Get your Sea Peoples | Late Bronze Age Merch below! Mugs: teespring.com/new-sea-peoples-mediterranean?pid=658&cid=102950 Hoodies | Shirts | Tank Tops: teespring.com/get-sea-peoples-mediterranean?pid=212&cid=5819 Get your Hittite Merch below! Mugs: teespring.com/HittiteEmpireMug?pid=658&cid=102950&sid=front Shirts | Tank Tops | Hoodies: teespring.com/hittite-empire-shirt?pid=2&cid=2397 Trojan War Merch Below! Mugs: teespring.com/trojan-war-coffee-mug?pid=658&cid=102950 Tank Tops | Shirts | Hoodies: teespring.com/TrojanWarShirt?pid=2&cid=2397
A massive amount of urns filled with the bones of thousands of children were unearthed in the Carthage temple mentioned. Felt that was worth mentioning.
What about bible holy genocides where Israelites on God's command killed other tribes kids, babies and pregnant women too?? Are we gonna ignore what "my" religion did to judge others?
@@hermitcard4494 The Jews were Gods chosen people because it was through them the Messiah would come and great pains were taken to insure this bloodline would survive as the gentiles knew this as well so the blood flowed. And what was the final message? We are all Gods children, forgiveness and atonement is the only way one can live live in harmony with ones neighbor. Those that reject the core teaching of do unto others as you would have others do unto you are what we see before and behind His teachings.
as a Tunisian I always thought Hannibal worshiped the Baal if his name is of any indication. it becomes more apparent in arabic (which should be closer to what his name sounded like since both are semitic languages) as his name is حنبعل pronounced "Hanna-Baal" the second part of his name is literally Baal (بعل). we never got around to the phonecian dieties in depth at school though so I could be wrong, just a little observation that's all. great channel with brilliant content, learned alot from you guys.
The philestines did it to the hebrews when they defeated the hebrews in a war and took their ark of the covenant but then returned because bad stuff was happening to them after that
@Herbal Shaman WRONG. First of all, Egyptians are genetically & culturally sons of the proto-Canaani who built Atlit Yam (see the similar -- but YOUNGER -- Nabta Playa in Egypt). PLoS had 2 articles on North Egypt's Dynasty Zero inheriting J2-172from proto-Canaani. Second, ABJD descends from Cuneiform.
@Herbal Shaman You cited a (non-scientific) article claiming that Phoenician was, indeed, the mother of all alphabets. Way to admit now that you didn't read (or weren't able to intellectually digest, at least) the article that you told US to read.
@Herbal Shaman The 1st alpha-bets evolved during the 2nd millennium B.C.E. (www.history.com/news/who-created-the-first-alphabet ), and PHOENICIA DIDN'T EVEN EXIST until the FIRST MILLENNIUM B.C.E. Thus Phoenicians would've needed to invent a time-machine for your nonsense theory to be true. Canaanites, e.g. Ugaritic as someone else above, who exposed your cockamamie lies, noted as an example, used alpha-bets (or rather, aleph-beits :-) ) LONNNNNNGGGGGG before Phoenicians and their language even EXISTED.
@@secretsquirrel6718not everyone can cope with reading books. I used to be an avid reader until health problems took away that pleasure. I now rely on podcasts and audiobooks; history books are not as readily available unfortunately.
I love it also. One thing that bothers me is how people automatically think of earlier civ's as primative. When we still don't know how they made the pyramids, or the great wall of China. I really think people are selling them way to short. I think you would like the RUclips video on Zorroastrioism.It takes the opposite view of the Bible,where Michael the Archangel cast Lucifer and his followers to the Earth. Zoroastrianism says that the Gods fell as fire from the sky. IT'S INTERESTING....
There will always be strong feelings about any narrative on such an important subject. My work is a general overview and not designed to influence anyone's thoughts. You are all the captains of your own minds, and you must all draw your own conclusions. My studies have demonstrated that ancient societies interpreted different mythologies in different ways, because verbally transmitted stories naturally alter. Ancient scriptures and traditional scriptures differ in their description of different aspects. My advice, do not believe the opinion of anyone, make your own study and formulate your own opinion.
@Nocentre Noborder so if the British and Irish are the PHOENICIANS which in fact were the canaanites, then that would make them hammites! "Ham" meaning burnt! Which translates to black. "Zondervans compact bible dictionary" ham the youngest son of Noah, probably 96 years old before the flood, was the progenitor of the dark races, not the "negros" But the libyans, ethiopians, Egyptians, and the canaanites. Do you see the problem with your theory? JS.
When learning ancient history one should first understand how ancients viewed the world and know something about the culture. It’s folly to view ancient history with modern mind
The phrase "nothing new under the sun " means what to you? Truth being hidden right in front of you. Check out mudfossil university channel and Tyson's mudfossil adventures. Pyramids and other megalithic structures are biological, remains of giant bodys, DNA tested and CT scanned.
@@lisatsuda amen these people think they know something but the truth hides right under their noses. It's very sad and I feel terrible. Every early civilization knew god but broke the first commandment.
Thanks. A great overview on subjects that sometimes don't get a broad context. The maps are very helpful and the language info is so important to understanding the region and its religion(s). Well done.
brilliantly objective presentation of near east history so far as we know. You will be my companion this evening as i work on new curtains. thank you for such a tremendous amount of info presented in format clear and uncomplicated.
I always think that the story of Ba'al being killed by Mot and being resurrected is similar to the story of Osiris and Set in Egypt. It's not out of the question that there was some connection between the two sets of beliefs.
@@historyoftheworldpodcast5234 I fucked up and said Ra. Fucking silly shit. But yes, it is very similar. If i am not mistaken brother vs brother and resurrected by sister is a theme that pops up in a few different polytheistic religions around the world. It really is intriguing to think about that.
@@historyoftheworldpodcast5234 The names differ percivilization, but there are to many simularities between the ancients all over the globe. Personally I think they were all based on the same gods, and that they all were in contact with one and other. Im glad you also briefly touched the subject that the ancients supposedly were "evil" civilizations. You made a great video.
This reminded me of books I would highly recommend here: Mark S. Smith's 'Early History of God' and 'The Origins of Biblical Monotheism: Israel's Polytheistic Background and the Ugaritic Texts to all. Based on what was then (19 years ago) recent scholarship/translations he explores the transition from polytheism > henotheism > monotheism; the concept of religion and divinity itself to the ancient Bronze Age mind. Interestingly the Ugaritic texts describe a complex pantheon in which YHWH and Baal are rival brothers among many other sons and daughters of El. Incidentally, both are described rain/thunder/storm gods thus symbolizing fertility and virility. This is significant as these texts precede any Biblical texts by centuries and explains the Biblical rivalry between the two. As the supreme deity, El is portrayed as a wise old man, with a white beard, sitting on a throne; often he is given epithets like 'El the Merciful', which brings to mind Islamic prayers and formulae. Though we consider it a caricature today, this image of God the Father is still with us. El is a 'first tier God', otiose, or astral god; they tend to be associated with beginnings (etiology and cosmology), they are concerned with the cosmos and are rather removed and distant from the realm of human experience, like weather phenomena or soil fertility, and as such are more like titular gods with little incidence on life. El rules the cosmos with a light touch, presides over a heavenly court occasionally intervening when things get out of hand between his children. The latter are the 2nd tier gods like Baal and YHWH who are the ones who were the focus of worship and effected daily life; the 3rd tier were specialist gods like Kothar (similar to Hephaestus/Vulcan) and the 4th tier are messenger gods, they usually relay messages between the 1st tier and the others, often found in the heavenly court. They bring to mind what would later become angels. Anyway, through a complex process of conflation which mirrors the transition of city-states to empires, then growing empires absorbing others and the transition from the Late Bronze Age Collapse into the Iron Age; the number of gods are gradually reduced; some disappearing entirely while others absorb several others or their attributes, the names often becoming titles or attributes. If I remember correctly, this is the case with YHWH, a most extreme example of conflation. Baal came to be a title 'Lord', still used today by Orthodox sects (Baal Shem Tov).
