Sample: 0:53 *JVNA Speaking:* 1:20 *JVNA Reaction:* 2:28 Mr. Bill Speaking: 4:35 Mr. Bill Reaction: 7:52 *Dyalla Speaking:* 9:21 *Dyalla Reaction:* 11:41 Andrew Speaking: 13:37 Andrew Reaction: 15:59
might be biased but i like Andrew's the most; the glitch mix is ok, but it doesn't quite fit the song; the warm summer vibe was also kinda off; JVNA's mix was hype, very ravey, 8/10
I don't listen too much to this genre of music, so there might be some resemblance to other composers, but your version reminded me of Purity Ring. And I really enjoyed it. Nice work!
Thanks for beeing part of this Malinda! It was super fun to watch you reacting and the original song is really great too. I love that in this series we get to watch the original artist of the sample hear the amazing creative mutations the 4 others came up with. Collaboration with you must be a treat. Thanks and all the best to you!
+Nathaniel C. Polley It's from her album, Love Letter. You can get it on most music platforms. I can't say everything, but it's definitely on Amazon and iTunes.
I feel like a lot of comments confuse their preference with which is the best track. Each artist went in with different intentions and have different outcomes. I think they were all successful at their goals which is the real metric: JVNA clearly wanted to preserve the tone and feel of the original track but put a spin on it which for many is a very nice listen. Some people want the style of the artist to be front and center, some seek out a different listening experience, her goal seemed to me at least "What if this artist had made this track in the style of EDM or Trap how might it be constructed?" Mr. Bill Clearly wanted to push the boundaries and wanted to break down the track into a thousand fragments and basically create something from the ground up. It was easily the most dense sound and complicated in structure but in creating that the side effect was it didnt preserve any of the original tracks intent or feel-- Not an issue just a totally different goal from the previous producer. Dyalla seemed like she went out of her way to challenge her self and to reinterpret the original track. The original is in a minor key and is clearly a more sad spin and swapping it into a major key and bringing brighter sounds gives a totally different message even with the same lyrics. She had totally different goals to the previous two producers and made a very nice track with that goal. Andrew was very upfront with his goals but to state it another way he wanted each of the sources of the samples to be self evident, its easy to destroy the source with enough distortion but he intentionally preserved those elements as like a trail of breadcrumbs, a puzzle of where they were sourced from the sample. Also different than the previous 3 producers, and also successful. I think the most important thing about evaluating art is to try and understand the artists intent and to judge for your self if they succeeded on their goals or if the medium was appropriate. Obviously I don't know for sure any of their intentions but they seemed to be somewhat evident in the results of their efforts. I think each producer wanted to create something specific with the sample, and set themselves a goal and I think each accomplished what they set out to do. The whole point of this project is to get different artists to get this very result, namely different approaches to the same basic premise "here is a sample, make something out of it" If each of them produced the same track the experiment would be a failure.
I actually think it's fair to equate ones preference for a song with its quality. As a listener I care about how a song makes me feel and whether I like listening to it, and I think that's the case for most people. Hence when we say a song is good it's a measure of our preference for a song rather than a measure of its technical aspects or the artists intensions. I personally enjoyed Andrew's take far more than Mr Bills take, so I'd call Andrews song a good song, and Bills less so (because what do the technical aspects matter if I don't enjoy listening to them?)
Not to diminish the huge amount of work that this took to create, but... MORE PLEASE! These are some of your best videos! If you continue to find good samples and interesting, diverse producers, this could be the coolest show on RUclips.
Wow man!!! I love this series. I hope you will make many MANY more episodes of this. It's so awesome how this highlights collaboration AND each artist individuality abd style and workflow. I love what this video says directly, and what's between the lines. Thanks to all of you, and especially to you Andrew, for beeing such a huge inspiration and positive influence on my creative life and creative scene in general 🙏 Best wishes man!
i love this series so much, so interesting to see how everyone chop things their way and bring their own personality while still having the heart of the sample
For people dissing Mr Bill, he literally started of saying that he wanted it to be as glitchy & trippy as possible. Usually glitchy songs aren’t supposed to sound “right” like JVNA’s which follows the usual EDM sound. His song was super detailed & good, why do you think the other producers were so speechless for?
