सबसे पहले राज्य सभा टीवी टीम को धन्यवाद देता हु कि आपने इतना बेहतरीन प्रोग्राम प्रसारित किया ।मेरा मानना है कि भारतीय शिक्षा पद्यति में खामियां है लेकिन उनको सुधरने के लिए जरुरी है ग्रामीण क्षेत्रो में भी स्कूल जाने की पहल हो , माता पिता भी बच्चों को स्कूल जाने के लिए प्रोत्साहित करे , साथ ही साथ उनका असेसमेंट खुद भी करे और अगर उन्हें लगे की बच्चा अभी भी अपने क्लास के स्तर की जानकारी नहीं सीख पाया है तो इसकी शिकायत उस स्कूल के प्रधानाचार्य से करे , मैंने देखा है कि सरकार ग्रामीण स्कूलों में बेंच कुर्सियों की व्यस्था करती है लेकिन ग्रामीण उसे वहां से अपने पर्सनल उपयोग के लिए चुरा ले जाते है तो कही न कही ग्राम वासियो को भी इन चीज़ो के प्रति सजग होना चाहिए । और तीसरी बात ये कि जिस इलाके में स्कूल है वहां के उच्च वर्ग के लोगो को भी उस क्षेत्र के विकास के लिए सहयोग करना चाहिए। तब जाकर शिक्षा व्यवस्था और सामाजिक स्तर सुधरेगा। यहाँ पर तो अपना काम बनता , भाड़ में जाये जनता वाली स्थित बनी हुई है। जय हिंद
सबसे महत्वपूर्ण बात ये है कि सरकार को teachers को प्रशिक्षित करना चाहिए वो भी बहुत अच्छी तरह से। यदि teacher skillful और पढ़ाने का तरीका जानता है तो बहुत अच्छा रहेगा
डर करणी , डर परम गुरु, डर पारस डर सार । डरत रहे सो उबरे , गाफिल खाइ मार । अभी इसी चर्चा मे हम सभी चिंता ( भय) मे है हमारी शिक्षा को लेकर ! तो नया सोच रहे है ! मैं मानता हूँ retention policy is useful !
Prof. Rampal is absolutely right ie. Que in exam not focus on thinking out of box / unique ideas but instead bookish knowledge only Teacher is not only to teach student & learn them But also made them to think which is lacking !! For ex- if a que asked to student other than given in book then he /she not able to speak a single word about it bcz they were not made to think . So finally need to focus on quality education MODERN EDUCATION
इन सब की बातों को सुनकर अब समझ में आया सारी परेशानियों का solution गुरुकुल शिक्षा प्रणाली ही है Rajeev dixit ji ko jarur sune ruclips.net/video/3wFqGt9-I0Y/видео.html
This is how the debates are to be conducted..full of insight fullness..not like arnab goshwamis show..loating each other and creating a scenario like fish market..
परिवर्तन को समझने की जरूरत है ....शिक्षा क्या है ....यूरोप में शिक्षा का मतलब है प्रैक्टिकल जीवन शैली ...भारत में शिक्षा का मतलब है ....समाज में सम्मान का सुचक....इसलिए बीई,पीएचडी, करनेवाले तो बहुत है पर उसका उपयोग कैसे करना है मालूम नहीं .....A.p.s Batham. ....
Public awareness and mobilisation is required , society as a whole really need to understand the concept of education and its value. Education as an issue need to be at the forefront of public debate.
The condition of Indian education system is in extreme grief.. The main reason behind it the lack of awareness among the parents of village areas.. They do not know the importance of education and their implementation in life.. So it's a first duty of the government and the local authorities to spread awareness among the people of village areas.. Children have to spent 4-5 hours in the skl and whole day in the home.. If parents will not aware than it can not be possible for any one to improve the quality of education.. Besides this should have common education at least at primary level..
Discussion Topic is most important ..hamari education system ki asaliyat world bank ne batayi tab hum discuss kr rhe hai. We must be serious abt our education System..spesially in rural areas Govt. Schools... now need of well nd quality education to given our rural children than the able to find out solutions from their problems...like poverty
Good .... This shud be told to Uddhav thakre ...he is closing 4000 school in Maharashtrala...they r supporting Pvt school as they are in coalition with NCP ....