@@chaseharrison5469 glad I could help! You don't get to do that so much through RUclips comments. I'm sure he's got newer publications but that the stuff I read in uni way back. Cheers
@@chaseharrison5469 nice! I've felt a pull to get back into reading ANE history lately. My readings lists are getting long! To answer your question, not quite. Just a few optional classes here and there. Focused on the ANE and Levant, studied Hebrew and Arabic and took a Roman history class just cuz. Happy reading!
Question; Are similar god and goddess statues found in the excavations where the Hyksos (the shepherd kings) occupied Egypt? Or rather, what gods did the Hyksos worship?
I've not studied the Hyksos extensively, but I am aware that the Egyptians associated the deity, Set, with the Hyksos. The Egyptians associated Set with chaos, and traditionally depicted him as a man with the head of a strange and unknown animal. Some traditions state that Set killed the great Osiris, while others possibly later showed Set in a more positive light, with him accompanying the sun god, Ra, across the sky, as well as inspiring the names of New Kingdom pharaohs and one of Ramesses II's army divisions.
@@historyoftheworldpodcast5234 Just seems that if they had occupied an area for a time, some of their own preferred religious artifacts would also remain at the sites to help identify where they came from. There is still that question unanswered. But it perhaps answers the question on why single tombs were moved to the valley of the kings, if tribute was required from a foreign ruler. Andsome older single tombs were used as a possible resource in difficult times.
Podcasts are really so informative videos and es such are beyond description incredibly for their importance. What a pronunciation of the speaker! Islamabad Pakistan.
This is charming... simply charming. I'm less than a minute in and I'm already enamored with the music and the scrolling images... this is like something straight out of 1995. It's beautiful. I feel incredibly nostalgic about it, lol. I also want the music playing at the beginning... not the choir music, but the music immediately following that.
@@jayh9529 No that was the Chinese. Beginning mostly in the Quin dynasty, and later dynasties built on as well. Partly for defense, and partly to help sure up trading routes
Hey man great video! Really interesting look at a particularly lost old culture and religion, your accent is a little hard to understand at times, but that’s just how language is at time! Thanks for making it his and dealing with some of these comments.
Beautiful map anime ... was listening to yale course lectures earlier today on hebrew bible ... your video and hers compliment each other very well. Thank U
What do you think of the book "the invention of God" Thomas Romer That posits that Yah and EL merged, and Asherah was taken out after Babylonian captivity. Also, what do you think of Proto-Hebrew which resembles Phoenician? That current square script was influenced by Babylonian captivity....and astrological aspects.
Intetesting the comic book character "Superman" real name in the comic is, Kal-El. There is something too that, and when you have eyes that can see, you see clearly.
"El" was not a deity, let alone the deity of water. It is a root word, a morpheme, meaning "deity". Hence "Elohim" means heavenly beings, and the angels are named Dani-el, Micha-el, Rapha-el, and so forth. Ba'el is a shortened version of Babylon, with "Ba" being the root of "gate", and El again meaning diety. So Ba'el and Bab-el-on both mean "Gate of/to the gods". Ba'albeck, like Babylon, is thus understood to be a temple, or perhaps a gateway to the gods, depending on how you enjoy it. Now, rather than getting to caught up in the morphology of the words, which are taken from variations of a non English script, it is perhaps more useful to follow the role of the various deities as they are recycled by succeeding cultures in the same region, and even beyond. The "Storm" god, for example, is one. The Sumerians called him Enlil, the Assyrians Ashur, the Greeks Zeus, the Romans Jupiter, the vikings Odin, and so on. Innana, the high priestess and daughter of heaven in Sumer, was also Asteroth, Athena, Minerva and so on and so forth. Follow the mythology, not the etymology. There are far fewer archetypes than first appear, which is why Genesis today is so very similar to Sumerian mythology from 4000 year ago.
My understanding is that El is also the symbol for Saturn, Saturday, Sabbath, Saturnalia, master/slave, usury, Nike zionist run corporatism...Okay, the last bits are my add-ons:P Got slave?
Enlil was not the storm god. He was their god of the sky and the Sun was his eye. Ishkur, his brother, presided over rain and thunder. However it's all very interconnected so I can see where the confusion might come. Most of these still very animist deities being facets of another, more primordial or greater aspect. For although Ishkur dealt with rain his brother Enki presided over fresh water. Along with Enlil they formed the heavenly triad. A triangle of interconnected concepts relating to the heavens and fresh water. Their father An embodied the entire heavenly domain and was the source of male life force/aspect, which included Anshar (the heavens), Lahmu (the stars) and Apsu (the primordial fresh waters of heaven). In as far as the female aspect is concerned there was Ki who embodied the entire earthly domain and was the source of female life force/aspect, which included Kishar (the earth/dry land), Lahamu (the seabed) and Tiamat (the primordial salty waters of earth). Apart from the main aspects all the lesser deities (aspects) were also children (mixings) of An and Ki. An-nuna-Ki. Presiding over lesser things like springs, plants, animals, hills, etc. It was all still very Animist/Shamanistic and it was all an attempt to rationalise the world. An extremely organised conceptual model compared with anything that came before (that we know of) to be sure, but at it's core Animism was still the order of the day in ancient Sumeria.
While it is true that the word 'el can be used as a generic term for "god," and was used that way in Mesopotamia, in Canaan it was indeed the personal name of a god.
I love this channel, it's very informative. You could work on making your videos more visually engaging though, no one wants to watch a map for five minutes. When you talk of gods and cities put relevant images on screen, together with the names, since it can be hard to judge what someone is saying from speech alone, especially if english isn't your first language. Just some tips to make the videos more appealing to a wider audience. Keep up the great work :)
The Canaanite pantheon was conceived as a divine clan, headed by the *supreme god El;* the gods collectively made up the *Elohim.* Through the centuries, the pantheon of Canaanite gods evolved, so that *El and Asherah* were more important in earlier times, while *Baal* and his consorts came to fore in later years. *Asherah* - early semitic Mother goddess, "Lady of the sea," *consort of El,* also called Athirat, *the mother of 70 gods* *El* - the *chief deity,* god of the sky, *father of many lesser gods* and ruler of the divine assembly, *also worshiped by the Israelites* *El Elyon* -Special title of El as *"God most High"* The Book of Genesis itself describes the *patriarch Abraham* as a worshiper of El-also called El Shaddai and *El Elyon* -- building altars, offering sacrifices, and paying tithes to him. ------------------------------------------------------------------ *Deuteronomy 32:8* *When Elyon (El) gave to the nations their allotted inheritances,* when he divided the sons of Adam, he established the boundaries of the peoples *according to the number of the sons of El* (El and Asherah had *70* sons and in line with the Table of Nations in Genesis 10 *(70 nations)* each son *(Elohim)* received a particular territory or people like the Canaanite god Chemosh in Numbers 21:29) Yahweh’s portion was his people, Jacob, the lot of his allotted inheritance *(Yahweh was given Israel by his father, the chief Canaanite god El).* *Psalm 82* *’Elohim (Yahweh)* stands in the *council of ’El (chief Canaanite god)* In the midst of the gods *(Elohim)* he holds judgment. “How long will you judge unjustly, and show partiality to the wicked? Selah Render justice to the weak and the fatherless; vindicate the afflicted and the destitute. Rescue the weak and the needy; deliver them from the hand of the wicked.” They have neither knowledge nor understanding; they walk around in darkness; all the foundations of the earth are shaken. I said, “You are gods (Elohim), sons of Elyon (El), all of you; nevertheless, you shall die like mortals, and fall like any prince.” Rise up, O *’Elohim (Yahweh),* judge the earth; for you shall inherit the nations! ------------------------------------------------------------------ Watch Dr Christine Hayes at Yale University. Watch lecture 7 from 30:00 minutes onwards and lecture 8 from 12:00 to 19:00 minutes. Google *"Jews and Arabs Descended from Canaanites - Biblical Archaeology Society."* Google *"The Canaanites weren't annihilated, they just 'moved' to Lebanon - The Times of Israel."* Google *"The Gods and Goddesses of Canaan - Essay - The Metropolitan Museum of Art - Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History."* Google *"Canaanite Religion - **Realhistoryww.com.**"* (Read about El the father of Yahweh, Chemosh and other Canaanite gods to see the how the Bible is fiction) Google *"The Boundaries of the Nations - Yahweh Elohim."* Google *"Excerpt from “Yahweh and the Gods and Goddesses of Canaan” by John Day - Lehi's Library."* Google *"Married Deities: Asherah and Yahweh in Early Israelite Religion - Yahweh Elohim."* Google *"God's Wife Edited Out of the Bible - Almost."* (Pay attention to whose wife Asherah is in the Canaanite texts) Google *"Yahweh’s Divorce from the Goddess Asherah in the Garden of Eden - Mythology Matters."* Google *"Canaanite Religion - New World Encyclopedia."* (Pay attention to the section "Relationship to Biblical Religion") Google *"How Did the Bible's Editors Conceal Evidence of Israelite Polytheism - The Evolution of God."* Google *"A Theologically Revised Text: Deuteronomy 32:8-9 - Ancient Hebrew Poetry."* Google *"The Most Heiser: Yahweh and Elyon in Psalm 82 and Deuteronomy 32 - Religion at the Margins"* based on the *majority scholarly consensus.*
Stop mixing, El means god Elohim son of god, Abraham worshiped El meaning god with a name Yahuah not yehovah. Fallen angels were El’s but Most High El is creator Yahuah one is one. Real truth seekers will understand. Yahweh has nothing to do with YaHUah. Its more a language translate problem. No moses did not copy name from yahweh since fallen angels know most high YaHUaH name and they make it similair to be worshipped.
