have him with a sinister expression. The references they got were outdated)
About "Do the doors change?": They do not. When the characters get their doors, the doors reflect how the keeper of the magic sees them as well as the magical ability they inherit. There are blink and you'll miss it flash backs to when they were younger and their door images are as they appear in the present day of the film.
I was hoping someone would point this out. I thought I remembered MatPat pointing this out, but as you say it's a blink and you miss it thing so I wasn't sure.
Before Luisa's song, I thought Mirabel's power was to be able to make everyone go into song. Because she starts the first couple songs, including the time stop one.
So i have a theory that the magic evolves with each generation. In the first one the triplets need to do something in order for their gift to work (feeling a certain mood to control the weather, making food to heal, big empty space and ritual to see the future) but in the younger generation the kids just use their gifts directly. IDK just thought it was a cool detail.
I think that Camillo knowing about the rats doesn't indicate that they were a before he was in the walls thing, but rather that Camillo has actually seen Bruno since he went behind the walls.
I thought the same thing about Isabela and crops! 😆 I wonder if, as a little kid, she just loved flowers, so Abuela assumed that was all she could grow and no one ever encouraged her to experiment with it. Although, a lot of food plants flower, sooo.. 🤷♀️
12:19 There is actually a double meaning here which is relevant to the film. While the given definitions for "encanto" are correct, it is also pronounced the same as "en canto", meaning "in song".
13:15 another example comes when Antonio is riding his tiger for the first time and almost falls. We can see Camilo doing this sign with his hands, which basically means “oof, so close” in most of Latin American countries
Audience: Who are the Super Carlin Brothers? SCB: Who's asking? Audience: US!!! SCB: Well "Us", Ben and Jay can't just talk about ourselves...... 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@Raffi Sabghir The two people on this channel are Ben and J, not Ben and Jay. I'm pretty sure the J stands for a longer name, but I can't remember what it is. I think that's what @timotheninja was trying to say
@@timotheninja @NinjaDragonGamer: I know that you both mean well. But at the same time, I respectfully think that there was no need to correct me. I've been subscribed to the channel long enough to know the names of the hosts. But I would also like to think that most people, even those part of the SCB team, would know who I'm referring to in the context of what I wrote. And might not even care that much whether I went with "J" or "Jay".
@Raffi Sabghir I also didn't mean to be rude, I just wanted to explain what @timotheninja was saying as your comment* made me think you might've been confused, so I tried to explain what they meant. I apologize if my comment came across as negative or mean *The comment that I thought you made in reply to @timotheninja's first comment. However, it's not there anymore, so now I'm having a whatever-the-opposite-of-deja-vu-is moment
I saw a really cute fancomic of Camillo sneaking downstairs to get snacks as a smol kid and seeing giant Bruno (also getting snacks) and freaking out and it just...fits so perfectly. I want to see more fancomics of the family history. Like I'd even go for a full romance story of how the husbands met and developed relationships with Pepa and Julieta. There's just so much cute story there.
I saw this one thing on tik tok saying another potential reason Mirabel didn’t get a door is because right before she went to open her door she wiped her hands on her dress, essentially giving herself the power but when you watch Antonio he doesn’t wipe his hands and he gets a door. Just a fun theory that i think also contributed to the fact that she is the new keeper of the magic
I argue that YES, Mirabel can see the future. Not only does she give Antonio a stuffed animal that later appears as a real animal when he gets his gift, but as a 5 year old girl, you can see an “adult” version of Dolores on Mirabel’s wall that she drew.
The images on the doors are fixed and don't change. If you look closely at the pictures by Abeullas door, all of them are five but their doors are the same as their ones in the movie. So with Antonio's door showing him young it tells you something is wrong with the magic, which is simular to Bruno and how he couldn't see past the houses "destruction"
i always thought about the "betrothed to another" line as Bruno seeing someone Dolores loves proposing to someone else and he stopped watching before he saw the happy ending like with the main vision.
I would say in the long run probably not. It definitely made it stronger in that moment, but Abuela was still not seeing them for who they were, just their powers/gifts. Everyone would still feel that pressure, and Abuela wouldn't change until something drastic happened.
I always thought that the vision was a misdirection, in a way so many of Bruno’s visions are. Isabela resembles young Abuela to an extent, so once I got to the end, it was obvious to me that the vision was referring to Abuela, albeit in a more symbolic way. As it was pointed out, Isabela and Mirabel’s relationship is tense, but more surface level pettiness like most siblings. Whereas Abuela set the tone in the household as the matriarch, so she had to play a role in fixing what was broken.
I would love a video that compiles all the theories about who all knew that bruno was in the wall. Like his sister leaving food out for him after breakfast. The husbands doing secret game night in the wall and dolores listening to the ratanovella each morning.🤣
Number 6 regarding the doors changing is a bit of a tricky one, as you can see in the song Family Madrigal and even in this video, the photos outside abuela’s door is the day everyone got their power and all the doors have their adult images, even though at the time they were 5!
I Personally think this is something only characters who are royalty or demigods can do. If you watch all the Disney movies only Select characters change their environment when singing.
In the pictures of each of the door ceremonies, there is everyone young and their doors are the adult doors we see them come out of later in the timeline. Small detail, might be an oversight, but it's definitely there. It's right next to Abuela's door.
