Netflix Did the Unthinkable | One Piece Live Action Review & Spoilercast
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
- We've watched way too many Netflix adaptations at this point to have expected what they did here.
Watch our other Spoilercasts: • GigaBoots Spoilercasts
Subscribe: www.youtube.co...
Become a podlord or normal patron today! / gbpodcasts
RSS Feed: gbpods.podbean...
Kris Wolfheart's Twitter: / kriswolfheart
GigaBoots' Twitter: / gigaboots
GB Main Patreon: / gigaboots
GB Fan Discord: / discord
#OnePiece #Review #LiveAction
This show gave me an interaction between Garp and Zeff something I didnt know I needed til I saw it.
Yeah. I ran out of available manga volumes before Garp was properly introduced, but I still suspected that was brand new material while I was watching it.
It's honestly a wonder why we haven't seen Garp and Zeff talk before. It fits the context of Garp knowing many big pirates from a couple generations prior. It doesn't come across because of how fit he is, but Garp is old!
Kris is slightly misremembering Kuro plan in the manga. The plan is mainly kill Kayla using the attack as cover, Then kill his Crew and Live on the Island as a sad old Colodore respected and loved member of society. Koro wants a quiet life.
KILLA KWEEN!
Here’s an interesting fact: Mackenyu, the actor who plays Zoro, has a long history of playing characters in live action anime adaptations. He’s been Okuyasu in the JoJo live action film, Scar in the FMA live action films, Pegasus Seiya in the Saint Seiya live action film that came out this year, and, interestingly enough, Yukishiro Enishi in the fourth Rurouni Kenshin film.
The fact that Netflix allowed a studio to work with a character with elastic powers and Marvel Studios didn't allow that with Ms. Marvel was something made to piss me off specifically.
If this doesn't get a season 2 Netflix is beyond help.
considering its breaking records left and right (even surpassing Stranger Things and Wednesday) I think it's very likely.
If it doesn't get a second season it's gonna be because it cost a shitzillion dollars
@@ArynBacklogDragon The number 1 in x countries isn't a strong metric. Views and hours watched are coming out, and it isn't competing with shows like Stranger Things or Wednesday even remotely, while being a ridiculously expensive show. I'm pretty pessimistic based on that.
@@Waytothedawn63you've underestimated the power of the anime fans 😂
@@Waytothedawn63Netflix's live-action One Piece adaptation debuted to 18.5 million "views" and 140 million hours viewed over its first four days of release, according to numbers provided by Netflix. These numbers surely makes One Piece at least amongst top 10 streaming charts, which is fantastic
If netflix wants to save their company they write the show a blank check and say do it all. Because the audiance is hungry for more one piece.
This comment dude. Yes 100%
Double budget?
Something tells me the budget for season 2 is going to be bigger because season 1 was originally supposed to be 10 episodes to include logtown and smoker but Matt says they kind of ran out of money so that's going to start season 2. Which is why after the fact they added that little smoker tidbit at the end
A great thing about that Jojo adaptation is that the actor for Zoro, Mackenyu, is also the actor for Okuyasu
Well this is a-
'Phone Rings'
Just a sec guys. Hello? Yeah..........uh huh. Apparently the Netflix Live Action One Piece was good. Uh-Huh. Yeah I'm as surprised as you are. Yeah. I don't know how they managed that either, I'm guessing you didn't have a hand in that? Uh-Huh, alright then bye.
'Hangs Up Phone.'
Sorry about that, That was The Devil, He wanted to know why Hell was covered in Ice all of a sudden.
42:10 In fact, her sister knowing is key! Nojiko's tattoos are there solely to make Nami feel better about having Arlong's brand tattooed on her shoulder. Sort of "Now I'm tattooed too, that brand doesn't cast you out anymore"
Yeah but this didn't apply to the LA cause she didn't know about Nami's decision
What a waste
You know the timeline is cursed when One Piece is better produced than Cowboy Bebop
Seriously, on paper one of these translates really well to live action the other has extremely insane proportions and designs and is incredibly manga coded.
One Piece never left Oda's creative control, always trust Oda.
Goes to show how much the passion from the team and involvement of the creator goes a LONG way in having a good production
That joke about Zoro being low-key racist hits even better when he just keeps getting set up against minorities by happenstance and circumstance for the rest of the manga
Person from outside of US of A here, don't really care about Stranger Things. Here's what I think about the lack of Hachi, Arlong in the live action actually took over East Blue as opposed to the original where that's his endgame. It's very likely the dude who is not that fond with the Fishman Supremacist angle left earlier. Dude can still be introduced much later alongside the girlfriend as "The one who is very apologetic about the Race War". And no the dude with multicolor spike hair is not him, no matter what the wiki/sites said.
