Should Man Utd consider making Rangnick permanent? | Gary Neville on United's manager hunt
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 дек 2021
- SUBSCRIBE ► bit.ly/SSFootballSub
PREMIER LEAGUE HIGHLIGHTS ► bit.ly/SkySportsPLHighlights2122
Gary Neville speculates on what would be seen as a success for Ralf Rangnick at Manchester United, and whether his interim role should become permanent at Old Trafford.
Watch Premier League LIVE on Sky Sports here ► bit.ly/WatchSkyPL
►TWITTER: / skysportsfootball
►FACEBOOK: / skysports
►WEBSITE: www.skysports.com/football
MORE FROM SKY SPORTS ON RUclips:
►SKY SPORTS FOOTBALL: bit.ly/SSFootballSub
►SKY SPORTS BOXING: bit.ly/SSBoxingSub
►SKY SPORTS CRICKET: bit.ly/SubscribeSkyCricket
►SOCCER AM: bit.ly/SoccerAMSub
►SKY SPORTS F1: bit.ly/SubscribeSkyF1
►SKY SPORTS: bit.ly/SkySportsSub
►SKY SPORTS GOLF: bit.ly/SubscribeSkySportsGolf 
Спорт
![Ralf Rangnick im Sportstudio über die Viererkette (1998) [English subtitles]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YdptfWFOLkQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Why does this debate start now when he’s only managed 1 game? We’ll see if he gets very good results after 3-4 months at least we can have that debate.
Because the ones running the club are clueless and the fans are desperate
Because sky love milking man united
Because people will click it, just like you and me.
nothing better to talk about maybe
Ole got very good start when he started as interim manager so....
Makes complete sense. He's managed one game. Give the man a 5 year deal 😂😂
He does not need a five year deal just a one season extension before he moves up stairs. The idea that there are better managers out there than Rangnick is just laughable.
What we current have is market of good coaches that are at well funded clubs and people act as if they are geniuses that built the club from the ground.
Klopp bought a £75 million defender four years ago and spent about £100 million on the front line. He is a good coach but people are acting like there are load of them out there and Pochettino is nothing like Klopp and is the most overrated manager in world football right now.
The United way
Yeah right and then make a video 6 months to a year time. Did they rush in making him coach?
@@bighands69 yet united and Everton have spent much more and haven't even mimicked a fraction of what he's done put some respect on his name
This comment doesn't make no sense its Ralf ragnick
Yes, definitely deserves a lifetime contract, his achievements and success with united this season speak for themselves.
United are back!
@@JamesHussain82 thanks , good luck to chelsea too !!
After 2 games??
What's the meme this time after Ole in the wheel?
Sarcasm?
Gary is a good observer of the game, and is a solid pundit. Except when it comes to Utd.
Hahahahhahaaaaahah..you made my day!
Or when it comes to Messi
@@vampycaltm5273 or ole
😁
@@vampycaltm5273 its pretty much linked to United because of ronaldo tbf
Considering Neville thought Ole needed more time. He's not the right man to be talking about standards of this club anymore.
It's impossible to take anything he says seriously anymore
All this says is you still don’t understand why he’s said that. 🤦♂️
Gary has lost the plot
stop listening to him then
Lol and he’ll be in a predicament having to give him the same as he gave Ole, so he won’t be able to criticise as much because he never did with Ole. You went easy on your mate, you have to go easy on every other man utd manager.
Nobody in history as ever said “the club” more than Gary Neville
Tiger Woods
Ronaldinho
lets calm down he won one match. The next few matches should be fairly easy. Infact he should be able to collect atleaast 20 points Out of 39 because of the fixtures
In the PL there’s no guarantees anybody could lose points in the next couple of fixtures but it’s how you lose that matters. Gary Neville is the least person who should be talking because he contradicts himself all the time.
Hes better manger in world allways as been
All of the top teams lose points against these sides every season. Nothings a given.
This is not the french league pal
If you SERIOUSLY think any game in the Premier League is easy then you are watching the wrong sport frankly.
On any given day, ANY TEAM can beat any other team!
Gary's opinion is on the mud at the moment. The man needs a rebuild.
😂😂😂
LMAOOOOOOOO
as it should, i mean we all got opinions but his takes on man utd when ole was manager was a joke
and if that wasn't enough you broadcast them and ask him like he's the guru know it all with all the answers lmao
sky is having a laugh
Agree 100%
@@HeaRtllesSs Ole was a great Manager and Utd's form only dipped after Ronaldo returned , when Cavani was playing up front we were winning game after game then Ronnie came in and it upset the balance of the team . Ronaldo coming back was a boardroom decision not Ole's .