Great video :D I was wondering if the doors in the new house stay 'bubbly' (and if so, what's the significance of that) or do they change to their normal lay-out once the members enter it for the first time
You say that the images on the door change and I thought this too but you see them stood in front of their door as children at the start of the movie and the image on the door is them as their current age.
When J's talking about the doors changing he says the doors must change because antonio's shows him as a child and everyone else shows them as they currently are, but in the same shot there are pictures on the wall next to abuela's door from each gift ceremony where the triplets have adult versions of themselves on the doors while they're still only five years old.
I scrolled the questions and didn’t see this there and I’ve googled it and couldn’t find anything there either. Any chance SCB can find out what Camilo’s door is? Every other gifted family member has their door down in the end credits but I can’t find his door anywhere. Any explanation?
My theory is Mirabel didn't get her gift due to when she was 5, after she touched the candle, she wipes her hands on her dress before she touches the Doorknob.
I have a few questions about Julieta's Gift in particular. 1. If she just did something like putting salt on an apple would that count, since she added something to it? (probably not, but it would be cool) 2. Does she have specific recipes for specific injuries? Like broken leg soup or something? 3. If she planted a crops, would whatever grew be healing food, since she "made" it?
The one act that Mirabel did was to trying to save "The Candle" while Casita was crumbling around. This then made Mirabel Madrigal the Keeper of the Magic as the magic went into Mirabel. Another thing that I have noticed is the decorations on the box that Mirabel gives to Antonio will be a representation of the gift that he will be receiving shortly at the door ceremony.
J, thank you for sending me down an interesting rabbit hole! your comment about Colombian body language sparked a thought about some of the mannerisms my non-verbal adopted son has been expressing... He has never left the USA, and was adopted as an infant... so it falls to NvN thing... still an interesting rabbit hole. Thank you! Love your Show, keep them coming.
If Camilo just remembered Bruno as being 7ft tall, but Bruno wasn't actually that tall, wouldn't Camilo turn into a 7ft Bruno in "We don't talk about Bruno"?
13:19 the pointing with your lips thing also applies to some Native American tribes! I have a teacher who talked about teaching on a reservation (I forget which one) and she said that they even ‘pointed around corners’ with their lips.
I think Abuela and Mirabel share a bit of the powers of the individuals they are most connected. The candle gives the gifts and the Keeper's mental state maintains the candle. So Mirabel received the vision after the candle ceremony in place of Bruno who "would" have had this vision if he didn't leave. And when they have one together, it recapitulates like a choose your own adventure novel
re: do the doors change question. The way I interpreted the movie- we see the young family members each touch their doors in flashback and it does show them as adults. The passing of the torch concept from abuela to Mirabel is so symbolic here because everyone in the family is struggling to live up to abuela's idea of them and their "proper" role in the family whereas Mirabel (in this idea the passing/turbulance of passing of the torch happened when Mirabel walked Antonio to his door rather than alone) just wants Antonio to be confident/comfortable with himself and to be happy and his door reflects him just as he is as a child. So maybe his door will change as he grows or the doors since the revival of Casita will have changed to more rightfully reflect the family members.
4:04 - actually, yes! In the official Encanto novelization epilogue (which is an "after the events of the movie" epilogue) and in an epilogue scene that was originally going to be in the movie (but this was back when Bubo was still in the movie), yes, Mirabel does get a door. But it isn't a door in the same way the rest of the family has doors,.. here.. Let me get the quote straight from the novel. "As for Mirabel... One day, the family playfully blindfolded her for a special surprise. They chatted and laughed as they guided her through the house and to her bedroom door. When the family pulled the blindfold from Mirabel's eyes, she smiled from ear to ear! Each member of the family had decorated her door with something that reflected their own special gift. It was made from magic and glowed with love. Her very own special door!" So she does get her own door! And of course, not a visual gift.
The pictures on the wall of everyone getting their doors, you can actually see the doors look the same as they look in present day. Weird right? They can see what they look like when their older.
9:26 OH my freaking goodness of course SCB would be the ones to pick up on something like that (I mean, I already knew they made a theory on that by this point, but still. 😝)
Her gift is actually multiple gifts,Hope, Inspiration,Growth,and she was able to see long enough to put the family back together,and then she inherited the gift of the magic keeper.
I feel like Mirabella's gift is to truly see people, specifically her family. Like she can see how worried her little cousin is and more or less knows what his gift is gonna be ( almost like she gave him his gift) and then her sisters are pretty open about telling her their darkest secrets or things they have been hiding and like c'mon no one talks about Bruno but they all tell her everything about Bruno. And while we are talking about Bruno, dude just tells her everything without any hesitation, like sure she's family but like he feels like a pretty private guy but not with her. She has a bigger connection to her family than anyone else, almost like they can't hide things from her. The only person that seems to be immune is Alma.
For the betrothed question, it made me think about how in Mexico, it's tradition for the guy and his parents to meet up with the girls parents and ask for her hand in marriage before he proposes. When I heard the betrothed to another line i immediately thought of this. Not sure if it is done in the rest of Latinoamérica but for sure in Mexico
Mirabel 'seeing the future'... she had a vision of the house cracking and collapsing during the party. Perhaps not the FUTURE but a darn insightful vision of current events. The fact that the symbolic divisions become real and break the house is a bonus.
Actually the doors showed the older version of the other Madrigal kids except Antonio. This is depicted in the pictures next to Abuela’s room door during “The Family Madrigal” song. Now I think this is because when the house broke down the Madrigal kids except Antonio were their older selves.