His wasn't my favorite to listen to, but man was it technically impressive and interesting. Especially, the amount he pulled from the sample to make the rest of the track.
I heard this, and I immediately thought, holy crap. That escalated quickly. I kind of had this video on in the background until I heard this part. Then I was just like, OOOOOOOOOH
I come back to these episodes a lot, and this one in particular. They're just all so damn good and distinctly wonderful. My favorite is whichever one is currently playing. Such a great blend of personalities, too.
Jvna has that predictable sound, but extremely good and polished. It’s very DJ. Dyalla’s was soo chill. She incorporated her own instruments into it. Vibey!
Exactly, after a few times watching this video again and again since last year I'm still wondering how the hell Andrew thought of putting Mr. Bill and a DJ in one place lol
All of these were so different and so cool. JVNA with a go-to EDM song, Mr. Bill's was super unique and different, Dyalla's was pumped up and so different from the sample, and Andrew's being slow with a pop vibe to it. I loved all these so much super good job to all the producers
@@nicck it does look good for self promotion, but I don't know that that's their motivation. It seems more the feeling that humans get when they get to collaborate with others on something that sparks their common interests. There's not much to compare with that happiness in my experience, getting to use your gifts and passions around someone else who also understands where you're coming from, at least somewhat. This is just my opinion and perspective, I may be wrong.
The four producers one sample thing is a really awesome way of seeing just how far you can go with just one kernel of a sample. Thanks so much for putting this together. I really like seeing what’s going on behind the curtain in the creation of these new mixes. Keep up the good work!
Dyalla's production was genius! Who knew you could make the melody major while also making the LYRICS uplifting, from a sample with a minor key and dark lyrics!
That horn drop goes through my head at least once a day. I lived with a producer once and as he put it "getting lost in the song and letting it take you on a journey is the holy grail of production". Guy was an ass, but absolutely right
I love how Dyalla was so open and ready for any genre to happen, from the others, she just accepted them with an open musical mind! Was a nice part of the video for me.
a suggestion for a future video: play the telephone game with a sample and some number of producers. to explain further, start with the original sample, give to the first producer, then take what they made and give it to the next producer with out sharing the first sample, and repeat until you've gotten through all your guests, then see how completely twisted it gets.
The appreciation you all have for each other’s takes on the sample is what makes this one great for me. Big fan of the series, really hoping for more in the future. Cheers!
@@BigDeepz I meant that people should listen to more than one song by someone before just jumping in and following them. If they do that then their feed might get filled with music they don't necessarily want to hear.
I Love the idea of this being a show here on your channel, a nice way of giving a shout out to other artists while also making incredible and interesting music!
I come back to this video over and over.... just the best chillest. It feels like a group of friends who decided to hang out. It's awesome. Thank you all!
I would have said hers is the worst, but that's at least partially my prejudice against the style she chose, dubstep, and its formulaic and homogeneous sound.
Dyallas song Made me wanna drive to a Beach in California at 4 am and blow bubbles while running on the sand as the sun slowly rises in the background.
This is the part of music I really love, the part where people share and communicate, the part where they collab not with the idea of making money and advertaisment but to learn from each other and to add new ideas for work ahead. Congrats to all of you, keep the good vibe and showing that competition against other people is not good at all , is not cunstructive yet self competition is so much worth it.
Mr. Bill put the most work into his remix, its truly insane. I wish he let it drop to let us get goosebumps but I think he wanted to teach more than show off.
What I really love with this show is the mood of it. It is all just so... Joyful! You are just all having fun and keep encouraging each other and providing sincere feedback to each other! It is really enjoyable and cheerful to watch, thanks all for that ❤️
That's the goal of syncopation...to throw you off and just make you sit there wanting more of the percussive tone. It's seriously so cool that while most artists don't even try it, dudes like Mr. Bill are creating absolutely breathtaking stuff in that spectrum
You just have to move to the down beat, as well as, the up beat. Eventually your down beat may become the up beat and then eventually back to the down beat. As long as you are on tempo you will always feel it.
Am I the only one who loves Andrew's the most. I like the others too but something about Andrew's craft is so perfected. He's so good at using samples. His experience in this field is really showing through.
