I must say, those were some great backup singers! It just goes to show that this song is not an easy one to sing, and only those with exceptional vocal skills can do it justice. While watching the performance, I felt like I was watching the official music video, except that Big Mama was not there as their ghost singers. Big Mama has the ability to sing this song perfectly anytime of the day. Anyway, nice try SISTAR!
The rapping part is really unnecessary. Bora should just try singing just like what JuHyun (from Spica) did. Still, no one can beat Spica in this cover. They're just too flawless.
So this is my first time watching this version of break away and I prefer the Spica cover. It felt more natural. I enjoyed it until the rap. I personally felt that it was unnecessary and just made it weird. Soyu did good same with Hyorin. This was back when dasom couldn't sing so yeah. But yeah I did enjoy this. But I did not like that rap. But I prefer the spica version because it felt more natural.
SISTAR is the BEST . spica's fans just shut up and get out here if you don't like this version or you prefer spica's version just go to listen it. don't be say too much nonsense
ML KAK T-ARA sang this too though I'm Queen's I can say SPICA did better than T-ARA and T-ARA did better than Sistar. If you visit their performance a lot of comments comparing them to Spica. However T-ARA and Sistar have been recognized than SPICA knowing they are a vocal group.
I didn't know Dasom can sing like that, and i didn't know Soyou can belt that high. I loveee these girls, they're legends. But too bad their company only focused on Hyorin's ability :'(
So...this version was mentioned in a comment on the Spica version. I won't get into the this or that directly, and I did read everybody's comments up to this point. There were three things here tho' that struck me: The rap...why? That was extraneous/unnecessary, & it did not add anything to the song; There were three additional background singers (on the left) and there were a couple of times where only one of the Sistar's was singing but there were harmonies from the backing vocalists - nothing wrong with that as it was clearly an arrangement decsion; The band here, and this is important, was just not as polished or strong as the band on the Spica version. That band had a little something extra and it felt like they were into the song. There was a groove/feel and there was that push-pull dynamic that you want between singers and the band. Here I think the band was - for lack of any other word - flat and did no favors to the ladies with the song. There was one comment from four years ago that I have to address tho' because I think there was a fundamental misunderstanding about how you go about arranging a song when you have five singers of the caliber of Spica. Here's the comment in question: "...here are two main singers hyorin aka Korean beyonce done the highnotes 3:28 and she done it without the help of someone cant say the same for spica! and also soyou also sang the highnote 3:48 where boa and bohyung had to harmonise to help each other out." ***Update Edit - with the return of Big Mama it should be noted that they also pair up vocalists in their arrangement, so the fact that Spica does it as well is actually true to the original arrangement.*** If you know Spica's vocals then you know Boa, Bohyung and Narae can easily handle any high parts by themselves, so that is not the reason. One of the things Spica did consistently in their songs was pair up combinations of two singers for harmonies (and Boa & Bohyung harmonizing are pure dynamite as any Spica performance where they did it and all of the KEEMBO songs show). That was exactly what they did on their version using four of the singers in various combinations as a dynamic part of the arrangement. It is that specific section of the song that gives their version the emotional lift and drive that takes the song home - starting with Narae & Bohyung and finishing with Boa & Narae. If you have singers at that level - and Spica was unquestionably a vocal group - then you use them.This may be a subtle musicians point but I felt it had to be said.
Yeah the rap is not necessary in this song, they just try to find a way that Bora could fit in. It's not like she can't sing, but most of the time she chooses not to sing due to lack of confidence and she just wants to focus on her job. The company could have left her out of the performance, but they're just rookies back then, so that's not a good choice for a girl group.
