If you enjoyed this, you will also like our first podcast with Husain Haqqani: ruclips.net/video/n1whXAXmn9A/видео.html It also addresses some of the questions asked in the comments when we made the guest announcement.
I am still waiting for you to call an Indian expert to comment on Modi and Indian politics and RSS and Indian laws.? Last time I requested you to refrain from making a Pakistani comment on India or Modi's position without having a Indian guest to throw facts on your face , but seems like @The Pakistan Experience is also another spineless youtube channel who prefer propogating lies without any facts , starting from 48:00 in the above video all of his discussion is purely based on assumptions I can give a point by point rebuttal to every silly thing this guy said , also that guy who visitied India jiska podcast viral hua tumhara , why dont you ask him did he see any discrimination against Muslims here?.
Facts- bjp is in puducherry..goa ..which are south india states and union territory. BJP has won In Buddhist ladakh , Christian nagaland...few months back. Its useless to convince those who see world as Darul isla* vs Darul harb.
The difference between Modi and Imran is that almost all the Pakistanis don't want Modi to be India's PM and almost all the Indians want Imran to be Pakistan's PM. IYKYK.
Ye gadhe hain. Ye naam nihad intellectuals inke chashme itne chhote hain k modi k sath inko hindutwa zarur dikhta hai. Wo hindu intehapasand hai inke nazar me. Pakistan aur congress ek hi sikke k do pehelu hain.
@@hydrakingff7339yeah. They are not interested in Famous BOOM Jacket Pakistan invented and love to use. Take yours out from closet and reach Zaman park to protect from Pak Army
Imran is nothing but a Thurki Budda, he screws every female PTI worker before making them Ministers. Now he is screwing the entire nation of Pakistan from the back..😅
"hum sab musalman Hain" is a quote that easily sums up Pakistan's renewed identity crisis. An ambassador is expected to have nuances, regard and care not to contradict oneself. He says that Pakistan had 3 major missteps initially, one of which WAS identity: an Islamic nation or a country for Muslims? Neither of which accommodate such gross misrepresentation of their own countrymen.. I believe most conversational threads were broken because of undue explanations and overtly intellectualising them, which led to the host not building on it, rather moving to a new thread.
@@kumaril05 I don't think loss of Diversity is happening in either of the countires, rather loss of political acknowledgement of diversity is rampant. The idea behind "sab musalman" in Pakistan OR "sab hindu" in India is sheer bullying of their respective minorities. I see this "sab musalman" in Pakistan happening more often than I see "sab hindu" happening in India.
@@PrateekBagga I think the concept of Kafirs ,and the mentality of no other god but Allah and no other messenger but mohammad is highly disrespectful ,bullying and Medieval, but surprisingly the so called Secular forces either don't find it objectionable or they avoid to resist it fearing beheading.. That's why they are now rightly being called SICKular 😆😆
the fight between extremists and liberals of pakistan is the fight beteween madarsa maulana class and convent maulana class. they may look different on the surface but same at the core.
Yea as soon as someone criticizes Modi all of a sudden they are all part of the same ilk. I guess BBC news that ran the documentary on Modi is also maulana and so is any left-wing who criticizes Godi. Andhbakhts pull your head out of Modis ass
What is "most" radical about Pakistan? When was the last time a "religious/fundamentalist" party was brought to power in Pakistan? Never! Can't say the same for India...first understand what "radical" means.
@@Anony479 hahahah, Pakistan was created by religious fundamentalist party,they don't need to elect them.....your ideology is radical...... whereas india suppressed hindu mahasabha, hindu fundamentals and stayed secular......now they are trying to take over and make india hindu state, aka hindu pakistan
I heard from many Journalists/Authors from Pakistan. When it comes to Modi, even the rational commentator from Pakistan will go nuts. They will show glass half empty of what is being done, they will never accept the facts, they will be clouded by the personal feelings, which are strongly against Modi.
And this makes me even more proud and happy and I will participate on the 2024 election with so much enthusiasm we need modi ... When your enemy is afraid of your leader it shows how strongly we are growing under that leadership 🎉
@@rumba_tumba_zumba_kumba This is the same rhetoric we hear from Imran fans. Imagine actually being so dense that you fail to even realise that you're using the same arguments. 😂
Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony aur jisko lg rha h fake news hai to lalantop ne video Dali h RUclips p aur Google p search krlo news aa jaygi
i am shocked after watching vlog between Aaliya Shah & Waseem Altaf from Pakistan about what Pakistani children are taught in schools through radicalized textbooks.
You see the Pakistani text books are full of hatred for Hindus and India...but you will be shocked to know that their aasmani kitab is full of hatred for all non-Muslims....the so called Kafirs
The funny thing is that after pursuing hate for 75 years, they assume that they will call the Indian PM and say lets trade and india will say sure!! To be honest india has had enough post kargil, 2001, and 2008. I have personally lost freinds in the mumbai 2008 attacks, and we will never forget that.
These people have a sense of entitlement.. they think they can do whatever they want and expect the opposite party to just fall in line. They genuinely think they are superior which is why they are where they are!
@@shailajapatil5304 no...they are just complete idiots, the made fools of Indian Seclulars for 65-70 years. Finally the Indians, specifically Hindus are waking up from deep slumber....no more.
They have to clear the dues worth USD 40 million to Indian Pharma Companies for supply of medicines. Addionally, the Freight train rack of Indian Railway is still with them. Beggers.
Nah mate, Paki expats especially in developed countries have great dealings socially, in the workplace and elsewhere with Indians of all backgrounds except Hindu right-wing nationalists (developing malignant views).. who's minds has been corrupted by contemporary anti-Pakistan propaganda by Indian mainstream electronics / TV media channels, etc. So sad, as a LOT of our parents/ grandparents are of course from India & born in India. Sad & sorry for you & at your views.
These Pakistani liberals and their obsession with Prime Minister Modi is beyond me…….When it comes to Modi the views of Pakistani right wing and liberal wing are indistinguishable. Says a lot..
Here's the thing: Pakistanis secretly admire Modi for being a strong and decisive visionary, but they can't reconcile these qualities with him being Hindu. In their minds Hindus are weak and effeminate while Muslims are the true leaders. So not only does Modi's effectiveness refute and rebuke their civilizational "logic", but his transformation of India's fortunes and trajectory sticks in their craw, as does the reality of their great Muslim genius being outsmarted by a "chaiwallah" Hindu. Because for them Pakistan can only ever be equal to India, or better than it, never inferior. And Islam can only ever be superior and never equal. So take these together and Pakistani Muslims can only ever be dominant, or victims, never equal or inferior to Hindus (and other cultures). Same logic for Islamists. Basically a deep inferiority complex. Hence the obsession and constant comparisons with Modi and India.
When Modiji travels in an open car, people shower rose petals on him. Imran gives speeches from enclosed container with a glass hole in it. Go figure 😮
Quite laughable to say that BJP hasn't delivered on Economic Front. The example that India grew double digits during Congress was because Indian Economy was smaller (10th largest in 2015) Libya has GDP growth rate of 31% annual, does that mean it's on its way to capitulate US? NO! Right now, we have 5th Largest economy. And if we go by growth in absolute terms, then I'm sure the numbers are greater than what they were back in 2014. You can't compare 10% of 100bucks to 2% of 10,000 bucks. China have slower growth rate than India yet in absolute terms it'd be higher than India. Let's not forget, COVID is followed by a war and global inflation yet India has managed to keep inflation at par with US (currently). Also to add the kind of Money this Govt has invested in Basic and logistics infra. I have seen my "tier 2" city change infront of my own eyes. From bus for local connectivity to 2 metro Lines and 1 Rapid Rail line now. People don't blindly vote for Religion, they vote after seeing the change on ground.
Spot on ... massive infrastructure happening in india . Exports crossed 750 bn$ ...india became 5th biggest economy. But pakis cant see this ..so is Haqqani.
@@MrXperx Infact, huge reduction in both scams and NPAs during BJP's tenure. People in India won't vote for communalism. Remember India voted for Congress and not BJP for a long time. BJP's communal politics is a headache but economically it is one of the best in the whole world at the moment, just by the scale of growth.
@@MrXperx in fact it almost collapsed Indian banking. It took more than 4 years to contain NPA problem. I have seen this Pakistan problem to comment without studying.
Multiple incorrect/ bad faith statements by Mr Haqqani in 'India & Modi' segment of an otherwise great podcast - 1. GDP growth rate was never in 'double digits' in Manmohan's govt. 2. BJP has govts in Kannada speaking Karnataka in the south & in Assmese speaking Assam in the north-east India. So, why insinuate that there will be intolerance only in the so called northie Hindi-belt ? 3. 'Anti-Conversion' law is actually 'Prohibition of unlawful conversion of religion' - and applies equally to anybody converting to any other religion . Religious minorities in Pakistan would have greatly benefited had there been such a law in the first place.
This guy knows nothing about Bharat. Congress government ke time pe bharat ka highest growth rate 2010 mai tha 8.5% or inflation bhi 2010 mai hi highest tha 11%. Last financial year Bharat ka growth rate 8.7% tha or inflation 5.13% tha
There's a barrier after which THEY cannot annalyse. Hindu - Muslim, Pak - India trade. There's a reason why they can't defeat Modi, cause they don't understand Modi. Modi has been CM for 15yrs - belongs to the most backward OBC caste, delivered 10%+ CAGR for 1.5 decade. Add to it Pak has NEVER SEEN A POLITICIAN FROM GRASSROOT who can win a state on his/her own.
Funny thing is, BJP had formed govt. In Jammu and Kashmir with PDP in 2014 after winning more than 20 seats, second only to PDP. If an average paki find these facts out, they will be really twisted let alone Assam and Karnataka.
Let them keep underestimating modi and the government. This will only lead to the gap widening as they will watch in disbelief. The anchor is comparing modi to a clown like Imran Khan . Let them... Hum Dekhenge..
I just want to thank Jinnah for dividing them from Bharat except (the crimes he committed against Hindus and Sikhs). because if Bharat was not divided,Bharat would not progress as it is doing now. These people could have become a headache for Hindus,India.
@@krisgray1957 what is india without UP and Bihar? Many major empires who have ruled the entire subcontinent like Mauryan empire (all) and large ones like nanda , shunga and gupta dynasty are from this region. Buddhism and Jainism formed here and even Guru Gobind singh ji who created khalsa was also born here only . Festivals like Holi and Diwali are UP festivals , Mahabharat and Ramayan happened in UP , Lord Ram and lord Krishna birth place is here , Sangham in Prayagraj is here and the cultural capital of Hindus Kashi (Varanasi) is here . Even the Rishi who wrote the first Veda Rishi Ved Vyas was born in UP including his father Rishi Parashar and great grandfather Rishi vashisht. Chanakya and Aryabhatta who gave zero was also from Bihar . These are just small examples and many are there . UP contribute 16% of total soldiers to army , biggest Wheat producing state with MP and Bihar is the biggest rice producing state with Bengal . Many IAS IPS come from here . Bihar is economically poor but UP is developing very rapidly and currently come 2nd or 3rd in SGDP . Even the Two biggest mahajanpada of 16 were from UP and Bihar only . just because the region is poor doesn’t mean it has no significance.
@@krisgray1957 Nabi laudakhor tattikhor Muhammad ki badboodar 💩 jaise shakal wale ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool, more like crores of rape jihad born cousin rapist ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool Muslim 🐖 like u from up and Bihar should be shoved up the 💩 islam filled Haji ghazi namazi aashiq gay rasool pichwada of islamic Republic of hira Mandi randistan porkistan bhikharistan Pakistan 😂😂😂😂💩🍑🍆
@vishal . Brother a can you give a little context when you stated "except the crimes he committed hindus and sikhs." With any journal, documentary video, reference books e.t.c?
This is hilarious when an economist such as Uzair Unus visits India and sees the truth and states this is India's moment while the so called all subject matter expert sitting in USA says India will not grow in the future 😅😅😅😅😅😮
@@tejesheconomics4072 If he is so good to understand economics so well as to comment on India's trajectory, he should have long back resolved all problems of a small country such as Pakistan
@@tejesheconomics4072 Indeed they are urban naxals without doubt.Calling a PM murderer and Butcher when the Supreme Court after various deliberations ie court cases, Supreme Court monitored SIT found no merit in the allegations of Murder and Butchery naxals still have the audacity to call him so underscores the fact that our systems requires a systematic cleansing of naxals.See the economic condition of Amartya Sen's mother state.