I really wish they had hachi but with 4 normal arms and 2 little arms I think good banter from zoro and hachi could have been made from that i also really hate that they cut the village from knowing about nami cause it makes nojikos tattoos not mean much other than looking cool
funnily enough, Django the hypnotist of the Kuro arc actually is on one of the wanted posters Luffy checks out with Koby. There’s also a bunch of other characters shown there that will not appear until much later.
There is one other particularly good One Piece fighting game, and it's actually a 2D one by Arc System Works. Problem is, it's a 3DS exclusive that was never localized. It's also kinda' jank, but in that crazy way some players like.
Also of note, it supports multiplayer with the 3DS Arc Sys Dragon Ball Z fighting game! You can only pick characters from the game you're playing on, but it's wild that it works at all.
Nazumi is part mink which is why he has whiskers. Minks are a species in the world of OP which are humanoid animals.
Is he? I thought he like merry a normal guys dress as animal
I just love how the One Piece world has four types of animal-people (Zoan fruit users, Smile fruit users, Minks and fishmen / mermaids), each with entirely different origins.
They use "We Are" at the end of Going Merry saling off and Brook's song when they introduced Shank.
OKAY THERE'S ACTUALLY HOPE FOR YUYU HAKUSHO LIVE ACTION??
Oh my god I forgot, oh no.
The Yuyu Hakusho live action is being done by a different studio entirely. Not Tommorrow Studios.
Hard maybe we got a cyberpunk that was good
"You're listening to Chewing Gum-Gum the One Piece Podcast where we watch ALL of One Piece!"
This thumbnail is killing me, good job.
Oh the spoilercast attached to it is also pretty good I guess
Having just gotten into Ted Lasso recently, it’s been rewarding to have any context for Dan’s fascination with it and a weirdly welcome surprise to hear mentioned at the end of a One Piece podcast.
REALLY?! You have issues with the score? I mean, that pop-song was a bit weird, but other than that I think it was absolutely stellar!
KING OF THE PODCASTS
Like I don't want more of these live action anime adaptations to keep happening because I think they're kinda pointlessly derivative, e.g: imagine Welcome to The N.H.K Live Action versus just watching the perfectly fine anime in its original form. I'm at least just glad this one finally seemed to have cracked the curse of terrible anime live action adaptations, Japanese and Western.
One Piece also only kind of works because this was the only way you'd get anyone that isn't already a fan of One Piece to come close to watching that walking 1000+ episode juggernaut in some digestible format.
I like that when i hear a non fan and fan of one piece talking about the live action they are like having same energy 😂
32:55 2 things about Hacchi:
1. The Fishman who Nami cheats at poker against and gets angry, that in the manganime is just a background fishman, is credited as "Hachi/Angry Fishman", but that's "Hachi", not "Hacchi" or "Hatchan" so they have leeway to backpaddle on him
2. They can include him at the beginning of season 2, or right when he comes back into the story (via flashback to the end of season 1). The season ended with the Marine searching the Conomi Islands (where Arlong Park was) for scattered Fishmen, so we can have one shot, POV of someone floating in the water, sees the Marine search, sees the ruins of Arlong Park, camera pans back, we see Hacchi's silhouette, as he dives back into the water. Boom, Hacchi is established, and we can have him accurately design when they have a more suiting budget for him
Garp is revealed as Luffy's Grandpa in water 7 if I am not mistaken. That's like episode 300ish not anywhere near 400
The One Piece is real ☠️
The Stranger Things thing at 46:10 is super true btw,
Don't give it up, Dr. Agro.The
So are you, like, an anger management specialist or something?
How does Amazon's kindle autocorrect _literally nothing_ into 'the'?
Small detail, Luffy and Usopp are 17 at this point.
One Piece Unlimited Adventure (US ver.) and Cruise (JPN Only) on the Wii are really good. Also, heard One Piece Odyssey is good RPG.
48:20 Google "Zoro minority hunter" (only if you are almost caught up to the animanga, or you'll be spoiled of some of his fights). You might be on to something
Calling it now. Season 2 will cause controversy with the LBGTQ on Bon Clay being a villain at first.
The LGBTQ who haven't seen One Piece, maybe. But the ones who have, know Bon Clay is the 🐐
@@Ozgarthefighter Bon Clay definitely the goat.
It's OK it would be batch and we gonna see he saving shp
They missed the emotional bond of when each member joined the crew.... They just sorted got together. Luffy saving Zoro? When he was about to get killed. Nami from the fishmen?
