Former Ghani adviser says Afghan leaders didn't see "writing on the wall"

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024

Комментарии • 64

  • @lindaminton
    @lindaminton 2 года назад +9

    Only Afghans can change the culture of Afghanistan.

    • @ishrendon6435
      @ishrendon6435 2 года назад

      Also you assume afghans want to change the culture. Theyre an ultra conservative society and they like it not everyone cares for liberal democracy. In my country the US tried pressuring us to change into liberal democracy. We rejected it as they never take culture and dofferent values into the equation

    • @ishrendon6435
      @ishrendon6435 2 года назад

      Which is why liberlism has failed worldwide

    • @lindaminton
      @lindaminton 2 года назад

      @@ishrendon6435 I don't believe that the United States should change anyone's culture, that's why I made the comment only Afghans can change afghan culture. I hate leftist liberals forcing people to accept their filthy ideology, they're trying to destroy the world.

  • @JohnPerez-yu4rd
    @JohnPerez-yu4rd 2 года назад +5

    [ 20 YEARS..!!!! ] And They Made ["NO PREPARATIONS/PLANS"] In All Those Years..????

  • @hintzod
    @hintzod 2 года назад +17

    This guy admitted it right here. He was hoping the United States would bail him out, so he didn't take negotiations seriously. His side was losing the war and he was negotiating as if he was winning.

    • @evilwestsidefan9249
      @evilwestsidefan9249 2 года назад

      He was as long as we were there to back them up. It is what the Globalists wanted, we were not there by our selves but we did have the most skin in the game. The only problem with our withdrawal was the cowardly way Biden and his administration executed their plan. Disgusting working direct with our enemy and not keeping everyone on our side involved and having a say. Because of Biden we have US Citizens and Afghan US supporters trapped being murdered along with a nation/children starving to death. This is all about Biden not knowing what hand to wipe with, I am sure by now he has someone to do that for him since he is next to brain dead.

    • @ComeCleanAmerica
      @ComeCleanAmerica 2 года назад

      @@evilwestsidefan9249 Trump negotiated cut and run deal and would have withdrawn without any effort to bring out Afghans who supported American troops; in addition, Trump slow walked processing all visas.

  • @freenevu2988
    @freenevu2988 2 года назад +6

    SUPPORT THE NATIONAL RESISTANCE FRONT OF AFGHANISTAN 💚🕊🖤🇦🇫❤

  • @mohamadfazli5575
    @mohamadfazli5575 2 года назад +3

    This winter had 350000 solders he could have wiped out the 10000 Talabans,,,but this puffter ran away with millions of dolar rather...

  • @miracle9089
    @miracle9089 2 года назад

    This moderator is the number one. She's so smart. You are great. Great questions. Thank you.

  • @pselvara3355
    @pselvara3355 2 года назад +2

    US spent a Trillion dollars in Afghanistan. This money could have been spent in the US to build our infrastructure and improve healthcare in rural and urban communities

  • @redciroc1211
    @redciroc1211 2 года назад +1

    He took money 💰

  • @JohnPerez-yu4rd
    @JohnPerez-yu4rd 2 года назад +1

    ????THE RUG WAS PULLED... (-20Years-!!!!!!) Of HELP An PROTECTION & WEAPONS/SUPPLIES From the United States..!!!!

  • @jayaz3902
    @jayaz3902 2 года назад +2

    Ask him how much money he looted and run away

  • @waynesmith9408
    @waynesmith9408 2 года назад +1

    " We did What was Best for AFGHANISTAN "...RUN AWAY...RUN AWAY

  • @ramsayjeremiah
    @ramsayjeremiah 2 года назад +1

    Anybody believe Blinkin I have a bridge to sell you in Brooklyn

  • @abdulghani8269
    @abdulghani8269 Год назад

    Thank you Mr. H. Mohib Allah bless you

  • @typheran1
    @typheran1 2 года назад +2

    No one believes this.

  • @elisebond
    @elisebond 2 года назад

    They didn't bring money, but they bought the president some new clothes?

  • @KurlandHickory
    @KurlandHickory 2 года назад

    We shouldn't have left. A free and Democratic Afghanistan is in fact something worth fighting for.

    • @klephenthurry3284
      @klephenthurry3284 2 года назад

      Go put on your helmet and grab a rifle then. Not our job.

  • @redciroc1211
    @redciroc1211 2 года назад

    So what is going on here???