@@nguyenhatien1787 It's interesting to note that Spica did not try to create a rap for Shiyun, instead she had multiple parts inside a song. It does speak to the "Idol culture" (which I do not care for) of specific and designated roles for each member. In the 60's American Girl Groups there was typically the lead singer and the two (sometimes three) backing singer (same for the men actually - with The Temptations a notable exception). The positive of the K-Pop GG's is the multiple singers with talent all getting a chance to shine. If they can sing, then sing. I will note that when rapping and singing in a song hit the charts in the US it was the artist doing it all (Blondie "Rapture" & Teena Marie "Square Biz"). That continued for the most part through the 80's but as Rap became a more commercial force the "guest Rap" on Pop songs became more common. Thanks for your comment here. I'm a (lifelong) musician & somebody who deeply loves music and all of its worldwide connections, and sometimes I'm not sure if my comments make sense to the more "casual" fans.
you guys need to stop hating on sistars version of break away, they sang this in 2011 and obviously back then they weren't as good and improved as they are now.
OMG, EVERYONE JUST SHUT UP AND STOP COMPARING THE TWO GROUPS!!! If u gonna think that Spica is better anyway, y bother watching this?! Do u not have anything better to do in life? Or do u just want to piss off Star1s? Smh -_- Btw, I LOVE both Sistar and Spica... And like a true KPOP fan, not a STAR1 or a MERCURY, I will appreciate both performances and continue to support both groups... (To the groups, not to u anti/hating fans -------->>) Hwaiting!
Rainier Surratt I have thought differently. I accept the version of the SPICA is singing live over the chorus SISTAR will rely on to help. But although I do like meat than it's unique sound of SISTAR SISTAR only. And I do not think that anybody's better not to compare.
I'm sorry, I'm using a little English. It might make sense out not so good. The conclusion is that both bands are uniquely their own. I want to end it all And listen to this song
열심히 준비한 씨스타입장도 있겠지만 노래라는게 참. .예술도 마찬가지고 잘못따라하면 원작을 망치는꼴이 될수있기때문에 좀 민감하지 대중들반응이 ㅋ. .진짜 진짜 진짜 최소한의 선이 스피카정돈되야했기에 자꾸언급되는건데 거기도 못갔으니. .게다가 가수가 코러스를 압도하진 못할망정 도움받고있으면. .
이번에 딩고 빅마마 라이브 보고 왔는데 와…역시 …
효린 소유까지는 그래도 ㄱㅊ 당연 빅마마보다는 훨씬 낮은레밸
애초에 비교하는게 이상하지.....
비벼져도 이상한거
아이돌은 아이돌
I must say, those were some great backup singers! It just goes to show that this song is not an easy one to sing, and only those with exceptional vocal skills can do it justice. While watching the performance, I felt like I was watching the official music video, except that Big Mama was not there as their ghost singers. Big Mama has the ability to sing this song perfectly anytime of the day. Anyway, nice try SISTAR!
와....이런게 실력차이라는거구나....빅마마가 진짜 천상계였네.....
4명중에 노래 잘하는애는 소유효린 둘밖에 없는데 대체 왜 빅마마 노래를 선곡한건지.....효린은 jyp빅마마로 데뷔할뻔 했는데 이거 들으니까 더 아쉽네
다솜이는 진짜 불안해보인다ㅠㅠ 음정이야 말할것도 없고 박자 혼자 빠르고ㅠ 가수인데 노래를 즐기는게 아니라 불안해보여ㅠ
쥬얼리 게리롱푸리롱
@@aa-sg8yp게리롱 푸리롱은 왜나옴 갑자기ㅡㅡ
빅마마 라이브보다 들어왔는데....
다시 빅마마로 돌아가야겠음..
이거원...차이가...
그때 봤을때는 캬 했는데 빅마마 돌아오고 나서 다시 들으니까 정말.... 부르면 안될곡이였음....
스피카가 부른 게 더 낫네요.
남돌이 부르면 본전도못건지는 그룹 브아솔
여돌이 부르면 본전도못건지는 그룹 빅마마
완전 공감ㅋㅋㅋ
노래 잘 하고 못 하고 떠나 성량 음색 너무 차이남.
