DID IT SUCK? | Doctor Who [THE WATERS OF MARS REVIEW]
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 авг 2024
- This week, Harry reviews the Doctor Who episode "The Waters of Mars" OR ""The many worried faces of David Tennant"
► SUBSCRIBE: / @harrysmovingmedia
DONATIONS:
► PATREON: / harryshauntedhouse
► PAYPAL: www.paypal.com...
SOCIAL MEDIA:
► Discord Server: / discord
► Tweeting: / harrys_haunted
► Facebook: / harrysmovingmedia
► Instagram: / hmm_instant
![DID IT SUCK? | Doctor Who [THE POWER OF THE DOCTOR REVIEW]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lqBHbpF0wfM/mqdefault.jpg)
![DID IT SUCK? | Doctor Who [THE POWER OF THE DOCTOR REVIEW]](/img/tr.png)
![DID IT SUCK? | Doctor Who [SILENCE IN THE LIBRARY / FOREST OF THE DEAD MEGA REVIEW]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/C9TRz1cT5O8/mqdefault.jpg)
![DID IT SUCK? Doctor Who [Rise of the Cybermen/Age of Steel MEGA REVIEW]](/img/1.gif)
1:07 Adelaide talks about it "being chaos back home. Forty long years. The climate, the o-zone, the oil apocalypse. We almost reached extinction."
That would mean it all kicks off in 2020. Not bad, Russell. Not bad.
It doesn’t though. We have enough fossil fuels for a good century lol. Don’t buy the climate agenda
Hmm and then at the end of the episode we see Adele’s house and street, and it looks like a picture perfect chocolate box art work.
@@PwnZombie so we shouldn't worry about the sustainability of people living on earth after the 100 odd years / after we're gone, or the damage to the ozone from the excessive use of fossil fuels whether we have enough to use or not?
@@ThePawags - It'd be selfishly comforting to think it'll all happen to the next generation. But it won't. 2050 is when it'll properly kick off. Infertile soil, carbon-rich air, lacking fossil fuels, recession recession recession. Boomers will be the last generation to have the luxury of an old age. I can't speak for everyone, but I'm shooting myself before the population topples over 10 billion. That's 2050. I'll be 48. Ten billion people on a planet with resources that can sustain only one. It's happening in our lifetime. Keeps me awake at night.
@@nightowl8477 Hate to say it we aren't under 10 million in population
The Time Lord Victorious scene is honestly some of Tennant's best acting in the show. His eyes, Jesus his eyes, are just so cold, so dark. This story fucking rules.
Makes Whittaker look childish in comparison. By far DWs golden age was with tennant
His expression is magnificent, alone in the snow as he realizes what he's done, who he is, all backed by that quiet, haunting score. Tennant really is one of the best actors of his generation.
@@Kyle_00 Not sure why we need to talk about 13 here. Let me enjoy Series 4 without mentioning her, haha.
@@ojigbo fair enough haha
I still think its one of these reasons hes been cast as a few psycho paths and killers the last few years.
Did you know that the Masters catch phrase in classic who was "they will obey me" and in this episode the doctor says "the laws of time are mine, AND THEY WILL OBEY ME" he used the masters fricken words
I must have seen this episode four or five times, and I've never thought of that.
You mean:
“I am The Master. You will obey me.”
@@eddherring4972 Indeed - it was part of his hypnosis routine. He only said it if he was trying to hypnotise someone.
Likewise with "tough"
Just like the master in Utopia
Best of the Specials, easily.
Best of the RTD Era
rusty key one of the best of RTD era but not best then yeah?
rusty key agree to disagree sure. Maybe midnight comes close. I’ll clarify that it’s the best episode RTD wrote (imo)
This episode single-handedly justified the existence of the specials in the first place.
Scariest
Short answer: No.
Long answer: Nope.
I feel that this is one of the most perfectly crafted episodes in the show's run, never have we seen the Doctor's sympathy and constant urge to help others be portrayed in such a selfish manner. It really highlighted how the Doctor is just one bad day away from being the Master, he even repeats some of the same stuff the Master said in series 3 (The Master says "tough" in Utopia when the Doctor begs him to stop, the Doctor says "tough" when Adaleid says he shouldn't have as much power as he has - both pleas coming from people who recognise that the person they're speaking to is in control of power they aren't fit to handle). Tennant's acting is just perfect, he's simply broken to have found himself involved in yet another disaster that he's known about for years, and even more broken to realise that he can't prevent it. Of course, when he decides to try and prevent it and convinces himself he's gonna beat "time itself", he's given a reality check when Brooke killed herself and he realises that he is in fact NOT the Time Lord Victorious, he's not the winner. The man who committed mass genocide against his own people in order to save time itself was taught a valuable lesson: Time does not reward one with power over it in exchange for saving it, Time just goes on no matter what he may try.
