the writers at starkid are too scared to put jamie and dylan as a couple/together in a show because they know it’ll put pretty much all the other shows to shame (not that i don’t love them but still)
I understand why you didn't do rogues medley but I'm also torn because it's so powerful it gives me heart palpitations every time, so obviously it's the best
@@user-hl7gi8ud2i They also say it in Listen To Your Heart. I think the fact that they could say it in this show (unlike, say Homecoming, where they seemed to be more censored) makes it even funnier that they chose not to for the entire opening number. It's also really sweet hearing "It's me and its... US!"
maybe it’s because i heard the apocalyptour version of “guys like potter” before the original, but i like it more! it’s one of my favourite styles of music, and i think the juxtaposition between lyrics and tone is hilarious! but i totally get why you’d put it lower if that’s not your jam!
I love it so much, so boppy and the MOST fun, but I also love the original with Tyler being dramatic and Joe Moses singing harmony so I really wouldn't be able to decide which I like better
it's a total bop, but for me, i liked the original because of the emotion. there was some comedy inserted there, but joe moses' acting is actually really good and underrated (though he's not exactly the strongest singer out there). but yep, everyone can have their own opinions! this is just mine :)
When I listen to the space tour recordings on Spotify, I'm sorry, I love starkid, but it is not good. Except for some songs. Like stutter. That is a true blessing
Indy D honestly I completely disagree, I have more songs from space tour than apocalyptour saved. Ready to go, even though, no way, to have a home, granger danger, even though, boy toy, Liam’s got a phone call, even though, the coolest girl, and days of summer are all on par, if not better than the original
@@bridgetspector6703 I got even though, to have a home and no way too yeah, but granger danger, little white lie medley, mamd/ready to go and a lot more from the apoclyptour. But everyone has different preferences and likes and dislikes and this is how I feel about it😊
So I love that “robin’s” (Brian Rosenthal sings it in apocalyptic) is changed to “ I want to meet Barack Obama” because Nick who played robin in HMB also plays Barack Obama in HMB
The main advantage the originals have is being in context and in costumes The main advantage thr apocalyptour versions have is way better sound quality and the posibility of great harmonies
It makes me so sad that Granger Danger is so low because I had the Apocalyptour version on all the time when I first found AVPM. I even played it for my friends. I've gotten more used to that version than the actual one. edit: also the "and now we dance" is on the professionally recorded version (at least I think? someone back me up on this pls)
that's valid! I still like this version of Granger Danger, I just think the original one is a bit better The "and now we dance" isn't included in the version on Spotify, so I'd guess it isn't on any other. However, she says it during the Space Tour. Maybe you were thinking of that one.
It’s always bothered me that in different as can be the line “ you won’t sleep on your tummy, you won’t sleep on your back” makes no sense, because if Voldemort wants squirrel to sleep on his back it means he wants to sleep on his tummy, which quirrel says he won’t do 😂😂😂
First time I listened to apocalyptour was on a coach in Belgium on a school trip and every single song I just melted at how amazing, making myself look more and more like an idiot until THAT PART IN NOT ALONE where I just died.
Personally I think with the A Very Potter Trilogy songs with better 'singing'(especially avpm which had limited rehearsal time compared to others) it's an audio thing
Me before starting the first video: wow I can’t wait to see how high my favorites are *sees MAMD/Ready to Go and Coolest Girl and Granger Danger close to the bottom* Well shoot...
David Tennant For the tour, it was also a plot, because the Starkids Love us and can’t just settle for live performances, so if you see the full tour (which is now just available for digital/DVD purchase on their site) there’s a plot following that justifies the outfits. And if their shoe choices in most all performances, Jesus Christ, are any clue, usually their outfits are available from the same stores we shop at. Lol, but the costume designer also definitely loved the fans, we were blessed.
The main bit I like better about the original of not alone is just the general group of the best friend of the play, joining together to address their friendship. Also the CA-A-A-A-AUSE sounds super cool when the shitty old youtube quality comes together for that one moment
I was going to, but after I started it i wondered if making a video on how they improved between their two tours would make more sense. Maybe I'll do both
I will remember Achmed you should definitely do both. This was so fun to watch, so I would recommend that you make this version for The Space Tour and then make the comparison 😊
Unpopular opinion (y’all gonna hate me for this one) but I think Lauren’s voice isn’t as strong as others like let’s say Jamie’s but yet she gets much more attention personally I think that is because Lauren has bigger roles than people like Jamie so gets to show her off voice much more. I also think that Jamie is just as talented as Lauren (maybe even more) and she has the strongest most beautiful voice but is left in the shadows which is kinda sad. I know she gets solos like lost without you, Harry, join us and die and she sings most of not alone but beside lauren and other females she has much less (I think I haven’t counted others) basically what I’m saying is Jamie shouldn’t be so forgotten and pushed to the side as she is an amazing actor and phenomenal singer (you know that already) so I think Jamie should get more love from people as when fans think of a female Starkid their mind goes straight to Lauren or Meredith and Jamie wouldn’t be the first when a lot of people think of the females of Starkid. So basically Jamie deserves more love and a lead #givejamiealead. Thank you for coming to my ted talk♥️ this whole thing might make no sense so I’ll explain Lauren gets a load of recognition for her voice and Jamie gets little of recognition.