Neville when Solskjær was manager: "We've tried the world class managers with Mourinho and van Gaal, didn't work. We need to trust Ole, he needs more time."
One match after Rangnick: "Let's wait until the end of the season when a world class manager can be brought in, or halfway through the season we might bring in a world class manager."
Yip. I will never forget those comments, or Jamie basically tweeting that he had never heard so much drivel in his life
Yep!
Exactly
It’s been one game!!! This mainstream Media need to stop fuelling this agenda where rival fans will say one game title contenders. Plus Gary Neville has lost a lot of respect from Utd fans for being biased towards Ole.
It's only been one game, he has to finish inside the top 4 and possibly get to a cup final.
He won’t do either but then no one is getting the plastics to a final
At Borussia Dortmund last season we appointed interim manager Edin Terzic. A few weeks into his appointment, BVB announced that Marco Rose from Moenchengladbach would take over from next season. Edin Terzic then rescued Dortmunds season, winning the cup, making the 1/4 finals of the UCL and making up a 12 point gap to make the champions league places. He also built a great relationship with the players and fans. Now with Rose this season, Dortmund are nowhere near that level of last season. Going for the former plan A isn’t always good.
Give him the job until the end of the season and bring in Ten Hag, if it doesn’t go well bring Rangnick back to manage the team.
I actually think that is their plan
Ten Haag has a completely different philosophy and just ruins what Rangnick is trying to build. Need to go for someone in the Red Bull group or just someone who uses gegenpressing and is coming on a step up.
@@bickdig ratio
@@arishemthejudge6780 *when you’re below the age of 12:*
They needed to commit to Jose, the guy go them to 2nd and a few trophies despite not really ever seemingly been backed.
Gary glazer should not talk about Manchester United period. I personally feel nowadays that Glazers were following the mates rates policy to please people like Gary Neville and other media personalities but when they found out that they are damned if they did and damned if they didn't, they got an actual football guy anyway and gave him a lot of power
I'm done with Neville when he talking about United next manager. Gary is part of United problem in Solskjaer's era. These United legend pundits always try to mimic Sir Alex Ferguson, but ended fool us all. I forgive Rio as he realize he's wrong and call out Ole, but Neville still "loyal", which in this case, it's toxic for United ambition.
facts
Rio call him out cause Ole took a pop at him. Had it not happen it would probably be the same thing all along.
Obviously this is all very premature. But my concern would be if he does have an inevitable dip in performance that's so low; it may damage his credibility when moving into the consultancy role.
Can’t tarnish his reputation with a 6-month stint. Unless they’re insanely terrible, which is almost unlikely.
@@zepho100 Soz, it wasn't clear. I meant if he was given the job at the end of the season.
If Rangnick does well and they can’t get Ten Haag, hold on to Rangnick for another season.
Yes. I don’t like Poch
@@12Hydrocarbon me neither, hasn’t done as well as I thought he would at PSG. Also, doesn’t seem like a good fit for Rangnick.
@@lee6704 yeah I don't think Poch could demand respect from the likes of Ronaldo
He was the flag bearer to ole to take the full time role, I even remember he asking what’s the salary you would take in a post interview
Listen Ralph is a breath of fresh air when it comes to knowing how to play football And what team he plays he is going to do well at unt giv him 6 months then take it from the
Imagine having this conversation seriously after just one game with the new manager lol
As a United fan, I've lost faith in Neville's 'punditry'. Perhaps the only reason why I may still tune in because of Carragher. Sigh... Neville's lost all his credibility, if at all he had any. I don't see him last long at Sky, if Sky really mean business.
Neville’s a good pundit when not talking about Ole.
@@liampowell5014 facts when he speaks about United it’s like he can’t stop his bias from creeping in especially ole
"where it went wrong with ole" ----he is not a good enough tactician, he did not prove anything before coming to Utd and when things got bad players lost confidence in him, also he can't be a leader especially for "stars" like Pogba, Sancho, Rasford.....
Ronaldo coming to united just made that gap between Ole and the players even bigger. Rangnick will make everyone responsible, but he will succeed more than Ole just because the players will perceive him differently than they did Ole....
It depends on Rangnick if he advises the board that he wishes to stay longer with the team then they will take it into account but the board needs to be interviewing/considering potential managers now.