I was rewatching encanto and realized a opposite/parallel with tangled. twords the end of encanto Mirabel says something along the lines of "the miracle is alive BECAUSE OF YOU...we are a family BECAUSE OF YOU..." and twords the end of tangled when Rapunzel confronts Gothel she says something like "this entire time I should have been fearing YOU... I should have been hiding FROM you." tangled was one of my favorite movies growing up and idk if it was intentional (knowing Disney it was) but it made me happy and I wanted to share :)
I'd like to think that when Bruno looked to the future to predict Delores' future love he only saw the scene we saw in the movie, which is Mariano on one knee proposing (or about to propose) to Isalbella. And that other members of the family told him to stop to prevent further upset, so Bruno couldn't look further to see if something changes.
Isabella and mirabel’s spilt second make up literally represented me and my brother’s relationship when we were kids because we would go from wanting to attack each other and then we would just start making up out of nowhere
something I've been thinking about in regards to the doors. when we see the pictures of all the kids when they've just gotten their gifts, they're all actually the same as when they're older. I don't know why this is the case, and put me on a spiral where I concluded that since Antonio is the only one to get a door with his 5 year old self on it, that means he'll die like way too young which I absolutely did not want to think about.
Observation about the image on the doors. If you look at the photo wall with everyone posing with Abuela and their door, the image on the doors are all of them as adults - except Antonio's. His image is of him as a child. I wonder if something changed after Mirabel didn't get her door that made Antonio's image be different.
Maybe a little off topic, but I just got my Trivia Night Extravaganza puzzle, and I am so excited!! You guys have been awesome and make me smile every time I watch a video. Thank you!
I have a headcanon that Mirabel actually does get her own door inside the house at the end of the movie. This is because 1. Abuela has a magical door, so it would not be logical to leave Mirabel in the nursery and 2. there is a shot at the end where you see all the doors have the glow from before they have become someone's door, like the glow from before Mirabel/Antonio touched their doors for the first time. I think they get to reclaim a door, and that Mirabel will also get to claim a door. Maybe a fun thing to make a video about as well? See if you can find any other clues for this.
Ok, but Abuela has her own door so wouldn’t it be logical to assume that if Mirabel is now the new Abuela that she gets her own door? Or when Abuela dies does mirabel inherit her room and door and it changes to a picture of Mirabel?
I just hope that Mirabel gets a nice if normal room in the new casita. It would be weird if she still lived in the nursery when new babies are born into the family.
with the line from we don't talk about bruno and the whole Mariano thing- i believe that bruno saw into the future and saw that Mariano would propose to isabela/tru to propose and then he thought that was the whole thing
If translated betrothed to german betrothed it says "verlobt" which means engaged. I don't know why people think it means they are/will definatly be married. I think what Bruno saw was Dolores being in love with Mariano but Mariano asking Isabella already holding the ring out to her, but he didn't see the outcome he just assumed that he would be betrothed to someone else.
I'd say maybe part of it comes from Zazu's line in Lion King when he's talking to Simba and Nala, he says pretty much word for word "betrothed, intended, affianced" Simba asks "meaning?" Zazu replies "one day you two are going to be married". Simba and Nala were young kids in that scene.
I love that you literally turn into abuela at the end. Just 'use your powers to solve all of everyone's problems!' Just goes to show how easy that mindset is to fall into and how good intentions can turn so bad
my personal theory is that just like isabella's gift, ALL their gifts can and will grow over time and I think this includes the keeper of the magic's gift... also encanto can mean a certain place... "The settlement-referred to as the Encanto-is located in the Colombian mountains. The colorful refuge also provides shelter for fauna appropriate for the locale."
Look at the pictures in the hall, though. When I saw them, the images were all the same. The triplets were standing next to doors showing their adult selves, and so were the older three Madrigal grandchildren, while Camilo is shown with his 15 year old self.
I love how, in Mirabel's prayer (song: Waiting on a Miracle), she names everything she 'would do'... and then does so in the story. Just not how she meant.
God, this just makes me think of the Google Autofill series-those were the episodes that got me into SCB to begin with, I was really sad to see them go
Yeah I really miss those. I wish they would bring it back.
Yeeees, I loved those!
It would be great if you guys brought that series
ah, one day maybe. one day.
That's the first thing I thought of seeing the thumbnail as well. I rewatched those videos so many times during the last years
I love the way Julieta sighs, rolls her eyes, and says, "Ay, Augustin," after she looks at his bee stings. Like, "not again".
Yea, I was lol-ling if thats a thing
@@blinks4ever969 Lol-ling is a thing
One of my favorite parts of the whole movie. I don't know why but it just makes me giggle so much.
Yes! I’m Venezuelan and it reminds me of my mom, just hilarious!
Love that. Augustin tries to help but seems like he's really allergic to bees.
So I have been thinking about this Pedro's death is kind of similar to Lily Potter's death. They both died willingly, sacrificing themselves to protect their family. They both could have ran away (Lily got a choice from Voldymoldy) and Pedro might've escaped with them but both chose not to and both had some kind of magic on their loved ones that protects them. I thought it was interesting at how much these storylines were similar.
i was thinking the same thing omg
Yess
It makes me wonder if he knew what was going to happen. Maybe other members of his family had powers or die to protect the family.
