My dear its simply another U_Turn of KHAN. Both the Establishment (Army + Judiciary + Bureaucracy etc.) & our Politicians are nothing to do with the problems of Common Public of PAKISTAN. Its a Bitter & Biggest FACT. May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! !
@@nishantsharma7832 yes , all kaffirs and qadiyanis and ex muslims love to listen to egineer. Something is certainly right obviously that he is doing that he is being loved by you.
@@abdussamad2471 I think,he is trying to push you on path of Muhammad,but you are admant to move on path of babas.I am not a admirer of Muhammad and Babas,I watched some of his video on social issues.👍👍 btw i also read and watched About Ibn taimiya,shah Waliullah,maulanaa Israr and many more😉😉😉
@@HirratShoukat wo to aaj bhi hai - aapko maloom nahin bas 5pm ke baad Sheen se shahad ka shauq resist nahin kiya jata Immu ke time pe aur bhi umda tha - 12noon to 3pm Immu hawaas mein hota tha - baaqi time hawa mein
When I was in 10th class, I accidentally watched one of your video no I am doing my bachelors in English in upper SWAT. Ur podcasts has completely changed my whole perception about religion Pakistan and politics thank you so much shehzad bhai. I wish that one day you come to swat and be my guest I want to have hours of conversations with you, it are beautiful really that you haven’t heard of, in swat 🖤🫶🫶 love u and thank u for making me a humman 🖤
Yup, Shehzad shouldn’t do it… This video’s core message is that Pakistani public should increase their independent political acumen. EON boys or other such influencers are also doing same, increasing awareness in public and making people critically analyze stuff themselves. Professional background is not a limit for being political analyst in a democratic system. May be this (influencers) is start of a free democratic system of Pakistan. Actual issue at hand is to fight the negative control of Authoritarian regime in Pakistan, actual threat to sovereignty. Shehzad, EON, other channels need to collaborate to mitigate that negative control and to propagate freedom of speech.
@13:17 i totally agree. Till 2018 there was a slow but evolution. But even then whenever i watched PTI dharnas i somehow knew this person IK (if got into power) would ruin the country and so he did eventually. Sadly we never recovered from that damage he has done.
This has to be ur best video. Shahzad I have hated loved n then hated n ultimately loved ur work. This is arguably better because u communicated it so well without making anyone feel bad or targeting one party. That's a smart effective way to get ur point across. Thanks for all that u do. Stay patient n humble like u have been
But Shehzad can there be a party independent of Elite and Establishment connections ? 2008 to 2018 though a so called evolutionary phase, 4 major events happened to offset this evolution: 1. Judiciary ousting Yousuf Geelani and Nawaz Sharif aiding and abetting judicial aggression. 2. MemoGate 3. Imran Khan, Tahrul Quadari Dharnas and Dawn Leaks 4. Panama cases and judicial coup against Nawaz Sharif . No , not at all, the python grip of elite - Fauz wasn’t loosened even for a while during last 75 years . May be you can point a small hiatus of 1972 - 74😢 Well “ Rights Movements “ leading to consolidating the political movements or growing in to democratizing the government is indeed an optimistic thought …… . Not a single such movement has succeeded in Pakistan so far . PTM has already hit a dead end. So called leftist outfits never really took off . One of the most outstanding example of ‘ Rights Movement ‘ turning in to a meaningful political party and a people’s government is ‘ Solidarity Movement’ lead by Lech Walensa in Poland , may be partly Iranian Revolution ( offCourse with lots of reservations). Well your thesis has proved right , time and again in India since middle fifties. Communists won Kerala assembly elections in 1957 based on rights movement of landless labourers and urban poor since British times. There are many instances like this in Tamilnadu, Punjab, Bihar, UP, West Bengal and few other states. But these successes came within a broad democratic setup with fairly fair elections at regular and prescribed intervals .
Hahahah bro 😂 That Ammar Ali Jaan & Laal hai sub Laal hai kinda conjucture cum analysis aside, but things really don't add up here. Deal agr Khan ny krni hoti to 8th Feb sy pehlay krta ya baad mai. Secondly there is no establishment here, only a sharif / zardari maafia which has successfully converted Pak Army into Sindh & Punjab Police. You have to be verrrrrrrrrrrry dumb to believe that a man who got more than 2/3rd votes across the country that too under fascist regime, would beg a toothless retired general for some kind of deal... reallly yar? 😅😅
@RahulMishra-ld2bo just don't interfere or comment on internal matters of Pakistan like we Pakistanis don't give a fuck about India...we never comment about what the Indian government do to Manipur Nagaland peaceful khalistani protesters Dalits and other minorities.. the list goes on
I can’t wrap my head around that in Pakistan, one electricity United is about 80 Pakistani Rupees. And the average wages in Pakistan is less than 10k Pakistani rupees. If you consume 200-400 units of electricity, 20-40% of your income goes into just paying electricity bills. How do people survive in Pakistan?