@@vhtevhte Buddy I called leaders in south asia butchers and Murderers not Modi😂😂 which proves you are already accepting and defending Modi as Butcher and Murderer ...😂😂 What Amartya Sen can do to West Bengal he has no power their...Amartya sen literally criticised Communists more than BJP...why would a naxalite do that 😂😂 I mean the kind of respect the noble laureate gets in india is a proof..India doesn't believe in logic but in magic...that is the reason we have Bageshwar Baba 😂😂 being worshipped not noble laureate.I don't my son to grow in this toxic Hindutva Radical state called Hindu Pakistan. Between I am also Hindu.....Youth like you are the reason I have applied and still trying to leave India ....
@@tejesheconomics4072 thugs have been saying this all along, yet India is doing fine economically. One particular section which keeps themselves in 7th century mindset will not progress, and that is also fine if they wish so. But we don't need lecture from you on butcher. Read how many wete butchered in 47 partition. And yes, we are confident that if you burn is, we will respond in a manner that your 3 generations will shudder to even think of it. Go figure.
This is the problem with elite of Pakistan, they have not idea of ground reality of India. The inflation in Manmohan's time was around 10% to 15%. The average inflation in Modi's regime is 7% for past 9 years, then why the hell common people will not vote against Modi
modi did a great job in inflation but average gdp growth is only 5.5% in last 9 years, corona ke pahle bhi growth 4% pe reduce hui thi yarr...unemployment rate bhi 7.3% chal rha hai
@@durgeshn8791 bhai mai real gdp growth ki hi baat kar rha hi. Real gdp me inflation cut hoke final amount aata hai, vo hi 6.8% tha dr singh ke time but he failed in inflation. Exports bhi 2004 me $126 billion the jo 2014 me $460 billion hue that is 269% of growth. Ye data bharat sarkar ka hai, pm modi ke time export $460 se aaj $750 billion hue jo sirf 70% ki growth hoti hai. Aur unemployment dr singh ke time 5% thi jo pm modi ke time 7% kam nai rhi. I think jo accha aur bura hua uska maan lena chahiye. Aur ek baat dr singh press conference ke through logo ke questions ko answer bhi karte hai aur kabhi bhi previous government ko blame nai kiya.
@@akshay_wakodikar Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony aur jisko lg rha h fake news hai to lalantop ne video Dali h RUclips p aur Google p search krlo news aa jaygi
@@ThePakistanExperience😂😂😂 anguthachaap jahil Nabi Muhammad ke aashiq rasool madrassa chap namazi, the saying " comparing apples with oranges " doesn't mean what u just pulled out of ur ghazi haji 🍑
Comparing Modi with Imran is just comedy. Modi is politically 1000 times ahead of Imran. People in BJP have come from cultural, political crucible of RSS. They are very much connected to ground. They are not parachuted by Army unlike Imran.
@@MrRhino101 basically pakistanis lack critical thinking. Modi ne infrastructure, foreign policy, welfare schemes pe jo kam kiya h wo Imam khan 10 janam mai bhi nahi kr payega
@@yasirpk2002 the same modi developed Gujrat in such a way that the 7-8 largest economy of India today account 26% of Indian manufacturing and 4 spot of economy
Pakistani media ko to khush hona chahiye na ki India me anti conversation law bana to ab Hindu Muslim ko convert nahi karenge but isko bhi pata hai ki hindu kisi ko convert nahi karte H to M hi hota hai M to H nahi 1000 saal se
Ye log kitne bi liberal BN Jaye lekin soch inki wahi rhegi madrsachap wali. Ye chate h ki jis tarah conversion Pakistan me hta h usi tarah hindu majority country me bi waisa hi ho.. mtlb dono hath me laddu chahiye.
@@avgman7376 I'm not sure they forget. Perhaps they simply wish India remains gullible. Afterall only an idiot would want a strong opposition, and I don't believe Pakistanis are idiots.
@@bharatkapoor4062 in rajasthan muslim cut the head of a tailor just becouse his son repost someone's post Becouse even there god teach to cut head Btw jake apna naam shi se rakh sharma Mt bhi tu apne hi Baap ka aulaad hai 😅
Why can't Indians take criticism? Why become hyper nationalists? Its his perception about Indian democracy, so be it. You may agree or disagree but you cannot deny Haqqani is a learned intellectual of international affairs. This podcast is all about playing a critical role about different political models but as soon as someone points India out there is a complete meltdown. TPE is all about growth and giving alternative viewpoints. That is why I listen to each episode even if I disagree.
Husain Haqqani is criticizing that the Indian economy is slowing down. He fails to mention that India is today the fastest growing economy in the world.
Aree Husain jee thoda Internet pe dekho Karnataka me BJP ki sarkar h ya nhi. Is he any kind of joke. He is saying India won't grow after 4-5 years. 😂😂😂 Good episode...we should invite him on Kapil Sharma show he is good comedian. 🤣😂
@@f.50 India has grown with or without modi.mits because of inherent tolerance of society.. modi has won the popular vote twice with full majority after 1984 who are we to label him??
@@f.50 aa gaya zombie bhakt bhakt karte karte 😂, can't say about you, but most of the Indians come to these podcasts to know what actually Pakistanis are thinking about us, maybe some do come here to boost their ego, but one can get bored of it very quickly, largely educated people listen to know what these innocent citizens of a nuisance state are thinking about our country India
The more I listen to paksthani podcaster, the more happier i get. Please Continue having the same way of thinking and phakisan will be the superpower in few years.
I also want them to keep the illusion and hate against Modiji & hindus....atleast 50 more years. Why make efforts to show the reality when they enjoy digging their own graves? Let's wait &watch.
Sir with due respect Indian politics works bit differently, state elections results hv no bearing on central govt election… and on the growth rate you are comparing double digit growth, tell us which country is growing at double digits now and hv single digit inflation…
Which country is having double digit growth? Not India. India is doing better than most but still growing that fast. And GDP growth doesn't indicate progress (,or lack of it) in healthcare, education , nutrition, etc. Neither does it indicate enrichment of democracy, freedom.
India cannot grow at double digits when the world growth rate is slowing down, to increase growth, export is a big factor that has been impacted by conflict. As you may have somewhere heard, Modi is not in power because of polarization but direct subsidies, LPG schemes, infrastructure, etc. Blaming polarisation and populism is a stereotypical representation of Modi winning elections, which is just outright laziness to not read and research deeper. Congress makes the same mistake.
@@nitishkumar-kc5hv I would recommend you read research papers rather than Googling and then commenting, if you want I will provide you the links to several of these papers which I am studying for my Ph.D.
This is the right time only to improve relationship under modi regime , if they are thinking about future then they have to remind themselves about Modi successor Yogi Adityanath 😂😂😂
some randomn pakistani youtuber makes a video adds a small time stamp of India and 95 percent comments and views are filled by Indians u very chalak broo
Won't be a long run though! Remember how cricket podcasts were booming during post-Lockdown tournaments and now it's all about the actual match and not much to do with xyz's rants! *And moreover, Indians only watch these crap for ego-boost or enjoy porkis whinning about their cunt-reee going in the gutter!
My perception of politics has completely changed in the last two years and the credit goes to your podcasts.I've learned so much about history which they wouldn't teach us in school's, and I was one of those people who used to think that political parties specially pmln or PPP etc are the problem, but I was wrong everyone is equally responsible for this mess.
This is the problem with elite of Pakistan, they have not idea of ground reality of India. The inflation in Manmohan's time was around 10% to 15%. The average inflation in Modi's regime is 7% for past 9 years, then why the hell common people will vote against Modi.
Multiple incorrect/ bad faith statements by Mr Haqqani in 'India & Modi' segment of an otherwise great podcast - 1. GDP growth rate was never in 'double digits' in Manmohan's govt.This guy knows nothing about Bharat. Congress government ke time pe bharat ka highest growth rate 2010 mai tha 8.5% or inflation bhi 2010 mai hi highest tha 11%. Last financial year Bharat ka growth rate 8.7% tha or inflation 5.13% tha. 2. BJP has govts in Kannada speaking Karnataka in the south & in Bengali speaking Assam in the north-east India. So, why insinuate that there will be intolerance only in the so called northie Hindi-belt ? 3. 'Anti-Conversion' law is actually 'Prohibition of unlawful conversion of religion' - and applies equally to anybody converting to any other religion . Religious minorities in Pakistan would have greatly benefited had there been such a law in the first place.
@@user-jt5jz6mq9l Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony aur jisko lg rha h fake news hai to lalantop ne video Dali h RUclips p aur Google p search krlo news aa jaygi
@@user-jt5jz6mq9l Excellent rebuttal with data. Wah bhai wah. You should actually tag "the Pakistan experience" or give this data under his remarks and ask him to respond.
The biggest Thing is Modi is Educating It's population Educated population doesn't get affected By religion politics and extremism waves They know what's best for them and the country
Hindus when start asserting against the appeasement politics are termed as Hindutva or radicalisation of Hindus. This narrative by most of the Pakistani analysts are itself flawed and aimed at drawing international attention. Further when Haqqani sir is saying about Indian economy falling is indeed farther from reality.
Great work, Shehzad. I think Pakistan looks at India through a very filtered glass. We are not idiots. People wouldn't choose a government which would break the social cohesion of India. Most of the people do understand the political techniques of bjp, congress and other regional parties. Bjp is very clever, it does populists politics to come in power. But it also has good plans and policies. I am not aware of any anti minority policies implemented by BJP . Isn't anti conversation law a good thing for minorities? For long India had a image of...... your humble servant. Congress is still in colonial hangover. It is telling the people that if you vote for the bjp the world will think India is intolerant. Congress has become very incompetent and its only politics is anti-BJP. At this point, it would be stupid to vote for congress or the grand alliance.
True, and the irony is, in Pakistan Hindu minority are asking for Anti forced conversion law and Muslim majority opposing it, Similarly in India Hindu majority is asking for anti-C law while muslim minority is opposing it🙃. When you have a fascist totalitarian ideology (my way of high way, anti-multiculturalism ideology on a mission to cnVrt whole world to their ideology), you can't blame ppl of an unorganised pagan(only surviving) to get organise n preserve themselves. N let's be honest, there's no H-M social cohesion in India, What Pakistanis n western Political gyanis called cohesion==Old Congress model==cucking Hindus, stop em from talking about injustices, past traumas, making them feel ashamed of their identity with fake history like(Hindu Ashoka dumped Hinduism n converted to Buddhism after keeling lakhs). Once Hindus stop following the above rule->society became Intolerant, cohesion breaks because Hindus won't celebrate Islamic colonizers n oppressors of Past (heros of Indian muslim), Imagine a group of ppl glorifying H1tler etc in Israel n Jews following Indian model allowing all this to happen to make minority happy, upheld multiculturalism🤡. H-M cohesion is that strong that few archeological surveys, historical surveys shakes the whole country n makes one minority sad😢, they'll say don't associate us with past Islamic colonizers but when someone changes Aurangzeb's named place, they get angry🤣🤣. Sorry if anyone is offended but you have to say truth as it is without sugar coating it, or thinking about what otrs will think, it'll offend one group, break social cohesion blah blah...
During Modi's period India has grown exceptionally well so much so that it has become the 5th largest economy from 11th position and will soon be knocking to 3rd position .During Manmohan Singh, India's growth was never in double digits. In fact, during Manmohan Singh's first term, India did grow at a rate of about 7/8 percent owing to the good jobs done by Bajpai but during his second term the growth slipped considerably. It was also one of the most corrupt governments. The difference between other PMs and Modi is that he calls spade a spade and pays back in the same coin. He is the most courageous PM India ever had. Besides this, he is non corruptable and doesn't tolerate corruption. He has been holding the top ranking amongst the world leaders since past several years He refrains from minority appeasement for vote bank unlike the Congress government and treated every citizen equally. He has a very firm policy towards Pakistan that terror and talk can't go together which every Indian appreciates. During his tenure, India's infrastructure has grown phenomenally world class and still continues to grow. He might not be suitable for Pakistan because he has cornered Pakistan and isolated it by his aggressive diplomacy but he is definitely good for India.