I have watched every video in this series many times, and I appreciate them more with each view. It’s so refreshing hearing the collaboration, enthusiasm, and all of the fantastic different takes together - and it’s so refreshing that the effect lasts through multiple views, so you know the idea is just really solid.
Dude, I love all of your videos. They always inspire me to try and get in to music myself. That said, this is my FAVORITE series you do. Keep it up, man!
I loved the variety! But I gotta Andrews blew me away, so clean, so fresh. Perfect for clubbing and chilling but also for casual listen in the background, awesome.
I liked Dyalla’s the most, the song was completely changed but in a good way, like they said it gives out summer vibes lol. JVNA stayed more true to the song and made a obvious bop, and technical wise Mr.Bill murdered it with the meticulous details. And yeah Andrew was pretty chill
They're all really good producers. I've been a musician since 1977 and a producer since the late 1990s and I've learned a lot in a short time from Andrew's videos and these producer challenges, such that I'm talking part in my first RUclips producer's challenge right now. They're all really good for different reasons and I can't wait to see what the other producer in my challenge brings forward. It's not a competition but more about learning and growing together.
I've been a huge Mr Bill fan for like -ever and it gives me chills to see these producers reacting to his music, being mind blown like I was the first time I heard it years ago. Love it
Video Quotes: "Blah Blah, Blah Blah" -Jvna 8:55 "Allow me to get turned" -Mr. Bill 4:56 "This is badass" -Dyalla 2:40 "That Synth" -Andrew 4:06 "WHAT" -Malinda 8:25
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Sample: 0:53
*JVNA Speaking:* 1:20
*JVNA Reaction:* 2:28
Mr. Bill Speaking: 4:35
Mr. Bill Reaction: 7:52
*Dyalla Speaking:* 9:21
*Dyalla Reaction:* 11:41
Andrew Speaking: 13:37
Andrew Reaction: 15:59
Thank you dude
Thank you!
Nice going there!
thanks
might be biased but i like Andrew's the most; the glitch mix is ok, but it doesn't quite fit the song; the warm summer vibe was also kinda off; JVNA's mix was hype, very ravey, 8/10
The Sample - 0:54
JVNA - 2:30
Mr. Bill - 7:53
Dyalla - 11:41
Andrew - 15:59
gamer0unreleased Thank you!
Thanks
You da real mvp 😥
Not all heroes wear capes
thanks
The Sample- 0:54
Jvna- 2:30
Mr. Bill- 7:53
Dyalla- 11:41
Andrew Huang- 15:59
Don't mind me just reposting comment ;)
(Man those likes Thanks! 😀)
you are a god among men thank you for this comment
@@shechinahchigwende6150 no problem
Tbh i need this to be a top comment
Thank you Saniel Don!!
@@lurchlogan no problem ;)
Everyone: 0oOOooo0o0OoooOoooOoooooooo0000
Mr Bill: -_______________- yeah cool guys
Underrated comment
That happens when you’re such a complex producer lol
@@kyokugami5134 Hes nutin but a nerd... weirdo
@@freshsoulbeats6084 I’d rather listen to that “nerds” music that’s waaay more intricate and mentally engaging than basic ass beats
@@kyokugami5134 "intricate and mentally engaging music" ... brother, 1000 dollars on, that you felt confused bein in the boys locker room
Thank you for including me in this!! This was sooo much fun!
I don't listen too much to this genre of music, so there might be some resemblance to other composers, but your version reminded me of Purity Ring. And I really enjoyed it. Nice work!
be my friend, you are amazing!
Dude. Dyalla. Your version was THE BEST in my mind. I love that you completely flipped the feel of the song. That was super creative. 👌
Loved your flip @Dyalla !!! Thanks for taking this into such an interesting direction. Really inspiring! Really fun to listen to!
You rock! 🤩
ahhhhh dyalla i love your stuff and was so amped when i saw u were on this
JVNA: 2:28 - 4:30
Mr. Bill: 7:52 - 9:18
Dyalla: 11:41 - 13:31
Andrew Huang: 15:59 - 17:00
Awesome, thanks
U did this last time!
Thank you for your continuous work soldier
You are welcome comrades
Thanks for this video and last video !
THIS WAS SUCH A BLAST MY GOODNESS thank you to the wonderful producers for blowing my mind!!
Hey Malinda,
This Running song, is there a platform I can purchase it from?