Shahzad, while minding his Ps and Qs, possesses a good knack of quality content. I always share his video link to my student groups. Keep rolling, Shahzad😊
It’s all about “looking” pious and handsome/strong etc. A deadly combination for the mentally subjugated awam of Pakistan who are always looking for the next Maseeha.
18:20 exactly why i feel like im biased against PTI. Problem is k PTI has such a HUGE opportunity to actually become an anti establishment force but all they care about is their personal fascism. Tbh if i run a party and if i get jailed i swear id be more focused on the VISION and not to get me out. Your focus as PTI should be to achieve your insaf related goals. Not focus on releasing one man from jail.
In a country like Pakistan, where the hold of establishment is so strong is it possible for any politician to go all in against the establishment and all those conspiring against the country or is it sane enough to carry things ownwards with a bit of discussions here and there get a way... Benazir and bhutto and other balochi leaders are great examples of going all in against the establishment. Thanks
Pakistan's politicians seem to crawl when asked to sit, yet believe they hold power when the military steps back. Since Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto's time, the PPP has recognized their limits and has been gradually diminishing the military's influence, although Bhutto missed a significant opportunity in Pakistan's history. Currently, discussions revolve around 'The Deal,' but it's important to remember that Imran Khan initially granted the military more power than it requested to secure his position. Later, he attempted to interfere in the military's internal politics instead of gradually reducing its control. For civilian supremacy in Pakistan, clear boundaries of power must be established, and politicians need to dismantle the military's peripheral influences first.
Let's say Pakistan's youth and communities unite for a revolution, but then... What will we do? Protest! If yes, what should be the outcome of the protest? Whom will we fight against: the military, the government, or the establishment? What set of actions will we demand, and how can we ensure that we achieve our purpose?
Pti is ruling KPK , PMLN is ruling punjab , PPP is ruling Sindhi ,Baluchistan is coalition . So every political party is governing . Everyone is getting chance and budget money to spend
Aaj ali aftab ka 12 saal pehlay ka song suna aalu anday us mai ek kamaal ki baat hai... Tehreek e insaaf = modern jamaat e islami 😊 Yaar kamaal itna pehly aap loogon ny pechan liya tha
Brother can't you stop Shoaib Chaudhry, Naila- Shaila , Sana Amjad , Muzzamil Qureshi, Nimra Ahmad & many like them !!! They have created havoc on you tube !!! Hope you will give a thought!!!!
You really need to make a podcast about the current issues plaguing Pakistan... 1. Bani gala sewage going into rawal lake which will make it undrinkable in future 2. Monsson rains and flooding, how will pakistan survive if that happens with no mouths to feed 3. Riko diq and Saindak issues 4. Lost cases in international criminal court and their subsequent fines 5. Wastage if CPEC resources 6. Dams construction 7. Import of clothes from Bangladesh in Zainab market where we once used to have only Pakistani products 8. Amount of money wasted in Diseases that can be avoided just by keeping streets clean 9. Negative impact of snap chat, tik tok, tinder and similar apps 10. unnecessary imports and what alternatives we can try or use 11. Zero content for our kids on TV 12. Exorbitant fee of private schools Every now and again we get a new circus in our politics which keeps the population away from the real issues.
I hope tpe podcast team will dedicate an episode to discussing the recent political developments in Balochistan, focusing on the Gwadar political gathering of the Baloch Yakjehti Committee. Specifically, I'd like them to explore the various obstacles and hurdles that prevented people from attending the gathering, and delve into the broader implications of these events."
Shehzad,A complete shutdown is being observed in Balochistan. Quetta is under lockdown at Lak Pass, while Mustang has been locked down for two days by the byc. Kech is also under lockdown from D baloch and Lasbela and Hub are closed by Baloch protesters,. A sit-in protest (Dharna) is taking place in Gwadar. Additionally, there is no internet or network connectivity in most parts of the province, and educational institutions and banks remain closed.No transportations in entire province,v r just setting at home at quetta and fully cooked with this terrible situations,both side govt and byc needs to show some way forwarded...