Not to hate or anything just from my perspective, Modi actually has been shown that he is very anti- muslim in Pakistan or the world by Western media because of funding from George Soros, actually he is just very open about his religion and rituals which someone has the full right too but the muslims here in India too thinks he is anti muslims, he has never given any anti muslim statements and Hindu Rashtriya is actually an ideology which has a geographical significance rather than religious
Some Pakistani intellectuals which are rationale and factual on Pakistan’s issue and problems talks highly of Nehruvian secularism without realizing it is pseudo-secularism based on appeasement of a specific religious community to form a vote bank. The support of modi and hindutwa ideologically is basically reaction of it. And it will continue until the political parties specially those calling themself secular mends there ways and truly becomes secular. Having a separate personal law for Muslims based on religions text and having secular personal laws for other community which is nehruvian secularism is biggest fraud in the name of secularism.
It is not about Modi or Khan.. it is all about strong institutions.. India developed and made their structures strong in a positive way and betterment of India.. Well planned !! Modi is a product of pure politics where khan is a counter product of deep state to balance the power and manipulation of perspective.
You can't compare Modi with Imran. Imran Is no where near. Modi can only compare with " Zia Ul Haq" . Zia has redicalise Pakistan and destroy next generation. Modi is doing same thing in india. Believe me people will forget Zia after few years after seeing Modi's damage to our nation and society.
@@shubhamsharma8867 Imran coudn't focus on infra development while modi is doing it pretty well. Imran didn't work for digitization of economy which modi did. Imran was called taliban khan and was pro blasphemy laws while modi is sitll dragging his feet on UCC and CAA implementation. Kuch bhi mat likha kar pakistaniyo ke likes lene ke liye.
Muslims remind Hindus of their religion. Pakistan reminds India of its nationality. Otherwise India and Indians have always been the believers of globalization and Vasudaika Kutumbam, even before the age of Internet. The reason why we have always welcomed our guests with the most fondness. It’s in our blood!
Modi maybe whatever but he is idealistic and also humble, ascetic in some sense. Imran Khan is a Playboy with an extreme ego. Imran Khan famously said somedays back ki tumse baat karkar cream nikal gaya. I don't think Modi is like that.
Modi ko koi mu lgaye tb na cream niklega smriti irani p try Kiya ldkiyo k phone b tapes Kiye kch n Mila. Modi k liye uska hath hi Jagannath hai. Imran was cited the sexiest Asian my topmost magazines kha ek Gigachad stud kha chomu
M of India are suffering and still doing stone pelti**..still doing targe** killings in Kashmir of H , still their population growing , still they are opposing uniform civil code and following uniform criminal code....... if pak has so much concern for indian m ...why dont pak bring citizenship amendment and gives them citizenship? As usual flogging m issue to keep pak ideology gng.
When it comes to India (or hinduism in particular), Pakistan's liberal and extremist class usually is on the "SAME PAGE." 😉 A good hindu (read Nehru's India) is one who turns another cheek for slap. If he resists, becomes "HiNdoOtVa".
Bilkul pehle lagta hai bande samajdar hai par jab ye hindu par aate hai sara purana majhabi zahar bahar nikalne lagta hai jane anjane me muje lagta hai yah inki aaju baju ki samaj k karan hai
@@abhijitchakraborty4659 What Superiority ?? Muzlims have not made a single invention despite being the largest followed religion on earth. They have a inferiority complex which is why they use religion to liberate themselves.
Haqquani said the relationship with middle East won't the same as it once were, I hope he was not referring to Nehru period or shastri era whom they put on such regards and in both 47, 65 and 71 war Pakistan enjoyed both arms and diplomatic support from middle East and Indonesia, Malaysia, while Modi who they accuse of religious divide, got full nod, and silence from middle East and Other Muslim countries when he removed article 370, or bombed pakistan. Thease fallacy claims might make you feel good or even enlightened in those disgraced circumstances in Pakistan, but rest of the world absolutely approve of Modi.
This is not because the middle east or Malaysia/Indonesia have developed any long-lost love for India and Indians. It is all due to our economy. If you are strong it attracts more people on your side while if you are weak people leave you. All this is because at this point in time, these countries see more benefit to their being in India's camp and ignore their love for Ummah.
Recently i have started listening your podcast. You are doing great work. One thing i would like to say that Modi government delivers on it's promises. Let me give you an example in 2014 India manufactured almost 0 mobile phones and recently alone Apple exported 3 Billion $ US from India . Pakistan current foreign exchange reserve is 4 Billion $US just let that sink in. Nearly 750 Billion $US of exports of goods and services has been done this year. I am from Delhi , India.
Under Nehru-Gandhi family's India,Pakistanis had a free run & would get away with it😂🤣....problem with intellectuals like Haqqani they take inputs from a select view & start making judgements in the comfort of their western homes....i'am wondering if these self proclaimed experts will talk about state of minorities in pakistan for even half an hour but have plenty of time to talk about so called intolerance on minorities in India......End result is people can't afford wheat in Pakistan🤣 & there's chaos across muslim world & Muslims can't co-exist with non-muslims & only end up creating clash of civilisations......Final word...draw a line from Baghdad to Beijing & India is the only shining democracy in Asia👍
Nowadays Pakistan youtuber ninja technique jldi jldi thumbnail m India mention kr dete hai views aayenge or kuchh b bkwas kis muh se minority ki baat kr re ho 1947 m 23% minority ti ab 2-3 percent b nahi bachi shrm aani chaiye plz hum bht achhe se grow kr re hai apna Gyan apne pas rkhe door hi rho humse aasmani kitab padho or aate ki line m Lago
1947 .... 24 % data of minority comes as east Pakistan ( Bangladesh) and west Pakistan combined..... West pakisthan always has 2-3 %.... 1.5 cr Hindus live in Bangladesh in country of 20-21 cr.... Check d present minority data of Pakistan and Bangladesh .... PS: but persecution of Hindus in Pakistan is real.
@@allyarjun-hs1xo thanx might be possible your data is right but my point is religious persecution in Pakistan and now a islamic country teachs us a secularism hypocrisy ki b limit honi chaiye
It's a terrible pity for Pakistan that it's best minds continue leaving the country in huge numbers. Husain Haqqani is one such gentleman having treasure trove of knowledge on international politics, political Islam, foreign policy, & global affairs etc. 😩 Many thanks Shehzad for having him in! Please continue doing the great work you are doing. 👍👍👍
Problem with knowledgeable people like Hussain sir, is that they largely reply on Indian English newspapers edited by anti Modi editors and journalists who are openly anti Modi, I don't blame him , the fact is they can think whatever they want to, anyways ground reality is completely different, fortunately for us it helps because if this is what there intelligencia really believes then also I am happy 😂
Agree with u . Left media is anti modi ..and they are open about it. Whole Liberal class of west ...pakis are feed constant churran on india muslims.. Sole goal is to destabilise india as world order changes. Ground reality totally different...people who lives in india or comes to see india are amazed.
@Modič when did he ever say that? journalists should be neutral neither support Modi nor be anti Modi. Always shouting against Modi even when he's right is not journalism. Media should be neutral without any bias. You mentioned Arnab let me mention raveesh chomu and male barkha dutt
@@Modicdeutsch Lol, for example read the recent BBC article with propaganda headlines on Rhino preservation "India is using Extremists measures and keeling Rhino poachers" and in the article they've added one small line, that security only shoot when poachers fire🤡🤡
The more I hear pakistani podcast.. the more it gets clear.. I am sorry to say there is a clear lack of understanding of statehood . It's pretty evident to see that how false self made beliefs in Pakistanis skew their perception of the reality of today. And what's more dangerous is that all this is actually prominent in puedo intellectuals of Pakistan or we can say the elite. No wonder they have no leader there to look upto because there is no sense of duty in the normal population.
Same here. I have been listening to some of these podcasts in last few monts. I have observed a common undertone of frustration combined with extremely narrow thought process. Simultaneously, they want to appease Indian crowd for views money.
@@SearchingSerenity bhai tou tu na sun apna paisa time or pesa nai waste ker? 🤣🤣 Just because that person criticized Modi, tum sub lund pe charh rahe ho. Modi IK se bara chutiya ha. I said it again. 🤣
He is just an English speaking Suit wearing Jihadi. He has dropped chote bhai ka pajama and badae bhai ka Kurta....because he lives in the west...but he is still a Jihadi
I request both of you to see this Kesavananda Bharati Case - An Overview of the Case and the Supreme Court Judgement of India Article 25: Right to practice & propagate religion Article 26: Right to manage religious affairs Article 14: Right to equality Article 19(1)(f): Freedom to acquire property Article 31: Compulsory acquisition of property In a Nutshell the it has been clarified by the Supreme Court that being a part of the Constitution, the Preamble can be subjected to Constitutional Amendments exercised under article 368, however, the basic structure cannot be altered. Therefore it is considered as the heart and soul of the Constitution.
Good podcast, Society mein debate har topic per honi chaiye . Yaha koi supreme leader ya King nahi hai. Jiske upper baatein ya question nahi hona chaiye. Love you bro🇮🇳🇮🇳💓💓
@@ThePakistanExperience u do clickbait. And yes ....370 was a temporary article.. Read the article and tell whole pak awaam who is forced to stand under the sun.
All Modi did was affirm that you don't have to be apologetic about your hindu identity. For 65 years, non-muslims in India were always to told to walk on egg-shells around Muslims and that Muslims deserve extra rights. Hindu politicians from Nehru onwards were gun-shy and too afraid for mini-pakistans arising inside India. Modi is the only one that had the courage to say - ALL are EQUAL
And the award of hypocrisy goes to Haqqani @growth is down because of Modi and in the second line he says @India has big Economic clout, so it gets away. Where do these people come from 😂 Haqqani ji, India will be a $7 trillion economy by 2028, mark my words
In an ironic way, Jinnah greatly helped India by keeping the majority of Jihadi population out of India. Without partition, Muslim population of undivided India would have been 40% of the population. Being ideological and group thinking, Muslims would have pushed jihadi religious politics, which would have greatly hindered India's growth. Therefore, Indians should be greatly thankful to Jinnah for the partition of India. 🙏🏽🇮🇳🙏🏽
It is quite unfortunate that even the educated Pakistanis like Hussain hakkani and almost all Pakistani anchors think that Muslims in India are suffering due to the Indian Government's Hindutva in fact They should visit India or speak to someone who visited India in the recent past to know how the country is progressing in all walks of life which include Indian Muslims also. Modi's mantra is sub ka saath , sub ka vikaas and sub ka vishwas !!! Wait till May 24 -2023 to know how our Kashmir is and compare with the Pakistan occupied Kashmir !!!
They dont care. They have deep agenda to keep flogging m issue of india ..to keep pak relevant. Their sole goal is to destabilise india. Haqqani is a usa citizen now and usa is doing all shit against india since biden came .
Thank you very much for your very informative and very interesting program It was very nice to hear Hounarable Hussain Haqqani sahib Masha Allah very knowledgeable person We need such types of people in Pakistan to lead Pakistan towards prosperity and stability
They are not interested. Liberal fundamentalis* of west and conservative pakis only interested in narrative building to keep pak project alive and it will only remain alive if m issue is flogged continuously.
Both cant be compared as Modi has been loyal to his own country and he has put India on a path of progress while Khan has taken Pakistan back 100 steps.
Yes you are right religious intolerance is growing in Hindi belt because most uneducated people are from there and also terrorism was a big problem there . I agree this polarisation will not be beneficial for India in a long run but India is still very diverse and a country for all religions
Haqqanii sahib It's very true That's the reason why I get engaged to these Podcasts for hours Because I am very hungry to know about the real facts You and Sheherzat sahib must have seen my long comments
Is Modi like Imran Khan? Consider: 1) Did army or anyone else rig elections to bring PM Modi to power? 2) Was Imran Khan a highly experienced CM for 12 years when he came to power? 3) Has PM Modi caused India’s foreign relations to deteriorate? 4) Has Imran Khan transformed India’s startup economy? 5) Did PM Modi blame his army chief for his political decisions? 6) Has Imran Khan transformed his country’s direct and indirect tax code? 7) Has PM Modi bought Toshakhana gifts at a fraction of their cost and then sold them in Dubai markets while claiming to have sold it in a local market by getting a fake receipt? 8) Has Imran Khan transformed the digital infrastructure of the country particularly the digital payment infrastructure? 9) Imran ran his country’s economy into the ground and further undermined it by giving a petrol subsidy at a time that the country could least afford it. Modi ended the petrol subsidy he inherited from Manmohan Singh and increased metro network from 5 cities to 20 cities. On several occasions on his watch India became the fastest growing large economy in the world. Yeah looks like they are almost the same.