Thanks for beeing part of this Malinda! It was super fun to watch you reacting and the original song is really great too.
I love that in this series we get to watch the original artist of the sample hear the amazing creative mutations the 4 others came up with. Collaboration with you must be a treat. Thanks and all the best to you!
Hey! Just wanted to tell u that ur song is really good! Aaah can’t wait for the video!
+Nathaniel C. Polley It's from her album, Love Letter. You can get it on most music platforms. I can't say everything, but it's definitely on Amazon and iTunes.
mr.bill is sexy boy
I thought I recognised Dyalla! We went to the same high school. Glad to see she's doing what she loves, was always a cool senior to us
I feel like a lot of comments confuse their preference with which is the best track. Each artist went in with different intentions and have different outcomes. I think they were all successful at their goals which is the real metric:
JVNA clearly wanted to preserve the tone and feel of the original track but put a spin on it which for many is a very nice listen. Some people want the style of the artist to be front and center, some seek out a different listening experience, her goal seemed to me at least "What if this artist had made this track in the style of EDM or Trap how might it be constructed?"
Mr. Bill Clearly wanted to push the boundaries and wanted to break down the track into a thousand fragments and basically create something from the ground up. It was easily the most dense sound and complicated in structure but in creating that the side effect was it didnt preserve any of the original tracks intent or feel-- Not an issue just a totally different goal from the previous producer.
Dyalla seemed like she went out of her way to challenge her self and to reinterpret the original track. The original is in a minor key and is clearly a more sad spin and swapping it into a major key and bringing brighter sounds gives a totally different message even with the same lyrics. She had totally different goals to the previous two producers and made a very nice track with that goal.
Andrew was very upfront with his goals but to state it another way he wanted each of the sources of the samples to be self evident, its easy to destroy the source with enough distortion but he intentionally preserved those elements as like a trail of breadcrumbs, a puzzle of where they were sourced from the sample. Also different than the previous 3 producers, and also successful.
I think the most important thing about evaluating art is to try and understand the artists intent and to judge for your self if they succeeded on their goals or if the medium was appropriate. Obviously I don't know for sure any of their intentions but they seemed to be somewhat evident in the results of their efforts. I think each producer wanted to create something specific with the sample, and set themselves a goal and I think each accomplished what they set out to do. The whole point of this project is to get different artists to get this very result, namely different approaches to the same basic premise "here is a sample, make something out of it" If each of them produced the same track the experiment would be a failure.
Thanks!
How to push your comment to sit on top
Thank you thank you for this!
Great analysis. This explains how art is perfectly!
I actually think it's fair to equate ones preference for a song with its quality. As a listener I care about how a song makes me feel and whether I like listening to it, and I think that's the case for most people. Hence when we say a song is good it's a measure of our preference for a song rather than a measure of its technical aspects or the artists intensions.
I personally enjoyed Andrew's take far more than Mr Bills take, so I'd call Andrews song a good song, and Bills less so (because what do the technical aspects matter if I don't enjoy listening to them?)
This is what RUclips is for, content like this is so rare
Klaus Werther you‘re so right.
No it isn't
Nope, it's everywhere :) just gotta talk to people ;)
@@kipchickensout yes it is even RUclips will agree why do you thing they have made a new app for commercial artist in mainstream
@@jgillylikesbudsalot7436 Why do you think did they do Rewind 2018
Not to diminish the huge amount of work that this took to create, but... MORE PLEASE! These are some of your best videos! If you continue to find good samples and interesting, diverse producers, this could be the coolest show on RUclips.
Agreed
It already is the coolest show on RUclips! This is soo much fun to see all the different aspects of the same sample
.
^Yes what they said^
Agreed its what made me discover you and when i woke up to that video it made my day man
Maybe even some big DJs.
The fact that every producers enjoys each other's music so enthusiastically .
And then there’s mr bill who is just like 😐 the whole time
@@Novacayne-alt he doesn't vibe ,how can he not ?
@@knowone4587 true!!
@@Novacayne-alt it’s refreshing how authentic he is
@@Novacayne-alt Id rather say that he"s 🙂 the whole time. He enjoys it the way he is.
JVNA 2:29
Mr Bill 7:52
Dyalla 11:41
Andrew 15:59
Aaron Van Dyk thank you!!