  • @gweebara
    @gweebara 2 года назад +4

    This Is the crooked attitude of the Afghanistan politicians ... cowardly & taking no responsibility. Ashraf ghani leaving Afghanistan and taking all the money with him is the exact reason we needed to get out of Afghanistan; our partners had become corrupt& ineffective . Time to stop pretending that we could fix this.

    • @gweebara
      @gweebara 2 года назад +2

      @@bilalmohammadi111 the leaders of these places both political & regions have given lies & false enemies to the people. They have stolen resources ment for the people. As an American, I cannot say that our leaders have not done the same, both to our people and to yours. The corruption of the powerful lies not in a religion, or a philosophy, or even a nationality it is something that is spread Beyond. Until we stop fighting with each other and bringing the corrupt / the violent / the hateful to bear for these trespasses we will no know peace or liberty.

    • @elbarca223
      @elbarca223 2 года назад +2

      Face the Nation anchor Margaret Brennan makes no sense about Afghan surrender and negotiation. Taliban won't have a thing if they can take it by force. 2 weeks before or after does not make any difference. Taliban is not there for a negotiated settlement. US was leaving and wants Afghans to die for two weeks for the same result? Really? Hamdullah Mohib saying as it happened. The US forced the Afghan govt to release 5,000 prisoners and many of them are terrorists with so much blood on their hands.

    • @mohamadfazli5575
      @mohamadfazli5575 2 года назад +2

      This robber flled Kabul with helicopter full of money's,,,do not beleive in any word of this winker..

    • @drrohanjacob
      @drrohanjacob 2 года назад

      @@gweebara Truth is the USA was fighting the wrong war in Afghanistan.
      Unless the usa was willing to stay on there as a sort of quasi colonial power for at least 3 generations and was willing to change the very nature of Afghan society and reigned in pakistan.
      All of which was near impossible mostly due to lack of political will there never was going to be a victory.

    • @drrohanjacob
      @drrohanjacob 2 года назад +1

      @@bilalmohammadi111 It was mostly a failure of every one
      Truth is Pakistan will never allow a stable Afghanistan as it's too risky for them and the need for strategic depth against India.
      As long as the issue between india and pakistan is not sorted out there will be no stability in Afghanistan.
      It's truly sad.
      The afghan people are not being allowed to choose their own destiny.
      Spoken as an Indian so I may be biased

  • @nabiamiri8794
    @nabiamiri8794 2 года назад +1

    This guy held multiple high ranking posts, actually just second to the president. I don't blame this poor guy but those who appointed him on his tribal ground.

  • @redciroc1211
    @redciroc1211 2 года назад

    Nah idk I'm just trolling

  • @MK-ws9mh
    @MK-ws9mh 2 года назад

    He is 100 percent right I see it

  • @ashaia7526
    @ashaia7526 2 года назад +6

    Shame on you Muhib, you wanted to bring Taleban in power, you released thousands of them from prison, you were in close contact with Haqqanis and acollaborating with them, you gave them and their supporters important posts in the government, and you replaced all those who wanted to and were fighting the Taleban with Taleban sympathiesers and thugs. Why don’t you admit, this was yours and Ghani’s goal. Shame on you, how will you face the people of Afghanistan.

    • @elbarca223
      @elbarca223 2 года назад +3

      A Shaia, Muhib and Afghan govt did not want to release. US forced them to release. Get this fact correct.

    • @mohamadfazli5575
      @mohamadfazli5575 2 года назад +1

      And also this puffter could have destroyed Talabans with 350000 soldiers when talaban conqured Herat,,,but this robber gave the whole country on hands of his Pashton brothers...

    • @ashaia7526
      @ashaia7526 2 года назад

      @@elbarca223 people of Afghanistan did not want them released, Ghani, Muhib, and Fazli released them regardless.

    • @mohamadfazli5575
      @mohamadfazli5575 2 года назад

      @@bilalmohammadi111 are you defending this Ezak?

    • @mohamadfazli5575
      @mohamadfazli5575 2 года назад +1

      @@bilalmohammadi111 You man this Ezak is your hero,,,then you must be a Ezak too..

  • @mohamadfazli5575
    @mohamadfazli5575 2 года назад

    No oh puffter your biggest mistake was that you didn't fight with your Pashton brothers despite having 350000 solders on hands...Tuff to you puffter..and robber

  • @maliktemoor2701
    @maliktemoor2701 2 года назад

    Mohib is product of Russian one night stand In kabul 🤣