Ay kaash kay Pakistani qaum shaksiat pasandi or maseeha dhoondnay say bahar aajai…or leadership kay dilemma say bhi bahar aajai. All we need good and honest elected people by people purely to run the country
0:01 Tum jeso ka khuwab he rehy ga k imran khan dollar army se deal karay ga , IK following the path of Imam Hussain A.S ye gardan kat tu sakti hai lekin yazeedi fooj ke samne jhuk nai sakti...🙌
Baqi apki baatain regarding everything thats happening in parachinar and across Balochistan and across kpk, jahan PTI walay ghungay ban gaya hn. But still a huge suppoeter of Imran khan. Not the idiots around him. Allah establishment walun ko ajar day ameen
Dear Shehzad I would like to discuss something that Adeel Afzal said in one of your recent programs. He had said that we should understand that there is no such thing as the 'Pakistani nation' as Pakistan is a country that comprises many 'nationalities'. My submission is that there seems to be a confusion about the definition of the terms 'nation' and 'qaum' 'قوم'۔ in the prevalent narrative of intellectuals in Pakistan. Just like the word 'captain' which has multiple meanings, the term 'nation' also has at least two different meanings Urdu. One meaning is what our intellectuals subscribe to, which is the one that is the traditional meaning of the Urdu, Sindhi, or Punjabi word 'qaum'. Which is a group of people who live in a distinct geographical region, have the same mother tongue, they may belong to different religions or sects but they share the same traditions, culture, literature, music, dances and history and who identify themselves as a distinct entity compared to those who do not share these things with them. But these intellectuals either do not factor in, or deliberately do not mention the fact that the term 'qaum' has another meaning in in Urdu also. That meaning is the same as the meaning of the English term 'nation': all citizens of a state irrespective of the region within the state they belong to, mother tongue, religion, caste, creed etc. They don't need to be born in the state, or even be its traditional inhabitants, they just need to acquire citizenship of that state through legal means. The second meaning of the term 'qaum' is used in 'aqwam e mutahemida', 'اقوام متحدہ' the Urdu translation of 'United Nations'. The 'nations' that are members of 'United Nations' are Afghanistan, Pakistan, India and Bangladesh and not the Pakhtoon nation, Punjabi nation and the Bengali nation. The interesting thing is that in Urdu the term 'qaum' is used for both types of groups, but in modern English native speakers don't use the term 'nation' for a group of people coming from a particular area within a state having shared language, customs and history etc. The term used for such grouping is 'ethnicity'. However, people from India and Pakistan call allegience to such groupings as 'nationalism' or 'sub-nationalism'. This is because of the influence of Urdu/Hindi and mother tongues in which the word qaum is used for such groupings and they translate the word qaum in English as 'nation' or 'sub-nation'. Yes, traditionally the term 'nation' was used for such groupings also, but only in the case of very large single tribes, e.g. the Sioux Nation, but not for a collection comprising multiple tribes having shared language and traditions. Similarly, the term 'nationalism' is also used for feelings and activities in the context of the state, even though we use it in the context of our ethnicities. Thus, in English a 'nation' is confined within the borders of a state, but an ethnicity can transcend state boundaries. If we take a Pakhtoon who holds the Afghan nationality and a Pakhtoon who holds Pakistani nationality, then if we take the traditional meaning of the term 'qaum' used in Pakistan and India, then both belong to the Pakhtoon qaum. On the other hand, if we take the other meaning of 'qaum' i.e., citizens of a particular state, which is equally valid in Urdu, then one Pakhtoon belongs to the 'Afghan qaum' and the other to the 'Pakistani qaum'. It depends on which meaning you take, both are valid; just as a captain could mean the leader of a cricket team, the senior pilot of an ailiner, or a naval officer who is one rank senior to 'commander' and one rank junior to 'commodore'. In the light of this I would say that it is not right to insist that out of the several meanings of 'qaum' or 'nation' only the one that matches our ideology is correct. Therefore, it is OK to call the citizens of Pakistan the 'Pakistani qaum' or 'Pakistani nation' and we can say that Pakistan is a 'multi-ethnic nation', or 'polyglot nation'. I would be interested in knowing your comments on this and please pass on my message to Adeel.
You are slightly conflating the words nation and a nation-state. Even in Canada indigenous people are called First Nations, they don’t see the use of the word as a threat to the Canadian Nation State. Pakistan is a Nation State, it is a nation of nations with several different quomain inside it, not acknowledging this and forcing nationalization by violence is what we are criticizing.
Do you really think these are issues of bankrupt and sinking Pakistan? I firmly believe that captions like this and videos that create negative emotion in public only give you views, there is no positive impact for spreading such hatred. Make videos on what matters the most to poor public and what are the challenges they face on daily basis. Who goes to Jail or who becomes PM is not public’s worry.
Generally correct analysis but pti has really went overboard with the anti establishment bakwas with 9 may, int'l resolutions, SM campaigns. Never say never in politics but it's hard to see a way back from that...