Mirabel Madrigal And The Fading Miracle
So, I'm wondering how abuela found out she should give doorknobs to 5 year olds. Is she just the most lousy gift giver and gave the triplets doorknobs for their birthday and they started hitting walls with it out of disappointment? Did the candle somehow tell her. Did the kids steal doorknobs?
I can just imagine it…
Bruno: “I wonder what we are going to do tomorrow…”
Pepa: “Forget about tomorrow. Today is super dreary.”
Julieta: “Can we just get along? Go find something to do?”
Pepa: “Steal some doorknobs?”
Bruno and Julieta: *confusion*
Bruno: “Sounds great!”
~five minutes later~
Bruno: “I know what we’re going to do tomorrow!”
I would guess that when Alma touched her own door and saw what happened, she figured thats what the other doors were for, so she let them each touch one to see what would happen.
@@_Egon abuelas room is a recreated version of the room she shared with Pedro. So it's still a basic room like the nursery
@@VoidKing666 I saw what you did there, Phineas and Ferbian!
@@DavidRay_40 I wasn’t thinking about that when writing this, but I am in the middle of re-watching P&F right now so, nice to see another!
If you look at the pictures on the wall when they received their gifts, Everyone had an adult version of them except Antonio.
I Do like to think it's because the previous ones were in the Era of Abuela- someone who Didn't look at them as who they Are; but what they could Be.
I think Antonio's door shows him at his current age because he is in the Era of Mirabel and she accepts him for who he is Now.
Also I Personally think only royalty and demigods change their environment when singing.
I absolutely think Agustin got into more "accidents" when he was younger just to have an excuse to talk to Julieta
I noticed your thing about bruno's height. THIS IS NOT MY THEORY but I saw it and thought it made sense
5 year old camilo gets up in the middle of the night for a snack. Bruno has recently gone into hiding. he sees bruno in the kitchen standing on top of the counter to reach food, which is why he says he has a "7 foot frame". bruno says "camilo?" as he has now seen him. seeing bruno put him into shock and made him faint, which is why "when he calls your name it all fades to black".
does it fit? does it work? i thought this was interesting.
makes senes. camilo getting up in the night and sees bruno. “Camilo-“ *camilo faints*
Sense*
oi- are /you/ the othe that made that tiktok??
I was literally going to comment this exact same thing. This theory is so logical to me that I've just accepted it as canon. 😂
@@xAbbieCx13 wicked! waiting for the day its confirmed the truth...
I think Mirabel's "gift" is to be exactly what is needed by people, just like Bruno said. I don't think that was a throw away line--I think it's true! Mirabel very effectively breaks through the barriers of every single person she talks to and gets them to confide in her and trust her. She gets everyone to tell her about Bruno, gets Luisa to show her vulnerability, gets Isabela to finally unleash herself, and gets Alma to face her grief. She always just happens to be in the right place at the right time or notice the right thing. It might look like dumb luck or plot armour but I think it's actually her Gift
Her power isn't to get people to speak with her. It's getting people to sing to her lol
Theory: Camilo knows about the rats and says he “sees your dreams and feasts on your screams” because Bruno use to check on his nieces and nephews while everyone was asleep and one night Camilo caught Bruno and his rats and they probably all screamed.
Camilo probably thought the whole thing was a dream
I just kinda assumed they were Bruno's pets as well
"Why did Pedro die?"
"Uh...because of the swords"
I died 🤣🤣🤣
Just like Pedro.
@@cjdragon1988 lucky for me, not by swords
Just quickly, I have a correction. You said that the doors change with time, but thats not true. In that one scene they show all the kid versions of everybody getting their doors, and they all show up as the adult version of themselves. I saw a theory that Antonios door is as a child because in Mirabels new generation of being the lead of the house, she doesn't need every person with a gift to be fully adult with adult responsibilities from age 5, she will let them be kids. And her new doors will grow as they age.
Interesting. The one theory I believe is that the doors show the owner’s age when the magic disappears.
@@Icelyn Yeah, I was about to say something like that too. I saw a theory that the doors show them how they look the next time some disaster is going to happen, for example, the magic disappears.
I literally just came to the comments to give this correction
Beat me to this correction too
I think they just didn't design doors with them younger. i think it was either the door designer or the director who said they're supposed to change
Reminds me of the old google autofill videos. WHY DOES VOLDEMORT KEEP STEALING MY SHAMPOO?!?!?!?
Well? Did you ever find out?
@@Rennies-World it was to maintain his fantastic head of hair
@@tarzan5932 😂
Half of these questions seem to come from people who didn't watch the movie, like 'where did Bruno hide' or 'do the husband's have powers'
Excuse you, Felix does have a power. It's being an amazing, caring husband who knows how to help Pepa through whatever she's going through🥺
I saw some people commenting that they were a toxic relationship and I was like WHAT! He literally is the main person always helping with her anxiety and working with her to overcome it. Also, there are several moments that just being near him helps her calm down immediately. They are so in love it's ridiculous and I love it so much.
When I first saw the movie, I heard the first song incorrectly and mistakenly thought he had bad luck powers. And we all thought Dolores's gift was a nightmare.
I saw on TikTok from the actress for Dolores that she and the director just thought Dolores needed something to make her stand out and she played around with different squeaks and noises.
New theory idea:
Abuela could "decide" what the gift for each child was gonna be (like what she though fitted the specific child best).