Any song from the tour is immediately better because of those shorts
Rehks Walls TrUe
you don't even need to specify who you're talking about lmao
DECEIT
But we can all agree that Rouges Medley is better than the original three in every possible way
Absolutely, and all of them were already fairly good anyway, the medley just blew it out of the water
Yeah, I was watching HMB the other day and when Rouges Are We came on I half expected it to immediately transition to Rouges (Reprise)
Yes we CAN
Exactly!
Not alone
Better: the audience singing Darrens parts during the chorus
In conclusion: the apocalyptour is a gift to this world
Sad, dark, lonely knight is missing the reins during I never had a pony
Oh god yes youre right
Yea I was so sad
I've never actually realised it's meant to be reigns for his pony before
dylan saunders has never missed a note ever
the writers at starkid are too scared to put jamie and dylan as a couple/together in a show because they know it’ll put pretty much all the other shows to shame (not that i don’t love them but still)
Emily Llewellyn they’re together in Black Friday aren’t they?
No, it’s Kim and Dylan
Glass Ferns whoever put Kim and Dylan together was genius! Their voices blend so perfectly omg 😭
Lmao imagine Sherman and Tom
Hey bud. How you feeling about this comment after Nightmare Time Ep 3?
Every time someone recognizes that Dylan and Jaime are the best Starkid singers I get a lil more optimistic about the world
I guess they don't have more duets because it would just make everything else a bit less amazing than them
Summer Star Jaime is an amazing singer but she has a tendency to go too hard when she’s singing harmonies and she goes above everyone else
HAHA I've never noticed Brosenthals face when they cut him off that's hilarious
Vicky Elle when crap like that happens the first thing that I look for is reactions
When was that?
In Get back up
if i wasn’t in love with JAMIE LYNN BEATY before i am now ahhhhhhhhh
Yaaaas! I didnt think she was the best female vocal (i like Mariah too) at first but the more I hear from her the more I believe it!
Sco6014 she just amazing honestly
She is a gift to this earth we honestly don't deserve
I understand why you didn't do rogues medley but I'm also torn because it's so powerful it gives me heart palpitations every time, so obviously it's the best
I can see what you mean about mamd, but i love that they didn't say d*ck it is hilarious
They do say it at the very end of the show after a very long dramatic pause and I think that’s beautiful
Apocalyptour: me and my-JOE
It ends on its me and it's........... Us!
And i love how they don't say dick, because of my family walks in on me listening they won't think I'm 100% completely bonkers
@@user-hl7gi8ud2i They also say it in Listen To Your Heart. I think the fact that they could say it in this show (unlike, say Homecoming, where they seemed to be more censored) makes it even funnier that they chose not to for the entire opening number. It's also really sweet hearing "It's me and its... US!"
we can't not acknowledge during your for granger danger joey sings "OH MY GOD beautiful to me" 😂😂
I'm convinced that Dylan and Jaime have never had a duet together in a show because they'd just be too powerful
when they sing sami/harry it sounds like 'hami'
I sure love myself Some hami
Whenever I listen to that one I like to think it’s Sami and Harry singing about each other
When I saw that sami/Harry was second i was about to rage I couldn't think of any song that was better *until i saw number one*
The better for dark sad lonely knight is so valid
maybe it’s because i heard the apocalyptour version of “guys like potter” before the original, but i like it more! it’s one of my favourite styles of music, and i think the juxtaposition between lyrics and tone is hilarious!
but i totally get why you’d put it lower if that’s not your jam!
I love it so much, so boppy and the MOST fun, but I also love the original with Tyler being dramatic and Joe Moses singing harmony so I really wouldn't be able to decide which I like better
it's a total bop, but for me, i liked the original because of the emotion. there was some comedy inserted there, but joe moses' acting is actually really good and underrated (though he's not exactly the strongest singer out there). but yep, everyone can have their own opinions! this is just mine :)
Well I prefer Denise as February, Jaimie singing her part in The Way I Do makes me feel things (Also please do one of these for the space tour)
Yes a space tour one because we need to decide which Stutter is better
When I listen to the space tour recordings on Spotify, I'm sorry, I love starkid, but it is not good. Except for some songs. Like stutter. That is a true blessing
Indy D honestly I completely disagree, I have more songs from space tour than apocalyptour saved. Ready to go, even though, no way, to have a home, granger danger, even though, boy toy, Liam’s got a phone call, even though, the coolest girl, and days of summer are all on par, if not better than the original
@@bridgetspector6703 I got even though, to have a home and no way too yeah, but granger danger, little white lie medley, mamd/ready to go and a lot more from the apoclyptour. But everyone has different preferences and likes and dislikes and this is how I feel about it😊
The harmonies on Status Quo from the space tour is actually one of my favorite things ever. Chills every time.