I thought ibrahim worshipped Nanna the moon goddess? Edit: Nanna = Allah, and Allah of Mecca is a moon god. The correlation and pronunciation is hard to dismiss as coincidence
@@phanuel... Everything you said is so outdated in 2023. Natufians did not have 50% Basal Eurasian, the people who made that paper made a new paper that corrected that mistake. The people with the most Basal Eurasian were the Dzudzuana samples from the Caucasus that had 28% Basal Eurasian. Natufians had 88% Dzudzuana and 12% Ancestral North African related ancestry which was not Basal Eurasian, it was pre OOA bottleneck.
My haplogroup y-chromosome is R-M167. It seems to have originated in Spain 2600 years ago. Its parent haplogroup is DF27 which also branched into the Basque population. as R-M153. This means that our ancestors were present at the time of Hanibal. Better yet, the Tartasos archeological site at Guerena Extremadura was named (guarena) by my ancestor Guarino de Verona's descendants. Of course guarino de Verona was also R-M167. How do I know? Its longitudinal coordinates are 6 W 6 ' 6'' or 666. Welcome to my world.
We know that the Baal of Ugarit and Yahweh aren't the same. The Baal of Ugarit was Hadad. But both characters are storm gods, and we know Yahweh "borrowed" attributes from Hadad. They were still definitely worshiped separately and in different locations.
@@erimgard3128 He didnt. He is the beginning and the end. The first and the last. He is the God of IS RAEL. Get it. The God of IS REAL. He's real. He created everything. He doesnt need to borrow or steal when everything is his. He makes these claims. No other gods ever do. *chuckles*.
And Israel didn't exist when the writings of Hadad that I'm talking about were chiseled. But you're not interesting in actually discussing facts. You're just chanting slogans designed for children. I'm not interested. I've studied the Bible my whole life. I've also studied other cultures and texts. You're not going to tell me anything new with your kindergarten level analysis.
I'm not sure about Egypt, but in Histories (2.44) he indicates that Heraclean worship by the Phoenicians predated Grecian veneration by at least 500 years as demonstrated by temples dedicated to Heracles in Tyre (Sur) and Thasos.
This is a good observation and I think I should have worded this a bit differently. Rather than them being thought of as the same, I should have said that Greek cultures linked these characters to the same person / deity.
Som or Dsom was Hercules to the Egyptians multiple historians talk about this... read A Dictionary of Greek and Roman Biography and Mythology: Earinus-Nyx edited by William Smith Page. 401
@@johnlove3505 read: A Dictionary of Greek and Roman Biography and Mythology: Earinus-Nyx edited by William Smith Page. 401 He was Som or Dsom to the Egyptians
From the word phonetians comes phone , Phonics etc. Phonetians were credited for writing and language , before this the written language was cuneiform or the symbols or characters used for words by sumer and Babylon. I'm not a historian but I wonder if the sanskrit from India is older than the phonetians or sumer. Btw great video , well done .
I'm not sure that phonetics are etymologically connected to Phoenicians. It might be worth citing a source for that fact. I think that the modern popular concensus is that the Phoenician alphabet modernised from a Sinaitic script which evolved from Egyptian hieroglyphs. Certainly cuneiform was contemporary to Egyptian hieroglyphs, but types of cuneiform were also still in use while Phoenician alphabetic scripts were evolving further west.
A pirate??? That kind of accent is from South West England. This man is from South East England, near London. If anything, he sounds more like a Victorian criminal.
Monotheism, as we have today, came from Egypt, from the worship of the Aten. Pharaoh Akhenaten, a half Hyksos (Semite) ruler established the Aten as the sole deity of Egypt, nearly abolishing Egyptian polytheism. The Aten, who had ‘no image or form’ (sound familiar?) was represented by the solar disk of the sun, although it was merely treated as a material representative of the god. Akhenaten was eventually forced to abdicate the thrown and was driven from Egypt. Scholars speculate that Tutankhamen, born Tutankhaten, was Akhenaten’s son, who was ultimately murdered and ‘hung on a tree’ by the Atenist priest Phinehas (Panhysy in Egyptian). Monotheism wasn’t new, the ruling elite always believed in a single, triun god-headed Creator. Polytheism was the exoteric creation myth for the masses, while monotheism was the esoteric teachings for the ruling class and priesthood (how little have we changed).
That is a great question! There's a position and a counter position. Firstly, there is no archaeological support of the kingdom, but secondly, there is no alternative argument.
In Africa only....because it has to go back to its inception....as it is born of genetic lines it must be followed as genetic lines are created...and DNA will tell you exactly what that genetic line is...the Middle East is important as a trading post...it was never the center of origin or genetic ascendency...that's why it's a war zone...there is absolutely no spiritual or genetic importance in that region...wealth is God in that region...and so if you want yo follow that line of people's who plunder for wealth...then you will find countless books and historical matter, treasures, riches...stolen as they were...but that's what you will find....theft and murder....
History of the World podcast I tend to accept things as likely true when they have evidence that supports it. I know absence of evidence is not evidence of absence but that which is asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.
The Kingdom of David is a fiction of 1st century rabbinical militant religious fanatics. It was an invented historical greatness for a fictional people, supposedly impervious to racial inpurity through a millenia of migrations and inbreeding with outsiders - propaganda, used to gee up pro-Israelite conscripts in their religious war against Rome. The same crap that Abrahamics and academics spit as actual factual history to this day. Pure lies! Archeologicaly proven. 100%. There was NO ancient Israel.
There is some evidence that Abrams comes actually from Urfa in Turkey near Harran (instead of Ur in South Mesopotamia) and Job is also related to the city of Urfa.
Im not sure where you got the idea that Israel was a nation given to Yahweh by his father Baal. Being quite familiar with the text I find it very difficult to accept that the conclusion you gave was a valid interpretation of the text. Are there any footnotes or other references you have on hand for your prior claim? I would be interested to see them if you have.