YES 100% he is a football man we have been crying out for this for 8 -9 years give him a go i can see us getting top 4 know problem then in a few years winning the league
“Listen, Man United might not thank me but get the contract out, put it on the table. Let him sign it. Let him write whatever numbers he wants on there, given what he's done since he's come in. Raplh's at the wheel, man. He's doing it. He's doing his thing. Man United are BACK.”
He’s only been there 5 minutes. Let the f00L win something first. D@mn!!!!
the second i saw the title and thumbnail is literally said out loud "oh my god its BEEN ONE GAMEEE!"
Honestly. That was really well put
After how Gary's been going around during Ole's reign (especially in comparison with his statements during previous managers' time), I don't think he should ever talk about managerial position, managers' success or anything else manager-related in Man United again.
Tbh I feel like Rangnick only recommends he has another 1yr to be the manager because he’s very confident he can win the league with the team by next season, he sees it as an opportunity to finally prove he’s good enough to win a league cause that’s what everyone seems to discredit him on! We’ve got a great team in United, he sees it as an easy job…my opinion 🤷🏾♂️
I truly think we're not that far away.
If we our players consistently perform to the level they're capable of, and we get a cdm, we can seriously challenge.
DDG, Bruno CR Varane are world class. Sancho, Shaw Greenwood Rashford are all top players.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Glory glory man united
Anybody else notice the badges behind them show last seasons teams? 😄
I think they should consider consider
No. This happened with ole. Let him stay till end of season then go Into his role behind the scenes
Everyone said “give Ole the contract” after a few games won. Having barely experience in Europe. Ralf has a lot of experience, has an identity. He has more validation than what Ole had. With Ole nobody doubted and they’re all doubting with Ralf. Makes no sense. I would give Ralf at least 1 year, having the preseason to prepare the team. I would love that
Gary spot on.
As an Arsenal fan, can we have Ole? Least we’ll finish top 4 each season. Oohhh how I miss the days when we were mocked for always finishing 4 but played prime Barca/AC Milan/Bayern every season. Simpler times lol 😂
How is playing Barcelona, AC Milan and Bayern every season an accomplishment? What you have said just reaffirms the problem at Arsenal: complacency and a mid-table club mentality. Playing aforementioned clubs in the CL every season would be an accomplishment for a smaller club, not a club like Arsenal. Top 4 every year, an FA cup here and there is not good enough for Arsenal.
I’m a Utd fan, by the way.
@@h8koN
>Making the champions league each year
>Mid table mentality
I'm not an arsenal fan but wat
@@Welshhomie Viewing just being in the CL as good enough/participation trophy is the mentality of a club not used to winning. Arsenal are bigger than that.
It’s not rocket science.
Ole had a a league winning squad at united and he finished top 4, he'd finish worse than Arteta with this arsenal squad
When we were finishing 3rd or 4th we were gunning for titles not just content qualifying for europe then getting thrashed eight goals or something if you call yourself a fan
they act like rangnick isnt a top class manager. he proved that many times at hoffenheim, schalke and leipzig. what more do you need? he is also great at getting a whole club into the right direction. of course, if he doesnt succeed, then he will be fired but im optimistic about this. he has all the skills, that are needed to do so. you dont need to search for anything, if it works out as expected. united can be glad, that he was willing to do this job and was available.
United have had COUNTLESS top managers since SAF, Jose - Van Gaal like them or not they were more successful than Rangnick. If he can't get them back to the top with this squad then look elsewhere, even Jose got them to 2nd.
@@jamesanthony4946 but rangnick never trained a top tier club. he has always had kind of the most success possible. im not saying, that those other guys, that you have mentioned are not great coaches but rangnick is also a great manager for the greater picture. jose and luis were "only" great coaches.
Man United will have big succes ...this guy is the goat from Germany grettings from Germany Stuttgart . man United we back
Who noticed *Considere Consider* in the title?
Football is to reactionary nowadays. 1 game and you're already discussing his performance and if he should be permanent. Thought pundits would be a bit more knowledgeable
What is the criteria for a 'world-class' manager. What makes Pochettino a world class manager? I'm not saying he isn't, but what constitutes one?
Facts
@@chedbeckford8067 certain terms get used so often they almost lose meaning.
@Rohan Chatterjee Which team of the calibre of PSG has Ragnick managed? Pochettino cannot be considered world class on the basis of winning the French Cup. Maybe on the basis of something else, but not the French cup surely.
@Rohan Chatterjee plus, Rangnick has won the Pokal, so you're actually wrong there.