And on Antonio's birthday Mirabel "decided" Antonio's gift to be surrounded with animals. signifying that Mirabel now "decided" the gifts
This would fit in with that Abuela maybe wanted a person to pass the torch to! And I feel that also fits in with the cliché of "the perfect beautiful grandchild" (Isabella) being one of the powers
Bruno-Abuela was afraid of what was to come in the future
Delores-Could hear when a raid (much like the one that killed Pedro) is coming
Julieta-Heals any wound with food
etc
I also feel that all the powers (up until Mirabel) show survival! And then Antonio is more of a "fun" gift that fits best for him.
actually would discourage the village when talking survival, I'm thinking of the cattle, that situation has got to be pretty awkward...
I have a Question. Camilo clothes changes when he shapeshifts. Is his clothes just his skin, or can he also shapeshift other things beside himself?
That is freaking good question. Can he shape-shifting, stript, and shape-shifting back? What will happen to separated clothes? Disappear? Stay as is? (in this case Camilo is infinite source of clothes)
I think his powers should be limited to what he has with him. He becomes another person and needs their clothes to do so. His gift is to imitate people not change objects. It's just that people include clothes.
A much simpler answered to why Dolores squeaks is that's just a part of how we speak in Colombia (first time that I have heard the explination of the video). For me her side of the family mostly represent the coasts and making that sounds is just a part of what make our verbal comunication. I had witness complete (short) conversations were "ajá" (in all its different pronuntiations) was the closer to an actual word being said
8:55 I think all of Bruno's visions had multiples but were given toward the "negative" outcome, partly from his outlook, but mainly due to the effort required to stop it. Like "He told me I would grow a gut", well you're clearly not going to change your ways, so if I say you might get abs instead, you'd just be more disappointed later.
When Mirabel saw the first cracks... how did they disappear so fast. That makes no sense to me. Hernando couldn't have fixed it all that fast.
I think that's where the question; "Can Mirabel see the future?" came from. Like, did she have a vision of the future or does Hernando just work super fast?
That spackle was magical!
The cracks show when the magic is weak. When there isn't cohesion in the family. Mirabel was feeling like she wasn't part of the family because she had no gift.
She see the cracks. She goes to get everyone. Aubela comes, Aubela believes, Aubela includes Mirabel. The house heals because the family is strong and united again.
Unfortunately removing the proof of Mirabel's words and immediately making the family and the magic weak again.🤷♀️
9:49 Partway through, I thought they were gonna reveal that Casita isn't magic at all, and it was just Bruno being as hyperaware as The Oracle from The Matrix but with an elaborate pulley system to shift things around at precise times.
About the image of the characters on their doors. During the opening song, you see Maribel by Abuelo's door. Next to her door are the framed photos of all the kids the day they got their door. If you look closely, it shows them as kids but the image on the door is of them as adults. They are children in front of the door but the image on the door is them the way they look currently in the movie. The exact moment that I'm talking about is even in this video at 4 minutes 47 seconds.
I've had my own theory that the house knew that it was going to lose its powers during that time. Bruno even says he had his vision of Maribel the night that she didn't get her door. She was 5 but his image shows her as the current age in the movie. Meaning that the house knew that it was going to be destroyed when she was that age
Mirabel
@@xandranicholai7301 yeah I was voice texting and it auto spelled it like that
And also in scene when Mirabel is decorating with the candle-things right before the pictures on the floor. The scene is 11min 36seconds and it's really close to the pictures.
The thing about Camilo saying Bruno has a seven foot frame is kind of a fun detail because as the song goes on, the claims about Bruno get more ridiculous and unrealistic. We go from an idea that is framed in reality (Bruno at the wedding) to blaming him about receding hairlines.
And that the vision he allegedly had about the natural consequences of poor pet husbandry directly killed someone's carp.
Camilo is bsing about Bruno. Being the same age as Mirabel, he remembers just as much as Mirabel which is next to nothing. I saw someone say he’s trying to get back at Mirabel for telling him (as Dolores) that Dolores is her favorite older cousin (of which Mirabel only has two).
(Camilo was also intended to be an antagonist in earlier versions, which is why many of the toys have him with a sinister expression. The references they got were outdated)
the toys haunt my dreams
Augustin and Julieta falling in love because he was accident prone and kept coming to her for cures is my news favorite headcannon. 🥰
It's canon, actually. Jared Bush confirmed that's how they fell in love.
About "Do the doors change?": They do not. When the characters get their doors, the doors reflect how the keeper of the magic sees them as well as the magical ability they inherit. There are blink and you'll miss it flash backs to when they were younger and their door images are as they appear in the present day of the film.
I was hoping someone would point this out. I thought I remembered MatPat pointing this out, but as you say it's a blink and you miss it thing so I wasn't sure.
Before Luisa's song, I thought Mirabel's power was to be able to make everyone go into song. Because she starts the first couple songs, including the time stop one.
So i have a theory that the magic evolves with each generation. In the first one the triplets need to do something in order for their gift to work (feeling a certain mood to control the weather, making food to heal, big empty space and ritual to see the future) but in the younger generation the kids just use their gifts directly. IDK just thought it was a cool detail.
I think that Camillo knowing about the rats doesn't indicate that they were a before he was in the walls thing, but rather that Camillo has actually seen Bruno since he went behind the walls.
Or that his sister confided in him which I think is most likely
I thought the same thing about Isabela and crops! 😆 I wonder if, as a little kid, she just loved flowers, so Abuela assumed that was all she could grow and no one ever encouraged her to experiment with it. Although, a lot of food plants flower, sooo.. 🤷♀️
12:19
There is actually a double meaning here which is relevant to the film. While the given definitions for "encanto" are correct, it is also pronounced the same as "en canto", meaning "in song".