@Lady Wanderer who pissed in your cornflakes sunshine ?
@Lady Wanderer
It's really not a lightning strike change in characterisation, because we've never seen the 10th Doctor be alone or have that realisation of power and especially having the hope of "just saving someone" in the fire of Pompeii rings a bell by Donna, and always losing someone in his journey highlighted in Journey's end shows how powerless he feels at times even though he essentially has the powers of a God right at his footsteps, so him being companion-less and showing what he really wants makes sense not to mention the thought of being the last time lord and the prophesy in the last episode further solidifies his action.
I think your second point doesn't make sense, is her dying still not a tragedy for her child? Not to mention the many mystery's surrounding her death and her being in the first group to going into Mars, is that not still inspiration? Why does the location change her dreams of following Adaleid?
Also disagree by 2050 I think we'd have technology to prove with absolutely certainty that they went to Mars I mean a explosion doesn't happen out of nowhere not to mention the missing crew members and the robot as proof, it's not too hard to believe. The message I think is more so of playing God the integral person who wasn't supposed to survive dies anyways really a contradiction of what he was thinking at that time, it shouldn't be something he plays around with especially in a fixed point.
The saved people don't play as an important factor it's more focused on characteristics of the Doctor and finding his faults of playing God (mainly in a fixed point of such an integral part of history) and being able to pick who lives and survives a reference to S3 Christmas special when the professor calls the idea of being able to decide who lives and who dies a monster in a way (or even attempting to), also the Doctor cracked once it doesn't mean the whole flood gate should be poured out because in an instant of his decision to save the crew, the realisation comes when there's a reflection to the Master when he says "Tough" something he said in Utopia or in the classic series where the master says "they will obey me" so you can see what the story is hinting at and it's something he shouldn't become.
"This why Doctor Who is in the state it is in today , because people like you praised thoughtless garbage like this."
How in the world is it thoughtless, you missed so many parts of the story yourself linking to other parts, if anything you're the one lacking actual good reasons or criticisms on why Doctor Who is in the state it's in, nonsensical conclusion in my opinion which stems from essentially nothing.
@Lady Wanderer
Again I don't see how that'll change her Son's influence I know they're not the same but how would that change her not believing in her and finding hope in her endeavours and using it as inspiration in what she was doing, seeing it as meaningless and having the perception of being a cover up is really redundant especially when you have the survivors to tell their story and isn't unbelievable especially when you have Earth moving across the universe and knowing aliens have that technology. The Doctor prefaces that her dream starts because in a way she's doing it to meet her, both still are surrounded in mystery, why did she kill herself sparking potential cover up theories or why did she self detonate the place in Mars which in turn still killed herself and the crew sparking up theories on how's a potential murderer?
Also being a cover up or being a liar seems too poignant especially when there other avenues to believe Adaleid and the fact the survivors stories don't sound too unbelievable especially when people have seen such technology. We all know the differences, but we are talking about changes of those differences, you're baffled because you're looking at the wrong thing.
He saved people in the fires of Pompeii but not the event, the story is talking about the very fixed point in time which is her death, so saving a few people wouldn't matter as the Doctor essentially says to Adaleid's face that she's more important showing his thoughts that he has the power so no, it's far more irrelevant, the Doctor's saved people all the time but this is different involving fixed points and how pivotal they are, time didn't bend to his will because the fixed point still happened anyways, those few people aren't more grander than the other being Adaleid.