Kindly make video on Pakistan education system ,there is curriculum problem or any other problem ,I think curriculum is not big problem the the delivery of curriculum is the problem if I am wrong kindly guide me shehzad Bhai ap ik video banaye and sorry my question is irrelevant according to video
So true 😢💔 no one is for Awam the people, may be we have to fix the mentality of Awam! the real Punjabi awam and their everlasting favourite establishments, these people will never help or voted to bring genuine changes in the country for everything these so called awami log keep their face 👀 and spread their hands in front of the powers be it America or establishment in their own country 😢😢😢
Ye Faisal wavda ne Samaa pr I think qureshi ke bete ke sath baith kar kaha tha ke government abhi tak Establishment VS PTI karana main kamiyab ho gai hai and other things, jis pr vo muskuraya Us ke bad PTI kuch dinon bad ye bat ghuma deti hai.
Shahzad I agree that considering Pakistan left leaning people are far better than right wing which is illetrate and extreme but what if the revolution happens and the left brings back socalist values or the far left which is now in USA
Are there any podcasters or influencers who can talk about other things like current situation in Parachinar. Everyone has the same job, Imran Khan, Imran Khan.
Why no one discusses zardari and how ge became the president if the country. Every one seems to he ok with that but why ? Where are those patriots these days ?
My dear its simply another U_Turn of KHAN. Both the Establishment (Army + Judiciary + Bureaucracy etc.) & our Politicians are nothing to do with the problems of Common Public of PAKISTAN. Its a Bitter & Biggest FACT. May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! !
🙌
I am your regular listener Engineer sahib despite being a firm kaafir😄😄
Boot chat la enginer
@@nishantsharma7832 yes , all kaffirs and qadiyanis and ex muslims love to listen to egineer. Something is certainly right obviously that he is doing that he is being loved by you.
@@abdussamad2471 I think,he is trying to push you on path of Muhammad,but you are admant to move on path of babas.I am not a admirer of Muhammad and Babas,I watched some of his video on social issues.👍👍
btw i also read and watched About Ibn taimiya,shah Waliullah,maulanaa Israr and many more😉😉😉
What's wrong with having 3 PMs - let's have them by rotation 2 days a week. Friday can be a rest day which umpire can officiate.
i swear, i also thought about one such idea k 9 to 5 job ho pm ki or uskay bad wo PM ka title nai use kr skta or 5 to 9 dusra PM ho 😂
@@HirratShoukat wo to aaj bhi hai - aapko maloom nahin bas
5pm ke baad Sheen se shahad ka shauq resist nahin kiya jata
Immu ke time pe aur bhi umda tha - 12noon to 3pm Immu hawaas mein hota tha - baaqi time hawa mein
PM b or baki saray heads army chief president CM in sb ki seats b 9 to 5 uskay bad common citizen bn k rahay ta k real issues sath b connect ho skay
@@HirratShoukat I think you live oversees - yahan to iqtedaar ke pachees saal baad bhi taqabbur nahin jata
Then it should be broadcasted on our tv channels so that our children can learn the tactics of musical chair contest 😜
When I was in 10th class, I accidentally watched one of your video no I am doing my bachelors in English in upper SWAT. Ur podcasts has completely changed my whole perception about religion Pakistan and politics thank you so much shehzad bhai. I wish that one day you come to swat and be my guest I want to have hours of conversations with you, it are beautiful really that you haven’t heard of, in swat 🖤🫶🫶 love u and thank u for making me a humman 🖤
🙌🙌❤️
You make me feel old 🤣
@@ThePakistanExperience hhhh just 🫶🖤🖤
Thank you TPE. You have added an incredible amount of value.
🙌
1:44 shahzad targeting #EON boys indirectly 😂😂😂
Yup, Shehzad shouldn’t do it…
This video’s core message is that Pakistani public should increase their independent political acumen.
EON boys or other such influencers are also doing same, increasing awareness in public and making people critically analyze stuff themselves.
Professional background is not a limit for being political analyst in a democratic system. May be this (influencers) is start of a free democratic system of Pakistan.
Actual issue at hand is to fight the negative control of Authoritarian regime in Pakistan, actual threat to sovereignty.
Shehzad, EON, other channels need to collaborate to mitigate that negative control and to propagate freedom of speech.
yup, bht small d*** energy hai shahzad bhai mein sorry to say.
shahzad ka argument, "mein 5 saaloun se sab kuch theek keh rha houn, baaki saare ghalat hain".
@@taimoor1995 One small spark and your strawman will burn the entire country.
@@taimoor1995keh rha tou sach hai👽
My heart weeps for Gwadar and Parachinar
Bravo Shahzad!
You never disappoint!
🙏
🙌
@13:17 i totally agree. Till 2018 there was a slow but evolution. But even then whenever i watched PTI dharnas i somehow knew this person IK (if got into power) would ruin the country and so he did eventually. Sadly we never recovered from that damage he has done.
And IK (sitting in jail) and his cult still have free rein to continue doing that. How is it even possible without Hafiz tola support??