Yeah this thing from the moment I heard them in talks I think 4 year ago I had hope. Fans in charge. They went to Japan to see the Kabuki theater plays and get in touch with Oda. He was in control of a lot some of the other people in change of the chapters and social media were helping
It was this project where if it failed it was over for live action hope for me. I’m so glad if turn out even better
I'm so glad they kept zoro as a racist in the live action
Just pay the damn license fees for the main theme music at least lol. They're already dropping hella money as is. A tad more won't hurt lol
They have rights to Manga, not the anime. Thats a whole lot of Toei animation and stuff...while its easier to be on board with the author himself.
I don't care about the flaws. I had so much fun watching the show............it ruined any reason for me to critique it. I didn't even know it had an animation or a comic. I felt something akin to "happy".
I think they bring osctpus man back if there flashback showing along being corrupted withal time as by and once he his leader is gone he leaving and adopts came and runs his food stand
yeah, Chilean here and I havent finish stranger things, not even Merlina...
Netflix One Piece is going to be fun. Cowboy Bebop could have worked. at it bones it is a serious sci-fi story they need not actually adapt. You change something to make it work in a different media. There nothing that is in animation of Cowboy Bebop that could not be done with CGI and actors. Luffy BY HIMSELF is going to be a bitch. His character and his powers. Luffy as an excitable upbeat idiot will get overplayed we might see Netflix Bebop ED Luffy variant, Stretching powers has never worked in live-action, it is suppose to be goofy and charming but will most likely be creepy, These two points put together results in problem three. Luffy in Manga is always stretching and doing something goofy. One piece design top to bottom to be manga.
This was comment I made on the Cowboy Bebop Episode. Somehow they actually hit a Solid 8/10. Luffy Worked, a lot of scenes work, It Just worked. I don't know how One Piece made a smoother transition than Cowboy bebop.
for me, key character missing for zoro was his pride. as during the end of mihawk fight.
luffy cahracter was handled well, if its cringe for others its really just how exagerated One Piece is and notably the localization; in contrast to Neflix Cowboy Bebop's Ed.
As you asked, I don't give a shit about Stranger Things
you've seen all the rurouni kenshin live actions but you don't recognize mackenyu, the actor who played the villain einishi in the final movie? he is the one who plays zoro haha (well to be fair, he looks a lot different in that movie)
it aint a lazy 1:1 adaptation, and the liberties to change the pacing but same direction still repsects the source and why it stil lretian its entertainment adn watch value regards already seen the anime. we need more adaptations where their creators are on board during the production of the film/series.
44:30 No, that’s false. First off, there have been trans characters since Impel Down, when Ivankov was introduced, literally changes peoples sexes. That was *YEARS* ago. Second, those “trans characters” you’re referring to, at least one of them is not actually trans because she identifies as a *specific person* (which the trans community said is a no no), not as the opposite gender. Plus, Oda drew her with all the women, confirming she’s a woman.
Zorro got lost... he's in jojos as well
TheOne-Piece live action show I oddly enjoyed a bit compared to the anime. I watched the anime, but my taste of that show has been ruined. Not by 4Kids, but by the Funimation release. The rating difference is pretty jarring. Also, I ain't trying to watch 1000+ episodes.
Pirate Warriors is pretty great. 3 was better than 4 for grinding and losing time in, 4 plays better and looks better. They also absolutely spoil everything, and dont do it as nicely as those Naruto storm games.
What the f they smoking the music is great.
So, I love Hachi, but I'd like an explanation by Oda as to why he cannibalizes octopuses
Cannibalism only occurs in the same species, not anywhere else on the phylogenetic tree. Hatchi is a fishman, so technically not even a cephalopod.
Also, an octopus making Takoyaki is funny. That’s probably Oda’s reason.
(There are also recorded incident of octopodes eating each other due to their solitary nature, particularly unlucky males after mating.)
great
German here, people care about Stranger Things
i mean there are plenty of good netflix shows they just aren't adaptations
It wasn't a perfect adaptation, but it was a good one none the less. I used this to get my wife into the show and she got a brief window into the world that I fell in love with while tempering it for the sensibilities for someone that's not an anime lover.
The characters were weaker than the anime.
Kaya lost some of her character development
Zoro's character development was neutered
Axe hand was underused.
I know they hasn't been any announcement of it yet(I think), but I still have high hopes for the live action Hellsing. Even after watching this video, I still have high hopes its going to be good.
Nami's Sister is the only race change, which looked Jawing.
The Way the Blue hair mixed with the skin colour change, really distracted me.