You could be right Scott. It's really the reference to Yahweh, the Lord, being granted "his people", the Israelites, in Deuteronomy 32:8, and it is very open to interpretation, but it is one accepted interpretation from what I have studied. Very little is plain on these early texts, and a lot of them have altered after different translations and interpretations. What do you think it means?
@@historyoftheworldpodcast5234 I may be incorrect as we are all prone to error but throughout the OT Yahweh refers to Israel in relation to himself as both a husband and a father. As a husband Israel is his wife who he "bought" out of eqypt. The idea being that those miracles spoken of in exodus were like a dowery payment. He bought Israel with His great deeds and because He did the required work the nation was "given" him. The second way spoken of especially in the Deuteronomy passage and elsewhere is as a father. The sense that Yahweh is trying to get across is that the people of Israel is His by right of him being creator. He "pulled lots" for them in the sense that he went out and choose them from among the nations to be His people. I can understand why there may be alternative interpretations of what is meant, old hebrew at times can be archaic and very context based. What i can't see through a plain reading of the text is putting Baal in any context larger then a false god. Throughout the OT it is very clear that Yahweh is superior to all other idols. To read anything else from the passages of the OT is commiting eisegesis. You would be guilty of reading your own presumptions into the text. If you would like some supporting passages for my claims I can provide, just replying on a phone and its a pain to type.
So you think that was unusual that Abraham was asked to sacrifice his eldest son? The Hebrews were most likely practicing the same thing at some point and gave it up.
This is the most informative information I studied the name for many years and I always came up with YA HA WA HA the Lashawan Qadash is the holy tongue which was lost in history.
There is a possibility that “YHWH” or “Yahweh”, could mean “creator, or to create”, Hebrew speakers can you confirm if you have a modern -perhaps mutated- word that confirms this. I’m a Syriac-Aramaic speaker, and for example the word “nehweh” is the -singular as well as first-person plural verb meaning “he’s/we’re creating” or simply “to create”, and as a matter of fact the original form of the verb in Ancient Aramaic was “yehweh” but in Classical Aramaic (Syriac) the “y” got replaced with “n” for these kinds of verbs... could this be a connection to the Abrahamic reference to God as “the Creator”?
The name transcribed as YHWH is based on the Hebrew verb root "hayah" which means to be. Hence, YHWH is sometimes translated as "the Eternal". Yes, the y- prefix does express the 3rd person masculine singular future tense in both modern and classical Hebrew.
@@raphaelalbert8110 true to Syriac as well; the root verb also means "to become" and "to be", in addition to what I stated in my first comment, which is "to create"... Also, the meaning for words such as "creation" and "creatures" stem from the same root in Syriac.
Get your Sea Peoples | Late Bronze Age Merch below!
Mugs: teespring.com/new-sea-peoples-mediterranean?pid=658&cid=102950
Hoodies | Shirts | Tank Tops: teespring.com/get-sea-peoples-mediterranean?pid=212&cid=5819
Get your Hittite Merch below!
Mugs: teespring.com/HittiteEmpireMug?pid=658&cid=102950&sid=front
Shirts | Tank Tops | Hoodies: teespring.com/hittite-empire-shirt?pid=2&cid=2397
Trojan War Merch Below!
Mugs: teespring.com/trojan-war-coffee-mug?pid=658&cid=102950
Tank Tops | Shirts | Hoodies: teespring.com/TrojanWarShirt?pid=2&cid=2397
Sea Peoples merch! They would be so proud. Hahah
Sounds Like Michael Caine.
One of my fa favorite actors
What music is playing at the beginning?
I hate that music
Canaan-
Biblical greek --Xavaana (Iksana) means on english land of pople or people land 😁
A massive amount of urns filled with the bones of thousands of children were unearthed in the Carthage temple mentioned. Felt that was worth mentioning.
Poisoned by jews
Child mortality was incredible in ancient times. It is why fertility and child bearing goddesses like ISIS are everywhere.
They don’t want to talk about what sacrificing the first born son results in a grave full of babies.
What about bible holy genocides where Israelites on God's command killed other tribes kids, babies and pregnant women too?? Are we gonna ignore what "my" religion did to judge others?
@@hermitcard4494 The Jews were Gods chosen people because it was through them the Messiah would come and great pains were taken to insure this bloodline would survive as the gentiles knew this as well so the blood flowed.
And what was the final message? We are all Gods children, forgiveness and atonement is the only way one can live live in harmony with ones neighbor. Those that reject the core teaching of do unto others as you would have others do unto you are what we see before and behind His teachings.
youtube historians taught me way more than school did
@@taylorjeremy71 worked for drivers Ed
I try harder on RUclips
Bitchute too
*[Aliens]*
Sorry.
as a Tunisian I always thought Hannibal worshiped the Baal if his name is of any indication. it becomes more apparent in arabic (which should be closer to what his name sounded like since both are semitic languages) as his name is حنبعل pronounced "Hanna-Baal" the second part of his name is literally Baal (بعل). we never got around to the phonecian dieties in depth at school though so I could be wrong, just a little observation that's all.
great channel with brilliant content, learned alot from you guys.
Woa, surprising! Thanks for fact!
@@ViriatoII I'm not sure it's a fact bro. I hope more knowledgable guys on this thread would give me a definitive answer.
@@tylerdordon99
It is.
The punic religion
Doesnt “Baal” often translate to “lord.” So then Hannibal would mean some sort of lord or something.
@@justinward3218
That's exactly it.
It means "grace of Ba'al" or. "By the lords grace".
To Hannibal, lord would have been the epitaph and the God.
So is it that the modern practice of capturing team mascots by the rival school ... may have begun with Marduk-snatching?
Lol
The philestines did it to the hebrews when they defeated the hebrews in a war and took their ark of the covenant but then returned because bad stuff was happening to them after that
@Herbal Shaman WRONG. First of all, Egyptians are genetically & culturally sons of the proto-Canaani who built Atlit Yam (see the similar -- but YOUNGER -- Nabta Playa in Egypt). PLoS had 2 articles on North Egypt's Dynasty Zero inheriting J2-172from proto-Canaani. Second, ABJD descends from Cuneiform.
@Herbal Shaman You cited a (non-scientific) article claiming that Phoenician was, indeed, the mother of all alphabets. Way to admit now that you didn't read (or weren't able to intellectually digest, at least) the article that you told US to read.
@Herbal Shaman The 1st alpha-bets evolved during the 2nd millennium B.C.E. (www.history.com/news/who-created-the-first-alphabet ), and PHOENICIA DIDN'T EVEN EXIST until the FIRST MILLENNIUM B.C.E. Thus Phoenicians would've needed to invent a time-machine for your nonsense theory to be true. Canaanites, e.g. Ugaritic as someone else above, who exposed your cockamamie lies, noted as an example, used alpha-bets (or rather, aleph-beits :-) ) LONNNNNNGGGGGG before Phoenicians and their language even EXISTED.
Thank you for this! It’s difficult to find much information on this topic online and thanks to this podcast I’m learning more about my ancestors.
Try "books".
@@secretsquirrel6718not everyone can cope with reading books. I used to be an avid reader until health problems took away that pleasure. I now rely on podcasts and audiobooks; history books are not as readily available unfortunately.
First time listening! I love the origins of religion. I am lucky that my first podcast is exactly what interests me.
I love it also. One thing that bothers me is how people automatically think of earlier civ's as primative. When we still don't know how they made the pyramids, or the great wall of China. I really think people are selling them way to short. I think you would like the RUclips video on Zorroastrioism.It takes the opposite view of the Bible,where Michael the Archangel cast Lucifer and his followers to the Earth. Zoroastrianism says that the Gods fell as fire from the sky. IT'S INTERESTING....
I learned a lot in this video. It was clear and organized. I like the sound of this vid too.