@Lady Wanderer this is far from lightning strike change remember in turn left when he went apeshit and genocides the racnoss
I have long felt many of the people that love him, seem to miss ALL of this deeper, darker characterisation entirely and purely focus on... well, let's be honest, Tennant himself; how charming and funny and dashing he can be. But for Ten it's frankly a very surface level facade. Timelord Victorious, in Turn Left when the MERE FACT that Donna was not there to say "Hey, this is wrong" causes the Doctor to go so ruthless and hard genociding the Racnoss that he blows everything up AND kills himself in the process. How do people miss that detail from Turn Left? It's extreme! People say "Ten is the most human Doctor" and in some ways I agree, but he's also very very cold, often emotionally manipulative (pay attention to Martha and Jack in the series 3 finale episodes), very hypocritical and frequently ruthless. These are all traits present in humans, but not *kind* ones, and when people claim his 'humanity' they tend to do so positively. He is *very* human imo, but nowhere near being the most emotionally available, or genuine; in fact, he's actually a massive d\*ck (particularly to Martha). Donna was much needed, she really brought him down a peg (watching him and Rose was like watching your rich bullies from the fifth form go on elaborate space dates, and watching him walk all over the brilliant Martha was painful). He needs others to restrain him so he doesn't just immediately commit *genocide* because it's so clearly instinctual for him (Turn Left, Journey's End), and so he doesn't just declare himself a god and start manipulating the entire universe to his skewed sense of 'right' (Waters Of Mars, End Of Time).
At its weakest moments, The Waters of Mars is the best 'Base Under Siege' story to date. At its strongest moments, it's the greatest deconstruction of Ten - _hell, just the Doctor generally!_
I could have had the whole of Series 5 follow the Time Lord Victorious, and I wouldn't complain.
well you're in luck they are doing a series of audiobooks, books and comics called "time lord victorious" so maybe 10+ years late but it's happening
@@imafgc Yeah but it's set in the time war
@@geminiferret4758 um not its not, and it involves the 8th, 9th and 10th doctors
I see nightowl comment on basically every doctor who related video
@@greglinks - best show in the world bro
6:49 disagree. Series 2 Ten would have left. It's Donna (with the likes of The Fires of Pompeii) that got through to him, but his sheer ego twists her "Just save someone" message into "Saving some little people."
Which really hammers home why The Doctor wouldn't "just save someone" - because if you can save someone, why shouldn't you save everyone? The Doctor didn't believe anyone, including himself, should have that kind of power.
In the end, he was right.
@@LabradorIndependent - comes up in Voyage of the Damned too. "To pick and choose who lives and who dies...That would take a monster."
@@nightowl8477 Which is apparently the basis for the first Time Lord Victorious novel coming out from what was put online whcih should be interesting..
I wouldn’t begrudge anyone for saying that this is the best episode of Doctor Who ever made.
@Voltaic Fire There's also dozens of seasons of classic who.
For me it's either this, Midnight or Dalek. Depends when I'm asked (at least in the revival)
I think Heaven Sent just eclipses it for me.
Voltaic Fire Dude you just need to get over that stuff. You’re missing some incredible television.
Imo it’s not the best, but it’s up there.
Honestly,The Waters of Mars deserves a 10/10. It is such a perfect episode; the way it turns water into a genuine threat is absolutely terrifying, and the Time Lord Victorious stuff is David Tennant at his absolute best.
Indeed, Tennant proclaiming that he is the Timelord Victorious is both glorious and harrowing.
The moment Adelaide kills herself, and the Doctor realises just what he's done, who he's become, I don't think I've ever felt fear like that watching anything before.
To see the Doctor responsible for the death of an innocent person, to see this man I've watched save planets and species for the last few years become this...tyrant of time, only for it all to come crashing down, knowing that newly created corpse lying in the house feet away from him is HIS fault as waves of horror and guilt and shock flood through him...dude, give me all the Daleks, Cybermen, Weeping Angels, Vashta Nerada in the world. They'll barely come close to the extreme emotions of seeing the Doctor rising up and falling down like that.
Truly incredible acting from Tennant and Duncan, with yet more RTD and Murray Gold perfection this episode.
Cried into a settee cushion, and didn't brush my teeth that night due to fear of water. 10/10
I wish we had more episodes like this exploring the darker side of the Doctor and what he’s really capable of. It gives his character a lot more depth and takes the viewer out of their comfort zone, which is what I love about it.
Billy 2 words. Classic Who.
Although it is probably best done sparingly so the concept doesn’t get old and it’s a fucking bombshell every time it happens
@@DanTheMan2150AD Yes Stories like The War Games, Inferno,Earthshock, Caves of androzani, Revalation of the Daleks side plotline aswell as main. (resurrection aswell for it's sheer kill count) are all dark stories with depressing outcomes
The cannibalistic Andragum in the Two Doctors, Solon who tries to decapitate the doctor.