Everybody else had percect casting.
it does match the found family feeling though.
Yet again, this isn't me being racist.
I just think changing something as important as someones looks is COMPLETELY STUPID.
She's dark skinned in the manga though. Oda even does that thing with the lighter colored lips that all Japanese artists do when they draw a black-skinned character.
For the record, Kris is wrong. Trans characters existed in One Piece about 400 chapters before Wano dating back all the way to Marineford. Please don't let transphobic or hateful people be something you associate with One Piece.
The character people were arguing about was Yamato because she was poorly written. In the first chapters she appeared in they flipped her pronouns a couple time without clarification. She was running around yelling that she was man who died, most of the time yelling that directly at the dead man's 8 year-old son, which caused the biggest shitshow from the fan base to date.
People only cared because of her big boobs.
Oda later stated Yamato is a her in either an SBS or card book (authors notes).
TLDR: Yamato was basically filler and people only care cause she had big boobs. Kiku was a better written character.
Yamato is a solid character, unfortunately a group took the fact that she used male pronouns and ran with it, ignoring the greater context as to why she did that. The fact that she has fat tits is hardly relevant considering literally every female in One Piece does.
Yamato is the Naoto Shirogane of One Piece, which is fitting because they're both based on the same guy, Yamato Takeru
There's a mixture of trans and gender non-conforming characters before Kiku.
Iva's Island and Impel Down are largely filled with Drag Queens, however, which are different than being trans. That said, Iva herself is very much a trans character as far as I can tell, and Mr 2 is non-binary because he fulfills the role of both the male and female agent duo that the rest of his organization has, his English title being the equivalent of "Mr 2 & Miss Happy Birthday" (Bon Kurei)
@@fenris5932Nah it's ass
Literally just that
So this is how we get the Gigaboys into doing the One Piece Anime Podcast for the next 30 years.
As someone who hasn't consumed anything One Piece, this is the first Netflix show in awhile I really devoured since Midnight Mass back in 2021. It works perfectly as a gateway to all of One Piece & as its own thing!
Midnight Mass is still top for me. ;)
They were very brave to just go ham with Luffy's rubber powers. Marvel/DC would never lol
Lmao
It's still toned down
Marvel definitely wouldn't. They literally changed Ms Marvel's powerset for her own tv show because they were too scared to do stretchy powers
Zoros actor does a decent chunk in Japan, he plays my favorite Kamen Rider Drive villian from a movie which was a bit distracting but at the same time id watch what they make him do in fight scenes and go oh of course he was in a toku thing
Netflix's live-action One Piece adaptation debuted to 18.5 million "views" and 140 million hours viewed over its first four days of release, according to numbers provided by Netflix. These numbers surely makes One Piece at least amongst top 10 streaming charts, which is fantastic
Zeff actor sounded so familiar than I looked it up went oh yeah he was gaz and ghost in OG cod mw 1 and 2
Oh shit
Glad that this adaptation didn't give you guys hives‼Hopefully the positive momentum continues into the next season if netflix bothers lmao
Yo ho ho he took a bite of Pod-Pod!
I have never watched or read One Piece, but hearing The Boys happy about things is making me smile a lot wider than normal today
Daym
Its been said before, but its kind of outstanding that One Piece of all things ended up translating to live action better then fucking Cowboy Bebop. Tomorrow Studios taking lessons from Bebops failure possibly helped, but its really in thanks to having a crew thats passionate about the material and willing to take risks with things like practical sets/effects and a fairly fresh cast (the only actors i recognize right away is Buggys who was in Agents of Shield and Zoros whos been in a bunch of japanese films and also that shitty Saint Seiya movie no one saw) as well as having the creator involved. Its not perfect but its clearly made with passion and that goes a long way especially comparing it to its peers where the only other ones id say had this level of passion in them were Speed Racer and Alita. Im honestly less concerned about it not getting greenlit for a season 2 (with how succesful its been the only thing holding back on it atm is the strikes) and more that they'll take the wrong lessons from it and greenlight a bunch more anime adaptations that dont have nearly as much love put into them. Great to hear you guys enjoy something on the Spoilercast!
This channel is severely underrated, found this randomly when looking at reviews and this discussion was so much fun to listen to, for real. Gotta binge the rest of your stuff now to help me pass this night shift
Ye
The distorted close shots in Ep.3 are to give a feel of being watched/heard. The dialogue there is what Buggy "overhears" from the hat and relays back to Arlong. It was weird the first time but on second watch it made sense.