Kamlendra Singh in bato ko bol kr ap log plla jharjate h mid day mil m konsa khana techaro ko bnna hota h government se ap moti rakam lete h to kam or farz v apko hi krna parega na
Mai bhi ek b. Ed ki student hu aur jo kuch shiksha ki pahlu h usko aab samajh pai hu..... Garib garib bolke unka majak banate ho aur desh shikshit nhi ho pa rahs h kabhi vahi bachho ke halat ko jano to samjhoge ki vo bachha kis muskil se Gujrat h... Class room process me ek teacher ki bhumika sabse important hoti h pratek teacher ka yah kartavya h ki bachho ko unki boli... Bhasha. Unki samajh ke stander ke anusar hi bachho ko shikshit kare... Bachhe ki ruchi ko mahatva de uski soch ko tark viratk chintan manam ki shakti ko badhana chahiye... Padhana ke samay aur padhane ke baad kitne bachho ne kitna shikha kis bachhe ne shikh nhi paya ye sab dhyan teacher ko dena chahiye........ Shiksha ka.. Vyaparykaran. Nini karan. Vaishvikaran. Upneveshikaran. Kar doge to jo raveendra nath ji ne mahatma ji ne jo buniyadi shiksha ki bt kahi h vo kabhi bhi safalta ko prapt nhi kar payega.... Aur bs Humesha yese hi niti banai jayegi aur usse kuch nhi hoga dekh lena.. .... Shiksha ka to astitva hi badal diya h inlogo ne.........
i only have question to Mr. subramanian you were in administration for last 35 years what were you doing at that time.... problem is that people like you when had authority you dont do any thing and now after retirement you are crying..
teacher's training and govt's active participation is must. Also contract based jobs are temporary and people with good ability don't go for teaching jobs because it doesn't look beneficial for their future. Govt schools in Delhi have improved significantly due to political engagement and greater resources to education. Also failure in the examination creates unnecessary pressure in the minds of children and later on those performing weak start creating some tendencies of deficiency. Better to evaluate them and retake the exam instead.
Mid day meal is one of the biggest problem.in govt school most of teachers are busy in calculation. like how much one can save. Government should make another department for mid day meal which keep teacher out of this
SARKARI JOB aur politicians ke liye apne bacho ko govt school m padana mandatory hona chahiye tbhi ye buerocrates aur politicians education m reform laynge
mera like education ke is mhan reformist k liye h jisko ts subrmanyam khte h agr ye sifarishe hmari andhi sarkare lagu kr de to bharat ka bahivsy behtar hoga
even if students are educated do u have proper jobs to employ them...??? instead the poor ppl feel investing in education is not a better option rather they drag them to child labor..atlest it meets their economic requirements in short time..no wonder we c many child beggars in India..Education to door ki baat h , yaha to 2 waqt ki roti b nai milti kai logo ka...
A goal set to to achieved by 2080 is not yet achieved? When I go to India, I see almost no improvement. In fact, it is much worse than we went to school in fifties and sixties! Privatization has divided the nation, Education is for the rich only!
education di jarhi h or berozgari baday jarhi h....aj shikshit hi aprado ko bdhava dene m aage h ...or ek nirbl jesa vivsh lif jine ko vivsh h ....geevn k bahumuly sal gvane k bad bhiii...smaj m educated ko woh smman nhi mil rha jo milna chahy....b.com.ma.etc...pas low post ki lambi line m lge nzr ate h ....puritrha nirasha s bhare huy h ag k shikshit....bqz.....hmari GOVERNMENT ko shiksha or shikshito ka smman nhi ata ....ek chay vla nhi janta smman shittt
dusare kaksha ke chatra do akshar nahi padh raha hai...shiskshit shikshak lage hai padhaneme nahi..caste aur politics me busy hai....agar padhate hai tho subject nahi sirf caste politics padhate hai....reason kya hai????? lack of descipline,,,are time pe ana aur gappe marna peth bhar khana sub karna lekin planned teaching nahi padhana nahi tho kya shiksha ka sthar sudhrega???? yaha discipline hai???? ek hal hai har ek shiksha samstha me pehele LIVE ka arrange kare....ek step tho equrate kare .baadme baate aur discussion ke bare me..soche.self descipline,self regultion automatically a jayega.