Thx hunny
Thankssssss
upvote for the avatar
Thanks!
Wow man!!! I love this series. I hope you will make many MANY more episodes of this. It's so awesome how this highlights collaboration AND each artist individuality abd style and workflow.
I love what this video says directly, and what's between the lines.
Thanks to all of you, and especially to you Andrew, for beeing such a huge inspiration and positive influence on my creative life and creative scene in general 🙏
Best wishes man!
Yes, please, make more!
i love this series so much, so interesting to see how everyone chop things their way and bring their own personality while still having the heart of the sample
We're waiting for your appearance in episode 3!
You gotta be in an episoooode
oh hey u, let's see what your twitter looks like
JOIN
I like your music. found your channel yesterday! what a coincidence seeing you here. small world
The level of music theory and control in Mr. Bill’s is completely insane and underrated.
For people dissing Mr Bill, he literally started of saying that he wanted it to be as glitchy & trippy as possible. Usually glitchy songs aren’t supposed to sound “right” like JVNA’s which follows the usual EDM sound. His song was super detailed & good, why do you think the other producers were so speechless for?
His wasn't my favorite to listen to, but man was it technically impressive and interesting. Especially, the amount he pulled from the sample to make the rest of the track.
I loved mr.bills honestly
Mr Bills was the best in my opinion.
Reminded me a lot of infected mushroom. I normally don't like edm but his version was great!!!
You're so right! I mean, Malinda's was so impressed, she did called it "witchcraft".
I think I like this series more than weird gear, and I *love* Weird Gear
I let out an audible, full-inhale gasp when I saw this in my feed, so excited to see this series continue, it's so fun and interesting!
Mr. Bill is so chill. Stoic & reserved. Watching him perk up while listening to jvna's mix put a smile on my face.
This is my favorite series
This series is the best. You instantly get a milion ideas seeing these different approaches.
and then, i made this chord progression: *insanely complex chord progression plays*
*IKR*
@@jt-mx4on not harmonically, but rhythmically.
*same*
yeah lmao
I heard this, and I immediately thought, holy crap. That escalated quickly. I kind of had this video on in the background until I heard this part. Then I was just like, OOOOOOOOOH
I come back to these episodes a lot, and this one in particular. They're just all so damn good and distinctly wonderful. My favorite is whichever one is currently playing. Such a great blend of personalities, too.
agreed, out of all of the episodes this one if my fave.
YES THE SEQUEL FINALLY
Ily
Hello Dan!😎
DAN
Dan ily
DANIEL THRASHER I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS
I love how appreciative everyone is of other people's efforts, nice atmosphere
Everyone: "Omg, this is nuts!"
Mr. Bill: *scratches armpit with indifference*
tbh his remix was complex but didn't fascinated I respect his work though
His mix was terrible imo
@blake visser You have no ears.
@@VagabondVerdas The mix was incredible though?
Mr. Bill is too IDM to be impressed
Jvna has that predictable sound, but extremely good and polished. It’s very DJ. Dyalla’s was soo chill. She incorporated her own instruments into it. Vibey!
Well, JVNA is a DJ, so...
Exactly, after a few times watching this video again and again since last year I'm still wondering how the hell Andrew thought of putting Mr. Bill and a DJ in one place lol
All of these were so different and so cool. JVNA with a go-to EDM song, Mr. Bill's was super unique and different, Dyalla's was pumped up and so different from the sample, and Andrew's being slow with a pop vibe to it. I loved all these so much super good job to all the producers
Dyalla managed to completely change the genre of the song and still make it sound complete instead of like a simple remix. Kudos to her
Everyone's so positive, appreciative, and helpful with each other, that's amazing
Because they want to look good. It's self promotion.
@@nicck it does look good for self promotion, but I don't know that that's their motivation. It seems more the feeling that humans get when they get to collaborate with others on something that sparks their common interests. There's not much to compare with that happiness in my experience, getting to use your gifts and passions around someone else who also understands where you're coming from, at least somewhat. This is just my opinion and perspective, I may be wrong.
JVNA’s “I knew this flood would last” part is unbeatable.
KEEP THIS SERIES GOING I'M LOVING IT
I love how Andrew got crap for his last flip and was just like 'here hold my plugins'
Dude, they all turned out to be amazing. Nice job!