Yes
This has to be ur best video. Shahzad I have hated loved n then hated n ultimately loved ur work. This is arguably better because u communicated it so well without making anyone feel bad or targeting one party. That's a smart effective way to get ur point across. Thanks for all that u do. Stay patient n humble like u have been
❤️
Its just a tussle to be the next favorite of military and civil establishment... shahzad bhai stay blessed ❤
❤️
You and Syed Muzammil Hassan are ❤❤❤, always stand with the oppressed
❤️
Justice for Bangladeshi student 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
You have made me learn the in-depth of dirty politics in such a good way that I've become a regular listener of you. Thankyou 🙏
❤️
aap aur syed muzmil both real analysis krty hn....aap donon rreal rational bandy hn....
🙌
This is a good thing anyway. Look at the bigger picture. Everyone - all stakeholders should get united and think of the "awam."
Thank you for this video. It was a great explanation
🙌
1:58 Thanks shehzad bahi to teach me "how to do case study,comparison ,critical thinking...and so many thing i 've learned from u.....❤"
❤️
But Shehzad can there be a party independent of Elite and Establishment connections ? 2008 to 2018 though a so called evolutionary phase, 4 major events happened to offset this evolution:
1. Judiciary ousting Yousuf Geelani and Nawaz Sharif aiding and abetting judicial aggression.
2. MemoGate
3. Imran Khan, Tahrul Quadari Dharnas and Dawn Leaks
4. Panama cases and judicial coup against Nawaz Sharif .
No , not at all, the python grip of elite - Fauz wasn’t loosened even for a while during last 75 years . May be you can point a small hiatus of 1972 - 74😢
Well “ Rights Movements “ leading to consolidating the political movements or growing in to democratizing the government is indeed an optimistic thought …… . Not a single such movement has succeeded in Pakistan so far . PTM has already hit a dead end. So called leftist outfits never really took off .
One of the most outstanding example of ‘ Rights Movement ‘ turning in to a meaningful political party and a people’s government is ‘ Solidarity Movement’ lead by Lech Walensa in Poland , may be partly Iranian Revolution ( offCourse with lots of reservations).
Well your thesis has proved right , time and again in India since middle fifties. Communists won Kerala assembly elections in 1957 based on rights movement of landless labourers and urban poor since British times. There are many instances like this in Tamilnadu, Punjab, Bihar, UP, West Bengal and few other states. But these successes came within a broad democratic setup with fairly fair elections at regular and prescribed intervals .
🙌
Hahahah bro 😂
That Ammar Ali Jaan & Laal hai sub Laal hai kinda conjucture cum analysis aside, but things really don't add up here. Deal agr Khan ny krni hoti to 8th Feb sy pehlay krta ya baad mai. Secondly there is no establishment here, only a sharif / zardari maafia which has successfully converted Pak Army into Sindh & Punjab Police. You have to be verrrrrrrrrrrry dumb to believe that a man who got more than 2/3rd votes across the country that too under fascist regime, would beg a toothless retired general for some kind of deal... reallly yar? 😅😅
Listening to people like Sabir Shakir has fried your mind
@@ThePakistanExperience Hahaha Ghias Bhai I never listened to him. I am not that wela of a person 😅 But I hope you did get my point..
Love your content.
❤️
As always exemplary clarity and effective communication. TPE fan for life!
🙌
One quick thing, "devolution" is an actual word Shehzad bhai 👍🏼😇
Yes but it doesn’t mean the opposite of evolution
بک رہا ہوں جنوں میں کیا کیا کچھ
کچھ نہ سمجھے خدا کرے کوئی ۔۔۔
غالب
Am still amazed that govt is opposing an anti terrorism protest rally...and no political party is supporting the protests...it beats me...
Because they all are in government
Same as manipur modibhakth
@@zyabsiddiqui8155I think you are an andhbhakt of Pakistani army. Where does modi comes here in this case?
@RahulMishra-ld2bo just don't interfere or comment on internal matters of Pakistan like we Pakistanis don't give a fuck about India...we never comment about what the Indian government do to Manipur Nagaland peaceful khalistani protesters Dalits and other minorities.. the list goes on
@@zyabsiddiqui8155 I think that has become the national duty of our neighbors.
I can’t wrap my head around that in Pakistan, one electricity United is about 80 Pakistani Rupees. And the average wages in Pakistan is less than 10k Pakistani rupees. If you consume 200-400 units of electricity, 20-40% of your income goes into just paying electricity bills. How do people survive in Pakistan?
They have to decide it because they support their army and it's all done by them only , no one else is responsible for this.
@@RahulMishra-ld2bo yeah
Shahzad, while minding his Ps and Qs, possesses a good knack of quality content. I always share his video link to my student groups. Keep rolling, Shahzad😊
🙌
Riyasat e Loot maal e Ghanimat - awam pe Bomb - Petrol/Bijli/Mehangai ki Bomb, kab Gazwa e Sindh hogi?