갑자기 조별과제가 되버렸잖어.....
하지말지...딴거하지...ㅋㅋ
이정도면 선방한거같은데
@@user-pu5kz9nb1z ruclips.net/video/IRkj5TDBV7A/видео.html
The rapping part is really unnecessary. Bora should just try singing just like what JuHyun (from Spica) did. Still, no one can beat Spica in this cover. They're just too flawless.
Omg i agree! The recent group covers Break Away is StayC. And still no group can top than Spica. Their cover still my fav.
I totally agree. I listened to a few different covers tonight and Spica nailed it like no other.
Shout out to the back up singers who are the ones actually doing the ad-libs at 2:48 they're the real MVPs.
씨스타의 명곡 박살내기
여긴 ㅋㅋㅋ 도입 색소폰부터 삐걱대네ㅋㅋ
씨스타 가창력이 이 정도 밖에 안됐었나?? 음... 원곡이 주는 전율과 감동은 다 어디 가고 밋밋하니 아무런 맛도 안나네.
빅마마나 컴백했으면 좋겠다.
축하합니다
이뤄졌네요 ㅋㅋㅋ
돗자리깔음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
성지순례 왔습니다 돈 많이벌게 해주세요
여기가 성지구나
성지순례요
Nothing beats the original.
빅마마 성님들 까지도 아니고 스피카선에서 정리 되겠는데 ㅠㅠ
대한민국 사람들 참 비교 좋아하지
누구보다 누가 잘했고 그런 비교 왜하나 싶은데..
근데 진짜 스피카 선에서 정리되긴하네..ㄷㄷ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@최동찬-n2h ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@최동찬-n2h ㅋㅋㅋ아 ㅈㄴ웃겨 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@최동찬-n2h ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
dasom was really nervous doing this legendary song but she did very well
화음은 코러스가 다 하네
맴버가 네명인데 ㅋㅋㅋ 코러스누님들이 뚫고 나오는건 무슨 경우인지
보컬이 코러스한테 털림ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
보컬트레이닝 1년 배워서 데뷔한 애들이랑 실용음악과 출신 코러스랑 비교가 되나ㅋㅋ 애초에 멤버들이 보컬트레이닝을 실용음악과 출신들 한테 배웠을텐데ㅋㅋ
효린이랑 그래 소유까지는 괜찮은데...래퍼랑 비쥬얼멤 있는 그룹이 부를만한 노래는 아니라서ㅠㅠ 아쉽당
랩 너무 오글거림ㅠ
Hyorin and Soyou could’ve done this with just the two of them they sounded amazing.
Yo amo a SISTAR , pero BIG MAMA es unico y nadie puede igualar sus voces
Te amo sistar ❤ gracias por cantar esa canción de las reinas del vocal
ㄱㅆㅎㅌㅊ
ㅅㅂ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㄹㅇ
하동균이 보컬연습때 발성연습을 엄청했다고 하더라. 결국 그 성량이 마이크 뚫고 나와야 음색도 더 돋보이는거고 청자들에게 울림을 주는 노래를 할 수 있지. 소유 효린이 노래 잘한다고는 하지만 경지에 이른 티가 전혀 안날정도로 발성이 안돼있음.
They're good. I've checked out Spica, and they're good as well, but, in my opinion, neither of them can beat Big Mama.
고생들 했는데 이노래의 핵심은 목소리도 중요하지만 화음과 코러스 인데 뭔가 많이 부족해 보이네요
효린만 선방했네ㅋㅋ
코러스누님들은 잘한다
7년전으로 시간여행왔는데...
얼른 돌아가야될것 같아요..
타임머신 예약 안해놨는데..
졋댔네
Nothing beats the original..Big Mama.
"아무나 소화못하는곡 역시나 소화못해.."