Peacefuls are being peaceful. This discussion about India part between these two gentlemen tells a lot about how the educated Muslims and uneducated Muslims think. They shall understand the most extreme Hindu will always be more liberal than the most liberal Muslim. Hindus can never go to a place or do things that Muslims do.
Youthia podcaster and Haqqani is worried about m of india . These people never ever gets worried about Hindus of pak. These people never get worried about ethnic clean** of hindus from Kashmir.
when their primary sources about india (NDTV, WIRE, QUINT, SCROLL ETC...) are one sidedly biased against modi, we can't really expect them to have proper idea about ground reality of India
Modi has polarized your country. You wont find hateful fascists like you in majority in Pakistan. The ones we have are laughed at and ridiculed. They are not mainstream whereas you lot have bajrangdal, RSS. Far right thugs running the show in your country.
It’s unfortunate how the self proclaimed rational Shehzad also couldn’t help but expose his hatred and ignorance towards India. This is not the first time. He tried his best to make the speaker equate the useless Imran with Modi but unfortunately for him, the speaker seems to be somewhat rational.
It is a pleasure to hear Husain on Pakistan Experience. I knew him back in 1970s at Karachi University at the International Relations Department. Congratulations Husain on being a remarkable trail blazer.
If he’ll leave Modi n India…how will he gt views…Pakistani RUclipsrs have realized it’s only whn thy mention India n Modi thyll gt views frm India…been listening to this guys podcast fr past 3yrs…all his recent podcasts India n Modi are prime topics.
Tab iss liberal ganduudin fatass ghazi ki begairat behaya mughaliya ammi khala behen ko atta ki line me namaz karna pad jayenga , inshallah mashallah 😂😂😂
It has become mandatory for Pakistani youtubers to compare Imran Khan with Modi. Modi is a stateman who has been the Chief Minister of Gujarat for 3 terms and the Prime Minister of India for two terms. You cannot regularly win election only with emotional appeal; one has to deliver on the expectations of the people. But, how would a Pakistani understand this because not a single Prime Minister has completed his full term.
Why is the onus on Hindus to prevent polarization when it is them that have been converted or killed for 1000s of years? In fact, it is faiths or religions that use the word 'only' (only my God is true, my way is the only way) that cause polarization. The word polar itself means mine vs yours. Sanatana Dharma or hindu spirituality is the only one that says every soul is a portion of the same divine and only a different expression of it, and hence all souls are equal in their root form.
In Karnataka BJP is ruling party. Seriously ye nahi pata inhe aa gaye podcast krne both you should read history and plz don't compare India and Pakistan ja k aate ki line Lago two rupees people
@parth parth karnataka is being talked abt here not pudducherry. Dnt try to change statement u made statement abt karnataka not pudducherry. Learn to admit your mistake
Please do podcast with kushal about BJP he campaign for them & different shades of BJP & where Pakistan fit in their agenda & future prospect about relationship
Nice video. As an Indian, I appreciate constructive criticism. However, comparing Modi with Imran and suggesting that India is moving towards polarization is baseless and irrational. It is important to state facts rather than making unsupported claims. If you want to discuss the policies and steps Modi has taken that have harmed Muslims, it is crucial to present evidence. In fact, Modi has done more for Muslims than any other leader, although the public perception may not align with this reality. When it comes to a comparison between Modi and Imran, I have never seen Imran Khan discussing his policies, plans for the country, or his achievements. All I have found is a focus on religion, religion, and more religion. On the other hand, Modi consistently talks about his vision, policies, and other important aspects. Furthermore, discussing peace seems futile when it comes to India and Pakistan. It was Pakistan, not India, that initiated four wars. Leaders like Modi and the late Atal Ji made efforts to engage with Pakistan. India has suffered due to numerous terrorists claiming to be freedom fighters. For the first time, a leader has taken a strong stance and rightfully challenged those who perpetrate violence. It is better to let Pakistan figure out what they want, as India has dealt with enough destruction caused by terrorists...
I love analysis on your programmes. A couple of things about India are off the mark which is fairly understandable. If u have to compare Imran sahab with any Indian politician then it ought to be Mr Arvind Kejriwal. You will find too many similarities there. Carry on with the good work.
@@samimusicplay1 Sir, many, more than enough are. But there is a race out there, consumerism, show off, ego, Money , position, jugad, haramkhoree, adjustment , sycophancy, as it is everywhere else these days. With so many vested agendas, it is rather difficult to be logical rational as well , even basic self respect is missing. We, and I mean middle class people all around the world are being driven and controlled by any Tom dick or Harry, be it politicians , who would rather keep us divided and fight among us to keep power, religious leaders would have our souls and turn us into non thinking zombies, crooks of all kind for a few dollars more. We are sheep for slaughter, born to pay taxes and keep working and they will keep us happy by giving us dopamine effect through media. It's same in Pakistan too. A bit more and a bit worse because population there has been given too much to fear and fight for and even religion has been a bit too stringent. People who understand can escape all the leftist liberal wokism, and all the bullcrap of the right wing, and keep there sanity and peace.
Modi have to balance both Hindutva liberal ( savarkarite) & Hindu conservative to gain power in BJP that's why Yogi changing his tune from extreme right to right
Religious extremism is actually unattractive. I vote for Modi majorly just for the infrastructure work. It's unprecedented; India is being built right now!
@ 47:45 he said about anti conversion law in India, there is no such law exist in India, I would suggest to do some research. " In 2015, the Ministry of Law and Justice announced that the federal government could not establish anti-conversion laws".
If you enjoyed this, you will also like our first podcast with Husain Haqqani:
ruclips.net/video/n1whXAXmn9A/видео.html
It also addresses some of the questions asked in the comments when we made the guest announcement.
I am still waiting for you to call an Indian expert to comment on Modi and Indian politics and RSS and Indian laws.? Last time I requested you to refrain from making a Pakistani comment on India or Modi's position without having a Indian guest to throw facts on your face , but seems like @The Pakistan Experience is also another spineless youtube channel who prefer propogating lies without any facts , starting from 48:00 in the above video all of his discussion is purely based on assumptions I can give a point by point rebuttal to every silly thing this guy said , also that guy who visitied India jiska podcast viral hua tumhara , why dont you ask him did he see any discrimination against Muslims here?.
@@trishatahluwalia719 let these jahils thikn that Modi BJP is not good for India. BEcause we should not care at all about what these dumbo think
Facts- bjp is in puducherry..goa ..which are south india states and union territory.
BJP has won In Buddhist ladakh , Christian nagaland...few months back.
Its useless to convince those who see world as Darul isla* vs Darul harb.
Bap bap ho ta hee yogi ji aaaegi Pakistan no nakse se mita dalege beta 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Hasain haQQAni soch madrash chap h hee beta aanpan gavar
The difference between Modi and Imran is that almost all the Pakistanis don't want Modi to be India's PM and almost all the Indians want Imran to be Pakistan's PM.
IYKYK.
Good one...
Ye gadhe hain. Ye naam nihad intellectuals inke chashme itne chhote hain k modi k sath inko hindutwa zarur dikhta hai. Wo hindu intehapasand hai inke nazar me. Pakistan aur congress ek hi sikke k do pehelu hain.
@@hydrakingff7339yeah. They are not interested in Famous BOOM Jacket Pakistan invented and love to use. Take yours out from closet and reach Zaman park to protect from Pak Army
Deep analysis
Imran is nothing but a Thurki Budda, he screws every female PTI worker before making them Ministers. Now he is screwing the entire nation of Pakistan from the back..😅
"hum sab musalman Hain" is a quote that easily sums up Pakistan's renewed identity crisis.
An ambassador is expected to have nuances, regard and care not to contradict oneself. He says that Pakistan had 3 major missteps initially, one of which WAS identity: an Islamic nation or a country for Muslims?
Neither of which accommodate such gross misrepresentation of their own countrymen..
I believe most conversational threads were broken because of undue explanations and overtly intellectualising them, which led to the host not building on it, rather moving to a new thread.
Because they believe everyone in the world will one day, be Muslims. It's radicalism and indoctrination
same thing happening in India, loss of diversity
@@kumaril05 I don't think loss of Diversity is happening in either of the countires, rather loss of political acknowledgement of diversity is rampant. The idea behind "sab musalman" in Pakistan OR "sab hindu" in India is sheer bullying of their respective minorities.
I see this "sab musalman" in Pakistan happening more often than I see "sab hindu" happening in India.
@@PrateekBagga you are right , but Islamic basic mentality is bullying ...
Unless that is cured we have no option but to bully the bully
@@PrateekBagga I think the concept of Kafirs ,and the mentality of no other god but Allah and no other messenger but mohammad is highly disrespectful ,bullying and Medieval, but surprisingly the so called Secular forces either don't find it objectionable or they avoid to resist it fearing beheading..
That's why they are now rightly being called SICKular 😆😆
the fight between extremists and liberals of pakistan is the fight beteween madarsa maulana class and convent maulana class. they may look different on the surface but same at the core.
Spot on ... those Indias who consider Hussain a great learned are a fool.
Truthbomb 🔥
Yea as soon as someone criticizes Modi all of a sudden they are all part of the same ilk. I guess BBC news that ran the documentary on Modi is also maulana and so is any left-wing who criticizes Godi. Andhbakhts pull your head out of Modis ass
What's the problem with you endians. You people literally watch every Pakistani channel/ podcast and spam comments with your negativity. Buzz off
true. Both believe in their pdf profit as the perfect man and STSJ as a lawful punishment for blasphemy/
If this is the analysis by him as a someone who claim himself "rational" then God bless Pakistan
The complete lack of realism he has with respect to India is astounding. 😮😮
BIGGEST IRONY IS THAT MOST RADICAL NATION IS TALKING ABOUT INTOLERANCE IN INDIA
Intolerance nhi hain India me?
@SmokerAjitabhTheAbusiveIndian Ajitabh naam hain aapka?
Both adjectives are correct
What is "most" radical about Pakistan? When was the last time a "religious/fundamentalist" party was brought to power in Pakistan? Never! Can't say the same for India...first understand what "radical" means.
@@Anony479 hahahah, Pakistan was created by religious fundamentalist party,they don't need to elect them.....your ideology is radical...... whereas india suppressed hindu mahasabha, hindu fundamentals and stayed secular......now they are trying to take over and make india hindu state, aka hindu pakistan
I heard from many Journalists/Authors from Pakistan. When it comes to Modi, even the rational commentator from Pakistan will go nuts. They will show glass half empty of what is being done, they will never accept the facts, they will be clouded by the personal feelings, which are strongly against Modi.
And this makes me even more proud and happy and I will participate on the 2024 election with so much enthusiasm we need modi ...
When your enemy is afraid of your leader it shows how strongly we are growing under that leadership 🎉
Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony
@@bharatkapoor4062 what the fuch are you talking about...you must be a member of peaceful religion with fake Hindus ID
@@bharatkapoor4062 abbey tere paas ek hi comment har jagah chepnay ko hai?? Bewakoof.
@@rumba_tumba_zumba_kumba This is the same rhetoric we hear from Imran fans. Imagine actually being so dense that you fail to even realise that you're using the same arguments. 😂
Sar tan se juda is common in France even.. It's islam problem not poverty...
Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony aur jisko lg rha h fake news hai to lalantop ne video Dali h RUclips p aur Google p search krlo news aa jaygi
Every religion has violent elements let's not pretend that we don't have terrorists in the hindu alt right
@@bharatkapoor4062
Avg Pakistani : Hinduo ke naam pe kuch bhi Hagg deta hu kisi ko kya hi pata chalega.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@bharatkapoor4062 spamming everywhere. Bloody momin in hindu disguise
@@bharatkapoor4062 Fake Pakistani Account Bharat Kapoor. Nice try.
Asli Account se Aa 😂
i am shocked after watching vlog between Aaliya Shah & Waseem Altaf from Pakistan about
what Pakistani children are taught in schools through radicalized textbooks.
If you wish to know first hand read : "The Murder of History" by K.K.Aziz
You see the Pakistani text books are full of hatred for Hindus and India...but you will be shocked to know that their aasmani kitab is full of hatred for all non-Muslims....the so called Kafirs
The funny thing is that after pursuing hate for 75 years, they assume that they will call the Indian PM and say lets trade and india will say sure!! To be honest india has had enough post kargil, 2001, and 2008. I have personally lost freinds in the mumbai 2008 attacks, and we will never forget that.