Ye line to line letter kyo padhte hai please change the anchor. You have very good anchors like kavindra, Deepak,amrita Rai,but Why are giving such a good program to worst anchor of Rstv
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
सबसे पहले राज्य सभा टीवी टीम को धन्यवाद देता हु कि आपने इतना बेहतरीन प्रोग्राम प्रसारित किया ।मेरा मानना है कि भारतीय शिक्षा पद्यति में खामियां है लेकिन उनको सुधरने के लिए जरुरी है ग्रामीण क्षेत्रो में भी स्कूल जाने की पहल हो , माता पिता भी बच्चों को स्कूल जाने के लिए प्रोत्साहित करे , साथ ही साथ उनका असेसमेंट खुद भी करे और अगर उन्हें लगे की बच्चा अभी भी अपने क्लास के स्तर की जानकारी नहीं सीख पाया है तो इसकी शिकायत उस स्कूल के प्रधानाचार्य से करे , मैंने देखा है कि सरकार ग्रामीण स्कूलों में बेंच कुर्सियों की व्यस्था करती है लेकिन ग्रामीण उसे वहां से अपने पर्सनल उपयोग के लिए चुरा ले जाते है तो कही न कही ग्राम वासियो को भी इन चीज़ो के प्रति सजग होना चाहिए । और तीसरी बात ये कि जिस इलाके में स्कूल है वहां के उच्च वर्ग के लोगो को भी उस क्षेत्र के विकास के लिए सहयोग करना चाहिए। तब जाकर शिक्षा व्यवस्था और सामाजिक स्तर सुधरेगा। यहाँ पर तो अपना काम बनता , भाड़ में जाये जनता वाली स्थित बनी हुई है। जय हिंद
नेताओं और जनता के पास education पर बात करने के लिए समय नहीं है।वे अपने अपने कार्य मे busy हैं । जगाओ भारत जगाओ।
Kurban Ali sahab aapka questions bahut accha hota h. Always relate question according to UPSC also please.
Best channel and anchor second to none Ravish kumar
सबसे महत्वपूर्ण बात ये है कि सरकार को teachers को प्रशिक्षित करना चाहिए वो भी बहुत अच्छी तरह से। यदि teacher skillful और पढ़ाने का तरीका जानता है तो बहुत अच्छा रहेगा
सभी विद्यालयों में एक ही बोर्ड की किताबों को लागू किया जाए ।
ताकि बच्चों की शिक्षा में परिवर्तन न रहे।
डर करणी , डर परम गुरु, डर पारस डर सार । डरत रहे सो उबरे , गाफिल खाइ मार । अभी इसी चर्चा मे हम सभी चिंता ( भय) मे है हमारी शिक्षा को लेकर ! तो नया सोच रहे है ! मैं मानता हूँ retention policy is useful !
Prof. Rampal is absolutely right
ie. Que in exam not focus on thinking out of box / unique ideas but instead bookish knowledge only
Teacher is not only to teach student & learn them
But also made them to think which is lacking !!
For ex- if a que asked to student other than given in book then he /she not able to speak a single word about it bcz they were not made to think .
So finally need to focus on quality education
MODERN EDUCATION
Kurban ali aap ka debate education programs per jaberdast laga
Thanku so much sir
Qurban.sir...thnx a lot for this excellent debate..,very useful for aspirants ...thnx to rstv also...
Anita ji ka quality par bahut acha speech raha
जिससे उन बच्चों का मूल्यांकन सरलता से हो।
तथा उन की शिक्षा में कमी को सुधारा जा सके।
Good program for Desh deshantar.....but last conclusion small...when something big conclusion
इन सब की बातों को सुनकर अब समझ में आया सारी परेशानियों का solution गुरुकुल शिक्षा प्रणाली ही है
Rajeev dixit ji ko jarur sune
ruclips.net/video/3wFqGt9-I0Y/видео.html
This is how the debates are to be conducted..full of insight fullness..not like arnab goshwamis show..loating each other and creating a scenario like fish market..
परिवर्तन को समझने की जरूरत है ....शिक्षा क्या है ....यूरोप में शिक्षा का मतलब है प्रैक्टिकल जीवन शैली ...भारत में शिक्षा का मतलब है ....समाज में सम्मान का सुचक....इसलिए बीई,पीएचडी, करनेवाले तो बहुत है पर उसका उपयोग कैसे करना है मालूम नहीं .....A.p.s Batham. ....