- Smoke - there are many many more with darker undertones and an interesting dynamic to the Doctor.
@@DanTheMan2150AD I know too many to list I was mainly picking through the highlights.
i think im scarred from watching this as a kid, those faces are actually terrifying
Same. I think I was 8 or 9 when I saw it. No easy nights in the weeks that followed watching it
Me too. I remember the day exactly. We had gotten mcdonalds takeaway and I was so excited because Doctor Who hadn't been on tv in months.
I was like 12 or so, but was young/immature for my age.
Then once the zombies appeared I felt genuinely sick. I couldnt bring myself to eat a burger for like 2 years after that, no joke.
I'm watching this video mow because I hardly remember the episode as I got scared. Surprised so many people are saying it was the best special. Feel i've missed out now
Harry just made a video that wasn't sponsored by Skillshare
Yes I'm in absolute shock
This was, without question, one of the BEST specials EVER
It was one of the best production quailty episodes of Dr Who up at that time. The story was a bit thin and somewhat laced with politically charged dialog. 7 out of 10 and that is generous
@@badwolfgooddog7979 What politically charged dialogue are you talking about? I don't believe I noticed such dialogue, but I could be mistaken.
@@SteymarStark global warming, making our planet habitable before colonizing others, global politics over individual national politics... this was made during the pre-Brexit era when the UK was in mid-swing of being colonized by muslim immigrants as well as the Obama tenure in the US.
@@badwolfgooddog7979 I get what you mean with regards to the whole global warming thing. But if we put global warming beside, issues like industrial pollution of the environment and overpopulation (which I think the episode was referring too) are certainly legitimate issues that the vast majority of people can agree on. Overall though, thankfully the entire environment narrative was not forcefully nor preachy and remained relatively in the background of the story. The same can't be said with regards to the woke shit we get nowadays, which sadly includes the latest Doctor Who.
I myself consider myself a nationalist and I completely agree that immigration levels into the UK have been way too high. Even more disturbing is that if the current trends continue, White Britons (i.e the native population of the UK) may become a minority in their own country in 2066. This is something that should be prevented.
@@SteymarStark I agree with a lot of what you said. I just like my science fiction to be neutral if not entirely silent on real world political issues. It takes away from the entertainment value. The latest season of doctor who is a testiment to how that can seriously detract from a show.
Waters of mars is the only doctor who episodes that still gives me nightmares at 18 lol.
the connection to the stolen earth is just amazing and it reminds the doctor of what he lost during those two episodes and David’s acting is just impeccable
9:55 shot reminds me of the Satan pit. That episodes deals with the idea of the devil. Perhaps the filmmakers intention is to suggest the doctor turning into the devil and controlling time and established events in history
Quinn Thomas it is 😉 fair play mate good taste in doctor who
I never got that the timelord victorious scene and now I realise the universe was basically telling the doctor he was no god
My favourite Tennant moments are when he really shows how alien he is. I love the condescending lines he gives at the end like *“I’ve done this sort of thing before; saved some little people”* or when he simply responds *“Tough”* or when he opens a door and even chooses to gloat about that saying *“That’s easy”.*
It just shows how truly out of touch he is with humanity deep down and demonstrates the god-complex he tries to suppress
People tend to forget that this is the man whose childhood friend was The Master, and that The Doctor was raised by a megalomaniacal race of elitists. He's very, very far from a humble man and moments like this episode show us how significant it is that he hides that side of himself.
I remember watching this episode as a child and finding it absolutely terrifying and to this day I still think it’s the scariest Doctor Who episode I’ve ever watched
I remember this scared the shit out of me when I was young. Went into school the next day and couldnt drink from the water fountain
I remember when I first watched this episode. I felt a combination of wanting The Doctor to save the day, but afraid of what would happen. This is a major character episode for 10 and it’s so artisticly done
Can’t wait to do a clean Music Suite for this episode. One of my favourite Gold scores.
DanTheMan 2150AD "no no no no they're not going to think like me they are going to become me" duh, duh, duh duh duh duh
The Botanical garden is the one in Carmarthen if I remember correctly! In day to day life it’s mostly home to plants that couldn’t usually grow in Wales
This is the biggest cause for my childhood nightmares. I literally had repeating nightmares of this shit, and I even had one a few weeks ago lmao.