Agree with your sentiments exactly 💯. No trade or relationship with Pakistan for next 1000 years
You guys need to focus on the Sardars in Punjab, they are a fraction of the Muslim population and will turn india upside down like they did in 1984
These people have a sense of entitlement.. they think they can do whatever they want and expect the opposite party to just fall in line. They genuinely think they are superior which is why they are where they are!
@@shailajapatil5304 no...they are just complete idiots, the made fools of Indian Seclulars for 65-70 years. Finally the Indians, specifically Hindus are waking up from deep slumber....no more.
They have to clear the dues worth USD 40 million to Indian Pharma Companies for supply of medicines. Addionally, the Freight train rack of Indian Railway is still with them. Beggers.
Pakistanis worried about india is the most funniest thing. A country created on the basis of Hindu hatred is concerned about India.
I don’t think they were part of aiml
Nah mate, Paki expats especially in developed countries have great dealings socially, in the workplace and elsewhere with Indians of all backgrounds except Hindu right-wing nationalists (developing malignant views).. who's minds has been corrupted by contemporary anti-Pakistan propaganda by Indian mainstream electronics / TV media channels, etc. So sad, as a LOT of our parents/ grandparents are of course from India & born in India. Sad & sorry for you & at your views.
These Pakistani liberals and their obsession with Prime Minister Modi is beyond me…….When it comes to Modi the views of Pakistani right wing and liberal wing are indistinguishable. Says a lot..
Here's the thing: Pakistanis secretly admire Modi for being a strong and decisive visionary, but they can't reconcile these qualities with him being Hindu. In their minds Hindus are weak and effeminate while Muslims are the true leaders. So not only does Modi's effectiveness refute and rebuke their civilizational "logic", but his transformation of India's fortunes and trajectory sticks in their craw, as does the reality of their great Muslim genius being outsmarted by a "chaiwallah" Hindu.
Because for them Pakistan can only ever be equal to India, or better than it, never inferior. And Islam can only ever be superior and never equal. So take these together and Pakistani Muslims can only ever be dominant, or victims, never equal or inferior to Hindus (and other cultures). Same logic for Islamists. Basically a deep inferiority complex. Hence the obsession and constant comparisons with Modi and India.
Yea sure and BBC news that ran the modi documentary is also madrasachaap and so is anyone in the left-wing. Andhbakht mindset☕️☕️☕️
It's actually for you to ponder as to why even liberals have objections at Modi's conduct. Even plenty of liberal Hindus hate him.
@@muhammadkamranyounis235 don't worry we elect him again because Pakistan has a problem with Modi ji
When Modiji travels in an open car, people shower rose petals on him. Imran gives speeches from enclosed container with a glass hole in it. Go figure 😮
Quite laughable to say that BJP hasn't delivered on Economic Front.
The example that India grew double digits during Congress was because Indian Economy was smaller (10th largest in 2015)
Libya has GDP growth rate of 31% annual, does that mean it's on its way to capitulate US? NO!
Right now, we have 5th Largest economy. And if we go by growth in absolute terms, then I'm sure the numbers are greater than what they were back in 2014.
You can't compare 10% of 100bucks to 2% of 10,000 bucks. China have slower growth rate than India yet in absolute terms it'd be higher than India.
Let's not forget, COVID is followed by a war and global inflation yet India has managed to keep inflation at par with US (currently).
Also to add the kind of Money this Govt has invested in Basic and logistics infra. I have seen my "tier 2" city change infront of my own eyes.
From bus for local connectivity to 2 metro Lines and 1 Rapid Rail line now.
People don't blindly vote for Religion, they vote after seeing the change on ground.
Spot on ... massive infrastructure happening in india . Exports crossed 750 bn$ ...india became 5th biggest economy.
But pakis cant see this ..so is Haqqani.
Not to mention what that growth was at the cost of, record scams and NPAs.
@@MrXperx Infact, huge reduction in both scams and NPAs during BJP's tenure. People in India won't vote for communalism. Remember India voted for Congress and not BJP for a long time. BJP's communal politics is a headache but economically it is one of the best in the whole world at the moment, just by the scale of growth.
@@MrXperx want to know more can you please enlighten me
@@MrXperx in fact it almost collapsed Indian banking. It took more than 4 years to contain NPA problem. I have seen this Pakistan problem to comment without studying.
Multiple incorrect/ bad faith statements by Mr Haqqani in 'India & Modi' segment of an otherwise great podcast -
1. GDP growth rate was never in 'double digits' in Manmohan's govt.
2. BJP has govts in Kannada speaking Karnataka in the south & in Assmese speaking Assam in the north-east India. So, why insinuate that there will be intolerance only in the so called northie Hindi-belt ?
3. 'Anti-Conversion' law is actually 'Prohibition of unlawful conversion of religion' - and applies equally to anybody converting to any other religion . Religious minorities in Pakistan would have greatly benefited had there been such a law in the first place.
This guy knows nothing about Bharat. Congress government ke time pe bharat ka highest growth rate 2010 mai tha 8.5% or inflation bhi 2010 mai hi highest tha 11%.
Last financial year Bharat ka growth rate 8.7% tha or inflation 5.13% tha
There's a barrier after which THEY cannot annalyse. Hindu - Muslim, Pak - India trade. There's a reason why they can't defeat Modi, cause they don't understand Modi. Modi has been CM for 15yrs - belongs to the most backward OBC caste, delivered 10%+ CAGR for 1.5 decade. Add to it Pak has NEVER SEEN A POLITICIAN FROM GRASSROOT who can win a state on his/her own.
Funny thing is, BJP had formed govt. In Jammu and Kashmir with PDP in 2014 after winning more than 20 seats, second only to PDP. If an average paki find these facts out, they will be really twisted let alone Assam and Karnataka.
Bhai the wire pe aata hai ap kya samjha rahe ho mindset toh wahi rahega .
Let them keep underestimating modi and the government. This will only lead to the gap widening as they will watch in disbelief. The anchor is comparing modi to a clown like Imran Khan . Let them... Hum Dekhenge..
I just want to thank Jinnah for dividing them from Bharat except (the crimes he committed against Hindus and Sikhs). because if Bharat was not divided,Bharat would not progress as it is doing now. These people could have become a headache for Hindus,India.
If UP and Bihar also gone with Pakistan, India would be even better.
@@krisgray1957 what is india without UP and Bihar? Many major empires who have ruled the entire subcontinent like Mauryan empire (all) and large ones like nanda , shunga and gupta dynasty are from this region. Buddhism and Jainism formed here and even Guru Gobind singh ji who created khalsa was also born here only .
Festivals like Holi and Diwali are UP festivals , Mahabharat and Ramayan happened in UP , Lord Ram and lord Krishna birth place is here , Sangham in Prayagraj is here and the cultural capital of Hindus Kashi (Varanasi) is here . Even the Rishi who wrote the first Veda Rishi Ved Vyas was born in UP including his father Rishi Parashar and great grandfather Rishi vashisht.
Chanakya and Aryabhatta who gave zero was also from Bihar .
These are just small examples and many are there .
UP contribute 16% of total soldiers to army , biggest Wheat producing state with MP and Bihar is the biggest rice producing state with Bengal . Many IAS IPS come from here .
Bihar is economically poor but UP is developing very rapidly and currently come 2nd or 3rd in SGDP .
Even the Two biggest mahajanpada of 16 were from UP and Bihar only .
just because the region is poor doesn’t mean it has no significance.
@@krisgray1957 Nabi laudakhor tattikhor Muhammad ki badboodar 💩 jaise shakal wale ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool, more like crores of rape jihad born cousin rapist ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool Muslim 🐖 like u from up and Bihar should be shoved up the 💩 islam filled Haji ghazi namazi aashiq gay rasool pichwada of islamic Republic of hira Mandi randistan porkistan bhikharistan Pakistan 😂😂😂😂💩🍑🍆
@vishal . Brother a can you give a little context when you stated "except the crimes he committed hindus and sikhs." With any journal, documentary video, reference books e.t.c?
30 percent of Indians defecate on the streets...32 percent dont have access to potable water very sad.
Laloo Prasad will be upset at you
This is hilarious when an economist such as Uzair Unus visits India and sees the truth and states this is India's moment while the so called all subject matter expert sitting in USA says India will not grow in the future 😅😅😅😅😅😮
He is a Diplomat and worked as High commissioner of Pakistan in Delhi.....So he knows much more than a one time visit 😂😂
@@tejesheconomics4072 If he is so good to understand economics so well as to comment on India's trajectory, he should have long back resolved all problems of a small country such as Pakistan
@@tejesheconomics4072 Indeed they are urban naxals without doubt.Calling a PM murderer and Butcher when the Supreme Court after various deliberations ie court cases, Supreme Court monitored SIT found no merit in the allegations of Murder and Butchery naxals still have the audacity to call him so underscores the fact that our systems requires a systematic cleansing of naxals.See the economic condition of Amartya Sen's mother state.
@@vhtevhte Buddy I called leaders in south asia butchers and Murderers not Modi😂😂 which proves you are already accepting and defending Modi as Butcher and Murderer ...😂😂 What Amartya Sen can do to West Bengal he has no power their...Amartya sen literally criticised Communists more than BJP...why would a naxalite do that 😂😂 I mean the kind of respect the noble laureate gets in india is a proof..India doesn't believe in logic but in magic...that is the reason we have Bageshwar Baba 😂😂 being worshipped not noble laureate.I don't my son to grow in this toxic Hindutva Radical state called Hindu Pakistan. Between I am also Hindu.....Youth like you are the reason I have applied and still trying to leave India ....
@@tejesheconomics4072 thugs have been saying this all along, yet India is doing fine economically. One particular section which keeps themselves in 7th century mindset will not progress, and that is also fine if they wish so. But we don't need lecture from you on butcher. Read how many wete butchered in 47 partition. And yes, we are confident that if you burn is, we will respond in a manner that your 3 generations will shudder to even think of it. Go figure.
This is the problem with elite of Pakistan, they have not idea of ground reality of India. The inflation in Manmohan's time was around 10% to 15%. The average inflation in Modi's regime is 7% for past 9 years, then why the hell common people will not vote against Modi
Bhai aur kam h. The average would be around 5 percent.
@@praveenkaurwar3188 5-7% hai average
modi did a great job in inflation but average gdp growth is only 5.5% in last 9 years, corona ke pahle bhi growth 4% pe reduce hui thi yarr...unemployment rate bhi 7.3% chal rha hai
@@durgeshn8791 bhai mai real gdp growth ki hi baat kar rha hi. Real gdp me inflation cut hoke final amount aata hai, vo hi 6.8% tha dr singh ke time but he failed in inflation. Exports bhi 2004 me $126 billion the jo 2014 me $460 billion hue that is 269% of growth. Ye data bharat sarkar ka hai, pm modi ke time export $460 se aaj $750 billion hue jo sirf 70% ki growth hoti hai. Aur unemployment dr singh ke time 5% thi jo pm modi ke time 7% kam nai rhi. I think jo accha aur bura hua uska maan lena chahiye. Aur ek baat dr singh press conference ke through logo ke questions ko answer bhi karte hai aur kabhi bhi previous government ko blame nai kiya.
@@akshay_wakodikar Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony aur jisko lg rha h fake news hai to lalantop ne video Dali h RUclips p aur Google p search krlo news aa jaygi
Bro am just laughing at this title. Comparing a self made man to an establishment ponny is laughable.
Comparing doesn't mean you are saying the two are the same. Poora podcast sunayn
@ThePakistanExperience you don't compare apples and oranges so why the comparison?
Correct bhai
@@Leftarmleggie you can compare apples and oranges that is why the saying is "comparing apples to oranges"
@@ThePakistanExperience😂😂😂 anguthachaap jahil Nabi Muhammad ke aashiq rasool madrassa chap namazi, the saying " comparing apples with oranges " doesn't mean what u just pulled out of ur ghazi haji 🍑
Comparing Modi with Imran is just comedy.
Modi is politically 1000 times ahead of Imran.
People in BJP have come from cultural, political crucible of RSS.
They are very much connected to ground.
They are not parachuted by Army unlike Imran.
Modi india ka development karna chah rha, or Imran khan civil war.