It did help a lot that it had Oda’s involvement
In interview Steven Meda one the show runner said want to add Hachi but the budget couldn't be done. They explain eye brow and Ussop Nose also why Iñaki Godoy wear shoes is he did own stunts also safety. Oda already said season 2 and said the straw hat need a great doctor and then drew Chopper.
Show runners for any upcoming live action avatar or one punch man should/better b taking countless notes from this show. If not, don’t even bother making it…
Dreamin
I really hope the Jim Henson Company will be working on Chopper for Season 2.
I need season 2! Such a fun show ❤
It's a crime that they never mention Down D. Stairs in the show.
Jokes aside, I have one minor complain that only affects me and maybe a few people that will listen this spoilercast. So, for the Spanish dub, the actor of Sanji voices himself since he's spanish and boy you can tell because the mic quality is totally different from the rest of the cast. He also doubles down in his natural accent, but I won't complain about that, it's funny. For the Latin America dub, Iñaki also voices himself, so I wonder if they had the same problem.
I suspect they didn't mention it because someone dying from a step slip would clash with Zorro shrugging off falling down a dry well multiple times.
For once I can type this without any sarcasm. I'm shocked. Truly I am.
Whattt????? You didn't like the music? The music was the strongest part part in this.
Unironically. Do a "One Piece Month" and then ONLY Play Pirate Warriors 1 and then 3.
Matt Owens and Steven Maeda hoped to get a 7/10, and fans gave it 8/10 on average. Like you all ended up giving on average. S2 oh whenever it happens we are here for it.
I completely forgot that Mackenyu played Okuyasu in the JoJo Part 4 Live Action
It’s doing great but it’s also expensiveAF. They could say it did it’s job. Got people into the franchise and not renew. 🤷🏽♂️
Renewed
The ps2 arena fighters are pretty decent they're very similar to Power Stone
Thank you for the double bonus podcast, Dan.
This show was a shock to my system. Even the first couple of scenes primed me for a worse production than it ended up. Caring about what you're making really makes a difference.
I want a season 2, but would be fine if it stopped here. I know where season 2 will end, and it definitely shouldn't go any further. I'm also worried because there's at least one character in season 2 range that must be CGI-heavy, but after seeing this, who knows how it would be handled.
43:52 This is very much up for debate and is a very very USA thing.
In Wheel of Time you have a village that is supposed to be basically alone for 2 thousand years.
A diverse cast in a village that is supposed to basically have been isolated from others for 2000years does not make the world a real place it makes it a fake place.
Then you have Stories set up in England or other European nations that until 1990s was something like 90% of one ethnicity.
Just like if you have a Japanese show if you make 50% European looking and 40% African looking and only 10% is Asian looking it would not feel like a real place it would not feel like japan.
When enough time goes by in a place and only a few new people comes in over time the population will start to look similar.
A fictional place if you want it to mirror reality should not be super mixed if it is an isolated place because that is not how reality works.
I think this was mainly made to appeal to people who've never seen or read One Piece before, because of it's length anime and manga wise. And they also did it without offending the established fanbase. I have heard from a lot of people who have never watched or read One Piece, that they may take up the anime or/and manga to get more.
Late response, I know, but as one such established fan in the fanbase, caught up completely to the manga, I can attest that the show actually KICKS ASS. These are heavily streamlined elements, yes, but in a way that still feels in-character, and honestly, they make it work.
The gigaboots one piece podcast inches closer to being a reality
the japanese voices are much better
zoro rarely ever says luffy, he almost always uses the word for captain
I have never watched stranger things and I have 0 interest to watch
Garp's luffy's fight makes no sense to me.
okay one piece is one of the best things Netflix has ever done but I was in Spain all last year and they fucking LOVE stranger things
Kris has no grasp on the Mainstream. He really believes he is in touch with most people
Meh
❤
The moment I heard the show was good rumbling across twitter, my first thought was 'Of course Oda gets the rare Netflix W' and my second 'The BTD crew bound themselves to watch something thats actually good?! Lets fucking Goooooooo!'
I think the JoJo movie is cool for what it is. It's a Miike movie so even if you're not into it you're at least getting some cool visuals and a unique look to everything. The way it ends honestly really bums me out that he didn't get to keep going, because he clearly had some fun plans for it.
As a Japanese who only read one story a week in a magazine 26 years ago for 3 years, my impression was "the manga and the live-action version are about the same" lol.
There's this One Piece Fighting game called "One Piece Fighting Path" but it only available in China. The gameplay looks cool
There are a lot more instances where the Live Action elaborates and goes in details, than just Arlong "using" Nami
What’s tuff is the budget and cgi like man does it get crazier, like there going to need universal studios to collaborate 🦖