That's very interesting! Thanks for sharing!!!
13:15 another example comes when Antonio is riding his tiger for the first time and almost falls. We can see Camilo doing this sign with his hands, which basically means “oof, so close” in most of Latin American countries
Audience: Who are the Super Carlin Brothers?
SCB: Who's asking?
Audience: US!!!
SCB: Well "Us", Ben and Jay can't just talk about ourselves......
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@Raffi Sabghir The two people on this channel are Ben and J, not Ben and Jay. I'm pretty sure the J stands for a longer name, but I can't remember what it is. I think that's what @timotheninja was trying to say
@@timotheninja @NinjaDragonGamer: I know that you both mean well. But at the same time, I respectfully think that there was no need to correct me. I've been subscribed to the channel long enough to know the names of the hosts. But I would also like to think that most people, even those part of the SCB team, would know who I'm referring to in the context of what I wrote. And might not even care that much whether I went with "J" or "Jay".
@Raffi Sabghir I also didn't mean to be rude, I just wanted to explain what @timotheninja was saying as your comment* made me think you might've been confused, so I tried to explain what they meant. I apologize if my comment came across as negative or mean
*The comment that I thought you made in reply to @timotheninja's first comment. However, it's not there anymore, so now I'm having a whatever-the-opposite-of-deja-vu-is moment
@@ninjadragongamer6861 J stands for Johnathan.
With the whole crops thing, Antonio could have his animals plough the fields.
I love these 25 questions videos! They're like a mix between fast facts and google autofill videos from the older days
That whole crops thing to spider man was *immmaculate* also good to see the fight against the giraphalents is still strong!
I saw a really cute fancomic of Camillo sneaking downstairs to get snacks as a smol kid and seeing giant Bruno (also getting snacks) and freaking out and it just...fits so perfectly. I want to see more fancomics of the family history. Like I'd even go for a full romance story of how the husbands met and developed relationships with Pepa and Julieta. There's just so much cute story there.
CAN U GIVE ME LINK?
I saw this one thing on tik tok saying another potential reason Mirabel didn’t get a door is because right before she went to open her door she wiped her hands on her dress, essentially giving herself the power but when you watch Antonio he doesn’t wipe his hands and he gets a door. Just a fun theory that i think also contributed to the fact that she is the new keeper of the magic
I argue that YES, Mirabel can see the future. Not only does she give Antonio a stuffed animal that later appears as a real animal when he gets his gift, but as a 5 year old girl, you can see an “adult” version of Dolores on Mirabel’s wall that she drew.
Not only that she predicted all the gifts the family would receive when she embroidered the dress she wears.
The images on the doors are fixed and don't change. If you look closely at the pictures by Abeullas door, all of them are five but their doors are the same as their ones in the movie. So with Antonio's door showing him young it tells you something is wrong with the magic, which is simular to Bruno and how he couldn't see past the houses "destruction"
i always thought about the "betrothed to another" line as Bruno seeing someone Dolores loves proposing to someone else and he stopped watching before he saw the happy ending like with the main vision.
because his visions aren't text, they're images. so he didn't see the words, he saw it happening
Question: If Mirabel and Abuela did not get into a fight would the embrace of Isabella and Mirabel have fixed the magic?
I would say in the long run probably not. It definitely made it stronger in that moment, but Abuela was still not seeing them for who they were, just their powers/gifts. Everyone would still feel that pressure, and Abuela wouldn't change until something drastic happened.
I always thought that the vision was a misdirection, in a way so many of Bruno’s visions are. Isabela resembles young Abuela to an extent, so once I got to the end, it was obvious to me that the vision was referring to Abuela, albeit in a more symbolic way. As it was pointed out, Isabela and Mirabel’s relationship is tense, but more surface level pettiness like most siblings. Whereas Abuela set the tone in the household as the matriarch, so she had to play a role in fixing what was broken.
I would love a video that compiles all the theories about who all knew that bruno was in the wall. Like his sister leaving food out for him after breakfast. The husbands doing secret game night in the wall and dolores listening to the ratanovella each morning.🤣
Number 6 regarding the doors changing is a bit of a tricky one, as you can see in the song Family Madrigal and even in this video, the photos outside abuela’s door is the day everyone got their power and all the doors have their adult images, even though at the time they were 5!
“Crops, you guys, crops”. “There’s only one man who would DARE give me the crops”.
Love that idea , they should make crop tops
4:51 YES!! The picture on the wall in a scene in The Family Madrigal showed EXACTLY that!! 0_0
I think Mirabel has the power to break into a musical which can see other person thoughts.
I Personally think this is something only characters who are royalty or demigods can do.
If you watch all the Disney movies only Select characters change their environment when singing.
In the pictures of each of the door ceremonies, there is everyone young and their doors are the adult doors we see them come out of later in the timeline. Small detail, might be an oversight, but it's definitely there. It's right next to Abuela's door.
Great video :D I was wondering if the doors in the new house stay 'bubbly' (and if so, what's the significance of that) or do they change to their normal lay-out once the members enter it for the first time
You say that the images on the door change and I thought this too but you see them stood in front of their door as children at the start of the movie and the image on the door is them as their current age.