@@MrRhino101 basically pakistanis lack critical thinking. Modi ne infrastructure, foreign policy, welfare schemes pe jo kam kiya h wo Imam khan 10 janam mai bhi nahi kr payega
Modi is a fake degree holder who likes gobar k parathay in breakfast
@@yasirpk2002 the same modi developed Gujrat in such a way that the 7-8 largest economy of India today account 26% of Indian manufacturing and 4 spot of economy
Just downvote their videos . They include Modi/India just for likes
Nehru was the best PM that Pakistan ever had 😂😂😂😂
Can't stop laughing at the title.😂
47:47 anti-conversion law to ki baat bolke isne Hindu ko Muslim me convert karne ka ki main goal he Pakistani ka ye sabit kar diya
Pakistani media ko to khush hona chahiye na ki India me anti conversation law bana to ab Hindu Muslim ko convert nahi karenge but isko bhi pata hai ki hindu kisi ko convert nahi karte H to M hi hota hai M to H nahi 1000 saal se
Ye log kitne bi liberal BN Jaye lekin soch inki wahi rhegi madrsachap wali. Ye chate h ki jis tarah conversion Pakistan me hta h usi tarah hindu majority country me bi waisa hi ho.. mtlb dono hath me laddu chahiye.
Yahi to locha hai bhai hindu pakistan me bhi anti conversion law mang rahe our bharat me bhi sare mulle tule dono jagah yahi kam me lage huve hai
@@Traveldiary_13liberal nahi hai. Dogley hain.
Pakistanis are sad that "India ab Nehru ka Bharat nahi raha" 😂
they want nehruvian growth and i guess they forget that out of 4 wars 3 wars have congress as a government
The pakistani narrative always stops them from checking the number of hundu muslim riots that happened in nehru's india and modi's india
@@avgman7376 I'm not sure they forget. Perhaps they simply wish India remains gullible. Afterall only an idiot would want a strong opposition, and I don't believe Pakistanis are idiots.
@@avgman7376 fax
Nehru stayed in the wrong country
Thank you Jinnah and Nehru for creation of 2 countries. Indians are really happy and grateful with partition. It was good riddance 🙏
Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony
@@bharatkapoor4062
Avg Pakistani: "Hinduo ke baare me kuch bhi likh deta hu koi kya hi kar lega hui hui hui hui hui hui........"
😄😄😄
@@bharatkapoor4062 prophet was child molester?
@@bharatkapoor4062 in rajasthan muslim cut the head of a tailor just becouse his son repost someone's post
Becouse even there god teach to cut head
Btw jake apna naam shi se rakh sharma Mt bhi tu apne hi Baap ka aulaad hai 😅
@@bharatkapoor4062 link de
Why can't Indians take criticism? Why become hyper nationalists? Its his perception about Indian democracy, so be it. You may agree or disagree but you cannot deny Haqqani is a learned intellectual of international affairs. This podcast is all about playing a critical role about different political models but as soon as someone points India out there is a complete meltdown. TPE is all about growth and giving alternative viewpoints. That is why I listen to each episode even if I disagree.
Well said!
Husain Haqqani is criticizing that the Indian economy is slowing down. He fails to mention that India is today the fastest growing economy in the world.
Aree Husain jee thoda Internet pe dekho Karnataka me BJP ki sarkar h ya nhi. Is he any kind of joke. He is saying India won't grow after 4-5 years. 😂😂😂 Good episode...we should invite him on Kapil Sharma show he is good comedian. 🤣😂
Bhakts come flooding to see India being praised so they can credit it all to Modi and when Modi is criticized, it's suddenly comedy.
@@f.50 Comedy should be called comedy. Usme galat kya hai? Bhakt to Pakistan me hai jo ek lawde ki bhakti me Pakistan jala re
@@f.50 jaldi jaldi name calling kr deta hoon fir dusro ko toh bhi bolna hai
@@f.50 India has grown with or without modi.mits because of inherent tolerance of society.. modi has won the popular vote twice with full majority after 1984 who are we to label him??
@@f.50 aa gaya zombie bhakt bhakt karte karte 😂, can't say about you, but most of the Indians come to these podcasts to know what actually Pakistanis are thinking about us, maybe some do come here to boost their ego, but one can get bored of it very quickly, largely educated people listen to know what these innocent citizens of a nuisance state are thinking about our country India
Comparing Gulliver to a lilliput!!😂😂😂😂
😂
🎯
😂
😂😂
Full support to Aamir UL Momin and Marde Mujahid Imran Khan from India 😂😂😂😂
Modi vs. kHAN
great comedy 🥳🤣🤣
Please don't even try to compare SHRI NARENDRA MODI JI with Imran Khan!!
You're right fascism has no comparison
The more I listen to paksthani podcaster, the more happier i get. Please Continue having the same way of thinking and phakisan will be the superpower in few years.
🙌
I also want them to keep the illusion and hate against Modiji & hindus....atleast 50 more years. Why make efforts to show the reality when they enjoy digging their own graves? Let's wait &watch.
Sarcasm smjh naa aya bhai ko 🤣🤣🤣
@@ThePakistanExperience bro yehh airport nahi hai!! Why are you raising your hands? You won't be body checked here
Sir with due respect Indian politics works bit differently, state elections results hv no bearing on central govt election… and on the growth rate you are comparing double digit growth, tell us which country is growing at double digits now and hv single digit inflation…
Which country is having double digit growth? Not India. India is doing better than most but still growing that fast. And GDP growth doesn't indicate progress (,or lack of it) in healthcare, education , nutrition, etc. Neither does it indicate enrichment of democracy, freedom.
India cannot grow at double digits when the world growth rate is slowing down, to increase growth, export is a big factor that has been impacted by conflict. As you may have somewhere heard, Modi is not in power because of polarization but direct subsidies, LPG schemes, infrastructure, etc. Blaming polarisation and populism is a stereotypical representation of Modi winning elections, which is just outright laziness to not read and research deeper. Congress makes the same mistake.
i call it stereotypical coping .
@@nitishkumar-kc5hv covid... ?
@@prateekmahapatra1789 coping or copying?
@@nitishkumar-kc5hv I would recommend you read research papers rather than Googling and then commenting, if you want I will provide you the links to several of these papers which I am studying for my Ph.D.
@@nitishkumar-kc5hv
Duniya ki economy ka kya haal hai 2019 se ???
This is the right time only to improve relationship under modi regime , if they are thinking about future then they have to remind themselves about Modi successor Yogi Adityanath 😂😂😂
@@pinkythakur9554 we all know modi is coming for 3rd time. And yogi bhakts all know yogi can only come in 2029 if he wins in UP again.
@@rockyyadav1695 yogi is already very popular outside UP
Yogi shayad hi pm ban sakega...amit Shah, nitin gadkari ase leader already line me lage hue hai...
@@Im_AbHiJiT Na na i think it will either be Yogi or BJP decides to venture south they can make Jai Shankar.
Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony
some randomn pakistani youtuber makes a video adds a small time stamp of India and 95 percent comments and views are filled by Indians u very chalak broo
Won't be a long run though! Remember how cricket podcasts were booming during post-Lockdown tournaments and now it's all about the actual match and not much to do with xyz's rants!
*And moreover, Indians only watch these crap for ego-boost or enjoy porkis whinning about their cunt-reee going in the gutter!
My perception of politics has completely changed in the last two years and the credit goes to your podcasts.I've learned so much about history which they wouldn't teach us in school's, and I was one of those people who used to think that political parties specially pmln or PPP etc are the problem, but I was wrong everyone is equally responsible for this mess.
Thank you!
This is the problem with elite of Pakistan, they have not idea of ground reality of India. The inflation in Manmohan's time was around 10% to 15%. The average inflation in Modi's regime is 7% for past 9 years, then why the hell common people will vote against Modi.
Multiple incorrect/ bad faith statements by Mr Haqqani in 'India & Modi' segment of an otherwise great podcast -
1. GDP growth rate was never in 'double digits' in Manmohan's govt.This guy knows nothing about Bharat. Congress government ke time pe bharat ka highest growth rate 2010 mai tha 8.5% or inflation bhi 2010 mai hi highest tha 11%.
Last financial year Bharat ka growth rate 8.7% tha or inflation 5.13% tha.
2. BJP has govts in Kannada speaking Karnataka in the south & in Bengali speaking Assam in the north-east India. So, why insinuate that there will be intolerance only in the so called northie Hindi-belt ?
3. 'Anti-Conversion' law is actually 'Prohibition of unlawful conversion of religion' - and applies equally to anybody converting to any other religion . Religious minorities in Pakistan would have greatly benefited had there been such a law in the first place.
@@user-jt5jz6mq9l Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony aur jisko lg rha h fake news hai to lalantop ne video Dali h RUclips p aur Google p search krlo news aa jaygi
@@user-jt5jz6mq9l Excellent rebuttal with data. Wah bhai wah. You should actually tag "the Pakistan experience" or give this data under his remarks and ask him to respond.
The biggest Thing is Modi is Educating It's population
Educated population doesn't get affected By religion politics and extremism waves
They know what's best for them and the country
Hindus when start asserting against the appeasement politics are termed as Hindutva or radicalisation of Hindus. This narrative by most of the Pakistani analysts are itself flawed and aimed at drawing international attention. Further when Haqqani sir is saying about Indian economy falling is indeed farther from reality.
True. No Paki whether the Left or Right winger will ever see this truth. They have a VICTIM CARD a RELIGIOUS VICTIM CARD to wave always.
Appeasement politics is a lie
Great work, Shehzad.
I think Pakistan looks at India through a very filtered glass.
We are not idiots. People wouldn't choose a government which would break the social cohesion of India. Most of the people do understand the political techniques of bjp, congress and other regional parties. Bjp is very clever, it does populists politics to come in power. But it also has good plans and policies. I am not aware of any anti minority policies implemented by BJP . Isn't anti conversation law a good thing for minorities?
For long India had a image of...... your humble servant.
Congress is still in colonial hangover. It is telling the people that if you vote for the bjp the world will think India is intolerant. Congress has become very incompetent and its only politics is anti-BJP.
At this point, it would be stupid to vote for congress or the grand alliance.
True, and the irony is, in Pakistan Hindu minority are asking for Anti forced conversion law and Muslim majority opposing it, Similarly in India Hindu majority is asking for anti-C law while muslim minority is opposing it🙃.
When you have a fascist totalitarian ideology (my way of high way, anti-multiculturalism ideology on a mission to cnVrt whole world to their ideology), you can't blame ppl of an unorganised pagan(only surviving) to get organise n preserve themselves.
N let's be honest, there's no H-M social cohesion in India, What Pakistanis n western Political gyanis called cohesion==Old Congress model==cucking Hindus, stop em from talking about injustices, past traumas, making them feel ashamed of their identity with fake history like(Hindu Ashoka dumped Hinduism n converted to Buddhism after keeling lakhs).
Once Hindus stop following the above rule->society became Intolerant, cohesion breaks because Hindus won't celebrate Islamic colonizers n oppressors of Past (heros of Indian muslim), Imagine a group of ppl glorifying H1tler etc in Israel n Jews following Indian model allowing all this to happen to make minority happy, upheld multiculturalism🤡.
H-M cohesion is that strong that few archeological surveys, historical surveys shakes the whole country n makes one minority sad😢, they'll say don't associate us with past Islamic colonizers but when someone changes Aurangzeb's named place, they get angry🤣🤣.
Sorry if anyone is offended but you have to say truth as it is without sugar coating it, or thinking about what otrs will think, it'll offend one group, break social cohesion blah blah...
During Modi's period India has grown exceptionally well so much so that it has become the 5th largest economy from 11th position and will soon be knocking to 3rd position .During Manmohan Singh, India's growth was never in double digits. In fact, during Manmohan Singh's first term, India did grow at a rate of about 7/8 percent owing to the good jobs done by Bajpai but during his second term the growth slipped considerably. It was also one of the most corrupt governments. The difference between other PMs and Modi is that he calls spade a spade and pays back in the same coin. He is the most courageous PM India ever had. Besides this, he is non corruptable and doesn't tolerate corruption. He has been holding the top ranking amongst the world leaders since past several years He refrains from minority appeasement for vote bank unlike the Congress government and treated every citizen equally. He has a very firm policy towards Pakistan that terror and talk can't go together which every Indian appreciates. During his tenure, India's infrastructure has grown phenomenally world class and still continues to grow. He might not be suitable for Pakistan because he has cornered Pakistan and isolated it by his aggressive diplomacy but he is definitely good for India.