Thankyou for this video , most awaited analysis
🙌
Great Valuable Content.
🙌
DEAL...WHAT BLOODY DEAL...
RUBISH.....ALL NONSENSE
.
Hats off--You are good. Really impressed
🙌
this is absolutely right , instead of seeing things in left and right/pmln vs pti, we should dissect every issue and nuance ko smjana chaiye
Yes
It’s all about “looking” pious and handsome/strong etc. A deadly combination for the mentally subjugated awam of Pakistan who are always looking for the next Maseeha.
Great analysis as always Shehzad. Sad to know how much lies are being fed to people nowadays.
🙌
18:20 exactly why i feel like im biased against PTI. Problem is k PTI has such a HUGE opportunity to actually become an anti establishment force but all they care about is their personal fascism. Tbh if i run a party and if i get jailed i swear id be more focused on the VISION and not to get me out. Your focus as PTI should be to achieve your insaf related goals. Not focus on releasing one man from jail.
In a country like Pakistan, where the hold of establishment is so strong is it possible for any politician to go all in against the establishment and all those conspiring against the country or is it sane enough to carry things ownwards with a bit of discussions here and there get a way... Benazir and bhutto and other balochi leaders are great examples of going all in against the establishment. Thanks
in log ki Gazwa e Pakistan kabhi Khatham nahi hogi.
Behtreen video Shehzad! Kudos to uphold the values on which TPE was based!!!!
🙌
Pakistan's politicians seem to crawl when asked to sit, yet believe they hold power when the military steps back. Since Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto's time, the PPP has recognized their limits and has been gradually diminishing the military's influence, although Bhutto missed a significant opportunity in Pakistan's history. Currently, discussions revolve around 'The Deal,' but it's important to remember that Imran Khan initially granted the military more power than it requested to secure his position. Later, he attempted to interfere in the military's internal politics instead of gradually reducing its control. For civilian supremacy in Pakistan, clear boundaries of power must be established, and politicians need to dismantle the military's peripheral influences first.
The thesis you built is excellent and very realistic.
🙌
I am not a subscriber but i do enjoy watching your videos... You know what i mean 😉🙏❤️
Karlo subscribe bhi
In short, nothing good will happen. Very few people think like you, we can count them on our fingers.
Pti is ruling KPK , PMLN is ruling punjab , PPP is ruling Sindhi ,Baluchistan is coalition . So every political party is governing . Its ideal
Let's say Pakistan's youth and communities unite for a revolution, but then...
What will we do? Protest!
If yes, what should be the outcome of the protest?
Whom will we fight against: the military, the government, or the establishment?
What set of actions will we demand, and how can we ensure that we achieve our purpose?
Pti is ruling KPK , PMLN is ruling punjab , PPP is ruling Sindhi ,Baluchistan is coalition . So every political party is governing . Everyone is getting chance and budget money to spend
Thank you for delivering good content even after the 'clickbait' thumbnail. :D
🙌
Aaj ali aftab ka 12 saal pehlay ka song suna aalu anday us mai ek kamaal ki baat hai...
Tehreek e insaaf = modern jamaat e islami 😊
Yaar kamaal itna pehly aap loogon ny pechan liya tha
Ali is a genius ❤️
Tell me onething Sehzad deal hua nahi hua how does it effect common man in pak. What relief does a middle class family get ?
None
❤ Thank you!!!
❤️
Pakistan is sinking in a swamp and only an extra ordinary force can pull it out of this situation however,right now there is no hope unfortunately.
😂 was not drowning before ???
this video will really hurt pti supporters in future 😂
Been listening you from last year
when i see thumbnail from you i assumed it is authentic😅
🤣
Brother can't you stop Shoaib Chaudhry, Naila- Shaila , Sana Amjad , Muzzamil Qureshi, Nimra Ahmad & many like them !!! They have created havoc on you tube !!! Hope you will give a thought!!!!
I don’t even know who any of these people are
its my request to have a program on edward saeed
Good request
Yaar oxford election par koi video banao..Youthiuo ny asman sar par utha lya hay k khan Chancellor bny ga😊
You really need to make a podcast about the current issues plaguing Pakistan...
1. Bani gala sewage going into rawal lake which will make it undrinkable in future
2. Monsson rains and flooding, how will pakistan survive if that happens with no mouths to feed
3. Riko diq and Saindak issues
4. Lost cases in international criminal court and their subsequent fines
5. Wastage if CPEC resources
6. Dams construction
7. Import of clothes from Bangladesh in Zainab market where we once used to have only Pakistani products
8. Amount of money wasted in Diseases that can be avoided just by keeping streets clean
9. Negative impact of snap chat, tik tok, tinder and similar apps
10. unnecessary imports and what alternatives we can try or use
11. Zero content for our kids on TV
12. Exorbitant fee of private schools
Every now and again we get a new circus in our politics which keeps the population away from the real issues.