Interesting how much myth plays into this episode of Doctor Who. You mentioned the Fall from Eden, and there’s also a heavy Greek resonance around “The Hubris Before the Fall”. That Ten becomes the Time Lord Victorious, the hubris; only for it to burst with Adelaide’s suicide.
Also interesting that Ten fights nature itself to save what is supposed to be an inevitable death for Adelaide, only for her to die through her own human agency.
i'm so glad you finally made this episode, it is truly an incredible Doctor Who story. I wish you'd touched on the Doctors speech to Adelaide when he starts talking about fixed points and her daughters daughter suzie frontana brooke being inspired by her, that really pulled on my heart strings.
I personally think this episode was the closest the Doctor has ever been in becoming exactly like the Master.
I highly recommend you check out the classic 3rd Doctor story: 'Inferno.'
It is 7 parts along, but I first decided to play it when I had to come home early as I was sick, and I couldn't believe how fast the time went by.
If I may use a spoiler to get you hooked- The Doctor actually has to leave a burning world behind.
The sound of water trickling down the drain was never the same for me after this episode.
For me the line that really made me question whether I even liked Tennant any more was when he referred to Yuri and Mia as the 'little people' and that comes from someone that, until this episode, was besotted with every element of his character. But this particular line was so cruel, so belittling and so vainglorious, it was poetic the way Adelaide shuts him down verbally and then mentally by killing herself, thus restoring him to a state of pureness and emotion again. It was refreshing to see how cruel The Doctor can be when they haven't got a companion by their side. And more refreshing to see them restored once again.
Harry: about to scream YESSSSS
RUclips: aight its ad time
Harry: “I literally screamed Ye-RAID SHADOW LEGENDS!”
This was the first episode I ever watched live as it premiered. I got into the show in 2009 and binged up to this point, and when this episode aired my mind was absolutely blown. Truly a special episode for me.
Best episode of new who it’s incredible from start to finish and it has everything you would want from an episode
What about Heaven Sent?
This scared me so so much when I was a kid my god I've still never watched it again
This is definitely a top 10 episode for me, the characterisation of the doctor was fantastic and quite possibly the scariest monsters EVER in Doctor Who
I remember being a young and not really paying attention to the story, only picking up on certain beats and making my own story out of what they had shown on camera, growing up now and being 15 watching the episode it’s one of my favourites if not my favourite episode of Doctor Who!
Probably the best the new series got.
I don't find the villains particularly interesting but the charcter development and the viewer already knowing the impending doom just makes this amazing.
Not to mention Adelade Suicide was the best use of shock value I've ever seen really broke your expectations.
There was a sort of comic tie in to the scene where David tennant says "time lord victorious" (not the one from this year) but an alternate timeline where after this the doctor goes mad with power after losing so many people and decides to leave wilfred mott in the radiation booth to die and he then stays as david tennant in series 5 not meeting amy (if the timeline still includes series 5) and if not he becomes a power mad tyrant who even the daleks cannot defeat and it took 24 doctors from different universes to defeat the one evil doctor. A raxocoricofalaptorian kills him with an anti regeneration round with the help from the 24 doctors. Even the evil doctors tardis went evil too. If series 5 does play out the universe ends as he's locked in the pandorica with nobody to help him and the show ends. Oh, even as an evil doctor the daleks still win in Victory that plays out the same, he's furious though. He's essentially Amy-less in series 5 if it does play out and the doctor doesn't become a tyrant.
He's so goddamn scary when he needs to be
A lovely dark episode that gets darker as the show progresses. It left me somber while still glad I watched it.
I never thought I would be scared of water but this episode changed that 😳
the audio story with these water of mars enemy's is amazing
The ending of this episode is my favourite depiction of The Doctor, reminding you that he is, essentially, a god and he can do whatever the hell he wants. He ends up becoming pretty scary.
When I was younger the waters of mars episode scared me so much I couldn't sleep well for a couple of days
“I literally screamed ‘YE’”
To be honest. It’s the same with me, I never rewatched or gave this episode much thought as a teen, but I re watched it again recently, and honestly it’s amazing, I have more of knowledge, emotional range and I understood all of the stakes involved more so than I did when I watched it when it aired, also now I know what’s to come and how doctor who has deteriorated over time it seems like a masterpiece
I always found Adelaide going into her house at the end and shooting herself horrifying and heartbreaking
I just love that at the end you think it will all happy good, then bang! Literally. It made me just sink especially after what he went through.