There will always be strong feelings about any narrative on such an important subject. My work is a general overview and not designed to influence anyone's thoughts. You are all the captains of your own minds, and you must all draw your own conclusions. My studies have demonstrated that ancient societies interpreted different mythologies in different ways, because verbally transmitted stories naturally alter. Ancient scriptures and traditional scriptures differ in their description of different aspects. My advice, do not believe the opinion of anyone, make your own study and formulate your own opinion.
"You are all the captains of your own minds" !??!?!! *ATHEIST!!*
Well said.
The Basque also ventured out on the Atlantic - thus "the Irish"
@Nocentre Noborder
There may be a true connection there -
Great point!
@Nocentre Noborder so if the British and Irish are the PHOENICIANS which in fact were the canaanites, then that would make them hammites! "Ham" meaning burnt! Which translates to black. "Zondervans compact bible dictionary" ham the youngest son of Noah, probably 96 years old before the flood, was the progenitor of the dark races, not the "negros" But the libyans, ethiopians, Egyptians, and the canaanites. Do you see the problem with your theory? JS.
Oh hell yes!
Subbed immediately.
I don't even need the video to start to know that youtube has messed up not recommending this sooner.
Kind sentiment!
Absolutely amazing how much you know about ancient times.
When learning ancient history one should first understand how ancients viewed the world and know something about the culture. It’s folly to view ancient history with modern mind
The phrase "nothing new under the sun " means what to you?
Truth being hidden right in front of you. Check out mudfossil university channel and Tyson's mudfossil adventures. Pyramids and other megalithic structures are biological, remains of giant bodys, DNA tested and CT scanned.
@@lisatsuda amen these people think they know something but the truth hides right under their noses. It's very sad and I feel terrible. Every early civilization knew god but broke the first commandment.
@@lisatsuda Awhoot awhoot awhoot!! Dive! Dive! Dive!
lisa Tsuda I disagree, that is a ridiculous claim
Modern Greco Roman Euro Gentiles. Afro Semitic people has a completely different world view and cosmology.
0:30 "Vee anchint wewd" this guys voice makes this podcast 10x better
Thanks. A great overview on subjects that sometimes don't get a broad context. The maps are very helpful and the language info is so important to understanding the region and its religion(s). Well done.
Definitely love the ancients maps amazing 🤩
brilliantly objective presentation of near east history so far as we know. You will be my companion this evening as i work on new curtains. thank you for such a tremendous amount of info presented in format clear and uncomplicated.
This video is phenomenal because he explains every single terminology.
Brilliant program old mate really interesting thoroughly enjoy it.your sound is fine!! many thanks take care 🤠🇦🇺
Really thankful for your content, i realize this is an older episode now but the audio is great
This was excellent and extremely informative! Thank you!
I agree , these episodes are important to understand the spiritual beliefs of these people in these regions.
Thanks again for these productions.
Funny how the story of Baal being brought by his sister is awfully similar to the story of Osiris and Isis.
I always think that the story of Ba'al being killed by Mot and being resurrected is similar to the story of Osiris and Set in Egypt. It's not out of the question that there was some connection between the two sets of beliefs.
@@historyoftheworldpodcast5234 I fucked up and said Ra. Fucking silly shit. But yes, it is very similar. If i am not mistaken brother vs brother and resurrected by sister is a theme that pops up in a few different polytheistic religions around the world. It really is intriguing to think about that.
@@historyoftheworldpodcast5234
The names differ percivilization, but there are to many simularities between the ancients all over the globe. Personally I think they were all based on the same gods, and that they all were in contact with one and other. Im glad you also briefly touched the subject that the ancients supposedly were "evil" civilizations. You made a great video.
@@minuterepeater2257 You have The Study of Antiquity and the Middle Ages to thank for the video.
Jabolon= Jehovah, Baal and Osiris. Black trinity
Love these podcasts thank you so much for your hard work!!!!
This reminded me of books I would highly recommend here: Mark S. Smith's 'Early History of God' and 'The Origins of Biblical Monotheism: Israel's Polytheistic Background and the Ugaritic Texts to all. Based on what was then (19 years ago) recent scholarship/translations he explores the transition from polytheism > henotheism > monotheism; the concept of religion and divinity itself to the ancient Bronze Age mind. Interestingly the Ugaritic texts describe a complex pantheon in which YHWH and Baal are rival brothers among many other sons and daughters of El. Incidentally, both are described rain/thunder/storm gods thus symbolizing fertility and virility. This is significant as these texts precede any Biblical texts by centuries and explains the Biblical rivalry between the two. As the supreme deity, El is portrayed as a wise old man, with a white beard, sitting on a throne; often he is given epithets like 'El the Merciful', which brings to mind Islamic prayers and formulae. Though we consider it a caricature today, this image of God the Father is still with us. El is a 'first tier God', otiose, or astral god; they tend to be associated with beginnings (etiology and cosmology), they are concerned with the cosmos and are rather removed and distant from the realm of human experience, like weather phenomena or soil fertility, and as such are more like titular gods with little incidence on life. El rules the cosmos with a light touch, presides over a heavenly court occasionally intervening when things get out of hand between his children. The latter are the 2nd tier gods like Baal and YHWH who are the ones who were the focus of worship and effected daily life; the 3rd tier were specialist gods like Kothar (similar to Hephaestus/Vulcan) and the 4th tier are messenger gods, they usually relay messages between the 1st tier and the others, often found in the heavenly court. They bring to mind what would later become angels. Anyway, through a complex process of conflation which mirrors the transition of city-states to empires, then growing empires absorbing others and the transition from the Late Bronze Age Collapse into the Iron Age; the number of gods are gradually reduced; some disappearing entirely while others absorb several others or their attributes, the names often becoming titles or attributes. If I remember correctly, this is the case with YHWH, a most extreme example of conflation. Baal came to be a title 'Lord', still used today by Orthodox sects (Baal Shem Tov).
Thank you man! I’ve been asking around trying to get recommendations about material to read on this subject. No luck thus far, until now.:)
@@chaseharrison5469 glad I could help! You don't get to do that so much through RUclips comments. I'm sure he's got newer publications but that the stuff I read in uni way back. Cheers
electrosyzygy I just ordered those books you mentioned. Did you get a degree pertaining to this field? If I may ask?
@@chaseharrison5469 nice! I've felt a pull to get back into reading ANE history lately. My readings lists are getting long!
To answer your question, not quite. Just a few optional classes here and there. Focused on the ANE and Levant, studied Hebrew and Arabic and took a Roman history class just cuz. Happy reading!
electrosyzygy Ah, I gotcha. Happy reading as well!
Question; Are similar god and goddess statues found in the excavations where the Hyksos (the shepherd kings) occupied Egypt? Or rather, what gods did the Hyksos worship?
I've not studied the Hyksos extensively, but I am aware that the Egyptians associated the deity, Set, with the Hyksos. The Egyptians associated Set with chaos, and traditionally depicted him as a man with the head of a strange and unknown animal. Some traditions state that Set killed the great Osiris, while others possibly later showed Set in a more positive light, with him accompanying the sun god, Ra, across the sky, as well as inspiring the names of New Kingdom pharaohs and one of Ramesses II's army divisions.
@@historyoftheworldpodcast5234 Just seems that if they had occupied an area for a time, some of their own preferred religious artifacts would also remain at the sites to help identify where they came from. There is still that question unanswered. But it perhaps answers the question on why single tombs were moved to the valley of the kings, if tribute was required from a foreign ruler. Andsome older single tombs were used as a possible resource in difficult times.
Outstanding. Wonderful presentation.
A bird's-eye view of an enormous land-
scape - from a rather long way up. 👍
Love this content. Audio sounds good to me.
Very rare. Not many vids on the topic of the Phoenicians cheers brotherman
Which one is your surname Zeke or khazier?
Podcasts are really so informative videos and es such are beyond description incredibly for their importance. What a pronunciation of the speaker!