Not to hate or anything just from my perspective, Modi actually has been shown that he is very anti- muslim in Pakistan or the world by Western media because of funding from George Soros, actually he is just very open about his religion and rituals which someone has the full right too but the muslims here in India too thinks he is anti muslims, he has never given any anti muslim statements and Hindu Rashtriya is actually an ideology which has a geographical significance rather than religious
Some Pakistani intellectuals which are rationale and factual on Pakistan’s issue and problems talks highly of Nehruvian secularism without realizing it is pseudo-secularism based on appeasement of a specific religious community to form a vote bank. The support of modi and hindutwa ideologically is basically reaction of it. And it will continue until the political parties specially those calling themself secular mends there ways and truly becomes secular. Having a separate personal law for Muslims based on religions text and having secular personal laws for other community which is nehruvian secularism is biggest fraud in the name of secularism.
Even though imran khan studied from Oxford but he is not even 0.001 of modi. Modi ji is way ahead of his time
No he is not , just a showbaz like imran khan.
Both are similar to each other one is orange other is green,thats the only difference
It is not about Modi or Khan.. it is all about strong institutions.. India developed and made their structures strong in a positive way and betterment of India.. Well planned !! Modi is a product of pure politics where khan is a counter product of deep state to balance the power and manipulation of perspective.
You can't compare Modi with Imran. Imran Is no where near. Modi can only compare with " Zia Ul Haq" . Zia has redicalise Pakistan and destroy next generation. Modi is doing same thing in india. Believe me people will forget Zia after few years after seeing Modi's damage to our nation and society.
@@shubhamsharma8867 Please don't Aline PM Modi with Sanatan Dharma. It is the plight of us Hindus that I need to tell you this.
@@shubhamsharma8867 Imran coudn't focus on infra development while modi is doing it pretty well. Imran didn't work for digitization of economy which modi did. Imran was called taliban khan and was pro blasphemy laws while modi is sitll dragging his feet on UCC and CAA implementation. Kuch bhi mat likha kar pakistaniyo ke likes lene ke liye.
Very Talented and very straight forward person.... Hussain Haqqani sahab is .
Muslims remind Hindus of their religion. Pakistan reminds India of its nationality. Otherwise India and Indians have always been the believers of globalization and Vasudaika Kutumbam, even before the age of Internet. The reason why we have always welcomed our guests with the most fondness. It’s in our blood!
Modi maybe whatever but he is idealistic and also humble, ascetic in some sense. Imran Khan is a Playboy with an extreme ego. Imran Khan famously said somedays back ki tumse baat karkar cream nikal gaya. I don't think Modi is like that.
Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony
@@bharatkapoor4062 🤣🤣🤣 pakistani
Modi ko koi mu lgaye tb na cream niklega smriti irani p try Kiya ldkiyo k phone b tapes Kiye kch n Mila. Modi k liye uska hath hi Jagannath hai. Imran was cited the sexiest Asian my topmost magazines kha ek Gigachad stud kha chomu
@@MohsinRaza-uq2ow imran khan is just like Muhammad.🤣🤣🤣 full of lust and Demigodry
@@MohsinRaza-uq2ow muh lagane ki baat nhi hoti. Tere papa bhi yhi karte hai kya? Idhar udhar muh marte hai aur ache admi ko judge karte hai.
M of India are suffering and still doing stone pelti**..still doing targe** killings in Kashmir of H , still their population growing , still they are opposing uniform civil code and following uniform criminal code....... if pak has so much concern for indian m ...why dont pak bring citizenship amendment and gives them citizenship?
As usual flogging m issue to keep pak ideology gng.
Bhai, apne Imran ko itna na uthao. Our Modi is different and only one. Pride of many Indians is our PM
There is so much intellectual depth in this video. Should be watched by everybody in the sub-continent
🙌
When it comes to India (or hinduism in particular), Pakistan's liberal and extremist class usually is on the "SAME PAGE." 😉
A good hindu (read Nehru's India) is one who turns another cheek for slap. If he resists, becomes "HiNdoOtVa".
100 % Correct
Well said.
Bilkul pehle lagta hai bande samajdar hai par jab ye hindu par aate hai sara purana majhabi zahar bahar nikalne lagta hai jane anjane me muje lagta hai yah inki aaju baju ki samaj k karan hai
This actually comes from muslim superiority,identy crisis and hindu hatrated..
@@abhijitchakraborty4659 What Superiority ??
Muzlims have not made a single invention despite being the largest followed religion on earth. They have a inferiority complex which is why they use religion to liberate themselves.
Haqquani said the relationship with middle East won't the same as it once were, I hope he was not referring to Nehru period or shastri era whom they put on such regards and in both 47, 65 and 71 war Pakistan enjoyed both arms and diplomatic support from middle East and Indonesia, Malaysia, while Modi who they accuse of religious divide, got full nod, and silence from middle East and Other Muslim countries when he removed article 370, or bombed pakistan. Thease fallacy claims might make you feel good or even enlightened in those disgraced circumstances in Pakistan, but rest of the world absolutely approve of Modi.
This is not because the middle east or Malaysia/Indonesia have developed any long-lost love for India and Indians. It is all due to our economy. If you are strong it attracts more people on your side while if you are weak people leave you. All this is because at this point in time, these countries see more benefit to their being in India's camp and ignore their love for Ummah.
Recently i have started listening your podcast. You are doing great work. One thing i would like to say that Modi government delivers on it's promises. Let me give you an example in 2014 India manufactured almost 0 mobile phones and recently alone Apple exported 3 Billion $ US from India . Pakistan current foreign exchange reserve is 4 Billion $US just let that sink in. Nearly 750 Billion $US of exports of goods and services has been done this year. I am from Delhi , India.
🙌
Under Nehru-Gandhi family's India,Pakistanis had a free run & would get away with it😂🤣....problem with intellectuals like Haqqani they take inputs from a select view & start making judgements in the comfort of their western homes....i'am wondering if these self proclaimed experts will talk about state of minorities in pakistan for even half an hour but have plenty of time to talk about so called intolerance on minorities in India......End result is people can't afford wheat in Pakistan🤣 & there's chaos across muslim world & Muslims can't co-exist with non-muslims & only end up creating clash of civilisations......Final word...draw a line from Baghdad to Beijing & India is the only shining democracy in Asia👍
Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony
@@bharatkapoor14 asli I'd se Abdul 😅😅😅😅
@@bharatkapoor14 log BJP lo vote dete hain hindu mahaasabha ko nhi.
Nowadays Pakistan youtuber ninja technique jldi jldi thumbnail m India mention kr dete hai views aayenge or kuchh b bkwas kis muh se minority ki baat kr re ho 1947 m 23% minority ti ab 2-3 percent b nahi bachi shrm aani chaiye plz hum bht achhe se grow kr re hai apna Gyan apne pas rkhe door hi rho humse aasmani kitab padho or aate ki line m Lago
1947 .... 24 % data of minority comes as east Pakistan ( Bangladesh) and west Pakistan combined..... West pakisthan always has 2-3 %.... 1.5 cr Hindus live in Bangladesh in country of 20-21 cr.... Check d present minority data of Pakistan and Bangladesh ....
PS: but persecution of Hindus in Pakistan is real.
@@allyarjun-hs1xo ally aur Arjun dono se apni begairat behaya ghasti rape jihad me teri 6 saala totally fuckable ammi hazrat Ayesha Zainab Fatima ki Tarah convert hue musalmina ammi khala baaji ka halala karwane wale ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool 😂😂😂
@@allyarjun-hs1xo thanx might be possible your data is right but my point is religious persecution in Pakistan and now a islamic country teachs us a secularism hypocrisy ki b limit honi chaiye
@@World_affairscloud inn chuțiyon ko Pakistani states se jyada Indian state ke baare me pta hai
Don’t degrade Imran Khan ,highly educated , outstanding sportsman handsome God fearing human compared with whom
It's a terrible pity for Pakistan that it's best minds continue leaving the country in huge numbers. Husain Haqqani is one such gentleman having treasure trove of knowledge on international politics, political Islam, foreign policy, & global affairs etc.
😩
Many thanks Shehzad for having him in! Please continue doing the great work you are doing.
👍👍👍
On the contrary radical people like Zaid Hamid is freely living in Pakistan
Problem with knowledgeable people like Hussain sir, is that they largely reply on Indian English newspapers edited by anti Modi editors and journalists who are openly anti Modi, I don't blame him , the fact is they can think whatever they want to, anyways ground reality is completely different, fortunately for us it helps because if this is what there intelligencia really believes then also I am happy 😂
Agree with u . Left media is anti modi ..and they are open about it.
Whole Liberal class of west ...pakis are feed constant churran on india muslims..
Sole goal is to destabilise india as world order changes.
Ground reality totally different...people who lives in india or comes to see india are amazed.
@Modič when did he ever say that? journalists should be neutral neither support Modi nor be anti Modi. Always shouting against Modi even when he's right is not journalism. Media should be neutral without any bias. You mentioned Arnab let me mention raveesh chomu and male barkha dutt
Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony
@@pulkitkaushik who is neutral ? All day hindu muslim debate news channels?
@@Modicdeutsch Lol, for example read the recent BBC article with propaganda headlines on Rhino preservation "India is using Extremists measures and keeling Rhino poachers" and in the article they've added one small line, that security only shoot when poachers fire🤡🤡
Best part of the podcast 1:36:00
Bade badmash ho yaar aap😂😂
Lol
😂
😂😂😂 jabardast yrr
Are these experts really experts? Hindu muslim riots increased after Modi. Bhai kuch bhi.
Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony
@A143 hahahahahahahahaha
@@bharatkapoor4062 it's a country with billion people. You need stats to compare.
Statistically Hindu Muzlim Riots have reduced drastically after 2014.
These Paksitanis don't study and just blabber lies.
Hindu Muslim riots have decreased because now it is one sided lynchings of muslims
The more I hear pakistani podcast.. the more it gets clear.. I am sorry to say there is a clear lack of understanding of statehood .
It's pretty evident to see that how false self made beliefs in Pakistanis skew their perception of the reality of today.
And what's more dangerous is that all this is actually prominent in puedo intellectuals of Pakistan or we can say the elite.
No wonder they have no leader there to look upto because there is no sense of duty in the normal population.
Same here. I have been listening to some of these podcasts in last few monts.
I have observed a common undertone of frustration combined with extremely narrow thought process. Simultaneously, they want to appease Indian crowd for views money.
@@SearchingSerenity bhai tou tu na sun apna paisa time or pesa nai waste ker? 🤣🤣 Just because that person criticized Modi, tum sub lund pe charh rahe ho. Modi IK se bara chutiya ha. I said it again. 🤣
I was expecting more research on Modi's policies by Sir Husain Haqqani, it was always great to listen to his analysis
He is just an English speaking Suit wearing Jihadi. He has dropped chote bhai ka pajama and badae bhai ka Kurta....because he lives in the west...but he is still a Jihadi
I request both of you to see this Kesavananda Bharati Case - An Overview of the Case and the Supreme Court Judgement of India
Article 25: Right to practice & propagate religion
Article 26: Right to manage religious affairs
Article 14: Right to equality
Article 19(1)(f): Freedom to acquire property
Article 31: Compulsory acquisition of property
In a Nutshell the it has been clarified by the Supreme Court that being a part of the Constitution, the Preamble can be subjected to Constitutional Amendments exercised under article 368, however, the basic structure cannot be altered. Therefore it is considered as the heart and soul of the Constitution.
Yeah in Agra hindu mahasabha people cut cow to create communal harmony aur jisko lg rha h fake news hai to lalantop ne video Dali hai
@bharat kapoor please writeci english as i do not understand hindi
@@nalinikoutha2091 Junaid Akram k Puri video hindi mein hoti h wo aajati h
@@bharatkapoor4062 yeah and Muslim jihadist cut open Kanhaiya's throat open in Udaipur to create communal harmony.
Good podcast,
Society mein debate har topic per honi chaiye .
Yaha koi supreme leader ya King nahi hai.
Jiske upper baatein ya question nahi hona chaiye.
Love you bro🇮🇳🇮🇳💓💓
Not all the comments are about one person. They are about the Nation. Moronic comment
Not a supporter of Modi, but no way can you compare him to IK, it's nothing but your bias against him that's showing
Comparing doesn't mean you're saying they're the same
@@ThePakistanExperience u do clickbait.
And yes ....370 was a temporary article..
Read the article and tell whole pak awaam who is forced to stand under the sun.
More Indians listening and commenting on this educated discussion.
Speaks a lot about Pakistan!!