Keep the good work up brother ❤
❤️
The business of content creation has brought a lot of mess in our society along with the positives. Need to be watchful as viewers/listeners
"بولو پینسل انقلاب کینسل"😂
More power to you brother
Keep exposing these hypocrite politicians.
Baloch Nation Meet at gwadar.
❤❤❤
👍👍👍
I don't click on any other videos, but you did fool me.
Why PTM is silent on Parachinar????
🔥
I hope tpe podcast team will dedicate an episode to discussing the recent political developments in Balochistan, focusing on the Gwadar political gathering of the Baloch Yakjehti Committee. Specifically, I'd like them to explore the various obstacles and hurdles that prevented people from attending the gathering, and delve into the broader implications of these events."
I’ll have to call people who know this more than me
Shehzad,A complete shutdown is being observed in Balochistan. Quetta is under lockdown at Lak Pass, while Mustang has been locked down for two days by the byc. Kech is also under lockdown from D baloch and Lasbela and Hub are closed by Baloch protesters,. A sit-in protest (Dharna) is taking place in Gwadar. Additionally, there is no internet or network connectivity in most parts of the province, and educational institutions and banks remain closed.No transportations in entire province,v r just setting at home at quetta and fully cooked with this terrible situations,both side govt and byc needs to show some way forwarded...
ہم نے سالہا سال اسامہ بن لادن کو چھپا کر رکھا ۔ عمران خان کو شائد اس بات کا بدلہ لینے کے لیے سپورٹ کیا جا رہا ہے امریکہ کی طرف سے😢
Hypocrisy is a true virtue of mankind
Good JOB
🙌
I love you
❤️
Within this system in our country no one can deliver.
Deal No Deal 😂! Open the briefcase 💼😅
Yeh na ho payega.They will call him a traitor and bury him.
Ay kaash kay Pakistani qaum shaksiat pasandi or maseeha dhoondnay say bahar aajai…or leadership kay dilemma say bhi bahar aajai. All we need good and honest elected people by people purely to run the country
What an intro....!!😂❤
❤️
Great analysis
Fan of your work
🙌
Mahrang Baloch zindabad
Love it
🙌
0:01 Tum jeso ka khuwab he rehy ga k imran khan dollar army se deal karay ga , IK following the path of Imam Hussain A.S ye gardan kat tu sakti hai lekin yazeedi fooj ke samne jhuk nai sakti...🙌
Bhai is jahalat se niklo, Pakistan main ek pagal kahana banana chaiye jahan molvi zada bemaron ka ilaj hona chiaye tkaay haqiqat main rehna seekhein
Baqi apki baatain regarding everything thats happening in parachinar and across Balochistan and across kpk, jahan PTI walay ghungay ban gaya hn. But still a huge suppoeter of Imran khan. Not the idiots around him. Allah establishment walun ko ajar day ameen
Well said
Let everyone express their opinions . Its their right . Its social media world must get used to it . Also believe or not believe is their choice
Dear Shehzad
I would like to discuss something that Adeel Afzal said in one of your recent programs.
He had said that we should understand that there is no such thing as the 'Pakistani nation' as Pakistan is a country that comprises many 'nationalities'.
My submission is that there seems to be a confusion about the definition of the terms 'nation' and 'qaum'
'قوم'۔
in the prevalent narrative of intellectuals in Pakistan. Just like the word 'captain' which has multiple meanings, the term 'nation' also has at least two different meanings Urdu.
One meaning is what our intellectuals subscribe to, which is the one that is the traditional meaning of the Urdu, Sindhi, or Punjabi word 'qaum'. Which is a group of people who live in a distinct geographical region, have the same mother tongue, they may belong to different religions or sects but they share the same traditions, culture, literature, music, dances and history and who identify themselves as a distinct entity compared to those who do not share these things with them.
But these intellectuals either do not factor in, or deliberately do not mention the fact that the term 'qaum' has another meaning in in Urdu also. That meaning is the same as the meaning of the English term 'nation': all citizens of a state irrespective of the region within the state they belong to, mother tongue, religion, caste, creed etc. They don't need to be born in the state, or even be its traditional inhabitants, they just need to acquire citizenship of that state through legal means.
The second meaning of the term 'qaum' is used in 'aqwam e mutahemida',
'اقوام متحدہ'
the Urdu translation of 'United Nations'. The 'nations' that are members of 'United Nations' are Afghanistan, Pakistan, India and Bangladesh and not the Pakhtoon nation, Punjabi nation and the Bengali nation.