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ홍진경
So this is my first time watching this version of break away and I prefer the Spica cover. It felt more natural. I enjoyed it until the rap. I personally felt that it was unnecessary and just made it weird. Soyu did good same with Hyorin. This was back when dasom couldn't sing so yeah. But yeah I did enjoy this. But I did not like that rap. But I prefer the spica version because it felt more natural.
음색 성량은 그렇다 쳐도 그루브도 없고 심지어 음정도 불안함 ㅋ 중간에 랩은 또 뭐야 ㅋ
데이터가 없어서
화면이랑 글자가 선명하지 않아서 그런데 저거 뭐슨 프로그램에서 하는건가 해서 봣는데 무슨 콘서트 적혀잇던데
개그콘서트에서 햇던거 맞나요?
저거 때문에 개콘 문닫앗나..
아무튼 씩스타님들
큰웃음 주셔서 감사합니다
아.. 빅마마 컴백 알고리즘 타고 들어 왔는데.. 내 귀 어쩔..ㅠㅠ
Hyolyn carrying the vocals as usual.
빅마마가 진짜 노래잘하는팀이었구나 ㅎㅎ
Break away를 잘하려면
성량.에드립은 기본이고
애초에 4명이 같이 부르기 때문에 화음도 맞아야 하고 가사 중에 니가 또 생각나 에서 "생" 을 가성으로 부르지 말고 그냥 앞에 음 처럼 진성으로 질러야 하는데 이 무대는 화음도. "생"도 성량도 다 망침
이노래가 이렇게 무의미하고 감정없이 느껴질수가 있나.... 이렇게 세상 지루할수가 있을까... 섹소폰 아저씨가 제일 잘하시네...
휴... 선곡해준 소속사가 안티인가 ㅠㅠ
SISTAR is the BEST . spica's fans just shut up and get out here if you don't like this version or you prefer spica's version just go to listen it. don't be say too much nonsense
ML KAK T-ARA sang this too though I'm Queen's I can say SPICA did better than T-ARA and T-ARA did better than Sistar. If you visit their performance a lot of comments comparing them to Spica. However T-ARA and Sistar have been recognized than SPICA knowing they are a vocal group.
이게 머선129....딩고 킬링벌스랑 빅마마 해외반응 보다가 알고리즘 떠서 봤는데 처참하네...
I don't know why was people doesn't like this version?? But i know THAT IS PERFECT.
SISTAR Fighting i believe you ♥
이 노래가 얼마나 어려울지 짐작이 됩니다.
I love soyou's black dress.
Hard for me
우와 여기에 음소거하고
빅마마노래 들으니까
완벽한 뮤비가 되었당
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
보라진짜 개쪽이네... 지금 저게 랩이야?? 아 진짜 명곡 개 망쳐놓네
I miss you girls so deep 😢😢😭😭😭😭
와 진짜 잘한다......첨에 트럼펫 색소폰...
두명이서 부르니 힘들지~~그래서좋네
I didn't know Dasom can sing like that, and i didn't know Soyou can belt that high. I loveee these girls, they're legends. But too bad their company only focused on Hyorin's ability :'(
화음 1도 안되는데 효린혼자 치고나간뒤 존나 만족한표정짓는것도 개웃기네ㅋㅋㅋ
교수님들 팀플 보고와라 제발…
역시 논란이 있어도 효린이 제일 특별하고 잘한다
ㅋㅋㅋ 선곡 미스로 인해 영원히 고통받는ㅋㅋㅋ 명곡은 건드리면 ㅈ되는걸 다른애들도 좀 알았으면 ㅋㅋㅋ
정말 좋네요...잘불렀습니다..진심...그래도 원조는 이길수는 없네요 ㅎㅎ
Why I didn’t know about this 🤌🏼😭😭💜💜😻🔥
So...this version was mentioned in a comment on the Spica version. I won't get into the this or that directly, and I did read everybody's comments up to this point. There were three things here tho' that struck me: The rap...why? That was extraneous/unnecessary, & it did not add anything to the song; There were three additional background singers (on the left) and there were a couple of times where only one of the Sistar's was singing but there were harmonies from the backing vocalists - nothing wrong with that as it was clearly an arrangement decsion; The band here, and this is important, was just not as polished or strong as the band on the Spica version. That band had a little something extra and it felt like they were into the song. There was a groove/feel and there was that push-pull dynamic that you want between singers and the band. Here I think the band was - for lack of any other word - flat and did no favors to the ladies with the song.