I like that they set 'The Stolen Earth' in 2009 and it establishes a time for the present day. However, what still puts me off is that, in Human Nature, the Doctor mentions that it was 2007 in the present day, meaning that Series 3 was set during 2007. Since they didn't mention the Web Star, I thought that maybe it hadn't happened yet. Then, in Turn Left, they set Smith and Jones after The Runaway Bride. So I thought that the episode Rose could be set in 2004 which then turned into 2005 but then there was The End of Time. Now I don't know what to think!
Doctor Who continuity is a hellhole you don't want to find yourself in.
This also occurs in "Blink", whereupon the Doctor mentions that 1969 is 38 years behind present day. However, it's never explained how the Doctor and Martha arrived at Wester Drumlins, so they could have travelled to 2007 instead.
The Waters of Mars was my first episode of Doctor Who that I watched, so it holds a very special place in my heart. Looking back at it over 10 years later, made me realise just how dark this episode can really be, with most of the mature themes such as Adelaide's suicide and Ten's Time Lord Victorious persona flying right over my younger self's head. The Flood while they absolutely terrified me, yet made me intrigued on wanting more of this show.
I just love hearing other people's opinions about this episode, wherever it be good or bad. Every time I rewatch this episode I always find something new that makes me appreciate so much more
EDIT: 8:28 I struggle to express my thoughts into words when trying to describe this scene to other people, but looks like you just took the words right out of my mouth. Such a beautiful analysis on arguably one of the most powerful scenes in DW.
Adelaide is a prime example of a strong female character. She’s a strong character who happens to be female rather than a female character who tries to be strong. Much better than more modern attempts
All the companions from when I started watching (Eccleston to Tennent) were all strong female characters. Rose, Martha, Donna. All of them brought something new and wasn't just a generic badass.
@@BritishTeaFGC Agreed. Rose was quick thinking and a strong leader (Shown in the impossible planet/satan pit episodes). Martha was a little soggy at first but was exceptional in the family of blood story, and had a lot of great qualities. Donna was strong willed, independent, and provided the doctor's moral compass.
I think that in trying to be 'woke,' western media has become less woke because of it. Martha was a great companion because she was a good character, not because she was black. Adelaide was a fantastic side character because she was a good character, not because she was a woman in a position of power. I hope that moving forward BBC takes a look back and realizes what made their characters good, else the show won't learn from it's recent mistakes and steadily decline in quality.
This episode was the most terrifying episode of Doctor Who I ever saw. It wasn't just the monsters (although yikes on bikes, they were scary, especially with the water contamination), but the Doctor himself who scared me. For such an iconic and beloved hero to fall like that...it broke my puny teenage heart.
This episode reminds me that a person who controls time can’t completely control time it’s self. He broke the rules and adilade knew that. She had to set it right. I want to rewatch this episode again
Tennant's era at its absolute peak. Funny in places, but mostly horrifying and tragic, with fantastic performances from David Tennant and Lindsay Duncan, and a truly fantastic ending that provides the perfect conclusion to the Tenth Doctor's character arc
Its a Doctor Who zombie episode...whats not to like? and the use of water as the catalyst for the zombies is just great and in my opinion its one of the 10th Doctors best episodes because he doesn't know what to do he usually reasons with his enemies but these zombies lack any form of communication so that flies out the window and even at the end where the doctor thinks he has a small win it all comes crashing down for him as Adelaide returns home and commits suicide
I always thought that this episode would be about the ice warriors but I love this so much better
Thanks for giving me my ptsd again!
Tennant's performance in this is the single best portrayal of The Doctor in the show's entire run.
So glad you finally got to this episode, one of my favourites especially showing the doctor is fallible.
Can’t wait to see you gush over tenants performance when talking to Wilf in the next one
This rollercoaster of emotion, self confidence and sheer personal megalomania portrayed by the doctor in this, in my opinion ‘Perfect Episode’ is magnificent! Never have I been so deeply invested in fictional characters in all my life!
Serious praise here to ALL of the cast involved in such a monumentally glorious production! Well done!!