Islamabad Pakistan.
Very informative...and yes ,the audio is Great,no problems hearing...
Jumping around from Ugaritic to Carthaginian - just a thousand-year leap
Thanks a lot for sharing this information! It's good to know how the development of Monotheism came about. God bless!
El is also where sinning cockneys go when they pass away. ;)
Bail , is what a Cockney pays to get out of jail .
HAHAHA!!!
i.ytimg.com/vi/tHp22IYQveg/maxresdefault.jpg
Michael Pritchard 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Michael Pritchard 😂
A new fan here. Thanks for the upload with the rich content.
Great show I learned a lot.
The episode I'm waiting for. Thank you for your great work!
This was great, first time listening, and love it, you got a new sub. all the best from Norway.
That's a nice map at 1:40, Is there somewhere I can download it in that high a resolution please? Ta!
Yeah that is what I was looking for as well
What were they doing to the child
If you're still looking for the map:
collections.leventhalmap.org/search/commonwealth:cj82kq367
upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/e/eb/A_map_of_Canaan_(8343807206).jpg/1920px-A_map_of_Canaan_(8343807206).jpg
This is charming... simply charming. I'm less than a minute in and I'm already enamored with the music and the scrolling images... this is like something straight out of 1995. It's beautiful. I feel incredibly nostalgic about it, lol. I also want the music playing at the beginning... not the choir music, but the music immediately following that.
This video is great! The information I was most interested in began about 18:30 I to the video. El, Ashera and YWH.
Best ancient mapping I've seen yet ! 👍👍
Domenic Localzo I've seen a Tartarian empire on old maps and it was bigger than Roman Empire
@@jayh9529 because tartary was just a catch-all term for people beyond the steppes in eastern europe central asia and into russia, not an actual place
Prince JellyFish they built Great Wall
@@jayh9529 No that was the Chinese. Beginning mostly in the Quin dynasty, and later dynasties built on as well. Partly for defense, and partly to help sure up trading routes
Prince JellyFish who built Philadelphia same architecture in Russia
Hey man great video! Really interesting look at a particularly lost old culture and religion, your accent is a little hard to understand at times, but that’s just how language is at time! Thanks for making it his and dealing with some of these comments.
For some reason this guy talking reminds me of the dude that always had the microphone trying to race the main character in Better Off Dead... lol
Beautiful map anime ... was listening to yale course lectures earlier today on hebrew bible ... your video and hers compliment each other very well. Thank U
Thanks for sharing your learning old bean; wishing you health, wealth and happiness
This is great. Superb presentation.
What do you think of the book "the invention of God" Thomas Romer
That posits that Yah and EL merged, and Asherah was taken out after Babylonian captivity.
Also, what do you think of Proto-Hebrew which resembles Phoenician?
That current square script was influenced by Babylonian captivity....and astrological aspects.
Intetesting the comic book character "Superman" real name in the comic is, Kal-El. There is something too that, and when you have eyes that can see, you see clearly.
The original creators of Superman were poor Jewish emigrants.
All movies are stolen stories of kemet (Egypt).
@jermaine moss great comment thanks
@@jermainemoss7809 not. Some parts of Canaán are more ancient than Egypt. The most ancient city in the world is a cananite city, Jericho.
@@DeviaNZe how old is it?
Everything you do on this channel is SUPERB..WONDERFUL CONTENT....BEST ON THE TUBE...MUCH LUV FROM N.AUGUSTA S.C
Your audio is great, clear and pleasant.
Great post, reminds me of my humanity's class from college.
"El" was not a deity, let alone the deity of water. It is a root word, a morpheme, meaning "deity". Hence "Elohim" means heavenly beings, and the angels are named Dani-el, Micha-el, Rapha-el, and so forth.
Ba'el is a shortened version of Babylon, with "Ba" being the root of "gate", and El again meaning diety. So Ba'el and Bab-el-on both mean "Gate of/to the gods".
Ba'albeck, like Babylon, is thus understood to be a temple, or perhaps a gateway to the gods, depending on how you enjoy it.
Now, rather than getting to caught up in the morphology of the words, which are taken from variations of a non English script, it is perhaps more useful to follow the role of the various deities as they are recycled by succeeding cultures in the same region, and even beyond.
The "Storm" god, for example, is one. The Sumerians called him Enlil, the Assyrians Ashur, the Greeks Zeus, the Romans Jupiter, the vikings Odin, and so on. Innana, the high priestess and daughter of heaven in Sumer, was also Asteroth, Athena, Minerva and so on and so forth.
Follow the mythology, not the etymology. There are far fewer archetypes than first appear, which is why Genesis today is so very similar to Sumerian mythology from 4000 year ago.
Awesome response!!!
My understanding is that El is also the symbol for Saturn, Saturday, Sabbath, Saturnalia, master/slave, usury, Nike zionist run corporatism...Okay, the last bits are my add-ons:P Got slave?
Enlil was not the storm god. He was their god of the sky and the Sun was his eye. Ishkur, his brother, presided over rain and thunder. However it's all very interconnected so I can see where the confusion might come. Most of these still very animist deities being facets of another, more primordial or greater aspect. For although Ishkur dealt with rain his brother Enki presided over fresh water. Along with Enlil they formed the heavenly triad. A triangle of interconnected concepts relating to the heavens and fresh water. Their father An embodied the entire heavenly domain and was the source of male life force/aspect, which included Anshar (the heavens), Lahmu (the stars) and Apsu (the primordial fresh waters of heaven).
In as far as the female aspect is concerned there was Ki who embodied the entire earthly domain and was the source of female life force/aspect, which included Kishar (the earth/dry land), Lahamu (the seabed) and Tiamat (the primordial salty waters of earth).
Apart from the main aspects all the lesser deities (aspects) were also children (mixings) of An and Ki. An-nuna-Ki. Presiding over lesser things like springs, plants, animals, hills, etc.
It was all still very Animist/Shamanistic and it was all an attempt to rationalise the world. An extremely organised conceptual model compared with anything that came before (that we know of) to be sure, but at it's core Animism was still the order of the day in ancient Sumeria.
Great comment thanks for posting
While it is true that the word 'el can be used as a generic term for "god," and was used that way in Mesopotamia, in Canaan it was indeed the personal name of a god.
I have often wondered about the similarities in some of the names of God.
Thoroughly enjoyed.
The level you conveyed these thoughts
How does "Internationally agreed Boarders''? Might be helpful to factor that into your patreon answer Mate.
I love this channel, it's very informative. You could work on making your videos more visually engaging though, no one wants to watch a map for five minutes. When you talk of gods and cities put relevant images on screen, together with the names, since it can be hard to judge what someone is saying from speech alone, especially if english isn't your first language. Just some tips to make the videos more appealing to a wider audience. Keep up the great work :)
Nice job all around! Thank you for your time.
Great information, thank you.
Put playback speed on x1.5 much easier to listen too. you can thank me later guys
I’ll thank u now 🙏🏽
I prefer 1.25
This is very good and informative thanks.
A deft handling of a really complex element of history. Really enjoyed it, thanks so much it was just what I was looking for.
The Canaanite pantheon was conceived as a divine clan, headed by the *supreme god El;* the gods collectively made up the *Elohim.* Through the centuries, the pantheon of Canaanite gods evolved, so that *El and Asherah* were more important in earlier times, while *Baal* and his consorts came to fore in later years.
*Asherah* - early semitic Mother goddess, "Lady of the sea," *consort of El,* also called Athirat, *the mother of 70 gods*
*El* - the *chief deity,* god of the sky, *father of many lesser gods* and ruler of the divine assembly, *also worshiped by the Israelites*
*El Elyon* -Special title of El as *"God most High"*
The Book of Genesis itself describes the *patriarch Abraham* as a worshiper of El-also called El Shaddai and *El Elyon* -- building altars, offering sacrifices, and paying tithes to him.