There was one comment from four years ago that I have to address tho' because I think there was a fundamental misunderstanding about how you go about arranging a song when you have five singers of the caliber of Spica. Here's the comment in question:
"...here are two main singers hyorin aka Korean beyonce done the highnotes 3:28 and she done it without the help of someone cant say the same for spica! and also soyou also sang the highnote 3:48 where boa and bohyung had to harmonise to help each other out."
***Update Edit - with the return of Big Mama it should be noted that they also pair up vocalists in their arrangement, so the fact that Spica does it as well is actually true to the original arrangement.***
If you know Spica's vocals then you know Boa, Bohyung and Narae can easily handle any high parts by themselves, so that is not the reason. One of the things Spica did consistently in their songs was pair up combinations of two singers for harmonies (and Boa & Bohyung harmonizing are pure dynamite as any Spica performance where they did it and all of the KEEMBO songs show). That was exactly what they did on their version using four of the singers in various combinations as a dynamic part of the arrangement. It is that specific section of the song that gives their version the emotional lift and drive that takes the song home - starting with Narae & Bohyung and finishing with Boa & Narae.
If you have singers at that level - and Spica was unquestionably a vocal group - then you use them.This may be a subtle musicians point but I felt it had to be said.
Yeah the rap is not necessary in this song, they just try to find a way that Bora could fit in. It's not like she can't sing, but most of the time she chooses not to sing due to lack of confidence and she just wants to focus on her job. The company could have left her out of the performance, but they're just rookies back then, so that's not a good choice for a girl group.
@@nguyenhatien1787 It's interesting to note that Spica did not try to create a rap for Shiyun, instead she had multiple parts inside a song. It does speak to the "Idol culture" (which I do not care for) of specific and designated roles for each member. In the 60's American Girl Groups there was typically the lead singer and the two (sometimes three) backing singer (same for the men actually - with The Temptations a notable exception). The positive of the K-Pop GG's is the multiple singers with talent all getting a chance to shine. If they can sing, then sing.
I will note that when rapping and singing in a song hit the charts in the US it was the artist doing it all (Blondie "Rapture" & Teena Marie "Square Biz"). That continued for the most part through the 80's but as Rap became a more commercial force the "guest Rap" on Pop songs became more common.
Thanks for your comment here. I'm a (lifelong) musician & somebody who deeply loves music and all of its worldwide connections, and sometimes I'm not sure if my comments make sense to the more "casual" fans.
2022 im still here and still waiting for you guys
3:36 호~
1:28 벌받고있니 혹시 ㅠ
딩고 보고 왔어요.......
하......아.......
수고요~
스피카 버젼 보다가
씨스타 버젼 보고나서
궁금한게 생겻는데
이거 뭐하는거예요?
you guys need to stop hating on sistars version of break away, they sang this in 2011 and obviously back then they weren't as good and improved as they are now.
빅마마 노래를 건드리지를 말아야지 .... 걍 자기 노래하면 잘하는애들인데 .
OMG, EVERYONE JUST SHUT UP AND STOP COMPARING THE TWO GROUPS!!! If u gonna think that Spica is better anyway, y bother watching this?! Do u not have anything better to do in life? Or do u just want to piss off Star1s? Smh -_-
Btw, I LOVE both Sistar and Spica... And like a true KPOP fan, not a STAR1 or a MERCURY, I will appreciate both performances and continue to support both groups... (To the groups, not to u anti/hating fans -------->>) Hwaiting!