My only gripe is I think part of their crappy singing at shows is chalked up to them being younger and in character (mainly Voldy-mort and Draco)
Dude they’re singing may have developed over the years but it was never crappy
if i was ranking this it'd just be
"meredith is here. i am in love with her. easy A+"
Sami/Harry has got to be one of my favorite songs here. Jaime and Dylan need to sing together more. Jaime and Joey also pair well in The Way I Do.
To Dance Again didn't have enough Quirrellmort
ikr!
Great to see Apocalyptour get some more attention. As for the list, I think it's a perfectly respectable ranking.
So I love that “robin’s” (Brian Rosenthal sings it in apocalyptic) is changed to “ I want to meet Barack Obama” because Nick who played robin in HMB also plays Barack Obama in HMB
The main advantage the originals have is being in context and in costumes
The main advantage thr apocalyptour versions have is way better sound quality and the posibility of great harmonies
DARREN SITTING IN THE BACK WITH HIS TIE IN THE LISTEN TO YOUR HEART CLIP SENT MEEE
I like how you switched between the two Different as Can Be’s just like Voldy and Quirrel switch lines
Dance again (3:43)
Worse: Joe's abs are absent
Better: Joe's legs are present
Get Back Up is such a bop 👌
Why am I so attracted to Joe Walker on this tour in particular?
It's the shorts
@@andrealister3970 and the half buttoned shirt
somebODY
once told me the world was gonna role me 😂😂😂 I loved it
What I also love about the tour not alone, is how the crowd sings Darren's parts.
13:44 Why can't you see...That I was orphaned at 33
It makes me so sad that Granger Danger is so low because I had the Apocalyptour version on all the time when I first found AVPM. I even played it for my friends. I've gotten more used to that version than the actual one.
edit: also the "and now we dance" is on the professionally recorded version (at least I think? someone back me up on this pls)
that's valid! I still like this version of Granger Danger, I just think the original one is a bit better
The "and now we dance" isn't included in the version on Spotify, so I'd guess it isn't on any other. However, she says it during the Space Tour. Maybe you were thinking of that one.
brosenthal's voice during missing you,,,, my beloved,,,
It’s always bothered me that in different as can be the line “ you won’t sleep on your tummy, you won’t sleep on your back” makes no sense, because if Voldemort wants squirrel to sleep on his back it means he wants to sleep on his tummy, which quirrel says he won’t do 😂😂😂
I've read somewhere that you can interpret it as Voldemort saying "You WONT sleep on your back", as in you're not allowed to/i wont let you, but idk
I will remember Achmed ahh see that makes sense ☺️
Finally, someone agrees with me. I remember there was another confusing line like that.
Can you do this with their other live performances
I love both the tour and originals
i’d keep it as eVvvVeRy sonG iS SpeCiAL iN itS owN wAY
wait wasn’t darren on the tour with them? why didn’t he sing his part in not alone? :(
He was only there for certain performances
He was there for NYC and some LA performances but not for the filmed performance
i think if you ever ranked shows on closing numbers HMB would be SO HIGH i get to hype to Super Friends
hugh janus @Lauren Manion did one of those
Counter: Inevitable, Days of Summer
First time I listened to apocalyptour was on a coach in Belgium on a school trip and every single song I just melted at how amazing, making myself look more and more like an idiot until THAT PART IN NOT ALONE where I just died.
I don't think anything could beat the original choreography from to dance again, it just too iconic
First!
Edit: 2:24 YESSS Brian is amazing.
That was worse than being rick rolled. I love it
In the Sami/Harry segment the cut from Jamie 2.0 to little Jamie gave me feels....the nostalgia...the growth
Thank you so much for doing this, i loved what you thought of each song and the reasons behind each one. Really made my day
Thanl you for the great idea!
The rogues medley absolutely slaps
How do I marry Brian Rosenthal's voice
3:26 "I start to swoon" Someone in the audience said me too ! Ha
You didn't do Rogues Medley because the sheer power radiating that would kill everyone
15:00 mood
DARREN TRYING TO DO THE SUPER FRIENDS CHOREO
Personally I think with the A Very Potter Trilogy songs with better 'singing'(especially avpm which had limited rehearsal time compared to others) it's an audio thing
4:01 I feel like they """stole""" Joe's moment, he deserves more spotlight
3:26 that one girl who screams “me too” is such a mood
I literally cry whenever I listen to Not Alone its so beautiful
The amount of Brolden content we got on this tour >>>>>
Me before starting the first video: wow I can’t wait to see how high my favorites are
*sees MAMD/Ready to Go and Coolest Girl and Granger Danger close to the bottom*
Well shoot...