All Modi did was affirm that you don't have to be apologetic about your hindu identity. For 65 years, non-muslims in India were always to told to walk on egg-shells around Muslims and that Muslims deserve extra rights. Hindu politicians from Nehru onwards were gun-shy and too afraid for mini-pakistans arising inside India. Modi is the only one that had the courage to say - ALL are EQUAL
Lol they talking about minorities rights in india 🇮🇳 but ignoring in minority rights in pakistan 😂
They are Pakistanis don’t expect them to be honest.
@@neelamchouhan3834 yess what am I accidentally considered that peoples minorities in india 😂🤣lol
Bhai puri video uspe thori thi
And the award of hypocrisy goes to Haqqani @growth is down because of Modi and in the second line he says @India has big Economic clout, so it gets away. Where do these people come from 😂 Haqqani ji, India will be a $7 trillion economy by 2028, mark my words
5 trillion bola he modi ne tu 7 bolraha he😅
@@hassanahmed541 pade likhe to tum hote nahin ho, Maine 2028 bhi likha hai, India AA jao, yahan hamare musalman Bhai acche colleges mein jaate hain
Logo ko colonial hangover hota hai, innko nehruvian Hangover hai😂
I love watching this video! HQ is one of few left in politics with a sane mind.
Who else can be a better commentator on political Islam than a person who was once part of Jamat e Islami .
Looking forward to his new book .
And The Pakistan Experience and Husain Haqqani romance continues.
In an ironic way, Jinnah greatly helped India by keeping the majority of Jihadi population out of India. Without partition, Muslim population of undivided India would have been 40% of the population. Being ideological and group thinking, Muslims would have pushed jihadi religious politics, which would have greatly hindered India's growth. Therefore, Indians should be greatly thankful to Jinnah for the partition of India.
🙏🏽🇮🇳🙏🏽
It is quite unfortunate that even the educated Pakistanis like Hussain hakkani and almost all Pakistani anchors think that Muslims in India are suffering due to the Indian Government's Hindutva in fact They should visit India or speak to someone who visited India in the recent past to know how the country is progressing in all walks of life which include Indian Muslims also. Modi's mantra is sub ka saath , sub ka vikaas and sub ka vishwas !!! Wait till May 24 -2023 to know how our Kashmir is and compare with the Pakistan occupied Kashmir !!!
They dont care. They have deep agenda to keep flogging m issue of india ..to keep pak relevant. Their sole goal is to destabilise india. Haqqani is a usa citizen now and usa is doing all shit against india since biden came .
Thank you very much for your very informative and very interesting program
It was very nice to hear Hounarable Hussain Haqqani sahib
Masha Allah very knowledgeable person
We need such types of people in Pakistan to lead Pakistan towards prosperity and stability
🙌
During Manmohan Singh growth rate:4-5%
During Modi ji growth rate:6-7%(even affected by COVID and an impending recission)
Aap logo ke conversation se aisa lagta hai ki India ke bare me aap log half knowledge rakhte hain
They are not interested. Liberal fundamentalis* of west and conservative pakis only interested in narrative building to keep pak project alive and it will only remain alive if m issue is flogged continuously.
Very true. They are used to seeing LIBTARD ecosystem media of India led by Coopta, Dallal etc.
Both cant be compared as Modi has been loyal to his own country and he has put India on a path of progress while Khan has taken Pakistan back 100 steps.
Yes you are right religious intolerance is growing in Hindi belt because most uneducated people are from there and also terrorism was a big problem there . I agree this polarisation will not be beneficial for India in a long run but India is still very diverse and a country for all religions
If idiot and ignorance has a face and comment
bsdk angez ke tatte
Haqqanii sahib
It's very true
That's the reason why I get engaged to these Podcasts for hours
Because I am very hungry to know about the real facts
You and Sheherzat sahib must have seen my long comments
Is Modi like Imran Khan?
Consider:
1) Did army or anyone else rig elections to bring PM Modi to power?
2) Was Imran Khan a highly experienced CM for 12 years when he came to power?
3) Has PM Modi caused India’s foreign relations to deteriorate?
4) Has Imran Khan transformed India’s startup economy?
5) Did PM Modi blame his army chief for his political decisions?
6) Has Imran Khan transformed his country’s direct and indirect tax code?
7) Has PM Modi bought Toshakhana gifts at a fraction of their cost and then sold them in Dubai markets while claiming to have sold it in a local market by getting a fake receipt?
8) Has Imran Khan transformed the digital infrastructure of the country particularly the digital payment infrastructure?
9) Imran ran his country’s economy into the ground and further undermined it by giving a petrol subsidy at a time that the country could least afford it. Modi ended the petrol subsidy he inherited from Manmohan Singh and increased metro network from 5 cities to 20 cities. On several occasions on his watch India became the fastest growing large economy in the world.
Yeah looks like they are almost the same.
Peacefuls are being peaceful. This discussion about India part between these two gentlemen tells a lot about how the educated Muslims and uneducated Muslims think. They shall understand the most extreme Hindu will always be more liberal than the most liberal Muslim. Hindus can never go to a place or do things that Muslims do.
Dunia ka koi Sa polititian MODI nhi ban sakta..We Proud Modi born in India for India..❤️❤️❤️✌️👌🤙🤞India LOVE Modi Ji..❤
Youthia podcaster and Haqqani is worried about m of india . These people never ever gets worried about Hindus of pak. These people never get worried about ethnic clean** of hindus from Kashmir.
when their primary sources about india (NDTV, WIRE, QUINT, SCROLL ETC...) are one sidedly biased against modi, we can't really expect them to have proper idea about ground reality of India
Modi has polarized your country. You wont find hateful fascists like you in majority in Pakistan. The ones we have are laughed at and ridiculed. They are not mainstream whereas you lot have bajrangdal, RSS. Far right thugs running the show in your country.
You mean to say, the more reliable sources
Payroll podcast
As soon as Hussain Haqqani was allowed to appear on Pakistani channels, he got Haqqani's podcast.
Hum trends follow nahee kartay
Hum trends banatay hain
ruclips.net/video/n1whXAXmn9A/видео.html
@@ThePakistanExperience LoL, can't make a single video without mentioning INDIA and wannabe a trendsetter... Indentity-chor porki bc! 🤡
It’s unfortunate how the self proclaimed rational Shehzad also couldn’t help but expose his hatred and ignorance towards India. This is not the first time. He tried his best to make the speaker equate the useless Imran with Modi but unfortunately for him, the speaker seems to be somewhat rational.
It is a pleasure to hear Husain on Pakistan Experience. I knew him back in 1970s at Karachi University at the International Relations Department. Congratulations Husain on being a remarkable trail blazer.
🙌
Don't be concerned about India or Indians. Focus on your banana republic. We need Modi to handle the affairs of India. Stop. Don't waste your time.
If he’ll leave Modi n India…how will he gt views…Pakistani RUclipsrs have realized it’s only whn thy mention India n Modi thyll gt views frm India…been listening to this guys podcast fr past 3yrs…all his recent podcasts India n Modi are prime topics.
Tab iss liberal ganduudin fatass ghazi ki begairat behaya mughaliya ammi khala behen ko atta ki line me namaz karna pad jayenga , inshallah mashallah 😂😂😂
Bro chill it was just a question in a podcast, offcourse modi is better for you may he live longer and healthier ❤
Please call Khurram Hussain on part 2 of pakistani economy and current situation of Pakistan economy btw your podcast are very informative ❤❤
On it. I have messaged him.
Before listening Mr Haqqani, I thought he is an intelligent, intellectual balanced man, but I had to change my opinion about him after listening him.
It has become mandatory for Pakistani youtubers to compare Imran Khan with Modi. Modi is a stateman who has been the Chief Minister of Gujarat for 3 terms and the Prime Minister of India for two terms. You cannot regularly win election only with emotional appeal; one has to deliver on the expectations of the people.
But, how would a Pakistani understand this because not a single Prime Minister has completed his full term.
Why is the onus on Hindus to prevent polarization when it is them that have been converted or killed for 1000s of years? In fact, it is faiths or religions that use the word 'only' (only my God is true, my way is the only way) that cause polarization. The word polar itself means mine vs yours. Sanatana Dharma or hindu spirituality is the only one that says every soul is a portion of the same divine and only a different expression of it, and hence all souls are equal in their root form.
In Karnataka BJP is ruling party. Seriously ye nahi pata inhe aa gaye podcast krne both you should read history and plz don't compare India and Pakistan ja k aate ki line Lago two rupees people
He said that bjp is only in Karnataka in South India. Try to listen
@@nitishkumar-kc5hv liberandu be like jldi se bhakt bol deta hi cool lagaunga 😂😂😂
@@sharmaakshay900 goa...puducherry is in north ?
@parth parth karnataka is being talked abt here not pudducherry. Dnt try to change statement u made statement abt karnataka not pudducherry. Learn to admit your mistake
@Jyoti Goswami do u even know what liberalism means ?? If u do then pls explain to me. I would love to see your opinion
Please do podcast with kushal about BJP he campaign for them & different shades of BJP & where Pakistan fit in their agenda & future prospect about relationship
No ,he won't. I hope I am wrong
Very good program; I may not agree with Husen Shahab. But no buddy can disagree with his intellect.
🙌
Nice video. As an Indian, I appreciate constructive criticism. However, comparing Modi with Imran and suggesting that India is moving towards polarization is baseless and irrational. It is important to state facts rather than making unsupported claims. If you want to discuss the policies and steps Modi has taken that have harmed Muslims, it is crucial to present evidence. In fact, Modi has done more for Muslims than any other leader, although the public perception may not align with this reality.
When it comes to a comparison between Modi and Imran, I have never seen Imran Khan discussing his policies, plans for the country, or his achievements. All I have found is a focus on religion, religion, and more religion. On the other hand, Modi consistently talks about his vision, policies, and other important aspects.
Furthermore, discussing peace seems futile when it comes to India and Pakistan. It was Pakistan, not India, that initiated four wars. Leaders like Modi and the late Atal Ji made efforts to engage with Pakistan. India has suffered due to numerous terrorists claiming to be freedom fighters. For the first time, a leader has taken a strong stance and rightfully challenged those who perpetrate violence. It is better to let Pakistan figure out what they want, as India has dealt with enough destruction caused by terrorists...
I love analysis on your programmes. A couple of things about India are off the mark which is fairly understandable.
If u have to compare Imran sahab with any Indian politician then it ought to be Mr Arvind Kejriwal. You will find too many similarities there.
Carry on with the good work.
good point, wish other Indians were also rational like you sir
@@samimusicplay1 Sir, many, more than enough are. But there is a race out there, consumerism, show off, ego, Money , position, jugad, haramkhoree, adjustment , sycophancy, as it is everywhere else these days.
With so many vested agendas, it is rather difficult to be logical rational as well , even basic self respect is missing.
We, and I mean middle class people all around the world are being driven and controlled by any Tom dick or Harry, be it politicians , who would rather keep us divided and fight among us to keep power, religious leaders would have our souls and turn us into non thinking zombies, crooks of all kind for a few dollars more.
We are sheep for slaughter, born to pay taxes and keep working and they will keep us happy by giving us dopamine effect through media.
It's same in Pakistan too. A bit more and a bit worse because population there has been given too much to fear and fight for and even religion has been a bit too stringent.
People who understand can escape all the leftist liberal wokism, and all the bullcrap of the right wing, and keep there sanity and peace.
Modi have to balance both Hindutva liberal ( savarkarite) & Hindu conservative to gain power in BJP that's why Yogi changing his tune from extreme right to right
Religious extremism is actually unattractive. I vote for Modi majorly just for the infrastructure work.
It's unprecedented; India is being built right now!
Would 100% prefer Nitin Gadkari as the next Prime Minister after Modi over Yogi.
@ 47:45 he said about anti conversion law in India, there is no such law exist in India, I would suggest to do some research.
" In 2015, the Ministry of Law and Justice announced that the federal government could not establish anti-conversion laws".
They are suffering from modi phobia
raghav har state luv jihad k base per anti conversation law nhi bna rha hai kyu jhooth bolrhe ho cool bnne k chkkr m.
@@rajatyadav2799
Yadav kya sab gunde hote hai kya … kuch padh le tareeke se
@@vg82 abee tere se jyda pdha hu fuddu samjhe jaahil sacchai hajam nhi hori kya dusro ko gyaan dene se phle apne girebaan m dekh jaandu.
🔊 Loud and clear":::: *WE NOT WANT ANY BAD/GOOD RELATIONSHIPS WITH PAKISTAN.* just be happy in your borders.