The interesting thing is that in Urdu the term 'qaum' is used for both types of groups, but in modern English native speakers don't use the term 'nation' for a group of people coming from a particular area within a state having shared language, customs and history etc. The term used for such grouping is 'ethnicity'. However, people from India and Pakistan call allegience to such groupings as 'nationalism' or 'sub-nationalism'. This is because of the influence of Urdu/Hindi and mother tongues in which the word qaum is used for such groupings and they translate the word qaum in English as 'nation' or 'sub-nation'. Yes, traditionally the term 'nation' was used for such groupings also, but only in the case of very large single tribes, e.g. the Sioux Nation, but not for a collection comprising multiple tribes having shared language and traditions. Similarly, the term 'nationalism' is also used for feelings and activities in the context of the state, even though we use it in the context of our ethnicities.
Thus, in English a 'nation' is confined within the borders of a state, but an ethnicity can transcend state boundaries.
If we take a Pakhtoon who holds the Afghan nationality and a Pakhtoon who holds Pakistani nationality, then if we take the traditional meaning of the term 'qaum' used in Pakistan and India, then both belong to the Pakhtoon qaum. On the other hand, if we take the other meaning of 'qaum' i.e., citizens of a particular state, which is equally valid in Urdu, then one Pakhtoon belongs to the 'Afghan qaum' and the other to the 'Pakistani qaum'.
It depends on which meaning you take, both are valid; just as a captain could mean the leader of a cricket team, the senior pilot of an ailiner, or a naval officer who is one rank senior to 'commander' and one rank junior to 'commodore'.
In the light of this I would say that it is not right to insist that out of the several meanings of 'qaum' or 'nation' only the one that matches our ideology is correct.
Therefore, it is OK to call the citizens of Pakistan the 'Pakistani qaum' or 'Pakistani nation' and we can say that Pakistan is a 'multi-ethnic nation', or 'polyglot nation'.
I would be interested in knowing your comments on this and please pass on my message to Adeel.
You are slightly conflating the words nation and a nation-state. Even in Canada indigenous people are called First Nations, they don’t see the use of the word as a threat to the Canadian Nation State.
Pakistan is a Nation State, it is a nation of nations with several different quomain inside it, not acknowledging this and forcing nationalization by violence is what we are criticizing.
coke studio waly xulfi ko invite karoo. ploitics kay ilawa koi baat nhi hoti iss channel pey.
Recording a podcast with Usman Riaz kal
Do you really think these are issues of bankrupt and sinking Pakistan? I firmly believe that captions like this and videos that create negative emotion in public only give you views, there is no positive impact for spreading such hatred. Make videos on what matters the most to poor public and what are the challenges they face on daily basis. Who goes to Jail or who becomes PM is not public’s worry.
My queation why those all elite shia dittibg in government and military establishment are silent on parachanar issue.
Generally correct analysis but pti has really went overboard with the anti establishment bakwas with 9 may, int'l resolutions, SM campaigns. Never say never in politics but it's hard to see a way back from that...
Kindly make video on Pakistan education system ,there is curriculum problem or any other problem ,I think curriculum is not big problem the the delivery of curriculum is the problem if I am wrong kindly guide me shehzad Bhai ap ik video banaye and sorry my question is irrelevant according to video
Very knowledgeable good work
🙌
So true 😢💔 no one is for Awam the people, may be we have to fix the mentality of Awam! the real Punjabi awam and their everlasting favourite establishments, these people will never help or voted to bring genuine changes in the country for everything these so called awami log keep their face 👀 and spread their hands in front of the powers be it America or establishment in their own country 😢😢😢
You don’t look to be neutral.one question?
Do you believe in democracy?if yes, who got the majority in feb24 elections?
Ye Faisal wavda ne Samaa pr I think qureshi ke bete ke sath baith kar kaha tha ke government abhi tak Establishment VS PTI karana main kamiyab ho gai hai and other things, jis pr vo muskuraya Us ke bad PTI kuch dinon bad ye bat ghuma deti hai.
I’m unable to watch this video without vpn. Why is that?
Strange
Shahzad I agree that considering Pakistan left leaning people are far better than right wing which is illetrate and extreme but what if the revolution happens and the left brings back socalist values or the far left which is now in USA
What about parachinar accept Imran khan and others
im ashamed i supporter PTI and really thought KHAN wanted the best of pakistani people..now i know they are all the same
Are there any podcasters or influencers who can talk about other things like current situation in Parachinar.
Everyone has the same job, Imran Khan, Imran Khan.
you didn’t watch the video, did you
Why no one discusses zardari and how ge became the president if the country. Every one seems to he ok with that but why ? Where are those patriots these days ?
It happened more than one time in Karachi 😢. It’s not the same still
bht achay bhai... ❤
❤️