Me with Guys Like Potter
It really broke my heart because theyre still so great! But something had to be last :(
It’s official: my life will not be complete until I see these people live.
this could mean
*aggressive foot tapping and head bopping*
dANGER
without the random sighing in missing you the quirrellmort just doesn’t feel complete 😔👊
Where is Rouges Melody? It's my favorite song from Apocalyptour
It's a Medley, that's why I didn't include it. It's harder to compare each song if they are kind of merged together. (and it would easily be #1)
1. So is there a reason they’re dressed like people from Jurrasic Park? I’m new to the fandom lol
2. Where can I get all of their shorts?
David Tennant
For the tour, it was also a plot, because the Starkids Love us and can’t just settle for live performances, so if you see the full tour (which is now just available for digital/DVD purchase on their site) there’s a plot following that justifies the outfits.
And if their shoe choices in most all performances, Jesus Christ, are any clue, usually their outfits are available from the same stores we shop at. Lol, but the costume designer also definitely loved the fans, we were blessed.
@@wonderlost6049 yep whoever decided Jim was going to look that majestic deserves a thank-you
8:20 poor baby lmfaoo
I know we said no medleys but Rogues Medley is literally my hype song like it is one of the best things on the planet🤧🤩
i was wondering if anyone could tell me why darren criss is only there a little bit?
He only performed with them in one city or two, so most footage is without him
@@IwillrememberAchmed thank you!!!
Okay but in Get Back Up I miss Joe Moses and his happy puppy vibe and the way he dances like a penguin. Anyone else?
YES joe moses is amazing
this is great
boy toy was robbed of this list
fucking Rogues Medley from Apocolyptour is the only fucking thing I listen to
The main bit I like better about the original of not alone is just the general group of the best friend of the play, joining together to address their friendship. Also the CA-A-A-A-AUSE sounds super cool when the shitty old youtube quality comes together for that one moment
3:24 "ME TOO!!" XD
honestly in my opinion , granger danger was better in the tour but yes, the acting is way better in the original, obviously
I'm so glad Jaime has learned to scoop less into notes. That was so annoying back in the day.
Sami/ harry will forever be the best duet
I hoped that would be number 1!! Jaime’s singing afahsjsjs!!!
YOU DIDNT INCLUDE THE APOCALYPTOUR "AS SOON AS SHE LOVES US AS WE LOVE HER" PART. UNSUB.
sami/harry is the best thing to come from both tours fight me
Wait Darren was in this tour and Brian still sang his songs?
He wasn't there for all performances and i included clips from differenr cities, so sometimes he"s there, sometimes he isnt.
The rogues medley is to powerful
Will you be making one of these for the space tour?
I was going to, but after I started it i wondered if making a video on how they improved between their two tours would make more sense.
Maybe I'll do both
I will remember Achmed you should definitely do both. This was so fun to watch, so I would recommend that you make this version for The Space Tour and then make the comparison 😊
I don’t like the original baby your not alone but I love the apocalyptour version
Super friends just doesn’t have nick. And it’s not the same.
6:23
excuse you, apocolyptour guys like potter is a B O P
Ehem where is kick it up a notch
Sorry for being stupid but who is Sami??
She's the main character in Little White Lie, it's a short series by Starkid. You can find it on youtube if you want to watch it
JAIME
Unpopular opinion (y’all gonna hate me for this one) but I think Lauren’s voice isn’t as strong as others like let’s say Jamie’s but yet she gets much more attention personally I think that is because Lauren has bigger roles than people like Jamie so gets to show her off voice much more. I also think that Jamie is just as talented as Lauren (maybe even more) and she has the strongest most beautiful voice but is left in the shadows which is kinda sad. I know she gets solos like lost without you, Harry, join us and die and she sings most of not alone but beside lauren and other females she has much less (I think I haven’t counted others) basically what I’m saying is Jamie shouldn’t be so forgotten and pushed to the side as she is an amazing actor and phenomenal singer (you know that already) so I think Jamie should get more love from people as when fans think of a female Starkid their mind goes straight to Lauren or Meredith and Jamie wouldn’t be the first when a lot of people think of the females of Starkid. So basically Jamie deserves more love and a lead #givejamiealead. Thank you for coming to my ted talk♥️ this whole thing might make no sense so I’ll explain Lauren gets a load of recognition for her voice and Jamie gets little of recognition.
Bonnie is the superior Hermione in general in my opinion