The four producers one sample thing is a really awesome way of seeing just how far you can go with just one kernel of a sample. Thanks so much for putting this together. I really like seeing what’s going on behind the curtain in the creation of these new mixes. Keep up the good work!
Dyalla's production was genius! Who knew you could make the melody major while also making the LYRICS uplifting, from a sample with a minor key and dark lyrics!
It sounded too much like pop/ nightcore for me. I can't lay my finger on it tho
You should check out her channel. She uploaded her version there.
the added guitar and spacey drums make the track
1. remix
2. acid
3. levitate
4. drop
love this
so true
I'm trying to figure out how to improve upon this comment. I foresee no possible way. This comment should be top.
I think dyalla's style was a LoFi ... Not sure if levitate
1.future bass I think
Dyalla's sounded like something that would be on MrSuicideSheep, so cool
Raeanne Joseph my exact thoughts
Yes, you're right. I like the vibe
I literally thought the same thing
Really reminded me of Odesza. I didn't think anyone could replicate their style but this song right here...
It had a Branchez/Odesza feel I think
That horn drop goes through my head at least once a day. I lived with a producer once and as he put it "getting lost in the song and letting it take you on a journey is the holy grail of production". Guy was an ass, but absolutely right
I love how Dyalla was so open and ready for any genre to happen, from the others, she just accepted them with an open musical mind! Was a nice part of the video for me.
a suggestion for a future video: play the telephone game with a sample and some number of producers. to explain further, start with the original sample, give to the first producer, then take what they made and give it to the next producer with out sharing the first sample, and repeat until you've gotten through all your guests, then see how completely twisted it gets.
DOOD THATZ AN AMAZING IDEA
MORE PEOPLE NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THIS
Anyone want to do it this? I’m down
YEEEAAHH
That is such a cool idea, but I think they're given the stems from the original sample, not a full song.
Mr. Bill’s style is really distinctive. Like I can imagine his tract in some type of video game
True!!
kairinaminemix fr thooo I wanna see him live now
Anyone know if there's a name for this kind of style?
Very reminiscent of older Aphex Twin.
@@SayJim yeh glitch!
Mr. Bill: This is not my final form
Honestly thought Mr. Bill had Air Pods in his nose at first
So that's not air pods??
Then what...is it then...?
peak capitalism
I thought he plugged his nose so he can't hear anything.
Wait, nevermind.
Dyalla seemed so happy throughout the entire thing
Must say Dyalla is super expressive
sorry can'thelpit her personality is so positive and it translates in her sample!
Yo she was a huge contributor for Casey Neistat's music. Check out Dyalla Swain - Need Someone.
lmao "This is BAYDAYUSSS"
Odesza Vibe ~
Dyalla Stuck on Repeat
@@shk10189
The appreciation you all have for each other’s takes on the sample is what makes this one great for me. Big fan of the series, really hoping for more in the future. Cheers!
I’ve never followed four artists so fast on Spotify.
Watch your impressionability, it can be the cause of much uselessness.
CockatooDude bro what
@@BigDeepz I meant that people should listen to more than one song by someone before just jumping in and following them. If they do that then their feed might get filled with music they don't necessarily want to hear.
I Love the idea of this being a show here on your channel, a nice way of giving a shout out to other artists while also making incredible and interesting music!
exactly this!
Koé
E ai Peste, beleuza?
Você tá em todos os canais, até aqui no do Andrew?...
This series has to be some of my favorite vids on youtube, keep it coming!
Same
I come back to this video over and over.... just the best chillest. It feels like a group of friends who decided to hang out. It's awesome. Thank you all!
Next time let them guess, who's piece is playing!
yeh that would be fun
And theyll reveal it on another vid
Dyalla is so SUPPORTIVE and was my fav on reacting and making this entertaining
The way Mr. Bill & Andrew just can take a piece of sound and make a whole new world is just briliant!
the ladies did a brilliant job as well, but i loved mr bills piece
Once I want to be able to do this too :)
Dyalla is such a personality lol
She's the hype-man you want talking up your set, getting everyone on her level :D
Holy crap Dyalla's edit was insane!
Goosebumps intensifies
JVNA's was the best by far
nah
it was really good tho
I would have said hers is the worst, but that's at least partially my prejudice against the style she chose, dubstep, and its formulaic and homogeneous sound.
