Hi! I think I have something to say that should affect the album's final cut. In 'Superstitious', the final chorus part is clearly Kendall, not Logan. I believe it's a significant time difference to be overlooked! Love you!"
As in the “i ain’t superstitious but I love it” part?? I strongly disagree, the “superstitious” kinda sounds like Kendall but nothing else does. All of it has Logan’s accent
I rewatched the video, and something caught my attention: Kendall was the only one who didn't record additional parts. Logan has the chorus and an extra ad-lib, James has the clear intro, and Carlos has the 'Nananana' part. But Kendall, from what I noticed, didn't have any extra parts. Was I correct?
Boyd, James and Kendall aren't on the chorus? I don't believe the only change from the original is Logan's added vocals. Plus, Kendall hits those high notes live, and that deep voice sounds just like James to me.
I think the deep voice is Carlos. Especially where you can hear the low voice clearly, it harmonizes perfectly with Carlos' main vocal. That sort of "unison" harmony is really only possible when you're harmonizing with yourself ( which ive learned through these videos, BTR does a lot) The high voice is definitely just one voice added to Carlos, not two. I could hear it being either Kendall/Logan. But remember live vocals and distributions don't always line up with the recording. If it did, Kendall would be singing alone during most choruses lol. I think the reason Kendall does that part live is bc Logan is too busy doing the "go" and "no" adlibs at that time.
@damonlopez2197 Yeah, that makes sense. I just found it weird that the only major change from the original was Logan's higher vocals, but it makes sense given Carlos' struggles with those notes. Anyway, this will put Logan ahead of Kendall on the album.
@@NobodyinParticula567 not sure about Logan but I def considered hearing Carlos there. I just think it’s one of those cases where Kendall’s using his voice in a way that sounds like Carlos, but that’s just me
@boydentertainment7666 yeah I agree, kendalls voice is so versatile. At 5:11 that extra sassy/fruity thing he throws in there which I thought was Logan, now I can understand why you said it was him after hearing it like 20 times. And the low part during the 2nd "oh yeahs" sound more like him than Carlos as well.
@@boydentertainment7666 watch the live performances of weekends and you’ll see James and Carlos harmonizing those parts, I think that’s the case in the official acoustic version too.
OMG it's gonna be so close, I didn't think it was Logan joining in the chorus there. But I think he's still gonna lose by like 2 seconds ...unless you add Logan in the final "oh yeah, oh yeah, oh yeahs" at the end of the song? I know it sounds like Kendall but it also does sound like Logan some. Idk lol I just want my boy to win one after getting robbed on Elevate
I think Logan has this one. He’s 29 seconds behind Kendall and in the original he won by 20. The only difference is Kendall’s time is unchanged while Logan is asking adlibing the oh yeahs and joining the chorus
I think Carlos joined with James at ‘be honest bout the reason then I can let it go’, and ‘I think I know the reason’
Logan is doing the oh yeah background adlibs on the first oh yeah part and Carlos is with Kendall on the 2nd
Hi! I think I have something to say that should affect the album's final cut. In 'Superstitious', the final chorus part is clearly Kendall, not Logan. I believe it's a significant time difference to be overlooked!
Love you!"
As in the “i ain’t superstitious but I love it” part?? I strongly disagree, the “superstitious” kinda sounds like Kendall but nothing else does. All of it has Logan’s accent
I rewatched the video, and something caught my attention: Kendall was the only one who didn't record additional parts. Logan has the chorus and an extra ad-lib, James has the clear intro, and Carlos has the 'Nananana' part. But Kendall, from what I noticed, didn't have any extra parts. Was I correct?
@@juliofonseca3618 correct! I noticed that too after recording the times haha
@boydentertainment7666 Wow, this is really weird, hahaha. Looks like Logan's gonna win this album unless there's a surprise!"
Boyd, James and Kendall aren't on the chorus? I don't believe the only change from the original is Logan's added vocals. Plus, Kendall hits those high notes live, and that deep voice sounds just like James to me.
I think the deep voice is Carlos. Especially where you can hear the low voice clearly, it harmonizes perfectly with Carlos' main vocal. That sort of "unison" harmony is really only possible when you're harmonizing with yourself ( which ive learned through these videos, BTR does a lot)
The high voice is definitely just one voice added to Carlos, not two. I could hear it being either Kendall/Logan. But remember live vocals and distributions don't always line up with the recording. If it did, Kendall would be singing alone during most choruses lol.
I think the reason Kendall does that part live is bc Logan is too busy doing the "go" and "no" adlibs at that time.
@damonlopez2197 Yeah, that makes sense. I just found it weird that the only major change from the original was Logan's higher vocals, but it makes sense given Carlos' struggles with those notes. Anyway, this will put Logan ahead of Kendall on the album.
Wow Carlos got so many lines
At 5:15 i think Carlos joins kendall saying oh yeah
I hear Carlos too there
@@NobodyinParticula567 not sure about Logan but I def considered hearing Carlos there. I just think it’s one of those cases where Kendall’s using his voice in a way that sounds like Carlos, but that’s just me
@boydentertainment7666 Yeah no i get that but I think this time it genuinely is Carlos I heard it a couple of times and it sounds so similar to him
@boydentertainment7666 yeah I agree, kendalls voice is so versatile. At 5:11 that extra sassy/fruity thing he throws in there which I thought was Logan, now I can understand why you said it was him after hearing it like 20 times.
And the low part during the 2nd "oh yeahs" sound more like him than Carlos as well.
It’s safe to say that the ranking will be the same as the original version only they should all have different time stamps.
At 4:39 and 4:49 I think Carlos joined in with James
@Starwarsfan06 I only hear James
@@boydentertainment7666 watch the live performances of weekends and you’ll see James and Carlos harmonizing those parts, I think that’s the case in the official acoustic version too.
@Starwarsfan06 I still don’t hear him. The live versions won’t always match with the studio versions
OMG it's gonna be so close, I didn't think it was Logan joining in the chorus there. But I think he's still gonna lose by like 2 seconds
...unless you add Logan in the final "oh yeah, oh yeah, oh yeahs" at the end of the song? I know it sounds like Kendall but it also does sound like Logan some. Idk lol I just want my boy to win one after getting robbed on Elevate
I think Logan has this one. He’s 29 seconds behind Kendall and in the original he won by 20. The only difference is Kendall’s time is unchanged while Logan is asking adlibing the oh yeahs and joining the chorus