------------------------------------------------------------------
*Deuteronomy 32:8*
*When Elyon (El) gave to the nations their allotted inheritances,* when he divided the sons of Adam, he established the boundaries of the peoples *according to the number of the sons of El* (El and Asherah had *70* sons and in line with the Table of Nations in Genesis 10 *(70 nations)* each son *(Elohim)* received a particular territory or people like the Canaanite god Chemosh in Numbers 21:29)
Yahweh’s portion was his people,
Jacob, the lot of his allotted inheritance *(Yahweh was given Israel by his father, the chief Canaanite god El).*
*Psalm 82*
*’Elohim (Yahweh)* stands in the *council of ’El (chief Canaanite god)*
In the midst of the gods *(Elohim)* he holds judgment.
“How long will you judge unjustly,
and show partiality to the wicked? Selah
Render justice to the weak and the fatherless;
vindicate the afflicted and the destitute.
Rescue the weak and the needy;
deliver them from the hand of the wicked.”
They have neither knowledge nor understanding;
they walk around in darkness;
all the foundations of the earth are shaken.
I said, “You are gods (Elohim),
sons of Elyon (El), all of you;
nevertheless, you shall die like mortals,
and fall like any prince.”
Rise up, O *’Elohim (Yahweh),* judge the earth;
for you shall inherit the nations!
------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch Dr Christine Hayes at Yale University. Watch lecture 7 from 30:00 minutes onwards and lecture 8 from 12:00 to 19:00 minutes.
Google *"Jews and Arabs Descended from Canaanites - Biblical Archaeology Society."*
Google *"The Canaanites weren't annihilated, they just 'moved' to Lebanon - The Times of Israel."*
Google *"The Gods and Goddesses of Canaan - Essay - The Metropolitan Museum of Art - Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History."*
Google *"Canaanite Religion - **Realhistoryww.com.**"* (Read about El the father of Yahweh, Chemosh and other Canaanite gods to see the how the Bible is fiction)
Google *"The Boundaries of the Nations - Yahweh Elohim."*
Google *"Excerpt from “Yahweh and the Gods and Goddesses of Canaan” by John Day - Lehi's Library."*
Google *"Married Deities: Asherah and Yahweh in Early Israelite Religion - Yahweh Elohim."*
Google *"God's Wife Edited Out of the Bible - Almost."* (Pay attention to whose wife Asherah is in the Canaanite texts)
Google *"Yahweh’s Divorce from the Goddess Asherah in the Garden of Eden - Mythology Matters."*
Google *"Canaanite Religion - New World Encyclopedia."* (Pay attention to the section "Relationship to Biblical Religion")
Google *"How Did the Bible's Editors Conceal Evidence of Israelite Polytheism - The Evolution of God."*
Google *"A Theologically Revised Text: Deuteronomy 32:8-9 - Ancient Hebrew Poetry."*
Google *"The Most Heiser: Yahweh and Elyon in Psalm 82 and Deuteronomy 32 - Religion at the Margins"* based on the *majority scholarly consensus.*
Stop mixing, El means god Elohim son of god, Abraham worshiped El meaning god with a name Yahuah not yehovah. Fallen angels were El’s but Most High El is creator Yahuah one is one. Real truth seekers will understand. Yahweh has nothing to do with YaHUah. Its more a language translate problem. No moses did not copy name from yahweh since fallen angels know most high YaHUaH name and they make it similair to be worshipped.
I thought ibrahim worshipped Nanna the moon goddess?
Edit: Nanna = Allah, and Allah of Mecca is a moon god. The correlation and pronunciation is hard to dismiss as coincidence
How did you know this information? This is very good
@@phanuel... Everything you said is so outdated in 2023. Natufians did not have 50% Basal Eurasian, the people who made that paper made a new paper that corrected that mistake. The people with the most Basal Eurasian were the Dzudzuana samples from the Caucasus that had 28% Basal Eurasian. Natufians had 88% Dzudzuana and 12% Ancestral North African related ancestry which was not Basal Eurasian, it was pre OOA bottleneck.
I love this thank you for the clarification.
My haplogroup y-chromosome is R-M167. It seems to have originated in Spain 2600 years ago. Its parent haplogroup is DF27 which also branched into the Basque population. as R-M153. This means that our ancestors were present at the time of Hanibal. Better yet, the Tartasos archeological site at Guerena Extremadura was named (guarena) by my ancestor Guarino de Verona's descendants. Of course guarino de Verona was also R-M167. How do I know? Its longitudinal coordinates are 6 W 6 ' 6'' or 666. Welcome to my world.
Mark Garon what do you know about Galicia?
Ancient Canaanite nobleman found in Nazareth haplo R1b. Canaanites, Israelites, Phoenicians...all the same people
Love the maps!
Love the class. Thanks for making this video.
Thanks, I appreciteyour podcast, _and_ your commentary afterwards.
It's interesting that the cannanites came from one man from the 12 tribes of Isreal, all from the same bloodline. Yet, so many different religions.
Everyone wants to feel special
We know that the Baal of Ugarit and Yahweh aren't the same. The Baal of Ugarit was Hadad. But both characters are storm gods, and we know Yahweh "borrowed" attributes from Hadad. They were still definitely worshiped separately and in different locations.
Yahweh was and is the first and only God. Just ask Him. He will tell you yes.
Then it's super weird that he decided to plagiarize Hadad lol
@@erimgard3128 He didnt. He is the beginning and the end. The first and the last. He is the God of IS RAEL. Get it. The God of IS REAL. He's real. He created everything. He doesnt need to borrow or steal when everything is his. He makes these claims. No other gods ever do. *chuckles*.
That's not what Israel means lol It means "I struggle with El"
El also happened to be the name of the high god of Ugarit.
And Israel didn't exist when the writings of Hadad that I'm talking about were chiseled.
But you're not interesting in actually discussing facts. You're just chanting slogans designed for children. I'm not interested. I've studied the Bible my whole life. I've also studied other cultures and texts. You're not going to tell me anything new with your kindergarten level analysis.
This is a very informative presentation! Thank you!😺♥️
Which city are you saying Hannibal visited the bronze pillars, Cadiz.. Spain?
Wow, one of the best breakdowns I've ever heard of the Canaanite religions.
The dawn of ancient time is way older than 5000 years
This is fantastic.
LOVE HISTORY...GOOD JOB SIR...IT IS SO IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND..".HIS-STORY"
YOU PREFER "HER" STORY ; OR PERHAPS THE PRONOUN "IT'S" STORY
Very interesting. But what on earth is a map of yearly border adjustments have to do with the religion of Canaan?
Good information and great research
12:00 I though Herodotus linked Hercules to Egypt? 🤔
I'm not sure about Egypt, but in Histories (2.44) he indicates that Heraclean worship by the Phoenicians predated Grecian veneration by at least 500 years as demonstrated by temples dedicated to Heracles in Tyre (Sur) and Thasos.
This is a good observation and I think I should have worded this a bit differently. Rather than them being thought of as the same, I should have said that Greek cultures linked these characters to the same person / deity.
Som or Dsom was Hercules to the Egyptians multiple historians talk about this... read A Dictionary of Greek and Roman Biography and Mythology: Earinus-Nyx
edited by William Smith
Page. 401
@@prairiestategenetixseeds9726 I appreciate intelligent retort. It does ultimately help.
@@johnlove3505 read: A Dictionary of Greek and Roman Biography and Mythology: Earinus-Nyx
edited by William Smith
Page. 401
He was Som or Dsom to the Egyptians
From the word phonetians comes phone , Phonics etc.
Phonetians were credited for writing and language , before this the written language was cuneiform or the symbols or characters used for words by sumer and Babylon. I'm not a historian but I wonder if the sanskrit from India is older than the phonetians or sumer.
Btw great video , well done .