Dyallas song Made me wanna drive to a Beach in California at 4 am and blow bubbles while running on the sand as the sun slowly rises in the background.
Lol
Why does this describe the song so perfectly!?
🤣
spot on!
20 minutes later..
Mr Bill hates anything with less than 1,000 GPM (glitches per minute)
How to:
Use Gross Beat.
And that's the end of the tutorial.
🤣
@@kola7106 Only if you're not imaginative enough :D
🤣
Foamy i found the fl studio user
Thank you for the "Whose Line Is It, Anyway?" reference. I'm old and it really helped me get through my day.
I've been waiting for another one of these videos, Andrew never disappoints
Praxi Plays hey what are you doing here?
Look who's here
Oh ma lawd... Al the legends in one comment section
Your content doesn't disappoint either
Praxi the goat
Why am I out of breath, I didn't even do anything
under rated comment
An accurate depiction of what it’s like to listen to a Mr. Bill track
JVNA's and Huang's sounded the best but Mr. Bill's was the most detailed and skillful
thats what mr bill would say
Agreed, Mr. Bill's was a little too odd at some parts. But I would say Mr. Bill's was epic.
yeah too detailed to the point where it kinda sounds like a little kid smashed the keyboard
Mr. Bill version sounds like autism lol
I don’t think using a glitch plug in is skillful, but that’s just me. Sounds very 90s
Nothing beats JVNA'S drop, could listen to it all day every day.
Antonio Morillas completely agree
How did one sample lead to all these different sounds?? You guys are so talented!
This man needs more likes on this post. It's so tru
People are creative creatures.
2nd beat was complete trash.
@@jmoa5758 I agree, it was borderline unlistenable
@@youdonegoofed "so glitchy" lol fucking trashy
This is the part of music I really love, the part where people share and communicate, the part where they collab not with the idea of making money and advertaisment but to learn from each other and to add new ideas for work ahead. Congrats to all of you, keep the good vibe and showing that competition against other people is not good at all , is not cunstructive yet self competition is so much worth it.
Wow RUclips you actually recommended me a good video
same lol
Mr. Bill left me speechless that was just epic
@DatrixTSW2012 they are just stupid
Wow you got Mr Bill on, that's badass. Amazing producer and sound designer
There's a full walkthrough on my channel where I explain exactly how I did it :)
The first episode was my favorite video on RUclips... With the second episode out this is now my favorite series on RUclips!
Mr. Bill put the most work into his remix, its truly insane. I wish he let it drop to let us get goosebumps but I think he wanted to teach more than show off.
They all did a great job, but Dyalla absolutely nailed this. I keep coming back to her track. Please release the full version so I can download it!!!
Wow.. This is my new favourite youtube series!
It's awesome to see people reacting to fellow musicians, what a great positive vibe!!
didnt expect a sequel
didn’t realise how much i wanted one
What I really love with this show is the mood of it. It is all just so... Joyful! You are just all having fun and keep encouraging each other and providing sincere feedback to each other! It is really enjoyable and cheerful to watch, thanks all for that ❤️
Dyalla: “why am I tired, I didn’t even do anything?” This was hilarious
me: omg I have four hours of homework tonight
also me: wait I hafta watch this 17-minute long video about cool music hol up
L A right? Ugh this is so good
lol same i have a huge test in HISTORY tommorow but im watching this
that's exactly me right now. except maybe 6 hours.
update i'm still working :(
SAME MATH QUIZ LMAO
"Allow me to get turnt" -Mr. Bill, 2018
Man that glitch stuff is super cool but it's so hard to bop to because I can't find a solid beat in there. I'm just frozen mesmerized.
Yeah syncopation makes that difficult because it is literally described as unexpected and off the beat
That's the goal of syncopation...to throw you off and just make you sit there wanting more of the percussive tone. It's seriously so cool that while most artists don't even try it, dudes like Mr. Bill are creating absolutely breathtaking stuff in that spectrum
Anyone loving this glitch sound should look at the album "Crying Over Pros for No Reason" by edIT, a member of the Glitch Mob.
trueeeeeee i lost it for a couple of times
You just have to move to the down beat, as well as, the up beat. Eventually your down beat may become the up beat and then eventually back to the down beat. As long as you are on tempo you will always feel it.