@Rohan Chatterjee ralf made the champions league semi finals with Schalke. That's a bigger achievement than Poch winning the French Cup with Psg
Gary has attended some me sprint session to deliver MVP
So we now have a technical director (would love to know what exactly that entails), we also now have a football director, and if Rangnick moves upststairs he will be a football consultant. I wonder what any world class manager would think about that? Add to the fact that a new manager will still ultimately report to our new c.e.o.
That it's a standard practice for modern top clubs? What exactly is your point?
Once the honeymoon period is over, the question that remains : is Ralf really a world class manager ? History hasn’t suggested it but he has never coached a world class team. I have no doubts that he is a world class student of the game. But a world class manager is different and trophies remains the gold standard. I really, really want Professor Rangnick to succeed.
What makes you think there is a world class manager out there at the moment and that a world class team exists right now?
@@bighands69 are you saying pep, klopp, liverpool and man city aren’t world class?
Reached the CL semi finals with Schalke and promoted 20 teams to the bundesliga. He also turned Leipzig and Salzburg from league 4 teams to consistent participants in the champions league
@@bighands69 I’m sorry but from my perspective, my Manchester United team will always be world class. And yes that’s a side effect of extreme loyalty no matter what happens. Regarding your second question about a world class manager, I don’t quite understand it. There are multiple world class managers out there at the moment managing teams across Europe and I’m not going to insult your intelligence by listing them.
@@dilyanal-kasem4139 His CV is impressive given the teams he coached and how transformative he was. I personally think he is a genius. I’m really rooting for him to gain that world class status he deserves. I’m sick and fed up of listening to ppl praise Klopp, Pep (and rightly so). I think it’s time for us United fans to have someone to puuuurrrrr about.
Ole's tenure was not "so good" as they say. There was still no structure and identity. It was just a feel good factor which produced results but it has always been free style football from day one with Ole.
I totaly agree with him if top manager is available at the end get the manager if their is no manager available keep going with him .
Neville is in dreamland
No, imo we need people at a consultancy role who actually knows what they are doing. If united get ten hag in the summer, we would finally be a title contender again and trophies would be coming to our trophy cabinet. This is what we need.
This is why Man United get absolutely nowhere, blokes been in charge one game and there’s talk of him being permanent already
Why not?
Are you one of these fans that wants managers changed every six months because they are not playing like your FIFA team.
@@bighands69 Because look what happened with Ole, history is going to repeat itself we give him the role now
@@bighands69 managers are replaceable not just in football it’s the same in any business there are standards
@@bighands69 What are you even on about😭, fans like you are the reason Ole had about 3 years in charge that we’re totally wasted
@@baldalan3921
Just admit it you probably wanted Moyes out so you campaigned and you probably did that to every manager since then.
They are never good enough for you and the moment you get your man in you probably pretend you never wanted them in.
Ole built a team because he arrived there was no backline, midfield or attacking line. The only positives Utd had when Ole took over was that Pogba and Rashford were at the club.
Tell us did you like Lukaku at the club?
Gary Neville was a world class manager.
I would keep giving him a 6 month extension manager contract with 2 year advisory role starting at the end of that for as long as he gets good results.
Imagine picking your next permanent manager based on him beating Crystal Palace 1-0 in his first game in temporary charge.
Man Utd are a joke that it's even being talked about - this is how you expect them to make decisions now.
But united haven’t picked their permanent manager based off a 1-0 win against Crystal Palace? 😂 This is just a panel of pundits discussing it hypothetically.
@M E
Imagine a toxic fanbase that does not want the club to develop some sort of new way and want their favorite FIFA players and their favorite coach of the hour.
And a toxic fanbase that would turn on a new manager and pretend that they did not want him in the first place.
@@lee6704 but that's what I said - the fact that this ridiculous idea is even being floated as a talking point shows how the decision making
within the club is being perceived
- it's not what they've done, but if they did, no one would be surprised.
I'm skeptical about this moving upstairs role, he is either a DoF or a manager, but I can't think on any circumstance in this country where a manager has done that and its gone well.
I'm a Blackburn fan and Kenny decided he didn't want to be manager anymore, they put Kenny upstairs and Ray Hartford got the job and it just didn't work. Players don't know who to look too, fans don't know who's in charge, even for the manager they are basically coming in underneath the person they're replacing.
Why does the MNF background behind Dave Jones have the teams from last season?
Amazing that they still haven't fixed the error in the video title.