Public awareness and mobilisation is required , society as a whole really need to understand the concept of education and its value. Education as an issue need to be at the forefront of public debate.
The condition of Indian education system is in extreme grief.. The main reason behind it the lack of awareness among the parents of village areas.. They do not know the importance of education and their implementation in life.. So it's a first duty of the government and the local authorities to spread awareness among the people of village areas.. Children have to spent 4-5 hours in the skl and whole day in the home.. If parents will not aware than it can not be possible for any one to improve the quality of education.. Besides this should have common education at least at primary level..
Discussion Topic is most important ..hamari education system ki asaliyat world bank ne batayi tab hum discuss kr rhe hai. We must be serious abt our education System..spesially in rural areas Govt. Schools... now need of well nd quality education to given our rural children than the able to find out solutions from their problems...like poverty
sahi baat
Nitin Mohan Saxenp
sahi bat hai
do parkar ke sichha prnali ko suchar kar same kre or teacher pr bhi work ho to , main anita mam se sahamt hun
sahi bat hai sir g
Good .... This shud be told to Uddhav thakre ...he is closing 4000 school in Maharashtrala...they r supporting Pvt school as they are in coalition with NCP ....
it's 100 present right
teachers se teaching ke alawa kitne kaam karaye jaate hain- saamohik vivaah me khana baatna, odf related works, mid day mil a lot type of others.
Kamlendra Singh in bato ko bol kr ap log plla jharjate h mid day mil m konsa khana techaro ko bnna hota h government se ap moti rakam lete h to kam or farz v apko hi krna parega na
I wait for jan sansad program
Rest in peace dear TSR Subramanian sir....
Sbushma g ka suggestions shi h ki fel n krne se teacher laprwahi kre ge
common school system hona chahiye
sahi baat
सर इस वार्तालाप में बोलने वालो के बच्चे कहा पढ रहे है
vajib saval dost
Yahi to vidambna hai is desh ki log A.C . Me baith gareeb-gurbo ke liye niti Tay karte Hain... Bloody Lutians...
sahi baat
Great question
Sir bahut hi uttam swal
I take down this lecture.video was very nice and important.Govt.'s will good efforts in the education field. Thank you
High level education kin desho ke baad india me
Mai bhi ek b. Ed ki student hu aur jo kuch shiksha ki pahlu h usko aab samajh pai hu.....
Garib garib bolke unka majak banate ho aur desh shikshit nhi ho pa rahs h kabhi vahi bachho ke halat ko jano to samjhoge ki vo bachha kis muskil se Gujrat h...
Class room process me ek teacher ki bhumika sabse important hoti h pratek teacher ka yah kartavya h ki bachho ko unki boli... Bhasha. Unki samajh ke stander ke anusar hi bachho ko shikshit kare... Bachhe ki ruchi ko mahatva de uski soch ko tark viratk chintan manam ki shakti ko badhana chahiye...
Padhana ke samay aur padhane ke baad kitne bachho ne kitna shikha kis bachhe ne shikh nhi paya ye sab dhyan teacher ko dena chahiye........
Shiksha ka.. Vyaparykaran. Nini karan. Vaishvikaran. Upneveshikaran. Kar doge to jo raveendra nath ji ne mahatma ji ne jo buniyadi shiksha ki bt kahi h vo kabhi bhi safalta ko prapt nhi kar payega.... Aur bs Humesha yese hi niti banai jayegi aur usse kuch nhi hoga dekh lena..
.... Shiksha ka to astitva hi badal diya h inlogo ne.........
i only have question to Mr. subramanian you were in administration for last 35 years what were you doing at that time....
problem is that people like you when had authority you dont do any thing and now after retirement you are crying..
One tax, one education system, one reservation
Thank you!!
Sahi hai
teacher's training and govt's active participation is must. Also contract based jobs are temporary and people with good ability don't go for teaching jobs because it doesn't look beneficial for their future. Govt schools in Delhi have improved significantly due to political engagement and greater resources to education. Also failure in the examination creates unnecessary pressure in the minds of children and later on those performing weak start creating some tendencies of deficiency. Better to evaluate them and retake the exam instead.