Dyalla might be the funniest producer I've ever had the pleasure of witnessing.
Wow, the one by JVNA reminded me of Seven Lions!
That build up synth is so similar to Seven Lions!
I Love Seven Lions! I like the 3rd Happiest One Though! Gahd i Love EDM!
omg me too
BLACKTIGERSEXMACHINE
Mr.Bill and Andrew !!! this is to much for me, My two fav music dudes in one video. Thanks you for making this happen!
YOU ACTUALLY DID ANOTHER ONE??? ❤❤❤❤❤ ILYSM
Also JVNA ❤
"why am I out of breath? I didnt do anything." Same Dyalla, same.
This definitely should become a monthly series! Killer mixes!!!
Am I the only one who loves Andrew's the most. I like the others too but something about Andrew's craft is so perfected. He's so good at using samples. His experience in this field is really showing through.
I love that anti-drop more than anything tbh.
I caught myself smiling during the whole video. So much creativity and happiness in one video... Please more of these !
lol Mr. Bill looks unimpressed with everyone.
lol that's his normal facial expression.He's always like this lol You never know what this guy is feeling
What's the song at 1:20 ?? Is it JVNA's track?
@@widamusic3993 yes, it's JVNA's track, as shown
@@alexc9278 He smiles, indicating happiness. What more do ppl expect?
@@gurkenhamster "indicating happiness"
You're a robot
Glad to see Mr. Bill getting some love. I've been keeping my eye on him for years. He deserves so much more credit
No he doesn't... He sucks.
Mr bill Is ~~~~~~~~~~~
@@billybarnett9834
@@billybarnett9834 why do you say that
You can tell dyalla was so hyped throughout everything
Why is nobody mentioning how good JVNA's edit was?! Damn!!
I know! Hers was amazing!
Wonder how it would sound as an oldschool dark dubstep(Burial like)edit...
yes omg it was AMAZING
Fr
The best among them. Most cohesive take.
I have watched every video in this series many times, and I appreciate them more with each view. It’s so refreshing hearing the collaboration, enthusiasm, and all of the fantastic different takes together - and it’s so refreshing that the effect lasts through multiple views, so you know the idea is just really solid.
Dude, I love all of your videos. They always inspire me to try and get in to music myself.
That said, this is my FAVORITE series you do. Keep it up, man!
I loved the variety! But I gotta Andrews blew me away, so clean, so fresh. Perfect for clubbing and chilling but also for casual listen in the background, awesome.
My thoughts:
1. JVNA was the coolest.
2. Mr. Bill was the most unique.
3. Dyalla had the most variety.
4. Andrew was the most chill?
Honestly mr bill had his own style that was yes very unique but I couldn’t keep track of it :(
I liked Dyalla’s the most, the song was completely changed but in a good way, like they said it gives out summer vibes lol. JVNA stayed more true to the song and made a obvious bop, and technical wise Mr.Bill murdered it with the meticulous details. And yeah Andrew was pretty chill
@@judityrezendes7244 Dyalla lowkey giving me louisthechild vibes
I'd say Dyalla was most chill
They're all really good producers. I've been a musician since 1977 and a producer since the late 1990s and I've learned a lot in a short time from Andrew's videos and these producer challenges, such that I'm talking part in my first RUclips producer's challenge right now.
They're all really good for different reasons and I can't wait to see what the other producer in my challenge brings forward. It's not a competition but more about learning and growing together.
Mr. Bill needs to hop on Flume’s future mixtape
I've been a huge Mr Bill fan for like -ever and it gives me chills to see these producers reacting to his music, being mind blown like I was the first time I heard it years ago. Love it
The third girl was dope, also loved her persona. She's too cool.
Video Quotes:
"Blah Blah, Blah Blah"
-Jvna 8:55
"Allow me to get turned"
-Mr. Bill 4:56
"This is badass"
-Dyalla 2:40
"That Synth"
-Andrew 4:06
"WHAT"
-Malinda 8:25
MrSUMO an extra on at 8:03
GLITCHY MAN
- Dyalla
turnt*
This is… BED ESS
Not just That Synth
_That_ Synth
Keep doing these! this concept was amazing.