Let’s stick to the plan; bring a top manager in for the next season. If anything gone wrong, Rangnick is still up there and he can come down to help no mattter what!
United fan here but it's so funny that he mentioned world class manager now but didn't when Ole, his mate, was in charge
Gary 'At this moment in time' Neville
They supposed to give him more time,this guy know what he is doing..Pochetino is having all the stars at Psg,and they still not looking like a team
True, psg fans complain that he doesn’t have tactics. I think he is same with ole
@@ootdbabangtamvan9275 same Ole,😀
Nothing better than an unbiased sensible opinion from a very great pundit that is, Gary Gunnar Solskjaer
Gary and Jamie ...feel for sky subscriber's.. 🙏
Did you cut the "and Liverpool" from that
Yes utd should give rangnick a long term contract. He may only have won one game but he did so off the back of a single training session. The improvement in utds game generally speaking has been 100%
Rangnick at the wheel
United is back!
*slaps hands*
Oh yh Gary's great unbiased anylysis.
Legend has it, Gary neville wants Ole back at the wheel
One match and all these people are acting like he has made a long term impact. By all accounts Eddie Howe is also Newcastle's greatest manager too for winning their first match of the season.
If he does well in the next few months. They should consider consider him.
What's the difference between being "agile and flexible" and "not having a clear long term plan"?
Results. If it goes badly, neville and 9thers will say they should have had a long term plan but right now he's encouraging them to just go with the flow.
Sounds like they are maybe being a little over cautious if they need to consider if they should even consider making him permanent!
Bruh I’m a United fan and already in love with Ragnick but it’s way to early it’s literally his first game
Ralf is world class
Yeah I would agree it's only one game, but we got hopes 👹🤔
Gary you have had good managers. The trouble is the players. They are destroying the club. You need to admit it's time for a clear out.
We should give him time. We cannot judge in 1 game. Yes player's have understood his game theory and they have started to respond.
My concerned question is will jess lingard leave man utd today? I'm so confused...so people are saying yes or no can somebody tell me the correct answer?
Ppl will say its just Palace and all but its not about beating one good team like Chelsea liv or City. Its about being consistent no one can go unbeaten whole season with this much competition in pl
Consider Consider
Wait till the end of this season. Judging by the team he turned out against Young Boys he his trying out all players THEN he will decide who stays and who will go. He has to bring these players back to their full potential. Those who can not achieve this I can see him letting them go. I feel sure that bringing new coaching staff thinks will defiantly change.
Why have they still got the Fulham, Sheffield United and west brom badges on the backdrop behind them? That was last season and we're almost at christmas
@gary mate what with the extensive use of the word "agile"- doing any SCRUM lately :)
Man United may not thank me for this but get the contract out, let him write whatever numbers he wants on there. Ralf's at the wheel man he's doing his thing!
Man united forever 😎💪
Why are Sheffield United, West Brom and Fulham on the screen in the back?
0:30 Garry turned into Borat for a minute lol
Listen, Man United might not thank me but get the contract out, put it on the table. Let him sign it. Let him write whatever numbers he wants to put on there, given what he's done since he's come in. Ralph’s at the wheel, man. He's doing it. He's doing his thing. Man United are BACK.
Still waiting on Keanes reaction to Fred’s goal
They should think think about it
The backround is for the 20/21 season 😂
Consider considering
no need to rush on anything relax wait till end of season every single thing will be clear the team the play and the manager so as other managers available in the market
has anyone noticed that sky hasnt changed the MNF screen from last szn? west brom, fulham and sheffield united are still there lmao
Yes he should be the manager. He is a technical man
Man U does well with older managers for some odd reason
What Gary Neville is saying makes no sense, as usual. He says he thinks it’s right that Ole got the job, but then later says if a world class manager became available, the people upstairs should consider him (and he uses Poch as an example - Poch, who was available the day when Ole got the job FT).
Gary.......SPOT ON
Incase we fail to land ten hag next season then yes let's extend ralf contract for one more season, but atm go for ten hag whatever it takes, ralf is a great coach however from what i see his true strength is when he act as sport director like what he did for the red bulls
And what then if Ten Hag cannot turn it around overnight. Do you want another manager in. Utd have to start investing into development that has a great view than one season.
We now have a coach that builds teams and coaching systems and he needs time. What could he possibly achieve in 6 months?
People are acting as if Klopp or Pep or Tuchel could turn that team around in half a season. And here is a thing Tuchel still may end up getting fired at Chelsea.
Aye they do need to consider consider
Finally Neville’s talking abit of sense