You spoke nothing but FACTS when you were talking about The Doctor's character. He is a complex protagonist and Tennant's era completely embodies it.
At the time this episode aired I was quite ill. And was throwing up easily. Watching the water zombies throw up the water made me throw up violently, and for ages after resulted in the same response due to my experience then. Not as bad now, but I certainly feel queesy.
Same here. Didn’t know this episode existed until I rewatch Dr. who on Netflix.
This, the Impossible planet/Satan Pit and Girl in the Fireplace are my fav episodes of all time
i always thought their mouths looked like roast beef
This episode scared the shit out of me back in the day
“Water of Mars… gets a 9.5/10” you crushed my soul
Watched this way to young and still thinking about it 15 years later never rewatching it
this episode is indeed a pogU and honestly what cemented my love for tennant's incarnation as the doctor. as much as i love capaldi and his ability to make literally anything watchable, the emotion that david shows in the role is what has me constantly debating which doctor is my favorite.
Didn’t think I’d be afraid of water today but here we are
To me this episode connected so much with me the build up to this and tenants acting push’s you on and on with him. Makes you go along with him till at the end your snapped back into it realising how wrong this is. Only the death can snap him out of this, as it all comes crashing down back to reality.
I was so excited for this review to come out, this is one of my favourite episodes of Doctor Who.
"Doctor Who: Prepare To Die Edition" made me giggle
Most underrated episode in my opinion, one of Tennant's best performances 🙌🏻
just show's what you can do with limited CGI,superior writing and acting ability
By far one of my favourite episodes ever made. To contrast this with current Dr Who, it's not even the same show anymore!
"You die, today... LOL!"
*[The Doctor runs off and steals the rocket]*
Lmao I went to that botanical garden like 10 times before I realised that that's where the waters of mars was filmed.
Is it Plantasia in this one? I know they used it for the Silurian episodes and the garden in the Doctors Daughter
hold on a second
David TENnant
TENth Doctor
This is probably the most iconic episode I personally think of
This is defiantly in my top 10 maybe even 5 episodes
Oh ye and good on u for Harry for giving such a brilliant score to a brilliant episode
An excellent and well thought out review. You’ve pointed out things that I hadn’t noticed before.
This episode haunted me as a kid, this and the weeping angels
Just gonna point out that Public support for Space Exploration is at its highest since the 60’s. When it was also very popular. Not sure where this idea of “concentrating on Earth” has come from. The two are hardly mutually exclusive.
Blink
Midnight
Waters of Mars
Hands down the best 3 episodes in Dr Who history
Absolutely.
Honestly you might be the only patron I actually get, your videos are. So good and I want more!!!!, I also want to support u as well
I remember watching this Episode in 2009 when it first broadcast, it scared me to death and I didn't watch it for about 9 years.
This is the only episode I remember watching because at the time I was like 4 at the time and I had just gotten into doctor who and when I rewatched the whole series I was shocked that I started watching so late because in that one episode I had made such a connection with tennants doctor
Are you releasing patreon exclusive videos on youtube 6 months after they are made?
Im saying this since I’m a fan of this channel but am unable to get patreon and it hurts to miss out.
I am really excited for the possibility of you moving on to reviewing more of eleven’s episodes as they are by far my favourite
This one had me have nightmares for years
This episode that gave me the fear of (creepy) eyes along with deadset
Great review, perfectly shows why I love this episode, it’s my favourite modern era, probably of Who as a whole. Also I have the answer to your question in the last review Harry.
The reason the credits fly by in series 4 and the specials is because at the time of the series being made, the BBC made their rule that end credits for their shows have to be 25-30 seconds, that rule is still in place today
This is the first episode of doctor who that actually got me hiding behind the couch
The monsters were TERRIFYING literally the only monsters I was actually scared of
Prepare to cry? Did someone say Vaati?
I just realised a huge plot whole(someone's bound to have noticed it before): If the Doctor's reset of the universe means that no one remembers the Dalek invasion from Stolen Earth/Journey's end- what inspired Adalade to see the stars? Maybe there's something I've missed that explains this, but if not, whoops lmao
"Time can be re-written." Even fixed points as 11 later proves.
Recently rewatching this episode again after getting the blu ray and seeing it finally in HD has just cermeted my opinion that this is the single best story in all of who. 11 years later and it still looks amazing, and hits just as hard.