Koi pm ji ko bataye yuva ladko ko job chahiye...naukariya nikale
Mid day meal is one of the biggest problem.in govt school most of teachers are busy in calculation. like how much one can save. Government should make another department for mid day meal which keep teacher out of this
Sudhakar Kumar right say. midday bhojan ka paisa sidhe student ke account me bhejna chahiye
SARKARI JOB aur politicians ke liye apne bacho ko govt school m padana mandatory hona chahiye tbhi ye buerocrates aur politicians education m reform laynge
mera like education ke is mhan reformist k liye h jisko ts subrmanyam khte h agr ye sifarishe hmari andhi sarkare lagu kr de to bharat ka bahivsy behtar hoga
Sir please add some energy and indulge in debate.
even if students are educated do u have proper jobs to employ them...??? instead the poor ppl feel investing in education is not a better option rather they drag them to child labor..atlest it meets their economic requirements in short time..no wonder we c many child beggars in India..Education to door ki baat h , yaha to 2 waqt ki roti b nai milti kai logo ka...
🙏🙏
A goal set to to achieved by 2080 is not yet achieved? When I go to India, I see almost no improvement. In fact, it is much worse than we went to school in fifties and sixties! Privatization has divided the nation, Education is for the rich only!
Qurban ali g aap charcha ka prarambh aise kar rahe jaise pura ratta laga k aaye hai ,bhut bura laga aap jase senoir journalist se aisa presentation
Dere shd be discussion but not biased.
Y only dis govt is being alleged.
N y not u consider dat a population is big problem
Conclusion is not optimum...
Bhai sahav pm modi ji ko bolo naukariya nikale....hamari to age bhi khatam hoti ja rhi hai....
Rip TSR Subhramanium.
Teacher ko regulate krene k liye government schools me jarurat h, ek committee ki, jo teacher doshi ho use barkhast kre
Ye subramanniyam sahab jab job me the to kitna change kiya hai??
Sab se corrupt regime me ye job me the.
N he was d part of main planning.
Y not u people discuss about reservation??
A reservation getting teacher got selected only after getting 35% den what u expect from him or her...
Bihar to fully decline h education me
sahi baat
Sushma mam sayed right.
aap mppsc ka prelims ka paper dekh lijiye ,,, 8th standard ke paper se bhi ghatiya standard hai ,,,
Jo kanun banate hai jo debate karte hai un sabke bachhe private me hai ghanta desh aage badhega
education aisa janha krisna or sudama saath main pad sake ....
Sir ek bord bna dia jay
education di jarhi h or berozgari baday jarhi h....aj shikshit hi aprado ko bdhava dene m aage h ...or ek nirbl jesa vivsh lif jine ko vivsh h ....geevn k bahumuly sal gvane k bad bhiii...smaj m educated ko woh smman nhi mil rha jo milna chahy....b.com.ma.etc...pas low post ki lambi line m lge nzr ate h ....puritrha nirasha s bhare huy h ag k shikshit....bqz.....hmari GOVERNMENT ko shiksha or shikshito ka smman nhi ata ....ek chay vla nhi janta smman shittt
dusare kaksha ke chatra do akshar nahi padh raha hai...shiskshit shikshak lage hai padhaneme nahi..caste aur politics me busy hai....agar padhate hai tho subject nahi sirf caste politics padhate hai....reason kya hai????? lack of descipline,,,are time pe ana aur gappe marna peth bhar khana sub karna lekin planned teaching nahi padhana nahi tho kya shiksha ka sthar sudhrega???? yaha discipline hai???? ek hal hai har ek shiksha samstha me pehele LIVE ka arrange kare....ek step tho equrate kare .baadme baate aur discussion ke bare me..soche.self descipline,self regultion automatically a jayega.
Ye punjiwadi log kabhi nahi chahenge desh mai aik saman education system lagu ho jaye
Anchor Ji...kuch home work karke aaya kariye...... don't ask very generalized questions
Ye line to line letter kyo padhte hai please change the anchor. You have very good anchors like kavindra, Deepak,amrita Rai,but Why are giving such a good program to worst anchor of Rstv
Ye punjiwadi log kabhi nahi chahenge desh mai aik saman education system lagu ho jaye
sahi kaha