3:48 Soyouuu!!!
So much haters for this group but look at them now
They disbanded :(😭
아 랩은 아닌데...
@@user-qg2vq3qv4i ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
보라가 랩 담당이라 그럼 병신아
@@짓수-e4m 스피카한거보셈 거긴 래퍼도 발라드함;;
"다 합쳐도 이영현선에서 정리가능"
빅마마 개개인 선에서 다 처리가능해..
신연아 박민혜 이지영 이영현 누굴 갖다대도 못이김..
there all great i love sistar so much
비교 당하기 딱 좋은 노래를 겁없이 선곡했지만 역시나...
딩고보다가 여기까지 왔네
확실히 빅마마는 빅마마다...
I love this, Sistar fighting! GO! GO!
Do not Care.
You're blind then pretty much.
Rainier Surratt I have thought differently. I accept the version of the SPICA is singing live over the chorus SISTAR will rely on to help. But although I do like meat than it's unique sound of SISTAR SISTAR only.
And I do not think that anybody's better not to compare.
Somying Thongyod spica did not sing with back up singers actually. they sang it all them selves and did the harmonies themselves.
I'm sorry, I'm using a little English. It might make sense out not so good.
The conclusion is that both bands are uniquely their own.
I want to end it all
And listen to this song
절반은 코러스 분들이 불러주시넹
I really like bora's blue shimmering dress!
Am here because of StayC ♥♥♥!
sistar ♥♥♥
........ 하..간 크다 진짜
편곡을 씨스타 스타일로 했으면 좋았을텐데… 원곡이 넘사라 아쉬움 남는 무대네…
트럼펫부터 찌글찌글 하네
트럼펫 진짜 거슬리네ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
spica did so much better... sorry :(
Big Mama is the best, nice try.
에이 그래도 코러스는 얼추 하는구나 했는데 .. 뒤에 코러스가 있구나..
ㅋㅋ이걸 불렀었네
역시 깡은 좋아
열심히 준비한 씨스타입장도 있겠지만 노래라는게 참. .예술도 마찬가지고 잘못따라하면 원작을 망치는꼴이 될수있기때문에 좀 민감하지 대중들반응이 ㅋ. .진짜 진짜 진짜 최소한의 선이 스피카정돈되야했기에 자꾸언급되는건데 거기도 못갔으니. .게다가 가수가 코러스를 압도하진 못할망정 도움받고있으면. .
옆에 코러스들이 나와서 부르면 개잘부를것같은데?? 진짜 씨스타 좋아하는데 코러스가 훨씬잘부름 코러스 계속 듣고싶다
just LOL.........spica cover was wonderfull.....and this cover again LOL
0:24 최종훈이..?
I prefer this version !
코러스 언니들 ~화음 넣는데 그 소리만 꽂히네. 이거 완전 뮤비랑 똑같은 상황처럼 보이네요
I like more spica's version :)
와 의상하고 다솜 단발 보니까 10년도 쿨 활동 할 때인 것 같은데..새삼 시간 빠르네 ㅠㅠ 빅마마 누님들에 비할 수는 없겠지만..도입부 효린 목소리랑 이어 받는 소유 너무 좋다ㅠㅠ 씨스타 최애 걸그룹이었는데 아쉽
빅마마가 그냥 쎈겁니다
딩고 봤다가 떠서 오 시스타가 이걸 했었네 눌러 봤는데 ㅎ 댓보니 스피카도 했다니까(씨스타 스피카 둘 다 조아했는데 암튼 이거보단 잘한다니까) 궁금하니 들어보고 정화하러 가야겠다 다시;; 그래도 소유 효린은 좀 나은데ㅜ
Love U Soyou
我覺得SPICA跟SISTAR都有努力過-光就 Break Away一曲來說
Spica's version Is better