When J's talking about the doors changing he says the doors must change because antonio's shows him as a child and everyone else shows them as they currently are, but in the same shot there are pictures on the wall next to abuela's door from each gift ceremony where the triplets have adult versions of themselves on the doors while they're still only five years old.
14:37 - 15:15 omgggg J just pitched the perfect Encanto sequel
When Camillo is disguised as Delores, does he have her super hearing ability? He can certainly pass off her squeak.
I scrolled the questions and didn’t see this there and I’ve googled it and couldn’t find anything there either. Any chance SCB can find out what Camilo’s door is? Every other gifted family member has their door down in the end credits but I can’t find his door anywhere. Any explanation?
Love your channel been watching for so many years now
My theory is Mirabel didn't get her gift due to when she was 5, after she touched the candle, she wipes her hands on her dress before she touches the Doorknob.
I have a few questions about Julieta's Gift in particular.
1. If she just did something like putting salt on an apple would that count, since she added something to it? (probably not, but it would be cool)
2. Does she have specific recipes for specific injuries? Like broken leg soup or something?
3. If she planted a crops, would whatever grew be healing food, since she "made" it?
When I first watched the movie I thought Mirabels gift was to slow time because of what happened in that one song.
Haha me too
The one act that Mirabel did was to trying to save "The Candle" while Casita was crumbling around. This then made Mirabel Madrigal the Keeper of the Magic as the magic went into Mirabel.
Another thing that I have noticed is the decorations on the box that Mirabel gives to Antonio will be a representation of the gift that he will be receiving shortly at the door ceremony.
J, thank you for sending me down an interesting rabbit hole! your comment about Colombian body language sparked a thought about some of the mannerisms my non-verbal adopted son has been expressing... He has never left the USA, and was adopted as an infant... so it falls to NvN thing... still an interesting rabbit hole. Thank you! Love your Show, keep them coming.
If Camilo just remembered Bruno as being 7ft tall, but Bruno wasn't actually that tall, wouldn't Camilo turn into a 7ft Bruno in "We don't talk about Bruno"?
During Mirabel’s song “Waiting on a Miracle” Mirabel “creates” the encanto as she sings
13:19 the pointing with your lips thing also applies to some Native American tribes! I have a teacher who talked about teaching on a reservation (I forget which one) and she said that they even ‘pointed around corners’ with their lips.
I think Abuela and Mirabel share a bit of the powers of the individuals they are most connected. The candle gives the gifts and the Keeper's mental state maintains the candle. So Mirabel received the vision after the candle ceremony in place of Bruno who "would" have had this vision if he didn't leave. And when they have one together, it recapitulates like a choose your own adventure novel
re: do the doors change question. The way I interpreted the movie- we see the young family members each touch their doors in flashback and it does show them as adults. The passing of the torch concept from abuela to Mirabel is so symbolic here because everyone in the family is struggling to live up to abuela's idea of them and their "proper" role in the family whereas Mirabel (in this idea the passing/turbulance of passing of the torch happened when Mirabel walked Antonio to his door rather than alone) just wants Antonio to be confident/comfortable with himself and to be happy and his door reflects him just as he is as a child. So maybe his door will change as he grows or the doors since the revival of Casita will have changed to more rightfully reflect the family members.
4:04 - actually, yes! In the official Encanto novelization epilogue (which is an "after the events of the movie" epilogue) and in an epilogue scene that was originally going to be in the movie (but this was back when Bubo was still in the movie), yes, Mirabel does get a door.
But it isn't a door in the same way the rest of the family has doors,.. here.. Let me get the quote straight from the novel.
"As for Mirabel...
One day, the family playfully blindfolded her for a special surprise. They chatted and laughed as they guided her through the house and to her bedroom door. When the family pulled the blindfold from Mirabel's eyes, she smiled from ear to ear! Each member of the family had decorated her door with something that reflected their own special gift. It was made from magic and glowed with love. Her very own special door!"
So she does get her own door! And of course, not a visual gift.
The pictures on the wall of everyone getting their doors, you can actually see the doors look the same as they look in present day. Weird right? They can see what they look like when their older.
Camilo is a mechief maker so lieing about his uncles height could be a thing where he was trying to freak out Mirabel
9:26 OH my freaking goodness of course SCB would be the ones to pick up on something like that
(I mean, I already knew they made a theory on that by this point, but still. 😝)
7:00
Another note about the photo at the end is except for Antonio (kind of) none of the family are showing off their powers like in the first photo.
Her gift is actually multiple gifts,Hope, Inspiration,Growth,and she was able to see long enough to put the family back together,and then she inherited the gift of the magic keeper.
4:46 if you look at the pictures next to Abuela’s door, it looks like all of the door show adult versions of the children standing in front of them
I feel like Mirabella's gift is to truly see people, specifically her family. Like she can see how worried her little cousin is and more or less knows what his gift is gonna be ( almost like she gave him his gift) and then her sisters are pretty open about telling her their darkest secrets or things they have been hiding and like c'mon no one talks about Bruno but they all tell her everything about Bruno. And while we are talking about Bruno, dude just tells her everything without any hesitation, like sure she's family but like he feels like a pretty private guy but not with her. She has a bigger connection to her family than anyone else, almost like they can't hide things from her. The only person that seems to be immune is Alma.
Question 26: Did you notice during the song we don’t talk about Bruno during dolores verse Bruno is in the background on the second floor dancing
They have a video about this or with this fun fact. So fun! I would have never seen it!!