I'm not sure that phonetics are etymologically connected to Phoenicians. It might be worth citing a source for that fact. I think that the modern popular concensus is that the Phoenician alphabet modernised from a Sinaitic script which evolved from Egyptian hieroglyphs. Certainly cuneiform was contemporary to Egyptian hieroglyphs, but types of cuneiform were also still in use while Phoenician alphabetic scripts were evolving further west.
I like this guy's accent. He sounds like a pirate. Or a character from Dickens.
COCKNEY!
A pirate??? That kind of accent is from South West England. This man is from South East England, near London. If anything, he sounds more like a Victorian criminal.
OMG HE'S FAGIN
Amazing Video!
Thank YOU!!!
👏😊♥️☝️
Really good video -- Thanks!
Thanks,Enjoyed
Monotheism, as we have today,
came from Egypt, from the worship of the Aten. Pharaoh Akhenaten, a half Hyksos (Semite) ruler established the Aten as the sole deity of Egypt, nearly abolishing Egyptian polytheism. The Aten, who had ‘no image or form’ (sound familiar?) was represented by the solar disk of the sun, although it was merely treated as a material representative of the god.
Akhenaten was eventually forced to abdicate the thrown and was driven from Egypt. Scholars speculate that Tutankhamen, born Tutankhaten, was Akhenaten’s son, who was ultimately murdered and ‘hung on a tree’ by the Atenist priest Phinehas (Panhysy in Egyptian).
Monotheism wasn’t new, the ruling elite always believed in a single, triun god-headed Creator. Polytheism was the exoteric creation myth for the masses, while monotheism was the esoteric teachings for the ruling class and priesthood (how little have we changed).
Is there any evidence of the united monarchy?
That is a great question! There's a position and a counter position. Firstly, there is no archaeological support of the kingdom, but secondly, there is no alternative argument.
In Africa only....because it has to go back to its inception....as it is born of genetic lines it must be followed as genetic lines are created...and DNA will tell you exactly what that genetic line is...the Middle East is important as a trading post...it was never the center of origin or genetic ascendency...that's why it's a war zone...there is absolutely no spiritual or genetic importance in that region...wealth is God in that region...and so if you want yo follow that line of people's who plunder for wealth...then you will find countless books and historical matter, treasures, riches...stolen as they were...but that's what you will find....theft and murder....
History of the World podcast I tend to accept things as likely true when they have evidence that supports it. I know absence of evidence is not evidence of absence but that which is asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.
@@gary_stavropoulos That's totally fair Gary.
The Kingdom of David is a fiction of 1st century rabbinical militant religious fanatics. It was an invented historical greatness for a fictional people, supposedly impervious to racial inpurity through a millenia of migrations and inbreeding with outsiders - propaganda, used to gee up pro-Israelite conscripts in their religious war against Rome. The same crap that Abrahamics and academics spit as actual factual history to this day. Pure lies! Archeologicaly proven. 100%. There was NO ancient Israel.
Whoa😮. Ty👍👍
There is some evidence that Abrams comes actually from Urfa in Turkey near Harran (instead of Ur in South Mesopotamia) and Job is also related to the city of Urfa.
Im not sure where you got the idea that Israel was a nation given to Yahweh by his father Baal. Being quite familiar with the text I find it very difficult to accept that the conclusion you gave was a valid interpretation of the text. Are there any footnotes or other references you have on hand for your prior claim? I would be interested to see them if you have.
You could be right Scott. It's really the reference to Yahweh, the Lord, being granted "his people", the Israelites, in Deuteronomy 32:8, and it is very open to interpretation, but it is one accepted interpretation from what I have studied. Very little is plain on these early texts, and a lot of them have altered after different translations and interpretations. What do you think it means?
@@historyoftheworldpodcast5234 I may be incorrect as we are all prone to error but throughout the OT Yahweh refers to Israel in relation to himself as both a husband and a father. As a husband Israel is his wife who he "bought" out of eqypt. The idea being that those miracles spoken of in exodus were like a dowery payment.
He bought Israel with His great deeds and because He did the required work the nation was "given" him.
The second way spoken of especially in the Deuteronomy passage and elsewhere is as a father. The sense that Yahweh is trying to get across is that the people of Israel is His by right of him being creator. He "pulled lots" for them in the sense that he went out and choose them from among the nations to be His people.
I can understand why there may be alternative interpretations of what is meant, old hebrew at times can be archaic and very context based.
What i can't see through a plain reading of the text is putting Baal in any context larger then a false god.
Throughout the OT it is very clear that Yahweh is superior to all other idols. To read anything else from the passages of the OT is commiting eisegesis. You would be guilty of reading your own presumptions into the text.
If you would like some supporting passages for my claims I can provide, just replying on a phone and its a pain to type.
Tophets under Carthaginian temples reveal the charred remains of infants
It's a terrible thing that other tribes picked up those sort of practices.
@@anonapop2614 Its one of the reasons the jews resented human sacrafice.
@@OmarHernandez-du7sx what is?
So you think that was unusual that Abraham was asked to sacrifice his eldest son? The Hebrews were most likely practicing the same thing at some point and gave it up.
@@jonthehermit8082 Both are based in Canaanite religion
This is the most informative information I studied the name for many years and I always came up with YA HA WA HA the Lashawan Qadash is the holy tongue which was lost in history.
???
Is the commentary in English? I can’t understand it.
No audio problem on my end at all. Sounds very good.
Awesome video and very informative. Everyone should see this.
THANK YOU FRIENDS
There is a possibility that “YHWH” or “Yahweh”, could mean “creator, or to create”, Hebrew speakers can you confirm if you have a modern -perhaps mutated- word that confirms this. I’m a Syriac-Aramaic speaker, and for example the word “nehweh” is the
-singular as well as first-person plural verb meaning “he’s/we’re creating” or simply “to create”, and as a matter of fact the original form of the verb in Ancient Aramaic was “yehweh” but in Classical Aramaic (Syriac) the “y” got replaced with “n” for these kinds of verbs... could this be a connection to the Abrahamic reference to God as “the Creator”?
Yes
From my understanding, I think Arabic uses y- as the 3rd-person prefix. Maybe it is the same for ancient Hebrew.
@@maxwellgarrison6790 yes Arabic does also use the "y" for 3rd person prefix.
The name transcribed as YHWH is based on the Hebrew verb root "hayah" which means to be. Hence, YHWH is sometimes translated as "the Eternal".
Yes, the y- prefix does express the 3rd person masculine singular future tense in both modern and classical Hebrew.
@@raphaelalbert8110 true to Syriac as well; the root verb also means "to become" and "to be", in addition to what I stated in my first comment, which is "to create"... Also, the meaning for words such as "creation" and "creatures" stem from the same root in Syriac.
Amazing pod cast!
Thank you!
Love the changing map starting at 22:53 - Fantastic!
I thought Nimrod, Semiramis, and Tamuuz were the original trinity and now are called by many different names
I guessed Enki, Ningishzidda and Ninmah.
MIND BODY SPIRIT
@@johndoe480 nope
I love this dude's style!!! I just wish he would come to terms in his heart that KHUFU DID NOT BUILT THE GREAT PYRAMID lol 😉🙏📜⚱🔺️
Great comment! Thank you!
THAT WAS THE GREAT BUILDER RACE
Beelzebub is the “LORD OF ALL THAT FLIES” not the “Lord of the flies”
Great video though
Where csn I find this to fact check. I ask because I hear everyone translate beelzebub translated as lord of the flies.
@Yousef Ghaneemah Thanks.😁
Jenni Jones the information is contained in both the greater and the lesser key of Solomon, two ritual magic books also called the Goetia
No. It is Lord of the House that was turned into Lord of the Flies as a way of being offensive.
@@swampthing4759 Close. The Goetia = The Lesser Key.
Thank you
I appreciate your work and channel
24:04 I would really like to read all the labels but they are totally fuzzy. Is there a link to such a map with the same place names somewhere?
First time listening. Love these topics. Subbed.