For the betrothed question, it made me think about how in Mexico, it's tradition for the guy and his parents to meet up with the girls parents and ask for her hand in marriage before he proposes. When I heard the betrothed to another line i immediately thought of this. Not sure if it is done in the rest of Latinoamérica but for sure in Mexico
Mirabel 'seeing the future'... she had a vision of the house cracking and collapsing during the party. Perhaps not the FUTURE but a darn insightful vision of current events. The fact that the symbolic divisions become real and break the house is a bonus.
Actually the doors showed the older version of the other Madrigal kids except Antonio. This is depicted in the pictures next to Abuela’s room door during “The Family Madrigal” song. Now I think this is because when the house broke down the Madrigal kids except Antonio were their older selves.
I was rewatching encanto and realized a opposite/parallel with tangled. twords the end of encanto Mirabel says something along the lines of "the miracle is alive BECAUSE OF YOU...we are a family BECAUSE OF YOU..." and twords the end of tangled when Rapunzel confronts Gothel she says something like "this entire time I should have been fearing YOU... I should have been hiding FROM you." tangled was one of my favorite movies growing up and idk if it was intentional (knowing Disney it was) but it made me happy and I wanted to share :)
Ok that story of how Julieta and Augustin met is absolutely adorable!!!
I'd like to think that when Bruno looked to the future to predict Delores' future love he only saw the scene we saw in the movie, which is Mariano on one knee proposing (or about to propose) to Isalbella. And that other members of the family told him to stop to prevent further upset, so Bruno couldn't look further to see if something changes.
Isabella and mirabel’s spilt second make up literally represented me and my brother’s relationship when we were kids because we would go from wanting to attack each other and then we would just start making up out of nowhere
something I've been thinking about in regards to the doors. when we see the pictures of all the kids when they've just gotten their gifts, they're all actually the same as when they're older. I don't know why this is the case, and put me on a spiral where I concluded that since Antonio is the only one to get a door with his 5 year old self on it, that means he'll die like way too young which I absolutely did not want to think about.
the squeak was what I was wondering about the most, that is really cool
Observation about the image on the doors. If you look at the photo wall with everyone posing with Abuela and their door, the image on the doors are all of them as adults - except Antonio's. His image is of him as a child. I wonder if something changed after Mirabel didn't get her door that made Antonio's image be different.
his talking about pronunciation them immediately mispronouncing camilo's name cracks me up
Maybe a little off topic, but I just got my Trivia Night Extravaganza puzzle, and I am so excited!! You guys have been awesome and make me smile every time I watch a video. Thank you!
This is a really great idea for a video! I'd love to see more of this style. Great job! 👍
The ‘Celebrate Yourself’ shirt is literally my favorite shirt. It’s always in the wash because I wear it so much lol
I have a headcanon that Mirabel actually does get her own door inside the house at the end of the movie. This is because 1. Abuela has a magical door, so it would not be logical to leave Mirabel in the nursery and 2. there is a shot at the end where you see all the doors have the glow from before they have become someone's door, like the glow from before Mirabel/Antonio touched their doors for the first time. I think they get to reclaim a door, and that Mirabel will also get to claim a door. Maybe a fun thing to make a video about as well? See if you can find any other clues for this.
My biggest question every time I watch the film. How does Mirabel leave Bruno's tower?
Ok, but Abuela has her own door so wouldn’t it be logical to assume that if Mirabel is now the new Abuela that she gets her own door? Or when Abuela dies does mirabel inherit her room and door and it changes to a picture of Mirabel?
I just hope that Mirabel gets a nice if normal room in the new casita.
It would be weird if she still lived in the nursery when new babies are born into the family.
4:35 Actually if you look at the pictures hanging up taken when they got their powers, the doors stay the same
with the line from we don't talk about bruno and the whole Mariano thing-
i believe that bruno saw into the future and saw that Mariano would propose to isabela/tru to propose and then he thought that was the whole thing
If translated betrothed to german betrothed it says "verlobt" which means engaged. I don't know why people think it means they are/will definatly be married. I think what Bruno saw was Dolores being in love with Mariano but Mariano asking Isabella already holding the ring out to her, but he didn't see the outcome he just assumed that he would be betrothed to someone else.
I'd say maybe part of it comes from Zazu's line in Lion King when he's talking to Simba and Nala, he says pretty much word for word "betrothed, intended, affianced" Simba asks "meaning?" Zazu replies "one day you two are going to be married". Simba and Nala were young kids in that scene.
I love that you literally turn into abuela at the end. Just 'use your powers to solve all of everyone's problems!' Just goes to show how easy that mindset is to fall into and how good intentions can turn so bad
my personal theory is that just like isabella's gift, ALL their gifts can and will grow over time and I think this includes the keeper of the magic's gift...
also encanto can mean a certain place... "The settlement-referred to as the Encanto-is located in the Colombian mountains. The colorful refuge also provides shelter for fauna appropriate for the locale."
Look at the pictures in the hall, though. When I saw them, the images were all the same. The triplets were standing next to doors showing their adult selves, and so were the older three Madrigal grandchildren, while Camilo is shown with his 15 year old self.
I noticed that the gift box to Antonio from Mirabel is decorated with animals.
The ad before the video was for Disney plus and it was Encanto. Very fitting!
I love how, in Mirabel's prayer (song: Waiting on a Miracle), she names everything she 'would do'... and then does so in the story. Just not how she meant.